Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Gryphon decom, foreign frustrations, and Centrica's Grain
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. This week there's been some
- 0:15updates on Humber Solar, some comings and goings with LNG and
- 0:21hydrogen, and of course, the Griffin FPSO gets a verdict.
- 0:27But to discuss that story in particular, I'm going to have to
- 0:30speak to my colleague, renewables reporter Michael
- 0:33Baer. How are you doing this week,
- 0:34Michael? Not bad, it's been a busy week.
- 0:37I think we've had some exciting same developments, so it's going
- 0:40to be good fun to to chat about them.
- 0:42Do you know else is making this episode kind of fun?
- 0:44We're introducing our latest edition of the editorial team,
- 0:47Floyd March, our NW correspondent.
- 0:50How are you doing today, Floyd? Yeah, good to be on the podcast,
- 0:54Ryan. Good to be debuting with you
- 0:56guys. Looking forward to getting on my
- 0:57soapbox for a bit. So TuneIn for probably a 10 hour
- 1:01episode. And of course, I'm Aberdeen
- 1:04features lead Ryan Duff joining after a couple of weeks off.
- 1:08But you don't want to hear about me, you want to hear about the
- 1:10Griffin FPSO. And Michael, you've been keeping
- 1:13a keen eye on that for a number of months.
- 1:17There's been ups and downs. What's happening, What's
- 1:21happening now? Yeah, so I'm I'm debating as to
- 1:24how far back into the past we're going to have to go.
- 1:27So Griffin FPSO is obviously a quite venerable FPSO.
- 1:34It's kind of long history, the total energies who bought it
- 1:39quite a few years ago now don't don't ask me exactly how many
- 1:42they've been planning on decommissioning it for quite a
- 1:46while that they put in their plan.
- 1:49I think it was 2023 and it was literally I think the first day
- 1:52of the year the, they, they went ahead and shut it down ahead of
- 1:58planning to decommission it this year.
- 2:01The I don't believe that that decommissioning plan has been
- 2:04approved yet and it was also held up pending judicial review
- 2:08because obviously Griffin is tied back to a number of fields,
- 2:12five if I remember correctly. And the operator of not the
- 2:17operator, someone who holds stakes, Noble upstream holds
- 2:19stakes in two of those fields. And obviously they were a bit
- 2:25unhappy about the decision to essentially stop oil and gas
- 2:29production from those fields. They argued that there was still
- 2:33economically recoverable oil reserves that could be could be
- 2:38extracted. And they start a judicial review
- 2:41for this. Now that was heard, I believe at
- 2:43the start of June 3rd, the 3rd to the 5th.
- 2:47So that wrapped up and we've been awaiting A verdict.
- 2:50And I've got the 141 page document right here.
- 2:54And I think maybe we should do something different.
- 2:56I feel like we should maybe start branching into ASMR. So
- 2:59maybe I'll just read every. Oh no, please don't do that.
- 3:03Geez. No, I can, I can summarise.
- 3:06I had a bit of a read and essentially it's not good news
- 3:09for noble upstream that the reviewers basically said that,
- 3:17yeah, they, they don't have a case basically and it's
- 3:20essentially been dismissed. So what of this doesn't mean
- 3:23that the, the decommissioning plan can go ahead.
- 3:27I think that still needs to be approved by operate.
- 3:29It's removing a hurdle essentially to the
- 3:34decommissioning going ahead. And you know, this is this kind
- 3:37of highlights a potential maybe worry for others or smaller
- 3:42players in the North Sea, right. A lot of a lot of these firms do
- 3:46have sort of stakes that are essentially just tie back fields
- 3:50to existing infrastructure. And yeah, this this sets our
- 3:55precedent of well, you know, to tells the operator Griffin,
- 3:59they've said, well, we don't want to operate Griffin anymore.
- 4:03We're going to decom the the the vessel.
- 4:05And now that means that Noble is up a Creek without a paddle.
- 4:10I'll be very I'll make sure you're not this where this
- 4:12episode, you know. So, yeah, it's it's an
- 4:16interesting, interesting sort of tone that I'm sure, you know,
- 4:21some of you guys, some of your smaller name operators are going
- 4:25to start looking at and going, oh, can that happen to us?
- 4:27I mean, we saw Total Energies looking to sort of scale back
- 4:32its UK operations, scale back its UK investment and was the
- 4:36last year after it was revealed that it was the largest taxpayer
- 4:42in the UK basin. And you know, this is despite it
- 4:45not being on the firm that has the most production in the
- 4:49country. And you know, it's a Patrick
- 4:52Poojan. You know, maybe sensibly if you
- 4:55if he's looking at his own balance book is going well,
- 4:57let's maybe not invest in the UK it it does raise some questions
- 5:03around the future of production hubs.
- 5:06I mean, definitely Nobel upstream has argued that this
- 5:10might set a dangerous precedent. Now, you know, I'm not going to
- 5:14lie to you. I look through the the judgement
- 5:17for the best bits. I'm not going to claim to have
- 5:19141 pages of of legal opinion memorized.
- 5:24Well, it's just not doing your job, Michael, come on.
- 5:26That's not. This is it, this is it.
- 5:29I'm afraid that this will be my last podcast for for that
- 5:32massive failure. One of the key I think the key 2
- 5:35points were about the the volume of oil.
- 5:39Now, I'm pretty sure there will be a disagreement between Nobel
- 5:42and the in the High Court opinion.
- 5:45They were of the opinion that the amount of oil is still
- 5:48modest. Nobel have said, you know, that
- 5:51there's still considerable revenues there.
- 5:54And given that they have, that they want this to keep going,
- 5:59that you'd probably go so far as to say that they're not, they're
- 6:03not wanting to extract the the oil and gas for the fun of it.
- 6:06They're a business. They're of the opinion that
- 6:08there's still money to be made. So, you know, maybe there's a
- 6:12disagreement there. The other one is that the, one
- 6:14of the, the reasons they've claimed before about why the
- 6:19total wants to decommission Griffin is that it was to meet
- 6:23their emissions standards. And the High Court said, no, we,
- 6:26we really don't feel that it is purely that this is an ageing
- 6:29vessel that they and they were looking at it going, there are
- 6:33vulnerabilities here. It's the maintenance is going to
- 6:36be difficult. It's and you know, there's going
- 6:38to be risk to losing production. Noel have previously said that
- 6:43they would, they'd offered to, to buy it.
- 6:45I think we found out in the the opinion that he offered a whole
- 6:48# but I think that was more of a token gesture that they said,
- 6:52look, we'll take over operations of it.
- 6:55You can get that decommissioning the emissions off of your books.
- 6:58And then, you know, we all continue to make money
- 7:01essentially. I think the the target of their
- 7:04ire has been the North Sea Transition Authority.
- 7:07They have very much been against the NSTA for what they viewed as
- 7:13it failing to to follow its job to maximize the amount of oil
- 7:17and gas production in the UK continental shelf.
- 7:20See, this is something that I found interesting because you, I
- 7:23read that line in your report, Michael.
- 7:25And I, I, I had a thought about that because maybe I'm wrong.
- 7:30And if, if someone from Nobel wants to, to get in touch,
- 7:33you're more than welcome to reach out and tell me otherwise.
- 7:37But from my understanding, the Nstas job isn't to maximize oil
- 7:41production or gas production in the UK.
- 7:45I, I believe it's hooked on that sort of that that document that
- 7:50Syrian Wood wrote a number of years ago is maximizing economic
- 7:53recovery. It's not about how you know,
- 7:56it's not about getting as many barrels out of the ground as
- 7:58humanly possible. It's about doing it in a way
- 8:00that is beneficial to businesses but most importantly the
- 8:04Exchequer, right? So it, it did hinge greatly on
- 8:08this, this idea of, well, how much oil and gas is there?
- 8:11How economic is it to produce it?
- 8:13What is the oil price? And I guess that that might be
- 8:16the point of contention. The, you know, there might be
- 8:20room for for debate. Maybe someone's going to say no,
- 8:23the High Court got it wrong. Look, we can run the numbers
- 8:25again. This is this is beyond my pay
- 8:28grade to to speculate on, but the the according to novel, this
- 8:32was really kind of one of the first tests of the Nstas
- 8:36position as having to, you know, maximize the economic recovery.
- 8:39I'll make sure that I'm saying economic recovery that this
- 8:44might, like you said, this might open up other cases similar to
- 8:48this where and as you point out that a lot of the big players
- 8:51have been looking to, to pull out.
- 8:54And I think the sort of the best case scenario was OK, these
- 8:57these companies pull out. Smaller players can, can still
- 9:00thrive in this ecosystem as as we produce, you know, the sort
- 9:04of the like, I don't want to say the last of it.
- 9:06There's still oil and gas out there, but.
- 9:09But yeah, this is this is the direction that the the North Sea
- 9:11has been going for the past decade or so, right?
- 9:14It's, it's been a case of the, the big players have had the big
- 9:18wins, your US majors, your Chevron's, your exons, your, you
- 9:22know, your US majors, your shells, your BP's, they're kind
- 9:27of like, well, we've got what we want, let's maybe start looking
- 9:31elsewhere. And then that allows your
- 9:35Cerakos and inquests to to sort of come in and jump on what's
- 9:41what's left. The stuff that maybe the majors
- 9:43go, well, it's a bit too small fry for us, but for a smaller
- 9:46company, that's still a major discovery.
- 9:48It's something that they can turn around or they can buy
- 9:51aging assets and sort of flip them.
- 9:53That's something that Sarah has kind of made its, its business
- 9:56keys on is buying old assets and sort of, you know, maintaining
- 10:00them and you know, so getting them to a place where they're
- 10:04profitable. It's very interesting to see
- 10:07like say that sort of these hubs can kind of just be done away
- 10:10with. And you know, Total obviously
- 10:13operates sort of are in Shetland and there's a lot of a lot of
- 10:17production that sort of goes through Total assets.
- 10:21Let's see what happens. Yeah.
- 10:23Is it a case that instead of, you know, this sort of narrative
- 10:26that we're hoping for the, you know, smaller pair coming the
- 10:29the Super majors are essentially pulling up the ladder a little
- 10:32bit The as the, you know, the vital infrastructure goes that,
- 10:37yeah, the smaller players are kind of left out.
- 10:40And I, I know the Nobel of, you know, I think in their statement
- 10:43they're like, we're we're reviewing what to do next.
- 10:45But in previous comments, you know, I think we've got quotes
- 10:48from them that they have said that theoretically this could
- 10:51see them quitting the North Sea, that, you know, we might see the
- 10:55similar players end up leaving on on the basis of other moves.
- 11:00That's that's quite interesting. I think it's one that we're
- 11:02going to have to keep an eye on. You know, let's, let's see if if
- 11:05Noble decided to up their, their price, the 2 lbs for Griffin
- 11:11that maybe that'll make a make a difference for total.
- 11:14Who knows. But like I say, this is a story.
- 11:16It's going to keep going and going and going, much like solar
- 11:21and how it's rolling out across the UK.
- 11:24Join us after this break as Floyd dives into that.
- 12:04So Floyd, you're making your energy voice out loud debut.
- 12:08We're speaking about solar, which is something that it, it
- 12:12feels like it's just going to keep hauling up, I guess, if you
- 12:15pardon the pun. I don't know.
- 12:16Is, is that a pun? I don't really know.
- 12:18But you've been looking at foreign ownership, which is
- 12:21something that which has been speaking about the North Sea.
- 12:24It's something that, you know, people have spoken about there
- 12:26in the past. And you know, when terabytes
- 12:28have also got that that concern, why are people worried about
- 12:32solar farms being bought by foreign investors?
- 12:37Well, I mean, for me as a Lincolnshire lad, it's kind of a
- 12:40tale as old as time for Lincolnshire, really.
- 12:43Whether it's a pylon, solar, any, any form of building that
- 12:48seems to be, you know, tons and tons of protests against it.
- 12:51It's like the the final evolution of Nimbism is, is
- 12:54based in Lincolnshire. If any Pokémon fans out there,
- 12:57you know, but yeah, but yeah, Lincolnshire is a hotspot at the
- 13:03moment, especially for solar, mainly because there's there's
- 13:08eleven major solar farms expected across Lincolnshire,
- 13:12one of the biggest over 1200 hectares.
- 13:15So, you know, not small projects, the mammoth tasks, but
- 13:19effectively this this week I found just scrolling social
- 13:22media really an independent counsellor in Lincolnshire,
- 13:26Marianna Roberton, denounced that the handing over of English
- 13:31farmland to global investors, which is the the new NIMBY line
- 13:37really in the sector. But I'll go into that a little
- 13:40bit later. But yeah, effectively she's
- 13:43claimed that Lincoln is no longer going to be in control of
- 13:46its own lands, primarily because the land can be sold off at any
- 13:51point in in the solar development.
- 13:53So you say like EDF might, might start the project, but it could,
- 13:56it could be sold off anywhere. So, so the main concern at the
- 14:00moment across Lincolnshire seems to be the fact that that lands
- 14:03been taken that could be used for farming effectively.
- 14:07And obviously Nsips don't don't help with that.
- 14:09That's quite interesting because you know, on the on the
- 14:11ownership side of things, I guess, I guess an argument
- 14:14against that would be, I mean, it could be a British
- 14:16corporation that buys the the land and you still don't get a
- 14:19say over it because it's their land there, right.
- 14:22Yeah. But I completely understand
- 14:24that, you know, we've spoken about it before.
- 14:26It was sort of foreign, foreign ownership of say wind turbines
- 14:29and wind farms. And it is it is a concern of
- 14:33like, well, shouldn't this sort of economic benefit be gone
- 14:36straight into British companies and various, various arguments.
- 14:39But it's interesting this kind of farmland discussion as well,
- 14:42because obviously the UK can't grow in size.
- 14:46You know, we have a finite amount of land.
- 14:49And so if it need, if it's needed for farming, that makes
- 14:52sense. I guess the argument is, is this
- 14:56land being used for farming because farming is not a new
- 14:59industry. It's not like people are going,
- 15:01Oh yeah, I should get into that. Like, you know, exactly.
- 15:05Are these fields being used already and or is that something
- 15:09that you know, or is it something that, you know, there
- 15:12was? So are we Farmer John, as you
- 15:14know, trying to try to buy the land but EDF and the like are
- 15:18just betting more money for it or what's what's the deal?
- 15:21A little bit of both across the projects, but obviously farming
- 15:24is huge in Lincolnshire as well. So you know, if there's land
- 15:28that hasn't been used for farming, now you know, there's
- 15:30an argument for, well would it ever have been, you know, that
- 15:33the heartland of Lincolnshire is farming.
- 15:36Then equally, you know, some farmers have sold their farmland
- 15:39to the developers. So, you know, that's their
- 15:40choice. You know, if they own the lands
- 15:42they can, they can move it on. But then I'm sure there are some
- 15:45that maybe could, could still be used.
- 15:47There's plenty of room in Lincolnshire, plenty of flat
- 15:50fields talking about. So although these these projects
- 15:53are on a huge scale, you know, 1200 hectares is, is a lot of
- 15:58land. But yeah, I did a bit of digging
- 16:00because obviously this was just a quote from a Lincolnshire
- 16:02councillor. So of the 11 major farms planned
- 16:07in the county, over 50% are wholly or jointly owned by
- 16:11overseas companies and that includes France, Denmark and
- 16:14Canada through you know EDF, France or STED and Canadian
- 16:18Solar. So 50% is quite a lot.
- 16:21But then through the planning Institute, I did go on to have a
- 16:23look at UK based company involvement and every project
- 16:28has some form of involvement either wholly or jointly through
- 16:33a joint ventures with those overseas companies.
- 16:37So in terms of like British solar phones for British people,
- 16:41I guess is the tagline for this, you know, there's still a lot of
- 16:44British involvement. So on, on terms of like, you
- 16:47know, just selling off the land to all the developers for me,
- 16:51probably, probably quite minimal.
- 16:53I'm getting the vibe from you, Floyd, that you seem to think
- 16:57that this, this argument from this independent counsellor
- 16:59isn't maybe as substantial as they're letting on.
- 17:04Is that Is that how you feel? Yeah, definitely.
- 17:08And I think that the messaging from councillors has changed
- 17:12since like 2008 ish when Nsips, you know, were first around.
- 17:17So local councils have less say on big infrastructure projects.
- 17:21In the case of solar, over 50 megawatts, it then goes to
- 17:24central government for a consent order.
- 17:27So in the past councillors, you know, they could, they could
- 17:31whip up enough people to block something.
- 17:33It happens a lot in the housing sector and that was quite a
- 17:36successful, you know, tactic for them for for good and for bad.
- 17:41You know, in some, some cases developments weren't great, but
- 17:45in but in this case, because they have less of a say.
- 17:48I feel like the the messaging, especially in Lincolnshire as
- 17:52how to evolve to, to kind of get all the people on side and try
- 17:56and send that message to central government that the farms, you
- 17:59know, are wanted. So yeah, I guess there's kind of
- 18:02what's prompting the the evolution from the yeah, but not
- 18:06in my backyard, the Nimbyism to you know, you know, from that
- 18:09sort of classic argument of it's ruining our landscape to but
- 18:14it's foreign owned and it should be.
- 18:15Ours, you see. That sort of the thing that's
- 18:18fueling this change. Yeah, definitely.
- 18:21I think it's come at kind of a time where net zero has become
- 18:26like the next divisive topic, you know, you know, is climate
- 18:31change real? Isn't it real?
- 18:32There's there was like a consensus for a while it seemed
- 18:35like you in the last parliament there was cross party support
- 18:38for for most net 0 development. So, so I think, you know, one of
- 18:44the most divisive tactics is just like the whole like
- 18:46sovereignty debate. You know, we've, we had it with
- 18:49a Brexit referendum. We've had it since.
- 18:51I feel like that that might be, you know, a way that some of
- 18:54these councillors are seeing, seeing the way in.
- 18:57But but it is worth caveating that Marianne has accepted that
- 19:02climate change is real. She's she's not against solar
- 19:06farms, she just doesn't think that they should be in
- 19:09Lincolnshire. It's quite interesting, I
- 19:11suppose with the with the advent of GB Energy, you know, it's
- 19:16kind of when, when all in on solar, you know, its first
- 19:20investment was rooftop solar across, you know, hospitals and
- 19:24schools and various other buildings.
- 19:27So it's clearly showing support. So maybe that could also be a
- 19:32incentive for them to look at solar farms and sort of this,
- 19:37this sort of scale rather than just rooftop.
- 19:40I don't know if they've said anything about that.
- 19:42Michael, you've spoken to Dan McGrail a couple of times.
- 19:44Is he, is he keen for Lincolnshire solar farms?
- 19:47Did he mention them? Was he going?
- 19:49I really want to set up in the Northwest.
- 19:52I'm afraid I can't really. Yes, he's absolutely frothing
- 19:55mad for them. He.
- 19:56Loves. I could give you exclusive news
- 19:59that Dan McGrail is planning on paving Lincolnshire with Solar
- 20:02France. I'm afraid that I could probably
- 20:04speak for him and say no comment just just now.
- 20:07I think we've we've spoken to him and I think you know the,
- 20:11what was it we? What was that wonderful headline
- 20:14you came up with? Up for anything.
- 20:15GB Energy is up for anything. Yeah, I'm, I'm, I'm still, I, I
- 20:20haven't heard from Dan since that.
- 20:22And I'm hoping that means that he's not mad with me because I
- 20:25feel like someone would have probably, probably got in touch.
- 20:28For those that are sitting confused, Michael did an
- 20:31interview with Dan McGrail, Chief Executive, GB Energy a few
- 20:35weeks ago in which Dan said that he isn't ruling anything out and
- 20:40to be not ruling anything out, I took as he's up for anything.
- 20:44So that was my subject line for our our newsletter on that given
- 20:49morning. Yes, all there's an interesting
- 20:52development. It's something that I feel like
- 20:53again is one of these stories that are just going to keep
- 20:55progressing, progressing. Do you see this debate sort of
- 20:59being something that's going to keep coming up, Floyd?
- 21:02Yeah, I, I, I think so or, or at least the, the councillors will,
- 21:06will especially will be talking about it because they've been
- 21:10talking about for years. So we ever ever since spring,
- 21:12well, which is the 1200 hectare solar phone came about.
- 21:16They, they protested from inception.
- 21:18So I guess, you know, once, once they're all installed, maybe the
- 21:21conversation will move on to something else.
- 21:24But but yeah, I think for the meantime, it will develop.
- 21:27But one more thing that allowed on the on the NIMBY debate is
- 21:32the Springwell site is actually in my constituency back home in
- 21:38Norfolk, Stephen. And I'm a bit of a geography
- 21:41nerd and I couldn't point on the map where this big solar farm is
- 21:45going to be. So I think it's going to be very
- 21:48much out of sight, out of mind once, you know, there's no more
- 21:50news on the development. And once it once it's built, I
- 21:53think people are just going to move on with their lives.
- 21:56I always try and bring up HS2 in these kind of debates.
- 22:00You know, everyone told us about the cost of HS2, how long it's
- 22:03going to be in environmental impacts, but how many people
- 22:05talk about HS one anymore? You know, once it's built, you
- 22:10know, it's out out of mind. So I think it will die down in
- 22:13the end when when people see or when they know these farms are
- 22:17are out there and generating electricity and it's not made
- 22:21any impact on the lives. I think maybe the conversation
- 22:24will die down for a little bit. Maybe I'm being optimistic.
- 22:28I, I guess the, the argument for domestic solar farms is that
- 22:32energy security angle that we keep hearing come up time and
- 22:35time again. And it's a good job we're
- 22:37touching on that because after this break, we're going to be
- 22:39speaking a little bit more about energy security as Centrica has
- 22:43been making some moves. So the morning of this podcast
- 23:43record just Concentrica likes to keep us on our toes.
- 23:46The firm announced that it had bought the Isle of Green LNG
- 23:50terminal. Now this is Europe's largest LNG
- 23:54terminal. It has the capacity to process
- 23:57around 50 million tonnes of gas annually.
- 24:00That's about the equivalent of 20% of the UK's demand.
- 24:06And as as promised, we are touching on that energy security
- 24:11angle because that's what Centrica CEO Chris O'Shea is
- 24:15really begging up. He is claiming that it will
- 24:19support the UK's energy security for many decades to come.
- 24:24Now. This, this is obviously sort of
- 24:28a big debate right now. We've, we've spoken about it
- 24:30sort of time and time again on the build up to the COVID
- 24:34pandemic. The big, the big talking point
- 24:37around energy in the UK was about reducing carbon emissions
- 24:41and ensuring that we're, you know, on that pathway to net
- 24:45zero. And then coming out of COVID and
- 24:48the invasion of Ukraine and various other geopolitical
- 24:52changes meant that we were, we were now speaking quite a lot
- 24:56about energy security. And that's become something
- 24:59that's become a means the talking point ever since.
- 25:03And it's it remains to be so. And you know, Centrica really
- 25:06seems to be hooking itself into this.
- 25:09But I always sort of take this with a little pinch of salt
- 25:13because let's face it, Centrica was also threatening to close
- 25:17close rough its gas storage facility just a few months ago
- 25:22if it didn't receive as our government, government support
- 25:27and the the right policy that it was looking for.
- 25:31To me, my immediate reaction to this is probably more the, you
- 25:35know, the RNS update suggested that this could add around £100
- 25:40million in EBITDA to the firm. And just like just a few weeks
- 25:46ago, we saw that Centrico was reporting a bit of a slump in,
- 25:49in its earnings before tax. And you know, I think we saw
- 25:52about £500 million slump from about 1.4 billion year on year
- 25:58to about 900 million. So a bit, a bit of a fall in the
- 26:03first half of the year. This is obviously going to add
- 26:06to the balance book. This is obviously going to help
- 26:08shareholders. They're going to be chuffed to
- 26:10bets, but you know, the, the energy security angle was
- 26:15something that I kind of latched on to him.
- 26:16So obviously this is what they're saying because it makes
- 26:19you sound better than saying it's going to make us festivals
- 26:22of cash. But obviously that's what
- 26:25companies are there to do. You can't really sort of blame
- 26:28them for that, you know, when it's being done responsibly.
- 26:32And LNG is definitely something that, you know, the, the gas
- 26:35sector at least says we we desperately, desperately need
- 26:39for for years and years to come. So Michael, you've, you've been
- 26:44with the publication away while Centrica, we've kept a close eye
- 26:47on them. Did this come as a bit of a
- 26:51surprise to you or do you feel like, much like I did, it's it's
- 26:54a way to sort of balance the books a little bit, try to sort
- 26:58of boost those earnings? I mean, I, I fully agree with
- 27:02you there. I mean, we look at, you know,
- 27:04they've taken a stake size. We'll see that, you know, I
- 27:10think they're, they do seem to be on a bit of a, an acquisition
- 27:13spree. Well, maybe not quite a spree to
- 27:16to make a Spree acquisition duo. Yeah, I think that probably
- 27:21makes more sense. Like you need to get up to 4 for
- 27:23a spree. But definitely there, I think
- 27:25there's a feeling that, you know, I'll go out and see it.
- 27:29We sat on our hands for for too long when it comes to a lot of
- 27:32EU KS energy infrastructure. And now we are playing catch up
- 27:36that there is definitely a sense that a new phase of the the UK's
- 27:41energy infrastructure is coming and I guess Centrica is sitting
- 27:44there going well, we should be making some money off of that.
- 27:47And so obviously nuclear that's being pushed as a big thing.
- 27:51So hence they've got that gas. It's interesting that they're
- 27:54pushing the energy security angle because I was very much of
- 27:57the impression that energy security is probably getting
- 28:00away from gas that. I think it depends on who you
- 28:04ask, right? Because if you ask the likes of
- 28:07OEUK, they would argue that energy security is producing oil
- 28:11and gas within the UK rather than sort of looking overseas.
- 28:16But then you've got to always add the caveat to that, that gas
- 28:19is sold on an international market.
- 28:20There's no guarantee that the the product that was produced
- 28:23here is going to stay here, that type of thing.
- 28:26I know Stuart Payne, as CEO of the NSDA has previously said,
- 28:30yeah, well, that's kind of true. We might produce oil or gas here
- 28:34and it might go elsewhere, especially in the form of oil.
- 28:37We might sell it overseas, but that's to then be refined that
- 28:40it comes back in the form of a different product, you know.
- 28:42So you might might produce oil and, you know, West of Shetland.
- 28:46And then it said that after refinery in Europe for it to
- 28:49come back as petrol for British cars or whatever it might be.
- 28:52So it's all about of a multifaceted debate.
- 28:56Can we on a technological level start stamping every methane
- 29:00molecule with all Union Jack so we can guarantee 100% British
- 29:05produced hydrocarbons? But yeah, the yeah, there's
- 29:08definitely the bit around the position of gas in in the energy
- 29:12security mix, but it's definitely an LNG import
- 29:14terminal that that is there for the purpose of bringing in the
- 29:19gas that we can't, we aren't slash can't produce ourselves.
- 29:24So being the, you know, let's be fair, the when we talk about
- 29:27energy security, the risk to energy security has a name and
- 29:32that's Vladimir Putin that we want to be not beholden to, to
- 29:38Russian oil and gas supplies. You know, I don't think we're,
- 29:40we're sitting there going, oh, we can't trust those Norwegians.
- 29:43They're going to start leveraging their, their power
- 29:46to, to take over. It is a case that, you know,
- 29:50like I said, really sat on our our hands, you know, Russia to
- 29:54Crimea back in 2014. We kind of knew what was on the
- 29:57the agenda. So yeah, there's the bit me that
- 30:00looks and goes, OK, well, where's an LNG terminal in
- 30:04energy security? Yeah, it's definitely a point
- 30:08worth mentioning. And like especially, you know,
- 30:10but you know, you mentioned size will see obviously they've made
- 30:13that investment there which is producing, you know, producing
- 30:16energy within the UK for UK homes and various other things.
- 30:21And they also pointed to that and said, you know, it
- 30:24demonstrates the attractiveness of the UK as an investment
- 30:28location was exactly what they commented this morning and the
- 30:32stock market update. But yeah, if you're going to
- 30:35pick up that energy security thing while also we'll also
- 30:40speaking about potentially decommissioning rough, it feels
- 30:44almost like, well, you can't have you can't have your cake
- 30:46and eat it too, right. So they said that the reason
- 30:49they've been able to make these dual investments recently was
- 30:53due to supportive government investment policies.
- 30:57But you know, clearly those investment policies aren't doing
- 31:01too well for Rough. And that then throws up
- 31:04questions about you were speaking about is gas energy
- 31:07security compared to sort of renewables.
- 31:10And you know, gruff has got this this plant and started doing
- 31:14hydrogen storage. But if you're going to decom the
- 31:17facility again, because bearing in mind that, you know, only
- 31:21sprung up back into action a couple of years ago, you're kind
- 31:25of then raising a question around, you know, well, as is,
- 31:31is energy security the heart of this or is it making money?
- 31:34And of course it is making money.
- 31:36And that's not to say that Chris O'Shea and Co aren't also
- 31:40passionate about energy security and helping helping the UK's or
- 31:43remain independent and sort of shield itself from foreign
- 31:47influence like say the the invasion of Ukraine and the
- 31:51disruption that had to the global gas and oil distribution
- 31:54network. But at the end of the day, it
- 31:58does it felt a little bit maybe to me a little bit and
- 32:02hypocritical to be saying or doing this for energy security.
- 32:06But don't look at rough because, you know, we, we aren't getting
- 32:09the government money we want or we're not getting the the
- 32:12government support we want to keep that going.
- 32:14And. I appreciate that there is
- 32:16security and diversity and that's the advantage of an LNG
- 32:19terminal that you can literally get gas from anywhere that offer
- 32:23that has a gasification terminal of its own.
- 32:26So, you know, it means that we can go to international markets
- 32:31in a pinch that there it removes the idea that some, you know,
- 32:34someone whose name is starts with AB and has AP somewhere.
- 32:38That was a terrible the VP yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 32:43He can't literally just turn a big valve, which is I'm sure how
- 32:47how things work that we can get gas anywhere.
- 32:51But yeah, it definitely feels the compared to developing
- 32:57renewables to compared to developing North Sea oil,
- 33:00compared to nuclear, that yeah, it feels like an LNG terminal is
- 33:05a relatively minor player on the the CHE relatively minor piece
- 33:11on the chess board of energy security.
- 33:13Took me a second to form that metaphor, but I'm glad I got
- 33:16there. We got there in the end.
- 33:17And Speaking of which, I think that brings us to an end of this
- 33:20podcast. Thank you very much, Floyd and
- 33:23Michael for joining us. We we started off on Griffin in
- 33:27North Sea production. We ended up on Vladimir Putin by
- 33:30speaking about Centrica. I don't think Chris O'Shea
- 33:33forecast that. Thank you very much for
- 33:36listening. If you'd like to hear more of
- 33:38our ramblings then you're going to have the TuneIn next week
- 33:42where I think we'll be speaking about offshore Europe as the
- 33:45biggest energy show in the UK returns to Aberdeen this
- 33:50September.