Latest / The Team House / Australian SAS Capture/Kill Missions | Ben McKelvey | Ep. 271
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today
- 0:03about a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already,
- 0:07we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple
- 0:10or Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get
- 0:15recognized, and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really
- 0:18appreciate your support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is
- 0:23to become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five
- 0:28dollars a month, and when you sign up, you get access to all
- 0:32of our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean,
- 0:36we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, but this is
- 0:41the biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if
- 0:47you'd like to, and we really appreciate that. So go and check us
- 0:51out at patreon dot com. Slash the Teamhouse, Special Operations, Cobert as
- 1:03Spionage, The Team House with Your Hopes. Jack Murphy and David Park.
- 1:17Hey, folks, welcome to episode two hundred and seventy one of the Team
- 1:19House. I'm Jack Murphy here with Dave Park. Tonight on the show,
- 1:23we have Ben McKelvey. He is the author of Find Fixed Finish. He's
- 1:29also the author of Missoul and the Commando. We're going to be mostly talking
- 1:33about this book tonight, which is about the Australian Special Air Service Regiment,
- 1:38some heroic actions that they took, and also some allegations of war crimes that
- 1:45we're going to go deep into. Right before we get into that, I
- 1:48just want to give a shout out to our Patreon and i'd ask you know,
- 1:53folks out there listening or viewing this, click the link down in the
- 1:57description for our Patreon and consider sponsoring the show. Supporting the channel, you
- 2:01get access to all of these episodes ad free when you sign up, and
- 2:05we really appreciate you guys helping this thing keep chugging along. So thank you
- 2:10Ben, Thanks for coming on the show. Man. I guess how I
- 2:14am doing? Real good early morning there in Australia. Yeah, it's a
- 2:22beautiful autumnal day Bunda Beach. It's sunny and gorgeous. So Ben, before
- 2:28we get into the book, I want to ask you a little bit about
- 2:30your background, how you came into journalism, how you came in specifically into
- 2:36you know, Australian military national security journalism. Yeah. I actually just wrote
- 2:42a book about how I got into journalism and how I got into that national
- 2:46security stuff. I had a phasic stroke when I was when I was twenty
- 2:51seven, so I was working in a magazine and I was boxing at the
- 2:54time, and then all of a sudden, I couldn't speak. I couldn't
- 3:00you know, comprehend language, couldn't read, couldn't write, went to hospital,
- 3:06had a sort of you know recovery of a number of months, you
- 3:08know, going back into you know, comic books and young adult novels and
- 3:14you know, like really sort of language skills. And then I had done
- 3:20all that, and I was sort of conceiving a life outside of the journalism
- 3:24life that I already had. I was working at a men's magazine. I
- 3:28was having a lot of fun with my friends. I had actually done a
- 3:30little bit of work with the Commandos. I'd gone and done their barrier test
- 3:34for a story, and then I'd also done a sort of exercise with them
- 3:38and the Incident Response Regiment which was later so the Special Operations Engineering Regiment,
- 3:45and I'd gone to East or in an MBED and I've done a few little
- 3:46bits and pieces, but that's what I really wanted to do. And eventually
- 3:52I petitioned to the Australian Defense Force to go to Iraq with them as an
- 3:55embed. And then while I was waite on that on that that request,
- 4:02which I thought was a hail Mary given where I was working, what I
- 4:06was doing, I had a heart attack and it was a stemy heart attack.
- 4:12So that was kind of like a pretty serious incident. And I had
- 4:15to have some open heart surgeries afterwards. And and then I recovered from the
- 4:20last surgery and I was, you know, I'm I'm ninety six kilos or
- 4:26something. I was, I was in the sixties. After the surgery,
- 4:28you know, I was, I was thin and ill and couldn't even walk
- 4:31up my street. And then I got an emar from the Defense Force saying
- 4:34okay, come to a rock, you know, in a few weeks time,
- 4:39and I went to my cardiology. I went to my surgeon and said,
- 4:44you know, I thought he was going to tell me you can't do
- 4:46this, and he's like, live your life, you know, which is
- 4:49a very sort of surgeon attitude. They're like that pic shit, like my
- 4:54work is good. You got to a rack, and then that sort of
- 4:58started it for me. I went to a rock, and then independently I
- 5:00worked as a freelancer and went through around in Syria and Afghanistan for other bits
- 5:03and pieces, and then I worked. The thing that really accelerated me in
- 5:11that space was working on a biography of Cameron Baird, who you're aware of,
- 5:15Jack, Yeah, yeah, how did you know? How did you
- 5:18know of Cam or did you know Caim? Did you have any interactions with
- 5:21him? No? I never met him. I knew of him through some
- 5:25of his teammates and people and the commandos who knew him, and they told
- 5:29me stories about how he'd camo up like the incredible hawk, and like he
- 5:33was big about charging out there and wanted the enemy to see him and shoot
- 5:38at him so he could shoot back, like just like a larger than life
- 5:41kind of figure. He really was. I remember one of the first interviews
- 5:45that I did with one of his CEOs was he always knew when they got
- 5:48out of the helicopters, which one was Betty, because no soldiers were sort
- 5:53of moving forward in a relatively uniform fashion. And then Betty was just like
- 5:56yoah off being a bullet magnet, you know. But yeah, there was
- 6:04this, you know, the Special Operations Task Group, which was Australia's a
- 6:11special forces commitment to the war in Afghanistan was large and very kinetic, but
- 6:17not known about much in Australia at all. No one had been embedded with
- 6:21the Special Forces. We had this protected identity status law, meaning that they
- 6:27couldn't legally speak to journalists about what they were doing. And that was the
- 6:30commandos and the SASR meaning and SOA and you know everybody else associated. So
- 6:36there was really a dearth of information as to what the Australians had been doing
- 6:41in her as Again. And then when I got the contract to do the
- 6:44book about Cameron Baird, the posthumous book about Cameron bird Did being killed in
- 6:48combat. I went to Holsworthy and started interviewing the guys and I was completely
- 6:55shocked, you know, I just had I had no idea. I kind
- 7:00of felt that I had sort of been paying attention to what had been happening
- 7:04in the war in Afghanistan, and it was it was a completely different story.
- 7:08And you know, that was a thread that I sort of pulled and
- 7:10pulled and pulled and had been doing that all the way to find fixed finish.
- 7:15So you feel that the Australian people were fairly naive about the intensity of
- 7:19the combat that their soldiers were getting into. Yeah, I mean not just
- 7:24that, you know, there was there was there was a failure not only
- 7:28within the public, but you know, on a political level to understand just
- 7:32the basic tenor of the conflict. I mean, even now, you know,
- 7:35my pet Peeve is there'll be a news report about the commandos on the
- 7:40drug job that they had done. You know, a historical news report might
- 7:43be related to war crimes or something else. And then uniformly, when they're
- 7:47talking about a gunfight, they they referred to the Afghanis as Taliban, and
- 7:51you know, sometimes they were finding the Taliban and sometimes they weren't. You
- 7:56know, it was it just I knew so little. I realized when I
- 8:00started that book that I knew so little, and that meant that most people
- 8:03in Australia knew so little about about the conflict that you know, we'd we'd
- 8:07sort of been heavily involved in and we only sort of understood after the fact.
- 8:13I'm just curious for you because we've talked to American journalists too, were
- 8:18in Badge with US sports is. How were you received when you first showed
- 8:22up. What was your relationship like with not only the command structures but the
- 8:28individual soldiers themselves. I think I was received better than most because on my
- 8:35body armor I just slapped a Ralph sticker which had a you know, so
- 8:39a half naked woman on the sticker, and soldiers almost uniformly had Ralph posters,
- 8:46you know, in tanks and you know, on their lines and you
- 8:50know, so, yeah, journalists from you know, ABC or two GB
- 8:54or something that they don't really give a ship but it's like, oh,
- 8:56it's the Ralph guy. It's like, I know what that outlet is,
- 9:01you know. So, so I the story that I ended up doing.
- 9:03I did a piece for Ralph and then I did a piece for the West
- 9:05Australian newspaper and a piece for The Bulletin, which was Australia's version of Newsweek
- 9:11at the time. You know, I did a piece that was really a
- 9:16soldier's view of things, which up to find fixed finish was was sort of
- 9:22the way that I operated was from the perspective of a soldier who's on the
- 9:26ground, you know, because I want to know what they know and then
- 9:30maybe I'll bring in some information about, you know, contextually where they are.
- 9:33But that's where I really started from a from a biography background, and
- 9:37that that was my perspective up until Fine Fixed Finish. So to jump into
- 9:41find Fixed Finish, if you can take us a little bit back in time
- 9:46to a little history lesson that you write about in your book about there's this
- 9:52large span of time for the Special Air Service regiment between the Vietnam conflict where
- 9:56they served, and the Global War on Tarer or could you tell us about
- 10:01the sort of like pre Global War on Terror Special Air Service, what their
- 10:05mission was, what their culture was, and then weading us into the Tampa.
- 10:11Yeah, well, in Vietnam they had sort of earned this monika,
- 10:16the ghosts of the Jungle. You know, they were sort of you know,
- 10:20there were special Forces as you would understand them to be. They'd sort
- 10:22of they disappear and reappear and you know, and kill and no one and
- 10:28know where they've been, and you know, they really kind of had this
- 10:31this sort of dangerous kinetic mission. And then after Vietnam there was a defense
- 10:37white paper, an Australian Defense White Paper, which is kind of a big
- 10:41deal. It only happens every you know, sort of ten to fifteen years
- 10:43or something, and I think the guy's numbers. Paul did wrote this white
- 10:48paper about the defense of Australia, and there was a structure of the Australian
- 10:52Defense Force that was dedicated on the defense of Australia, which it seems sort
- 10:58of you know, obvious and and it sort of makes sense, but that
- 11:03meant that we didn't have much capacity for force projection and within a Defense of
- 11:07Australia structure, the SAS would sort of primarily be engaged with during guerrilla warfare
- 11:13and Northern Australia, which is not particularly populated, and there was even a
- 11:18program where they were working with Indigenous Australians to do demolitions and things like that.
- 11:26Yeah, there's still a group up there called nor Force that they get
- 11:30guys who're sort of traditional owners of land and then engage them to you knows,
- 11:35to work in commns or in demolitions. Yeah, that's right for guys
- 11:39who really understand the really uninhabited areas of Australia. So the sa SR that
- 11:46that ended up becoming their job. But you know, there was outside of
- 11:50a few little missions, you know, they ease team or there was a
- 11:54time where they were like seriously engaged. But but they you know, one
- 11:56of the quotes in the book is that they just spend a lot of time
- 11:58wondering and the desert, counting train cars. You know, they'd sort of
- 12:03secrete themselves in a position and watch a train go by, and then you
- 12:05come back and that'd be there, you know, because there are mean mission
- 12:09at the time was strategic reconnaissance. Yeah, basically that's right in Australia as
- 12:16well, which is a large empty place. So you know, it just
- 12:18meant it just meant being really good at being out for a long time and
- 12:22then coming back and coming back with information or you know, or whatever one
- 12:28of the job was at the time. But the guys who were within the
- 12:31regiment, there was a lot of people who who you know, it just
- 12:35wasn't it wasn't an engaging role for them, you know, it was it
- 12:39was sort of preparing for something that they thought probably was never going to happen,
- 12:41and it wasn't a it wasn't a particularly explosive job. But then Tampa
- 12:50happened. So Tampa was Tampa was a ship that came into nearly came into
- 12:56Australian waters with a lot of refugees. So refugees and they were mostly Afghan
- 13:01had come on an Indonesian fishing vessel to try and come to Australia illegally,
- 13:09and then their ship started to sink and they put out an SOS call and
- 13:13then the Tampa came and rescued them, and then a lot of them were
- 13:16sick. So you know, the law of the sea is that they need
- 13:18to be they need to be brought to Australia. So they've been given to
- 13:22be given medical treatment. But there was a lot of political doing and throwing
- 13:28at the moment then and actually at the moment about illegal migrants coming into Australia,
- 13:35and they had set up a policy where they weren't going to let anyone
- 13:39come into Australia. So when Tampa, when the Tampa decided that they were
- 13:43going to come to Christmas Island, which is a territory in Australia, the
- 13:48government told them they couldn't, and then there ended up being this stand up
- 13:52and then the Sas were actually sent to storm the ship because erroneously there were
- 14:00reports that, you know, some of the refugees I don't think of the
- 14:05report that they were armed, but that they might have been dangerous, and
- 14:07you know, they all had gastro and they were all lying on the deck
- 14:09and they're all exhausted and sick, and they've been at sea for weeks and
- 14:13weeks. So the Essas end up storming Tampa, and there was some leaked
- 14:16photos and video of it, and it all looked very very dramatic. But
- 14:22in the book I sort of mark that as the moment where the SAS to
- 14:26a certain extent became a political tool, because only a few weeks later nine
- 14:30to eleven happened, And as soon as nine to eleven happened, the guys
- 14:33at Campbell Barracks where the SAS started preparing for a mission to go into Afghanistan,
- 14:39and they were one of the one of the first forces after the Marines
- 14:43secured I can't remember which basically is. I'm sure you guys remember was it
- 14:48Bagroom or Kanda horror? No, it was in Kandaha. Yeah, okay,
- 14:52Well, talk to us a little bit about the early g y years
- 14:56in Afghanistan where the Special Air Service really did some quality work in my opinion
- 15:01based on what I read in your book. Yeah, I mean basically they
- 15:05would they would, like you said, they were doing reconnaissance, and you
- 15:09know, they they would. There were a few instances where they would.
- 15:13They were working with the Marines, primarily with the Mathis, and he really
- 15:22loved their work because they would go out for such a long time. You
- 15:26know, they would have reconnaissance teams that go out for you know, I
- 15:30come ten twenty days and I think some of the SASL teams went out for
- 15:33fifty or sixty days in these sort of open top vehicles in the freezing cold,
- 15:37you know. But they were so happy to get the work that they
- 15:39were just meant, they were happy to you know, to just keep going
- 15:43and going. And then they they had done a lot of instances where they
- 15:46had identified targets, sat there, waited, looked at the pattern of life,
- 15:52send all the information back and then there were either strikes or there weren't
- 15:54strikes, or you know, a larger force would come in and prosecute the
- 15:58targets. And they had done all that and then they were they were given
- 16:03a role that ended up being ended up being relatively integral in Operation Anaconda and
- 16:11you know where Robert's Ridge and all of that activity happened. But the primary
- 16:18Australian force was working was working as a as a blocking force with other international
- 16:23special forces. But there was one team that was in this position that was
- 16:29just sort of perfect for bringing in air and ordinance and they did that day
- 16:33after day after day after day after day, you know, without without having
- 16:37any direct confrontation with the enemy, but bringing in this ordinance. But that
- 16:42was at the time a sort of perfect essay as mission. You know,
- 16:47that's that's what they were really good at and they they had executed that really
- 16:51well. But that sort of mission moves on because technology moves on, you
- 16:56know, with with with drones and the sort of satellite technology that we have
- 16:57now it's you don't need as much of that. So then their their capabilities
- 17:03and their missions changed. And so with with that, if we we fast
- 17:08forward a few years, well is it ers Gan Province? Uh yeah,
- 17:15talk to us about you know, Sasser landing in that province their first stops
- 17:23in April two thousand and six, and and then and then their their relationship
- 17:26with the Dutch who were also in charge of that sector. Yeah, I
- 17:30mean the Dutch. The Dutch came in a little later. So Australia had
- 17:34put their hand up to say that they would be part of ISA, of
- 17:37the International Security Assistant's Force, but we didn't know or the Australian government didn't
- 17:44know exactly where that force was gonna was going to end up, on what
- 17:47the composition of it was going to be. But there was there was a
- 17:51suggestion that they would go to Uruzgan, and there's a couple of quotes in
- 17:55the book about they just weren't prepared for a province Oruzgan perhaps, or that
- 18:00they didn't know necessarily what they were going into the Australian government because you know,
- 18:04Uruzgan is along with Candor Hearts, it's sort of one of the it's
- 18:10sort of one of the heartlands of the Taliban. You know, it's where
- 18:11Mulaoma was from, that's where his village is. So they sent the SASR
- 18:17into some ground truth thing and there's a story in the book about an element
- 18:22going up to the northwest corner of Uruzgan and you know, they see some
- 18:29locals and they're sort of like, hey, how are you going? And
- 18:30then all of a sudden, there's just RPGs and bullets and you know,
- 18:34these were just locals who are aggrieved with with the Australians coming into to Uruzgan.
- 18:41They ended up being this massive gun fight. You know, they ended
- 18:44up bringing in apaches, the whole thing. I mean, this is just
- 18:48meant to be a hey, hey, you gun with the locals ground truthing
- 18:51mission. And then they come back to they come back to tarran Cott and
- 18:56when they do, the Australian Defense Minister Robert Hill is there and he sees
- 18:59all the shot up vehicles and blooded soldiers. None of the Australian SASR guys
- 19:03are killed, but but there's there's a lot of injuries. Uh. And
- 19:07he has never spoken about this, but he retired from his position a few
- 19:12weeks later, and the speculation was that he he had always had an issue
- 19:18with Australia's involvement in Iraq and that he didn't think that it was within australia
- 19:23strategic interest to be involved in Iraq is my understanding, but there is speculation
- 19:30that he saw what the what the Afghan mission was going to be for the
- 19:33Australians in the in these sort of years to come, and he was perhaps
- 19:38and this is not something I did actually speak to the Prime Minister and the
- 19:41Foreign Minister at that time. It's not something that he that they would speak
- 19:45to me about. But there may have been issues within the National Security Cabinet
- 19:49as to as to whether Australia should have had that role in Afghanistan. And
- 19:53then the essays are sorry gone. I was just going to ask. I
- 19:56mean, as as things develop, you know, the says ends up in
- 20:00this capture kill mission. But the Dutch have a different approach, that's more
- 20:06hearts and minds oriented. Yeah, the Dutch, the Dutch mission was was
- 20:12very much there. There had to be a political mandate for the things that
- 20:18they were going to do, and with the way that the Dutch government was
- 20:22constructed at the time, there were a lot of left leaning government or left
- 20:26leaning parties that had influence into what was what ended up being the Dutch operations.
- 20:32So that was part of the reason why they weren't comfortable doing kill capture.
- 20:37But the other issue is that they wasn't an issue. It was a
- 20:41boon to them. They had these sort of anthropologists, They had a lot
- 20:45of people at this place called the liaison organization that were given them really great
- 20:48intel into the way that the tribal structure worked in Euroscam. And so they
- 20:55were sort of suggesting to the Dutch forces that endlessly attacking the enemies of the
- 21:02warlord that we have associated ourselves with, which was a guy called called John
- 21:08Muhammed Khan, and then a guy called back to Yola Khan afterwards he said,
- 21:11you're just going to create more conflict. And so they didn't necessarily believe
- 21:15in the American mission that was sort of maximalist and more kinetic than the Dutch
- 21:21thought it should be. And then the Australians put their hand up and they're
- 21:23like, yeah, yeah, we'll do that good. And talk to us
- 21:30a little bit about how those ops get stood up. You know, June,
- 21:37in your book June second, two thousand and six, there's an operation
- 21:40where a Special Air Service operator Ben Roberts Smith is said to kill the teenager
- 21:45during an engagement, maybe legitimately maybe not. Yeah, yeah, I mean
- 21:52that was that's the sort of integral and important moment in the history of Australia's
- 21:59engagement in Afghanistan, because this was this was the sort of combined op this
- 22:03is when they were working with with the Dutch. And the idea of that
- 22:08off was there's a valley coming into Tarankott, which is where the multinational base
- 22:12is and where the provincial capital is. But there were a lot of there
- 22:18was a lot of opposing forces. Some of them were associated with the centralized
- 22:22insurgency, but a lot of them were the enemies of this war or Jamahamad
- 22:26Khan at the time, and Shura and Baluchi came through to a place called
- 22:32Durafshan, which was sort of on the plane very close to taran Cott,
- 22:36and so you basically had this this non permissive area that was leading into the
- 22:41capitol. So the idea was that they would clear Chor out, they'd have
- 22:45this this large operation and they'd have this force pushed through all the way through
- 22:51to taran Cott and be a series of battles and they take control of this
- 22:53area, and that you know, the Afghanisa the Dutch would sort of seeze
- 22:57these areas, put up control bases and then you know, we'd have a
- 23:00permissive environment close to close to where the multinational basis and where the provincial capital
- 23:04is. Uh Incidentally, they they ended up fighting in that area consistently,
- 23:11you know, all the way through basically, you know, there were there
- 23:12were there were periods of peace and periods of war, but but it never
- 23:17ended up becoming a sort of a wholly permissive area. But Ben Robert Smith
- 23:22was sent up to be part of a patrol that was going to be doing
- 23:26an overwatch not just similar to you know, the overwatch mission that Matthew Bully
- 23:33who was the guy who was who was the patrol leader for the mission.
- 23:37Operation at a condo, not dissimilar to that, you know, center,
- 23:40hang out a little spot, see what's happening down there, send intel back,
- 23:44perhaps bring ordnance in if you have to, and then secrete your way
- 23:47back. But you know, this is the subject of a defamation case at
- 23:52the moment, so you know, we can't specifically know what happened. But
- 24:00un armed or unarmed actually I think they've agreed that it's unarmed, but may
- 24:03or may not have been a spot or a teenage kid walks across, perhaps
- 24:08preteen walks across the observation post and they decide to go and find him and
- 24:14kill him, and they do that, and then that starts an engagement and
- 24:19they have to sort of fight their way back, which they do, and
- 24:22they end up bringing in air support and you know, so the fight ends
- 24:26up, the sense of gravity of the fight ends up being at the top
- 24:29of the mountain, not down in the valley where it's meant to be.
- 24:32But depending on who you speak to, that that was sort of, you
- 24:37know, an integral and valorous moment within the sa SR, and people have
- 24:41given medals afterwards, and some people have suggested that that sort of set a
- 24:45pre cindent within the SAS be the s s R in Afghanistan, because you
- 24:49know, that was that perhaps could be seen as a strategic net negative moment,
- 24:55and yet people were people were awarded medals for it afterwards. And then
- 25:00you also, as you know, going forward a little bit in time,
- 25:06you have the creation of the Special Operations Task Force SOTG, which brings in
- 25:10the commandos. Could you talk to us a little bit about the role of
- 25:14the commandos, you know, their history, their mission, and the rift
- 25:18that developed between them and the SAS Yeah, I mean, you know,
- 25:23most of my friends are within the Commander Regiment in their space. They are
- 25:30a force, that is, they were designed to work hand in glove with
- 25:33the SASR. Probably in the way I mean you definitely not better than Eye
- 25:37in the way that the Rangers were were they meant to be a cooperative force
- 25:42with Jason. They were not initially stood up for that reason, but I
- 25:48mean they kind of became that, right, They became When you need a
- 25:52lot of manpower to do things that a small specialized unit can't do, Yeah,
- 25:57you call the Rangers. Yeah, And did they work sometimes as a
- 26:02cordon force and or or direct action and direct actually to strike strike targets that
- 26:11a small surgical, hostage rescue focused unit isn't necessarily set up for. Yeah,
- 26:15I mean it sounds like you're describing the commandos, you know, the
- 26:18commandos. There was a suggestion just before nine eleven actually that the Special Operations,
- 26:25the Australia Special Operations Command, should be expanded because of the type of
- 26:30technological innovations that had come with the type of heavy weapons that can be carried
- 26:36by by an individual, and by the type of the type of communications that
- 26:40can be used. So they thought that the force structure would benefit from having
- 26:47this sort of direct action you know, sort of hyper infantry style force that
- 26:52could work with the SASR. So they were they were starting to stood up
- 26:56be stood up around ninety nine two thousand and then two thousand and one there
- 27:00was an acceleration so they could bring the companies on board. Because they assumed
- 27:03that the commandos might be used in the future. They were sent into Iraq.
- 27:08The SASR we're doing a series of different things in the western desert of
- 27:15Iraq, including scud hunting, and the commandos were meant to be their quick
- 27:22reaction force. So they were just across the border at H two in Jordan,
- 27:26and then they were actually never used, even though there were instances where
- 27:29they could have been used. And that I think is the moment where the
- 27:32rift developed between the ss ARO and the commandos, because the SASR saw them
- 27:37as this force that couldn't be trusted to go out and to be used,
- 27:41whereas the commandos they thought they were ready, and they probably were ready.
- 27:45You know, they've been training up on this close quarter battle. They've been
- 27:49they've been stood up for a couple of years at that point, and so
- 27:53a lot of the guys within the commandos actually went off and worked as pmc's,
- 27:56you know, especially a lot of the a lot of the sort of
- 28:02junior NCOs. But then Afghanistan happened, so the Special Operations Task Groups,
- 28:07the Special Forces Task Group and then the Special Operations Task Group needed guys to
- 28:14come into a risk and so a lot of the guys who had been working
- 28:17as PMC sort of came in and that they couldn't get the two units to
- 28:22work cooperatively. There are times where they both that they were both on on
- 28:26target at the same time, but primarily they they they didn't work together.
- 28:32And part of the issue was that, you know, there were fistfights in
- 28:34the mess. There were you know, there were like people threatening to kill
- 28:38each other. You know, there were there was there was there was a
- 28:41real rancher between between those you know, there was there was a lot of
- 28:45fraternity between some of the some of the parts of those two of those two
- 28:48regiments, but but there was there was definitely animus as well, and I
- 28:53think part of the issue I was just going to point out. It should
- 28:56probably be mentioned also that these two units were all pitted against each other by
- 29:00the Australian military in some ways. That you have two soft units. Eventually
- 29:06they're both given the direct action mission, so they're both competing for missions which
- 29:10only I imagine escalates the animosity. No, that's right. And then if
- 29:15you look at the SASR, you know they're doing this coordinate these coordinate search
- 29:18missions, and they're doing direct action as well, and they're not necessarily designed
- 29:22for that. You know, there are the four structures that they've meant to
- 29:26be a sort of more surgical, and you are that they are Australia's elite
- 29:32unit. Whereas they're doing something that the commandos are actually kind of like perfectly
- 29:37built to do with their force structure. And so sometimes the commandos are sent
- 29:41off to do things that the essays would like to do, but they're just
- 29:44just by dint of their force structure, the commandos are better suited to do
- 29:48it. And so then that creates this incredible resentment and the SASR see them
- 29:53as the little brothers and the commandos like, you know, our guys are
- 29:56dying. Also the dose, the which one. I know you've heard that
- 30:02term, the doze, the dose, I haven't what of it? You
- 30:04haven't that the sas guys call the commando's the does the dose? Can you
- 30:10spell it out? D oees like a female deer? Oh yeah, yeah,
- 30:15the dose? Yeah, and the commandos call the SAS the poo poop
- 30:18barrows. I've heard that. I mean, it's all a little sophomoreck.
- 30:25Yes, but that's the thing fifteen years later and Sime, it's black and
- 30:30dead, you know. Yeah. Yeah, it's like it's like super serious
- 30:33stuff. Uh. And some guys did go over, you know, some
- 30:36guys do the commando it work as commandos and then do selection and go within
- 30:41the SAS. But it never really it never really disappeared the animals between the
- 30:48two units. Let's also talk a little bit at this point about some of
- 30:53the structural issues within the Australian Department of Defense. There's that's really interesting stuff
- 31:00in your book. I mean, you talk about a lot of breakdowns that
- 31:03happened, but one of them that especially strikes me is that it feels like
- 31:11at some point civilian control of the military was lost and even commanders in the
- 31:17military didn't understand what their own force was doing. Like there's one quote in
- 31:22your book where I think you said it was the commander of Australians Special Operations
- 31:26saying that capture kill missions are an invention of the media, which is either
- 31:33a lie or it just speaks to the complete obliviousness of the chain of command.
- 31:37I can answer that it's a lie, okay, I mean, it's
- 31:42a top the patrol reports. You know, it's like everybody knows the nomenclature.
- 31:48You know. The problem in Australia, I think at that time was
- 31:52that there was this culture of bullshit because Australia had to be involved in the
- 31:59war in that it was it was very important for us to be a good
- 32:04alliance partner with the US, and we always wanted to be a good alliance
- 32:07partner. We have always wanted to be a good alliance partner. Not only
- 32:12that, when you go a little bit, a little bit further down the
- 32:15command structure, there was this technology transfer and this skill transfer that was happening
- 32:19as well, because you know, we were eventually working as a sort of
- 32:22fungible software, so they were working as a fungible soft force. So they
- 32:25were sort of from a modular perspective, becoming useful within an American structure,
- 32:31which was which was good for the America. For the Australians, you know,
- 32:34they were they were up skilling very quickly. But the Australian public,
- 32:39the political class would not accept the Australians doing the things that the Americans were
- 32:45doing. You know, the major, the major thing that I sort of
- 32:52lean on from an ethical perspective in the book is that the Australians were doing
- 32:57these kill capture missions and the ROW allowed them to directly target individuals, which
- 33:05is basically an assassination without any attempt to capture, whether they're uned or unarmed.
- 33:10There is no way that that would have been accepted if a politician explained
- 33:15to the Australian public that that was what was happening in Afghanistan. So there
- 33:19had to be this sort of top level, this sort of top level layer
- 33:25of bullshit between public facing information from the highest people within government and within the
- 33:31military saying that you know, this mission is really about you know, standing
- 33:37up for an Afghan battalion, it's about protection of women's rights, it's about
- 33:40all these things. Whereas all of those strategic goals had gone in Urazgan by
- 33:45probably about two thousand and nine, you know, like it just wasn't happening.
- 33:49You know, everybody on the ground knew that wasn't happening. Correct me
- 33:52if I'm wrong, band, But in your system, there is a a
- 33:58Chief of Defense, which is a military officer, and there's a Minister of
- 34:01Defense, which is a civilian. So when the civilian is saying, I
- 34:06can't get information out of the military, I'm not getting all of the information
- 34:09I need. I don't know what's going on. Is that a lie or
- 34:12is that part of that public facing propaganda if you will. Yeah, well,
- 34:17I mean that's that's a direct quote from a defense minister who I interviewed
- 34:22for the book, and that was one of two defense ministers who told me
- 34:23that they couldn't get information from from the military, and so, you know,
- 34:28in a democracy that's completely unacceptable. But I think I think the Department
- 34:34and the ministry there were some things that they didn't want to know, so
- 34:37they had they'd sort of punted on some information. You know, they had
- 34:42empowered the military to do certain things without any understanding and oversight, and then
- 34:46when they do want information, they have already they've already created this system where
- 34:52it's difficult for the ministry to get information. So the ministry has plausible deniability
- 34:57and it's the same as the Department as well. This is this is speculation,
- 35:00but this is this is the way that this is I think one of
- 35:01the issues. So, yeah, there wasn't there was a major issue.
- 35:07There may well still be a major issue within the Australian government that there isn't
- 35:10as much civilian oversight as there should be. But to go back to my
- 35:14point of that sort of layer of bullshit that we were at the top that
- 35:17sort of dripped through all the way down to the ground. You know,
- 35:21like as long as we're already not being transparent about our strategic goals and so
- 35:27then when we're not transparent about what are what the specific types of missions are,
- 35:34and then we're not specific with patrol reporting, you know, so just
- 35:37dripped all the way down. So moving on to some some spicy content here,
- 35:45not not not particularly lawyer exactly not not not not a particularly great moment
- 35:52for the s. A S tell us about the moment that they were flying
- 35:55a swastika in Afghanistan that was actually the Mandos. Oh it was identified that
- 36:01book. Yeah, okay, thank you for for having so. Yeah,
- 36:06they were out on operations, and I mean there has been this this issue
- 36:15within I mean, the soldiers probably wouldn't necessarily said as a problem, but
- 36:20there is this sort of impunity within some certain some some of the units in
- 36:28that there were rules that were allowed to be bent and rules that were allowed
- 36:30to be broken. Like one of the obvious ones is drinking. So the
- 36:35Essay has had a bar in tarn Cott. You know, they're not meant
- 36:37to be drinking, and they have a bar, and all the generals went
- 36:39there, you know, like everybody went to the to the bar. They
- 36:42actually famously in the book one of the one of the sort of signature war
- 36:45crimes. One of the things that's being contested in this defamation case at the
- 36:51moment is whether there was an execution of a disabled Afghan who had a who
- 36:58had a prosthetic leg. Yeah, and then that ends up becoming a drinking
- 37:02vessel in the bar that the SASR had, So that was sort of allowed.
- 37:08So nobody really knew where the line was, and so somebody thought that
- 37:13the line allowed swastikas to be flat on operations. I was told by lots
- 37:19of people that it was a joke. But then I've subsequently learned that that
- 37:22guy was actually a Nazi and part of a a sort of Nazi group,
- 37:28another regiment before he came to this prest operations man. I very much doubt
- 37:31that the other guys around him, you know, were of that of that,
- 37:38but they certainly saw it. They certainly saw it. Yeah, they
- 37:43saw it. Yeah, And that one of the other issues with that photograph
- 37:45is there's a major there who ended up becoming a very senior soldier and was
- 37:51was someone who was on a track to end up being chief of chief of
- 37:52Defense. And the guys that I spoke to about that major, I said,
- 37:59well, you know, why didn't he and the men why did he
- 38:00stop him from doing it? And he's like, well, he didn't.
- 38:02Necessarily he didn't like it. He was obviously upset about it, but he
- 38:05didn't feel at the time that he could he could reign in a sergeant in
- 38:08that way, which is which is a problem that That's a perfect segue because
- 38:13I want to ask you next about officers losing control of the SAS and how
- 38:19that kind of came about. Yeah, I mean, one of the problems
- 38:22with the officers in the SAS is that they come in and out of the
- 38:25regiment, and having having a successful, successful period in the s a SR
- 38:31is hugely important for your career, especially if when you're on you know,
- 38:37on a sort of combat deployment. You know that really is your opportunity for
- 38:42advancement in Korea and and chances for medals, and you know, having that
- 38:46on your on your resume is hugely important. And within the Australian military there
- 38:52there has been a long succession of people who have gone through the sas and
- 38:57then have gone up to even to the point of ar chief are are governor
- 39:01General who's you know, the most senior person of the government is a former
- 39:06Essays officer. So it's very important for an officer to have a successful deployment.
- 39:12But if you have your your you know, your your sergeants and your
- 39:15corporals in open revolt because they're upset about the things that you're doing. And
- 39:20these are guys who have sort of set the tone and have a greater understanding
- 39:22of what the ground truth is, then that's gonna that's going to be a
- 39:27problem in your career. So that that that means that officers who want to
- 39:32go against something that may be unethical would take a massive amount of moral courage.
- 39:37You would have to go against the entire system. You know, like
- 39:39if you're out, if you the special Operations task groups are relatively small.
- 39:44So if you're an officer and you you think that one of your patrols is
- 39:47doing the wrong thing and you run them in or you bring in you know
- 39:52charges or the I G. A d F, which is basically our you
- 39:55know, our military police. To investigate these types of things, you've probably
- 40:00create a seaesops. So you might even create like a political issue, right,
- 40:05So it was it was incredibly tough for the officers to do that.
- 40:09But then before that they actually have to understand what's happening in the first place.
- 40:14So quite often they're in this sort of like overwatch position, you know,
- 40:15they're not necessarily on the ground. You know, with this defamation case,
- 40:19we had a lot of officers coming in in instances where there had been
- 40:23suspected war crimes and they're like, I don't know it blew in and there
- 40:25were some dead people. You know, what can I tell you? In
- 40:30the book, you talk about how the sas came to have a tribal culture.
- 40:35I mean, one of the operators you spoke to described it as a
- 40:37ward of the Flies culture where they were sharing kill videos with one one another,
- 40:45where there was even there's this kind of stone walling of any acknowledgment of
- 40:52PTSD within the regiment. Can tell us about how that developed. Yeah,
- 40:57that I think that quote it might actually go from the the unit psychologist of
- 41:01the s A s R. But the that that sort of linger culture,
- 41:06that's the that's how they would describe people who would suggest that they had a
- 41:09PTSD issue. A linger means that you're a malingerer, you know, so
- 41:15you're you're not taking on the duties that that you should be taking on,
- 41:19and you're you're basically letting everyone down. The the the way that it was
- 41:23described to me over and over again is like a motorcycle gang. You know,
- 41:29it's like you do not break the trust of the guys within the motorcycle
- 41:31gang. But then also coercive violence is something that that that was kind of
- 41:37enforced a certain structure there as well, So you know, guys could be
- 41:42beaten, guys could be slapped, it could be for some people it could
- 41:45feel dangerous breaking outside of that code of silence. And there was an instance
- 41:51in Australia where somebody's house got blown up because they had fallen off out of
- 41:55this this code of silence. I don't necessarily understand how it developed, but
- 42:02there were people who who sort of talked to me about coming into that that
- 42:06environment, because when you come into Campbell Barracks and you come into into the
- 42:10regiment, you know, that's that's the top of your career, whether you're
- 42:15a whether you're an operator, or whether you're an officer, or whether it's
- 42:16a physio or whatever you are. You know, especially in a in a
- 42:21time of war, you really want to do the best job, you know,
- 42:23and everybody's super intense, and you're like, that's okay, I understand
- 42:27this because this is the time of war, so I want to do the
- 42:29best job. But there were there were, like you said, there was
- 42:34this that the psychologist described it to me as a sort of tinder box ready
- 42:38to be ready to blow. You know, the fact that there were a
- 42:42lot of instances of domestic violence, a lot of people getting super drunk,
- 42:45a lot of people assaulting people at pubs, a lot of like death porn
- 42:50being shared as well, like sort of weird snuff porn, a lot of
- 42:52kill videos, a lot of photos of you know, heads being blown off
- 42:57and stuff like that. Like at some point a sort of responsible adultshire to
- 43:01come down and said, Okay, we kind of need to we need to
- 43:04clean this up for the benefit of the people who were in this structure,
- 43:07you know, not to be not to be a dick about it and tell
- 43:10everyone, hey, you know you're all getting detention, but just this is
- 43:14going to be healthier for everybody, and we're going to be more effective as
- 43:15a fighting unit if you did clean this stuff up. You've writ in the
- 43:19book about how as time goes on, the culture of the unit changes and
- 43:23guys are sort of deferring on advancing their career because they just want to be
- 43:29gunfighters, like they've gotten addicted to the combat. Yeah. Well, I
- 43:32mean the idea is that you know, you're a patrol commander and then you
- 43:37sort of work your way up and you become a warrant officer, and you
- 43:38sort of spread the you know, the the experience that you've had across the
- 43:43regiment and sometimes across the military as well. You know, it's meant to
- 43:45be it's meant to be an area of excellence, and it is an area
- 43:50of excellence where they can go out into the Greater Defense Force and sort of
- 43:54bring some of that excellence with them. But because I think so many of
- 44:00the guys became addicted to the combat and we don't have any any sort of
- 44:07solid numbers on what the level of PTSD is. But you know, there's
- 44:13a psychologist explains to me that he said, you know, we the literature
- 44:19that we have suggest that it's not accumulative. It multiplies. And so when
- 44:23you've got guys who've done these sort of eight, nine, ten combat deployments
- 44:27and that is the number that guys ended up doing. SASI guys, you
- 44:30know, and I can imagine similar to the Americans as well. You know,
- 44:34so they're in these sort of you know, intense environments for you know,
- 44:38ten deployments might be six months each, you know, it's five years,
- 44:42like it's a super intense thing to do. They just want to go
- 44:46back in because that's a place where they feel comfortable. They start to feel
- 44:50uncomfortable in a civilian environment. And there was that was the case of the
- 44:54commanders as well. There was lots of guys who's you know, their lives
- 44:58were forming a bar to a certain extent outside of the outside of their deployments.
- 45:01You know, they're having problems with their wives or you know, their
- 45:06friends, they didn't relate to their friends anymore, or you know, so
- 45:08they just wanted to get back out, and you know, just being a
- 45:14warrant officer and you know working at working at QCB course for the rest of
- 45:20your life is not as exciting. Yeah right right. Tell us a little
- 45:25bit about the one Commando operation in two thousand and nine where it's sort of
- 45:30like the first time I if I'm understanding correctly that the issue of war crime
- 45:35starts coming into the public, like there are some aspects where they might prosecute
- 45:39this guy they might not. Yeah, yeah, that was that. That
- 45:45was a sort of a very important, sort of forgotten part of the Australian
- 45:47war crime story. So by two thousand and nine, we'd had three years
- 45:52of these at these deployments of commandos and SASR, and you know, everybody
- 45:59was getting tagged, and you know, they basically needed to re up some
- 46:04of the guys who they were bringing into the Second Commando Regiment especially and and
- 46:07the s s R. So they decided to do a deployment of one Commando
- 46:12guys who are reservists. This is this is Australia's oldest continuous Special Forces regiment,
- 46:21but they hadn't been used in operations for such a long time. So
- 46:24a lot of these guys, you know, some of them are soldiers full
- 46:27times. Some of them are policemen, you know, some of them are
- 46:30have other jobs. And so they did they did pre deployment readiness, which
- 46:36supposedly was was a little lacking, and then they were they were sent to
- 46:40Uruzgan and then they were they were doing the hill cap trovisions. So there
- 46:45was there was a house actually again in the place where you know Chare and
- 46:51Blueci and I think it was into actually direction, so it was very close
- 46:53to to taren Cott and they were going to be this compound of interest,
- 46:59and they were good night mission. I think it was midnight, two am
- 47:01something like that, and they go to this house and they find it empty,
- 47:06and so they decide that they're going to just go to the house next
- 47:08door and do that house instead, which they had already had. There was
- 47:15an ESAP order that that was they were not allowed to do that. You
- 47:19wanted just allowed to go into an adjacent compound because you had some intelligence about
- 47:23a certain compound. Anyway, so they went into this house, you know,
- 47:29and this is something that you have to be sort of relatively legally wary
- 47:34about. But I think it's uncontroversial that there was a guy who was there
- 47:38with his family. He heard someone breaking into his compound. He got his
- 47:45rifle. One of the soldiers saw him, they shot him, and then
- 47:50they hadn't killed him. He was shooting through a door. A machine gunner
- 47:53fired into the room where him and his family were. And then afterwards this
- 47:59is the the part that is somewhat controversial, as there some some have suggested
- 48:05that there was a ceasefire call, some have suggested that they were still shooting.
- 48:09You know, it's contentious, but grenades were thrown in and some babies
- 48:15were killed and some children were killed. The most interesting aspect of that is
- 48:22what happened next. At the time, the Australian military had this independent judiciary
- 48:27that was beyond the chain of command. So there was a brigadier who got
- 48:30a brief from the IGADF and believed that this was a war crime, and
- 48:35so she was going to prosecute the guys, and she was going to prosecute
- 48:37Lieutenant colonel who ordered the second house to be to be assaulted. And so
- 48:43she tried to go through this prosecution and the Australian media were very upset by
- 48:47it, and the chain of command were very upset by it, and eventually
- 48:52she was chased out of the army and there was there was a ruling that
- 48:57was made in court that previously it was assumed that the soldiers owed a duty
- 49:00of care to civilians in Uruzgan, and then a ruling was passed down that
- 49:06there was no obligation to have duty of care for civilians. And she was
- 49:13quite upset by this. This this brigadier who was who was the chief legal
- 49:16officer of the Australian Defense Force at the time, and she said that she
- 49:19thought that they were creating new law with this ruling. And yeah, the
- 49:24guys that didn't end up being prosecuted, and so that that was the standing
- 49:30rule afterwards that the Australian forces did not have an obligation of judio care over
- 49:35civilians. And then another controversial operation was an assault. I believe the target
- 49:42was called Whiskey one o eight. Yeah, well Whiskey went Away. It
- 49:45was one where the guy with the prosthetic leg was was shot. So that's
- 49:50something that's under appeal at the moment. So it had been alleged that there
- 49:55was an assault on Whiskey one o eight. There was fighting going on between
- 50:00the conventional forces who had a patrol based very close to that compound and guys
- 50:06who were there in that village which was ration as well, So it was
- 50:08it was really close to the place where there's these one commando killings that happened
- 50:13and where so much of the so much of the Australian war crime story happens,
- 50:16despite the fact that it's this time in area with with with not that
- 50:20many people living there. They there had been a battle, they called in
- 50:27an air strike. They've blown up a compound. The Sas come in and
- 50:32they either kill these legally or don't kill them legally. But there were there
- 50:38were news reports saying that they hadn't killed them legally. The Bender of the
- 50:42Smith had either executed or ordered the execution of a couple of these guys,
- 50:46including this guy with the prosthetic leg and yeah, they'd under apeal at the
- 50:52moment. So that's that's that's the first instance of SAS murders being reported happened,
- 51:00I think in two thousand and nine out of curiosity, you know,
- 51:04kind of lent or I guess, leading into the idea that maybe he was
- 51:08or wasn't executed. Who was he or who do they think he was?
- 51:14Like was he just yeah, Was he just a random guy on target or
- 51:19did they think that he was somebody who had been evading capture and that local
- 51:27forces wouldn't hold well? In that defamation case, somebody actually suggested that he
- 51:34was a jpel target and he was objective zyphoid, and he kept explosives.
- 51:38He was known for keeping explosives in his prosthetic leg. I think we can
- 51:45fairly safely discount yeah, that was the case. I don't think he was
- 51:49that Bond villain. But he and the other guy who was killed in his
- 51:52sumb is the center of this defamation case. They had come out of a
- 51:58tunnel and in the there were weapons. The major issue in her as again
- 52:04though, is that you know they were they were almost certainly local militia.
- 52:09But were they and they were probably local militia who are shooting at the Australian
- 52:14conventional forces. But you know, do you want to kill all of your
- 52:19local militia who agreed by putting up a patrol base village question? And the
- 52:23only reason I asked is and it's not to justify a killing if if the
- 52:27killing is true. But I'm curious because there were In my mind there was
- 52:30like a significant difference between a killing of a guy who just happens to be
- 52:35on a target or you know, in a house nest target and killing a
- 52:39guy who is a suspected ID maker who has been rolled up a few times
- 52:46and released every time. And again I'm not justifying it. I'm just asking
- 52:51if there was something in their mind that for them that justified it. Well,
- 52:55that's that's the difference between an ethical question of the legal question, right,
- 53:00you know, because you know, regardless of whether this person's a civilian
- 53:04or whether whether they were had been previously a combat, once the person is
- 53:07sourced to combat, if you kill him, then that's merger exactly. So
- 53:13I think, I mean my instinct that is that the Australians were not just
- 53:19randomly killing people on target. There may have been a couple of instances where
- 53:22they did, because they got later on in the war they believed that there
- 53:23were places where they were just full of shit people. They just they call
- 53:28them shit cuns, you know, and in certain incant villages it's just like
- 53:31all the guys in this in this village of shit cums. And I don't
- 53:35know whether you're following the British inquiry that's going on at the moment, But
- 53:38there has been evidence profit that the British says, in hellmant In some villages
- 53:45killed every finding age male that they could find on certain targets. But I
- 53:51think primarily the Australian says, if they had killed people illegally, they generally
- 54:00believed that they that they were were combatants. But yeah, oh go ahead,
- 54:06please, well no, from my perspective, one of the major issues
- 54:12of Australian operations in Neuroscam was an over aggregation of the enemy. You know,
- 54:15I think that you have to be very selective, you know, in
- 54:19coin operations as to who you decide to target, and I think there was
- 54:22a sort of maximal approach sometimes in regards to some places. Yeah, and
- 54:29again like talking about like the legal versity ethical, I absolutely agree with you.
- 54:35It's just you know, sometimes it's when it's reported that a somebody was
- 54:39killed, you know, somebody was killed in custody. Yeah, a lot
- 54:45of times I think there's a deeper story to it than just you know,
- 54:47these guys are savage, you know, or the Coalition Forces US Australian whoever,
- 54:53are just savages off the rails in their minds, even though it's not
- 54:58legal, in their minds, it makes sense. I think there probably were
- 55:01some people who had white luft, and I think there are a lot of
- 55:07people who who perhaps thought they were doing the right thing. But from a
- 55:09strategic perspective, it's not a smart thing to do. You know, you're
- 55:14not getting closer to your strategic goal. If your strategic goal is pacification,
- 55:17right, you know, if your strategic goal is you know, getting a
- 55:22paddle of the back from a certain person who wanted to kill as many people
- 55:27as possible, then that's different. And that's why I've been arguing for there
- 55:30to be a Royal commission in Australia into these killings, because I think that
- 55:35they've poorly understood, and I think that we should understand the link between the
- 55:40civilian structure of the Department and the Ministry Special Operations Command and the soldiers on
- 55:45the ground, because I think there is this sort of connected picture that doesn't
- 55:50exist in the public consciousness in the way that it should. And there's a
- 55:54real scenario in these wars that I think, you know, Western societies were
- 56:00not read for or ready for in the sense of, you know, if
- 56:04you take like an id maker, a bomb maker who never places the bombs
- 56:07himself. He pays farmers. He gets rolled up because of the local justice
- 56:13and you know how it is, he gets bought out of jail every time
- 56:17he gets rolled up, and then he hits coalition forces. He's known for
- 56:22the risk the death. It's like, how many times do you want to
- 56:24roll this guy up just from the released over and over again. And I
- 56:28think that a lot of the soldiers on the ground got frustrated in those situations,
- 56:32like how he is an enemy commandant. He may not be shooting at
- 56:37me right now, but he'll sure as hell blow me up tomorrow. Yeah.
- 56:40Yeah, And that's definitely the issue in allstrlim you know, there's there's
- 56:44a che There's a chapter in the book and I described the sort of porous
- 56:46Afghan justice structure, right and the fact that you know, there was this
- 56:51sort of you know, this ability to certain people to take people out of
- 56:55the legal the legal system, the Afghan legal system, you know, unitarily
- 57:00just because of the power that they had, and then recycle them back into
- 57:04the battlefield. And there was an incredibly admirable effort by some of the Australian
- 57:09Army lawyers and some of the soldiers and the reservists to create this thing called
- 57:14the Rule of Law Cell. So they tried to they tried to sort of
- 57:17train a lot of the soldiers, the SS guys, and the commandos to
- 57:21basically work as forensic investigators and then build up the courts so they could get
- 57:24the prosecutions. And part of the reason, there's a quote in the book
- 57:28from one of the guys who were setting up this Rule of Law cell saying,
- 57:30you know, we thought it was a good thing to do to the
- 57:32soldiers because you know, it's just not good for the soul to be endlessly
- 57:37killing these people. And had this rage about these people who are combatants and
- 57:39were not legally allowed to kill them. But from my perspective as a civilian,
- 57:44so this is something that I sort of stress over and over again.
- 57:46Is I am just I'm just an impartial observer. Sure, if I was
- 57:52a soldier, I'd have a completely different perspective, I'm sure, But from
- 57:58a civilian's arms length, look at this thing. If that is the case
- 58:01that we are recycling these guys, and then the guys are like, fuck
- 58:04it, we have to kill them, you know, we have to protect
- 58:07those guys from doing that, because if they do that, they may be
- 58:10subject to Australian laws that might put them in prison for the rest of their
- 58:13life. Right, And if we are doing that, we have to articulate
- 58:16to the public, these are why we're killing these people, this is why
- 58:20we're doing it, and we have to link it all the way up to
- 58:22some sort of strategic goal that makes sense for Australia. And I think they
- 58:25failed in that obbligation. Ben, could you tell us a little bit about
- 58:30the SAS's undeclared fourth Squadron. I thought that was an interesting fact in your
- 58:37book. Yeah. I mean, I actually don't know that much about four
- 58:40squadrons, but I have spoken to some of the guys and they can't talk
- 58:45to me that much about it. But it's sort of an intelligence gathering squadron,
- 58:51you know. They are sort of the most technologically capable of the squadrons,
- 58:57and it's they have this gray role, you know, it's not a
- 59:00bit sort of it's meant to be a sort of clandestine role as well.
- 59:05So one of the tensions that they had within the SBS while they were on
- 59:09operations in Afghanistan when there were so many guys in operations in Afghanistan was that
- 59:15they only had so many soldiers. You know, it's a relatively small regiment,
- 59:19but they were trying to bring these guys into this gray role. So
- 59:23it's the issue started at selection. So say it's two thousand and nine and
- 59:29you're in the middle of war in Afghanistan, and you know that you know
- 59:31when you have someone that you have selected and then you're going to put them
- 59:36in the rear cycle, that they're going to go into combat with guys like
- 59:38Ben Robert Smith against you know, the opposing forces in Uruzgan. You want
- 59:44them to have the capabilities to succeed in that environment. So one of the
- 59:49guys in the book describes the tension within selection there is because you know,
- 59:53we want these big, scary gunfighters to do this type of direct action stuff,
- 1:00:00and so we are selecting for that, and we're selecting for these sort
- 1:00:01of like ruthless killers, you know, these Cameron bed types actually sort of
- 1:00:07frankly within the SAS, but there is there is there is a tension because
- 1:00:14there's people within the SAS that are looking at the sort of strategic future of
- 1:00:17the regiment and they're like, well, we need these sort of weedy dorks
- 1:00:22who just you know, can walk on any street and just don't look like
- 1:00:24anyone. You know, like Ben Roberts Smith. There's only certain environments in
- 1:00:30which he can sort of walk down the street and look normal. I don't
- 1:00:31know whether you guys are familiar with him, but he's you know, six
- 1:00:34or five, one hundred and twenty kilos something like that. You know,
- 1:00:37he's a giant. He looks like a v SER recipient. He looks like
- 1:00:40a soldier, you know, whereas you need these guys who are going to
- 1:00:44be sort of low pro so, even from a perspective of selection and the
- 1:00:50way that the sas they rotate through to four Squadron and then also to the
- 1:00:55the can terrorism tag, had the ability you need someone who could sort of
- 1:01:00do everything. So they were selecting for these guys in Afghanistan and the other
- 1:01:05issues that they that they found. And this is something that one of the
- 1:01:08people who's doing selection was, you know, he was doing the psych screening
- 1:01:13for these guys. Is that they were they were trying to weed out as
- 1:01:15many as they can, but they weren't weeding out everybody who wanted to hunt
- 1:01:20and kill people because they knew that that's what they were doing in Afghanistan.
- 1:01:22So there were people who select who were selecting who were going into the SAS
- 1:01:27because they knew at some point they'd be able to go on target and start
- 1:01:30doing this this these kill capture missions. So there's an interesting sort of vignette
- 1:01:36that maybe not a lot of people are aware of where the Special Operations Task
- 1:01:40Group do Australian Special Operations for USS. They have a team up with DA
- 1:01:47American Drug Enforcement Agency Fast Teams in Afghanistan. Can you tell us about that
- 1:01:52relationship? Yeah, I mean that came of that came the tension between the
- 1:01:58SAS and the second commander. There was a lot of there was a lot
- 1:02:02of contention as to who would get the air assets because Australia didn't bring its
- 1:02:07own air assets into Afghanistan, so we had to use we had to use
- 1:02:09pool helicopters and pull ISR and so there would be these air windows where the
- 1:02:15SAS would go and they'd have their air window, you know, so they'd
- 1:02:17take their helicopters out into ambisions and then there were periods where the commandos had
- 1:02:22their air window and you know, if there was bad weather or something like
- 1:02:24that, and somebody missed the day. You know, the regiments them not
- 1:02:28hating each other because you know, somebody else would get their helicopters, and
- 1:02:31so the commandos are like, well, we need to find our own helicopters.
- 1:02:36So I think I have told this story. I can't remember all the
- 1:02:40details, but I think it was actually at a funeral, someone met someone
- 1:02:45within the DEA and the DA said, you know, we're running our own
- 1:02:47helicopters. You know, we have you know, these old Russian helicopters,
- 1:02:52and we have these guys that we call the expendables, you know who these
- 1:02:54sort of like some of them, some of them flew in Vietnam, you
- 1:02:58know, these these sort of contract pilots that are working for the DA.
- 1:03:01So why don't you come and work as gunfighters for us? And it was
- 1:03:05this really fruitful relationship in the context of they managed to destroy a lot of
- 1:03:10drugs, They managed to attack a lot of a lot of drug labs.
- 1:03:14You know that there was a lot of fighting. But there has been a
- 1:03:16lot of questions as to whether that actually I mean, the idea was that
- 1:03:22they were going to take money away from the insurgency that's why they were doing
- 1:03:27these drug missions. But there has been a lot of suggestions since that that
- 1:03:31basically they were just working for the benefit of other drug laws who weren't being
- 1:03:37attacked. Oh interesting, but like intentionally, or that the other drug lawyers
- 1:03:43were just feeding them the intel so that they would go like take out them.
- 1:03:45Some of them were feeding in the intel. Some of them had political
- 1:03:49connections, you know, especially connections to the Karzai family, you know,
- 1:03:52people who had who were working with the coalition in Uruzgan and Helman. Because
- 1:03:58most of these missions were conductive in the Helmant, but they were I mean,
- 1:04:03there's this this sort of leads into the or goes back to the political
- 1:04:09disconnect. You know. I think if the Australian public really knew the way
- 1:04:13that these drug missions worked and the way that the DA worked, they probably
- 1:04:16wouldn't have allowed it, especially considering that we had this strict mission and the
- 1:04:20strict parameters under which the Australians could operate. But there was there was this
- 1:04:26sort of tendency towards action. So the commandos went and did these missions and
- 1:04:30you know, and there was a lot of action. They really enjoyed it
- 1:04:33for you know, were they were the Australians under the same structures like the
- 1:04:38U S forces in terms of like the capture kill. If they're captured,
- 1:04:42would they just go into basically a coalition detention facility or to the local authorities
- 1:04:47or what. Did the Australians have something else set up? No, yeah,
- 1:04:53they had their own, They had their own their own facility later on,
- 1:04:56but then they would go into into local tension afterwards because they had to
- 1:05:00go through Afghan courts. Going back to the drug missions, the drug missions,
- 1:05:05they had a certain rule of engagement. They certain set of rules of
- 1:05:09engagement was distinct to the other missions that they were doing. And I don't
- 1:05:15know you guys, Are you guys familiar with the ros that the ISAC was
- 1:05:18using in Afghanistan? I assume you would. I mean relatively. So there
- 1:05:23were different change all the time, So like they changed like week to week.
- 1:05:29Do you know? So there's four twenty nine ROE four twenty nine A
- 1:05:31and B, which are the offensive ros as is my understanding, And then
- 1:05:38is there four twenty nine ROI E which is the direct targeting ROI. Basically,
- 1:05:44honestly, I, honest to God, could not tell you. And
- 1:05:46those ROS became so complicated. From what I've been told, it was like
- 1:05:51a stack of three ring binders this high, and a very very small group
- 1:05:56of people really had any mostly j Tax actually had any sort of understanding of
- 1:06:00how they were. And I think that the r's actually differed. Uh there's
- 1:06:04a NATO, Yeah different there. Yeah, there's soft ROI, so they
- 1:06:10also differ from unit to unit. It was it was insane. It was
- 1:06:14insane. That's crazy. Yeah, I mean that's something that that they that
- 1:06:17there is speculation that that's going to pop up in in the criminal cases.
- 1:06:20You know, there has been one essays got charge for murder and it's on
- 1:06:25video. I'm sure you guys have seen its standing out in Afghani says do
- 1:06:28you want me to drop this count and kills him, and there is speculation
- 1:06:31that they're going to mount the defense that they believe that that killing was within
- 1:06:36a certain r OI as it was explained to them. That's part of the
- 1:06:43Australian issue is that everybody has told me what they believed the ro O E
- 1:06:47that they were operating under was, and quite often it's quite different. I
- 1:06:51honestly don't outside of like outside of like Jack mentioned, the g tax because
- 1:06:58the G tax like their job depending on note dependent on knowing the roes,
- 1:07:02because they were waiting, like their fire came from higher headquarters right who were
- 1:07:08who the attorneys were sitting there for. But for the average joe on the
- 1:07:12ground, whether it was SAS or Tenth Mountain or Special Forces or whatever.
- 1:07:15They they have their general roes like you don't you know, you don't shoot
- 1:07:21somebody who is a non combatant like they have the general. But at any
- 1:07:27given time they could have been breaking ro O s because they've changed a little,
- 1:07:30a little vignette. I mean I I was deployed with Special Forces in
- 1:07:34two thousand and it was two thousand and eight or two thousand and nine.
- 1:07:40I never saw an ROE. Yeah, we we asked for one too,
- 1:07:44Yeah, and we were never giving it for people who are watching, listening,
- 1:07:47who aren't, who might not you can probably get it from context,
- 1:07:50but are r O E is a rule rules of engagement and it basically tells
- 1:07:56a soldier why they can shoot at another person. And you would think it
- 1:08:02seems like a simple question, but but it gets very very convoluted. It
- 1:08:08becomes like how big is the structure? Can the structure be reduced. You
- 1:08:13know, what is the acceptable sieve cast if any right, and it's and
- 1:08:16armed combatants. Okay, you can shoot at somebody who's armed. Or what
- 1:08:20if he doesn't. What if he doesn't raise his weapon at you. What
- 1:08:24if he's not shooting at you. What if he has his cell phone and
- 1:08:27there's intelligence that there are spotters in the area. What if the guy tries
- 1:08:30to steal your home v What if he tries to steal a radio? What
- 1:08:32if he's running What if he doesn't have a weapon, but he's running off
- 1:08:35a target where you know bad guys are, and he's running towards a known
- 1:08:40location of weapons or a suspected location of a weapons. Cash like it gets
- 1:08:45it sounds it sounds like civilians would think, well, it's kind of obvious,
- 1:08:48right the guy's he's a bad guy or not right, But it gets
- 1:08:51very conflicent in very quickly, especially when you know everybody's on uniformed and you
- 1:08:57know there are certain groups that you could directly target, you know, the
- 1:08:59telebate and obviously is one of them, but then there's these other malicious It's
- 1:09:01like, is he part of this group or another group? Yeah? Then
- 1:09:05if only they would have worn uniforms to know who they were. I know,
- 1:09:10there's consider it. I know, something I want to make sure that
- 1:09:16we talk about here is I'd like to ask you about the big firefight where
- 1:09:20Ben Roberts Smith was a ward of the Victorious Cross for and for our American
- 1:09:27listeners, the VC if that's the Australian or Commonwealth equivalent of our Medal of
- 1:09:31Honor. Yeah, yeah, I mean it was the Battle of Tizzak,
- 1:09:36which was part of the Shawoi offensive. Like everything you know, post this
- 1:09:45defamation case, there are multiple versions of this, you know, so there
- 1:09:48was the official version of what Ben Robert Smith did regardless. You know,
- 1:09:53it was an incredible feat in which he charged a machine gun post, two
- 1:09:59machine gun posts. You know, killed lots of people. You know,
- 1:10:03they were they were hugely undermanned in in this in this Battle of Tiszac.
- 1:10:09But the war crime story has emerged not from without but within. You know,
- 1:10:15it's been soldiers who are upset with with Ben Robert Smith. You know,
- 1:10:19bener of Smith has ended up becoming the most decorated soldier since Vietnam because
- 1:10:25he was awarded the Victoria Cross. He was warded the Medal of Gallantry and
- 1:10:28the Commendation of Distinguished Service. So when he was awarded the Commendation of Distinguished
- 1:10:32Service, somebody went actually back to Tizzak after Ben Robert Smith was awarded the
- 1:10:38Victoria Cross and past out where he where he was involved in this firefight and
- 1:10:45looked at the official reporting and said that they you know that the official reporting
- 1:10:48is is a little bit skew if but yeah, I mean, I don't
- 1:10:54think there's any question that you know, he was involved in this, in
- 1:10:57this incredibly difficult situ. Do you want to describe a little bit of that,
- 1:11:00because it sounds like the SAS was engaged in entrenched you know, dug
- 1:11:04in enemy they were outnumbered, and you write about this scenario where Ben Roberts
- 1:11:10Smith and another operator are like kind of in a gem and like are pretty
- 1:11:15convinced they're about to die. Yeah, they really are. I mean,
- 1:11:17you know, they're pinned down by PKM two PK and machine guns and they
- 1:11:23basically need to see the initiative again, you know, so they have to
- 1:11:26charge across open ground to you know, to silence these machine guns and kill
- 1:11:30these guys while they're getting lateral fire as well. It's my understanding, but
- 1:11:34he did it with another guy who who was one of his best friends,
- 1:11:39who was a junior soldier, and it was contended in the defamation case that
- 1:11:44this is one of the people that he ordered to commit execution, and so
- 1:11:49this person is in their own legal jeopardy. This person is also someone who
- 1:11:54has a significant psychological issue. But this is there's also someone who in the
- 1:11:58defamation case says that, you know, he loves Ben Robert Smith, you
- 1:12:00know that that he's someone that who who he really kind of appreciates. But
- 1:12:06he claims in the defamation case that both he and Ben Roberts Smith basically did
- 1:12:12the same thing. That they fought together, you know, to resolve this
- 1:12:16situation, and that Ben Robert Smith was given the Victoria Cross and this guy
- 1:12:20was given the Medal of Gallantry after this guy who hasn't been named, after
- 1:12:27this guy had been told that he was going to get the Victoria Across.
- 1:12:30And an aspect of this defamation case is that after the Battle of Tizzak,
- 1:12:34you know, defense needed a pr win and Ben Robert Smith is a judge's
- 1:12:39son. You know, he went to a private school. He looks the
- 1:12:42way that he does you know he could he could speak well to to a
- 1:12:45certain category of Australians and so, you know, it could be argued that
- 1:12:50this is the point where the rift began. Let's see, what else do
- 1:12:59we want to get into here. Oh, there's another another operation that struck
- 1:13:01me from reading your book that this was a very legitimate, well executed operation
- 1:13:06was the twenty eleven operation where the Australians got intelligence that there was a group
- 1:13:13of children's suicide bombers that were moving into her Ao. Yeah, I mean
- 1:13:19one of the problems in I mean, one of the problems in Afghanistans generally
- 1:13:25was that the Taliban had this sort of area, this decomfliction area in Pakistan
- 1:13:30and that there was a porous border. So they basically, you know,
- 1:13:32there was the crediturer that basically ran the centralized insurgency and they couldn't be touched
- 1:13:36and they basically had this city where you know, they could live with impunity.
- 1:13:42They you know, it was four hours away by by motorcycle from central
- 1:13:47Luriscan, so they could basically go in and out of theater when they wanted
- 1:13:51to. And so this is a story that has has not been told and
- 1:13:58perhaps may not be told because of the you know, because of the compartmentalized
- 1:14:01nature of some of the information. But they had to sort of build up
- 1:14:06this intelligence structure that included an understanding of what was happening in Pakistan, you
- 1:14:15know. So they wanted to when these guys sort of came in, they
- 1:14:17wanted to hit them when they'd come into theater, and they you know,
- 1:14:19they couldn't they couldn't go to into Pakistan. But they had heard that these
- 1:14:25these child suicide bombers were coming in. They got some information in uh the
- 1:14:30way that the information is gathered, I know, but it isn't detailed in
- 1:14:34the book and can't be detailed in the book. So they get this information
- 1:14:38that these these child suicide bombers are coming in, and I think they actually
- 1:14:44ended up they ended up neutralizing them about killing them. Is that right?
- 1:14:47Yeah, that's that's that's what's in your book as I recall read. Yeah,
- 1:14:51I mean it's my information, But like I said, two books,
- 1:14:55so there's some there's some stuff I don't remember. And then the last couple,
- 1:15:00the like final years of the SOTG, you write about how that's really
- 1:15:04where a lot of the murders in Mayhem, alleged murders really pick up and
- 1:15:10things really get bad. Yeah, it's twenty twelve where the sort of bulk
- 1:15:15of the murders are alleged to have happened. And I mean it makes sense.
- 1:15:21You know, from an ethical perspective, we are all moral beings,
- 1:15:27you know, regardless of who we are and what we've done and what we
- 1:15:29think is appropriate and not appropriate, we have this sort of like understanding of
- 1:15:32what is right and wrong. And if you're if you're leaving Orusgan having committed
- 1:15:40so much bodily and emotionally to the fight, I can understand why you believe
- 1:15:48that you think there are these people who you know that are bad and that
- 1:15:51the province will be better off if you have killed them. You know,
- 1:15:55there is no justification legally and personally, I don't think there's any justification morally
- 1:15:59to execute people. But if you are at the back end of this thing,
- 1:16:01you've seen so much death, You've had friends die as well, you
- 1:16:04killed so many people, you don't want it to be for nothing. You
- 1:16:09know, you don't want to just be walking away and going, oh,
- 1:16:12well, we didn't when you know, especially after you know, spending your
- 1:16:15entire thirties or or you know, like a great chunk of your life to
- 1:16:19this thing, you know, in Australia and in Afghanistan. That's just that's
- 1:16:27just my speculations as to what happened, But yes, it it happened in
- 1:16:30primarily in twenty twelve. The other thing that I wade about in the book
- 1:16:33is that a lot of the guys talk about the incentive structure that had built
- 1:16:38up around then. Jackpots was a big thing. So jackpots j PEL targets
- 1:16:44who were prosecuted, who were either killed or were in detention, in long
- 1:16:47term detention. So if you recycle a guy, you go and catch him
- 1:16:51and you put him, you know, into the Afghan justice system, and
- 1:16:55it doesn't it won't count as the jackpot. But at the top of the
- 1:16:59mission sheets it says jackpot, you know, and there's a box for whether
- 1:17:01you've got a jackpot or one or two. And I think the sotgs were
- 1:17:05trying to rack up as many jackpots as they could. And I don't know
- 1:17:11this because this hasn't necessarily been investigated, but I think some of the ogster
- 1:17:15combat killings may have been JPELL targets to make sure that this person was killed
- 1:17:19rather than recycled them, that they weren't counted as the jackpot. One of
- 1:17:25the things you wrote actually kind of even though no one was actually killed in
- 1:17:30this scenario, there is I mean, I thought this was in a sense
- 1:17:33the most shocking part of your book was that you write that Ben Roberts Smith
- 1:17:39on training exercises in Australia was having the junior operators conduct mock executions and saying,
- 1:17:46hey, that's how we do it overseas. That's not something you can't
- 1:17:50chalk that up to, like in the heat of the moment, you know,
- 1:17:54we're in combat, things happen. That's very premeditated. If it's true,
- 1:18:00well, I mean all of all of the alleged murders, or most
- 1:18:03of the alleged murders are premeditated. In that drop weapons were involved, so
- 1:18:06they took weapons on target or radios on target so that when they had executed
- 1:18:11people they could for the sc photos drop a weapon or a radio on them.
- 1:18:15That was evidence that was given at the defamation case by I think two
- 1:18:20witnesses who were involved in these in these pre deployment readiness exercises from memory as
- 1:18:32well. They gave evidence that this had happened in front of lots of people
- 1:18:38that you know, these mock exe mock executions, and the Ben Robert Smith
- 1:18:41has allegedly in this in this deformation case, had said to these junior soldiers,
- 1:18:47you know, execute this this outgame, because that's how it's going to
- 1:18:49be over there. And then one of the guys who gave evidence came and
- 1:18:55picked him up at it later and just said, what the what the fuck
- 1:18:58are you doing? You know, what are you doing here? And then
- 1:19:05we get into twenty twelve, Ben Robert Smith is accused of kicking a guy
- 1:19:11off a cliff. Yeah, what happened there? I mean a few of
- 1:19:20the killings. And the part of the reason that I think Australia and it's
- 1:19:25a royal commission is that that was in the wake of a Green Old Blue
- 1:19:30killing where a guy called Hec Matula had been being trained by conventional forces in
- 1:19:36a patrol base and he turned his gun on the Australian conventional forces and killed
- 1:19:42a number of people and then ran off into the ran off into the ether,
- 1:19:46and they had some intelligence as to where he was, but they were
- 1:19:49sort of a little bit behind. The eight ball. So this is one
- 1:19:53of the missions where they flew into this area they were trying to find him,
- 1:19:58and it's entirely possible that they found someone who had been on a phone
- 1:20:02who was trying to facilitate his escape, and that they may have decided to
- 1:20:09take things into their own hand in that in that context. But yeah,
- 1:20:13it's it's that that's one of the things that's up an appeal. It was
- 1:20:16upheld in the original ruling that Ben Robert Smith had stood a guy in front
- 1:20:23of a cliff. You know, there was long deliberations as to whether it
- 1:20:28was a cliff or whether it was an incline or whatever it was. But
- 1:20:32the judge, which is misruling is now an appeal, found it credible that
- 1:20:38Ben rob Smith had kicked this guy off this cliff. He sustained some facial
- 1:20:41injuries, and then he ordered another junior soldier in a machine gun into death
- 1:20:45afterwards. Going back to that, to that question of things happening in the
- 1:20:49heat of battle, all of these murders supposedly happened in a permissive environment after
- 1:20:56you know, there was no more shoes, right. But and to clarify,
- 1:21:00this guy was suspected or or known to be linked to the guy they
- 1:21:06were after hanging about to her. Well, I mean, there's there's been
- 1:21:11an incredible amount of reporting about this killing into including two relatively famous Australian books,
- 1:21:17and the intimation has been that he was someone who just sort of flew
- 1:21:23into this town and was the wrong place for the wrong time. But I've
- 1:21:26been told by multiple people that you know, he was he was part of
- 1:21:29a local militia and you know took Heck matullur In and basically set him off
- 1:21:32north after you know, after he after he'd escaped from this Australian Patrol base.
- 1:21:39So you know that's something that might come out in a criminal trial.
- 1:21:42But yeah, we'll see. There's a lot of it that's just will say.
- 1:21:45You mentioned, you know, some of the ideas for the Australian government
- 1:21:49and what you think should happen with some of the stuff. How much responsibility
- 1:21:55do you think that the governments of like western nations have when we go into
- 1:21:59this sort of these nebulous environments with the rotating justice systems and allow soldiers to
- 1:22:06complete, you know, repeatedly deployed to these like they they obviously get to
- 1:22:13a level of frustration where nothing is changing and yet the governments themselves and their
- 1:22:20generals, the military structure is not sympathetic to what's going on there. No,
- 1:22:28that's right. Do you think there's a solution to that? And how
- 1:22:30the government had would we would handle these types of conflicts going forward? Yeah?
- 1:22:38I mean, my there were so many times where I was writing fine,
- 1:22:42fixed finish, where I was like, why why doesn't a civilian reach
- 1:22:45down, you know in false effect finding mission to have an actual understanding of
- 1:22:49the nuts and bolts, especially of the s OTG operations and then come back,
- 1:22:57you know, and you probably need some people who are retired military people
- 1:23:00to sort of, you know, assemble a plan of action to make sure
- 1:23:04that we are operating a industry strategically coherent way and b in an ethical and
- 1:23:11moral way and see in a way that's not going to be damaging to your
- 1:23:14forces. You know, there were so many times where I just I just
- 1:23:17I just thought, you know, why does the department on the ministry not
- 1:23:20reach down? You know, there was there was a JTF commander. So
- 1:23:25the structure is that, you know, we had the s O tgs,
- 1:23:28we have all of the all the individual task groups, across across the Middle
- 1:23:31East, the Australian Task Groups. They report to an officer who's in who's
- 1:23:38in the UAE, and he's the JTF commander, so he's a major general
- 1:23:41and then he reports to Australia which reports the government. And the JTF commander,
- 1:23:45who Boy interviewed, said JTF commanders quite often didn't even have access to
- 1:23:48the Australian Special Forces, you know, they were sort of told that they
- 1:23:53didn't have the required clearance to be around in their compound, you know.
- 1:23:57So you're never going to have this sort of transparency if you have made generals
- 1:24:00who are part of the command structure unable to gain access to the soldiers.
- 1:24:05So I think that it would have been useful whether if the civilians would be
- 1:24:11able to reach down and actually speak to the soldiers, not only from an
- 1:24:15operational level, but from an actual boots on the ground level. What do
- 1:24:17you guys do you know, grab some of these guys and go what's your
- 1:24:19day to day? You know, what are you told about the ROE,
- 1:24:21what are you told about the missions? And then from that you can build
- 1:24:25up an understanding of what the strategic picture is and then move things because there
- 1:24:30were these firewalls all the way through. And you know, I I'm very
- 1:24:33sympathetic with the ministers because they are given this political appointment, you know,
- 1:24:40but then also they do have an obligation, especially when lethal forces being employed,
- 1:24:46to represent the Australian public, to represent in a democracy, the things
- 1:24:51that are being done on our behalf, and there was a failure in being
- 1:24:57able to do that. It also seems, you know, we were very
- 1:24:59busy advising the Afghan military and aspects of the NDS, you know, the
- 1:25:04security apparatus, but we weren't to my knowledge, like there were no coalition
- 1:25:11forces in the actual correctional system. And it's like that that was the leaky
- 1:25:15hole. And if somebody higher in command in the military or people in governments
- 1:25:23would have recognized that. And because I'll tell you, like, I'm sort
- 1:25:28of on the opposite side of you in the sense of, I know what,
- 1:25:30it's not legal, but I do find it ethical. But the thing
- 1:25:33is we need to take people, we need to take that situation and make
- 1:25:40it so that it meets your expectations right, so that any non judicial killing
- 1:25:47is ethical or I mean isn't ethical. It isn't ethical. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:25:54sorry about that, but isn't ethical where these guys aren't rotating back through
- 1:25:58and you know it's not kind of dirt bags that you're dealing with. Yeah,
- 1:26:02I mean, from my perspective as an Australian, all Australian forces have
- 1:26:06to be subject to Australian law. Sure, that just absolutely, because you
- 1:26:11know, from a moral perspective, these people are citizens. They are going
- 1:26:15to be fighting in Afghanistan for a certain period of time and then they're going
- 1:26:16to be coming out into the community and they have to be members of the
- 1:26:19community. You know, if you are going to be pushing the bounds of
- 1:26:26what is allowed and what is you know, what is legal, there has
- 1:26:30to be at least some sort of strategic reason for that to be happening,
- 1:26:32rather than just you know, this is the fight that we're in, this
- 1:26:34is the vice we've been sent in. So you know, perhaps there is
- 1:26:39more, there is more understanding for rule bending if you are an American because
- 1:26:44you are committed to this, to this war that you have decided that that
- 1:26:47is strategically important. But if you're an Australian, there's no justification for it.
- 1:26:53If it is just alliance coherence, no yeah, I'm agreeing with you
- 1:26:59on that point. The sense of there shouldn't be that there shouldn't be rule
- 1:27:03breaking. But in order for there not to be rule breaking, I think
- 1:27:06that the people on the ground have to know that the rules will be fault
- 1:27:12that when they put a guy away, he's going to stay away. And
- 1:27:15that's what I'm saying is that that they should, you know, these governments
- 1:27:19should recognize that there's a leak in there, just in like the indigenous justice
- 1:27:25system, and not put the operators or soldiers and people on the ground in
- 1:27:30the position of making these bad legal decisions. Yeah, but then also I
- 1:27:35agree, I highly agree. But then you also need to understand that you
- 1:27:41know, you're here for a reason. You're in a country that has a
- 1:27:44poorest legal system you have. It is a country that is tribally based,
- 1:27:49and you know, the idea of being an Afghan isn't the same idea as
- 1:27:54being an American or Australian. So there are going to be these things that
- 1:27:57are infuriating to you, and perhaps recycling targets over and over again is one
- 1:28:01of those things. But you have to you have to still be an Australian
- 1:28:04and American they're going to be an Afghan, You're not going to be an
- 1:28:08Afghan. You have to try and you have to try and understand the motivations,
- 1:28:12which is an incredibly difficult thing to do as to why they're doing the
- 1:28:15things that they do. But you still have to stay who you are.
- 1:28:19You have to you have to represent your uniform, you have to represent your
- 1:28:23set of rules, as much as it sucks, annoying as it's going to
- 1:28:27be, but you kind of have to do that. And I mean,
- 1:28:30I think the major thin of Australian operations in Afghanistan is that doing less might
- 1:28:36have been the right thing to do, because then you could just let Afghans
- 1:28:40rule the way that appens. Rule right. Tell us about how that's tough
- 1:28:45thing to do. How did this whole war crimes issue explode into the public
- 1:28:49consciousness in Australia. How did that come about, leading into the the Ben
- 1:28:54Roberts Smith that now defamation trial, the Barenton Report, all these things?
- 1:28:59How did that happen? And you know back home, well, I mean
- 1:29:02it happened internally. It was there. There were a lot of sort of
- 1:29:06squeaky wheels within the command who didn't like that you know, the lot of
- 1:29:12this stuff had happened. There was a moment where a new Special Operations commander
- 1:29:16came in and basically said to the guys, look, everybody's talking about it.
- 1:29:24I don't know what year this was, it's in the book. We
- 1:29:28we you know, we want to clear the air this This can't be something
- 1:29:30that sort of drags the command down for the for the rest of the immediate
- 1:29:34future. So everybody, you can just write down anonymously on a piece of
- 1:29:41paper, give me an envelope, and just tell me what happened, you
- 1:29:44know, so then we'll just have a sort of un understanding. And you
- 1:29:46said he got likes, Yeah, he got like two hundred letters. And
- 1:29:50some of the stuff are the most outrageous stuff, I think. I think
- 1:29:54it was sort of like a case of Chinese whispers, where lots of people
- 1:29:57would be like someone I had heard that someone that I hate did this certain
- 1:30:00thing, you know, like done these executions or whatever, and you know,
- 1:30:02like some outlandish stuff. And I can imagine a lot of the stuff
- 1:30:05were things that had actually happened, and so they were like, well,
- 1:30:10how can we reconcile with this? So they brought in a civilian sociologist,
- 1:30:15which was has been hugely contentious. A woman called doctor Samantha Comforts, and
- 1:30:21she is, you know, essentially a culture expert, and so she interviewed
- 1:30:27a lot of a lot of soldiers about what had happened, and then she
- 1:30:30filed this report and the report was meant to be about, you know,
- 1:30:34the culture. She gave it to the Chief Defense about the culture within Special
- 1:30:39Operations Command, but a lot of it was detailed detailing the ethical failings as
- 1:30:45she saw it within the command. And so the Comfort Reports, you know,
- 1:30:48became big news in Australia. It was you know, it was very
- 1:30:54much a big deal. And then the IGADF at that point stepped in and
- 1:30:59they worked on a report for a long time as well. One of the
- 1:31:02issues with that report, my understanding is that one of the issues of that
- 1:31:06report is that they impelled witnesses to speak. So they interviewed sas soldiers and
- 1:31:14commandos and they were compelled to talk, you know, they couldn't basically take
- 1:31:17a fifth. And then the report came out and the report detailed thirty nine
- 1:31:21murders and there were nineteen people who had who had allegedly committed these murders.
- 1:31:28The report stressed that these this wasn't the totality of what we think the war
- 1:31:33crimes problem was, but these are people who we think can be referred to
- 1:31:39a prosecutor. And so after that the Australian government there was the Burdon Report
- 1:31:45came out. It was a big day in Australia. You know, the
- 1:31:45Prime Minister stood up on the Dais with the Defense Minister and the Chief of
- 1:31:50Defense and said, you know, we're all outraged by this. You know,
- 1:31:54no one's more shocked than I am, saying all the right things.
- 1:31:57The Buron Report, by the way, said that you know, while there
- 1:32:00was some moral failings within the command, you know, it's basically the responsibility
- 1:32:04of the soldiers who pulled the trigger, which is not how I But they
- 1:32:13then built this new body called the Office of the Special Investigators, and so
- 1:32:17they were then going to build these briefs of evidence from these referrals from the
- 1:32:24Breton Report and then take them to the Department of Public Prosecutions and then these
- 1:32:30would go through and become trials. But Brereton was twenty twenty I believe,
- 1:32:35So it's now four years later we've had one arrest a guy called Oliver Schultz,
- 1:32:41and he was the person who pulled the trigger in the infamous video where
- 1:32:45he's standing over an Afghan youth saying do you want me to drop this count?
- 1:32:49And then he kills him. There hasn't been any other referrals. There
- 1:32:54haven't been any other arrests. There was one of the other things that after
- 1:32:59the Breton was announced, the Prime Minister announced that there was going to be
- 1:33:02an implementation Panel and Afghan Implementation Panel, so this was going to this was
- 1:33:10going to address all the structural issues and the command issues. So they got
- 1:33:13these three experts and they were working on it for a couple of years on
- 1:33:17the things the Defense might have done wrong. They were meant to table the
- 1:33:21reports to the government and then the government were meant to make these reports public.
- 1:33:27They didn't, so people have had to go on FI these requests,
- 1:33:30which is a freedom of information mechanism that's within Australian law where you could get
- 1:33:35governments out of you can get documents out of government. And then the final
- 1:33:40report, which I can imagine there's going to be particularly damning of government and
- 1:33:47defense that hasn't been made public. So the Deputy Prime Minister who's also our
- 1:33:56Defense minister, has been given the report. He was given the report a
- 1:34:00long time ago. FOI requests have been made. Those requests have been denied,
- 1:34:05incidentally by someone who is involved in the the the revitalization of defense post
- 1:34:13Afghanistan. The Senate in our Australian Senate has asked for it to be tabled.
- 1:34:18In fact, they've ordered for it to be tabled. They have twice
- 1:34:21ordered it for it be tabled. It's gone to a vote in the Senate.
- 1:34:25The Senate that the vote has passed, that report is still not like,
- 1:34:30it still isn't available to us. So, you know, years and
- 1:34:32years and years on, the thing sort of drags on and we have you
- 1:34:38know, we have this this high profile General Smith's defamation case where there's no
- 1:34:43criminal liability in jeopardy. We have this one soldier who is going to be
- 1:34:47tried for this murder. And then we have this you know report about about
- 1:34:53defense accountability and what you know what what the government of the day knew or
- 1:34:59didn't know or should have s wouldn't have done and it's nowhere to be seen.
- 1:35:02And meanwhile the war goes on for Australian special Operations. These guys get
- 1:35:09sent right off to Iraq to deal with ISIS. Yeah, that's right.
- 1:35:13And there was always speculation that, you know, the four Squadron guys go
- 1:35:17over to a thing called Gallant Phoenix. Have you guys interviewed anyone who was
- 1:35:23part of Gallaphini. I'm pretty sure we have, even if they didn't use
- 1:35:28that term. Yeah, it's like a collective intelligence gathering in Jordan, I
- 1:35:34believe, where they tracked all the international jihihi that went over to Syria and
- 1:35:39Iraq. And then you know, I think there was some targeting the TF
- 1:35:45Hydra, the Brits and the French and from your what you write about the
- 1:35:49Australians also, Yeah, in Australians as well. So that was the that
- 1:35:54was an s AS element that went and did that. But then the commandos
- 1:35:58went on and worked in the in the strike cells in around Mossel and Alasade
- 1:36:05and attacking them and places like that. And the Australians are actually in a
- 1:36:09house with Eddie Gallagher when when the Eddie Gallagher incident happened. Yeah, So
- 1:36:15that was seals and commandos who were who were together in Bartella in the Battle
- 1:36:18of Mosol. Interesting. Yeah, I've actually been told that the Special Air
- 1:36:24Service has kind of taken over from the Americans, uh, kind of mentoring
- 1:36:29the white reaction regiment in the Philippines. Yeah, I mean that would make
- 1:36:32sense given that we're you know, we're sort of much closer to the Philippines
- 1:36:36than you guys are. And the Australians, I mean, the Mint and
- 1:36:42now insurgency issue, I can't remember. Do you guys remember when that was?
- 1:36:46I mean, it's it's still like ongoing going. Yeah, but I
- 1:36:53know Australians are over there bringing air strikes and jay tax and sort of the
- 1:37:00prototypical strike cells there as well. So yeah, I would imagine. I
- 1:37:03mean, I'm my visibility is with is with operations in Afghanistan. You know,
- 1:37:10I'm not figuring on the pulse of stuff that's happening now, but that
- 1:37:13wouldn't surprise me at all. Do we have questions? Yeah? Yeah,
- 1:37:16did you know if do we have any Patreon stuff? Okay, let me
- 1:37:20get to this real quick. So where do things stand today, Ben?
- 1:37:26With like, if you could talk a little bit about the forced disposition of
- 1:37:30the Australian Special Operations community, Well, I mean everybody almost uniformly everybody I'm
- 1:37:38in contact with is retired because I think part of the reason is because that
- 1:37:45was the party. You know, Afghanistan was the place where where you know,
- 1:37:49you could be involved in combat, and I think there was going to
- 1:37:53be at least a long interregnum after Iraq. I mean, Iraq was was
- 1:37:58very different. You know, the caw rice, this stuff was was not
- 1:38:02gun fighting. And the people that I speak to are sort of generally an
- 1:38:09agree group for various the various different reasons, you know, I mean,
- 1:38:14there are a lot of there is a lot of unity within the community in
- 1:38:19that they think that the command piece of the war crime story in Afghanistan should
- 1:38:24be understood and should be exposed. It shouldn't be that the entire weight of
- 1:38:30those failures should be on the soldiers, of the guys who are on the
- 1:38:32ground. And so even though you know there's a lot of different voices and
- 1:38:35there's a lot of people who hate each other, and you know, there's
- 1:38:39a lot of old, old, old wounds, I think most people think
- 1:38:44that there should be an understanding of of of what the command piece is.
- 1:38:49Yeah, what do we got for ben here M Corbyn, thank you very
- 1:38:54much. And Aussie budd asks how important was b R. S's family backgrounding
- 1:39:00the protection of him. Was there a cultural problem in other squadrons? There
- 1:39:05were, there was a cultural problem in other squadrons, but presumably it wasn't
- 1:39:10as bad as two squadrons. So just a bit of background. They were
- 1:39:14right, Sorry, was that the squadron that was disbanded. They were supposedly
- 1:39:20disbanded, but you know it's a bit of a black box at the moment.
- 1:39:25So yeah, Veneral smith'sdat is Lenn Robert Smith, who was a major
- 1:39:30general and he was he was the head of the jagquars. I believe here
- 1:39:34in Australia he was the head of a task force. I think just before
- 1:39:42the Robert Smith alleged murders. He was someone who was in charge of of
- 1:39:49taking bullying out of the Australian Defense Force. I believe he was part of
- 1:39:53a task force doing that. So whether his family, I think it's highly
- 1:40:00unlikely it his family was was sort of directly involved in covering up any of
- 1:40:05the stuff, and you know that would be I'd be amazed by that.
- 1:40:10But I think, you know, being someone who is from a background that
- 1:40:16is that is what it was, and it may have made it more difficult
- 1:40:23to people to point the finger and to shine a light. I think the
- 1:40:26Victoria Cross might have done that as well. So I don't think that they
- 1:40:29would have been sort of like, you know, a cover up in that
- 1:40:30way, but I think that it would have given people pause to come forward.
- 1:40:38Scott G. Thank you very much. What what's your opinion David McBride
- 1:40:43and how he would have had protections under the whistible olarge with experts testifying,
- 1:40:48but the government blocked the testimony for security concerns. Yeah, that's a really
- 1:40:54interesting question. So McBride lived just down the road from me, someone that
- 1:40:58needs to see all the time if you don't know what he did. He
- 1:41:01was a legal officer Special Operations Task Group legal officer who was deployed in twenty
- 1:41:06thirteen and he was given this Rule of Engagement amplification. So it was basically
- 1:41:15new steps within the new steps that the soldiers had to adhere to to use
- 1:41:19lethal force. And his speculation was that this was because commands knew that there
- 1:41:27had been these murders that had happened and that they wanted to have this ROI
- 1:41:31amplification. So if it all comes to light, they can say, look,
- 1:41:36you know, we did what we could. The soldiers were bad soldiers.
- 1:41:40You know, we've given this roe that they weren't adhering to what can
- 1:41:44we do? And he took umbrage to that. And there were a few
- 1:41:48other things. There were an incident in which a soldier was being investigated for
- 1:41:53a killing and he didn't believe that the soldier had erred, and that he
- 1:41:59thought that this was again, you know, this selective prosecution, basically protecting
- 1:42:03themselves against some sort of exposures to these other war crimes that had happened.
- 1:42:11And so eventually he leaked a bunch of documents to a journalist, to an
- 1:42:16Australian journalist who published some of those documents, and you know, you could
- 1:42:20argue that that was sort of the beginning of all the internal stuff. You
- 1:42:25know, the Conference Report and the Burnt Report might not have happened, but
- 1:42:28that there was this public pressure because these documents had been had been shared on
- 1:42:32the ABC. And then the Australian Federal Police charged him and the journalist who'd
- 1:42:40been given the documents with Espionage Act breaches. McBride was found guilty, and
- 1:42:46you're making reference to the fact that there's these whistleblower protections. McBride David McBride,
- 1:42:55who's a lawyer himself, and the person who was acting for him,
- 1:42:58you know, is a very senilar too. They have built this defense and
- 1:43:03I can't go into what the defense is because of because of the way Australian
- 1:43:09law works. But they had built this defense and at the eleven thousand Australian's
- 1:43:15books came in and said, you can't present this defense. You know,
- 1:43:17national national security information involved, so you can't present this to the court.
- 1:43:24And so there were going to be witnesses. I had made a submission on
- 1:43:27his behalf as well, that we're going to be presented to the judge.
- 1:43:31And then you know, this national security information interjection basically meant that he had
- 1:43:38to abandon his defense and then either defend himself with no evidence or pleet guilty
- 1:43:45and sort of throw himself onto the and to the mercy of the court.
- 1:43:47So he did the latter. He's waiting and sentencing at the moment, and
- 1:43:51that that is a blight against Australian law that someone had who had done something
- 1:43:58that ended up being public good. There's been a lot of contentious conversation as
- 1:44:02to why he did what he did. I think it's kind of relatively material.
- 1:44:06You know, he did expose these crimes. It's you know, it's
- 1:44:11a blight on Australian law that he wasn't without the contradiction in the law is
- 1:44:16it's factually true that he exposed criminal activity, but it's also true that he
- 1:44:23broke Australian law by breaking classification. And there's a real problem there that he
- 1:44:29wasn't granted some sort of whistlebull or protection. But I think the other issue
- 1:44:33is, yes, that's true that there should have been some sort of whistleblower
- 1:44:36of protection for him. But when those two things happen, you know,
- 1:44:40when there are these sort of immovable forces within the law, there should be
- 1:44:44some sort of public conversation about where we actually should fall. And that never
- 1:44:47happened. You know that his trial never happened. He basically the whole thing
- 1:44:53just disappeared and he went straight to sentencing, which is what he's waiting for
- 1:44:55at the moment. And it also sort of highlights the idea that yes,
- 1:45:00reporting crimes or you know this stuff is important, but if the state commits
- 1:45:06the crimes, then then it's not. Then then then the state trumps the
- 1:45:12crimes. Yeah yeah, I mean that's that's definitely something that happens in Camber.
- 1:45:15You know, it's definitely an entity that is incredibly good at protecting itself.
- 1:45:21Right, So rules for you know, the but not for me kind
- 1:45:26of we have issue ahead. Your issue is what the Australian Broadcasting Corporation,
- 1:45:35which is the the National broadcaster, recently did a piece about David McBride.
- 1:45:43Uh and you know, it wasn't a hitch of but but it just it
- 1:45:45just wasn't particularly sympathetic to him and especially the reasons why he made these disclosures.
- 1:45:50And it there is just this there's this perception, I mean it's not
- 1:45:57even really perceptions, just the way that it sort of looks is that they
- 1:46:00ended up being part of the government ganging up on this guy who it's all
- 1:46:03the individuals that end up bearing the brunt of of of these things. The
- 1:46:10soldiers. It's always the soldiers. The institution crushes the person they crushed the
- 1:46:15soldier and and not and and it's it's the generally the low level soldier,
- 1:46:23right, So it's it's the enlisted or the one to four or three.
- 1:46:29It's the general. The generals are fine. At worst, they quietly retire,
- 1:46:34yeah and get it and get a multi million job on on some board
- 1:46:39somewhere. Nobody's ever going to take him a pass for the lies they told
- 1:46:43or the people they sent. You know. Yea's exactly right. And you
- 1:46:45know, the way that it worked is, you know, because we had
- 1:46:48such a poor understanding of what was happening in Afghanistan, everybody was lauded and
- 1:46:53promoted and given medals for this campaign that was that was the lack direction.
- 1:47:00But then they were already in those positions when when all of the failures were
- 1:47:02exposed, so they're like, oh well I'm already yeah, yeah, it's
- 1:47:05like what we do. Yeah yeah, I got feels about that. Okay,
- 1:47:15Scott, thank you very much. We really appreciate. What do you
- 1:47:17think of how there are soldiers who post on a scrab and describing how when
- 1:47:21they were in the Second Commander Regiment they would throw down radios on people they
- 1:47:26killed to claim they were enemy combatants. I think I think I know specifically
- 1:47:32who this person is talking about, which Instagram they're talking about, and you
- 1:47:38know he's he's a good friend of mine, and he has a tattoo of
- 1:47:41a radio of a dead affgues on his arm. Yeah. I actually,
- 1:47:48I actually don't believe that this guy ever actually threw a radio down on a
- 1:47:54dead app gut if we are talking about the same people. Uh. And
- 1:47:59in conversations that I had with him, he's like, we don't set the
- 1:48:02rules. You know. The rules are if we are told that if we
- 1:48:05see someone with an ICM radio, we're allowed to shoot them. Those are
- 1:48:09the rules that that we're given. And the tatoo is making reference to the
- 1:48:15context, which is you're going to give me ship for the job that I
- 1:48:18did the way that you told me to do it. You know that that's
- 1:48:23that's not appropriate. I'm just going to I'm going to do what you told
- 1:48:26me to do. I'm a soldier. I don't get to make my own
- 1:48:29rules. I don't get to you know, legal officers tell me what the
- 1:48:31what the what the bound of engagement are. So yeah, that's that's that's
- 1:48:35my understanding of the of the throwdown stuff that's happening on Instagram. Yeah,
- 1:48:41and that's it for the questions on feed guys. Uh, I hope you
- 1:48:45go out and get yourself a copy of Fine Fixed Finish. This book is
- 1:48:50this is the best book I have ever read about just how how how how
- 1:49:00elite soldiers come off the rails? Like how does how does a special operations
- 1:49:05a very elite unit people were specially selected and trained, but also it's a
- 1:49:12very insular culture and how does that come undone? How does that happen and
- 1:49:16why? And I think this book does a really good job of explaining that.
- 1:49:21Go check out the both find Fixed Finish, also Masul and the Commando.
- 1:49:28I don't know, Ben, do you do you have anything else that
- 1:49:30you want to tell the audience out there? Where can people find you?
- 1:49:33What's the next book coming out? Uh? Well, I mean this book
- 1:49:39came out last year, which is my memoir, which is about recovering from
- 1:49:44that stroke and that heart attack and then sort of going off and doing the
- 1:49:47things that I did, So you can check that out. The other book
- 1:49:53that I'm working on the moment is I'm working with the Australian picket captain called
- 1:49:56Pet Cummins on a book about leadership. So that'll come out out back into
- 1:50:00this year. So yeah, read all the pet Commons books, but I
- 1:50:04write will you? Uh? Will you hold up your the other book again,
- 1:50:08I'm going to read I'm going to say it for the people who are
- 1:50:10listening on a podcast, a scar is also skin. I mean the good
- 1:50:15thing is you probably won't be able to find fine fixed finish in America,
- 1:50:18but scars also skin. It's like on Spotify and Audible and well yeah,
- 1:50:23I mean full, full, full disclosure I interview or I'm sorry. I
- 1:50:28ordered this book off of Amazon and it only took like three months to get
- 1:50:31to me. You can probably get it on Kindle quite a bit faster.
- 1:50:38I would think that might be the way to go for most of the folks.
- 1:50:42So yeah, books for the other books. Yeah. Uh So on
- 1:50:47Monday we're going to be back with Rick Kaiser, who is a seal that
- 1:50:53wrote a book about Frogman stories. And then on Friday we're going to have
- 1:50:57a retired B one pilot here in studio our first Yeah, we'll be talking
- 1:51:04we'll be talking about with us. Yeah, we won't be talking about grenades
- 1:51:09and rifles in that one. It will be more of the strategic level stuff.
- 1:51:13So that'll be interesting. Ben, thank you for spending your Australian Friday
- 1:51:19morning with us. Saturday a Saturday morning is a Saturday morning or Friday morning,
- 1:51:24Saturday morning, Saturday morning. You're missing all the cartoons. Yeah,
- 1:51:30big guys. Thanks, I appreciate it, and we'll see everyone else out
- 1:51:35there next week. Thanks everyone,