Latest / MUBI Podcast / In LINGUI, Mahamat-Saleh Haroun honors women's "invisible resistance"
Transcript
- 0:04A heads up, this episode contains spoilers.
- 0:06It also includes discussion of reproductive issues and sexual violence.
- 0:10Listener discretion advised.
- 0:16It's evening, in the city in the African country of Chad, and a single mother named Amina has had a long day Her unwed teenage daughter, Maria, is pregnant, and Amina has been trying to find a way to get her an illegal abortion.
- 0:31No one's been much help.
- 0:32A local doctor, the imam at her mosque, even the guy who wants to marry her, Amina is puffing on a much needed cigarette when her daughter catches her.
- 0:41Maman?"You smoke?" she says.
- 0:45Oui.Je ne veux plus cacher."Yes." Amina says.
- 0:50"I don't want to hide anymore." After which, slowly at first and then with abandon.
- 0:56She starts happily dancing, all by herself.
- 1:08That's one of my favorite scenes in Mahamat-Saleh Haroun new movie Lingui, The Sacred Bonds.
- 1:13And I love it because it captures what's amazing about the film and all of Haroun's films.
- 1:17Here's this tough, complicated society and here's this tough, complicated person trying to transcend it.
- 1:24Yeah, it's about power in general, and it's about violence.
- 1:29If you are marginalized in a society like the mother and her daughter, the only thing that you can oppose it to the violence, the public violence is just tenderness.
- 1:42So the film is more about, you know, tenderness.
- 1:45It's the way to resist to the violence of men against women.
- 1:53That is the Cannes winning director himself.
- 1:55I am Rico Gagliano.
- 1:56And welcome back to the MUBI podcast.
- 1:59MUBI's the best place to stream beautiful hand-picked cinema.
- 2:02On this show, we tell you the stories behind beautiful cinema.
- 2:05Season two is on the way.
- 2:06Meanwhile, today, we got another special episode to tide you over.
- 2:10You're going to hear my interview with Haroun about Lingui.
- 2:13It's maybe one of the best reviewed movies of the year.
- 2:15And also, especially given the recent news out of the USA.
- 2:18It's one of the most timely movies of the year.
- 2:20You will also hear us talk about Chad's sole surviving movie theater, which makes sense because in Haroun's first feature, which is called Bye Bye Africa, he cast himself as a filmmaker who watches Chad's movie theaters vanish.
- 2:35But I started by asking Haroun what inspired him to make this new film, Lingui?
- 2:39His answer was startling.
- 2:41Well the inspiration, was an article I have read in a newspaper in Chad and it was about newborn babies, you know, that we find in garbage.
- 2:55And it's commonplace because I saw a lot of articles, and the last one was like two weeks ago.
- 3:03We have two cases.
- 3:05We found a newborn baby in a garbage and another woman, which is married, and she has a lot of kids, I think.
- 3:12And she throw her newborn baby in a toilet.
- 3:15Oh, my God.
- 3:16And so that's why I decided, you know, to make a film about this story, because a lot of women has to face this kind of problem.
- 3:25Abortion is forbidden in Chad.
- 3:28It's illegal.
- 3:29It's forbidden by religion, of course.
- 3:32And so they don't have any contraception and all these things, you know, so they are really in a kind of very bad situation.
- 3:40And I started, like, thinking about all this woman I know.
- 3:45And I remember my grandmother I grew up with her.
- 3:50She got divorced in the early 40.
- 3:55And she got just the one kid which was my father.
- 3:58And she has never been, you know, married again and she never get any kids, you know.
- 4:04So I think she has invented something like contraception, maybe, or abortion, I don't know.
- 4:11But it was a kind of tribute to my grandmother and to all these woman who are suffering of not having the possibility, you know, to make the choice that they want.
- 4:24Actually along these lines without giving things away.
- 4:27There's a whole series of challenges these female characters have to surmount in this movie.
- 4:32And there's this whole kind of underground network of women that they have to tap into to get by.
- 4:40How much of that is based on real events that either you've witnessed or been told about?
- 4:45Or is it kind of like you're just imagining what your grandmother had to go through?
- 4:49Well, you know, what we had in Chad is what we call, you know,pareille, pareille is a kind of group of women and they try to collect money every month.
- 5:00You have like one hundred woman, you know, a neighbor neighborhood.
- 5:04They put like $10 each, you know, and the whole money is given to one of them.
- 5:10And every month, you know, they start again the same, you know, collection of money and it's a way to help each other, you know, and try to find a solution.
- 5:20Are these groups created specifically for cases of abortion or are they giving each other money, you know, to help them in whatever they need?
- 5:27Yeah, in every problem that they face, you know, but I think that also they try to find solution when there is a young lady pregnant and if she doesn't want it, they try to help.
- 5:39You know, they are in an invisible way.
- 5:43It's a kind of fight and struggle and that has inspired me.
- 5:47And that's why you have all these women in the film.
- 5:51They try to help Amina to resolve the problem.
- 5:54Are there any scenes in particular that come from stories that someone told you or something that you have seen for yourself?
- 6:02Yes. Yeah.
- 6:02I made an investigation with nurses, and so they told me a lot of stories.
- 6:10They didn't tell me really...
- 6:12Who is the woman who has been involved in this kind of problem.
- 6:16You know, because they don't believe me, as a man, they are not confident to give me all, you know, the information and I do believe that they are right.
- 6:26You know, as a man, you can be just like an enemy.
- 6:30But I had a lot of information and then I started writing the script, yeah.
- 6:34So like the scene, for instance, there is a scene where an abortion clinic a doctor whose office does abortions is raided. Yes.
- 6:42Yes.
- 6:43So that unfolds basically how it might have in real life.
- 6:46That's based on an actual scene.
- 6:47Yes, of course. We have some doctors.
- 6:50You know, they used to practice abortion they know that it's illegal.
- 6:55But in a human way, they do it because they think that it's the right way, you know, to help this woman.
- 7:02I mean, it's a harrowing scene the daughter is basically she's sleeping at the clinic the night before the procedure and she's... wakes up to the sound of armed men banging on the door of the clinic.
- 7:14She sees the doctor getting shoved into a vehicle in handcuffs.
- 7:19And she ends up, she basically ends up running home alone, wearing nothing but her hospital gown.
- 7:24I mean, it's a film that shows the consequences of a lot of issues that it sounds like people in Chad
- 7:30don't want to talk about: abortion, rape, patriarchy.
- 7:34don't want to talk about: Did you have any concerns about making this in the first place?
- 7:38don't want to talk about: So I remember that I have, like, four sisters, you know, I have a lot of aunts, my mother and et cetera.
- 7:46don't want to talk about: And as the only active filmmaker in Chad.
- 7:50don't want to talk about: It was a kind of duty for me to talk about this story, because the fact in Chad is the word rape doesn't exist in our languages.
- 7:59don't want to talk about: That means that it doesn't exist if you have sexual relation by forcing a woman, it's not rape.
- 8:06don't want to talk about: It's just it happened and that's it, you know?
- 8:09don't want to talk about: So how could you talk about something which doesn't exist?
- 8:15don't want to talk about: And I'm happy to see that the film has a great success in Chad, you know, because during the screenings in Chad, we saw women, you know, a group of women, they came there and they asked Achouackh Abakar Souleymane the main character, to become their icon.
- 8:32don't want to talk about: And they want to struggle and fight to legalize abortion because they saw the film.
- 8:39don't want to talk about: I'm really happy about that.
- 8:41don't want to talk about: I was going to ask you about this because this film really doesn't pull punches in the institutions that it levels criticism at.
- 8:49don't want to talk about: That religion and the authorities all come under fire.
- 8:53don't want to talk about: And I know that the regime in Chad is not known for being especially tolerant.
- 8:58don't want to talk about: How are you even screening this film?
- 9:00don't want to talk about: Like where's it even being shown?
- 9:01don't want to talk about: Well, the film has been shown in I mean, we have just, only one cinema theater.
- 9:08don't want to talk about: And because of the COVID, it's closed now.
- 9:12don't want to talk about: So we did it at the French Institute and we did also, you know, screenings in several places, like in associations and et cetera.
- 9:21don't want to talk about: So and as I'm well known, it's difficult, you know, to say we have to forbid the screening of this film.
- 9:29don't want to talk about: It's going to be a huge like reaction, I think, in the world, because I'm a little bit well-known, you know, so I think that because I'm well-known, so I'm protected, it's my status.
- 9:42don't want to talk about: I would think it would be the opposite, though.
- 9:43don't want to talk about: It's like you're very well known and then you're attacking them.
- 9:46don't want to talk about: They would be like, well, we definitely can't allow this to be shown.
- 9:48don't want to talk about: Yeah. But the fact is just they are really very happy when I'm in Cannes, when people talk about the film in a certain way, it's a positive thing for the country, even if the film is bad, you know, it's just like a good thing because we talk about Chad in a positive way and they think that I'm a good player, you know, in a way, yeah.
- 10:14don't want to talk about: It's maybe a decent advertising for Chad that such a filmmaker could come from there.
- 10:18don't want to talk about: Yes. Yeah, I think so, yeah.
- 10:21don't want to talk about: You, I was going to ask you about this, actually.
- 10:23don't want to talk about: You left Chad as a young man during the civil wars there, and yet you live now in France, but you make almost all your movies have been set in Chad or about Chad.
- 10:32don't want to talk about: How do you think your kind of expatriate status affects the way you make these movies?
- 10:38don't want to talk about: Like how are they different than films that would be made by someone who actually lives there?
- 10:42don't want to talk about: Well, there is no difference because, you know, I'm always in Chad every two month.
- 10:48don't want to talk about: I'm always connected with the country.
- 10:51don't want to talk about: And my duty as the only filmmaker from Chad is to talk about Chad.
- 10:57don't want to talk about: If I stop, like making films in Chad, there will be no images, you know, from Chad.
- 11:03don't want to talk about: And that will be very sad.
- 11:05don't want to talk about: And I think that, you know, cinema has something to do with music.
- 11:10don't want to talk about: Cinema is a kind of symphony, you know, and in this symphony, you need all music.
- 11:16don't want to talk about: I mean, all instruments have to play.
- 11:18don't want to talk about: And I think that I am part of this symphony as a filmmaker.
- 11:23don't want to talk about: And it's important to let people, you know, listen, my little music and my little point of view, that's why it's a kind of duty for me to come back to Chad and to tell stories from this country.
- 11:36don't want to talk about: How can you be still, though, after so many years of making movies, really the only filmmaker coming out of that country, has it not inspired others to maybe make films themselves?
- 11:47don't want to talk about: Yes, I inspired a lot of people.
- 11:50don't want to talk about: You know, when I'm in Chad, I used to wear, you know, traditional clothes.
- 11:56don't want to talk about: And then now you have young filmmakers.
- 11:59don't want to talk about: They want to become like, Haroun, that's what they say.
- 12:02don't want to talk about: So they wear the same clothes and they have the same look.
- 12:07don't want to talk about: You know, trying to become like Haroun.
- 12:09don't want to talk about: And a lot of them want to make films.
- 12:11don't want to talk about: But the fact is just they are not educated in cinema.
- 12:15don't want to talk about: And as you may know, it's not easy if you haven't studied cinema and if you don't have the opportunity also to watch movies to become a high profile filmmaker, So my legacy is to try to build this cinema school.
- 12:31don't want to talk about: You know, I don't know how, but I'm more than 60, you know, 61, 62.
- 12:38don't want to talk about: So I have to let young people, you know, make films also.
- 12:42don't want to talk about: If not, it has no chance.
- 12:44don't want to talk about: If I die tomorrow, there is no young filmmaker coming from this country.
- 12:49don't want to talk about: I want, that's my goal.
- 12:51don't want to talk about: Yes, please. By the way, stay with us a little longer.
- 12:53don't want to talk about: 62 isn't that old.
- 12:54don't want to talk about: [Laughing] I mean, I do know I hear how much you love the country, and I can see it in this film.
- 13:02don't want to talk about: I notice that as grim a picture as you paint of the society, in some ways, there's actually a lot of beauty.
- 13:08don't want to talk about: You don't go out of your way to emphasize squalor or something.
- 13:11don't want to talk about: Or abject poverty.
- 13:12don't want to talk about: There are moments of showing the place almost serene.
- 13:16don't want to talk about: Even if there are a lot of problems.
- 13:18don't want to talk about: I think that there is beauty somewhere.
- 13:20don't want to talk about: You know, even if I am talking about dramas and all these tragedy, I try always to find the beauty in these places because, you know, beauty is everywhere.
- 13:33don't want to talk about: And if you want to touch people, you you have to bring out, you know, the beauty of the place.
- 13:40don't want to talk about: It's not only drama, misery and all the things.
- 13:44don't want to talk about: So that's why I'm trying to do.
- 13:47don't want to talk about: I spoke to a filmmaker one time.
- 13:48don't want to talk about: He's actually a documentarian and he said he was making...
- 13:51don't want to talk about: It was actually nothing like your film.
- 13:53don't want to talk about: It was kind of like a true crime drama.
- 13:55don't want to talk about: And he was always having a hard time with his editor because the editor was saying,"Is this guy that we're portraying"who may or may not have killed somebody, is he a good guy or a bad guy?"- Yeah.
- 14:05don't want to talk about: - And he kept saying, he can be both.
- 14:08don't want to talk about: - Things can be both.
- 14:08don't want to talk about: - Yeah, he can be both. Yeah.
- 14:11don't want to talk about: The fact is, just like there is so complexity, you know.
- 14:14don't want to talk about: Every one has his black face and his white face, you know?
- 14:19don't want to talk about: So I think that we should try to to reveal this complexity of human being, you know, and that's what I'm trying to do with my means, of course.
- 14:30don't want to talk about: - Yeah.
- 14:30don't want to talk about: - To that point.
- 14:33don't want to talk about: As I went back and watched Bye Bye Africa.
- 14:34don't want to talk about: Oh yeah.
- 14:35don't want to talk about: And you kind of star as a version of yourself.
- 14:38don't want to talk about: And at the end of that film, your character kind of seems to give up on Chad, is like, I'm leaving this place.
- 14:44don't want to talk about: Whereas in this movie there is there's beauty and there's this kind of surprising hope in it.
- 14:49don't want to talk about: It's not bleak.
- 14:50don't want to talk about: Does that reflect a change in you?
- 14:52don't want to talk about: Are you more hopeful about Chad or maybe even about what's possible in the world?
- 14:56don't want to talk about: Because it's not a super hopeful time.
- 14:57don't want to talk about: Yeah, I think I'm hopeful with...
- 15:02don't want to talk about: Yeah, some people not maybe with Chad, you know, but with this character in the film.
- 15:07don't want to talk about: Yeah.
- 15:09don't want to talk about: Yeah, I'm hopeful because I know a lot of women, you know, struggling every day trying to find a sense to their life.
- 15:18don't want to talk about: They, they keep going on, you know, even they face a lot of problems.
- 15:23don't want to talk about: And I think that...
- 15:25don't want to talk about: In a moral way, I have to give hope to these people, not about the country, but I think that it's important, you know, that if the story is just like at the end, it's a story of loser.
- 15:39don't want to talk about: There is no science also tell it.
- 15:42don't want to talk about: I think that hope is very important.
- 15:45don't want to talk about: That's why we continue to live.
- 15:51don't want to talk about: Something it's pretty clear Haroun lives for?
- 15:53don't want to talk about: Making movies and watching them.
- 15:56don't want to talk about: And actually one of the more hopeful developments in Chad has to do with that theater you heard him mentioned earlier, the only cinema left in the country, a place called The Normandy.
- 16:05don't want to talk about: For a long time, Haroun says it was an empty ruin until the government miraculously brought it back to life.
- 16:11don't want to talk about: And he told me for him, it was like getting back a little piece of his youth.
- 16:19don't want to talk about: When I was a teenager, I used to go there.
- 16:22don't want to talk about: You know, there was a screening at ten on Sunday, so we used to invite, you know, our girlfriend and we walk in this big avenue, you know, and just it was a kind of, yeah, we were happy, you know, it was happiness.
- 16:41don't want to talk about: Just like walking in the street with your girlfriend, going to cinema you know, and then in this black cinema theater, you know, you touch her hand, et cetera.
- 16:53don't want to talk about: So I had a lot of souvenir, you know, and visits.
- 16:56don't want to talk about: Yeah, my favorite cinema theater.
- 16:59don't want to talk about: What kind of theater is it?
- 16:59don't want to talk about: Is it a very old theater?
- 17:01don't want to talk about: Yeah, it has been built in the early 40 and I think that it's named Normandy because it has built by a guy from Lebanon.
- 17:12don't want to talk about: And there was a boat, a famous French boat called Normandy.
- 17:17don't want to talk about: And I think that he, he gave this name just because of this boat. You know.
- 17:21don't want to talk about: It's like a great cruise ship of a movie theater.
- 17:23don't want to talk about: Yes. Absolutely.
- 17:26don't want to talk about: Is it kind of like Art Deco?
- 17:27don't want to talk about: Well, I'm thinking 1940s, is it a movie palace?
- 17:29don't want to talk about: Yes. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 17:29don't want to talk about: It's a movie palace.
- 17:33don't want to talk about: With red seats.
- 17:35don't want to talk about: You know, it's a nice place.
- 17:37don't want to talk about: Absolutely a nice place.
- 17:39don't want to talk about: But you say it fell into ruin for a while.
- 17:41don't want to talk about: What made the government reopen it?
- 17:43don't want to talk about: I won the special jury prize in Venice, and there was no place to screen the film.
- 17:50don't want to talk about: You know, the president wanted to watch the film, and it was impossible.
- 17:54don't want to talk about: We didn't have any place.
- 17:56don't want to talk about: So we organized a screening at the president's office, and we had the whole government there.
- 18:03don't want to talk about: And it was not secure to switch off the light because it could be dangerous.
- 18:09don't want to talk about: So we screened the film in a bright, you know, place, and of course, you can see nothing.
- 18:17don't want to talk about: The images were so, I mean, it was very, very absurd in a way.
- 18:22don't want to talk about: But from this time, I think they were starting just "We need a cinema theater." And then when I won the jury prize in Cannes, they said, well, we cannot just like...
- 18:34don't want to talk about: Listen about Haroun's movies without watching them.
- 18:38don't want to talk about: So we have to renovate Normandy.
- 18:41don't want to talk about: And we started like screening movies of course, Hollywood movies, because everyone everywhere loves Hollywood movies.
- 18:49don't want to talk about: So yeah, we did it til the Corona virus, you know, killed everything.
- 18:54don't want to talk about: And I hope that in a few months we will reopen again and we can watch a movie there.
- 19:01don't want to talk about: Fingers crossed that that comes back.
- 19:03don't want to talk about: Different cultures they have different cinema culture, like in some European theaters, they have, you know, an intermission where you go out and you grab a beer halfway through the movie is there anything very specific to moviegoing in Chad?
- 19:15don't want to talk about: Yes. Yeah. You know, when we had like cinema theaters, we used to have people, you know, selling sandwiches, Coca, et cetera, you know, so it's just like a kind of African market.
- 19:30don't want to talk about: I do love these places because you have a lot of people coming there sometimes just to sleep, to play cards...
- 19:37don't want to talk about: To be just with other people to share, just like the screening.
- 19:41don't want to talk about: But they don't come there for cinema.
- 19:44don't want to talk about: So it was a yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 19:46don't want to talk about: I enjoy it very well. Yeah, very well.
- 19:48don't want to talk about: Very much.
- 19:50don't want to talk about: There are people like playing cards in the theater while the film was going on?
- 19:53don't want to talk about: Yes. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 19:54don't want to talk about: Because they have seen like the same film for ten times, you know?
- 19:58don't want to talk about: So it's just like, it's being in a cinema is a way to share the same moment, you know?
- 20:05don't want to talk about: And sometimes we some of us, you know, when we were young, they don't have like money they can't come to cinema.
- 20:13don't want to talk about: So one of us or two, three, when we finish towards the movie, we come back and then we tell them the story, you know, step by step for one hour and a half.
- 20:23don't want to talk about: You have to tell the whole film, you know?
- 20:26don't want to talk about: So it's yeah, it was a good experience of loving cinema, yeah.
- 20:30don't want to talk about: You think that's how you became a filmmaker.
- 20:32don't want to talk about: You got good at telling stories, I bet.
- 20:34don't want to talk about: Yes. Yeah. That's how we will...
- 20:36don't want to talk about: That's how I learned.
- 20:37don't want to talk about: You know, we analyze by telling the story of the film.
- 20:42don't want to talk about: We analyze at the same time, you know, the script of the film, telling the story of the film to the others.
- 20:48don't want to talk about: You can discover at this step the script, it's not really right.
- 20:52don't want to talk about: It's a little bit like...
- 20:54don't want to talk about: Weak.
- 20:56don't want to talk about: - Yeah, it's weaknesses.
- 20:56don't want to talk about: - Yes.
- 20:57don't want to talk about: Yeah. So we we learned a lot.
- 20:59don't want to talk about: You know, it was a kind of school, you know.
- 21:06don't want to talk about: Mahamat-Saleh Haroun he was apparently well schooled at the Normandy, the National Board of Review named Lingui, the Sacred Bonds, one of the top five international movies of the year.
- 21:16don't want to talk about: It's streaming on MUBI in the US, UK and many other countries as we speak.
- 21:21don't want to talk about: It's a taut 90 minutes and it really ropes you in. Seriously go check it out.
- 21:25don't want to talk about: And that is our special episode of the MUBI podcast this week.
- 21:28don't want to talk about: We got one more to come leading up to June, when we'll drop our full season two, which is all about movie theaters that made history and it's shaping up to be very fun.
- 21:37don't want to talk about: Follow us wherever you get your podcast so you don't miss it.
- 21:40don't want to talk about: While you're at it, please leave us a five star review.
- 21:43don't want to talk about: It helps others find and love us.
- 21:45don't want to talk about: We would love to hear your questions, comments, or what you think of Lingui once you see it.
- 21:48don't want to talk about: Email us at podcast@mubi.com This episode was hosted, written and cut by me, Rico Gagliano.
- 21:55don't want to talk about: Yuri Suzuki composed the theme music and Martin Austwick composed our reflective midpoint tune.
- 22:01don't want to talk about: Thanks this time to Michael Lieberman and Abby McNeil.
- 22:03don't want to talk about: The show's executive produced by me, along with Jon Barranchea Efe Cakarel, Daniel Kasman and Michael Tacca for MUBI.
- 22:10don't want to talk about: Thanks for listening.
- 22:10don't want to talk about: Be safe watch movies.