Latest / No Way Out / John Boyd's Destruction and Creation at 50: The Paper Behind the Real OODA Loop
Transcript
- 0:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose, very important day today, 50 years ago.
- 0:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Tell me what happened 50 years ago today, man.
- 0:25Mark McGrath: This is a big year, and this is a big day.
- 0:28Mark McGrath: I turned 50 May 26th this year, and somebody else turns 50 today.
- 0:35Mark McGrath: That is the published version of John Boyd's Destruction and Creation came out the 3rd of September, 1976.
- 0:43Mark McGrath: And you and I have held in our hands and read with our own eyes many of the drafts that predate this.
- 0:49Mark McGrath: Some I saw were from 75 and whatever.
- 0:52Mark McGrath: But I do like to think that I came into the world the same year that these ideas came into the world, as it is so central to the core of everything, Boyd.
- 1:00Mark McGrath: If you don't understand this paper, forget about it.
- 1:03Mark McGrath: Stop talking about Uta, stop talking about John Boyd, stop talking about a lot of things because you're gonna have a lot of, you're gonna have a hard time.
- 1:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, fantastic, man.
- 1:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't I I think a lot of folks miss the opportunity to read Destruction and Creation.
- 1:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think a lot of folks say that John Boyd never published anything.
- 1:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And this isn't really published, right?
- 1:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is just a something he pushed out there.
- 1:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can't really call this a published paper, can we?
- 1:24Mark McGrath: I think we can, and I understand what you're saying when we can't.
- 1:28Mark McGrath: He did it with no accolades.
- 1:30Mark McGrath: He just put it out there.
- 1:31Mark McGrath: Uh hell with it.
- 1:32Mark McGrath: You know, I've got other shit to do.
- 1:33Mark McGrath: And he kept his other shit to do was building and building and building on this, which you and I have talked a ton of times about how the logical follow-up to this exact paper academically would be conceptual spiral and then the essence of women winning and losing, which is the only place he ever drew Oodaloop's sketch.
- 1:50Mark McGrath: And then there's the peripheral things that are kind of like the test beds for the arguments powers of conflict, uh, strategic game, etc.
- 1:57Mark McGrath: So to your point, you you hit it the nail in the head.
- 2:00Mark McGrath: Like if a lot of people read it or try, because it is dense.
- 2:03Mark McGrath: You think, ah, it's just this little paper.
- 2:05Mark McGrath: It's not this little paper, it is dense.
- 2:07Mark McGrath: I really have to be clear with people um that I didn't grasp it fully until Chuck Spinney came out with his evolutionary epistemology, which he's revised and refined too, and that's an excellent companion.
- 2:19Mark McGrath: But nowadays with AI and models that can pressure test things, I mean, this it if if you don't understand destruction creation, something's wrong.
- 2:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I think you nailed it.
- 2:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Everybody that they think they know the OODA loop, everybody who says they do, uh almost nobody has read this.
- 2:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, we're gonna kind of go through this.
- 2:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have a slide deck up, we can talk about that too.
- 2:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I I I do want to go here.
- 2:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What is it really about in my mind?
- 2:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I like this.
- 2:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh it's to comprehend and cope with our environment.
- 2:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is important because if you're paying attention to what's happening on No Way Out recently, we've been talking about the environment, the coupling to the environment, what's missing from the linear depiction of the OODA loop.
- 2:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, but that is absolutely critical.
- 2:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're talking about cognitive warfare, we're talking about intent-based leadership, mission command, and of course, constraints-led approach, all center around the environment, which I'll argue does not exist in the way most people draw the oodaloop, but I don't think we want to get into that today.
- 3:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But we develop mental patterns of can or conceptions of meaning.
- 3:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is the uh abstract from uh destruction and creation.
- 3:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And can you confirm it's the same that you have in your hand or very similar?
- 3:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because I know there's a many versions of this out there.
- 3:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're going through a cycle of destruction creation.
- 3:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're on you're on mute.
- 3:31Mark McGrath: There we go.
- 3:32Mark McGrath: We just reoriented.
- 3:33Mark McGrath: So yeah, you're you're you're exactly correct in environment.
- 3:37Mark McGrath: And people that are familiar with our work and our discussions and our library at No Way Out and our library over on the world of reorientation know that I've done a lot on Boyd and Marshall McLuhan.
- 3:50Mark McGrath: And Marshall McLuhan, like John Boyd, is the other misunderstood guy that gets reduced to medium is the message.
- 3:56Mark McGrath: But what he's talking about is exactly what Boyd's talking about.
- 3:58Mark McGrath: Bring it back to Boyd.
- 3:59Mark McGrath: Boyd is talking about our environment.
- 4:01Mark McGrath: How do we deal with our environment?
- 4:03Mark McGrath: How does our environment have an effect on us?
- 4:05Mark McGrath: How do we interact with our environment?
- 4:07Mark McGrath: How do we update our cognitive software within our environment?
- 4:11Mark McGrath: It's always misunderstood as media or something else.
- 4:14Mark McGrath: It's environment, it's technology, and it's how people, people, ideas, things for John Boyd, it's how people deal with it.
- 4:23Mark McGrath: That is all this is saying, and that is what nobody reads, or if they do read, they certainly don't understand it.
- 4:30Mark McGrath: And when they teach it, they just go right back to the oodaloo business, little circle thing that goes around and around and around and around.
- 4:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But she brought up uh Chuck's Penny and epistemology.
- 4:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the way I understand epistemology and the way I came to understand it was actually reading through uh Chuck's work and looking back through it.
- 4:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But how does a mind build a model of the world and what happens to that model over time?
- 4:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think the a better definition of epistemology, and I've learned this through the world of complex adaptive system, it's a branch of philosophy that studies the nature, origin, and limits of human knowledge.
- 4:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So again, this is not a, to me, it's not a decision-making process where it doesn't end up being that way.
- 5:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's bigger than that.
- 5:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's how living systems emerge, how we build a model of the world, and what happens to that model over time as the environment changes.
- 5:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that consistent with the way you look at it?
- 5:16Mark McGrath: Absolutely.
- 5:16Mark McGrath: And this is what this is what you and I do.
- 5:18Mark McGrath: This is how you and I came together, is like we see this, and this is what we this is what we're trying to show people that um John Boyd was so far beyond for anything that he's memorialized for.
- 5:30Mark McGrath: And he was thinking of these things years in advance.
- 5:36Mark McGrath: And uh using maybe different different terms, but we've had come on the show, we've had Carl Friston, we've had so many others come in and basically confirm what Boyd was talking about back in the 1970s.
- 5:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Absolutely.
- 5:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How we destroy and create these patterns to permit us to shape and be shaped by a changing environment.
- 5:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That connection to me is really about uh shape and be shaped, right?
- 5:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 6:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Arrows go both ways.
- 6:02Mark McGrath: Yeah, and that's where that's where you start to bring in other thinkers, just like Boyd did, back to your word about epistemology.
- 6:07Mark McGrath: It it's not just John Boyd.
- 6:09Mark McGrath: It's John Boyd plus Marshall McLuhan plus Friedrich Hayek plus Carl Poyani, plus Carl Friston, plus all these others that I mean, if you look at the uh at John Boyd's bibliography just in the paper, and by the way, this is my original printed paper.
- 6:22Mark McGrath: It's yellow.
- 6:23Mark McGrath: I've had this for 20 years.
- 6:25Mark McGrath: Uh, he's got 36 sources in this little tiny paper, including Alan Watts.
- 6:30Mark McGrath: Right?
- 6:30Mark McGrath: People are like, oh, Alan Watts, like the guru that I see in the YouTube feed.
- 6:34Mark McGrath: Yeah, that guy, Alan Watts, was a source for John Boyd.
- 6:38Mark McGrath: And if you go to Chuck's just epistemology, he's integrated Chet Richards' visual epistemology showing Boyd's evolutionary thinking, evolutionary of thought, evolution of thought, from the time that he published this, September 3rd, 1976, up until just before his death, where he came out with the essence of winning and losing in Oodaloop Sketch, which is the only place he's ever drawn Oodaloop Sketch, and they're not four little arrows going in a circle.
- 7:06Mark McGrath: There's I I forget the exact number of arrows, but it's it's a lot more than four, and they're not going in one direction.
- 7:13Mark McGrath: They're going in a lot of directions.
- 7:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So on the speaking of that bibliography, there's a I I found this today.
- 7:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He actually quotes himself from there, or uh entry two in that is his destruction and creation, 23 March 1976.
- 7:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you brought that up earlier that the published version is actually 3 September.
- 7:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh I do want to go back in time because I've I think most folks forget the timeline we're talking about.
- 7:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's go back to 1972.
- 7:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and you read about this and I've read about this.
- 7:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Take us back then.
- 7:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh this is before 1976, before the YF-17 and YF-16 fly off.
- 7:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Take us back then and what was going on in Boyd's world.
- 7:48Mark McGrath: Okay, so Boyd's writing letters to his wife from what was called the chapter in the book of Robert Coram, Boyd the Fighter Pot that Changed the Art of War.
- 7:58Mark McGrath: The chapter is called Spook Base, and basically John Boyd was in command of the base where they were running a lot of black ops or dark ops inside of uh the Vietnam War out of uh Thailand.
- 8:08Mark McGrath: And he's writing to his wife, and he's and he's coming, he's I I forget the exact quotes.
- 8:12Mark McGrath: I don't have my copy of the book here with me, but um, he was saying something along the lines of, you know, hey, babe, I I have this like idea and this concept that I think is gonna change the way we approach learning and how we approach uh uh interacting with our world as as humans, and it's like everybody's gonna think I'm nuts, but but um I'm I'm I'm not stopping on this.
- 8:33Mark McGrath: And the way Chuck and Chet have talked to us about it, and they've said this on the show, and we've talked about this on the show, was that Boyd was sitting over there thinking, he's like, how in the hell did me, right, I don't have a PhD in aerospace engineering, I don't have a PhD in whatever, I don't even have a master's degree.
- 8:51Mark McGrath: I have two bachelor's degrees, one in economics and one in industrial engineering.
- 8:55Mark McGrath: Yet somehow I came up with energy maneuverability theory when I was a major.
- 9:01Mark McGrath: And somehow, when I was uh first lieutenant and then a very junior captain, I myself, in my free time, came up with the aerial attack study, which is still the definitive air-to-air combat study in all NATO Air Forces, even today.
- 9:16Mark McGrath: And I did that as a captain on my own time with my own busy life, my wife, my five children, one with uh special needs.
- 9:24Mark McGrath: How in the hell did I do this?
- 9:25Mark McGrath: And that was his starting point when he eventually came up with uh destruction and creation, because after he retired and so he wrote that article, or I'm sorry, that letter home around 72.
- 9:36Mark McGrath: He retires in 74, and then he basically goes subterranean as a monk and is reading thousands and thousands of books.
- 9:45Mark McGrath: And you and I have held these books in our hands and we've looked at them.
- 9:48Mark McGrath: He's not just reading them, he's reading them and he's going to war with these books.
- 9:52Mark McGrath: He's arguing with the concepts, he's fighting with whoever's writing these books, and there's thousands of them in the uh in the archives.
- 9:58Mark McGrath: And then destruction and creation is essentially the distilled core point of what he fuses together.
- 10:05Mark McGrath: There were three things that he came up with that I'm sure we're going to talk about here in a second.
- 10:09Mark McGrath: But everything he did for the next 20 years, because he died 21 years after this uh was published in 1997, everything he did after that was building off of this kernel, K-E-R-N-E L, not kernel like he was C O L O N E L.
- 10:25Mark McGrath: But this is like his, you know, like in Linux, they have the Linux kernel that everything's built off of.
- 10:30Mark McGrath: This is John Boyd's kernel of uh the everything that he built off of can all be traced back and rooted to this, which by the way, goes back and is rooted in other things that have been scientifically uh confirmed.
- 10:42Mark McGrath: And you and I say this all the time.
- 10:43Mark McGrath: We're not into pseudoscience, we're not into fake shit, right?
- 10:46Mark McGrath: So what are we talking about?
- 10:47Mark McGrath: Things that are actually grounded in science and still continue to be open to be challenged because that was Boyd's other point, is like, you know, this was one day, you know, September 3rd, 1976 was just one day, and then the next day everything changed and he riffed and kept, you know, he kept editing.
- 11:06Mark McGrath: I forget how many final versions he had of destruction and creation, but it just it never uh it never stopped.
- 11:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's safe to say that the research question that uh emerged from 72 through 76 is how did I see that and why did nobody else?
- 11:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you brought that up.
- 11:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is this is really what he's uh pursuing now.
- 11:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I think uh let's see, we got that, we looked at that.
- 11:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's go into uh the the what do we have here?
- 11:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The uh dialectic engine, where that comes from.
- 11:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I know that's in there quite a bit.
- 11:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we got two copies of uh two versions of destruction and creation in front of folks.
- 11:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But uh have you ever wondered where dialectic engine came from?
- 11:42Mark McGrath: Hegel, because I went to Jesuit school and they taught us about it.
- 11:46Mark McGrath: They taught us about philosophy, which by the way, having gone to the Jesuit school and having having been required to study 12 upper division credits of philosophy, a lot of Boyd made more sense to me faster because if you look at his source work, and again, we've seen these books in in the archives, when you look at his source work, he's sourcing philosophy, not just science, not just engineering, not just mathematics, which he also has philosophy, history, literature, eastern thinking, uh Alan Watts, like you know, talking about the Taoism and things like that.
- 12:16Mark McGrath: It it's an interdisciplinary approach, that approach that uh is is mind-blowing.
- 12:22Mark McGrath: And again, when we when we have gone in there and looked at these and held these books in our hands, it's amazing to see how he tears these books to parts and he's engaging with the author and he's going back like I guess kind of like you could think like he's dogfighting with the uh with the with the uh with the writers of these books.
- 12:39Mark McGrath: But yeah, the philosophy part of it is I think what I I think honestly, that's probably what everybody screws up and how they just get reduced to the uh mechanical linear uh model is because they're all ignorant, and I don't mean that in the in the negative way, you know, say like with a small eye, um but but ignorant in the sense that they they don't have a philosophy background or they don't have the history background or whatever, and and they don't understand that those were massive infusions into Boyd's work.
- 14:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let me uh let's go to the You brought this up a moment ago.
- 14:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's go to it right now.
- 14:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But 1931, 1927, and the second law.
- 14:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Talk to me about those, how they fit.
- 14:15Mark McGrath: Yeah, so he pulls together three things that no one ever did before.
- 14:19Mark McGrath: And if you read the bio, the biography, the quorum biography, this is something that he's actually getting like ridiculed for, but then everybody goes, Oh my god, he's right.
- 14:29Mark McGrath: Like I don't know how he did it, but but he's right.
- 14:31Mark McGrath: And what he he's because uh I forget who exactly it was either Pierre Spray or Tom Christie, and he was saying, like, John, nobody combines those things to look at those things.
- 14:38Mark McGrath: Like that they're not supposed to be combined.
- 14:40Mark McGrath: And that Boyd was like, no, F that, no.
- 14:42Mark McGrath: These things, these things do combine.
- 14:44Mark McGrath: So first one is second law thermodynamics entropy.
- 14:47Mark McGrath: Second one is the uh uncertainty or indeterminacy principle by Werner Heisenberg, and then the third thing is the incompleteness theorem by Kurt Girdle.
- 14:59Mark McGrath: G E O with the two dots over it.
- 15:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep.
- 15:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: D E L.
- 15:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So in order to determine the consistency of any new system, we must construct or uncover another system beyond it.
- 15:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's an I believe that's in destruction creation.
- 15:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's uh Goodle.
- 15:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you say it again?
- 15:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you how do you pronounce it?
- 15:13Mark McGrath: Girdle.
- 15:13Mark McGrath: He said Girdle.
- 15:14Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 15:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in Heisenberg is the uncertainty values represent the degree of intrusion by the observer upon the observed.
- 15:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll get into the observe and observer and all that stuff a little bit later on.
- 15:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And of course, the segmental law thermodynamics.
- 15:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, put it in layman's terms.
- 15:30Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 15:31Mark McGrath: I love to put it in layman's terms for people that know nothing of any of this stuff.
- 15:33Mark McGrath: All right.
- 15:34Mark McGrath: So girdle incompleteness.
- 15:36Mark McGrath: You cannot know everything.
- 15:38Mark McGrath: I mean, stop hiring people, stop looking to hire people that know everything.
- 15:42Mark McGrath: Stop telling people you know everything or you're capable of knowing everything, or attending classes with a professor that thinks he knows everything.
- 15:48Mark McGrath: It's been proven to be impossible.
- 15:51Mark McGrath: In that same thing with girdle, you cannot use algebra to prove that algebra is correct.
- 15:56Mark McGrath: You cannot use calculus to prove that calculus is correct.
- 15:59Mark McGrath: It's like Ponch just described.
- 16:00Mark McGrath: You have to be from outside the system looking in.
- 16:03Mark McGrath: So when you're sitting there in your organization looking around from the inside, guess what?
- 16:08Mark McGrath: You're surrounded by what you think is complete information in reality, is not complete.
- 16:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you brought up calculus, and I found this when I was scanning through there, but check this out.
- 16:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In one of his drafts, he would he actually took a uh jab at exactly what you just said.
- 16:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know if you ever saw that before.
- 16:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's down at the bottom of the slide there.
- 16:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, but it says the calculus is an analytical tool.
- 16:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He took this out of destruction creation, by the way, but that's why I put that in there.
- 16:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But go ahead.
- 16:33Mark McGrath: Yeah, I mean that and by the way, that's the other advantage of going into the archives or looking at this stuff, is because you can realize that Boyd's thinking was not linear.
- 16:41Mark McGrath: It was complex.
- 16:42Mark McGrath: And a lot of the stuff that he didn't publish that we found is massive and and has been uh massive in our mission of you know advancing his ideas and continue to build on them.
- 16:53Mark McGrath: But yeah.
- 16:54Mark McGrath: So that's girdle.
- 16:56Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 16:56Mark McGrath: Now, Heisenberg, I'm gonna need some help from uh from a naval aviator here.
- 17:00Mark McGrath: But basically, as I understand it, it's I cannot f if we're staying in a room together, I can fix my position, but not yours with exact with the with exactness.
- 17:08Mark McGrath: There's always gonna be because the you can't do that anywhere in the universe.
- 17:12Mark McGrath: If you're on one star and you're shooting a distance to the other, like you can never determine exactly two fixed positions.
- 17:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm down with that.
- 17:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Clear enough.
- 17:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 17:21Mark McGrath: And then the second law of thermodynamics is that all natural processes generate entropy and closed systems generate them at a a higher rate to obsolescence or irrelevance or complete dysfunction versus open systems, which embr bring in new energy, whether it's intellectual energy or human energy or whatever.
- 17:44Mark McGrath: Uh all natural processes generate entropy.
- 17:48Mark McGrath: And I think as I recall in the bio, energy and entropy were the two big wake-up calls that he that he had.
- 17:56Mark McGrath: Realizing that, again, I'm gonna rely on you, the naval aviator, the energy exchanges exchanging energy states as a as a as a as a pilot or an aircraft in the complex adaptive system of a fighter jet with a fighter pilot inside of it.
- 18:10Mark McGrath: Uh, and then entropy being when the system is closed.
- 18:13Mark McGrath: I think when my organization is closed off to outside thought, guess what?
- 18:17Mark McGrath: You're highly entropic.
- 18:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep, so you you brought up uh the second law connection to e-theory.
- 18:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have an image up on the screen that brings the three together, the three the trinity together.
- 18:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But there's a there's a document that was written in uh August 76, uh a new conception for air-to-air combat that talks about fast transients and tempo.
- 18:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Again, that will emerge later on, but the key here is ER theory, Boyd, second law of thermodynamics, and part of the uh 72 to 76 journey, which was trying to understand how did these pilots that are flying these Y F-17 and Y F-16s experience something that the air theory didn't predict, right?
- 18:52Mark McGrath: So that that's their I do want to go back to Well and then just a quick add-on to that.
- 18:57Mark McGrath: Remember in the story or when he was doing it, he was shocked with the outcome.
- 19:01Mark McGrath: So there you see the two planes, the F-16 and what became the F-17, which became the F-18, and they had a Y or a you know a Yankee at the beginning of that as they were test models, but he was shocked that they chose the F-16 over the F-18, because on paper on the E diagrams, the F-18 should have been the one that everybody chose, but the pilots were like, no, overwhelmingly, yeah.
- 19:22Mark McGrath: The F-16.
- 19:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you put the this trinity together and we get any inward-oriented yeah, snowmobile, yeah.
- 19:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any inward-oriented and continued effort to improve the matchup of concept with observed reality will only increase the degree of mismatch.
- 19:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's where he's going with this, the the Trinity.
- 19:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can expect confusion to increase until disorder approaches chaos, death.
- 19:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Fortunately, there is a way out.
- 19:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What is the way out?
- 19:52Mark McGrath: So this is funny because people are like, well, wait a minute, your show's called No Way Out, and in a conceptual spiral, he said no way out.
- 19:59Mark McGrath: Right.
- 20:00Mark McGrath: The the the way out is to do what he's telling you to do, is to constantly break and update and revise your cognitive understanding of your surrounding and your environment because the maps that you build in your head will never match reality 100%.
- 20:14Mark McGrath: And the and and if you cannot continue to do that, then that's your well, then there's no way out of the you know, that's the world because what we're talking about is the world of reorientation.
- 20:24Mark McGrath: He just used, you know, the opposite.
- 20:26Mark McGrath: He he used it to describe there is a way out and there's no way out, saying the same essentially the same thing.
- 20:31Mark McGrath: But if you're not doing that and you're not doing that well, and you're not constantly radically breaking your assumptions, you're you're you're losing.
- 20:40Mark McGrath: You're gonna you're gonna lose all those things, uncertainty, uh, entropy, and and uh incompleteness, those are gonna overwhelm you.
- 20:49Mark McGrath: And what he ended up saying is his famous quote, and he brings it out in conceptual spiral, which everybody can link and see our free copy that we put out to the world of the transcript, is that no system can determine the you know its own characteristics and nature within itself.
- 21:03Mark McGrath: And the more that, and this is the key part, moreover, the more you attempt to do that, your disorder is only gonna skyrocket.
- 21:12Mark McGrath: And that's really where that's where teams fail, that's where relationships fail, that's where organizations fail, that's where uh many human enterprises fail because they're trying to overcome those things rather than harness them and reorient within them.
- 21:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you brought up the archives.
- 21:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we right now I have an image of an earlier draft up there, and this actually addresses the question about observer and observed.
- 21:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that draft there, uh, when the observer and observed become essentially one and the same.
- 21:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I could dive a little into that more.
- 21:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But when he published it, he said when the intended distinction between observer and observed begins to disappear.
- 21:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh we know through Mary and Chet, Mary uh uh Mary Boyd that Boyd was very particular about words.
- 21:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you go back and look at the archives and you look at the number of uh copies and iterations he has on this, I mean this wasn't something he wrote in a couple days.
- 22:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It took took some time.
- 22:03Mark McGrath: Long time.
- 22:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But uh and and the references back to the case.
- 22:06Mark McGrath: Can I add one thing to that comment?
- 22:08Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 22:08Mark McGrath: Not only did it take him so um, and we have pictures of this, and I I've put this has been on the world before, he hand wrote it several times before he typed it.
- 22:17Mark McGrath: The and when you read the handwritten copies, his curse is is is is phenomenal.
- 22:23Mark McGrath: But when you're reading the handwritten copies, it's as if you're reading the actual stuff.
- 22:28Mark McGrath: Like he, you know, because cause the the there there may be a word change or a punctuation mark or something like that.
- 22:34Mark McGrath: But to see how many times he would write, not just destruction and creation, all of his briefs, how he would write them out by hand repeatedly.
- 22:42Mark McGrath: People don't do that anymore.
- 22:43Mark McGrath: Don't need I don't know that they ever need to, but but that feat in and of itself is uh uh impressive in the sense that his mind was completely focused on improving this and refining it and revising it and making sure that it what he put out there was good enough because when it got out there, he was expecting dudes like me and you to keep breaking and building and breaking and building and and and and riffing off of it.
- 23:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so hey, we talked about tempo and fast transients uh previously, but I do want to come back to that because this becomes very important later on.
- 23:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: People talk about speed.
- 23:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They they exclude the idea that the environment's part of the Ootaloop.
- 23:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And again, that's my view when they draw it with the linear uh circular version.
- 23:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But uh going back to uh something we brought up earlier in August of 1976.
- 23:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is before this uh destruction and and creation is published, there is a connection to fighter aviation again.
- 23:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We already brought brought up the YF-17 and Y Y F-18.
- 23:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you talk a little bit about that?
- 23:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh uh again, going back to the uh F-16, YF-17 and fast transients and tempo, why they're so important?
- 23:50Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 23:50Mark McGrath: Right behind me.
- 23:51Mark McGrath: Hold on, I'm gonna grab it.
- 23:52Mark McGrath: It just so happens that I have a laminated copy of this courtesy of one Brian Pontre.
- 23:59Mark McGrath: And this is this is where so much Boyd gets screwed up on speed.
- 24:03Mark McGrath: People go back to like, well, Boyd was this fighter pilot, and what he did was uh, you know, when he was a dog fighting over Korea, he could figure out this, like all I had to do is observe Orient, decide to act faster than my opponent, and I won it every time, and that wasn't the case.
- 24:18Mark McGrath: So after destruction and creation, so because the lineage that Chuck Spinney puts out is energy maneuverability theory begets destruction and creation.
- 24:26Mark McGrath: That eventually leads him to destruction and creation, which brought him to asymmetric uh fast transients because out of, and he shows how this kind of flows out of out of came the uh F-4 Phantom tactics that he said, look, this play this thing is a buzzard, but if you use these certain tactics, you could be successful with it.
- 24:46Mark McGrath: Um there was the redesign of the F-15, which was going to come out as another buzzard, and he said if you make these tweaks or whatever, you're gonna be able to improve its energy and its profile.
- 24:56Mark McGrath: Uh, and then the lightweight fighter program, which created the lightweight fighter flyoff, is what you have the uh what you have the picture in.
- 25:04Mark McGrath: And eventually that got him to asymmetric fast transients.
- 25:08Mark McGrath: That what those are is that when you're in a basketball game or a hockey game or a business meeting or a negotiation, and you keep getting hit rapidly in a way that destroys your perception of what's going on, and you're no longer able to act independently, somebody else has the uh has the edge on you.
- 25:30Mark McGrath: That's because you're all those things that you get overwhelmed with and overloaded from, you can't reorient and identify the mismatches fast enough.
- 25:38Mark McGrath: You can't change your perception fast enough to deal with those things.
- 25:42Mark McGrath: And that brought him back to going back in time and saying, uh, there's more to the story of why the F-86 was successful, more successful over the MiG.
- 25:51Mark McGrath: Not that that was his, this is where it all came from, me sitting around thinking about that.
- 25:55Mark McGrath: No, it didn't do that.
- 25:56Mark McGrath: He went back to that and he said, so now that's a lot more complex and complicated than we realized that even he had realized, and that was flowing out of his work from this sort of the convergence of destruction and creation and what he learned with the lightweight, the lightweight fly off, the lightweight fighter fly-off.
- 26:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Plenty of sense to me.
- 26:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do want to continue with why does this matter today, man?
- 26:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why, why does destruction and creation matter more today?
- 26:23Mark McGrath: Ponch, I'm sorry, I forgot to finish your other point that you always bring up.
- 26:26Mark McGrath: And you've you've talked about this with clients at the uh at the Advara Hazy Center.
- 26:31Mark McGrath: Boyd, practicing destruction and creation himself, got called out by the top gun pilots who were like, hey, wait a minute, this is all great.
- 26:39Mark McGrath: There's one thing you're forgetting the uh the pilot in the cockpit.
- 26:43Mark McGrath: Once that pilot straps in, that that machine becomes a complex adaptive system.
- 26:47Mark McGrath: It's no longer simply just the engineering of the plane or the fuel or whatever.
- 26:50Mark McGrath: It's also now how that pilot integrates himself into that system.
- 26:55Mark McGrath: And what did Boyd do?
- 26:56Mark McGrath: Shit, you're right.
- 26:57Mark McGrath: Let me reorient and keep keep moving.
- 27:00Mark McGrath: Rather than what we normally see, you're wrong, I'm right, I'm gonna ride this thing down to the bottom because it's my idea.
- 27:07Mark McGrath: And Harvard gave me a very cool doctorate, and the and the military is paying me a ton of money to tell me that I'm but right and you're wrong.
- 27:14Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 27:14Mark McGrath: It's like uh Top Gun.
- 27:16Mark McGrath: It's like your data on the MiG isn't accurate.
- 27:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 27:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So just for our listeners, the Pentagon sees that I know more than you.
- 27:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh where Moose is bringing this up from is we had an opportunity to meet with uh Captain Dan Peterson, godfather of Top Gun.
- 27:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that story is actually in his book uh where they met with John Boyd.
- 27:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is uh uh don't quote me on the dates, but it's around 69, 70, 71.
- 27:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And Top Gun bros, they had some folks that understood math as well.
- 27:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They could look at EM theory and they challenged Boyd on and said, You're forgetting about the most important uh thing in your in your equation.
- 27:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're you're leaving it out, right?
- 27:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's the human in the cockpit.
- 27:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's where our top gun, our U.S.
- 27:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Navy top gun accelerated beyond what the Air Force was doing.
- 27:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I believe, and this is my view, Moose, but that was a uh a watershed moment for Boyd that, hey, there's something wrong with this analytical approach to applying it to human or complex systems, right?
- 28:05Mark McGrath: Yeah, we can't say that yeah.
- 28:06Mark McGrath: Because remember, too, it's not just that they told the guy that came up with e theory, it's the guy that came up as a senior first lieutenant junior captain with the definitive air-to-air combat study, and they just told that to.
- 28:19Mark McGrath: And he still is like, shit, you're right.
- 28:21Mark McGrath: Let's we gotta I gotta I gotta factor that in now.
- 28:24Mark McGrath: I gotta re I gotta I gotta reorient that.
- 28:27Mark McGrath: You know, Boyd wasn't just the e theory positive, he was the e theory positive with the definitive air air-to-air study that's used at all NATO, NATO uh things.
- 28:36Mark McGrath: And I think remember, he was also what they called the high priest, you know, the high priest of uh fighter weapons school out at Nellis Air Force Base.
- 28:44Mark McGrath: And you would think, oh, there's no way they can get better than that.
- 28:47Mark McGrath: Yeah, they can.
- 28:47Mark McGrath: And that and Boyd was always open to that.
- 28:49Mark McGrath: And he always knew that that that's how you had to approach things.
- 28:51Mark McGrath: So so when Navy guys were, I don't even know if they were like, you know, calling him out like like punking him out, like they were saying, Hey, have you thought of this?
- 28:59Mark McGrath: And he's like, No, I hadn't.
- 29:01Mark McGrath: And by the way, you just you just helped me uh piece that into everything that I've done and make it even better, which is what he wants, because nothing was set in stone.
- 29:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So again, the timeline is there is no sketch at this point.
- 29:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There, you know, we're still 19 years or or so from the emergence of the Otaloop sketch.
- 29:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We are 25, 30 years away from folks like Carl Fristin coming up with the free energy principle, and I want to point out something back in destruction and creation that just double check me on this to make sure it's accurate.
- 29:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We use observations to sharpen a concept and a concept to sharpen observations, both directions in one breath, right?
- 29:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's in there.
- 29:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're talking about the arrow going back and forth.
- 29:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Perception updates the model, and the model decides what counts as evidence.
- 29:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is the prediction error loop that that uh Carl Friston talks about.
- 29:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, orientation generates predictions, we have new information coming in.
- 29:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Boyd called them what?
- 29:56Mark McGrath: Hypotheses.
- 29:57Mark McGrath: And mis yeah, hypotheses and mismatch, right?
- 30:00Mark McGrath: Mismatch, yeah.
- 30:01Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 30:01Mark McGrath: So I think that's the other that's the other thing that we've been adamant about, but also too, because this is what Boyd actually drew in the actual Oodaloop sketch.
- 30:11Mark McGrath: Decisions are hypotheses.
- 30:14Mark McGrath: They're not set in stone, they're not, they're hypotheses that get acted upon.
- 30:20Mark McGrath: Action is a test.
- 30:21Mark McGrath: He put it on the sketch so you can see that.
- 30:23Mark McGrath: A decision is a hypothesis.
- 30:25Mark McGrath: He's telling you that.
- 30:26Mark McGrath: A test, an action is a test.
- 30:28Mark McGrath: Oh, and by the way, there's a feedback loop that's that you get the feedback and the results, and you need to reorient that.
- 30:35Mark McGrath: And that's all rooted back uh right into this, uh, right into this paper, destruction creation.
- 30:40Mark McGrath: If you don't understand that, that's how you get speed kills, and you know, I just go fast and I just go around these four steps, and we just our ood loop was faster than their oodaloop, or I'm gonna get inside their oodaloop.
- 30:50Mark McGrath: And that those aren't necessarily wrong in a linear, simplified situation explanation of things, but in reality, yeah, they're way off.
- 30:58Mark McGrath: And as a uh when you're competing and you don't understand that, you're in trouble.
- 31:04Mark McGrath: If you're a if you're a basketball coach, if you're a stock trader, if you're a uh anything, you if you can't change your model, you're going to you're going to lose.
- 31:16Mark McGrath: If you can't reorient and readapt because, well, I'm from this coaching tree, or this is the way we've always learned it, or this is the way they taught it at war college, or this is the way they're you're off.
- 31:25Mark McGrath: You're done.
- 31:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We had Carl Friston on here, and he brought up exactly what you talked about when we showed him the loop, and he asked about the hypothesis three.
- 31:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do you remember what he said?
- 31:36Mark McGrath: First of all, let me just preface that.
- 31:38Mark McGrath: The most cited neuroscientist in history, Carl Friston.
- 31:43Speaker 1: So so did did he actually use the words hypothesis and test for those two?
- 31:48Mark McGrath: He he did, yes.
- 31:49Mark McGrath: Yes.
- 31:49Mark McGrath: When he drew out the sketch, he he did use uh those those exact terms.
- 31:56Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, that uh you know that's my frame of way of thinking about the free energy principle.
- 32:00Speaker 1: This is you know, I talked about inference to the best explanation, but you know, um you could equally frame that in terms of hypothesis testing.
- 32:07Speaker 1: Um so all my active engagement in the world is just soliciting the right observations that enable me to disambiguate and test my hypotheses.
- 32:19Speaker 1: So you know th this is isomorphic with um with active inference.
- 32:23Mark McGrath: Um Boyd was not only ahead of his time, but when you when you get consultants in or people quote unquote coaching on decision-making processes and stuff like that, you almost never hear of of of a decision as a hypothesis.
- 32:37Mark McGrath: Right.
- 32:37Mark McGrath: Right.
- 32:38Mark McGrath: So hey, you don't hear of strategy as a mental tapestry of changing intentions either.
- 32:42Mark McGrath: And these are again things that Boyd demonstrated that the the linear textbook approved business school uses and applications of these things is wrong.
- 32:50Mark McGrath: And if you're stuck to that, you're married to that, someone's gonna get you every single time.
- 32:55Mark McGrath: Exactly.
- 32:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's go back to uh well, I want to go to orientation last, but I do want to talk about mismatches.
- 33:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: With Carl Friston, we talk about surprise.
- 33:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Mismatch is the engine.
- 33:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I would say is it that's what we want to create for our opponents.
- 33:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what we want to create on the on a on the gridiron.
- 33:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what we want to create on a basketball court, is a mismatch, right?
- 33:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But we want to do what?
- 33:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We want to minimize our mismatch.
- 33:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So somebody else takes an action.
- 33:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We want to make sure we perceive it, we see that information, and our model is updated towards it so we can reduce the energy or reduce the free energy, uh, reduce the surprise.
- 33:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any thoughts on that?
- 33:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: On on how he's gonna be able to do that.
- 33:31Mark McGrath: We want to minimize our yeah, we want to minimize the friction, no matter where it comes from.
- 33:37Mark McGrath: It could come from mismatches, it could come internally, it could come come externally.
- 33:41Mark McGrath: We want to minimize friction and increase that of our of our opponents.
- 33:46Mark McGrath: And how we do that is via mismatches.
- 33:50Mark McGrath: When something doesn't add up and I have to call back and ask, hey, if something I see I've never seen before just happened, what do I do?
- 33:57Mark McGrath: I don't know.
- 33:58Mark McGrath: Let me stop and let me ask.
- 33:59Mark McGrath: Oh yeah, we're not sure.
- 34:01Mark McGrath: You know, or or do what the book says, do what the formula says.
- 34:04Mark McGrath: You're done.
- 34:05Mark McGrath: You're done.
- 34:06Mark McGrath: There's and there's so many examples.
- 34:08Mark McGrath: We could talk about, we've talked about blockbuster, we've talked about Kodak, we've talked about the six-day war, you know, predictable patterns.
- 34:16Mark McGrath: People that set predictable patterns and operate off linear formulas do not handle mismatches well.
- 34:22Mark McGrath: And if you as an insurgent, if you in in an organization understand that in a competitor, if you can solve that for yourself, you're gonna see that gap, that mismatch in your competitors a lot faster than you would otherwise.
- 34:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose, I'm wondering if uh we can kind of come up to wrapping this up here in a moment.
- 34:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A couple last final thoughts from you, and then uh try to bring this home as to what's on the last page or the the the final sentence of the paper.
- 34:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What you know, if you if you have that available, I don't know if you do.
- 34:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do.
- 34:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and I have it available.
- 34:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think it's up on the screen.
- 34:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have a couple versions of it.
- 34:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But and I read that.
- 34:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, this is critical, right?
- 34:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's in the abstract.
- 35:00Mark McGrath: We'll start with the, yeah, we'll start with the last line because I have I have five questions to ask the opponents of this that you know we can maybe even edit out and have as just as a thing for them to think about.
- 35:11Mark McGrath: But the last line of destruction and creation, as indicated earlier, these mental concepts are employed as decision models by individuals and societies for determining and monitoring actions needed to cope with their environment or to improve their capacity for free and independent action.
- 35:31Mark McGrath: And contextually, I mean, you in theory, you should read the other two sentences, which basically was saying, like, hey, look, I'm putting these three things together: entropy, uncertainty, and incompleteness.
- 35:43Mark McGrath: And the result is that the universe is always changing, and guess what?
- 35:47Mark McGrath: And expanding.
- 35:48Mark McGrath: And guess what?
- 35:49Mark McGrath: If our mental concepts aren't doing that either, then we're we're screwed.
- 35:54Mark McGrath: You know, we might think that a basketball game this Saturday will be different than the one on the next Saturday.
- 35:59Mark McGrath: No, the next Saturday will be different.
- 36:01Mark McGrath: Why?
- 36:02Mark McGrath: Everybody's gonna be a week older.
- 36:03Mark McGrath: The seasons will be a week, you know, this the the Earth's temperature and everything, it will be a week longer.
- 36:09Mark McGrath: They have more or less daylight.
- 36:10Mark McGrath: You know, all these things are changing around us all the time.
- 36:13Mark McGrath: And destruction and creation is teaching us to say, I don't have to count for all of that.
- 36:17Mark McGrath: I just have to accept that that's happening, and that's why I have to constantly update my cognitive software.
- 36:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's great, man.
- 36:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So a changing and expanding universe of mental concepts matched to a changing and expanding universe of observed reality.
- 36:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So 1972, he was chasing the theory of learning, understanding why him.
- 36:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: By March of 1976, he had the draft, and September 3rd, 50 years ago today, he had the document, which Yes.
- 36:46Mark McGrath: And and this was not the final rendition.
- 36:49Mark McGrath: He kept, he kept revising it.
- 36:50Mark McGrath: He kept revising it, and then he kept building off of it with, say, patterns of conflict.
- 36:55Mark McGrath: Well, guess what?
- 36:56Mark McGrath: There's 39 versions of patterns of conflict that we know about.
- 36:59Mark McGrath: I mean, there's uh I think Mary said there might even be a few more.
- 37:02Mark McGrath: Same thing with conceptual spiral.
- 37:03Mark McGrath: He was going to call it originally No Way Out, right?
- 37:06Mark McGrath: So he didn't stop and set these things in stone.
- 37:08Mark McGrath: That's why he hated to put things down.
- 37:10Mark McGrath: Um, that's why he was so hesitant to publish this.
- 37:12Mark McGrath: That he was just put it out there.
- 37:14Mark McGrath: That's all that's really all that happened.
- 37:15Mark McGrath: And remember, 1976.
- 37:17Mark McGrath: I mean, I don't remember that day.
- 37:18Mark McGrath: It was my grandmother's uh 64th birthday, by the way, that day.
- 37:22Mark McGrath: And um there was no internet, there was no AI, there was no Google, there was no cell phones, you couldn't airdrop this to people, it couldn't spread.
- 37:31Mark McGrath: You know, he had to run around and tell people the old-fashioned way.
- 37:34Mark McGrath: And and and I want to glue this together with this punch because in sad and uh uh Osinga's book, which by the way, a lot of UDA scholars have never read because they don't source it in their writing, the last line of that kind of adds in that.
- 37:49Mark McGrath: The last line, he developed a rich, comprehensive novel theory that is proven strong, valuable, and influential, even if he left it deliberately incomplete.
- 38:00Mark McGrath: That's where we are, that's why we exist, that's how we know each other, is to help people keep building on that and Boyd recognize that.
- 38:08Mark McGrath: And when when Osinga says the theory, well, it's this.
- 38:11Mark McGrath: This is the starting point.
- 38:12Mark McGrath: This is the this is the core.
- 38:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what I'm sharing on the screen right now, most uh just so our listeners can hear it, right?
- 38:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's destruction and creation, it's patterns of conflict, uh, organization design for organic design for command and control, the strategic game and conceptual spiral.
- 38:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then he breaks it down and he tells you where the Oodaloop came from.
- 38:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh I do have a question to our listeners out there.
- 38:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The OODA loop scratch.
- 38:33Mark McGrath: Yeah, the yeah, the OODA loop scratch.
- 38:34Mark McGrath: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 38:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, so this is this again, it starts with destruction and creation.
- 38:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But for our listeners out there, uh if you can see in the left side under the strategic game, there are uh acronyms that Moose I don't have a clear picture of.
- 38:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's S-E-E P I C W.
- 38:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: IT, I think I I have, but I'm trying to get a grip on that.
- 38:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But anyway, you can see the Oodaloop sketch uh evolve over time.
- 39:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm sharing that with our listeners right now so they can see that Boyd never sketched or he never published the Oodaloop as a linear four-step process.
- 39:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we need to stop that.
- 39:11Mark McGrath: We absolutely need to stop that.
- 39:12Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 39:13Mark McGrath: I've got so 50 years, I can think of 50 questions to ask people that don't understand Boyd or teach Boyd the wrong way, but I've distilled it down the five for them.
- 39:24Mark McGrath: Okay, number one, if your picture of reality is wrong, what exactly do you gain by moving through it faster?
- 39:32Mark McGrath: Right?
- 39:33Mark McGrath: I mean, that's the whole point of destruction creation, is to try to make your perception, your picture of reality, updated to what reality actually is.
- 39:41Mark McGrath: And if you don't understand that, and if you don't understand about orientation and that orientation shapes, what difference does it make how fast you're going?
- 39:49Mark McGrath: So, Moose, I want to build on that if I can, if I may.
- 39:51Mark McGrath: Yeah, but in a flow state or more, but that's what we're gonna do.
- 39:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what I got them.
- 39:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In a flow state, it it's likely, and I can't confirm this, and I don't know if neuroscience can back me up on this, you're probably not moving.
- 40:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're you're not operating as fast as you possibly can.
- 40:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you're you're seeing more, you're perceiving more, you have more energy to apply to novelty.
- 40:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're not going faster in an Oodaloop.
- 40:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can't.
- 40:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 40:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're in a flow state.
- 40:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And flow doesn't mean fast.
- 40:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It means everything slows down around you.
- 40:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just a just a thought there.
- 40:21Mark McGrath: Continue.
- 40:21Mark McGrath: That's right on.
- 40:22Mark McGrath: I mean, you're show, you're showing the multidimensional complex nature of reality versus just go really fast, go really fast, go really fast.
- 40:30Mark McGrath: Blockbuster went really fast.
- 40:32Mark McGrath: Let's be honest.
- 40:33Mark McGrath: They went really fast right off the cliff.
- 40:35Mark McGrath: Why?
- 40:35Mark McGrath: They they were completely disoriented, and their competitors like Netflix and others understood that.
- 40:40Mark McGrath: Okay, number two, Boyd warned that you cannot determine the character of the system entirely within itself.
- 40:47Mark McGrath: So, what happens to an organization that keeps consulting the same doctrine, the same data, the same experts, and the same assumptions?
- 40:57Mark McGrath: You sound like sports.
- 40:58Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 41:00Mark McGrath: If I got a limited understanding of the ODA loop, I'm not orienting.
- 41:03Mark McGrath: I don't understand orientation.
- 41:04Mark McGrath: It's not it it it the the sketch is multidimensional.
- 41:07Mark McGrath: And if I don't understand how it shapes implicit through implicit guidance and control, I can't do that.
- 41:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 41:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh one one thought that comes up here is when you talk to uh the coaches that are in the constraints-led approach space, they say that younger coaches uh that are curious uh and that are are struggling with uh understanding why things aren't changing, those are the ones that actually want to learn about perception action coupling.
- 41:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And where I'm going with this is that it's not the ones that have been doing it for 40 or 30 years.
- 41:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In fact, anytime anybody comes to me and says, I've been coaching for 20 plus years, I'm like, that doesn't make you an expert in anything, man.
- 41:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You need to get outside your your own domain.
- 41:43Mark McGrath: Yeah, and curiosity is such a bad rap, right?
- 41:46Mark McGrath: Because curiosity allegedly killed the cat.
- 41:48Mark McGrath: But when you think about it, curiosity is what kills your competitors.
- 41:51Mark McGrath: If you're, if you're gonna, if you're gonna, if you're not curious, guess what?
- 41:56Mark McGrath: You know, maybe we have to define that word because sometimes he's kind of a curious person.
- 42:01Mark McGrath: You know, like there are, as Boyd, you you brought it up earlier, words have meanings, and you know, but if you're not curious, if you're not, let's put it this way, if I don't have a humble approach to in my intellect and learning, I there's no way.
- 42:16Mark McGrath: You have to be humble because why incompleteness.
- 42:19Mark McGrath: I I can't have all information.
- 42:21Mark McGrath: And if I think that I can't, if I'm a know-it-all, I'm screwed.
- 42:24Mark McGrath: Remember, Boyd loathed the term analyst and expert.
- 42:28Mark McGrath: Analyst was a half-wit, because you're not synthesizing, and expert was a know-it-all.
- 42:32Mark McGrath: And that says you can't learn anything.
- 42:34Mark McGrath: It means your orientation's frozen.
- 42:35Mark McGrath: All right, ready for number three?
- 42:36Mark McGrath: Yep.
- 42:37Mark McGrath: Yep.
- 42:37Mark McGrath: All right.
- 42:38Mark McGrath: If uncertainty, incompleteness, and entropy are unavoidable, why are you trying to eliminate them instead of learning to operate better than your competitors inside them?
- 42:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 42:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Those are features of the basically features of the environment.
- 42:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't eliminate, we can't eliminate them, right?
- 42:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What does he say?
- 42:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's the name of our podcast?
- 42:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's no way out.
- 42:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can't do it.
- 42:58Mark McGrath: Of the world of reorientation because yeah, of those things.
- 43:01Mark McGrath: Okay.
- 43:01Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 43:02Mark McGrath: And by the way, people listening, and you have a company, I'm sorry, that's worth millions, maybe billions of dollars.
- 43:08Mark McGrath: If you don't understand that alone, your competitors do, and you don't, it's the difference between profit of a billion or loss of a billion in some cases.
- 43:15Mark McGrath: All right, number four, which is more dangerous?
- 43:18Mark McGrath: A competitor who acts faster than you, or one who can recognize that the entire situation has changed while you are still executing yesterday's models.
- 43:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hmm.
- 43:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I like that one.
- 43:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A competitor who acts faster.
- 43:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: First mover doesn't mean me doesn't always work out.
- 43:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 43:36Mark McGrath: Right.
- 43:37Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 43:37Mark McGrath: Because you're disoriented.
- 43:39Mark McGrath: And if that guy's moving faster and my computer Well, if I'm not if I'm Netflix and my competitor's blockbuster, I mean we beat that one up, but it's so readily, it's so easy to see.
- 43:50Mark McGrath: Um they're just gonna go really fast, just right off the cliff.
- 43:53Mark McGrath: Okay, last one, ready?
- 43:54Mark McGrath: Yep.
- 43:55Mark McGrath: All right, here we go.
- 43:57Mark McGrath: If your competitor can destroy a failing concept, create a better one, and regain freedom of action before you even realize your orientation is obsolete, what makes you think you're still competing?
- 44:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hmm.
- 44:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I like that too.
- 44:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Nice.
- 44:15Mark McGrath: And that just goes right back to sum it all up to this the stated goal, as he says, in order to improve our capacity for free and independent action.
- 44:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well done.
- 44:26Mark McGrath: If your competitor can destroy a failing concept, read in your mind, and and and I can't, right?
- 44:32Mark McGrath: If if your competitor can, you can't.
- 44:34Mark McGrath: If your competitor can destroy a failing concept, create a better one, and regain freedom of action before you even realize your orientation is obsolete, what makes you think you're still competing?
- 44:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well done.
- 44:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, I'm gonna uh share one last screen, and it's just Boyd's handwritten notes about uh the timeline.
- 44:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh timeline from patterns, you know, uh you can look from 1957 through 1991.
- 44:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I think this note is from 1991, but look at where DNC fits, and that's what we're saying is the uh genesis, if you will, the origins of the the real Oodaloop.
- 45:09Mark McGrath: It's one of my favorite uh things because uh overwhelmingly so much of what people say as the They quote unquote are experts about Boyd or write books about Boyd or whatever.
- 45:24Mark McGrath: They've never seen this in Boyd's own hand, in Boyd's own words.
- 45:28Mark McGrath: That's the thing that gets so frustrating.
- 45:30Mark McGrath: Boyd actually who said so?
- 45:32Mark McGrath: John Boyd.
- 45:33Mark McGrath: How do you know?
- 45:34Mark McGrath: Because we went to the archives and we found it.
- 45:36Mark McGrath: So there you go.
- 45:37Mark McGrath: There it is, right there.
- 45:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Awesome, man.
- 45:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, we'll get this out today.
- 45:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So for our listeners out there, we've got a lot going on on the on No Way Out everywhere.
- 45:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Actually, Moose, you want to tell folks where you are at the moment, if you don't mind?
- 45:48Mark McGrath: I can't, I yes, that's actually I am uh in the midst of a live experiment over a period of a few months to intentionally crash orientation and rewrite it in a uh uh a radical environment of radical destruction creation.
- 46:03Mark McGrath: I am in Buenos Aires, Argentina, deliberately to use this as a laboratory to, as you can see, I have my theory, I've got my compendium of boyd briefings, I've got my snowmobile book that is going all around me and constantly, constantly, constantly challenging my assumptions using Buenos Aires as the testing ground.
- 46:23Mark McGrath: And yes, I will be writing a lot about this, as I have been, uh, since I've been here now two weeks and two days.
- 46:30Mark McGrath: I'll give you, I'll give you a great example.
- 46:32Mark McGrath: You know, every everybody who's who's a regular listener knows that you and I are both Hispanic.
- 46:35Mark McGrath: Yours is a little easier to detect because of your last name.
- 46:38Mark McGrath: Mine's a little harder to detect because mine uh I have an Irish last name, um, but I'm Irish and Puerto Rican and I speak Spanish.
- 46:45Mark McGrath: I've been academically and and conversationally studying Spanish since I was in grade school, did it all through college and used it practically, blah, blah, blah.
- 46:53Mark McGrath: I thought I knew Spanish well enough.
- 46:55Mark McGrath: Boy, Argentina is a different kind of Spanish, right?
- 46:57Mark McGrath: This is the exact example of like we'll say, how are you applying destruction and creation?
- 47:03Mark McGrath: I literally have to destroy almost daily my model of what I think Spanish is and how I speak it versus the reality that I'm confronted with every single day.
- 47:11Mark McGrath: And I've started to to integrate different words, different pronunciations, different accent things so people can understand me better.
- 47:17Mark McGrath: Because I I came down here with a map, and that map is constantly changing because of the reality that that Buenos Aires uh puts in front of you.
- 47:26Mark McGrath: So, yes, that's the uh that's the intent of this uh of this trip to be a living experiment in uh destruction and creation.
- 47:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sweet, let's wrap it up there, man.
- 47:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh 50th uh anniversary of destruction and creation, 3 September 1976.
- 47:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That is today.
- 47:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're gonna get this out today.
- 47:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh let us know if you have any questions and if if you can help us uh solve some of the mysteries of uh Boyd Zoodaloop, uh please join us here on No Way Out and the World of Reorientation.
- 47:52Mark McGrath: And if you check out the world today, there is uh something you see behind me, I have it as the backdrop, my uh using you know, using to help me create illustrative things to help people understand Boyd better.
- 48:03Mark McGrath: Um article today.
- 48:05Mark McGrath: I I didn't, no, no, and I didn't pay seven grand to a uh a graphic artist to go through it on paper.
- 48:12Mark McGrath: No, I just don't do that.
- 48:13Mark McGrath: Yeah, because I destroyed and created the, you know, the the old model has been destroyed, the new one's been created.
- 48:18Mark McGrath: So by the way, you know, maybe another it's another podcast probably, but talk about destruction and creation.
- 48:24Mark McGrath: How many people have destroyed their own conceptions and allowed it to be created by AI such that they go to an article, they scan for AI, using AI to see what's AI and not human, as the human framed everything they wrote to not sound like AI, and they don't they completely misunderstand their environment.
- 48:41Mark McGrath: And that's where the Boyd and McLuhan connection comes in, and there's a lot coming on that, and there's I've written a lot about that, and a lot more to come on that, because people are seeding their own agency and their own autonomy, exactly the opposite of what Boyd is telling you to do by searching the world to see who's using AI and allowing AI to tell you what is AI and what's human.
- 49:03Mark McGrath: And they just don't get it.
- 49:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 49:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Cycles of destruction creation.
- 49:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're all going through them.
- 49:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh appreciate your time, Moose.
- 49:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll keep you on here for a moment and we'll uh get to the Urban.
- 49:12Mark McGrath: Ciao, as we say in our as we say in Argentina.
- 49:13Mark McGrath: Ciao.
- 49:14Mark McGrath: Ciao.