Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Risk Appetite and Risk Management Framework
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03We are here today to talk about corporate governance.
- 0:07You could call it corporate governance part two.
- 0:09You could call it risk management framework.
- 0:11We're going to talk about risk appetite and.
- 0:14Issues that we discussed in a previous episode, which was the global
- 0:19concept of corporate governance.
- 0:21And I'm joined as I am frequently with Steve Farr and Todd Miller
- 0:26of my team, and formerly of NCUA.
- 0:30Good morning.
- 0:31Yeah, good morning.
- 0:32Good morning.
- 0:33And if just in case we have a first time listener, if you guys
- 0:38could give a brief intro of your time at NCUA and what you did.
- 0:43There and why don't we start with Steve?
- 0:45Yeah.
- 0:46All right.
- 0:46You're what my 30 years specifically more applies to this subject for my 1st, 15
- 0:52years into I was involved in the field.
- 0:55Most of it is the problem case officer.
- 0:57Along those lines, you get to become involved.
- 1:00In the operations of those trouble credit unions and fixing.
- 1:05The operations and planning and setting them up for success.
- 1:09So I think that comes in into play a lot here for this subject.
- 1:13Then the last 15 plus years I had it into I was in the central office.
- 1:18Where worked a lot on developing guidance for the examiners and looking at,
- 1:24how other regions were dealing with.
- 1:27Credit unions in helping them resolve operational and issues and such.
- 1:32And then I was involved in a lot of rulemaking at NC way, which provided
- 1:36a good basis for dealing with this subject very good and Todd, your
- 1:41background at NC way before retirement.
- 1:45I spent about 34 years with NCUA.
- 1:48I can break my career into about three parts.
- 1:51The first third of it as an examiner and a problem case officer dealt with a
- 1:56lot of troubled credeans there as well.
- 1:58The second part of my career, I was a capital market specialist for about
- 2:02a decade and trained NCUA's staff on interest rate, liquidity worked with a lot
- 2:08of troubled credeans in that era as well.
- 2:12And that capital markets position really focused on risk management to a great
- 2:16extent in very specific details as to interest rate and liquidity risk.
- 2:22And then the last third of my career, I was the Director of Special
- 2:25Action Supervising Problem Case Officers, Capital Market Specialist,
- 2:29Regional Lending Specialist.
- 2:30And once again, a big focus on troubled credit unions are
- 2:34large, complex credit unions.
- 2:36Enjoyed my 34 years with NCUA, learned a lot.
- 2:39Hopefully, we can share a little bit of that experience with listeners today.
- 2:45That's fantastic.
- 2:46All right, guys.
- 2:46Risk management framework.
- 2:48How do we want to kick this this hot topic off?
- 2:51I wanted to start with that, we've talked a lot about the proposed rules
- 2:56that FDIC put out that would apply to their financial institutions above
- 3:0110, 10 billion, and it was guidelines, establishing standards for corporate
- 3:06governance and risk management.
- 3:08And there was a notice of proposed rulemaking issuance of guidelines.
- 3:12And I think it's important that we like the document and what it, how
- 3:17it pretty concisely lays out all of the elements of corporate governance
- 3:22and it does a good job of that.
- 3:25I wanted to make it clear that we're not, saying, that they
- 3:28should put this rule in place.
- 3:29So I thought why don't I look at what the comments came in on that, because
- 3:33the comment period for that ended.
- 3:35They ended originally in it goes October, December of 2023, and they extended it
- 3:42for another month and a week into 2024.
- 3:47And so I looked at the comments on there are 67 comments, which is
- 3:51quite a bit, but, then they had a form letter that was 82 comments.
- 3:55It was exactly the same.
- 3:57But in summary, the banks and bank trade organizations really had
- 4:04some concern about, the cost of implementing this and certainly.
- 4:08All these guidelines proposal policy, do have costs associated with them.
- 4:13And, that's something we bring up a lot in terms of when NCOA
- 4:17or other agencies tell you to do something is, remind them of that.
- 4:22It's not cost free.
- 4:24And they had some issues over the time that it was going to be spent on
- 4:28this that are inside the regulation.
- 4:31They thought it might be overly prescriptive blurred the line
- 4:36between the board and management.
- 4:39And I think 1 thing we like about this, and it does put.
- 4:42The emphasis back and the power back in the board of directors for taking control.
- 4:47They would like to, they think it's misaligned a little bit with
- 4:50the Federal Reserve Bank and OCC.
- 4:52The OCC has very similar requirements inside of their regulation that
- 4:59apply to banks over 50 billion and which you can find in 12 CFR 30,
- 5:05the safety and soundness standards.
- 5:08It, and everyone was there's a concern that.
- 5:11Because of the requirements put on the board of make it difficult
- 5:14to attract new board members and I think that is institutions get
- 5:19bigger that certainly you're looking for good quality board members.
- 5:24And I would think that if your institution has a good reputation and
- 5:28standing in your community, that's probably shouldn't be that difficult
- 5:32to attract good board members.
- 5:34Too many policies to approve.
- 5:36Yes, there are a number of policies that it emphasizes in there.
- 5:40The overuse of the word ensure that could set up unrealistic expectations.
- 5:48They asked, making that size consistent with the OCC's rules.
- 5:54There are some potential conflicts with state laws.
- 5:57So that's what the institutions have in there.
- 6:00Nobody said anything about, wow, this is just really poor guidance.
- 6:05None of that.
- 6:07That's interesting.
- 6:08And as you said that, I go to my friendly dictionary dot com.
- 6:12You, you know what a word means, but when you look at the actual words of it,
- 6:16it can it, it can actually sometimes.
- 6:18Drive a point home, even more certainly.
- 6:21So insurer means make certain that something shall occur or be the case.
- 6:26So you're making certain they're basically putting a heavy burden on that
- 6:29board with the use of the word insurer.
- 6:31So that's a good point.
- 6:32And your point that it's only guidance will it ever get approved?
- 6:37Who knows?
- 6:38But the reason we refer to it a lot here on the podcast and here in credit
- 6:42union conversations, is because.
- 6:44Is it's principle based and has a lot of really good ideas.
- 6:47So I think it's good to talk through that.
- 6:49I'm glad you brought that up.
- 6:50Steve had any comments on what Steve post there.
- 6:54It's principle based and that's good.
- 6:56And I think we'll probably get into this more in the podcast.
- 6:59You see this a lot in exam reports.
- 7:01You see it a lot in writing.
- 7:03You see it from the F.
- 7:04D.
- 7:04I.
- 7:04C.
- 7:05All the regulators are consistent on, a risk management philosophy and program.
- 7:11sophistication.
- 7:12Things should be commensurance with the institution size and complexity.
- 7:17You just see that throughout the gamut.
- 7:18And I think probably in this case, I didn't look at the
- 7:22comments like Steve did.
- 7:24When you start regulating specific instances for specific institutions,
- 7:30Regulators and employees and examiners, they tend to drag that bar down to
- 7:37way below where the regulation says it's just their natural tendency.
- 7:41I think part of it is, it's an attempt to improve institutions when they do that.
- 7:46But examiners specifically, they tend to lose sight of that cost
- 7:51piece when they start placing burdens and expectations from a larger
- 7:56credit union on a smaller one.
- 7:59And we see that off, we saw it a lot when we were at NCUA and we're seeing
- 8:02it now in our current roles that trickle down you can say it's 10 billion.
- 8:06And ironically too is you get a lot of comments as Steve
- 8:10described on the cost, right?
- 8:12And you'd think, okay the 10 billion credit union or a 10 billion bank who
- 8:16commented on this would be a bank is concerned about the costs of all this.
- 8:21So even the big institutions.
- 8:24Have cost pressures.
- 8:26And then when you throw that trickling down below the 10 billion, because an
- 8:29examiner looks at it, or we look at it and tell a credit union that, hey, you
- 8:34might want to consider these principles.
- 8:35That does have a trickle down effect and a huge cost effect.
- 8:39So risk management framework.
- 8:41What is it?
- 8:42What does it include?
- 8:43And what can credit unions glean from the concept of risk management framework
- 8:49and what they should do to keep keep their institution running optimally.
- 8:54If you look at all the regulators, they break a risk management framework down
- 8:58into basically three parts, at the top, they have a risk culture, which the
- 9:03board establishes along with management, they have a risk appetite and we'll
- 9:09talk about those because it becomes more and more important, the larger you
- 9:13get, and then you have your basic risk management system, which maybe you're
- 9:171 or 2 parts in smaller credit unions, but as you get into the larger credit
- 9:21unions and more complex credit unions, you're looking at 3 lines of defense,
- 9:27a separate risk management department, and internal audit departments.
- 9:32So you're looking at 3 separate departments.
- 9:33And then where the cost starts becoming is you build out the risk management officer.
- 9:39Within a credit union, and you have a chief risk officer and staff in that
- 9:43department, you're looking at very expensive, very experienced people and
- 9:47systems to aggregate across your risk.
- 9:50It's expensive really quick, but at the top of that whole process,
- 9:55our framework is risk culture.
- 9:58And we talked about boards establishing culture in part one of this, and
- 10:03I'll just say that risk management culture that the board and management.
- 10:07Establishes in that tone from the top is really the most important
- 10:11piece of this because I don't care what you put in writing under it.
- 10:15I don't care what your org chart looks like.
- 10:17If you don't have a good risk management culture to begin with all of that stuff
- 10:23underneath it is going to be ineffective.
- 10:26Yeah, I found it interesting.
- 10:29I think we both looked at the same.
- 10:30There, there's a pyramid inside of the O.
- 10:32C.
- 10:33C.
- 10:33S.
- 10:34Guidance on the corporate governance and being a pyramid.
- 10:39It reminded me of, I was a big.
- 10:41Sports person growing up in the pyramid that guided me when I was early was
- 10:45John Wooden's pyramid of success.
- 10:48Now, what I look at this 1 is, John wouldn't have the pyramid of success.
- 10:51This is your pyramid of success.
- 10:53And at the top of theirs, it's risk culture and we're
- 10:57correctly pointed it out.
- 10:58Their middle section is the risk appetite.
- 11:01And at the bottom of the pyramid, they have the three lines of defense.
- 11:05And I think that was to me, I always think that's a good way to look at
- 11:08things because John Wooden, of course, was very successful as the head coach of
- 11:12UCLA in the sixties and early seventies.
- 11:16A couple things now you're gonna now I'm going down all sorts
- 11:18of rabbit holes in my brain now because you brought up John Wooden.
- 11:21So I wasn't until recently that I learned that John Wooden was was offered a job
- 11:28to coach at the University of Minnesota just before he accepted UCLA and Minnesota
- 11:34was supposed to give him a call back and they didn't give it back in time.
- 11:37And then the UCLA offer came in and As a golden gopher discovering
- 11:43that the greatest basketball coach of all time could have been a
- 11:48gopher had they responded timely.
- 11:51I was crushed and the other John Wooden, two other John Wooden
- 11:54references there's a great quote by him.
- 11:56Be quick, but don't hurry, which is what he told his basketball players, which
- 12:00might've been part of this pyramid of success and okay, the trifecta down this
- 12:04rabbit hole is there was a recent three or four part ESPN documentary on Bill Walton.
- 12:11Which was Bill Walton.
- 12:12I'm the luckiest man alive.
- 12:13Something like that came out just before Bill Walton passed away earlier this year.
- 12:18Then that he talks about the pyramid of success and how it, it made
- 12:22him who he was as a player and how much love he had for John Wooden.
- 12:26Let's get forward so we can get to the actual meet here.
- 12:29But I like the reference to that pyramid in this pyramid time.
- 12:32Any rabbit holes you want to go down or anything we triggered
- 12:35there with our discussion of basketball and John wouldn't.
- 12:38No, I do think we got ahead of ourselves.
- 12:40We never really defined what a risk management program is or, and so
- 12:45we started talking about it, but without defining it in any specific
- 12:48case, and maybe we shouldn't have done that, risk management.
- 12:51Basically, it's a program that identifies major monitors that manages risk.
- 12:56It's something that we do every day as individuals, whether
- 13:00we do it consciously or not.
- 13:02We're thinking of that risk reward when we get in our car and drive to work, we
- 13:05think about risk management, or we don't think about it, but we practice it when we
- 13:10look both ways before crossing the street.
- 13:13You do it when you put insurance on your house and maintain things.
- 13:17It's just an expectation of regulators that when you get into a financial
- 13:20institution, you do this a little bit more consciously rather than unconsciously.
- 13:26And that's what that risk management culture is about, is in instilling
- 13:30in people this whole thought that there's some conscious thought
- 13:34into their risk management, risk reward decisions as they go.
- 13:39Yeah, so the pro, as you said, a program that identifies measures,
- 13:43monitors and manage risk.
- 13:45Steve, any thoughts you want to highlight there on the,
- 13:48what it is than the definition?
- 13:50No, I think we're good.
- 13:51That's good.
- 13:52Excellent.
- 13:53Excellent.
- 13:53All right.
- 13:54So what's up?
- 13:54What's next?
- 13:55Guys?
- 13:55We walked through the risk culture, the risk appetite, the risk
- 13:58management system as 3 major areas of this pyramid of this program.
- 14:04Anything you want to expand upon on the risk culture?
- 14:07We talked about the importance of the tone from the top.
- 14:09Anything else there we want to hit?
- 14:11Nothing other than if you go and look at all our troubled credit unions, it's
- 14:16almost always you can trace it back to a breakdown in that risk culture.
- 14:21Yeah, that's a great point.
- 14:22And then risk appetite.
- 14:23Any thoughts specifically on risk appetite?
- 14:26I know we've talked about this in some discussions on other podcasts.
- 14:30That we're seeing examiners wanting credit unions to develop
- 14:36a risk appetite for particular concentrations, et cetera, et cetera.
- 14:40What are your thoughts on a risk management framework, specifically
- 14:43as it relates to risk appetite?
- 14:45This one is an interesting one, and this is probably where you have the hugest
- 14:49variants from small criteens up to large sophisticated organizations, certainly
- 14:55within ones, they expect risk appetite statements to be very formal address
- 15:01and see you a seven risk categories.
- 15:04Listeners who are involved with credit unions are familiar with
- 15:07those seven risk categories.
- 15:09Your other regulators, they add concentration and model risk to
- 15:13NCUA's seven risk categories.
- 15:15But small credit unions, you do this in a very informal way.
- 15:18You lay out that risk appetite statement by just having a business plan and
- 15:23having limits in your various policies.
- 15:25You put limits in your loan policy, you put interest limits in your
- 15:29liquidity policy, you put limits in.
- 15:32your ALM policy.
- 15:33As you get into larger organizations, these risk appetites get a little bit
- 15:39more sophisticated and more formal.
- 15:41You start adding concentration risk policies.
- 15:44You start putting more metrics around your business plan and what success
- 15:49looks like or what failure looks like.
- 15:52It's appropriate as part of your risk appetite statement that you
- 15:55have ways to measure risk and measure whatever you're trying to control.
- 16:00So Establishing metrics for that is a very important piece of it.
- 16:06Within your business plans, business strategies, quite often
- 16:10you see the qualitative things.
- 16:11Here's what we're trying to do and why in a big picture type of thing.
- 16:15We're willing to accept moderate risk or we don't want to be operating
- 16:20in an unsafe, unsound manner.
- 16:22Our investments so those are qualitative type of ways where you can identify
- 16:28and lay out your risk appetites.
- 16:31Like I said, once you get into the larger cranes, I know we see this in ones.
- 16:35There's an expectation that these large complex organizations will
- 16:39have formal risk appetite statements.
- 16:42And then they'll have policies underneath them that are all consistent with that.
- 16:46And this kind of goes back to the culture thing, what you lay out in your risk
- 16:50appetite, it should be consistent with your business plans, business strategies.
- 16:56There should be some level of consistency across your organization with that.
- 17:00And you communicate that to your staff to be effective.
- 17:04But to me, the biggest thing with risk appetite, it's not
- 17:06necessarily where these are.
- 17:08It's that they're communicated that they are in writing in some way, shape
- 17:12or form, even if it's in within other policies and the big piece of it,
- 17:18appropriate metrics for measuring risk.
- 17:20And then the 2nd, big piece of that is a reporting system
- 17:24that tells you where you're at.
- 17:26There has to be some quantitative measures there, and there has to be some
- 17:29reporting of those quantitative measures.
- 17:32You won't read this in any of the regulators guidance, but the way
- 17:35I've always framed it throughout my career is it's incumbent on
- 17:38management to demonstrate they're complying with those board policies
- 17:42and risk appetite statements.
- 17:44I like that.
- 17:45I like that.
- 17:45Steve, any thoughts on what Todd just shared there?
- 17:49Yeah, no, that he covered it really well.
- 17:51The big thing always comes to my mind when I think of risk
- 17:54appetite and, you're looking at how you're trying to define that.
- 17:58Mine always comes down to with consistency is it should start
- 18:03with how much capital do we have?
- 18:06Is that really defines how much risk you can take on if you're
- 18:09operating on those lower ends and close to those PCA triggers.
- 18:16You probably need to have a risk appetite that's pretty conservative
- 18:20because you really don't have the ability to absorb the losses.
- 18:24So now you look at institutions that are really well capitalized and they can
- 18:30take on more risk, but it goes too far.
- 18:32The best example we have, of course, is the taxi credit unions.
- 18:36So talk about concentration risk and their risk appetite tech,
- 18:41medallions in these major cities.
- 18:45And some of these, those credit unions had capital ratios in excess of 15
- 18:50percent to thought, wow, we're okay.
- 18:53No matter what happens.
- 18:54So your risk appetite, you have to understand how aggressive
- 18:59it is, especially in terms of that concentration risk.
- 19:03Yeah, capital can cure a lot of things.
- 19:07But just because you have a lot of capital, if your asset quality in those
- 19:12concentrations or the game changes where you don't have diversification, you're
- 19:16referring to the those credit unions that all they did was the medallion loans.
- 19:20And when the medallion was worth a million dollars in New York City, for example, and
- 19:25you had 28 percent net worth, yeah nobody could envision that wasn't going to work
- 19:30out well when a medallion is worth 100, 000, 28 percent net worth wasn't enough
- 19:36in that situation for the risk that was inherent in that huge concentration.
- 19:42So people will be like, how do, how exactly do you define that risk appetite
- 19:46and find risk appetite statements?
- 19:48I did some searching around.
- 19:49I did find, some pretty good examples out there and you can even look across
- 19:55the industry as to how other industries do it because NCOA and OCC, they all
- 20:01have their own risk appetite statements.
- 20:03So that's one you can look at.
- 20:05There are you don't have to start from scratch if you think you're trying to
- 20:09develop one of these there are some Examples out there that I think people
- 20:13would find helpful And steve when you talk about examples, you're seeing that
- 20:17in the banking agency guidance or you're seeing it in what type of What kind
- 20:22of search result is triggering that?
- 20:24I was just searching for specific really bank ones that might
- 20:28be out there and available to look at, and I did find a few.
- 20:31There's some that were European based, and I've had good luck looking at
- 20:36examples from some of these other regulated institutions, but it's not
- 20:40just America that's after corporate governance, but it's international and
- 20:45part of Basel, it's interesting that Steve mentions kind of concentration risk.
- 20:49One of the things, NCUA has their seven risk areas.
- 20:52Concentration risk isn't one of them, but within NCUA's National
- 20:56Supervision Policy Manual, they have a whole section on concentration risk.
- 21:01But one of the things we see consistently amongst our clients is this whole
- 21:06DOORS bindings to credit unions support your concentration risk limits.
- 21:14We see that consistently.
- 21:15They expect them to be measured against capital, as Steve said, but that's a
- 21:20pretty common finding nowadays in our larger organizations where examiners
- 21:24are demanding that institution through stress testing or some other means,
- 21:29justify their concentration limits.
- 21:32And I don't know, that's been a pretty much a constant since we started this.
- 21:36It has been, and I think as we may have discussed in other episodes,
- 21:40or I know we've talked about it with certain credit unions, there are
- 21:44concentrations limits that are not public that trigger we've talked about
- 21:49how higher levels have to review exams.
- 21:51If certain institutions go over certain thresholds, as far as
- 21:55concentration limits, it's actually not just the region that they're.
- 22:00Exam has to be cleared by it ends up going to the Office of Examination of Insurance.
- 22:04And that could be commercial loans over a percent X percentage of net
- 22:08worth that they're going to have to get the okay or the concurrence
- 22:13from the Office of Examination of Insurance that is reasonable.
- 22:17And sadly, those things are not public, not in N.
- 22:21C.
- 22:21U.
- 22:21A.
- 22:21S.
- 22:21The N.
- 22:22S.
- 22:22P.
- 22:22M.
- 22:22that you referred to.
- 22:24They're either redacted or at dead links.
- 22:26And that's something we've mentioned on occasion.
- 22:29But so there is some guidance out there, but it's not perfectly
- 22:33available to the credit union world.
- 22:35I think just one last thing with Rick's appetite, and this kind of
- 22:39ties in with corporate culture, too.
- 22:41And this kind of gets Cardine sideways with examiners somewhat is, there needs
- 22:47to be a process or a specific action steps when limits are neared or breached.
- 22:53And COA does expect that.
- 22:56There will be an action plan when appropriate when you get close to
- 22:59limits or when you go over limits.
- 23:02You quite often we see this in our clients.
- 23:05They're outside their limits and, they haven't done anything.
- 23:08Hasn't been discussed with the board.
- 23:09Hasn't been discussed in ALCO.
- 23:12Oh, we think it will correct itself.
- 23:13We don't do anything.
- 23:14There actually has to be a sense of urgency with addressing situations when
- 23:19you are overboard established limits.
- 23:22And I think a second piece of that too is You need to have an environment
- 23:28where your staff is comfortable to say, Hey, risk is getting out of hand here,
- 23:33whether it's been quantified or not.
- 23:36In the, the, so three, let's say someone has a risk appetite that we will have
- 23:40300% of net worth in commercial loans.
- 23:43And then all of a sudden a member comes in with a fabulous opportunity for the
- 23:47credit union and for the member, and they want to blow through that 300% limit.
- 23:52They don't document it in the board minutes, they don't have any conversations
- 23:55with it, or they just, change the policy from 300 to three 50 without having.
- 24:01Any analysis that supports that limit that kind of goes to where NCWA says we want
- 24:06you to be able to support that limit it wasn't a goal and now you've established
- 24:10a new reach goal It actually is a limit for the risk and it's important that
- 24:16Your documentations and your discussions and all those committees and places you
- 24:20mentioned Are indicative of that or you could end up getting criticized, in the
- 24:26examination definitely risk management systems and the three lines of defense do
- 24:32we want to walk through each of the three lines of defense and and discuss those?
- 24:37I think so.
- 24:38In larger complex organizations, we'll talk about 3 lines of defense.
- 24:43Generally, you have that frontline business units.
- 24:46That 2nd line of defense is, usually a department that's
- 24:50underneath your chief risk officer.
- 24:52Then you have internal audit.
- 24:54Realistically, that's at the end of that long ruler of sophistication
- 25:00where you have three lines of defense for many of our credit unions really
- 25:04more break this down into two lines of defense and that they have their
- 25:08frontline units and management and then they have that internal audit
- 25:11under the supervisory committee.
- 25:13You don't start seeing this whole third line of defense or a separate risk
- 25:18management department until credeans start crossing over a billion to three
- 25:23billion dollars and they start thinking about hiring chief risk officers and
- 25:27setting up separate risk departments.
- 25:30You typically don't see it in smaller credeans, but smaller credeans can
- 25:34still accomplish all the same things without adding those extra people.
- 25:38It just, needs a little bit more diligence on the part of their executive management.
- 25:42First line of defense, it's always those people conducting your transaction.
- 25:46That's your loan officers, your tellers, your people that are interacting with
- 25:50the members There are where things start.
- 25:53There are where your risk assessment starts for specific lines of business,
- 25:58whether that's commercial lending, consumer lending, real estate lending,
- 26:02what have you, it's that first line of defense that, hey, let's do things
- 26:06in a safe, sound, appropriate manner.
- 26:08Let's make sure we have liens perfected on these vehicles.
- 26:11Let's make sure we're making loan checks out to the right people
- 26:14and aren't getting defrauded.
- 26:16Let's make sure these people have the ability to repay and that loan is
- 26:20for a provident productive purpose.
- 26:22But that 1st line of defense, think of that as your business unit.
- 26:25These are the people that interact with our members.
- 26:28They're performing transactions.
- 26:30It's important that they understand their job and understand that risk
- 26:34reward opposition and their role in it.
- 26:38That's the best way I can think of to lay out that 1st line of defense.
- 26:42They're closest and nearest to those members and those transactions
- 26:46in whatever area you're at.
- 26:48Yeah, so they're carrying out that strategic plan compliance with
- 26:52those policies that were put in place that have the limits that.
- 26:56We're, are part of the the risk appetite.
- 26:59The other thing that comes into place is you, of course, these are
- 27:01the people that are, staffing and training, the keeping their staff
- 27:06adequately staffed and trained.
- 27:08And and they're all the other resources that it takes in to, to run
- 27:12the credit union, including it, tho they're all in that frontline unit.
- 27:17So that's that's their role is to.
- 27:20Carry out the operations consistent with the, with what the board is directed.
- 27:25Great points.
- 27:27Go ahead.
- 27:28No, go ahead.
- 27:28Mark.
- 27:30Anything relative to the internal audit function on the third line of defense,
- 27:34what it is, general thoughts on how to principles and things that credit unions
- 27:41should be keeping in mind as it relates to the internal audit side of this.
- 27:45So you're going to jump from one to three and skip to smaller credit is
- 27:50you just have the You just have that supervisory committee internal audit,
- 27:55their role is really to test internal controls and verify that things are
- 28:00working the way they're supposed to.
- 28:02That's the whole role of that supervisory committee audit.
- 28:05Are our financial statements accurate?
- 28:09Are our reporting processes accurate?
- 28:12They're the ones that verify everything is working the way it's intended.
- 28:16And that's an important piece of it.
- 28:18You need some confidence there and some testing of those things.
- 28:21Examiners fall into this a little bit, even though they're never ever mentioned
- 28:25anywhere in this risk management process.
- 28:29But that third line of defense, it's important.
- 28:33And just having the existence of internal audit, And someone looking over everyone's
- 28:38shoulders and actually help staff comply.
- 28:41They'll do a better job of complying with internal policies procedures when
- 28:46they know someone's checking up on them.
- 28:48Yeah, it's like that.
- 28:49It's like the empty police car, right?
- 28:51You see it, you slow down, you go, Oh, wait, look, there was nobody
- 28:54in that car, but you slowed down because you saw it, it's there,
- 28:57they're going to be doing the reviews.
- 28:58And Todd, that's exactly why I skipped over the second line of defense was
- 29:02your reference to, First line and third line are smaller credit unions will
- 29:06have that they might not necessarily have the second line Steve any
- 29:09thoughts on the third line of defense?
- 29:11Yeah, if you're, credit union, you're trying to communicate to your with
- 29:16your examiner and that how you're doing that internal control when the big
- 29:21tool that you can provide them is that audit plan that so that the examiner or
- 29:27anybody else looking at the department can quickly go through and say.
- 29:31During a year, this is what they're going to cover and that they cover all
- 29:35the important items and that becomes 1 of their main communication tools is
- 29:39to that kind of is their strategic plan as to what they're going to try and do.
- 29:44And then this is how they're going to go about doing it.
- 29:46And then, of course, they need the staff.
- 29:49According to that audit plan, the other thing we run into is sometimes that
- 29:55auditors are seeing has a wink and a wave, just, just do it, but don't make trouble.
- 30:00That's also a problem and that they're appropriately
- 30:03respected by senior management.
- 30:05If you catch a.
- 30:07Examiners, if they feel that they're put in the back room and poor lighting and
- 30:12all that kind of stuff and not giving good resources, that's a real telltale
- 30:16sign that something might be a mess.
- 30:19Great point.
- 30:19Great point.
- 30:21This all worked together.
- 30:24Speaking of cop cars, Mark, I have four pictures, one from Oregon,
- 30:29three from small towns in Montana, where they park cop cars with
- 30:33dummies beside the side of the road.
- 30:35I'll stop and take their pictures when I see that.
- 30:38You need to do that next time and we'll put that on a podcast
- 30:42art for one of the podcasts.
- 30:44My wife laughs because it does make me slow down.
- 30:47So it's effective.
- 30:48I was going to say something else about what Steve just said.
- 30:51No, I lost my train of thought.
- 30:53Oh, so like auditors and independents, and this is important.
- 30:56These systems work together.
- 30:59Auditors are not necessarily, they're also getting paid.
- 31:03They're trying to preserve client privileges.
- 31:06I've had auditors look right at me and tell me in the face that they've signed
- 31:10off on something that wasn't GAAP.
- 31:12And I said the client's paying the bills.
- 31:13That's happened a couple of times in my career.
- 31:15Which kind of leads into why larger organizations need that 3rd middle leg
- 31:24in that 2nd line of defense and that whole, their own internal risk management
- 31:30department under a chief risk officer is you need that other assurance.
- 31:35The other thing is in smaller cruddies and there's nothing wrong with it.
- 31:38It's a reality.
- 31:40In smaller, less sophisticated places.
- 31:43Risk management or risks tend to get managed in silos.
- 31:47You're lending people manage your lending risk.
- 31:49Your CFO or another executive is going to manage that interest
- 31:53rate and liquidity risk.
- 31:55You're going to have an IT person back there is going to manage all that cyber
- 31:58security type risk and transaction risks.
- 32:01And you tend to do that separate and not bring them together.
- 32:04But the thing is all these risks that Kind of add up over time and they're
- 32:09all stressors on your capital and you reach a point in size and complexity
- 32:15where You can't be managing this stuff in silos anymore You need a way
- 32:21to aggregate these risks across the organization And that's when you start
- 32:25adding a whole risk management department a chief risk officer Sometimes it's
- 32:29one person in larger organizations.
- 32:32That might be three or four persons You But now you start aggregating
- 32:36risks across the organization.
- 32:38These people tend to be very experienced type people at
- 32:41that chief risk officer level.
- 32:44They start adding support to the first lines of defense.
- 32:47Here's other legal risk.
- 32:48Here's things you didn't think about.
- 32:50You're really talking about beginning steps are actually a fully
- 32:54implemented enterprise risk management system at this point in time.
- 32:58And you start aggregating these risks across the organization.
- 33:01And, the biggest thing is with the chief risk officer.
- 33:04And if we have this department, it's another department with that.
- 33:08Reports directly to the board or the supervisory committee.
- 33:11So it's a way to watch over management.
- 33:16It's the department that you can supervise have a little bit more control
- 33:19over than necessarily an independent auditor where you get what you pay for.
- 33:24Actually you get what you pay for with this as well in that second line
- 33:27of defense, but it's another just important piece where you can start
- 33:32aggregating risks across the organization.
- 33:35When you silo things on a complexity wise, sometimes you can get blindsided
- 33:39by risks you didn't know about or didn't realize they were there.
- 33:43That's another reason you put that second line of defense in.
- 33:46Under a chief risk officer is hopefully you avoid being blindsided
- 33:50by these siloed risks when you start aggravating, aggregating
- 33:55them and putting them together.
- 33:58And it's a way to.
- 34:00It's a way to reinforce your risk culture too, because now you got one
- 34:03point that says this is how we're going to measure and monitor risks.
- 34:07It tends to get every case of the organization on the same page.
- 34:11So to speak.
- 34:12And in those individual silos, like on the loan risks, the constant, if
- 34:17I'm out there and I'm a loan officer and My goal is to get loans out.
- 34:21I'm not going to, I'm going to want a higher risk appetite than
- 34:24somebody who's looking at how does that really relate to net worth.
- 34:28So having that second line of defense that can do all the things you just described
- 34:32can help mitigate and control that to make sure that it's consistent with the
- 34:36risk culture that the board and management want to make sure is ever present.
- 34:42Steve, any thoughts on the second line?
- 34:44Just 1 thing comes to mind that we've had a couple of our larger clients that
- 34:48have that position and has commented on how they think that person should be
- 34:56included in the organizational chart.
- 34:59And I think we've had general disagreement with on that and
- 35:03that the chief risk officer.
- 35:06Is going to be involved in virtually all of your major committees
- 35:09because they need to know what's happening throughout the institution.
- 35:14So I'm looking for your recollection of those discussions
- 35:17that we've had with clients.
- 35:19Yes, that's definitely been an issue.
- 35:22And it's a scenario where the second line a couple of different scenarios,
- 35:27if I'm remembering right, where the second line has been given,
- 35:30it's almost as if it's veto power.
- 35:32So the board wants to do X and management wants to do X, but this committee is
- 35:36saying we shouldn't be doing X, we should be doing Y and NCOA almost framing it.
- 35:41Like they have more authority.
- 35:44Then the CEO and or the board, and I'm definitely not not convinced that's the
- 35:51way that it should be necessarily set up.
- 35:54And then also we've seen situations where where NCOA is saying why
- 35:59is this person on this committee?
- 36:01And what, what's their role on this committee?
- 36:03And and the reality is based on the principles, they
- 36:06should be on that committee.
- 36:07Todd Any thoughts on what Steve or I just said there?
- 36:10Yeah, I have a note here somewhere about segregation and duties and how
- 36:15this plays out, but I'm not going to wait through it for the moment.
- 36:20Essentially, you have a separation of those who measure monitor risks
- 36:25and those who take risks and I think sometimes NCUA blurs this a little bit.
- 36:30And I've seen this a couple different times in larger organizations where
- 36:35NCUA's expectation is that you would give this chief risk officer veto authority.
- 36:42And that's not the way the thing sets up.
- 36:45They're the folks that measure risk.
- 36:47Yes, there should be a measure or an effective channel for them
- 36:51to communicate, with the board.
- 36:54Through the supervisory committee or however you want to set it up.
- 36:58If they believe that risks are getting on a line, but at the end of the day
- 37:02of that whole risk reward proposition, the folks taking risks or the board
- 37:07defines how much risks are allowable.
- 37:10And it's the chief executive and management staff that
- 37:15engage in risk taking.
- 37:17I don't think it's appropriate that your chief risk officer should have.
- 37:23blanche veto authority.
- 37:25They're there to support these other functions in
- 37:27measuring that aggregated risk.
- 37:30It's their role to say, hey, we missed something here, let's think
- 37:34about this a little bit more.
- 37:36But, they are not the risk takers and I don't believe you should
- 37:39necessarily give a Chief Risk Officer veto authority either.
- 37:44They're one part of this tripod, but they're not any greater are.
- 37:50And then the other part of it, and I do think N.
- 37:53C.
- 37:54U.
- 37:54A.
- 37:54gets that wrong when they lay out an expectation that a chief risk officer
- 37:58should have veto authority over things.
- 38:00The other thing we've seen is N.
- 38:03C.
- 38:03U.
- 38:03A.
- 38:03's take an exception to a chief risk officer having voting privileges
- 38:08on whatever committee it might be.
- 38:11I don't think that's the regulator's role.
- 38:13There's a ruler of sophistication and there's no right or wrong answer to this.
- 38:17That individual is involved in aggregating risks across the organization.
- 38:23Whether they're a voting or a non voting member, they probably need to be parts
- 38:27of these committees and understand what is going on in the various
- 38:31departments across the organization.
- 38:33And whether they're a voting or non voting member, it doesn't matter.
- 38:36Let them be a voting member because their role is to bring up
- 38:39discussions of risk and enhance this.
- 38:42And I don't think it's the regulator's role to necessarily say you can or can't
- 38:46be a voting member on any committee within the organization just because
- 38:50you're in the chief risk officer's chair.
- 38:53I think in that case, it's a case of NCUA maybe overstepping their duties.
- 38:58And we've seen that a couple of times.
- 39:00Great points.
- 39:01And that goes to it's not a regulation that requires how it's structured.
- 39:05It's a management decision.
- 39:07They rely on safety and soundness.
- 39:08They rely on sound business practices.
- 39:10They rely on finesse to get NC, get the credit unions to
- 39:14structure it in a particular way.
- 39:16But in the end, it's the credit unions decision.
- 39:19Particularly because there isn't a regulation that says it has
- 39:22to be done exactly A, B, and C.
- 39:24The credit union is responsible.
- 39:26As NSUA points out, corporate governance, the board is responsible.
- 39:30It's the board with the interaction with senior management that lays
- 39:33out the framework that makes most sense for the individual
- 39:37credit union, regardless of size.
- 39:40Guys, what else, anything else here that I missed, any other topic we want to hit
- 39:43on the concept of the risk management framework the pyramid, anything else we
- 39:48need to hit here before we wrap today?
- 39:50I wanted to go through, we've talked about, resources available
- 39:53for credit union boards that NCOA doesn't have their board of
- 39:57director manual that was out there.
- 40:00The OCC does have the director's reference guide.
- 40:03And that has a good section on risk governments governance, and
- 40:09it has questions to consider.
- 40:12And red flags that that would be brought to me 1 of the red flags
- 40:17would be the number of issues.
- 40:19Identified by regulators so we can put that and then in at the end of the, that
- 40:24section on there, it has a big example of all the references that they have
- 40:29that relate back to the subject of risk governance and corporate governance.
- 40:34That's very complete.
- 40:36So we'll make sure we get that out there.
- 40:39Yeah, if you could send me those links, I'll put them in the show notes,
- 40:42any of those that you think people might be particularly interested, be
- 40:46good to, I may have those, but make a note to send me those and I'll
- 40:50put them in the in the show notes.
- 40:51Todd, anything you think we should hit here before we wrap up?
- 40:55I'll just reemphasize what we started out at the beginning and we brought this up in
- 40:58our 1st podcast on corporate governance.
- 41:02This all really starts with culture that the board and management put in place.
- 41:07And like I said, it doesn't necessarily matter what's in writing and what
- 41:11that org chart looks underneath.
- 41:13Like underneath it, the most important piece of that is that
- 41:17culture that is established by the board and by executive management.
- 41:22And a lot of this isn't rocket science identify major monitor
- 41:26control risks or concepts that have been around hundreds of years.
- 41:29I used to have a banking risk management books as concepts go back to Roman times.
- 41:33There were even documents in Latin about that.
- 41:35So those core concepts haven't changed.
- 41:38I think it's.
- 41:40For directors, you just be independent, ask good questions about this.
- 41:44It's not rocket science.
- 41:46You can get up to speed on it.
- 41:47But just be independent in your thought.
- 41:49And it goes back to corporate culture again.
- 41:53Let's have a way to articulate our risk.
- 41:55Let's have appropriate limits in place.
- 41:58Let's hold management accountable for those limits.
- 42:00And I think that's a big piece of that culture too, is there has to be
- 42:04consequences when people choose to not stay inside the box, so to speak.
- 42:11That's a great place to wrap guys.
- 42:13This was a deep topic and I learned a little bit.
- 42:16Hopefully the listeners picked up some points here.
- 42:19I appreciate your thoughtful comments as it relates to this important topic.
- 42:24Thanks, guys.
- 42:25And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 42:28As always, I hope you will listen again soon.
- 42:30This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.