Latest / Interfaiths / Beyond Brokenness: A Desire-Based Framework for Interfaith Peacebuilding
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today, we are
- 0:02grappling with a set of ideas that, I have to
- 0:05be honest, I found a little unsettling when I
- 0:08first read through them. They are unsettling,
- 0:10aren't they? It's one of those topics where,
- 0:11you know, once you see the pattern, you can't
- 0:13unsee it. It changes how you watch the news,
- 0:15how you read a fundraising email, everything.
- 0:18And it starts with a premise that just feels
- 0:20completely backward to my intuition. Usually,
- 0:24if I see a problem like a social injustice, my
- 0:26gut says, OK, I need to prove how bad it is.
- 0:30Right. Bring the receipts. Exactly. I need to
- 0:32document the pain, the trauma to get people to
- 0:35care enough to actually fix it. That just feels
- 0:37like the logical first step. And that is the
- 0:39standard operating procedure for almost all social
- 0:42change work. The logic is, you know, pretty simple.
- 0:45If I can show you the damage, you'll be morally
- 0:47compelled to intervene. But today's deep dive
- 0:50suggests that this very instinct, this obsession
- 0:54with documenting brokenness, might actually be
- 0:57a trap. We're unpacking a really seminal open
- 1:01letter from 2009 by a scholar named Eve Tuck.
- 1:04It's titled, Suspending Damage, A Letter to Communities.
- 1:08And this is a foundational text in Indigenous
- 1:10studies. Eve Tuck is an Angus, and she was writing
- 1:13specifically to Indigenous communities and researchers.
- 1:16But we're talking about it today because we're
- 1:18cross -referencing her work with a new analysis
- 1:20on interfaith peacebuilding. Which seems like
- 1:23a big jump at first, but the connection is actually
- 1:25really, really tight. We're looking at how her
- 1:28warning applies to religious conflict and polarization
- 1:30today. Exactly. The mission is to figure out
- 1:34why defining a community by its pain is so dangerous
- 1:36and to understand what on earth Tuck means by
- 1:40a desire -based framework. And look, just clear
- 1:43the air before we start because I know what some
- 1:44listeners might be thinking. This isn't toxic
- 1:46positivity, is it? We're not saying just ignore
- 1:49the suffering. Not at all. And that is the hardest
- 1:51part of this to grasp. This isn't about pretending
- 1:53everything is fine. It's about refusing to let
- 1:56the not fine parts be the only definition of
- 1:58who you are. Okay, so let's get into the gears
- 2:00of this. Tuck coins this term, damage -centered
- 2:04research. Can you break that down for us? It's
- 2:07a bit more specific than just any research that
- 2:09talks about bad things. Tuck defines it as research
- 2:12that operates, even with the best intentions,
- 2:14from a specific theory of change. Okay. The idea
- 2:18is that you intentionally document pain and brokenness
- 2:21specifically to hold power accountable. You establish
- 2:25harm to get reparation. Which, to be fair, sounds
- 2:28like a solid strategy. It sounds like a lawsuit.
- 2:30Oof. You hurt me. Here's the proof. Now pay up.
- 2:33That's exactly what it is. The source material
- 2:35calls this the litigation model. Think about
- 2:38it. If you're in a personal injury case, you
- 2:40don't walk into court talking about how great
- 2:41your life is. No, you bring the medical bills.
- 2:43You show the jury the cast on your leg. You have
- 2:46to perform your brokenness to get paid. Right.
- 2:48And history shows this works. To a point. The
- 2:51sources mention Brown v. Board of Education.
- 2:53That's the holy grail of civil rights litigation.
- 2:56For sure. And they bring up the famous clock
- 2:58doll test used in that case. Yeah. From the 1940s,
- 3:01researchers showed black children a white doll
- 3:04and a black doll and asked which one was nice
- 3:07or bad. I've seen footage of that. It is absolutely
- 3:10heartbreaking. It's get wrenching. And Thurgood
- 3:12Marshall used that data to argue that segregation
- 3:14wasn't just unfair. It was psychologically damaging
- 3:17these children. He proved the injury and he won.
- 3:20So I'm going to play skeptic here for a second.
- 3:23Yeah. If it worked for Thurgood Marshall, if
- 3:25it ended legal segregation. Why is Eve Tuck saying
- 3:28we need to suspend it? Why fix what isn't broken?
- 3:31Because the courtroom is a very specific place.
- 3:34And when you take that litigation logic out of
- 3:36the courtroom and apply it to an entire community's
- 3:39identity, for decades, things start to get toxic.
- 3:42How so? Because it pathologizes them. That's
- 3:45the key word she uses. Pathologizing, like from
- 3:47pathology. It sounds medical. It is. It treats
- 3:50the community like a chronic disease case. If
- 3:52the only time you hear about a community is in
- 3:54the context of their suffering or their poverty
- 3:56or their trauma, you stop seeing them as people
- 3:59and start seeing them as patients, as permanently
- 4:01broken. I see. It's the difference between saying,
- 4:04I have a broken leg and I have a broken person.
- 4:08Exactly that. And in the interfaith and peace
- 4:10building world, which is the other half of our
- 4:12source material, this is just rampant. Think
- 4:15about how we talk about conflict zones. Oh, I've
- 4:17seen the grant proposals. They always start with
- 4:19the casualty counts. They start with hate crime
- 4:21statistics. It's just pages and pages of, look
- 4:24how much everyone hates each other. Precisely.
- 4:26It's a catalog of despair. And the assumption
- 4:29is, if I show the donor how awful it is, they'll
- 4:32give us money to fix it. But the source argues
- 4:35that when we do this, we strip these communities
- 4:38of their complexity. Can you give an example
- 4:40of what that stripping away looks like? Well,
- 4:42just look at how major religions get discussed
- 4:44in the media during conflicts. We risk reducing
- 4:47Judaism solely to the Holocaust or the events
- 4:50of October 7th. Right. Or reducing Islam solely
- 4:52to post 9 -11 security threats or Christianity
- 4:56in the global south just to the wounds of colonization.
- 4:59And those things are so real. You can't just
- 5:01pretend the Holocaust or colonization didn't
- 5:04happen. No, and Tuck is very clear about this.
- 5:06This is not amnesia. But she asks a crucial question.
- 5:10If that is the only story we tell, is that history?
- 5:14Or is that an act of aggression? An act of aggression.
- 5:16That's strong language. It is, but think about
- 5:18it. If I introduce you to someone and I say,
- 5:21this is so -and -so, they were the victim of
- 5:23a terrible crime, and that's all I say, I've
- 5:26just defined you by the worst thing that ever
- 5:28happened to you. You've robbed me of my agency.
- 5:31You've made me a character in someone else's
- 5:33tragedy, not the protagonist of my own life.
- 5:35Exactly. OK, that clicks. So if we fall into
- 5:38this damage trap, what's the alternative? This
- 5:40is where she brings in the desire based framework.
- 5:43Right. And we have to be really careful with
- 5:45that word desire, because in English we usually
- 5:46think of, you know, wanting a slice of pizza
- 5:49or something. Yeah. I desire a vacation right
- 5:51now. Me too. Yeah. But Tuck is drawing on some
- 5:53heavier philosophy here, Deleuze and Guattari.
- 5:56And in this framework, desire isn't about lack.
- 5:59It's not. I want what I don't have. It's what
- 6:03she calls an assemblage. Okay, you're going to
- 6:05have to translate assemblage for us. That sounds
- 6:07a little like art school jargon. It does a bit.
- 6:10Think of it as a generative accumulation, a mosaic.
- 6:13It's the sum total of your wisdom, your hope,
- 6:17your contradictions, your heritage, and your
- 6:19pain. The source has this great quote. desire
- 6:23accounts for the loss and despair but also the
- 6:26visions and the wisdom of lived lives so damage
- 6:30is a snapshot of the wound but desire is the
- 6:33whole movie that's a perfect way to put it to
- 6:35make this concrete tuck describes a photography
- 6:38exhibit at the schomburg center in new york stereotypes
- 6:41versus human types i love this part of the reading
- 6:44walk us through it because i think it really
- 6:45helps land the plane so imagine you walk into
- 6:47the first room the damage room It's filled with
- 6:50these grotesque historical caricatures of African
- 6:53-Americans, alligator bait images, Uncle Tom
- 6:56posters. Just flat, one -dimensional images of
- 6:59mockery or pity. Exactly. But then you walk into
- 7:02the second room, the desire room. These are the
- 7:05human types. They were old photographs, the Gary
- 7:07types of African -Americans from the Victorian
- 7:09era. And what's the shift in feeling there? It's
- 7:11profound. These people were posed. They chose
- 7:14their clothes. They chose how to be seen. They
- 7:17look back at the camera with dignity, with complexity.
- 7:19They weren't just reacting to a system of oppression.
- 7:21They were just being. They were subjects of their
- 7:23own lives. They were subjects of desire. They
- 7:26had a past and a future that belonged to them.
- 7:28And that is the shift Tuck wants us to make.
- 7:30Stop looking at the stereotype of the victim
- 7:32and start looking at the complex human. Okay,
- 7:35emotionally, I completely buy that. But I can
- 7:38hear the pragmatist in my head saying, if I'm
- 7:41working in a conflict zone, isn't focusing on
- 7:43desire a little bit? Soft. Aren't you just glossing
- 7:48over the fact that the house is on fire? And
- 7:50that is the number one criticism. Aren't you
- 7:52just in denial? But Tuck tackles this with her
- 7:54storm analogy. She says a desire -based framework
- 7:57is not the song about looking for a silver lining.
- 8:00It is the song about walking through the storm.
- 8:02I highlighted that line, walking through the
- 8:04storm. It acknowledges the storm is real. You
- 8:07might get wet, you might get hurt, but it refuses
- 8:10to let the storm be the only interesting thing
- 8:13about the person walking. It says the storm is
- 8:16happening, but I am still here and I am still
- 8:18creating and I am still me. So it's the difference
- 8:20between look at this poor victim in the rain.
- 8:23And look at this person navigating the rain.
- 8:25Precisely. And in the interfaith world, this
- 8:27just changes the entire conversation. Right now,
- 8:30so many dialogues get stuck in what scholars
- 8:32call competitive victimhood. Oh, I've been in
- 8:35those rooms. My tragedy is bigger than your tragedy.
- 8:38It's a race to the bottom. It is. And it's a
- 8:40dead end. Because if your only currency is your
- 8:43pain, you can never let it go or you go bankrupt.
- 8:46A desire -based framework flips that. It allows
- 8:49communities to show up as bearers of wisdom.
- 8:51They bring their theology, their humor, their
- 8:54traditions. They show up as what Avery Gordon
- 8:56calls complex personhood. Complex personhood.
- 8:59Okay, another term we need to pin down. What
- 9:02does that look like in the real world? It means
- 9:04acknowledging that people are messy and full
- 9:06of contradictions, and that's okay. Tuck shares
- 9:09this story from her colleague, Monique Gouchard,
- 9:12that is just perfect. The sneaker line paradox.
- 9:15Yes. This story really stuck with me. So Monique
- 9:18is working with these youth researchers in the
- 9:20Bronx. Right. And they spend the whole day doing
- 9:23this incredibly high level critical work. They're
- 9:26critiquing corporate capitalism, breaking down
- 9:28globalization, analyzing how these systems exploit
- 9:31their communities. They're sharp, socially conscious
- 9:34critics of the system. And then the sun goes
- 9:36down. And then the sun goes down. And where do
- 9:39these anti -capitalist warriors go? They go stand
- 9:41in line for hours to buy the new Air Jordan sneakers.
- 9:45Which are the ultimate symbol of the corporate
- 9:47machine they just spent all day tearing apart.
- 9:49Exactly. Now, a damage -centered researcher looks
- 9:51at those kids and says, hypocrites or, you know,
- 9:55false consciousness. You judge them. You think
- 9:57they failed the test. Right. But a desire -based
- 10:01framework looked at that and sees. The kids knew
- 10:05it was a contradiction. They were at ease with
- 10:06it. They can critique the system and still want
- 10:09the shoes because in their world, those shoes
- 10:11represent status, style, joy. It's allowing them
- 10:15to be human, not just a political talking point.
- 10:18And this sneaker logic, this ability to hold
- 10:20contradictions is actually life or death in peace
- 10:23building. OK, connect those dots for me. How
- 10:25do we get from Air Jordans to peace? Because
- 10:27people in conflict zones are living the ultimate
- 10:30contradiction. This framework allows us to understand,
- 10:34for instance, a Palestinian imam who is deeply
- 10:36mourning the destruction of his village, but
- 10:39who is also studying Hebrew to read Jewish philosophy
- 10:41in the original. Which would seem impossible
- 10:43if you only view him as a victim. Right. Or an
- 10:46Israeli rabbi who is grieving a terror attack,
- 10:49but who is also building a local coalition with
- 10:51his Muslim neighbors. It breaks the binary of
- 10:54victim versus aggressor. Or broken versus whole.
- 10:58We are addicted to those binaries, aren't we?
- 11:01Totally. A spoiler named Edward Soja calls the
- 11:03alternative thirding. It's moving beyond either
- 11:07to a third space where multiple truths can exist
- 11:10at once. So this leads us to the final big concept
- 11:13in the stack. If we aren't just surviving the
- 11:16damage, what are we doing? The term used is survivance.
- 11:20Is that just a fancy word for survival? No, and
- 11:22this is crucial. It comes from Gerald Vezinor,
- 11:24an Anishinaabe scholar. Survival is just staying
- 11:28alive. It's defensive. It's a reflex. You survive
- 11:31a car crash. You just hold on tight enough. Exactly.
- 11:34But survivance is active. Vezinor defines it
- 11:37as a creative, generative, sovereign presence.
- 11:41It means you are creating new ways of being while
- 11:44you stay alive. You aren't just reacting to the
- 11:45oppressor. You are out creating them. Gives an
- 11:48example of that. The source material mentions
- 11:50these communities in South Florida, Jewish and
- 11:52Muslim communities who, you know, have plenty
- 11:54of reasons to be at odds given global events.
- 11:56For sure. The tension must be incredibly high.
- 11:58A survival mode would be them just issuing press
- 12:01releases, condemning violence, and then going
- 12:03back to their separate corners. That's damage
- 12:05control. But they did survivance instead. They
- 12:07did. They came together to co -author new theological
- 12:11frameworks for coexistence. They were analyzing
- 12:14their scriptures together to find a path forward.
- 12:17They weren't rehearsing their grief. They were
- 12:19generating new wisdom. That is a sovereign act.
- 12:22So given all of this, Tuck ends her letter with
- 12:25a really radical demand. She calls for a moratorium.
- 12:28A moratorium on damage -centered research. It's
- 12:31a bold move. She's essentially saying stop the
- 12:34presses. Does she mean we just stop doing research?
- 12:37Just stop asking questions and go home? No, it's
- 12:40not anti -intellectual. It's a call for a time
- 12:43out, a freeze on the kind of research that just
- 12:46extracts pain for academic tenure or for funding.
- 12:49She wants us to rethink our theories of change.
- 12:52Are we just collecting pain stories or are we
- 12:54helping a community thrive? There's a story at
- 12:56the very end of the material that I think sums
- 12:58all this up better than any theory could. The
- 13:00story from the Australian Parliament in 2008.
- 13:03Yes. So it was this historic day. Prime Minister
- 13:05Kevin Rudd was offering a formal national apology
- 13:08to indigenous peoples for the stolen generations.
- 13:11A massive moment of acknowledging damage. But
- 13:14then the opposition leader, Rendon Nelson, stood
- 13:17up and he gave this. this hollow counter narrative
- 13:21he started minimizing the impact making excuses
- 13:23classic yes but response mistakes were made but
- 13:27let's not get carried away exactly and the gallery
- 13:29is packed with indigenous elders and allies and
- 13:33instead of shouting him down they did something
- 13:35else one by one they stood up and they turned
- 13:38their backs they just turned around They turned
- 13:40their backs on him and then they started a slow
- 13:42clap, a rhythmic slow clap. And the sound grew
- 13:45until it literally drowned out the voice of the
- 13:47man speaking at the podium. Wow. That gives me
- 13:50chills. Tuck calls this a sovereign act. It wasn't
- 13:53a riot. It was a rejection. They essentially
- 13:56said, we are done listening to a story that defines
- 13:58us by your terms. We are done. That image, turning
- 14:02your back on a narrative that doesn't serve you.
- 14:05That really is the core of this entire deep dive.
- 14:07It is. It's the refusal to be a victim, the refusal
- 14:10to be a statistic. And for anyone listening,
- 14:12that is the lesson. So let's bring this home.
- 14:14What's the final takeaway? How do we apply this
- 14:17tomorrow morning? I think it's this. We have
- 14:20to stop thinking that the only way to get people
- 14:22to care is to show them the blood. We need to
- 14:25look for the desire. We need to look for the
- 14:27human type, not the stereotype. Because you can
- 14:30pity a victim, but you can only partner with
- 14:33a person. Beautifully said. You can't build a
- 14:35future on pity. You can only build it on shared
- 14:38hope. I think that leads us to a really provocative
- 14:41thought to leave our listeners with today. I've
- 14:43been thinking about this, about that silence
- 14:45that Tuck talks about, the silence when you stop
- 14:48listing your grievances. So here's the question
- 14:51for you. If you stop telling the story of your
- 14:54life or your community through the list of things
- 14:56that have hurt you, what story would be left
- 14:59to tell? That's a scary question. Because for
- 15:02some of us, that list is our armor. It is terrifying.
- 15:06If you take away the damage, is there anything
- 15:08left? Is that silence just empty? Or is that
- 15:11silence exactly where the real work begins? A
- 15:14question worth sitting with. Thank you for diving
- 15:15deep with us today. Always a pleasure. See you
- 15:17next time.