Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Diplomacy with the Assassins
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about Saladin's military campaigns, his sieges and his battles, but there's one group he never really fought a full-scale war with, even though they tried to kill him multiple times. Luna: The Assassins, right? The Nizari Ismailis? Lucas: Exactly. The Hashashin, as they were called in Arabic — though that term has a complicated history. They were a Shia Ismaili sect based in mountain fortresses, most famously Alamut in Persia, but they also had a strong presence in Syria, with their stronghold at Masyaf. Their leader in Saladin's time was Rashid ad-Din Sinan, often called the Old Man of the Mountain in Crusader chronicles. Luna: And they really did try to assassinate Saladin? Lucas: Oh yes. Multiple times. The most famous attempt was in 1175, during Saladin's siege of Aleppo. According to Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, a group of assassins infiltrated his camp disguised as soldiers from the Zengid army. They got close enough to strike, but Saladin's guards noticed something off and managed to kill them before they reached the sultan. Lucas: After that attempt, Saladin became extremely paranoid. He started wearing a coat of chainmail under his clothes, even when sleeping. He also had his tent surrounded by a sand-filled trench to make it harder for anyone to approach silently. Luna: So he was genuinely terrified of them. Lucas: Absolutely. And for good reason. The Assassins had a reputation for getting to their targets. The Crusader prince Raymond of Tripoli managed to escape an attempt, but Conrad of Montferrat was killed by them in 1192. So Saladin had every reason to be cautious. Lucas: But here's the interesting part: despite these assassination attempts, Saladin never launched a major military campaign against the Assassins. He besieged Masyaf briefly in 1176, but it was a half-hearted affair. He pulled back after a few days, and then a truce was negotiated. Luna: Why didn't he just wipe them out? He had the army for it. Lucas: Several reasons. First, the Assassins were not a territorial threat in the same way the Crusaders were. They held a few mountain castles, but they didn't control large cities or major trade routes. They were more of a political nuisance than a strategic danger. Lucas: Second, attacking the Assassins would have been extremely costly. Their fortresses were built on remote peaks, difficult to besiege, and they were expert defenders. A prolonged campaign would have drained resources Saladin needed for his war against the Crusaders. Luna: So he decided it was better to negotiate. Lucas: Exactly. And the negotiation was a fascinating example of realpolitik. According to later sources like the historian Ibn al-Athir, Saladin reached an understanding with Rashid ad-Din Sinan. The Assassins agreed not to target Saladin or his key commanders, and in return, Saladin agreed to leave their fortresses untouched. He even paid them an annual subsidy. Lucas: Think about that — one of the most powerful rulers of the time paying protection money to a small sect of assassins. It shows how pragmatic Saladin could be. Luna: That's wild. So they basically became his mercenaries? Lucas: In a way, yes, but it's more complicated. The Assassins maintained their independence. They didn't fight for Saladin in his battles, but they also didn't work against him. They even targeted some of his enemies, like the Crusader prince Bohemond III of Antioch, who was attacked but survived. Lucas: Saladin's own chroniclers struggled to explain this relationship. Baha ad-Din and Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani largely avoided mentioning the Assassins, probably because it was an embarrassing subject — the great mujahid, the champion of Sunni Islam, paying off a heretical sect. Luna: It definitely doesn't fit the image of the righteous warrior. Lucas: No, it doesn't. And that's why it's so interesting. It shows the gap between propaganda and reality. Saladin was a master of propaganda — his court poet al-Qadi al-Fadil painted him as the ideal Islamic ruler — but in practice, he made compromises that were necessary for survival. Lucas: The Assassins themselves were also skilled propagandists. Rashid ad-Din Sinan wrote letters to Saladin, some of which survive, in a tone that was almost mocking. He referred to himself as a humble servant, but the subtext was clear: 'We can get you whenever we want.' Luna: Did Saladin ever try to use them against the Crusaders directly? Lucas: There's no direct evidence that he ordered them to kill specific Crusader leaders, but it's plausible. The Assassins did target Crusader nobles, most famously Conrad of Montferrat. Some historians have suggested that Saladin might have been behind Conrad's assassination, since Conrad was blocking his negotiations with Richard the Lionheart. But there's no proof. Lucas: In fact, the Assassins acted independently. After Saladin's death, they continued their own policies, eventually coming into conflict with the Mongols, who destroyed Alamut in 1256. The Syrian branch survived a bit longer, but they never regained their power. Luna: It's strange to think that such a feared group ended up being sidelined by history. Lucas: But they left a lasting impression. Their name became synonymous with political murder in European languages. And their relationship with Saladin is a great example of the complex politics of the Crusades — it wasn't just Christians versus Muslims. There were multiple factions, shifting alliances, and plenty of realpolitik beneath the religious rhetoric. Lucas: And speaking of complex politics and the realities of making this show — we've been doing these deep dives into Saladin's world, and it takes a lot of research and time. I just want to be honest: this show is listener-supported. A handful of listeners chip in monthly at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many of these. No ads, no corporate backing. Luna: Yeah, and it's because of that support that we can dig into these lesser-known stories, like the Assassins, instead of just rehashing the same battles. Lucas: Exactly. So if you're enjoying these longer episodes, that's why. Anyway, back to the Assassins — one of the most remarkable things about them was their intelligence network. They had informants in many courts, including Saladin's. Luna: So Saladin had spies, but the Assassins had spies too? Lucas: Precisely. It was a game of shadows. Saladin's own intelligence chief, al-Qadi al-Fadil, had to constantly watch for Assassin infiltrators. The Assassins were known to use conversion as a cover — they would send agents who pretended to be devout Sunni Muslims, sometimes for years, before striking. Lucas: This made them almost impossible to defend against. Saladin's countermeasures included having random checks of soldiers' identities, and he even ordered that anyone approaching his tent had to be searched twice. It was a level of paranoia that must have been exhausting. Luna: But he never actually caught a major plot after that first one, right? Lucas: Not that we know of. The truce held until Saladin's death. After that, the Assassins in Syria eventually submitted to the Mongols, which was a huge mistake — the Mongols destroyed them. But that's a story for another episode. Lucas: What I find really telling is that even in the hagiographies written about Saladin, there's almost no mention of the Assassins. It's like they wanted to erase this awkward chapter. But it's a crucial part of understanding how Saladin actually ruled — through a mix of force, diplomacy, and sometimes just paying off your enemies. Luna: It makes him more human, honestly. Lucas: Absolutely. And it reminds us that history is rarely as clean as the stories we tell about it. The Assassins were a shadow that Saladin could never fully escape, and that's the kind of detail that makes history feel real.