Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Deconstructing the DCF Model: The Intrinsic Equation - How Warren Buffett Values Businesses
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine you're trying to buy a friend's business.
- 0:02OK, I'm picturing it. Right.
- 0:04So you're in the room. How do you, how do you decide
- 0:08what it's actually worth? Do you look at how pretty the
- 0:11storefront is? Probably not the best metric.
- 0:14Or maybe you ask how much they sold last month, right?
- 0:17And you just base your whole offer on that.
- 0:19Which is what a lot of people actually do.
- 0:21Exactly. But if you look at the absolute
- 0:24top value investors, both of those instincts are just, well,
- 0:28they're completely wrong. Fast track to losing your shirt,
- 0:30yeah? See your shirt.
- 0:32Welcome to today's deep dive. Today we're focusing on a a
- 0:37really fascinating YouTube transcript from the channel A MU
- 0:41A. Great breakdown.
- 0:42It really is. It breaks down the ultimate
- 0:44valuation tool used by legends. We're talking Warren Buffett,
- 0:46Peter Lynch, the. DCF.
- 0:48The DCF, right, the discounted cash flow model.
- 0:50So our mission for this deep dive is to translate this this
- 0:54seemingly complex financial concept into plain English.
- 0:57Because it really gets wrapped up in Wall Street jargon.
- 1:00So much jargon. We want to figure out exactly
- 1:03how to price a business and understand why blindly trusting
- 1:07the math is actually a really dangerous trap.
- 1:10OK, let's unpack this, because the core philosophy of this
- 1:14whole DCF model, according to the source, is just one golden
- 1:18rule, $100 today is worth more than $100 next year.
- 1:24It really is that simple and the reason why the time value of
- 1:27money is just fundamental right. If you have $100 today, you can
- 1:30put in the bank, you earn interest, you invest it.
- 1:33You put it to work. Exactly.
- 1:35But if you wait a year to get that same $100, that money just
- 1:39sits idle. It's doing nothing for 12
- 1:41months. And inflation is eating away at
- 1:44it the whole time. Eating away.
- 1:45It's purchasing power. Yeah.
- 1:47So a smart buyer really only asks one question.
- 1:50Which is. How much money can this business
- 1:53help us make in the future? That's it, just the future cat.
- 1:56Right. The whole logic of the DCF is
- 1:58taking all that projected future money and discounting it back,
- 2:02penalizing it basically to figure out what it's worth
- 2:04exactly today. So we're punishing the future
- 2:07money because we have to wait for it.
- 2:09What's fascinating here is how the model standardizes that
- 2:12penalty. They use what's called WACC, the
- 2:16weighted average cost of capital.
- 2:18Which sounds terrifying. It sounds like a grad school
- 2:20textbook, but since you put it's just the alternative return you
- 2:23could have gotten. If you just invested your money
- 2:25somewhere else. Exactly.
- 2:27Instead of buying this specific business, what could you have
- 2:30safely made in the market? That's your discount rate.
- 2:33OK, so let's do the math. The source uses this great
- 2:36analogy of AMU milk tea shop. A very grounded example, yeah.
- 2:40So let's say this shop generates a clean 1,000,000 in free cash
- 2:44flow every single year. A naive buyer might walk in and
- 2:48think, hey, 1 billion a year, I'll just pay 10 million and
- 2:52make my money back in 10 years. A standard 10 year payback
- 2:55period, which sounds logical until you remember the time
- 2:58value of money. Right, because that year 10
- 3:00million is worth way less than the year 1,000,000.
- 3:03Way less. So the source walks us through
- 3:05the discounting action for the first five years and let's say
- 3:08we use a 10% discount rate and to make the math super clean,
- 3:12the source scales that 1,000,000 down to a base unit of 100 for
- 3:17the calculations. Makes it much easier to digest.
- 3:20Definitely. So year ones 100 units or
- 3:221,000,000 is actually only worth 90.9 today.
- 3:25Because of that 10% hurdle. Exactly.
- 3:27Then year twos million is worth 82.6.
- 3:31The penalty compounds. Year 3 drops to 75.1.
- 3:35Year 4 is 68 point three, and by year five that million is only
- 3:41worth 62.1. You're waiting half a decade for
- 3:44that cash, so it takes a massive haircut.
- 3:46A huge haircut and adding those five years together gives us a
- 3:50present value of just 379, not the 500 the naive buyer expects.
- 3:55But obviously a business doesn't just spontaneously combust after
- 3:58five years. Right, hopefully the milk tea
- 3:59shop is still open in year 6. Right, it keeps making money and
- 4:03that introduces the terminal value.
- 4:04Which is what exactly? It's the total value of the
- 4:07company from Year 5 onward into perpetuity.
- 4:10Forever. Forever Now, the source uses an
- 4:14assumption of a 3% perpetual growth rate for the shop.
- 4:17Kind of matching standard inflation or GDP.
- 4:20Exactly. So using that rate, the future
- 4:22terminal value is calculated at 14171 but.
- 4:25Wait, that's the value in Year 5?
- 4:27Right. So you still have to discount
- 4:28that massive number back to today, which brings it down to
- 4:32913. OK.
- 4:34So the final price tag, we take the 379 from the first five
- 4:38years, add the 913 from the terminal value and we get an
- 4:42intrinsic value of 12192 for the whole shop.
- 4:46That's your anchor, your mathematically derived intrinsic
- 4:49value. Here's where it gets really
- 4:50interesting, because now you know the intrinsic value is
- 4:54roughly 1300. If the market is selling this
- 4:57shop for 800, it's undervalued. It's.
- 4:59Screening by. Right, but if the current owner
- 5:02wants 2000 for it, you know for a fact it's way overpriced.
- 5:06You can confidently walk away. It's brilliant, but I know
- 5:09you're about to throw cold water on this.
- 5:11I have to be the voice of caution here, because the
- 5:13illusion of precision is the most dangerous part of this
- 5:17entire framework. A danger zone, the.
- 5:20Absolute most dangerous thing you can do is learn this
- 5:23formula, calculate that 12192 number and then blindly trust
- 5:27it. Because it looks so official.
- 5:29It has decimal points. It feels like a law of physics,
- 5:32but the source highlights three massive traps.
- 5:36OK, let's hit trap one. Garbage in, garbage out.
- 5:39The DCF is 100% reliant on assumptions.
- 5:43Human assumptions. Right.
- 5:45If your free cash flow predictions are slightly off or
- 5:49your discount rate is wrong, your final valuation is just a
- 5:52precisely accurate garbage number.
- 5:54It's built on sand, which leads right into trap 2 discount rate
- 5:58sensitivity. This blew my mind in the text.
- 6:00It's staggering. So we use a 10% discount rate to
- 6:04get our valuation, but the text shows what happens if you tweak
- 6:07it just a tiny bit. If you drop the discount rate
- 6:10from 10 to 8%, the valuation skyrockets to 1800 and. 20 A
- 6:15massive jump. But if you tweak it up to 12%,
- 6:18the value plummets down to 950. That's almost a 40% difference.
- 6:23From tweaking one single percentage point, you cannot
- 6:26just guess this number. You can basically massage the
- 6:28math to justify any price you want, and that vulnerability
- 6:32ties into trap 3. Terminal value risk, right?
- 6:36Look back at our milk tea shop. The terminal value is 913 out of
- 6:40the 12192 total. So the terminal value made-up
- 6:43over 70% of the total valuation. Over 70%.
- 6:48That means the vast majority of the company's supposed value
- 6:52relies entirely on guessing what will happen 510 or 20 years from
- 6:57now. Which is impossible.
- 6:58If we connect this to the bigger picture, it completely explains
- 7:02why the DCF model is actually terrible for valuing highly
- 7:06unpredictable tech startups. Yeah, nobody knows what an AI
- 7:08startup's going to be doing in five years.
- 7:10Exactly. The model requires stability.
- 7:13If you don't have predictable cash flows, you're just writing
- 7:15financial fiction. So then how do billionaires
- 7:18actually use this? If it's so risky and sensitive?
- 7:21How is Warren Buffett using it successfully?
- 7:22Well, the secret is that Buffett only uses the DCF on companies
- 7:26with incredibly simple business models.
- 7:28Like Coca-Cola Coca. Cola Apple companies with highly
- 7:31stable cash flows and strong predictability.
- 7:34So it's a shift in mindset. Completely, the DCF is not a
- 7:38stock price calculator. It's not a Magic 8 ball.
- 7:40No, it is a fundamental thinking framework.
- 7:43It forces you to actually analyze as a company score
- 7:46business. Yeah, because solid assumptions
- 7:48lead to reliable conclusions. Well, casual assumptions just
- 7:52give you a false sense of security.
- 7:53Precisely. If you're ready to take this
- 7:55analytical mindset to the next level and really get into
- 7:58institutional grade modeling, we have a great resource for you to
- 8:02access more advanced researches, applications and our latest
- 8:05published personal intelligent multi agent deep value
- 8:08intelligence. Welcome to subscribe on Deep
- 8:10Values dot AI and Research dot deep values dot AI.
- 8:14It's a fantastic toolkit for doing this kind of rigorous
- 8:18fundamental analysis. It really is, and also to track
- 8:21total market temperature. Welcome to search and download
- 8:24the iOS App Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 8:27Highly recommend checking that out and of course we need to
- 8:30cover our bases here. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 8:34on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 8:38or differing interretations. All contents from this channel
- 8:41is for educational and research purposes only and does not
- 8:45constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 8:48before making investment decisions.
- 8:50Always do your own homework. And hey, if you like to access
- 8:53wider topics including lice and investing philosophy, please
- 8:56subscribe to our sister channel at Deep Values.
- 8:59Don't forget to like this video. Much appreciated.
- 9:01We really appreciate the support.
- 9:03So what does this all mean? When you strip away the Wall
- 9:06Street jargon, valuing a business is really just about
- 9:08objectively measuring its future cash generation.
- 9:11That's the core. Of it, but it requires immense
- 9:13caution. You have to use realistic
- 9:15assumptions or the math will act work against you.
- 9:18This raises an important question, though, if the DCF
- 9:22model works best on predictable, simple, traditional businesses.
- 9:26Like we said Coca-Cola, but our modern economy is increasingly
- 9:31driven by unpredictable, rapidly disruptive technologies.
- 9:34Right, the whole tech sector. How do we fundamentally value
- 9:37the future of innovation when these traditional models fall
- 9:40so. Short, that is a massive paradox
- 9:42and definitely something to chew on.
- 9:44Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive.
- 9:46Keep questioning the numbers, keep challenging your
- 9:48assumptions, and we'll see you next time.