Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Renault Scenic E-Tech: French Soul in the Electric Era
Transcript
- 0:10So imagined you were just, you know, walking through a quiet
- 0:12supermarket parking lot, right? And you hear a car pulling up
- 0:15behind you, but it isn't the rumble of a combustion engine.
- 0:19Because it's an EV, obviously. Exactly.
- 0:21But it's also not that generic kind of ghostly hum that most
- 0:26electric vehicles make to warn pedestrians, either.
- 0:29Oh yeah, the standard spaceship noise.
- 0:31Yeah, not that at all. Instead, you hear this custom
- 0:34low speed warning sound that was literally composed by the
- 0:39legendary French electronic musician Jean Michel Jarre.
- 0:43Which is just so incredibly cool.
- 0:45I mean, it immediately tells you that the engineers behind the
- 0:48wheel didn't just pull parts from a standard bin, they wanted
- 0:51to make an entrance. It really is.
- 0:53It's such a quirky, distinctively French
- 0:55introduction to the world of the new Renault Scenic E tech, so
- 0:59welcome to this deep dive. Glad to be here for this one.
- 1:01Yeah, our mission today is to figure out if this newly
- 1:05reimagined 100% electric family SUV actually has what it takes
- 1:09to stand out in an absolutely flooded EV market.
- 1:12And it is flooded. It is, but this car just snagged
- 1:17the incredibly prestigious Car of the Year 2024 award and,
- 1:21well, we need to know why. Beating out some absolute Titans
- 1:24of the industry to get there too, which is no small feat.
- 1:27Right, And to figure out how Renault pulled this off, we have
- 1:29an excellent stack of sources to go through for you today.
- 1:32We're looking at official press releases straight from the
- 1:35Geneva Motor Show. The primary source.
- 1:37Plus a really comprehensive Australian review of the car.
- 1:40And honestly my favorite part? The spicy, highly technical
- 1:45comments section from EV enthusiasts who have just been
- 1:48tearing these specs apart online.
- 1:50They do not hold back in the comments.
- 1:51They never do. OK, let's unpack this, starting
- 1:54with the vibe of the car itself. Because that avant-garde sound
- 1:56on the outside is just a hint of what is happening on the inside.
- 1:59The cabin design is arguably the battleground where family
- 2:02vehicles are won or lost. Today, it's so crucial.
- 2:06And lately, the current trend for EV interiors feels almost, I
- 2:10don't know, hostile to families. Yeah, I'd agree with that.
- 2:13It's all very cold. Exactly, automakers are building
- 2:16these sterile hospital waiting rooms or these minimalist
- 2:19spaceships where you can't even figure out how to adjust the
- 2:22mirrors without tapping through like 3 sub menus on a giant
- 2:26iPad. Which is incredibly frustrating
- 2:28when you're just trying to drive.
- 2:30Right, but the scenic E tech seems to be actively rebelling
- 2:34against that. It feels much more like a
- 2:36thoughtfully designed eco friendly living room.
- 2:39What's fascinating here is the psychology behind those design
- 2:42choices. The sources note that the
- 2:45aesthetic leans heavily into recycled fabrics and softer
- 2:48matte finishes. Instead of just hard plastics
- 2:50and screens. Exactly.
- 2:52Automakers know that buyers expect environmental mindfulness
- 2:55today, sure, but Renault is also actively trying to reduce
- 2:58cognitive load. Oh, that makes sense.
- 3:00Yeah, a softer, fabric heavy cabin actually absorbs sound
- 3:03better and feels less demanding on the eyes than a cabin full of
- 3:07glossy reflective screens and harsh ambient lighting.
- 3:10It actually has some character and the tech they did include,
- 3:13well, it actually works. It features a 12 inch vertical
- 3:16touchscreen, but the crucial detail is that it has Google
- 3:19built in. A massive relief for anyone who
- 3:21hates native car software. Seriously.
- 3:23Yes, you aren't fighting with some clunky proprietary system
- 3:27that drops your Bluetooth every 5 minutes, But my absolute
- 3:30favorite detail, and it's honestly a little sad we even
- 3:33have to celebrate this, is the return of the physical button.
- 3:36Oh, you are talking about the climate control toggles?
- 3:38Yes, sitting right below that screen having a tactile switch
- 3:42to turn down the AC without taking your eyes off the road is
- 3:46a massive safety insanity feature.
- 3:47It really is. It proves the designers are
- 3:50actually thinking about the driver's attention, not just how
- 3:52sleek the dashboard looks in a glossy brochure.
- 3:55And that intense focus on practical family living is
- 3:58deeply rooted in Renault's DNA. If we look back to 1996, Renault
- 4:03essentially invented the compact MPV.
- 4:05The multi purpose vehicle. Right.
- 4:07For anyone unfamiliar, the MPV was the European precursor to
- 4:10the modern minivan. It prioritized vertical space,
- 4:13modular seating, and clever storage over, you know,
- 4:16aerodynamics or aggressive styling.
- 4:18So the scenic nameplate carries a lot of historical weight for
- 4:21European families. It really does.
- 4:23The 1996 McGann Cynic completely changed the automotive landscape
- 4:28over there by building this new 100% electric 5th generation on
- 4:34that specific heritage, Renault is deploying a very deliberate
- 4:37strategy. To stand out from the.
- 4:39Past yeah, they're trying to offer a sanctuary from the
- 4:43aggressive hyper performance EVs flooding the market.
- 4:47Which brings us to the backseat. Because if you have kids, the
- 4:50backseat is the ultimate proving ground.
- 4:52Oh. Absolutely.
- 4:52It's make or break. And Renault put something back
- 4:54there that is just brilliant. The review calls it a command
- 4:57center. The rear armrest full holds
- 4:59down, but it isn't just a padded cushion with a sad little cup.
- 5:03Holder Oh, it's way more involved than that.
- 5:04It has clever hidden storage. It has rotating cup holders that
- 5:08accommodate different size bottles.
- 5:09And this is the kicker. It features slotted articulated
- 5:12mounts for smartphones and tablets.
- 5:15Which is genius. Kids can watch videos completely
- 5:17hands free. That solves a very specific
- 5:19universal pain point. Designers clearly observed how
- 5:23modern families actually behave on road trips.
- 5:25Yeah, dropping screens is the worst, right?
- 5:28Keeping kids entertained without them dropping their iPads under
- 5:31the front seats every 10 minutes is a massive quality of life
- 5:35upgrade for the parents who are just trying to navigate traffic
- 5:38upfront. Combine that with a very usable
- 5:40545 liter boot and you have a car that is fundamentally built
- 5:43around the passenger. But you know, driving a heavy
- 5:46family box is a different story. Physics of the thing.
- 5:49This vehicle weighs 18190kg and stretches 4.47 meters long.
- 5:55How does it actually handle that burden on the road?
- 5:58Well, the Australian review relies on one specific word to
- 6:01describe the driving dynamics, and that word is calm, very
- 6:05calm. OK, I have to push back on that
- 6:06a little. Fair enough.
- 6:07In an EV market obsessed with sub 3 seconds zero to 100 times
- 6:12and these crazy launch control modes, is calm actually just
- 6:16polite automotive journalist code for boring and sluggish.
- 6:20It is a totally valid suspicion, especially since electric motors
- 6:23have completely warped our perception of standard
- 6:25acceleration. Like we expect everything to be
- 6:28a rocket ship now, but let's look at the actual mechanics
- 6:30here. The long range version packs an
- 6:3387 kWh battery paired with 160 kilowatt motor that gets you
- 6:40from zero to 100 kilometers per hour in 7.9 seconds.
- 6:44Which, OK, compared to a Tesla, feels like an absolute eternity.
- 6:48True, but 7.9 seconds is still faster than most combustion
- 6:52engine family SUV's from just five years ago.
- 6:54That's a good point. It is more than adequate for
- 6:56merging onto a highway. The suspension is tuned softly
- 7:00to absorb broken city pavement and the steering is light.
- 7:03The goal isn't to set a lap time on a track right?
- 7:06The goal is to prevent your passengers from getting carsick.
- 7:09A hyper responsive throttle in a car full of toddlers and
- 7:12groceries is actually a huge liability.
- 7:14OK, the cruiser over sprinter philosophy makes total sense
- 7:17when you put it like that, but the trade off for sacrificing
- 7:20that next snapping speed has to be endurance.
- 7:22Right, and that is exactly where the engineering pays off.
- 7:24Renault claims up to 625 kilometers of range on the
- 7:28strict WLTP testing cycle. We should probably clarify the
- 7:31WLTP part for anyone who just, you know, glazes over at
- 7:34acronyms. The Worldwide Harmonized Light
- 7:37Vehicle Test Procedure is the current highly rigorous European
- 7:41standard. So when they say 625 kilometers,
- 7:44that isn't some wildly inflated fantasy number achieved by
- 7:47driving downhill in a vacuum. No, not at all.
- 7:50It is a highly realistic expectation for a mix of city
- 7:53and Hwy. driving. Precisely.
- 7:55For a family doing the daily school run, weekend sports and a
- 7:59long holiday road trip, 625 kilometers is the metric that
- 8:02actually eliminates range anxiety.
- 8:04That's a. Huge number.
- 8:05It is, and they achieved this partly because 1890 kilograms is
- 8:09surprisingly light for an EV. With a battery this large, many
- 8:13competitors are pushing 2200 kilograms.
- 8:15Wow, so it's significantly lighter.
- 8:17Yeah, Renault kept the weight down by optimizing the battery
- 8:20packaging and making a very specific drivetrain choice.
- 8:23All three variants of the Scenic E Tech are front wheel drive
- 8:26only. Wait, hold on, front wheel drive
- 8:29only in the premium family SUV? When almost every competitor is
- 8:32throwing dual motor all-wheel drive setups at their vehicles,
- 8:36doesn't that feel like a massive corner being cut?
- 8:38I know how it sounds. I mean, if I'm putting my family
- 8:41in this for a winter road trip, I want maximum traction.
- 8:44It definitely sounds like a downgrade on paper, but
- 8:46mechanically it is a very calculated compromise.
- 8:49OK, so. Well, in a traditional gas car,
- 8:52front wheel drive can struggle for grip because the engine
- 8:54weight is entirely upfront. But in an EV, that massive 87
- 8:59kWh battery is distributed low across the floor pan.
- 9:03So the center of gravity is different.
- 9:05Exactly. You have excellent natural
- 9:07balance combined with sophisticated modern traction
- 9:10control systems. A Hunt wheel drive EV can handle
- 9:14rain and light snow incredibly well.
- 9:17By omitting the rear motor, Renault saved hundreds of
- 9:20kilograms of weight and thousands of dollars in
- 9:22manufacturing costs. So they basically sacrifice the
- 9:25all-wheel drive edge case to guarantee that 625 kilometer
- 9:29daily rain. Precisely.
- 9:30It reinforces that calm, predictable persona.
- 9:34But driving dynamics are really only half the story here.
- 9:36Here's where it gets really interesting, because Rennell is
- 9:39making a massive bet that this car's primary value to a family
- 9:43might actually be when it is parked in the driveway.
- 9:46We need to talk about the VBG hype.
- 9:48Vehicle to grid capability. It is the concept that is
- 9:51absolutely dominating EV marketing right now.
- 9:53The promise is that your driveway becomes a giant rolling
- 9:56power bank, right? The car can theoretically send
- 9:59power from its massive battery back into your home to run your
- 10:03appliances during a blackout, or even sell electricity back to
- 10:07the local grid during peak demand times when prices
- 10:10highest. It's a very appealing concept.
- 10:13It could literally pay you to own it.
- 10:14And Renault is pushing this hard, stating they hope to see
- 10:17V2G practically usable for consumers within the next 12
- 10:20months. That soon.
- 10:22That is bold considering many legacy automakers are terrified
- 10:26of V2G because they just don't want the liability of
- 10:29accelerated battery degradation warranties.
- 10:31It sounds like a complete game changer, but we need a serious
- 10:35reality check here, right? Because the commenters in the EV
- 10:38media articles do not miss a trick.
- 10:40They really don't a. Username V2H posted a highly
- 10:44technical breakdown that fundamentally changes how we
- 10:46should understand Renault's V2G rollout.
- 10:49It is a crucial piece of technical verification.
- 10:52V2H points out that it is highly misleading for any automaker to
- 10:56suggest a car has V2G quote UN quote out-of-the-box.
- 11:01Right V2H explains that what the scenic actually has built into
- 11:04the car is an 11 kilowatt or 22 kilowatt bi directional AC
- 11:08charger. The alternating current.
- 11:10Yeah, the ability for power to flow both ways is there, but
- 11:14think of it like speaking different languages.
- 11:16The AC output from the car is speaking fluent French, but your
- 11:20house and the city power grid only understand German.
- 11:23That's a great way to put it. If you just rig a cable and plug
- 11:26them directly together, it is not just a miscommunication, it
- 11:30is a catastrophic short circuit that will result in a massive
- 11:34repair bill. And this raises an important
- 11:36question about the friction between automotive marketing and
- 11:38the reality of consumer adoption.
- 11:40Right, because they make it sound so easy.
- 11:41Exactly, to make that my directional AC charger actually
- 11:45work, you need a sophisticated real time translator.
- 11:48You need substantial piece of external hardware installed on
- 11:51your house to synchronize the car's power frequency with the
- 11:54grids frequency safely. And V2H specifically mentions
- 11:58what that hardware is. You need an external V2G device
- 12:02like the mobilized power box they're rolling out in France.
- 12:04The commenter even points to a real world proof of concept.
- 12:09The Dutch city of Utrecht has a trial slated for 2025 using
- 12:13Renault 5 rental cars equipped with a similar AC based V2G
- 12:18setup. OK, so it does work.
- 12:20The technology absolutely works, but it requires that dedicated,
- 12:23expensive external infrastructure at the charging
- 12:26location. That distinction changes
- 12:28everything for the buyer. The car is ready to play, but
- 12:31you still have to buy a multi $1000 adapter to join the game.
- 12:35Automakers are selling a future promise that relies heavily on
- 12:38local grid and expensive home installations that most
- 12:41consumers don't even know they need yet.
- 12:43It is the messy reality of the energy transition right now.
- 12:46The vehicles are advancing faster than the infrastructure
- 12:48and the legislation can accommodate them.
- 12:50So what does this all mean for the person walking into a
- 12:53dealership? Today we have explored this
- 12:55incredibly thoughtful, family focused cabin.
- 12:58We debated the mechanics of its calm, lightweight front wheel
- 13:01drive performance. We untangled the expensive
- 13:04reality hidden behind the V2G marketing.
- 13:07We've covered a lot of ground. We really have, but we have to
- 13:10zoom out and ask will people actually buy this, Especially
- 13:14when commenters like one named Klaxon Awuga bluntly stated
- 13:18quote, the French can't cut it in our competitive market.
- 13:21The ultimate test of all this engineering is the price tag.
- 13:24In Australia, the Scenic Etech is positioned between 55,990 and
- 13:29$65,990.00 plus on road costs. Which puts it right in the
- 13:34crosshairs of some incredibly aggressive, highly subsidized
- 13:37competition. But if you look at the global
- 13:39market, Australian buyers are actually getting a remarkable
- 13:43deal here. The pricing strategy is
- 13:45fascinating. The review highlights that in
- 13:46the UK the exact same vehicle starts at just under £37,000.
- 13:51Wow. If you do the convergent that is
- 13:53over 70,000 Australian dollars. That's a massive difference.
- 13:56Renault is artificially compressing their profit margins
- 13:59in certain markets just to gain a foothold against the flood of
- 14:02new competitors. And they are backing up that
- 14:05price with a giant, undeniable trophy.
- 14:09I mean, it didn't just casually win Car of the Year 2024 at the
- 14:13Geneva Motor Show. It dominated.
- 14:15It really did. A jury of 59 seasoned automotive
- 14:18journalists from across 22 countries awarded it 329 points.
- 14:23The context of who it beat is what matters most here.
- 14:26It outscored the BMW 5 Series, which represents the pinnacle of
- 14:30traditional German luxury. It beat the BYD Seal, which is
- 14:34the vanguard of hyper affordable high tech Chinese manufacturing,
- 14:38and it beat the Volvo EX30. Making it the 7th Renault
- 14:42vehicle to ever take on the title.
- 14:44How did a front wheel drive family cruiser beat luxury
- 14:47sedans and high tech disruptors? Well, if we connect this to the
- 14:50bigger picture, Renault hit the exact Goldilocks zone for those
- 14:53journalists. They aren't trying to out tech
- 14:55the startups with gimmicks and they aren't trying to build a
- 14:58track car. They are selling a highly
- 15:00considered anxiety free transition to electric mobility.
- 15:04They are betting that millions of families don't actually want
- 15:06an iPad on reels, they want a reliable, usable car from a
- 15:11brand with over a century of manufacturing history.
- 15:15But history doesn't fix your car if it breaks down, which is
- 15:17their biggest hurdle in markets like Australia.
- 15:20That's a real challenge. The review points out that while
- 15:23everyone recognizes the Renault badge, their actual footprint of
- 15:26dealerships and service centers is relatively sparse compared to
- 15:30the incumbent brands. They're trying to sell European
- 15:33engineering and hoping that the heritage down to the little
- 15:35French flag stitched into the front seats and that cool Jean
- 15:38Michel Jarre sound will reassure buyers to take a leap of faith.
- 15:42It is the classic industry battle playing out in real time,
- 15:46legacy versus disruption. Can deep experience in building
- 15:49comfortable family cabins outweigh the flashy, attention
- 15:53grabbing specs coming from newer, incredibly ambitious
- 15:56manufacturers? That is the defining question
- 16:00for the entire automotive sector right now and it brings us to
- 16:03the end of our journey. Today we have unpacked how a
- 16:06brand rebelled against sterile spaceship interiors to create an
- 16:10eco friendly living room. We explored the physics of why a
- 16:141890 kilogram front wheel drive setup is the secret to a 625
- 16:19kilometer range. We translated the complex
- 16:22reality of bi directional charging and we examined how a
- 16:25sharply priced European champion is leveraging its heritage to
- 16:29survive. But you know, stepping back from
- 16:31the specs and the market strategies, the Scenic E tech
- 16:34leaves us with something deeper to ponder about the future of
- 16:37transportation itself. What?
- 16:38Are you thinking? Well, if automakers are so
- 16:41successful at making the cabin feel exactly like a comfortable
- 16:43living room, and the driving dynamics are engineered to be
- 16:46perfectly calm and unnoticeable, and the vehicles primary
- 16:49financial value comes from acting as a stationary grid
- 16:52battery in your driveway, have we engineered the romance of
- 16:56driving entirely out of existence?
- 16:57Are we turning the automobile into just another household
- 17:00appliance, no different from a very expensive refrigerator that
- 17:04you happen to sit inside? Wow.
- 17:06That is a phenomenal point. If the ultimate goal is 0
- 17:10friction and maximum utility, we might be witnessing the end of
- 17:13the car as a machine of freedom and the birth of the car as just
- 17:17another white good. Exactly.
- 17:19It is a brilliant thought to leave off on, and before we wrap
- 17:22up, we want to take a moment to explicitly say thank you.
- 17:25Absolutely. Thank you to you, our listener,
- 17:27for coming along on this deep dive.
- 17:30Whether you are prepping for a meeting, looking for your next
- 17:32family car, or just insanely curious about how the world is
- 17:36changing, we know your time is valuable.
- 17:38We genuinely appreciate your curiosity and your desire to
- 17:41always keep learning alongside us.
- 17:43It is always a privilege to unpack these complexities with
- 17:45you. It really is.
- 17:47So next time you are walking through a parking lot and you
- 17:50hear what sounds like an avant-garde French synthesizer
- 17:53gliding into a spot, just smile. Because now you know the massive
- 17:57engineering and historical weight behind that quirky little
- 18:00sound. We will catch you on the next
- 18:02deep dive.