Latest / Film And Whiskey / Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace / Calumet 14 Year Single Rack Black Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 1999, director George Lucas and star Liam Neeson gave the
- 0:04world a stunning new entry into a Galaxy we all longed to return
- 0:07to. And 10 years later everybody
- 0:10lost their crap and decided they hated it, even though when it
- 0:12came out it had mixed to solid reviews, even getting a 3 1/2
- 0:16stars from fame movie credited Rodger Ebert.
- 0:19But I digress. In 2024 we try a rare whiskey
- 0:23from a non distilling producer. The film is Star Wars Episode
- 0:27One, The Phantom Menace. The whiskey is Calumet 14 year
- 0:32Single Rack Black Label. And we'll review them both.
- 0:36This is the Fill in Whiskey Podcast.
- 0:59Welcome to the Film and Whiskey Podcast, where each week we
- 1:01review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 1:04I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:07And I suppose it's that time, Brad.
- 1:10Bob, I am so excited for this episode.
- 1:15Can I can I ask one question, Brad?
- 1:18You can ask as many questions as you want, Bob.
- 1:21Why? Why are you excited for this
- 1:24episode, Brad? 'Cause I love this movie,
- 1:27Robert. Folks, today we are reluctantly,
- 1:31some of us are reluctantly diving back into the world of
- 1:34Star Wars for the first of what seems like, I don't know, eight
- 1:38more times this season, we are dipping our toes in George
- 1:42Lucas's pool. And folks, I don't know what
- 1:45temperature the water is, and it seems to agree with Brad, but
- 1:49it's a little too a little too cold for my taste.
- 1:52It's a beautiful like 104° Jacuzzi.
- 1:56Just chilling. Is that is that what you really
- 1:58wanted to just chill in a Jacuzzi with George Lucas?
- 2:02Yes. I would kill to do that, Bob.
- 2:05That would be so much fun. Just have a beer with George
- 2:07Lucas. Brad, I have been thinking about
- 2:11this episode for a minute now because I watched this movie, I
- 2:15don't know, 5-6 days ago. I've had a good long time to sit
- 2:19and reminisce and ruminate and. When's the last time you watched
- 2:23it? Five or six days ago.
- 2:25Before that. I watched it during COVID.
- 2:29I I watched all the Star Wars movies again during COVID
- 2:32because like with some of the other classic films in in the
- 2:36American catalog, I don't like them that much.
- 2:39And I keep thinking that you know everyone likes these so
- 2:42it's got to be something wrong with me and maybe that thing
- 2:45will will reverse itself someday.
- 2:48And so I keep trying it's like with 2001, I keep trying and
- 2:53alas Brad I am I am just allergic to the the Star Wars.
- 2:58So I've been thinking about this for a long time and I think Brad
- 3:03what I would like to do today with your permission is I would
- 3:06like to reverse our rules today. Not in terms of like I'm not
- 3:10going to do Brad explains or anything like that.
- 3:12But I'm very aware that I talk a lot, Brad, and I think that the
- 3:16the split of talking on our podcast instead of being 5050,
- 3:20it's it's like 6535, like I talk much more than you I.
- 3:24Think it's more like a 67? Yeah, I was going to say 7030,
- 3:28but like you know, I I'm trying to temper expectations a bit.
- 3:32I do that because I feel very passionately about the movies we
- 3:35talk about and I frankly am not that passionate about this
- 3:38movie. Now I I will also say up front,
- 3:41I'm not coming into this as begrudgingly as I thought I
- 3:44would. I think there's a lot to like in
- 3:46this movie and I don't feel antagonistic towards it.
- 3:50I also don't feel ambivalent towards it, like I'm ready to
- 3:53talk about the movie. I just, when I look at my list
- 3:56of notes, if I was leading the discussion today, Brad, I think
- 4:01this episode would be about 35 minutes long, 'cause I just,
- 4:04it's one of those things that I don't really know where to go
- 4:07with this. And you as a guy who's super
- 4:09passionate about the movie, I think can guide us through the
- 4:12film a lot better than I can. So if if you're feeling up to
- 4:16it, and I'd like to kind of turn this episode over to you to be
- 4:20our our guide, you can be our Virgil guiding us through the
- 4:24layers of hell that is the prequel trilogy.
- 4:28Here, here's the thing, Bob. This is, this is going to blow
- 4:31your mind. Why?
- 4:32Why? We're ready for this role
- 4:33reversal. I have a page of notes.
- 4:37A whole page. And and that's a first.
- 4:40You did it, man. You you wrote a one page
- 4:43document. I did.
- 4:45Now when I say one page it is like you know like the Amazon
- 4:49notepads that are that are like. Like a 5 by 7.
- 4:54Yeah, yeah. Yeah, sure.
- 4:55It's one of those. Pages.
- 4:56I thought you were going to say You typed it in like 18 point
- 4:59Comic Sans do. You remember in college when
- 5:01like a professor would be like you can have one note card of a
- 5:05cheap note card and people would like print whatever, whatever
- 5:09they are like a 5 by 7 note card and they would print in like
- 5:13size 6 font every fact from the entire semester.
- 5:17Is that what you did here? No.
- 5:20First off, I would walk into those tests without a note card,
- 5:24because who has time to make a cheat note card?
- 5:27Just be smart. Come on.
- 5:29Secondly, I don't. I don't need much preparation to
- 5:33defend a movie like this, but I just was so excited to talk
- 5:38about it that I had to write things down.
- 5:41You know what? And like, again, I'm not going
- 5:43to be snarky with you about this movie today.
- 5:46Yeah. And I.
- 5:47Think I trust you, Bob. Like, I think the the, the weird
- 5:50place I'm in is that I thought that I was going to end up being
- 5:53in the Brad GI didn't really care for this movie and so I'm
- 5:56going to like tank the audio and I don't feel like that either.
- 6:00Like it's it's fine. It's a fine movie with some
- 6:05really bad acting and some some pretty bad special effects at
- 6:10points and also some really great film making in some
- 6:13stretches too. So like, I, you know, I don't
- 6:15feel any any worse about this movie than I did talking about
- 6:19Independence Day or Armageddon or any like, there are things to
- 6:22appreciate here for sure, but you just have to lead me, your
- 6:26horse, to water to drink of them.
- 6:30Hey, I'll, I'll lead you to the waters I can't make you drink.
- 6:34And I'll say on my side of it, Bob, like the the prequels are a
- 6:38step down from the originals for me.
- 6:41Not a not a massive step down just a just a small one.
- 6:44The the the sequels are a massive step down, but we we've
- 6:49already gone over that and we'll go over it at the end of the
- 6:51season. I think that my stance on the
- 6:56prequels has always been that they are incredibly fun.
- 7:01They're great film making. The sound design is light years
- 7:05ahead of its time, as were the originals.
- 7:08And the acting's not great. And I like.
- 7:11I think the same thing could be said for the originals, except
- 7:15for the fact that Harrison Ford is just beyond incredible.
- 7:19I think Mark Hamill is great. Carrie Fisher's great.
- 7:21Like, there's just so many great actors and actresses in those
- 7:24films and you just don't quite get that as often in the
- 7:28prequels. But other than that, I I really
- 7:31love these movies. I'm not going to sit here and
- 7:34say it is the greatest movie of 1999.
- 7:37Like, like there there are other movies that were better movies
- 7:40in Star Wars Episode One. But man, the mixture of
- 7:44revisiting this film as an adult and appreciating how great of a
- 7:47film it is and having the nostalgia attached just has me
- 7:52real jazzed. Well, let's carry that jazz
- 7:55music and that jazz feeling into our next segment, our first
- 7:59segment of the day, which we call Brad explains.
- 8:01Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 8:05taken on the clock, so let's go ahead and hear your take with
- 8:08this little segment that we call.
- 8:10Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 8:13podcast where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he
- 8:16has just seen. This time I'm going to say this
- 8:19is your, I don't know, 32nd time watching episode one.
- 8:23No. See, here's the thing, Bob.
- 8:24You watch movies 30 times legitimately.
- 8:28I've probably seen The Phantom Menace 8 times, maybe 10.
- 8:34So like. That is an extravagant number
- 8:37for you. For.
- 8:38Yeah, not for me, Bob. For the average person, anybody,
- 8:44any human being alive in America, the most they've
- 8:48probably ever seen. One movie is like 6 to 8 times.
- 8:52I'm going to disagree. With you there, we don't need to
- 8:54get off on a tangent here. I'm definitely if we're on the
- 8:57bell curve, Brad. Like I'm definitely way far over
- 9:00on one. End in the 99th plus bro.
- 9:02I I think especially for people who grew up like we did in the
- 9:07era of Betamax, VHS or DVDs when they were the primary way to
- 9:12watch movies, when people had movies at home, they watched
- 9:16them a lot, dude. And I think that you just grew
- 9:19up in a in a household that didn't watch movies that often
- 9:21and so legitimately for you, 8 is a lot.
- 9:24But if you ask the average person, what's your favorite
- 9:26movie of all time? Or like how many times did you
- 9:30watch The Lion King on VHS when you were a kid?
- 9:33Like 30 is on the low end for some kids, man.
- 9:37You know what I mean? Yeah, but does that really
- 9:39count? Watching it 30 times when you're
- 9:426 years old? Is is that an actual view?
- 9:46I guess, I guess you can't love things as a child, according to
- 9:49Brad. All right.
- 9:50Dude unable to. You have one minute on the clock
- 9:53to spoil this movie. You should be able to do it
- 9:56because you've seen it, as we've established 8 whole times.
- 9:59So Brad, the floor is yours, man, and go.
- 10:04The Phantom Menace is a film where the Trade Federation is
- 10:08controlled by Lord Palpatine of the Sith and they invade the
- 10:11peaceful planet of Naboo. Jedi's Qui Gon Jinn and Obi Wan
- 10:14Kenobi attempt to negotiate, but are nearly killed in the
- 10:17process. They rescue Queen Amidala of the
- 10:20Naboo and go on an adventure to that detours onto the desert
- 10:24planet Tatooine. There they find and free a slave
- 10:27boy named Anakin and have an incredible pod race.
- 10:30They continue on their way to the capital planet Croissant.
- 10:33There, Amidala pleads her case before the Senate realizes it is
- 10:36pointless and flies back to Naboo, enlisting aid from
- 10:40unexpected quarters to defeat the Trade Federation.
- 10:45Did you write this down? This sounds written.
- 10:48I did, yeah. I was going to.
- 10:49Say that was that was so much more eloquent than what we
- 10:52normally get and here's here's how I know that is because
- 10:54usually you start I can hear you collecting your thoughts.
- 10:57I can hear inside of your brain because you always start with
- 11:01Armageddon is a film about such and such and I always think it's
- 11:05so funny dude. I just like We are on a podcast
- 11:07called Film and Whiskey, if there is one, given it is that
- 11:11you watched a film. We know, buddy.
- 11:15I still started with that. That's true.
- 11:18I mean, I think you're just honoring a time tested tradition
- 11:21at this point of. Course I am.
- 11:23Yeah. I mean, I will say this is one
- 11:25of those movies that either I was going to give a really
- 11:30esoteric like 12 seconds or I was going to hit the 67 second
- 11:36mark and get bogged down in the details and I I wanted to strike
- 11:39a nice balance. Now, is it because this movie is
- 11:41so bad that you had to affirm that it is in fact a film?
- 11:46No, The Phantom Menace is, for the record, a film.
- 11:50Fun fact, as you just said, I've said that for every single movie
- 11:55we've ever reviewed. So no, it's not the fact that
- 11:59it's quote UN quote a bad film. All right, man, let's jump into
- 12:03talking about the movie, and I'm going to hand it over to you.
- 12:05I'm going to sit back and rest on my laurels here.
- 12:09I want us to, I want to talk about the characters, Bob,
- 12:11because I I think that the acting is not great on a lot of
- 12:16different levels accurate, I think.
- 12:18I think that Ewan McGregor, Liam Neeson are both stellar in their
- 12:23acting. I think that Natalie Portman is
- 12:27like AB minus. She's like pretty solid in
- 12:30certain points and then she kneels down to to to boss Nas
- 12:37and goes, no I beg you and I'm like George, couldn't we have
- 12:43taken like any other take of that and put that in the film?
- 12:49But overall, I think Natalie Portman is solid.
- 12:52Jake Lloyd is terrible. Could could we just agree on
- 12:55that and leave it, leave it be? Yeah, we can agree on that.
- 12:58I I truly, truly regret and and abhor the treatment of him that
- 13:04led to him having some mental health issues and everything.
- 13:06Like don't don't give child actors so much crap.
- 13:10People like it's OK to admit now with some distance.
- 13:13Like, no, it's not good. Yeah, but like, he's just a kid,
- 13:17man. What do you want?
- 13:18Yeah, yeah. And at that point, it's George
- 13:21Lucas for choosing him and maybe even for, like, for directing.
- 13:25Not. Yeah, for directing him and not
- 13:27giving him the right notes and just the fact that, you know,
- 13:31maybe you get a few days into it and go, you know, this isn't
- 13:34quite working out. Yeah, like, let's, let's get. #2
- 13:37and Haley Joel Osment off 6th Sense and bring.
- 13:39Him over here. Oh dude.
- 13:42Yeah, Brad, I think one of my big not fears.
- 13:45But as a noted non Star Wars fan, and I don't consider myself
- 13:49a Star Wars hater, I'm just not like this is just not my thing
- 13:54that grabs me and causes me to nerd out.
- 13:57Not your cup of blue milk. Yes, drunk out of clearly
- 14:01plastic glasses. Like, where's the plastic
- 14:04production happening in this universe?
- 14:06In every Star Wars movie? It's like a Dollar Tree plastic
- 14:09cup. What are we doing here?
- 14:12OK, anyway, not my cup of tea. However, the prequels are always
- 14:18really interesting to me because I can never pin down with
- 14:21somebody like you who grew up with the prequels.
- 14:24So this was like, these were your Star Wars movies.
- 14:26You know, the the original trilogy was kind of inherited,
- 14:29but these are the ones that came out when you were of the right
- 14:32age to start watching Star Wars. Well, here's the thing, though,
- 14:36about the originals. It's not like my parents passed
- 14:40them down to me. Like like one of my best friends
- 14:43in the world, Mike, he had like his parents passed Star Wars
- 14:47down to him. They love Star Wars, my parents.
- 14:50It was just like VH s s that we had.
- 14:53And when I was probably six or seven I I started watching them
- 14:56and I really liked them. And then The Phantom Menace came
- 14:59out and I went and I remember being scared of Darth Maul.
- 15:02And like I I liked it a lot and and then the second one came
- 15:07out, I liked it a lot. And then the third one came out
- 15:09and I skipped school and saw it and it was really cool because I
- 15:12was like what, 1516 at that point.
- 15:15And it I think it was around there that my fandom really
- 15:18cemented itself. Because at that point I I'm
- 15:21playing Star Wars video games. I'm reading Star Wars books from
- 15:25the 80s and 90s that are just incredible.
- 15:28And I, you know, the movie is coming out and and I think
- 15:31that's kind of the era where it really got cemented for me.
- 15:35So my point was going to be I I wonder how hard it is.
- 15:39And I'm not accusing you of anything, but like, I wonder how
- 15:41hard it is to separate the prequels from the legacy of the
- 15:46original trilogy or even from the sort of like narrative, like
- 15:51shared narrative knowledge of the original trilogy.
- 15:54Like, we know who these people are because we've watched the
- 15:57other movies and these are prequels.
- 15:58And so every time there's like a fan servicing thing of Qui Gon
- 16:02first being like now, now Obi Wan Kenobi, and I can just hear
- 16:05an audience in 99 going like he's the guy from the movie.
- 16:09You know what I mean? Yes, exactly.
- 16:15I want to talk about this movie as much as it is indebted to
- 16:19those other movies. I want to talk about it in a
- 16:21vacuum because I think that this is where Lucas's writing and
- 16:27directing really suffer sometimes.
- 16:30I think he relies a lot on your prior knowledge of these people.
- 16:34And sometimes that's an OK thing to do.
- 16:35You don't have to give tons of back story because A this is the
- 16:38back story and and B like you just make passing nods at
- 16:42certain characters and that's fine.
- 16:44But I I'm wondering, Brad, like do you, when you watch this
- 16:48movie, do you think of it as a piece of a big hole or do you
- 16:53evaluate it solely on like if this was the first Star Wars
- 16:57movie, would you think differently about it?
- 17:00You know what I mean? Yes, is the answer to your
- 17:04question. Like, I like, 'cause I I think
- 17:07that when you take, especially The Phantom Menace, like I think
- 17:14that there's two, sorry, 4 characters that we know from the
- 17:21later films. There's Anakin, there's Obi Wan,
- 17:25there's C3PO, and there's R2D2. Other than that, not a single
- 17:30character in this film. As best as I know, Star Wars
- 17:33fans, you can come at me. That's.
- 17:34Fine. I mean the emperor.
- 17:35'S somebody else? OK, sure.
- 17:36Yeah. The Emperor.
- 17:39So 5 characters that are known in the later films.
- 17:42Pretty much everybody else is not a known character.
- 17:46And so I I think it's easy to come into this and treat it in a
- 17:49vacuum to just say all right, like what do we have just here
- 17:53in this film? And that's where I I think you
- 17:57are off on the wrong foot already, Bob.
- 17:59I think that the writing in this film is great and not not
- 18:04necessarily the dialogue. Like as you have informed me
- 18:08many times, like the script is not just the dialogue, it's
- 18:11everything that goes into this movie.
- 18:14I actually think that the story here is really well done and the
- 18:18characters are are really interesting and they they flesh
- 18:23each other out in really fascinating ways.
- 18:26All right. So I am going to disagree with
- 18:28you a little bit. Yeah, man.
- 18:30It's so weird being not in the driver's seat of how these
- 18:33conversations go. Brad, I'm in the Brad G role
- 18:35today. Yeah.
- 18:37So here's what I'm thinking about the writing of this movie,
- 18:40like we've both established the dialogue is not great.
- 18:42We'll get around to examples of how it's not great.
- 18:44That's fine. There are great moments though.
- 18:47Oh for sure, for sure, when Qui Gon goes.
- 18:50The ability to speak does not make one intelligent.
- 18:54It's it is one of the most priceless lines I think I've
- 18:57ever heard in a movie. When we did episode three, I
- 19:00think you were kind of shocked by how much I appreciated the
- 19:05grand overarching narrative of the the prequels.
- 19:10I think that like taken as one huge meta story, it's really
- 19:17cool what George Lucas did here. Yeah, I think that it also kind
- 19:21of when it doesn't work like I think, you know, Episode one and
- 19:24Episode 2 are obviously weaker films than Episode 3.
- 19:27And so to some extent it works less well in both of those
- 19:30movies. And I think that when it's not
- 19:31working as well, it's almost to me like the story that these
- 19:37movies are telling is almost a more compelling Wikipedia
- 19:41article because you at least see what the broad strokes that are
- 19:44being painted are. And I think if this movie is the
- 19:47only thing you have to go on, you don't have prior knowledge
- 19:51of the the, you know, the original trilogy.
- 19:55I think this movie's kind of a mess, like in terms of what the
- 19:58through line is. Because you know, even if you
- 20:00look at the Wikipedia on this movie, Lucas says that he's
- 20:03trying to tell 5 separate narrative threads, but it's not
- 20:07that they're intertwined with each other.
- 20:08They like are supposed to logically flow from each other.
- 20:12And the big main overarching thread of episode one, according
- 20:16to Lucas, is Palpatine's power play here.
- 20:21Which is fine and which is good. I just think that like if
- 20:24Palpatine is kind of the quote UN quote main character here we
- 20:28need to see a little bit more of his wheelings and dealings.
- 20:31I think you need to just like abandoned the the ruse that we
- 20:36don't know that he is palpate like they even to the end of the
- 20:39film they're still shrouding him in shadow.
- 20:40Like we don't know it's the same guy And the audience is one step
- 20:45ahead of where Lucas thinks the audience is or or will allow the
- 20:49audience to go because he's like I need to save that for the 2nd
- 20:52movie or the third movie or whatever it might be.
- 20:54The characters themselves are interesting characters, but the
- 20:58choices that he makes in terms of who to develop and how much
- 21:02to develop each of those characters, I think that the
- 21:05calculus is just a little bit off here.
- 21:08It's it's hard for me to fault Lucas for like narratively
- 21:15choosing not to reveal Palpatine earlier like because he knew he
- 21:23was making multiple films like like I'm With You and like let's
- 21:27evaluate this film on its own merits.
- 21:30But part of its own merits are that it was made to be part of a
- 21:35trilogy. Sure.
- 21:37And and so I like for me I think it's this is going to sound like
- 21:42a Marvel defense but like that's kind of part of the appeal of
- 21:47the the prequel trilogy is that you get to see this story
- 21:52through all three films And so the the Palpatine of it all like
- 21:57pretty much everybody knew that like that you know Palpatine,
- 22:02Sidious, they're they're all the same person even as you're
- 22:04watching it. And so I I think it's to me it
- 22:07makes it much more sinister of an antagonist that like he is
- 22:12behind the scenes, he's showing up in one form to the Trade
- 22:18Federation and showing up in a different form to the Senate,
- 22:23and he is getting all of his enemies to attack each other and
- 22:27weaken each other. And then he doesn't come in and
- 22:30destroy them all. He comes in as the hero to save
- 22:34them all. And and again, like I I think
- 22:36that's a really great touch. I think the the decision though
- 22:38to keep showing the, you know, the Darth Sidious side of things
- 22:44as like a hooded figure who just happens to have the same chin
- 22:47and mouth as this other guy that has the same voice.
- 22:50Like have a scene where we see him say like, OK, see you later,
- 22:56Amidala. And then turn around and put his
- 22:58hood up and a hologram pops up of the Trade Federation guys.
- 23:01And then you, you know, like we know the reveal that Lucas
- 23:06doesn't actually show us. And and I'm thinking of like,
- 23:09you know, Lord of the Rings in in the Fellowship, the second
- 23:12you see Christopher Lee come on screen, you're like that mother
- 23:15the bad guy. Like look at him, do you know
- 23:17what I mean? Like, even.
- 23:19But even before he gets revealed as the bad guy, it's like, you
- 23:22know what's coming here, but you still need that turn for the
- 23:26audience's sake, for the character's sake.
- 23:28And even if he doesn't want to reveal to the characters within
- 23:31the film that this is the bad guy.
- 23:34I just, like, I just kept wondering, like, why are you
- 23:36still doing this whole thing at the end of the movie?
- 23:39Because we're we're we know already, George.
- 23:42Yeah, but like, wouldn't that be too much telling and not enough
- 23:46showing? I mean it.
- 23:47They took him on in the first movie and he lasted through
- 23:50three movies, 2 1/2, you know what I mean?
- 23:54Sure, but I don't know this. This doesn't feel like a
- 23:59sticking point for me. Like to me it's a I think that
- 24:02this is Lucas doing a great job of show.
- 24:05Don't tell. Like he shows you that he is the
- 24:07villain. He doesn't tell you that he's
- 24:09the villain. And like look at the character
- 24:12of Darth Maul. Darth Maul is one of the best
- 24:15written characters in the entire Star Wars universe because he is
- 24:20set up as the embodiment of evil.
- 24:23Like, tell me you didn't see him as a 10 year old child.
- 24:26Oh, he's you know. That is a pure demon.
- 24:30Not like he is. But here's the thing, man.
- 24:32Like the character design, the makeup, the lighting, like all
- 24:37of the all of the film making things that aren't on the page
- 24:41are what makes him a good character, though, Like, 'cause
- 24:43as an adult, you go back and watch this movie and you're
- 24:45like, oh, this dude's in the movie for four minutes and 12
- 24:48seconds. And like, yeah, and I feel kind
- 24:51of cheated out of what should have been a character that
- 24:54lasted many films because he is such an he looks different than
- 24:58any character I've ever seen in Star Wars And he's like he
- 25:01sounds so intelligent and his like he has the coolest
- 25:05lightsaber I've ever seen. He is clearly the equal of these
- 25:08guys in terms of fighting with the lightsabers.
- 25:11Like I don't think Lucas wrote a great character here.
- 25:14Brad, I think he's, I think he's the most underwritten of all
- 25:18characters in this movie. But that's the beauty of the
- 25:21character. He has all of those things, and
- 25:24he is a pawn insidious's game. Like, like, that's the beauty of
- 25:29Darth Maul. He represents everything that
- 25:32the Jedi fear. He's terrifying.
- 25:35He's a demon. He has incredible fighting
- 25:37capabilities. He's manipulative.
- 25:40And then at the end of the film, they ask, like, is he the master
- 25:43or is he The Apprentice? And they don't know the answer
- 25:46to that question, but we do, because Lucas has been showing
- 25:51us throughout that he is not the Master and it but it sets up for
- 25:56the characters within the universe this, this ambiguity
- 26:00that's really important to understand why the Jedi do the
- 26:04things that they do. You make a great point.
- 26:06I'm just saying, give me 12 more minutes of him.
- 26:11I don't need him. You know, even if you say, OK,
- 26:13I'm going to kill him at the end of the first movie, though,
- 26:15cool. But like, let's have two more
- 26:17fight scenes. Like let's, you know, let's have
- 26:19three more lines of dialogue. I want to know this guy a little
- 26:22bit before you often. I I don't totally disagree with
- 26:25you. I would I would love to see more
- 26:27Darth Maul fighting. And like you know, Speaking of
- 26:31of fighting I I just saw Dune 2. Fun, fun fact in theatre.
- 26:36You're welcome, Robert. What a great theatre going
- 26:39experience Dune 2 was. Yeah, I saw it in XD.
- 26:43I've I've been told that Dolby is the way to go.
- 26:47So like XD is is Cinemark's answer to IMAX.
- 26:51It is a floor to ceiling screen and it is more widely available
- 26:55than IMAX and it's more affordable.
- 26:56And so I am a huge proponent of seeing stuff in XD.
- 27:01That's just an aside. Sorry.
- 27:02Yes, totally, Which is it's OK we we should do a bonus episode.
- 27:06Just talking about the specs of like movie theaters, I'm sure it
- 27:10would get so many downloads. I bring up Dune 2 to say that
- 27:16there's an incredible fight scene near the end of the movie
- 27:19that I wish we had something like that with Darth Maul.
- 27:23Like like the and not like an extra 1.
- 27:26But I wish that the middle fight scene when they're on Tatooine
- 27:30and Qui Gon fights him for like 30 seconds.
- 27:33I wish that one was a little more developed.
- 27:36I think you could have spent a little more time there and it
- 27:39would have established him even more greatly as this threat.
- 27:43Yeah, totally agree, man. And I realized that we we were
- 27:46supposed to be talking about the characters in general.
- 27:48We probably should talk about the performances that go along
- 27:51with the characters, because otherwise I don't know that
- 27:53we'll ever get through the list of characters.
- 27:55We've we've spent like 12 minutes talking about two
- 27:58characters, Brad, So I don't know.
- 28:00You go ahead and introduce whoever you want to talk about,
- 28:01and let's just work down the list here.
- 28:03I want to talk about Jar Jar Binks.
- 28:05Jar Jar Binks. Ahmed Best another person who
- 28:10just got like true like like Liam Neeson, talks about this in
- 28:15an interview where he's like I spent, you know, however many
- 28:19days on set with him. Liam Neeson literally called his
- 28:22agent and said I'm at Best is the next Eddie Murphy.
- 28:26He is that funny and incredible to be around and just an awesome
- 28:30guy. And yeah, and Liam said he's
- 28:33like and I think his career kind of got ruined because of Star
- 28:37Wars and how he was treated. It absolutely did and and not OK
- 28:41Not OK. Same deal though with with Jake
- 28:45Lloyd man Jar Jar Binks that I will have none of the Jar Jar
- 28:50Binks revisionist history or or reclamation project.
- 28:54He is as bad as advertised, folks.
- 28:56Like, no, he's not the the. Character.
- 28:57He literally is not. The character is horrible.
- 29:01The writing is atrocious. It is.
- 29:05It is like if I could find the most annoying program for my 4
- 29:11year old on Netflix. The writing for that and the
- 29:15repetitive idiotic nature of the noises that come out of that
- 29:20thing's mouth pale in comparison to Jar Jar Binks.
- 29:24Like it is. It's like it is like nails on a
- 29:27chalkboard. The and The thing is like I
- 29:29don't fault the guy at all. I don't think the voice is very
- 29:31good. It doesn't sound super
- 29:32convincing but Lucas trying to do this weird like proto
- 29:37Jamaican Rastafarian thing coupled with like a broken form
- 29:42of English coupled with like all of the Gungans doing the like
- 29:48Brad, it's it's terrible. And they they all go on 45
- 29:53seconds too long. You are you of all people are
- 29:56attuned to when you think a scene is going on too long.
- 29:59Every single time they interact with the Gungans, Brad, it is
- 30:03excruciatingly, horribly paced. That this is this is just a
- 30:09matter of preference, Bob, 'cause that that I think
- 30:11everything you just said is objectively false.
- 30:15I don't. I don't know that you that you
- 30:18can evaluate this film without the lens of a guy that just
- 30:22loves everything. Star Wars, dude.
- 30:23Like it? No, see that?
- 30:25That's where I think you're completely wrong.
- 30:27I I don't just view this as a Star Wars fan watching this
- 30:32movie again. And I I watched it maybe a year
- 30:34and a half ago. So like watching it twice in the
- 30:38in the time of us doing this podcast, I've been able to watch
- 30:42it with an objective lens. And I look back on Jar Jar and I
- 30:47think that there are moments with him that are not great,
- 30:50where he's annoying and frustrating and silly.
- 30:54And the more time I spend with him, the more I think that
- 30:58that's kind of the purpose of the character.
- 31:00Well, it sure it is. And I'm OK with that.
- 31:03Like the the whole the whole thing.
- 31:06With the end of the Ryan Johnson, one can't even think of
- 31:12the name of it right now. It's called The Last Jedi.
- 31:15What a garbage movie. The thing with The Last Jedi
- 31:19that a lot of people loved and were pumped about was like, oh,
- 31:22he's reintroducing this idea that anybody can be a Jedi and
- 31:25that anybody can have an impact on the universe.
- 31:28And then they come, the same people like you, They come and
- 31:32they all over Jar Jar. And I'm like, the entire purpose
- 31:37of Jar Jar is to say that even idiotic bumbling nobodies can
- 31:42have an impact. When they have a good heart, and
- 31:46when they are kind to the world around them, Brad, they can have
- 31:49an impact on the universe. And without Jar Jar, you don't
- 31:54have any of the end of the film. Like, like, listen, I'm not
- 31:58arguing with the function of the character.
- 32:00Like, I know what he's there for.
- 32:01I know what he's supposed to be doing.
- 32:03He's his dialogue is awful, his character is grading and they
- 32:08let his scenes run too long. Like that has nothing to do
- 32:10with. It's not that I misunderstand,
- 32:12and I know he's supposed to be annoying, but you can still
- 32:15convey the the character's annoyance with him without
- 32:19pulling your audience completely out of the movie because of
- 32:21their own frustration with him. Like, I'm not alone here on on
- 32:26thinking that Jar Jar is a hindrance to the film.
- 32:30And I'm not alone in saying that that's just not the case for a
- 32:34lot of people who watch this movie.
- 32:36Sure I don't. You said people like you Bob,
- 32:40praise The Last Jedi and then shut on Jar Jar and and
- 32:44essentially because we don't understand the function of Jar
- 32:46Jar. First of all, this has nothing
- 32:48to do with The Last Jedi. And also like I I get Jar Jar.
- 32:51I just I just don't think it's a well executed character.
- 32:55I think it is. Cool.
- 32:57But you don't have to say that. Like, you don't have to say that
- 33:00I'm too dumb to understand it because of that.
- 33:02Like, I I just, ah, man, we got to work through some characters
- 33:06here because that now I'm starting to get angry.
- 33:08I feel like I have been as generous as possible with your
- 33:14take on this movie versus my take on this movie.
- 33:16I would hope that you can be equally generous when we get to
- 33:19some of the later Star Wars films this season.
- 33:21Because brat, like, you know, I just don't think it's a
- 33:24controversial statement to say, like, yeah, I don't think Jar
- 33:26Jar works and I'm defending the guy who played him because I
- 33:29think Lucas did a poor job writing him.
- 33:33But like I I guess I can't. I can't say that.
- 33:37I think that Jar Jar is a character who has been pooped
- 33:40upon too much, and I will defend him because I don't think he's
- 33:44the best character in this film, but I don't think that he's the
- 33:47worst. Let's do that.
- 33:49Who's the worst character in this film for you, Jake?
- 33:51Anakin. But as a character, not as a
- 33:54performance Like I'm talking like the the writing of the
- 33:57character itself, the dialogue. Within.
- 33:59Within the, yeah, within the world of the movie.
- 34:01Like who is not fleshed out enough who or who is like just
- 34:06an unnecessary character. Like who's the worst at
- 34:09accomplishing what this story wants it to accomplish?
- 34:13Oh, that that's an interesting question.
- 34:16I've not thought about that question before.
- 34:19All right. So we've talked about Ahmed
- 34:21Best. We talked about Jake Lloyd,
- 34:22Justice for both of them. I I agree with you man.
- 34:24They have been crapped on too much.
- 34:26I think it's fair. And I think what I'm trying to
- 34:28say, Brad is like I I said this with the first Star Wars.
- 34:32I don't think George Lucas is good at directing actors because
- 34:35he's worked with some all time great actors and almost without
- 34:39fail the worst performance they've all ever turned in is
- 34:41when they were like performing with George Lucas.
- 34:44And I think it says a heck of a lot about the the charisma of
- 34:47Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher in particular that like they did
- 34:50not fall victim to this. Because even like Mace Windu in
- 34:54this movie though you could tell the directions that he was
- 34:58getting from Lucas, he comes across more, more as an hole
- 35:03than as like a a guy who knows more than he's letting on.
- 35:06Where's, like, Yoda? Still, Yoda's like, oh, this
- 35:09dude knows something, but he's not.
- 35:10A Mace Windu is just kind of a smiffy.
- 35:14And I think, like, how do you mess up having Samuel L Jackson
- 35:18on set? How do you mess up Natalie
- 35:19Portman? Like it, You know?
- 35:22It's just it really surprises me that more people didn't say, you
- 35:26know what, Maybe like some of the problems we have with this
- 35:28movie rest on George Lucas's shoulders and we shouldn't take
- 35:32it out on this 10 year old kid. Sure.
- 35:35Yeah. No.
- 35:35And Bob, I've, I've always said to you that his weakest aspect
- 35:40of being a director is directing actors for sure like like that.
- 35:44I I've always said that that's his issue.
- 35:47I just think that the characters he writes are not as poorly
- 35:52conceived or executed as people think.
- 35:56I think sometimes the acting isn't great, but the characters
- 35:59themselves I actually really think are well done and there's
- 36:03a lot more, there's so much more intent behind the characters and
- 36:09ability to advance the story that I I just I I think Lucas is
- 36:15really good at writing characters.
- 36:16You know what, I I will agree with you that I I I think
- 36:19there's like a confluence of things happening.
- 36:21I think it's the writing is kind of poor for especially for the
- 36:24dialogue with some of these characters.
- 36:25I think the direction is pretty bad and it leads to bad
- 36:28performances. And then the fourth thing is, I
- 36:30think sometimes this movie just could use a little bit of
- 36:33tightening up in the edit and it's not even like I'm not even
- 36:36advocating for a whole scenes to be cut out.
- 36:38It's it's one of those movies where we note sometimes Brad
- 36:41that like there's a two second pause between the time that
- 36:44somebody finishes their line and then they cut to the character.
- 36:46And then you watch the character react and every line with
- 36:50Anakin's mom, whose name I believe is Shmi, but they don't
- 36:53actually say her name. Like I don't think at all in the
- 36:56movie, like Sis is not good in this movie.
- 37:00And I think it's not even necessarily because she's a bad
- 37:03actress, although I would not say she's a great actress.
- 37:06I think it's because every time Qui Gon says something to her,
- 37:09they cut to her and she mulls it over for like 4 seconds and then
- 37:12she reacts and then she says her line.
- 37:15Everything that happens before the pod race on Tatooine is like
- 37:22it. The movie slows down a lot,
- 37:24dude. And I I think it's all these
- 37:26things happening at the same time.
- 37:28But I really do think that Lucas could have been bailed out a
- 37:31little bit if they just kind of tightened up the edit a bit.
- 37:35Sure. Yeah, there's definitely moments
- 37:37in the movie that drag. I I think that to answer your
- 37:42question from before I would say that Shmi is probably the poor
- 37:46the poorest written character that they they don't flesh out
- 37:50her relationship with Anakin enough and the there's not
- 37:55enough connection there like you you need some time to establish
- 38:00that mother son relationship that's so important and and
- 38:03there's moments like I I actually think the the one scene
- 38:06where she kind of shines is when she's telling Quagon about his
- 38:11birth and the the the chosen one nature of it all the Messiah
- 38:16nature. Like I think that that's
- 38:18actually a really solid scene between the two of them.
- 38:20I agree. And also some weird some weird
- 38:23chemistry going. I was like, is Quagon?
- 38:24Oh dude, is Quagon getting some some booty while he's on
- 38:27tattooing? All I have to say is there is so
- 38:31much chemistry between her and Liam Neeson.
- 38:35It's wild. That's like, that's probably the
- 38:38thing that completely flew over my head as a kid that now as an
- 38:41adult I'm like, oh man. Oh, they were boating on this.
- 38:44Yeah, 100%, dude. I mean, listen, it's like a no
- 38:49harm, no foul situation. Like you're not getting her
- 38:51pregnant. The Force gets her pregnant.
- 38:53You're good, man. All right, Brad, I think we're,
- 38:58we're running a little long. Do you want to come back and
- 39:00kind of finish out the main cast and then go into the rest of our
- 39:03stuff, or do you want to knock it out right now real quick?
- 39:06Let Let's knock out just a few more.
- 39:09What are your issues with Natalie Portman?
- 39:11Because I like her a lot in this, There's moments she's not
- 39:14great. I think Natalie Portman has
- 39:15grown into one of the best actresses working today.
- 39:18I think she's been in some incredible movies.
- 39:20She's an Oscar winner. I just don't think she was very
- 39:23good as a kid. And I just watched a movie for
- 39:26the first time about a month ago that she was in called The
- 39:28Professional, which is it's an IMDb Top 250.
- 39:31I just never seen it before. It came out in like 94, I think
- 39:3595. And Natalie Portman's like the
- 39:38star of this movie. And I'm like, oh man, I expected
- 39:41her to be like grown up Natalie Portman in terms of how good she
- 39:44is as a kid actress. And she's just very much had the
- 39:48limitations of being a kid actor.
- 39:50And that might just be me like reading, reading expectations
- 39:53back on to her when she wasn't as good.
- 39:55But this is, this is like that. But then also to your point,
- 39:59let's deliver every line in the most monotone way.
- 40:03And you know, and I just don't understand like the the accent
- 40:06when she's Amidala, like what what are we doing here?
- 40:09Like it's not explained. And I think it takes away from
- 40:12when she's, when she's acting as Padme, very naturalistic, really
- 40:16charming. I loved it a lot.
- 40:19But as soon as she puts that makeup back on, it's like, I do
- 40:21not care about you anymore. Yeah, I I think that that's I
- 40:26can see what Lucas was going for there.
- 40:29Like the the idea of a queen being regal and measured and in
- 40:36control of her emotions and like they very clearly lean into like
- 40:40like Japanese kind of kabuki tropes of like the way she
- 40:46presents herself and her costuming and things like that.
- 40:49And so I think that there is an affect that is presented that
- 40:54that just doesn't totally work. I think within the world of the
- 40:58movie it it works. But I I would agree with you.
- 41:01It's honestly, it's not when she has the makeup on like the very
- 41:06opening scene that she's in, when she talks to the Trade
- 41:09Federation, she has that white makeup with the red dots on the
- 41:11cheeks. I actually think that the the
- 41:14demeanor and affect works really well when she is in full
- 41:18regalia. It's when she's the queen but
- 41:21she's not in full regalia that that I'm kind of like, OK, like
- 41:26give me a little bit of emotion like something and you know I'll
- 41:30go back to the line I said before when she, like, bows and
- 41:32she's like, we are asking you, no begging you.
- 41:36And I'm like, OK, honey, like, sure, when you're talking to
- 41:40your enemies, the Trade Federation don't show any
- 41:42emotion. Totally makes sense when you're
- 41:44begging another military nation to come to your aid.
- 41:49Like, give me, give me a little something, just anything, right?
- 41:54And I think if I can steer us into OK, I don't even think we
- 41:56need to talk about Ewan McGregor because we have, we have talked
- 41:59about him before. He's great.
- 42:00He is absolved of all wrongdoing in this situation.
- 42:03Yes. I'm I'm really disappointed in
- 42:07Qui Gon Jinn and and it it breaks my heart to say it
- 42:11because from a character design standpoint, there are very few
- 42:16people who have ever looked cooler in Star Wars than Liam
- 42:21Neeson, as, like, he is the prototype for like, I want to
- 42:26watch a movie about this Jedi, 'cause he just looks like a guy
- 42:29I want to learn more about. And I think that's my thing is
- 42:31we don't actually learn much about him.
- 42:34He's just like, he's he's the guy that is the seasoned vet.
- 42:37He's like, he's kind of on his way out.
- 42:38He's inching towards retirement it seems like here and like you
- 42:42don't. He's only really there to be,
- 42:44like, utilitarian, to serve the plot, to spout some exposition
- 42:48and to, like, negotiate over, you know, car parts for 1/2
- 42:52hour. And like, I just wish we had
- 42:54more of what's going on inside Qui Gon's head.
- 42:57I love that he wants to, he wants to buck the trends and
- 43:00like, you know, resist the orders of the jet, like the Jedi
- 43:04order. Like, that's really cool.
- 43:06Why? Why are you such a rebel?
- 43:07Tell me more about that. And we just don't get it.
- 43:10And I think that's the most frustrating thing about it.
- 43:13I I don't understand how your brain works, Bob.
- 43:17You don't. I mean, you think we get, you
- 43:18think we get enough fleshed out about him to make his death at
- 43:22the end be, like, as impactful as it could be?
- 43:26Yes. OK, like, like, again, I'm not
- 43:28knocking the performance. I'm not knocking the character
- 43:30design. I just think he's underwritten.
- 43:36Is he underwritten? Question tangential question.
- 43:40What would it take to make you happy, Brad?
- 43:43Like, I feel like I'm giving you a lot here and I'm like, here's
- 43:46my issue with this character. I'm going to elucidate it as
- 43:49clearly as I can. And then you're like, you're
- 43:51just crazy. Like, I don't, I don't know,
- 43:54man. Like, if you don't think he's
- 43:55underwritten, like, what's your reasoning for thinking that he
- 43:59is in fact fully fleshed out? I think I feel so flabbergasted
- 44:05by it is because I've never like the idea of Qui Gon being
- 44:10underwritten is so far from my consciousness.
- 44:14I've never even thought about it.
- 44:18Like it's that just ridiculous to me.
- 44:21I here's the thing with Qui Gon. He is in a lot of ways the main
- 44:28character of this movie. Like we spend most of the movie
- 44:31with him. The like the majority of the
- 44:34film is learning how he thinks about the world.
- 44:38And it's through him that we get the lens of what we think Jedis
- 44:44ought to be like for the rest of the Star Wars universe.
- 44:49Like he has the viewpoint that the most important thing we do
- 44:54is listen to the Force and like he says that constantly
- 44:57throughout the film. And so I once again, I feel
- 45:00like. I feel like you're asking for
- 45:03telling more than showing. Like for me, Qui Gon Jin shows
- 45:08you what it means to be a Jedi. All of the other Jedi in this
- 45:12film. Samuel Jackson, Yoda.
- 45:15Kiadi Mundi Pocoon. Not that I know all their names
- 45:18or anything. I was going to say, are you just
- 45:20making up sounds now? No.
- 45:24No. So the the large skulled
- 45:28conehead Jedi is Ki Adi Mundi. Sure, the one with the gas mask
- 45:34is PLO Coon. OK.
- 45:35Yeah, of course. Anyways.
- 45:37Stands to reason. It stands to reason anyways.
- 45:41All of them show up where on chorus and they're all wrapped
- 45:47up in the politics of the realm. And Qui Gon is held up as this
- 45:51paragon of like he listens to the Force and trusts it to do
- 45:56what what it needs to do. And I and I think that that's
- 46:00like the beautiful thing about Qui Gon And you know I'm going
- 46:06to take the movie out of the the vacuum for a second to say like
- 46:11Duel of the Fates write the song at the end of the film.
- 46:15It's about the fate of Anakin Skywalker and the fate of the
- 46:19Force. And the duel is will Qui Gon
- 46:24live or Will Qui Gon die? Because if Qui Gon doesn't die,
- 46:28he goes on to mentor Anakin in the ways of the force and
- 46:33possibly like doesn't become Darth Vader.
- 46:37And so that I I think that's why for me Qui Gon represents this
- 46:42super impactful character within the universe that is incredibly
- 46:48well acted and I think well written and I so I I guess I
- 46:53don't know is that a cogent defense of why I.
- 46:56Think he's actually a? Really well written character.
- 46:57I I think it is. And I I do still think that
- 47:00sometimes you're confusing like my displeasure with, you know,
- 47:06the lack of dialogue or the lack of monologues that flesh out the
- 47:12characters backs, whatever, with like an inability of me to see
- 47:16the function of the character. Like, I think you're absolutely
- 47:18right. Qui Gon sets the template for
- 47:20what a Jedi should be for the rest of this prequel trilogy.
- 47:24And you're right, overarching like Star Wars.
- 47:27I just wish that we got like, you know, one scene of Obi Wan
- 47:33being like, hey man, like what's what's driving?
- 47:36Why are you insisting on this kid being the chosen one and him
- 47:39being like, you know, it, it sends me back to what I was
- 47:42about. Like just give me something that
- 47:44like, fleshes him out a little bit, 'cause I want, I think it's
- 47:47the highest compliment for me to say I want to spend more time
- 47:50with him. And what pisses me off is that
- 47:53we don't, we don't get that time.
- 47:54And I felt, I don't know, I just didn't feel like it was.
- 47:57His story was completed before the rug got pulled out from
- 48:00under us, both him and Darth Maul give us, give us another
- 48:04half movie with them, kill them in the middle of the second one.
- 48:06It'll be even more shocking, You know what I mean?
- 48:09Sure. Yeah.
- 48:11I, I, I I think that's the beauty of the movie is you don't
- 48:16get everything you want. I I don't know.
- 48:20I think we should. I love.
- 48:21I think we should drink whiskey too.
- 48:23We've been going for 45 minutes, Bob.
- 48:26All right, let's get to it, Brett.
- 48:33All right. So today we are checking out
- 48:34Calumet Farm Single Rack Black Bourbon Whiskey.
- 48:39This is a 14 year old product, Brad, I think it's the first
- 48:42Calumet we've ever had on the podcast.
- 48:44Is that right? Yeah, as far as I know.
- 48:47But who knows? I've drank a lot of whiskey.
- 48:50Yeah, so have I. My friend, I keep seeing Calumet
- 48:53all over the place. It is you know for the most part
- 48:55a premium brand and these like 12/14/15 sixteen year
- 49:00expressions that sit on the top shelf would tell me that they
- 49:02are ultra premium. Now because this is the first
- 49:06time we've had the brand on the show, I'll I'll give a little
- 49:08bit of back story. As far as I know Calumet is a
- 49:11non distilling producer so they release whiskeys but they don't
- 49:15distill them themselves. They partner with a distillery
- 49:18they say that is also in Kentucky.
- 49:20It looks like it's it's called Western Spirits.
- 49:23So they're sourcing this whiskey.
- 49:26It's like super premium small batch.
- 49:28I'm reading something right now that says that this particular
- 49:31product is from a small batch of only 19 barrels.
- 49:35So they're all from a single center cut rack from.
- 49:40And this is a quote, Brad, from the ideal maturation location
- 49:44and conditions inside the Rick house, I mean.
- 49:47Obviously it's ideal, Bob. What else would it be?
- 49:49We picked suboptimal conditions for this limited release.
- 49:53Yeah, so they. I love when people like ask
- 49:55directors or something like, you know, what's a, what's one of
- 49:58your movies you made that you didn't like?
- 50:00And it's like, dude, I like all my movies.
- 50:02All my movies were cut from an ideal condition.
- 50:05Every time they're like, was Timothy Chalonet your first
- 50:07choice? Like what are they going to say?
- 50:09Like, no, I wanted. I wanted Tobey Maguire or
- 50:12something like no, like. It's just it's the same thing in
- 50:14sports Like like, oh, the quarterback, was he your first
- 50:18choice? No, no, he was not sure wasn't.
- 50:21I hope he can go kick rocks. OK, so 19 barrels all from the
- 50:25same rack in the same Rick house.
- 50:27This is clocking in at 96.2 proof.
- 50:30I do not have mashbill, you know, breakdowns here, Brad.
- 50:34So it could be weeded, it could be high rye.
- 50:36I have no idea. Yeah.
- 50:38This is 74% corn, 18% rye, 8% malted bar.
- 50:42Oh thanks man. So it is not weeded and it is
- 50:44high ish rye. Yeah, let's dive in.
- 50:48Yeah, I as I got into the nose on this, it's a decent nose.
- 50:51I got some orange zest, some dark chocolate.
- 50:54The overarching note for me though, or I should say the over
- 50:59oaking note, was oak. There is so much oak on this,
- 51:06and I just I, I, I I am repeating what the whiskey world
- 51:11has said for decades. But the fact that bourbon has to
- 51:15be aged in new white oak, American white oak barrels means
- 51:20that you can't go much past 10 to 12 years without it becoming
- 51:24wildly over oak. And I'm going to say something,
- 51:26my own preference, Brad, through the years.
- 51:29I sometimes think even 10 years is too much.
- 51:32Like, yeah, especially if you're drinking barrel strength
- 51:34whiskey, like if we get a good Knob Creek 10 or 12, I think
- 51:38those are too oaky Most of the time.
- 51:40I just do. But so, like, you know, take
- 51:43your Pappy 23 and do whatever you want with it.
- 51:45But like, that's too freaking long in a barrel for bourbon.
- 51:48It just is. Yeah, no, I I'm with you because
- 51:51this is a heavily oaked nose. I'll give it a 7 1/2.
- 51:56I I think that there's some nice stuff going on here, but I I'm
- 51:59worried I'll. I'll just say that.
- 52:01Yeah, there's some really nice baking spices under here.
- 52:03It's like baked apples a little bit, but the oak is so heavy
- 52:07that it almost turns sour on the nose.
- 52:10It's like it doesn't smell like char or ash.
- 52:14It's just it's almost like that toasted barrel thing that we
- 52:17don't like on a lot of toasted barrel finishes.
- 52:19Brad, so I'm with you. I'm gonna give it a 7 1/2 and I
- 52:23think the flavor is kind of a similar story.
- 52:25Like it's a really, really solid tasting whiskey that just has
- 52:29way too much oak that comes in on the back part of the pallet
- 52:33and into the finish. I I mean, I don't know.
- 52:36Where are you falling on the pallet here?
- 52:39It's it's it's decent. I'd give it a 7 out of 10.
- 52:42There's oak, the the char really comes through for me.
- 52:47There's some vanilla notes. I I almost felt like it was
- 52:49almost like a Sour Patch Kid kind of vibe that I was getting.
- 52:53But there there's not enough complexity for me.
- 52:59Like I can tell that it's a well made whiskey, but it's not a
- 53:04very flavorful whiskey. Yeah.
- 53:06And I I don't know if that's like a a huge insult to say you
- 53:10you did a good job making it and then there was no flavor.
- 53:13But that's kind of where I'm at. The fact that it is a well made
- 53:17whiskey. I'll still give it a 7 out of
- 53:1810. I just, I just want more out of
- 53:23it. It's an underwritten character.
- 53:25It is. If I it is the.
- 53:27Quigon of whiskeys. It looks really cool and I want
- 53:31to learn more about it, but damn it, it under delivers, so it's.
- 53:34Just not enough there. I I actually think that the
- 53:37flavor is a little bit better than the nose, but then I think
- 53:40like OK I gave the nose a 7 1/2 Is this an 8 on the palate?
- 53:44And I don't think it is. So I think I'm still going to
- 53:45give it a 7 1/2. But like you know, dear
- 53:48listener, in your mind, I want you to think of it as like a
- 53:507.51, you know what I mean? All right man, you give it a
- 53:567.51 and the nose of 7.4. Nine.
- 53:58There it is. Yeah.
- 53:59It balances out perfectly. We have brought balance to the
- 54:02force. You were supposed to bring
- 54:04balance to the Force. On the finish I'm I'm kind of
- 54:08surprised because there is that oakiness but then it dissipates
- 54:11really quickly. I think there's a there's a bit
- 54:12of a chest burn it drinks a little bit hotter than 96 proof
- 54:16like I would have thought this was in the like 104105 range.
- 54:20It's really nice. It's a nice finish.
- 54:22I just again, if there's nothing really distinctive about it and
- 54:25there's nothing that screams you should pay triple digits for
- 54:27this. So like, yeah, maybe the value
- 54:31or you know what will be the value score is kind of tainting
- 54:34my my score's here a little bit, but like this is fine.
- 54:38I'm going to give it a 6 1/2 on the finish.
- 54:41Yeah, I I give it a six on the finish it it falls off.
- 54:44It doesn't last as long as you might think, but it is only in
- 54:48the 90s proof, I think 96 proof. It's OK balance wise.
- 54:54I give it A7 like I I think what they're trying to do here, they
- 54:58accomplish. I'm just not super impressed
- 55:01with it. Man, what a perfect pairing for
- 55:04the Star Wars prequels, I tell you.
- 55:06What a terrible pairing for the Star Wars prequels.
- 55:09All right. I think we're pretty much in
- 55:10lockstep. I'm going to give this A7 as
- 55:12well. Why don't you take us to our
- 55:14value score, Brad, What will a bottle of this cost you?
- 55:18Well, I mean at this point it's on their own website, Bob.
- 55:23They have at the bottom of the the stats sheet availability
- 55:27level and the availability level of this is low slash rare.
- 55:35Technically it's an MSRPI believe of $120.00.
- 55:40I would so I don't normally do this Bob, but I'm going to do
- 55:45it. I drank this Calumet earlier
- 55:48today. Right now I am currently
- 55:50drinking a bottle of Barrel Rye private release that we
- 55:54purchased at the Kentucky Berlin Barrel.
- 55:57Yeah, I'll I'll just say this. I think we paid like $85 for
- 56:02that bottle, $90.00. I would pay $120.00 for that
- 56:07bottle. I would never pay $120.00.
- 56:11No, I gave it a 2 out of 10 to be nice, but this is bad value
- 56:17folks. Listen, it's 14 years old.
- 56:19It's 19 barrels. This is like the absolute
- 56:23minimum that this could possibly cost is like 100 bucks, yes.
- 56:28So I think they're overcharging for it slightly.
- 56:32I don't think that it's like astronomically priced, but it is
- 56:36not. A whiskey that tastes like the
- 56:38flavor of this whiskey is not worth $120.00.
- 56:41I'm going to be a little bit kinder than Brad.
- 56:43I'm going to give it a 4 1/2 on the value.
- 56:45But again, that's just because I think it's like in the range
- 56:48that it should be based on the market.
- 56:50Yeah, no, 100%. Like I think Calumet is doing
- 56:53really interesting things here, like to make ultra select.
- 56:59We're only taking 19 barrels and figuring out what we can do with
- 57:02them. Like it's It's interesting the
- 57:05juice is not worth triple digits.
- 57:08I'm coming to a 33 out of 50. Brad, what are you at?
- 57:1229.5. 29 Wow. It's been a minute since we've
- 57:16had one in the 20s, so we're coming to just a 31.25 out of
- 57:2050. Folks, this is what we do here.
- 57:22Like, you know, we're not here to poo poo whiskeys.
- 57:25But I feel very strongly Brad, as a guy who has limited funds
- 57:28and I I believe you do as well. Otherwise you should have been
- 57:31paying for a lot more throughout the course of our friendship
- 57:35that we have a responsibility to tell people when we think
- 57:37something is overpriced or just not even overpriced but just not
- 57:41worth the money in, in terms of just pure flavor.
- 57:45And I think this is one of those, one of those times.
- 57:47I'm I'm very grateful to our friend Wes for sending us a
- 57:50sample of this, but I I would not purchase this for myself.
- 57:53Brad. Wes is incredible.
- 57:55Bob, I have a very important question for you.
- 57:57Yes. Was the $5 bag worth the value
- 58:02that you got? What?
- 58:03What's the value score on that bag?
- 58:04The return on investment of just the story itself was worth at
- 58:08least ten $5 Taco Bell bags. That's.
- 58:13Good. Thanks.
- 58:13I appreciate that. Yeah, let's get back into you
- 58:15calling me an idiot for not understanding Star.
- 58:17Wars. Maybe our friendship is
- 58:19sellable. Maybe.
- 58:27All right, everybody. That was Calumet 14 year single
- 58:31rack Black. A whiskey that I will give a
- 58:34black mark to. Here, here, here, here, here.
- 58:40You know what? I would not give a black mark to
- 58:42Bob. What's that, Brad?
- 58:44Canada's favorite segment 2 Facts and a Falsehood.
- 58:48Brad is going to try to stump your ball. 2 All right and what
- 58:55is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 59:00and A Falsehood is the part of the podcast where Brad presents
- 59:02me with three items as fact about the making of this movie,
- 59:06one of which is a complete lie, and I have to suss out which one
- 59:10that is. I'm a little nervous today, man.
- 59:12You know a lot about this movie, so I think you could very easily
- 59:16just make up some more words about how, you know BLARF in the
- 59:20Hut did a whole bunch of stuff. And I I'm just going to think
- 59:22that it's it's accurate. I don't like, I thought about
- 59:26just letting you have this one. But I got screwed over by our
- 59:29friend Noah Guttel last week who saddled me with two losses on
- 59:33Armageddon. So I went from 8:00 and 2:00 to
- 59:358:00 and. Four, just like that.
- 59:38I'm in a precarious position here, man.
- 59:40Yeah, I'm glad for it. All right, man, hit me with your
- 59:45two facts and a falsehood. Fact number one.
- 59:48In an early version of Luke's script for The Phantom Menace,
- 59:51there was a subplot involving a young Wookiee named Warka, who
- 59:55was intended to be a companion of the young Anakin Skywalker.
- 59:57During his time on Tatooine. However, he was dropped in favor
- 1:00:03of the one and only Jar Jar Binks.
- 1:00:07Fact #2 according to Jake Lloyd. There was a six hour cut of the
- 1:00:11film that was screened for several people before the film
- 1:00:14was relieved, with those who saw it proclaiming it to be mind
- 1:00:18bogglingly good. End Quote Fact #3.
- 1:00:22Ewan McGregor once stated that before filming began he and Liam
- 1:00:26Neeson were taken to a private room where two Lucasfilm
- 1:00:29employees approached them with a long locked wooden box.
- 1:00:33When opened, they saw 20 various lightsaber hilts, and that they
- 1:00:37were allowed to choose one of them to be their character's
- 1:00:40official weapon for the movie. I like how they received their
- 1:00:43lightsabers as if they were like in the Russian mob.
- 1:00:47Like they got taken to a shady backroom.
- 1:00:49Some guy opened a briefcase. Pick your weapon.
- 1:00:54Oh man. Choose it now.
- 1:00:55Duh. OK, I feel like #2 is true.
- 1:01:02I just feel like George Lucas really thought that he had made
- 1:01:05the Great American film here. It was like, you know what?
- 1:01:08Let's do a six hour version that's gonna bring him in.
- 1:01:12So it's either what? I would watch a six hour version
- 1:01:16of this movie. You know what, I might actually
- 1:01:18watch a six hour version of this movie too, 'cause I feel like it
- 1:01:21certainly can't get any slower than the slow parts of this
- 1:01:24movie. You you would probably get your
- 1:01:26your hour and a half that I. Want.
- 1:01:28Yes, exactly. So it's.
- 1:01:32I was watching this with Haley and I told her I was like, I
- 1:01:37could watch like four or five hours of this.
- 1:01:40What does Haley think of this movie?
- 1:01:43Oh, she likes it a lot. Fun fact, Haley really likes Jar
- 1:01:46Jar. She thinks that he is of.
- 1:01:48Course she does. Of course she likes Jar Jar.
- 1:01:54Literally Everything that I like, she thinks sucks.
- 1:01:57And literally everything that I'm like, that's not for me.
- 1:02:00It it's for Haley. We are the Yin and Yang, holding
- 1:02:03the universe together. Usually hyperbolic speech is
- 1:02:06like obviously false, but it is I.
- 1:02:10Don't know for so far off. Oh, man.
- 1:02:15OK, so it's either one or three. Three.
- 1:02:17Sounds pretty true as well. Remind me of what number one was
- 1:02:20again. That there was a a companion for
- 1:02:24Anakin. Called Wiki, Yeah.
- 1:02:26Yeah, but it got dropped for jar jar.
- 1:02:32I don't know, man. These are both really good.
- 1:02:35I think 3 sounds true, so I'm tempted to say one is the
- 1:02:38falsehood, but I don't freaking know, man.
- 1:02:44Yeah, I'll just go with my gut. I'm gonna say one is the
- 1:02:46falsehood here. Bob, you are on a streak of
- 1:02:51trusting your gut. Cause number one is the
- 1:02:53falsehood. Oh.
- 1:02:54Hey, all right, cool. I thought you were going to say
- 1:02:57I'm on a streak of losing. No, you're not.
- 1:03:00You've been nailing it this this season for two facts and a
- 1:03:02falsehood. Here's my here's my reasoning.
- 1:03:05I figured that George Lucas was so bought into Jar Jar Binks
- 1:03:09that there could not have been another version like from the
- 1:03:11get go. He was like, no, no, this is the
- 1:03:14thing that works about this movie.
- 1:03:16Like we have to stick with it. This is the one thing that makes
- 1:03:20sense to me in this crazy messed up universe.
- 1:03:23Misa Love Jar Jar Binks. Here.
- 1:03:26Here's one thing I I will say about Jar Jar.
- 1:03:31I would encourage you to watch George Lucas's interview where
- 1:03:35he talks about the racism complaints about Jar Jar because
- 1:03:42frankly I I think it's ridiculous and.
- 1:03:44The racism complaint is ridiculous.
- 1:03:46Or. Yes.
- 1:03:47Oh, OK. There's there's nothing about
- 1:03:50the character that was meant to be, or I think is racist about
- 1:03:55it, but I'll leave that. Let it be known we're taking a
- 1:03:59principled stand here at film and Whiskey Jar Jar Binks.
- 1:04:02Not. Racist, not racist character.
- 1:04:05This episode has gone so much differently that I would have
- 1:04:09expected it to go. This is my favorite episode
- 1:04:11we've. Ever.
- 1:04:11I'm sure it is, man. Talk about cone headed Jedi's
- 1:04:15and stuff. Can we talk about the pod race,
- 1:04:18please, for the love of God? OK, so this is what I was most
- 1:04:21excited to talk to you about because it is by far the best
- 1:04:23piece of filmmaking in this movie.
- 1:04:25Everything builds to this and I think it builds for even too
- 1:04:28long, but it still pays off. And my question to you, Brad G,
- 1:04:33is now that you have seen in full the film Ben Hur, does it
- 1:04:37make you appreciate the pod race more or does it make you feel a
- 1:04:42little bit like I have now seen how the sausage is made and I
- 1:04:45can tell that Lucas kind of ripped it off a bit here.
- 1:04:49No. OK.
- 1:04:50I think that for a new era and a new generation, this is the Ben
- 1:04:55Hur race. Like, like, yes, there are
- 1:04:59there. It's a very clear through line
- 1:05:04from Ben Hur to The Phantom Menace and I'm a OK with that.
- 1:05:09Like like I I think that's part of the fun of doing this podcast
- 1:05:13is that now I can watch The Phantom Menace and go oh oh Ben
- 1:05:17Hur. That one of the best race scenes
- 1:05:20I've ever seen put to film. Followed up by The Phantom
- 1:05:23Menace 50 years later. One of the best race scenes I've
- 1:05:26seen put to film also on a desert.
- 1:05:29Also great sound design. Great visuals.
- 1:05:32I I'm here for it, man. I thought it was excellent and I
- 1:05:36also thought that it did the best job of covering up how bad
- 1:05:39some of the CGI is in in 1999 and we'll get into talking about
- 1:05:44before we get out of here. Brad, I do want to talk about
- 1:05:46the CGI a little bit, but even at this early stage of fully CG
- 1:05:50characters, Lucas uses it to great effect in this scene
- 1:05:53because you can cover up shoddy CGI if you make it fly by at
- 1:05:58like 300 miles an hour. And I think that that's really
- 1:06:02like the key to the scene is like you put a camera inside
- 1:06:05the, you know, the cockpit, whatever you want to call the
- 1:06:07seat with Jake Lloyd. And there's like minimal CG that
- 1:06:13you focus on. Like it's all there, but it's
- 1:06:15whizzing by so fast that it's like it looks, it looks like a
- 1:06:18real environment. And I think that it's like it is
- 1:06:22so clearly defined like what the geography of this racetrack is
- 1:06:26that at a certain point you're going to have the what are the
- 1:06:29bandits called that shoot at them.
- 1:06:31The the Sand people. Yes, yeah.
- 1:06:34Like, you know, they're gonna come around this curve, they're
- 1:06:36gonna get shot at, they're gonna go through this cave.
- 1:06:37A guy's gonna hit this like, stalagmite thing and blow up
- 1:06:40like it's it's very clearly laid out for you.
- 1:06:43And there's character saying at every point like this is how
- 1:06:46many laps they have to go. This is who's in what place in
- 1:06:49the race. The only complaint, Brad, that I
- 1:06:52have with that whole sequence is like I know that Jedi Knights
- 1:06:56are like stoic people, but qui gon my guy?
- 1:06:59And Shmi can you just like cheer a little?
- 1:07:02Like I have never seen such disinterested spectators at a
- 1:07:05sporting event in my whole life. I mean, I think that Qui Gon
- 1:07:10should be disinterested. That's who the Jedi are.
- 1:07:13I think that Shmi does a decent job of showing emotion.
- 1:07:18Like, like, there's a few moments where she kind of gasps
- 1:07:20and grabs her mouth, and I can easily see a world where a
- 1:07:24mother isn't, like, weeping in fear.
- 1:07:26She's, like, shocked in fear. But but I'm.
- 1:07:30I'm with you. She doesn't show much emotion.
- 1:07:32Qui Gon's off the hook. He he's not supposed to show
- 1:07:35emotion. Listen, Qui Gon is allowed to
- 1:07:38bet some money on the side on the Celtics to win the title and
- 1:07:42stuff like like just let him say a fan.
- 1:07:44Of something? Qui Gon was spending all of his
- 1:07:46emotion on secret glances between him and SH me.
- 1:07:50Alright man, he didn't have any. What's?
- 1:07:52Going on underneath that robe. That's my question.
- 1:07:56All right, so we have we have touched lightsaber.
- 1:07:59Nope. Nope.
- 1:07:59Nope. Nope, Nope, Nope, Nope.
- 1:08:02We have touched on the pod race. We need to talk in a little bit.
- 1:08:05Go ahead. Hold on, pod.
- 1:08:07Race, Yeah. The writing of the pod race is
- 1:08:09incredible. Yeah, I just said that.
- 1:08:12No, but but even just like the structure of it, right?
- 1:08:16Lap #1, Anakin gets stuck and we follow everybody else and learn
- 1:08:21the dangers of the course. Lap #2, we spend the whole time
- 1:08:26between Sebulba destroying his opponents and Anakin, you know,
- 1:08:31showing off how skilled he is and, you know, proving all the
- 1:08:35things that were said about him, that he's this great,
- 1:08:39oppression, precocious pod racer.
- 1:08:42And then lap three is the showdown, and it's just
- 1:08:46incredible writing of an action scene.
- 1:08:49And I think that's that's George Lucas for me like like he has
- 1:08:55lots of flaws. He has a lot of places where
- 1:08:57he's like AC to AB Plus director.
- 1:09:02But his action sequences, I think he is a legendary all time
- 1:09:08Hall of Fame director and the pod races that in this film.
- 1:09:12For sure. Like no notes on that man.
- 1:09:16OK I do want to talk CGI for a second because the I don't I
- 1:09:20feel like I've said this, I'm I am a nerd and I'm very weird and
- 1:09:23I acknowledge this. But like I feel like every
- 1:09:26digital CGI house has their kind of house style of like when
- 1:09:32you're watching Lord of the Rings like you know what works
- 1:09:34really well from weta digital, you know what they're good at.
- 1:09:37Like the the the translucency of the skin on Golem is like next
- 1:09:42level stuff that no one else was doing.
- 1:09:44When you watch like Pixar, you know what Pixar is really good
- 1:09:47at? Like even from the get go in
- 1:09:49toy. Story Piper Short.
- 1:09:50Oh yeah, photo realistic. But like, even even in the
- 1:09:54original Toy Story where the humans look horrifying, like
- 1:09:57their ability to replicate textures and wood grains and
- 1:10:00things like that, it's it's next level.
- 1:10:02Industrial Light and magic. There has always been something
- 1:10:05weird to me about their CGI. It never ever fully works for me
- 1:10:09and like the the things just seem rubbery and they don't seem
- 1:10:14like they're actually like part of the environment.
- 1:10:16They feel like they're slapped in front like they have a
- 1:10:18completed shot and instead of making the the thing seem like
- 1:10:21it's a part of the depth of the shot it just seems like they
- 1:10:24held a puppet up in front of it and like this doesn't.
- 1:10:27It doesn't always work for me but what I will say Brad in the
- 1:10:31in favor of this movie is that Lucas was doing a lot of on
- 1:10:37location shooting and and you know by episode 3 you've got
- 1:10:43environments that are like it's just a guy on a blue screen and
- 1:10:45everything is CGI. In this movie in particular,
- 1:10:48especially like that final battle scene where you've got
- 1:10:50like the Droid army kind of coming over the hill.
- 1:10:53It's like, it sounds stupid to be like, oh, that's a real hill,
- 1:10:56but I love the way that the the camera shots are designed to
- 1:11:02take place in a real world setting and then the CGI is
- 1:11:06placed into that real world setting instead of just we're
- 1:11:09going to construct everything inside of a computer.
- 1:11:11Because I think this movie could look a hell of a lot worse than
- 1:11:14it does if George was using his Episode 3 mindset here.
- 1:11:20Sure. I I mean, I'll say this about
- 1:11:23the CGI. What year did Shrek come out?
- 1:11:272001, 2002. Tell me that this doesn't look
- 1:11:3110 times better than Shrek CGI. Like, yeah, although if you put
- 1:11:36Shrek in this movie, he would probably be a believable
- 1:11:39character on on Naboo. Shut up, Bob.
- 1:11:43Get the heck out of here. Here's here's the deal with the
- 1:11:46CG I I think that the advancement of technology has
- 1:11:51done this movie no favors. I think that in 1999 it looked
- 1:11:56pretty solid. I'm not going to say it was like
- 1:11:59great, but I think it looked pretty good in 99 and it
- 1:12:03advanced the medium of CGI in in important ways.
- 1:12:09And I that I say that as somebody who hates CG.
- 1:12:13I I I think it's garbage. I think in this movie it's OK.
- 1:12:18I think in the second and third film it gets kind of ridiculous.
- 1:12:22And I think for the same reason that you said like there's you
- 1:12:24can still tell there's a tactile nature to a lot of this movie
- 1:12:29that's really beautiful. And.
- 1:12:31And I think that the other reason I'm a kind of OK with the
- 1:12:34CGI is that so many of the wide shots of Naboo and Tatooine and
- 1:12:39Coruscant are just gorgeous. Like like they are immaculately
- 1:12:46beautiful shots of these planets.
- 1:12:49And it and it sets up just this really cool world that Lucas is
- 1:12:54inhabiting with all these weird creatures.
- 1:12:57And I think that 4 KTVS and even like Blu rays to a point.
- 1:13:03Like they don't do the aging of this film any favors.
- 1:13:09I think that if you were watching this on Avhs or an
- 1:13:12early DVD in like 2001, I don't think your complaints about the
- 1:13:16CGI would be as pronounced. All right, cool.
- 1:13:21And that's not me saying that you like you're wrong.
- 1:13:23I I just think that. No, no, no.
- 1:13:24I'm with. I'm with you, man.
- 1:13:25Yeah, I mean, listen, Jurassic Park looked years ahead of its
- 1:13:29time on DVD and VHS, and now on 4K.
- 1:13:32It's like, Oh yeah, like this is starting to finally look old,
- 1:13:35You know what I mean? Yeah, yeah, 100%.
- 1:13:38But also Jurassic. And I'm saying this during a
- 1:13:42Star Wars review, Bob, Jurassic Park is a perfect.
- 1:13:45It's a perfect movie. It's so good.
- 1:13:48All right, Brad, it is time for us to get to our last segment of
- 1:13:51the day, which we call. Let's make it a double.
- 1:13:54We're near the end of the episodes of Things Listening to
- 1:13:57the Film and Whiskey show. Let's favor another film with
- 1:14:00this one, even if it's struggling.
- 1:14:01It's a final segment of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:14:04Let's make it a double is the part of the podcast where we
- 1:14:07pick a movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect
- 1:14:10double feature. Brad, would you like to go first
- 1:14:12or do you want me to go first? Bob, of all the weeks, I I
- 1:14:17literally didn't even know that we did this segment.
- 1:14:20Like that's how unprepared I am. Well, it it's really funny that
- 1:14:24you finally decided to go to a movie and see Dune because I am
- 1:14:28going to pair this movie with the first Dune, not the second
- 1:14:31one. I think it would be unfair to
- 1:14:32pair it with the second one because I think the first Dune
- 1:14:34is significantly more flawed than Dune 2, agreed.
- 1:14:38I just, you know, when I'm thinking about world building
- 1:14:41sci-fi epics that take place mostly on sand, it really limits
- 1:14:47my choices here. But I think that you could do a
- 1:14:50heck of a lot worse than looking at what Lucas built in his.
- 1:14:57And I don't mean this in a bad way.
- 1:14:58It's a very kid friendly, ultimately optimistic, bright,
- 1:15:04pretty happy movie versus like what Denis Villeneuve is doing
- 1:15:08with Dune, which is a huge downer of a series.
- 1:15:11Like do you know what I mean? And I think it'd be like a fun
- 1:15:14pairing in that, like you can see what audiences wanted in
- 1:15:171999 and what they responded to versus what they responded to in
- 1:15:212019 or whenever the hell Dune came out.
- 1:15:23So yeah, man, that's my pick. Dune One and Star Wars One.
- 1:15:28Yeah, I I think that's actually a great pick, Bob.
- 1:15:30I am gonna jump back about five years from The Phantom Menace,
- 1:15:36and I'm going to pick a movie that I think thematically and
- 1:15:41stylistically feels somewhat similar in the sense of
- 1:15:44adventure and fun that it brings.
- 1:15:47I'm going to pick 1994's Stargate.
- 1:15:52I think that that would be a really, oh, such a fun movie.
- 1:15:57I think it would be a really fun evening of like 90s cinema to
- 1:16:01just sit down and enjoy Stargate and Star Wars.
- 1:16:06Brad, I have AI have a quiz, a pop quiz for you.
- 1:16:10How many Oscars do you think that Episode One was nominated
- 1:16:15for? Oh, I am going to guess.
- 1:16:20Can I can I go like through a few categories?
- 1:16:22Sure. Maybe this is a reach, maybe
- 1:16:28best supporting actor for for Liam Neeson.
- 1:16:32Partially. I guess that because Liam's like
- 1:16:34established on the scene, I'm guessing best visual effects,
- 1:16:39best sound effects or sound design.
- 1:16:42Is it? Is it sound design?
- 1:16:43Yeah, they actually had two categories for sound back then.
- 1:16:46There was sound effects editing and then there was just best
- 1:16:49sound. Oh, I would.
- 1:16:52I would guess they'd be nominated for both.
- 1:16:55I don't know. We'll say two thinking through
- 1:16:58that. I'm guessing like 4 to 6
- 1:17:00something in that range. 33 And it went over 3, Brad, because it
- 1:17:06was going up against a little movie that used the CGI
- 1:17:09significantly better called The Matrix.
- 1:17:13The Matrix won for Best Visual Effects, it won for Best Sound,
- 1:17:16and it won for Best Sound Effects Editing.
- 1:17:18So it lost to the same movie in all three categories.
- 1:17:21See, I I will say a an avid 10 out of 10 love.
- 1:17:27Like, I think that The Matrix might be the best science
- 1:17:31fiction movie of all time. I I love that movie.
- 1:17:35I don't actually qualify Star Wars a science fiction, but
- 1:17:39that's just me being a genreist. I would say loving The Matrix.
- 1:17:44I think that the sound design, whatever the the more technical
- 1:17:48version of sound is, I think that I think that Star Wars is
- 1:17:52better. There's just so much beauty to
- 1:17:57the sound design in this film. Like even beyond the pod race,
- 1:18:01which I think is a master class in sound design.
- 1:18:03There's just so many incredible moments of of lightsabers and
- 1:18:09the the sounds of the the blasters on the ships.
- 1:18:14Ah man, yeah, the sound design in this is better than the
- 1:18:17Matrix overall score. Maybe not.
- 1:18:20But how did you got to do all the fates, Bob?
- 1:18:24You do have Duel of the Fates, Brad.
- 1:18:26That's true. 99 What a year for movies.
- 1:18:28I'm going to run down a couple here, Brad.
- 1:18:30American Beauty wins Best Picture, also competing in Best
- 1:18:34Picture. You've got The Cider House
- 1:18:35Rules, Green Mile, The Insider and The 6th Sense.
- 1:18:40You've got movies such as Let's go through some of these.
- 1:18:43Hilary Swank wins her Oscar for Boys Don't Cry.
- 1:18:46Angelina Jolie wins Best Supporting Actress for a Girl
- 1:18:48Interrupted. Being John Malkovich comes out
- 1:18:51this year, Paul Thomas Anderson's Magnolia.
- 1:18:54You've got let's see what else Disney comes out with Tarzan
- 1:18:58this year. It's just a really, really great
- 1:19:00year. Fight Club comes out this year.
- 1:19:02What a great year for movies, man.
- 1:19:04Your your favorite film of the. Year.
- 1:19:05My favorite film. You even have a a nomination
- 1:19:08here for Best Makeup for the second Austin Powers movie and a
- 1:19:13Best Sound nomination for The Mummy, which I freaking rock
- 1:19:16with, man, I love The Mummy. I have not seen any of the the
- 1:19:22Austin Powers movies and I have not seen The Mummy.
- 1:19:24Oh man, not. No wonder why you like this
- 1:19:26movie so much. Brad, we've got to expose you to
- 1:19:30good cinema here. Brad, it's time for final
- 1:19:32scores. I'm going to go first because
- 1:19:34you're going to hate me. I told you this the other day
- 1:19:36though. Like I told you, I was falling
- 1:19:38somewhere between A5 and A6 on this movie and it is an
- 1:19:41infuriating movie to score because I don't dislike it.
- 1:19:45But there are just so many stretches of this movie that I
- 1:19:48think are just actively bad, coupled with many sequences of
- 1:19:53some of the best sci-fi and action film making I have ever
- 1:19:56seen and it just is is just thrown together in a pot and
- 1:20:01makes the most weird tasting Stew I've ever encountered.
- 1:20:05It's like man, I'm going to give it AI want to say 5 1/2.
- 1:20:12I'm not going to give it a 5 1/2, and the only reason why is
- 1:20:14because we also gave. Back to the Future five and A
- 1:20:17halfs across the board. And I don't want, I don't want
- 1:20:21to insinuate that I like this movie on the same level as that.
- 1:20:24So I'm going to give it a six out of 10, but no higher.
- 1:20:31That's disappointing. I think you gave the original
- 1:20:33Star Wars like a 7 out of 10, which is bonkers.
- 1:20:38I'm at a nine out of 10 Bob. I think that this film has so
- 1:20:43much going for it. There's so much charm if you
- 1:20:47want to subscribe to like auteur theory.
- 1:20:50I think that Lucas is doing exactly what he wants to do here
- 1:20:54to set up the rest of the series.
- 1:20:56Like so many fans were disappointed with The Phantom
- 1:21:01Menace because it featured a child, Anakin.
- 1:21:05And I think that when you look at the the series as a whole, it
- 1:21:09it works beautifully because you have that innocence and that
- 1:21:14childlike nature stamped in your memory.
- 1:21:17Because who could ever forget Jake Lloyd saying Yippee right
- 1:21:22Like it's stamped in your memory?
- 1:21:23Pod racing. Oh man.
- 1:21:26I love it, Yeah, I love it. I don't even care that he says
- 1:21:28that. I'm like, good for you, man.
- 1:21:33I I think that overall, Lucas did exactly what he wanted to
- 1:21:37hear. The sound design is incredible.
- 1:21:39The the world's that you visit are gorgeous and beautiful.
- 1:21:44The the even just the the introduction of the Gungans and
- 1:21:48the Naboo is like every other planet you've ever been to.
- 1:21:52Is just like aliens and humans coexisting and and you don't
- 1:21:57really know, like are any of these natives to the world or
- 1:22:01are they just all transplants like here for the first time you
- 1:22:05get like, no, the Naboo are from here and the Gungans are from
- 1:22:08here and they've coexisted, you know, very tenuously for
- 1:22:12centuries and you feel that history.
- 1:22:16There's just so much going on here that's just wonderful and
- 1:22:20fun and I love it. And it's a nine out of 10.
- 1:22:23All right folks, there you have it.
- 1:22:25Brad has completely gone off the rails and given this movie a
- 1:22:27nine out of 10. I'm giving it a six out of 10
- 1:22:31and I really regret not giving it the five and a half that it
- 1:22:34deserved. So we are coming to a 7.5 on
- 1:22:37average, but we'd like to know what you think.
- 1:22:39Where are you landing on The Phantom Menace 25 years after
- 1:22:43its release? You can let us know on all of
- 1:22:46our social media platforms, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram,
- 1:22:50Tiktok or YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:22:54Or you can give us a follow on Discord.
- 1:22:56We are on there every single day talking to you guys, the fans of
- 1:22:59the Film and Whiskey Podcast. So if you'd like to join the
- 1:23:01conversation, you can find a link at the end of every single
- 1:23:04one of our show notes. Next week Brad, a film that we
- 1:23:07will be united in our hatred for.
- 1:23:09I'm predicting the truly God awful Ron Howard film, How the
- 1:23:13Grinch Stole Christmas. We're watching this literally
- 1:23:17the week of Easter, so we are way off in our timing on this
- 1:23:20one, but there's no time like the present to review whatever
- 1:23:25this is Brad, so join us next week for that.
- 1:23:28But until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:23:31And we'll see you next time.