Latest / The Vegan Report / My Call For Action.
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan and today's episode will be a concentrated
- 0:09version of this podcast.
- 0:12I have gathered some of the highlights of previous interviews in one episode just for
- 0:18you.
- 0:19My goal was to capture the spirit of the show, this mission I gave myself to inspire you
- 0:26to take action in the animal rights struggle, to do some good.
- 0:33Making this podcast also allowed me to reflect back on conversations I had, think of all
- 0:40the things I learned and remember how those episodes came about.
- 0:45You will find a link to all the interviews featured in this episode in the description
- 0:51below.
- 0:52Plus, this is a great goodbye episode.
- 0:56Don't worry, the show will go on by goodbye, I simply meant I'm taking a summer break
- 1:02before coming back in August with brand new episodes.
- 1:07During this break, I will be recording an array of fascinating, thought-provoking and
- 1:14frontier-breaking episodes.
- 1:16I will be running after the unreported stories and hopefully, hopefully you will still be
- 1:23here in August to listen and continue this adventure with me.
- 1:29Having said that, let's now begin with our first segment of interviews going over the
- 1:35theme of factory farming.
- 1:38You will first hear Colin, who was a worker of this industry before becoming vegan, Kennedy,
- 1:45who works for Farm Transition Academy, a non-profit helping farmers abandon animal expertise and
- 1:53basically change their business model.
- 1:55Then Natalie, who told her story of breaking in a farm located just an hour drive from
- 2:02where I am right now.
- 2:05And the great Dr. Fitzgerald, who has deeply taught and studied animal expertise.
- 2:11And of course, my good friend Varun, who is following the footsteps of Dr. Fitzgerald
- 2:17in one of the most hostile universities for animal rights activists.
- 2:23You know, as a kid when I worked on a ranch, I had never had as much opportunity to work
- 2:28in like a slaughterhouse.
- 2:31But now I had to.
- 2:33Now I had to do, you know, and I remember taking like a carcass evaluation course and
- 2:38that course was the beginning of the week you see the animal, you as a live, you palpate,
- 2:45you know, the fat on its back, you see its muscles, you see its skin, you see all this,
- 2:51you give it a grade.
- 2:52And then at the end of the week, they slaughter it and you have the carcass and then you have
- 2:58to evaluate the carcass.
- 2:59And it was very strange seeing this animal and it's just whatever.
- 3:04And then the end of the week you see it's dead carcass.
- 3:07And but the thing that really, really drove me kind of the very final thing was I had
- 3:15been working for a dairy on a dairy farm.
- 3:20I had been working with a veterinarian, a large animal veterinarian, and we were doing,
- 3:25we were mostly doing animal reproduction work for cows.
- 3:29But part of that, we also had to go do regular veterinary work.
- 3:34And we had this dairy cow that, you know, she was very, very sweet.
- 3:42She was great.
- 3:43But she was down on the floor and she wasn't walking.
- 3:48Legally in the United States, you can't send an animal to slaughter if it's not able to
- 3:51stand up on its own weight.
- 3:55So essentially you have 800 pounds, a thousand pounds of wasted money.
- 4:03So we essentially, we gave it steroids, hoping that it would get up and go on living and
- 4:11walking.
- 4:14That didn't happen.
- 4:15We came back the next day and it was still there.
- 4:18And so my boss essentially had me euthanize it and euthanasia with livestock.
- 4:28It's not, you know, a hundred dollars of barbiturates and chemicals and the peaceful, like quiet
- 4:35thing.
- 4:36You shoot it in the back of the head.
- 4:39And I remember shooting it in the back of the head and it just, it really, really, it
- 4:51really got to me because I was sitting there, you know, for many years saying, you know,
- 4:57I wanted to help animals.
- 4:58I wanted to be, I really cared about animal husbandry.
- 5:01I really love these animals.
- 5:02I always consider myself an animal lover.
- 5:05And yet here I am doing this.
- 5:08I don't want to contribute this to this anymore.
- 5:10I don't want to give any more of my money to this.
- 5:14Even if it's, you know, dairy cows, chickens, backyard eggs, any of it.
- 5:21So from there I ended up going vegan because I just, I couldn't see myself thinking of
- 5:27myself as an animal lover and still contributing in this way.
- 5:32So yeah, it was, it was a very, very drastic change.
- 5:42It's been certainly very interesting.
- 5:45You know, when I talk to people from my past, you know, I'll talk to family and they're
- 5:51kind of very taken aback, you know, and they just, they're not aggressive against it.
- 5:57You know, they're not, you know, I don't get as much pushback as you would expect.
- 6:03But you, but I do get a lot of the, you know, oh, I could just never do that.
- 6:07I love bacon and cheese too much.
- 6:09So I try and always have just an honest, genuine conversation with them.
- 6:13Why do you think others who work in that industry have not jumped out of the, this nightmare,
- 6:22those nightmare factories and those practices?
- 6:26Why are they still doing what they're doing?
- 6:31Even though they might have, you know, slaughtered innocent creatures like that cow.
- 6:40Do you have any reflection on that?
- 6:43Yeah.
- 6:44I mean, ultimately a lot of it does.
- 6:48Money makes the world go round.
- 6:50I think that's a huge contributing factor.
- 6:53As I mentioned earlier, you have, you know, when I was talking about people who work in
- 6:59these slaughterhouses, oftentimes they are, you know, without going up and asking them
- 7:05for, you know, legal documentation.
- 7:07They're often migrant workers who are oftentimes illegally here with, you know, wrong information.
- 7:15These are the facilities that are choosing to employ them.
- 7:18The people working there are often going to, they have to make a decision.
- 7:24Do I feed my family with a paycheck?
- 7:25Do I get a paycheck?
- 7:26Do I feed them?
- 7:28Or do I work in this industry?
- 7:31They're often going to choose to work in this industry because they have family at home
- 7:35to feed.
- 7:36They have bills to pay.
- 7:38And these are the facilities where they can get jobs at.
- 7:42You know, I was even talking about, you know, there was underage workers, 13 and 14 year
- 7:47old workers at the plant in Nebraska that, you know, they recently came under fire.
- 7:5313 and 14 year olds don't want to work a night shift at a slaughterhouse cleaning.
- 8:00They need money though.
- 8:01People need to pay bills.
- 8:02So these kids are often forced into that type of thing.
- 8:08You know, and even for a lot of the other players in the industry, you know, the regular
- 8:15rancher who's just raising 20 cows, he's not working in the slaughterhouse.
- 8:21It is a very, you know, meat is a very cultural thing.
- 8:24Very, very ingrained in our society.
- 8:30So it's very, very hard for people to give up that aspect of their life.
- 8:36Even for me personally, like I think about like fish and hunting, you know, that's, I
- 8:41love fishing.
- 8:44I loved going out with my buddies on, you know, the canoe and we would sit out there
- 8:49and fish and, you know, have a great time.
- 8:53And it was just awesome.
- 8:56And you know, but that is an activity like I do miss.
- 9:00It's not even, it's not the eating the fish.
- 9:02It's just an activity.
- 9:03I admit it was so, you know, part of my culture and just part of who I am.
- 9:09Even to this day, you know, I, I still, you know, I don't hunt, but I still go and I end
- 9:18up, I still do like long range rifle shooting and I'll oftentimes talk with some of these
- 9:22people who do hunt.
- 9:24And you can tell that them going and taking their son hunting, that's a bonding experience
- 9:28that they have, you know, their dad took them hunting.
- 9:31So they want to take their son's hunting.
- 9:34It's just a very cultural thing to them.
- 9:38And it's very, very hard for them to break those habits.
- 9:43But you know, as I said, it's a slow process.
- 9:48You're seeing more and more people moving away from animal agriculture and eating animals
- 9:54to plant-based diets, but it's going to take time.
- 10:00And I do see that the, I do believe that the animal agriculture industry is going to start
- 10:05shrinking significantly in the future.
- 10:11Those are, you know, not these living, breathing, sentient beings that we know them to be within
- 10:18the agriculture industry.
- 10:20Their lives are just completely reduced to nothing as if they are nothing more than livestock,
- 10:27quote unquote.
- 10:28That's where that term comes from, living stock on a shelf.
- 10:31And it's such, you know, a very interesting thing when you look into it, because those
- 10:36things are perpetuated and that kind of science allows farmers to continue to do the work
- 10:42that they do because they're not really seen as animals with personalities as we know them
- 10:47to be.
- 10:48When you're looking at how these animals are treated within the animal agriculture industry,
- 10:52they're taught to be no more than a number.
- 10:54They're taught to be no more than a face behind a barbed wire or within a cage.
- 10:59And so that autonomy, that personality is completely stripped away from each of them.
- 11:04And another thing as well is that for a lot of these farmers, they are bringing these
- 11:07animals into the world with forcible impregnation.
- 11:10So they kind of see that as I'm bringing these animals into this world and I'm taking them
- 11:14out, this is part of my job.
- 11:16They have no autonomy.
- 11:18So those are just little things that really do create a very upsetting implication on
- 11:25the lives of these animals and on the lives of animal rights activists as well, because
- 11:30their lives are just being completely erased as nothing more than a number or nothing more
- 11:33than a package label.
- 11:36I attend the University of Guelph.
- 11:38It's the most animal agriculture heavy university I can think of.
- 11:42On my first day, my first class was in animal science building and I'm like, my program's
- 11:46in sociology, why on earth have I, why am I in this building?
- 11:50And when it comes to funding, I guess this goes away from political more towards kind
- 11:55of educational, less social level.
- 11:57I'm going to be, there's more scholarships available.
- 11:59There's more funding opportunities available for the animal agriculture sciences.
- 12:05And these projects, they're not about the rights and justice of animals.
- 12:09It's about their welfare in regards to how can we treat them as an object in the nicest
- 12:13way possible?
- 12:14They're essentially trying to find a way to do something inherently wrong in the most
- 12:17nice compassionate way, which is a fundamental contradiction.
- 12:22If you were to go, anyone were to go to the University of Guelph website right now and
- 12:25look at what their graduate students are doing.
- 12:27I don't think they should be harassed or anything like that.
- 12:29I don't want anyone listening to this to go harass them.
- 12:30I'd love for people to email them and ask the students, hey, so how do you do this to
- 12:34the animal ethically with concern for the animal when you don't need to have those conversations
- 12:39going?
- 12:40But like there's more resources for these, for these people that essentially mess up
- 12:43animals.
- 12:44So, and that leads like the fourth kind of angle, like economically, this ties in with
- 12:50school, but there's more money invested into big dairy, big beef, big chicken, big whatever
- 12:56animal agriculture related.
- 12:58The resources they have to fight this battle is a lot more than anyone like myself would
- 13:03have, anyone like partners of this movement, like Animal Justice, which is one of Canada's
- 13:08premier legal advocacy groups for animals, PETA, Mercy for Animals, you name it.
- 13:15No one has as much resources as the big animal agriculture industries.
- 13:19It's in human culture, almost in every culture in the world.
- 13:22You know what?
- 13:23No, I'm going to say confidently, in every culture in the human world, in history, to
- 13:28mess up animals.
- 13:29And I just say mess up as another way for violence.
- 13:30I just, I get tired of saying the same thing, but there is.
- 13:35What is it like to, to be an animal rights activist in a university devoted to serving
- 13:42the animal industry?
- 13:43I feel like you must feel like an anomaly in this college community.
- 13:54First and foremost, I feel like a piece of shit.
- 13:56I don't know how to say that more politely because if I had stayed at the University
- 14:03of Windsor, I feel like I would have been doing better work just because I'm not a part
- 14:06of a university that's so frankly disgusting in my mind when it comes to supporting these
- 14:11kinds of things.
- 14:12But at the same time, it's important that I acknowledge I am at the University of Guelph,
- 14:16which is very animal agriculture heavy, but it's got to start somewhere.
- 14:22If there's no one else who is focusing on ways to address animal justice, I don't think
- 14:28I'm the first, though I hope I'm not the last.
- 14:32And wherever they are, whichever pockets of society that you're in where you're dealing
- 14:38with a very, very uphill battle, I'm not saying go for the hardest thing, but don't shy away
- 14:44from that challenge as much.
- 14:45It needs to happen because I've been able to raise questions and concerns and make comments
- 14:50that no one else is going to think about in the sociology department at my university.
- 14:54And if I wasn't there, maybe someone does, maybe someone doesn't, we don't know, but
- 14:57we do know that because I am there right now, I can raise those.
- 15:01But I try not to be too hard on myself there.
- 15:04It is hard not to be hard on yourself, though.
- 15:07But in regards to how I feel generally about it, like it sucks because a lot of my cohort,
- 15:15my peers, a lot of initiatives on campus are about making sure we don't harm humans.
- 15:20We don't harm people or the environment based on any arbitrary social aspect, you know,
- 15:26race, gender, class, whatever it might be.
- 15:28And I'm all about that.
- 15:30I'm all about that.
- 15:32It very rarely extends to animals.
- 15:33And when it does, it's superficial, it comes in the form of animal welfare, which you're
- 15:38still hurting them.
- 15:39And it's just, disheartening is probably the most appropriate word.
- 15:44Frustrating and disheartening.
- 15:47All I knew was this was a peaceful action.
- 15:52And that I was going to be driving there, you know, with a biosecurity suit and with
- 15:57these people that I had met.
- 16:00We had one meeting to talk about it, where we got the equipment that we needed for the
- 16:07day.
- 16:09And then we did it.
- 16:10And yeah.
- 16:11So let's talk about the details, the logistics of going there.
- 16:19What happened on that fateful day?
- 16:23I think I woke up at two in the morning, if you can call that waking up.
- 16:27I don't even know if I slept.
- 16:28I can't remember, but I woke up and I got dressed and I walked to this park.
- 16:38We were also supposed to meet at Park Lafontaine at 2.30, I think in the morning.
- 16:45And so we met there.
- 16:46There were a number of cars already and we divided ourselves into the cars so that we
- 16:52could carpool to Saint Hyacinth, or Saint Hyacinth in English, which is where the farm
- 17:00was.
- 17:01We didn't know where we were going, only the drivers knew where we were going.
- 17:04It was still pitch black when I was walking to this park to get to the other people.
- 17:11And I remember thinking to myself, what am I doing?
- 17:13This is crazy.
- 17:15Waking up early in the morning to do this, I have no idea what I'm walking into.
- 17:19All I know is that it's a peaceful action and I feel like this is important and I'm
- 17:26going to do this.
- 17:27But I was scared and it felt mind boggling that I was walking into this situation.
- 17:36So then we drive there, we leave at 3 a.m., we get there at 4.
- 17:40And again, it's still pitch dark when we get there.
- 17:42It's the middle of nowhere countryside farmland.
- 17:45There are no streetlights.
- 17:46It is just black.
- 17:47Sorry to interject, Nathalie.
- 17:50Saint-Jacent is actually the city where you can find one of the biggest vet hospitals
- 17:59for farm animals in Quebec, which I find interesting that this is happening where there's this
- 18:08big vet hospital and vet school to, I think, most veterinarians in Quebec who go into the
- 18:16agribusiness to get their training in Saint-Jacent.
- 18:20Really?
- 18:21I didn't even know that.
- 18:23I've never heard that before.
- 18:25I think so, yeah.
- 18:27Yeah, it's a strange contradiction of veterinary practice for most people that are veterinarians
- 18:36because most people eat animals and then the school is in a place where they're exploiting
- 18:39so many animals.
- 18:40I mean, the whole society is just so contradictory, isn't it?
- 18:43But that's an interesting fact I didn't know about.
- 18:45Wow.
- 18:46So, we arrived there in the dark and I'm sitting in the back of this car and the people that
- 18:57I'm in the car with, they leave to go to another car.
- 18:59I don't remember why.
- 19:00So, I'm sitting there in the back and I put on my biosecurity suit and I'm given these
- 19:09little booties to put on my feet.
- 19:12By the way, I'm also wearing a diaper.
- 19:15We're all wearing diapers because there are no bathrooms in there.
- 19:18If you have to go, I did not have to use mine, but if you have to go, there's nowhere for
- 19:25you to go in there.
- 19:26We're going to be in there for hours.
- 19:27We're going to be with the police after.
- 19:30So we actually wore those just in case.
- 19:31So I'm sitting in the back of this car in the middle of nowhere in the dark in a diaper,
- 19:36in a biosecurity suit.
- 19:38I'm alone.
- 19:39Someone has just ran in the dark to the farm, ran top speed to go and check out the doors
- 19:46are still unlocked if we can still go in before we all go.
- 19:49And I'm just thinking like, what am I doing here?
- 19:51This is crazy.
- 19:52But then we're given the go-ahead that we're going to assemble.
- 19:59And the first thing we want to do is we want to take a picture.
- 20:02So a lot of people have seen this picture.
- 20:04It's been the cover photo for our event, our court date event pages and that sort of thing.
- 20:10But we're in the dark.
- 20:13We're underneath the sign outside of the farm says Poor Greg across the top.
- 20:17Poor Greg is the name of the farm because porc is pork in French and their name was
- 20:23Grégoire.
- 20:24It was a family-run farm by the Grégoires.
- 20:30So anyway, we're at this farm and there's this car and their headlights are going to
- 20:38be put onto us because there's no other light there.
- 20:39So we take the photos.
- 20:40Someone had to put their car so that the lights are shining on us and we line up and we have
- 20:47some piglets in our arms.
- 20:51Some dead piglets.
- 20:52They're not alive.
- 20:53They're dead.
- 20:54And some masks, some pig masks.
- 20:58They look like we're like pig face masks.
- 21:02And we take the picture and then it's time to go in.
- 21:05So we go towards the door.
- 21:07We get there.
- 21:08Our hearts are all beating fast.
- 21:09Most of us, I think all of us, I don't think any of us, no, maybe most of us, almost all
- 21:16of us have never done this before.
- 21:17I've never gone into a farm before.
- 21:22And we open the door and we walk in and it's just shocking.
- 21:29It just hits you.
- 21:30The smell, the atmosphere, and the eyes of all these mother pigs, these sows that are
- 21:43in cages the size of their own bodies.
- 21:45We were in the gestation area.
- 21:48Gestation?
- 21:49Gestation?
- 21:50Or farrowing.
- 21:51No, excuse me.
- 21:52Farrowing area where they have their babies next to them.
- 21:56And they are still in a cage the size of their body.
- 21:59And then there's another cage for their babies next to them.
- 22:03So they can't turn around.
- 22:04They can only stand up and lie down.
- 22:07But the moment you go in, these huge animals with these very human-like eyes are looking
- 22:13at you and you just can't believe what you're seeing.
- 22:15You just can't believe that this is legal.
- 22:18They walk through the door and there they are right in your face and caged with their
- 22:22babies.
- 22:23Their babies are also dead, some of them in the cages, dead babies in the hallways.
- 22:28The smell is just incredible.
- 22:32There's no windows.
- 22:33It's just dark in there.
- 22:36It just feels like somewhere out of a horror film.
- 22:38And it just got worse as we went on this farm.
- 22:41Even though it was a local family-run farm, it had about 4,000 animals on it.
- 22:46We spent the next few hours going through every single section and carefully documenting
- 22:54everything that we saw.
- 22:56It was just, it was very shocking.
- 23:00It is definitely the worst place in the world I have ever been and will probably ever be.
- 23:06I'm even trying to explain how it felt to look at these animals.
- 23:15There were just so many, there was a variety of just horrible situations.
- 23:18There were the faring area, the gestation area, which is where they're being impregnated
- 23:25and they're in cages their own body there as well on concrete.
- 23:32There was the area where they kept the males, the adult males, which was extremely filthy
- 23:39and we could barely breathe in there.
- 23:40We couldn't understand how animals could breathe in there.
- 23:43There was the area where there were babies, babies that were too old to be with their
- 23:49mothers, but not old enough to be with the adults.
- 23:52They were so overcrowded and so filthy and oppressive.
- 23:56Sorry, that's the word I was trying to find earlier and I couldn't find it for some reason.
- 24:02It was such an oppressive, horrible place.
- 24:05All these little individuals, they were all so sweet and curious and they wanted to come
- 24:10up to us.
- 24:15I'm sorry, I'm still like, it's hard to talk about.
- 24:21It's hard to talk about it and I've been ranting for a long time now, so I think I'll
- 24:24stop it.
- 24:25Let me know what your next question is.
- 24:29I want to now get to the activism part and how to fight this because you're making such
- 24:36great points.
- 24:38Every argument points to, every piece of information and study we have points to, this is a bad
- 24:46idea.
- 24:47This is not a smart idea.
- 24:49We should abolish those institutions.
- 24:52Then you have activism work around it.
- 24:57First of all, would you rate the efficiency?
- 25:02We talked about how social media has helped putting the pressure on them and making them
- 25:10feel threatened.
- 25:12But then you have people breaking in, doing sit-ins inside.
- 25:19You have the animal liberation front who enters those places and liberate animals.
- 25:27You have all kinds of activism around slaughterhouses.
- 25:31Do you have an idea of which ones are the most efficient in terms of making an impact
- 25:36and getting us near the goal of abolishing those institutions?
- 25:43My thoughts are, I think the most effective are those where we can form coalitions around
- 25:54the issues.
- 25:57Having forces with environmentally focused organizations and individuals and knowing,
- 26:04okay, there are going to be some differences.
- 26:07You're not going to be dealing with a group that's entirely vegan or same thing with workers'
- 26:15rights groups.
- 26:19I think forming those coalitions is helpful because sometimes I think it's easy for the
- 26:29general public to look away from animal focused messaging.
- 26:38For all the reasons we've been talking about, people don't want to think about where their
- 26:44meat comes from, where their dairy comes from, their eggs, et cetera.
- 26:52It's easy for them to shut down.
- 26:54But if you're making a broader argument around not just the animals but also human rights,
- 27:04environmental justice, I think then you can... The effect of the message might spread
- 27:12a little more widely.
- 27:18I like what one of your previous guests, Robert Cheek, had to say about, it's really hard
- 27:27to bring people over to your side if you're calling them names and telling them how horrible
- 27:35they are.
- 27:38But it helps if you can show people these connections and convince people that even
- 27:46if you don't care about the animal issues, they're interconnected with so many other
- 27:54issues and concerns and hit them where they live.
- 27:59That's their own personal wellbeing for many people.
- 28:06That's their point to all of the implications of this industry.
- 28:15Also I think it helps to put it into historical context and show people this is, historically
- 28:23speaking, relatively new development.
- 28:26It's not like we're stuck with it.
- 28:29It's not like it's part of our... It's not etched into our DNA or something.
- 28:38It's a relatively new social institution and it can be changed.
- 28:46It just takes people being willing to mobilize and work with other people.
- 28:55I think that helps to get the message out and also fighting as hard as possible against
- 29:05these legislative aims and strategies to prevent the public from gaining information about
- 29:17what's going on.
- 29:20I think people should have the right to know how their food is being produced.
- 29:27I don't think there's anything all that controversial in that statement.
- 29:34I think conveying that to people might help to make them think, okay, yeah, that's a fair
- 29:45point.
- 29:48I also think it can help sometimes to put yourself in a position where you can be a
- 29:59model for other people and say, okay, I was once in the position that you were.
- 30:05I didn't know what was going on, but now I do and here's how I live my life as a result.
- 30:15I think that's important.
- 30:17To be honest with you, it's something I didn't used to do as much as I do now.
- 30:23It occurred to me one day, I was teaching a class and it was corporate and governmental
- 30:29crime class.
- 30:31We were talking about a number of different industries and we were talking about the animal
- 30:36agriculture industry.
- 30:38At one point, one of my students raised his hands and said, but what's the solution?
- 30:44It's not like we can all be vegan, we would die.
- 30:48He really thought that.
- 30:51At that moment, I realized, okay, I need to start telling my students that I'm vegan because
- 30:59otherwise they really do believe these things.
- 31:04Some of that is sponsored by the industry itself.
- 31:09Tell people that they're going to die from protein deficiencies or that they need meat
- 31:15to survive.
- 31:18I think sometimes it can help to put yourself out there and say, okay, look, this is totally
- 31:26feasible for you to do.
- 31:30My caveat to that is be ready for people to try to discredit what you're saying because
- 31:40you're taking that position, because you're vegan.
- 31:44Even if you're speaking about something that's totally unrelated.
- 31:49I've had that happen.
- 31:50I actually just had an instance of it a couple months ago where I had to appear as an expert
- 31:57witness in a court case.
- 32:00It was totally unrelated to food.
- 32:06One of the first things during cross-examination that was raised was, Dr. Fitzgerald, would
- 32:11you agree that eating meat is wrong?
- 32:14I answered it, honestly, but I thought the question has nothing to do with the case,
- 32:22but the reason it was raised was to try to discredit everything else that I was saying.
- 32:29I think the more that people put themselves out there and identify as healthy vegans,
- 32:37I think that can help.
- 32:40Like I said, just be ready because you will have people who will challenge everything
- 32:46you have to say because you've made that position clear.
- 32:58Covering the topic of factory farming has helped me understand better the powerful role
- 33:06played by veterinarians in the exploitation of animals.
- 33:11I had the chance to welcome one of the most vocal activists on this issue, Dr. Crystal
- 33:17Heath.
- 33:18She founded an organization called Our Honor, and they sell great merch on their website.
- 33:26Mugs and t-shirts are printed with the words, my favorite veterinarians don't eat their
- 33:32patients.
- 33:33I think that message captures perfectly the issue.
- 33:37I want you to hear from her, but first Marina Belotnikova, who is this super smart and talented
- 33:45reporter working for Vox.
- 33:48Look her up.
- 33:49She wrote an article on Dr. Heath and veterinarians in general, and it did not go as planned.
- 33:58Take a listen.
- 34:00So Marina, I first heard from you, of you from Dr. Heath.
- 34:05I interviewed her on episode 12 of the podcast.
- 34:10Basically she's a veterinarian who spoke up about animal abuse and got this huge backlash,
- 34:17and she was basically canceled.
- 34:19And you wrote about her in an article called The Bitter Civil War Dividing American Veterinarians
- 34:26back in January.
- 34:28So as an icebreaker question, I was wondering if you could maybe reflect back on that article
- 34:34and maybe share with us some details that did not make the final cut.
- 34:39Yeah.
- 34:40Yeah.
- 34:41Thank you for calling out that story.
- 34:43That was one of my favorite stories I worked on, and I think it's so important.
- 34:47It was about how the veterinary profession and the institutions of veterinary medicine,
- 34:53the American Veterinary Medical Association is the biggest one, are basically structurally
- 34:59and systematically aligned with factory farming and the interests of the meat industry.
- 35:07It came out of like, in early 2020, I was doing a lot of reporting on the rise of, about
- 35:17the 2022 bird flu, which resulted in the mass extermination of nearly 60 million chickens
- 35:26and turkeys over the course of about a year.
- 35:32And I wrote about what was happening to these animals that had to be mass killed whenever
- 35:39there was a bird flu outbreak detected at a factory farm.
- 35:43And I wrote a lot about the rise of a method called ventilation shutdown.
- 35:47You probably heard about it if you know crystal, and it's been very topical in the animal movement
- 35:54the last couple of years.
- 35:55But a ventilation shutdown basically means mass exterminating animals through heat stroke.
- 36:01So they literally, like the factory farms literally rent industrial heaters and pump
- 36:09in heat.
- 36:11Sometimes steam is used in the pork industry, like pump in heat to the sheds to quickly
- 36:16mass kill animals.
- 36:18So you can compare it to a dog dying in a hot car.
- 36:22He's literally death by heat stroke, and this takes hours for animals to die from this in
- 36:28the poultry industry.
- 36:30So it's like, in case it's not obvious, it's basically the most inhumane and the most excruciating
- 36:41way to cull animals, despite the euphemism that you sometimes hear the industry using
- 36:50and calling this a kind of euthanasia.
- 36:52So I did a lot of writing and reporting on that, and through that I picked up on how
- 37:03important the veterinary profession was in validating and providing a justification and
- 37:13basically like a scientific and medical and moral cover for it.
- 37:20And it made me, like the more and more I learned, I was like, I thought this is really interesting
- 37:26and I think would be surprising to a general audience.
- 37:32We associate veterinarians with our cats and dogs.
- 37:36I feel like that's such an evocative association in people's minds.
- 37:42And yet the veterinary profession is actually very closely connected to the institutions
- 37:52that are responsible for animal torture on a massive scale.
- 37:58I was just so fascinated by that and the political and intellectual history of veterinary medicine,
- 38:07how it came to be that way.
- 38:10And so yeah, and I decided to turn it into a story.
- 38:13I was actually, so I started working at Vox last November.
- 38:20Before that I had been freelancing and I pitched this story around to, so back when I was a
- 38:27freelancer, I pitched this story idea to so many outlets.
- 38:31I had a spreadsheet tracking everywhere where I was sending a pitch and this pitch had gone
- 38:39out to literally 17 different places and I just couldn't get it picked up.
- 38:44And I was so baffled because I think it's so interesting, so important.
- 38:48There's so much there.
- 38:49It's like, it's, obviously it's such a real story.
- 38:55And it was discouraging.
- 38:57And then I started my job at Vox.
- 38:59In my section we write a lot about factory farming and animal rights.
- 39:04And so it was a no-brainer for this veterinarian story to fit there.
- 39:09So I ended up writing it for Vox.
- 39:11It was published this past January of 2023 and it did, audience traffic wise, it did
- 39:20very well because the headline, the Civil War, dividing veterinarians.
- 39:27I think people want to read about that.
- 39:29Even if they don't have a special interest in factory farming, I think that that subject
- 39:34is so intriguing.
- 39:36Yeah.
- 39:37So I'm really happy I did it and I want to continue reporting on the veterinary profession
- 39:45for sure.
- 39:46So, doctor, tell me, is there a fight you want to talk about and that you're leading
- 39:53with your organization and I haven't asked you about?
- 39:58We are also addressing the harmful use of animals in medical school training, veterinary
- 40:04school training.
- 40:06People don't realize that veterinary students have to kill their patients often in veterinary
- 40:13school.
- 40:14The cadavers that students use to learn anatomy, they're often animals purchased from bioscience
- 40:24companies, purposefully bred for that purpose.
- 40:28And there's an alternative, there's humane ethical alternatives which are willed body
- 40:34programs.
- 40:35When our own dog, cat, horse, goat passes away, we can donate their body to veterinary school
- 40:42for veterinary students to learn on.
- 40:44We don't need to be purposefully breeding animals for veterinary students to learn on.
- 40:50But also, there are veterinary students who have to anesthetize a healthy animal, perform
- 40:57one or more surgeries on them, and then kill them before the animal is even allowed to
- 41:02wake up.
- 41:03And that is horrifying and against our ethics.
- 41:09And students are bullied into doing this, worrying that they're going to face a failing grade,
- 41:15worried that they're going to be ostracized.
- 41:17And the threats are really ramping up.
- 41:19I feel like the veterinary students are even more afraid now to speak up when it's very
- 41:25clear.
- 41:26There's no evidence against these sorts of training models when there's so many more
- 41:31alternatives.
- 41:32But the students are at the same time more fearful about speaking up.
- 41:36So we're going to put on some Know Your Rights trainings in the future for veterinary students.
- 41:40If there's any veterinary students out there, and you feel threatened and you feel like
- 41:45you can't speak up, reach out to us.
- 41:48Our honor wants to write to these schools and advocate for change in curriculum that
- 41:55requires less animal harm.
- 41:58We're going to come out with the numbers of how many animals are killed at each school
- 42:01and make a ranking of the most ethical to the least ethical veterinary schools.
- 42:08And there's going to be a lot more information coming out in that area.
- 42:13And that's a huge opportunity for change.
- 42:16And veterinary students shouldn't feel scared.
- 42:21Just know that animal law attorneys are wanting to take on some sort of case First Amendment
- 42:28attorneys.
- 42:30We have your back.
- 42:32There's a lot you can do and a lot of animals you can save.
- 42:36And some people say, oh, what's the most ethical vet school to go to?
- 42:40And I encourage if you're bold, go to the worst ones.
- 42:43And because you're going to save more animals by changing the curriculum at the worst schools,
- 42:49you could save thousands of animals by changing the curriculum.
- 42:54Whereas you're not going to save any animals if you go to school that doesn't harm animals.
- 42:58So that's my philosophy.
- 43:01So stay tuned and follow us on social media to hear more about that.
- 43:06Why are they not suing the colleges?
- 43:10Because this is a traumatizing experience.
- 43:12I hear about lectures getting cancelled in colleges because they are insensitive.
- 43:20And then there's this horrible situation going on at your vet school department.
- 43:28If this is not a lawsuit material, then I don't know what it is.
- 43:35And it's against our oath.
- 43:37It's anti the three Rs.
- 43:39The most welfarist basic.
- 43:42This isn't even animal rights stuff we're talking about here.
- 43:45This is basic adhering to the ethics of the veterinary profession.
- 43:49And Gary did sue a lot of schools for this.
- 43:54And sadly, there's been silence lately.
- 44:00I feel like we really need to ramp that up again.
- 44:05More lawsuits.
- 44:06There's so much potential here for change.
- 44:17I think that what Dr. Heat went through was a case of discrimination.
- 44:23Discrimination for her speech, for her beliefs, for basically being vegan.
- 44:30And that was one other incredible team covered by the podcast.
- 44:35When the amazing Tamara Bedeck, chair of the animal rights committee for the New York National
- 44:42Lawyers Guild, reached out to me and asked if I would like to partner and promote a webinar
- 44:49they held on vegan discrimination, I said yes.
- 44:52Right away.
- 44:53I interviewed Tamara and one participant of the webinar Astrid Prevot, whose legal case
- 45:00against France National School of Dietitians was pending.
- 45:05Let's hear what they had to say.
- 45:08You have individual discrimination cases that are moving forward because vegans are being
- 45:13discriminated against at work, at school, in divorce proceedings, in detention.
- 45:20Well let's give some concrete examples to listeners.
- 45:24Sure.
- 45:25Well, all right.
- 45:27I'll start sort of sequentially with the US and Jerry Friedman's case.
- 45:32So Jerry Friedman was at the time a computer, he was a computer repair person for Kaiser
- 45:40Permanente, which is a very large hospital chain.
- 45:45And he was working for a pharmaceutical company repairing their computers and they were very
- 45:50happy with his work.
- 45:52And they offered him a full-time permanent position, which he was very happy to accept
- 46:00or as happy as a vegan in a pharmaceutical company could be.
- 46:06But he did accept the position and then they told him that he must be vaccinated and take
- 46:13the MMR vaccine.
- 46:15And Jerry said, you know, this vaccine is cultured from chicken embryos and I don't
- 46:22feel comfortable taking it.
- 46:26Perhaps we can keep me in the computer repair shop away from anyone who might be a patient
- 46:39and accommodate me that way.
- 46:42And they said no and they rescinded the job offer, the full-time job offer, and they stopped
- 46:48using his services as a contractor.
- 46:52So they backpedaled quite a bit and he was horrified and he took them to task on it.
- 47:00Jordi Casamidana's case about 20 years later or 18 years later came about because he was
- 47:09working for League Against Cruel Sports.
- 47:14And as an ethical vegan, he was curious as to where his pension fund was going.
- 47:18So investing in a pension fund became mandatory, I think, in 2015 in the UK.
- 47:24So everyone at LACS had a pension fund and he was just curious as to what he was investing
- 47:32in.
- 47:33He found out, much to his horror, that he was investing in tobacco, oil, and big pharma
- 47:40that tested on animals.
- 47:42So he raised this with his managers.
- 47:46They appeared equally horrified.
- 47:48They told him they would change the pension fund, but in fact they didn't.
- 47:54And despite nudging them for over a year, they didn't.
- 47:58And in the course of that year, he begged them to at least stop investing his own money
- 48:05so that it wasn't like his own pension was contributing to animal testing.
- 48:11It turns out they didn't even do that.
- 48:14So he found a mechanism to change his own pension fund to something more ethical.
- 48:23And he changed his own pension fund, his own monetary stream, to something more ethical.
- 48:31And he told his colleagues at LACS about it.
- 48:35And LACS fired him.
- 48:40Astrid Prevost is an aspiring dietitian in France.
- 48:46To get her dietitian's license, there was a mandatory cooking class.
- 48:51I don't know why there was a mandatory cooking class, but there was.
- 48:55They insisted that she use animal ingredients.
- 48:58She requested to be able to substitute the animal ingredients with vegan alternatives.
- 49:06She even got a doctor's note.
- 49:07They said no, and that she would risk failing the cooking class and thereby not being able
- 49:14to pursue her dietitian's degree unless she used animal products.
- 49:22So there are other kinds of cases as well.
- 49:26There are cases in detention or in hospitals where a person in detention is not getting
- 49:33vegan food despite the fact that they are quite clear about what it is they eat.
- 49:40We're hoping that Representative Congressman Ro Khanna opens the webinar.
- 49:46We're waiting for his staff to give us the green light and let us know if he's available
- 49:51for a couple of minutes on October 17.
- 49:54Congressman Khanna is very involved in making sure that American servicemen and women have
- 50:01plant-based and vegan options in the military.
- 50:06The congressman of which state?
- 50:10California.
- 50:11So there are these many, many different examples where vegans are.
- 50:18I'll give you a sort of divorce example.
- 50:22Imagine, if you will, you have two people divorcing.
- 50:26One is not vegan.
- 50:28One is vegan.
- 50:30The not vegan claims that the vegan is jeopardizing the health of their child and should therefore
- 50:37be the parent that gets custody.
- 50:39Now in some places they may or may not be laughed at because we know that it's entirely
- 50:46possible to have a child that's on a vegan diet and have that child be extremely healthy.
- 50:53But in some places that's quite a strong argument.
- 50:58And there are some places in the world where to be vegan is to be openly vegan is to be
- 51:04scared of retaliation where vegans are called terrorists.
- 51:08There's a Italian politician who wants vegan parents to go to jail, go to jail, vegan parents
- 51:18to go to jail because they're jeopardizing the health of their child.
- 51:25So depending on where you are in the world, your discrimination is going to be different
- 51:31and more or less severe.
- 51:33So Astrid, my first question for you is why did you decide to be vocal about your fight?
- 51:40Well, I decided to be vocal about my fight because I think it's very important for other
- 51:47vegans to realize that we can fight for our rights and also that our rights defend animal
- 51:55rights.
- 51:56It's all linked.
- 51:57So I think it's very important not to just let it go.
- 52:01What I know is that discrimination against vegans really prevents people from becoming
- 52:08vegans because people are afraid to be discriminated against.
- 52:12Some become vegan and then they quit veganism because of the social injustice and because
- 52:19they feel they are not accepted and they are mocked and they have a hard time finding food
- 52:26where they live.
- 52:27So yeah, I think discrimination against vegans has really like very concrete outcomes.
- 52:36And so yeah, I think that's also why we should fight against it because the final outcome
- 52:43is that it promotes animal exploitation, even if it's not direct, but still.
- 52:57Even though this podcast is in English and my reference countries are pretty much Canada
- 53:03and the US, I really try my best to cover the animal rights fights going on in other
- 53:10countries like France with Astrid, but also Vietnam with the inspiring Catherine, founder
- 53:18of Vietnam Animal Aid and Rescue, George, founder of Lebanese Vegans, Jimena, founder
- 53:25of Obstructious Microsanctuary in Columbia, and ASMR Nobility, Whispers Red, founder of
- 53:33Wispouse, a sanctuary located in Serbia.
- 53:37I admire them so much.
- 53:41Their battle is such an uphill battle, yet here they are making breakthrough after breakthrough,
- 53:48claiming victory after victory against cruelty and violence.
- 53:55I live in a tourist town.
- 53:56It's the same thing.
- 53:57We get all these messages from people saying, I found this kitten on the side of the road.
- 54:01I'm leaving tomorrow.
- 54:03What can you take the kitten?
- 54:04No.
- 54:05Well, I mean, we can't because you're one of nine this week that have sent me that message.
- 54:12I know you feel powerless and helpless and whatever, but I don't own an island to put
- 54:17all these cats on.
- 54:19Let's get this straight.
- 54:20There is just no place for them to go.
- 54:22You have to get used to the idea that you can't help everybody.
- 54:25I think that's one of the worst parts of being a compassionate and empathetic person is being
- 54:30able to close your eyes and say, I understand the big picture.
- 54:34I'm doing everything I can on a daily basis, particularly as vegans, to eliminate my part
- 54:42in exploitation, torture and murder.
- 54:45That's bigger than what everybody else around here is doing.
- 54:52You can't help every single individual.
- 54:54There's not the resources or the homes or the space or the veterinarians.
- 55:00It just isn't like that.
- 55:02I can say that after 10 years running a rescue, but ultimately it is what led me to run a
- 55:08rescue.
- 55:09This idea of like, I'm not going to stand for this.
- 55:12I won't stand for this.
- 55:14I will do something.
- 55:16I am somebody who can do something.
- 55:18Listen, Ryan, I think that the problem resides not just in Lebanon.
- 55:25So a key question to this podcast might be how are animals treated and perceived by Lebanese
- 55:35people?
- 55:36Sure.
- 55:37Listen, Ryan, I think that the problem resides not just in Lebanon, but worldwide.
- 55:42Of course, now there are countries that are more animal welfareists than others, but when
- 55:47it comes to animal rights, all of us who are very far behind.
- 55:54So regarding animal welfare, we have some few organizations that take care about cats
- 56:00and dogs, basically pets, but they brand themselves as animal organizations, whereas they only
- 56:08focus on a few cats and dogs and a few horses, which I am completely against because it gives
- 56:13the impression that all other animals are okay to abuse and to gain and to eat.
- 56:21The community is being educated as much as possible with Lebanese Veganism Organization
- 56:28that I created years ago and others as well.
- 56:33We try as much as possible to expose the horrors about animal agriculture, especially regarding
- 56:39the ethical aspect of it, because we're vegan for ethics and it's all about ethics.
- 56:46Of course, now we have advantages of going vegan relating to the environment and our
- 56:51health, but mainly it's for ethics.
- 56:53So yeah, we try as much as possible in Lebanon, especially that here the mentality is quite
- 56:58like, I mean, manly in a way that, you know, you should be eating some kind of meat to
- 57:06be man or something of the sort, which is completely wrong, of course, especially like
- 57:13in the mountains, they still eat sometimes some raw meat with some spices, you know.
- 57:19So yeah, the more we go away from the capital, Beirut, the more the idea of animal rights
- 57:26and veganism becomes blurry, you know, but yeah, as much as possible, we try to raise
- 57:32awareness and we're on it.
- 57:36What is it like to have an animal sanctuary in Colombia?
- 57:40Is veganism?
- 57:42It's very hard.
- 57:43I can relate with Jessica and Tracy about the fear because in Colombia cattle farming
- 57:51is very important.
- 57:55It's not just an industry, a powerful industry, but it was related with foreign military army
- 58:06years ago.
- 58:08They are very powerful.
- 58:11So when you try to make a cultural transformation, people doesn't take it like, ah, that's cool.
- 58:20No, it's like you want to change me.
- 58:22You're crazy.
- 58:23You're rebellious.
- 58:24People doesn't like it.
- 58:25At the beginning of the sanctuary, it was at the same time of the pandemic.
- 58:36Our sanctuary was vandalized a few times.
- 58:43We were always with the fear that because they, if they broke some pipes or steal some
- 58:50machinery or whatever, it doesn't matter.
- 58:53But we were always afraid that they may come to the or hurt the girls, the cows.
- 59:02So it was difficult to deal with.
- 59:07That's why I was saying before that we are just like put again ourself on our feet because
- 59:14it was not just bankruptcy, but all the attacks that we had at the beginning.
- 59:23Even from my husband's family, they are all cattle farmers.
- 59:29And right now in Colombia, there is a debate.
- 59:32In fact, tomorrow is the final debate of the Congress about bullfighting.
- 59:39And our neighbor at the farm is one of the main bullfighting lawyers.
- 59:52He owns, in fact, the main bullfighting ring in Bogota has his last name, Santa Maria.
- 1:00:02So it has been difficult.
- 1:00:06It has been a difficult path, but I think we were able to do it.
- 1:00:14And right now we are feeling more comfortable and that's why we are planning to move to
- 1:00:19the farm with the cattle.
- 1:00:21So we are not depending on someone or feeling that fear.
- 1:00:27But if we are there, I think we can feel more comfortable and safe being all the time with
- 1:00:35the animals.
- 1:00:38So but it's always the there are nice people, but there are always the people with the prejudice
- 1:00:50that you're crazy and you're trying to you're a hippie.
- 1:00:57Like they say in Colombia, you're a weed smoker like Maribuanero.
- 1:01:03So like crazy once the sanctuary was broadcasted at the TV national news.
- 1:01:15Some people were like insulting us or saying like ugly things.
- 1:01:21So but I think that is part of the choice that we made trying to promote a cultural
- 1:01:32transformation that respect and having into account animal lives.
- 1:01:39So I think this is the price and we were we were willing to assume that and we are in
- 1:01:47that in that in that way.
- 1:01:52So many times I've been in a situation where they're talking about me in Serbian, assuming
- 1:02:03that the only reason why an English person or any person would come over to Serbia to
- 1:02:09do something with the animals is because they were trying to make money somehow.
- 1:02:16And and then of course, I find out because the manager of the sanctuary who who the family
- 1:02:23that live there and take care of the animals, they were very close and people don't expect
- 1:02:30that we are that close.
- 1:02:32So I learn everything that they've been saying in Serbian because their perception of animals
- 1:02:40is so different to us.
- 1:02:44And it's not that they're not good people.
- 1:02:48It's that they have a complete indifference to animals.
- 1:02:55They're not they're not connected to everything around them like we like we are.
- 1:03:01It's quite difficult to explain.
- 1:03:03And I'm still I'm still trying to figure it all out anyway.
- 1:03:08But they're just objects to them.
- 1:03:14The possessions.
- 1:03:15But I would argue that this is one good reason of opening a sanctuary in Serbia because this
- 1:03:24feeling is the default feeling of the people there.
- 1:03:30A sanctuary is such a rebellious entity in such context.
- 1:03:40And it's there to also teach them is there, of course, to help the dogs, the animals,
- 1:03:47but also to teach them that compassion, to teach them to make that link with animals.
- 1:03:52Yeah.
- 1:03:53To set an example through action.
- 1:03:56It's very, very difficult.
- 1:03:57I'll be honest.
- 1:03:58So many times I've felt like giving up because it's just not easy.
- 1:04:05And to run a charity full stop just isn't easy at all.
- 1:04:09But to operate in an environment like that when I'm not there all the time as well.
- 1:04:17So, so the family that we're very close to that are managing the place and with the animals
- 1:04:2324 seven.
- 1:04:24I mean, they've got the greatest hearts.
- 1:04:26They're such beautiful people.
- 1:04:30But we've even, you know, we've still had to have the conversations about and set the
- 1:04:34policies on exactly how they take care of the animals because they've grown up with
- 1:04:39no money at all.
- 1:04:40They've never been able to afford to to neuter an animal or to keep them, you know, in the
- 1:04:47conditions that we've got them in.
- 1:04:49They've never been able to afford anything like that.
- 1:04:51So it's not there.
- 1:04:52It's not the one thing that they think of straight away.
- 1:04:57I took over some heaters for our living space for the dogs back in January.
- 1:05:04And it took me a while to convince them that they need to actually put them on for more
- 1:05:08often than more often than they were because they were thinking, well, it's going to cost
- 1:05:11a fortune.
- 1:05:13And I said, well, yes, but the dogs will freeze.
- 1:05:19And they love the dogs.
- 1:05:20You know, it's hard.
- 1:05:22It's hard for me to explain because they love the dogs, but they've never lived in a situation
- 1:05:29where they could afford to heat the dogs and their default position is, but we can't afford
- 1:05:35it.
- 1:05:37So you know, we still have to have these conversations where we decide exactly how we're going to
- 1:05:42do things and then make sure they're done.
- 1:05:47And then we're dealing with the public and the people that just think, oh, you know,
- 1:05:53there's a sanctuary there.
- 1:05:54We'll just, we'll just dump the dogs outside the gate.
- 1:05:59We'll dump the puppies outside the gate or not even that.
- 1:06:03They just leave them on the road further up.
- 1:06:07And the locals who we went to pick up a dog.
- 1:06:15This guy wants to get rid of his, his pointer.
- 1:06:18He was about eight years old and he's, he's in the local village and we went to see him.
- 1:06:25And normally they would take that dog and they would just dump them by a busy road.
- 1:06:29So you know, he didn't, he didn't do that.
- 1:06:32He contacted us.
- 1:06:33So that was a good thing.
- 1:06:35But he wants to get rid of him because he's eight years old.
- 1:06:38He's had enough of him.
- 1:06:39He couldn't, he said he couldn't afford to feed him anymore.
- 1:06:42His wife was in hospital, fair enough.
- 1:06:46But when we went round there, this dog was in such terrible condition, kept in a tiny
- 1:06:52little cage and that didn't need to, that didn't need to happen.
- 1:06:56Regardless of whether he had money or not, he didn't need to do that because he had a
- 1:06:59courtyard that the dog could have been in.
- 1:07:06But he, he thought, he thought that it was fine that the dog was in the cage and he had
- 1:07:11lots of cats around.
- 1:07:13And and of course, and whenever I'm around cats, like I can't stop touching them and
- 1:07:19I'm standing there and these cats are coming towards me.
- 1:07:24And so I'm like, you know, chatting with the cats and, and I picked up one cat and I'm
- 1:07:29cuddling this cat and, and the guy just turned to me, said, I'll take the cat.
- 1:07:34I said, what do you mean?
- 1:07:38Just take it.
- 1:07:39Because he wanted us to take the dog.
- 1:07:40So he was in his mind, he was being nice to me.
- 1:07:43Just have what you want as long as you take the dog.
- 1:07:47But I said, I said, no, this is the cat.
- 1:07:49This is your cat's home.
- 1:07:52And all of these cats here, they're your cat's family.
- 1:07:57I'm not going to take them.
- 1:07:59Why would I, you know, it was just in his mind, he was being kind.
- 1:08:05But in mine, obviously I'm like, you can't do that.
- 1:08:10You can't just give away the cat just like that.
- 1:08:13Not even knowing where the cat's going to go or what environment they're going to be
- 1:08:18living in or, you know, it was just, I've come across these situations that are really
- 1:08:24strange often when I, when I go there.
- 1:08:29And and it's heartbreaking really.
- 1:08:31I mean, that's definitely nowhere near the worst situation that there is over there.
- 1:08:36That's that's very tame.
- 1:08:38But it's just a small example.
- 1:08:41But the way that some people treat animals out there is absolutely disgusting.
- 1:08:46It's absolutely heartbreaking.
- 1:08:48And yeah.
- 1:08:52Finally, talking about uphill battles, let's get political.
- 1:09:03This podcast has not shied away from being political.
- 1:09:07I welcomed the amazing address and the so very kind Michelle, two vegans identifying
- 1:09:15as conservatives.
- 1:09:18I also welcomed Liz White, leader of the Animal Protection Party of Canada, Miles Trafigen,
- 1:09:25a researcher who wants us to demolish the southern border wall, and Dr. Vlasak, who
- 1:09:31defends the illegal actions of the ALF, the Animal Liberation Front.
- 1:09:37So basically people from everywhere on the political spectrum.
- 1:09:41So take a listen.
- 1:09:44I'm wondering why did you choose to appear as guests on this podcast, because it can
- 1:09:48be a bit intimidating to talk publicly about your position.
- 1:09:53So I'm curious, what made you want to become guests on on the vegan world?
- 1:10:01Would you like me to go first?
- 1:10:02Sure.
- 1:10:03Okay.
- 1:10:04So I saw your Reddit and I was like, oh, because you know, there's just this huge political
- 1:10:12divide.
- 1:10:13And I'm like, you know what, I'm gonna take a chance.
- 1:10:15I'm gonna put it out there, because maybe we can find something that will give us that
- 1:10:21common ground that will bring us all together.
- 1:10:24There's actually more conservative vegans than you can even begin to imagine.
- 1:10:29I'm part of a conservative vegan Facebook group.
- 1:10:33For a small group, there's only 1500.
- 1:10:36But that's 1500 people strong, you know, and I feel like that's just in Florida.
- 1:10:42Maybe there's more.
- 1:10:43And so I love that you opened this up.
- 1:10:46And I think it's a great thing.
- 1:10:49Yeah, similar.
- 1:10:50Anytime there's some discussion about veganism and right wing politics or just politics in
- 1:10:57general, I do like to chime in.
- 1:11:00I like to remind people that vegans don't all fit into one box politically.
- 1:11:06Gary Yourofsky, if you're familiar, he has a very famous speech that's a lot of people's
- 1:11:11first introduction to veganism.
- 1:11:13All right.
- 1:11:14Good afternoon, everybody.
- 1:11:15My name is Gary Yourofsky.
- 1:11:16Please take a moment and jot down my email address and my website in case you want to
- 1:11:21contact me later on.
- 1:11:22Today, we're going to talk about the world's forgotten victims, animals, and the world's
- 1:11:27oldest and strongest addiction, meat.
- 1:11:35And he at the start of his speech, he's saying, you don't have to change anything.
- 1:11:41You don't have to give up your friend group, your religious beliefs, your political beliefs,
- 1:11:46just leave animals alone.
- 1:11:47I am not trying to take you away from your religion.
- 1:11:52No religion mandates meat eating.
- 1:11:55The golden rule states do unto others as you would have done unto yourself.
- 1:12:03Animals qualify as others and thou shalt not kill.
- 1:12:10The four most important yet most ignored words in all religious teachings.
- 1:12:16There's not an asterisk next to that commandment saying, unless you walk on all fours, have
- 1:12:21fur, feathers, horns, beaks, or gills.
- 1:12:24You can keep your friends, your politics, and your patriotism, still watch your favorite
- 1:12:30TV shows and listen to your favorite music, even if it's Ted Nugent.
- 1:12:35So I like to remind people that you don't have to abandon these beliefs or change who
- 1:12:42you are really.
- 1:12:44It's all about just kind of aligning your actions with your beliefs.
- 1:12:49And a lot of us believe that animal abuse is bad.
- 1:12:51So regardless of what you believe politically, economically, religiously, you can live in
- 1:12:58a way that leaves animals alone.
- 1:13:00So I definitely want to highlight that.
- 1:13:02And so I'm grateful for the opportunity.
- 1:13:06The most common thing that people say to me when I talk about the political parties, they
- 1:13:11hate politics.
- 1:13:12They don't like politicians.
- 1:13:14They don't trust them.
- 1:13:15They don't want to have anything to do with them.
- 1:13:17They're going to turn their back on democracy and walk away.
- 1:13:20And I say to them, that is a huge mistake.
- 1:13:26Because like it or not, if we really want things to change for animals in Canada, we
- 1:13:32have to do the politics.
- 1:13:35And it's the politicians.
- 1:13:36They're the gatekeepers of all the legislation.
- 1:13:38They decide who lives, who dies, when they die, in what manner, is it cruel, how they're
- 1:13:43sold, what's done with them.
- 1:13:45All of that is political.
- 1:13:47And until we address that, there is no way that we are going to change the landscape
- 1:13:53with regard to how we treat animals, particularly food animals, which of course, accounts for
- 1:13:57the largest number.
- 1:14:00There was a law that was enacted in 2005 called the Real ID Act of 2005.
- 1:14:07And that sounds fairly benign.
- 1:14:08Okay, we're all supposed to carry identification.
- 1:14:11But there was a clause in that law that said that the Secretary of Homeland Security has
- 1:14:18the authority and power to waive all laws for the construction of border barriers.
- 1:14:24And this includes the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, the
- 1:14:32Rivers and Protection Act, the Wilderness Act, Bald Eagle, Golden Eagle protection.
- 1:14:36And the list goes on to about 70 different laws that they have the authority to waive.
- 1:14:42And so because of this, we were not able to do environmental studies to try to assess
- 1:14:50the impact of the border wall on wildlife, on water, on the ecosystem.
- 1:14:58So they essentially can just do what they want to do.
- 1:15:01And that's exactly what they did is they don't really have to notify anybody except to put
- 1:15:07it in the US Federal Register saying, we're going to build a border wall here, and we
- 1:15:11are waiving all of these laws.
- 1:15:15And that is a very scary thing.
- 1:15:18And it set a horrible precedent around the world because this is the erosion of democracy.
- 1:15:27How can an unelected politically appointed official, which is who the Secretary of Homeland
- 1:15:33Security is, how do they have the authority to waive laws that both houses of Congress
- 1:15:39have passed and whatever sitting president signed them into law, and then it withstood
- 1:15:44decades of judicial review and challenges at the Supreme Court?
- 1:15:48How does that person have the power to do that?
- 1:15:52Unchecked power.
- 1:15:54This is something that people should be scared of because it's starting to proliferate around
- 1:15:59the world.
- 1:16:00There are now nearly 70 countries in the world that have border walls.
- 1:16:07And they are following the same playbook where in Poland and Belarus, they built a border
- 1:16:15wall two years ago, a 200 kilometer long border wall between Poland and Belarus right through
- 1:16:21the Białowice Unesco Biosphere Reserve.
- 1:16:27So there's bison there, there's wolves, brown bears, and they waived all the laws to construct
- 1:16:34that.
- 1:16:36In Slovenia, they're putting up border barriers.
- 1:16:39And once again, they did the same thing saying that, oh, in order to put these up, we need
- 1:16:43to bypass all the laws.
- 1:16:45And unfortunately, that's something that I believe that the United States exported to
- 1:16:52a lot of places who are taking advantage of this autocratic power that really should not
- 1:17:03exist in a true functioning democracy.
- 1:17:09Do you believe that our governmental institutions have been captured by the agriculture industry?
- 1:17:16Well, absolutely.
- 1:17:19Not only the huge amount of subsidies that are delivered by the government to animal
- 1:17:24agriculture, heavily subsidized industries such as the meat and dairy industries, as
- 1:17:30one example, make it very clear that the government is in collusion with the animal agriculture
- 1:17:36industry.
- 1:17:37And to no surprise, these are the wealthy corporations that deliver suitcases full of
- 1:17:44cash to our government people every year.
- 1:17:49So of course, they're going to get what they want, which is the subsidization of their
- 1:17:56industry.
- 1:17:57And of course, people in government are just like everybody else, they're a new word to
- 1:17:59the violence they're used to and brainwashed by these industries into thinking that animal
- 1:18:06abuse is completely acceptable, normal, and the usual way of doing business.
- 1:18:13And of course, none of that's true.
- 1:18:16Yeah.
- 1:18:17And that gives the feeling that the game is rigged.
- 1:18:23And most certainly after what's happening right now in Canada with the ag-gag laws at
- 1:18:31the federal level and how many obstacles we're putting in the way of vegan activists, it
- 1:18:41feels like the gold past is moving and that we're playing against such strong forces.
- 1:18:53So yes, civil disobedience is one answer against this issue.
- 1:19:02And I think that's the part that makes people anxious.
- 1:19:06It's breaking the law.
- 1:19:10What would you say about that?
- 1:19:12First of all, point of clarification, at least here in the States, we use civil disobedience
- 1:19:18in a different way.
- 1:19:21Civil disobedience to the best of my knowledge, at least as applied here, implies breaking
- 1:19:27the law but doing so openly and accepting the consequences.
- 1:19:31So for instance, if you were to chain yourself in front of a first or something as a statement
- 1:19:37and obviously break the law, but fully expect to be arrested and accept those consequences,
- 1:19:44we would call that civil disobedience.
- 1:19:46What the underground animal liberation movement is doing, such as the ALF, is by our definition
- 1:19:51not really civil disobedience.
- 1:19:52These are people that are breaking the law and getting away with it for the most part
- 1:19:59so that they can be out there to do it again.
- 1:20:02And breaking the law to help animals is certainly justifiable, is certainly commendable.
- 1:20:09We support it 100%.
- 1:20:11We have supported it for more than 20 years.
- 1:20:14So yeah, that just is a matter of difference in terminology, though we don't use that term
- 1:20:20civil disobedience for what the ALF and other organizations are doing.
- 1:20:24And I'm sorry, your original question again?
- 1:20:27Yes, I just wanted you to comment on that part of breaking the law.
- 1:20:33And I guess this is what people are anxious about.
- 1:20:38If you look at every single struggle for liberation, both historically and concurrently in any
- 1:20:45movement, whether it was against apartheid in South Africa, whether it was for civil
- 1:20:51rights here in North America, various anti-colonialist efforts in places like Algeria and other
- 1:21:00places, all of those struggles for liberation included an underground component.
- 1:21:07And it's necessary in all of these struggles because power is not going to give up their
- 1:21:12dominance just when you ask them nicely to do so.
- 1:21:16They have to be persuaded by a variety of different means and not just illegal means,
- 1:21:22but a variety of different means, but including illegal direct action, what we call direct
- 1:21:26action.
- 1:21:28And so I don't think the struggle for animal liberation is any different than these other
- 1:21:31struggles unless you're a speciesist and you think that animals don't count nearly as much
- 1:21:36as humans, which we believe that animals are just as important as humans.
- 1:21:40And so the animal liberation struggle, it's just like all these other liberation struggles
- 1:21:45throughout time.
- 1:21:46And it will require a component that involves breaking the law.
- 1:21:51Each of those other struggles has mostly included the use of real violence.
- 1:21:57One could argue in self-defense, again, perfectly justifiable in my mind.
- 1:22:02In our mind, certainly justifiable to use violence to protect yourself if someone's
- 1:22:06trying to kill you.
- 1:22:08You have a right to defend yourself.
- 1:22:09And animals are being murdered by the millions every day and they have a right to defend
- 1:22:15themselves.
- 1:22:16And if they can't defend them, then we have the right to defend them.
- 1:22:20Just like if your child is being abused, you have a right to defend your child.
- 1:22:24Well, we have a right to defend animals when they're being abused.
- 1:22:27And even though that particular strategy hasn't been widely used in the struggle for animal
- 1:22:32liberation, it would certainly be justifiable if it was ever used.
- 1:22:42Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:22:44Please don't hesitate to reach out.
- 1:22:47I want to hear from you.
- 1:22:49You can message me on Instagram at veganreportpodcast or leave a review.
- 1:22:55Make yourself known.
- 1:22:56This is as much your podcast as it is mine.
- 1:23:00And when I know that you are enjoying this show, that you are getting something out of
- 1:23:05this, it just gives me the energy to keep going.
- 1:23:11Thank you so much for your support.
- 1:23:12I wish you a great summer or winter, I guess, if you're listening from the Southern hemisphere.
- 1:23:20And as always, thank you for caring.
- 1:23:23But I like to tell all every vegan that's listening or at home, you have to be a voice
- 1:23:32for the animals every single day.
- 1:23:33It's not enough just to be vegan.
- 1:23:35And I think a lot of us say, well, I'm vegan, so I'm saving X amount of number of animals.
- 1:23:42But that's all you're saving.
- 1:23:44You need to save more.
- 1:23:45And those are the kinds of people that are who are content to share recipes and talk
- 1:23:49about restaurant offerings and hey, that's all fine.
- 1:23:52But please make have to take the next step.
- 1:23:56Because the animals, as Nicole said, desperately need us.
- 1:24:00And we feel that if you think back in our history, every great social justice movement
- 1:24:06has started in the streets with protests, whether it's gender rights, sexual orientation,
- 1:24:13civil rights, obviously, right down the line.
- 1:24:16So animal rights is no different.
- 1:24:18You have to voice your outrage.
- 1:24:20You have to let the average person know there's something wrong here.