Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Where Is Our World Going: Brave New World, Animal Farm, or 1984? | Dr. Ernest Nasto
Transcript
- 0:25Coming live from Chicago. USA is our guest tonight.
- 0:30Welcome to this very special edition of the cage, a
- 0:32masterclass life. The show, which ensures that you
- 0:35profit from your time. Spent here with experts, either
- 0:39through their insights information or simply learning
- 0:42from them. And today we have dr.
- 0:46Earnestness toe Albanian, American political analyst,
- 0:50lecturer, and public policy expert, with college teaching
- 0:53experience in a Albania, France and Kosovo.
- 0:56Welcome to the show. So welcome to India.
- 1:01Thank you very much Jay for this invitation.
- 1:04Thank you. Very happy to talk with you.
- 1:08Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:08And it's a pleasure to have you on the show.
- 1:12So sir, you have grown up in a communist Albania and your
- 1:16approach on different subjects about politics and society would
- 1:19be quite original for our audiences.
- 1:23And that's, that's something I am.
- 1:24Very excited to understand from your point of view, things from
- 1:29your point of view, and that's why we'll be talking about about
- 1:32world politics, about American politics about how much was
- 1:37happening. And in what, what extent, also
- 1:39as an outsider as an Albanian, who is now in the u.s., how does
- 1:44he see everything? And how the way we are seeing
- 1:47though, future of the world through your eyes will try to
- 1:51understand. So firstly is that a growing
- 1:54Going up after a growing up in communist Albania and then to
- 1:59the US. What is it that you see now in
- 2:03the US and what, what was your perception when you are seeing
- 2:08the u.s. from Albania, okay? Growing up in Albania a.j. was a
- 2:14very oh. So very original and peculiar
- 2:17experience because Albania as that time was the most closed
- 2:23country in the It was like a North Korea of Europe if you
- 2:30want. It was the harshest Communist
- 2:34dictatorship in Eastern Europe and the country being closed, we
- 2:40could only watch. I would say, our only window to
- 2:46the outside world was the Italian TV and radio.
- 2:51Obviously right radio was easier, but also, So it hasn't
- 2:55TV. So lots of information about the
- 2:57outside world came from there and also from books and
- 3:03magazines that we still have access through different
- 3:07channels. You know.
- 3:09But that was our our knowledge of the outside world.
- 3:14I mean I'm not talking about the knowledge that was transmitted
- 3:19by our by the previous generation.
- 3:23Like they were saying that Albania was not always like
- 3:26that, the the Communists are not the best people that you can
- 3:33that you can choose to run the government.
- 3:35And there was there were there was a lot of persecution of the
- 3:41of descent at that time. And but the main, the main, the
- 3:46main feature I would say was the closeness And then we were back.
- 3:54Now, speaking for myself, and for, for a certain group of
- 4:01people in the, in the capital and in other big cities of
- 4:05Albania, I will say that they were able to be in contact with
- 4:11with outside the word through Italian media and through all
- 4:16the books Etc. And so to keep, To keep
- 4:20ourselves at least, from from being totally brainwashed.
- 4:24That's what I am saying. And then when I went to France,
- 4:30after Albania, in 1989, I saw that.
- 4:36I was struck by the, by the difference is that I see.
- 4:40And I mean, curiously, enough and Jay one of the first
- 4:47memories that I have of. The differences was the bond of
- 4:51the abundance of information. You had information about what
- 4:58was in a certain way in a certain package of food.
- 5:03What what are the ingredients there?
- 5:07Even you have you have this even on bottle of water?
- 5:11Right. What what ingredients are in the
- 5:14Bowl, on, in a bottle of water? Which was, I mean, unseen of
- 5:19Albania. But this is, this is a little
- 5:20thing. Which stayed with me, the
- 5:22abundance of information, and we were coming from a society where
- 5:27the information was was totally control.
- 5:32That was the main, the main difference of a soul Okay.
- 5:38Okay, okay. Doctor National.
- 5:40Now if you look at it from being in Albania but how was the
- 5:47regime the government at that point in time?
- 5:50How did it present America u.s.? Yes.
- 5:55And you know and the European World much more of the Free
- 5:58World where people could have so much of information?
- 6:02How was that projected in your country at that point in time?
- 6:07Yes, there is even propaganda the Viewpoint of the regime
- 6:12propaganda was that America and the capitalist countries?
- 6:18The imperialist countries were the enemies of the true ideals
- 6:23of Communism and of the people's happiness you know and they were
- 6:29trying to To quell any, any good example?
- 6:35That communist? Little Albania was giving to the
- 6:38world. They are saying that everybody
- 6:43starting with American imperialism but also European
- 6:50capitalists. And later on the Soviet, they
- 6:56call the the Soviets social imperialism because they did not
- 7:00agree with their, their version of Communism.
- 7:04I mean, albanians or communist, but they didn't did not agree
- 7:08with Soviet version. Because the Soviet version was a
- 7:11little bit more open that our version.
- 7:15So they were saying that both sides, both those two
- 7:19superpowers have Albania in there.
- 7:22A in their target. They want to oppress us.
- 7:26They want to to destroy us and we have to stand firm and it
- 7:31exactly the propaganda that you hear today from North Korea.
- 7:35That's what I made the The comparison because it is easier
- 7:40for people to to listen, to day, to be familiar today with a
- 7:45North Korean propaganda. They are the only ones stay
- 7:48standing up etcetera, and that was Albania that time.
- 7:55I hope in the middle of all that.
- 7:57I would say that the regime they've been regime did not
- 8:02manage to make albanians anti-American because when there
- 8:09is Jim called the Communist Regime fell in 1990 91 albanians
- 8:15turned out to be a mean according to all polls the most
- 8:19Pro American country almost in the world.
- 8:24Because America was seen as the historical.
- 8:27I President Wilson during the Versailles conference in now,
- 8:321919 had their sure the rights of little of small countries to
- 8:39be governed by themselves, the right of ethnic groups to be to
- 8:46be self-governing. And to be independent.
- 8:50And that's why we we had that that admiration for America So,
- 8:57when I came to America, I mean, in 97, after eight years in
- 9:01France, I saw that. I mean, I started to follow
- 9:06American politics very closely. I've been writing and appearing
- 9:12in Albanian met yet, honors villain media for for those me
- 9:17to talk about these issues. But there isn't really what I do
- 9:22not like, and I see with a little bit of Being trapping.
- 9:29Then I would say that I see a lot of Aspects of American
- 9:38political life being similar to what, what happening what was
- 9:43happening, in Albania like the totalitarian totalitarian,
- 9:48Tendencies from both sides of the aisle.
- 9:53And that's what really, really it's troubling to me.
- 9:57And I can give you examples right?
- 10:00Right now, dr. Nicastro, one thing I want to 10
- 10:05for the audience is that you went to France.
- 10:08So you saw that abundance of information about things, but a
- 10:12lot of people in your country at that point in time, perhaps did
- 10:17not have that opportunity to only to see that word in its
- 10:23real form. The Democratic where you can
- 10:25say, or the open world, the European world or the American
- 10:28system. Then how come they were in spite
- 10:34of the regime or the government at that.
- 10:36In point, I'm being opposed to the American system, America
- 10:41American policies. How we're Albanian, people still
- 10:47pro-american way of living. How was that happening with?
- 10:53This happened? Exactly.
- 10:54In that way because as I said, Albania was very poor.
- 10:59Or that time like North Korea, you know, keep in mind, not
- 11:04North Korea, who can understand will be new Albania.
- 11:06So now we were seeing on Italian TV, the abundance of
- 11:14capitalistic Society. And we are seeing I mean,
- 11:18American movies. Etc.
- 11:19So we knew how the capitalist world was from a material
- 11:25standpoint. So everybody, you know, that so
- 11:30when there is Jim fell in 1991 basically end of 1990.
- 11:37Then everybody wanted to get to that research to the to that
- 11:44great wealth of capitalism as a right at the same moment, I mean
- 11:51right away. And that's why lots of people
- 11:54left Albania to go to the west to enjoy this kind of new, new
- 12:02life of abundance of abundance that we're seeing on TV.
- 12:08But when for lot for lots of them, you know, it's it turned
- 12:13out to be not that easy, but still, but still people were
- 12:19happier that they were able to leave Albanian.
- 12:22To improve their own conditions. And then they started to become
- 12:29accustomed to the new rules in the west to live in in free
- 12:34societies where you can say anything and nobody is going to
- 12:40come after you and the same system was established in you
- 12:45know Vania to after the change of regime because there was a
- 12:49democratic system which was Implemented in Albania with a
- 12:55help of Western allies. And there was there was to rule
- 13:01a plurality of of parties. There were lots of new parties
- 13:07that were created free elections.
- 13:09Etc, etc. So Pharmacy it was, it was made
- 13:15function functioning western-type democracy but very
- 13:20corrupted. So this is another Subject.
- 13:24But I wanted to say, from a formal point of view, albanians
- 13:28could say, even in Albania, anything that they want, without
- 13:34being in danger of persecution or anything.
- 13:37So everything changed, that's how they got used, right?
- 13:43And then your life, also, chased you move to that us and that was
- 13:48the first time looking at u.s. from outside.
- 13:53Active. Yeah, it was different land.
- 13:56Then you landed there and then you are seeing it from your own
- 14:00eyes. You had your own way to write up
- 14:03the ladder. So what did you see as an
- 14:07outsider? And what did you find?
- 14:10When you solve when you actually touch that line?
- 14:13And what has been your experience in terms of the
- 14:17politics down there? In terms of the general
- 14:20population in terms of do they also have A propaganda in a
- 14:25different form. Maybe maybe not in that
- 14:28authoritarian manner, but different interests are
- 14:31involved. I'm asking several questions at
- 14:34the same time so that you can answer them at your own
- 14:37business. Doug propaganda propaganda.
- 14:40Nevertheless. That's that's, that's a good way
- 14:43to describe it. Yes.
- 14:46First of all, I saw that, my husband American society was
- 14:51very well organized. Everything was functioning.
- 14:55Well, I mean, if you see it from from steal, from from an
- 14:58outsider viewpoint, but then, when you get to know it more,
- 15:03you see that there are entrenched interests who are
- 15:09able to control the flow of information.
- 15:15Right. And these, these entrenched
- 15:18interests, I was able to see for myself, are controlled by the
- 15:24so-called Elites. The wealthy Elites which
- 15:32unfortunate is unfortunate to say, they they direct the the
- 15:39issues that they want to people to be to be worried about, they
- 15:46direct their these issues to be in their own interest.
- 15:50So they don't want. For example, the people to be
- 15:55worried about the economic inequality, which is really,
- 16:01really large here in this country, but they want people to
- 16:06worry about cultural issues. Like, gay marriage, abortion
- 16:20entertainment, they want people to, to worry what Kim Kardashian
- 16:28is doing today. And what is she going to do
- 16:31tomorrow? So it's, I see this as a form of
- 16:36propaganda J, because it's directing people away.
- 16:42From the real problems of their everyday, their daily existence.
- 16:49It's I mean, this was the eye. I noticed that little by little,
- 16:56it was the the politics of of Kardashians of being being
- 17:06always in thralls by this, by this famous people and trying to
- 17:13imitate their what or to or to listen to what they say one when
- 17:19we know very well, that they don't have anything special to
- 17:22say, because they they are not qualified qualified to talk
- 17:28about politics and still, they are very prominent or we have
- 17:34this now with this New Tendencies.
- 17:39From the from the left, we see that the propaganda from the
- 17:44left is that the, the Western system and the American system
- 17:51in particular is oppressive. At least I cannot understand
- 17:56that all how they can not accept or deny all the achievements of
- 18:05America. And of the western system on the
- 18:11other side, on the other side of the of the aisle, you have that
- 18:16propaganda churned out by by the right.
- 18:21Bye-bye concerned by conservative media.
- 18:24Situations where they say that any policy, any common good
- 18:30policy that the government can try to implement will take us
- 18:38one step further towards the Socialist system.
- 18:44And when they talk about socialist system, they talk
- 18:47about the Soviet style icon type of dictatorship and this I find
- 18:54totally Ali, unbelievable. It's absurd to have this battle
- 18:59of capitalism versus socialism because it doesn't make any
- 19:04sense. I will say LJ that this is a
- 19:07remnant of the Cold War. These are two economic systems,
- 19:12first of all, in the first place.
- 19:14But they become, they became ideological during the Cold War.
- 19:21For known reasons, they were two systems with Soviet Union was
- 19:25there. So the Americans had to find A
- 19:31way of standing up to that. And that's why capitalism became
- 19:38an ideology when it's not an ideology.
- 19:42It's, it's a, it's a not economic system, which was
- 19:46proven to be much, more Superior than the Socialist system of
- 19:50Soviet Union. And that was it.
- 19:53And that's why the West Was victorious in the, in the Cold
- 19:59War. The Socialist system crumbled
- 20:02upon its own under its own weight.
- 20:08Right? But this propaganda is very very
- 20:12prevalent today in American in the American landscape in the
- 20:18American discourse. They this is the propaganda that
- 20:22comes from the from the right. That's all, that's why I'm
- 20:25emphasizing it. They say like a very
- 20:30common-sense policy like Universal Health Care.
- 20:32For example, this will take us one step towards The Soviet type
- 20:40dictatorship. This is, this is absurd.
- 20:45We saw that when we when we had the great debate about the
- 20:50universal, not not with universal health care about
- 20:54about Obamacare in 2009 2010 we saw the Tea Party Movement
- 21:00talking about death panels etc, etc.
- 21:03So the looming, the looming fear was that this is socialism And
- 21:11socialism is the Soviet style which is not true at all.
- 21:18It they would say that we can get to the, to a socialist
- 21:23system gradually by the government taking over different
- 21:28sectors of economy. When we know that this agyei has
- 21:34never happened in the history of the world, you cannot name a
- 21:39single all communist dictator who came to power that way by
- 21:46taking over parts of the economy.
- 21:49One part today. One part tomorrow.
- 21:53All all the Communist regimes of you is that we saw in the East
- 21:57Eastern Europe or in Asia. There were, they they came to
- 22:03power as a result of exceptional circumstances.
- 22:05The World War One, Russia World War Two Eastern Europe, China
- 22:10Vietnam, Etc. So that that was the reason and
- 22:15it has nothing to do with Western democracy, going little
- 22:20by little that way. Which is the message, which is
- 22:24given here. That's why I am really
- 22:26flabbergasted to hear this kind of misinformation propagated by
- 22:32the, by the, by the right wing, and the left wing has its own
- 22:38faults and absurdities. Also, Okay, so the left wing and
- 22:44the right wing, are fighting each other.
- 22:46And the plane is not able to take off the play.
- 22:49The the plane is not able to take off because it looks like
- 22:54nobody is able to talk about to talk for the for the middle
- 23:00class EJ. And I believe that was.
- 23:05I mean, let me say in passing, that was one of the great
- 23:12reasons that the Maga movement and the Trump phenomenon came on
- 23:19the scene. The great polarization because
- 23:23nobody is taking the interests of the Middle America,
- 23:28seriously. Okay, okay, okay, that Doctrine
- 23:33Astro. Now let me ask you.
- 23:35A couple questions here, sure in a socialist or socialism system,
- 23:41the factors of production are basically owned by the
- 23:45government state and then they distribute according to what
- 23:49they think best, yes, in a capitalist system.
- 23:54There it is. There say that you work hard and
- 23:58you play hard. And after you enjoy hard,
- 24:02whoever works hard and gets the money.
- 24:04Yes. But you're the way you have put,
- 24:07it seems that the Cold War still exists in a different format,
- 24:13may be of different sort of a propaganda.
- 24:15Yeah. In the minds of people that
- 24:17socialism is still a threat somewhere.
- 24:20Now if that is the propaganda where as for Kim Kardashian, if
- 24:26I am even pronouncing it, correctly becomes more important
- 24:32than other more important things of life.
- 24:35Then I want to understand from your understanding that who is
- 24:40doing it. Who is still carrying on with
- 24:43this cold war remnants. And why are they doing it?
- 24:48What are they achieving from this?
- 24:51Sure. Okay, not enough for this is
- 24:54Jay. I have to take a step back and
- 24:59talk a little bit, very shortly about the policies that were
- 25:04implemented in America during the so-called New Deal during
- 25:10emslie are Roosevelt years right?
- 25:14After the Great Depression of 1929 33.
- 25:21So what happened? was that the governor of the
- 25:28Roosevelt administration with its policies with a with a great
- 25:34with mass intervention of the government in the economy to
- 25:40open you to make top to open, lots of to have a new lots of
- 25:49job openings, you know, and to create Alec Works to create all
- 25:54those agencies, National Tennessee, Tennessee, valet of
- 25:59Valley Authority National, Recovery Administration, etc,
- 26:03etc. So the message, I mean, I wanted
- 26:07to be to be brief here. So, the message that was given
- 26:10by the new deal policies was this, The Government Can can
- 26:15work for you. That was the matches that was
- 26:19given to the American people by by the, by the New Deal.
- 26:25Now, the the New Deal had always its discontents the big
- 26:32corporations. There are lots of people who did
- 26:36not like these, this kind of intervention intervention
- 26:40because they thought that that would be a first step towards
- 26:47All encompassing socialist dictatorship.
- 26:51Now I will say that that at that time, they were right because
- 26:55the Soviet Union was there. So, there was a model of
- 27:00socialist State dictatorship. So this this strand of all these
- 27:10New Deal, New Deal New Deal discount discontents.
- 27:14I would say LED very prominently by the great Economist Friedrich
- 27:20Hayek. They came together and they put
- 27:26some put together, some principles, which came to be
- 27:29known as the neoliberalism, which said that the markets
- 27:36should be left alone. We should we should not accept
- 27:40any intervention of government in the in the economy or very,
- 27:45very little and the individual, the the call the corporate of
- 27:50the corporation should should have always the main the main
- 27:54say, No, this was this was good for men.
- 28:00This, this worked for some time because the the brought the
- 28:08programs that were implemented by the New Deal were not taken
- 28:14away. Even when the Republicans were
- 28:16in the height of White House under Eisenhower, for example,
- 28:21so they were like they were they were part of the American
- 28:28American society since then since the 1930s when they were
- 28:34implemented. Then little by little after the
- 28:4070s. When with, with the new with new
- 28:45political, New Economic Policy set up by a Reagan.
- 28:50Those started to be to be turned around because there were a lot
- 28:57of under Reagan. For example, there were a lot of
- 29:00tax cut for the wealthy and the Gap between the rich and the
- 29:08poor started to grow enormously. A little a little fact is that
- 29:14starting in 79 or 80, if I'm not mistaken, the productivity, the
- 29:21increase of the productivity and the increase in the increase of
- 29:26of wages, which up to, that time, had been gone going side
- 29:31by side. They started to go sideways.
- 29:36Productivity was was increasing our increased in 2018, compared
- 29:46to nine to nineteen, seventy nine 3.3.5 times faster than
- 29:53the, than the wages. Which means that they the
- 29:57productivity was increase, it much faster, which means that
- 30:02the gains from Productivity were not enjoyed by the People, by
- 30:06the salaries, by the, by the, by the wage earners.
- 30:10And then this was one of the factors which made polarization.
- 30:15I mean, I mean, okay, the gap between between the rich and the
- 30:21poor, then you have the globalization which which had
- 30:26the same effects with middle class, losing the losing
- 30:32employment. I was going to China or to
- 30:36Southeast Asia, and then you had the, the final, the final
- 30:40coffin. The final nail on the coffin of
- 30:44this narrow liberalism was the crisis of 2008.
- 30:48The mismanagement means management of the crisis of
- 30:512008. After 2008, a.j. the people got
- 30:56the different, the opposite message of the New Deal.
- 31:00The government is not Working for you anymore.
- 31:06And that was the message that Donald Trump seized on.
- 31:12And he with that message, he was able to win the election of
- 31:172016, as you know. And that was the the
- 31:23contribution of the main contribution to that.
- 31:26I would say Donald Trump brought to the American political scene.
- 31:30He told the people, the government is not work.
- 31:33Working for you anymore. So the system has to be Changed
- 31:41or radically changed. And that's why people in 2016
- 31:46voted for two candidates will, we were both anti-establishment
- 31:52Sanders and Trump. Now, Sanders was, he was not
- 32:00able to win over his party's establishment, but Rambo was so,
- 32:07the rest is history. But these were the economic
- 32:13reasons of this great polarization, which brought
- 32:16Trump to power. Right.
- 32:20So now who is the come country voting for, who is the American
- 32:26public looking for to take care of themselves?
- 32:30Because somebody who was trying to change all that lost and
- 32:36somebody who is, you know, there is this whole propaganda and all
- 32:42that stuff. Which is difficult for a for a
- 32:44person sitting far off in a country called India.
- 32:48How Billion be make out of it. Because then why is what is the
- 32:52public afraid of socialism? And what are they actually get
- 32:57tight? Now means the are their hosts in
- 33:00the air. That is keeping you afraid.
- 33:03Why I'm asking you is this that American System, American
- 33:07influence is going to is very much on a large part of the
- 33:11world, either in terms of economy in terms of politics
- 33:16globally also, which way Planet will go and every other aspect.
- 33:23So that is where it becomes very important, even in the flow of
- 33:28information. Because now, you understand that
- 33:31the flow of information in France, or Germany, is different
- 33:35than the flow of information in, in a country called USA.
- 33:39How do you see it all the way? All this sitting down there, mr.
- 33:44Nashville. That's how I see.
- 33:47I see that way AJ after the election of 2020.
- 33:55I think the the Maga movement. Led by Donald Trump made a big
- 34:02mistake by undermining the institutions.
- 34:09I say that because in every democracy, no matter where it
- 34:16is, India Albania, Switzerland Norway, America France, the
- 34:25survival of democracy, I would say the Depends mainly on the
- 34:31attitude of the losing side. Why?
- 34:36Because in a in a democratic contest, after the election, The
- 34:44Winning Side would go and I would go ahead and implement it,
- 34:47so it's program. Okay, nothing?
- 34:50Nothing to nothing extraordinary there.
- 34:54But the losing side has two choices now.
- 35:00Either they will accept the result of the election and end
- 35:05of all their complaints in different levels of the
- 35:11Judiciary. Right?
- 35:16And at the end, they will say, okay, everything was decided
- 35:20against us, so we will accept that we lost, and we will try to
- 35:26improve our message for next time in four years and will have
- 35:32a chance to win again. And the other options that the
- 35:37losing side has is this. We are not going to accept the
- 35:43result and we are going to say that all the institutions are
- 35:49corrupt because for the for the only reason that they decided
- 35:55against us, So that's why you have these two options with
- 36:02losing side and in 2002, any the Republican Party, the Republican
- 36:07Party led by the Maga movement made the wrong choice.
- 36:12There are to choose the wrong option.
- 36:15I would say, they they decided to undermine democracy by
- 36:20attacking the institutions, by saying that institutions are
- 36:26captured by the, by the Liberals.
- 36:28Those by the enemies of the state, by the Deep state by this
- 36:32and by that. So we are going to undermine.
- 36:35We are not going to accept the legitimacy of the elections
- 36:39because they were. I mean, because we lost
- 36:43basically and this is the most damning the most damaging
- 36:49attitude that you can have in a democratic system.
- 36:52And that's why the opinion of the American on Democracy in the
- 36:59world has gone, really, really down?
- 37:03I would say, because of all this unfortunate deep a for no
- 37:10reason, that is happening in America.
- 37:13Only because one side does not want to accept that they lost.
- 37:21That's why I say it's it's it's it's it depends mostly on the
- 37:27attitude of the losing side. The losing side is the one who
- 37:33has to prefer to live in a democracy where they lose
- 37:39compared to living in a fake democracy where they can can
- 37:45always win. This is the, the trade that they
- 37:48have to do. Right right now, dr.
- 37:53Nash toe. Almost everybody knows what they
- 37:58want from the US. They were we great.
- 38:02They want to do business. They want to there so many
- 38:06hundreds of things, and even through about Kim Kardashian's,
- 38:09many people are interested. There are syndicated yellows and
- 38:12all those things. At one point in time, it was
- 38:15just come out of the newspaper. Even social media is quite
- 38:20impacted by that. Yes, but being from being in the
- 38:24US, Is what have you understood? What does America want from the
- 38:31world? Why why does it behave?
- 38:35In a particular manner the way it does, former President, Jimmy
- 38:40Carter, he said that us is the worst war mongering some some
- 38:45something like that country in the world that is been at War
- 38:49for quite number of years, over different issues.
- 38:52So what is in your opinion? What does the US want from the
- 38:57world? now, us wants to To dominate the
- 39:04world, but not through, not through the old system of
- 39:10colonialism. And that's a big difference.
- 39:14I would say us, if you look through their history, they
- 39:20never had any goals of of taking over countries as colonies.
- 39:31Because they were convinced that they could dominate through the
- 39:37free trade. And the free trade which means
- 39:42the interest of the higher classes in America and the free
- 39:49trade was the the instrument of of world domination.
- 39:57It was similar to the to the British Empire, but British
- 40:00Empire had colonies. Also.
- 40:03But they were, they were big in trade as well.
- 40:06Now America did not have a colonial Empire but they were
- 40:12they wanted to dominate by going through through the, through the
- 40:17free, the free trade. So what happened is that the the
- 40:25principles of American democracy Of the western principles of
- 40:31America wanted to impose in all over the world because they were
- 40:36under the impression that if the countries become like us, then
- 40:39they will, they will trade freely with them.
- 40:43And it will be in our own interest but will promote
- 40:46democracy to. Now, the difference with the
- 40:52difference in this Viewpoint, compared to 1945 when the UN was
- 40:58created as was. And when the world system was
- 41:02created dominated by the United States is that those liberal
- 41:10ideas liberal democracy, Ideas can be implemented or even
- 41:19forced to be implemented when you are the sole superpower in
- 41:25the world. You can do that, but as the
- 41:29world has evolved and now the Europe is very powerful, you
- 41:35European Union is very, very powerful, you have the rise of
- 41:39China and of India as big powers.
- 41:43And you have also the rise of Russia, then you cannot do that
- 41:47anymore. You cannot offer. the the word
- 41:53unique system to follow, which would be the Western type
- 41:58democracy and liberalism And that's why now America sees
- 42:05itself struggling to maintain. Its it's all the dominance
- 42:12because it is caught in this contradiction.
- 42:17You could do that before. But you cannot do it. now, when
- 42:22others are becoming powerful, And that's the problem of the of
- 42:28the American dilemma today. Now, they were able to, to Rally
- 42:35NATO countries against putting and Aggression in Ukraine, okay?
- 42:43Which is which is good but then you see that those ideas of
- 42:48implementing democracy in China failed, you know, Tian an men
- 42:55events and also the opening of the World Trade Organization to
- 43:00China in 2000. They thought that by by liberal
- 43:05a liberalizing the trade with China.
- 43:07China would be would be adopting.
- 43:10Liberal ideas also on the political domain, which is not
- 43:14true. I mean, did not did not come
- 43:16true also, they will try to do that in Iraq.
- 43:22You remember the justifications that were that were given for
- 43:27the, for the war in Iraq, only, they will be very happy to to be
- 43:34with to be with us to become like us to implement the
- 43:37western-style Democracy in your life.
- 43:39It turns out that there are many Societies in the world who do
- 43:43not want a liberal Western democracy.
- 43:47And you cannot force them and the experiences in Iraq and in
- 43:52Afghanistan, prove that right, prove.
- 43:56The the shortfalls of the liberal ideas of the, this
- 44:04liberal Viewpoint of Western democracy, they cannot work Now,
- 44:10as as, as long as the, as far as the warmongering you said that,
- 44:16why America has always have an issue with with Wars and with
- 44:21guns. I think there are historical
- 44:23reasons because you have to keep in mind that the American
- 44:27Revolution a.j. was the main big upheaval or the revolution in
- 44:34modern times which ended well It did not end in a in a bad in a
- 44:42blast in a bloodbath like the like the French Revolution.
- 44:47It did not end in a bloodbath as the Russian Revolution or the or
- 44:53as a Chinese Revolution. But it ended well.
- 44:56So that's why Americans have always a sympathy for for guns
- 45:02for For for dissolving, the resulting problems through
- 45:09through violence. By the barrel of a gun.
- 45:14This is one of the reasons. Okay.
- 45:18Okay, so now, looking from all these perspectives, America is
- 45:25the biggest democracy. Yes, India is the largest
- 45:30democracy. Yes.
- 45:32Now, we have had a mixed economy for quite a long time.
- 45:37Now, we take decisions. According we have the government
- 45:41sector, we have the private sector.
- 45:43We are making due with whatever we have in the best, man.
- 45:47Impossible, and we are still good democracy, a thriving
- 45:52democracy. Yes, you have got many, many
- 45:54political parties, not only at the central level, but also at
- 46:00the state state. Yes.
- 46:02Very and I sometimes wonder why America is still.
- 46:06There is a two-party system. Then then there is it's like
- 46:12when you talk of a free market then you don't obviously talk
- 46:16about. Monopoly and duopoly or
- 46:18oligopoly. You talk about a free market.
- 46:21You can't talk of a free market and talk about Monopoly and
- 46:24duopoly or maximum oligopoly, but they're also, you have got,
- 46:29you know, people can same amount of P.
- 46:31Same people controlling the system there.
- 46:35So, in that perspective, what is it for the developing world?
- 46:40Now, we are a developing world, but we are on the verge of
- 46:43breaking that barrier and moving towards it.
- 46:45You that develop. Category, but still we we are
- 46:50synchronized with a big part of the word that is together in
- 46:54either, in terms of culture, in terms of the ideals of
- 46:58democracy, in terms of achieving things, as human beings, either
- 47:04is even even for contribution to climate, you know, restoration
- 47:09or Net, Zero and everything. What is it?
- 47:13Then that we can or other countries in the developing
- 47:17world can take from the US. If they're their freedom ideas?
- 47:22Or you can say the Democratic ideas are different and where
- 47:28there is so much of internal rambling within that American
- 47:32System itself with so many parties and how is it treated
- 47:36their treated much different than that of China?
- 47:39Which everybody wants to have business with the word?
- 47:42Word. The and, and they have their own
- 47:44ways, that what is it for the rest of the world to take from
- 47:47the US now, except going to the US and taking a big bite out of
- 47:52the Big Apple. Yes.
- 47:56Is through lots of people from all over the world, want to come
- 48:00to the u.s. and because the main the main advantage that the that
- 48:07the u.s. system offers Edge a compared to other Western
- 48:11countries. I would say is that there is no
- 48:18the the American society is not elitist like the Europeans Which
- 48:25means you are not discriminated against here.
- 48:31Because you are not a native-born American.
- 48:36You are not from, you are not from you.
- 48:38You are an immigrant because in some, in some in some way, in
- 48:43some kind of meaning, everybody here is an immigrant.
- 48:48So there is this larger and more profound acceptance of the
- 48:54other. if this has been historically, true, It's much
- 49:01easier for foreign Albanian or for an Indian on for further,
- 49:07Senegalese to tweet to be integrated here.
- 49:12Then in then in Europe, I would say and this is one of the Of
- 49:21the big advantages of the of the American system.
- 49:23Now, as far as the, the Democratic model that America
- 49:28offers, I would say that one of the biggest assets that America
- 49:38had until the last election was the exemplary passage of power
- 49:47peaceful. Enough power.
- 49:52Mmm. Unfortunately, everybody saw
- 49:55that, this was no longer true in 2020 because the power was not
- 50:03passed peacefully. And still today, as I said, most
- 50:12of the Republicans do not accept Joe Biden as a legitimate
- 50:17president, they say the election was stolen.
- 50:21So, this is not a good example for those developing countries
- 50:26which want to implement a democratic system.
- 50:30But the Democracy in itself, I would say in developing
- 50:34confidence would have lots to do with the National Council.
- 50:43The national features of the of the country itself.
- 50:47For example, account democracy would be very successful in
- 50:53societies where the level of trust is high.
- 50:59You have to, to have a high level of trust.
- 51:05If you, if you want to do, think that the your elected officials
- 51:12will work in your interest, you have to believe them, you have
- 51:16to trust them that they will do the best.
- 51:20That's why I say it has to. It has a lot to do, is trust in
- 51:27society. So, for Here's where the trust
- 51:30is high. Democracy is much easier to
- 51:32implement for cultures where the trust is low.
- 51:37Then they would have much more corruption.
- 51:41Much more problems in implementing democracy.
- 51:44I see that in my country of Albania is very hard to
- 51:47implement a very functioning democracy there because of
- 51:51bananas, don't trust themselves. Don't trust their their, their
- 51:56fellow countrymen. They think that everybody is
- 51:59corrupt. Everybody is out to steal.
- 52:02And to, to benefit for themselves, nobody is, is his
- 52:08head, is having the public good at heart.
- 52:11So, that's why it's hard. And not only has been about some
- 52:15other countries of the East where those newly implemented,
- 52:19democracies are having a bumpy road.
- 52:23Cause of this trust issue, and I would say the same is in is true
- 52:27for, for India, for other developing countries, right?
- 52:32But I would say, also, this a.j. that democracy is not
- 52:38necessarily A condition, a basic condition for economic
- 52:47prosperity. Guys, not, we have examples.
- 52:51For example, of the of the four Asian tigers, they were all
- 52:58under dictatorships when they achieve their greatest Economic
- 53:02Development, right? South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore.
- 53:09They were all under Auto Ray authoritative authoritarian
- 53:15leaders. So it's not a democracy and
- 53:20economic Prosperity. Don't go hand in hand.
- 53:24That's my point, but America has a lots of a lot of good good
- 53:30features tool to offer. For example, the mass
- 53:34participation in local level, Americans are very passionate
- 53:39about voting, especially in local lab in local levels.
- 53:44And also I would say that America gives some historical
- 53:51examples of really, really bipartisanship and I would give
- 53:56you one example of President. Lincoln, second inauguration,
- 54:06Speech. When in the middle of bloody
- 54:10war, they were killing each other during the Civil War in
- 54:14nineteen, sixty sixty-five. He said that we don't have to
- 54:20have any malice through each other, but we have to pray to
- 54:24God that this this bad thing of the of the war, this this curse
- 54:35of the War is taken away from us.
- 54:37And we have to, to heal the, the wounds of everybody.
- 54:41So he spoke not, as a representative of one side of
- 54:48the north, he was the president of the United States of America,
- 54:53but he spoke, as a president of all America, and this is
- 54:58something to keep in mind if for if, for any leader who wants to
- 55:04follow, Bipartisan. Path.
- 55:09I would say they have to speak for the interest of all the
- 55:13people not of their party alone which recently has not been the
- 55:18case. But okay, what can you do?
- 55:22Right, we have to speak truth. So in this times of polarization
- 55:28of American politics, Where does it take the word?
- 55:33Because you see America everybody looks at in terms of,
- 55:37as I said, as we discussed democracy, in terms of economic,
- 55:43in terms of see the big five, big tech companies are they are
- 55:48mostly from the US. So that's going to take the
- 55:53world towards the next stage. Yes, all the humanity towards
- 55:57the next stage. Even there are other countries
- 56:00but it's Actually the US and America u.s. is also such a big
- 56:05economic power in terms of because it's it's a lots of
- 56:09consumers also without it. There is there is no sin, no
- 56:16particular. It's like the engine of a train
- 56:21almost like in so many aspects people look up.
- 56:24So how do you see it impacting the way we will move forward as
- 56:31you. Entity as individuals if there
- 56:33is continuing sort of a polarization and there is no
- 56:39clear distinction between what America is an any other country
- 56:46in the deepest corner of the world is in terms of the way
- 56:50they are politics happens. Now, I will say that the big,
- 56:55the big danger in this in our time a.j. is Not that we are
- 57:02going to go through towards the Socialist world as I said, as I
- 57:10said, is the main propaganda here in this country with no
- 57:14basis at all? But we are going to go through
- 57:19towards the model which would be more similar to the famous
- 57:25Brave, New World of Aldous Huxley. why I'm saying that
- 57:31because you see the big accumulation of wealth at the
- 57:35top with a big tech companies, you see your see the the next,
- 57:43the next groups of of economic actors which are the media and
- 57:53the Academia, for example, or the math, the middle managers
- 57:58who Those groups at the top who serve the top and then you have
- 58:06the small small businesses and the worker bees, who are always,
- 58:13they find it more and more difficult to go ahead to be
- 58:20socially mobile. So, if we remember from from the
- 58:28Brave New World, it was a world where the state would entertain
- 58:35to no end the masses. So the masses were always
- 58:40entertain But they are not allowed to to think for
- 58:46themselves. So they they were in a state of
- 58:51happy servitude, they were servants but we were happy with
- 58:56that. And curiously enough.
- 59:00Aldous Huxley, put it that way in 1958, he said, so the first
- 59:07half, if he said of the 20th century of the 12th century was
- 59:13the age of technical engineers. Because, you know, you know
- 59:19basins are Industrial Revolution, etc, etc.
- 59:23Then the second half is said, is going to be the age of social
- 59:29engineers. And we saw that a lot with the
- 59:34communist state, the Communist system, they were trying to do,
- 59:38lots of social engineering and he said, maybe after that, the
- 59:4421st century would be The age of world controllers.
- 59:51Like in the Brave New World they were controlling because they
- 59:56were supplying endless entertainment.
- 1:00:01And endless Kardashian is MM, right?
- 1:00:06And everybody was entertained and about.
- 1:00:09It was thinking about there, I mean, more more fundamental
- 1:00:15issues of like, the mean they were fed.
- 1:00:19They were not. They're not, they're not must
- 1:00:23starving, but they were just thoughtless servants.
- 1:00:28And that's where I see the biggest danger.
- 1:00:31Going now, of the world going now with those high tech,
- 1:00:36Companies of the, at the top, the masses of the media and the
- 1:00:40middle manager serving them. And then the, the struggle is
- 1:00:45with the middle class the small owners.
- 1:00:50If you want small ownership, small proprietor Proprietors
- 1:00:55which with with with the workers of the, of the workers of the of
- 1:01:02the Element of lower lower functions.
- 1:01:08They are always struggling to to get ahead.
- 1:01:12And we see that the social Mobility has been totally.
- 1:01:17It has been decreasing a lot even in America between, for
- 1:01:22example, 1940s and 1950s. It has been decreasing and this
- 1:01:28is not a good thing and how we can counter that this this this
- 1:01:34nail feudalism. If we keep the same, I like this
- 1:01:40Thomson. Yeah, it's a near feudalism.
- 1:01:45According to the amine, to the parallels with the France before
- 1:01:49the Revolution, the three Estates.
- 1:01:52And we can we can counter that by resisting and by by telling
- 1:01:58the truth. Bye-bye telling those big guys
- 1:02:03in in the big Tech Open. He's that.
- 1:02:08The accumulation of wealth is not good is harmful for the
- 1:02:12society and the government has to do to implement masses, good
- 1:02:19common, good policies to reduce the gap between the rich and the
- 1:02:24poor. Because if the Gap is large,
- 1:02:27then the message of you are conveying to the lower classes,
- 1:02:31is that the system is rigged. That is the message that is
- 1:02:36conveyed like this large gap. People can accept that the CEO
- 1:02:42can be like 30 times or it or at most 50 times smarter than me
- 1:02:51the lower worker. But it's, it's hardly acceptable
- 1:02:56that the CEO is 400 smarter than me or more capable than me than
- 1:03:03the than the worker. I mean, which is energy, which
- 1:03:08is the difference now in America, right, whether smarter
- 1:03:11or not. But in terms of maybe you, in
- 1:03:14terms of paycheck capability here, but just because the, the
- 1:03:18paycheck has to reflect the capability, right?
- 1:03:22The aptitude It is, is hard to imagine.
- 1:03:27Somebody is, is 400 times more capable right under our class.
- 1:03:37So, tell me that if this big companies and which are mostly
- 1:03:42American, yes, where does that leave the rest of the world, do
- 1:03:46you think the European Union will Whiteley be, just
- 1:03:49entertained and, and get lost into all these things or is It
- 1:03:54so powerful entertainment that they will let it let it fully
- 1:03:59and cross them. What about China?
- 1:04:01China is still kept its it intact.
- 1:04:05What about India? We have our soft power.
- 1:04:07We have got our culture's that can still keep a lot of people
- 1:04:12across the world. Don't have a mobile phone even
- 1:04:15now they don't have shoes to wear.
- 1:04:17Where will they get this? They will be not taking are
- 1:04:20accepting this sort of an entertainment.
- 1:04:22So is it that just Us. Some companies look to be
- 1:04:27controlling in some manners. Does it mean it actually
- 1:04:31encompasses the whole world? How do you see this?
- 1:04:35No, I said that Jay only because of the influence that the
- 1:04:41American system in general has upon the others.
- 1:04:45I don't say in that, India has to go the same route.
- 1:04:50And it would be a good thing. If India doesn't go the same
- 1:04:53route because of then, India would be an example for the
- 1:04:57Americans. Now, the, Chinese example, I
- 1:05:01would say it's a little bit different because we're you have
- 1:05:04a centralized right leadership, which is imposing there.
- 1:05:12Their control upon the economy but the what is special about
- 1:05:17China? I would say is that they they
- 1:05:20work with very long-term goals in mind.
- 1:05:27And this is, this is important. This is this is one of those
- 1:05:34advantages that an autocratic system can have compared to a
- 1:05:41democracy Because the decision making in in an autocracy is
- 1:05:48much easier and Rapid, then decision-making in a democracy,
- 1:05:55right? Because democracy can be messy,
- 1:05:58but still it offers people more satisfaction and we have seen
- 1:06:05with the example of Western European countries, I think
- 1:06:11gives us some good examples. Samples that where democracy is
- 1:06:16more developed. The lives of the people are, are
- 1:06:22really, really good, and improved, and how you slide that
- 1:06:28you see that in, in some, in lots of European countries in
- 1:06:33Canada, Australia, or New Zealand where the gap between
- 1:06:36the reason. The core is not so large as in
- 1:06:39America, and they have good. Good rankings in all societal
- 1:06:47indicators. Almost So it's it's not that
- 1:06:50they are against each other, but America is more individualistic.
- 1:06:54They are more towards common good policies and that's where
- 1:06:59America can try to imitate some of those, if that, if it were
- 1:07:05not for that propaganda. Just described.
- 1:07:09I guess, common good policies. Right, right.
- 1:07:13So now let's again start from Albania from where you began.
- 1:07:18Yes. And you saw that when you saw
- 1:07:21the u.s. from from Albania that point in time, when you visited
- 1:07:26France you looked at information as something which was very
- 1:07:30empowering. Then we escaped to the US you
- 1:07:34now see information not in the real form, but actually not
- 1:07:39empowering but controlling trying to control its Citizens.
- 1:07:43Yes, in the same way that propaganda or information in the
- 1:07:47form of propaganda, for propaganda in the form of
- 1:07:52information is doing the same thing.
- 1:07:55Do you think either you or the albanians back home, they're
- 1:08:02being pro-american all this while they were only as it's
- 1:08:07expecting just information in the form of propaganda
- 1:08:12propaganda. Died in the form of information
- 1:08:14or did they actually gain more than that, that they can still
- 1:08:18look at the American system? And the right example to take
- 1:08:23not just one country their region but the whole world
- 1:08:27forward. How do you look at it?
- 1:08:29If you are where transport back yourself in time, and look at
- 1:08:33the America today by being an Insider from an outsider's
- 1:08:39perspective, how do you look at it today and would you make the
- 1:08:41same choice? Isis, given that choice?
- 1:08:45I will say that the main, the main features and the main
- 1:08:49characteristics of the American system of are still laudable.
- 1:08:55Because the free flow of information is still there.
- 1:08:59Even if I see, as I said, is unfortunate that there are these
- 1:09:04authoritarian, Tendencies on both sides.
- 1:09:08On one side, you have on the right side of Of the political
- 1:09:13Spectrum you have a pure personality cult, I would say
- 1:09:19where everything is about Donald Trump and where the purity of
- 1:09:25the Purity is imposed by whatever.
- 1:09:30Whatever the leader says, and this is like our old system.
- 1:09:35But in the left, i j. I see, another kind of another
- 1:09:42sort of authoritarianism totalitarian ideology, it's not
- 1:09:49a cult of personality because the left the progressive left
- 1:09:53has not any any dominant figure yet dominant personality yet,
- 1:09:59but it's a cult of a certain ideology.
- 1:10:04And the ideology is that what we call enacted here in America,
- 1:10:11with a therm walk? The walk ideology where the
- 1:10:16system is totally oppressive. There is nothing.
- 1:10:21Good to be uploaded by the for the American system.
- 1:10:27They don't recognize any achievements at all, and they
- 1:10:31say that America was built on slavery.
- 1:10:35It has been oppressive. All the West has been
- 1:10:39colonialist, racist and patriarchal.
- 1:10:44System. And they do not achieve, they do
- 1:10:47not recognize any achievement, and these two are equally.
- 1:10:53Harmful, they are totalitarian, but in their own way, as I said,
- 1:10:57now, as an Albanian, I mean, real Benhams today, they should
- 1:11:02be very careful, not to embrace any of these, but what I see in
- 1:11:10Albania today, when I, when I, when I speak to to their knees,
- 1:11:14Tia, I see that they are more focused on the Issues of
- 1:11:21day-to-day life and of their problems with, with the
- 1:11:26neighbors with, with the serbs, with a graph with the Greeks,
- 1:11:31you know? And they do not think a lot
- 1:11:36about this walk ideology or are Maga ideology.
- 1:11:43There are a lot of people who like trampled and what about
- 1:11:49giving for. Whatever is it?
- 1:11:51What about Kim Kardashian? They talk about politics or
- 1:12:06whatever, they feel confident to walk to talk about with no, no
- 1:12:13basis at all. Only because they are famous.
- 1:12:18They are they are known entertainers, or they are known
- 1:12:23artists, or singers or whatever. It, which is the same logic as I
- 1:12:28said about about Kardashian, right?
- 1:12:32Right, I guess this is a phenomenon in a lot of other
- 1:12:36places also but perhaps they are there to serve, not only their
- 1:12:40own purpose but also for specific purposes of some people
- 1:12:44who still believe in their own system of looking at their word,
- 1:12:49the word. Yeah.
- 1:12:50This propane and less entertainment.
- 1:12:53For evolved frivolity rains, right, right?
- 1:12:59And whatever way we look at it, the fact is dr.
- 1:13:03Nash do that. You have given a very great
- 1:13:06perspective of not just as an outsider, but also as an Insider
- 1:13:13and from all these things, you are also given a peek into how
- 1:13:17you look at where the world is going, where the word politics
- 1:13:22is. And we're perhaps the future of
- 1:13:26humanity is bowing. And if not the right steps are
- 1:13:29taken then perhaps, we'll all be in a very, very difficult
- 1:13:34position. My last question is, how do
- 1:13:37people get more of your perspective?
- 1:13:39How do they connect with you? How do they know more about you?
- 1:13:43How does it work for them? They can find me on Facebook,
- 1:13:47basically. And on on Twitter, these are my
- 1:13:51my main Channels of social media.
- 1:13:55I always post on Facebook, all my period appearances in the
- 1:14:00media, what I write, which is more in Albanian but still by,
- 1:14:05alright, sometimes in English as well.
- 1:14:08So Facebook is the is the main is the main Channel and also
- 1:14:13Twitter Great. Great.
- 1:14:17On this note it's a wrap on this.
- 1:14:18Very special edition of the cage, a masterclass life.
- 1:14:21Thank you so much, indeed dr. Maestro for joining us and
- 1:14:26helping us with this whole 360 degree worldview.
- 1:14:31Thank you Jay. It was really a great pleasure
- 1:14:34talking to you. Thank you.