Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Hot Off the Press: NCUA Exam Priority Letter - Our Take
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:02episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04This is our fourth annual podcast on NCOA's Priority Letter, and I'm here with
- 0:10Steve Farr and Todd Miller of my team.
- 0:13Guys, how are you doing today?
- 0:16Steve Farrar: Doing good,
- 0:17Todd Miller: even
- 0:17Steve Farrar: though it's cold.
- 0:19Todd Miller: Doing well.
- 0:19Woke up last night with a sore throat and I've been sucking on cough drops
- 0:22for a few hours, but I feel good.
- 0:24I might sound a little off though today.
- 0:26Treichel: Yeah, so to those who've heard your voice before,
- 0:28they might say, hey, Todd's got something wrong with the speaker.
- 0:30It's actually his throat.
- 0:32So I hope you're, I hope we hope we don't ruin your throat for you today.
- 0:36But this is.
- 0:37I always say to clients or credit unions when I'm talking to them that
- 0:41the most important letter that NCUA comes out with is this priority letter.
- 0:45And the other day when it came out I don't know why this popped into my head,
- 0:50but I had a vision of Steve Martin in the movie, The Jerk when he's, when he gets
- 0:55all excited because the new phone books are here, the new phone books are here.
- 0:58And his phone, his name was in the phone book for the first time and
- 1:01he was really excited about it.
- 1:02He was somebody.
- 1:04Yeah, he was somebody right there.
- 1:07Exactly.
- 1:08And so I feel a little bit like Steve Martin when this letter comes out.
- 1:12And I I think last year I even did some predictions about
- 1:16what I thought would be in it.
- 1:17I did a separate podcast on that this year.
- 1:19It snuck up on me cause it came out a little bit early
- 1:21and we can maybe speak to that.
- 1:23Typically it's not out quite as quick.
- 1:24And I think we might have a sense as to but Yeah, so that's it.
- 1:29We've got we've got the priority letter and guys just in case somebody's
- 1:33hearing this podcast for the first time, could you give a little bit of
- 1:36your background at NCUA before you ended up departing and changing teams?
- 1:40Steve, what was it that you did at NCUA back in the day?
- 1:44Steve Farrar: I always break my career into two parts.
- 1:46The 1st half of it, 15 years or so was in the field predominantly as a
- 1:52problem case officer overseeing a lot of the worst problems predominantly in
- 1:57the western part of the United States, including dealing with conservatorships.
- 2:02A lot of special assistance and those types of and merger packages
- 2:07and those types of things.
- 2:08Then I shifted to the central office and working remotely for the most
- 2:13part for the next 15 plus years.
- 2:16And in the division of risk management and along those lines
- 2:20many things, including the training of the PCOs, which I really enjoyed.
- 2:26And then later I ended up writing a lot of regulations.
- 2:30Cause once you write one and it works and you know how to do it, you
- 2:33get pegged with doing that a lot.
- 2:34And the biggest one on that one would have been the risk based capital regulation.
- 2:38So that's sums my career up.
- 2:40Treichel: Very good.
- 2:41And Todd.
- 2:43Todd Miller: I'll break my career down into 3 parts for the 1st, 3rd of it.
- 2:47I followed Steve.
- 2:48We were hired by the same person.
- 2:50We were PCOs at the same time, although he did it a lot longer than
- 2:53I did, but I was an examiner PCO for about the 1st, 3rd of my career.
- 2:58The second third of my career, I spent a decade basically as a regional capital
- 3:04market specialist and doing a lot of the training on liquidity and interest rate
- 3:08risk for examiners and writing policy and exam processes back in that decade.
- 3:14That was basically from 2000 to 2010 from 2010 to when I retired in 2011, I
- 3:20was The director of special actions in the Western region, supervising problem
- 3:25case officers and the regional capital market specialists and a few other
- 3:29duties here and there along with that.
- 3:31But altogether, I spent 31 years with NC way in those 3 pieces.
- 3:35It was a very enjoyable 31 years.
- 3:40Treichel: Yeah, it was.
- 3:40It was.
- 3:41I had a good time there as well.
- 3:43And those problem credit unions, you always learn things.
- 3:46They learn things.
- 3:47And when those troubled institutions can be reborn and get back on the right
- 3:52path, whether it's a camel code improving or whether it's capital improving it,
- 3:56that was always fun to be part of.
- 3:57And we all played a big role in some of those.
- 4:00Now, this priority letter is an effort by NCUA to say, Hey, it's
- 4:04Here's how you stay out of trouble and they point out some things here,
- 4:08some trends and different things.
- 4:09But why don't we walk through the letter in order of what NCUA put
- 4:14them and first up on NCUA's priority letter this year is credit risk.
- 4:20Any general thoughts about what NCUA says here relative to credit risk and
- 4:26who wants to go first on this one?
- 4:30Steve Farrar: I'll hit it up since Todd's a little under the weather and
- 4:33put some general comments out there.
- 4:35The comments in this letter, particularly are real generalized.
- 4:40And they basically, if you look at the FPR for the industry.
- 4:45They, it's just real logical items that they noted that they put out there.
- 4:49And it talks about, delinquency rising and the 12 month charge off ratio rising.
- 4:57And, yes, so those are what are happening in, particularly in the area of credit
- 5:01cards and commercial real estate.
- 5:04One thing I did notice is I was comparing Credit unions results against what
- 5:09community banks reported and you end up with all the stuff through q3 And, they
- 5:14have the same thing going on as we do, but I found that 1 thing really interesting
- 5:18on the credit card delinquency, highly regionalized and I don't know exactly why.
- 5:23And I would imagine that we have the same thing going on in our credit unions.
- 5:28And particularly, it was like, the New York region had just a huge
- 5:33problem with the credit cards.
- 5:36And I think those could be driving a lot of the numbers.
- 5:39And there's a, and there is generally we consider that loan losses and
- 5:45credit quality is going to return to the norm because we've been outside of
- 5:49normal because of outside influences that have affected ever since
- 5:53covid and, even going back to 2008.
- 5:56So what is normal losses and that kind of drives what the allowance thing is.
- 6:01And it's normal is somewhere around the 0.
- 6:034 to 0.
- 6:045%.
- 6:05So we'll, I think we're going to see that PLL expense, return to normal.
- 6:10The only item under there that I am more concerned about is.
- 6:15When you look at the credit union systems allowance for loan losses against
- 6:20delinquency, we're running significantly a lower percentage of coverage than
- 6:27you'll see in the community banks.
- 6:29And that could be because of the difference of lack of commercial
- 6:34lending, but it's a pretty large difference and it makes me a little
- 6:38bit concerned that CECO reporting and maintaining their allowances adequately.
- 6:44Treichel: That's interesting.
- 6:45That's I hadn't picked up on that.
- 6:48Todd any thoughts on what Steve said or anything you'd like to
- 6:50add on the credit risk side?
- 6:52Todd Miller: I'll add a couple other nuances to the whole thing, and some of
- 6:56this is just the way the credit industry is react to the marketplace in the way.
- 7:01They've reacted to NCUA.
- 7:03As we come out of COVID and interest rate risk, our interest rates
- 7:07rose, NCUA really started beating people up on interest rate risk.
- 7:11Credit unions had very significant portfolios of underwater securities.
- 7:17How do they make up for that in earnings?
- 7:19For the most part, the industry has raised their loan to share ratio.
- 7:23You look at loan concentrations to capital credit cards have jumped from 36 to 50
- 7:29percent of net worth real estate loans.
- 7:32And you would assume with the rising rates that real estate loan portfolios
- 7:36wouldn't be growing, but relative to capital, they've jumped from 270
- 7:41percent in 2021 to 342 percent today.
- 7:45That's a big shift in concentration risk right there.
- 7:49Auto loans have stayed the same.
- 7:51For the first time here in September 2024, commercial loans are now exceeding 100
- 7:56percent and at worth across the industry.
- 7:59In response to the agency beating them up over interest rate risk and
- 8:04their need for earnings, credit unions have expanded their loan portfolios.
- 8:08And so their concentration risk has kept, crept up on them.
- 8:12And to see credit risk here as the first supervisory priority, it
- 8:17absolutely has to be, out there.
- 8:20I think economic conditions have created this whole situation where
- 8:24delinquency and loss levels are rising.
- 8:27And the industry has increased their concentration risk especially in that real
- 8:32estate, commercial, and unsecured areas.
- 8:35Car loans have stayed relatively the same, but delinquency and charge offs
- 8:38have really spiked with that unsecured and while we don't see losses in the
- 8:42real estate loan portfolios yet or the residential real estate loan portfolios,
- 8:48those delinquency levels have pretty much doubled in a couple years.
- 8:52They're still pretty low at 70 basis points, but That are still
- 8:56doubled in the last couple years.
- 8:58So there will be interesting to see how that plays out.
- 9:02And I noticed just in my local market, and I don't know how many other
- 9:06markets are you, I get a lot of emails from Zillow just because I looked
- 9:11when my son was buying a house, but.
- 9:13I haven't seen this before, but in the last three, four or five months,
- 9:16you're seeing price increases on, homes that were listed for sale.
- 9:21And that is something, at least in our local area, I
- 9:24haven't seen for several years.
- 9:26And all of a sudden you're seeing it now, right?
- 9:28When real estate delinquency is going up and things of that nature and, NCUAs.
- 9:35They do talk about interest rate risk, we went until September of this year.
- 9:40The yield curve was inverted for 790 days.
- 9:43Makes challenging situations for our credit unions and they're still
- 9:48sitting on a lot of underwater securities and really fed funds were
- 9:53inverted compared to treasuries right up until the middle of last month.
- 9:56So almost two and a half years.
- 9:58Hopefully a flat yield curve, it will give credit unions a
- 10:01chance to Maybe adjust earnings.
- 10:04I think overall they've reacted well to the conditions that we're
- 10:08throwing at them, but we'll see.
- 10:12Treichel: It's interesting to the real estate to capital and
- 10:15the concentration risk going up.
- 10:17As you described, as you said that I did a word search and NCWA
- 10:20uses references concentration risk three times in the letter.
- 10:24We've seen concentration risk hit hard in a lot of credit unions recently,
- 10:29but to see some of those number peaking up, I could bet that we're that if
- 10:34a credit union is listening and they are getting hit on these concentration
- 10:38risk percentages, similar to what the collective industry is getting
- 10:42hit that they may see some things in their examination relative to that.
- 10:46We've got some podcasts that talk through that.
- 10:49That you you can go back.
- 10:50I, if you go to our website and and type in concentration risk, you'll get
- 10:54a podcast that will pop up on that.
- 10:56And if I remember, I'll put that in the show notes.
- 10:59I'll also say that NCUA.
- 11:02Under credit risks has 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 links to other sources.
- 11:10They link to the examiner guide.
- 11:11They link to the commercial real estate loan, accommodation, and
- 11:14workout letter from oh five.
- 11:16They link to allowance for loan loss letter from oh four.
- 11:20They link to a home equity line of credit.
- 11:22Letter from oh eight, a link to concentration risk.
- 11:26That's one of the three links to a letter from oh three and four other
- 11:30letters that go as far back as oh one on credit union loan charge off guides.
- 11:35I'm, I didn't test all these links.
- 11:37I'm hoping they work better than the links work in their examiner guide.
- 11:41Sometimes those take you to dead links, but I would bet a hundred
- 11:43percent of these work if they're tying it to this letter to credit unions.
- 11:47But while I didn't.
- 11:48While the letter is shorter, they have a lot of hyperlinks that
- 11:52provide good resources but are also incorporated by reference.
- 11:56Another general thought.
- 11:58I I like to, I did that word search.
- 12:01Credit or concentration risk came up three times.
- 12:04I looked back at the letters the last two years.
- 12:082023 there were roughly 3, 000 total words in the letter and about 15
- 12:14percent of that related to credit risk.
- 12:17In a paragraph or two or a category of credit risk.
- 12:20Last year, There were an additional, there were 350 words in the credit
- 12:26risk section, but the credit, but the letter itself had shrunk by 500 words.
- 12:30So it was up to 20%.
- 12:33This year, the letter has about 650 words in two different categories.
- 12:38On credit risk.
- 12:39It's about one out of every four words in this letter are devoted to credit
- 12:44risk, which kind of gives you a hint at really where they think their problems
- 12:49could be coming from where credit unions problems could be coming from and oh, by
- 12:52the way, they haven't listed first and you should have your top priority first.
- 12:56So that all seems to be congruent.
- 12:58Any thoughts relative to what I added there?
- 13:01Or should we move on to the next topic?
- 13:03Todd Miller: I just thought it was interesting that they put
- 13:05a 1991 letter about interest rate adjustments on arm loans.
- 13:09We just went through a two year period where rates went up.
- 13:12Now they're going down again and they throw this in and you know you on your
- 13:17surface you might think that doesn't make sense but I do know in my career
- 13:22most of the time when we've made credit unions go back and audit their interest
- 13:26rate risk adjustments, it's always failure to adjust them back down.
- 13:34Is where most of the problems were.
- 13:35The problems went both directions.
- 13:37And quite often when you have a credit audit, they would have errors both ways.
- 13:41But it is interesting that they for throw this old thing in there from 1991.
- 13:47They're telling you, hey, watch rates as rates fall.
- 13:50Make sure you're adjusting those arms.
- 13:52Down and I don't know who thought to throw that in there But it's
- 13:55interesting that they threw it in there and it's probably someone that's
- 13:59been around a long time Who's actually went through a cycle like this?
- 14:02So I thought that was an interesting ad
- 14:04Treichel: One of the yeah, one of the old timers and I guess the reason
- 14:07I didn't i'm glad you pointed that out Because I didn't catch that.
- 14:09It's the last one listed there, but it's because they changed The way
- 14:13they number it, they used to put the year apparently back in 1991.
- 14:17They put the year on the front end of the number, as opposed to on the.
- 14:22Back end of the letter or am I getting all those or all the other ones?
- 14:28Yeah.
- 14:28Yeah.
- 14:29So I actually flipped it.
- 14:30So the numbers I was citing were from the, they were the numbers
- 14:33of the letters, not the years.
- 14:35Okay, that's a great catch.
- 14:36Good clarification.
- 14:37But yeah, that's
- 14:38Todd Miller: you mentioned.
- 14:39You mentioned links.
- 14:39I didn't check them all, but I checked a lot of them.
- 14:42Most of these letters, the links work, but I did find places inside the links
- 14:48where there's other links that don't work.
- 14:50Treichel: Got it.
- 14:50Which that's, that can be hard to track, but they should be able to.
- 14:53Change your websites,
- 14:55Todd Miller: Over decades.
- 14:56It's hard to keep that.
- 14:57It is.
- 14:58Treichel: It is very hard.
- 15:00All right.
- 15:00So, that's a wrap on credit risk.
- 15:03What do we have next?
- 15:05They call this balance sheet management and risk to earnings and net worth.
- 15:10I don't think I've ever seen a bolded headline of that category.
- 15:14We've seen all of those things in priority letters, but not where
- 15:18it's been all encompassed in that.
- 15:20So balance sheet management and risk to earnings and net worth.
- 15:23What are your thoughts guys?
- 15:25Steve Farrar: I think we can break it into Todd hit on it a little bit.
- 15:27We can break it into the 3 topics.
- 15:29Number 1 being, basically interest rate risk and then we can talk about
- 15:33earnings and net worth, but it'd be easier to break it apart like that.
- 15:37Yeah, my, 2 cents worth on interest rate risk is, what's
- 15:41happening with net interest margin?
- 15:44It's expected to, probably not improve on the throughout the next year.
- 15:49The prognosticators are saying that there's 3 to expecting 3 to 4 rate
- 15:54cuts from Fed funds to end up with 3.
- 15:575 to 3.
- 15:5875 this year.
- 16:01It will be interesting because with with the political influences could be on that,
- 16:05but there is some additional uncertainty and how that would play forward.
- 16:10I saw a lot of the commentaries about when you have the declining interest
- 16:14rate margin, you'll have the low deposit betas that are existing credit unions and
- 16:19that we're slow to as an industry adapt to that, which Todd hit on even earlier.
- 16:25The outlook per interest rate risk is, declining rates and how are
- 16:29set up to react to that, Todd?
- 16:32Todd Miller: Yeah, I think, the interest rate risk piece is still there.
- 16:35It's somewhat interesting because liquidity is talked about in this too.
- 16:39And this is part of it too.
- 16:40During COVID deposit and liability structures just got really distorted.
- 16:45And even before that with low interest rates where you can differentiate,
- 16:49the rate paid on your Regular savings versus your money market versus a CD.
- 16:55When rates started rising, our deposit structure has changed.
- 16:59I think it's actually reverted back to normal, what it
- 17:01looked like, in 2007, 2008.
- 17:04It didn't change very much between December of 2023 and September, other
- 17:09than some borrowed money paid down.
- 17:12People borrowed money here when rates went up because they had a huge amount
- 17:16of securities that are underwater at one time that unrealized loss was 2 trillion
- 17:22and it's still 20 billion of unrealized losses and investment portfolios.
- 17:27Hopefully the falling rates will allow parties to normalize
- 17:31that investment portfolio and improve things along those lines.
- 17:36Maybe people now can take some losses to actually get some adjustments
- 17:39in their yields or if rates fall, it'll just make those investments
- 17:45a little bit more worthwhile.
- 17:47The industry has been really beat up on interest rate risk over the
- 17:50last few years, and like Steve said, some people were slow to adjust.
- 17:54I think the important thing is people, especially with the CDs and higher
- 17:57rates, adjust quickly this next time around as rates continue to fall.
- 18:04If they continue to fall, I think that's a big question.
- 18:07They're forecasting them to fall, when you have a new party
- 18:10in government, who knows whether they're really going to fall or not.
- 18:14So credit unions need to be a little bit quicker.
- 18:15Flexible along those lines.
- 18:17They do talk about earnings and net worth in here.
- 18:20It's interesting.
- 18:21They basically put, balance sheet management in one category
- 18:25where historically they've broken this out to interest rate lists.
- 18:29Interest rate risk, liquidity risk, and then, your whole capital plans.
- 18:34And they've thrown three really, really broad areas into one thing.
- 18:37But I think it boils down to this.
- 18:40They're going to be looking at your business plans, and they're
- 18:42going to be looking at how adaptable are you with tactics.
- 18:46Conditions change, but and we're seeing this, just amongst our clients in the
- 18:51last couple of years, there's been just an increased focus on business plans.
- 18:55And in some ways credit unions get criticized if
- 18:58they're just off a little bit.
- 19:00And it's Oh, conditions are changing quite a bit.
- 19:03They can't really predict that.
- 19:04So there needs to be a little bit of grace there.
- 19:06But at the same time, a lot of credit unions.
- 19:09They need to be up front about what's in their business plans, and if things
- 19:12aren't working and they're changing things, let's be transparent in how
- 19:15we're doing that and why we're doing it.
- 19:19Treichel: All great thoughts and yeah, they did.
- 19:21It's I used to say 4 or 5 years ago.
- 19:25I think the 1st time we did this, I maybe the 1st, 2 times we did this.
- 19:29I talked about if everything's a priority, nothing's a priority and
- 19:33has gotten better at scaling back on what they're calling a priority.
- 19:37But like you said, they've collapsed.
- 19:38They've collapsed basically 3 categories into this 1 paragraph.
- 19:42And that could be just because they had a new starting author at NC way.
- 19:45That could be because the current N.
- 19:48C.
- 19:48U.
- 19:48A.
- 19:48chairman said, Hey, let's take a little bit different approach to this.
- 19:51Or this could be that the likely incoming chairman, Kyle Hauptman,
- 19:56who should be named chairman of N.
- 19:59C.
- 19:59U.
- 19:59A.
- 19:59shortly after Trump is inaugurated, it could be that he had a little
- 20:03bit more influence on this.
- 20:05I was quite frankly surprised the letter came out this quick.
- 20:08I didn't know if they would just delay it until Hauptman came on so he could
- 20:13sign it or conversely the opposite.
- 20:16It was going to be one of two things.
- 20:18They rushed to get it out so Todd can sign it or they wait
- 20:23and they let Hauptman sign it.
- 20:24Now, Hauptman could go out and start doing speeches to tweak this.
- 20:27He can, put his finger on the scale a little bit about what goes on.
- 20:32And what he communicates to the executive director and the the
- 20:37regional directors, but that gets difficult for the field staff.
- 20:39And I know we have some field staff that, that that listened to this podcast,
- 20:43but, this is something, this is a kind of a beacon for credit unions to look
- 20:47at this letter, but it's also something that, that is to a staff looks at.
- 20:51So with the administration changing that could get that could get
- 20:55interesting as we see a pivot there.
- 20:58But I do believe that is why this came out quicker.
- 21:00I think Todd wanted to get done on his watch, but he also was very collaborative
- 21:05generally speaking, when you compare all the different board chairs and how
- 21:09collaborative they were or weren't, Todd tends to be collaborative from what I've
- 21:13seen and from what I've heard and from what I know when I was still back at N.
- 21:18C.
- 21:18U.
- 21:18A.
- 21:18Any more thoughts on this topic or any thoughts on anything?
- 21:21I just pondered there, gentlemen.
- 21:25Steve Farrar: No, but, as we move forward on that, and we'll look
- 21:28at, the comment in the letter is that net interest margins have only
- 21:33slightly exceeded operating expenses.
- 21:35And so I looked at how we compare to community banks on that.
- 21:39And yeah, we're running at operating expenses interest margin 97 percent
- 21:45and that that we're just a little bit there and that same measure in
- 21:49that, the community banks have a significantly higher margin there
- 21:53between the net interest margin and their operating expenses.
- 21:56And there's going to be pressure on operating expenses.
- 21:59They have been rising more than net interest margins.
- 22:02Isn't that, credit unions are going to be looking at, having to deal with
- 22:07their systems and how you're going to compete against, the fine tech fintechs.
- 22:12So there's, there's lots of opportunity there, but it's going to require
- 22:15probably some new significant investment.
- 22:18Treichel: That's
- 22:19Steve Farrar: going to be interesting to see how the industry deals with that.
- 22:22Treichel: And
- 22:23Todd Miller: go ahead, Todd.
- 22:25Question for you, Steve.
- 22:26Did you look at fee income from banks to credit unions?
- 22:29Because I know credit unions, their fee income has fallen about 30 basis
- 22:33points over the last three years.
- 22:35And that's a big number.
- 22:3630 basis points is drop in fee income, compared to assets.
- 22:41It's the difference between 70 basis points of earnings versus 1%.
- 22:46Yeah.
- 22:47So did you look at that compared to our banks?
- 22:50And I didn't really, analyze the fee income of why it fell.
- 22:54You can probably surmise that some of it is loan origination fees
- 22:58have shrunk with the rising rates, although I don't know that to be true.
- 23:02I just do know that fee income has been tumbling the last
- 23:07several years in credit unions.
- 23:09Steve Farrar: Yeah, I believe it's also in tumbling in the community
- 23:11banks is that right now great unions that have a higher fee income ratio
- 23:17to assets than in the community banks.
- 23:19Go
- 23:21Treichel: ahead.
- 23:21I'm sorry.
- 23:21Go ahead.
- 23:22Steve Farrar: The short term impact has been some of the pressure on
- 23:26the supposedly junk fees and the.
- 23:29NSF fees that has been out there, so that was expected, at least on the short run.
- 23:36Now, we'll see if rates.
- 23:38Come down, there's an opportunity for refinances.
- 23:42And even though margins may get compressed, there's opportunity there
- 23:45for fee income on the refinance side,
- 23:48Treichel: And that is an area to where I think the political change the
- 23:51Biden administration coined junk fees.
- 23:54They had banking regulators at the White House.
- 23:57When making statements about junk fees, which then it was extrapolated
- 24:03into the regulators talking about it.
- 24:05Chairman Todd Harper talked about it, saying that fee income concentration is
- 24:09a concentration risk, even though it's not said that it is anywhere else by N.
- 24:13C.
- 24:13U.
- 24:13A.
- 24:13But he said it.
- 24:14So that makes it but that's the point that once you have a new chair, he can
- 24:18go out and say things and do things that can calm the nerves down and maybe
- 24:24maybe there'll be a little bit of a recovery here on that fee income side.
- 24:28The other thing as you're talking about those All those
- 24:31pressures about making money.
- 24:33I've had a few calls with clients.
- 24:36I've had a few calls with prospective clients this week.
- 24:39And the merger is a big theme where there's credit unions that you wouldn't
- 24:44think would necessarily be contemplating merger are contemplating merger.
- 24:48And then others I've had, I had a conversation with the smaller
- 24:51credit union this week and they're ready to throw the towel in.
- 24:55Just because of the challenge of the exam, the challenge of making a profit
- 24:59and having self determination where they can actually influence it and
- 25:03make a decision on a merger when they can actually help pick who that is,
- 25:07which is how most of them get done.
- 25:09You want to do it when you still have ample capital, but the pressures
- 25:13that are out there are real.
- 25:14And I got a feeling that mergers as a percentage of outstanding units in 2025
- 25:21will probably they're not going to go down and that they probably might even go up.
- 25:25Steve Farrar: Yeah, most prognosticators figure M& A activity will increase.
- 25:30This year.
- 25:30Yeah,
- 25:31Treichel: very good.
- 25:33So cyber security.
- 25:34Just 1 last comment on,
- 25:36Steve Farrar: Net worth.
- 25:37Yep.
- 25:37There is some new in the banking industry.
- 25:40It's some new bought Basel 3 accord kind of stuff coming out.
- 25:44It's mostly affects really large institutions.
- 25:47It.
- 25:47Tends to maybe change some of the risk weightings to reducing some of the
- 25:51risk weightings for risk based capital.
- 25:53So there's a little bit of downward pressure on the amount of capital
- 25:58for financial institutions to hold.
- 26:00But I think that's going to play out this year as to where exactly that goes.
- 26:06Treichel: Got it.
- 26:07Got it.
- 26:08So next on NCOA's letter is cyber security.
- 26:11Any thoughts on cyber security in general or what NCOA said here?
- 26:18Todd Miller: I don't see that ever coming off of this list.
- 26:22It might get higher some years than others, but just the instances that
- 26:27we've had in the last year with some, of our large credit unions having
- 26:31security incidences, the whole AI is creating whole new environments of fraud.
- 26:39You got the regulators going after the Zelle, and what's happening with fraud
- 26:45losses there and who should pay for them.
- 26:47I just I don't see this ever not being a challenge for our credit unions.
- 26:54I will just say at the moment, based on our clients, NCUA is still very
- 26:59much, is still very much let's hold your hands and help you through it.
- 27:05They're not being punitive.
- 27:07They're being, let's instruct our credit unions and do our
- 27:09best to make them better.
- 27:11That seems to be their approach to cyber security, but.
- 27:15From my perspective, like I said, I don't think it's ever
- 27:17going to come off this list.
- 27:19It just seems to be getting worse and more challenging every year.
- 27:25AI comes out, you'd think, hey, can that help us with cybersecurity?
- 27:28It helps the bad guys create more holes in cybersecurity, so it's just
- 27:32a constant leapfrog battle there.
- 27:36So I don't ever see it coming off the list.
- 27:38I do think it's positive that NCUA takes a Helping approach to this
- 27:42with their credit unions, they're not beating them up over it there Let's
- 27:47mature our whole information security platform seems to be the approach
- 27:52that Ncua has historically taken and are still taking to our knowledge
- 27:57Steve Farrar: Yeah, I would say what we've learned from people that have
- 28:00experienced problems when you hit that button to you know turn on a new,
- 28:04Application or something for your members.
- 28:08Make sure it works because if you hit that button and it fails, it's
- 28:13just total misery on every level.
- 28:15Oh yeah.
- 28:16This is always interesting because it's such a fast moving area that it is
- 28:20even difficult for regulars to keep up because I was reading then about the,
- 28:24the quantum computing that's coming out.
- 28:26And there's obviously expenses in there, but there are opportunities
- 28:30there to improve items such as fraud detection and just the more,
- 28:36about what your customers want the better you're able to react to that.
- 28:41But that's just shows how fast this part of operations moves
- 28:46Treichel: Very good point.
- 28:47And I think every issue a board member ever at when asked what
- 28:52keeps him up at night lists.
- 28:54Cyber security is 1 of the top 2 or 3 things.
- 28:57So I agree.
- 28:58It's going to be here forever.
- 28:59And it's something you need to.
- 29:01The dollars you spend on it will only go up and you need to prioritize that.
- 29:06But it is a definite and real risk that all financial
- 29:09institutions and consumers face.
- 29:13Speaking of consumers Consumer Financial Protection is always
- 29:17going to be on here, most likely as well, always has been on here.
- 29:20Any general thoughts?
- 29:21I know you guys aren't Consumer Financial Protection specialists from your
- 29:25background at NCUA, but any thoughts about what is said in the letter here
- 29:28on Consumer Financial Protection?
- 29:32Todd Miller: I think it's interesting that Fair Lending has
- 29:34showed up here two years in a row.
- 29:35Usually, they change these from year to year, but Fair Lending
- 29:39was in last year's letter too.
- 29:42Treichel: Yeah, they've hit pretty hard on that.
- 29:44They've added staff in the budget.
- 29:46I quite frankly thought they'd add more fair lending examiners than than
- 29:50they did over the last two years.
- 29:52That being said they've doubled, I think, the number of fair lending exams.
- 29:56That they've had going on.
- 29:57But yeah, there's definitely a focus there.
- 29:59That could be something that you see a little bit of the emphasis.
- 30:03But probably not probably not a quick turn.
- 30:06I think they'll probably do what they are planning on doing in 2025, but by
- 30:10the time the budget rolls around next time, they may deemphasize that when
- 30:14we're doing this recording in 2026.
- 30:17That may fall out.
- 30:19I'll just comment on the overdraft program.
- 30:22I've got a recording of a podcast scheduled with Joe Goldberg, one
- 30:27of our team members here at Credit Union Exam Solutions, to talk
- 30:30about NCUA's letter that came out on overdraft programs last month.
- 30:35More to follow on that.
- 30:37Steve, any thoughts on consumer financial protection?
- 30:40Steve Farrar: Yeah, didn't we have a few publicized instances of fines being
- 30:45imposed on some of our credit unions?
- 30:48Treichel: Yes.
- 30:48Yeah.
- 30:48N.
- 30:49C.
- 30:49U.
- 30:49A.
- 30:49Has has been and the Justice Department has been aggressive on a couple
- 30:54of such situations making, raising some things into the spotlight,
- 31:00if you will, for some situations.
- 31:02And that's also an area I think with the pivot to the Trump administration
- 31:06will probably be de emphasized.
- 31:11Todd Miller: So I haven't listened to your podcast on Overdraft, so I was going to
- 31:14ask you which direction do you think it goes, because I find the whole Overdraft
- 31:19thing somewhat interesting, and while I'm sure there's banks and credit unions out
- 31:24there that kind of abuse it, in general, Though for the most part overdraft fees
- 31:31actually almost become a service that actually helps their members more than
- 31:35hurts them you know, it's a way to keep them out of the payday lending and the
- 31:39pals lending and the pawn shops and it's a short term financing vehicle and they
- 31:44know they're getting feed for it They're still going to use it anyway, because
- 31:48they have needs to do so You know, they might not build up their credit cards
- 31:52because of that and it's one of those things from my mind It seems well This
- 31:56is the best intentions in the world.
- 31:58But at the end of the day, it may actually hurt more members than it helps.
- 32:04Treichel: Todd, what you just said is my opinion.
- 32:06I think the attack on overdraft program is whack a mole.
- 32:09If you can't fee him here, you'll find a way to fee him there.
- 32:12And there are people that need that.
- 32:14And they'll go to the fees that credit unions are offering.
- 32:17Generally speaking are better off.
- 32:20Than the other the payday lending like you described.
- 32:23Now, we haven't recorded that podcast and that one is going to be recorded
- 32:26next week and come out in a couple weeks.
- 32:28But so I
- 32:29Todd Miller: advertised for you.
- 32:30Yeah,
- 32:31Treichel: you did.
- 32:31But what you said I would agree with.
- 32:33And I think if you if and I have to believe and I do believe that because
- 32:40the administration and because N.
- 32:41C.
- 32:41U.
- 32:42A.
- 32:42Has focused on this, there have been people and credit unions
- 32:45who've shut programs often are just bouncing the checks now.
- 32:49And and there's rules they need to follow relative to that.
- 32:51So people are being driven to payday lending sources in an environment
- 32:56where You know where things are inflationary and it's going to get
- 33:01harder and harder for the people that they're trying to help in my opinion.
- 33:04So I would agree with that.
- 33:08So other updates exam updates.
- 33:10I've got a couple of thoughts on this, but I'll just read this 1.
- 33:13it says in 2025, the NCUA will update its exam flexibility initiative to
- 33:18provide an extended exam cycle for credit unions over 1 billion in assets
- 33:22where the NCUA rated the credit union, a camel composite or camels composite 1.
- 33:27One or two with no change in CEO since the last exam, these institutions will now be
- 33:33eligible for a 12 to 16 month exam cycle.
- 33:36Additionally, the extended exam cycle for the eligible federal credit
- 33:40unions will be shortened from 14 to 20 months to 14 to 18 months.
- 33:46So they're trimming it two months on one end, but they're allowing the big credit
- 33:51unions to have an elongated exam cycle.
- 33:55Any general thoughts on that?
- 33:57What you've seen historically in this area?
- 33:58I have a separate podcast I did on this when they brought this up when they snuck
- 34:03it into a statement at the board table.
- 34:05But what are your thoughts on that guys?
- 34:09Todd Miller: I'm sure they're doing it because they can't
- 34:10meet their own exam program.
- 34:12But let's just say they've moved their exam cycles many
- 34:15times over our 30 year careers.
- 34:18And it's every time they extend it, it just doesn't turn out well for them.
- 34:23Treichel: Meaning it leads to insurance fund losses in the
- 34:25end, which is what the game is.
- 34:27They end up having more losses because things, more things can get missed
- 34:30and more situations can go from bad to worse before they go back in.
- 34:36Todd Miller: Troubled credeans ends up accelerating and speeding up on them.
- 34:40Treichel: Sure.
- 34:40Yep.
- 34:41Todd Miller: Yep.
- 34:41In some respects, I think if this is a thing with all the regulators
- 34:45and it's like cybersecurity, you're reacting to the environment.
- 34:49You're reacting to political situations.
- 34:53It's very difficult for them to get ahead of situations.
- 34:55They're always reacting to things that went on behind them.
- 34:59So excellent
- 35:00Treichel: point.
- 35:01Steve, anything you want to
- 35:03Steve Farrar: this is going to put, examiners, need to do good on
- 35:07those cases assigned to them on how they're managing their district.
- 35:11And, looking at the periodical, we're actually looking at the reports.
- 35:16Hopefully they're getting enough budgeted time to where they're going to do.
- 35:20Feel like they get to spend enough time to monitor their district and
- 35:25feel like they know what's going on.
- 35:27So they can spot negative trend.
- 35:29Earlier and react.
- 35:31Treichel: Great point.
- 35:32Great point.
- 35:33I'm looking back to try and see the name of that podcast.
- 35:36I did on this.
- 35:39It was episode number 222.
- 35:44By the way, guys, we're on about 230 episodes of With
- 35:48Flying Colors at this juncture.
- 35:50But episode number 222, I called it NCOA Changes Exam Frequency,
- 35:55colon, or Regulatory Theater.
- 35:59Todd, you Pointed out that N.
- 36:00C.
- 36:01U.
- 36:01A.
- 36:01Has had a difficult time doing their exams timely.
- 36:05They've pointed that out in their annual performance report where they put their
- 36:11goals that link to their strategic plan.
- 36:13And Kyle Houtman, who I've mentioned a couple of times
- 36:15here, is going to be the chair.
- 36:17Has said, Hey, we're not even getting our exams done on time.
- 36:20We're not getting our code fours done on time.
- 36:21We're not getting our code threes done on time.
- 36:23I guarantee you if they're not doing the fours and threes on time, that they're
- 36:26not doing the twos and ones on time either, because those have less risk.
- 36:30I was talking about this as it happened and my wife was sitting in here, and
- 36:35she came up with a perfect analogy.
- 36:38Before I recorded that last podcast saying that it sounds like what the
- 36:43airlines did when the airlines 10, 15 years ago, couldn't get anywhere on
- 36:48time and they were getting beat up in the press that they were always late
- 36:51here and they were always late there.
- 36:53What did they do?
- 36:54They added a half hour or 45 minutes to every flight and every flight was on time.
- 36:59So this is more.
- 37:01We haven't been doing them timely.
- 37:04We haven't been getting there in there every 12 months.
- 37:06So we might as well get the good political soundbite of saying we're elongating our
- 37:11cycle setting aside the fact that people take forever to get their exams, but
- 37:16they're really just changing their policy to match what has actually been being done
- 37:20for, I would say two, maybe three years, maybe all the way back to the pandemic.
- 37:24It sounds good.
- 37:25It's a good sound bite.
- 37:26I got some ideas on who in that building might've figured out how
- 37:29they might be able to spin it.
- 37:31When you've been there 34 years and you see the spin you got a column on it.
- 37:36Todd Miller: Steve mentioned something, about district
- 37:38management for credit unions.
- 37:40And so Steve was a PCO for 15 years.
- 37:42I spent 15 years dealing with troubled credit unions, probably
- 37:45more because a lot of my first CMS time was troubled credit unions.
- 37:49And I'm sure you've seen a lot of this too, Mark.
- 37:51The district, So there's postmortems that NCUA always issue when a crating fails,
- 37:56and they always say management, caused the failure of the crating, which is true.
- 38:00But what they almost rarely say is how frequently NCUA should have caught
- 38:06things a lot sooner and didn't because district management wasn't there.
- 38:10It's interesting.
- 38:11They've created tons of tools to now examiners have reports
- 38:16like crazy to fill out.
- 38:17They have rate reviews.
- 38:18They have these risk reviews.
- 38:20They have tons of things, but it's still just they still don't just seem to
- 38:24catch up on let's catching things early.
- 38:27And I think maybe they're, they've created so many tools that examiners are checking
- 38:32boxes and not really thinking about what's happening in their credit unions.
- 38:36I don't know how the agency fixes that, but when they get to cycles like this.
- 38:40They do need to figure out a way where there's less false positives
- 38:46in their monitoring system.
- 38:47I think their monitoring system creates lots of false positives.
- 38:50So people miss the real important things when they start going south.
- 38:55Treichel: Yeah, great point.
- 38:56And when they talk about credit risk and they're, they seem to really
- 39:00be concerned about credit risk, the data is going the wrong way.
- 39:03And then they say, Oh, by the way, we're increasing the exam cycle.
- 39:06That's not congruent.
- 39:07That's just not congruent.
- 39:08Any final thoughts, guys before we wrap?
- 39:10I know there's a category on minority depository institutions and which I,
- 39:15that tends to be something that's in there under Democrats and it tends to
- 39:19fall out under Republican Republicans.
- 39:21And that's all good language there and things credit unions
- 39:24should do if you're an MDI.
- 39:26Credit union, you should take a look at that.
- 39:28There are resources available from InsuA to assist, but any final thoughts on this
- 39:32or or any other topics in the letter?
- 39:36Todd Miller: I think it's just a big one there.
- 39:37Number one is credit risk, and that's what causes the vast majority
- 39:40of failures in credit unions.
- 39:42Okay, there's a fraud last year in there, but it's credit risk most of
- 39:45the time and really credit unions.
- 39:47I had a CEO I don't know.
- 39:49It was about a 700 million credit.
- 39:51And one time tell me his number one responsibility was ensuring
- 39:55that their credit risk was solid.
- 39:58Even though that was a large credit and that person probably never
- 40:00touched loans, he seen that as one of his key responsibilities.
- 40:03And what we see with clients over the last few years, there's a huge emphasis
- 40:08on getting your concentration risk numbers aligned appropriately with
- 40:12your capital position getting your whole loan servicing systems in place.
- 40:17If you're a commercial lender, it's not just did you make a good loan today,
- 40:21but are you servicing it appropriately?
- 40:23The NCUA has told credit unions, hey, we're focused on
- 40:27credit risk, credit unions.
- 40:28You need to make sure your credit lending systems are up to par,
- 40:32collection systems are up to par, credit monitoring systems for all
- 40:36your various loan types are up to par.
- 40:39They're going to be looking at those things and really for the survivability
- 40:43of your institution, if you're a lender.
- 40:46You need good credit risk management systems in place
- 40:49and a good credit culture.
- 40:51Another member of Mark's team, Ben Beaton, he hammers on credit culture all the time.
- 40:56And NCA is going to be out there assessing your credit culture.
- 41:00Treichel: That's a fact.
- 41:01That's a fact.
- 41:02Great point, Steve.
- 41:04Steve Farrar: One thing I was surprised that didn't appear in the letter.
- 41:08Because we saw it a lot in some of our clients is Either examiner
- 41:12findings or document resolutions was the topic of corporate governance
- 41:16Treichel: Yeah, i'm shocked.
- 41:18You got one of you guys had pointed that out before we started recording
- 41:20I'm shocked that's not here because it is very present in Examinations as
- 41:26you said when someone gets an examiner finding or a door It seems to be
- 41:30linked back to corporate governance.
- 41:32Yeah very surprised it's not there, but just because it's not there don't
- 41:36expect NCOA to stop asking you about it.
- 41:38There's good, we have good podcasts out there, two or three different
- 41:41podcasts on corporate governance that you should listen to.
- 41:45They will help you with your exams for sure.
- 41:46Yeah.
- 41:47Steve Farrar: And Todd kind of hit on that whole credit.
- 41:49Management thing in culture is, what is your risk appetite?
- 41:52Can you describe it and share it with your employees?
- 41:56So they everybody's on this on board with what the mission is
- 41:59in terms of a credit culture?
- 42:02Treichel: Absolutely.
- 42:02Yep.
- 42:03Great point.
- 42:04All right, guys, as always, this is a fun one.
- 42:06Listeners Stephen Todd, I want to thank you for being available today
- 42:09to talk about this with our listeners.
- 42:11And listeners, I want to thank you for listening as always.
- 42:14I hope you listen again soon.
- 42:15This is Mark Treichel signing off.
- 42:18With flying colors.