Latest / No Way Out / Strategic Evolution: Unrestricted Warfare and the Future of Asymmetric Conflict with Bill DeMarco
Transcript
- 0:20Mark McGrath: So we have Bill DeMarco joining us.
- 0:22Mark McGrath: Bill, you are a retired Air Force officer and a retired Air Force pilot, or do we?
- 0:29Brian Rivera: say aviator too.
- 0:30Mark McGrath: You've spent a career asking questions about a lot of the things that we talk about and you came on our radar screen in a conversation around the golden, mean and sacred geometry and the application of that concept in a treatise of two Chinese officers that was written decades ago, called Unrestricted Warfare.
- 0:49Mark McGrath: That we've talked a lot about, about the grand plan of China versus the United States in the years to come, which is likely not going to be a naval showdown in the South China Sea, as we've talked about on other episodes, more asymmetric, more nonlinear, more the type of things that we talk about with John Boyd and Plexity and the Kedeman Framework and things like that.
- 1:11Mark McGrath: How did you let's start there.
- 1:14Mark McGrath: So you're a strategist, you're a teacher.
- 1:17Mark McGrath: How did you come across that, specifically gravitating towards chapter six of that around the golden ratio, what really jumped off the page for you?
- 1:26Mark McGrath: And then we're just we're going to riff off that.
- 1:28Bill DeMarco: Yeah, that's a good question.
- 1:30Bill DeMarco: So you know, first of all, guys, thanks for having me on.
- 1:32Bill DeMarco: You know, mark, you reached out on LinkedIn.
- 1:34Bill DeMarco: Then I kind of went and looked at all the stuff you guys have going on and it's amazing.
- 1:37Bill DeMarco: So one of the things that I'm always looking at is how do I learn more?
- 1:41Bill DeMarco: So just going into your website, looking at things you guys are up to, it's really, really impressive.
- 1:47Bill DeMarco: So thanks for reaching out, mark, and thanks for this opportunity For me and that idea of learning more.
- 1:52Bill DeMarco: So I went to SAS, the School of Advanced Air and Space Studies here at our university many, many moons ago and one of the first books we had to read was Unrestricted Warfare and of course, that book came out in 1999.
- 2:05Bill DeMarco: But I keep thinking from a historical point of view, how many times do we look back at situations and go the information was all there?
- 2:13Bill DeMarco: I mean just something as simple.
- 2:16Bill DeMarco: As you know, if you look at the version of Unrestricted Warfare I have, it's got the Twin Towers burning on the cover, so I think it was like the first or second edition of the book.
- 2:25Bill DeMarco: Now there's a new cover, but I look at like that, just in 9-11, you know, we look at the reports after the information was all there, we just failed to piece it together.
- 2:34Bill DeMarco: So when we think about China, or, as a Gen Xer, you know we looked at the Soviet Union.
- 2:39Bill DeMarco: There were so many things that were written that nobody read.
- 2:42Bill DeMarco: And if you go back to World War II, I mean you know it's like stuff is all out there.
- 2:47Bill DeMarco: So I thought I need to pick up Unrestricted Warfare and give another read, and that was maybe 12, 18 months ago.
- 2:52Bill DeMarco: But I read it and I was just like, oh my word, it's all right there.
- 2:57Bill DeMarco: Everything, even though it was written 25, 26 years ago, everything that we see going on right now, whether it's the South China Sea, the Taiwan Strait, economics, cyber, you name it, and think where we're at with cyber back in 1989, and think where we're at now, worlds apart.
- 3:13Bill DeMarco: Yeah, it's all there.
- 3:14Bill DeMarco: So that was kind of why I picked it up.
- 3:16Bill DeMarco: I just figured, looking at that book and of course we all know that was released by the state right, the state approved that book to be released.
- 3:23Bill DeMarco: So then you have to start wondering well, what did the state want us to know?
- 3:27Bill DeMarco: They clearly want us to know that.
- 3:28Bill DeMarco: I'll pause there.
- 3:30Bill DeMarco: I'll go on forever.
- 3:32Mark McGrath: No, it's interesting, you know, when you talk about books like that.
- 3:35Mark McGrath: I remember as a young officer I was a first lieutenant and one of my second lieutenants came up to me to complain that one of the Marines was reading Mein Kampf and I said well, you know, it's actually on the Commandant's reading list and the reason that was on the reading list was to try to understand how the you know the mindset and the frame of reference and the thinking that led up to the invasion of Poland, or you know the rise of the rise of national socialism and things like that.
- 4:01Mark McGrath: And you know he was shocked.
- 4:03Mark McGrath: And then I also said by the way, guerrilla Warfare by Mao Zedong is also on the Commandant's reading list.
- 4:08Mark McGrath: And there's, you know, there's very clear reasons that we're encouraged to read these things, and that's to broaden our scope and to broaden our perspective as warfighters.
- 4:17Mark McGrath: And we translate now the work that Ponch and I do, that you're familiar with, we translate the warfighting ideals to business and sports and other areas.
- 4:25Mark McGrath: But, taking the same concepts, it's very important to read as many perspectives as possible, even things that would seem on the surface unseemly, because it gives us a frame of reference and understanding of how circumstances unfold and how things interacted such that, as we become better at sensemaking in our own environments, we're able to identify patterns faster, so like if you had read Mind Comp or if you've read Guerrilla Warfare by Mao Zedong, when you see things emerging that match those patterns, you're able to do something about it faster than if you had.
- 4:57Mark McGrath: And unfortunately, a lot of that is lost in, I think, the modern military People.
- 5:02Mark McGrath: One, they're not reading and two, they're focusing on tech, they're not focusing on thinking, they're not focusing on the cognitive software that shapes and scans and comes up with decisions, actions and the learning capability.
- 5:14Brian Rivera: Hey Moose, I want to bring up something.
- 5:16Brian Rivera: Bill brought up that unrestricted warfare was released by the state and that may be a misdirect, it may be a probe, it may be to create some type of mismatch.
- 5:25Brian Rivera: I want to point out something that Air University released, and that is this book here right, the Discourse on Winning and Losing.
- 5:30Mark McGrath: Okay.
- 5:31Brian Rivera: This is out there but nobody reads it.
- 5:33Brian Rivera: Very few people understand, right.
- 5:35Brian Rivera: So, bill, back to you on this.
- 5:37Brian Rivera: Is it possible that the unrestricted warfare document that's been around since 1999, there you go, love it, love it.
- 5:46Brian Rivera: That's been around since 1999 is not?
- 5:48Brian Rivera: It could be a misdirect, it could be a mismatch, it could be out there just to throw us off, or, in fact, it could be a sound document that very few Chinese leaders understand and even fewer American military thinkers understand.
- 6:03Bill DeMarco: No, poncho.
- 6:03Bill DeMarco: I think that's a really good point.
- 6:04Bill DeMarco: When I said released by the state, I don't mean as a misdirect, I mean they released it for a reason and I think it might have been more of the idea of, hey, this is what we're thinking and think about.
- 6:13Bill DeMarco: When it came out, it was kind of a.
- 6:15Bill DeMarco: It was a new way of looking at warfare, maybe, but it wasn't, as I don't want to say mainstream, that's the wrong word.
- 6:22Bill DeMarco: But the way we look at it now is like we're like, yeah, of course you know you've got all these different asymmetric ways of attacking an enemy.
- 6:30Bill DeMarco: It's not all going to be like you said.
- 6:32Bill DeMarco: It won't be probably fought in the Straits of Taiwo, I don't believe.
- 6:40Bill DeMarco: You know, like in Air Force, we talk a lot about this idea of dogfight.
- 6:42Bill DeMarco: I think the dogfight could come back, but I don't think it's going to be a massive dogfight, you know, in the channel or in the streets.
- 6:45Bill DeMarco: It's going to be much more nuanced, it's going to be more asymmetric, all the things that we know.
- 6:49Bill DeMarco: I mean that Boyd talks about.
- 6:51Bill DeMarco: So I mean I didn't mean that in terms of it's a misdirect.
- 6:54Bill DeMarco: I kind of meant it in terms of it's something that the Chinese probably want us to know.
- 6:58Bill DeMarco: Interesting too.
- 6:59Bill DeMarco: You brought up this idea of not reading.
- 7:01Bill DeMarco: Since I teach at the Staff College and the War College.
- 7:05Bill DeMarco: I shouldn't say this because our students that take our courses it's kind of an elective.
- 7:09Bill DeMarco: We do a research task force on innovation, so the students pick this course and so I don't see a lack of reading in that course.
- 7:17Bill DeMarco: But I know there's a lack of reading when you go to the core courses and I've had this conversation with several majors over.
- 7:23Bill DeMarco: Well, why do I need to read?
- 7:24Bill DeMarco: And there's sometimes you have to read and reread.
- 7:27Bill DeMarco: So I look at unrestricted warfare.
- 7:29Bill DeMarco: Now I'm that.
- 7:30Bill DeMarco: I'm that geek that I bought the audio because I already had the book.
- 7:35Bill DeMarco: So then I have the book and the audio because I want to be sure, am I really hearing or reading everything that's in the text?
- 7:42Bill DeMarco: And you get something different when you listen to it.
- 7:44Bill DeMarco: You know what I mean versus when you read it.
- 7:46Bill DeMarco: So I've done both of those with Understricted Warfare, trying to understand the nuances of Chinese culture, because that's really what we mirror, image ourselves on the Chinese or the Russians, and it's not the case.
- 7:59Bill DeMarco: I was in a briefing with a general.
- 8:02Bill DeMarco: It's been a couple of years back, but they were talking about something along the lines that there's no main highway or freeway between Moscow and like St Petersburg or something like that.
- 8:11Bill DeMarco: And they were saying well, that shows you how backwards Russia is, why wouldn't they have a main road there?
- 8:16Bill DeMarco: And this general said you're mere imaging, they're Russians, they don't need a freeway because they're Russians.
- 8:23Bill DeMarco: I mean, it's like the idea is we're saying you should have a freeway.
- 8:26Bill DeMarco: That shows that you're, you know that you have achieved a certain level of infrastructure.
- 8:30Bill DeMarco: And maybe in Russia it's like well, we don't need an American freeway, we're Russians, we just go.
- 8:36Mark McGrath: We're not really good at cultural alignment and it's funny other books that have been on service Cheech reading lists, like Seven Pillars of Wisdom by TE Lawrence.
- 8:44Mark McGrath: We have somebody forthcoming that we're going to be talking with next week that recommends reading books that Boyd talked about, like Andrew Kopredovich's, the Army in Vietnam and others, and one of the things Bing West's, the Village, is another great one.
- 8:56Mark McGrath: Disconnection from culture is a huge problem that we have.
- 9:00Mark McGrath: That we go around thinking everything is like us.
- 9:01Mark McGrath: That we go around thinking everything is like us.
- 9:03Mark McGrath: General Stanley McChrystal talks about this in Team of Teams that we're running around Iraq with JSOC looking for a group of people that have a CO, xo, s1, s2, s3, s4, and then we realize they don't have any of that stuff.
- 9:17Mark McGrath: And they don't have any of that stuff for a reason because if they had that stuff we'd pulverize them and they would come at us our way.
- 9:27Mark McGrath: I find that the unrestricted warfare thing is not only important to read.
- 9:31Mark McGrath: It is scary that a lot of people don't know about it.
- 9:34Mark McGrath: One thing I would add too.
- 9:35Mark McGrath: In Science, strategy and War by Franz Ossinga, he read that he cites it as a source.
- 9:40Mark McGrath: In fact, he dedicates a good section of the last chapter to asymmetric warfare, the things that the Chinese officers were talking about in that book.
- 9:47Mark McGrath: And the last thing I would say was that we had GI Wilson on the show before.
- 9:51Mark McGrath: That was an acolyte and a collaborator of Boyd within the Marine Corps from 1979 till Boyd's death in 97.
- 9:57Mark McGrath: Had those officers that wrote Unrestricted Warfare?
- 10:06Mark McGrath: They've likely read the discourse book that both you and Ponch have held up.
- 10:07Mark McGrath: They read Boy, but they also read the book, the article rather, that he co-authored with Bill Lynn, mike Wiley and I forget the name of the army officer called the Changing Face of War, which was released in October of 1989, a month before something that they predicted basically happened the know the Berlin Wall coming down.
- 10:25Mark McGrath: That nobody expected.
- 10:26Mark McGrath: And these guys were talking about these patterns.
- 10:28Mark McGrath: And I don't think the tone of unrestricted warfare is doing anything other than trying to dial us in and attune us to the patterns that Boyd talked about.
- 10:36Brian Rivera: Sun Tzu talked about Moose.
- 10:38Brian Rivera: But it's going to be the patterns that we're not oriented to right that we need to pay attention to those weak signals that are out there that people like Bill are pointing out.
- 10:45Brian Rivera: So that orientation within the OODA loop is we can't project our orientation onto other cultures, onto other people.
- 10:51Brian Rivera: You and I don't have the same orientation right, and that's what the OODA loop is telling us.
- 10:54Brian Rivera: It's an active process.
- 10:55Brian Rivera: Bill.
- 10:56Brian Rivera: I've read books.
- 10:57Brian Rivera: I've gone to every university, I've gone to ACSC years ago.
- 11:00Brian Rivera: I get your point about people not reading.
- 11:01Brian Rivera: We've had many folks on the show, several that talk about flow systems and physics of flow, and in their books they have sections on the golden section, the golden mean, the golden ratio, that I ignored.
- 11:12Brian Rivera: I just passed through.
- 11:13Brian Rivera: I'm like whatever, this is some nonsense that somebody's talking about Reading Unrestricted Warfare.
- 11:18Brian Rivera: Years ago I didn't pay attention to chapter six.
- 11:21Brian Rivera: I was like what the hell?
- 11:21Brian Rivera: Is this Some nonsense?
- 11:23Brian Rivera: So again, mark and I say this quite often and we hear it in the complex adaptive system world, and that is, in the neuroscience world is we only see what we expect to see, right?
- 11:34Brian Rivera: We have the idea that seeing is believing and believing is seeing that type of thing too.
- 11:36Brian Rivera: So I want to start there with what is the golden section?
- 11:39Brian Rivera: Golden mean where we find it in nature, that type of thing.
- 11:42Brian Rivera: So how did you get attracted to chapter six, based off of the golden section?
- 11:47Bill DeMarco: I'd love to tell you.
- 11:47Bill DeMarco: I just came across it and it was boom and I was like check it out.
- 11:51Bill DeMarco: Somebody told me about it, and I don't remember who.
- 11:53Bill DeMarco: I wish I did, but it's one of those that it was in a conversation, I think, when somebody mentioned or it might've been even it might've been another podcast, but somebody had mentioned chapter six and the golden mean and I thought, man, I need to go back and look at that.
- 12:06Bill DeMarco: So I picked it up, went back and looked and, yeah, it's so interesting to see that this idea of this mean is everywhere and it's like we find it aesthetically pleasing almost to go and seek this mean out.
- 12:19Bill DeMarco: Now, of course, when we apply it to strategy, I don't think it's as maybe obvious or as potent as like, let's say, you look at the, you know in Athens, you know.
- 12:30Bill DeMarco: You look at the up on the hill.
- 12:33Bill DeMarco: What do they call it?
- 12:33Bill DeMarco: The apocalypse, not the apocalypse.
- 12:36Bill DeMarco: Yeah, that's it.
- 12:37Mark McGrath: The acropolis.
- 12:38Mark McGrath: The acropolis, thank you.
- 12:39Mark McGrath: The parthenon on the acropolis the parthenon?
- 12:41Bill DeMarco: Yes, exactly, the pillars, all those things are designed along the lines of the golden mean.
- 12:46Bill DeMarco: So if you think about that, you think about a spiral shape of a shell.
- 12:49Bill DeMarco: You know the golden mean is everywhere in nature, it's everywhere in architecture.
- 12:53Bill DeMarco: Is right here.
- 12:54Bill DeMarco: I don't think you can measure it in strategy, if that makes any sense, but you can see it because maybe we default to it and we don't know we're defaulting to it.
- 13:14Mark McGrath: Let's hammer down on that, though we can't measure it by way of, maybe, objective metrics.
- 13:19Mark McGrath: But does it mean that it's not still occurring?
- 13:22Mark McGrath: It doesn't mean that it's not still present.
- 13:25Bill DeMarco: I think we desire to measure things.
- 13:27Bill DeMarco: You know what I mean.
- 13:27Bill DeMarco: It's like back to even what Ponch was kind of saying.
- 13:30Mark McGrath: I get that.
- 13:30Mark McGrath: I guess what I'm saying is that, in spite of our desire to measure things, it still appears that any universal phenomena, be it human action or otherwise, keeps presenting this ratio continuously.
- 13:43Mark McGrath: We talk a lot about how it appears in markets.
- 13:47Mark McGrath: Why would we think that geopolitical intercourse between nations would be any different?
- 13:51Mark McGrath: Why would we think that strategy would be any different?
- 13:55Mark McGrath: These are still humans.
- 13:56Mark McGrath: Humans are part of the ecology.
- 13:58Mark McGrath: They're part of the cosmos.
- 13:59Mark McGrath: Why would they not be acting in accordance with the way the universe is designed?
- 14:04Mark McGrath: We don't have to go too far, I agree.
- 14:05Bill DeMarco: I just think that that's the thing that was, like somebody said, like you know, in this, this piece that I was playing with, which was totally just riffing off this chapter of trying to find out where do we, where do we see this ratio, and I kind of played with this idea of fortifications and defensive positions, the idea of, maybe, military formations and tactics.
- 14:21Bill DeMarco: You know, uh, you think about this idea of infantry and cavalry.
- 14:27Bill DeMarco: You know the idea of do you see, more obviously, you have more infantry than you have cavalry.
- 14:31Bill DeMarco: Did that mean was it there in battles with Alexander the Great?
- 14:36Bill DeMarco: I think the answer is yeah, but I don't know if Alexander measured it intentionally.
- 14:41Mark McGrath: Yeah Well, it's kind of like equilibrium.
- 14:42Mark McGrath: You don't know that you're in it, but it still happens.
- 14:43Mark McGrath: It's still.
- 14:44Mark McGrath: It's kind of like equilibrium.
- 14:44Mark McGrath: You don't know that you're in it, but it still happens.
- 14:45Brian Rivera: Yes, it still is.
- 14:45Brian Rivera: I wonder if we can go back to the air war in Iraq, and you know those first days, and look at the proportion of something.
- 14:53Brian Rivera: I'm sure there's something there and the reason I bring that up is Iraq one or two?
- 14:55Brian Rivera: One One.
- 14:57Mark McGrath: Go for it, go for it.
- 14:58Brian Rivera: Yeah, so my time in an air and space operations center.
- 15:00Brian Rivera: Think about it, with how we're allocating weapons or weapons on platforms and things like that.
- 15:05Brian Rivera: It's based off the threat.
- 15:07Brian Rivera: So the context is driving the way we behave, right, and that's changed in the last 20 years.
- 15:11Brian Rivera: We're not going to see that type of warfare, or at least I don't think we are today.
- 15:16Brian Rivera: And I struggle with the application of I'll call it sacred geometry for now to strategy, because we just don't know how to do it.
- 15:22Brian Rivera: But I believe it's there right.
- 15:24Brian Rivera: I just don't know, like you and Mark, I don't know how to measure it.
- 15:26Brian Rivera: And then the path that we've gone on in the last few years is we've looked at the golden ratio inside the pyramids.
- 15:32Brian Rivera: We've seen it in the Vitruvian man from Leonardo da Vinci.
- 15:36Brian Rivera: We're learning more about squaring the circle.
- 15:37Brian Rivera: We've discovered that President Lincoln sat in his office for a couple of days trying to square the circle, which is matching the area of the circle to the area of the square, using nothing more than a compass and a straight edge.
- 15:47Brian Rivera: We're learning about harmonics in the application to understanding markets, music why is music appealing to us?
- 15:54Brian Rivera: Why do we see patterns?
- 15:55Brian Rivera: And then a connection to the free energy principle.
- 15:58Brian Rivera: We're trying to minimize the energy we spend in connecting with the world, and that's probably why these things are the way they are, why beauty is the way it is, because that helps us minimize surprise, reduce the energy we spend on things.
- 16:10Brian Rivera: So, when you think about strategy, what are you trying to do?
- 16:12Brian Rivera: Are you trying to minimize the energy spent on influencing your opponent?
- 16:16Brian Rivera: And again, I'm throwing this out there because I struggle with how do we apply this to strategy, but I do believe it's there.
- 16:23Bill DeMarco: Yes.
- 16:23Bill DeMarco: So that's exactly what I'm getting at is is that we look at this and we're like, well, show it to me.
- 16:28Bill DeMarco: And I don't know that I can, maybe I could.
- 16:31Bill DeMarco: Another thing we talk about math.
- 16:33Bill DeMarco: You know what I mean.
- 16:33Bill DeMarco: It's like I'm so not a math guy, I mean.
- 16:36Bill DeMarco: So that's the other problem too.
- 16:37Bill DeMarco: If I had a mathematician, maybe we could pull these things apart.
- 16:41Bill DeMarco: That's an interesting scenario.
- 16:45Bill DeMarco: Desert Storm I wonder if there's something there.
- 16:47Bill DeMarco: You think about the opening night of just taking down the IADs using soft on the ground Apaches and then stealth fighters.
- 16:54Bill DeMarco: Could you play that out with something along the lines of the ratio of the idea of the man on the ground or the small team on the ground?
- 17:03Bill DeMarco: I think it was two Apaches and a few stealth fighters, and then you know the idea of the man on the ground or the small team on the ground.
- 17:05Bill DeMarco: You know, I think it was two Apaches and a few stealth fighters, and then you go through the hole with all the bombers.
- 17:11Bill DeMarco: So there's your, there's your bulk.
- 17:12Bill DeMarco: You know, there's the 1.68 or whatever you want to say.
- 18:14Bill DeMarco: That's the bulk of it, but maybe those lines are actually smaller as you look to the opening of that door with the force coming.
- 18:21Mark McGrath: Well, we talk about too in the article, though it's not a rigid formula.
- 18:24Mark McGrath: It's not rigid, yet it doesn't mean, like we were saying, it doesn't mean it doesn't exist, yeah.
- 18:34Bill DeMarco: so that's why I find it fascinating, because I'm very attracted, like Ponch you mentioned, art music and, again, not an expert in any of those things.
- 18:42Bill DeMarco: In fact, music has been, it is a passion of mine.
- 18:45Bill DeMarco: But I played an instrument many, many years ago.
- 18:48Bill DeMarco: I played guitar and I was terrible and I was in a couple bands that I just leaned on the talent in the band and kind of hid in the background, if you know what I mean, in other words, enjoyed the experience, but I was not the person that added much to the team.
- 19:00Brian Rivera: Well, I'm wearing my Tool shirt today because they're a band that actually understands sacred geometry and they use it quite a bit in their music.
- 19:08Brian Rivera: So, kind of like you, I grew up around music.
- 19:10Brian Rivera: I understood the way they train music when you're younger and all that.
- 19:13Brian Rivera: I never came across the math.
- 19:14Brian Rivera: At least I don't remember coming across the math and the geometry inside of music.
- 19:17Brian Rivera: It years ago when one of our colleagues pointed out to us you know from his type of work he's doing on Wall Street and then I shared with my daughter.
- 19:25Brian Rivera: You know there's Euclidean geometry and there's this new type of geometry out there that it's kind of three-dimensional and all kinds of stuff.
- 19:32Brian Rivera: Then you get into the fascination between you know what's going on with the pyramids.
- 19:35Brian Rivera: Why are people like Aaron Rodgers going to the pyramids?
- 19:37Brian Rivera: To go experience something at another level?
- 19:40Brian Rivera: So you're starting to see this come into.
- 19:42Brian Rivera: I'll call it mainstream.
- 19:43Brian Rivera: You can find it on the web.
- 19:45Brian Rivera: You can find it on different specials on Netflix and wherever Gaia, wherever you want to look.
- 19:54Brian Rivera: But why aren't military leaders thinking like this?
- 19:56Brian Rivera: What are your challenges with communicating what's in this document?
- 19:58Bill DeMarco: with leaders.
- 19:58Bill DeMarco: I really think we're looking for the like back to the measurement, like show me that two and two is, show me that this makes sense.
- 20:06Bill DeMarco: You know, we, we invite.
- 20:07Bill DeMarco: You.
- 20:07Bill DeMarco: Guys might have heard of CASI, the Chinese Air and Space Institute.
- 20:10Bill DeMarco: It's an air university thing, but it really is part of NDU also.
- 20:13Bill DeMarco: So Dr Mulvaney is Brandon Mulvaney is the lead, and, and so we asked Dr Mulvaney to come out every year to speak to our class, and one of the things that he says every year that I just I think some of the students get it and some of them don't.
- 20:27Bill DeMarco: But we look at China and we want to say there's good and there's bad.
- 20:31Bill DeMarco: You know what I mean.
- 20:32Bill DeMarco: In other words, we do this and it's good, they do that and it's bad, and he'll say it's not good or bad, it's different.
- 20:38Bill DeMarco: And I think sometimes it's that space that we want to say, like two and two is four, so like the golden ratio.
- 20:45Bill DeMarco: When, when you read about this, you go well, that should be easy.
- 20:49Bill DeMarco: Then right, I mean, if it's a mathematical equation, I can solve for x.
- 20:53Bill DeMarco: I don't know that you can solve for x.
- 20:55Bill DeMarco: It's more of a.
- 20:56Bill DeMarco: Like, mark, you said it's fluid, right, I mean it's it's not necessarily there.
- 21:01Bill DeMarco: Like you listen to a song, you know the math might say this is a great song, but you hear it and you're like, oh, I don't know there's something off, it's not quite right.
- 21:11Mark McGrath: OK, so we're Gen Xers, right?
- 21:12Mark McGrath: You know it's song from the 80s that I absolutely abhor, I hate and everybody loves except me White Snake.
- 21:21Mark McGrath: Here I go again on my own, absolutely hate that song and I actually do believe it is something with the frequency or the impulses of that song that just absolutely put me off.
- 21:32Mark McGrath: I can't stand it's funny.
- 21:34Bill DeMarco: Um, yeah, it's just funny that you say that about white snake.
- 21:37Bill DeMarco: I saw white snake as a lieutenant over in germany and we went to the monsters of rock tour and aerosmith.
- 21:43Bill DeMarco: It was like a whole day, but just total side note.
- 21:44Bill DeMarco: White snake was a lieutenant over in Germany and we went to the Monsters of Roptour and Aerosmith.
- 21:44Bill DeMarco: It was like a whole day, but just total side note.
- 21:45Bill DeMarco: Whitesnake was a headliner.
- 21:47Bill DeMarco: Aerosmith was the band right before Whitesnake, and Aerosmith destroyed them and I just wondered what the conversation was backstage because it was just like they were so much better.
- 21:56Mark McGrath: So I wonder if it goes to what Ponchal teaches us, is that it goes to a state of flow Like something like white snake.
- 22:09Mark McGrath: To me doesn't flow.
- 22:10Mark McGrath: Say like I'm a grateful dead guy, I love jazz, I love, I love the beatles, like I don't feel like when I listen to something like that maybe it's I don't get to the the level of flow.
- 22:14Mark McGrath: And then, as a as an additionally to what we're talking about too, remember that john boyd never published or printed anything because everything was constantly changing, constantly flowing, and his snowmobile of what he made OODA Loop Sketch out of was entropy right.
- 22:29Mark McGrath: And then the other two would be uncertainty and incompleteness.
- 22:34Mark McGrath: So when we go around with this desire to constantly measure everything, we've got to constantly measure this, we've got to constantly measure that.
- 22:40Mark McGrath: It's the same thing in war fighting.
- 22:42Mark McGrath: It's the same thing in business.
- 22:43Mark McGrath: It's the same thing in war fighting.
- 22:44Mark McGrath: It's the same thing in business.
- 22:44Mark McGrath: It's the same thing in sports.
- 22:45Mark McGrath: Rigid measuring doesn't get you where you're going to need to be, because things are constantly changing.
- 22:49Mark McGrath: And when they do and you're stuck to those rigid formulas, then what?
- 22:53Mark McGrath: And even the Chinese officers are telling us like hey, this is a good baseline and guideline, this is how the universe presents itself, but don't use it as a rigid formula.
- 23:02Mark McGrath: Just have it in mind as you scan and sense make of the world.
- 23:06Brian Rivera: Moose, I'm going to riff off what you brought up here and I'm totally going to get this wrong.
- 23:10Brian Rivera: Okay, so going back to your Whitesnake point, I read this over the weekend that typically in music we know when something is going to happen.
- 23:16Brian Rivera: We can anticipate it because music has patterns in it.
- 23:19Brian Rivera: What we don't know is what.
- 23:20Brian Rivera: So it is possible that you could anticipate something in the Whitesnake song and that what isn't surprising to you.
- 23:26Brian Rivera: It doesn't satisfy you right?
- 23:34Brian Rivera: So there's great examples in a book I'm reading about music, that why we're attracted to different types of music.
- 23:37Brian Rivera: But the key point here is the patterns tell us when something is going to happen.
- 23:40Brian Rivera: They don't tell us what right.
- 23:42Brian Rivera: So maybe that's true with strategy.
- 23:43Brian Rivera: Just throwing that out there because I'm building on that Whitesnake piece.
- 23:45Mark McGrath: Jazz there's the baseline, there's the structure of the overall piece and then each individual takes a ride, right?
- 24:07Mark McGrath: So the saxophone guy's going to go, then they're going to go through the whole progression, and then the trumpeter's going to go, they go through the whole progression, and the pianist, et cetera, et cetera.
- 24:17Mark McGrath: To Poncha's point if you know the baseline, you can.
- 24:22Mark McGrath: If you know music well enough, you can sit there and be like, hey, I could go up there if I knew how to play it.
- 24:26Mark McGrath: But I can think of notes in my head that fit these scales.
- 24:29Mark McGrath: So, in other words, something fits the scale, but I don't know exactly what.
- 24:34Mark McGrath: But I can anticipate.
- 24:35Mark McGrath: And if something is off, I'll know, because it'll be out of sync.
- 24:40Mark McGrath: It'll be out of sync, right.
- 24:40Mark McGrath: It'll be out of harmony, right, we talk about the difference between harmony and synchronization.
- 24:43Mark McGrath: It'll be out of harmony with what?
- 24:48Mark McGrath: The scale or the structure or the rhythm pattern is right.
- 24:53Mark McGrath: Yeah, so it goes back to the whole thing, Like, well, why wouldn't strategy be any different?
- 24:59Brian Rivera: So one more thing, and I'm sorry, this is amazing, because over the weekend I listened to Ella Fitzgerald sing Mack the Knife from 1960s, where she got it wrong, but she knew everything about the structure of the song and she even sang in the song that she's making a wreck out of it.
- 25:12Brian Rivera: Right, but it got her.
- 25:13Brian Rivera: I think it got her an Emmy or whatever.
- 25:14Brian Rivera: Yes, the structure of something we can improvise in it, right, and that's the whole point of warfare, I think, is if we have a sound structure that we allow those distributed warfighters to improvise hopefully I'm saying that right then you create the conditions to win a war.
- 25:36Brian Rivera: You're right on.
- 25:37Brian Rivera: Okay, bill, can you build on any of this man?
- 25:39Brian Rivera: We're just throwing things out there.
- 25:41Bill DeMarco: No, no, this is so.
- 25:42Bill DeMarco: If you and I know, you guys have gone to my blog and my blog, really, the whole reason I did that, which I've been doing it for just like 15 years now, is that I don't have a huge following, I mean, but it's because I was trying to figure things out.
- 25:55Bill DeMarco: So there's a lot of pieces on there where I'm looking at a piece of music and trying to pick, like, okay, what did the artist mean when they said this?
- 26:03Bill DeMarco: And they're trying to lay it over leadership, strategy, innovation or whatever.
- 26:06Bill DeMarco: So everything you guys are saying it's like.
- 26:11Bill DeMarco: I'm just like, yeah, these are my people.
- 26:12Bill DeMarco: So it's funny.
- 26:12Bill DeMarco: When you talked about, you know the idea of the methodology to the music, because, moose, you talked about the Grateful Dead and I know there's that great piece on your is it Substack?
- 26:28Bill DeMarco: Or on the, the blog.
- 26:29Bill DeMarco: But I went to it and was was checking it out, uh, last week, um, you know, the dead are so interesting because they break those norms in so many different ways.
- 26:32Bill DeMarco: But we love yes, exactly, but we love the dead.
- 26:33Bill DeMarco: And then I ponder music today and again I sound like the old crusty, whatever white beard guy.
- 26:37Bill DeMarco: I got it, but but the idea is like so much of music today is just so basic and maybe that's because, to your point of, if you know what's coming, it's like the warm blanket.
- 26:46Bill DeMarco: You know what I mean.
- 26:47Bill DeMarco: In other words, I can wrap myself in it, because it's not, it's not really challenging me the way.
- 26:52Bill DeMarco: Honestly, jazz so much of jazz challenges us when we listen to it, because you don't always know.
- 26:57Bill DeMarco: But then you listen to it a few times and you're like LFS Geraldine and her version of mac the knife, like I love that version, but I can't remember the first time I heard it and it was wrong.
- 27:08Bill DeMarco: You know, I mean, but now I hear it and it's right.
- 27:10Bill DeMarco: So, in other words, we, we adapt to the grateful dead.
- 27:13Bill DeMarco: When I first listened to the dead I was very young, but I thought the grateful dead had to be a heavy metal band, you know, because, like zeppelin, and I'm like, yeah, they have names like mega death, you know, and guns and roses grateful dead isn't like metal.
- 27:28Bill DeMarco: How do they get to be the grateful dead?
- 27:29Bill DeMarco: Oh well, it's a little bit of blue corps, it's a little bit of jazz, it's a little bit of eastern music and philosophy.
- 27:37Bill DeMarco: You know, I I saw them years ago at stanford and they had two drummers and I was like well, how do you do that?
- 27:43Bill DeMarco: I mean, so it was all these things that don't make sense that later do make sense.
- 27:47Mark McGrath: Well, that so.
- 27:48Mark McGrath: And they had no studio albums like that.
- 27:50Mark McGrath: Well, they did, but but that's not what people you know, that's not what people went after.
- 27:54Mark McGrath: They, they were totally in flow state.
- 27:56Mark McGrath: That was the whole idea to to have like a core, a core riff and then build flow around it.
- 28:01Mark McGrath: They made all of their stuff available so if you came to a show you could tape it and you could trade those tapes and you could bootleg those tapes.
- 28:10Mark McGrath: And the reason that they did that was so that the word spread and their fan base ended up becoming their biggest marketing group.
- 28:18Mark McGrath: And it was decentralized, it was harmonized.
- 28:22Mark McGrath: It just seems to me like it.
- 28:23Mark McGrath: It's the john boyd type of of music for a lot of, a lot of reasons and it's extremely misunderstood because it's not produced.
- 28:31Mark McGrath: You know what I mean.
- 28:31Mark McGrath: It's not quote unquote, measured and structured and what we're expecting from sort of the mainstream, that it actually kind of goes along with the rhythms of the universe.
- 28:40Mark McGrath: And the last thing I'll say is another john Boyd angle of it is it's interdisciplinary.
- 28:44Mark McGrath: They had all different types of music.
- 28:46Mark McGrath: Phil Lesh was a classically trained composer.
- 28:50Mark McGrath: They wrote suites, they integrated music from every single genre.
- 28:56Mark McGrath: To your point about Eastern philosophy, which, of course, is a big part of John Boyd's OO-Loop sketch.
- 29:00Mark McGrath: Who used it?
- 29:02Mark McGrath: Phil Jackson was a deadhead and he talked about how he built the bulls and he looked at Michael as like the sort of the Jerry Garcia and constantly building an act around them that could bring them to a consistent state of flow as they encountered.
- 29:17Mark McGrath: Uh, and it was never the same.
- 29:18Mark McGrath: It was always always changing, built around that same core.
- 29:23Bill DeMarco: So those loose, loose ties, like like Poncho was saying.
- 29:26Bill DeMarco: That's when I think about strategy.
- 29:28Bill DeMarco: That's kind of what I'm getting at is how do you build those things around?
- 29:31Bill DeMarco: Strategy, in other words, it's not do this, then do that, and I do think that so much.
- 29:36Bill DeMarco: I hate to say that doesn't sound right, but so much of what we think of today has to be if I do this, then that will happen, and increasingly that's not the case.
- 29:46Bill DeMarco: If you do this, we don't know what will happen, but you need to get off your ass and do something.
- 29:50Bill DeMarco: Don't sit there and be paralyzed by what do I do?
- 29:54Brian Rivera: Do something and then react to the action, so the strategy is adaptive.
- 29:58Brian Rivera: I mean it's taking feedback from the environment and adjusting as necessary.
- 30:03Brian Rivera: So go back to the 1999, look at where we are today with technology.
- 30:07Brian Rivera: And I think what did the Chinese put in that document?
- 30:09Brian Rivera: As far as hacking, I forget they called it something other than Well, they had a really good name.
- 30:14Bill DeMarco: It was a crazy name.
- 30:15Bill DeMarco: I wonder if they had it here.
- 30:18Brian Rivera: It was an interesting name that they had for their hackers.
- 30:19Bill DeMarco: What I'm going with this is yeah, they totally called in the hacking.
- 30:23Brian Rivera: Yeah, so there's a pattern to the strategy that looks more than likely aligns to the geometry or the golden ratio, the golden section, and then, if you can set your strategy up such, then there's touch points where you can anticipate when something's going to change.
- 30:38Brian Rivera: It's the what that matters.
- 30:40Brian Rivera: How do you take that information from the environment and adjust at the local level?
- 30:45Brian Rivera: And that's what we're trying to tell folks.
- 30:47Brian Rivera: With strategy, you can't have a rigid approach to warfare, right, and that's maybe what the Chinese are telling us with this document is we're going to be an adaptive approach to kicking your ass while you guys are spending billions of dollars on aircraft carriers fighting the wars from 20, 30 years ago.
- 31:04Mark McGrath: Do you find that, bill, as you're interacting with officers today at every level, from flag officer, general officer, all the way down to brand new into the force do you find that much of what they're being taught and much of what they're exploring personally and I'm talking on the great average, I'm not talking about the outliers say, like us, that are reading obscure things that no one's thinking about like maybe Boyd would be, but do you find that what they're doing is it's more tech-heavy or it's more agenda-driven top-down?
- 31:36Mark McGrath: Or do you find that it's kind of like the old days, like where generals that graduated from West Point in the 19th and 20s and 30s that these were well-rounded, not only engineers but trained in liberal arts and languages and culture and other things, to give them a broader understanding of how the world works?
- 31:54Mark McGrath: Where do you see us at right now?
- 31:56Bill DeMarco: So that's a really interesting question because I've worked for, honestly, I've been fortunate where I've had some really, really amazing bosses.
- 32:03Bill DeMarco: I mean I think about people like you know, general Post.
- 32:06Bill DeMarco: General Post is not your average general.
- 32:08Bill DeMarco: The guy is he's a different level of thinker General Duncan McNabb I worked with him.
- 32:13Bill DeMarco: Same way, different level of thinker Kip Self.
- 32:15Bill DeMarco: I mean these generals were definitely not your standard.
- 32:19Bill DeMarco: Like, this is what we do things.
- 32:20Bill DeMarco: So I know that we have some amazing leaders.
- 32:23Bill DeMarco: I mean I look at, you know, general Alvin, our CSAP.
- 32:26Bill DeMarco: He and I were on the staff together a million years ago, so he is a deep, deep thinker.
- 32:30Bill DeMarco: We've been lucky to have people like Brown and Goldfein and Welsh that I think they do think very different.
- 32:37Bill DeMarco: But if you think about it from an org behavior perspective, what does our organization reward?
- 32:43Bill DeMarco: It's not those thinkers, like you know, quast, and that's what I think is really interesting.
- 32:49Bill DeMarco: Yet a guy like General Quast can raise up and be a three-star.
- 32:52Bill DeMarco: You know, arguably.
- 32:53Bill DeMarco: You know my opinion should have been a four-star, but nobody called me and I didn't get to sit on that board.
- 33:18Bill DeMarco: No-transcript, acsc.
- 33:24Bill DeMarco: You see, maybe fewer of those folks, and then probably War College, maybe a few less.
- 33:29Bill DeMarco: There's a great book you guys have probably read it called Over the Giant Hairball by Gordon McKenzie, and one of the things he has in there is he talks about going into classrooms and saying, like in kindergarten, how many of you are artists?
- 33:41Bill DeMarco: And every hand goes up.
- 33:42Bill DeMarco: And you go back in in like fourth or fifth grade and maybe half the hands go up.
- 33:46Bill DeMarco: You go back in high school maybe 20%, you know.
- 33:49Bill DeMarco: So the idea is that we kill this idea of this innovative and creative thinking in, especially the bureaucracy.
- 33:55Bill DeMarco: So I think that the talent is there and I think some of the people who've been assimilated can still do that thinking but they also know they're in this organization doesn't necessarily reward that thinking.
- 34:07Mark McGrath: Does that make sense?
- 34:08Mark McGrath: It goes back to yeah, you're right on, and it goes back to what our friend Don Vandergriff talks about all the time with mission command.
- 34:14Mark McGrath: You know, mission command the term has been completely perverted from what it was intended, and one of the things that Don calls for all the time is an overhaul of the personnel system Because, to your point, the personnel system does reward metrics, bureaucratic metrics, and the innovators and the thinkers likely get pushed out and they go into Wall Street or they go somewhere else because they don't want to deal with the machine anymore, so to speak.
- 34:43Mark McGrath: I think it does go back to the well-roundedness of leaders and thinkers.
- 34:48Mark McGrath: Now I do say and I'm biased as a Marine I really do think that the Marine Corps always did a good job at least when I was in of getting us to read and think about things that weren't really top-down.
- 34:59Mark McGrath: So we were reading Mal mein kampf was on the list and starship troopers by robert heinlein and other science fiction books.
- 35:05Mark McGrath: You know, it wasn't all just hey, america's great, this is the way you do it.
- 35:10Mark McGrath: One, two, three always equals this, and that's that's how we do it.
- 35:13Mark McGrath: Um, it was promoting uh, you know, fluid thinking, knowing that, as it says, in war fighting, knowing that everything is chaotic, frenetic, constantly changing, that you have to have the ability to do that and what Don always talks about we've done some staff rides with him and others.
- 35:32Mark McGrath: When you look at these great leaders of times past, I mean these were not just engineers, these were also men of letters and culture.
- 35:38Mark McGrath: I mean these were people that could speak multiple languages.
- 35:41Mark McGrath: These were people that could, uh, read philosophy.
- 35:44Mark McGrath: I'll never forget this as long as I live.
- 35:46Mark McGrath: So I was the second lieutenant at field artillery school in fort sill and the marines were segregated away from the soldiers in the platoons, like they.
- 35:52Mark McGrath: They broke us in platoons, although we did have one strand of army guys and they were all like future 82nd guys or whatever that would be in our platoon.
- 35:59Mark McGrath: I guess they could pt with us anyway.
- 36:01Mark McGrath: I was reading a john paul sart book, yeah an arm sir called me out.
- 36:06Mark McGrath: Why would you read that?
- 36:07Mark McGrath: That has nothing to do with artillery?
- 36:09Mark McGrath: And I'm like, well, no, actually it's philosophy and we should be talking about these types of things.
- 36:13Mark McGrath: I mean, like it's just like it's.
- 36:14Mark McGrath: It's it's ridiculed and mocked, like it's it where it should be.
- 36:18Mark McGrath: The other way around, we should be having these conversations about Chinese culture, sun Tzu, the golden mean, jazz music, grateful Dead, white Snake, whatever it is, and the thing about you brought up this idea of reading who's reading?
- 36:31Bill DeMarco: but the thing is, it's not just a one read either, like Sun Tzu.
- 36:34Bill DeMarco: I can't tell you how many times I've read Sun Tzu or Lao Tzu.
- 36:37Bill DeMarco: Or you mentioned Sartre.
- 36:38Bill DeMarco: I mean the idea of nausea, or how do you?
- 36:40Bill DeMarco: I mean, when I was working on my doctorate, I really started reading a lot of existential philosophers, because what I was looking at was existential.
- 36:48Bill DeMarco: So how do we understand that, except to go back to those philosophers that were wrestling with these ideas of what it means to be human?
- 36:56Mark McGrath: Well, I want Ponch to chime in on this, because this is something that boils our blood.
- 37:00Mark McGrath: So.
- 37:00Mark McGrath: So OODA loop is always reduced to a mechanical, formulaic template that you can put on any situation.
- 37:06Mark McGrath: As long as you're faster than the other guy, you're going to win.
- 37:09Mark McGrath: And then OODA loop sketches, we know it, which came at the end of John Boyd's life.
- 37:12Mark McGrath: So Ponch and I have spent considerable hours and days inside of Boyd's archives and books that he has there.
- 37:20Mark McGrath: Thousands of them cover every single category and they're drowning in margin notes.
- 37:24Mark McGrath: What would you add, ponch?
- 37:25Mark McGrath: What's your experience of learning from that?
- 37:27Mark McGrath: Of what was input?
- 37:30Mark McGrath: You know what Boyd was inputting for himself to give us what he gave us before he died.
- 37:35Mark McGrath: That's reduced.
- 37:37Brian Rivera: Man, you got me thinking on this and something else that Bill wrote about optimization and decision making.
- 37:41Brian Rivera: So the OODA loop could reflect this ratio where tempo matters, right, we know that there's connections to harmony.
- 37:48Brian Rivera: He writes about that all the time.
- 37:49Brian Rivera: So what I'm thinking now is the way you use the OODA loop is consistent with nature, which is we know that we actively engage with external environment to solicit input and feedback, to get sensory signals to tell us what's going on the outside world.
- 38:03Brian Rivera: So it's constructed inside out or top-down inside out.
- 38:06Brian Rivera: With that being said, I think what we're learning about today, and what you and I have learned about the OODA loop, is it is not, it's not the reductionist, passive approach that many people use.
- 38:15Brian Rivera: In fact, the AI community is quickly finding out you can't scale linear OODA loops, the reductionist approach.
- 38:21Brian Rivera: What they are finding out is you can scale what John Boyd actually sketched out and gave us, which is an active inference approach, a Bayesian inference approach, a mathematical approach to dealing with uncertainty, right?
- 38:32Brian Rivera: So I don't know if I'm answering your question.
- 38:35Brian Rivera: I've actually got a question about the golden, mean, golden section connection to economics that Bill came across, because I think it feeds into decision-making and optimization, which the OODA loop is about minimizing energy and maximizing not control, but adaptation and learning in the environment.
- 38:56Brian Rivera: Sorry, bill, I just kind of rambled there, but is there a connection to what you discovered with the economist that was studying the golden section?
- 39:04Bill DeMarco: Yeah, I mean that was interesting too was to go in and see who actually has been using this, and there was an economist and a mathematician and of course I'm terrible with pronouncing Chinese names, but Lao Zhen, I believe, is how to say that name.
- 39:17Bill DeMarco: But Lao Zhen was looking at this idea of from a mathematic perspective.
- 39:21Bill DeMarco: No-transcript.
- 39:47Brian Rivera: Moosted, my answer and what you just heard from Bill.
- 39:51Brian Rivera: How's that resonate with you and the question you asked about Boyd's work?
- 39:55Mark McGrath: Well, I think it goes right to the things that Bill points out in his article about strategic positioning, flexibility, adaptation, deception, misdirection, holistic thinking, patience, long-term planning and, lastly, leveraging strengths and weaknesses.
- 40:07Mark McGrath: I mean, that's right out of the John Boyd playbook, which is heavily Eastern influenced, and this is lost on most that, I think, in our military establishment that focus on Western models which are largely driven by bureaucracy, they're largely driven by metrics, they're largely driven by personal gain or or or an obsolete personnel system that is not enabling our orientation to deal with reality as it actually is.
- 40:36Mark McGrath: Now, I'm not saying that the Chinese officers are like spot on that to what reality actually is, but at least it seems that they're trying to create and destroy and destroy and create models that are trying to help them align to it more than, say, your average, average american here's another thought.
- 40:56Brian Rivera: You and I had folks on to talk about attractors, adjacent possible and affordances in the external environment.
- 41:01Brian Rivera: If we look at music again, if you look at sacred geometry, these little attractors, the adjacent possible and affordances in the external environment, if we look at music again, if you look at sacred geometry, these little attractors are out there, right.
- 41:06Brian Rivera: So maybe that's what we need to be looking at are the attractors, the affordances, the adjacent possible in the external environment and looking for patterns there.
- 41:13Brian Rivera: And that informs our strategy.
- 41:15Brian Rivera: By the way, the way we develop a strategy by looking outside in right.
- 41:19Brian Rivera: Not inside out.
- 41:23Mark McGrath: Yeah, and that's why Boyd didn then just take patterns of conflict.
- 41:25Mark McGrath: I mean, why does he start all the way back as far as he could go with recorded military history?
- 41:29Mark McGrath: Because his point was these concepts don't change, they don't go away, and, and, and.
- 41:34Mark McGrath: What empowers an underdog to defeat um, not an underdog, I don't know what empowers David to defeat a Goliath is exactly this type of thinking.
- 41:44Mark McGrath: It's exactly this type of exposure to interdisciplinary ideas.
- 41:49Mark McGrath: Understanding how things flow, understanding how patterns actually work and why you study, why you make Marines read Mein Kampf and Mao and other things, is so that they can identify these patterns, so that when they do happen, it's evident to me, it's part of my orientation, so that when I'm sense-making and it occurs, I can see it faster than my opponents.
- 42:09Mark McGrath: And it's radical, it's decentralized, what Boyd talks about, what Marshall McLuhan talks about being radical, decentralized and pervasive in understanding media.
- 42:19Mark McGrath: And that, unfortunately, is not a popular way if you want to climb the ranks in a bureaucracy.
- 42:26Mark McGrath: Yet at the same time, that doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to be able to win everything just because we have all the capital, all the tools, all the weaponry, all the sensors, all the guidance systems, all the missiles and rockets and bombs, et cetera.
- 42:38Mark McGrath: Because, as Boyd pointed out in Patterns of Conflict, using Andrew Kropenovich's book, the Army in Vietnam as an example, we had everything and we lost to people with bicycles, ak-47s and we killed more of them than they killed of us.
- 42:53Mark McGrath: We didn't win the moral war and we didn't understand the cultural war there and the places where we did with, like the Marine CAP program and the and the uh, the green beret, uh a teams and things like that we did, we completely undermined all that in the name of open field showdowns, trying to lure the nva into the open field showdown with with force on force and go after terrain and, as we know, terrain does not win wars.
- 43:19Mark McGrath: Technology does not win wars.
- 43:20Mark McGrath: People do and they use their minds and that's what is lost, I think.
- 43:25Brian Rivera: This is a very deep-thinking episode where we're just throwing things out there.
- 43:28Brian Rivera: Bill, I mean this topic.
- 43:30Brian Rivera: I don't have an answer.
- 43:31Brian Rivera: I don't think Mark has an answer.
- 43:32Brian Rivera: Have we triggered anything?
- 43:34Brian Rivera: What are you going through?
- 43:38Brian Rivera: What's going through in your mind right now?
- 43:39Brian Rivera: Are we?
- 43:40Bill DeMarco: crazy.
- 43:40Bill DeMarco: No, no, I'm totally with you and I think that some of the things that Mark just brought up it makes me think about.
- 43:47Bill DeMarco: If you get back to this idea of just basic Eastern philosophy and you mentioned this idea of strengths and weaknesses how do we look at these things?
- 43:57Bill DeMarco: One thing that I've always been drawn to is this idea of yin-yang, and I kind of break it down when I'm talking to students.
- 44:04Bill DeMarco: You know, I put it up there and I always kind of make the joke that this is not something you get drunk and just get it tattooed on your butt.
- 44:09Bill DeMarco: I mean, like what does that symbol really mean?
- 44:12Bill DeMarco: It's one, it's unity, it's also order and it's chaos.
- 44:17Bill DeMarco: So if you start thinking about order and chaos, you know what is the US really trying to do so many times is to bring order to the chaos.
- 44:25Bill DeMarco: But the chaos is always going to be there.
- 44:27Bill DeMarco: The chaos isn't going to go away.
- 44:29Bill DeMarco: So, as we go into these fights a lot of times, think about, you know, the war on terror.
- 44:33Bill DeMarco: We were trying to bring order into a place like Afghanistan, which historically has always been chaos.
- 44:39Bill DeMarco: Well, how did that go for us?
- 44:41Bill DeMarco: Or back to your point, mark, about Vietnam.
- 44:43Bill DeMarco: I mean we were trying to impose our will on a situation that we couldn't that mean and that yin-yang was still going to exist.
- 44:50Bill DeMarco: So how do we exist in the chaos?
- 44:52Bill DeMarco: Our bureaucracy is all about order.
- 44:55Bill DeMarco: You know what I mean.
- 44:56Bill DeMarco: That's, what we promote is order.
- 44:57Bill DeMarco: Yet future conflicts, past conflicts, but let's just talk about the future is going to be chaos.
- 45:02Bill DeMarco: So how do we train and educate our leaders to understand the chaos and the order?
- 45:45Mark McGrath: no-transcript, because he figured out, like Lawrence did, how to harness culture, how to assimilate with culture and be a true liaison, how to bridge two worlds from a point of empathy, from a point of a cultural understanding.
- 46:01Mark McGrath: And he actually had marked progress that could be measured, because violence went down, the influence of the enemy went down, just like it had with the CAP program in Vietnam, just like it had with the Special Forces A-teams in Vietnam.
- 46:15Mark McGrath: That always is going to get pushed aside for something that's more.
- 46:19Mark McGrath: Hey, this is what America does.
- 46:21Mark McGrath: It's Uncle Sam, we don't want any casualties, we're going to bomb you into the Stone Age and you're just going to submit.
- 46:26Mark McGrath: That doesn't work, it doesn't work and that's why we can't.
- 46:29Mark McGrath: It's why Afghanistan was a failure, it's why Vietnam was a failure, because that cultural aspect, I think, goes back to Boyd and Sun Tzu.
- 46:36Mark McGrath: It's tying in.
- 46:38Mark McGrath: Can I connect with these individuals on the philosophical level, on the moral level?
- 46:43Mark McGrath: And if I can, I'm going to build a bond that cannot be disrupted by competing ideas, competing forces or whatever.
- 46:50Mark McGrath: I'm going to build trust and be able to build mutual trust.
- 46:54Mark McGrath: We're going to have intuition.
- 46:56Mark McGrath: We're going to be able to accomplish things together because we're able to connect on the moral plane.
- 47:01Mark McGrath: I used to tell clients this in my previous life in Wall Street.
- 47:05Mark McGrath: Asset Management was like if you can build relationships with your clientele on the moral plane, on the philosophical plane, that bond is indisruptible and you can't get underbid by a lower price, you can't get beaten by a competitor because that bond that you have with that client assuming that you're not a lawbreaker or anything like that that bond is impenetrable.
- 47:28Mark McGrath: And I think that what we're talking about, what we started talking about, about why unrestricted warfare shocks so many people or they don't even want to read it is because it does great against what we're taught culturally from a bureaucratic complex versus a bottom-up.
- 47:44Mark McGrath: This is how things work and this is how we can assimilate and work together in a part of the world that's still, by and large, completely misunderstood by intervening in the Far East since the 1830s.
- 47:56Mark McGrath: So I do think that the Navy and the Marine Corps does have some kind of edge just my own personal theory of understanding sort of Eastern ways or being open to Eastern ways more than maybe the Army and the Air Force.
- 48:11Mark McGrath: We should be open to that, especially if they think that this is where adversaries are going to be.
- 48:15Mark McGrath: We should be learning why they think the way that they do, why they understand things the way that they do, so that we could hopefully get to a point where we don't have to fire a shot, which is also very Sun Tzu and very John Boyd.
- 48:27Brian Rivera: Thought here Chinese healing.
- 48:29Brian Rivera: You brought up yin and yang.
- 48:31Brian Rivera: I know there's some sacred geometry in that too.
- 48:34Brian Rivera: I don't have the document in front of me, but the way they look at healing in the East is not how we look at it here, right?
- 48:41Brian Rivera: I mean they're more into functional type approaches, whereas we're into siloed approaches in our healthcare system.
- 48:48Brian Rivera: So those experiences, that culture, if you will, triggers how they are oriented to the external world.
- 48:52Brian Rivera: We're not that way.
- 48:53Brian Rivera: So I'm just wondering is there a connection to-.
- 48:56Bill DeMarco: So I think it's a really interesting point because you read unrestricted warfare and it's a spectrum right, that's why it's called unrestricted warfare.
- 49:03Bill DeMarco: It was a new way of looking at warfare, in other words, and that translation is not a great translation of the title either.
- 49:11Bill DeMarco: But let's just think about the United States we talk about and I don't care what acronym you use, I always go back to because it's simple diplomatic information military economics Over the last 30 years or so.
- 49:21Bill DeMarco: Military economics Over the last 30 years or so.
- 49:25Bill DeMarco: We've really gotten to this giant lowercase d, lowercase I, giant lowercase e.
- 49:31Bill DeMarco: To your point, ponch, I think that's the stovepipe right back to the healing.
- 49:32Bill DeMarco: We're going to cure cancer.
- 49:33Bill DeMarco: That's it.
- 49:33Bill DeMarco: It's all about this cancer drug or the military will solve all of our problems and we know that's true.
- 49:40Bill DeMarco: You look at what China's doing right now with things like just picking up Belt and Road Initiative.
- 49:44Bill DeMarco: I mean, that's not necessarily military, although there's an M component in there, there's a D component, there's an I component and there's an E component, all in that idea of a Belt and Road Initiative so we can span the spectrum from the Eastern side.
- 49:57Bill DeMarco: We're not doing that very well on the Western side.
- 50:00Bill DeMarco: Arguably, I would say that we might've done a better job in the Cold War.
- 50:04Bill DeMarco: The idea was that we had a pretty robust USAID as an example.
- 50:08Bill DeMarco: Usaid aid is like they're minuscule.
- 50:15Bill DeMarco: I worked with them a lot when I was in the Pentagon and the quote was always something like we have more band members in the DOD than they have members in USAID.
- 50:20Bill DeMarco: But USAID is really important when you're trying to do things that are not military oriented trying to make friends and influence people.
- 50:30Mark McGrath: Huh, so there's a great picture of David Shoup, who was the Commandant of the Marine Corps Medal of Honor recipient the Battle of Tarawa, reading the book how to Win Friends and Influence People, which I think, to double check me, I'm pretty sure that's been on Service Chief reading list at some point, and what is it ultimately trying to do?
- 50:51Mark McGrath: It's trying to teach you how to become empathetic as a leader, to try to understand rather than just simply know.
- 51:00Mark McGrath: Anyway, back to your article, though.
- 51:02Mark McGrath: What about the side principle rule?
- 51:03Mark McGrath: That's the.
- 51:04Mark McGrath: That's a concept that's talked about in chapter six.
- 51:08Mark McGrath: I've seen other people write about that too.
- 51:11Mark McGrath: There's Quintus Curtius, who's a former Marine that does a translation of military thinkers that we hope to have on the show at some point too, and he talks about.
- 51:21Mark McGrath: It was in the chapter six side principle, the side principle rule, and they spelled principle not with a L-E, with an A-L.
- 51:32Bill DeMarco: Yeah, and also the side element is another way of looking at that.
- 51:35Bill DeMarco: I'm just looking at it right now, but the idea is I remember what they called the hackers.
- 51:39Bill DeMarco: Now they were called web rascals, but the idea was that there were these web rascals that would get into the system and in a way, that's kind of the side element.
- 51:47Bill DeMarco: Right, it's how do I attack or do things on the side.
- 51:50Bill DeMarco: That's not a frontal assault.
- 51:52Bill DeMarco: And we started thinking about.
- 51:53Bill DeMarco: Think about China.
- 51:54Bill DeMarco: I don't think to your point.
- 51:56Bill DeMarco: They don't want conflict over the Taiwanese Strait, they want it to be obvious.
- 52:07Bill DeMarco: In other words, how do I win without firing a shot?
- 52:08Bill DeMarco: Yeah, when it becomes obvious.
- 52:09Bill DeMarco: And just think about, over the weekend, those pictures released of their new, possibly sixth gen fighter.
- 52:11Bill DeMarco: Um, you know like hey, look at all the stuff we have fighting us is useless, we will win.
- 52:16Bill DeMarco: Think about back to ronald reagan and star wars.
- 52:19Bill DeMarco: The idea of star wars wasn't really a thing.
- 52:21Bill DeMarco: You know what I mean.
- 52:22Bill DeMarco: It was like we didn't have the technology but this idea that we could do this.
- 52:26Bill DeMarco: And then, knowing that America, if they say they're going to do it, is going to do it.
- 52:29Bill DeMarco: I'm not saying it's what won the Cold War, but I'm just saying it was one thing on top of it, kind of a side principle or side element of how do we keep attacking this from the sides so we're not doing the frontal?
- 52:41Mark McGrath: It amplified the adversary's friction.
- 52:43Mark McGrath: It got them thinking about things that they shouldn't necessarily be thinking about.
- 52:48Mark McGrath: It got them entertained with a sideshow and they get distracted from focus.
- 52:52Mark McGrath: And I think that that's what when I take away and I think about unrestricted warfare.
- 52:56Mark McGrath: That's why I give TikTok a double take, and that's where I give a lot of the things that we see in media, you know, a double, a double take, because I think that the distractions are being put out there and then we wind up losing our focus.
- 53:09Brian Rivera: So the principle side rule is that kind of like the concept of obliquity.
- 53:13Brian Rivera: And I don't know if you ever read John Kay's book I think it's about 15 years old now.
- 53:17Brian Rivera: It's the same thing in complex adaptive systems thinking is you generally don't want to take things head on, you take an oblique approach.
- 53:25Brian Rivera: No, exactly right.
- 53:25Brian Rivera: How do you come up with things from?
- 53:26Bill DeMarco: the side we do some work with Michigan and a guy up there named Jeff DeGraff and he always talks about the side door.
- 53:30Bill DeMarco: You need a side door into this.
- 53:32Bill DeMarco: How do you get in through the side, especially in bureaucracy?
- 53:36Bill DeMarco: The idea of, oh, just get a few generals on board.
- 53:38Bill DeMarco: Okay, generals are really busy and to get a general's attention is really hard.
- 53:41Bill DeMarco: And just a little side note I spent a lot of time working with generals.
- 53:45Bill DeMarco: They don't like saying no either, so they get their henchmen to say no, which is usually their colonels to go say no, or their captains, in your case Fonch.
- 53:53Bill DeMarco: But the idea of you know, like the general's, like that's a great idea.
- 53:56Bill DeMarco: Then they look over at you and like, hey, go kill that.
- 53:58Bill DeMarco: But so the side doors.
- 53:59Bill DeMarco: Really, how do I come in it from the side, maybe how do I go talk to the 06s before I talk to the general?
- 54:04Bill DeMarco: Get the 06s on board.
- 54:06Bill DeMarco: You know what I mean.
- 54:07Bill DeMarco: And now you run a casual schlock maneuver.
- 54:09Bill DeMarco: The idea of like you've got a cauldron around the individual and they don't even know that they're surrounded.
- 54:14Brian Rivera: Do you just describe what's happening now with the current war right?
- 54:17Brian Rivera: I mean, people don't know that it's happening to them.
- 54:20Bill DeMarco: Yes, exactly right, it's the frog in the water.
- 54:22Bill DeMarco: Interesting.
- 54:24Bill DeMarco: You brought that up too, because I believe and again, I have a terrible tendency to give the adversary too much credit.
- 54:31Bill DeMarco: I learned this.
- 54:32Bill DeMarco: You know, panchano, you were over in the Air Operations Center, I was too.
- 54:35Bill DeMarco: There are so many times that I would look at things like, well, the enemy's going to do this and they wouldn't do it, and I'm like that was an obvious left hook.
- 54:47Bill DeMarco: You could have got me right in the chin and you didn't do it.
- 54:49Bill DeMarco: So I do that often.
- 54:49Bill DeMarco: But I look at China right now and I do believe Bill DeMarco.
- 54:50Bill DeMarco: Only they can hear us think.
- 54:51Bill DeMarco: So they know what Americans do Think about it.
- 54:55Bill DeMarco: They're all in Hollywood right now and it sounds so stupid.
- 54:57Bill DeMarco: I wrote a piece on this too.
- 54:58Bill DeMarco: Why are there no Chinese bad guys?
- 55:00Bill DeMarco: Like back in the Cold War?
- 55:02Bill DeMarco: There were Russian bad guys all the time.
- 55:04Bill DeMarco: Red Dawn classic example right, I mean the first Red Dawn, not the second one, I mean you're describing the Gen X canon.
- 55:10Bill DeMarco: Yes, but the idea was the Soviets were the bad guys, and you know movies and all these things.
- 55:15Bill DeMarco: In other words, it was in our culture that you went to a blockbuster.
- 55:20Bill DeMarco: The bad guys were Soviets.
- 55:22Bill DeMarco: Today, the bad guys are who, aliens, monsters, you know what I mean.
- 55:27Bill DeMarco: The idea is like, well, it's just everybody's okay, but it's not, because China already owns so much of a massive percentage of Hollywood that you can't do that.
- 55:35Bill DeMarco: Red Dawn, the sequel, or not the sequel, the current version, I guess it's like 10 years, 20 years old now.
- 55:41Bill DeMarco: But they wanted to be China and China said no, so it became North Korea.
- 55:45Bill DeMarco: So the fact is, we all know North Korea has no capability to launch an airborne assault on the United States of America and their members are too small, blah, blah, blah.
- 55:53Bill DeMarco: But the Chinese said no, so we said it's okay.
- 55:56Bill DeMarco: Fentanyl, fentanyl, drugs, tiktok great example of social media, all these things that the Chinese are like.
- 56:04Bill DeMarco: We'll just side door here.
- 56:05Bill DeMarco: We'll just do this oblique movement here, here and here, so they can hear us think.
- 56:10Bill DeMarco: I'm sorry, bruce, I stepped on you.
- 56:12Mark McGrath: No, no, it's interesting because I think back to World War II and you look at the movies that were produced before December 7th 1941, like Abbott and Costello in the army, now about getting drafted the dictator, with Charlie Chaplinplin.
- 56:24Mark McGrath: I mean it feels like there was a lot of things that were programming us and preparing us for uh, for war in europe.
- 56:31Mark McGrath: And then every movie that came out after I always was very clearly the bad guys were the nazis and the japanese.
- 56:38Mark McGrath: I mean that was every single movie we ever, we ever grew up with into your boys bunny and daffy duck, I mean I was like even the cartoons and the Japanese.
- 56:41Mark McGrath: I mean that was every single movie we ever grew up with, even Bugs.
- 56:43Bill DeMarco: Bunny and Daffy Duck.
- 56:44Bill DeMarco: I mean, I was like even the cartoons had the same thing.
- 56:46Bill DeMarco: Yeah, the propaganda.
- 56:48Mark McGrath: Yeah, I mean, that's really.
- 56:49Mark McGrath: It is really fascinating to think about.
- 56:51Mark McGrath: But again it goes.
- 56:53Mark McGrath: I think that people understood that the war is also in the mind.
- 56:55Mark McGrath: It's not just.
- 56:56Mark McGrath: It's just not against the terrain or against, you know, people we don't like.
- 57:01Mark McGrath: It's just not against the terrain or against people we don't like, in those cases Germans or Japanese.
- 57:05Mark McGrath: In those days we have to be conditioned to think that.
- 57:07Mark McGrath: First, because in our country, as we all know, before December 7th 1941, there was a lot of Japanese people that were Americans and a lot of Germans that were Americans, that were living amongst us and a vibrant part of our culture, just like China.
- 57:24Mark McGrath: Chinese have been in the United States since the 1800s.
- 57:27Mark McGrath: You know from the very beginning.
- 57:30Mark McGrath: And then when you read books about, like you know, james Bradley that wrote Flags of Our Fathers and the Flyboys, about the Aishimara, he has been taken off the good list because he wrote a book called the China Mirage and he goes list because he wrote a book called the China Mirage and he goes back and he documents a lot of these things that over the last hundred or so years that China really has a burr in their side, that the Western world, between the United Kingdom and the United States has caused for them, like the opium wars and pushing opium and selling opium into China and taking Macau and and uh, hong kong and stuff and what we forget and this is about the cultural differences right back to that.
- 58:07Mark McGrath: They're thinking back thousands of years, like a hundred years to them is like, but like, think about us.
- 58:13Mark McGrath: We think like 24 hours ago, like people are already not talking about how quick did donald trump getting shot came right out of the news site, right?
- 58:21Mark McGrath: We don't even think in terms of that because we're so attuned in the West to this 24-hour news cycle, whereas their minds and their thinking is going back, you know, thousands and thousands of years, in some cases, such that where the golden ratio comes from right, I mean, that's not a new concept.
- 58:40Mark McGrath: No, it's an ancient concept.
- 58:42Mark McGrath: Yeah, we talk about psychedelic therapies all the time.
- 58:45Mark McGrath: That's not a new thing.
- 58:47Mark McGrath: Those are thousands of years old.
- 58:49Mark McGrath: It's new to us because I didn't see it on CNN in the last 24 hours, although more and more it's on.
- 58:54Mark McGrath: CNN.
- 58:55Mark McGrath: Yeah, a recency bias is a massive problem, but it goes back to the loop sketch.
- 59:00Mark McGrath: I mean, if I understand my opponent's biases, I'm able to leverage those to my advantage, I'm able to amplify their friction.
- 59:09Mark McGrath: And to your point, bill, we broadcast our biases religiously.
- 59:13Mark McGrath: It's everywhere.
- 59:14Brian Rivera: Yeah, you do it on social media everywhere.
- 59:16Brian Rivera: So that's it.
- 59:17Brian Rivera: The capturing of the external environment by the Chinese informs their strategy.
- 59:20Brian Rivera: That's it right?
- 59:22Brian Rivera: I mean, we can't, we don't think like that.
- 59:24Mark McGrath: We've all lived on bases overseas right Me, not only as an officer but also as a kid.
- 59:30Mark McGrath: And you step on Grafenwoehr Army training area in 1983, you leave Germany, you leave Bavaria and you go into America.
- 59:40Mark McGrath: It's got the PX, it's got American cars, it's got everything.
- 59:43Mark McGrath: It's like everywhere we go we put America.
- 59:45Mark McGrath: And I remember reading about Jim Gant in the book American Spartan was written by his wife, ann Tyson.
- 59:51Mark McGrath: They're talking about how whoever relieved them or replaced them like the first question when they would get to these villages that he had been so successful with the first thing out of their mouth well, where's the chow hall?
- 59:59Mark McGrath: Where's the weight room?
- 1:00:00Mark McGrath: Where's the PX?
- 1:00:02Mark McGrath: Where's all this stuff that we're so accustomed to versus what was culturally attuned to success, understanding how things operate elsewhere?
- 1:00:12Bill DeMarco: So then I always have to wonder how to fix it, because then you realize that we're not going to get rid of the idea of social media.
- 1:00:20Bill DeMarco: That's not going away, no.
- 1:00:20Bill DeMarco: So what do we do?
- 1:00:21Bill DeMarco: How do you counteract it, to get rid of, you know, the idea of social media?
- 1:00:24Bill DeMarco: That's not going away, you know.
- 1:00:25Bill DeMarco: So, like, what do we do?
- 1:00:28Bill DeMarco: How do you counteract it?
- 1:00:28Bill DeMarco: And the problem is, as a capitalist entity, you know, you think about let's go back to Hollywood.
- 1:00:30Bill DeMarco: It's all about the money.
- 1:00:31Bill DeMarco: There was some interesting work done, you know, speaking of philosophy, all this you guys probably have read some of the stuff from the Frankfurt School.
- 1:00:36Bill DeMarco: But there was this whole bit about how do you make art in a capitalist society.
- 1:00:42Bill DeMarco: Because the fact is, you'll keep making the art that makes the money.
- 1:00:45Bill DeMarco: And again, I love capital.
- 1:00:48Bill DeMarco: Capital is a great thing, but the fact was, if you keep making art to make money, you'll keep making the same things over and over again.
- 1:00:55Bill DeMarco: So then I look at superhero movies.
- 1:00:58Bill DeMarco: Just an example they were great.
- 1:01:00Bill DeMarco: Think back to 1989, batman.
- 1:01:02Bill DeMarco: That was just Michael Keaton and Batman, amazing.
- 1:01:05Bill DeMarco: And then all of a sudden, wow, that made a lot of money.
- 1:01:07Mark McGrath: Still, the best Jack Nicholson the Joker.
- 1:01:09Bill DeMarco: Yes, we've got to keep on making that movie over and over again, the Niagara of Gotham.
- 1:01:13Mark McGrath: That was the best.
- 1:01:14Mark McGrath: Kim Basinger, come on.
- 1:01:15Mark McGrath: Yes.
- 1:01:15Bill DeMarco: It's a great movie, but we keep on trying to remake, then Marvel comes out.
- 1:01:24Mark McGrath: The first Marvel movies are really great.
- 1:01:25Mark McGrath: When's the last good Marvel movie, bill?
- 1:01:26Mark McGrath: How many movies have been made about TV shows that we grew up with?
- 1:01:28Mark McGrath: There's a Chips movie and a Dukes of Hazzard movie and a Charlie's Angels movies and things like that.
- 1:01:32Mark McGrath: It's like find something original.
- 1:01:33Mark McGrath: What do?
- 1:01:34Bill DeMarco: we keep on remaking it because that's where the money is, although arguably not, but it's a safer bet than making something new.
- 1:01:41Bill DeMarco: So the Frankfurt School is saying the same thing with art.
- 1:01:43Bill DeMarco: The fact is that, basically, art will continue to only be made based on what we know we like.
- 1:01:49Bill DeMarco: That worries me a bit.
- 1:01:50Bill DeMarco: This is a way tangent, but since we talked about music earlier, it worries me with the algorithms now and like Apple Music Because what it's doing is feeding me the music it knows I like, but I'm the guy that likes music.
- 1:02:01Bill DeMarco: I don't know that I like, if that makes any sense.
- 1:02:04Mark McGrath: Well, so now you've done it.
- 1:02:05Mark McGrath: Now you've opened another thing that we've talked a lot about Marshall McLuhan.
- 1:02:08Mark McGrath: So Marshall McLuhan thought that the artists were actually the do line.
- 1:02:11Mark McGrath: If you remember the defense early warning system artists, out away, the money-making art that you're talking about, and you're actually looking at the art for art's sakes, the actual legitimate artists.
- 1:02:28Mark McGrath: That's the do-line, that's telling us what's coming and that's what's actually leading the turn that are coming.
- 1:02:36Brian Rivera: Huh, hey, Ponch, I don't know about you, I smell a live broadcast with Bill John Robb and Andrew McLuhan go and then does a lot of work in sacred geometry, very familiar with Shakespeare, and he actually had a series that I watched called the America Codes where he decoded the Declaration of Independence.
- 1:03:06Brian Rivera: What's in there and all that.
- 1:03:07Brian Rivera: It's kind of interesting Connecting back to Tao and Phi.
- 1:03:10Brian Rivera: Again, there's a lot of connections in there to what we talked about.
- 1:03:13Brian Rivera: But we're pretty early in our exploration of this topic and we've come across it again in physics from Adrian Bijan and his work on the physics of flow and beauty.
- 1:03:24Brian Rivera: In time it's in the back half of some of his books.
- 1:03:26Brian Rivera: We've come across it in music.
- 1:03:36Brian Rivera: We've definitely come across it in the world of psychedelic assisted therapy and some work on Wall Street with Mandelbrot connections to Mandelbrot, in fact, mark and I pointed out that John Boyd was starting to explore a little bit of Mandelbrot's work before he passed.
- 1:03:43Brian Rivera: And then, of course, we're looking at sacred geometry applied to the planets, the universe, and understanding the connection to the pyramids.
- 1:03:51Brian Rivera: What do the pyramids really mean?
- 1:03:53Brian Rivera: Finding more connections back to the pineal gland, back in the sarcophagus of the pyramid.
- 1:03:59Brian Rivera: So there's so many unknowns right now and I think what we definitely want to do is have you back and continue this conversation as we explore with experts in the field of sacred geometry what this means, because I do believe, like you do, I think you do.
- 1:04:14Brian Rivera: There's a solid connection to strategy or decision-making.
- 1:04:19Bill DeMarco: Yeah and I think Moose brought it up the idea that it has to be fluid and agile, because if we're looking for the absolute answer, it's probably not there.
- 1:04:26Bill DeMarco: In other words, it's not going to be full every time you put these two things together.
- 1:04:30Bill DeMarco: But if we don't have a basis to build off of, then we've got nothing.
- 1:04:34Bill DeMarco: And I kind of feel like right now we're taking a lot of shots in the dark when it comes to national level strategy and we don't really know what it is, so that we're not basing on anything.
- 1:04:43Bill DeMarco: We're like chinese, they're bad.
- 1:04:45Bill DeMarco: So therefore, the strategy should be we'll kick your ass.
- 1:04:47Bill DeMarco: Well, I don't know.
- 1:04:48Bill DeMarco: That's a good strategy, because do you really want to go toe-to-toe?
- 1:04:50Bill DeMarco: Do you really want?
- 1:04:52Bill DeMarco: I mean, I don't think anybody wants, but you have to deter also, which means you spend money on defense.
- 1:04:58Bill DeMarco: So it's's like I don't know.
- 1:04:59Bill DeMarco: It's just one of those that I agree with you and obviously I'm very early on in these thoughts as well.
- 1:05:04Bill DeMarco: I mean, I'm throwing spaghetti at a wall hoping to see what sticks.
- 1:05:07Mark McGrath: Are you familiar with SACO?
- 1:05:09Mark McGrath: S-a-c-o is the Sino-American Cooperation Organization.
- 1:05:14Mark McGrath: It's also the nickname was the Rice Paddy Navy and it was commanded by an admiral, a US admiral, named Milton Miles.
- 1:05:22Mark McGrath: His call sign was Mary, because there was a famous actress, mary Miles, so it's Milton Mary Miles.
- 1:05:28Mark McGrath: In his book which I challenge you to find it, I actually have a copy and I paid a lot of money for it it's called A Different Kind of War.
- 1:05:36Mark McGrath: And how I heard about this was General Gray, who we lost last year, who was a collaborator with John Boyd and was the force behind warfighting, the MCDP-1 warfighting, said he was talking about one of his predecessors, robert Barrow, that had won the Navy Cross at the Chosin Reservoir and then the Distinguished Service Cross in Dewey Canyon in Vietnam.
- 1:05:57Mark McGrath: But he talked about how General Barrow, when he was fighting in World War II, general Barrow was not on the islands.
- 1:06:03Mark McGrath: He wasn't in Tarawa, guadalcanal, iwo Jima, any of them.
- 1:06:05Mark McGrath: General Barrow was in the Rice Paddy Navy under Admiral Milton Miles and what they were doing was basically creating a guerrilla force inside of China to counteract the Japanese domestically in China and basically it came down to sort of two rival arguments One was the Chinese nationalist argument and the other one was the communist argument.
- 1:06:26Mark McGrath: And then I guess the Americans were kind of split on that.
- 1:06:28Mark McGrath: So Milton Miles, he had one view one way, and Donovan, who was the first CIA director, I think or he was at OSS at the time he had a different view and that split in his assessment was what was causing all the problems with China after World War II, like how Mao came to power and things like that.
- 1:06:49Mark McGrath: But the point of it is is that we actually do have a history, we do have a lineage of these things like Seiko, like the CAP program.
- 1:06:56Bill DeMarco: Seiko, like you know, the CAP program, we do have a history of these types of things that are aligning with cultures and making massive outsized outcomes with very small, very small, differentiated inputs.
- 1:07:12Bill DeMarco: Yeah, it's interesting you bring that up too, because I ponder things and similar but very different Things like Radio Free Europe, like our culture, the american culture is extremely, very I don't know, I haven't read, maybe I have.
- 1:07:24Bill DeMarco: I imagine the chinese are afraid of our culture, which is why they're attacking us, and I don't mean that in a weird way, because they're not necessarily, it's not, it's a side door, right, it's, it's hollywood, it's music, it's this it's not wrong yeah, james bradley talks about, in the china mirage, how the the, the mandar and the Emperor of China.
- 1:07:43Mark McGrath: I mean, we were referred to, let's say we, meaning Westerners, anglo-saxon Westerners, from the United States and the United Kingdom.
- 1:07:50Mark McGrath: They were called barbarians.
- 1:07:53Mark McGrath: They weren't allowed to leave the areas.
- 1:07:57Mark McGrath: What became Hong Kong, what became Macau?
- 1:07:59Mark McGrath: They weren't allowed to leave those areas.
- 1:08:00Mark McGrath: They had to be restricted.
- 1:08:02Mark McGrath: They could only do business certified, with all approved.
- 1:08:06Mark McGrath: And we were again.
- 1:08:07Mark McGrath: We I didn't say we, but Westerners that were intervening in China have always been referred to as barbarians.
- 1:08:13Mark McGrath: Yes, that's.
- 1:08:16Mark McGrath: Who was at the gate that overturned Rome, right?
- 1:08:19Mark McGrath: I mean, I guess that's the understanding maybe of sort of the Eurocentric lineages were barbarian hordes.
- 1:08:26Mark McGrath: I guess I don't know.
- 1:08:28Brian Rivera: Bill, is it possible that and I don't want to use a term here that I don't like that much but center of gravity is culture?
- 1:08:32Brian Rivera: Is it possible?
- 1:08:40Bill DeMarco: I think for the Chinese it is something that they feel is a center of gravity.
- 1:08:41Bill DeMarco: Maybe not the center.
- 1:08:42Bill DeMarco: Of course we can argue if there's multiple or one centers of gravity, but I do think that the culture for the Chinese is a center of gravity, but to the point of this whole conversation, that's a very loose center of gravity.
- 1:08:52Bill DeMarco: In other words, what do the metrics look like to attack somebody's culture In the West?
- 1:08:56Bill DeMarco: We'd want to know.
- 1:08:57Bill DeMarco: Have we degraded the culture by 6.2%, or is it 8.9%?
- 1:09:01Bill DeMarco: Or is it the Chinese?
- 1:09:03Bill DeMarco: Don't care, I don't believe.
- 1:09:04Bill DeMarco: I think they just know if I can buy enough studios in Hollywood, if I can influence music, if I can get into social media, I am making a difference in their culture.
- 1:09:13Brian Rivera: So the world of complex adaptive systems thinking says that you just amplify the behaviors you want and dampen the ones you don't.
- 1:09:18Brian Rivera: It's really simple.
- 1:09:19Brian Rivera: Says that you just amplify the behaviors you want and dampen the ones you don't.
- 1:09:21Brian Rivera: It's really simple.
- 1:09:22Brian Rivera: You don't measure it, you just keep going in a direction, direction of travel.
- 1:09:24Brian Rivera: We struggle with this with our leaders, right, they're challenged with this type of thinking.
- 1:09:27Brian Rivera: So when you brought that up, I'm thinking if you're going to attack us, you break our culture.
- 1:09:31Brian Rivera: You leverage the internet, create tribalism, amplify that, you make us hate each other Democrats hate Republicans, republicans hate Democrats.
- 1:09:41Brian Rivera: So this is the idea of Boyd Zutley too is to fold us upon ourselves.
- 1:09:44Brian Rivera: And I don't know, mark man, when you're talking about that this is it.
- 1:09:51Mark McGrath: This is the war that we're fighting.
- 1:09:52Mark McGrath: It goes back to what Sean Ring was talking about the other day when we were live on X, that, when you think of, we talk about the 24 hourhour news cycle right, a four-year presidential term is not that much longer than a 24-hour news cycle in the scope of things.
- 1:10:08Bill DeMarco: No, four years is nothing, it's nothing.
- 1:10:10Mark McGrath: A two-year congressional term and a six-year senatorial term and even a two-term president in eight years in the grand scope of things.
- 1:10:19Mark McGrath: We're constantly, constantly on this, like got to get things done quick.
- 1:10:24Mark McGrath: So we don't have the ability.
- 1:10:26Mark McGrath: Just, I think, by design of our system with representative democracy, we don't have the ability to take a long view.
- 1:10:33Mark McGrath: And I'm not advocating a system.
- 1:10:35Mark McGrath: I think that our system of a representative republic, as we were founded, I think, is naturally biased.
- 1:10:40Mark McGrath: I swore no to defend that, as you did too.
- 1:10:42Mark McGrath: The one thing about it and it seems to get worse and worse is that we're not able to take the things that you talk about in your article.
- 1:10:48Mark McGrath: We're not able to take a long-term, holistic view because there's so many competing interests in the short run of people that want to get satiated by money, by fame, by promotion, whatever it really does put us at a massive disadvantage and vulnerability from that respect.
- 1:11:07Bill DeMarco: So I agree 100%.
- 1:11:09Bill DeMarco: The fact is that, not saying we alter our system at all.
- 1:11:13Bill DeMarco: Yet you talk about the long-term.
- 1:11:15Bill DeMarco: We took a long-term approach.
- 1:11:17Bill DeMarco: When you think about things like containment, long telegram, you know all this stuff was like like we were able to rally around something like you know the Soviet Union and communism and say that's bad and it lasted for several generations.
- 1:11:31Bill DeMarco: How do we do that?
- 1:11:33Bill DeMarco: You know I mean now and you can look back at Truman and Eisenhower interesting time for the United States.
- 1:11:38Bill DeMarco: You know Eisenhower inherited this massive debt from Schuman because we were lusting up everything we could to fight the Soviets and Eisenhower knew that's not sustainable.
- 1:11:49Bill DeMarco: Nsc 68, these other things that all came from that era.
- 1:11:51Bill DeMarco: The fact was, or even the Solarian Project, I mean these things that happened under Eisenhower's watch that we could easily replicate today if we could get past the partisanship.
- 1:12:02Bill DeMarco: And then to argue is our partisanship exacerbated by Russia and China?
- 1:12:09Bill DeMarco: Again, I don't want to sound like I'm a conspiracy theorist or anything else, but we have to admit it's a possibility.
- 1:12:14Mark McGrath: No, I think it goes back to cultural understanding, though.
- 1:12:18Mark McGrath: So here's a name for you, Lieutenant Colonel Pete Ellis.
- 1:12:21Mark McGrath: Earl Ellis was his name, Pete Ellis and he had been over in the Far East.
- 1:12:26Mark McGrath: He was a Marine officer, and he had come back and basically predicted everything that was going to happen in the Far East, for no other reason other than understanding them and going over there and saying that we are going to have to go back over there in 20 years and take these islands back from the Japanese because of how they're after the 1919 Paris Agreement, how they're just taking all these German possessions, how it's just going to keep pushing down on us, taking things from us, right, Like Guam and the Philippines and other things.
- 1:12:56Mark McGrath: I think, too, we got to look at a guy like MacArthur.
- 1:12:57Mark McGrath: I mean love or hate MacArthur.
- 1:12:59Mark McGrath: Macarthur had his finger on the pulse of the Far East for most of his entire life, With the exception of World War I, his time at West Point, his time with Chief of Staff of the Army.
- 1:13:09Mark McGrath: Almost all of his career was spent over in the Far East, and he had a much different understanding.
- 1:13:14Mark McGrath: Success in Japan after the war is because there was an overseer like MacArthur that did have an understanding of the culture that was able to recognize the value of things that we've talked about.
- 1:13:27Mark McGrath: Ponch with Charlie Protzman that if we mix these cultures and they can understand each other, we can get a much better outcome than saying one's better than the other and we're going to force that one out.
- 1:13:37Mark McGrath: We're going to make you do this.
- 1:13:39Brian Rivera: All right, let's build on that.
- 1:13:40Brian Rivera: So Pratt's been a Shingo Prize winning author, talks about the origins of lean, the Toyota production system and other things.
- 1:13:47Brian Rivera: So what did it take?
- 1:13:48Brian Rivera: It took Japanese to come over here and look at what we're doing, to see the world from their perspective and take it back right, whereas we couldn't do that that well.
- 1:13:56Brian Rivera: So you can't change the system from within, you have to go outside the system, correct, mark?
- 1:14:00Brian Rivera: Okay?
- 1:14:01Mark McGrath: Yeah, and the more that you try to do it, the more confusion and disorder increases per jumboid.
- 1:14:06Mark McGrath: That's the whole point of this creation, that the more I try to fix the system within itself, with all the views within the system, that's where I get the incestuous amplification of confusion, disorder and, if I can get my opponent to do that, more and more and more and more, irrelevance, obsolescence and ultimately, extinction.
- 1:14:23Mark McGrath: That's what has to happen.
- 1:14:25Brian Rivera: That's a lower energy approach to warfare.
- 1:14:26Brian Rivera: Right there you just yeah, yeah, okay, right, but to piggyback on that too.
- 1:14:30Bill DeMarco: Think about George Kennan.
- 1:14:31Bill DeMarco: He wasn't here, he was in Moscow, so he was outside the.
- 1:14:36Bill DeMarco: He's part of the system, my God, but outside the system learning about what was going on.
- 1:14:55Mark McGrath: What did he see in Russia?
- 1:14:56Mark McGrath: I don't know how that happened, but how do you learn about the adversary?
- 1:14:58Mark McGrath: He's sitting in Moscow making notes and saying in Berlin, and he was writing about all these things that were going on in Germany and nobody listened.
- 1:15:06Mark McGrath: Like nobody listened and bam, you know, hitler comes in.
- 1:15:11Mark McGrath: And he was writing about that.
- 1:15:12Mark McGrath: I think it was like the New York Times correspondent in Berlin and he was sending these dispatches.
- 1:15:16Mark McGrath: I think it's like the rise and fall of the Third Reich was his book, but but he had been saying for years as the correspondent all these things that were happening and everybody's like no, no, no, hitler's good.
- 1:15:25Mark McGrath: You know he's bringing order, you know he's the Time Magazine man of the Year.
- 1:15:29Mark McGrath: Little did we know, but he challenged assumptions, right, I mean, and that's always.
- 1:15:36Bill DeMarco: Yes.
- 1:15:37Mark McGrath: Yep, which, again, I think that that's the value of what it is.
- 1:15:42Mark McGrath: Just to say that article that you put out about decoding asymmetry, about the Chinese using the golden ratio as a starting point, and then you say, as they say, that there is a fuzziness to it.
- 1:15:57Mark McGrath: Though it's not exact, there's a fuzziness to it.
- 1:15:59Mark McGrath: That's the other thing that people in the West don't understand.
- 1:16:02Mark McGrath: They're always looking for exact, correct.
- 1:16:05Mark McGrath: This is it, you know, and they're not allowing for the things that Boyd talked about entropy, uncertainty and incompleteness, that it's always going to be fuzzy, fluid in a constant state of that.
- 1:16:22Brian Rivera: Like you said, that's a good warfare, that it's fuzz and it's well.
- 1:16:24Brian Rivera: That was fun.
- 1:16:24Brian Rivera: That was one of the more, uh, challenging episodes, because it's just, we're just riffing off each other there.
- 1:16:27Brian Rivera: That's what we want from this, which is jazz.
- 1:16:29Brian Rivera: That's what we're talking about, yeah, and it doesn't mean everything we put out there is gospel.
- 1:16:33Brian Rivera: It's just like, hey, we're thinking about this live and and I mean there's a lot more to be discussed as we reflect on this.
- 1:16:40Brian Rivera: So, bill, I really appreciate you coming on today.
- 1:16:42Brian Rivera: Man, this has been a really, really, really fun conversation.
- 1:16:46Bill DeMarco: Yeah, and you have to come back.
- 1:16:48Bill DeMarco: Well, I'd love to.
- 1:16:49Bill DeMarco: I'd love to, you know, and I get it, because at the end I feel like we didn't solve anything.
- 1:16:53Bill DeMarco: We just actually just muddied the waters, probably more, but it's good to have those conversations.
- 1:16:58Mark McGrath: I think it goes, but one of our guests that we're putting out soon, sam alima, was talking about the importance of the study of philosophy and one of the things he was talking about socrates.
- 1:17:06Mark McGrath: Yes, yeah, the more, the more that we ask and the more that we question, the more we realize that I don't know, you know, and people don't like the socratic way of thinking, but that's that's important to keep asking as if you don't know.
- 1:17:18Mark McGrath: You know because I think, as Boyd said, he reviled the term expert.
- 1:17:24Mark McGrath: If you called him an expert, he absolutely reviled.
- 1:17:27Mark McGrath: He said that that is not what I am, it's a know-it-all.
- 1:17:30Mark McGrath: And the other thing he hated to be called was an analyst, because an analyst means I can break things down but I can't put things back together as a synthesis.
- 1:17:37Mark McGrath: And he said the worst thing you could say on top of those things would be an analytical expert.
- 1:17:40Mark McGrath: So you know, we don't want to be those, we want to be, and I think maybe this goes back to really what we were talking about earlier.
- 1:17:46Mark McGrath: Officers should be scholars and they should be in a constant state of learning and they should not be limited into what it is that they're learning and questioning, because if they're pursuing things that can help enlighten reality, they shouldn't be written off as a quack, like Pete Ellis was written off as a quack and Patton and others that were doing radical thinking.
- 1:18:06Mark McGrath: That should be encouraged, not discouraged.
- 1:18:09Bill DeMarco: I agree 100%.
- 1:18:10Bill DeMarco: It's interesting the book or the movie we Were Soldiers.
- 1:18:13Bill DeMarco: When Hal Moore is in the movie, he shows them in his barracks or in his on-base house doing all this studying and this reading.
- 1:18:20Bill DeMarco: I always thought that was so interesting because I don't know that we do that anymore.
- 1:18:23Bill DeMarco: He was getting this mission that he had to go over to Vietnam.
- 1:18:27Bill DeMarco: What was the helicopter going to do or not do?
- 1:18:29Bill DeMarco: There's that scene where he's in his house on base and he's reviewing all these books and he's trying to get smart.
- 1:18:44Mark McGrath: For me, that always stuck in my head, because Hal Moore actually came and spoke at SOS when I was a student, a million years ago, before the movie came out, and I remember just thinking my word this guy, he's amazing and like Hal Moore from Bardstown, kentucky, and turn him into a Harvard-level scholar, interdisciplinary thinker, that's able to combine philosophy, technology, strategy, able to fuse all that together to be successful in his own right.
- 1:19:12Mark McGrath: Ask people hey, have you read Street Without Joy by Bernard Folling?
- 1:19:16Mark McGrath: Who's Bernard Foll?
- 1:19:17Mark McGrath: What's that about?
- 1:19:21Bill DeMarco: There's this idea.
- 1:19:21Bill DeMarco: I think that some of our officers not all of them, because this is a problem, you know the bureaucracy wants one size to fit all.
- 1:19:26Bill DeMarco: In other words, we're widgets, because the idea is when one widget fails, everybody moves up one.
- 1:19:30Bill DeMarco: That's the personnel system.
- 1:19:32Mark McGrath: It is, and there's a lot of talk about you know, redoing it and all this.
- 1:19:36Bill DeMarco: I don't know We'll see if if it happens, but the idea of a polymath, like we need polymaths in the military, and I just don't know that we reward it.
- 1:19:45Bill DeMarco: Yes, exactly right yes, it has to be.
- 1:19:48Bill DeMarco: You don't want everybody to do that, just like you don't want like innovation where I live.
- 1:19:52Bill DeMarco: You don't want everybody to be an innovator.
- 1:19:53Bill DeMarco: It'd be absolutely a shit show.
- 1:19:55Bill DeMarco: But you need to find those folks who do it well and reward them.
- 1:19:59Mark McGrath: Yeah, yeah, it needs to be encouraged, not discouraged.
- 1:20:04Mark McGrath: Yes, yeah, so well, let's pause there, then, and we will continue.
- 1:20:11Mark McGrath: Tell everybody your website so we can.
- 1:20:13Mark McGrath: We want people to go to your website and read the article Decoding Asymmetry.
- 1:20:18Mark McGrath: Yeah site and read the article.
- 1:20:23Mark McGrath: Uh, decoding asymmetry, yeah, it's uh, I'm sorry, decoding asymmetric doctrine, revisiting unrestricted warfare, the golden section and the china's quest for victory.
- 1:20:27Bill DeMarco: It's uh, m100 group is acom, m100 the number 100 groupcom, or if you just look up google mastermind century group, you'll find it.
- 1:20:36Bill DeMarco: Now, are you on X or have you?
- 1:20:38Bill DeMarco: No, I am, but my presence is not.
- 1:20:42Bill DeMarco: It's just not huge, but I am on.
- 1:20:44Mark McGrath: X.
- 1:20:44Mark McGrath: Okay Well, if you want to go live with us, we need you on X Sure.
- 1:20:48Bill DeMarco: I can do that, no problem, I'd love to do that.
- 1:20:53Mark McGrath: Thanks for coming on and sharing time with two naval officers a Marine and a naval aviator.
- 1:20:59Bill DeMarco: Yeah.
- 1:21:00Mark McGrath: It's the beauty of jointness, it's what it's supposed to do.
- 1:21:03Bill DeMarco: Thank you, I appreciate it.