Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Trailing PE Versus Forward PE Explained
Transcript
- 0:00So if you're an astute learner, you know you're doing your due
- 0:03diligence on a company. You've absolutely run into this
- 0:06scenario. I think we all have.
- 0:07You look up the valuation metric, let's say the price to
- 0:10earnings, the PE ratio on one respected financial platform and
- 0:14it screams 65, right? So you immediately cross
- 0:18reference it maybe on your broker's app and that one says
- 0:2032. And if you're like most people,
- 0:23your first thought is, wait, is the data wrong?
- 0:27Did someone just, I don't know, hit the wrong button somewhere?
- 0:30Because the numbers are wildly different for the same stock at
- 0:33the. Exact same price.
- 0:34Exactly. Well, that discrepancy, that
- 0:36whole moment of confusion, that is precisely what we're diving
- 0:40into today. And here's the key take away
- 0:41right up front. Neither number is necessarily
- 0:44wrong. Yeah.
- 0:45They're just measuring 2 completely different things.
- 0:47One is, well, it's a historical fact, an accounting reality.
- 0:51The other is more like a consensus forecast, a shared
- 0:55hope about the future. And understanding that
- 0:57distinction, the difference between looking backward and
- 1:00looking forward, is probably the single most crucial step to
- 1:03avoid a flawed investment conclusion.
- 1:05It absolutely is. If you start your homework with
- 1:08a number that misrepresents what's actually going on, you're
- 1:11basically building your whole thesis on shaky ground.
- 1:14So our mission today is to really understand what separates
- 1:19trailing PE or TTM from forward PE.
- 1:22And maybe more importantly, understand the flaws in each
- 1:24Yes. The flaws in each.
- 1:26OK, let's unpack this. We should probably start with
- 1:28the foundational math. Let's use a simple example,
- 1:31something rounded. A bread shop.
- 1:32A bread shop? Perfect.
- 1:33But we won't stay here too long because you are a learner, you
- 1:36already know the basics. Exactly so the PNPE is easy
- 1:40price. Let's imagine our fantastic
- 1:42local bread shop is for sale. The price is, say, $1 million.
- 1:46That's our numerator. $1 million.
- 1:48Got it. Now for the denominator, the E,
- 1:51the earnings. Let's start with the trailing
- 1:54PE. That stands for Trailing 12
- 1:56months. ETM Yeah.
- 1:57And this is based on verified historical facts.
- 1:59We're looking at the actual profits from the past four
- 2:02quarters. It's like looking at the tax
- 2:03returns. So we pull the books and we see
- 2:06that over the past year, the Breadshot made a total profit of
- 2:09$50,000. That's a verifiable number.
- 2:12So the calculation is $1 million / 50,000 dollars.
- 2:17Which gives us a TTMPE ratio of 20X. 20 times simple
- 2:21interpretation, right? If the business just stays
- 2:23exactly the same, it would take 20 years to earn back your
- 2:26purchase price. The beauty here is its
- 2:28reliability. That earnings number.
- 2:30It's a done deal. It's audited.
- 2:32It's concrete. It is.
- 2:34Trailing PE is reliable because the denominator is a verified
- 2:38figure. That's its greatest strength,
- 2:40but it's also its biggest weakness.
- 2:42So it only tells you what was, and it's really susceptible to
- 2:45distortion from one time events. Yeah, what if, what if last year
- 2:49the bread shop sold a piece of land it wasn't using?
- 2:52That massive cash injection, which won't happen again, would
- 2:55artificially inflate the earnings, making that TTMPE look
- 2:58deceptively cheap. You'd be paying 20X for an
- 3:01earnings power that just isn't there going forward.
- 3:03That's a really powerful point, and it could be misleading the
- 3:06other way too, right? Like if a company had a big one
- 3:09time loss, a restructuring charge or something.
- 3:12Absolutely. The TTM earnings might be close
- 3:14to 0 or even negative, which sends the PE to the moon, even
- 3:19though the core business is actually perfectly healthy now.
- 3:21So even the fact based number needs some critical thinking.
- 3:24It's just the starting line. It's like driving but only
- 3:27looking in the rear view mirror. We're buying the road ahead, not
- 3:30the one we just drove over. Which brings us directly to the
- 3:33future Forward PE, because investors are buying anticipated
- 3:38growth, so we have to shift from history to expectation.
- 3:42That's right. Forward PE is based on expected
- 3:44future earnings, usually for the next 12 months.
- 3:48And this forecast is, well, it's usually an aggregate of
- 3:50predictions from dozens of Wall Street analysts, the consensus
- 3:54estimate. OK, back to the bread shop.
- 3:56Same $1 million price, but you, the owner, you announced you're
- 4:00launching the influencer pretzel line.
- 4:02The influencer pretzel. I like it.
- 4:03And analysts believe this is going to double your profits.
- 4:07They forecast future earnings of $100,000 for the next year.
- 4:11OK. So we run the math again, $1
- 4:13million in price divided by the expected 100,000 in earnings.
- 4:17Which gives us a forward PE of 10X.
- 4:20And look at that, the price didn't change at all, but the
- 4:22valuation multiple just got cut in half from 20X down to 10 X.
- 4:26It just goes to show you the valuation is all about where
- 4:29people think profits are headed. It's about market sentiment.
- 4:32If TTM is the rearview mirror, then forward PE is, I don't
- 4:37know, like consulting a crystal ball or maybe just checking the
- 4:40weather forecast. You hope the rain holds up, but
- 4:43you know forecasts can and often do change.
- 4:47OK. So let's scale this up.
- 4:48Let's see how this 20X versus 10X gap plays out in the real
- 4:51world. This is what explains that 65
- 4:53versus 32 discrepancy you might have seen.
- 4:56Let's use a hypothetical high growth company.
- 4:58We'll just call it tech. All right, let's say tech is
- 5:00trading at $120.00 per share. Now we need to separate the fact
- 5:04from the forecast. OK, the fact First, the
- 5:07company's verifiable historical TTM earnings per share from its
- 5:13last four reports as up to $2.00 per share. $2.00 so they are
- 5:17profitable. That's the current reality.
- 5:19But Wall Street is, let's say, in an optimistic frenzy.
- 5:22They're predicting a huge AI infrastructure build out and
- 5:26they forecast that tech is going to more than double its earnings
- 5:29next year to say $4.00 a share. OK, so let's run the two
- 5:33different valuations right there.
- 5:34First TTMPE. It's the one $120.00 price
- 5:39divided by the past EPS of $2.00.
- 5:41That's ATTMPE of 6060. 60 times, which on its face looks
- 5:46incredibly expensive. Yeah, big risk premium, but.
- 5:49Then you do the forward PE calculation, the same $120.00
- 5:52price, but this time divided by the analyst prediction of $4.00
- 5:56EPS. And that gives you a forward PE
- 5:58of 30. Times 30 times, which you know
- 6:00while still high for some industries, looks a lot more
- 6:02reasonable for growth company. And there it is.
- 6:04There's your initial confusion 60X versus 30X.
- 6:08That gap, that huge difference, is the market's entire
- 6:12expectation of explosive profit growth priced in today.
- 6:15When that forward PC is dramatically lower than the
- 6:19TTMPE, like a 50% discount here, it's signaling massive optimism.
- 6:25Investors are paying a premium now because they're confident
- 6:27that profits will catch up. But that's exactly where the
- 6:30danger is, isn't it? That's what I was thinking.
- 6:32If the market has already priced in a doubling of earnings and
- 6:35you're buying at that 30X forward multiple, you're
- 6:39assuming perfect execution. What if they only grow by 50%?
- 6:43That is the critical caveat. And what's fascinating here is
- 6:46that the forward PE is based on well on 2 pretty volatile
- 6:49inputs. First, analysts projections rely
- 6:52heavily on guidance from company management.
- 6:54And management is never incentivized to be conservative.
- 6:57Rarely. And second, the earnings figure
- 6:59they use is often a non jab metric which excludes things
- 7:02like stock based compensation, so it makes the E look better
- 7:04than actual cash profit. So the very number we're using
- 7:07that $4.00 EPS, it's often an optimistic non standard number
- 7:11to begin with, which just adds another layer of risk.
- 7:15Let's talk about the downside scenario, because this is where
- 7:17people get crushed. The downside can be cyclical.
- 7:20Let's take a copper miner today. The price of copper is spiking,
- 7:25so their TTM earnings are at an all time high.
- 7:27TTMPE might look really low, say 8X.
- 7:31Okay, 8X seems cheap. But the market is predicting a
- 7:35global slowdown, so analysts project next year's earnings
- 7:38will drop a lot. They forecast a forward PE of
- 7:42say, 15X. So here we see the opposite gap.
- 7:45The forward PE is higher than the TTMPE.
- 7:47That means the market is pessimistic, right?
- 7:49It expects earnings to shrink. Exactly.
- 7:51But say you the investor, you only look at that 8 by TTM and
- 7:55you think wow that's a bargain and you buy in ignoring that
- 7:58forward multiple. What happens next?
- 7:59The danger comes when the miner reports it's the next quarter.
- 8:02If copper prices did drop, the analysts don't wait around.
- 8:05They instantly revise their future profit forecasts
- 8:08downward. So the E in the the equation
- 8:10shrinks, it shrinks, and that shrinking E instantly makes the
- 8:14stock look much more expensive. That 15X multiples could jump to
- 8:1725X or 30X overnight just because the expectations were
- 8:21dashed. And when the valuation multiple
- 8:23double s like that, the market corrects violently.
- 8:26It's a double whammy. The prediction was wrong and
- 8:29then the correction itself causes momentum selling.
- 8:32Forward PE truly is market emotion.
- 8:35It's sentiment, not fact. So this all brings up a really
- 8:39crucial question for you, the learner.
- 8:42How do you actually use these two numbers?
- 8:44They often conflict. There's no single right answer,
- 8:46is there? There isn't.
- 8:47It really depends on the type of company.
- 8:49Let's break that down for stable, mature companies like a
- 8:52utility or a big consumer staple where earnings don't fluctuate
- 8:55much year over year. Like a regulated power company,
- 8:58right? The TTMPE is actually pretty
- 9:00reliable there. It gives you an accurate
- 9:02snapshot. The form PE probably won't be
- 9:04that different anyway. But for high growth tech or or
- 9:07maybe a turnaround story, the TMPE can be completely
- 9:11meaningless. It might even be negative if a
- 9:13biotech company just launched A blockbuster drug after years of
- 9:17losses. It's TMPE is terrible.
- 9:20It's terrible, but the forward PE is the only metric that
- 9:23captures the new reality. In those cases, you pretty much
- 9:27have to look at the forward PE. But if we're going to rely on
- 9:29that forward PE, we have to treat it with, well, extreme
- 9:32caution. We're trusting A collective
- 9:34guess. Exactly.
- 9:36When you use forward PE, you have to mentally apply a
- 9:38discount. You need to factor in a margin
- 9:40of safety. You should also probably compare
- 9:43that forward PE to the company's own historical average or the
- 9:47average of its competitors. See if the optimism is, you
- 9:50know, justified. So what does this all mean?
- 9:53We need to blend historical reality with future possibility.
- 9:56It's the relationship between the two ratios that tells you
- 9:59the real story to. Sum it up then TTMPE is fact,
- 10:03historical, verifiable, but it can be distorted forward.
- 10:06PE is prediction, it's sentiment, emotion, but it's
- 10:09denominator is constantly shifting.
- 10:12The gap between them tells you how much growth is already
- 10:14priced in. Before we wrap up, we do need to
- 10:16give our required disclosure. All the analysis we've shared is
- 10:19based on publicly available sources and is strictly for
- 10:22educational purposes. It is not investment advice.
- 10:25Please conduct your own due diligence before making any
- 10:28investment decisions. Definitely.
- 10:30And on that note of diligence, for those of you who like to
- 10:32track the a broader market who want that macro view on
- 10:35valuation, we'd encourage you to search and download the iOS app
- 10:39Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 10:41It helps track the total market temperature.
- 10:43That's a great tool for context. OK, so here's the final
- 10:47provocative thought we want to leave you with.
- 10:49The next time you see APE ratio, don't just ask is it high or
- 10:54low. Or even is it TTM or forward?
- 10:57Ask instead how much of the current stock price is based on
- 11:01last year's audited performance, and how much is based on a Wall
- 11:04Street forecast that could just vanish with the next quarterly
- 11:08report. That distinction is where the
- 11:10real insight is. That's the perfect challenge.
- 11:12If you want to listen to our full deep dive about this topic
- 11:15or access more advanced content, you're welcome to join the Deep
- 11:18Value Club membership or subscribe to us on Apple and
- 11:21Spotify podcasts. The channel is deep value
- 11:24investing. We'll talk to you next time.