Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Twosday ASOTU Style, Cirillo Goes Shopping, & Stick Shift EVs
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] All right, it is Tuesday. Yeah, I said it, T-W-O, Tuesday. And this is Kyle, and I've got my man Michael Cirillo filling in for Paul. Let's go. Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know- Paul...
- 0:16who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. If I said I wants no beef- Who I is... but the people wanna know what's for tea. Who I is and who I be, right? That's, that's- Man... that's the whole theme.
- 0:25I know, right? It's, it's, it's so catchy. It... You know what's really ridiculous about it? Is- Hm... we, we, we checked out the rest of the tra- uh, the tracks on the album. Not so good. [laughs] Not, not so good.
- 0:40It's like one hit wonder. It always happens that way. It, it always happens.
- 0:42It's like, oh, that's why it landed on, like, the, the top searches for, for bumping songs on, uh, on fr- you know, whatever streaming music thing that we have access to, so oh well.
- 0:53But- Yeah, th- this reminds me of back in the day I'd go to this store called Sam the Record Man and I'd go and buy my CDs. [laughs] And I just knew I...
- 1:01If, if it was a band I liked, I just had to go to track three, 'cause that was, like, the thing- Right... in the '90s and the early 2000s. Like, track three was the banger. Always gonna be good, right?
- 1:10So it was always track three. That was the single. It was always track three. [laughs] Exactly. Yeah. Sweet. So if you are paying in- attention and you are on Paul's LinkedIn right now, you recognize that neither,
- 1:23neither is this Paul, and yes, this is Michael Cirillo.
- 1:26So Michael Cirillo [laughs] is a good friend of Paul and mine, and just a real troublemaker, like a guy that is pushing back in the industry, and has been for a long time. Actually, we had a conversation, like, what?
- 1:37A little over a week ago, and we were just- About a week ago, yeah...
- 1:40yeah, we were just talking and, and Michael's like, "Dude, I, I've been doing this for, like, four years thinking there was nobody else trying to do the thing.
- 1:48And now there's lots of people trying to do the thing," and, and it's really exciting. So, um, yeah, I'm glad, glad you're here and hanging out with us this morning, man. Yeah, man.
- 1:57And the four years was more like nine years. Oof. There you go. Nine years, man. I was like, "I'm all alone. There's no other troublemakers." [laughs] I didn't call them troublemakers. Right.
- 2:06But, you know, this is super exciting to, to see you guys doing this, to see others doing this sort of thing and really trying to provide value to the industry.
- 2:13It's something I'm a huge advocate for, so I love that you guys are doing this every day. Exactly. Every day. And, and- Holy smokes...
- 2:19legitimately between, between nine years and being in Canada he had, like, all the boxes checked for troublemaking, right? [laughs] Or something like that. Yeah, but just no population to see it. Right. [laughs] Hi, Mom.
- 2:31[laughs] There's the farmer across the street, right? Exactly. [laughs] Well, cool.
- 2:37Let's get into it today because, uh, we've got a lot to cover, and the very first thing is the thing that everybody knows, that everybody on any podcast, LinkedIn, Instagram, or Facebook post is talking about today, including Google, and that's the fact that it is 2/2/22 on a Tuesday for the last time in 200 years.
- 3:00Yeah. Which is absolutely [laughs] ridiculous. We nerded out, we did it. But our big thing today, my, my, my thing that I'm watching today is wouldn't you know it, but Charmin.
- 3:12[laughs] Which I texted Cirillo this this morning, and I texted him the Instagram account, and he's like, "Why? Why are we looking at, at Charmin?" But we draw a f- few things out.
- 3:22Just so you know, if you, if you, uh, if you clink in it, it's in the show notes or in, or, uh, in, in any of the descriptions. But you can click over to their Instagram account or get on their Snapchat account.
- 3:32And today there will be a poop emoji floating down a river adventure, or on Snapchat you can actually make yourself into a poop emoji. So Cirillo, have you ever made yourself into a poop emoji?
- 3:46[laughs] Um, not voluntarily. I, I, I don't- Thank goodness. [laughs] But I, you know what? It's brilliant marketing. Yes.
- 3:54I mean, like, we're, we're seeing some really interesting marketing execution come out of these companies these days. A lot more creativity.
- 4:00And almost what I think is interesting is in this, like, um, you know, where, where we're not quite sure what to say anymore in public and we're not quite sure how to behave anymore- Yes...
- 4:10in public 'cause you're not sure who you'll offend. I'm a huge advocate of, like, the best marketing attracts the right audience and it repels the wrong audience, and clearly they have a...
- 4:20I mean, they, they've got a persona of people that like to turn into poop. Yes, exactly. Well, and here's the other thing is, like, sometimes just calling it like you see it, right?
- 4:30Is, is enough for people to go, "Okay." At least, at least they're not afraid of what they're, you know, what's happening or what's talking, uh, what they're talking about, right? They've got a...
- 4:39I scrolled down on their Instagram and to see, you know, their y- they've got their iconic bears that are in the commercials that use the Charmin and all that, and it's...
- 4:48They're just at the Super Bowl and it says, "Charmin loves tight ends," right? Which to most people would be like, "Oh, can you s-" You know, like you...
- 4:57Think about how many times you've been in, like a dealer or an agency has been in a room talking about the next campaign and everybody's like, "Are we sure? Can we say that? Are we... No, we probably- [laughs]...
- 5:07we, we should probably pull back on that one," right? Like, someone probably asked that question, but someone also said, "Hey.
- 5:13No, look, if we say it, like, we've got the opportunity to, to attract a lot of attention, but also good attention," right? Because it gets a laugh and all that type of stuff.
- 5:22I, I think that a lot of times we hedge in a lot of our marketing meetings because we just instead of going, "No, we're just gonna throw it out there like we see it," right?
- 5:31We kinda hold back and don't say it because it may q- you know, may offend someone or may do, you know, and so we start hedging- Mm-hmm...
- 5:39against all of these, you know, like theoretical, our friend Darren Doane says, um, like, uh, theoretical no tress- no trespassing signs, right?
- 5:49It's not really no trespassing sign, but we've kinda put it up there, right? Have you... I'm, I'm sure you've- Yeah... seen that in your days, 'cause, uh, your agency, you know, Flex Dealer, has a lot of that.
- 5:59Like, "Hey, we're gonna push back on, on some of the things that are typical marketing," right?Yeah.
- 6:05And I mean, one of the most brilliant ways to stand out when everyone is doing the same thing is to, ready, drum roll, stand out. Mm.
- 6:13And actually lean into it and take advantage of the fact that everyone else is trying to look, feel, smell, taste, and behave the same way. Uh, I don't know if why... Taste is probably- [laughs]...
- 6:24mm, smell, uh, I don't know. [laughs] But you know what I mean. Talk. And so- You know, communicate. We'll, we'll use the regular words. [laughs] Hey, well look, we saw it during the Super Bowl. I mean, they- Right...
- 6:34they're taking a spin on this. Like, we're, we, we love tight ends. Um, shocked that there isn't some sort of, like, hemorrhoid cream company, like, ta- Right... on the tail end- Really leaning in...
- 6:45of this, like, as a response, as a funny response. Right But they're leaning into it. And, and you know,
- 6:51I, I've talked a little bit about this on my show, but, but it's like, hey, everybody expects certain types of advertising, and then what happens? We become fatigued. We, um, you know, we, we start to ignore it. Yes.
- 7:05And then all it takes is somebody to just come through the middle and say, "Hey, this is different," and to lean into it.
- 7:10And there's nothing worse, by the way, Kyle, than somebody who has a brilliant idea and then almost, like, pulls back on it, like you said. Right.
- 7:17And then they don't lean into it, and then they just look like a really shy, un- i- you know, the no vision kinda company, and that, that just doesn't play well either.
- 7:26You know- So I love that they're just leaning fully into this. You know, and, and especially for, like, dealers or smaller business companies, right?
- 7:32Where, um, you know, like Coinbase, you knew millions upon millions of people were gonna see that. So there's an element of, like, if it doesn't land or it does hit wrong, then there could be some bad press around it.
- 7:43But the reality is for most of the businesses that would be paying attention are in automotive, right? The ability to recover or, you know, like, fix a mistake or anything like that is pretty- Mm-hmm...
- 7:56like, it's pretty realistic, right? So if, if something, if you try something and it misses, like, the amount of audience that actually saw it or engaged with it is pretty low, right? Yeah.
- 8:07And so the ability for you to recover from that or shift from it, like say some- say an idea doesn't work, right? Mm-hmm.
- 8:14Especially if you have the pieces in place to kinda shift quickly, it's, uh, you know, it's kinda no skin off your back to just, to just keep, keep rolling and, and try something- That's true... new again, right?
- 8:25There's another brilliant thing about this. There's almost like a, a, a, a sub guerrilla marketing strategy that they're deploying here. I mean, you've got kids. I've got kids.
- 8:34Anybody watching this who has kids knows that their children say one word more than any other word- Anything... and it's the word poop. I don't know why they say the word poop. [laughs] I don't know.
- 8:44That smells like poop. That tastes like... Everything's poop. Right.
- 8:47And so they know, Charmin knows, I'm sure of it, they know that millions upon millions of children today are gonna be like, "You can turn yourself into a poop emoji," and, and, and so they're gonna use placements of children- [laughs]
- 9:01Everywhere... in homes turning themselves into poop emojis to put their brand- Absolutely... in front of the adults who buy the, the poop wipes. Absolutely.
- 9:08And you know where they're gonna put, you know where they're gonna call Walmart and Target and all those place, people to put their product on what shelf? You know where it's going, right? Uh-huh.
- 9:16Bottom shelf right now, right? [laughs] It's no longer on the top shelf that only the adults can reach. It's going straight bottom shelf so that when the kid walks by, it's like, "Mom, Dad, we wanna..."
- 9:26Actually, speaking of that. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Okay, so I didn't plan this one, but we're s- we're on the marketing thread, and wouldn't you know it, Kyle and Cyril are talking about marketing.
- 9:38But my son, uh, we, you know, last week he had the sniffles and, um- Mm-hmm... so we needed to get Kleenexes, right?
- 9:47And typically in our house, like, we have kinda sensitive skin and all that type of stuff, and, and sp- particularly my wife and my son, and so we always go with the, like, Puffs Plus lotion, right? That one.
- 9:59Well, they've been- Mm-hmm...
- 10:00hard on a TV campaign, but interestingly enough, they have the TV campaign, the commercial campaign, running a ton on children's programming, and it's basically a child sitting there about to decide to pick out a Kleenex that, that then becomes, like, a box of fire, right?
- 10:20And, and then the, the adult kinda swoops in and brings the Puffs Plus lotion right back in. And, and my son, we bring this into the house. He comes home from school.
- 10:31We, my wife puts that on there, and he goes, "Oh, good. You didn't get the fire ones." Right?
- 10:38So [laughs] like, he just, he totally, like, grabs that, brings it down, and, and, like, we know in our house we can't get the fire ones anymore, right? 'Cause he's been marketed to.
- 10:48It's brilliant 'cause they're speaking the language of their target audience. They knew for a fact, oh, hey, parent comes in to save the day. I'm a kid. I understand parent coming in to save the day. Right.
- 10:59I'm speaking fire box, fire brand, can't get that. And ultimately, we know that when we're pushing a child in a shopping cart through Walmart or through Kroger or whatever- Every time...
- 11:10they're gonna be like, "That's the one we need. Mom, you need to get that one." [laughs] Like, Mom, the mom's gonna be like, "Uh, my kid..." "Oh, shut up." [laughs] "Just get the, the non-fire brand one." [laughs] Right.
- 11:20Exactly. Exactly. All right. Well, I wanna keep rolling.
- 11:24Uh, I wanna spend a little bit of time talking about you posting on LinkedIn, uh, this weekend, talking about a little bit of a shopping experience that you're having shopping for a vehicle for your family.
- 11:35And particularly I wanna lean in. You, you said, I, you said you've submitted over 30 leads. Is that right? Yeah. It's- First-... closer to 40 now. First of all- But, uh-... kudos.
- 11:45That's, that takes some serious gumption. [laughs] Man, oh man. But second of all, you said how m- uh, like, what's the response look like from that? Uh, still five have responded, three robots, two real people.
- 11:59Still waiting for responses from the real people. The robots won't shut up. [laughs] The bots are taking over. They're like, they're hitting you all the time. The, the bots are taking over.
- 12:07And you know exactly what they are, right? Yeah. Yeah.
- 12:10So-I think that's so interesting because, you know, in our industry, like I was talking to someone yesterday that the, the theme of NADA, the theme of Digital Dealer, the theme of DMSC, the theme of all of this is like BDC, internet response time, digital showroom, all of this type of stuff.
- 12:27It seems like the m- the overall theme of our industry is this has to be top of mind, yet out of 40 different vehicles and stores, you're getting a 25% return on communication at best, right? Mm-hmm. Which is- It-...
- 12:44shocking. It, it is shocking, and it brings me back down to a fain- foundation that I maintain, which is that all the best tools in the world won't work unless you do. Um, I use...
- 12:57I, I like to sometimes use ridiculous analogies that, that people would be like, "Cirillo, that's the dumbest thing I've ever heard," and I go, "Exactly."
- 13:05So the analogy that I tend to use, especially around NADA, because you know you're gonna be, you're gonna be getting things flopped in your face like- Just everything... all the pushers on the, on the strip, right?
- 13:15It's like, "Hey, come over here. We, we're doing massages, and I got-" Yeah. It's actually, it's- "...
- 13:18you know, we're using mineral oil today" [laughs] You know, it's like very- It's actually so, it's actually so perfect that it's held in Vegas, right?
- 13:24Because you come off the strip and you get the same thing in the conference center. Sorry. Keep rolling. [laughs] The, the exact same thing.
- 13:30So I, I use this analogy, Kyle, of you go to Home Depot and you purchase the most expensive hammer you can find, and the darn thing still won't hang pictures on the wall for you. It still won't build the house for you.
- 13:45Yep. You still have to know how to hold that hammer, and for anybody that doesn't know how to hold a hammer, yes, there are more appropriate ways to hold a hammer to get the job done more efficiently. But,
- 13:57you know, I think what we find is we, we, we tend to suffer, and this is not an industry isolated- No... you know, thing. We, we get attracted by shiny objects. We are lured in.
- 14:08This will lasso the sun, the moon, and the stars for you.
- 14:11We bring it into our store, and I'm sure you've experienced this as you were creating efficiencies in the stores you worked in, where we don't even, though, anticipate whether or not we have the bandwidth to fully invest into this tool from a human perspective.
- 14:24And so we go blindly based on the promise that it's going to do all of these things for us, and then we sweep it under the rug. Yep. We don't pay attention to it.
- 14:33We don't even know if it's working, and I see that a lot in our industry. In this case, with my shopping experience, and by the way, I'm a complete lay down.
- 14:41[laughs] If these people just knew, I'm like a that one sir kinda guy. Right. Uh, and, uh, you know, when can I have it? Well, I have to pick my kids up from school at 2:30.
- 14:50I'd like to do it in this new vehicle sort of a thing. Yeah. Um,
- 14:56the, the fact, though, that I'm kind of in a new, uh, shopping experience where I haven't done this before, I'm not around some dealers that I usually- That you know... can go, "Hey, I trust this."
- 15:07Like, I'm a super loyal guy. So this is really being approached blindly as a customer without any connections to the, the, the market that I'm looking for this vehicle in, and, um, I feel lost. Ah.
- 15:21Completely lo- even though I know how... I work with car dealers all day long. I know how the process goes. Right.
- 15:26I know all this kind of stuff, but I can't break through the barrier of entry to even get a meaningful conversation started. Wow. Yeah.
- 15:36That's, that's in- that's an interesting kind of thing to draw out that, that you as someone who's been in the industry, that knows the industry, that knows probably the tools that they're using and the communication platforms and the inventory, and you, you know the, you probably know the web providers and how to look at the inventory.
- 15:52You feel this sense of being lost, right? And, and so how, like, how distant does that become for a consumer that hasn't bought a car in nine years or interacted with a dealer, right? Mm.
- 16:03Man, what, so- You know what they do? They, they go to Marketplace, and by the way, [clears throat] if I have to go into our beloved Facebook Auto Marketing Collective group
- 16:16and see somebody ask what the best chat provider is again or- [laughs]... or this company that can post my vehicles to Facebook Marketplace, I'm sorry. With all the love in my heart, don't. Right.
- 16:29It's the worst experience ever because, like- Period... what, what happens? You start losing trust a little bit in the franchise or in the, in the, in the dealership community. So what I notice is I'm like, "Screw this.
- 16:41I'm just gonna go private." Right. So I go to Marketplace, and I go private. It's an awful experience. No, like, no insult to anybody intended here.
- 16:50It's an awful experience because you don't know who to trust there either, and so- Right... you actually get to the point of fatigue really, really quickly.
- 16:57I would anticipate, I don't know what it is particularly in the United States. In Canada, Google study showed an average purchase process time of about 73 days, 74 days, depending on the province.
- 17:09I, I would anticipate that could be a lot shorter if we empathized with the fact that consumers are going through a complete emotional rollercoaster on something that really shouldn't be- Right... that way at all.
- 17:22Well, and- It is like I would rather go and get a root canal at this point... and right now, in a timeframe when anxiety and depression are at an all-time high- Mm... worldwide, right?
- 17:32So you're al- you already have a consumer that is coming into a purchase process with an all-time high level of anxiety or depression, and then you're filling it with more anxiety, more lostness, more feeling.
- 17:45So th- uh, uh, challenge to the dealers, challenge to the industry partners, like, how are we meeting people with a high level anxiety and depression where they're at with the empathy and, and, and what they need?
- 17:57We're way out of time, but I cannot, I cannot not get to this. Toyota has filed for eight patents that will allow EV purchasers to have a feeling of shifting a car. Wait, wait, wait. Shifting a car,
- 18:14putting the clutch down, and would you guess it, but stalling out. They're gonna [laughs] they're gonna give you that old feeling of being 16 again, going up a hill, and stalling it out 'cause you popped the clutch.
- 18:28What a mess. Give us your quick thoughts as we head out. Um, Dave Grohl on Guitar Hero. You could just pick up a real guitar and learn how to play it. [laughs] All right. With that, we've had a whole bunch of fun today.
- 18:46We've talked marketing, we've talked consumer interaction, and we've talked 2-2-22. Cirillo, thank you for coming on. Go and get today just like all our troublemakers. [upbeat music]