Latest / Newcomer Pod / Freeloaders, Fat cats & Ne'er-do-wells (w/Alex Heath)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome back on Sally. Hey everybody.
- 0:14Welcome to this week's dead cat condo town here from Insider
- 0:17joined by Katie Benner of New York Times and Eric newcomer of
- 0:21newcomer, we've got this week, Alex, Heath from The Verge on to
- 0:25talk about the State of the Union of social media.
- 0:29He Throat. A PC other week about how Zack
- 0:31is cracking down on all the lazy fat cat, rest investors at
- 0:36Facebook. And that piece also came out
- 0:38around the same time that meta had it sir.
- 0:41I'm still not good at saying meta forces, Facebook meta had
- 0:45its earnings, which were not great.
- 0:48You know, of quarterly decline, q1q, decline in Revenue.
- 0:51Not a good place to be for supposed growth stock.
- 0:55And then also, the bigger story was that Instagram was rebuked
- 0:59by its shadow. Chief product officer, Kylie
- 1:01Jenner and the whole jenner/kardashian crew also not
- 1:04great and the FTC is suing them to stop.
- 1:07Its acquisition of a VR company. So Heath is going to be on to
- 1:11talk about all of that and then also because Heath is on and
- 1:14I've just plagued Eric and Katie anytime I had the opportunity to
- 1:17we should talk about snap, which had like a near-death experience
- 1:22as one analyst said, but it had shit earnings, its stock is
- 1:25trading near all-time lows. So that's That's the mess over
- 1:30there with SNAP. But before wild the highs and
- 1:34lows of snap, like it's hard to understand how I mean talk about
- 1:39sort of a critique of the efficient market hypothesis.
- 1:42I don't, I'm interested understand how it could be as
- 1:46wild as it's been. I don't think snap knows what to
- 1:49make of not only like its stock price, but itself like all of it
- 1:52just seems to be a mystery to the company.
- 1:55But before we do that, I want to shout out the composer of our
- 1:57theme music Young Chomsky Great synth music that we have opening
- 2:02and closing the show from Young chomsky's composer.
- 2:04He's also a co-producer on another podcast called true and
- 2:07on and he very generously. Let us use one of his pieces for
- 2:11a music. So I can't let it go without
- 2:14without mention because it's been too long.
- 2:16Okay, Heath, thanks for joining, thanks for having me.
- 2:19Good to be back. Thank you.
- 2:20So okay, where should we start with all of this?
- 2:24Let's just go high level with the with the earnings just
- 2:26because we are in the midst of earning season and, you know, It
- 2:30has been you know eating shit over the last six months,
- 2:33they're down like 50 percent nothing that jolts listeners out
- 2:35of their seat more than let's talk about earnings.
- 2:38Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:40Okay. I mean nothing jolts listeners
- 2:43worth of learning 50% of their. It's good, it's good.
- 2:45It's important substance. Eat your carrots.
- 2:48Let's understand the business with where we just argue about
- 2:51whatever feed should look like. Yeah, no, tell me what I should
- 2:54take away from from from zux earnings.
- 2:57What should you take away? I guess the headline was Had
- 3:00Revenue declined year over year for the first time ever.
- 3:03I thought was really interesting about that was though that they
- 3:07said, if it wouldn't have been for currency conversions, and
- 3:11headwinds there, which means you know the dollar obviously is
- 3:14gotten a lot. Stronger relative to other
- 3:16International currencies, they would have had a four percent
- 3:21Revenue growth so that like I thought that was a pretty
- 3:25interesting call out. But yeah, it's it's not doing
- 3:28great there. There there.
- 3:29In the during a hard hard period right now.
- 3:32And this is basically because of I mean there's still the
- 3:35overhang from Apple's privacy changes that limited their
- 3:38targeting ability. I mean just the general
- 3:40recession fears when which is it, it's still Apple it's mostly
- 3:46recession ad budget right now. I would say it's like 40% apple
- 3:51on top of that. Uh-huh.
- 3:53I think it's hard to parse the to out with Facebook in
- 3:55particular and see exactly how bad just the The macroeconomic
- 4:01stuff is relative to just the Apple stuff.
- 4:03They're actually waiting internally for, I think the
- 4:06first year of the full Apple worked when we're talking about
- 4:10a, we're talking about the prompt on your iPhone.
- 4:12That says, do not track me. It cost Facebook, 10 billion
- 4:15dollars last year, which is the same amount they spent on the
- 4:18metaverse and they're waiting until a year of that has been
- 4:23fully out in the world of that prompt being out in the world
- 4:28before they kind of do it. Full assessment.
- 4:30So they don't even really know internally.
- 4:32How Bad Apple has been relative to just what everyone is
- 4:35experiencing Facebook was a trillion plus dollar company
- 4:39right now. It's worth four hundred thirty
- 4:41point six billion like so was I mean what was Zoom?
- 4:44I mean there were so many companies that were right, these
- 4:48astronomical valuations that. Yeah.
- 4:50Everyone's just kind of coming back to Earth and I think met is
- 4:54no longer. It's no longer a gross talk
- 4:56anymore. That's really the problem,
- 4:58right? Is that They're not growing and
- 5:01they still make a good amount of profit.
- 5:04So it isn't that your expertise? You were big on when Apple sort
- 5:07of switch from being a growth stock to Value stock?
- 5:12Yeah, I mean I think the difference is the apples kind of
- 5:14got the market used to the idea that it wasn't going to be a
- 5:16growth stock. Whereas with Facebook, they
- 5:19continue for reasons that I'm sure.
- 5:21Alex knows more vis-à-vis, the psychology of the c-suite, the
- 5:25company itself seems to not be able to reckon With the fact
- 5:30that it either needs to start talking about itself as a stock,
- 5:33that's not going to grow, but will throw off value because
- 5:35it's Communications company because it's as essential, as a
- 5:37telephone company or whatever new story would want to tell.
- 5:41And for all these regulatory reasons, this story seemed
- 5:43somewhat unappealing, or it has to convince the market that is
- 5:46going to get. And next huge spread of growth,
- 5:49akin to what happened in the switch to mobile and it will be
- 5:52just as powerful and I think that's why they're paying so
- 5:54much on the metaverse but I don't know.
- 5:55Alex, what do you think, like, why do you think the company
- 5:58isn't willing to start? Talking about itself in kind of
- 6:00a new, a new way. Well, I think they were until
- 6:03about the beginning of this year.
- 6:05So I've noticed Zuckerberg kind of reorient it back to the
- 6:10present, whereas, for like the pandemic.
- 6:12He only wanted to talk about the future and about the gross stuff
- 6:15and the metaverse stuff and the Rebrand was done really right
- 6:19before the market went into freefall, like it was really at
- 6:22the end of this, like two-year bubble.
- 6:23We were in which is just kind of an interesting was that their
- 6:25Apex, it was like he was able to evolve into his final form.
- 6:29Has, he was so ahead of its powers accent.
- 6:31Yeah, there's like a Cronenberg movie kind of like, yeah, I am
- 6:35becoming, I am becoming mad and it's like with the stock price.
- 6:39You can track his public comments shift into like
- 6:42actually talking about the the current business more and
- 6:45talking about actual like soap. He didn't want to talk about
- 6:49like social media for two years like which is the company's
- 6:52business. Like it was all metaverse.
- 6:54All the time he let's take your temperature as of proximate for
- 6:58face. Facebook.
- 6:59Because last time, we talked to you, you were extremely bullish.
- 7:01Yeah. About metaverse like, uh, are
- 7:05you raining that in tactically seen a sort of shift in strategy
- 7:09from Facebook, or you're still pretty optimistic?
- 7:12I've so boldly flip-flopping? No, no, I'm still I think the
- 7:18headsets like what I was saying in the last episode are about to
- 7:21get really good. I think the problem with metal
- 7:23versus that no one gets it and no one wants to like think it's
- 7:27potentially going to be something.
- 7:29Because like the it sucks right now like Quest is like not a
- 7:32great experience. It's not something you want to.
- 7:34It takes 20 minutes. You think the headsets could be
- 7:36good? Facebook could make a lot of
- 7:38money off them in the next couple of years.
- 7:40Yeah, I think if the, I think if the headsets in the interface
- 7:43and the battery, and the resolution and just being able
- 7:46to like, actually interact with people gets a lot better in
- 7:50these things. I do think people will use them,
- 7:52I think, I think it will become inevitable to a degree for for
- 7:56certain use cases, not for everything.
- 7:58I love the way. Real world.
- 7:59I just think. Yeah, one of them are so
- 8:01metaverse fight I just yeah. Curious how much they're going
- 8:04to back away? I think this has like moved the
- 8:08goalposts farther out where now they're thinking he's being a
- 8:11little more clear saying this isn't going to really be a thing
- 8:14for us until the end of the decade was just like, okay, how
- 8:17long can you acknowledge? Why would you do that?
- 8:20Unless, like, what sentence was, he getting about its Evolution
- 8:23that caused him to push it further out?
- 8:24I don't understand. Like, there hasn't been that
- 8:26much to change between now, then and now other Its stock price
- 8:30and like a continuing decline. Like why would you suddenly like
- 8:33re next time just not being ready they keep thinking that
- 8:36Apple's been the same way Apple. First up, their first headset
- 8:38was going to come out like two years ago they all these
- 8:41companies just are suit so over optimistic about how fast the
- 8:45tech will progress. And Zack has been pretty clear
- 8:48that this is like the hardest technical problem that exists
- 8:51right now is like building a compelling.
- 8:54Lightweight pair of are glasses. So yeah they're all night.
- 8:58Can't I get Guess you don't want to be the guy in, you know, the
- 9:01labs tells us look like, yeah, we're not even close, dude.
- 9:04I know a couple of months ago, we were kind of telling you that
- 9:06it's gonna get pretty close. Yeah, we did that.
- 9:08We ran the numbers again, resolutions bad.
- 9:11It's not going to be good, man. I mean, I kind of feel for them,
- 9:14but again, I don't see why this was a new revelation.
- 9:17There's an element of this where because this is Ox baby and his
- 9:21pet project. What I've heard is that, you
- 9:23know, it's like and there's been other reporting on this even at
- 9:27Apple and other companies is like the demos They get given to
- 9:29these Executives. Internally are like there is no
- 9:33other supporters of the paper dummies.
- 9:35That was it? Yeah.
- 9:36Or they're just like them away know people?
- 9:39Yeah, it can be hard to have people tell you how it really is
- 9:44when you become someone like a Mark Zuckerberg or and also when
- 9:47you start running the company in such a way that people are
- 9:49afraid to tell you how. I mean that was one of the
- 9:51interesting things about the story that you wrote about the
- 9:54all-hands meeting that, you know, Zuckerberg used to be far
- 9:57more involved in those meetings. And Are more willing himself to
- 10:01take harder questions and he's sort of like created a world in
- 10:05which he's insulated himself from both hard questions and
- 10:08annoying questions. And so, how do you tell us, how
- 10:11do you be honest? But somebody who's created that
- 10:13structure around themselves. Well, it's two sided because I
- 10:15would say, yes, he has insulated himself as the company gets
- 10:19bigger, but the questions themselves have also changed
- 10:23like the in the way that the what is on employees mind and
- 10:27that's that's really the main reason I wrote this Sorry is
- 10:29like in the last two years, the employees have really shifted.
- 10:32It's all about perks and about like, are there going to be
- 10:35layoffs? And are we gonna have extra
- 10:36vacation days? Like the stuff that gets
- 10:39filtered up to him? And all hands is not like
- 10:41strategy and like big picture. They're activists but for their
- 10:46own quality of life and well I think it it just goes to show
- 10:49like we're big Tech is at. I think it's the new Wall
- 10:52Street. It's the new cushy place where
- 10:55you can go and get paid a lot to not work that much.
- 10:59And there's this horse from Never As Good.
- 11:00Almost. Right.
- 11:01And at least wash we pretended your came to work super hard.
- 11:05Like they took away their free lunches.
- 11:07They totally there but like the perks were not that good, right?
- 11:11The money was good. The money was good.
- 11:13But the perks for the expense account Facebook gave you free
- 11:16bike parts and laundry and dry cleaning and bus rides, Michael.
- 11:20And they told you all the way they took it all away for like
- 11:23the promise you could live in Chicago, you know, it's all over
- 11:26Facebook. So I can I read a quick section
- 11:28for beer. It really gets to the core of
- 11:30it. And also, I, your article pissed
- 11:32me off, not like, the way you reported or the writing, but I
- 11:36was a little angry about the way Zach.
- 11:38Handled himself throughout all of this.
- 11:40All right, all right. So here's a two graphs.
- 11:43This is a question from one of the people at the All Hands.
- 11:46Hi there. The first pre-recorded employee
- 11:48question, started. I'm Gary, and I'm located in
- 11:50Chicago, his question would met a days.
- 11:53Extra days off introduced during the pandemic, continue in 2023
- 11:57Zuckerberg appeared visibly, Frustrated.
- 12:00All right. He stammered.
- 12:02He just explained that he thought the economy was headed
- 12:04for one of the worst downturn that we've seen in recent
- 12:06history. He'd already Frozen hiring in
- 12:08many areas, Tick-Tock was eating their lunch and would take over
- 12:11a year and a half for they had line of sight to overtaking it.
- 12:14So this is, like, what said, suck up to like his.
- 12:17I don't know, like Wolf of Wall Street, like tirade against his
- 12:19employees, for being lazy. Okay.
- 12:22Before we get into my opinion here, like it's tell me.
- 12:25Tell me, it was this the first time anyone ever asked Jacques
- 12:27about a perk. I thought these all They're
- 12:29famous for people asking about, like why did you take away the
- 12:31MMS in like the lunch room that we're like, previously stalked,
- 12:36you know, 20 years ago? Here's what happened.
- 12:38So this was, this was an incredibly unusual.
- 12:40All hands like like a Zuckerberg doesn't do them all the time
- 12:43anymore. So whenever he does them, it's
- 12:45kind of notable anymore. They're usually very scripted.
- 12:48Very like he just walks through like what they announced
- 12:50externally like in the previous week and says he's excited about
- 12:53it. It's really like become so
- 12:55buttoned up because I mean people like me, we could all the
- 12:57time and then Then what happened this week was he showed up?
- 13:01And I really don't think they knew he was going to go into the
- 13:04kind of rant that he went into where he spent the first 15. 20
- 13:08minutes, basically saying like real.
- 13:09Yeah, realistically, there's a bunch of people who shouldn't be
- 13:11working here and I'm going to make you said that make it sing
- 13:15thing, everybody? Yeah.
- 13:17The quiet part out loud. And realistically, I'm going to
- 13:20and he was saying, like, look, I'm not going to do layoffs
- 13:22necessarily I'm not going to roll them out, but I'm just
- 13:24going to make it to where you self-select out and that's okay
- 13:27with me like, you Gary Even worse than just gonna squeeze
- 13:31you so hard that you don't want to be riding at turn up the
- 13:34heat. Going to be a lot of dead frogs
- 13:36in this, in this pot of water. Yeah.
- 13:37So so and then I could because I saw the recording of This and
- 13:41like, even like the internal comms person who's like the
- 13:44person who transitions the meeting into the different
- 13:46sections as like visibly. Like you could tell, they did
- 13:49not know he was going to like go into this mode, right?
- 13:53Put the fear of God into him, you've got a surprise people and
- 13:56then they have this pre-recorded thing teed up.
- 13:58These Our highly produced like, right, graphics on screen like
- 14:02again, how can you be honest with anybody at the executive
- 14:05level when this is your like point of communication with the
- 14:07employees? Anyway continue?
- 14:09Yeah. And well, I'm just saying it was
- 14:10it kind of threw poor Gary under the bus because you know, it was
- 14:14pre-recorded, he's a recruit, he's a recruiter.
- 14:17So he, you know, this is actually, we know Gary is real,
- 14:20do we know Gary is a real Gary is real.
- 14:22He was a meme internally. There were like poles internally
- 14:26about like, Gary for CEO. They should We fire this guy
- 14:30like, you know, and like ever exactly Tim Armstrong did white
- 14:33one, is it Mary Poppins where they take the guy's hat and they
- 14:35turn it inside out or whatever? They were like Shirley Jackson.
- 14:40Yeah, exactly, exactly. Now, there is like, just a
- 14:42cinder somewhere like in, you know, North River Chicago.
- 14:46Where Gary used to be? Because it's like trying to pull
- 14:49his like Darth Vader Force like maneuver on him.
- 14:51Yeah. And then he asks about he has
- 14:53this pre-recorded thing about the vacation days and stock is
- 14:56just like flabbergasted that. Hey, this This was asked but be
- 14:59that his team probably had this cute up and didn't like adjust
- 15:03on the Fly. He wants just to be clear.
- 15:05The employee wants to have like the extra vacation days they got
- 15:09because of the pandemic being terrible RuPaul so they weren't
- 15:12they worked in Gary worked in recruiting.
- 15:14So so it was like he's selling like talk to people about,
- 15:17right? This is like the Practical
- 15:19question, it's not just self-oriented.
- 15:21I see. It's like, oh yeah, so what
- 15:23should I tell very unfortunate timing and then suck is like,
- 15:26you know, based on my tone you can see how I'll probably
- 15:29Respond to this and then he proceeds to say that meta days
- 15:31are cancelled. Right?
- 15:32Wow. And he's welcome to hell, you
- 15:36know, tell them is not going to be a good place to work anymore.
- 15:40Like keep in mind like just last year.
- 15:43You know, Facebook's HR team produced a video similar to the
- 15:46Virgin America video about. You know, like fááá is flight
- 15:49preparedness. All about their health care
- 15:50plans where they did like wraps and songs about like, how their
- 15:54health care plan was changing. So yeah, the pendulum is fucking
- 15:57swung lady widest point. Certainly of all this is that
- 16:00this meeting ended with a video of an executive surfing, so like
- 16:04he goes on this and it was it was pre-recorded and it was
- 16:07already like set up but he does this like huge you know talk
- 16:10about we got to buckle up for intense times and then they they
- 16:13throw to this video of an executive which is that can.
- 16:16Why how long was it like two hours long you have to why?
- 16:19Like I know everyone is just strapped to their chair was like
- 16:24a mini videos, like just it was like an exact profile but like
- 16:27following her surfing, Amazing. That's so good.
- 16:30Gary, you don't get any more fucking time off.
- 16:33All right, well, I'm like the antenna days is Lancel.
- 16:37Here's my airport. I'll give him mine.
- 16:40Zuckerberg is working from Hawaii to like how Shaggy yeah
- 16:44like employees. Want like a meta day so they can
- 16:47leave their like one bedroom apartments in Chicago and go sit
- 16:49by the lake for 20 minutes but suck is like working from his
- 16:52Lanai. Oh well that's yeah that's the
- 16:55duality of this is like there's a shit Posting group inside
- 17:00Facebook internally called shitposting at meta.
- 17:02And they're literally, there are memes of like Zuckerberg, you
- 17:06know, hydrofoil along with the American flag and people being
- 17:08like, look at this coaster and brutal.
- 17:12See ya. Cuz there was a note that went
- 17:15out that really pissed. People off after that, where
- 17:17this executive at the company. This engineering executive, he
- 17:20posted it in a manager's only group and it was like identify
- 17:23coasters. Put them in a list by 5 p.m.
- 17:27Monday. We can't have like Ours at meta,
- 17:29very blunt. Very like, not how you should,
- 17:32you know, communicate something like this in written form and it
- 17:35leaks someone in the managers group leaked it on.
- 17:37Oh my why? I think it leaked to the
- 17:39information, love it. People are very unhappy at this
- 17:41company. Executive later is like it was a
- 17:43draft. I didn't mean to publish it as
- 17:50yet voters, Fat Cats, well, meme.
- 17:55This becomes a mean and thoroughly.
- 17:56And, and there's like, you know, Because there's this new mantra
- 18:00inside the company called Meta, Meta mates.
- 18:02Me, it's this new, like, what would you value called?
- 18:04Is this what, man? It's like, primates or meta
- 18:10mates, like, like meta mates? Like like em, you know, how
- 18:13bundlers Google employees? Our googlers.
- 18:15Yeah, if you work at metal, you're a meta mate.
- 18:17And then of me, this is what that's really, what everyone
- 18:20like this was after the Rebrand he did this big company value
- 18:23reset. I didn't screw Thread about it.
- 18:25And it was, it was absolute was absurd because like, you know,
- 18:28they had moved Ask that other company values.
- 18:30He's like we're going to go through and change some of these
- 18:32and a new one was Meta Meta mates me so it's like about it's
- 18:36meant to be like like we're all in it together.
- 18:38I guess is the vibe of the Mantra but now people were doing
- 18:42coasters coasters meet coasters. Posting me I'm making like
- 18:46coasters like mock-ups of actual coasters.
- 18:48Right. And that's what I was going to
- 18:50say. If I were selling anything, it
- 18:51would be coasters. Coasters.
- 18:52Yeah. So yeah, there's just, there's
- 18:54still a very strong even with all the Crackdown they've done
- 18:56internally on like can employee communication.
- 18:58I was very pleased and Reporting.
- 19:00This story to see that there's still a strong shitposting
- 19:02Community. I am amazed, how much open
- 19:04descent. There is like Bloomberg never
- 19:07had, like, employees me mean about, like how terrible, the, I
- 19:10mean, and I, there's no way babe, it is when, when Mike,
- 19:14when Mike was mayor of New York City though and he was album
- 19:18veto, right? A lot was going on in The
- 19:22Flipper, Jeffrey mayor. And the public was an employee
- 19:26at Facebook. Another stat in Story.
- 19:29Is that 42 percent of employees have confidence in leadership.
- 19:33So this was an employee survey that went out right God.
- 19:35No wonder, you're getting people leaky.
- 19:37You so much shit. They fucking hate this, man.
- 19:39And they never, they never understand.
- 19:41This is the best company in the world to cover right now.
- 19:44They never understanding stuff. I mean, even like, when we were
- 19:46talking to a meal last week and he was talking about, like,
- 19:48there were so many leaks happening at Uber at the time
- 19:50and it's like, yeah, dude, that's what happens.
- 19:52When people are really unhappy at your company, right?
- 19:55These leaks track to the stock price more than anything.
- 19:58I mean, Absolutely. We've all we've all experienced
- 20:00this, like, in common. These companies when the stock
- 20:02is down because peep for people who don't work in Tech, which
- 20:05I'm sure is like no one listening to this.
- 20:06Show why job and tanker I can hang up the podcast right now.
- 20:11Yeah, you get compensated heavily based on the stock price
- 20:15and you know, people are looking.
- 20:16They hired an entire company's worth of people like they
- 20:19started. They went into the pandemic with
- 20:2140-ish thousand, they hired that amount in about 2 years.
- 20:24So they like more than doubled and they were all working in
- 20:27this remote environment when the stock is All-time highs.
- 20:30And now they're seeing their compensation cut by like more
- 20:33than 50% and they have no confidence or low confidence
- 20:37record, low confidence and Leadership so it's just a bad
- 20:40combination of like Duck saying, you're all a bunch of like
- 20:43grifters. And then everyone's saying, hey,
- 20:45we don't really like you either. So it's really interesting that
- 20:48you say this because like this is a little bit of a reap what
- 20:52you sow situation to like I remember in 2010 basically all
- 20:56of corporate America tried to Recreate, the, the sort of like
- 21:00Tech Perk Tech lifestyle phenomenon, because it's having
- 21:03so much trouble recruiting people out of college, because
- 21:05they were like, when we give them less, we give people
- 21:08literally free shit, like hand over fist, and give them free
- 21:13food and free, espresso bars and all this complete bullshit.
- 21:16We will never hire anybody out of a top 50 school again and the
- 21:20tech industry to a company. But especially at Facebook, they
- 21:24just talked about how great this was in terms of, you know,
- 21:27getting the best work out of people.
- 21:28They were never willing to concede, it was just going to
- 21:31create an incredibly entitled Workforce.
- 21:35And so it's kind of and there's something very poetic but saying
- 21:37that incredibly title entitled Workforce come and bite Facebook
- 21:42in the ass. Like you're just like, you know
- 21:44what, you made this monster, right?
- 21:46If me if you want us to work for something other than free.
- 21:49Shit, good luck, you created, the culture of Brooklyn for free
- 21:52shipping and and let's also talk about what's going on here.
- 21:55Which was that during the pandemic, the momentum swung.
- 21:58Sharply towards employees because there was, you know,
- 22:02difficulty in hiring and recruiting and attrition and all
- 22:05the issues that these companies were facing.
- 22:07Suddenly they had a huge amount of Leverage because you could
- 22:10work for a huge number of companies wherever you were
- 22:12living and, you know, yeah, companies.
- 22:15Wherever you're living in the country and this couldn't stand
- 22:19this, you know, this aggression could not stand when it came to,
- 22:22you know, the executives. And so I think they see the
- 22:24recession as the ability to do like a little bit of a reset on
- 22:27their part and say, You know that meta mates, or sorry, you
- 22:30know, the metadata things that we rolled out and your ability
- 22:33to live in fucking Chicago, Gary that whole thing.
- 22:36Yeah, we're not doing that anymore.
- 22:37And the reason is that, it's your fault and and this is what
- 22:39pissed me off about about suck single.
- 22:41You kind of jump me to it is that the employees are unhappy
- 22:44too. And how much is suck himself
- 22:47taking responsibility for the fact that he only has 41 percent
- 22:50approval ratings within his gun. Salute, 42, I'm sorry.
- 22:53Yeah, it's important to be exact here Tom.
- 22:55No. Oh yeah.
- 22:57That one percent is not a coaster.
- 22:58Sure, sure it's a good question. I don't know the answer.
- 23:03I don't know what's inside his mind.
- 23:04I think he does think they hired they over hired and they hired a
- 23:07lot of he needs missionaries right now and they hired a lot
- 23:10of non missionaries and I think that's how I seize it.
- 23:13And, you know, when you used to be able to just go to Google or
- 23:16vice versa for an extra 20, 30 percent pay bump like with no
- 23:20effort, which was the reality of life for these Tech workers for
- 23:24the last few years, especially it was, you had to hire like,
- 23:28Had to lower your bar a little bit because like people have a
- 23:31lot of options and now people don't have as many options.
- 23:33Google's not hiring, you know, their competitors aren't hiring
- 23:36either. So the it's you're right, the
- 23:39pendulum is swinging back to the management and not the employees
- 23:43and I think that's what this meeting really represented.
- 23:46And this duck is unique in that he's the you know, God king of
- 23:48Facebook and can say whatever he wants.
- 23:50And say the quiet part out loud and is not really like I think a
- 23:54lot of these CEOs are probably thinking similar thoughts, but
- 23:57they for whatever Other reasons, you know, there may be like
- 24:00negotiating their next comp package with their board or
- 24:03whatever, they feel like they can't, you know, tussle the, you
- 24:06know, tells all things up too much, but Zuckerberg doesn't
- 24:09really care. I mean, he can, he can do
- 24:11whatever he wants at the company.
- 24:12So I think he was just ready to just say the quiet part out
- 24:15loud, but he's also not an inspirational guy.
- 24:18I mean, I think he's also kind of uniquely week in this period
- 24:21because he's not the guy that can go out there and give like
- 24:24the Don Draper speech and everybody, rallied to work on
- 24:27weekends and shit, right? He's the uh, Weird person who I
- 24:30don't know what his face looked like when he was angry, but I'm
- 24:32sure, you know, it wasn't red. Very red maybe.
- 24:35Yeah, we got red mark. He was better than everybody
- 24:38else has been wrong. I mean, that's the thing.
- 24:39Yeah, always had he didn't get cycle, privacy, but never told
- 24:43me. I was an idiot when we did this.
- 24:44I mean, it's sort of transitioning to our next topic.
- 24:47I mean, like nobody thought feet, like users didn't like
- 24:50feed, you know, it's sort of like, and that's clear is
- 24:52coming. I can't think of one, I can
- 24:54think of not one CEO. Who's always been right?
- 24:57Yeah. And you can argue that The
- 24:58problems is consistently always right problems there in right
- 25:01now, is because they didn't get a couple key things.
- 25:03Right? Which Tom you mentioned, they
- 25:04didn't see the Apple changes, hurting them as badly as they
- 25:07did. They had plenty of opportunity
- 25:09to see that they were kind of like in denial for a while and
- 25:12they also didn't see the tick tock threat, right until it was
- 25:15arguably too late. So yeah, he does see around
- 25:17corners and certain key moments, but I think they're in the
- 25:19position, they're in right now because for whatever reason,
- 25:22maybe because he's really a dog's back from Hawaii.
- 25:25This is the new rallying Cry. He's asleep at the wheel.
- 25:28Come back as like a bird in California.
- 25:31I think it's no I think it's a matter of focus.
- 25:33He's definitely not asleep at the wheel.
- 25:34Like he's been super dialed in based on everything I hear to
- 25:37like a kind of like stressful degree for people who are
- 25:40working on projects, he's interested in but the problem
- 25:43is, is like the projects. He's been interested in are not
- 25:45making the company money and they're not they're not going to
- 25:48save it from the current environment that they're in.
- 25:51It's all like very few cleaning stuff, which is why I find it,
- 25:54really frustrating for him to be chastising coaster fat, cat
- 25:57employees for not pulling their weight.
- 25:58Wait when you know he missed the Apple privacy changes.
- 26:01He didn't anticipate Tick-Tock the Instagram thing was a
- 26:04fiasco, what? You got to one second and he's
- 26:06trying to get people inspired about this completely vague
- 26:08metaverse thing that it's not clear anyone really wants.
- 26:11So I just I find it. It's a little Rich for me suck.
- 26:14It's a little Rich for me so I am taking your buyout offer.
- 26:18I'm not saying it's Tom's out, I'm gone.
- 26:23I'm gone. You could, you could see me
- 26:24walking along Michigan Avenue right now.
- 26:26Me and Gary, just hand in hand. But you didn't heck talking
- 26:30about meta days the metadata. If you're okay talking, let's
- 26:33talk about Instagram because that was a really funny story.
- 26:37Why don't you actually lay out what happened?
- 26:39Because I was actually out all of last week so it really was
- 26:41just the bits and few times that I sadly turned on Twitter.
- 26:44So I need about him. Yeah, tell ya.
- 26:46Instagram has been testing this redesign that looks and works
- 26:50like Tick-Tock and people are starting to get the get in the
- 26:53ABC group. You know?
- 26:54For the test, they were planning to originally make it available
- 26:57for everyone in October. It's Fullscreen, right?
- 26:59Isn't that? I have full screen swipeable
- 27:01video, you know, and just a huge departure, the whole not just
- 27:06real correct and people obviously didn't like it.
- 27:09And the other reason beyond the interface is that part of this
- 27:13redesign is a lot of what Facebook calls unconnected
- 27:16content, which is just content, that's not from people, you
- 27:18follow. So a lot of that is getting put
- 27:21in which is also Tick Tock, right?
- 27:22That's Tick-Tock you know, tick-tocks for you page is like
- 27:24you know hardly what you follow. If at all Kylie Jenner who you
- 27:27know, Leveled snap with a Tweet back in the day.
- 27:32Tom and I remember this, well, when she hated the snap
- 27:34redesign, she wiped like over a billion off their market cap.
- 27:38She came out and said was writing analyst having to put
- 27:40out notes following the Kylie Jenner announcement.
- 27:42Yeah, she was like, bring back the old Instagram, you know, it
- 27:45became this like me and there was a there was a, like a
- 27:48petition, you know, all it reminded me of the snap redesign
- 27:51blowback which didn't didn't she say something about it being for
- 27:54family or something, which she's talking.
- 27:57I want to see photos from my friend.
- 27:58Which is like shit, like, come on.
- 28:01Really like that. Was you?
- 28:02I think she's the second most followed Instagram right now.
- 28:05She has like, over 300 million followers.
- 28:07Come on II, don't like. So, dumb brands are our friends,
- 28:10Eric, you as a millennial should know this.
- 28:13I mean, if you're a celebrity, I understand you built a lot of
- 28:15time and money into getting a huge follower base of people to
- 28:18see your stuff. And all of a sudden, the company
- 28:20is deciding that they want to show people other things.
- 28:23And that's going to hurt your reach.
- 28:25So I can see why celebrities would be mad about this.
- 28:28But she Add and then what was happening simultaneously is
- 28:30internally. This test was just performing
- 28:32horribly, it was just tanking engagement metrics ad revenue
- 28:37and so they paused it and Adam moceri.
- 28:40The head of Instagram did an interview with Casey Newton on
- 28:43his wonderful newsletter. Platformer and was like, we are,
- 28:46you know, the test of not been good and we are going to
- 28:49re-evaluate this and what's not changing as the unconnected
- 28:52content part. So you're still going to be
- 28:54seeing a lot more posts from people.
- 28:56You don't follow and Instagram and Facebook.
- 28:58Look, but the redesign that makes it look and work like Tick
- 29:01Tock with swipeable video, that's that's been put on ice.
- 29:04So he made your L major. It sucker Berg posted a photo of
- 29:08himself with weekend on the lake.
- 29:11I just think it's odd on Instagram.
- 29:13That Zack is posting a photo. Isn't he supposed to be posting
- 29:16videos right now? Oh my God.
- 29:19What a fucking coaster? Yeah I mean I don't care.
- 29:27I say a couple things on this. Go, please, you know, stories,
- 29:31have shifted everyone to stories away from sort of the permanent
- 29:36photos and I get that. Facebook is a company that rides
- 29:40different Trends and they see people having sort of better,
- 29:44internet connections, and better phones with the capacity to
- 29:46record video. And so they're like, okay, we
- 29:49need to have video everywhere. But as a consumer part of what I
- 29:53like about the history of Instagram is just that the feed
- 29:57of photos is. Very like clean and high-end and
- 30:00part of the reason people are posting less is because there
- 30:03are so thoughtful about the quality of photos that they put
- 30:08in the feet versus the stories, write stories are for sort of
- 30:11quickfire and feed is for highly curated content.
- 30:14And so then, that's what you're incentivizing people to create
- 30:17and then they're mixing that feed with absolute garbage.
- 30:20And to me, that's part of the issue here.
- 30:22It's like, yes people are engaging with the core of
- 30:25Instagram less, but that's because they wanted to Be really
- 30:29premium and you're taking this Premium app and just like
- 30:32filling it with a bunch of random shit.
- 30:34Do you think that's a fair articulation?
- 30:37Well what sort of going on here? I think you're getting at it.
- 30:39I think what's really happening here?
- 30:41Is that the grand experiment of organizing human communication
- 30:45at scale around the feed has not worked.
- 30:48It hasn't worked on for rocket and it hasn't worked on
- 30:51Instagram. And what they've observed is
- 30:55that posting into feed whether it's Instagram or Facebook has
- 30:58just been on the decline for a long time.
- 31:01So what they have is an inventory problem.
- 31:03So when when your follower list is no longer posting in the
- 31:06feed, which matters because feed is how they make the most money,
- 31:10so they need to feed to have good content in it.
- 31:13Well, guess what, when your friends are no longer posting in
- 31:16there, they need to show you something.
- 31:17So they're going to try to figure it out.
- 31:19The problem is that they're way behind on a, i that makes that
- 31:22something interesting. Whereas Tick-Tock has shown them
- 31:26that like, oh my God, this is so good.
- 31:29Yeah. But at it and because Facebook
- 31:32invented, the idea of ranking based on, you know, your
- 31:35follower list, this was the original news feed Insight that
- 31:38Twitter and everyone else has since copied Tick-Tock took that
- 31:41idea step further and said we don't even need to know like who
- 31:44you're following? Your dog is amazing.
- 31:46I feel like you aren't on it. Do not understand how good it
- 31:48is. It's serving you.
- 31:49What? So Facebook is internally meta
- 31:52is reorganizing around this new, a I push and it's next to the
- 31:56metaverse, the most, you know, the highwomen.
- 31:58Highest like priority. Most money being spent is on how
- 32:02to build AI that no longer relies on who you follow but
- 32:06this is an extremely naive thing to say and I know sort of the
- 32:10answer but as a user, why can't you build a new tic toc
- 32:13Facebook? Why do you need to cannibalize
- 32:16the app we liked if it's slowly dies.
- 32:18Don't worry about us. You have stopped.
- 32:19You remember last? So Eric do you remember?
- 32:21I know it doesn't work. That's the answer our paper.
- 32:23They were paper. They're basically going to
- 32:25murder the thing we like when also they can't acquire a new
- 32:28App either exactly. They just tried that and it
- 32:32didn't work and was even a nap. Yeah, they can't acquire and
- 32:36they need to put it where the user activity is, you know, this
- 32:39is if they're good. The problem is it's like people
- 32:41are leaving the app, they're not engaging the most with it
- 32:44because of tick-tock and they need to bring Instagram.
- 32:48The problem with all, this is like, they've lost the identity
- 32:50of what these apps were, right? Instagram is about
- 32:53entertainment. They when they tout the video, I
- 32:55find it so fascinating when they're bragging about like
- 32:58video. Metrics on Facebook and
- 33:00Instagram like over 50% or something of time spent in
- 33:03Facebook is just watching video which is just not what Facebook
- 33:07was originally about. A Facebook was an active,
- 33:10participatory thing and Instagram was also that I mean
- 33:14there was definitely an element of like passive lean back with
- 33:16Instagram. Obviously, there always has
- 33:18been, but they've lost the participant.
- 33:21Yeah, the participatory element of this and it's because all
- 33:24this behavior is shifting into private groups chat.
- 33:28DMS more content is shared into GM's and a shared.
- 33:31In this story's more content is started shared into stories that
- 33:34are shared in to feed. So it's kind of like, finding
- 33:36Jim hierarchy. So everything is funneling.
- 33:39Yeah. So everything is funneling down
- 33:41into DM's and it's because I think they've, they've created
- 33:46an environment in the feed that is just not conducive to like,
- 33:49human communication, which was there a grand experiment for the
- 33:52last 12 years and it worked briefly for a moment in time.
- 33:56And then I don't know, I'm Do you guys know have you guys
- 33:59heard of this idea called context collapse?
- 34:01This ring a bell for anyone? Yeah, I mean, it's just, it's
- 34:05this idea in social networks where you let the graph, which
- 34:08is your follower list, just expand and expand and expand and
- 34:12you lose a sense of who you're talking to anymore, because the
- 34:15purpose of the app has just become too vague.
- 34:18There's too many people on it. These apps tend to Decay when
- 34:21they lose their original like framework of what their what
- 34:24they are for people. And so be real I think is taking
- 34:28off, right? Because be real has identified
- 34:30that the close friend graph, which is what Facebook used to
- 34:33be in its earliest days. What?
- 34:35Instagram was also in its earliest days.
- 34:37No one's doing that anymore. Everyone has let their lists
- 34:40expand and expand and expand and people don't know who to talk to
- 34:43anymore. They don't feel comfortable
- 34:44posting because if you have hundreds and hundreds of
- 34:46followers, you're not going to post your what you would post on
- 34:49be real. And you're also not going to do
- 34:50the highly curated thing, maybe even anymore.
- 34:53And this is so ironic because if you guys remember the last major
- 34:56ranking change that Did was called meaningful social
- 35:00interactions. This is actually a thing that
- 35:02Francis Haugen called out in the all the leaks documents it was a
- 35:06big deal in 2018 and what they were trying to do is there was a
- 35:08bunch of passive shallow engagement happening because
- 35:11they were optimizing for time spent.
- 35:13So people were just watching dumb videos that's what was
- 35:15getting up. Voted the most in the feed they
- 35:18were like we're going to reorient it around.
- 35:19Two things that your followers comment on.
- 35:23So what do they do? They created this like flame War
- 35:25environment, right? Where the and you know I've
- 35:27talked to But the company who admit that this ranking change
- 35:30caused a lot of unintended consequences where they're
- 35:33actually trying to solve for an Integrity problem, which is that
- 35:35like the engagement was super shallow, people weren't having
- 35:38meaningful experiences in the feed and in doing.
- 35:40So they actually just hyper-charged the emotions of
- 35:43everyone because they're optimizing for comments and
- 35:46reshares from from your friends. And guess what, what guess and
- 35:48we see this in Twitter and retweets what gets the most
- 35:51engagement at stuff that's either going to piss you off or
- 35:54you know, like that kind of stuff.
- 35:56And so now they're just like screw it.
- 35:58Uh, kit like the feed is now just going to be like videos.
- 36:01Yeah, I think what's so ironic and hilarious about this
- 36:04argument is that it is being, you know, the argument against
- 36:08Instagrams redesign is being made by the person who is
- 36:11responsible for Content collapse.
- 36:13Because Kylie Jenner and that whole group of influencers, turn
- 36:16the app from something that could have been.
- 36:18These are my vacation photos, you know, some kind of iteration
- 36:21of the thing that be real is going after into we are all
- 36:24celebrity at Hawkers that are trying to make a business of
- 36:28Cells because our lives are so interesting but we should it's
- 36:31not their fault. This is the company.
- 36:33I just did an episode a podcast episode about the history of
- 36:36Instagram and kind of how they woud, celebrities onto the
- 36:39platform. The country had teams of
- 36:41Executives today, specifically just went and trained
- 36:43celebrities. Yes, and attracted them.
- 36:45We interviewed the executive who ran this program, it was a
- 36:48concerted like intentional effort to get celebrities
- 36:52posting on the platform. It wasn't how the app just
- 36:54organically happened. They literally had to go
- 36:57convince the Uber and the supermodels to like post and it
- 37:02was, it was super intense oils. Yeah.
- 37:03So like I think it's the fault is not of users.
- 37:07It's the company is the one who decides how these networks
- 37:10works, and how they want the context to continue in the
- 37:13network. And if they want to expand it,
- 37:14or if they want to shorten it. And and that's that's been the
- 37:17problem is that like Facebook and its quest for engagement and
- 37:19revenue as just widen and widen and widen the aperture of what
- 37:23Instagram is to where it's now this weird shopping mall Meats,
- 37:26like video meets. Times meet stories and now no
- 37:30one knows what it's for anymore. That's, that's super interesting
- 37:33because now, like, I feel like the mood on my Tick Tock is very
- 37:36much like, celebrities aren't like, you and me, like, it's
- 37:40almost a cuz the people can get famous on Tick.
- 37:42Tock aren't these like big celebrities, but just
- 37:45interesting creators like, maybe a Majors, right?
- 37:48I saw one sort of charting out, you know, like the Ellen, you
- 37:51know, that Ellen selfie, that was a one point of the epitome
- 37:55of like culture and it helped like that was sort of Of and now
- 37:59a tick tock is like so hostile to that, you know?
- 38:01I mean yeah no argument to that is like the the depth trial or
- 38:05whatever, but until they get famous right and then they can
- 38:08build a business off of. Well, I don't know that that's
- 38:10even happened to that extent. I'm like that's the funny thing.
- 38:13Like it was it Charlie d'amelio, she got her reality show so you
- 38:16would think she would have been made the leap into like bigger
- 38:19celebrity. But the reality show was
- 38:20basically about how much he hated being sold a pretty good,
- 38:24right? I mean like, because very few
- 38:26human beings are emotionally. Mentally equipped for the
- 38:29pressures of people staring at them all the time is totally
- 38:31fucked up. Like, you can't leave the house.
- 38:34Heath, I ask you this question because it's my wishful thinking
- 38:36are there. Also, it feels like the
- 38:38especially because of the pandemic, their cultural
- 38:41headwinds to working, against what social media has always
- 38:44been this, like highly curated. Look at people's lives like and
- 38:49I wonder how much of the departure is in addition to
- 38:53context, collapse people just thinking is it really worth my
- 38:57while to pretend like Like, my life is great right now.
- 39:00I would say that Tick-Tock is less fake than Instagram was.
- 39:05Oh, I guess that's what I mean, about Instagram.
- 39:07Yeah, yeah. And and that's what Instagram is
- 39:09trying to get to and it's kind of there's an optimist angle to
- 39:14it. That I've heard where, you know,
- 39:16maybe humans are the problem here.
- 39:18And when you're braking based on how humans like interact, and
- 39:22what they kind of like Ops towards, which is usually like,
- 39:26you know, bad My opinion, like, in terms of like how social
- 39:30media has been organized, like, people just, it can make people
- 39:32horrible to each other, maybe if you're optimizing for just this
- 39:35like, AI driven approach, where it's just content that this AI
- 39:40thinks, like could be interesting for people, maybe it
- 39:43will actually incentivize like a healthier posting.
- 39:46I do think it would be good for America, to, obviously, have a
- 39:49tick, tock competitor. I mean, that would be the
- 39:51strongest defensive Facebook. Oh, you're like a monster trout
- 39:55here on what media You're Gonna Go.
- 39:56The Nationalist route here on Is getting detailed psychological
- 40:01profiles on all of us. What are they going to do with
- 40:04that information? Like that we are already doing
- 40:07with to ourselves? Let's go here and even even
- 40:09forgetting the Nationalist thing.
- 40:10Even forgetting the Nationalist thing, it would be good for
- 40:13there to be competition. I think Tick.
- 40:15Tock is going to be huge, like, it's only beginning, I mean,
- 40:19it's huge already, but it's going to just the beginning, I
- 40:22know. But like, I feel like TV is not
- 40:25run by Tick-Tock yet. You know, it's still getting
- 40:27there. Until there is evidence that
- 40:29there has been a coordinated intentional.
- 40:32A I like a i induced like campaign from China to like
- 40:36influence what Tick-Tock recommends to people.
- 40:39I don't buy this argument. That Tick-Tock is like a
- 40:41national authorized thinking to do with that information.
- 40:44You know, below looks like Olivia Rodrigo's kind of
- 40:46meaningful to a lot of people in America these days.
- 40:49There's some people don't even say, like suicide on Tick-Tock.
- 40:53There are lots of speech controls on Tick-Tock.
- 40:56I think that the bigger thing with tick-tock Has that we
- 40:58actually don't know how other people see.
- 41:00So, Their audience outside of the United States.
- 41:02We're seeing very pro-russia videos on Tick-Tock at the very
- 41:05same time that in America. We were seeing very pro-ukraine
- 41:08messaging on Tick-Tock at the start of the war against, you
- 41:10know, Ukraine. So like I think that is the
- 41:14bigger thing is a, we'd have less visibility into who sees
- 41:18what? And obviously, what happens on
- 41:20Tick Tock is extremely influential when it comes to
- 41:22public opinion. And so, I think that that's why.
- 41:26It's not, it's less like a Chinese Best large mind control
- 41:30game, and just that another government may have the ability
- 41:33to really influence public opinion in countries outside of
- 41:36their own. So, in a country where the
- 41:39government is willing to influence their companies very
- 41:42direct but even in our country where I don't think we have to
- 41:45worry about see the, you know, the CCP like influencing General
- 41:49Motors. But I think that we saw with the
- 41:51Johnny Depp and Amber Heard trial that an algorithm was able
- 41:55to very much influence how people thought of those two.
- 41:58Human beings outside of the merits of the legal case, and
- 42:01then had real implications for, for example, you know, domestic
- 42:04abuse survivors all over who dared, talk about what happened
- 42:08to them with little, you know, with little consideration of how
- 42:12much a single company was able to influence public opinion.
- 42:16And I think that's like the bigger issue, you know, is that
- 42:19what you really want happening with no Insight or controls?
- 42:22But this is the same argument of any algorithm and that would be
- 42:25a problem if the company were can to it.
- 42:28Just that Regulators would have more ability to dig in and ask
- 42:32questions like have an oversight hearing for example, blah, blah,
- 42:36blah. Well, yeah, I mean, don't forget
- 42:37like, Taylor Ren's had. That story about how I gen sake,
- 42:40whoever we're like meeting with Tick-Tock influencers, so they
- 42:43could get people hyped about the American assistance in the
- 42:46right, like at the very same time that like, you know,
- 42:49intelligence Community people were like, wait, what the fuck
- 42:52is going on? Over Tick-Tock?
- 42:54It was really cool. It's really weird.
- 42:56Katie, you're speaking to this unease that I I think is only
- 42:59going to become like a more pronounced saying, we're talking
- 43:01about in the next couple of years because like every app,
- 43:04Facebook, Instagram, Twitter is leaning into recommendations,
- 43:07every app is going into recommendations and feed like
- 43:11heavy. And so when we're already
- 43:13concerned about, I mean, are you guys kind of?
- 43:15I'm kind of shocked that Facebook given all the scrutiny.
- 43:17It's already had is just like fuck it.
- 43:20Like we're going to just dictate everything or Tech is going to
- 43:23just dictate everything. You see, it's not even because
- 43:25they're fallback for years. Was well, at the end of the day,
- 43:27you pick who Follow and yeah. We met like do recommendations
- 43:31like on the edges but this is there.
- 43:33Like I would hear time and time again.
- 43:35I'm right blame it on his like maybe they're doing that they're
- 43:38still saying that. People are engaging with video
- 43:41more. Well that argument is not going
- 43:43to hold water. When like over half of your feet
- 43:45is like, AI recommendation is based recommendations and so
- 43:49yeah like we're already talking about like man could the CCP
- 43:52influenced Tick-Tock to be like turning the dial up on this or
- 43:56whatever. I don't think that has happened.
- 43:58Yeah. But it very well like support
- 43:59Ukraine versus support Russia. Yeah and we already have that
- 44:04unease. We already like we are in our
- 44:06bones. We think these systems can be
- 44:08manipulated and controlled this way and like it's just a concern
- 44:11people have this is like this is going to be Facebook like in a
- 44:15year. Like this is going to be the
- 44:16exact same thing so I don't think they fully have grappled
- 44:20with the scrutiny that they're about to walk into and I hope
- 44:23what it does is actually clarifies the role that
- 44:25regulation could play on this because I think for a while
- 44:27we've been Dancing around. What is really the Crux of like
- 44:31the power. These companies have, which is
- 44:33recommendations and now that they're really leaning into
- 44:36recommendations as like their business strategy.
- 44:39I hope that maybe we get a little more sense of like where
- 44:41the power actually sits with these companies and I think
- 44:44that's kind of the core of it whenever we want to talk about
- 44:48snap because it's time favorite company ever and it feels and
- 44:51value I wondering like when you look at all these company's
- 44:54earnings Facebook snap and you see you know, usage, Drop.
- 44:58But do you see any signs that people are just kind of turning
- 45:01away from social media all together?
- 45:03No, actually, what was interesting is that Facebook
- 45:06users grew a little bit after they declined for the first
- 45:09time, a couple quarters and that's being a tested to time
- 45:13spent on video actually. So I think the the dumb videos
- 45:16are working from an engagement perspective in the short term,
- 45:21but I don't know if it will in the long term, the thing is with
- 45:23like even snap. It's still growing like the user
- 45:26Ace is snap, is a business is one thing.
- 45:28Like the user base is still growing.
- 45:29They have more users than Twitter and yeah and like
- 45:33they're these companies are growing their users.
- 45:35It's mostly like outside of the US and Western Europe but it's
- 45:39more of a business story than it is like a user growth story.
- 45:42Yeah. And so snap is also an
- 45:44interesting case here going back to like earlier in our
- 45:46conversation we're talking about like this hierarchy of DMS to
- 45:49post stories or whatever. I mean snap is an excellent DM
- 45:53tool, right? That's that's that's main usage
- 45:56for a lot of people is that it's a very, very good message.
- 45:58Judging app, that's not a very good business and it's also,
- 46:02it's also a company that is done.
- 46:03I think a good job relative to everyone else with the problem
- 46:06of context collapse, because if we remember what the redesigned
- 46:09did was separate media from friends.
- 46:11And that was intentional, because snaps been, I think
- 46:15fairly intentional and trying to keep your your friends on snap
- 46:19as your actual friends. Not have a bunch of like people
- 46:22you don't know or like, you know, people from high school
- 46:25that you don't keep in touch with anymore, they actually try
- 46:27to encourage you to like Keep that graph clean.
- 46:30And so I think that's why they've, they've kind of had
- 46:32consistent growth. Honestly it's that's a that's a
- 46:35differentiated approach honestly in the market these days.
- 46:38But yeah, the business is not there, it still remains to be
- 46:41seen whether they're the next Twitter and that they languish
- 46:45forever trying to figure out how to have a scale dad business or
- 46:49they are something different. They haven't proven that they
- 46:51can be beyond the next Twitter from a business perspective and
- 46:54I think we saw that last quarter and a pretty big way.
- 46:56Yeah I mean that I think actually It was last time that
- 46:59you were on that I brought this up and maybe sounded dumb to a
- 47:01lot of people but I still don't understand what its business is
- 47:05like what its ads offering is. And that's also it's a smaller
- 47:09less, scaled less Advanced version of Facebook, sad
- 47:12business. It's yeah, wreck staff marketer
- 47:14just for context is worth 16 billion dollars.
- 47:18That's worth less than it was as a private company.
- 47:21I believe, right? Yeah.
- 47:22Yeah, I think it's last round before it went public was a
- 47:24brutal teen 15? Yeah.
- 47:27It's not the lowest it's ever been.
- 47:28As a public company, I think it was like, dipping below, like,
- 47:31$5 a share. Yeah, a few years back.
- 47:34Yeah, back in 2019. Yeah, it's not it's a company
- 47:37that's public that still acts like a start-up, you know, and
- 47:40the terms of like how it just lurches from, you know, strategy
- 47:43to strategy and like, let's the business just tank for a couple
- 47:47quarters and I think they just they're not running the business
- 47:50while yet. I think that's the biggest
- 47:51problem and they're spending way too much on stock-based
- 47:54compensation. And, you know, if Facebook was
- 47:56IP out in 2012, Right? And then rode this, the road,
- 47:59you know, the bull market really well, snap was kind of coming in
- 48:04later into the bull market but like I like even more Euphoria
- 48:07where it was like, Evan has if Mark Zuckerberg has just over
- 48:11fifty percent voting control 11 has 99%.
- 48:14If, you know, Facebook spent this much on stock comp like
- 48:17Snap stock, comp is through the roof.
- 48:19Like what they spend on stock. Calm and guess what?
- 48:21Like the market used to be okay with that.
- 48:24As long as you were growing and snap has been growing and other
- 48:26markets completely changed and is like no I need to see like
- 48:29bottom-line results and guess what?
- 48:31Snaps never turned a profit. And it's, that's that's a huge
- 48:36like issue. Going into this next phase of
- 48:38the economy. And the reason Facebook I think
- 48:40is set up fairly well relative to them as they do still print
- 48:43money. What's so inexcusable about
- 48:45snap. And I guess Twitter and
- 48:46Pinterest is that ads are a great fucking business.
- 48:49These are a high margin business and if you can't structure your
- 48:52company and and, you know, sell yourself to Wall Street in a way
- 48:55to build yourself, a sustainable Profitable company that's
- 48:59totally on you. And I think that the companies,
- 49:02you know, in Mark Zuckerberg, we spent a lot of time talking
- 49:05about his leadership. We see, like a similar kind of
- 49:07problem happening with Evan right now.
- 49:09I did not listen in on earnings, I don't cover this company
- 49:12anymore, he wasn't on there. He wasn't on earnings at all.
- 49:15He didn't answer one question. She was.
- 49:16So that's the thing, right? He apparently was on earnings
- 49:19but as an was were asking questions.
- 49:20He never took an answer. He just kicked it over like
- 49:23silently to, you know, their Chief Financial Officer and
- 49:27their head of business. And it got to a point where I
- 49:29saw Rich Greenfield tweeting at Evan.
- 49:32He'd be like Evan how are you not taking an answer right now?
- 49:35Your company's stock is cratering right now.
- 49:37You guys are down, 82 percent in the last six months.
- 49:39I was just looking, he didn't say that, but like that is the
- 49:42that's the context here and Evans response was like, yeah,
- 49:45I'm here. But um, you know, I thought my
- 49:48deputies were doing a good job. Your point about Evan, Tom, like
- 49:52he's younger than Mark Zuckerberg, he's made billions
- 49:55of dollars. There's a lot of people at snap
- 49:57who have made hundreds of millions of dollars in the
- 50:00companies never made a cent in progress and so it's kind of
- 50:04uber in that way. We're like you need the
- 50:06incentives of the top to align with the needs of the business.
- 50:10And I'm just not sure that even necessarily feels, he feels the
- 50:15pressure and that his employees want to leave when the stock is
- 50:17low. And he can't like hire and
- 50:19retain people. But we're also going to this
- 50:21like recession where it's going to be, people aren't going to
- 50:23want to jump jobs, really. Anyway because everyone, you
- 50:26know, all the stocks are down. So I don't know, it's I think
- 50:30Evan got a lot of credit for, you know, snaps early years
- 50:33where they really pioneered stories and all these social
- 50:35formats and they're still growing.
- 50:37But like, yeah, the business is just his metaverse.
- 50:39Is these AR lenses that will become shopping ways.
- 50:43We shop and advertising in and of itself.
- 50:46That's why snap is like doing this developer platform, where
- 50:48they're putting their camera and all these other apps is like,
- 50:50eventually the a our lenses in those apps will be snap ads and
- 50:54like they'll have their inventory everywhere.
- 50:56The problem is is like that's just not Not scaling as quickly
- 50:59as they thought and it's hard to get advertisers to like wrap
- 51:02their minds around that and advertising is a scale game.
- 51:05And it just, you know, you've got Amazon Google and meta and,
- 51:10you know, if they can reach the the entire world for you, why
- 51:13would you necessarily like, invest a lot in another
- 51:15platform? This is why a Pinterest and
- 51:17Twitter and snapping all these companies can't figure it out.
- 51:19You know, they can't figure out scale, dad plays and the worst
- 51:21that snap does. The less flexibility or Freedom.
- 51:24He will have to pursue his interests that are the reasons.
- 51:27He's But running this company which is building a our glasses,
- 51:31releasing selfie drones all this shit.
- 51:33That is part of I mean look if that can turn a profit and their
- 51:36stock price continues to languish they're going to have
- 51:39to cut that whole team at some point right there will be there
- 51:42will be no snap glad you cannot defend a Wall Street, they're
- 51:45going to be spending however many tens of millions of dollars
- 51:47a year. It takes to keep this thing up.
- 51:49That turns out a new pair of glasses, every couple of years,
- 51:51for no profit in, you know, in perpetuity.
- 51:55And so yeah, there is a reality to the Business.
- 51:58We can knock Zuckerberg but he did.
- 52:00He did, build the second, largest ad business in the world
- 52:03that throws off billions of years, you know, billions each
- 52:05year in profits and your can actually that he can that he can
- 52:09use to actually like he can he can find some stuff right.
- 52:12Like he has a little bit of a leash to do that whereas like
- 52:15your right snap, they don't their leashes tightened
- 52:18completely and I don't know, I just when I'm waiting to see
- 52:21like the next ACT from snap as a product like I think idealistic
- 52:26lie like be real. That would have been I could
- 52:28snap thing right. Bottle is that that to me, feels
- 52:30like a kind of like stories like conceit in terms of like getting
- 52:34back to office and authenticity and to see another company do
- 52:38that. And for SNAP to not be doing,
- 52:40that is a little worrisome for me because I'm like, I thought
- 52:43that's what you guys were about. As you're identifying, those
- 52:45needs that people have. Do you think that snap could
- 52:48acquire them with that make sense?
- 52:49Maybe. Maybe because I don't think that
- 52:51snap is going to be barred by Regulators from making
- 52:54Acquisitions. In fact, I think Regulators
- 52:55know, I could be a good idea for me to get bigger.
- 52:57Love it. I think their investors would
- 52:59frown on another like stock heavy deal right now when their
- 53:01stock Compass, like through the roof and then you do like, cut
- 53:04up in snap right now. Say okay, Eric?
- 53:07You want to like could they inhale all my Instagram photos
- 53:10and let me just keep building my Instagram like if I want to get
- 53:13a snap. No, no, but if it's, because
- 53:16he's no way for that to work. Somebody wants to build an
- 53:18Instagram rival, can they suck up with an API?
- 53:23All my they can't get my. I feel like that's where
- 53:25Regulators most need to step in. Like I feel You want you want
- 53:29interoperability know just the reason we I wanted you to let it
- 53:32go data portability, I just want easy as the reason we had
- 53:36Cambridge analytic. I find this.
- 53:38So fascinating, I cheering Cambridge analytic.
- 53:40I'm perfectly consistent on the no.
- 53:42No, I'm just saying the reason that that even existed is
- 53:45because of data portability shit on Cambridge, analytical as a
- 53:48story to be clear? No.
- 53:49As a story as what it did, it was, yeah, we should shit on it
- 53:52but in terms of what happened, like the thing people were
- 53:54pissed about. That wasn't the Trump stuff.
- 53:56It was Data portability, right? So the Fact that the EU is like,
- 53:59we're going to try to mandate data portability, it didn't work
- 54:02out. Well, the first time like that
- 54:04was Facebook's entire ethos was we're going to be the social
- 54:06layer of the web and let you take your friends with you and
- 54:08your friend data with you wherever you go.
- 54:11And like we're going to be that the operating system with
- 54:13Facebook friend graph. But if I want to like yeah
- 54:16defect and take all my stuff. I mean that would be cool.
- 54:19Then stab can say. Okay, we're going to rebuild
- 54:22your main photo memories app for your friends here and you can
- 54:25take all those things. And well, where would wear this?
- 54:28Where that ideal actually go is, like, picking your algorithm.
- 54:30So that's something Twitter's working on.
- 54:32That's something that I think Facebook will do eventually.
- 54:34We're basically like, you can say, I want my feed to be no
- 54:38politics or I want my feed to be like, mostly my friends with
- 54:42like 20% recommendations. I think an ideal scenario is
- 54:45like, you getting to like fine. Tune your feed, everyone.
- 54:48I am very skeptic. Everyone's just going to pick
- 54:51the AI optimized feet. Yeah.
- 54:53It's like default rule the day, everybody knows that.
- 54:56Yeah. Well, the companies like Offer
- 54:58you the ability to make your own feed.
- 55:00So you complain, less probably, but I think that's a
- 55:03distraction. Yeah, yeah.
- 55:06It's all about making money. That's what I say.
- 55:08It's all about making money. Okay.
- 55:10I think we should have Federal bill on social media.
- 55:13That's not about antitrust. We need Congress to actually
- 55:16have principles about what could be done.
- 55:21To make it so other companies could really compete with
- 55:24Facebook. And so users would have more
- 55:26like companies. I think be reels of, I mean be
- 55:29real is a perfect example of like, the fact that this is
- 55:32something that is relatively fragile.
- 55:35I open up be real. It's all venture capitalists.
- 55:37Like it's not my fault, that's because that's who's hard to
- 55:39build a network. It's really hard to build a new
- 55:41network, that's because you need more friends in your address.
- 55:44Yeah. I feel like you found exactly
- 55:45the amount of real that you're willing to accept.
- 55:49What is what is Hunter walk doing right now?
- 55:50Real investors, you know? Yeah.
- 55:54Like I don't think two things can be true at once.
- 55:56Here you can't say Facebook is like a monopoly and like social
- 55:58media is this entrenched thing where no one can compete and you
- 56:01can't also say like Facebook is like being destroyed by
- 56:05Tick-Tock and likes like relearning the entire company to
- 56:08try to compete with Tick-Tock and be real as at the top of the
- 56:10App Store charts and snap is still growing and Discord is
- 56:13still growing. Like I just I think social media
- 56:15is like I don't know what it I mean you're saying you don't
- 56:19want the bill to be an actress Focus, right?
- 56:20You I want it to be focused on what I mean if it's not about
- 56:23trust and also to your point with antitrust, like antitrust
- 56:27regulation is creating the conditions by which a company
- 56:30other than Facebook will be incredibly innovated and get to
- 56:33get big, right? Yeah.
- 56:35Yeah. So Eric, what do you mean in
- 56:36terms of like, what What legislation do you want to see
- 56:38on social media? He would be great to see
- 56:41Congress. Think through like the oversight
- 56:43board type category, like what sorts of decisions should be
- 56:47outside of companies, and what sorts should be in them, what?
- 56:50Stability for transparency about their decision.
- 56:53You know, to give the conservatives about if somebody
- 56:56is Shadow band or whatever. Do they have a responsibility to
- 56:58disclose it? You could put a lot of reporting
- 57:00requirements on these companies and say, you have to be
- 57:02transparent about XYZ. You have to implement this
- 57:05process for this, obviously any rules like that then sort of
- 57:09Advantage the bigger players, you could set some sort of
- 57:12threshold of market cap, or users or something for who has
- 57:15to apply it. But I would just like a
- 57:17principles-based approach, where our society, T actually reckons
- 57:22with what it wants and social media, and puts that into
- 57:26legislation, isn't that? That's what government is
- 57:28supposed to be. We think about our values
- 57:30collectively and we articulate them through.
- 57:32I don't think people know what they want.
- 57:34I don't think people know what they want, me neither, I mean,
- 57:36I'm not on social media. I think the politicians who talk
- 57:39about this, don't know what they want and a trade on the lazy way
- 57:41to do it. Like antitrust is just we hate
- 57:43it booing. No antitrust is we're going to
- 57:47make sure there's not a monopoly antitrust is we're putting But
- 57:50going to position right now where it can't just keep on
- 57:52buying other companies. So other companies have the
- 57:55chance to rival Facebook. So then there can be Market
- 57:58competition. That's not.
- 57:59We hate Facebook. That is literally, we won't
- 58:02there be a motivates them is hatred of Facebook.
- 58:07No, it's literally, we don't want a monopoly.
- 58:09I mean, I guess you could say that.
- 58:11I guess you could say that they hated the big railroad
- 58:13companies. I mean, it's just saying we want
- 58:16to have competition in this area of growth and we don't want one.
- 58:20Many to be able to buy all of these smaller companies are used
- 58:23in competition worrying about antitrust, whatever worried
- 58:26about Microsoft antitrust, lawsuit that gave us.
- 58:28Google wouldn't have had Google if there hadn't been in her
- 58:32chest regulation, imposed on Microsoft like that is the
- 58:36creation. That is why that is why it's
- 58:38done so that competition can create new and Innovative
- 58:42companies that have the chance to become.
- 58:44Sure large company, I'm not saying I hate antitrust law
- 58:47overall, but I think antitrust is a cop-out in terms.
- 58:50Actually regulating Facebook and social media based on a
- 58:55must-have thing, you care about is whether or not have a
- 58:56monopoly in which case it is the actual right?
- 58:58Let me tick tocks. Huge as we've been saying, yeah,
- 59:01there's like there's I feel like there's the capacity to talk is
- 59:05not an American company. No, but I hear what Eric saying?
- 59:07I do think there is a difference between one of the main goals of
- 59:10antitrust which is that a concern with the monopolies that
- 59:14they can do price fixing and they could, you know, charge
- 59:17advertisers, you know, infinite amounts of money to reach people
- 59:20because they're the The only Outlet to reach people which is
- 59:22just not the there's not the case with Amazon became a like
- 59:26Google that I trust and much more supportive like Google
- 59:30behaves like I'm a not well they own they own the rails and like
- 59:34what sits on top of it? That's the Google problem,
- 59:36right? But Katie actually would love to
- 59:38know what you think about Lena cons.
- 59:39First, big move as FTC chair trying to get meta to not buy a
- 59:45tiny VR company. That's what I was referring to
- 59:48earlier. Yeah, it was really interesting.
- 59:50Basically, it sounds like she's saying, well, Mark Zuckerberg if
- 59:53you're telling us that this is really the future, this is where
- 59:56all the money is going to be, and this is going to be the most
- 59:59important thing. Well, then I need to let lots of
- 1:00:02different companies experiment in this area before you just buy
- 1:00:04them all because otherwise. Yeah, all that's happening.
- 1:00:07Is you're upping the game. You've called the end, we know
- 1:00:12how it's going to, how it's going to turn out and you're
- 1:00:15ensuring that nobody else can reap any of the benefits.
- 1:00:19But apple is Your competitor in this one.
- 1:00:22Oh well, not yet, but they will be.
- 1:00:24But Katie like what is the? I would love to know like the
- 1:00:27legal argument for. We think this thing might happen
- 1:00:31therefore based on antitrust grounds is what is what is this?
- 1:00:36I don't know. We think it will.
- 1:00:38It's it's like, it's like you the company told.
- 1:00:40Uh, yeah. Be the company turn left if the
- 1:00:43market is not what it is yet, but the regulation is being done
- 1:00:48because it may be become that She mentioned The Clayton Act in
- 1:00:52her in the complaint where it was like we basically have to
- 1:00:55defend this Under The Clayton Act and my understanding of that
- 1:00:58is not I don't really I see how that applies to something like a
- 1:01:02tiny VR startup in a market that is is not monopolize door, nor
- 1:01:07does it have like significant Powers is not like a power.
- 1:01:09I guess the I guess I'm getting my tan again.
- 1:01:11Keep in mind, I'm not a lawyer but I think that the piece of
- 1:01:14The Clayton Act that she be referring to be the predatory
- 1:01:16piece. Probably not that, which is the
- 1:01:18purpose of the Instagram and WhatsApp challenges, right?
- 1:01:20Right? It's not time to embrace legal
- 1:01:22realism at this point, who cares?
- 1:01:25Like I mean, watch anything happening.
- 1:01:27Our society, like Eric has very interesting, you can't be like I
- 1:01:33want there to be. You can't say, I want Congress
- 1:01:36to come up with a really rational articulation of what
- 1:01:39they want from social media, and then later, say, have you seen
- 1:01:41anything that's happening in our society?
- 1:01:43Why do we think this is going to happen?
- 1:01:45I'm saying that in line with my belief that there's legal, I'm
- 1:01:48just saying it's sad that we now live in a society Where we can't
- 1:01:52use the legislature to actually, formulate our views on social
- 1:01:55media, but we just whine about it all the time.
- 1:01:58And similarly, we live in a society where yeah, like the
- 1:02:01legal system is not values-based.
- 1:02:02I mean to me those those things are related.
- 1:02:05I'm not saying antitrust laws, not values.
- 1:02:07I'm sitting a lot like the effect of the Microsoft
- 1:02:10decision, Microsoft antitrust, prosecution basically failed.
- 1:02:13But it's succeeded by just scaring the shit out of
- 1:02:15Microsoft and allowed people to compete.
- 1:02:17And that a lot of the actual antitrust politics are just
- 1:02:20power. Politics.
- 1:02:21And so, whenever you're arguing about, how are you allowed to do
- 1:02:23that? It's like well, if she can do it
- 1:02:25for long enough that they're not able to acquire it, that's what
- 1:02:27matters more than sadly vote. Is that values-based or not
- 1:02:31value space. I'm saying, its power power
- 1:02:33base, and as I value, were announced in sort of some legal
- 1:02:37rationale has, and we couldn't you say that every law is that
- 1:02:40Eric without that would be sort of like legal rulings.
- 1:02:42You say that like anti-discrimination laws and I
- 1:02:45hate crimes law that the, you know, the Matthew Shepard James
- 1:02:49Byrd anti-hate. A law is simply that screen that
- 1:02:52shit out of people say, don't punch people.
- 1:02:54I mean, I'm not really sure what I mean.
- 1:02:56What do you think a lot does? But the Lena con idea is to
- 1:02:59expand antitrust views as much as you can get away with.
- 1:03:03Like I just think that's a fair. Well let's be like let's be
- 1:03:06clear. She herself leenock on herself
- 1:03:08said and one of her first interviews that I'm going to
- 1:03:11intentionally make do cases where I know that our odds of
- 1:03:14winning are incredibly slim to none but I'm doing them to send
- 1:03:17a message. Really right power.
- 1:03:19That's what I think. I've heard people say the same
- 1:03:22thing. They're like even if the justice
- 1:03:23department could never win a case against Trump, they should
- 1:03:26indict him to send a message. It is exactly the contrast and
- 1:03:29think how Merrick Garland seems to behaving and Lena?
- 1:03:31Could you think that there are garlic?
- 1:03:33Do you think that the justice department should indict?
- 1:03:35Donald Trump, even if they think that they could lose before a
- 1:03:38jury of his peers? Even if they think that it's the
- 1:03:40right thing to do, and that he did something wrong, do you
- 1:03:43think that it apartment should indict Donald Trump?
- 1:03:45If they think they could lose in a court of law?
- 1:03:47I'm guessing. The answer is, I'm guessing.
- 1:03:49The answer is no. Thank you can lose.
- 1:03:50It depends on percentages and what the case is.
- 1:03:53And yeah. But I do think like, certainly,
- 1:03:56you want to think it's more likely than not.
- 1:03:58You could convince somebody right II do think that's a
- 1:04:01reason. Some people, some people say
- 1:04:04that even if they had airtight evidence, very good evidence and
- 1:04:08they could indict Donald Trump that they would ultimately lose
- 1:04:12because the case we get appealed and it would never pass the
- 1:04:14appeals bench in DC or nevertheless, it's really not so
- 1:04:18at that point. Should they indict him?
- 1:04:20If if the chances are slim to none will ultimately Prevail, I
- 1:04:24think with antitrust specifically right now when
- 1:04:26we're talking about, you know, citing The Clayton Act in order
- 1:04:30to explain the acts of 21st century companies there has
- 1:04:33been. I know this is a very, you know,
- 1:04:35debated Topic in DC or among like antitrust lawyers, it is
- 1:04:38very difficult to find the exact perfect legal precedent in which
- 1:04:42you can explain the actions of a lot of these tech companies and
- 1:04:44how that falls into the typical umbrella of antitrust, which is
- 1:04:49that, this is causing consumers. Because they can be price
- 1:04:52gouged, right? That is not the coralina cons
- 1:04:54whole paper on Amazon, right? And, and and right, and so, I
- 1:04:57think I actually have less issue with her taking a novel, legal
- 1:05:01approach to, you know, filing cases against Facebook because
- 1:05:05it doesn't necessarily fit within, you know, historical
- 1:05:08precedents. But saying look, let's try this
- 1:05:10out. Let's, let's see if we can get
- 1:05:11these arguments out there in the public and debated in a way,
- 1:05:14that maybe the suit doesn't work, but it at least pushes
- 1:05:17things and the conversation, the legal conversation in a way that
- 1:05:20we can have. An intelligent modernization of
- 1:05:22antitrust law. That we all I think would agree
- 1:05:25that there is some issue with multi hundred billion dollar
- 1:05:28trillion dollar companies having untrammeled power over the way,
- 1:05:32they run their business and other small businesses that, you
- 1:05:35know, the current system hasn't fixed.
- 1:05:37And so I, yeah, Tom. I'm coming around to this
- 1:05:40actually in that, I think she will have an easier time,
- 1:05:42defining Market, power Monopoly, power with VR, then she will
- 1:05:46with social media because Oculus is by far the VR industry.
- 1:05:50It is a pretty much just Oculus, so if you want to have like a
- 1:05:53narrow market definition to try to argue Monopoly power, she
- 1:05:56should be doing it in VR and not social media.
- 1:05:58And that's why I think the ftc's already had trouble with its big
- 1:06:02complaint. The suit about Instagram and
- 1:06:03WhatsApp and Market definitions. They didn't even include
- 1:06:06Tick-Tock and their Market definitions for the Instagram.
- 1:06:09WhatsApp challenge, which is insane to me.
- 1:06:11But yeah, I think the VR side You could argue there a monopoly
- 1:06:15and so maybe they should, you know, if you could go back to
- 1:06:18like early App Store and make sure that that Apple couldn't
- 1:06:21just leverage the App Store to become what it has, which they
- 1:06:25most certainly did. There's no question then yeah,
- 1:06:29maybe you should do that and if Mark Zuckerberg does think, this
- 1:06:31is the next major Computing platform.
- 1:06:33I just have a problem with like the like we think this might be
- 1:06:36a things. Therefore, we're going to do
- 1:06:38this now. Yeah.
- 1:06:40You got to like, come up with the fact that this is a monopoly
- 1:06:43in the same Market. It could, it could happen.
- 1:06:46I mean, I think it's hilarious. That this like government
- 1:06:48complaint is like talking about beats a Brr and how you trying
- 1:06:52to like Define beat saber as a competitor to Supernatural are
- 1:06:56just totally not. And it's just really funny to
- 1:06:59see them. Try to stretch this like idea
- 1:07:01what you think to like antitrust is in some ways unique, but at
- 1:07:04the end of the day, especially around policy.
- 1:07:07These things do get changed like our government positions.
- 1:07:12And the way that laws operate and the way that things are
- 1:07:15regulated through laws are through laws and courts.
- 1:07:20Often shift and change because people are willing to bring
- 1:07:25novel cases, right? And stretch the law or try to
- 1:07:29move the law. So I mean we don't just see an
- 1:07:31antitrust, we see it with abortion, for example, we've
- 1:07:34seen in a lot of ways so I don't think it's Unique.
- 1:07:37I don't think that what Lana Khan wants to do is necessarily
- 1:07:40incredibly unique. I mean, it because she did come
- 1:07:43out and say it upset a lot of people, but I think that we see
- 1:07:46it happening and we'll all sorts of ways around others.
- 1:07:49Things, you know people saying like we're going to start
- 1:07:51bringing novel cases and states and rest country because we want
- 1:07:55to bring a challenge to Roe versus Wade and get it to the
- 1:07:57Supreme Court. So finally, can someone can
- 1:07:58finally help us figure out in this context the 21st century,
- 1:08:02what we really think of this practice, we're going to bring a
- 1:08:05bunch of Novel cases so we can get them finally to another
- 1:08:08litigate, you know, to another Judiciary, but bold this case
- 1:08:11again the Supreme Court we can finally figure out what's what
- 1:08:14school should do around their admissions policies and race
- 1:08:18around voting rights. Around election issues.
- 1:08:22Like it is not that unusual to say, it doesn't matter if we're
- 1:08:25going to win or lose. We want to bring the case to
- 1:08:27test it, to see what happens and to see where we get like lots
- 1:08:32and lots and lots of times this happened.
- 1:08:34I just wish like on other issues, the Democratic party,
- 1:08:37would lay out like what it wants like what the end state is like,
- 1:08:40we think app stores should have these dreams.
- 1:08:43You're like, like if they had legislation Republicans Really
- 1:08:46Gonna, they're like, we want to get rid of affirmative act,
- 1:08:48right with this, is the gold. These are the cases we're gonna
- 1:08:50lose exact 25 years and they did lose for 25 years, but they're
- 1:08:54gonna win now, like, lay out what you want and legislation,
- 1:08:57and then if you feel like, okay, we can't pass this bill, but
- 1:08:59this is what we have all come together and said we want.
- 1:09:01Use antitrust to get it. I'm like, okay, at least it's a
- 1:09:04line with principles, you've articulated, but I think the
- 1:09:07inability to articulate in legislation what they want,
- 1:09:10reflects, just how dumb and simplistic.
- 1:09:13The thinking about social media is and then antitrust is being
- 1:09:16wielded. It's not that it's dialed, its
- 1:09:18political they don't want to What is the real motivation of
- 1:09:22this? Which is that, like, it's hatred
- 1:09:24of Facebook. Like it's, you cannot tell me
- 1:09:27that out of all the Monopoly antitrust, concerns Apple just
- 1:09:31kneecaps. The digital ads online.
- 1:09:33Ecosystem unilaterally, right? Prompt more than any regulator
- 1:09:37has ever been able to, like change how digital ads work
- 1:09:40Apple. Just did it with a prompt.
- 1:09:42I know Facebook worked on an antitrust lawsuit.
- 1:09:44They were about to file other companies of looked at it this
- 1:09:47is pissed. A lot of companies off its He's
- 1:09:49destroying small businesses, like I'm working on a story
- 1:09:52about this. It's actually fascinating how
- 1:09:54like d to C Brands can't advertise effectively anymore
- 1:09:57like it's their cost of gone so far through the roof because of
- 1:10:00Apple. So we talk about pricing Power
- 1:10:02Platform power. There's Google, there's Apple,
- 1:10:05there's legitimate like monopolies that exist in the
- 1:10:07world. Today, I would love for our
- 1:10:09government to be focusing on those and not necessarily.
- 1:10:13I do think it's important to look to the future but I think
- 1:10:15we have a lot to deal with in the present.
- 1:10:16And I think the fact that Lena cons first, big case was about a
- 1:10:19Our app that is a meta thing says, a lot about.
- 1:10:22Just where the government how the government feels about
- 1:10:25Facebook. Yeah.
- 1:10:27And it's not with the startup industry one.
- 1:10:28I'm sure that the regulator's personally hated Andrew Carnegie
- 1:10:33Rockefeller like you're right? There's all kinds the I mean
- 1:10:36these these things are often about power and so is there, you
- 1:10:41know, animus against some of these companies or people as The
- 1:10:45Regulators are dealing with them?
- 1:10:47I'm sure if you read like a really great history, Three of
- 1:10:50you know us steel you would totally see the biggest personal
- 1:10:55hatred of Carnegie motivating a lot.
- 1:10:59I'm sure. Anyway, thanks Keith, this was
- 1:11:02great. Thanks so much for joining.
- 1:11:03We'll see everybody. Yeah everybody back here next
- 1:11:05time. Thanks so much.
- 1:11:06Bye-bye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:11:21Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:11:23Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:11:21Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:11:23Goodbye.