Latest / Surrounded / Why It Always Comes Back to Butt Stuff | We Followed Up With Zander Moricz
Transcript
- 0:00If I had come in swinging,
- 0:01or if I had come in like.
- 0:04All right,
- 0:04conservatives,
- 0:05let's put you in pocket,
- 0:06you redneck hillbilly morons,
- 0:08then it would have been a disaster.
- 0:10It would have been a disaster.
- 0:16From Jubilee Media,
- 0:17this is the Surrounded podcast.
- 0:19I'm John Regalado,
- 0:20and this is our first follow-up episode.
- 0:22I will be interviewing Xander.
- 0:24He was at the center of last week's episode of Surrounded.
- 0:28He debated 25 conservatives
- 0:31focused on LGBTQ+ issues,
- 0:34and I will be asking Xander what the experience was like from his perspective,
- 0:38and we'll be digging into some of the most heated
- 0:40and interesting moments
- 0:42of debate throughout the episode.
- 0:45So let's get into it.
- 0:49Xander,
- 0:49thank you for being here.
- 0:52John,
- 0:52thank you for having me.
- 0:53So you're,
- 0:54this is the first official,
- 0:56um,
- 0:57follow up,
- 0:58which is,
- 0:59yeah,
- 1:00so this is a new,
- 1:02yeah,
- 1:02debut.
- 1:03So yeah,
- 1:04the intention of this pod is
- 1:06trying to get to a human level
- 1:08and finding a comfortable way to hold disagreements
- 1:12and um.
- 1:14Yeah,
- 1:14you
- 1:16You definitely gave that your all
- 1:19in uh the episode of Surrounded you were in,
- 1:22which I,
- 1:22I've,
- 1:23I've watched.
- 1:24You haven't seen the,
- 1:25the footage yet.
- 1:26You don't know what the comments are going to be.
- 1:28It's going to be
- 1:29pretty
- 1:30heated and intense,
- 1:31but I'm curious like
- 1:33how you feel about the experience and just like what.
- 1:36How it's sitting with you right now.
- 1:38Yeah,
- 1:39it was
- 1:40a really interesting experience,
- 1:42and it was obviously intense,
- 1:44but it was also really
- 1:46Enlightening these conversations are conversations I have
- 1:49every single day at Sea Alliance,
- 1:51and so
- 1:52I was very prepared to deal with that type of opposition and that type of emotion,
- 1:56and I think what I wasn't expecting
- 1:58was
- 1:59people being so vulnerable and being so willing to talk
- 2:02after the conversation and have aha moments and make concessions
- 2:06or just
- 2:07move on some of the issues.
- 2:09There's some people who are going to appear on the show
- 2:11that
- 2:12people already know,
- 2:13you know,
- 2:13such as Ben Shapiro.
- 2:15Um,
- 2:16you were admittedly like a new face,
- 2:18a new name
- 2:19to me.
- 2:21How did you get into this work?
- 2:23Yeah,
- 2:23I'm Florida grown.
- 2:24I grew up in Sarasota.
- 2:26I have been organizing since I was 15.
- 2:28I founded Sea Alliance or Social Equity through Education
- 2:31Alliance as a club at my high school.
- 2:34It was really focused on
- 2:35how do young people,
- 2:36how do students get a better
- 2:38grip into and control over local politics.
- 2:41We were kicked off of campus very quickly,
- 2:43which
- 2:45Checks out
- 2:45and we decided,
- 2:46OK,
- 2:47we're either going to disband or we're going to pivot
- 2:49and we're going to become something new and we decided
- 2:52to become a community organization
- 2:54and what we found is that school boards are the best place to build power.
- 2:57They're winnable,
- 2:58they center young people
- 2:59and they result in electoral gains in all other levels of government too.
- 3:03And so by starting in a school board,
- 3:04creating momentum in a school board,
- 3:05winning in a school board,
- 3:06you're
- 3:07setting the path to do so
- 3:09up the ballot.
- 3:10And we started having a lot of success,
- 3:12and we started winning,
- 3:13and we started making really powerful relationships,
- 3:15and so.
- 3:17Things just really spiraled up and the momentum has kept going.
- 3:20Did you grow up like in a political family,
- 3:23um,
- 3:23because you,
- 3:24you're good at this,
- 3:24like you're,
- 3:25you're good at
- 3:27politics and it seems like you're very passionate about it
- 3:29and I'm curious like where did the spark come from?
- 3:33No,
- 3:33I did not grow up in a political family.
- 3:35Both of
- 3:37my parents work in mouth.
- 3:38There's a dentist and an orthodontist,
- 3:40shout out teeth.
- 3:42Um,
- 3:42they are not politically involved,
- 3:44but
- 3:45I also wouldn't say I'm particularly interested in politics as much as.
- 3:48I'm required to be like the idea of
- 3:51politics itself doesn't attract me,
- 3:53but the policy
- 3:55that is devoured within politics and the way people's lives are shaped by it
- 3:58is so fundamental to everything that it's just essential to
- 4:02get into it and to think about it.
- 4:03Um,
- 4:04had you seen the show before Jubilee reached out?
- 4:07Yes,
- 4:07I had.
- 4:07I had seen some clips on TikTok and I had ended up watching
- 4:11the Michael Knowles one on YouTube.
- 4:13You're not really married.
- 4:14You,
- 4:14you have a relationship with a man,
- 4:16but you're not really married.
- 4:17I understand that you think that and that's fine.
- 4:20And did you have any
- 4:22feelings or frustrations or positive,
- 4:24like,
- 4:25I'm just curious what your impression was of the show.
- 4:28Yeah,
- 4:28I had lots of feelings.
- 4:30I thought
- 4:31a lot of the conversations were really incredible and
- 4:37I think
- 4:38it was really clear to me that
- 4:40A lot of people arrived with the intention of having
- 4:43a viral one-liner or having a gotcha moment and less of an aha moment and more of
- 4:49a destruction and less of a realization,
- 4:51and I thought.
- 4:52That was unfortunate,
- 4:53but I also think that it's just important to have these
- 4:56conversations and for people to see that clash of perspective.
- 4:58And so all in all I still thought the series has been productive.
- 5:01I just wish that people would show up more with,
- 5:03OK,
- 5:04how do we
- 5:05be vulnerable in this space?
- 5:06How do we try to have a productive conversation?
- 5:09Yeah,
- 5:09you're right,
- 5:10it can devolve into political porn.
- 5:14Um,
- 5:14it can become a a format that platforms
- 5:19an opinion and a worldview.
- 5:22That
- 5:23a viewer believes is harmful.
- 5:25Um,
- 5:26but I think something,
- 5:27you know,
- 5:27when I worked at Jubilee and as I continue to work with Jubilee.
- 5:31There really is
- 5:32a true intention to try and meet the world where it's at.
- 5:36And,
- 5:37you know,
- 5:38I,
- 5:38I hear you saying that.
- 5:39And,
- 5:40you know,
- 5:41to a certain extent,
- 5:42we are at this moment.
- 5:43We're at this moment where,
- 5:45There's a wide
- 5:47range of values and ideas that we can choose from.
- 5:52And I think this format kind of reflects the tension that can erupt from that.
- 5:56And I,
- 5:57I want to,
- 5:58you know,
- 5:59dig into some of the characters and specific arguments you had.
- 6:03Um,
- 6:04while we talk,
- 6:04I'm going to do my best to steel man,
- 6:07some of the arguments
- 6:08from the characters,
- 6:10um,
- 6:11that you talk to and see if I can kind of.
- 6:13If we can get to interesting places,
- 6:15if I sort of steel man what they were trying
- 6:17to convey to you and what you guys disagreed on.
- 6:19OK.
- 6:20Your first claim was Elon Musk and Trump do
- 6:22more grooming than like the LGBTQ community does.
- 6:27The first character that I saw you interact with was Michael.
- 6:30OK,
- 6:31I,
- 6:31I understand what you're saying.
- 6:32Um,
- 6:33for the sake of the argument,
- 6:34I would say that,
- 6:35um,
- 6:36I agree to an extent.
- 6:38Right?
- 6:38Obviously it depends on what we,
- 6:39what we're,
- 6:40what's grooming,
- 6:41right?
- 6:41Well,
- 6:41let's define grooming.
- 6:42Yeah,
- 6:42so what you define grooming.
- 6:43So typically in,
- 6:45I mean,
- 6:45most political circles,
- 6:46right,
- 6:47they would say grooming is any kind of act that
- 6:49kind of leads to like a sexual acts sexual grooming.
- 6:52Grooming also works with terrorist organizations and cults.
- 6:54So I would say that grooming has a broad definition,
- 6:56but I would say that grooming is not intrinsic or exclusive to the political.
- 7:01Correct,
- 7:01right,
- 7:01grooming is,
- 7:02no,
- 7:02it's not,
- 7:03it's something that happens everywhere happens everywhere.
- 7:05Democrats do it,
- 7:05horrible,
- 7:06Republicans do it,
- 7:06right.
- 7:07It was very easy to get everyone to agree on the shared definition of grooming,
- 7:10people with influence using that influence to take advantage
- 7:13of or change the way a young person thinks,
- 7:15and if we actually just take that definition at
- 7:17his face value and process what that means,
- 7:19Donald Trump and Elon Musk are doing that
- 7:21more than anyone else in the country,
- 7:22and I also phrase it that way just to show that like,
- 7:25I'm sure
- 7:26there are
- 7:27some LGBTQ plus people that are groomers.
- 7:30But they are groomers because they're
- 7:31bad people and they're groomers because they're pedophiles,
- 7:34not
- 7:35not because they're LGBTQ plus.
- 7:36I actually thought it was kind of interesting that you,
- 7:39you're trying to kind of flip
- 7:41the script cause
- 7:43I think the an argument
- 7:45against
- 7:46The advancement of LGBTQ or queer
- 7:50identity and rights and and cultural representation is that it's not good for young
- 7:54people and so you're trying to kind of flip it and be like,
- 7:57well,
- 7:57actually I think Elon and Trump
- 7:59are not good for young people,
- 8:01um,
- 8:02and I thought that was interesting.
- 8:04am I kind of interpreting like that
- 8:06that claim
- 8:07in the way that you meant for it?
- 8:09Yeah,
- 8:10I think.
- 8:11more so than anybody else,
- 8:12and this is proven by so many different studies
- 8:14are changing the way young people think and behave,
- 8:17and
- 8:18I deeply believe they're doing it for
- 8:20a selfish interest,
- 8:22and I believe it is harmful to the young people,
- 8:23and so we think about what grooming is,
- 8:25it's
- 8:25trying to take advantage of young people for your own personal benefit,
- 8:29and
- 8:30here it's more political than sexual,
- 8:32but I thought it was a really important comparison.
- 8:34An unfortunate truth to what you're saying.
- 8:37And this just seems to be,
- 8:38I think a condition of like this moment that we live in,
- 8:41especially because of phones.
- 8:43Young people really are
- 8:45the currency of culture.
- 8:46I mean,
- 8:47people are
- 8:48the currency of culture
- 8:50and young people are just especially
- 8:52influential and impressionable
- 8:54right now and so whether it's MAGA
- 8:57or dark MAGA
- 8:59or um.
- 9:01You know,
- 9:01I think liberal values,
- 9:04like you're seeing
- 9:06young people pick that up through social media,
- 9:09but there was a disagreement that you had with Michael,
- 9:13just for a moment
- 9:14where,
- 9:15I mean,
- 9:15I think he said like
- 9:17the LGBTQ community is organized and you guys have
- 9:21an agenda and you pushed back on that.
- 9:23You were like,
- 9:24we don't have agenda,
- 9:25there's no agenda.
- 9:26What you're actually trying to say is that
- 9:28the agenda that LGBT activists.
- 9:32Everyone has an agenda.
- 9:33It doesn't matter.
- 9:33Well,
- 9:34of the LGBTQ activists make it sound like there's a coordinated agenda
- 9:37when in reality there's a bunch of people who if you're organized,
- 9:39if you're an organized group,
- 9:40you have an agenda.
- 9:40We're not organized.
- 9:41I promise we're disorganized.
- 9:44Yeah,
- 9:44I think it's just important to note that
- 9:46the queer and trans community is not the Illuminati,
- 9:48and we don't meet underground once a season and convenient fire and
- 9:52place people in positions of power and decide,
- 9:55OK,
- 9:55we're all gonna start saying this,
- 9:56we're gonna start doing this,
- 9:57we're gonna contact HBO and make them push this,
- 9:59like that is not happening,
- 10:01I think,
- 10:02and I,
- 10:02I think it's just important to unpack that because people do
- 10:04genuinely believe that there are punch cards and it's like.
- 10:08It is a membership.
- 10:09It is being queer and trans is a political movement and our
- 10:12attempt is to change the political structure of the United States of America
- 10:16and in reality this is just not true.
- 10:18Identity has been politicized
- 10:20and therefore it has to come forward in politics.
- 10:23Either queer and trans people stick up for themselves and say,
- 10:26no,
- 10:26I deserve and demand civil rights,
- 10:28or we don't get them.
- 10:29And now because we've been forced
- 10:31into this political situation because of an
- 10:33identity that is not inherently political,
- 10:35it's politicized.
- 10:36I think I totally understand what you're saying.
- 10:38Like,
- 10:39you,
- 10:39you're not,
- 10:40you're not a card holding queer,
- 10:43you know,
- 10:43like that doesn't,
- 10:44that's not a thing.
- 10:45And I think that makes sense.
- 10:47I think on the flip side,
- 10:48I can see what Michael's saying though is like there are.
- 10:53Organizations that have political methods and goals
- 10:58to further the rights of
- 11:00the LGBTQ plus community
- 11:03and so,
- 11:04you know,
- 11:04at the end of the day I think it is just a reality
- 11:07and so
- 11:08I could see somebody hearing you say
- 11:12we're not organized,
- 11:12we we're not a political movement
- 11:14as you denying a reality
- 11:17and so like there was like a little bit of this dissonance I I saw with you and Michael.
- 11:21Yeah,
- 11:22and I think there are political groups that advocate,
- 11:24but if I were to say,
- 11:25oh,
- 11:26I
- 11:28Dolphins have an agenda because there are
- 11:31conservation organizations that wouldn't be
- 11:33genuine either and that wouldn't be based reality.
- 11:35I think
- 11:36I don't,
- 11:37I don't know all of
- 11:39the Human Rights Campaign's political platform and so to say that
- 11:42they are leading a political movement for all queer and trans people
- 11:45or Glisten is doing that or someone is doing that
- 11:48isn't genuine and that is a political perception that is held is that
- 11:51there is a large scale coordinated movement for all queer and trans people.
- 11:55You're gay,
- 11:55right?
- 11:55You identify as gay.
- 11:57And I guess I'm curious,
- 11:59when did you know that?
- 12:00And when did you feel this political valence placed on that identity?
- 12:06I feel like I realized late in the game,
- 12:09it may have been 14:15,
- 12:10I'm not sure.
- 12:11I don't totally remember,
- 12:12but it was definitely later,
- 12:14um,
- 12:15and I immediately
- 12:16Felt the politicization.
- 12:17I think that I
- 12:19didn't consider that I was
- 12:21gay for such a long time because I was so
- 12:24worried about that
- 12:25politicization.
- 12:26I grew up in Sarasota,
- 12:26Florida,
- 12:27super red area.
- 12:28Most of my friends
- 12:30casually tossed around homophobic rhetoric all the time.
- 12:33I didn't think twice about it.
- 12:34I was just like,
- 12:35of course people are gonna say
- 12:37something is gay if it's not cool,
- 12:39duh,
- 12:40and just stuff like that.
- 12:41And then when I realized,
- 12:42uh oh.
- 12:43You are totally gay.
- 12:45I was like,
- 12:45oh my God,
- 12:46this is gonna be the worst.
- 12:47This is gonna suck.
- 12:48People are gonna be so nasty.
- 12:49I have no interest in this.
- 12:51And so I tried so hard.
- 12:52I was like,
- 12:52you know what,
- 12:53let's
- 12:54let's talk to Jesus.
- 12:55Let's
- 12:56let's watch a movie with straight people kissing.
- 12:58Let's lock in,
- 12:59let's not be gay.
- 13:00And I was like,
- 13:01OK,
- 13:01well that didn't work.
- 13:02I'm gay,
- 13:03now what?
- 13:03And I think it my my first part about being gay was like I am,
- 13:07there's no way
- 13:08in hell
- 13:09I'm letting my life be defined by this
- 13:12or be constricted by this,
- 13:13so.
- 13:15There's an interesting,
- 13:16you know,
- 13:17like
- 13:18contradiction even in that,
- 13:20you know,
- 13:20not wanting it to define your life,
- 13:22but then realizing that
- 13:24there was political action that you wanted to see
- 13:28done,
- 13:29you know,
- 13:29did redefine your life.
- 13:31Yeah,
- 13:31I,
- 13:31I,
- 13:32I'm also incredibly proud.
- 13:34To be gay,
- 13:35and I think in the first moments there was never a hatred of gay people.
- 13:39I just,
- 13:39I recognized because I witnessed it already.
- 13:42This will make my life unnecessarily challenging.
- 13:45If I can avoid that,
- 13:46I'm going to.
- 13:47And then I realized,
- 13:48OK,
- 13:48this is not avoidable,
- 13:49we're locked into being gay.
- 13:51It it it was,
- 13:52it was literally such a simple process of googling and reckoning and I was just like,
- 13:55OK.
- 13:56Yeah,
- 13:57no,
- 13:57I appreciate you kind of peeling that back.
- 14:00OK,
- 14:00so pivoting back to the conversation.
- 14:02Let me tell you what's going on.
- 14:03The LGBTQ community has gone too far.
- 14:06OK,
- 14:07so I'm an ex-Democrat.
- 14:08I used to live in San Francisco.
- 14:11Yeah,
- 14:11yeah,
- 14:11so,
- 14:12yeah.
- 14:12His name was Roman,
- 14:14and
- 14:15you guys kind of got.
- 14:17There was some disagreement around pride.
- 14:19Gay pride is everyone making out and having sex on the street.
- 14:22No,
- 14:23it's not that.
- 14:23I was there.
- 14:24That's illegal.
- 14:26That's illegal.
- 14:26The vast majority of pride events,
- 14:28we're the vast majority of San Francisco here.
- 14:30OK,
- 14:30San Francisco's extra gay,
- 14:31but the vast majority of Pride extra sexualized.
- 14:34It's a European city inherently sexual.
- 14:37San Francisco.
- 14:38As a European city,
- 14:39San Francisco is in the United States of America.
- 14:41Come on now,
- 14:43it's not a European and it's city the gay capital,
- 14:45and now that,
- 14:47that has gone everywhere,
- 14:49all over again.
- 14:50I would say we ho is the
- 14:51capital.
- 14:51Shout out.
- 14:52No,
- 14:53yes,
- 14:54we do.
- 14:55Watching people try to characterize all of Pride as being
- 14:59guys dancing around in leather thongs with their balls hanging out.
- 15:02I was like,
- 15:02oh my God.
- 15:04First of all,
- 15:05like.
- 15:06Uh
- 15:07Go to Mardi Gras,
- 15:08dude.
- 15:09Like I promise you this is not the only place that
- 15:12drunk adults in the street are not keeping it 100%.
- 15:14Like that,
- 15:15that's the common denominator.
- 15:16The common denominator
- 15:18is drunk adults outside,
- 15:19not
- 15:20gay people.
- 15:21Well,
- 15:21and he was like,
- 15:21yeah,
- 15:22I like going to ride cause there's also straight women there.
- 15:25I'm straight.
- 15:25I want to see the women.
- 15:26I thought that was actually really funny.
- 15:28It was so funny.
- 15:29I,
- 15:29I went to gay pride and it was fun,
- 15:31you know,
- 15:32there's girls there,
- 15:32they're straight women,
- 15:34so
- 15:34obviously that's awesome,
- 15:36but uh.
- 15:37Where I can,
- 15:38I think Steelman Roman
- 15:40is just in the algorithm,
- 15:43the algorithmic experience of what
- 15:46someone sees,
- 15:47um,
- 15:49of a pride parade when they don't attend one.
- 15:51And so like
- 15:52I've been to pride parades.
- 15:54I have also been scrolling through X or you know,
- 15:57and seeing
- 15:59pretty intense stuff from like San Francisco Pride
- 16:02and
- 16:03it just makes sense that on the Internet
- 16:05that kind of material is going to.
- 16:07It's just going to get distributed a lot more.
- 16:10How important is it to start enforcing,
- 16:13you know,
- 16:14enforcing or communicating a standard
- 16:17around
- 16:18What is a good expression of pride and when is it kind of hurting the movement?
- 16:21Well,
- 16:22I think there's layers to it because one,
- 16:23I wouldn't say that pride is a unified movement.
- 16:25There's not a president,
- 16:26there's not a CEO of pride.
- 16:28Pride is a word that needs to be proud,
- 16:30and
- 16:31I think that
- 16:32there just needs to be a better organization,
- 16:34like these pride parades aren't coming from the Illuminati,
- 16:37they're coming from local pride networks
- 16:38and local organizations and local glisten.
- 16:41And so it's up to those individuals and
- 16:43those local organizations to better organize their pride.
- 16:46And so for San Francisco pride organizers,
- 16:48I would be like,
- 16:48oh my gosh,
- 16:49let's be very clear about where the family,
- 16:52let's be very clear about where and
- 16:53when the family friendly programming is happening.
- 16:55Let's be very clear about
- 16:57where and when you can have your balls out
- 16:59and then let's communicate that widely so that there isn't a PR crisis.
- 17:02Of course.
- 17:03The algorithm is going to reward the most shocking,
- 17:05disgusting,
- 17:06sexual,
- 17:07exciting visuals all the time.
- 17:09The videos of
- 17:11families dancing in the street blowing bubbles,
- 17:13that's not going viral.
- 17:14The video of the bald hairy dude in a jockstrap running down like
- 17:18with his tongue out,
- 17:19that's going to go viral for people who feel like
- 17:21their children are under attack.
- 17:22And so
- 17:23that's not a responsibility of.
- 17:26Human beings,
- 17:27that is a reality of being online and it's more
- 17:30about how we monitor ourselves online,
- 17:32show up online,
- 17:33process information online,
- 17:35that's the issue we need to address then.
- 17:37The bald man who probably wasn't doing anything wrong,
- 17:39if it was at the adult portion.
- 17:41Right,
- 17:42no,
- 17:42I hear what you're saying,
- 17:43and I think that's unfortunate.
- 17:45That is just sort of a,
- 17:46a symptom of the media ecosystem we have right now.
- 17:49It's just the outliers do characterize the whole,
- 17:52and that's probably not the healthiest thing.
- 17:55I want to talk about your conversation with Richie.
- 17:57Uh,
- 17:58you debated him after your second claim,
- 18:00which was
- 18:01healthcare costs and gun violence harm young Americans.
- 18:04LGBTQ+ acceptance does not.
- 18:07Hi,
- 18:08hi,
- 18:08I just wanna make sure I can we agree that,
- 18:11can we agree that our shared value for this debate should
- 18:12be that all young Americans have safe and healthy childhoods?
- 18:16Absolutely.
- 18:16OK,
- 18:16beautiful.
- 18:16Yeah,
- 18:16I just want to make sure I heard that right.
- 18:18Young Americans referencing children.
- 18:20So then I want to switch the focus on what the plus represents and LGBTQ plus.
- 18:24He had concerns about the plus alluding to
- 18:29pedophiles or minor attracted.
- 18:33Um,
- 18:34people attracted to minors.
- 18:35He referred to it with the acronym MAPS.
- 18:38That plus is a placeholder
- 18:40for maps for minor attractive persons,
- 18:42minor attractive pedophilia.
- 18:45I'm glad that you think it's pedophilia and it's insane,
- 18:48but you,
- 18:48I think you understand and you know that your side of the aisle
- 18:51does not feel that way.
- 18:53There's a lot to
- 18:54To hit on here,
- 18:55but
- 18:56first of all,
- 18:57what,
- 18:57what were your reactions?
- 18:58Is that something you commonly hear where people go,
- 19:01hey,
- 19:02you know,
- 19:02the next thing
- 19:04that you're gonna be telling us to include is
- 19:06people who are attracted to minors or pedophiles.
- 19:08Like why,
- 19:09why is that something that keeps coming up,
- 19:11this inability to separate.
- 19:15sexual orientation
- 19:16among consenting adults and
- 19:18pedophilia.
- 19:20Aggressive intentional disinformation and taking advantage of people's fears.
- 19:24Like there are so many people who make money,
- 19:27make money because of the algorithms we're talking about,
- 19:29because of the way the most shocking
- 19:32information and material is perpetually rewarded,
- 19:34they make so much money.
- 19:35They're gonna keep doing that.
- 19:36Yeah,
- 19:36that was something that came through in the video,
- 19:38and I thought you
- 19:39were picking up on it,
- 19:40like he was genuinely concerned and it was like it was almost like a
- 19:45There was an urgency and a despair
- 19:48in his tone.
- 19:50I'm saying things that I know.
- 19:51I believe you've developed and,
- 19:53and put yourself in this sort of matrix fictional reality,
- 19:56and you feel safe there.
- 19:56I'm glad you do.
- 19:57But here's the problem,
- 19:59where we're headed is why I'm concerned.
- 20:01I'm not,
- 20:02I'll tell you where we're headed.
- 20:03We're headed towards maps.
- 20:04Whether or not you agree with that is,
- 20:05is.
- 20:05Regardless,
- 20:07what evidence is there that we're headed towards maps?
- 20:08I mean,
- 20:08are you kidding me?
- 20:10We,
- 20:10it's even,
- 20:11even on the conservative side,
- 20:13they're,
- 20:13they're opening up the discussion on whether or
- 20:15not this can be considered a legitimate,
- 20:17uh,
- 20:17sexual orientation.
- 20:18No one is saying that pedophilia is a legitimate sexual orientation.
- 20:22I think what he wanted to hear from you,
- 20:23which I,
- 20:24I do think you said in a variety of ways,
- 20:25which was just like,
- 20:26I don't support that,
- 20:28you know,
- 20:28that seemed to be so important for him.
- 20:30I don't think he,
- 20:31he wasn't misrepresenting what he
- 20:33felt or what he thought or what he was scared of.
- 20:35He genuinely deeply believed
- 20:37that acceptance for queer trans people would open up the door
- 20:41for pedophiles to take advantage
- 20:43of children throughout the country.
- 20:44I don't exactly know why,
- 20:46but there's just like a lot of
- 20:48differentiating that needed to happen throughout the whole episode.
- 20:52Like we're talking about gay people now,
- 20:53we're talking about trans people now,
- 20:55you're talking about pedophiles,
- 20:56that's not the same thing,
- 20:57um.
- 20:58And I,
- 20:59you know,
- 20:59it's just,
- 20:59it's a,
- 21:00a recurring pattern that comes up when we talk about.
- 21:04LGBTQ plus issues,
- 21:06and I've seen it come up in other videos is like.
- 21:09There's too many people are
- 21:11lumping too many things together at the same time.
- 21:14The complexity comes from the fact that being
- 21:18Queer being trans
- 21:19is not about having sex.
- 21:22It is an identity that is a part of your human being,
- 21:24and for many of us it changes who we're attracted to and therefore who
- 21:28we'd like to have sex with and who we will have sex with,
- 21:30but it's not about sex in the same way being straight
- 21:33isn't about having heterosexual sex all the time or
- 21:36just thinking about sex or being about sex.
- 21:38It is
- 21:39one part of your identity.
- 21:41Being straight isn't just about sex,
- 21:43and marriage isn't just about sex,
- 21:45and wanting to be able to talk about your wife
- 21:47or hold her hand in public isn't just about sex,
- 21:50it's about compassion.
- 21:51Human beings crave
- 21:53the connection
- 21:54to and compassion from other human beings.
- 21:57And so if we're telling
- 21:59a bunch of human beings,
- 22:00hey,
- 22:01You can't have that,
- 22:02of course they're gonna fight for that,
- 22:03but if you're
- 22:04only focused on the sex of it,
- 22:06it's going to become inherently sexual,
- 22:07and some people will show up with an inherently sexual viewpoint,
- 22:11but that was super important to unpack in that moment for me is like it's not.
- 22:15Well,
- 22:16about sex.
- 22:17Well,
- 22:18yeah,
- 22:18it is and it isn't,
- 22:19you know,
- 22:20what you're saying is like the identity of being gay is not just
- 22:24Having gay sex,
- 22:25it's,
- 22:26it's a perspective,
- 22:27it's a lived experience,
- 22:28it's about connecting with people
- 22:30and
- 22:31sex is a facet of that identity,
- 22:34but it's not the whole identity.
- 22:35And I,
- 22:36and I think it's,
- 22:36it's,
- 22:36it,
- 22:37it's almost we do so much study of it,
- 22:39but it's
- 22:40for so many people so simple to the point that it's almost ridiculous.
- 22:43For some people,
- 22:44the problem they have with the entire queer and trans community
- 22:48is that
- 22:50Man on man gay sex
- 22:52breaks the patriarchy to them,
- 22:53and it makes men weak,
- 22:54and that fear or lack of understanding or
- 22:57discomfort is enough for them to want to shut
- 23:00everything down for everyone.
- 23:01And that came up.
- 23:02Sarah was um one of the women you spoke to.
- 23:05She,
- 23:05she,
- 23:06it was pretty heated with her and your debate with Sarah
- 23:08happened in the portion of the episode focused on the claim
- 23:12anti-LGBTQ plus policies are anti-Christian
- 23:15and anti-American.
- 23:17You can have
- 23:19consensual sex with someone
- 23:21and that's not loving them because participating in homosexual
- 23:24acts is inherently not loving because it's damaging.
- 23:28It's inherently damaging.
- 23:28It violates naturally damaging.
- 23:30It doesn't violate natural law.
- 23:31There are over 1000 species that are proven to have queer relationships.
- 23:36God literally designed why does the G-spot exist?
- 23:38I don't know.
- 23:39God literally designed male and female bodies to know God's vision.
- 23:42How about this?
- 23:42Let's not pretend to know God's How come 12% of men who have sex with other men
- 23:47one or more times a week
- 23:49have problems where they are not able to control their bowel movements?
- 23:54Because when
- 23:56you.
- 23:57Well,
- 23:57why?
- 23:58If it's healthy,
- 23:59if it's perfectly healthy.
- 24:02I'm not going to try and steal,
- 24:03man,
- 24:04that argument because.
- 24:06I think what this comes down to is just a fundamental.
- 24:10Way
- 24:11of viewing.
- 24:14Morality.
- 24:15Sarah's not the only person in the United States
- 24:17who feels this way and you've acknowledged that.
- 24:19How can America,
- 24:20when we get to like these bedrock
- 24:23differences where it's just like
- 24:25you just believe that sex should only happen with a man and a woman,
- 24:29and that's like really
- 24:31crystallized in your
- 24:33worldview.
- 24:34Where,
- 24:35where do we move forward when,
- 24:36when there's that?
- 24:37You bump up against that.
- 24:39I think it
- 24:40depends on the person that you're speaking with
- 24:43or the group of people you're speaking with,
- 24:44which is why consistent conversation will always be the answer,
- 24:47but there is always a why.
- 24:48For a lot of people it'll be religious teaching,
- 24:50for some people it'll be a connection to their biological
- 24:53understanding,
- 24:54and then for some people it literally truly.
- 24:56Exclusively is that it feels like a scary visual to them.
- 24:59It feels like,
- 25:00shouldn't that hurt?
- 25:01That's not natural,
- 25:01that's wrong,
- 25:02therefore all of it is wrong,
- 25:04and
- 25:05it's just about unpacking that person to person,
- 25:08situation to situation,
- 25:09and
- 25:10acknowledging that it can feel
- 25:11like a bedrock issue,
- 25:12but there's
- 25:13always the why.
- 25:15There's always a place that these thoughts come from.
- 25:17Most people
- 25:19have
- 25:19a relationship with.
- 25:24The thoughts are always coming from somewhere,
- 25:26and so you can
- 25:27figure out where they're coming from,
- 25:28you can better
- 25:30address where you're at.
- 25:31And so for Sarah,
- 25:33it came from the church
- 25:34and
- 25:35eventually,
- 25:36and I don't even think it happened on camera,
- 25:38the conversation did spin into a more productive place about
- 25:42the way we interpret religion,
- 25:43and if I had
- 25:452 months to have that conversation with her,
- 25:47I think there's a chance we end in a place where it's like,
- 25:49OK.
- 25:49I can see how it is not against the Christian worldview
- 25:53to have man on man sex,
- 25:54and over time I believe that she could
- 25:56separate herself from that really strong opinion.
- 25:58It's just the fact that we get to these places
- 26:00that feel really hard
- 26:02and the only answer is lean into the pure discomfort
- 26:05of the conversation
- 26:07or pull away entirely.
- 26:08Like eventually,
- 26:09for some people,
- 26:10you're gonna have to have a conversation about butt holes,
- 26:12and that is ridiculous and.
- 26:14Because you shouldn't have to,
- 26:15and it's so ridiculous.
- 26:17It's almost instinctual to be like,
- 26:18oh my,
- 26:19oh my God,
- 26:20I'm not talking about anal sex with you,
- 26:21you fool,
- 26:22and that's a valid reaction.
- 26:24But also to that person they're going,
- 26:25yeah,
- 26:26of course you don't want to talk about anal sex cause it's dirty
- 26:28and you're a freak and you know what you're doing is wrong.
- 26:31And then suddenly they walk away vindicated,
- 26:32they walk away validated.
- 26:33They're like,
- 26:34yeah,
- 26:34I don't want to talk about anal sex and neither today cause it's evil.
- 26:37But if you can kind of just lean in and be like,
- 26:38hey,
- 26:40you said like G-spot,
- 26:40yeah,
- 26:41I was gonna bring up the G-spot comment.
- 26:42So
- 26:44again,
- 26:44I don't like reverting to that because it's ridiculous,
- 26:46but it is like it,
- 26:47it,
- 26:47it's I watched it spark things like it's
- 26:51I thought it was a funny response.
- 26:53I see why
- 26:54it's kind of disarming and funny at the same time,
- 26:57um.
- 26:59Something I'm,
- 26:59and
- 27:00I,
- 27:00I liked what you said,
- 27:01like the thoughts are always coming from somewhere.
- 27:03I think that's a really provocative
- 27:05idea.
- 27:06Like you can always trace the thoughts back to a source
- 27:09and that's,
- 27:09there's always
- 27:10a direction for self-discovery.
- 27:12So I think that's really interesting.
- 27:14A question I had for you is like,
- 27:16you know,
- 27:16when you're
- 27:18confronted with
- 27:20Confrontation like that.
- 27:21What is going on in your body?
- 27:23What are you feeling in your body,
- 27:25in your head
- 27:26over the course
- 27:28of time?
- 27:28I think,
- 27:29especially when I started having these conversations in high school,
- 27:31I was having them with people twice my age,
- 27:33and
- 27:34I got way more emotionally invested.
- 27:36I would go for the kill shot,
- 27:38the funny line,
- 27:38the ha ha ha every time.
- 27:41Like I would try to,
- 27:41I was like,
- 27:42what is.
- 27:42The most disgusting read,
- 27:44like what is the cleanest brutal takedown that I can
- 27:47provide to this person to show them that they're stupid,
- 27:50and that would be the name of my game for a while,
- 27:53but if the goal is to instead
- 27:55change the way people think about things,
- 27:56that has to be done
- 27:57way less
- 27:59aggressively
- 28:00and way more surgically,
- 28:01and I think that.
- 28:03That also doesn't mean just
- 28:04sitting back and be like,
- 28:05oh,
- 28:05I'm sorry you don't like me.
- 28:07I,
- 28:07it it does mean showing up as someone that they can
- 28:10feel they need to challenge and they can respect and that is holding their own,
- 28:13and that is at times when you need to be aggressive,
- 28:16but it isn't about being aggressive.
- 28:18It's about trying to challenge the perspective,
- 28:20and I think the fact that they
- 28:22didn't feel like I deeply hated them was so important to this,
- 28:25and there was one moment,
- 28:26I don't know if it'll make it into the cut.
- 28:28But one of the
- 28:29people walking away is like,
- 28:31I hope you don't hate me now.
- 28:33Thank you,
- 28:33thank you.
- 28:33Hope you don't hate me.
- 28:36And
- 28:36I'm just like,
- 28:36I don't hate you.
- 28:37I don't hate any of,
- 28:38there's too much information for us to all be on the same page.
- 28:41The point is for us to work together to get on the same page
- 28:44because we're not in the multiverse.
- 28:45There is one reality,
- 28:46there is truth,
- 28:48there are facts,
- 28:49there is,
- 28:49there just is.
- 28:51And so
- 28:52the closer we can get to acknowledging that together and to living in that together,
- 28:55the better.
- 28:56One more person I want to talk about,
- 28:58and this is kind of the more,
- 28:59the most,
- 29:00I think this is like the most complex and tricky issue that
- 29:05Exists in the zeitgeist right now.
- 29:07This was with Angelina.
- 29:09She was
- 29:10very fixated on um children being given gender-affirming care too soon.
- 29:16And if it's reversible or irreversible.
- 29:19I think gun violence is an issue and I think healthcare is an issue.
- 29:22However,
- 29:22what I would like to talk about today is,
- 29:24um,
- 29:25children being targeted and transitioned at a young age.
- 29:27I don't believe it is children are being targeted in transition.
- 29:30So currently in the United States,
- 29:31you can start gender transitioning a child as early as they're starting puberty,
- 29:35and that's anywhere from 8 to 13.
- 29:37And so at that age.
- 29:38Putting them on puberty blockers,
- 29:40and which is not reversible,
- 29:41by the way,
- 29:42puberty.
- 29:42OK,
- 29:42so how many irreversible gender affirming care procedures have been done
- 29:46on ages 13 or under in the United States of America?
- 29:48Listen,
- 29:49just the idea that you even put them on puberty blockers,
- 29:51that's irreversible.
- 29:51Do you understand that?
- 29:52Not all puberty blockers are irreversible.
- 29:53New treatments are coming in every day.
- 29:54So let me break down.
- 29:55No,
- 29:55no,
- 29:55no,
- 29:55no,
- 29:56no,
- 29:56no,
- 29:56no,
- 29:56no.
- 29:56Puberty blockers,
- 29:57do you know what puberty blockers are?
- 29:58Puberty blockers is Lupron.
- 29:59That is the brain.
- 29:59The brand name for puberty blockers,
- 30:01Lupron.
- 30:01Lupron is used on children,
- 30:038 to 13 year olds to pause their puberty.
- 30:06It is the same drug used in chemical castration for pedophiles that stops
- 30:11their sex drive.
- 30:11OK,
- 30:12if I thought 8 to 13 year olds would be chemically castrated,
- 30:14that would be horrible.
- 30:15That would be evil,
- 30:16that would be unacceptable.
- 30:17That's not what's happening.
- 30:18Well,
- 30:18no,
- 30:18let's break it down.
- 30:19I would love to break it down for you.
- 30:21This is where I think like,
- 30:23I guess my first question is like trans issues.
- 30:28are
- 30:29taking
- 30:30a ton of oxygen in the political
- 30:33arena right now and I mean Jubilee does this as
- 30:36well as anybody because we've made a lot of content
- 30:39circling these
- 30:41issues and it
- 30:43It just keeps coming up and people care a lot about it.
- 30:47Do you ever wonder
- 30:49if it would be better
- 30:51now that we're in this moment in time
- 30:53where,
- 30:54you know,
- 30:54gay marriage is legal,
- 30:56to,
- 30:56to start differentiating groups,
- 30:58like,
- 30:58do you ever worry that like the bucketing
- 31:01harms
- 31:03the movement or harms the public?
- 31:06Yeah,
- 31:06why not?
- 31:08They're attempting to divide us.
- 31:09That is the entire goal.
- 31:10And so if we do that for them,
- 31:11we'd be ridiculous,
- 31:12stupid,
- 31:13and
- 31:14in part abandoning
- 31:16a part of our community.
- 31:17I think that that.
- 31:19is a really
- 31:20disappointing consideration that folks have.
- 31:22I understand where it comes from.
- 31:24I totally get it.
- 31:25Being trans is not the same thing as being gay,
- 31:28and being gay isn't the same thing
- 31:29as being bisexual,
- 31:30and being bisexual isn't the same thing as being non-binary.
- 31:33The point is,
- 31:34is because
- 31:35we are persecuted
- 31:36for gender and sex,
- 31:38and so the LGBTQ plus,
- 31:40the queer and trans community really is
- 31:42people who have
- 31:43gender and sex identities
- 31:45that are different
- 31:47than
- 31:48What has typically been celebrated and accepted in the United States of America.
- 31:52And that is point blank it and to try to further divide
- 31:56that group,
- 31:57like I don't,
- 31:58I don't see the point.
- 31:59I think.
- 32:00Yeah,
- 32:00I don't know if I would frame it though as dividing.
- 32:02I guess I would say like,
- 32:03OK,
- 32:04that you could interpret it as progress,
- 32:06like,
- 32:07OK.
- 32:08We're at a moment in time where now like a fuller consideration
- 32:12of
- 32:13the gay American experience or the
- 32:15lesbian American experience or the trans-American experience
- 32:18can be thought of case by case
- 32:21because I,
- 32:21I think sometimes a lot of confusion is generated where you're like,
- 32:24wait,
- 32:25oh,
- 32:25we're talking about trans kids right now,
- 32:26like,
- 32:27while it's a line we've all heard a million times and therefore we're like huh,
- 32:30that's trite.
- 32:33When they come for one of us,
- 32:34they come for all of us.
- 32:35And so
- 32:36in actuality,
- 32:37there
- 32:38is so much strength in holding the community,
- 32:40but it's not just a strategic imperative.
- 32:42There are
- 32:43shared identities and shared elements to the queer experience
- 32:46and the trans experience in the United States of America
- 32:48that are bound by culture,
- 32:50by history,
- 32:51by economics,
- 32:51by everything,
- 32:53and to pull them apart,
- 32:54would it make
- 32:56sense.
- 32:56Well,
- 32:57well,
- 32:57this is where,
- 32:58this is where I think I,
- 33:00um,
- 33:01I,
- 33:01I wanna build on the,
- 33:03the disagreement that you're having with Angelina because,
- 33:06oh well,
- 33:07and it's also came up with another person.
- 33:09Wait,
- 33:09because you know 13%,
- 33:10which you stated was 1%,
- 33:11but actually 13% of people do de-transition.
- 33:14So to avoid that,
- 33:15no,
- 33:16they can bring it up.
- 33:16I'll even show the study on my phone to you right now.
- 33:18Well,
- 33:18I'm sure you have things that say that,
- 33:20but it doesn't make it true.
- 33:21So this,
- 33:22you're just invalidating the entire study that's true.
- 33:24You're invalidating the entire study.
- 33:26We got to the point of like studies like science and research and data
- 33:31and what is it telling us?
- 33:33And
- 33:34this is where I wonder if
- 33:36delineation is important because
- 33:38a lot of the science is still new.
- 33:41And so
- 33:42I sometimes wonder if you need to be more granular
- 33:45as something is like that when puberty blockers should be.
- 33:49Prescribed and what kind of puberty blockers or what kind of hormonal treatments
- 33:53and why it is or isn't reversible.
- 33:55Like you're getting so granular that
- 33:57that really is,
- 33:59it's a trans issue,
- 34:00that's not really an anybody,
- 34:01that's not really an LGBTQ issue.
- 34:04Well,
- 34:04in the same way there can be like you can,
- 34:05if I say there are
- 34:07um
- 34:09Neurodivergent people
- 34:11in the United States,
- 34:11you're not assuming,
- 34:12well,
- 34:12we're giving the same medicine and treatment to people with ADHD
- 34:15as people
- 34:16who have autism.
- 34:17That's not what we're discussing here.
- 34:18That's not the point here.
- 34:19And I'm not saying
- 34:20there aren't programs and organizations and communities and spaces
- 34:24specifically for people who have autism versus ADHD.
- 34:27No one's comparing the two,
- 34:28they're not
- 34:29comparable,
- 34:30but because
- 34:31they're.
- 34:32Are shared overlapping constructed evolving circumstances and relationships
- 34:37that being neurodivergent means that people have in the United States of America,
- 34:41that
- 34:42term exists and you like there's an understanding like I don't,
- 34:44so there's a time where we're talking about neurodivergence.
- 34:47There's a there's there are times all the like
- 34:50boxing the community in Tupperware and then labeling it is not going to help people
- 34:55process what's going on or become less hateful.
- 34:57It's doing exactly what they like
- 34:59and it's because they would like to characterize the community.
- 35:01As a political movement that they want to pull it apart and say,
- 35:04well,
- 35:04this agenda doesn't align with this agenda and this
- 35:07medical care is different than this medical care.
- 35:08But I suspect
- 35:10because,
- 35:11you know,
- 35:12there's the whole Donald Trump ad campaign,
- 35:14he's for they them
- 35:15or she's Kamala's for they them,
- 35:18Trump's for you
- 35:19or us or whatever.
- 35:21I can't remember that,
- 35:22but you know what I'm talking about.
- 35:26My guesstimation is that the majority of Americans
- 35:30have,
- 35:31they think that trans people
- 35:33should be allowed to do whatever they want,
- 35:35and by trans people I mean trans adults.
- 35:38I think where a lot of the people who swing between parties.
- 35:44Get
- 35:45concerned and get antsy is around
- 35:47what is the right way to approach
- 35:50uh
- 35:50people experiencing gender dysphoria
- 35:53as minors,
- 35:54trans youth,
- 35:55however,
- 35:55whatever the right way
- 35:57is to label that experience and that,
- 35:59um,
- 36:00population,
- 36:01and there's a lot of disagreement there.
- 36:04And there was a lot of disagreement in the episode
- 36:06about what is scientific consensus,
- 36:10and you were very confident in citing
- 36:12the organizations and the studies that you see as supporting
- 36:16your perspective,
- 36:17but I guess I'm curious,
- 36:18you know,
- 36:19do you think
- 36:20the ink is dry on the science there?
- 36:21or do you think
- 36:25there is justification for,
- 36:25for,
- 36:26for caution and
- 36:28And nuance once we get to minors.
- 36:31All of the science is saying we need to be cautious when it comes to minors.
- 36:34I don't think the ink is ever dry.
- 36:36What I will say is that every major,
- 36:39every respected medical organization on the planet.
- 36:43Agrees that gender affirming care for young people
- 36:46is not only appropriate in certain circumstances,
- 36:48but it is life saving,
- 36:49and to look for really niche studies that have been poorly done,
- 36:53funded by very questionable people,
- 36:55and are not peer reviewed
- 36:57as competing evidence for what is
- 37:00the closest to medical consensus you can arrive at in modern history
- 37:03isn't genuine.
- 37:04It it doesn't make sense.
- 37:06It's not real in the arguments,
- 37:08and that's why I,
- 37:09a lot of times I'd be like.
- 37:11What you're saying isn't happening and they're like,
- 37:12well,
- 37:12it has happened once,
- 37:13so now I know you're lying and it's just like,
- 37:14I'm not saying,
- 37:15I'm not saying things
- 37:17have never happened before.
- 37:18I'm saying
- 37:18the situation you're characterizing and what you're trying
- 37:20to get me to admit to is happening
- 37:22isn't happening the way you're putting it.
- 37:24What you're concerned about,
- 37:25what you're saying,
- 37:26what you're promoting in this conversation
- 37:28isn't happening.
- 37:29And I saw that I saw that come up a lot though,
- 37:32where it was like you're saying
- 37:34you were like,
- 37:34no,
- 37:34it's not happening
- 37:36everywhere the way you're suggesting,
- 37:38but they're saying,
- 37:38but it has happened.
- 37:40And
- 37:42it seems like
- 37:43both of those are true,
- 37:44but like they're very different ways of looking at reality and characterizing it.
- 37:48Yeah,
- 37:49and again,
- 37:49I think it's about being genuine about it.
- 37:51Are we,
- 37:51what is the intention of you bringing
- 37:53because it's really like
- 37:55you have to put your blinkers on
- 37:58and go full tunnel vision through the information to get to the places they're going
- 38:01without reading 100,000 sources
- 38:03that are going to.
- 38:05Challenge their viewpoint,
- 38:07explain why the source that they're about to cite isn't correct,
- 38:09and then give them new information to consider instead.
- 38:12But the people who cited evidence
- 38:14in this conversation didn't do that.
- 38:16They didn't even try to do that
- 38:18and didn't even pretend they were doing that.
- 38:20There were some,
- 38:21I,
- 38:21and again,
- 38:22I'm not an expert.
- 38:22I,
- 38:23I didn't like.
- 38:24Prepare heavily for this part of the studies they cited,
- 38:27that's on page 14 of the Google search results.
- 38:29And so if you're only citing that without the context of everything around it,
- 38:33I can't legitimately believe that you're attempting to have information.
- 38:37Again,
- 38:37I don't know the exact studies they were citing,
- 38:40but what I can say is it seemed like there was um
- 38:43genuine pushback towards
- 38:45towards your characterization of some of the specific studies that they.
- 38:50You know,
- 38:50I think you were saying,
- 38:51are these politically motivated,
- 38:52which I think is a valid question,
- 38:54but what
- 38:55they were asserting is no,
- 38:56these are legitimate
- 38:57and
- 38:58at that point,
- 38:59I mean that just requires more rigorous analysis for
- 39:01somebody to get to the truth of that,
- 39:03but I would say
- 39:05if I could draw a dotted line around.
- 39:08A part of the liberal or democratic platform that needs to be workshopped
- 39:13in a way to better communicate.
- 39:16Where people stand,
- 39:17I think.
- 39:19Gender affirming care,
- 39:21trans identity,
- 39:21and minors just
- 39:23That is something that is very hard
- 39:26for people to get
- 39:27consensus on,
- 39:28and I think the closest,
- 39:30and we've tested some of these things,
- 39:32the closest that
- 39:33folks
- 39:33can get right now that'd be a very productive place to go is.
- 39:37We want parental rights.
- 39:39We want
- 39:40families to be able to make decisions for
- 39:42themselves with the guidance of medical professionals.
- 39:45No one
- 39:45is advocating
- 39:47for a child to make this choice
- 39:48without parental support and without medical support.
- 39:51The thesis on the Jennifer and care for young people
- 39:53that I've successfully delivered to really,
- 39:55really
- 39:56far right conservative individuals and have gotten
- 39:58them to step back from their perspective
- 39:59is the government shouldn't have the say.
- 40:01You and I don't know what's going on.
- 40:03With the 16 year old girl in Alabama,
- 40:05we don't know what's going on with the seventeen-year-old boy in Utah.
- 40:07We don't know what's going on with the 15-year-old in New York City.
- 40:10We don't know these people.
- 40:11We don't know what's going on.
- 40:12We don't know what's going on their whole lives.
- 40:13We don't know what's going on with the parents.
- 40:14We don't know what their psychologists are saying.
- 40:16We don't know what their medical professionals are saying at all.
- 40:18What we need to be doing is making sure
- 40:19that these medical professionals have better access to information,
- 40:23have better abilities to care for and support people,
- 40:25that we're getting more people involved,
- 40:26that we're having a more universally.
- 40:29Appreciated
- 40:30and individualized process because having one size fits all,
- 40:34one rule fits all will never work.
- 40:36I think what you're getting at is a strong
- 40:38platform.
- 40:39We're against the government making the choice and we want parents to
- 40:43have the best quality information and understand the options that they have
- 40:47that are on the table for them to navigate that as their family.
- 40:50Like I think that
- 40:51that makes sense.
- 40:53Do you think there's a way to
- 40:54build a coalition?
- 40:55With people who have some varying points of view
- 40:58around this very complicated issue.
- 41:00I do think that coalition building is possible.
- 41:02I think it's essential,
- 41:03and I also think we just need to be very real about what it means to do that.
- 41:06It means that
- 41:07we're going to have to be very careful about how
- 41:09we build these coalitions and who shares space with who
- 41:11and who talks with who and who builds with who
- 41:13and what the intention of each part of the coalition is
- 41:16because right now.
- 41:17We're facing
- 41:19an attack on democracy.
- 41:20And if we can all hold shared values to protect democracy,
- 41:23and then build out from there and build from the common ground,
- 41:26we're going to see that,
- 41:27oh,
- 41:27wait,
- 41:27you just want what's best for
- 41:29this child.
- 41:30I just want what's best for this child.
- 41:32We both agreed that the parent knows better than us.
- 41:34Let's take a step back.
- 41:34I've watched those moments happen
- 41:36in our office.
- 41:37I've watched them happen and so I know they can.
- 41:40There were a lot of moments that came up though,
- 41:42which is something that I thought was encouraging was like
- 41:44there were a lot of middle ground moments that you had
- 41:47and I would,
- 41:48I would love to just kind of call out
- 41:50a few of them.
- 41:51And so like I had written some down.
- 41:54And you know there was a moment with Benjamin where
- 41:57he was like,
- 41:57trans girls can be trans girls.
- 41:59We're teaching people things that are young people things that are not true.
- 42:02For instance,
- 42:03we're teaching boys that they can be girls.
- 42:06That fundamentally,
- 42:06I think is Boys can't be girls.
- 42:08Trans girls can be girls.
- 42:10Trans girls can be trans girls,
- 42:11right?
- 42:12And I wouldn't disagree with you that they
- 42:14don't exist.
- 42:15They're human beings.
- 42:15You're a human being.
- 42:16I love you and care about you as a human being.
- 42:18That's a dub.
- 42:19We'll take it from there.
- 42:19We agree.
- 42:20OK,
- 42:20let's take that.
- 42:20That's a dub.
- 42:21People are people.
- 42:22We see each other.
- 42:22We're human beings,
- 42:23right?
- 42:23I genuinely,
- 42:24I love that.
- 42:24OK,
- 42:25but within that
- 42:27there are still things we can teach people that can harm them.
- 42:30And you guys like agreed and and kind of like shook on on that
- 42:34and I,
- 42:34there were moments like,
- 42:35um,
- 42:37you know,
- 42:37acknowledging that gender dysphoria is a real experience,
- 42:40you know,
- 42:40for
- 42:41even people who are struggling to get to
- 42:44a fuller understanding of trans identity,
- 42:47they,
- 42:47they acknowledge
- 42:48the reality of gender dysphoria.
- 42:51Um,
- 42:51I saw middle ground around um.
- 42:55You know,
- 42:55sexual abuse of minors is bad.
- 42:57It,
- 42:58that was like an important thing that somebody needed to hear.
- 43:01There was common ground about some
- 43:02book bans are out of pocket,
- 43:05or aren't inherently sexual,
- 43:06drag shows aren't inherently bad.
- 43:08I think especially towards the end,
- 43:10once a lot of the conversations had gotten
- 43:12from their most primal into something more nuanced,
- 43:15we were able to get to a lot of great places.
- 43:17That was so beautiful,
- 43:18and I think.
- 43:19If I had come in swinging,
- 43:21or if I had come in like,
- 43:23All right,
- 43:24conservatives,
- 43:25let's put you in pocket,
- 43:26you redneck hillbilly morons,
- 43:28then it would have been a disaster.
- 43:29It would have been a disaster.
- 43:32I know.
- 43:33Even if it's so hard to know it,
- 43:36that the majority of the people surrounding me were not
- 43:39bad,
- 43:40hateful people.
- 43:41They were deeply,
- 43:42consistently misinformed people
- 43:45and
- 43:47What the data shows us is that with enough time and enough conversation,
- 43:50these people can change the way they think
- 43:53and can do the same for others.
- 43:54This is something that's always on my mind.
- 43:56Do you worry,
- 43:57um,
- 43:58do you ever worry that you're misinformed?
- 44:00Um,
- 44:03I worry I sometimes don't have enough information,
- 44:06but
- 44:07I interrogate,
- 44:08I interrogate,
- 44:09I watch some Fox News.
- 44:11I
- 44:11talk to
- 44:12wild people all day long.
- 44:14I've read the studies.
- 44:15I,
- 44:16I dive deep into it.
- 44:17I can under
- 44:18the idea of surgery on young people that is not reversible is scary.
- 44:22I understand that.
- 44:23I.
- 44:23I'm not acting like I don't,
- 44:24and so I look into it.
- 44:26If I'm going to be fighting for something
- 44:28as a young person who's never experienced it,
- 44:30I want to deeply understand it.
- 44:32I talked to people,
- 44:33I talked to people who have transitioned and it saved their lives.
- 44:35I've talked to people who have transitioned and then chosen to de-transition,
- 44:38and
- 44:39I'm sure I'm misinformed about stuff.
- 44:41That's part of the game,
- 44:42but
- 44:44Being honest with yourself and having discipline is the most important thing.
- 44:47Like I can tell
- 44:49when I'm not trying my hardest to be challenged and when I am,
- 44:52and most of us can.
- 44:53Most of us can feel it in our guts.
- 45:00Xander,
- 45:00thank you so much.
- 45:02I appreciate you digging back into this,
- 45:04defending your,
- 45:05your,
- 45:05your views and your opinions and,
- 45:07and
- 45:08your beliefs.
- 45:08I think that's really important and it was really generous of you.
- 45:11Yeah,
- 45:11of course,
- 45:12I think
- 45:13I appreciate you having this conversation with me and
- 45:15giving me the opportunity to reflect on some of it.
- 45:17Life moved fast.
- 45:18This has been
- 45:19a good chance for me to
- 45:21think back to that moment.
- 45:24If you want to hear more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 45:27be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
- 45:31You can also check out Jubilee on YouTube,
- 45:33and if you want to send me a message or give me feedback from today's episode,
- 45:37you can find me on X or YouTube.
- 45:39John Regalado,
- 45:40thanks so much for listening.
- 45:42Remember,
- 45:43you could be wrong,
- 45:44and so could I.
- 45:45Until next time.