Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 158. Birth Control, IUD, Hypothyroidism and Weight Gain
Transcript
- 0:08Thanks for listening to the Thyroid Fixer podcast with your host, me, Dr. Amy Horniman, AKA the Thyroid Fixer. Also, functional medicine practitioner, hormone and weight loss expert. We're talking all things thyroid, hormone, and health-related in order to empower, educate, and transform you. Remember, I fix your thyroid, I fix your hormones, I fix your life. So let's get started.
- 0:34Hey everyone, coming to you live from God's country once again. So today we are talking about birth control, IUDs, hypothyroidism, and weight gain. So I hear, I have so, so many, so many patients.
- 0:56that are on birth control. And the big thing that I say is, are you using it for birth control? Are you just using it because your doctor put you on it as a bandaid, put you on it because you had heavy periods, put you on it because you had fibroids or PCOS? It's important to distinguish because listen, if you're 22 and you're on birth control for birth control because you just don't wanna get pregnant, you're not quite ready in your life for a baby.
- 1:26That's okay, but I wish there were still other things that we could have you do. I wish the sponge was still around, right? Like the Seinfeld episode of being sponge worthy. But listen, I still, I understand if you're using birth control for birth control, but there are things that you have to be aware of when you do, and we're going to get into that today.
- 1:49For my other ladies, maybe you've already had kids. Maybe you're a little bit older. Maybe you really don't need to be on birth control. This is something for you to think about because I'm going to tell you a story and it's going to hit home, especially if you are still struggling with weight gain. I had a patient that had an IUD. It was the Mirena IUD. And she went to her doctor who I absolutely love. I love this OBGYN.
- 2:17And she said, you know, I've put on all this weight and it seems to be correlated with when I've had my IUD inserted. No, no, no. It does not cause weight gain at all. That's not it. That is not it at all. And she's like, yeah, but I really think it is. And then, of course, we met and we started optimizing her thyroid and we started balancing our hormones. But it's very hard to balance hormones, your own hormones and the hormones that I see on
- 2:47when you're putting in synthetic hormones all the time. And we're going to talk about the difference between your real hormones in your body and synthetic hormones, such as those in a birth control pill or an IUD. So we really couldn't get a good read on what her hormones, her own hormones were doing.
- 3:05but we knew enough that we could trace it back to say that things started happening after she had her IUD inserted. And on top of that, we know she has hypothyroidism. And honestly, this was a few years ago. Knowing if I knew then what I know now, I would have even correlated the onset of her hypothyroidism with the IUD implant. So now we know that
- 3:34IUDs and birth control pills cause hypothyroidism. So that would have been very interesting to see. I did not think about it back then. I didn't think about to correlate those two incidences, but nonetheless, we discussed, she decided to get it out. And she lost 16 pounds in a month, 16, one six in a month.
- 4:00We have to put a little asterisk saying these results may vary, not typical for everyone. I'm not saying if you run and get your Mirena out that you're going to lose all this weight, but it could happen. It could. And we have to be aware that birth control in any form, synthetic hormones, whether you take a pill or you put it in you, birth control of any forms interferes with thyroid function.
- 4:29We're going to tell you why. First of all, birth control, synthetic hormones versus your bioidentical hormones that your body makes. Two completely different things. It is like, I always say it's like comparing apples and a car. That is how different they are. We're not talking apples and oranges. We're talking apples and a car. Two totally different things.
- 4:53However, the receptor site on your cells for estrogen, progesterone, those fake hormones come in and they will bind to that receptor site. But they won't do the same exact things 100% what natural bioidentical, let's say, estrogen will do.
- 5:16So we know that there's a lot of xenoestrogens in the world, fake estrogens, and they come into your body and they bind to that receptor site and they start to wreak havoc. They actually start to cause estrogen dominance, but it's not really your own estrogen, your natural bioidentical estrogen that is raising. It's the fake estrogens coming in your system. Well, this is no different. Birth control is no different. IUDs are no different. This is no different whatsoever. Right.
- 5:43This is a fake hormone coming in and binding to that receptor site and wreaking havoc in your body, sometimes triggering those things that estrogen and progesterone are supposed to be doing, such as tricking your body into thinking that it's pregnant. That's what the birth control is meant to do, and it does that most of the time, unless you take antibiotics or something or forget it.
- 6:06Most of the time it does what it's supposed to do, but it is not going to provide the benefits of proper estrogen levels like better skin, like vaginal lubrication, like collagen and elastin production, kind of going back to your skin.
- 6:21It's not going to provide the hormone and mood balancing that progesterone provides. Progesterone is the calming, balancing hormone. It takes down agitation. It takes down irritability. It reduces water retention and helps you sleep. Synthetic birth control hormones are not going to have those beneficial effects because it's not going to provide the hormone and mood balancing.
- 6:43of bioidentical hormones, they're just not. On top of that, we also know that these hormones can actually cause hypothyroidism.
- 6:52So when studies are done looking at these fake hormones in birth control, we can actually see TSH go up and free T3 and free T4 go down. Now it can be because of a variety of different mechanisms. Number one, we know that birth control pills, synthetic hormones, synthetic birth control hormones deplete nutrients. So they deplete things like selenium and zinc. Now we know that these are required
- 7:19for T4 to T3 conversion. We talk all the time. We talk all the time about how T3 is your active thyroid hormone and T3 is powerful. And that's what gets into the cell.
- 7:30And if you are not converting your own body's T4, or if you are taking T4 only, or if you are taking NDT, and you are not converting that properly over to T3, you're screwed. It's going to convert to reverse T3. Reverse T3 is going to go up, and you are going to go in survival mode. And what that means is your body is going to hold on to fat for dear life.
- 7:52And it will shut down your metabolism. It will slow your pooping down. Everything goes low and slow because you are in survival mode. Your energy will go down and your weight will go up if reverse T3 is elevated. If you don't have enough zinc or selenium or minerals, we even know that iodine and different minerals like magnesium are depleted.
- 8:14when you take birth control. So if these are depleted, you're not gonna convert T4 to T3. B vitamins, we know birth control pills, similar to metformin. Metformin depletes B12. Birth control pills deplete all B vitamins.
- 8:29So now we're getting into the energy realm, right? So many of you are saying, but I have low energy and I'm trying to fix my thyroid here and I still have low energy. But if you are taking synthetic hormones and you're depleting your B vitamins, even if you're replacing it, even if you're replacing it with a high quality multivitamin, like a Designs for Health B Supreme,
- 8:48you still can become depleted. So your body can still deplete those B vitamins and thus interfere with T4 to T3 conversion and affect your energy because you need proper B vitamins to have good energy. The birth control pill also increases thyroid binding globulin, TBG. So thyroid binding globulin binds to thyroid hormones.
- 9:14We don't want too much of that because that is taking away from the hormone available to the cells. So we just said T3 is the most active, is the active thyroid hormone. It's not the most. T4 is just your storage hormone. T4 has to convert over to T3. T3 is active. Every single cell in your body has a receptor site on it for T3. If T3 is bound to thyroid binding glybulin, it's no longer available for your cell to pick up.
- 9:43If you can't get T3 into the cell, what's going to happen? You're going to gain weight. Your energy is going to go low. You're going to lose hair. You're going to be backed up and not poop every day like we want you to. Everything will become low and slow again. If thyroid binding globulin goes up, you literally bind to the thyroid hormone that is so desperately needed by your cell and that you so desperately want.
- 10:07As even a non-Hashimoto's, non-hypothyroid patient, you want T3. You want your own body's T3 that your thyroid is making to get to the cell, to give you metabolism, to keep you in a good mood, to keep your energy up. And if you have hypothyroidism or Hashimoto's, you definitely want T3 because chances are your doctor isn't giving you enough.
- 10:33In the form of medication, you're probably on T4 only or you're on NDT that's a low dose. Maybe your reverse T3 is high. Nobody's paying attention to you. So you want all the T3 that you can possibly get to get into the cell. Well, if you're taking birth control or you have an IUD, your thyroid binding globulin is going to increase and it's going to bind to some of that thyroid hormone and not let it get into the cell.
- 10:57So now you have depletion of nutrients, you have increased thyroid binding globulin. Those are two major, major problems. And then we also know that the birth control pill and synthetic hormones are inflammatory. So those of you with Hashimoto's, you're already in an inflamed state. Any autoimmune condition whatsoever is a state of inflammation.
- 11:19Many of you also have insulin resistance. So I say all the time, I see insulin resistance in about 99% of my hypothyroid Hashimoto patients. Insulin resistance is rampant. We're at about 80% in the country right now. 80% of people have insulin resistance. And that's why we have this, I mean, more than the pandemic that we're in, we have a pandemic of obesity. We have obese children.
- 11:45I mean, go to Walmart, go to Disney. Walmart and Disney are your two cross sections of America and just stand there and observe. I dare you. I did this one time with my parents at Disney. We played a game. We said throughout the whole day that we're here, because you know, you spend like 10 hours there, we are going to count how many actually in shape fit people we see because there's going to be fewer of those. There was one day that maybe we had like 10 to 20 people.
- 12:15The rest, all obese and overweight. Obesity, insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes, those are all states of inflammation. Those are states of our body being so stressed out and so inflamed that it literally just lays down fat. Well, any autoimmune condition is inflammatory as well.
- 12:35So now you have Hashimoto's and you're taking birth control pills that cause inflammation. And now we're pairing that all together. We know that inflammation is the root of all chronic disease. So when we're talking about cancer, when we're talking about Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, dementia, heart disease, we know that that core is inflammation.
- 13:05We're just creating multiple, multiple, multiple states of inflammation that is going to take down our body. And this is why I'm so adamant about these synthetic hormones and birth control, because it's not just about, hey, let's change it to a different birth control method. Maybe you use condoms. Maybe you use a sponge if we can get Seinfeld and Elaine to bring them, be sponge worthy and bring that back. I don't even know if there still is.
- 13:31that out there. I'm not quite sure. I haven't checked in a while. Maybe you use timing. Maybe you track your cycles. I don't know. I don't have the answer for you as to what's gonna work for you.
- 13:42but I have the answer as to what birth control and IUDs are doing to your body. And believe me, I do not come from a place of higher than. I took birth control for years. And again, because we know that it can cause hypothyroidism, I'm half-assed wondering if that wasn't one of the main triggers of why, in addition to just me having a genetic predisposition for Hashimoto's,
- 14:07And then over exercising and over dieting when I was competing. If you throw birth control on top of that, well, no the hell wonder I got Hashimoto's in my 20s. No wonder it presented itself and said, hello, I'm here and I are going to gain 25 pounds. It just makes sense because I was doing all the wrong things because we didn't know. And I took it for many years. I mean, I started when I was 17, maybe 16, something like that.
- 14:34So a good 10 some years, I was on birth control. And actually, eventually, the reason why I got off of it was not because of any of this knowledge that I'm sharing with you. It was because my body was basically rebelling. And I had every side effect, all of a sudden, just like that, every side effect that you could possibly think of, I was gaining weight again, even though my thyroid was actually optimized at that time, I was gaining weight again, I was breaking out, I was like, you know, enough is enough.
- 15:02And then you have the whole blood clot issue, which that is something to consider because we know that birth control pills can cause blood clots when taken over a long, long period of time. Okay.
- 15:16So the other thing I got a little bit off track, I apologize. C-reactive protein, that's an inflammatory marker that we measure via blood. Many of my patients get that. So what we'll see in blood work is actually an elevation in CRP, C-reactive protein, when women are taking oral contraceptives. So this is for the pill. And then we'll also see an increase in fibrinogen and cereplasm.
- 15:42So we know that the birth control pill actually increases inflammation via those blood markers. So this is not just me blowing smoke up your bum saying, oh, yeah, birth control pill and synthetic hormones cause inflammation. No, we can actually see it and measure it. And that's how we know it's affecting you to that level.
- 16:02Going back to hormones, birth control pills, we know that they lower certain nutrients and then deplete the body of nutrients, but they also lower DHEA. DHEA is the anti-aging hormone. It is a precursor to all other sex hormones, especially testosterone. And ladies, how often do I tell you that I see low testosterone in all my female patients?
- 16:26all the time. I was just on with a new patient before this. I said to her, I see low testosterone in 100% of my patients who are not on testosterone already. It is so very rare that a woman will come to me with thyroid problems already, hormones dysregulated, and this is what we are working on to balance, right? So you are working with me, we're getting your thyroid optimized, we're balancing your hormones out, but I am always
- 16:56low testosterone across the board in women. And remember with testosterone, whether you're male or female, we do not go by the standard lab value range. We absolutely do not go by the standard lab value range. We go by what is optimal. And optimal for women is 40 to like a hundredth.
- 17:17So our optimal range is wide. It's vast. And, and it's, and, but we have to target that higher range. We can't stay in the lower range because you're going to get flagged normal. If your testosterone comes in at a 20, that's not optimal. So we want you in that beautiful optimal range. So you can have a libido and you can build sexy lean muscle and you can burn fat and have some
- 17:43as we're working on your thyroid. So thyroid and hormones together. So birth control pills, lower DHEA levels. This is also very important for autoimmune conditions. So those with autoimmune, we like using DHEA. It's very supportive to the adrenals, but it also kind of nurtures and pushes along that testosterone. We do not want your DHEA levels depleted. Birth control pills deplete folate. Many of you are
- 18:09MTHFR, you have MTHFR positive, whether you're heterozygous or homozygous, 50% of the population has the genetic SNP of MTHFR. Now we're still learning about MTHFR. We do not know everything about it. We know it is correlated with
- 18:26Birth defects, we know it's correlated with miscarriages. I had one patient that had multiple miscarriages and it wasn't until we tested genetic testing on her to find that she had that MTHFR SNP and needed folate.
- 18:41that we found that that was the cause of her miscarriages. So we know a few things about MTHFR we're still learning. But one thing we know is that most people with an MTHFR genetic mutation need folate. They also need the methylated forms of B vitamins. So here we go again, we're gonna tie this together. Birth control pills, deplete your B vitamins. Let's say you're MTHFR2 and you're taking some crap-tastic B vitamin from Sam's Club that is not methylated.
- 19:09Or let's say you are taking a beautiful methylated B vitamin that actually says methylcobalamin, methylated B vitamins, but that birth control pill is depleting your body of it. Now you're going to be so low in the B vitamins, your hair is going to fall out. You're not going to have energy and T4 to T3 conversion isn't happening. We're also pulling down folate with these birth control pills. So now you're trying to get pregnant and you don't have enough folate.
- 19:35That is imperative for the baby's brain. Folate and iodine, imperative for baby brain development. That is why we are seeing an increase in autism. We're seeing an increase in autism and ADD and ADHD and neurodevelopmental delays because we are so scared of iodine. We're depleting people of iodine. We got women walking around with undiagnosed and undertreated hypothyroidism. And before they got pregnant, they were on birth control pills and decided to go out the birth control pills because they wanted to get pregnant.
- 20:04Those pills have depleted their folate and then their doctor sticks them on a prenatal vitamin with folic acid. Body can't even use it. So now we're depleting natural folate out of the body with the birth control pills. We're depleting the B vitamins. We're depleting zinc. We're depleting minerals like iodine. We're depleting magnesium. We're depleting selenium. And we expect to have a healthy pregnancy. That's not going to happen because your body is starving of all the nutrients because the decades of birth control pill use that you were on.
- 20:34we need to build that back up again. So you need to stop the birth control and then you need to replete with the methylated B vitamins with folate instead of folic acid, with a high quality prenatal if you're gonna, if you plan on getting pregnant, very, very important. Birth control pills can also,
- 20:52change and suppress our body's own production of estrogen and progesterone. So remember I told you about those benefits in the beginning. So the benefits of estrogen are plump skin, actual production of collagen and elastin, and hyaluronic acid. So you ladies that are getting injections of fillers into your face, that is hyaluronic acid.
- 21:13What they put into your knee joint is hyaluronic acid. Estrogen actually helps with our skin by boosting our collagen, elastin, and hyaluronic acid production, which is also why it helps with pain and joint pain. So we see when estrogen goes down, it's just like, think about a menopausal state, although this can happen regularly.
- 21:34Way, way, way before menopause, ladies, I see low estrogen levels, low testosterone, low progesterone in people's 20s. And my patients that are coming in in their 20s and 30s, when that should not be happening yet, but I see it. Could it be because of birth control use? Yes, it could be. It could also be from the increased rates of hypothyroidism and Hashimoto's. We're seeing increased autoimmune diseases right now as well. So we're seeing this low estrogen.
- 22:02We're seeing low hormones across the board, but I'm talking about estrogen right now. Estrogen being low actually causes drier skin, hair wrinkling. Estrogen delivers nutrients to the hair follicle. So all my people out there that are freaking out about hair loss, and I know there's a lot of you, and that's a big concern with women and that's a big concern with hypothyroidism. Having optimal hormones.
- 22:26levels of estrogen is also vital for your hair because low estrogen will result in hair loss and hair thinning. It's usually the hair thinning with low estrogen, but we can experience hair loss as well. And we'll see hair thinning and hair loss with hypothyroidism. So what if you're hypothyroid and you're taking birth control and you're lowering your natural estrogen and your estrogen is going in the tank because all you're giving your body is synthetic.
- 22:53We also know that birth control pills suppress progesterone. Progesterone is the calming balancing. I'm going to say it again, calming, balancing hormone, calming and balancing. So if we're depleting your own body's progesterone levels, you're going to be more anxious. You're not going to sleep well. You're going to retain water because progesterone is a diuretic. It calms us. It chills us out. And in fact,
- 23:16For depressed individuals, if we give them T3 and progesterone, we can nine times out of 10 avoid that band-aid of antidepressants. So how about that? Birth control pills can also change the gut flora. Now we know your immune system starts in the gut. We already said birth control pills are inflammatory. So now we're creating the state of inflammation. We're changing your beneficial bacteria, your beneficial gut flora.
- 23:42And we know that T4 to T3 conversion happens in the gut. Serotonin is produced in the gut. Your immune system starts in the gut and there is a gut brain connection. So when we deplete that flora in the gut and we mess it all up, all of those processes that rely on the gut being in a healthy state start to go awry. So that's where we see T4 to T3 conversion impaired and reverse T3 go up. That's where we'll see leaky gut. We'll see more inflammation.
- 24:12We'll see a suppression of the immune system. So people get colds more often. We see all that with dysregulated gut flora. We also know that when your gut flora is a disaster, you have an increased risk of insulin resistance and type two diabetes. We know this in studies now. We've heard of the estrobilome, that is the estrogen gut connection. Anything with bolome in it is your gut. There's also, there's something, there's another term connected to metabolism.
- 24:41and your metabolism in the gut. Because if the gut is messed up, we also see more weight gain. Many birth controlled pills contain lactose. So we know that many of you that are Hashimoto's, you are not lactose tolerant whatsoever. And when you get pills, even your own medication and they contain fillers, you react to them.
- 25:04That's why many of you go the natural route. That's why we're looking at the manufacture of your, your cytomel and the manufacture of your generic P3 and the manufacturer. Maybe we change you up to tyrosine because it's more pure. We don't want pills that will contain something that could
- 25:19spur on an autoimmune attack. Now they're not as bad as gluten, but who knows, there might actually be gluten in the birth control pills too, because we know that they can be in thyroid medication. So there are a bajillion makers of birth control pills out there. There aren't too many IUD makers, developers, whatever you want to call it. There are
- 25:39Many, many companies that make birth control pills and you do not know whether or not they contain gluten. There is no way that you can know with 100% certainty whether or not they contain gluten. The IUDs that are copper, we do not know that much about them. They are non-hormonal. Some people say that it can throw off our zinc to copper ratio because of the amount of copper in them.
- 26:04So when it comes to those implantable copper IUDs, we do not believe that they affect hormones, but there has not been enough studies done to actually figure that out and to know with 100% certainty. Okay, so let's summarize all of this because I really want you to take this home and think on it.
- 26:29and maybe take some action steps to use a different form of birth control. If you are not, like I said, in your 20s and it's just not a great time, and maybe we give you a pass then, and you have to use birth control pills because you're young and we don't want you having babies just yet.
- 26:46But if you are older and you are using this as a form of contraception because it's easy or because you don't want heavy periods or your doctor put you on it so long ago and you've just been on it forever, I want you to think twice about this because this could be a major change that could affect your weight and could affect how your thyroid functions.
- 27:06There are often times when we take a woman off her longstanding birth control method of pill or IUD. And not only does she lose weight, but she needs less thyroid medication.
- 27:18Because now you don't have that thyroid binding globulin binding to the 3T3, not allowing it or rather preventing it from getting to the cell. So there are so many benefits to changing up your birth control pill. I want you to take this and really think on it and possibly make some changes in your own life, especially if weight and energy are one of the things that you are really struggling with, which I know so many of you are, even if you're my patient.
- 27:45This is something that we need to talk about. We really need to dive into a little bit more if you are on the birth control pill and what we are doing together in optimizing your thyroid isn't quite hitting the mark or you're not quite losing, especially if you're in that like month two, three, four, and you're still not seeing weight loss. This could be one change that we could implement that would really hit home and really kickstart that weight loss and really take you to the next level. Just like I shared the story in the very beginning,
- 28:15of my patients that had her marina taken out and lost 16 pounds in a month. That is powerful, powerful stuff. So I want you guys to really think on this, take this information with you and make some considerable changes. I know there are going to be lifestyle changes. I know, I know, I know many of you are thinking like, what am I going to do? How am I going to have sex without birth control? Right. My husband won't get a vasectomy. And I certainly don't want you going
- 28:45Way easier for the guys, by the way. Way easier for the guys. Much, much harder for us ladies. But you might want to at least explore alternative options for birth control. All right. I hope I gave you some great info here.
- 29:03As always, you can subscribe to the Thyroid Fixer podcast on all podcast platforms, but that way you also get notifications of every single new podcast that comes up. You can binge, you can learn. I promise it's a ton of great information from just myself and also from my guests that I interview. So Thyroid Fixer podcast on all podcast platforms. Make sure you subscribe and go to my YouTube channel as well and subscribe there. That way you can watch the videos. All right.
- 29:33Hey guys, thank you so much for listening to the podcast. I hope you loved it. And as always, if you would be so kind to leave a review, if you are listening on Apple podcast, that would be absolutely amazing. I read all of them. Also anything that you hear on this podcast is not intended to diagnose or treat any kind of medical condition. So we always recommend that you check with your medical provider, your doctor, your nurse practitioner before implementing anything that you hear on this podcast.
- 30:01And if you want to find out more about working together, you can click the link below in the show notes to book a discovery call. And there you'll be talking to a member of my team. They are an extension of me. They are amazing. And you and I will talk after that once we get you all signed up and you and I get to work together. All right, I hope to see you soon.