Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Perfecting Your Fee Agreement So It Protects You
Transcript
- 0:03Hi there. Welcome to this great and important
- 0:07for all of us webinar today. My name is Dean
- 0:11Serwin. I'm the chair of the wellness section
- 0:14here at the Beverly Hills Bar. And I was formerly
- 0:16the chair of the law practice management section
- 0:18who's presenting this important program. I'm
- 0:21going to give you a little background and then
- 0:23we'll jump in with Marshall Cole. So it's that
- 0:27time of year and it's that time of the three
- 0:30year for myself, I get to do my compliance, my
- 0:35MCLE compliance. The Beverly Hills Bar is fantastic
- 0:39for helping out with that. We have these programs.
- 0:42This is the second one I've introduced today.
- 0:44I'm sure there's gonna be another one at four
- 0:46o 'clock today. We have one to three of these
- 0:49a day. They're all available in the BHBA on demand.
- 0:55locker room, sort of a YouTube for MCLE that
- 0:58we do. If you're like me and in the past you
- 1:02needed a few extra hours, you'd click on one
- 1:06of those emails or back in the day faxes that
- 1:09would come in offering you all 25 hours for $75
- 1:13and the programs you'd get on back then VHS and
- 1:18then DVDs were awful. They were old, they were
- 1:21poorly produced, they were boring topics done
- 1:24by very professorial speakers that were hard
- 1:29to follow. BHBA, we've got programs like today's,
- 1:35important things that are important to your practice.
- 1:38If there's a new case that comes down or important
- 1:40legislation or just something important that
- 1:42happens in the business or legal world, we're
- 1:45probably going to have a program on it within
- 1:46a week. That program is then going to be in the
- 1:49on -demand locker room. I know it's not called
- 1:52that, but I like calling it that, where you can
- 1:54go and watch it again. After today, you want
- 1:58to review this, you can go and review it. You
- 2:00can send it to your partners, your associates,
- 2:03your friends and say, hey, go check this out.
- 2:08It's really fantastic. Then when it comes time,
- 2:11like it is for me, I guess we get an extension
- 2:13of a month now, to actually do that, All the
- 2:17videos that you watch, they're all participatory
- 2:20credit. They're there in a format and on a sheet.
- 2:26So all you have to do is a couple of clicks and
- 2:28you turn that into the bar and you're done, you're
- 2:30ready. And if you look and you need, like I do,
- 2:33I need some of those specialty hours, then you
- 2:36go into the on -demand and you go, hey, I want
- 2:38to watch this one on substance abuse. I want
- 2:40to watch this one on stress. And it's really
- 2:43easy to do. appreciate the the BHBA for having
- 2:49that available for us and Lawyers Mutual that
- 2:53sponsors that. So let's get to this. There is
- 2:58a chat. There'll be some posts in there with
- 3:00the materials from today. It'll be monitored
- 3:03by the representative from BHBA who will repost
- 3:08those as necessary. This is a webinar. You can
- 3:11raise your hand. You can post questions in the
- 3:13Q &A. Marshall is going to work to monitor that,
- 3:18but there'll be a Q &A section at the end. So
- 3:21go ahead and post those there. And I'm going
- 3:25to introduce them. Marshall Cole, protecting
- 3:28your fee agreement so it protects you. Great
- 3:31title. Marshall is the managing attorney at Nemesek
- 3:34and Cole, a nationally recognized trial lawyer
- 3:38known for his success in complex, high -profile
- 3:41professional liability and civil litigation matters.
- 3:44Named by the Daily Journal as one of California's
- 3:47top professional liability attorneys, he's renowned
- 3:49for his proactive solutions -driven approach
- 3:52and consistent record of winning results at trial.
- 3:56Marshall, thank you so much for being here today.
- 3:58I'm gonna go off camera. Take it away. Thanks
- 4:02Dean and thanks to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 4:04as always for having me. I prepared a PowerPoint
- 4:07here so we'll work our way through it. But for
- 4:11starters, everything that we're going to go through
- 4:13today regarding fee agreements, it's something
- 4:17my office has dealt with and most likely has
- 4:20dealt with within the last 12 to 24 months. So
- 4:24all these tips that I'm going to provide you
- 4:26with or pitfalls that we're seeing are real claims,
- 4:30either legal malpractice claims or mandatory
- 4:32fee arbitration issues that we're seeing, arbitration
- 4:35issues that we're seeing. And so as we walk through
- 4:38each of the slides, hopefully you're going to
- 4:40leave with the ability to go back to your retainer
- 4:43agreement, take a look at it and see how you
- 4:45can make it better because. there's oftentimes
- 4:50a poorly drafted retainer agreement can create
- 4:53a lot of issues in a legal malpractice case that
- 4:56are otherwise avoidable. And so if you draft
- 4:59it and it's tight and you've complied with all
- 5:01the rules, you're gonna get all the protections
- 5:04that you put into that agreement that are gonna
- 5:07benefit you versus having it potentially avoidable
- 5:10by the court and set aside. So with that, I'll
- 5:13share my screen here, and we'll work our way
- 5:15through the slides. If you have questions, feel
- 5:17free. I'll try to monitor it. It can get a little
- 5:20tricky with sharing screen, but I'll do my best
- 5:23here. So give me a second. All right. So. Really,
- 5:31these are the rules that I'm not gonna go through
- 5:33each one of these rules with respect to this
- 5:36presentation, but you need to be aware of these
- 5:39when drafting your firm's fee agreement. And
- 5:42we'll touch on some of them, but again, I don't
- 5:44put the actual content of the rule. But this
- 5:48is just like 30 ,000 foot. These are the rules
- 5:51you need to focus on. And then we'll look at
- 5:54the business and professions code as well regarding
- 5:57each of the aspects of your attorney -client
- 6:00relationship, from formation to referral fees
- 6:03to the responsibilities that the lawyer has,
- 6:06the responsibilities that the clients have, and
- 6:09then also withdrawing and concluding your services.
- 6:12If you find yourself in one of these situations,
- 6:16the first thing you need to do is refer to the
- 6:18rule. See what you need to do and what you can
- 6:22and cannot do. And then, of course, the second
- 6:24thing you can always do is call me or my office,
- 6:27and we can walk you through any issues that come
- 6:29up. We offer outside general counsel services
- 6:33to a number of firms, from sole practitioner
- 6:36to hundreds and hundreds of lawyer firms. So
- 6:39we're always just one call away. After you've
- 6:43reviewed these rules, when you're starting to
- 6:45take a look at drafting your retainer agreement,
- 6:48the first thing you really need to focus on is
- 6:50obviously if you're going to have a contingency
- 6:52fee agreement or a non -contingency fee agreement,
- 6:55an hourly fee agreement. Both are governed by
- 6:59different code sections under the Business and
- 7:00Professions Code, and both have different aspects
- 7:05that you need to cover in order to make sure
- 7:07that it's in compliance with the rules. both
- 7:11generally need to be in writing unless it's for
- 7:14very small amounts, both need to be signed by
- 7:17the attorney and the client. And I know that
- 7:19sounds like such an obvious thing, but the amount
- 7:22of claims that I've handled where the attorney
- 7:25fee agreement is not signed by either the lawyer
- 7:28or the client is staggering. So many attorney
- 7:30fee agreements. Either don't come back signed
- 7:33or the attorney themselves never signed them.
- 7:36And again, just an easy mistake to avoid. And
- 7:39so some of this may seem like, of course, this
- 7:41is so obvious, Marshall, but I wouldn't be talking
- 7:44about it if it didn't happen on a regular basis.
- 7:47And sometimes it happens with people who never
- 7:49have this issue. And then, of course, they get
- 7:51busy. and they forget to get it signed or sign
- 7:54themselves. So these are the two business and
- 7:56professions code sections that are very important
- 7:58to know and understand when you're drafting an
- 8:01attorney -client fee agreement. And if it's been
- 8:04a year or two years or more since you've looked
- 8:07at your attorney -client fee agreement, you need
- 8:09to take the time after this presentation to go
- 8:11back and look at it and see if it's still applicable
- 8:14to the type of work you're doing to the type
- 8:17of clients you're servicing because I don't believe
- 8:20that retainer agreements are a form type of contract
- 8:23that you can take from one client to the next.
- 8:26You can certainly have a template but you definitely
- 8:29want to take a look at it for each client to
- 8:33make sure that that particular agreement fits
- 8:36for what you're going to be doing. My office
- 8:38has a number of different types of attorney -client
- 8:41fee agreements for different types of matters
- 8:43that we handle. Private business litigation,
- 8:47state bar matters, insurance defense matters,
- 8:50plaintiff side contingency matters, should we
- 8:52handle one of those. There's a number of different
- 8:54provisions that we like depending on what type
- 8:58of matter we have. If you're the managing partner
- 9:01of a firm, small or large, you really need to
- 9:04understand what retainer agreements exist within
- 9:07your firm and what's being sent out to clients
- 9:10and make sure there's a large amount of oversight
- 9:12over that because we've seen cases arise from
- 9:16retainer agreements. that gets sent out to a
- 9:19client, which haven't even been approved by the
- 9:21firm's general counselor managing partner. And
- 9:24they've modified and tweaked things and lo and
- 9:26behold, firm gets sued and now they're dealing
- 9:28with a retainer agreement that the managing partner
- 9:31didn't otherwise approve. So again, this requires
- 9:34a lot of oversight and a lot of ongoing diligence,
- 9:38similar to, I often give sort of ethics presentations
- 9:42on conflicts of interest. And like a conflict
- 9:44of interest in a conflict waiver, Conflicts modify
- 9:47and change over time, and you need to get your
- 9:49waivers updated. Now, an attorney -client fee
- 9:52agreement, it certainly can change, but you're
- 9:55not going to get more than one throughout the
- 9:57representation. But definitely, from one client
- 10:00to the next, you need to take a look at the agreement,
- 10:04make sure it complies with the rules, and make
- 10:05sure it's benefiting you and the firm in the
- 10:10way you want it to. And as we move forward here,
- 10:14if you don't comply, it can become a problem,
- 10:17and it can become a problem really fast. And
- 10:20each of these four issues that I've provided
- 10:23here as examples, we've seen very recently. The
- 10:27first one, I just resolved a case about 10 days
- 10:30ago, not because of the issue that both the attorney
- 10:34and the client didn't sign, but because the issue
- 10:37of the duplicate copy was not sent back to the
- 10:41client. So the way the rule works here, and it's
- 10:45It's a little bit overkill, but it's the rule.
- 10:50And what it says is once the agreement is fully
- 10:53executed by the attorney and the client, you
- 10:56as the lawyer need to send a fully executed copy
- 11:00of that retainer agreement to the client. And
- 11:04the issues come up when the lawyer signs the
- 11:08retainer agreement, then they send it to the
- 11:10client. The client signs the retainer agreement
- 11:13and emails the agreement back. The lawyer often
- 11:17thinks, well, look, I've got a fully signed agreement.
- 11:19They clearly have the copy because they scanned
- 11:22and sent it, so I don't need to do anything.
- 11:24Or there's just an oversight altogether and they
- 11:26don't send it. The argument that was made in
- 11:30the case that I was defending was that it didn't
- 11:33comply with the business and professions code
- 11:35because a fully executed copy wasn't sent and
- 11:39a retainer agreement was avoidable at the client's
- 11:41option. And the firm I was representing had a
- 11:44cross -complaint for attorney's fees and they
- 11:46were of course claiming that we shouldn't get
- 11:48those fees or at best we would be entitled to
- 11:51quantum merit as you see there on the screen
- 11:53and if that kicks in depending on what your hourly
- 11:57rate that you're charging at your firm is you
- 11:59may not be getting a thousand dollars an hour
- 12:02eight hundred dollars an hour you may be getting
- 12:04depending on your jurisdiction three hundred
- 12:06dollars an hour and you want to avoid that situation
- 12:08now if the matter had excuse me I think in front
- 12:15of a jury, irrespective of the rule violation,
- 12:19I think we have a lot of strong arguments and
- 12:21evidence in those types of cases where I've dealt
- 12:23with this to sort of neutralize that what I would
- 12:26characterize as like a ticky tack sort of breach
- 12:29regarding the business and professions code.
- 12:32But nonetheless, it exists. and where it can
- 12:36really cause problems if you don't send it back
- 12:39and then the client raises it in litigation that
- 12:41it's avoidable is with respect to an arbitration
- 12:44provision. If you didn't strictly comply with
- 12:47the rules and there's a petition to compel binding
- 12:50arbitration, I've had numerous courts deny petitions
- 12:54to compel binding arbitration, which were then
- 12:56affirmed on appeal because strict compliance
- 12:59was not adhered to. And so it's just a simple
- 13:03issue. And again, think of it, you've spent all
- 13:06this money, you've got this perfect retainer
- 13:08agreement, it's doing everything you want, it's
- 13:10protecting you, the client's protected, only
- 13:13for it to be voided because you just didn't send
- 13:16that duplicate copy back. I harp on this one
- 13:21a lot because it's such an easy one. And if you
- 13:24have a high volume practice, it's a very easy
- 13:29oversight. And so it's one that you want to have
- 13:32sort of standard operating procedure in place
- 13:35to ensure that your staff members or you are
- 13:39complying with this rule to just send it back,
- 13:43get that duplicate copy there, and then you've
- 13:45taken care of this issue. The next issue that
- 13:51we see a lot is, and it's coming up more and
- 13:55more, is dealing with unconscionable fees. And
- 14:00because rates are getting so high in the city
- 14:03of Los Angeles and presumably in metropolitan
- 14:06areas throughout the state of California, courts
- 14:10are taking a harder look at what is an unconscionable
- 14:14fee. And so, there's a number of factors in play
- 14:18that are listed here. Experience is a big one.
- 14:22And also now I want to point out on the contingency
- 14:25side, and other states have taken a much more
- 14:28hard line with this, which is quick settlements,
- 14:31right? If you're a contingency fee lawyer, part
- 14:34of the one perk of being a contingency fee lawyer
- 14:37is a quick settlement, right? You've got a nice
- 14:3930 % contingency fee, 40%, whatever it might
- 14:42be, and you get a big case and you settle it.
- 14:4510 days into the case or whatever it might be.
- 14:48The California case law is pretty clear that
- 14:50those fees are earned. That's a benefit of being
- 14:54a contingency fee lawyer, because of course,
- 14:56for every one of those cases you get, there's
- 14:5820 where you work for five years and don't get
- 15:01a dollar. And so despite that, I think courts
- 15:06are starting to take a different look at quick
- 15:08settlements, but also setting aside the rule
- 15:11and whether it's proper or not, Dealing with
- 15:16these types of issues at trial in front of 12
- 15:19jurors are creating certain issues that I am
- 15:24seeing. And look, there's nothing that can necessarily
- 15:26be done about it. If you're a contingency fee
- 15:28lawyer, you get a quick settlement and then you
- 15:30end up in litigation. You just have to neutralize
- 15:34sort of the greed component, but that's something
- 15:37that exists here. And again, if your firm's charging
- 15:40a high hourly rate, you really need to make sure
- 15:43that you're overseeing your associates, that
- 15:46the work is not being block billed, that the
- 15:49hours being charged are reasonable for the task,
- 15:52because bills are a very important part of the
- 15:58process and tie directly into the retainer agreement,
- 16:02especially if hourly rates are denoted in that
- 16:04retainer agreement. you're going to want to make
- 16:07sure that there's oversight there. And if you
- 16:10find yourself in a case where you've got a big
- 16:12receivable and you want to go collect it, the
- 16:15first thing that a savvy plaintiff's lawyer is
- 16:17going to do if you're just dealing with a fee
- 16:19dispute is hire a billing expert who's going
- 16:21to go through and chop up the bills based on
- 16:24block billing, hourly rate, skill required, lack
- 16:27of experience, all these factors. And again,
- 16:31you're going to have that huge receivable chopped
- 16:34up 50 % at least. And if there was proper oversight
- 16:38from the outset, you would have potentially avoided
- 16:42that issue. So as we get into the actual terms
- 16:47of your retainer agreement, another part that's
- 16:50really, really important is the scope of representation.
- 16:54We see a lot of cases come up because the scope
- 16:59of representation isn't clearly outlined in the
- 17:02retainer agreement. And what I mean by scope
- 17:06of representation isn't just what you're going
- 17:09to do for that client. What's also really, really
- 17:13important is to identify what you are not going
- 17:16to do. And that's really where the issues come
- 17:19up. For instance, in my firm's retainer agreement,
- 17:21I don't care which version it is, every one of
- 17:24them is gonna say that we don't give tax advice.
- 17:26We're not tax lawyers. I don't know anything
- 17:27about tax law. So when settlement money comes
- 17:30in or we're dealing with settlement, oftentimes
- 17:32questions come up. Is this taxable? How am I
- 17:35gonna get treated with respect to this money?
- 17:38We refer them out to a lawyer who can specialize
- 17:40in that. No guarantees on outcomes is very important.
- 17:45Not to say that if you don't have something like
- 17:47that, the client can say he guaranteed me this
- 17:49outcome. But if you put it in the retainer, it's
- 17:51quite clear that you're not guaranteeing an outcome.
- 17:54And I think it's really important, especially
- 17:56for lay clients, to set their expectations from
- 17:59the outset. Look, we're going to do work for
- 18:01you. We're going to do our best. But we're certainly
- 18:04not guaranteeing a particular outcome. And then
- 18:08the other area where I often see or two other
- 18:11areas where I often see issues is if you get
- 18:13a judgment, whether or not the scope of your
- 18:16retention is going to cover collecting that judgment.
- 18:19And then the other one is if there's a judgment,
- 18:23whether your firm is going to handle the appeal.
- 18:26And if you're silent on those two issues and
- 18:28you go through trial on a particular matter,
- 18:32there can become problems regarding whether or
- 18:35not the scope of your representation covered
- 18:38judgment collection or Appellate work and so
- 18:42I think depending on the type of work you do
- 18:44It's really important to say what you're going
- 18:46to do and then again what you're not going to
- 18:48do another big issue that we see a lot is A single
- 18:54retainer agreement for repeat clients repeat
- 18:56clients are great Some of the best people to
- 18:59deal with but you've got to remember no matter
- 19:02how many times you've been to dinner with that
- 19:04person played tennis or golf or whatever it might
- 19:07be with that client, they really aren't your
- 19:09friend. And you really don't want to let your
- 19:12guard down. And when you start to have repeat
- 19:14clients, we let our guard down, it becomes more
- 19:17casual. One matter turns into two matters, two
- 19:21matters turns into five. And the next thing you
- 19:23know, you're handling a divorce and you do business
- 19:27litigation, okay? You just want to have a single
- 19:31retainer for each matter. And it's not burdensome
- 19:36for the client. Everyone understands that, you
- 19:39know, contracts are part of what we do, and it's
- 19:42the foundation for the relationship. And it just
- 19:45makes it so everyone's objectives are clear for
- 19:49that particular matter. And if you have a retainer
- 19:52agreement that's six years old or two years old
- 19:55from seven matters ago, it's very easy when something
- 19:58goes wrong for that client to say, this agreement
- 20:03Didn't apply to that look at what we're handling
- 20:06Compared to what that retainer agreement applied
- 20:08for if you are gonna have a single retainer agreement
- 20:11Which says this agreement applies for this matter
- 20:14and any other future matters that we are gonna
- 20:16handle it better be It certainly shouldn't be
- 20:20for litigation. It should be for Ongoing advice
- 20:24right if you're servicing a client on an ongoing
- 20:27basis that spans a number of years That's a different
- 20:32thing. And because you're handling the same thing
- 20:36within that scope of representation, some clients
- 20:38that I provide outside general counsel service
- 20:40for, we have a retainer agreement and it enables
- 20:43them to pick up the phone, call me regarding
- 20:46general counsel advice. If it starts to get into
- 20:51a litigation matter, we have a new retainer agreement.
- 20:53I'm separately retained to handle the litigation
- 20:56matter. And we go forward. just like that. Never
- 21:00once have I had an issue with it. And oftentimes
- 21:02I find the single retainer agreements come up
- 21:05in the entertainment context for whatever reason.
- 21:08So if you're an entertainment lawyer and this
- 21:09is something that's part of your practice, I
- 21:12would really try to eliminate it as best you
- 21:16can and just have a separate retainer agreement
- 21:20for each file. Let me just check and see if I
- 21:22have any questions here. If I can figure that
- 21:25out real quick. Q &A we got hold on one sec.
- 21:29I got a few here. So give me a sec Okay AI and
- 21:35your agreement I'll touch upon I think that would
- 21:37be better serve we I've given a ton of AI Presentations,
- 21:41but I'll touch upon whether you need to disclose
- 21:42that Is the signature The signature requirement
- 21:53is required That's another question. So DocuSign,
- 22:00DocuSign is okay, but I don't do it. And I think
- 22:04I sort of have a negative view of DocuSign. I
- 22:09think even though a contract is when you receive
- 22:12it and sign it, you're. deemed to have read it,
- 22:15right? That's well -established California case
- 22:17law. I think everyone in society docusigns things
- 22:21all day long, right? You go to the doctor's office,
- 22:23you sign that little gray box, and you don't
- 22:24even know what you're reading. So I think if
- 22:27you're at trial, you're going to run into more
- 22:29of an optical issue with a bunch of jurors and
- 22:32a client who docusigns something, everyone's
- 22:34going to understand that they didn't read it.
- 22:36And what sympathies may come into play from there.
- 22:39Who knows? So I think for a retainer agreement,
- 22:42just get the wet signature. I know that's asking
- 22:45a lot and that's certainly best practice. That
- 22:48is not, I don't think your retainer agreement
- 22:50is going to be voided because it's a docusign.
- 22:53I'm just going to hear, I'm here to tell you
- 22:55what best practice is. Have I had clients send
- 22:57back a docusign? I'm sure we have, but it is
- 23:00not something that I allow, certainly from the
- 23:04attorney end. And we always try to get a wet
- 23:07signature on a retainer agreement. Other types
- 23:09of documents, of course, I think e -signatures
- 23:12are okay with regarding pleadings and things
- 23:14like that. There's a question about Zoho sign.
- 23:20I don't know what that is. I don't know what
- 23:24that is. So forgive me. There's a bunch here.
- 23:29So, okay. If you hand the fully executed copy
- 23:35of the retainer agreement to the client right
- 23:37away, for instance, if they come and sign it
- 23:39in person, memorialize that. I had a case where
- 23:43a lawyer said, look, we signed it in person,
- 23:46and they walked out with the duplicate copy.
- 23:49Of course, the client disputed that. The court
- 23:52sided with the client. And so that wasn't enough.
- 23:54If you're going to let them walk out with the
- 23:56duplicate copy, memorialize it in an email. Great
- 24:00meeting you. Thanks for sending the retainer
- 24:02agreement, maybe even attach it and say, here's
- 24:04another copy of it or confirming that you walked
- 24:07out with the fully executed copy. That's what
- 24:10you need to do. If you don't memorialize it,
- 24:11I think you're just going to run into a credibility
- 24:13issue. And I've dealt with that. Someone asked,
- 24:16what is the greed component? The greed component
- 24:20is view is basically a plaintiff's attorney convincing
- 24:24a jury that a contingency free lawyer getting
- 24:27a quick settlement and trying to keep the money
- 24:29is greedy. That's the greed component. If you
- 24:33get a $2 million fee after 10 days of work, a
- 24:36plaintiff's lawyer is going to have some impact
- 24:39with a jury that the lawyer trying to keep that
- 24:43fee is being greedy. They didn't really do the
- 24:45work. They didn't deserve the money. I disagree
- 24:47with that completely, and we've dealt with it
- 24:49in jury trials. But it comes up, and depending
- 24:52on the amount of the fee. That's just an issue
- 24:53to be aware of. It was sort of a comment I made.
- 24:57Let me pause on the rest of these questions.
- 25:01because I've got to get through this, and I'm
- 25:03always happy to answer some via email. And then
- 25:10I will point out differences in my advice regarding
- 25:13purely transactional practices. For the most
- 25:15part, for those of you who are just handling
- 25:18transactional work, the fee agreement rules are
- 25:21the same. We handle transactional clients all
- 25:25the time. Most of the matters that we deal with
- 25:28regarding fee disputes of recent are transactional
- 25:30in nature, entertainment, tax, and trust in the
- 25:35states. So everything that I'm saying here applies
- 25:39with full weight to litigation, as it does to
- 25:42transactional. please don't think I'm ignoring
- 25:45one group over the other. I really group retainer
- 25:49agreements in two boxes, contingency and hourly.
- 25:52And so if you're a transactional lawyer, you're
- 25:54gonna fall into the hourly portion of that. So
- 25:58let me jump back in and I'll try to keep monitoring
- 26:01the questions as I go here. Okay, so this is
- 26:10another big issue. I keep saying that all of
- 26:12these are big issues, but. Clients authority
- 26:14over settlement. So it's really important to
- 26:16understand you can point these types of things
- 26:19out in your retainer agreement. That would be
- 26:21a best practice. Certainly doesn't have to be
- 26:24a must, but understanding when it comes time
- 26:27to settlement. It's a good time to pull back
- 26:30out your retainer agreement and make sure everything
- 26:33is covered in there. If you're on the contingency
- 26:36costs, where are those coming from? You want
- 26:39to make sure that you're compliant. and that
- 26:42your client's complying, and that your client
- 26:43understands what's going to happen. But it's
- 26:47important to note in the retainer agreement what
- 26:50decisions the client, generally speaking, is
- 26:53going to make. Our clients really drive the outcome
- 26:56of critical decisions within a case. We as lawyers
- 27:01certainly have authority to make decisions on
- 27:05a day -to -day basis regarding a case without
- 27:07our client's consent. They have a right to make
- 27:12informed decisions on critical issues. I gave
- 27:14a couple examples here. And depending on the
- 27:18type of practice you have, whether that's transactional
- 27:20or otherwise, and depending on your client base,
- 27:23you may want to have more of these types of items
- 27:26identified as examples in your retainer agreement
- 27:29than not. I don't necessarily have very many
- 27:33of these based on the type of business that I
- 27:36operate. And so, again, it's a really important
- 27:40point in time where we see things go wrong, of
- 27:44course, is when settlement comes up. And so these
- 27:51are prohibited provisions, which we have seen
- 27:53in retainer agreements, which have voided retainer
- 27:56agreements as a whole. The attorney certainly
- 28:00can't say, I have exclusive authority to do these
- 28:03types of things. A big one that comes up is that
- 28:07an attorney can settle the case if it's a good
- 28:11offer, if it makes sense, if it's in the client's
- 28:14best interest. If there's any attorney approval
- 28:18in there, you cannot have it. It's just something
- 28:22you can't do. And again, it's kind of shocking
- 28:26the amount of times I give these seminars, say
- 28:28these types of things. And then six months later,
- 28:32we see a retainer agreement come in where this
- 28:36type of provision is against public policy and
- 28:39it's going to be voided. And it doesn't necessarily
- 28:41have to be tied to settlement. And we'll get
- 28:44to some slides regarding withdrawal, I think
- 28:46the next slide. You really don't want to have
- 28:50anything in your retainer agreement where there's
- 28:52sort of an if that, right? You don't want to
- 28:54be conditioning anything you can do on something
- 28:57else regarding the particular matter or the deal
- 29:00that you're handling because it's going to most
- 29:04likely look like avoidable provision. And once
- 29:08you avoid, once there's a avoidable provision
- 29:10in your retainer agreement, unlike contracts
- 29:13in general where you can void out a particular
- 29:16provision or a settlement agreement where you
- 29:17see an integration clause. and a severance clause
- 29:22where the rest of the contract is going to survive.
- 29:25That's not going to happen in a retainer agreement.
- 29:27Either the retainer agreement is going to live
- 29:29or it is going to die. And I think for good reason,
- 29:34courts are going to view it in the light most
- 29:38favorable to the client because we know the law,
- 29:41we know the rules, we drafted the contract. And
- 29:43so if we're going to try to shortcut something
- 29:47or you know, frame it in our advantage in a way
- 29:50that's truly unfair to the client, courts can
- 29:52and should set those aside and they do it quite
- 29:55often. So again, these are easy ones to try and
- 29:58avoid. Same thing with restricting termination
- 30:05rights. This also comes up quite a lot. You want
- 30:10to avoid these types of things. And if you are
- 30:13going to put in what happens upon termination
- 30:17or what could happen upon termination or what
- 30:20could cause a lawyer to want to withdraw. Certain
- 30:23things are okay in our retainer agreement and
- 30:25in most retainer agreements I see and I certainly
- 30:27recommend attorney -client communication is key.
- 30:32Number one. Number two, you as the lawyer are
- 30:35not required to do whatever your client tells
- 30:38you to do. If your client is not listening to
- 30:42you, and not following your advice, you are certainly
- 30:45free to end the representation and withdraw.
- 30:49If that's in a transactional matter, it's certainly
- 30:51easier to do so than if you're in litigation.
- 30:54If you're in litigation, you've either got to
- 30:56get a signed substitution or you got to file
- 30:58a motion with the court. These are pretty clear
- 31:02rules, but it's important again to just accurately
- 31:06frame when it can happen. And so that the client
- 31:10is better informed and claims arise often because
- 31:15attorneys try to withdraw, whether that's in
- 31:18any setting on the eve of a deal closing or litigation
- 31:21or trial date, too close in time to the event.
- 31:25And then the client is abandoned, right? They're
- 31:28sitting there saying, I can't do the work. That's
- 31:31a problem. If sometimes these types of issues
- 31:34come up, at the very end of the matter and these
- 31:37issues can get a little sticky, but you as the
- 31:39lawyer want to have the retainer agreement teed
- 31:42up and drafted in a way that it's been clear
- 31:44from the outset as to when you as the lawyer
- 31:48can withdraw and get out of the representation.
- 31:50If you don't have anything like that, it's not
- 31:52that you can't withdraw. Of course you can, but
- 31:55it's just better to have it clearly identified
- 31:57and the client has signed a document noting that
- 32:00I've read when the lawyer can withdraw from the
- 32:03representation because you Oftentimes, if you're
- 32:06representing a new client, you don't know that
- 32:08person. You think things are going to go fine.
- 32:11You hope everything is going to go great. But
- 32:13then they stop listening to you and taking your
- 32:15advice or demanding that you do things that are
- 32:19against either the strategy that you believe
- 32:21is in the best interest of the client or any
- 32:23other myriad of reasons, and you want to get
- 32:25out. So that's really important to have this
- 32:30just clearly outlined so the client knows what
- 32:33their rights are. if this circumstance were to
- 32:36come up. This is a thing that I didn't use to
- 32:41see at all. And now I'm seeing quite a bit. And
- 32:45I think it's because lawyers are trying to characterize
- 32:48advanced fees as retainers and aren't necessarily
- 32:51doing it right. And this is one that comes up
- 32:54more in transactional settings than otherwise.
- 32:57First and foremost, if you get an advanced fee,
- 33:00it is not it can never be non -refundable, okay?
- 33:04And if you haven't earned that fee when the representation
- 33:08ends, you are likely going to have to refund
- 33:11the balance of the unearned portion of the fees.
- 33:14If you don't keep track of your time, that can
- 33:16become a more difficult issue and you're gonna
- 33:21want to... Avoid that at all costs. So the only
- 33:26time that you can have a true retainer and these
- 33:29are rarer and rarer is if the Client is paying
- 33:33for your availability At at will right like they
- 33:37can call you that you're available. You're jumping
- 33:40on a plane You're doing something and I'm retaining
- 33:43that access. I don't see that very often and
- 33:47so That's can be a real problem And again, I
- 33:51don't know why these are coming up. But again,
- 33:53because of that, I added this slide to note to
- 33:56all of you that if you get advance fees from
- 33:58a client, keep it in your trust account. As you
- 34:01earn that fee, withdraw it from the trust account.
- 34:05But the safest place for that money for your
- 34:07benefit and the client's benefit is for it to
- 34:09sit in the trust account until you've earned
- 34:11that. And when you do, you should have your invoices
- 34:15reflect the hours or whatever work was done to
- 34:18point out the fee's been earned and you can take
- 34:21it out. Let me just try to hit a couple more
- 34:26questions here. Arbitration provisions I'll get
- 34:30to, don't worry about that. I would not, pre
- 34:41-authorizing settlement should not be a thing
- 34:44if I'm following that question. A client can't
- 34:47authorize a settlement when they don't know the
- 34:49number, even if it's a hypothetical, I don't
- 34:51think that's informed consent. I would stay away
- 34:54from that. Jennifer's question regarding settling
- 35:02out from under the agreement. So you're correct,
- 35:07yes. If the settlement, sorry, I don't know if
- 35:11everyone can even see these questions, but the
- 35:13question is, The client may not settle without
- 35:15the attorney. Isn't it intended to indicate that
- 35:17the client shall not communicate on the side
- 35:19with the other side and settle out from under
- 35:21the agreement without the attorney, or excuse
- 35:23me, with the attorney? Yes and no. Number one,
- 35:26I don't think you can prevent your client from
- 35:27communicating with the other side if they want
- 35:29to communicate from the other side. I've never
- 35:32seen that provision and also you can't prevent
- 35:34that. Clients can discharge you and then settle
- 35:38out from under you and then you have a number
- 35:42of rights and likely would be able to get your
- 35:45full contingency fee based on the question. I'm
- 35:47assuming that's a contingency fee issue. And
- 35:51it would either be on quantum Marowitt or another
- 35:53basis. And if it's quantum Marowitt and you've
- 35:55done all the work to get the settlement, I've
- 35:58resolved cases where the full fee is obtained
- 36:00for the law firm based on the work that was done.
- 36:02And that happens quite often with clients who
- 36:04try to get out from paying their lawyer, fire
- 36:07the lawyer on the courthouse steps and settle
- 36:10around and try to keep the fee. It's never worked
- 36:13in matters that we've handled, but it does end
- 36:15up costing the lawyer a little bit of money.
- 36:19Okay. Can the attorney require the client to
- 36:24consult? with an attorney before accepting a
- 36:27settlement, you certainly can do that. That would
- 36:29be an absolute best practice. It's not necessary
- 36:32at all. As long as you've conveyed the good and
- 36:35the bad of the settlement, I don't believe you
- 36:37as a lawyer need to recommend a settlement or
- 36:40recommend a settlement be rejected. Your job
- 36:42as a lawyer is to outline the scenarios of accepting
- 36:46or rejecting a possible settlement. And if they
- 36:49ask you, you can make recommendations. But I
- 36:51don't think you need to step into that world
- 36:53of making recommendations. I've had cases revolving
- 36:57around recommending and not recommending settlements.
- 37:00And I think, again, it's not something you need
- 37:02to do. And it's certainly not something you need
- 37:04to have in your retainer agreement. OK, let me
- 37:10jump back in here. Keeping a credit card on file
- 37:14advisable. That's more of a collection issue
- 37:17if you're to if you're Accepting fees via credit
- 37:20card. You can certainly Keep it on file. But
- 37:23if they don't they really should be authorizing
- 37:27that payment each month I don't think you can
- 37:29issue an invoice and then just charge the credit
- 37:31card because your clients generally have the
- 37:33right to dispute your fees and if Each month
- 37:36and so if you're just charging that could be
- 37:38a little bit of an issue If I hope I answered
- 37:40that question, so Let me pop back in here to
- 37:43where we left off. And again, I'll do my best
- 37:46to track additional questions. All right. The
- 37:59other thing that we see here is withholding client
- 38:04files. You really cannot do it. When the representation
- 38:10ends, the client's file is their property, other
- 38:14than your work product. You can keep your work
- 38:17product behind, but once litigation ensues, if
- 38:20you were to be a defendant in a legal malpractice
- 38:21case, your work product's generally going to
- 38:24get turned over as well. But for purposes of
- 38:26the client file, if there's a demand that's made
- 38:29for it, they're entitled to the original file
- 38:32at the end of the representation. this day and
- 38:34age original file has become a little bit of
- 38:36a difficult thing to understand because paper
- 38:40files don't necessarily exist anymore. So it's
- 38:43really just your digital file on whatever software
- 38:46you're using, iManage or whatever it might be.
- 38:49If you're gonna produce your original file to
- 38:51your client, be based on their demand, make sure
- 38:54you make a copy of it. So for yourself, a lot
- 38:56of lawyers turn it over and then they don't keep
- 38:58a copy for themselves. And then the original
- 39:01file obviously can become tampered with down
- 39:03the line and create issues for a subsequent representation.
- 39:10Just this is kind of just a very straightforward
- 39:13one You also if they haven't paid you you can't
- 39:17say I'm not going to turn over your file As soon
- 39:19as the demands made you have a reasonable time
- 39:21to to provide the file depending on the size
- 39:24of the file a reasonable time obviously can differ
- 39:27you certainly don't have to do it the next day
- 39:29or even the day after You have a reasonable amount
- 39:33of time to prepare it and provide it to the client
- 39:38So in relation to referral fees, which I'm a
- 39:42big fan of referral fees. I think it's a great
- 39:44part of in California we can have and we can
- 39:50get and and Pay pure referral fees. You don't
- 39:54actually have to do work on the case in order
- 39:56to get the referral fee But you've really got
- 40:00to comply with some basic rules otherwise your
- 40:04referral fee agreement it can be voided and This
- 40:08isn't necessarily just a client attorney issue
- 40:11This can be a lawyer to lawyer issue and quite
- 40:15often the disputes that we deal with Aren't lawyer
- 40:18client. They are lawyer lawyer, right? It's a
- 40:21lawyer refusing to pay a referral fee and oftentimes
- 40:25using as a sword rule 1 .5 .1 because it wasn't
- 40:30complied with and courts generally have zero
- 40:34sympathy for lawyers who fail to comply with
- 40:37rule 1 .5 .1 in relation to getting a referral
- 40:41fee by and large because it has nothing to do
- 40:44with the client's recovery. And so if you didn't
- 40:46comply with the rules, you're jeopardizing your
- 40:51referral fee. So number one, and I am gonna kind
- 40:54of walk through this because it's very, very
- 40:56important, the client's informed written consent
- 40:59is extremely important. And if you don't get
- 41:03it, your referral fee is not going to be able
- 41:05to be paid. And it has to be done at the time
- 41:08the referral agreement is executed. There's case
- 41:12law on point where the client executed the referral
- 41:16fee agreement months or years later. They didn't
- 41:20object to it. They just did it too late. And
- 41:22the court held that the referral fee agreement
- 41:24that the lawyer was trying to enforce was not
- 41:27enforceable because the informed written consent
- 41:29wasn't at or near the time the referral was agreed
- 41:32to. You've got to identify the division that's
- 41:34made. You've got to obviously identify the lawyers.
- 41:37You've got to disclose that the client's fee,
- 41:40the client's portion of the settlement is not
- 41:42going to be negatively impacted. They're not
- 41:44receiving less money because of this referral.
- 41:48that both lawyers execute the document. Another
- 41:53issue that I see with referral fees, and this
- 41:55happens to come into play more often on the plaintiff's
- 41:59PI catastrophic injury side, is the referral
- 42:02fee agreement is contained in the retainer agreement.
- 42:06The reason why that is problematic is because
- 42:09the retainer agreement can be voided for a number
- 42:12of reasons. And if you void the retainer agreement,
- 42:15you're very likely also voiding the 1 .5 .1 agreement
- 42:19so best practice in this area is to have a standalone
- 42:24One -page document that is its own contract That's
- 42:29not tied to any retainer agreement or whether
- 42:31you're doing work for that client anymore or
- 42:34whether you've been discharged And it's a nice
- 42:37clean document that exists and when that settlement
- 42:39Comes in you pull it out and you demand the referral
- 42:43fee and you shouldn't have any any issues with
- 42:47that. So this is a really important rule to comply
- 42:52with and a separate document to execute if you're
- 42:56in the world of paying or receiving referral
- 43:00fees. See how we're doing here. Does production
- 43:06of a file Include email communications you had
- 43:10with opposing counsel. I would say yes, it does.
- 43:12It doesn't include internal emails or memos.
- 43:15Again, that's going to be work product, but the
- 43:17client file is going to be defined to include
- 43:20that. You can put a shorter retention period,
- 43:27but you definitely don't want it to be with like
- 43:31a year or something like that. You have an obligation
- 43:33to maintain the client file for a period of time.
- 43:37Sorry, one other question here. Are there standards
- 43:48for referrals of hourly rate cases? It's gonna
- 43:51be rule 1 .5 .1. So if you referred an hourly
- 43:54case and you're getting, I don't know, 15 % of
- 43:58the total at the end of the case, or whenever
- 44:01you break that down, You're just going to have
- 44:04to comply with rule 1 .5 .1. Referral fees certainly
- 44:07can be dealt with in hourly cases just like they
- 44:12can in contingency. They're just more common
- 44:13in contingency fee cases. I have not dealt with
- 44:16a case regarding an hourly referral fee gone
- 44:20wrong. All right. Oops. Excuse me. OK. So this
- 44:27is an issue that comes up from time to time,
- 44:30which is the insurance disclosure. This is a
- 44:34newer rule. If you don't have insurance, California
- 44:38is one of the fewer states that you can provide
- 44:41professional legal services in without carrying
- 44:44professional liability insurance. I hope all
- 44:46of you listening to this have insurance, even
- 44:49if it's $100 ,000 through Lawyers Mutual, who
- 44:52sponsors these programs. Great company. I highly
- 44:54recommend you use them. And I highly recommend
- 44:58you have insurance because if you don't have
- 45:00insurance, uh being sued uh is becomes very expensive
- 45:05very quickly and if you have insurance this is
- 45:08a little bit stepping aside from uh retainer
- 45:11agreements if you have insurance make sure number
- 45:14one you report all potential claims uh at the
- 45:18time of your application i have had a number
- 45:20of people come to me who've been denied because
- 45:23they failed to disclose a potential claim a potential
- 45:26claim is i lost at trial the client was mad That
- 45:31is how loosely an insurance company is going
- 45:34to view that and looking to deny coverage because
- 45:37you failed to disclose a potential claim on your
- 45:40application. The other thing that's important
- 45:42is if you have insurance, is to timely tender
- 45:45the claim. We've had a number of cases where
- 45:47lawyers come to us because they got denied because
- 45:49they didn't timely tender the claim. They thought
- 45:51they'd handle it themselves. They thought it
- 45:53would go away. Next thing you know, it's a year.
- 45:55And next thing you know, they get denied. pay
- 45:58money for this product, use it. If you don't
- 46:01have it, you need to have this disclosure in
- 46:05play. And if it lapses, you need to notify your
- 46:10clients right away. So this is, I think, a rule
- 46:14that comes into play, certainly for sole practitioners
- 46:17who are out there. And again, if this is something
- 46:19you're going to do, it is against everything
- 46:21that I advise to practice without insurance.
- 46:25But this is something you have to put in your
- 46:27retainer agreement. And I've seen it in various
- 46:30retainer agreements along the way. So the next
- 46:34thing I want to discuss, which is it's an older
- 46:38case now. This was the biggest case of the time
- 46:43regarding conflict of interest, advanced conflict
- 46:47waiver deemed to be unenforceable. And I've given
- 46:52a number of seminars on this case and we could
- 46:55talk for at least an hour about it and the implications
- 46:57of it. But it's really important to know here
- 47:01because it really touches on quantum marowit
- 47:04and the guidelines as to how that's going to
- 47:07be treated and it gets applied oftentimes when
- 47:10retainer agreements get voided, and you're stuck
- 47:13now getting in the world of quantum marijuana.
- 47:16So if you haven't read the Shepard -Mullen case,
- 47:19you should read it. There's just a very high
- 47:22level bullet point summary of what it covers.
- 47:27But again, the main takeaway is don't ever have
- 47:30an advanced conflict waiver, because they're
- 47:33generally going to be... unless it's very specific.
- 47:36And then as your conflict changes and evolves
- 47:38over time, you may need to update that conflict
- 47:40waiver when the actual conflict arises. So you
- 47:43have your conflict waiver at the start, and then
- 47:45you're going to modify it. So again, this is
- 47:49the case that's going to void a lot of agreements,
- 47:52and you should know and be familiar with it.
- 47:56That said, it does allow quantum error recovery.
- 47:59And I talked about quantum error a lot. And the
- 48:05case law is pretty clear that even if the violations
- 48:08are severe, whether it be the rules of professional
- 48:11conduct, the Business and Professionals Code,
- 48:14or just California case law, lawyers are entitled
- 48:17to get their quantum arrow in, but there are
- 48:21gonna be things that are going to take away from
- 48:23it. And these factors that are listed here, are
- 48:27the issues that are going to come up that you're
- 48:29going to be dealing with if you're in the world
- 48:31of quantum heroin. And quantum heroin comes up
- 48:34all the time. Once you're a defendant in a legal
- 48:38malpractice case, if you have a cross complaint
- 48:41for fees, it just comes up a lot. And so you
- 48:45really want to be careful if you did happen to
- 48:48take advantage of your client or you were just
- 48:50had your pedal to the metal and were billing
- 48:53over billing. these are the issues that are going
- 48:56to take away from quantum arrow it and certainly
- 48:58the more serious the ethical violations, the
- 49:01more serious the conduct, the more willful the
- 49:04billing discrepancies are, the less likely it
- 49:07is that you're going to get the full value of
- 49:09the services. And again, as I noted at the outset,
- 49:12that sort of starts with the hourly rate. Let
- 49:17me just pop back to our questions here. Okay,
- 49:27text messages, are they part of the client file?
- 49:29I would argue they would be. I would also argue
- 49:32that, or argue, I would also tell you, as the
- 49:36question points out, can an attorney inform the
- 49:37client not to communicate substantively by text?
- 49:40Absolutely. I don't think communicating by text
- 49:43is a smart thing to do other than for routine
- 49:48tasks, dates, scheduling, things like that. But
- 49:51if you're communicating settlement offers with
- 49:53your client, I don't think that's smart, because
- 49:56as we all know when we text, we talk very casually
- 49:59via text. We abbreviate. There's nuance. If you
- 50:04throw in an emoji, it gets even worse. You just
- 50:07don't want to be communicating about anything
- 50:09serious via text message. If you have less sophisticated
- 50:13clients, that can become more difficult. So if
- 50:17you are going to communicate via text, and certainly
- 50:19you can do it, just remember that You need you're
- 50:23the lawyer, right? You're not their friend and
- 50:25you need to do it formally Send a text like you
- 50:28would send an email so it's clear and there's
- 50:31no vague Content in there regarding whatever
- 50:34important issue there is Okay, let me jump back
- 50:38to the presentation here because I'm running
- 50:40a little light on time and again I'll answer
- 50:42any questions after the presentation Okay So
- 50:48this is an issue that's coming into play, which
- 50:53is fees that aren't necessarily contingency fees
- 50:59regarding these business and professions codes.
- 51:02So this is something to just kind of keep your
- 51:05eye on depending on if you handle non -litigation
- 51:09matters, whether or not business and professions
- 51:13code 6147 is going to apply. And we see words
- 51:19in retainer agreements, as you can see here,
- 51:20like hold back or bonus based on a deal, right?
- 51:24If you're getting pieces of the action, A, you're
- 51:27going to have conflict issues. But the question
- 51:30is going to come up of whether this is more like
- 51:32a contingency fee agreement versus something
- 51:35that was hourly. You certainly can weave these
- 51:38components into an hourly fee agreement if you
- 51:41get a kicker at the back end regarding something.
- 51:43There just needs to be informed written consent,
- 51:45and you just need to make sure that you need
- 51:48to comply with the rules. So this is just an
- 51:52issue that's coming up that you should understand,
- 51:55depending on your practice group. And forgive
- 51:59me, I'm kind of going a little fast here towards
- 52:01the end just to make sure we get into a couple
- 52:05other issues. OK, so these, I believe we've kind
- 52:09of discussed this, but this is really The quick
- 52:12settlement slide. I'm going to move on from it.
- 52:16You just need to understand that other states
- 52:19are taking a harder position with respect to
- 52:23quick quick settlements and the state bar has
- 52:26recognized that other states are doing this so
- 52:29they may start to do it and the state bar may
- 52:32take one view of something and the California
- 52:34Superior Court may take another view of it. So
- 52:38if you're practicing in this field, just note
- 52:41that. things may change, but I think until a
- 52:44California published decision comes out on the
- 52:46topic, there's not going to be any issue for
- 52:48you. So these are block bill entries and issues
- 52:52that we see with the bills themselves and something
- 52:57that you're going to see if you look at the bad,
- 52:59the red slide there, which we see all the time.
- 53:02If you're putting commas in your bills on the
- 53:04transactional side or litigation side, it's bad
- 53:07practice. Is it Malpractice? No, it's just something
- 53:11you should avoid because the same task should
- 53:14be separated so that you can see the task, it's
- 53:18identified, there's more specificity, and a very
- 53:22qualified expert is going to have no problem
- 53:24slashing that 5 .5 hours down to 1 .5 hours because
- 53:28you just can't tell what was done there and which
- 53:31one of those tasks took which amount of time.
- 53:35And so best practice here to... Allow you to
- 53:39keep your money when you've got that receivable
- 53:41and you're filing that cross complain You're
- 53:43filing that complaint for fees or your in fee
- 53:45arbitration is to have your bills look like this.
- 53:48Is it more time -consuming? Absolutely. Are your
- 53:52associates gonna give you grief about it? Absolutely,
- 53:55but this is the best practice and This is how
- 53:58you get your money. So if you're the managing
- 54:02partner or you're running your own shop and you're
- 54:05billing with commas and semicolons and things
- 54:08like that, you should try to avoid doing that
- 54:11because I think your bills will tell a cleaner
- 54:13story and the bills will be upheld and you'll
- 54:17be able to collect your money. Arbitration came
- 54:22up in some questions and I definitely want to
- 54:26touch upon. Two issues prevailing party fee clauses
- 54:31and arbitration clauses There is no one -size
- 54:35-fits -all here. It really depends on what you
- 54:39want to do I have clients who do not include
- 54:41prevailing party fee provisions for a number
- 54:44of reasons And it just comes down to whether
- 54:47you want one and whether you need one My firm
- 54:50generally does have a prevailing party fee provision.
- 54:54Obviously, you know the downside of that if you
- 54:56lose You're going to be paying fees if you win
- 55:00you can get fees the one thing that's important
- 55:02to consider I think above all is who are your
- 55:05clients and a and b Are you ever going to collect
- 55:09a dollar from them if you prevail? If you have
- 55:13a prevailing party fee provision and you represent
- 55:16individuals With potentially little to no means
- 55:20you are never going to collect that money. So
- 55:22why have it because if they win you likely have
- 55:25Potential money that's collectible if you represent
- 55:28big businesses, that's a different story, right?
- 55:31They're collectible and it might make sense But
- 55:34if you just have it because you've never thought
- 55:37about it. That's a bad approach. So you really
- 55:40want to think about Whether you want one in your
- 55:44retainer agreement and I think looking at it
- 55:46from the perspective of who your clients are
- 55:48Is the best way to go about it? The next issue
- 55:52here, and I know we're running out of time and
- 55:54this is the end, is arbitration. There used to
- 56:00be this common theme that arbitration was cheaper
- 56:04and it was quicker. And it used to be cheaper
- 56:07and it used to be quicker. That's not necessarily
- 56:10the case anymore. Depending on who your arbitrator
- 56:13is, it can be more expensive and it isn't necessarily
- 56:16going to be quicker. So again, it before just
- 56:19including an arbitration clause in your retainer
- 56:22agreement, think about A, do I really want this
- 56:25to be private? Do I need it to be private? Am
- 56:27I the type of lawyer that I just cannot have
- 56:30any public filing against me and period? That's
- 56:34the case. So be it. The downside of arbitration
- 56:37is the following. We have a tremendously high
- 56:41success rate at getting clients out on summary
- 56:43judgment motions, anti -slap motions and defense
- 56:46verdicts at trial. If you you don't get that
- 56:50in arbitration, okay You just don't get an msj
- 56:53It's not going to happen even a demur on a statute
- 56:55of limitations We get out doing any of those
- 56:58things with an arbitrator is extremely difficult
- 57:00Your case is going to be heard most likely on
- 57:04the merits and you're going to get a decision
- 57:05Certainly we prevail in arbitration quite often
- 57:09as well But we don't have as many weapons available
- 57:12to us. And then of course if things do go sideways
- 57:15in arbitration your right to appeal that decision
- 57:18is much more limited than it is in the superior
- 57:22court. So you really got away whether or not
- 57:27arbitration is important for your firm based
- 57:30on the various needs that it has. And so again,
- 57:35there's no one size fits all and it's a really
- 57:38complicated discussion versus the costs. And
- 57:41benefits because if you don't need it to be private,
- 57:44then honestly, it may not be that important to
- 57:46you. I have some insurance companies that tell
- 57:50their insurers. If you have an arbitration provision
- 57:53before you can invoke it, you have to get the
- 57:56permission of the insurance carrier because insurance
- 57:59carriers are pretty aware that they get good
- 58:02results in the superior court or federal court,
- 58:05wherever it might be, because of motions for
- 58:07summary judgment that attack causations and other
- 58:11things like that. And also, if you don't have
- 58:14a high insurance limit, let's say you have a
- 58:16half a million dollars, then you're going to
- 58:19run into an issue with respect to eroding limits
- 58:22because, again, a private arbitrator can unnecessarily
- 58:27cost money and erode the limits when it otherwise
- 58:30would. So I know that was a little bit quick,
- 58:35but those are generally the issues that come
- 58:37up with two hot topics, prevailing party fee
- 58:39clauses, and arbitration clauses. And I have
- 58:43clients go both ways on it, especially arbitration.
- 58:46And it is certainly for those same firms. It's
- 58:49a discussion that has evolved over time. So just
- 58:53lastly, we've touched on these pitfalls. This
- 58:56is kind of summarizing everything. And you're
- 58:58going to get these slides. So feel free to call
- 59:01or email me to discuss any of these issues. These
- 59:05are the key takeaways for all of you. And then
- 59:11lastly, if you have any issues, feel free to
- 59:14call or email me. And I think I cut it right
- 59:18on time.