Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP108: When Do You Need To Replatform and How Do You Justify The Investment?
Transcript
- 0:02You listen three platform podcast sponsored by down
- 0:05tiant's an API. First headless, CMS and damn
- 0:08Murray platform as part of a in 2022 spring, their wealth of
- 0:11Industry, knowledge and experience.
- 0:12Our audience gives us a fresh perspective on e-commerce,
- 0:15technology and customer experience from a strong voice
- 0:17and headless Commerce Community today.
- 0:20You have the unbridled bridled Joy.
- 0:23Even of listening to me. James Gunn and my co-host.
- 0:25Paul Rodgers. How are you doing?
- 0:27Yeah, I guess I think this is the first one.
- 0:30We've recorded this year, right? Yes.
- 0:32Because the first release of 2022.
- 0:34We recorded in December to get ahead of ourselves.
- 0:37It is it's a new bright year. How is how is the year started
- 0:40for you ever gone mental? Yeah, same as last year, then.
- 0:44Yeah. Really nice.
- 1:00This week was a week of planning and learning ready for next
- 1:03week's chaos to start. So let battle commence and it's
- 1:06a new calendar for us for Content, three platform and
- 1:10happy New Year to our regular listeners.
- 1:11Thanks for tuning back in and a warm welcome.
- 1:13If you're joining us for the first time, we have you going to
- 1:15put you off a world of econ, Wonder, awaits do subscribe to
- 1:19get episode alerts and we'd love you to like us on YouTube
- 1:21Spotify or apple to satisfy our fragile egos.
- 1:25So let's do a tldr what we've covered today.
- 1:27So the topic is, when do you need to read Platform One, what
- 1:30justifies the investment and effort with the key things were
- 1:32going to cover is valid reasons, three platform, building the
- 1:35business case for investment and scenarios.
- 1:37When a company has to Pivot and throw an existing migration to
- 1:40something else. So that's quite an interesting
- 1:42one that set it up. Well enough to reckon pull.
- 1:46Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, I'm sure will Meander down side paths as
- 1:53well as we usually do. So, let's start question - and
- 1:56what are the just for reasons? Why business needs to wrap up
- 1:59every platform? I'll kick up and then we're just
- 2:01going to go to and fro one on common reasons and valid reasons
- 2:04this is. So number one is total cost of
- 2:07ownership is often seems to be a key driver where the cost in
- 2:10terms of the percentage of gmv or in terms of the amount of
- 2:14spend of capex. Not Bates is prohibitive to what
- 2:17the business is able to or willing to spend and it's
- 2:20unsustainable and that's increasing.
- 2:22So even though the revenue might be increasing the percentage,
- 2:24share of the govt is not coming down as it should do over the
- 2:27lifetime. So cost is often And one of the
- 2:30key drivers of why Financial teams and even as teams start to
- 2:34look and reconsider their options.
- 2:38Yeah. And then so I'll go with another
- 2:40one and I think this is the one I'm seeing the most, to be
- 2:45honest is a agility and I feel that everyone a lot of brands
- 2:50that kind of maybe aren't on these stuff Platforms.
- 2:53In particular, I just frustrated while other brands or their
- 2:57competitors are kind of moving faster, introduced a new feature
- 3:00Is by a kind of third parties that don't exist in their
- 3:02ecosystem and I think your point on cost as well.
- 3:06Same principle. I had a call yesterday with
- 3:08someone that is spending a lot of money on their online store
- 3:12but actually don't care about the expense.
- 3:15It's more what they're spending that money on and like it's
- 3:18entirely focused on upgrades maintenance, you know, like
- 3:21discussions around Integrations that probably don't need that
- 3:24level of discussion and like, yeah, if you're very little very
- 3:28small portion, their It is going into new features and
- 3:31optimization and improvements that kind of stuff.
- 3:34Yeah, that's a really good point actually.
- 3:36I have a client where the, the cost of dirt they can do stuff
- 3:39on the platform because the vendors flexible.
- 3:42They've got development team, it's a proprietary system, it's
- 3:45not done through agencies but the issue isn't bility to do it.
- 3:48It's the time to get. What should be just a simple?
- 3:51Well, we have a pre-existing connector, let's turn it on and
- 3:54do some configuration in the back end and that is maybe a
- 3:56day's work to get that up and running versus this is a
- 3:59one-way. Project.
- 4:00It's 4,000 pounds cost rather than 1,000 pounds.
- 4:03And then when you apply that, across all of the elements in a
- 4:06roadmap that are cut, our client wants to push through suddenly,
- 4:08what should be q1 and takes you into Q2 and Q3 so yeah, exactly.
- 4:13Agility is a really good point and the costs associated with
- 4:15that and often the other cost for that in a platform is if you
- 4:20have a platform where it's not so simple to just turn things on
- 4:23because they're pre-built and pre-approve.
- 4:25And so you take like apps within Bigcommerce Shopify, even in
- 4:29shock wave. The ecosystem where actually the
- 4:32pre development and QA Works being done at the code level.
- 4:34So when you turn on your not home to do extensive QA of it,
- 4:38because it's a proven additional feature, having to do all of the
- 4:42Q&A, you pay more to the development unit testing, you
- 4:46pay more in your own uat and actually that slows you down in
- 4:49terms of where you're focusing your time and effort.
- 4:51And then I think link to that, another important one is you've
- 4:55referenced earlier, they limited ecosystem where they don't have
- 4:58the same level of pain. Ships with parties and that can
- 5:02be either development Partners or feature providers, where you
- 5:06suddenly have to go and do a proper scope in project in order
- 5:09to get a capability turn on because there aren't three or
- 5:12four existing Partners in that ecosystem.
- 5:15Yeah, I agree. I think the majority of the
- 5:17reasons can be linked probably back to ecosystem and cost.
- 5:22I think the other one on what you just said about the a piece
- 5:25and like stability don't because if they another like a really
- 5:28good example that is like Like, with the SAS platform, where
- 5:31they've got their standardized payment options, which are
- 5:33available via configuration options, all pre-built pre-made,
- 5:37like maintain platform level. I think that versus paying 50
- 5:41grams, move payment provider. And some of these other
- 5:43platforms is, yeah. Another big kind of example, of
- 5:48some of these things we've already talked about another
- 5:51one. So maintenance patches upgrades,
- 5:54you know, the amount of time and effort on both sides.
- 5:57The deployments all of that kind of stuff.
- 6:00Again, probably one of the biggest ones for me, and I think
- 6:03the most common conversation I've had this resulted in
- 6:06re-platform. Recently is two things.
- 6:08One is all of those costs. Looking at it, bundling it
- 6:12together, maybe of the few additional feature, suddenly,
- 6:14you've got 100 150 Grand, that's really platform.
- 6:18That's the business case. Or the other one is unexpected
- 6:21costs. So, you know, you've got a 20K
- 6:25earmarked for an upgrade and actually suddenly the agency
- 6:28serving 60k, And actually that's one of the frustration that then
- 6:32leads to a real platform and project.
- 6:34And I think that kind of like building of a journey called
- 6:39capex budget or Journal is justifying a large proportion of
- 6:43their and then looking at a free year cost money that's kind of
- 6:47typically where I see a lot of people moving particularly this
- 6:50app platforms at the moment. Yeah.
- 6:52And that upgrade one's interest. I've got friendlies at a like
- 6:57program director Project Lead. I need works with one of the the
- 7:02big I guess, they're still called monolith platforms, but
- 7:06the Legacy platforms are not going to name them, but they
- 7:10have a client is a massive like, you know, 200 million plus
- 7:14complex retailer B2B b2c International.
- 7:17And when they move from the the old version to the new major
- 7:20version, it cost it's taken 12 months to finish the upgrade and
- 7:24it's been a million pound plus because it's not a it's not a A
- 7:31separated like application layer and front end all of the logic
- 7:36that sits in the back and it had to be updated because the system
- 7:39that they've created is so heavily customised and it's
- 7:42taken ages. And the amount of development
- 7:44resource in-house to manage that and do all of the release
- 7:48management the testing and it's slow them down for the business
- 7:50in terms of what they can res. Incremental, new functionality,
- 7:53because they've had to get all the core existing stuff stable
- 7:56in the new version before they can release the new features.
- 7:59And and You realize actually went even when Legacy systems,
- 8:03say yes, we are, we've got headless capability, but
- 8:05actually the logic layers, not, not separated, and therefore
- 8:08anything you've built on top multiplayer.
- 8:10You have to then read it when the underlying logic changes in
- 8:13a new release. Yeah, I I actually had a very
- 8:16similar conversation before Christmas and we're yeah someone
- 8:20was on one of those more Enterprise monolithic platform
- 8:24and it would have cost more to upgrade from their older version
- 8:27to the new kind of cloud-based. More agile, ecosystem oriented
- 8:32version. Which I do believe is the case
- 8:34to a Commerce tools or you know, it would have been 5 10 times
- 8:38more than a big Commerce, Shopper by kind of project and
- 8:42yeah same principle and I think yeah it's probably gonna be a
- 8:45lot of those around actually and that's kind of a year or so as
- 8:49well. Yeah it's okay.
- 8:51I think this is a really important point, isn't it is as
- 8:54if you were on Legacy no matter how much modernization you've
- 8:57done in a second, how much customization you Each time that
- 9:01Legacy system has a major release their.
- 9:04It's a, it's not a simple update, it's a major project and
- 9:07it needs to be, you need to do risk assessment and you need to
- 9:10treat it as a separate project which has a cost stream to and
- 9:13that can slow you down in turning.
- 9:15That is often as you referenced the, The Tipping Point for
- 9:18saying, actually, we really should consider our platform
- 9:21which shows. How is this still the right
- 9:22technology? We're going to spend five
- 9:24hundred grand on this and it's going to take us six months, but
- 9:27we better spending 500 Grand on a new platform.
- 9:29And getting that more, modern text back straightaway.
- 9:33And now another good example I've got is, is closed systems.
- 9:36Where there are certain platforms that have been brought
- 9:41into the market from a retailer who develop their own Enterprise
- 9:45systems. And it's done very, very well
- 9:46and been successful. They then turned ourselves into
- 9:48a Service Company like. Yeah.
- 9:49And the way the Amazon did but it's a closed system and you can
- 9:54customize it. You can't you can't accept,
- 9:57doesn't have separation at API layer.
- 9:59And the extensibility where you can create a custom version,
- 10:02you're on instance, and you are dependent on their road map and
- 10:05their release cycle for added functionality and you can't
- 10:08influence it that heavily. So say, for example, you
- 10:11suddenly decide you want our goalie or a play Vu, as your
- 10:15search merch tool, but that's not what they're using their
- 10:17platform. You can't just get it requested
- 10:20as a, as a project implemented on your instance, that has to go
- 10:24through their internal development, evaluation to
- 10:26determine whether it's the right thing for their overall
- 10:28platform, which is normally biased by what's right for their
- 10:31business model and it can lead to a lot frustrations or people
- 10:35can't use the technology they want to.
- 10:37Yeah. Yeah.
- 10:38So again my next one and this is B, the smaller one, I guess.
- 10:44But again I have this conversation.
- 10:45A lot more but and I match going to combine it with another one
- 10:48but I guess one simplifying. So, you know, they want to
- 10:52maintain less. They want to be responsible for
- 10:55less as a business. They want more sass to And that
- 11:01you know is out is kind of readily available provided as a
- 11:04service and is constantly improving.
- 11:06So like a tech stack essentially built up of that and they want
- 11:09to kind of essentially, build out a tech stack in a more
- 11:12modern way. Yeah, we're kind of things are
- 11:15connected. You can kind of improve
- 11:17different things along the way, or like I said, SAS products are
- 11:20improving long way except her, and I think the other one that's
- 11:23kind of like, slightly connected to that is because just because
- 11:26of the control aspect is the ability to do more.
- 11:29Or internally, that isn't technology-related.
- 11:32So yeah, either kind of own in different parts of platform or
- 11:36or even development, actually, like taking development
- 11:38in-house. That's a big Trend in the SAS
- 11:40space. And I think, you know, suddenly
- 11:42you're worrying more about front and, and less about back.
- 11:45And we've talked a lot about in Housing Development, and it's
- 11:49not an easy thing to do, but I think it's easier with the SAS
- 11:52platform. So I'm later than it is with
- 11:54some of, the more complex monolithic platforms.
- 11:58And, you know, when you have to think about hosting them,
- 11:59Structure and everything else. So that's another big Trend and
- 12:03another thing that's kind of driven real projects as well.
- 12:06Yeah, that's a good point. Yeah.
- 12:08Lines of one of the the we are reside.
- 12:11I was thinking about which is alignment with technical
- 12:13business principles, so often, I'd when I sit down and
- 12:17projects. The starting point is to say,
- 12:19what are your business and technology principles?
- 12:21What do you believe in what then you believe in, how do you want
- 12:23to work? And why, and does your current
- 12:26more platform aligned with that? Or is it providing barriers?
- 12:29Us and all those barriers prohibiting.
- 12:31Yeah, your strategic goals a good example is, I had one
- 12:37premium fashion brand and they were working with a solution
- 12:43that open source have been customized.
- 12:45But they to achieve the functionality set they wanted,
- 12:48they had over thirty third parties or plugged in and some
- 12:51of them were point-to-point Integrations.
- 12:54Others of vision API somewhere just like hacked in and
- 12:58therefore not very stable. Some of those third parties.
- 13:01Then the third party stopped Traders, so they had to swap it
- 13:05out and work out how to manage that project.
- 13:07It wasn't an ecosystem where it was plug and play and easy
- 13:10transferable. You had upgrade challenges where
- 13:14third-party updates their product, it then has to go
- 13:17through a project itself to assess the upgrade version, do
- 13:20that development work. Do the testing and it was, they
- 13:24realize that their web Ops Team of just spending all their time,
- 13:26managing relationships with their parties and not do
- 13:29anything. Proactive.
- 13:30So they're their technology business parental going into
- 13:33platform. Assessment was, we need a
- 13:35ecosystem where we don't have that replicated and we can focus
- 13:39on trade in and growth and not on just making sure that these
- 13:43plugins work. So, sometimes that, that whole
- 13:45kind of operational piece of how do we want to work, can make a
- 13:49current platform that you've got not fit for purpose, or it might
- 13:52be that the platform is fine, but the way the solution has
- 13:54been designed is not, right? And you need to change that and
- 13:56that might mean shift in parliament's.
- 13:58Yeah, I think along side that I've had two conversations
- 14:02recently well and internal teams become a big part of that we're
- 14:05like this kind of complicated like systems kind of
- 14:09architecture approach but the way that everything works is
- 14:13kind of intertwined between agencies third-party products
- 14:17and the internal demon and there's a project that I'm kind
- 14:21of loosely working on which is essentially taking a very
- 14:25complex big bespoke implementation with a
- 14:29particularly Complex Erp integration with not this whole
- 14:32thing just can't move and 13 are in.
- 14:35You know, like a silly go or equivalent shot the buyer.
- 14:38A big comment that just simplifying the whole piece and
- 14:41and the whole process is geared around.
- 14:42Everything is to have standardized.
- 14:44Well-documented documented apis like yeah just simplify the
- 14:48whole thing is that same point I said before but I think from a
- 14:51technical perspective your point is yeah, definitely really
- 14:54relevant. Yeah it is it's interesting she
- 14:57in one of the pods or the few years Like the trigger for
- 15:02evaluating e-commerce platform wasn't eaten e-commerce trigger.
- 15:06It was a back office trigger, so the business was changing Erp
- 15:10and introducing middleware. So yeah, similar to silly going
- 15:14high, pass layer and the current platform they had didn't have
- 15:18any existing projects where that integration of being done.
- 15:22There were no clients using either point to point or through
- 15:26middleware that Erp and that was Perceived as a big risk because
- 15:31of the nature of Erp integration is made.
- 15:33They are massive projects in their own, right?
- 15:35And, and often cause lots of unforeseen headaches so that
- 15:38then triggered, a re-evaluation of well actually is the issue.
- 15:41The e-commerce platform. We've got to move this Erp.
- 15:43It's a global solution putting in.
- 15:47That's the most important system for the business because of all
- 15:50of its touch points. And that then LED them to relook
- 15:53at the market and go and find where there was people with
- 15:56experience of integrating platforms and which platforms
- 15:59Had the best proven deep connections into that.
- 16:02That Erp, I think that actually is relevant to point.
- 16:07We haven't discussed it, don't think we probably both see a lot
- 16:10of as well, which is a big business change and that's
- 16:15amazing money and something let's review other parts of the
- 16:18business, same time the bit of a transformation project or you
- 16:21know, invest in all this money over here actually week on
- 16:24platforms. Very important to look at that
- 16:25as well. I think that's another quite
- 16:27often another reason why people look at real.
- 16:29That for me always more like investing in the econ platform
- 16:33or Channel, I guess. Yeah.
- 16:36And I'm one more that I guess it's it's less critical than
- 16:40some of the ones we talked about special extra for things like
- 16:43cost of ownership and overall solution sign.
- 16:45But the admin tool in that, the business teams have access to,
- 16:49in order to do day-to-day management of the website
- 16:52catalog management updates. Removals trade in merchandising
- 16:57you name it, One of the few clients where they are on a an
- 17:03old Fender, not one of the market leaders.
- 17:06You'd seen like the Gartner quadrants and Forest of waves.
- 17:10Yeah, really nice platform, lots of features, but the admin tool
- 17:13him is so convoluted to do anything.
- 17:15So, setting up a new promotion that wasn't like a half hour
- 17:18job. Like, you're seeing some, if you
- 17:19go into the back end of a shop where a Shopify Bigcommerce
- 17:22cetera, it was taken them up to half a day to set up a simple
- 17:27promotion because they had to go through one particular.
- 17:29The system to create a new promotion, then they had to go
- 17:32through another part of the admin to set up the promotion
- 17:35code to attach to it. Then they had to go to the
- 17:37developer to developers to actually enable that so that it
- 17:40was live and functioning and by the end of that, you've lost
- 17:45half a day, set up a basic promotion code.
- 17:47And if you're trying to every time, you know, if you're if you
- 17:49are a discount driven research a lot High Street is, oh my God
- 17:53you've just lost a shedload of working time doing basic things
- 17:57that should take a matter of minutes today.
- 17:59And that was one of the drivers, it's all.
- 18:01Well actually, the opportunity cost us a stain on this system
- 18:04is X thousand pounds which is in the tens of thousand pounds per
- 18:07year in lost, lost time and effort, anything else.
- 18:14We miss any other key reasons went on projects, you worked on
- 18:17clients. You work with why they start to
- 18:20look at a re platform and a justifiable reason to do so
- 18:23think not necessarily justifiable.
- 18:26But and this isn't this ties into a lot of what we talked
- 18:29about. Because the rationale would
- 18:30probably be driven by a lot more to talk about, but I think new
- 18:33team or team member is a big reason quite often as well.
- 18:36I've had clients where, you know, the business is actually
- 18:39perfectly fine on a magenta or any platform but actually the
- 18:43person's come in and said, you know, last brand I worked out
- 18:46grew from 1 to 50 million in a year on Shopify.
- 18:50Therefore, you know, we need to go move Shopify or, you know,
- 18:53all of this stuff can be much easier and Bigcommerce or
- 18:55whatever else. I think that's another reason
- 18:58not. Always right reason, that's what
- 19:01a question is, it just is it? Okay, let's pick the support
- 19:04because sometimes it's just fine.
- 19:06I was at what would make that a justifiable reason?
- 19:09What happens is the stuff that we talked about really, I think,
- 19:13you know, they need to show a cost benefit or functional
- 19:17benefit or exactly efficiency benefits.
- 19:21And I think before this we talked about potential episode
- 19:24in the future which is I said there was an example of it.
- 19:27Someone I spoke to that with on Shopify.
- 19:29Got sold to dream like perfectly happy growing doing really well
- 19:33as a business good, like brand experience, Etc.
- 19:35Got cells to dream of Magento by another agency because they
- 19:40mentioned the word internationalisation spent all
- 19:43this money. Moving to Magento, tiny team
- 19:45wasn't really the right fit and then now they're probably going
- 19:48to have to write it off and and go back to shop for all like
- 19:51that's on the table. And, you know, that was an
- 19:54example of someone going to the CEO and selling the dream.
- 19:57And I think that also happens quite a lot.
- 19:59A yeah, it's like a be the Panacea for all your business.
- 20:03Woes is to move technology whereas the issues on always
- 20:06technology-based are often processed.
- 20:07I think that's an important thing is when we talk about
- 20:09justifiable in this episode it's not just all Shopify.
- 20:13Could do this better? Or Bigcommerce does this little
- 20:15Salesforce as it's it's it's what are the current business
- 20:18issues? What are the impediments to
- 20:20growth? What are the goals and strategic
- 20:22games? Where a different type of
- 20:24Technology? Gives you an affordable way of
- 20:26achieving that quicker, better more more efficiently.
- 20:29Etc. And that's what justification is
- 20:32and it's for you. Yeah, you're right, it's fine.
- 20:34If somebody comes in with experience for another business
- 20:36of having gone through that transformation thanking
- 20:38articulate that in the context of the current business and that
- 20:40is, you don't have to go through a selection process.
- 20:43If you've already got a solid business case, and you can save
- 20:45yourself a lot of time and effort.
- 20:47Yeah, I'd say and I think so on to your next point, which is
- 20:51kind of very relevant to their. I think it's the other very,
- 20:57there's a few variables and I think as long as As you know,
- 21:00there's a justifiable argument timing I think is really
- 21:03important is always a good time for a business to make a big
- 21:06change Searcher. I think that is really
- 21:10important. Your next point which I had
- 21:13touched on was I've kind of interrupted during just gone
- 21:17AWOL here a little bit. But in terms of kind of sunk
- 21:21projects and a time where that when it's sometimes good to just
- 21:26like, right off a project, I think that's a really
- 21:28interesting way. Because I see that a lot of the
- 21:30moment as well. People have been bested loads of
- 21:33money one. I think they've been made to
- 21:34change in platforms recently. That what would have been an
- 21:38optimal considered optimal best-in-class modern, 23 years
- 21:43ago, definitely not going to be the same now because they think
- 21:46there's more noise about the simplified SAS platforms or
- 21:51potentially more slightly more simpler by headless builds and
- 21:55maybe what people were talking about a couple of years ago but
- 21:58I've definitely seen. Examples of why people have gone
- 22:01into this kind of Enterprise that.
- 22:04Realistically, the mistake was that they hadn't thought about
- 22:09what they needed enough and the pros and cons of different
- 22:13approaching platform going to because they just go on and
- 22:15said, you know, this is Enterprise, it will scale.
- 22:18Therefore, we'll put our money into this and actually, it
- 22:20doesn't mind the team project hasn't been planned properly.
- 22:23They don't have the resources, internally, to even go all that
- 22:26work with an agency to really scope it out properly.
- 22:30And there's one example I have in my head, where they decided
- 22:33to go with this, you know, apis first platform, and then build
- 22:38out, this really complicated technology stack and then well,
- 22:43into the hundreds of thousands, they wrote off and now they're
- 22:46moving to a safe platform. And I think that is going to be
- 22:51quite a common thing that we'll see over the next year or two as
- 22:56well. Where I think for a while.
- 23:00It was seen that the South platforms are too small and they
- 23:03probably couldn't scale endlessly.
- 23:07And then you've got the ones in the middle.
- 23:09There are probably not necessarily with modern people.
- 23:11Don't necessarily believe in a vision lots of horror stories
- 23:15flying around and then you had this like dream approach which
- 23:20was apis burst best-of-breed, you know, micro service is build
- 23:25something that ultimately will scale, but it's probably not
- 23:28necessarily aligned We're some of the smbs have gone down that
- 23:31route and I think that would be an interesting one will see.
- 23:35Now is people kind of essentially building these
- 23:38massive Capital budgets and then backing out of them.
- 23:41Yeah this is an interesting question.
- 23:42Why do some businesses rise of projects and pivot to
- 23:44Alternative it? Is it is it justifiable or is it
- 23:47needs you? And I I've got what I've got
- 23:50Point related to actually because you've been talking
- 23:52about under estimating complexity and the cost and the
- 23:56time frame and suddenly What was a Project to replicate, as is in
- 24:01a new modern, composable stack, or had to stack or however, you
- 24:05want to call it. Is now 12 months in is 500 Grand
- 24:09over budget. They can't get the right
- 24:11resources in its stagnating, it's losing internal buying, and
- 24:16I've seen this in a large fashion brand and, and I've seen
- 24:20it in in other businesses to and the issue is always poor product
- 24:25structure. Yeah.
- 24:28One use one example. I've seen where a technology
- 24:33decision was made by an IT team to go down a particular, a
- 24:37particular vendor, and a particular architecture, but
- 24:40that technology decision was made in isolation of the
- 24:42business functions. So there's no consultation from
- 24:45a operational model and strategic point of view for
- 24:47e-commerce and digital, it was about technology principal and
- 24:51businesses don't exist as technology principles or just
- 24:54business from four to work together and Technologies the
- 24:57enabler of the business vision. And Getting that wrong meant
- 25:00that the wrong you didn't have the right stakeholders set, you
- 25:03didn't have the right project, definition, the technology could
- 25:06have potentially being the right fit.
- 25:09If in scope correctly and the solution design is aligned with
- 25:12business. Need what?
- 25:13It ended up with is a first release of a product which has
- 25:18no meaningful admin function for business users.
- 25:20Do what they're used to doing, they start again?
- 25:22Well, where do I create my campaigns?
- 25:24How do I set up my merchandising rules?
- 25:26How do I go and change my solder here?
- 25:28And all the Stuff. You just get any kind of splat
- 25:32an off-the-shelf mature, e-commerce platform.
- 25:35So yeah, often this is what what?
- 25:36Screws up and then the cost of fixing that is way more
- 25:41expensive than saying been it pivot, go to a proven platform.
- 25:46Yeah, I think nine times Outta ten, this stuff will come down
- 25:49to. Yeah.
- 25:50The client making a poorly informed decision and not being
- 25:54diligent enough or and the thing is I guess the client will
- 25:57always argue. They shouldn't need to do that.
- 25:59What with the right set up in terms of providers but I think
- 26:02this is where and this is probably all of our episodes or
- 26:05at least half come down to this which is if you're going into
- 26:09every platform and project as a as a business, you need to be
- 26:12super diligent and you need to do your kind of research, you
- 26:16know, make sure that you know, you're bringing in the right
- 26:19people to tell you how much planning needs to be done.
- 26:22Because yeah, I mean, we had another client who are pretty
- 26:25big. They've got really small, e-comm
- 26:26team, very non-technical for some reason. they made this
- 26:30decision, independently to move all of their European sites to
- 26:34what is a very new bleeding-edge platform from a bespoke
- 26:39platform, went live 1214 months, later should have been a
- 26:42three-month project, you know, a month later, let's roll back,
- 26:45just because so many of other business processes just weren't
- 26:50considered and they were trying to kind of you know work with it
- 26:53and everything else but it just had too much of a hit on other
- 26:56departments and they have to roll it back and right off the
- 26:58project That probably go and look at re-platforming again in
- 27:01a year. But yeah, I think almost all of
- 27:05it comes down to that like an initial phase, probably pretty.
- 27:08As I phase where you just need to get your kind of ducks in a
- 27:12row and yeah think broadly. Yeah it did going down going
- 27:17down the route of changing technology.
- 27:20Has an impact across the business and although touch
- 27:23Voice have you, understood in the right stakeholders,
- 27:24consulted to come up, will not to move you because what MVP
- 27:28means to an it. He team is different to what it
- 27:30means for business team and then it needs to have a level of
- 27:34oversight governance to be able to tie the two together to
- 27:36create, what is an acceptable scope and then make sure
- 27:39everyone buys into that process. For yeah I don't mean link to
- 27:43that. One of the reasons I've seen a
- 27:44project be burned and an executive team.
- 27:47So right, we're writing it off which unfortunately, sometimes
- 27:50means people lose job roles as a result of it, which is horrible,
- 27:54but one of the reasons is the project if you've lied earlier.
- 27:59Complexity sparring and it moving them away from what
- 28:02they're focused on and diverting from electoral strategy.
- 28:04So they become a technology company rather than the retailer
- 28:08and the executive team don't want to be a technology company
- 28:11suddenly, that engineering function is had to go from five
- 28:14people to 15 people and to achieve what they needed to.
- 28:18That needs another five ten people over the next 12 months,
- 28:20you suddenly see the cost of that side business dwarf, what?
- 28:23License fees and support fees would be.
- 28:26If you took an off the shelf, whether it's SAS or You know,
- 28:29whether it's a Magento solution and in the executive team make
- 28:35that call and say that we're losing our, our strategic focus
- 28:39and that's to the detriment of the overall business.
- 28:42Yeah absolutely it's not probably ties up that one.
- 28:47Yeah. Is there anything else you've
- 28:48seen where there is why people have written off projects and
- 28:52and swallowed that that cost from a justifiable point of
- 28:55anything else we've missed? I think that same point around
- 28:59new people and bias and you know maybe stakeholder not being
- 29:03bought him and just continually creating reasons the right
- 29:06project up in that hole that internal.
- 29:08Peace is another one. I also think sometimes Because I
- 29:12think there's two almost up to types of businesses in my head.
- 29:16When we do these upset, you've got the smaller one and so it's
- 29:18an easier decision to go in the South platforms and you maybe
- 29:21need a bit less preparation. And then the bigger project by
- 29:25as much bigger decision. And there's a lot more
- 29:27stakeholders and lot more factors at Play.
- 29:29It's and I think with the bigger ones, sometimes a project will
- 29:34take years and I think sometimes you get to a certain point and
- 29:37actually it s OK, shit, we went on this or which publishes
- 29:41weren't welcome. Hospice or we've done a let's
- 29:44let's wait 2022 the year of swearing all the podcast.
- 29:47Yeah yeah and yes we've gone down this route, you know we've
- 29:53had to because of all these reasons than actually these
- 29:55platforms over here which would have been much better for us of
- 29:58now suddenly introduced all these features or fixed or has
- 30:01issued and now they're the right rear.
- 30:02Andrew. Yeah I think that's another one
- 30:05that I've seen a bear if it's a two-year build and suddenly
- 30:08there's been a huge amount of improvement in these other
- 30:10off-the-shelf platform and Massive amount of pain going
- 30:14through the build where this more complex technologies that.
- 30:17Yeah. And one other last one for me,
- 30:19actually. And I've seen it all with one of
- 30:22the clients I work with was a change in in either ownership or
- 30:27so, it could be a change in financial aid ship, ivc's coming
- 30:30in with a different strategic Vision or it could be a shift at
- 30:33board level in terms of strategic Focus for business.
- 30:35So the business is an e-commerce letters decided to move and I
- 30:40had one who were moving from an old platform to one of the the
- 30:44more modern SAS platforms but then they business strategy
- 30:49shifted to be more trade, Focus feat, be and less on the retail
- 30:53retail growth of plan to be about seventy percent of the
- 30:56growth of then it's switch to to trade.
- 30:58Now all of a sudden that changed the focus because the platform
- 31:01that they were planning to switch to you and they had
- 31:03already had a project and they were already at the point of
- 31:05signing contracts and had spent time and effort on Discovery,
- 31:10Etc. So not a mass amount of But
- 31:12still cash spent tens of thousands.
- 31:15Well that platform wasn't best in breed for trade.
- 31:18And they had some more advanced requirements around things, like
- 31:22multi user accounts, tiered account, tier pricing volume
- 31:25discount, Co tax and Duty hand, in curated catalog management.
- 31:29All of that jazz, but that suddenly makes us a B2B Focus
- 31:33platform for more suitable and less costly because of the
- 31:38amount of effort to customize, they didn't want multiple
- 31:40platforms. They wanted one platform.
- 31:42To do both trade and Retail and then that that meant that
- 31:44project Focus being shifted. So sometimes it is its strategic
- 31:48changes as some of those are preventable and others are not.
- 31:52That's just the way business evolves.
- 31:54I would, I would say that's a huge trend of moment.
- 31:57I chat, a really good point. So three of our clients have
- 32:00been required new companies in the last three months.
- 32:04We've had other clients are, like, either take investment
- 32:07from private Equity, Firm or VC or whatever.
- 32:10And then others are like looking at And part of a rollup except
- 32:13charts and all of those have had some level of.
- 32:17I think, all of the parent, organizations have dictated the
- 32:21platform or wanted to do a lot of private Equity firms.
- 32:24Nowadays will have some level of agreement with a Shopify or some
- 32:28of the big platform companies. And all of the brands are go
- 32:31into a lot of organizations who have a multi brand magenta
- 32:35mentation and they'll just pull people in use the kind of theme
- 32:39structure. I used a whole kind of back end.
- 32:42And then just like essentially style up in line with brand
- 32:46etcetera. Like, there's I think there's a
- 32:48ton saying the sails for sailboats, have a lot of like
- 32:50group groups under there under them.
- 32:56Yeah. And I can that's actually
- 32:57massive do that is actually such a really topical one moment
- 33:02because there's just so much Ma and they become space.
- 33:07Yeah, good point. Let's move on to our third and
- 33:09final question. How do you build a business?
- 33:12For change. So regardless of what's driving
- 33:14the change, how do you build a business case for investment and
- 33:18validate that? There's a reason for doing this.
- 33:20So I think we probably already on system away from my
- 33:24perspective I think usually people will quite often people
- 33:27try and demonstrate a saving over a period of time by
- 33:31migrating and they also show an additional benefit, sometimes it
- 33:35would be if someone's got specific goals in terms of
- 33:38features functionality you know grown deep sea excetera.
- 33:42We're trying to demonstrate how things would be delivered faster
- 33:45on another platform. Other times, it might be like
- 33:49specific business goals and international version, or
- 33:51whatever else and kind of just buying it by that.
- 33:55Yeah, they're probably my biggest ones that cost being the
- 33:57most common. Yeah, I think that's thing.
- 34:02And it's getting the detailed onset.
- 34:03Of course. World are often people don't
- 34:06think enough about the cost model as it is and the customers
- 34:10as it will be. I compared them where they might
- 34:13have new costs to think about and where they might be able to
- 34:17avoid costs in the future. So few examples that is got
- 34:21license fees, he might be moving from licensee To None.
- 34:24I seen this where we're cost model for Magento investment was
- 34:28based on using open source and not having a license fee and
- 34:30suddenly saving 80 grand a year from the existing one that could
- 34:33be spent on additional development.
- 34:36Work, that was needed to get the open source when he needed to.
- 34:40But you then also got internal, Cost to use a platform like how
- 34:43much time and effort does it take your team to do stuff
- 34:46currently on the current platform and how much time
- 34:48effort, can you save? Because the new platform, it's
- 34:51got better admin tools, it's got better automation.
- 34:53It's, you know, it's set up better to deliver what the
- 34:56business needs or it's got better, third-party tools with
- 35:00pre-existing connectors that can save you, time and effort doing
- 35:02things. All of this stuff is to achieve
- 35:05the functionality. You need how much time and
- 35:08effort. Is it one versus the other?
- 35:10It's a really important. On cost to think about and to
- 35:15many people, don't they just look at the, the the obvious
- 35:18cost. What's it cost to develop?
- 35:19What's the license fee wants to support maintenance?
- 35:22Yeah, yeah yeah. Yeah.
- 35:24And I think the other one is picking as a lot of bundling.
- 35:31I see a lot of bundling to justify that and maybe there's
- 35:34other projects going on in the business.
- 35:36It might be like a me as an example or yeah.
- 35:39Looking at Integrations and because I think there's as you
- 35:42that there's often a lot of opportunities within other
- 35:45projects that happening to try. And you know where you've got
- 35:47expensive by the upgrades, we talked about maintenance,
- 35:50overheads unexpectedly, high costs through, you know, project
- 35:54or a new feature, Etc. And then putting those together
- 35:58building out a bigger project. I think over I'm like a massive
- 36:02Banner building capital projects than just pulling laser scope to
- 36:05get because I think it's more efficient in terms of like how
- 36:07you test, how things are released ever been girls.
- 36:11And I think a People try and do that quite often.
- 36:15I think it's easier to swallow. If the cost is part of a bigger
- 36:20plan will cost. Yeah, I also like looking at the
- 36:23opportunity cost so the opportunity cost of not moving
- 36:26if you know you have inefficiently example that
- 36:28client of reference earlier who's on an old proprietary
- 36:30system and to do simple things like adding marketing tracking
- 36:33tags, which topics God, you should be able to do it
- 36:36yourself. You should be able to drop those
- 36:38into the site without requiring any better and they wanted to
- 36:41see, Add certain third-party tracking tags, it's going to
- 36:44cost him a few thousand pounds, which crazy.
- 36:46So you look at all of those that you look at your road map for
- 36:49the next 12 to 24 months. Look at everything, where you
- 36:52can't self-serve and you look at what you could sell Servo and
- 36:56what the cost of doing it in the existing one is and it's
- 36:58amazing. I've done some projects with
- 37:00suddenly you identify a 20 to 30 grams worth of cost per year for
- 37:05doing the things that you should be able to do with your own time
- 37:08or a much reduced cost. And all of a sudden you find
- 37:11there's a big We'll save it in there which helps you with your
- 37:13business case and also their there is an emotional business
- 37:17case, it is the financial one that needs need validators, that
- 37:20get signed off by the executive team and the financial director.
- 37:25But there's also the emotional one of your team will and you
- 37:29will the new platform, give your team.
- 37:30A better set of tools that they can be more effective, more
- 37:32efficient happier, you can give them better job enjoyment, which
- 37:37means hopefully they'll stay for longer and you get a better more
- 37:39productive e-commerce environment, focused on positive
- 37:41outcomes. And it's hard to put a number to
- 37:44that, but you can certainly put an emotional value and that's
- 37:47equally as important because you want your eCommerce team,
- 37:50functional efficient and happy. Yeah, I think the other Trend
- 37:54I've seen recently which is not a good one.
- 37:57Is people recruiting senior econ, managers head of becomes
- 38:02an action. He's they don't want to work
- 38:04certain technology stuff and people I have jobs where I've
- 38:08said to people, you know, this could be a really good fit for
- 38:10you and I That was the Technologies which is, you know,
- 38:14not going to be super common. But it certainly that, you know,
- 38:17if you go into a job as a head of econ, you want to be able to
- 38:21do stuff quickly and grow Revenue in particular.
- 38:25And I think that platforms and technologies that probably does
- 38:29tie into that. Yeah, that's a really good
- 38:32point. And actually links for some of
- 38:33the other point you made earlier which is if the business is
- 38:36deciding to build out cell, internal engineering function
- 38:38and wanting to control more elements like front end.
- 38:41Development. Yeah.
- 38:42The whole ux Leo doing that, where there is a rich pool of
- 38:49developers with experience of that technology out there is
- 38:52going to be a lot easier for you to achieve that goal and if you
- 38:55are on a platform where actually it's such a close Community, the
- 38:58you're going to very quickly Source ability to to get Junior,
- 39:02mid senior developers. So, yeah, really really good
- 39:05point about that is, is, do you have a technology with an
- 39:09ecosystem that gives you the resources?
- 39:12You need a month? Yeah, absolutely.
- 39:15Anything else we've missed. I'm trying to think of the other
- 39:18things about building, a business case for change money
- 39:20money and return investment. Clearly number one, operational
- 39:25efficiency, and ability to execute against your strategy.
- 39:29To number, to efficiency, and tooling, for e-commerce teams,
- 39:35that they actually have a job. They can do and enjoy and focus
- 39:38on value, added three. And then the ecosystem and
- 39:41Bility in alignment with your what you're trying to change
- 39:44business number for anything else, but not for from probably
- 39:48cutter that I was just thinking about ones where maybe you've
- 39:51got like a more you're trying to achieve a more complex, you
- 39:54know, subscription blur or order management capability or
- 39:58International banking else falls into that luggage or form.
- 40:02But yeah, I think so. Maybe they're probably the
- 40:04underlying reason or most common ones.
- 40:07Yeah, cool. Well, that brings us the end of
- 40:10this episode so Actually it's been useful, giving people a bit
- 40:13food for thought, we'd love to hear what your takes are.
- 40:16You know, if you've got anything to add, if we have, we missed
- 40:18anything. What are justifiable reasons why
- 40:20businesses need to very powerful and do re-platform?
- 40:24You know, how do you build a business case?
- 40:25Please do like wherever you're listening or watching at the
- 40:30comments, message me and pull on Twitter LinkedIn would love to
- 40:34hear from you. We don't think we know
- 40:35everything always open to learning from other people, and
- 40:40thanks for listening. Keep an ear out for The next
- 40:42episode, they'll and every Tuesday and let us know of any
- 40:44topics you love us to cover, but do tell us why.
- 40:46So, we understand the context rate, subscribe if you haven't
- 40:49already. And we'd love a rating.
- 40:51If you've liked this episode and 38.
- 40:54Hopefully, we'll see you all again next week for the next
- 40:56episode. More information on this topic,
- 41:06head over to re-platform dot. F m, for our audio podcasts to
- 41:09discuss a project or if you'd like to chat about any of the
- 41:12topics covered in this episode in more detail.
- 41:14Please reach out to myself, James curd and my co-host.
- 41:16Paul Rogers via LinkedIn and Twitter.
- 41:18Thanks again for listening and keep your ears peeled for the
- 41:20next episode.