Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Terminally Unique: Is AI the Greatest Gift or Biggest Threat to Authenticity?
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:21This is I Love you. Keep Going.
- 0:23It is April 11th, 2024 at 7:36 PM Pacific Daylight Time, and
- 0:30what I was thinking I would talk about tonight is AI.
- 0:35Maybe you've heard about it lately in the news from it being
- 0:40the next thing ever to being the destruction of our way of life
- 0:48seems to be the the two poles of the discussion.
- 0:54I thought I would relate it more to practice and also to some of
- 0:58the things that we talked about here routinely, which is
- 1:03perception of things that are actually happening and also
- 1:06authenticity. One of the things about relying
- 1:12on media for most of the stuff that we understand about the
- 1:15world is some suggestion of the veracity of it, the
- 1:22believability of it, it actually representing something.
- 1:27And then as we move into this new era where the technology is
- 1:32such that really pretty much anything can be faked.
- 1:36At this point, how do you believe actually what what's
- 1:41coming in from the world? I am actually old enough to to
- 1:52remember a world where there was no television.
- 1:58And I remember very fondly the the 2 tone zenith, which was our
- 2:02first black and white TV which had the UUHSI think it's UHS,
- 2:09isn't it? There was, there was the
- 2:12channels that you could click on to and there was also like a
- 2:15tuner that you you you use like the radio to tune in to high
- 2:19frequency stations for the the more local less less national
- 2:25stuff. And I remember in 1964 my my
- 2:31grandmother, us my father's mother bought a color television
- 2:39which was considered a, a, a, an extreme, a luxury item.
- 2:44And back in those days the the tubes were not square.
- 2:48They were round. Of course it didn't matter
- 2:54whether they had a color television or not because almost
- 2:56everything was broadcast in black and white.
- 2:58It was quite unusual to to have a show broadcast in color.
- 3:06When she died we inherited the TV and and really the only show
- 3:10that we could watch was Garfield Goose, which was a children's
- 3:15show which came on after school like the the first television
- 3:21babysitter. And they had a a program on
- 3:26there that really shaped my whole life, which was called
- 3:30Fractured Fairy Tales. I don't know if you remember it
- 3:32as a cartoon, but it it took very standard rims type fairy
- 3:40tales and just completely put them on their head, which I
- 3:44found hilarious. And we had the news cycles and
- 3:49we had these these established reporters like Walter Cronkite
- 3:57that would speak to the nation from one of our three channels
- 4:01and and people generally thought of him as telling the truth when
- 4:11Reagan came to office. And I you may not know this, the
- 4:18requirement that the news tell the truth was let go of because
- 4:23of free speech claims. Apparently lying on the news was
- 4:33a violation of free speech. At least that's how the courts
- 4:36held it. And so we don't have that
- 4:39requirement anymore. So we but we didn't change the
- 4:44name of news to opinion, which would have been helpful, I
- 4:48think, distinguishing it. And then as the computer
- 4:58manipulation of media came along and the clumsiness of it,
- 5:04usually if you looked closely, you could tell the difference
- 5:07between what was authentic and what had been manipulated.
- 5:11Certainly if you could think about it, the the news as it
- 5:16came through, people had reputations of relaying the
- 5:25truth and and other forms didn't.
- 5:29Of course, the libel laws in the US are very light.
- 5:36Let's say there is no defense against it.
- 5:41Really what there is is discernment, which we talk a lot
- 5:46about in the meditation world. Discerning things that are
- 5:49really happening from things that are not happening or
- 5:53discerning the sensing data and understanding what the sensing
- 5:57data is and then understanding the meaning that we attach to
- 6:01it, which creates the experience of reality.
- 6:06And I think you'll see the effect amplified really in that
- 6:12we don't take in a survey of everything that's happening.
- 6:15We take in this highly curated selection of the things that are
- 6:22meaningful to us, rejecting the things that are not meaningful
- 6:25to us. So we often leave them out.
- 6:29And in this highly curated selection of the things that we
- 6:33pay attention to, we assign meaning to that highly curated
- 6:38selection. And the meaning that we assign
- 6:41to it is rooted in this, in this high level of selection.
- 6:47And then we create the sense of reality from that.
- 6:50So our sense of reality is really embedded in our
- 6:56experience and the meaning that we hold to it.
- 7:02But now what you're what we're finding with this first launch
- 7:07of AI and artificial intelligence that the capacities
- 7:17simply discern based on what's being presented to us as real or
- 7:23not real is is going to be lost. I it just popped into my mind in
- 7:30the in the mid 80s I was a systems analyst and my job was
- 7:38to go into corporations and take at that time the model was 5
- 7:47employees per manager and when the the micro computers came in
- 7:52and and you could link them via networks move away from the
- 7:58mainframes the the corporations largely had the idea to save
- 8:02money that they would compress the middle management by
- 8:06requiring each manager to manage eight people instead of five
- 8:11people. And I would come in and do an
- 8:14analysis of the structure of middle management and who was
- 8:19formally talking to who and who was informally talking to who.
- 8:25And part of my instruction for developing the capacity to do
- 8:30that was an early exploration of AI, artificial intelligence and
- 8:37understanding that the, the, the level of computing power that we
- 8:42had was not even close to being able to to do that.
- 8:49I don't know if you remember Alan Turing, but the Turing test
- 8:55was, could a computer engage you in such a way that you couldn't
- 9:00tell that it was a computer, that you would actually think it
- 9:03was a human? And I think we're really getting
- 9:06to the point now where that's gonna change, that you won't be
- 9:09able to tell that you're talking to a computer, that the
- 9:15processing speed will be fast enough and the the the large
- 9:19language models be predictive enough.
- 9:23But then where does that leave us?
- 9:25If you can just say what you can do now is say ChatGPT, write me
- 9:32100 Ikus and then in 2 minutes you'd or 40 seconds or 20
- 9:38seconds you'd have 100 Ikus. You might try it as an
- 9:44experiment. Some of them are pretty good.
- 9:46A lot of them are not. They do understand the rules
- 9:50really well, which I notice it when writing haikus.
- 9:53A lot of people don't. You have one sentence of of
- 9:57seven syllables. Is it 575?
- 10:01I guess it's 5755 syllables. The second sentence, which is
- 10:06not related to the first sentence, which is 7 syllables,
- 10:10and a third sentence, which is five syllables, that ties the
- 10:13two sentences, The first two sentences together.
- 10:17That's the the, the task. My friend James Merrill said to
- 10:35me that when computers came out that there was going to be a
- 10:39glut of terrible poetry that we were going to have to endure.
- 10:43And if you think there's going to be a glut of terrible poetry
- 10:51from just a word processor, imagine what it's gonna be.
- 10:55Now with AI we use a perplexity and we just type in a a prompt
- 11:03and it creates a text Christian. George, I wonder if they created
- 11:15like a reverse Turing test. I feel like most people.
- 11:19I feel like people ongoing are gonna start being able to pass
- 11:22that more and more like it's gonna people instead of the A is
- 11:27being more like people, the people are going to be more
- 11:29like. A is like.
- 11:32The little R2D2, and they had a little guy in there.
- 11:35It's just going to be like little little guys in in robots,
- 11:39in robots suits. The reverse Turing test is can
- 11:43you tell if it's a human right? Yes.
- 11:50I think I could out AI in AI. Well, at this point, certainly
- 11:55maybe what I notice in doing it, and I think that this is one of
- 12:01the things that I think will save us is that because it's
- 12:05averaging, it's generic, people aren't like that.
- 12:12And So what I really look at AI is doing is pushing us back into
- 12:17the quirkiness of individuality that we we we've lost in a way,
- 12:22because everything is so homogeneous.
- 12:30What's coming to mind at the moment is I the last time I was
- 12:33in London. This is, I don't know, maybe 5
- 12:36or 10 years ago I should say. The last time I went shopping in
- 12:41London I went to the King's Road and it used to be one of in the
- 12:4580s. It used to be one of the great
- 12:47pleasures of shopping because the the culture was not
- 12:55international in the way that it is.
- 12:57And you would find these very local designs and these local
- 13:00products and shoes made in the UK.
- 13:05And I don't know if you've ever had a thing for English shoes,
- 13:09but they were just these wonderful objects, all sorts of
- 13:14styles. But that I went this particular
- 13:18time, I couldn't find any English shoes.
- 13:19The closest thing I could find were Italian shoes, and the most
- 13:23popular jacket on the street was a North Face puffy jacket.
- 13:28And it was so disappointing that the homogenization of the of the
- 13:34culture and the franchising of everything, Yes, you can get a
- 13:40cup of coffee at Starbucks and it tastes very similar to a cup
- 13:43of coffee in Starbucks anywhere you go.
- 13:47But all of those that quirkiness that in that uniqueness that
- 13:51comes from the local involvement of people is, is lost in that.
- 13:58And I think that we are going to be bored out of our minds by the
- 14:03generic quality of everything. AI is the thing that creates it,
- 14:08and it's going to push us to react against it in a way, and I
- 14:16don't know whether that will solve the dilemma of
- 14:19authenticity or not. Maybe it will just enhance our
- 14:24capacity to pretend, which is also possible.
- 14:31Christian. When I used to go to Poland as a
- 14:35kid, they would have like shirts with American writing on them
- 14:40and they'd be like, just total. They'd be just this delightful
- 14:43nonsense. And then a couple years later, I
- 14:46went back and like all of that stuff was gone because they had
- 14:49gotten hip to it. Couple years later the IT was
- 14:54like quirky and they were trying to recreate it but they already
- 14:58knew too much and like it wasn't.
- 14:59It wasn't the same. Yes, Yael, I'm glad that you're
- 15:10already bored with the generic quality of AII think I am too,
- 15:14which is one of the things that led me to this conversation.
- 15:23The thing that we want as human beings, and this will not be
- 15:27solved by AI, is to allow trusted people to see us, to
- 15:35really see us, and to really know us.
- 15:39And we want to be able to know that we have an effect on the
- 15:42people that we love, that are close to us, that that our
- 15:47experience matters. And then we want to be able to
- 15:51explore us in ways that we derive meaning from and not as a
- 16:02distraction, not as a simulation really in actually engaging in
- 16:12activities that we find meaningful that are that are
- 16:16that create some challenge in discovery for us in exploration.
- 16:22And then we want to be able to come back and express what it is
- 16:26that we've discovered about this wild, unique life we have and we
- 16:36want somebody else to do that for us.
- 16:38And so that there's a synergy around these, these primary
- 16:43paths of exploration with the people that are close to us.
- 16:48And this is the thing that matters really.
- 16:54I'm not sure how much it would matter to explore these
- 17:05artificial environments. I know that the the idea that we
- 17:11we are going to upload and merge with a computer and and our
- 17:16entire life will be this interaction of code and that we
- 17:21won't have the body that we live in.
- 17:23And I I somehow I I so thinking I want my body.
- 17:28I don't care that it's aging and and changing in that way.
- 17:34I'm I like the experience of being in a body and I I find the
- 17:39the while sometimes dopammergic is the word that I really use
- 17:46about computer games and that kind of stuff.
- 17:49It feels in the end like a distraction in something that
- 17:52doesn't have meaning. Really it's a distraction from
- 17:57the pursuit of meaning. And we live in, in such a
- 18:03challenged time because of the the way that we have allowed
- 18:09really the order of power to distribute resources, the
- 18:24economic system that that externalizes costs, it's a way
- 18:29of making a profit. It's an amazing thing.
- 18:34And I think what's unique about this time is that the the
- 18:40addition of climate change, which is really out of our
- 18:44control is going to happen and then we're going to have to
- 18:50respond to it. I I think the that fateful
- 18:56moment when we pass 1.2°C has already happened, even though I
- 19:01know it it the press, they talk a lot about when it happens, but
- 19:06it seems to have already happened and so you have that.
- 19:14It's almost crazy making, isn't it?
- 19:16The way that the the world is represented in in the media that
- 19:22we experience And then what what is happening?
- 19:30You know the the Biden demand for a ceasefire, which was
- 19:35followed the next day by the delivery of a massive amount of
- 19:39new arms, makes makes it kind of crazy.
- 19:50If you can learn the type of prompt, which is a new skill
- 19:54that we're all going to have to develop into your AI, you can
- 19:58represent anything there, really.
- 20:02I was getting ads for these. If you want to make a video, all
- 20:09you need is a text and you can type in.
- 20:14You can upload the text and select who you want to speak it,
- 20:17and you can select the voice you want them to speak it in and
- 20:21then create a video where they're actually.
- 20:24Speaking the text as if they had performed it for a video, What
- 20:38will happen when, when our orientation toward the way that
- 20:44people look are these very homogeneous, perfect looking
- 20:50people on the screen? How will that be for the rest of
- 20:54us actual humans? I'm fascinated to see how that
- 20:59happens and who's real and who isn't.
- 21:02And of course, with deep fakes, anybody can be doing anything or
- 21:08saying anything in pretend mode. Of course, this reaction to not
- 21:20being free to be authentic because of the fearfulness
- 21:23around that authenticity, that expression in the acceptance of
- 21:27who you are, people who use inauthenticity and people who
- 21:36use pretend mode suddenly have a vast array of tools to really
- 21:43amp that, that up in terms of the way they represent
- 21:47themselves. Will it get to the point where
- 21:52we're, we're simply having avatars relate and we are.
- 21:56We are not there. I I think that there was a movie
- 21:59about that. What do you think?
- 22:13I think more and more I like my body.
- 22:15I like interacting with other bodies.
- 22:18I like the uniqueness, the the unpredictable expression of
- 22:24other people that engagement. And can we then use AI as a tool
- 22:39that is actually going to hands things?
- 22:42I'm not. I'm not so frightened about the
- 22:46computer systems themselves, but people are still frightening,
- 22:52and people in relationship to these systems can be quite
- 22:56frightening. There is of course in the in the
- 23:04body politic at the moment, a question about the veracity of
- 23:13things. Things that to me seem
- 23:15completely obviously not true are embraced, and they seem so
- 23:25obviously not true to me. I have a a hard time believing
- 23:28that people who embrace these ideas do so because they believe
- 23:33the idea, not because it's a it's useful to them in some way.
- 23:40So in Buddhist practice and in this idea of liberation, this
- 23:44idea of enlightenment, really what we're attempting to do is
- 23:48to come into a place where we experience what is happening and
- 23:55we're free not to get caught up in misrepresentations of things
- 24:02and by knowing ultimate reality. Ultimate reality, of course is
- 24:08the things that we sense, and conceptuality is the meaning
- 24:14that we assign to it. But what end is that?
- 24:20What end is that? Seeing things clearly, sensing
- 24:26them clearly, understanding what's happening?
- 24:29The discernment between what is real and what is it real isn't
- 24:34so much the the factor, but the discernment of what you
- 24:38understand is happening and the meaning that you assign to it.
- 24:43And always this bouncing back between self and world, Self
- 24:48being the experience that you have in the world being the
- 24:50people that you surround yourself with.
- 24:54We already live in a world particularly in we're mainly in
- 25:00affluent societies where the the social social isolation is
- 25:07extreme, the loneliness factor is extreme.
- 25:18The Aloe Aloe family system has been lost in effluence.
- 25:23I think in that multiple generation requirement of
- 25:30participation so that we can get along in the world has been lost
- 25:35in effluence. I was hanging out with a 5 day
- 25:45old child last week and it was quite marvelous to see that that
- 25:52beginning where we all began, that that little baby, the
- 26:00experience of the world outside of that, the body, the wonder,
- 26:10you could see very clearly in the in that infant, the wonder
- 26:15of everything fully operational. And I think that's one of the
- 26:20things that we can lose easily enough in this process of
- 26:25isolating ourselves in this inhibition to express
- 26:30authentically what our experience is.
- 26:35This goes back to that early attachment conditioning.
- 26:38Of course you can't survive as a five day old baby without
- 26:42somebody attending to you. And it takes quite a long time
- 26:46for human children to get old enough where they can make their
- 26:50own way. We might underestimate that.
- 26:54I I remember watching documentary footage of children
- 27:02in Brazil and in the slums and, you know, as young as three or
- 27:09four years old, as part of a pack of adultless children
- 27:14managing the world. We turn toward the caregivers
- 27:28not only to receive the physical care for the body that we need,
- 27:33but also to understand ourselves in relationship to the world.
- 27:39And the early basis of that understanding comes from that
- 27:43original interaction. And we create this working model
- 27:47of ourselves and who we are, what our capacities are.
- 27:52And we create a perception of the world, what we can expect
- 27:56from the world, based on how that interaction happens.
- 28:06If somebody comes well enough and attends to us well enough
- 28:12and reflects back to us the the delight of our beingness, we
- 28:18create a whole model of ourselves as this marvelous,
- 28:21delightful, lovable person. And we create this expectation
- 28:27of the world as this loving, safe place where we can thrive,
- 28:37where we can express who we are. But if that doesn't happen, of
- 28:46course you create these other views, the dismissing view,
- 28:49which is that nobody will take care of you.
- 28:52So you have to take what you want.
- 28:55The preoccupied view that I need to pretend to be helpless in
- 29:03order to get people to pay attention to me.
- 29:06The disorganized view is that people will harm me, so I need
- 29:10to keep myself at a distance. Now imagine just typing a prompt
- 29:23into AI and creating these very compelling representations.
- 29:28All that be kind of interesting to see what happens Christian.
- 29:35George, you know there's already AIIPF resources now.
- 29:41Are they really? They're all right.
- 29:43I didn't want to. I didn't want to look.
- 29:45I didn't want to see what it what it was.
- 29:48But I was like, all right, well, I guess there there goes, there
- 29:53goes my usefulness. Oh, I think you're safe,
- 29:58actually. I think I am too.
- 30:01I am too. Please.
- 30:10This is a plea from over here. Hold on to your uniqueness as a
- 30:18person, as a people. It's a group of people.
- 30:22I don't. I don't think you'll have any
- 30:25choice about it. But the the process of ideal
- 30:33parent figure protocol is this guided meditation where you, the
- 30:39facilitator, takes in the representations of self and
- 30:44world that the person generates in response to prompts and
- 30:50guides the visualization toward a sense of security in the
- 30:56world. But people's representations are
- 31:00really so unique and so specific to who they are, and there isn't
- 31:08a generic response to it, to it. I would imagine that we're a
- 31:19long way off from an AI that could actually do that, and that
- 31:26a generic response is good in the beginning, but it it's not
- 31:29gonna take you too far. But we could do the reverse
- 31:35Turing test to make sure that we're actually working with a
- 31:41human and not a computer. So what is this enlightenment,
- 31:52this idea of understanding the nature of the sacredness of this
- 31:56human life that we're in? Why would you wanna dump that as
- 32:02as a possibility, right, To live out endless repetitions?
- 32:14One of the things I noticed in in these discussions, of course,
- 32:17is the value. What is the value of all of this
- 32:21stuff? What is?
- 32:27What is the production in? In some sense, we should reward
- 32:31the citizens that participate in society and contribute to it,
- 32:37and we should not award people who are unwilling to participate
- 32:42in this. But are we then to decide
- 32:51culturally what has value and what doesn't?
- 32:56We do that largely already, and we do restrict the distribution
- 33:01of resources already. Just imagine automating that,
- 33:16then having to pass these requirements of usefulness in
- 33:23order to have resources to support yourself, support the
- 33:28body that you're in. What is that?
- 33:34Who gets to make that determination?
- 33:35What's it based on? We've had so many variations of
- 33:45what what's useful and what is it useful.
- 33:48And in this last period, 70 years, let's say 5070 years,
- 33:58where maybe it was just The Beatles who did this.
- 34:05The first international pop sensation where all of a sudden
- 34:13being at the top of the game in one country which produced a
- 34:17certain level of of remuneration was just blown out of the arena
- 34:23by this worldwide phenomenon, such a vast amount of resources.
- 34:30I I think I saw that Taylor Swift's tour took in $5 billion,
- 34:37which was a a record fantastic amount of money.
- 34:50So already the resources are directed in these ways we talk
- 34:55about in the tech world. Unicorns which are companies
- 35:00that are valued at a billion dollars or or more inventing
- 35:07these services that we we take on or 100 billion like a
- 35:13Facebook or Google something like that.
- 35:22This vast accumulation of resources at the very top and
- 35:28yet it has a lack of impact. I I was travelling in Myanmar
- 35:42several years ago and I wanted to go up and see these historic
- 35:56Buddhist sites from around 700 E, up 700 AD and it was way up
- 36:10in the mountains and you gradually become aware of what
- 36:19the economies are like. And in this particular area the
- 36:22the wage was $2.00 a day. I don't know if you've ever been
- 36:26to parts of the world where the wages are $2.00 a day, but from
- 36:33a western point of view, there's nothing nice there.
- 36:38From the way that I'm used to living, certainly even the food
- 36:45isn't isn't good. It's not of a good quality.
- 36:51It's there but not of a good quality, even in better places
- 36:56there. So we create these these
- 37:03economic systems that really just pull everything up and if
- 37:07you can participate in in in the the activities of the world that
- 37:16are rewarded in that way, it's a staggering amount of money, a
- 37:23staggering amount of resources. And how does this map on to this
- 37:35pursuit of the sacred, this pursuit of really understanding
- 37:38the nature of the human conditioning, the human
- 37:42condition, why practice right the touch into this.
- 37:52So I think largely in in the West, if it isn't really
- 38:00something a practice that is meant to enhance a a lifestyle,
- 38:06the deeper practices for people who this system is already not
- 38:10working, there isn't satisfaction that comes from it
- 38:15or you're you're not in one of the groups that allow this
- 38:19bounty to fall on you perhaps not willing to do what is
- 38:26necessary for that. So you touch in the sacredness
- 38:42of all things, the sacredness of all life.
- 38:48And then you take a non harming stance and reaction to that
- 38:51because the the harming of life is so painful when you see the
- 38:57sacredness of it. And then you move into a place
- 39:03of trying to protect the world, protect the people and protect
- 39:10all life really in in the world. Because you can see into this,
- 39:16you can touch into this authenticity.
- 39:27So maybe in some way this new arrival of this much more
- 39:31compelling AI will push us in the other direction, the way
- 39:37that makes this even more difficult to touch it.
- 39:43It's right at the beginning, interesting to see, but why
- 39:53don't we do some practice? I'm going to suggest that we do
- 39:58Vipassanus that we can really touch into the the nature of the
- 40:01sensing experience in this body that we're living in.
- 40:08That we begin to see that process of selecting the sensing
- 40:12experience, touching into it, and then assigning meaning to
- 40:17it. The sensing is one thing and the
- 40:21meaning that we assigned is another.
- 40:23That's the first main major insight in the the Terrafatum
- 40:29map. But the Sensing experience is
- 40:32one thing, and the meaning that we assigned to it is another.
- 40:38We'll start with a little bit of concentration practice so that
- 40:41we can settle the mind. So go ahead and take your
- 40:46meditation posture. All right, Let go of the
- 40:52meditation. How'd that go?
- 40:58Good enough. So Saturday is the second day in
- 41:10in the the four half day day longs on level one.
- 41:14If you're interested in that. Come along, it should be good.
- 41:22I am leaving the week of May 6th to do the retreats in Europe and
- 41:31then I'll be back the week of June 17th.
- 41:35So in that five week period we won't have this class.
- 41:40So just keep that in mind. You'll get some emails about
- 41:45that I guess, or posts somewhere.
- 41:53We have some day long series coming up when I get back on the
- 42:02meditation and addiction track and we're going to do in the the
- 42:08summer the first meditation and and addiction intensive.
- 42:14So if you are have issues around that this will be a 12 week
- 42:19course that beats 3 * a week for an hour.
- 42:23So Monday, Wednesday and Friday at 6:00 to 7:00 PM Pacific Time
- 42:31and the structure of it is a didactic class on Monday, a
- 42:34meditation instruction on Wednesday, and A and a
- 42:37processing group on Friday around our four modules of
- 42:42addiction, Craving and Urging is the first module.
- 42:51Stress, Anger and depression is the second module.
- 42:53Persistent negative emotions is the third module, and difficult
- 42:57interpersonal relationships is the 4th model.
- 43:00So the first three are really about mental mentalizing and
- 43:04emotional regulation, and the last one is about how attachment
- 43:08conditioning creates the ground for addictions to flourish,
- 43:13mainly because of the avoidance of emotional regulation with
- 43:17other people. We will do another level one and
- 43:21we're gonna start a couple of level twos over the summer as
- 43:24well. You're interested in that
- 43:26intensive one will be on a Tuesday, I think afternoon and
- 43:311:00 will be on a Friday morning.
- 43:33So take a look at that. It's on the website.
- 43:37Really appreciate your practice. Ioffer the teaching freely, but
- 43:41I do hope that you'll make a donation if you can.
- 43:44The link is on the site. Thank you so much and we will
- 43:49see you soon. Bye.