Latest / Reclamation Radio / Episode 9 - Bill Gowdy with SLR Consulting
Transcript
- 0:00welcome to another episode of Reclamation Radio.
- 0:02My name's Elise Neumann, and today I'm joined by Bill Gowdy from SLR Consulting.
- So this year at the Canadian Line Reclamation Association Conference in 2026, he presented on the main stage, and it was a great presentation.
- We can talk a little bit about that today.
- He's also presented in the past at CLRA, and Bill keeps on telling me over and over again that he is not a reclamation person, but I've seen his presentations, and I think he has a lot of interesting things to say about reclamation.
- So I'm gonna go ahead and hand it off to Bill, and he can introduce himself a little bit further.
- So I'm, uh, Bill Gowdy.
- I've been, uh, it's hard to believe now, but out of, at a university for 40 years now.
- So I'm actually an exploration geologist.
- So started in gold, copper, nickel, platinum, industrial mineral exploration.
- Worked in Canada for about 10 years, and then I was overseas for eight years.
- Some interesting places an eye-opener, uh, on occasion for me.
- So I was in Guyana, I was in Mexico, Panama working southeastern United States in Georgia and South Carolina, South Africa.
- And then I actually moved to Indonesia for two and a half years and was the country manager for a junior mining gold company a- as well, uh, before coming back to Canada, and now have been in the Edmonton area for 25 years now working predominantly in the, in the gravel sector, both as a consultant and with a multinational as well, and sort of saw all the facets of gravel and s- and limestone for cement, uh, development, of regulatory approvals, of monitoring, of reclamation, and getting involved a lot with public affairs dealing with the public, dealing with regulatory approvals, whether it be the people, public consultations appeal hearings.
- So it's been a, a smattering of everything along the way.
- Wow, that is an impressive amount of experience.
- Is that kind of how you got involved with reclamation is kind of like closure planning and what is this gonna look like once we're done disturbing it? So combination of, of a few things.
- So did get involved with putting together conservation and reclamation plans.
- The big thing is to understand what you've got in the ground first, what the geometry of it is, what your limiting factors are, do you have water, what your soil limitations are, your vegetation limitations.
- So that will dictate, again, what you're starting with will sort of lean you into what you're going to end up with.
- And there's also not just- the scientific components to it.
- There's a lot of political components, I'll call them as well.
- So sometimes you're dealing with individual landowners and you're working on their land, s- other times you own it and you've got more flexibility.
- But sometimes there's a desire by the landowner to end up with a certain type of thing at the, at the end of the day as well.
- The other thing I've certainly learned is you have to be flexible, adaptable.
- It changes, the requirements change, the desires change.
- You'll get things that might be in production for 10, 20, 40 years, and technologies change, policies change, regulations change, or even the desired requirements or what people want these things to be at the end of the day.
- Like quite commonly, and I think I touched on this at the CLRA last year, you might start something, by the time you get to the end of it, y- you might have a community that desires something like a, a park or a, a recreational area, and it didn't necessarily start out that way.
- Or you, you didn't even consider it when you first started your operation.
- So I think you need a lot of flexibility in the process, and even at the regulatory side of things.
- You can't be prescriptive up, upfront.
- Um, you have to be able to be adaptable and change to the changing requirements over time Yeah, that's, you know, I learned quite a bit about that when I was a reclamation approvals coordinator at the government.
- So I was processing those initial pit applications, that's how Bill and I know each other.
- We know each other from my government days, and I definitely noticed that about you could see the progression of the pits, and as you mentioned, they're sometimes up to 20 and 30 years, maybe even beyond that.
- So when you're looking through the, the older files, you can see that as they learned more about the pit and as they more, learned more about what's in the ground, the plans can change significantly, even if you have good exploration data, you're always learning more about the site as you go.
- So reclamation and conservation and reclamation plans can be quite complex in these cases because you do have to, like, adapt and shift as you go along.
- You wrote, an article recently about some good examples of sites that used to be gravel pits, and maybe not everybody is aware of that they used to be gravel pits, can you give us some example of those? I- it's, again, it's, it's more history.
- Again, if you've done a proper job of reclamation, you shouldn't recognize that it was once an industrial activity.
- The general population, and even industry for that matter, doesn't even know or even appreciate that the entire city of Edmonton River Valley, they're all fluvial, glacial fluvial, or fluvial deposits along the rivers.
- Everything in the city of Edmonton that's a park, a golf course, they were...
- Every one of them was a gravel pit, and basically all of downtown city of Edmonton, and even outside of downtown, was all constructed from those gravel deposits.
- It's often not too hard to recognize them because you get little depressions, so you'll get little water bodies.
- So some of these parks that you see, so, uh, Hawrelak Park, Terwillegar Park, Rundle Park golf courses.
- There's, uh, Legends Golf Course.
- Again, they're just absolutely spectacular reclamation jobs where you wouldn't even know that they were gravel pits.
- Uh, there's another one, the name kinda gives it away, but the Quarry was also a a gravel pit.
- Um, there's, uh, Goose Hummock, which is, uh, north of, of Edmonton, another golf course, which I...
- When I go there, I throw a sleeve of golf balls into the water 'cause they're gonna go in there anyway before I start.
- So might as well have a ceremonial sacrifice with that.
- But that was another gravel pit.
- And again, nobody realizes that these were once industrial operations, again, because they might have occurred 20, 30, 40 years ago as well.
- And again, I find even the industry personnel that are actually in that business don't know that they were gravel pits I actually didn't know about Goose Hummock.
- I knew about a couple of the others, but I've been to Goose Hummock and I wouldn't have guessed.
- But once you know, you can start, you know, looking at the land forms.
- Reclamation's really i- interesting that way.
- You can start looking at the land forms and kind of say, "Yeah, maybe that does look a little bit shaped by humans."
- I'm kind of interested, um, what do you think like people should take away from those examples that, historical mining happened in the past, but now they're like integral parts of our communities? Is that what you're kind of looking for people to take away with those stories? Uh, certainly, certainly part of it.
- That's one component of it.
- What I wanted to sort of emphasize is that gravel extraction or any other type of extraction, whether it be a coal mine or anything else, are interim land uses.
- They have a finite period of time.
- We're not creating any more land.
- So if you can get multiple uses out of the same parcel of land and convert it to something else for some other benefit down, down the road and get the sequence right.
- One example would be if you put a housing development on a gravel deposit, you're never going to develop that gravel deposit, but if you get the gravel deposit out, then you can turn it into a housing development at that point in time.
- So there actually is one piece of remaining gravel in the city of Edmonton which will never be developed.
- And that's the Mayfair Golf Course.
- You're not gonna rip apart that golf course to get the gravel out of it.
- Right next door to it is Hawrelak Park.
- That has been extracted, and that's why the water body is in Hawrelak Park, and that's, that's what they use as their swimming hole for the triathlon- Right Competitions there.
- There is like a bylaw in the City of Edmonton, like it's just a, a whole memorandum.
- You can't excavate gravel within the City of Edmonton limits, which is pretty fascinating, right? I guess no, no new They're getting to have more and more of those as well too.
- The unfortunate part of it is you're actually sterilizing these deposits, and it's driving a lot of, uh, development for aggregate, which we all need.
- In the province of Alberta, the consumption rate is 15 tons per person per year, every man, woman, and child every single year.
- That's what our demand is.
- 60% of it's going to infrastructure purposes, so to build any schools, hospitals, roads, bridges.
- Those are examples of, of communal projects, I guess.
- And the rest goes to things like private usage for development of plants, factories, houses, that sort of thing.
- But reclamation can be some of these really neat or really spectacular examples, but reclamation doesn't necessarily mean that you're putting the soils back and you've established vegetation too.
- You can have some very unusual reclamation examples.
- At the CLRA, I did do a, a talk that gave one example, which is Quarry Park in Calgary.
- So the whole thing now is all housing development and businesses, offices.
- That's another form of reclamation, so it doesn't necessarily have to be going back to the s- exactly the same usage as well.
- But then again, you've got multiple uses out of the same parcel of land for continued benefit for the public.
- Yeah, I think when we think about reclamation, we're thinking about, like, return to pre-disturbance is kind of what we are aiming for.
- But depending on how that land is being used before, currently, and after, an alternative use ma- might make a lot of sense, and then I think there still would be some parameters to measure success like, landscape, soils, vegetation, hydrology.
- There might be different components, but how do we measure it to say, yes, it has been reclaimed sufficiently we'd need to modify those a little bit.
- Yeah, so I, I'd have to say again, the public demands often have a major bearing on it.
- Butchart Gardens in Victoria, it used to be an old limestone quarry and cement plant, uh, there.
- It's absolutely spectacular, the vegetation, the flowers there.
- And again, public usage.
- Another one is Lafarge Lake in Coquitlam, was a former sand and gravel pit.
- The government of BC actually built the LRT system to the lake itself because it was...
- It's such a spectacular park now, and the festivals they have there, the activities they have there.
- So now it's accessible to more people to get to as well.
- Wow.
- So again former sand and gravel pit.
- Um- Yeah but again, it's taken some insight and sometimes a little nerve from a combination of, of, um, the companies government regulators as well to do these things too.
- There's a commitment.
- And I'm guessing, like, for those two, two in BC, there, there was a lot of, like, community involvement 'cause if it's, like, a public space, I'm guessing that, you know, there was a need for a public space, and y- the municipality was, um, supportive of it.
- Totally.
- In the case of, of, uh, Lafarge Lake, the land was donated, again, for...
- from an operator perspective.
- Um, when they're done with their sand and gravel side of things then it doesn't matter at that point.
- So lands can be sold off, they can be donated, they...
- Whatever it happens to be.
- And then you get involved with uh, different levels of government participation and that sort of thing as well- Yeah at that juncture.
- So definitely multi-stakeholder involvement- with these things as well to to get them to evolve to the point they are.
- Yeah.
- Do you have another interesting example that you've been involved with, just that sort of community involvement and creating the reclamation and closure, the closure idea, I guess? So s- I'll give you one that's actually I haven't been involved with at all.
- It's actually an Alberta Transportation pit and this was out near Whitecourt as well.
- And gravel pits are often a very popular target for ATVs and motorbikes.
- Yeah.
- So they actually came up with an idea in conjunction with the municipality itself to develop a, a motocross recreation area in, in the gravel pit itself as well.
- So again, no involvement on, on my part.
- This was Alberta Transportation and, and Woodlands County that, uh, that did this.
- But again it's sort of a process that had evolved, I guess, on its own, and why not just augment that? I totally agree.
- Like, um, a lot of these gravel pits, there's a lot of trespassing, and people start using it, and it's like, you know what if it's acceptable to everyone and everyone's on board, why don't we just open it up to what people naturally wanna use it for? That makes a lot of sense to me, and another couple I've s- I've seen a few of these, have been involved with some of these, where they've actually been converted to RV parks as well too.
- So now y- you end up with a water body as part of the reclamation so then they've established campsites o- on these as well.
- Oh, yes.
- So- I've seen those too.
- Yeah.
- That's interesting.
- Wanted to ask you about your upcoming presentation and article for CLRA about biodiversity and how it factors into reclamation planning.
- If you could talk a little bit about that? So biodiversity's, again, diversity that's the big thing.
- So a lot of reclamation that's done, if you look at something like farmland, you put a, a monocrop in, in on sites.
- You can take it to a whole different level.
- In...
- with a biodiversity situation, you're looking for multiple plant types you're looking for a whole sustainable equalculture so it includes anything from bugs to rabbits to bats.
- Do you have lots of different plant types that flower during the year so it's of interest to different types of bees natural or even domestic as well, butterflies? You can also start to look at things that are kind of further up the food chain, more apex predators.
- If you've got apex type predators in, in an area, so if you've got things like foxes or coyotes, uh, even cougars.
- We had one gravel pit where we were picking up cougars on, on some of our monitoring programs as well.
- That means you've got all that supporting material underneath it to feed up the ecosystem, uh, as well too.
- So you're tr- returning it to more of a natural type of setting that's not just a sing- single crop, uh, on a particular property.
- So you're getting a diverse range of, of plants, animals.
- It's really neat to see that.
- So it's returning it more to what you would have as an original setting in a remote area.
- And I guess what kind of advantages are there for incorporating this biodiversity aspect to it? Because I think sometimes it seems like an extra or something that we're going over and above to incorporate these things.
- But in the industry over the last few years, there's been interest in nature-based solutions.
- This sounds kind of like nature-based sol- solutions to me.
- Totally is.
- Certainly.
- But it's also an indicator of your success of reclamation.
- If it helps, and I'm a strong proponent of having monitoring programs for biodiversity.
- It can be things like avian species, what's present.
- Uh, it can be amphibians, reptiles.
- If you've got a good population of, of amphibians, frogs salamanders, those sorts of things, it's usually an indicator that you've got good water quality as well too, and you're providing filtering systems for water also.
- So, um, having the presence of these is also an indicator of the success of the reclamation and how good it is at being returned to, to a natural environment and the quality of that.
- Yeah, I feel like I've, I've come across some reclamation plans where there's more incorporation of wildlife and what, what kind of species we're seeing on the site.
- And the one thing that maybe like a word of caution is that the reclamation, Like for example, like sand and gravel reclamation in Alberta, we do have the code of practice of pits.
- So if we're kind of like, oh, I'm gonna show that like wildlife is coming back to the site, but I didn't meet my requirements under the code of practice of pits, it might be missing the mark a little bit, right? When we go for our reclamation certificate application.
- I feel like I've been involved with those projects where I come in and I'm like, that's a cool thing, but- the code isn't, uh, it's not exciting or anything, but it does need to be followed.
- Well, and it partly comes back to your upfront assessments too, looking at the soils and vegetation that are already- Right on the site.
- Like y- your reclamation has to fit the setting.
- You don't want something that's- Right not going to be compatible Yeah, that is so true that, yeah, sometimes, you know, as we come to the end of a project, we get pretty excited about something and, what was it before? Is that even possible there? Is it possible? Yeah, that's why, again, you need the baseline information to see what you can potentially support.
- And you can do a couple things with it.
- It's getting back to close to what it was or needs to be, but you can also look at potentially augmenting some of those things as well.
- Yeah, do you have a good example of when you've been successful kind of, like, augmenting what's already there? A, a lot of excavations quite often you end up with, uh, wetlands or water bodies.
- That's probably one of the main ones- Mm-hmm that I've dealt with over the years.
- So again, you, you've got things that are gonna support migratory birds amphibians, uh, and again, depending on how you reclaim it, also diversity of even things like insect populations.
- Mm-hmm.
- Yeah, I think some of the projects I've been involved with for end pit lakes, like on, on gravel pits, is that they can be quite deep.
- And if we're going for a more wetland type environment, it should be two meters or less deep.
- So then it kind of encourages those like wetland components to come back to the water body a little bit.
- And it depends on what the desires are up front.
- Mm-hmm like the, a lot of the excavations that I've seen or been involved with take place on things like farmland.
- And what you're trying to do at the end of the day, you remove material you're changing the there's a volume that's gone.
- If you're trying to maximize the amount of available farmland at the end of it you're not stretching your a lo- a large flat wetland area.
- You've got them more, more confined so that you've got more arable land than for, for farming purposes.
- So if you're, if you're working with a, a farmer as a landowner, it can be very different than if you're trying to do something else and end up with more of a naturalized setting.
- That's such a good point that, you know, when I was reviewing files, we talked ex- exactly about that kind of thing.
- That sometimes it does make sense to make an end pit lake that is quite deep so you can maximize the land use otherwise, yeah.
- There's, uh, one group in Ontario right now that's kind of interesting.
- They're And this is where a, a deep cold lake is actually more desirable, but they're actually using them for fish farms now as well too.
- So you have to have excellent water quality, but you also have to have cool water, uh, well oxygenate, well oxygenated, uh, which you don't get with a shallow environment as well too.
- And they're using them for fish farms.
- So these, these people are actually supplying, raising fish and supplying them to, to grocery stores.
- Wow.
- So it's like a different farming, right? I think from a public perspective, I think it's important as well to get the word out, let the public know, get the public involved as well.
- So I've always enjoyed having biodiversity programs, getting the public involved, showing them what can be accomplished through some of these reclamation programs the biodiversity programs.
- So it helps get a better understanding of the science, what is being done from an industry perspective and it's educational.
- The other side of it as well is you can get the citizen science component as well too part of it, where you can get them involved in being interested in it, doing monitoring programs as well.
- So it just helps overall education of, of, uh, the public as well.
- But having these programs where you're getting the public involved, quite often nobody's got a monopoly on ideas by any stretch of the imagination.
- Quite often having that input from outside perspectives too, it's, it's something that you wouldn't have come up with otherwise as well.
- So anytime, I find if you can get more people involved, opens the dialogue, you're getting more constructive options as to what you could potentially do or what direction maybe you should be taking these things in.
- Yeah.
- I totally agree.
- And seeing is believing.
- If you can get members of the public involved with the project I think some of these things, just from a permitting perspective, You're reading the description or you're looking at the, at the conceptual drawings, and it can seem a lot scarier than what it actually is.
- And when people actually go and see what it's like and, like, how it's evolving and getting involved and experiencing it for themselves, I think that makes a huge difference.
- No, I, I think the dialogue is huge.
- And, and again I've sometimes been shocked myself.
- It's like when they come forth with a suggestion or idea, it's like, "I never would've thought of that."
- That's actually incredibly helpful, and it takes you in a, in a different path that maybe you wouldn't have derived otherwise.
- Yeah, especially like we were talking about, these, these operations can go on for 40 years.
- Like, a lot happens in a 40 years,.
- you're going to discover things you didn't quite know about yet.
- So it's always good to have, like, lots of different ideas and kind of like co-craft it as you're going along The, the other side of it too that, that can change or evolve over time it's different working on something like a well site or a pipeline.
- You've got a very confined area, but large things like mine sites to me the progressive reclamation is huge.
- Like, always trying to minimize and mitigate your footprint.
- The other thing too is if you're doing things like introducing plants and trees, y- you, you want to get these things established because sometimes they take years- to grow.
- And again, that might, it might follow 10 years later.
- Y- you'll plant a tree and then, uh, you really start to notice it after 10, 15 years, not- Yeah the next day.
- It's not gonna happen.
- That is so true because I feel like in oil and gas reclamation, it's very much about we got our, like, distinct area.
- We're trying to reclaim that one, but we don't get to see that longer timeline, and for more of a mining situation, you have areas that you're not re-entering.
- Okay, that one's ready for reclamation, and then you can do your progressive reclamation, and you can kind of see...
- you can also learn from those other areas what worked there, and then you can bring it to the other areas of the site and make your reclamation plan better as you go along.
- And you can also change things up.
- The, the one thing on the divi- the diversity side is you can have different plant species or different areas that will support diff- different, uh, fauna- as well So it all, it's all intertwined.
- Um, the other thing it does is help improve conductivity as well too, so maybe you've got forests or something in the surrounding area.
- The animals are gonna go where they feel comfortable at the end of the day.
- it sometimes can even help improve conductivity of, or connection with things going from one place to another.
- There's one pit I can think of a couple years ago, it was so funny.
- The uh, the, the reclaimed areas so everything was green and lush.
- Well, it was like a buffet, but we had mule deer and elk all over the place grazing on the thing afterwards, and it's still an operating a gravel pit in this particular case.
- Oh.
- But they were out there because that was their desired food source.
- Yeah, and it's always nice to see you know, like wildlife coming back because like you said, that shows us that we were successful, that they want to actually use the land.
- It's desirable to them.
- At the end of the day.
- The other thing that happened was once you got some of these other things in there, like, like deer and so on, and we had wildlife cameras installed.
- And quite often, like you could go out and do studies, you'd see tracks and things like that.
- But we put cameras up, and you'd get a sense of the populations of the animals that were coming into the area, the different types of animals.
- Some of these species you would never even see actually in person, but they're floating around.
- Absolutely.
- As well.
- B- and sometimes it was things like apex predators, um- Yeah the one operation we were working in.
- We had, we had several cougars in the area.
- Nobody has ever once seen one.
- Mm-hmm.
- They're there.
- But if we didn't have the cameras, we wouldn't know they are worth every penny because the other way of documenting wildlife use for a site that we're not at, uh, all the time, or even if you were there all the time, you're a person walking around, is kind of like those secondary observations of them foot- you know, like paw prints and scat and fur.
- And if we can actually have a camera, then we can start c- counting individuals.
- This individual is here on site.
- We can start counting, like, how many were there, the diversity, how much diversity do we actually see on the site, and different kinds of wildlife, that information is invaluable.
- It really tells a story and kind of says how, what's the frequency of use, what's the diversity that we see on the site.
- Well, and populations.
- Are the populations changing as well- And how is it changing over time? Like, it'll give you a sense of how well you've done from your reclamation standpoint, uh, to see is it recovering at a faster rate, a slower rate is it being used- Mm-hmm we had s- one project where we installed bat apartments as well.
- So bats, you've gotta have a good water source.
- You have to have a good insect population.
- The first few years that we had them in they didn't even take to them at all, and then all of a sudden they started using them.
- And then we had acoustical monitors- for the bats.
- So what those do is it picks up every time something flies by.
- So it was, uh, basically a microphone.
- So you can get the population sense of what it is, and it went up tenfold over a couple of year period as to how many bats were actually going through there.
- Wow.
- The, the other thing that we determined with that is different bat species have different frequencies when they're echolocating.
- So you can actually discern somewhat.
- There's some that overlap a little bit, but some are very distinctive as to what species of bat you're dealing with.
- And what we found is we had approximately five different bat species in this particular project area.
- That's fascinating that you guys could tell by the different frequencies.
- I love that I think that's, um, you know, that's really not in our, um, reclamation policies right now.
- At, at least for the ones that I'm familiar with.
- But as far as I know, for sand and gravel wildlife's not really a indicator or, you know, like our measure of success.
- It's not really in there.
- But I really like the idea of if we can show that there's a trajectory of in- it's increasing over time.
- Mm.
- That's like a really, really powerful a- argument, I think.
- Yeah.
- Well, it's similar to doing vegetation e- evaluations, right? Mm-hmm.
- You start- Yeah with something and- Productivity.
- Yeah it's a sense of productivity or, or density or variation or variability- so again, it's, it's getting those healthy e- ecosystems, it's important to just get a broad range of things that, uh, are appearing not a single thing.
- Songbirds are another thing.
- Uh, doing things like songbird surveys visual.
- And again, you can get into the citizen science on this as well too.
- So if you've got a, a huge variety of species that are accepting or, or adapting to that setting that you've been working on that's a good indicator of, of a success- as well.
- Bill, thank you so much for joining me today.
- This was great.
- No, thank you.
- I, I...
- It's something I'm, I enjoy and passionate about, but I, I love to see the recovery, progressive reclamation.
- I enjoy seeing it go back to something that's useful, uh, a- and gets continued on for some other use for the benefit, whether it's the public, for wildlife.
- It's...
- To me, it's just, it's an interim use, but it's important to be progressive on this as well and, and, basically adopt or change with it as, as it goes along.
- That's exactly what land reclamation is.
- Like, you're one of us, Bill.
- One of us.
- Even though he's an exploration geologist.
- Yeah, no, you're one of us.
- Thanks so much, Bill.
- I've really learnt a lot from you.
- Thank you.
- Okay, you're very welcome Thanks again to Bill for joining me on the podcast.
- I was excited to dive into the topic of sand and gravel reclamation, and I hope you found our conversation as interesting as I did.
- If you're involved with sand and gravel reclamation and have a project, experience, or lesson learned you'd like to share, I'd love to hear from you.
- I'm also excited to announce that our next episode will feature a conversation with a recent land reclamation graduate.
- I'm looking forward to highlighting her experiences and hearing a firsthand perspective on entering the profession.
- And that got me thinking, for students, re- recent graduates, and early career professionals working towards a career in reclamation, what has your experience been like? What challenges are you facing? What surprised you most about entering the field? If you'd like to share your story, please reach out to me at reclamationradiopodcast@gmail.com.
- I think it's incredibly valuable to hear directly from people who are just starting their careers, and I'd love to continue these conversations.
- Until next time, thank you for listening to Reclamation Radio