Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #45: The Types of Polarization...And How Any of Us Can Become Polarized
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan and nonideological
- 0:05analysis and information.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:10Today, we're going to talk about the types of political polarization.
- 0:15Did you know that there are different types of political polarization?
- 0:19What are those different types?
- 0:21Why is it important to understand the different types?
- 0:24How do we measure them?
- 0:26How long has America been polarized?
- 0:28And which particular type of polarization is one that can, unfortunately, be exhibited by
- 0:34any one of us?
- 0:35All this and more is on tap for today's episode.
- 0:38But first, there is some debate as to how high the level of polarization is in America, but it
- 0:44is undeniably increasing in some fashion.
- 0:48On the TV, on the radio, the Internet, even in person encounters, you'll notice an unhealthy
- 0:54level of toxicity as the political divides become increasingly apparent and worsen.
- 1:01It's permeating our political discourse and has seriously hindered our ability to have real
- 1:06conversations about important topics.
- 1:08Most people can see this, but what is understood much less is the fact that
- 1:13polarization is not a one dimensional concept.
- 1:16There are many ways to measure it because there are multiple types of polarization.
- 1:22And as polarization becomes progressively more relevant, so does the need to understand the
- 1:27ways that polarization manifests and foments.
- 1:31So today, we are diving into the ways that polarization can be broken down, where we see
- 1:37these types of polarization, and why all of us need to be careful about exhibiting polarized
- 1:43attitudes.
- 1:44Because if you think that you cannot possibly be polarized in some way and that there is no
- 1:49way that you could be dragged down into the political fray, I have some unfortunate news
- 1:54for you.
- 1:55But it's not all doom and gloom.
- 1:57I have good news too.
- 1:59So here we go.
- 2:00First, we should talk about how long has America been polarized.
- 2:05We might romanticize an era where we were younger or grew up in as devoid of polarization
- 2:11where most people got along.
- 2:13At least that polarization was not that common.
- 2:17The level of hostility might have been lower, but part of it is just because of your
- 2:22cognizance of things.
- 2:24When we are younger, we tend to romanticize an era with our nostalgia goggles.
- 2:29We tend to not see all the terrible things going on because we're just not aware of it.
- 2:35What was a fantastic time for us to grow up in or for one person to grow up in was a terrible
- 2:41time for somebody else.
- 2:43In reality, polarization in America has ebbed and flowed at different points in time and a
- 2:50really great book to read on this topic.
- 2:53I don't necessarily agree with everything that is said in the book, but this book right here,
- 3:00if you can see it, it is called the second civil war civil war, excuse me, by Ronald
- 3:06Brownstein, how extreme partisanship has paralyzed Washington and polarized America.
- 3:11It's a really long extended look at the ways that polarization has ebbed and flowed, mostly
- 3:19in terms of partisanship.
- 3:21But, again, great book for you to read.
- 3:25You should definitely go ahead and check it out.
- 3:27But let's just think about the fact that, for example, we've had multiple assassinations or
- 3:33attempts at assassinations of political figures.
- 3:36Sadly, we just had the other day a former Minnesota house speaker.
- 3:42The for the state house, she and her husband were just let's call what it is.
- 3:46They were assassinated.
- 3:48And US history has, unfortunately, plenty of those instances too.
- 3:54And then, obviously, not just US history, but world history in general.
- 3:58Presidents that were assassinated, Abraham Lincoln, William McKinley, John f Kennedy.
- 4:03We've had other presidents where there were attempts to assassinate them, Donald Trump,
- 4:09Ronald Reagan, FDR, more not necessarily well known attempts.
- 4:16But as a president, you're going to be your life is gonna be threatened simply by the fact
- 4:22that you are the chief executive of The United States.
- 4:26But it's not just presidents that have been targeted.
- 4:28We've had plenty of other political figures too.
- 4:32Probably one of the more famous ones, Aaron Burr, prominent scumbag of early US history,
- 4:38killed Alexander Hamilton in a duel.
- 4:40We've had other major instances in earlier times in America.
- 4:45For example, what's referred to as bleeding Sumner, US senator from Massachusetts, Charles
- 4:50Sumner.
- 4:50He was viciously caned in his office by US senator Preston Brooks of South Carolina
- 4:56regarding an anti slavery speech that Charles Sumner had just had on the congressional floor.
- 5:05I forget the exact year that that happened.
- 5:07Then in 1798, you had the Lion Griswold brawl, a fight with a cane and fiery tongs between US
- 5:15house representatives Roger Griswold of Connecticut and Matthew Lyon of Vermont.
- 5:21They had a personal feud going on there.
- 5:24So polarization has reared its ugly head multiple times throughout US history, even
- 5:30since The US declared independence from Britain.
- 5:34Now, obviously, not necessarily in the term in terms of assassination or actual fistfights,
- 5:40but the very fight for independence in America was by no means supported by all Americans.
- 5:47There were still a lot of Americans that were loyal to the British crowd, and then there were
- 5:51a lot of Americans that just didn't wanna be involved.
- 5:54They just wanted to be left alone.
- 5:56Whatever happened happened.
- 5:58And then after the American Revolution, the states were actually quite disunited with many
- 6:05conflicting interests.
- 6:07Really, the only thing that had united them at that point was opposition to Britain.
- 6:12And, again, not everybody in the population supported independence from Britain.
- 6:17But in terms of the actual governments, really, the only thing that had united them was being
- 6:22opposed to the British crown and its rule over the then the colonies.
- 6:28So it really took a while to resolve those issues, and you saw the eventual shift from the
- 6:37Articles of Confederation to the US constitution.
- 6:40That was not supported by everybody either.
- 6:42There are a lot of people that were very vociferously in support of the articles of
- 6:48confederation and some that were very much against the US constitution.
- 6:52Also, technically, the US constitution was illegal according to the text of the articles
- 6:58of confederation.
- 6:59The constitutional convention was supposed to be at least it was under the guise of heavily
- 7:05revising the articles of confederation, not completely throwing them out and putting an
- 7:09entirely new document in effect.
- 7:11And a really great book to read about that is this one right here, the quartet orchestrating
- 7:18the second American revolution seventeen eighty three to seventeen eighty nine by Joseph J.
- 7:23Ellis, an American historian.
- 7:26So definitely read up on that one as well.
- 7:29And then you had sectional interests more so in terms of geography that were more pronounced in
- 7:36the early days of American history.
- 7:38The North and the South, obviously, slavery being one of the really big ones, but you also
- 7:42had the expanding West and their own interests that were being regarded, and again, partially
- 7:49about how to expand and to prevent slavery in the newer states.
- 7:56So this level of polarization that we see or polarization in general is not a new concept in
- 8:05American history, and it really hasn't necessarily been an upward trajectory that
- 8:13entire time either.
- 8:14Largely was at least up until the civil war because that was just something that was
- 8:18fomenting for a long, long time with the North and South having various spats regarding
- 8:24economics and slavery and various other issues too.
- 8:32But after the civil war, it's been kind of like an ebb and flow, at least depending on how
- 8:37exactly you measure polarization, which we will, of course, get to shortly.
- 8:41But it's hard to argue against the idea that the height of polarization was the civil war.
- 8:46I mean, we became two countries after all.
- 8:49Although if you ask Abraham Lincoln, he didn't really believe that we were two countries.
- 8:54He just saw the Southern states as in rebellion.
- 8:57But if we wanna go back to or at least trace the origins of today's polarization, one could
- 9:05argue that it can be traced back to the nineteen fifties and nineteen sixties.
- 9:10In 1950, the American Political Science Association had a report called toward a more
- 9:15responsible two party system, a report on the committee of political parties.
- 9:21And back then, the Democratic and Republican parties were I mean, they weren't the same
- 9:28exact thing, obviously, but there were a lot of conservatives and and liberals ideologically in
- 9:37both parties, especially pronounced in the Democratic Party with the civil rights
- 9:43movement.
- 9:44Southern Democrats very much not in support of the civil rights movement.
- 9:50Northern Democrats a lot more amenable to it.
- 9:53Republicans had their own schisms as well.
- 9:57And so the American Political Science Association was basically saying these parties
- 10:02need to really figure out who they are and make distinct choices for Americans to pick from.
- 10:12Now they did kind of get their wish.
- 10:14Now there's a lot of distinction between the two parties, and some might argue that it's
- 10:21really gone the exact opposite way of what the American Political Science Association was
- 10:25complaining about.
- 10:27But during the nineteen sixties and nineteen seventies, citizens became more cognizant of
- 10:31the concepts of liberal and conservative ideology.
- 10:35Now people have their own definitions of what those exactly are, but just thinking about
- 10:40those labels.
- 10:40Now there's still a lot of people that, believe it or not, really don't think along those
- 10:44lines, but it started to become more pronounced during that frame.
- 10:49And one of the really big impetuses for that was Barry Goldwater's nineteen sixty four
- 10:54presidential campaign where he really made his conservative political philosophy the center of
- 11:00his campaign.
- 11:01Now he got trounced by Lyndon B.
- 11:04Johnson in the overall election, but his influence on politics at large was felt for
- 11:11years and years to come.
- 11:11And we've talked about him on a couple previous episodes of the podcast.
- 11:16And you started to see what's called the great sorting out.
- 11:21Some people call the great sorting out where more and more conservatives move towards the
- 11:27Republican Party and more and more liberals move towards the Democratic Party.
- 11:32And you saw a lot of states that strongly leaned toward one party around that time slowly
- 11:39started going another way and becoming much more towards that side.
- 11:44For example, Southern states once considered the bastion of Democratic party strength, now
- 11:50they're very Republican.
- 11:52Several Northern states like Massachusetts and Vermont, once incredibly Republican, now are
- 12:00very democratic.
- 12:02So there's been a lot of change, obviously, but at the same time, polarization has still
- 12:09persisted in some sort of way.
- 12:12So let's get to why it is important to distinguish the types of polarization.
- 12:19Because when you're studying anything, especially in an academic context, it's
- 12:23important to operationalize, which is a fancy academic term for saying define.
- 12:29Define terms to know how it is being studied.
- 12:33Several reasons that is important is because other people who study the same topic can look
- 12:37at your data and try to replicate it more easily.
- 12:41If people want to agree or disagree with your findings, they'll at least know how you got to
- 12:46it so they can try to refute it or support it.
- 12:49And then when you're trying to teach people anything, we need to be on the same page as to
- 12:53what words mean.
- 12:54If people don't know what you mean by something, they're not really learning about
- 12:58the concept or at least not in the way that you're trying to teach it.
- 13:02Because polarization is not simply a question of, is this person or group polarized?
- 13:08We need to know how they are and to what extent they are polarized.
- 13:14So there are multiple ways to study polarization, and they aren't necessarily
- 13:18perfect measures either.
- 13:19There are countless academic studies of polarization that have measured it in various
- 13:26ways and some that make a point of the fact that political polarization has had a whole
- 13:31bunch of different ways to measure it.
- 13:33And some of those ways we're gonna talk about in the rest of this episode.
- 13:38But you also got to think about sometimes the types of polarization can look
- 13:43indistinguishable or they overlap.
- 13:45For example, if I want to measure the ideology of the political parties in congress over time,
- 13:51is that a measure of partisan polarization or ideological polarization?
- 13:55Because I'm looking at the parties in Congress, but I'm also talking about their ideology.
- 14:00So people can be polarized in one way, but not necessarily another way.
- 14:07And depending on how people are polarized, it will change the best approach toward trying to
- 14:14depolarize them.
- 14:16So how exactly do we measure polarization?
- 14:21So for this podcast, this is not necessarily a foolproof, I guess, not necessarily an entirely
- 14:28agreed upon, like, this is exactly how people would divide it up.
- 14:31But just to make things simplified and and straightforward and so we're on the same page,
- 14:39I'm gonna talk about four different types of polarization.
- 14:43One is partisan polarization, which is polarization between political parties.
- 14:48Usually, that's democratic versus republican.
- 14:51Obviously, they are the two major parties, but you might be surprised to find out that this
- 14:56can also apply to certain third parties as well.
- 14:59Number two, ideological polarization, just polarization between ideological camps.
- 15:05Liberal versus conservative.
- 15:08Three, issue polarization.
- 15:10So polarization on specific issues, beliefs on specific issues.
- 15:15So we might be talking about abortion, guns, LGBTQ policies, foreign policy regarding
- 15:22specific countries like Russia and Ukraine, Israel and Palestine, all sorts of other places
- 15:31in the world.
- 15:32And then number four is affective polarization, not effective, affective with an a.
- 15:39That is polarization in thoughts and feelings about other people, even if they are in your
- 15:44party or lean towards your ideological side.
- 15:46Usually, it's referring to people who think differently than you, but there can be certain
- 15:51affectively polarized attitudes towards people that are on your side as well.
- 15:56We'll get more into that, of course, but affective polarization at the end is one that I
- 16:02really want to hone in on.
- 16:04And for each type of polarization, I'm going to go into more detail about what they are and
- 16:10what they look like, followed by some of the ways that we can study it and ways that it has
- 16:16been studied before.
- 16:18Because you could be polarized in one of these ways, but not in others.
- 16:23Maybe you have a strong partisan affiliation.
- 16:26Maybe you are a lifelong democrat or a lifelong republican, but maybe you're not ideologically
- 16:31polarized or vice versa.
- 16:32Maybe you're a very strong conservative or liberal, but you do not like the party that you
- 16:38would normally be allied to because you don't think that they're far enough to decide.
- 16:42Maybe you think the Republican Party is not to the right enough.
- 16:45Maybe you think the Democratic Party is not to the left enough.
- 16:49So polarization can vary along those kinds of lines and also various other lines too, like,
- 16:55for example, political participation levels.
- 16:59If you're more politically active, you tend to be more polarized.
- 17:02You're not necessarily more polarized, but you tend to be because you tend to have a more
- 17:07vested interest in what happens.
- 17:09You tend to see politics as a sport, as an existential crisis.
- 17:14Political polarization can also vary along the lines of elites versus non elites, elites being
- 17:21government officials.
- 17:22So government officials tend to be more polarized than citizens are.
- 17:26And polarization can also vary along geographical lines, that is to say, national
- 17:31versus state context, because there's varying degrees of polarization across states, and some
- 17:37are more polarized than the national context.
- 17:40There are some very democratic states.
- 17:42Or some very republican states.
- 17:44First type of polarization to talk about today, partisan polarization.
- 17:50That refers to the level of polarization between political parties.
- 17:55And, of course, that usually refers to the Democratic and Republican parties because they
- 17:59are the most prominent ones.
- 18:02But this can also apply to some third parties as well.
- 18:06Some may criticize Democrats and Republicans as being too extreme to one way or another, but
- 18:13some third party members think the two main parties are not extreme enough.
- 18:18But instead of going completely independent of any party, they may find a third party that is
- 18:23far to their side.
- 18:25Couple of examples there.
- 18:27I'll use one for both the left and one for the right.
- 18:32The Green Party, generally very left leaning, particularly focused on environmental issues,
- 18:37but a lot of times, they don't think the Democratic Party is liberal enough, and so they
- 18:42go to the Green Party.
- 18:45And then you have on the right side, you have the constitution party, generally very right
- 18:49leaning and particularly focused on states' rights.
- 18:55They don't think the Republican Party is conservative enough in a lot of cases.
- 19:01But, of course, just to be clear, not every third party is far to one side or another.
- 19:06There is, for example, the Libertarian Party, which is the most common third party you see.
- 19:11Now a lot of the prominent libertarians that people see, they tend to be allied with or vote
- 19:18Republican.
- 19:19So some people may assume that libertarians are actually just more to the right, but that's not
- 19:25necessarily the case.
- 19:26Libertarians tend to be economically conservative but socially liberal.
- 19:32And depending on how strongly they feel about each of those kinds of issues, they might
- 19:38typically lean towards the Republican Party or they might lean towards the Democratic Party.
- 19:42Maybe they care more about the social issues that they're liberal on, so they might vote
- 19:46Democratic.
- 19:47Maybe they care more about the economic issues that they're conservative on, so they vote
- 19:51Republican.
- 19:53Really just depends on which libertarian you talk to.
- 19:56Now, of course, a lot of these libertarians probably some of them prefer to vote for a
- 20:01libertarian candidate, but there's not always a libertarian candidate to vote for.
- 20:06So they might just have to vote for their party that they typically would align with if they
- 20:11weren't libertarian.
- 20:12Essentially, the more strongly someone identifies with a party label, the more
- 20:17partisanly polarized they are.
- 20:19They tend to support that party and everything.
- 20:22They tend to make excuses for the behavior of that party if it's some in some way benefiting
- 20:30them.
- 20:31So what are some of the ways that we can measure partisan polarization?
- 20:36One way you could do that is by studying party platforms.
- 20:40This is more qualitative and less quant quantitative.
- 20:43Qualitative meaning you're studying more of the qualities, the descriptions of something as
- 20:50opposed to quantitative, which is more numerical.
- 20:54If you're studying party platforms, it's kinda hard to put numbers on things because you're
- 20:58looking at specific words, and you're using these descriptions of platforms.
- 21:03But that is a way to do that.
- 21:05If you look at the Republican party platform nationally versus the Democratic party platform
- 21:09nationally, you can study it that way.
- 21:12There are both pros and cons, benefits and drawbacks to studying things in a qualitative
- 21:17fashion versus a quantitative fashion.
- 21:20Really just depends on what exactly it is you're studying.
- 21:24Personally, I think having both is very beneficial, but sometimes you can't have both.
- 21:29But in any case, you can look at it from a national context, the national platforms, the
- 21:34state parties sometimes have their own platforms as well.
- 21:38Again, some variation in how polarized parties are in each state.
- 21:44Some Democratic parties may be less liberal.
- 21:48Some Republican parties may be less conservative.
- 21:51Really depends on the context you're looking at.
- 21:54Second way to study partisan polarization is you can look at straight ticket voting, which
- 22:00basically describes how much voters just vote for the same party across offices because,
- 22:08obviously, there's a lot of officials that you gotta vote for.
- 22:12Might be presidents, might be governor, might be US Senate, US house, state house, state
- 22:18senate, local.
- 22:19There's a lot of things to vote on, and some places have more things to vote on and more
- 22:23people to vote on than other places do.
- 22:26So how much do geographical units vote for members of the same party across these offices?
- 22:32We can look at it in terms of states and whether they vote for the same party.
- 22:38So maybe does the state vote for the same party for president and for US senate or if it's one
- 22:46of those states where they only have one US house rep, which means it's a statewide race.
- 22:51And then governor, attorney general, if it's if that's an office that that state votes on, not
- 22:56every state votes on their attorney general.
- 22:58I'm talking about the state level attorney general, not the federal attorney general
- 23:02because that's appointed by the president.
- 23:06So you can look at it through states.
- 23:08You can look at it in congressional districts.
- 23:10You can look at it in terms of counties.
- 23:13You can look at precincts.
- 23:14Precincts are voting subunits to show wherever somebody lives, it dictates what exact precinct
- 23:23they're in.
- 23:23So you can look at it very, very minutely, very granularly that way, or you can look at it
- 23:31through towns and cities as well.
- 23:35You have to use these units, though, because you can't look at individual voters and how
- 23:40they voted.
- 23:41So you have to work with these groups.
- 23:44I can't go to a voting machine and see, okay.
- 23:49This exact person, how did they vote?
- 23:52Okay.
- 23:52But you don't know who exactly that person is.
- 23:55You'd have to have them tell you that they split ticket vote or that they straight ticket
- 24:00voted.
- 24:00You're not necessarily going to get the answer from them depending on whether they think, oh,
- 24:08I don't know if I should tell people that I straight ticket vote.
- 24:11But some states allow you to actually fill out a simple option that says, I want all
- 24:17Democratic candidates or I want all Republican candidates.
- 24:20And I'm gonna tell you right now, obviously, I don't put any sort of opinions on specific
- 24:26parties or individuals or ideological groups or anything like that, and I try to keep all my
- 24:32other opinions out as much as possible.
- 24:34But I'm gonna say right now, I think having an option to just lazily put, I want all
- 24:40candidates of this party, I think that's ridiculous.
- 24:43You should have to fill out every single one of those bubbles yourself if you really want to do
- 24:47that.
- 24:48I think that's just lazy and really adds to polarization, but that's beside the point.
- 24:55So could also, again, just pull people on whether they straight ticket voted, but they
- 25:00might not want to say they straight ticket voted because they may perceive that as
- 25:05socially undesirable.
- 25:07And sometimes people will change their responses on polls if they think somebody's
- 25:12gonna look down on them even if they are anonymous polls.
- 25:17The third way that you can study partisan polarization is by pulling on whether people
- 25:23find meaningful differences between the parties.
- 25:27Earlier, I mentioned how people became more cognizant of the terms of conservative and
- 25:32liberal starting in the 1960s, maybe even arguably in the 1950s, but especially in the
- 25:371960s.
- 25:39And we've had several polls since then, probably more than several, that have included
- 25:44questions basically asking people, do you think there are more important differences or excuse
- 25:49me.
- 25:50Do you think there are important differences between the parties?
- 25:54And trends have shown people increasingly agreeing with that statement.
- 25:58It was much lower during the sixties and seventies, but it started going up eighties,
- 26:02nineties, more recent decades.
- 26:05And then a fourth way that you can study partisan polarization is that you study party
- 26:11in government, party and organization, and party and electorate.
- 26:15Now what does that mean?
- 26:16These terms describe studies of party in terms of how they operate in elected office, which is
- 26:22party and government.
- 26:24Party and organization is the campaigning arms of the parties slash interest groups, and party
- 26:32and electorate is the voters.
- 26:35So how partisan polarization looks can and often does differ within those three.
- 26:41Now there is some debate as to whether partisan polarization is looking more and more similar
- 26:47across all three of those, but still levels of party polarization differ to some extent within
- 26:54those three spheres.
- 26:56Now those are not the only ways to study partisan polarization, but they are examples.
- 27:01Now let's move on to ideological polarization.
- 27:05This refers to the level of polarization between ideological camps, between liberal and
- 27:10conservative.
- 27:11Do not fall for the trap of conflating party and ideology.
- 27:17A former professor of mine from grad school, doctor Craig, would be beside himself if I
- 27:22didn't make that clear or at least if people listening to this made that error in judgment.
- 27:30Yes.
- 27:30The parties tend to be ideologically one way or the other.
- 27:34Democrats tend to be more liberal.
- 27:36Republicans tend to be more conservative, and that's been increasingly the case since Barry
- 27:40Goldwater's presidential campaign in 1964.
- 27:44But ideology and party are two different dimensions.
- 27:47I can tell you from reading polls myself that there are still liberals in the Republican
- 27:52party.
- 27:53There are conservatives in the Democratic party.
- 27:55It's partially depending on how people define those terms of conservative and liberal.
- 28:02Because if I asked five different people what liberal meant and five different people what
- 28:06conservative meant, I could very well get five different answers.
- 28:10And, again, some people don't really think in ideological terms anyways.
- 28:17And there's also differing levels of conservatism and liberalism within the
- 28:22respective, quote unquote, correct parties.
- 28:25So some Republicans are somewhat conservative.
- 28:29Some of them are very conservative.
- 28:31Some Democrats are somewhat liberal.
- 28:33Some of them are very liberal.
- 28:36And some people identify with either the Democratic or Republican parties for reasons
- 28:41other than their general ideology.
- 28:43Maybe they vote that way simply because their parents voted that way, and they don't think
- 28:48much more beyond that.
- 28:49Well, my daddy and my mommy, they voted for Democratic party.
- 28:53They voted for the Republican party, so I do too.
- 28:56So it's sort of like almost an inherited trait that they that they got from their parents to
- 29:01just keep voting that way, and so it might take a lot more time for that opinion to change.
- 29:08But in any case, people have varying reasons for voting democrat, varying reasons for voting
- 29:15republicans, so it might not be about the ideology.
- 29:18But in essence, the more strongly someone identifies with an ideological label, the more
- 29:24ideologically polarized they are.
- 29:27So what are some ways that we can measure ideological polarization?
- 29:30Well, one way we can do it is by pulling differences in economic and social ideologies.
- 29:36You can be economically conservative, but socially liberal or vice versa.
- 29:41Whenever you just generally depend depends on what exactly you're studying.
- 29:46But in some cases, it's not very helpful to just ask, are you conservative or are you
- 29:53liberal?
- 29:54Unless it's like a very specific situation that you're talking about.
- 29:58But when you're talking about people's general ideologies, yeah, there are still plenty of
- 30:03people that are both economically and socially conservative, and there are a lot of people
- 30:06that are economically and socially liberal.
- 30:09But it usually helps to make a distinction in that regard, and a lot of studies do.
- 30:15And a lot of studies say the same thing of not looking at conservatism and liberalism as a one
- 30:22dimensional left to right spectrum.
- 30:25Look at it through two dimensions or even more dimensions than that.
- 30:30Another way you can study ideological polarization is by pulling self identification
- 30:35and ideological views.
- 30:37So this is often depicted as a seven point scale, one being very liberal, two being
- 30:44liberal, three being somewhat liberal, four being moderate, five being somewhat
- 30:50conservative, six being conservative, seven being very conservative.
- 30:56Some like the Gallup poll just generally trying to get an idea of how of how many people or the
- 31:02percentage of Americans that are conservative, liberal, moderate.
- 31:05They might just simply ask, are you conservative or are you liberal?
- 31:09And over time, there has become a little bit the percentage of people saying that they're
- 31:14moderate has gone up a little bit depending on polling that you're looking at.
- 31:20Sometimes you see a little bit of an uptick in conservative, but it partially depends on where
- 31:25exactly you go get that information.
- 31:27Another way that you can do it is by doing it on a strong, somewhat neutral, somewhat strong
- 31:33spectrum.
- 31:34Basically, strongly liberal, somewhat liberal, moderate, somewhat conservative, strongly
- 31:40conservative.
- 31:41You could also do it on a zero to 100 scale.
- 31:44And these all have their own benefits and drawbacks too.
- 31:48Zero to 100, some people might not necessarily think that granularly.
- 31:54And if you ask them on one day, they might say, oh, I'm 60.
- 31:57And then another day, they might say that they're 63.
- 32:00And is there a meaningful difference between the two?
- 32:03But you can get a lot more detail that way as opposed to a seven point or a five point scale.
- 32:09A third way that you can study ideological polarization is by pulling how much people
- 32:14believe their party should be uniformly ideological.
- 32:18You often hear both Democrats and Republicans lament that some of their fellow Democrats or
- 32:25Republicans are, quote, unquote, not true Democrats or Republicans.
- 32:30Is that no true Scotsman fallacy?
- 32:32And so you might hear the term dino, which is Democrat in name only, or more commonly, you
- 32:38might hear rhino, which is Republican in name only.
- 32:41The question of how much they think their correct, quote, unquote, party should be an
- 32:47ideal ideological lockstep can also differ.
- 32:51So somebody may be very strongly liberal, very strongly conservative, but they don't
- 32:57necessarily think about the fact that their party should be the exact same way as well.
- 33:02Some people do, and they will let you know they think that, but obviously not everybody's gonna
- 33:07feel that way.
- 33:09A fourth way that you can study ideological polarization is by looking at the ideology of
- 33:14elites versus the ideology of voters, and I want to highlight a specific study from long
- 33:21ago in that regard.
- 33:23It was Philip Converse and his seminal work, The Nature of Belief Systems in Mass Publics,
- 33:29all the way back from 1964.
- 33:31The study that he did indicated that there's a lot of difference in the sophistication of
- 33:36belief systems of government officials versus the public.
- 33:40Basically, elites' belief systems are more rigid and tied together while citizens are much
- 33:46more fluid and far less abstract.
- 33:49For government officials, being conservative, being liberal is a core part of their identity,
- 33:56and they have to have their issue beliefs in line with that conservative or liberal belief
- 34:04system.
- 34:05And if one issue belief changes, that tends to change beliefs in the rest of the system
- 34:11because they're so interconnected.
- 34:14For citizens, there's a lot less of that.
- 34:16If they change their belief on one issue, they're not necessarily going to change their
- 34:20belief on another issue.
- 34:22And they don't necessarily think in terms of ideology.
- 34:24They may think in simply in terms of has the party in power benefited a a social group I
- 34:30belong to?
- 34:31Is my wallet doing well while this party is in power?
- 34:37The ideology may not even cross their mind.
- 34:41One instance that you see this kind of thing in is in retrospective voting, which is simply
- 34:46people voting according to whether they think the party in power has done a good job or not.
- 34:51And if they think they haven't, then they're just gonna vote against them.
- 34:53If they think they've done a good job, they're gonna vote for them.
- 34:55A fifth way that you can study ideological polarization is through VoteView's DW Nominate
- 35:02scores.
- 35:03VoteView is a data repository on how members of congress have voted on bills and nominations
- 35:10and so on, specifically just taking into account what has come up for a vote and giving
- 35:16it a sort of, is this a liberal way to vote on it, or is this a conservative way to vote on
- 35:20it?
- 35:21And so they have this measurement called DW nominate, which spatially represents members of
- 35:27congress's ideology purely on how they voted, not how they identified themselves.
- 35:34Because due to what bills and nominations and so on are voted on, it can actually make
- 35:40somebody appear more or less liberal or conservative than they say they are, and it's
- 35:48just because of what's come up.
- 35:50So there's actually an article they wrote.
- 35:52I don't know how much it's relevant to them now, but you talk about Alexandria Ocasio
- 35:58Cortez, Rashida Tlaib, Ilhan Omar, Ayanna Pressley, very progressive, very liberal
- 36:05members of congress.
- 36:07But according to these DW nominated scores, at least early on, they appeared to not be that
- 36:14liberal, but that was partially because of simply what was coming up for a vote.
- 36:18So it didn't really let them show how liberal they were, at least to some extent.
- 36:25And just like any other measurement that you wanna use, it has its pros and cons.
- 36:30So it's in some ways useful to know how liberal or conservative they were based on what exactly
- 36:36was up for a vote, but sometimes you wanna know how conservative or liberal they are on things
- 36:40that theoretically could come up for a vote too, especially if you're a voter who cares
- 36:45about that kind of thing.
- 36:47And so and these scores go all the way back to the first congress for every party that has
- 36:52ever elected a member to congress.
- 36:54Even some very esoteric third parties that have long since come and gone, there's a DW Nominate
- 37:01score for them.
- 37:02In fact, let me show you right here the actual parties overview that they have here.
- 37:08This is congress at a glance, major party ideology, Federalist party when they still
- 37:15existed, then later on when they were replaced by the Whig party, and then when the Whig party
- 37:21became replaced by the Republican party.
- 37:23And then so you have also the Democratic Republican party, which later became the
- 37:27Jacksonians and then became the Democratic Party.
- 37:31So the Democratic Party has actually been around since the very beginning of the nation,
- 37:35technically.
- 37:36Republicans have only been around since the eighteen fifties, but you see all these median
- 37:41ideology scores here.
- 37:42That's largely because of what bills and nominations were up for a vote at that point.
- 37:48And then you've got the congressional medians as well, and they also do things by the
- 37:53chamber, by geography, but you also have these third parties here as well, like readjusters,
- 38:00national greenbacker party, prohibitionists, union labor, all sorts of things like that.
- 38:05So that's just another way that you can measure ideological polarization.
- 38:10You'd see it by how far the gap is here between the two major parties here and where the
- 38:19congressional median score for their ideology is here as well.
- 38:24Third type of polarization to talk about here, issue polarization.
- 38:29So this refers to the level of polarization on a particular issue, and this can look a lot
- 38:33like ideological polarization because there are there are often a lot of times a liberal view
- 38:39on a on an issue and then a conservative view on an issue.
- 38:42But this that is more for overall ideological views, not just on one specific issue.
- 38:48And these can be anything from the most pressing issues that the most people care about
- 38:54to more esoteric issues that maybe you're not even aware of.
- 38:59But even though a lot of political issues have a Republican or Democratic view or a
- 39:04conservative or liberal view, some political issues are not necessarily partisan or
- 39:09ideological in nature.
- 39:11For example, in a lot of ballot measure campaigns, you may see some odd pairings of
- 39:16government officials or candidates or interest groups that would otherwise not work together
- 39:23on anything.
- 39:25But how strongly they feel about that ballot measure, whether it's for or against, can
- 39:33indicate a measure of issue polarization.
- 39:37Broad policy issues are always much more nuanced than those with vested interests in
- 39:44them would have you believe.
- 39:45Now, you might still wholeheartedly support or oppose some issue while still acknowledging
- 39:50those nuances, not saying that that's not the case or that it's inherently wrong, but when
- 39:57you have a very strong opinion on a specific issue and you tend to lean very strongly one
- 40:05way or another, you tend to disregard the nuances and the little nooks and crannies of
- 40:11the issue.
- 40:13And you can be polarized on one or multiple issues, but not on others.
- 40:17Maybe you feel very strongly about guns or abortion, but you don't really care about
- 40:23what's going on in The Middle East or in Europe or or Russia.
- 40:29One example that you tend to see a lot of issue polarization on is the single issue voter.
- 40:34These are voters who choose a candidate purely based on their views on one issue, and they do
- 40:39not care about anything else.
- 40:41Or at least they might be like, I kinda wanna know what they have to say about that, but
- 40:46whatever that candidate has to say about one issue, any other issues they have, almost
- 40:52definitely not gonna change that single issue voters' opinion.
- 40:54Maybe they just care about marijuana, and who cares about what's going on with anything else.
- 41:00So these voters tend to be issue polarized.
- 41:04They might not care about party.
- 41:06They might not care about ideology, so they're not partisanly or ideologically polarized, but
- 41:10they are polarized on that specific issue.
- 41:12Maybe not any other issue, but that specific issue, they have a hardcore belief on that.
- 41:18But maybe they don't have a hardcore belief.
- 41:20Maybe they are a little bit middle of the road, but that's still the only issue they care
- 41:23about.
- 41:24But generally speaking, if you're a single issue voter, you tend to think very strongly
- 41:28one way or another on that issue.
- 41:33And in essence, the more strongly someone supports or ish opposes an issue, the more
- 41:38issue polarized they are, at least for that issue.
- 41:42So what are some of the ways that we can measure issue polarization?
- 41:45Well, one way is you can pull how much people agree or disagree with statements on a
- 41:50political issue.
- 41:51If you wanna simply ask, do you support abortion?
- 41:54And then you can depict this in several ways that we've talked about before.
- 41:57The zero to 100 scale, the strong, somewhat neutral, somewhat strong oppose or support.
- 42:03Strongly oppose it.
- 42:05Somewhat oppose it.
- 42:07Neutral on it.
- 42:09Somewhat support it.
- 42:10Strongly support it.
- 42:12Couple of different ways there.
- 42:14A second way that you can study it is by the support of nuances on a political issue, And
- 42:21there's been plenty of studies on this in the past.
- 42:24Another study in particular I'm thinking of, and I can't remember the exact name of it, but
- 42:30it was pulling abortion attitudes in a grad school professor of mine.
- 42:34The one actually who I talked about would be beside himself if I didn't specifically note
- 42:40the difference between ideology and party, Doctor.
- 42:44Stephen Craig, shout out.
- 42:46He was part of a study that actually, it might have been a couple studies that looked into
- 42:52abortion attitudes, and it took several specific situations.
- 42:55And I can't remember the exact situations, but when you're studying supportive nuances on a
- 43:00political issue, you take that one issue and break it down into specific situations and
- 43:04context and whether citizens support or oppose those contexts.
- 43:08Some people may generally say they support abortion or that they oppose abortion, but if
- 43:13you take specific context, now they start thinking, Oh, actually, I don't know if I
- 43:18support it in this context or I oppose it in this context.
- 43:21So if we want to use abortion, if you take the context of the life and health of the mother or
- 43:27the life specifically, if their life is in danger or maybe their life's not in danger, but
- 43:32they could have a severe health issue for the rest of their life.
- 43:36Do you support or oppose abortion there?
- 43:38What if the baby has birth defects?
- 43:42What is the economic status of the mother?
- 43:44Whether the baby was conceived through incest?
- 43:49All sorts of different context to think about.
- 43:52Doesn't mean that you necessarily can't oppose or support it in all those contexts, but it's
- 43:56just you might get different views on it when you start to break it down further.
- 44:02Or talk about owning guns.
- 44:04What if it's an automatic?
- 44:06What what if it's a semiautomatic?
- 44:09What about getting larger magazines to for more bullets?
- 44:16What what about bump stocks, which basically lessen the recoil of the weapon so that you can
- 44:23fire more shots off?
- 44:26Whether 18 year olds should be able to buy it or they have to be 21.
- 44:31Do they need background checks?
- 44:33All sorts of context to think about as to whether people support or oppose guns.
- 44:38And then a third way that you can study issue polarization is by studying how much one party
- 44:44or one ideology aligns on a particular issue.
- 44:48Now this can look like partisan or ideological polarization, which it is to some extent, but
- 44:53it's focused on a specific issue.
- 44:55So you're thinking of how much do Democrats support or oppose this issue?
- 45:01How much do Republicans support or oppose this issue?
- 45:03You'd ask the same question of conservative or liberal and see how much those ideological and
- 45:09partisan camps diverge on this issue.
- 45:12Again, not the only ways that you can study it, but some of the more prominent ways too.
- 45:18And then the fourth type of polarization to look at, affective polarization, which refers
- 45:24to the feelings and attitudes that we have toward other people, particularly those with
- 45:29differing political views.
- 45:30Note, this is affective with an a, not effective with an e.
- 45:37Most notably, this is the kind of polarization that contributes to the hatred we see today,
- 45:43And it doesn't have to be explicit hatred of other partisan ideological or issue groups.
- 45:48This can also be fear, disgust, distrust.
- 45:52If it's relating to your emotions, it's probably relevant to affective polarization
- 45:59because that translates to your feelings and attitudes about different groups of people or
- 46:05specific people.
- 46:06And so essentially, the more strongly and viscerally someone reacts emotionally to
- 46:12someone or something, the more effectively polarized they are.
- 46:17How do they feel about the Republican Party, the Democratic Party, conservatives, liberals,
- 46:23independents, moderates, specific issues.
- 46:27Yes, obviously, those also relate to partisan and ideological and issue polarization, but
- 46:33when you're talking about how they actually feel about those kinds of things, that becomes
- 46:38affective polarization as well.
- 46:40So what are some of the ways that we can measure affective polarization?
- 46:45One way, simple pulls of feelings about people's about people of different parties and
- 46:51ideological views, more so if a lot of people exhibit strongly or extremely positive or
- 46:57negative opinions about an individual group or entity.
- 47:01So maybe they have like a, well, I'm not a huge fan of the Republican Party.
- 47:07I'm not a huge fan of the Democratic Party, but I don't hate them.
- 47:10But then you have people that are like, I hate the Republican Party.
- 47:13I hate the Democratic Party.
- 47:15Maybe they hate both of them.
- 47:16That still is a measure of polarization, at least effectively, especially if these feelings
- 47:24are couched in partisan or ideological bias.
- 47:27For example, if you look at approval ratings of a sitting president and you look at it in terms
- 47:32of, well, how much do Republicans approve of this president?
- 47:35Obviously, Donald Trump in this case.
- 47:37How much do Democrats approve of the president in that case?
- 47:40A lot of it is both partisan and effective polarization.
- 47:45Democrats, not only are they tend to oppose Trump, they tend to strongly dislike, if not
- 47:51hate him.
- 47:53Republicans, not only do they support him, they tend to praise him, matter of partisan and
- 48:00affective polarization.
- 48:01Or if you looked at conservatives versus liberals, similar results, but again, partying
- 48:06ideology, not the same thing.
- 48:09A second way that you can measure affective polarization is looking at the errors in
- 48:14perceptions of the membership of other parties and the ideological extremity of social groups.
- 48:20So research has demonstrated this many times in the past where if you take, let's say, a
- 48:26Republican and you ask them how ideologically extreme they think Democrats are, or if you
- 48:31take a Democrat and ask them how ideologically extreme do you think Republicans are, they tend
- 48:35to think that their the other side is more extreme than they actually are.
- 48:39And a lot of times, they also tend to think that their side is less extreme than they
- 48:43actually are.
- 48:44Or people tend to overestimate the membership of social groups in a party.
- 48:50Maybe a Republican overestimates the number of black voters in the Democratic party.
- 48:56Maybe the Democratic party overestimates the number of Protestant Christians in the
- 49:01Republican party.
- 49:04Because of your effect of polarization, you tend to think, oh, there's probably a lot of
- 49:08those other people that are in that party that I tend to disagree with.
- 49:12Maybe not necessarily hating of those other social groups, but you still it's still couched
- 49:19in some sort of negative attitude or feeling that you have about that party.
- 49:24Another way you can study affective polarization is by studying the respect for
- 49:30political institutions, not just the membership of those institutions, but the institutions
- 49:36themselves.
- 49:37So how do people feel about the presidency, not just if it's Donald Trump there or Joe Biden
- 49:43there, Presidency itself.
- 49:46What about congress as a whole?
- 49:48Congress routinely very, very low in approval rating.
- 49:53US Supreme Court has experienced a lot of recent struggles in perception in that regard.
- 49:59So not just the people in these entities, the entities in themselves.
- 50:04And fourth way to study affective polarization, I'm gonna highlight a specific poll, and it's
- 50:11not, it was not one that was actually trying to measure effective polarization specifically,
- 50:16but some of the findings they have indicate a level of effective polarization.
- 50:22Georgetown University, I believe it's every year, they have a poll detailing general
- 50:29thoughts and feelings people have in regards to politics, not necessarily who they support, but
- 50:35general thoughts and feelings about what's going on.
- 50:39And several findings indicate a very incredibly unhealthy level of affective polarization.
- 50:47One example, the poll in 2023 found seven in 10 voters believed that their personal values were
- 50:56under attack, and that was a vast majority of Republicans, but it was also sizable majorities
- 51:00of Democrats and independents.
- 51:02You think your personal values are under attack.
- 51:05You're generally gonna have a very negative opinion of other people because you think
- 51:08they're trying to attack the core of who you are, that they're that it's an existential
- 51:13threat.
- 51:14And another way that that poll indicated a factor polarization was people's perception of
- 51:20the level of political division, the average rating they had there, and it was a zero to 100
- 51:25scale.
- 51:26And in that year, the average rating was 72.9 out of a 100.
- 51:33A 100 meaning you feel that the country's on the verge of civil war.
- 51:38So 72.9 is disturbingly high in that regard thinking that, boy, this level of political
- 51:45division is that's a really spillover.
- 51:48And then they also the poll also asked their perception or their prediction of the level of
- 51:54political division one year later, and it was actually up.
- 51:57It went from 72.9 out of a 100 to what of what they thought the level of political division
- 52:04was to 73.65 of what they thought it was going to be one year later.
- 52:12So they are thinking their personal values are under attack, the very nature of who they are
- 52:19was under attack, and also just the general level of political discord was astronomically
- 52:25high, which goes into the biggest point I want to make here.
- 52:34And it's why effective polarization is particularly insidious and can infect infect
- 52:41can also affect anyone, including me, and it's something I've I've gotta make sure I watch out
- 52:48for.
- 52:48Some people are partisanly polarized.
- 52:51Some are ideologically polarized.
- 52:53Some are issue polarized.
- 52:54Some people are a combination of the three.
- 52:56They might be partisanly and ideologically polarized, for example.
- 53:00And these can be problematic, but I don't want to say that people are inherently wrong by
- 53:08being largely one way or another.
- 53:11I'm trying to be impartial here.
- 53:13That's not really the problem, at least not by themselves.
- 53:20Being polarized along these lines still doesn't inherently mean you act in a toxic manner to
- 53:26others.
- 53:26Somebody can be very conservative, very liberal, very republican, very democrat, and
- 53:33still get along with a lot of different people that don't think like them.
- 53:39But anybody of any partisan, ideological or issue group can be effectively polarized.
- 53:48Not just extreme Democrats or Republicans, not just extreme Liberals and conservatives,
- 53:53independents and moderates can be just as susceptible to affective polarization because
- 53:59we're talking about emotions here.
- 54:00We're talking about thoughts and feelings towards other people, especially people who
- 54:05don't tend to agree with you on politics.
- 54:10For example, some studies have found many independents, not all, but many independents
- 54:14are motivated by their distaste or even hatred of the party they typically vote against or
- 54:20both major parties.
- 54:22And hate is a very powerful motivator for bringing people to the polls, especially those
- 54:28politically active people, because they tend to see things as an existential crisis.
- 54:33And moderates can be hateful of conservatives and liberals too.
- 54:38So we may all want to think that we're above polarization.
- 54:43What I talked about at the very beginning, we can all believe that we're above the political
- 54:48fray, and it's nice to think that way.
- 54:50Some people actually revel in the fact that they're in the mud and dirt of politics.
- 54:58Some people don't like that or at least say they don't like that, and they think that
- 55:03they're above it.
- 55:04But the problem is when it comes to affective polarization, any one of us can fall into those
- 55:09traps because the real issue is when we become affectively polarized.
- 55:14What are some of the things that that can lead to?
- 55:16It can lead us to treat politics as an existential crisis as a sport.
- 55:21I'm I'm a big sports fan too.
- 55:23Sometimes I am very biased against certain other teams or certain other fan bases.
- 55:31I try to as much as possible not to feel that way in politics, but it's a very easy thing to
- 55:37do to get very angry at somebody or some group or something when you have strong political
- 55:45beliefs.
- 55:46Another reason that the issue of effective polarization is the biggest issue when it comes
- 55:54to polarization is we think everyone's out to get us.
- 55:57So in turn, we are out to get them, and we justify that.
- 56:00We say, Well, I'm going to get them before I get God.
- 56:04I'm going to make sure that I'm protecting my beliefs and my people that I tend to agree
- 56:10with, and I'm going to stop these other people from trying to get me.
- 56:13You go back to that Georgetown University poll where how many people thought their personal
- 56:19values were under attack.
- 56:22Another issue with affective polarization is that it can feed into and reinforce the other
- 56:28types of polarization and that there is no way that they can start budging.
- 56:32Again, there is nothing inherently wrong with where you are on the party spectrum or the
- 56:39ideological spectrum or the issue spectrum.
- 56:41The issue comes from how you feel about people who have different opinions or the fact that
- 56:48you won't ever budge from your opinion because you think you have everything figured out,
- 56:53which is unfortunately a very big problem in politics.
- 56:56People who think that their worldview explains everything, even though it doesn't.
- 57:01Another effect of affective polarization is it can lead to the suppression of other opinions,
- 57:07and then you justify along various grounds.
- 57:10Oh, that that's something other people are saying.
- 57:12That's hateful.
- 57:13It's dangerous.
- 57:14It's unpatriotic.
- 57:17It's not just that you just tune them out that you just sit in your silo, your echo chamber,
- 57:22but you might actively start suppressing that opinion.
- 57:27How many times have we seen a political view that fit that in the minority that feels like
- 57:33it's being oppressed, that it's not getting its time to say anything that it's lambasting the
- 57:39majority party, majority power, and and how it tries to squash minority opinion.
- 57:46And then when that minority opinion becomes the one in power, they start to suppress other
- 57:52people's opinion.
- 57:53It's a tale as old as time, long before The US even became an entity.
- 58:00Another effect is that there's a reinforcement of echo chambers that are already prevalent in
- 58:07media, especially with these social media algorithms that just reinforce these attitudes.
- 58:13There's a litany of TV, radio, social media channels that will cater your specific views
- 58:19and make you feel all warm and fuzzy because you found somebody else that agrees with what
- 58:24you believe.
- 58:25Cause we all want to find people that agree with what we believe and so that we can have
- 58:30conversations with them.
- 58:31That's not nothing inherently wrong with that.
- 58:33It's one that's becomes the only group that you go to for information and to talk about, to not
- 58:40have any sort of challenge to your worldviews.
- 58:44And another issue to highlight that comes from affective polarization is it leads to people
- 58:50being more willing to justify and support the use of violence against even outright murdering
- 58:57opposition.
- 58:58We just saw it.
- 59:00Well, it was actually just today or yesterday for this recording.
- 59:05But by the time this comes out, it'll be several days ago.
- 59:09We just saw a former Minnesota state house speaker and her husband were just assassinated.
- 59:15Are you on the democrats that's on the democratic side, republican side.
- 59:21Donald Trump was the target of an assassination on the campaign trail last year.
- 59:26It's becoming a very disturbing trend how much that's becoming an answer for some people.
- 59:35And not only that, some people even justifying that or making an excuse.
- 59:40Maybe they're saying, you know, I don't I don't condone murder, but, you know, this person said
- 59:46that's not the point.
- 59:48The point is that violence in this regard is never ever the answer.
- 59:53You can't just beat people up because you disagree with them.
- 59:56You certainly can't kill them because you don't agree with them.
- 1:00:00And you have social media and media in general is just making this such a commonplace thing.
- 1:00:08And even if they're not outright saying to be violent towards somebody else, they are
- 1:00:15basically they are still riling you up and trying to get your emotions heightened, and
- 1:00:21then you do start to become more, if not approving, at least justifying of that kind of
- 1:00:30attitude, of that kind of action.
- 1:00:34And that's not something that we should ever, ever be okay with.
- 1:00:39Now, not everybody who exhibits some level of affective polarization will do all these
- 1:00:45things.
- 1:00:45Again, may only lead you to do something as simple as just constantly yell at people on
- 1:00:50Facebook and Twitter as if that's gonna solve anything.
- 1:00:54You may routinely ignore any opinions that are not your own.
- 1:00:58You may not actually try to suppress them, but you may just tune them out.
- 1:01:01But these are still issues that can lead to being susceptible to what your echo chambers
- 1:01:06tell you to do and what they tell you to think.
- 1:01:10You should never ever get to a point where you're just closing off, shutting off any sort
- 1:01:16of other opinions.
- 1:01:18It makes you a lot more easily manipulated because it's easy to get mad and be afraid of
- 1:01:25something, to hate something or somebody, to be disgusted with them, to have knee jerk
- 1:01:30reactions.
- 1:01:31They're very human emotions, and at some points in time, those are okay emotions to have.
- 1:01:39Some things should make us mad.
- 1:01:41Some things should be disgusting.
- 1:01:43We should hate certain things.
- 1:01:44We should be afraid of certain things.
- 1:01:47But this effect of a polarization, which is where we get exceptionally angry and
- 1:01:53exceptionally afraid and disgusted and distrusting of our fellow Americans, of our
- 1:02:00fellow human beings.
- 1:02:02Affective polarization is what is ultimately preventing us from achieving real long lasting
- 1:02:07solutions to our biggest issues.
- 1:02:11Also, funny enough, a lot of effectively polarized people, they don't think they're the
- 1:02:15problem, but that it's everybody else that needs to shape up.
- 1:02:19That Georgetown University poll, one of their other findings was that basically large
- 1:02:25majorities of people found while they supported the idea of compromise, they thought their side
- 1:02:31had compromised enough, and that's the other side that needs to give a little bit more
- 1:02:36ground.
- 1:02:37Although funny enough, they also did get asked later on.
- 1:02:40They said, okay, maybe we can give up a little bit more ground.
- 1:02:42So there's been some mixed signals from people to some extent in that Georgetown University
- 1:02:46poll, but it's a problem when you think that you are not susceptible to any sort of
- 1:02:53manipulative ploy.
- 1:02:55Unfortunately, with how human nature is and how our brains work, anybody can be manipulated.
- 1:03:03I can certainly be manipulated.
- 1:03:04I certainly not something I want to ever think is possible, but it can be.
- 1:03:10And I obviously, I don't support any of these real any hateful acts or any violent acts, but
- 1:03:16there are still ways that I can be effectively polarized.
- 1:03:19Any one of us can be effectively polarized even if we don't ever ultimately support drastic
- 1:03:26measures like murder or or at least beating the crap out of somebody, you can still completely
- 1:03:36shut people off and and go to your echo chambers, which still foments this affective
- 1:03:41polarization that other people are particularly susceptible to and start taking drastic
- 1:03:47measures because of.
- 1:03:49And there's a lot of social grifters, especially out in social media, that want to
- 1:03:55capitalize on affective polarization because our emotions make us ripe for manipulation, and
- 1:04:01these people know it, and they do it not just for political gain, but for monetary gain.
- 1:04:06You get a lot more clicks on your news articles and your YouTube channel by being loud and
- 1:04:14obnoxious and insightful.
- 1:04:18Not insightful as in, oh, this person's got really great things to say as in they incite
- 1:04:23people.
- 1:04:25And it just becomes this vicious cycle that self perpetuates these effectively polarized
- 1:04:33attitudes and actions.
- 1:04:35So I don't wanna just leave it, of course, on all that doom and gloom because there's there
- 1:04:40are ways that we can really check our propensity for effective polarization at the
- 1:04:48door.
- 1:04:48How do we check ourselves so that we aren't so effectively polarized?
- 1:04:53I will, as much as I don't like to self promote, I've mentioned it at the end of each
- 1:04:59episode, my educational email course about how we make mistakes when trying to depolarize the
- 1:05:08political climate that actually can make it more polarized and why we make those mistakes
- 1:05:13and how we can correct those mistakes.
- 1:05:15So that those are some ways.
- 1:05:19And I want to point you out to that.
- 1:05:21I don't want to give it all away here, but some other ways that we can be cognizant of our
- 1:05:28propensity for affective polarization and how we can make sure we at least lessen how much we
- 1:05:35act in that kind of manner to be actively cognizant of your own biases.
- 1:05:41Everybody's got them.
- 1:05:42Doesn't matter what your party affiliation is, or if you even have a party affiliation,
- 1:05:47doesn't matter your ideological affiliation or if you even care about ideology or what you
- 1:05:52think about issues.
- 1:05:55Everybody's got a bias because everybody's a human.
- 1:05:57Everybody has human nature affecting their thoughts and feelings and actions.
- 1:06:02How does how do those biases affect the kind of information you seek or let in?
- 1:06:08You think about, you know what?
- 1:06:10Maybe I am starting to really create this echo chamber.
- 1:06:14Maybe I am kind of getting this whole I've I'm I know everything kind of attitude.
- 1:06:20Maybe I do need to really start looking for other information that conflicts with my
- 1:06:25worldview or at least not so actively just look for just the things that agree with me.
- 1:06:31Another way is to expand your social and media circles with people of different backgrounds
- 1:06:36and views.
- 1:06:38Because not only is social media becoming more siloed, but our in real life, we're becoming
- 1:06:43more siloed too where we're I mean, people are severing friendships purely because differences
- 1:06:50of political opinion and not over things that are, like, like, the justification of violence
- 1:06:55kind of thing.
- 1:06:56Some people are just simply like, oh, that person's a conservative.
- 1:07:00Oh, that person's a liberal.
- 1:07:01I'm not gonna have anything to do with them.
- 1:07:02We can't do that.
- 1:07:04So expand your social and media circles so you have more of those kinds of people because
- 1:07:10we're all on the same team here.
- 1:07:12Another way to try to prevent affective polarization from affecting you.
- 1:07:19Do you reevaluate your opinions of other people and be willing to update your views?
- 1:07:24Every one of us can easily get upset at something or somebody and even if we don't
- 1:07:29remember the exact reason that we were upset at them, we remember that we were upset at them.
- 1:07:35So be willing to try to think about, okay, well, why did they think that way?
- 1:07:40Maybe they came across as a jerk, but they weren't actually trying to be.
- 1:07:46I mean, there's been times where I've had an opinion about somebody that I thought was and
- 1:07:51I'm just talking about in personal life, not necessarily specifically in politics.
- 1:07:56Although I've had a few of those too where I encounter somebody I think, oh, you know what?
- 1:08:02Actually, maybe I had this person wrong.
- 1:08:04I had people that have done that to me as well too.
- 1:08:06And and sometimes, you know, sometimes it is their fault.
- 1:08:09Sometimes it's my fault.
- 1:08:13It could be all sorts of reasons that you had that previous opinion about somebody.
- 1:08:18Be willing or something.
- 1:08:20Be willing to reevaluate it when you have more information.
- 1:08:24Another way to prevent affective polarization or at least hinder affective polarization from
- 1:08:30getting you is you recognize how your emotions can be manipulated for somebody else's game.
- 1:08:36I had not too long ago, several episodes ago, a a a bit about clickbait and rage bait and how
- 1:08:42effective it is and why it's so effective because we have a propensity to let our
- 1:08:48emotions get the best of us when we see something that makes us mad.
- 1:08:52And it's not just these these videos, these rage man clickbait videos, they're not just for
- 1:08:58the people that agree with them.
- 1:09:00Sometimes the people that disagree with those videos, they still engage with it.
- 1:09:05They still share that content and say, look how stupid and terrible this is.
- 1:09:09You're playing into these social grifters game.
- 1:09:13You are circulating that content.
- 1:09:16Even if you're not actually explicitly sharing it, you looked at it.
- 1:09:20You commented on it.
- 1:09:22You even if you didn't click on the video, you lingered on it and thought, oh, that thing
- 1:09:27really makes me mad.
- 1:09:28I wanna click on it.
- 1:09:30Don't do it.
- 1:09:31You're playing into their game.
- 1:09:33Ignore it.
- 1:09:33Unless it's something so that absolutely needs to be addressed, and even then, that can
- 1:09:41oftentimes be detrimental.
- 1:09:44Like, if there's something saying something racist or sexist, just report it.
- 1:09:48Don't don't engage with it because it's still circulating it.
- 1:09:52Report it if there's a way to report it because that way you, at least theoretically, hopefully
- 1:10:01if it is actually racist or sexist or homophobic or whatever, that content will
- 1:10:06actually be cut off before it really gets to reach a lot of people.
- 1:10:11It is, and it's, it's getting harder and harder to stop that kind of hateful content,
- 1:10:15unfortunately.
- 1:10:16But just don't let your emotions being manipulated to the point where you actually
- 1:10:21engage with that content in a way that helps that content fester and circulate.
- 1:10:27And then lastly, and this shouldn't really be something you have to say, and I think most
- 1:10:35people do get this, but never ever ever condone hate or violence.
- 1:10:43It's alright to get mad.
- 1:10:45It's alright.
- 1:10:46Or at least in a lot in some cases, it's alright to get mad.
- 1:10:49It's alright to be disgusted or to just have a visceral reaction.
- 1:10:55I mean, that that's that's normal.
- 1:10:57We cannot get to a point where we are outright hating somebody and wanting violence to happen
- 1:11:04to them and being okay with that violence because of differences in political views.
- 1:11:10We cannot have this.
- 1:11:11We cannot have what happened in Minnesota happen again or what has happened to countless
- 1:11:18Democrats, Republicans, independents, third parties, people being attacked, if not murdered
- 1:11:25for their views.
- 1:11:26We cannot have that happen in this country.
- 1:11:31And, hopefully, we're gonna be able to stem that tide at some point, but it's gonna have to
- 1:11:39take a lot of reevaluation from all of us in how we engage with political content.
- 1:11:48And so hopefully we will be able to fix these kinds of things.
- 1:11:53And I do have faith that we can fix these issues.
- 1:11:57But again, does not mean you can't be angry at anything or anyone that we can't hold people
- 1:12:02accountable because people do need to be hold held accountable.
- 1:12:06But a lot of times we mistake accountability with simply being, I don't like what this
- 1:12:10person said.
- 1:12:12If you're only attacking people that are on not on your side, that's and I'm not talking about
- 1:12:18physically attacking them.
- 1:12:19I mean, attacking them.
- 1:12:21That is not accountability.
- 1:12:23That is just getting mad at somebody for being different than you.
- 1:12:27We we can't keep doing this.
- 1:12:31This is not healthy for anybody, and we're not gonna solve our biggest issues by continuing
- 1:12:39this behavior.
- 1:12:42So hopefully those tips there that I gave are a good beginning point for people to for all of
- 1:12:52us to really step outside ourselves and really look at how we're engaging with politics.
- 1:13:01So I'm gonna end it there.
- 1:13:03As always, thank you so much for listening to the podcast.
- 1:13:07Please like, comment, subscribe, share the podcast with anybody you know, especially
- 1:13:14people that you you think could especially use a talk about polarization.
- 1:13:21Although, obviously, you gotta be careful with how you approach those kinds of people.
- 1:13:25You can't tell, Hey, you're an idiot and you need to watch this.
- 1:13:28That's not gonna help, but please like comment, share, and subscribe for the podcast.
- 1:13:33It's on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple podcasts.
- 1:13:38My links in the show notes like my Facebook, my LinkedIn, my educational email course that I
- 1:13:44just talked about, about some of the ways that we accidentally make polarization worse and why
- 1:13:51we make those mistakes and how we could do better and and fix those mistakes and believe
- 1:14:00that's it.
- 1:14:01So I'm gonna end things off here.
- 1:14:04Once again, as always, thank you so much, And let's all come together a little bit more and
- 1:14:12and really try to listen to each other a little bit more and not be so quick to anger.
- 1:14:19But, anyways, talk to you next time.
- 1:14:23Take care.