Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Gun fired on race to AR7, ship shape at North Star and capturing carbon out of thin air!
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, your weekly
- 0:06update on all the top news going on in the UK energy industry.
- 0:12My name is Erica Askelan, I'm the news editor of Energy Voice
- 0:16and I'm here with a bumper show. The news just keeps on happening
- 0:21and supposed to be a quiet time y'all, but like the stuff just
- 0:25keeps on going here. So you tune in and we've got it
- 0:28here. So today I've got reporter
- 0:33Michael Baer and I've got reporter Matthew Perry, and we
- 0:37are going to be taking you through a few exciting things
- 0:40that have happened, including the firing gun being shot at the
- 0:46opening of AR 7, which is very exciting.
- 0:50I also spoke to the chief executive of North Star Gita
- 0:55guard Tamo, on, you know, their absolutely exciting deal that
- 0:59they've done. And then we'll find out more
- 1:03about what's going on with direct air capture of carpet in
- 1:06the northwest of England. Hi, Michael, and hello, Matt.
- 1:10So how are you this morning? I'm not doing too bad, Erica.
- 1:14Things are pretty normal around here.
- 1:16But I think we're all pretty excited about AR 7.
- 1:19This is, this is going to be a bit of a, a live reaction, isn't
- 1:22it? Because the news has really just
- 1:23come in. So we're kind of pouring over
- 1:26the documents. But yeah, I'm good, Erica.
- 1:28I normally like to ask the the host how they're doing just to
- 1:31make sure you're not left out as well.
- 1:32Oh. Thank you again.
- 1:33Once again I I feel great. Actually, I'm looking forward to
- 1:37a few sunny days after our, like, terrible named storm that
- 1:43was florist. Although, you know what I
- 1:46sometimes think, you know, if we get named storms coming through
- 1:50in Scotland, it's a bit kind of blowy.
- 1:52Whereas everyone else is like, you know, running around like
- 1:54headless chickens. How did you survive Storm
- 1:57Flowers? I just bunkered down.
- 1:58So a little bit of a Michael lore.
- 2:01I recently moved into a new flat, so this was really me
- 2:04discovering whether it was a whether I got myself a lemon.
- 2:08One storm and the windows in. Yeah, one storm and the windows
- 2:12just blow off and I go, oh, that was a bad thing to get a
- 2:15mortgage on. You survived and and Matt Perry,
- 2:19how did you survive to name storms?
- 2:20Did you get a lot of those in your homeland of Australia?
- 2:23Well, not particularly named storms.
- 2:24They usually tend to be cyclones in in my neck of the woods.
- 2:27So a bit bit more. There was one that hit my
- 2:30hometown of Brisbane earlier this year, which was a a a
- 2:33novelty, but no offshore wind in in Queensland to be taking those
- 2:38heavy, heavy winds. But there was certainly probably
- 2:40a lot of quickly spinning turbines around up the coast of
- 2:44Scotland, I imagine in the midst of florists.
- 2:46Yeah. So would they have been shut off
- 2:49then? Almost certainly.
- 2:51Yeah, absolutely. The trouble is too much wind
- 2:53sometimes. Yeah.
- 2:54So we are the AR 7 is coming now Michael, you have been looking
- 3:03at maybe just some of the things that are going to be coming up
- 3:07for it, both of you have actually.
- 3:08So tell us what's going on, Michael.
- 3:10So and let's like I said, this is very much the live reaction.
- 3:13So we've just been kind of going over the documents.
- 3:16I mean, I think the first things to kind of look at probably are,
- 3:20you know, I think we're looking for any kind of surprises
- 3:22because AR 7 there's a lot riding on this, isn't there?
- 3:27We've seen, for example, AR5 was a big disappointment when we got
- 3:33no offshore wind base disaster. Yeah, AR 6 was the course
- 3:37correction. Everyone was getting really
- 3:39behind and going, oh, yeah, offshore wind is back.
- 3:42Until, you know, some commentators poured some cold
- 3:45water on it, pointing out that, well, if we're going to meet our
- 3:482030 goals, this was not enough. So AR 7 needs to be the big ramp
- 3:55up so. Well, but AR 6, you know, we
- 3:58also saw arsed pull out of that round because it turned out then
- 4:02it wasn't enough money. And def, I think money that's on
- 4:07the on the cards right now because we've been seeing that
- 4:11maybe the consensus around net 0 has been starting to break down
- 4:15a bit. We've definitely seen some
- 4:16criticism of people pointing out that, yeah, as prices have been
- 4:20going up after coming down for ages, that people are now kind
- 4:25of using that as a, a bit of a bit of a stick to beat
- 4:28renewables to point out, oh, you're, you're not the the
- 4:32cheapest option anymore, that you're kind of on par with gas.
- 4:36So that's definitely going to be one thing that we're going to
- 4:39have to look out for is, you know, are are we going to see
- 4:42prices go up so high that it becomes a bit prohibitive?
- 4:45I think it's fair to say that this AR 7 round will make or
- 4:49break Ed Miliband potentially because there is a lot riding on
- 4:52this. They've made a a big song and
- 4:55dance about this clean power by a 2030 target.
- 4:58They've they've not backed down in the face of a lot of other
- 5:01criticisms of their energy policies such as around the the
- 5:03windfall tax and and the prohibitions on further
- 5:07licensing in this with the oil and gas.
- 5:09So there really is a lot riding on this offshore wind,
- 5:13particularly auction bringing a big, big boost.
- 5:17And you know as as you mentioned, Erica that we've seen
- 5:19Hornsey 4 cancelled after and that was after they'd secured a
- 5:23CFD in AR-6. But we've seen we've it'll be
- 5:27interesting to see because there's been a lot of a lot of
- 5:29changes. You know, there was a lot of
- 5:30uncertainty leading into this around zonal pricing.
- 5:33That's now been confirmed that it's going to be dropped.
- 5:35We've got clean industry bonus coming in.
- 5:37We've got a plan to extend the length of CFD contracts from 15
- 5:41years out of 20 years. So this is a really very much a
- 5:44a new look CFD round for for AR-7, particularly when it comes
- 5:48to offshore wind. And we've got also the potential
- 5:53for fixed bottom offshore wind projects which haven't yet
- 5:57secured their full suite of consents to still bid in to make
- 6:01that competitive is, is the. Idea, the elephant in that room
- 6:07clearly bared bank, right? Because of course they received
- 6:11their planning permission recently and then I think that
- 6:14means that they're going into AR 7.
- 6:15You did a bit of work on runners and riders, didn't you, Matt?
- 6:19Yes. Tell us about who's who do you
- 6:20think is going to be throwing their hat into this ring?
- 6:22Well. We've seen from Energy Pulse,
- 6:25which is part of Renewable UK, they sort of do climate data and
- 6:29analytics. They've kind of run the rule
- 6:31over all of the projects around the UK that could be eligible.
- 6:34And there's about 25.1 gigawatts of offshore wind capacity that
- 6:38are eligible to enter. Now, of course, that doesn't
- 6:40mean that all of those projects will enter into AR 7 and it
- 6:44certainly doesn't mean that all of those projects will secure
- 6:47ACFD in AR-7. It's, it's interesting, I've not
- 6:51seen many predictions going around.
- 6:52I think people maybe might be a bit shy to to throw numbers out
- 6:56there considering some of the surprises we've had in the last
- 6:58few years. But we did see earlier this year
- 7:01Siemens MV Chief Executive Darren Davidson, he said that in
- 7:06his view, AR 7 will need to secure 6 gigawatts and that
- 7:10result would be higher than the record roughly 5 1/2 gigawatts
- 7:13secured in AR three-way back in 2019.
- 7:16That feels like another another world, another time 29/20/19 But
- 7:23you know, we we've to reach the government's Clean Power plan,
- 7:29the UK's offshore wind capacity currently at around 15 gigawatts
- 7:33and it needs to grow between 28 and 35 gigawatts by 20-30 to
- 7:38meet the government's Clean Power Plan.
- 7:40That is a lot of turbines, a lot of foundations, a lot of
- 7:44jackets, a lot of installation vessels all need to be scurrying
- 7:48around off the coast of the UK in the next few years.
- 7:50And to do that, they need some money, they need some revenue
- 7:53certainty. And that's what the government
- 7:56is aiming for with the as as Michael mentioned, pushing up
- 7:59the the strike price. I've seen a lot of commentary
- 8:02around that, you know, oh, this is so incredibly expensive.
- 8:05This obviously that's the maximum price the government is
- 8:07willing to pay. That will be coming down as
- 8:10these bids come in. And the idea, I guess is to
- 8:12opening up the the auction that will make it more competitive
- 8:15and bring that down further. But of course, the, the proof
- 8:18will be in in the pudding. I guess we really won't know
- 8:21whether all of this really won't know whether all of these
- 8:24policies, whether all of these changes will, you know, have any
- 8:27effect. Because as we've seen Hornsey 4
- 8:31don't think anyone was expecting that.
- 8:32So who, who I think the only people know people that know
- 8:36what's going on in, in terms of these bids are the the
- 8:40developers themselves. So, but as you said, Erica,
- 8:43Berwick Bank is, is one of the bigger ones that's eligible.
- 8:45We've also got the West of Orkney, one of the first
- 8:47Scotland projects off the ranks. If I can jump in on that, that
- 8:52I've heard gossip that that is the the one to watch because
- 8:56West of Orkney is one of the the most advanced Scotland projects.
- 8:59I don't want to say the most advanced.
- 9:01I'm sure I'll get an angry e-mail from some of the
- 9:03developers go and know we're more advanced.
- 9:05But the gossip is that if it doesn't to get a strike, if it
- 9:10doesn't get ACFD in this round, then it's probably going to mean
- 9:14that most of the Scotland projects aren't going to be able
- 9:17to to get CFDS. Not, you know, I don't want to
- 9:20make any comments on project economics, but just the
- 9:23timelines push them back to 2030.
- 9:26W of Orkney, the most advanced, can't get in there.
- 9:29Well, see, you know, we're kind of resting everything on this AR
- 9:347, you know, and it's coming up, which is why it's important.
- 9:38So thanks. That's a lot of drama, you know,
- 9:41coming up as everyone kind of submits their bids and we'll
- 9:45look to see if we reach the gigawattage as required.
- 9:49Before we finish up, should we make each throw a prediction out
- 9:53there, which do we think is the most likely?
- 9:57Michael, it sounds like you've got you're pretty confident that
- 9:59West of Orkney will be be coming up well.
- 10:01I want to jump in on your make or break, Ed Miliband.
- 10:05I want to do we think are we going to go bold and are we bold
- 10:09enough to see say that maybe there might be a change in the
- 10:13the Secretary of State if if AR 7 is a washout.
- 10:17Well, I certainly think that Ed Miliband will be having a few
- 10:21long weeks in the office in the in the coming weeks to get this
- 10:24go ahead. But in terms of in terms of
- 10:27projects, I'm just going to throw a random guess out there.
- 10:30I, I quite like the look of East Anglia 1 N Scottish Power
- 10:34renewables projects off the coast of Lowestoft.
- 10:36I reckon that will potentially be coming away.
- 10:39They've they've put a lot of money.
- 10:40Ibadrola's got some deep pockets, so that's one of the
- 10:43ones I think will be one of the ones to watch.
- 10:45Well, Ibadrola actually just did that big financing too with a
- 10:50consortium of like 24 banks and Masdar, which are pretty deep
- 10:55pockets from the UAE. So they've actually de risked
- 10:59everything, which is damn. Handy.
- 11:01Any predictions from either of you or am I going to be the only
- 11:03one to stick my neck out? Sticking your neck out.
- 11:06No, you know, I'm a I'm an offshore wind booster.
- 11:09So I'm going to I'm going to come on, say come on with the
- 11:11work. Nate lead the lead the Scott
- 11:13Wind Pack to to 2030. Well, what do you think of this
- 11:17cobra or white cross? I mean, you know, one of the
- 11:20first in Celtic Sea. Maybe they should maybe have a
- 11:26have a go. They've got in there, in there,
- 11:27just in time. In the floating family, they're
- 11:29they're certainly one of the stronger contenders, I think.
- 11:31But who knows? I guess we'll all we'll all see.
- 11:35Well, you know what, If anyone wants to kind of favorite this
- 11:38recording and come back, you know when the results of AR-7
- 11:42announced, then you'll know how good we are at this actual
- 11:45prediction game. We, we just tell you what's
- 11:48going on. We're not.
- 11:49We're not soothsayers. Well, stay tuned for the next.
- 11:56We'll take a quick break and then stay tuned for a little bit
- 12:00of a a setting sail with North Star, who's going to be creating
- 12:04100 jobs along the East Coast of the UK.
- 12:44You too welcome and thank you very much for joining us.
- 12:46Congratulations on the landing, the big deal.
- 12:50Can you tell us a little bit about that?
- 12:52Yes, first of all. Thank you for inviting me,
- 12:54Erica. And yes, North Star has secured
- 12:58a multi 1,000,000 LB landmark deal which was announced
- 13:01yesterday, which is a very big deal for the company and it is
- 13:05the largest deal within our sector or our segments which is
- 13:09service operation vessels ever made actually.
- 13:12So here at North Star it is a pretty vibrant workplace at the
- 13:17moment, a lot of happy Co workers and good atmosphere.
- 13:21Indeed, Indeed. So now and of course, this is
- 13:24also going to create more jobs for the group.
- 13:28You know, we'll probably have to focus on that a little bit.
- 13:30So 100 more people are going to be involved with the business in
- 13:36order to kind of meet this contract.
- 13:37Is that about right? That is true, and yes, and that
- 13:40is true. Just to frame it a little bit,
- 13:41that is an agreement between Northstar and RWE, which is one
- 13:47of the world's leading companies within offshore wind.
- 13:49So it's a big deal for us to be given this trust by our new
- 13:54clients. So it's a completely new client
- 13:56for a North Star. And the deal compromises of two,
- 14:02two term, long term contracts on 2 existing vessel, our Grampy
- 14:05Castrol and our Grampian Eagle. So our vessels and our excellent
- 14:09crew will serve two of those long term contracts and the
- 14:12other two vessels that will be served available to RWE is 2 new
- 14:19bills which we an agreement we went into with valve also
- 14:24yesterday announced yesterday. So 4 vessels.
- 14:27This is a four vessel agreement between Northstar and RWE.
- 14:32As for the 100 new jobs, most of them are offshore but also
- 14:37onshore. People will be higher along the
- 14:40East Coast of UK, both hopefully here in Aberdeen and our
- 14:45headquarters in Newcastle and in Lovestock.
- 14:49We will also probably be looking to increase our staff in our
- 14:53Hamburg office. So yeah, good day for North
- 14:57Star. Exciting times.
- 14:59Exciting times, absolutely. I think there's something unique
- 15:02about what North Star is doing here and it's about creating
- 15:08relationships with this great industry, You know, that's right
- 15:16on, you know, our coast, right off our shores.
- 15:20But then you're also delivering unique vessels that are, you
- 15:26know, specifically aimed at, you know, the needs and requirements
- 15:30of offshore wind because I guess, you know, as a, as an
- 15:34operator of, you know, surface vehicles, vessels for the oil
- 15:41and gas industry for many, many years, you're now doing
- 15:46something different and you're building new boats.
- 15:48I mean, we love new boats, right?
- 15:50That's always exciting, too. Yeah.
- 15:52But is this because, is it because we need specifically
- 15:57unique boats to tackle this market?
- 15:59Or is it because the market just needs the new boats just because
- 16:03there's so much going on with the advent of more offshore
- 16:06wind? No, it requires specific vessels
- 16:10with specific qualities, technical capabilities and also
- 16:13specific mission critical equipment such as gangways.
- 16:17But the cool part about it, if you take North Star, this
- 16:21company has 139 years history, it's a legacy company in
- 16:25Scotland and the marvet incompetence is fully
- 16:29transferable. So the people on board are
- 16:33vessels, 60% of the people on the SOV, the service operation
- 16:37vessels are transferred from the Earl fleet, the emergency
- 16:41response and rescue vessels which you've seen all along
- 16:43Scotland and especially here in Aberdeen.
- 16:45So it's the same competence. But we have utilised their
- 16:48tremendous historical maritime competence within this house,
- 16:52this fully integrated chip owning company into a new
- 16:56offshore wind market. So for me it is cool over more
- 17:01than one scale. It is cool to the big national
- 17:03international deals etcetera. But how cool is it, Erica, to
- 17:07utilise the competence you have in one segment, an oil and gas
- 17:10segment and transfer it into offshore renewable?
- 17:14And it's the same people, it's the same skill set.
- 17:16So we are using the maritime competence, which all of
- 17:19Scotland is known for, to make a big splash in a new, new
- 17:25segment. Just as a reference point, in
- 17:292021, N Star had 0 backlog in offshore wind.
- 17:33Today, 70%, Sixty to 70, I haven't really calculated it.
- 17:37Percent of this company's backlog is an offshore
- 17:40renewable, so same competence, we're able to utilize it in more
- 17:45than 11 segment and the vessel requirements, they're different.
- 17:50So it's not easy for us to wreck or fit or rebuild the vessel we
- 17:54had in oil and gas and used them in the in the new segment.
- 17:58The first move into that was you.
- 18:01Your previous landmark deal was with Dogger Bank developing new
- 18:06vessels, you know, for that the biggest offshore wind farm in
- 18:10the world once it's completed. And so is that, is it the
- 18:14learnings that you got through that deal that do you think has
- 18:18brought you to, you know, new customers such as this one, that
- 18:23deal that you've signed with RWE?
- 18:24Very good question and the answer is, if I should put it
- 18:27simply, it is yes. To explain, Erica, when you are
- 18:31to penetrate the new market to enter an adjacent market to
- 18:35where you're at, the one thing that you will are short of in
- 18:38the beginning that is track record and operating offshore
- 18:41vessels. It's a very advanced and
- 18:43operationally challenging industry.
- 18:45Whether you're in the industry or you're in the offshore
- 18:48renewable segment, it's challenging.
- 18:50It is capital intensive industry.
- 18:52So you need and our clients wants to see a track record.
- 18:56So for Equinor to put the trust in North Star that is has a
- 19:00tremendous help for North Star and building the track record we
- 19:04need it. And after that we have now a
- 19:06contract with E MB W, we have it Siemens Commerce and this
- 19:09landmark deal with RWE. So very good question.
- 19:12And that is like the main, you know hurdle you meet the lack of
- 19:17actual operational experience and track record, but now we
- 19:20have it. No, I, I don't, you know, and
- 19:24not to put, you know, kind of like too fine a point on
- 19:27anything, but you know what is there anything specific that
- 19:30North Star offers these customers to get into that
- 19:34market? You know, there's, you know, we
- 19:37see some, you know, other vessel operators, you know, across
- 19:40Europe, you know, also kind of servicing this market to tell us
- 19:44maybe a little bit about the dynamics about how you break in
- 19:48and how you, you know, kind of deliver what these customers are
- 19:52looking for. What are they looking for?
- 19:54The dream question for Northstar now I think there is a
- 19:57difference at the Northstar path and there are two things.
- 20:00One of them is that we are fully integrated ship owning company,
- 20:03meaning that we have all disciplines in house, whether
- 20:06it's HR, whether it's crewing, technical operations, HSEQ.
- 20:11This is a ship owning and maritime competence house.
- 20:15So we have all of the disciplines in house.
- 20:18Of course that is a safety for a client who wants to have a long
- 20:21term relationship with the ship owner that we are a fully
- 20:24integrated ship owning company. That is one part of it.
- 20:29And I think also then the other part and it's the more vital
- 20:31part is the more incompetence. We are big enough.
- 20:34We are, we have the scale with our 48 vessels and operations
- 20:39seems to be 50 vessels when the new bills are delivered.
- 20:41We have enough people and flexibility.
- 20:44So we have the systems in place, strong system values and also
- 20:47large number of people. So we're not vulnerable if one
- 20:51person cannot come one day. The scale of North Star equals
- 20:56the flexibility of the company, which again equals operational
- 21:00safety for our clients. So for me I would say, yeah,
- 21:05scale and that we are fully integrated chip owning company.
- 21:09Also of course you mentioned Partners Group.
- 21:11It doesn't hurt to have an owner that believes in you and that
- 21:15are steadfast to your strategy. And our owners are very lucky.
- 21:19They also know the offshore wind industry all the way through the
- 21:23value chain. We have been part of developing
- 21:25of the wind farms and so to have an owner and a steadfast
- 21:29investor who believes in the strategy are not dedicated to
- 21:31it, that also helps. We've got another break coming
- 21:34up, stay tuned where we find out about how you can capture carbon
- 21:39from the air in England. Have you ever heard of
- 22:36technology where you can just literally suck carbon out of the
- 22:40air? Now, if you could make this
- 22:43work, this would kind of like end, you know, all the problems
- 22:46with greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, wouldn't it?
- 22:50So I'm going to get Matt to dial in.
- 22:55He's a bit of a direct air capture specialist on our team.
- 22:59Tell us what's going on. Seems like Climb Works is coming
- 23:02to England. Well, yes.
- 23:03Well, for those who aren't aware, direct air capture is a
- 23:06form of carbon capture and it differs from a lot of the carbon
- 23:09capture that we talk about quite often on this show, which is
- 23:12more I think known as point source carbon capture.
- 23:15So when you talk about high net, the Northern Endurance
- 23:18Partnership, ACORN, what those projects are doing is capturing
- 23:23carbon emissions from an industrial process.
- 23:25You know, you're burning gas, you're burning all sorts of
- 23:28things, creating that emissions, you're capturing it and then
- 23:30you're storing it. Whereas direct air capture that
- 23:33just sucks air through these big fans and rolls around in a VAT
- 23:36and pulls a carbon directly out of the atmosphere.
- 23:40So that's not from an industrial process.
- 23:42It's just out of the air that we all live and breathe in.
- 23:45And, and so as you're saying, Erica, that's it's a, it's an
- 23:49interesting concept, isn't it? If you could scale this up, if
- 23:51you could make it affordable, if you could make it efficient
- 23:53enough, then you know, Bob's your uncle.
- 23:55We can just pull all the carbon around out of the atmosphere and
- 23:58we'd all be be great. It does sound great.
- 24:00The reality is, is, is quite different because, well, the
- 24:05reason we're talking about this is because the UK government has
- 24:08outlined a couple of track one expansion projects that are
- 24:12shortlisted for the negotiations phase for the high net project
- 24:15in the northwest of England. And one of those ones that we've
- 24:18not really heard about before. It was an interesting addition
- 24:20to the list is called the Silver Birch project from Climbworks.
- 24:25And Climbworks is one of the, the leaders in direct air
- 24:28capture around the the world. They're a Swiss firm and they've
- 24:32got a big project up in Iceland that I was lucky enough to go
- 24:35and visit last year called Mammoth.
- 24:37And Mammoth is you basically walk it's connected to this big
- 24:41geothermal power plant. It was huge.
- 24:44They were only halfway through building it when I was up there.
- 24:46But they, it's, it's sort of this giant facility that has
- 24:50these huge, it looks like, you know, the world's biggest air
- 24:52conditioning unit is, is what it, what it feels like.
- 24:55And it's basically this huge fan sucking the air goes through
- 24:59these pipes, say they swirl it around.
- 25:01You can tell I'm, I'm very technically minded in the way
- 25:03I'm describing this, but pulls the carbon out.
- 25:05And then what they do in Iceland is, say, push it into this.
- 25:10They use a company, an Icelandic company called Carb Fix is able
- 25:13to mineralize that carbon into the rock.
- 25:14And all of that is powered by the very reliable geothermal
- 25:18electricity that Iceland produces.
- 25:20And what Kleinworks appears to be looking at is doing a similar
- 25:23thing, making use of Enny's Liverpool Bay CCS project and
- 25:28some of the power generation at Hynet.
- 25:32But you know, a lot of scepticism around this sort of
- 25:36direct air capture. There is, you know what I mean?
- 25:40It kind of, you know, I would have thought that, you know,
- 25:43kind of when they made this announcement that there would be
- 25:45a bit of a fanfare, but it like really wasn't.
- 25:47It's like they're trying to keep it secret.
- 25:49Is it just because people are like going and that's not going
- 25:52to happen? Well, one of the main criticisms
- 25:55about direct air capture is that there's a lot of uncertainty
- 25:59about what the market is it really the, the only market for
- 26:02direct air capture companies is to sell the, the carbon that
- 26:05they pull out of the atmosphere as credits.
- 26:07And it's really only been a lot of large sort of tech companies,
- 26:12you know, like Microsoft and and Stripe, they were some of the
- 26:16big backers of, of climb works in particular.
- 26:19They sort of buy these credits and then then they can go to
- 26:22their, you know, customers and investors say, look, we're,
- 26:24we're offsetting all of our emissions.
- 26:26Look how how wonderful we are, but there there has been a lot
- 26:28of investigation into, you know, climb works as operations up in
- 26:33Iceland. There was a lot of the the orca,
- 26:37which was a pilot project that they built before it was meant
- 26:40to suck 4000 tons of of carbon atmosphere.
- 26:43It, it has really struggled to reach that that target and then
- 26:46mammoth simile that's aiming to capture up to 36,000 tons of CO2
- 26:51per year. In the grand scheme of things,
- 26:53these are very, very tiny numbers.
- 26:55But what Kleinworks argues that this is, these are pilot
- 26:58projects. You know, you the first lithium
- 27:00ion batteries when they were being getting developed, the
- 27:03first solar panels, you really wouldn't have thought solar
- 27:06would be, you know, powering so much of the world's electricity
- 27:09demand at the moment. But they've gotten more
- 27:12efficient, they've gotten better They've they've, they've built
- 27:14those processes from those early stage projects.
- 27:16That's the argument they're making in favour of direct air
- 27:18capture. But, you know, these are very
- 27:23energy intensive. They're expensive to run.
- 27:26They have struggled to, to meet our climate actually earlier
- 27:29this year had to cut up to around 20% of its global
- 27:32workforce. I mean, more uncertainty because
- 27:34after Donald Trump and his second presidential
- 27:36administration came in, they, you know, there's a lot of
- 27:39uncertainty around their support for a proposed DAC plant they
- 27:42had going Louisiana. So there's there's really kind
- 27:44of not this ready made market, but what is interesting is if
- 27:49you can actually make a product out of that.
- 27:51So there are a few other companies one of them is in
- 27:54based in the UK called Mission 0 technologies.
- 27:56They're piloting DAC technology that pulls that carbon out of
- 28:01the atmosphere and then uses it to create things like synthetic
- 28:04aviation fuel, uses it to create carbon negative building
- 28:07materials from captured CO2. There's another Icelandic firm
- 28:10that I spoke to last year and they advancing several projects
- 28:14around the world which use captured CO2 and green hydrogen
- 28:17to produce their focus on E methanol.
- 28:19Equinor is an investor in this company which is carbon
- 28:21recycling international. So there's a lot of investment,
- 28:26a lot of money being spent still in this, this area.
- 28:28It's I guess uncertain as to whether, you know, purely just
- 28:31selling the carbon credits is really the, the, I guess the,
- 28:35the best business model for these companies.
- 28:38And I think we're something like the high net.
- 28:40If climb works can integrate this technology into a company
- 28:44combined with, you know, you've got ET producing low carbon
- 28:47hydrogen there. If you've got carbon, you've got
- 28:50hydrogen that opens up and you've got the Ellesmere Port
- 28:53Stanley refinery, but all of those companies up there, that
- 28:57potentially creates some interesting possibilities of
- 29:00using that captured carbon to create, you know, I'm, I'm
- 29:03already thinking of the, the marketing possibilities, but you
- 29:05know, carbon negative jet fuels things, things like that, You
- 29:09know, cement, we've got Heidelberg materials there,
- 29:11carbon negative cement. So it's interesting that now,
- 29:15you know, climb works is, is because they've initially built
- 29:18this big project up in in Iceland because they have that
- 29:22readily accessible geothermal power, electricity that can, you
- 29:26know, can run this very, very cheaply.
- 29:29But now they're looking at, you know, high net and these huge
- 29:32industrial plants. And maybe that could be an
- 29:34indication of where they see direct air caption moving into
- 29:37more that providing a, a fuel stock for for these sort of
- 29:41carbon, carbon derivatives. Can we talk a lot about hydrogen
- 29:44derivatives? But maybe we'll start talking
- 29:46about, you know, captured carbon derivatives in there and the
- 29:49fuels and the products you can make and, and sell from that.
- 29:52So. But of course, as you were
- 29:53saying, you know, a lot of the other criticism is that the only
- 29:57companies really investing in these sorts of things, apart
- 29:59from tech companies are oil and gas companies.
- 30:01A lot of people saying they're only doing so so they can keep
- 30:04their current oil and gas developments going.
- 30:06But it was interesting coming across a few posts on LinkedIn
- 30:09after this sort of story came out and you had people like
- 30:13Cerica Energy Chief Financial Officer Martin Copeland.
- 30:16He could have compared to the Emperor's New Clothes fairy
- 30:19tale. And I thought that hunting Chief
- 30:22Executive Jim Johnson had probably the the most amusing
- 30:25take. He had quite a simple response.
- 30:27Just plant some trees because that is certainly a a way to
- 30:30capture carbon from the atmosphere is plant some trees.
- 30:32Indeed, indeed. Although I guess, you know, I I
- 30:35mean, you know, I love a tree. You know, I, I think I, I have a
- 30:39business card somewhere that says tree hugger on it, you
- 30:41know, in an ironic kind of way. But you know, you can't, You
- 30:45know, I think maybe the thing about carbon sinks and, you
- 30:48know, forestation and stuff like that probably means that you'd
- 30:52have to basically forest everywhere in order to kind of
- 30:57plant as much carbon as we're trying to, you know, kind of
- 31:01removed from the atmosphere. Which of course, you know, makes
- 31:04it difficult for, you know, things like roads and homes and
- 31:07farming and all that sort of stuff.
- 31:09But yeah, you know what I mean? I remember the first time I
- 31:13heard someone mention direct air car, direct air capture and I'm
- 31:16like going we can do that. That's amazing, right?
- 31:20Like I've just always been really kind of like enthralled
- 31:24by it. And if I were, you know, like a
- 31:28multi squillionaire Bond villain type, I'd probably want to be
- 31:32putting my money into it. But that said, you know, I mean,
- 31:36yeah, AI think you're thank you, Matt, you know, for going all
- 31:39through that because you either need a market for the car carbon
- 31:41to pay for it, or you need, you know, kind of it needs to be
- 31:47improved technology, which means that it uses less energy than it
- 31:53creates and or that it takes in in carbon, you know, or else
- 31:57it's kind of like a 0 sum game. And that's the point that we
- 31:59haven't reached yet. So climb works as as cops and
- 32:02criticism because I think it came out recently that they
- 32:06created more emissions recently than they captured.
- 32:12So they may argue that we're still in early stage start up.
- 32:15We're we're getting there, we're scaling up.
- 32:17This is a this is a process. But I think one of the other
- 32:21things that is really important for directory capture, as we was
- 32:23talking about is a reliable, stable, cheap electricity source
- 32:27to to power these machines. So, you know, they're, they're,
- 32:30I was talking to Mission 0 technologies recently and we, we
- 32:34often hear about hydrogen, electrolytic hydrogen as a
- 32:38potential for, you know, when offshore wind production in
- 32:44places like Scotland exceeds the, you know, the capacity of
- 32:47the grid they have to currently power down.
- 32:49There's this talk of, you know, we could use that excess to
- 32:51those degrees to create hydrogen.
- 32:53Mission 0 Technologies believes that there's a potential there
- 32:55to use their carbon direct air capture technology as in a
- 33:01similar way to the way people are proposing.
- 33:02So when you've got like during storm florists, instead of
- 33:06powering down on those wind farms, the DAC plants power up
- 33:09suck as much carbon as they can during the storm.
- 33:11That's kind of the idea. And I guess the other proposals
- 33:16that I've also seen that the UK government is is putting some
- 33:18some early funding into. We we talk about the yeah, the
- 33:22government is currently saw the golden age of nuclear and we are
- 33:25seeing a big investment in in nuclear energy.
- 33:27That's obviously seen as a very carbon friendly stable base load
- 33:32security supply. So there is been some early work
- 33:34done on where whether the size will see nuclear power plant can
- 33:40incorporate a direct air capture plant with it.
- 33:43So there's a lot of interesting work going on, a lot of
- 33:47scepticism as well. And as ever, we'll be keeping
- 33:51you abreast of everything that happens, the good, the bad, and
- 33:54the ugly. I don't think we're skeptics
- 33:56here at Energy Voice Out Loud, but I think we do need to kind
- 34:00of sometimes interrogate, you know, some of these things that
- 34:03are emerging. You know, some of the greatest
- 34:06ideas started out as some sort of like lunatic suggestion.
- 34:11So we're keen on finding out, you know, just what's going to
- 34:16happen and what's going to take place out there.
- 34:19So thank you, Matt, for really giving us that deep dive into
- 34:24direct air capture in the UK and around the world.
- 34:29And thank you, Michael Baer for giving us your insights into
- 34:33what we're going to be doing with AR-7.
- 34:36I've been Erica Ascoland from Energy Voice and you've been
- 34:40listening to us. And I'd like to thank you
- 34:43listeners. And if you want to keep
- 34:45listening, always find us every week.
- 34:48Energy Voice out loud on your platform of choice.