Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / Attack of the Karens!
Transcript
- 0:01My sister's a therapist and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:09Hello and welcome to my Sister's a Therapist.
- 0:12My name is Virginia Jones. I'm a stand up comedian who
- 0:15lives in Portland, OR, but my sister's a therapist.
- 0:17Hello, I'm Laura Ryan. I'm a licensed marriage and
- 0:20family therapist, but my main credit is sister to the Lioness
- 0:23of Laughter, Virginia Jones. No.
- 0:25Comment Laura, On this show, we take turns researching a talk
- 0:30that we're interested in and then springing it on the other
- 0:32person who gets to be surprised and hopefully interested in the
- 0:36topic at hand. This week, it's your turn.
- 0:37What would you like to talk about?
- 0:39Well, Virginia, this week you get to be the potted plant
- 0:42because I am the knower of all things.
- 0:44This week's episode is a listener idea, so I'm going to
- 0:48read the listener's e-mail. And also if you are a listener
- 0:51and you would like your idea on the show, just e-mail us at
- 0:54hello@mysistersatherapist.com. So this is an e-mail from Anna.
- 0:59Hello ladies. I want to suggest a topic that I
- 1:02think you'd absolutely crush the current social media
- 1:04conversations about white womanhood.
- 1:06There's been a lot of commentary flying around.
- 1:08Everything from this is peak white woman to observations
- 1:12about how middle-aged women, especially white middle class
- 1:14women, are often pathologized or unfanalized in public discourse.
- 1:18I think this could make for such a rich conversation about race,
- 1:20gender, mental health, privilege, and even how people
- 1:23perform trauma or innocence depending on context.
- 1:26Maybe even discuss broader dynamics like entitlement and
- 1:29performative victimhood. So, Virginia, as a white
- 1:32middle-aged lady, how do you feel about this?
- 1:35Dynamic, I think it's really interesting.
- 1:37Obviously I carry, I think, a standard amount of white guilt
- 1:41like. A standard amount of what?
- 1:43Buckshot I. Think we all have a?
- 1:45Standard amount of buckshot. We grew up in the state of
- 1:48Texas. I appreciate the dialogue.
- 1:51I appreciate being forced into a different perspective.
- 1:54Perspective. I sit before you today and say
- 1:56that if your feminism is not intersectional feminism, it's
- 2:00not feminism. But my friend Amy Miller, a very
- 2:03funny comic, just wrote about this on Threads and said
- 2:06something I learned this week is you cannot anger our fellow
- 2:09white women who spend all day on Threads.
- 2:12They're unwell, unfunny, and they've got nothing but time.
- 2:16The thing about being trolled by my fellow unhinged white women
- 2:19is that they're usually so unoriginal and unfunny.
- 2:21It gives me a nice little sense of job security.
- 2:23If you call me fat or teamu somebody, usually Teamu Amy
- 2:26Schumer. Now I know you've never said a
- 2:28funny or unique thing in your life and your hat is ugly.
- 2:30She is experiencing a lot of carroting, a lot of carroting
- 2:34and a lot of judgement you can feel in social media.
- 2:38You just can't win with anybody. Your beliefs and attitudes are
- 2:42either way too liberal or insensitive and not liberal
- 2:47enough. No one's opinion can possibly be
- 2:49correct because someone else is always going to be in conflict
- 2:52with it. I wouldn't really own that
- 2:53entitlement. Right.
- 2:54And I think the problem for me as a white woman is sometimes
- 2:57I'll want to make a funny joke and then I think, but I'm a
- 3:00white woman, so it's going to be more offensive or it's going to
- 3:03be read differently. I was watching a TikTok today.
- 3:06It was a spoof on a women's podcast, but it was 3 gay guys
- 3:10dressed up as women and it was really funny.
- 3:12But they all had facial hair. And so I was going to do a joke
- 3:17about, hey guys, a little wax on the upper lip can do wonders.
- 3:21But then I thought, no, someone's going to be offended
- 3:23by that. Right.
- 3:24I was going to say, how dare you.
- 3:26Women can have mustaches, women can have beards.
- 3:28Yes, that's true. My friend Jackie Kashian, who is
- 3:31now and has always been for the working person, pro
- 3:34intersectional feminism, pro minority, has been called the
- 3:38Karen many times just because she's a middle-aged white woman.
- 3:41Back in the day, being a middle-aged white woman wasn't a
- 3:43crime, but these days it certainly does feel that.
- 3:46Way it absolutely is. I've got a bit called The
- 3:48backlash against Karen memes is Peak White Feminism by Stephanie
- 3:52Younger. Karen is a term that is aimed
- 3:54towards entitled and demanding white women.
- 3:57One of the most common caring stereotypes is that of a white
- 4:00middle-aged woman, typically American, who has a Bob cut
- 4:03Laura and a poor attitude towards customer service
- 4:05workers. Such women are depicted as
- 4:07demanding to quote, speak to the manager.
- 4:09This is from Wikipedia's definition of a caring meme.
- 4:11While white women have the privilege of simply being called
- 4:14a quote Karen UN quote for enforcing oppression against
- 4:16marginalized people, Black women and girls are dismissed as
- 4:19angry, aggressive, and confrontational when we speak up
- 4:22about the injustices that we experience.
- 4:24Jackie, I know personally, tries to use her caring for good.
- 4:28She tries to use her power to stand up for other people to
- 4:31defend them. But I know many white women are
- 4:34defending their position as the next to most dominant species in
- 4:39our. Society, the white supremacist,
- 4:41patriarchal pecking order. White women are under white men.
- 4:45I think a lot of times white women will get a little uppity
- 4:48as they say and think I deserve special treatment.
- 4:52I was thinking there's a lot of commonality in Karen's and
- 4:56narcissism because they meet a lot of those same criteria.
- 4:59They believe that they should receive special treatment just
- 5:02simply because they are older white women.
- 5:04I think a lot of the agita and the internal struggle of the
- 5:08Karen is maybe you were an eating disordered blonde woman
- 5:13who got a lot of attention 1520 years ago and now you don't
- 5:17occupy the same space, you don't have the same visibility, so you
- 5:20have to agitate for that visibility.
- 5:22You have to fight for a special treatment.
- 5:24That's what I see a lot of the I want to speak to your manager as
- 5:27being. I also think that white women
- 5:29have had a fall from grace. I think we used to be able to
- 5:32sort of rule the roost and people did defer to us.
- 5:35If you think about women of my mother's generation or even her
- 5:38mother's generation, when I talk to older black people, I notice
- 5:41the way they talk to me is very different from younger black
- 5:43people who. See you as an equal.
- 5:45Probably even less than. I mean, I'm old, right?
- 5:48I went to a school field trip recently and these kids of every
- 5:52race treated me like and I thought my God I would never
- 5:56have had the gall to speak to an adult like this at 11 years old.
- 6:00But it's a different time. It's a different time and as
- 6:04much as youth was fetishized in the 60s and 70s and 80s, now it
- 6:11is ultimate. Just being older than 20 is
- 6:16pretty much dead. This is my least favorite
- 6:18comment on TikTok when people find out how very very old I am.
- 6:22Oh my God way to go. I didn't know you were that old.
- 6:25My least favorite comment in the halls of my home is yeah, boomer
- 6:30brother, I am not a boomer. Your grandfather was a boomer,
- 6:33and he's dead. Exactly what exactly is a Karen
- 6:37and where did it come from? Says Ashida Nagesh.
- 6:40Karen has in recent years become a widespread meme referencing a
- 6:44certain type of middle class white woman who exhibited
- 6:46behaviors that stem from privilege.
- 6:48The Karen stereotype is that they weaponize their relative
- 6:51privilege against people of color, British feminist Julie
- 6:54Bindle tweeted. Does anyone else think that
- 6:56Karen slur is woman hating and based on class prejudice?
- 6:59End Quote. A black birder named Christian
- 7:02Cooper was walking in Central Park, New York when he ran into
- 7:05a woman called Amy Cooper, no relation, who had let her dog
- 7:08off the lead in a leash only area of the park.
- 7:10He asked her to put her dog back on the lead.
- 7:12Her response was to call 911 and in histrionic tones, tell
- 7:16operators that that quote, there's an African American man
- 7:18threatening my life. End Quote.
- 7:19The entire exchange was filmed, uploaded to social media and
- 7:23Miss Cooper was from then on known as Central Park Karen.
- 7:26Chris Cooper has made a career out of this moment, and well, he
- 7:31should. I believe he got a show.
- 7:33We can't just optimistically say there's no crappy white women
- 7:38and that white women have not historically behaved in a very
- 7:42questionable way. Reference.
- 7:43Emmett Till. Yeah, white women freaking out
- 7:46over people having a family BBQ. White women trying to express
- 7:51their dominance that they feel is slipping away.
- 7:54The hard truth is my age, my race gives me no rights over
- 7:58anybody else ever. But I guess when you've grown up
- 8:02with that privilege, it's hard to feel like you're losing it.
- 8:05Our mother didn't go to an integrated school.
- 8:08Her mother was not racist at all until black people started
- 8:12having their own rights and she couldn't pay someone $0.25 it's
- 8:15an hour to clean her house anymore.
- 8:17Our grandmother moved to Peak Racism when she discovered that
- 8:21black women were being hired for the same job that she had.
- 8:23When you think of a segment of people as being inherently
- 8:28inferior to you, you're still being racist.
- 8:30It's just, it's just not hateful.
- 8:33You're not being overtly racist. She was being covertly racist.
- 8:36But by the time we got to her, I mean, my God.
- 8:39She was out of the gate talking about what they were up to, what
- 8:43they were talking about, who's they grandma?
- 8:46And this is the grandmother that I am named after.
- 8:48So thanks a lot, mom. What a privilege to be named
- 8:51after such a wonderful woman. This is where it starts to get
- 8:54uncomfortable for me. Is Barbie peak white?
- 8:56Feminism? Doesn't even matter by Jordan
- 8:58serials. However, it is true that
- 9:00Gerwig's work is dominated by white characters vocalizing the
- 9:03concerns of women who are already seen as the default.
- 9:06Even Barbie herself is the default.
- 9:08She refers to herself multiple times in the film.
- 9:10Is stereotypical Barbie? If that is the case, how could
- 9:13she know the nuances of being any other kind Barbie?
- 9:15Robbie plays the character as often apologetic for the things
- 9:18she doesn't know because up until now, everything was easy
- 9:20for her. This isn't just a story of
- 9:22Barbie finding herself. It's about her seeing the world
- 9:24as it really is for the first time.
- 9:26And who would be more in need of a reality check than a thin
- 9:29blonde white woman when Barbie encounters America Ferrera's
- 9:32daughter and just goes in assuming she's going to like
- 9:36Barbie Because everyone likes Barbie and she's like, you know,
- 9:38I'm pretty, I'm cool. People like me being confronted
- 9:42with a child who does not like her and has no use for her, it's
- 9:45very hard on Barbie. She's just not used to this
- 9:47response. I think we all experience that
- 9:50in some ways as society moves and changes.
- 9:53I don't have inherent value just being a white woman.
- 9:57And I used to think, Oh yeah, I'm not like those other white
- 10:01women. I'm a cool white woman.
- 10:03But on the field trip, when this young white woman was openly
- 10:07rolling her eyes at me for telling her to stay with the
- 10:10group, I was like. Come on man, I'm cool.
- 10:13I'm one of the good ones, that's the thing.
- 10:15Everybody thinks they're one of the good ones.
- 10:17I really. Thought I was.
- 10:18I thought I was special. I had a savior complex.
- 10:21I remember as a child crying over Ethiopian children and
- 10:26having this white savior crap going on and I really thought I
- 10:29was something. I understand that Greta
- 10:31Gergwig's work is dominated by white female characters, and I
- 10:36do think representation is very, very important in Hollywood.
- 10:39Also, when you're telling your own story, I understand why it's
- 10:43compelling to make that person look like you.
- 10:45If you look at the Barbie franchise, it's always been
- 10:48white dominated. It's made by a white.
- 10:50Woman in the. 60s but she did get a black friend eventually.
- 10:54And I remember when I was a young woman living in San
- 10:57Antonio and I wanted this particular white Barbie, and I
- 11:00ended up getting the Hispanic one because all the white ones
- 11:02were sold out. I was disappointed.
- 11:05I wanted to see my face reflected back at me because I'd
- 11:07grown so used to it. So we're going to talk about
- 11:10white woman's tears when white women cry.
- 11:13How white Women's Tears Oppress women of color by Mamtra Latwani
- 11:17acapati while white women are members of an oppressed group
- 11:20based on gender, they still experience privilege based on
- 11:24race. This dual oppressor oppressed
- 11:26identity often becomes the root of tension when white women are
- 11:30challenged to consider their white privilege by women of
- 11:33color. While white women have been
- 11:34depicted to be the foundation of purity, chastity, and virtue,
- 11:38women of color have historically been characterized by the
- 11:40negative stereotypes and the historical lower status position
- 11:44associated with the racial communities in American Society.
- 11:47I was listening to a Shakespeare scholar today talk about women's
- 11:52portrayal in Shakespeare and she was saying Shakespeare was one
- 11:55of the few playwrights of his time or her time depending on
- 11:59who you think Shakespeare is. To develop characters that were
- 12:01fully realized women, the Victorian people took
- 12:06Shakespeare and made Shakespeare about white women.
- 12:10This idea of white women as pitiful and sick and strange and
- 12:15needing help and crying all the time.
- 12:17When I was a child especially, but even as an adult, when I'm
- 12:21crying, people listen. People notice.
- 12:24Oh gosh, we have to cater to that white woman crying up
- 12:28there. I don't know that I've ever
- 12:30found myself using it as a weapon.
- 12:32I probably have. I definitely have when it comes
- 12:34to the police, but I've never confronted.
- 12:37The fact that I get preferential treatment.
- 12:38Until the last 15 years or so, I definitely have used crying as a
- 12:42weapon, but mostly in relationships.
- 12:44When I'm feeling overwhelmed or I'm confused or dysregulated, my
- 12:48first thing to do is to cry, which tends to shut everybody
- 12:51up. We were just talking about the
- 12:54Victorian ideal of women as weak and preferably with
- 12:58tuberculosis. TB is always a plus.
- 13:01In our beauty Myth episode, one of the first things that I
- 13:03really liked about Shakespeare was that the women were not all
- 13:07totally good or totally evil, or we're not just there to be
- 13:10sexual objects, or we're not just there as a body joke.
- 13:13They're multi dimensional. Lady Macbeth is not the same as
- 13:16the Wicked Witch. She had problems.
- 13:18She had solutions. Most of those solutions were
- 13:21bloody. Ophelia probably is the
- 13:23crummiest. She's just running after a man
- 13:26and being sad and then throwing herself into the water.
- 13:29This is what I was listening to the analysis of today and
- 13:32basically it was really interesting.
- 13:34They were saying get thee to a nunnery as apparently a horrible
- 13:37thing to say to a person. You're a whore.
- 13:40Yeah. You should go to a house with
- 13:42the whores. Right, they were saying that she
- 13:45probably did have sex with Hamlet.
- 13:47That is the intimation. That means that she's forced to
- 13:50marry Hamlet, She was saying. We're not sure if she wanted to
- 13:54have sex with Hamlet or if she was forced to have sex with
- 13:57Hamlet. But we do know that now that she
- 13:59has done it, that's why she's so upset.
- 14:01I thought it was just because she was so besotted and in love
- 14:03with him. Her boyfriend's rejecting her
- 14:05and it's sad, right? But really it was because now
- 14:09she's been deflowered and she's forced to marry this person who
- 14:12seems very mentally ill. They were also saying we're not
- 14:15even sure that she chose to kill herself.
- 14:17That may have been someone else's decision as well, because
- 14:21you're going to be just out in them streets and we can't have
- 14:24that so. And her father's been stabbed
- 14:25through a curtain. By her betrothed.
- 14:29It wasn't an easy time for Ophelia.
- 14:31Guys. Let's practice having a little
- 14:32more sympathy for Ophelia and Medusa.
- 14:35I have lots of sympathy for Medusa.
- 14:37Additionally, as Palmer states, the problem for white women is
- 14:40that their privilege is based on accepting the image of goodness,
- 14:43which is powerlessness. This powerlessness informs the
- 14:46nature of white womanhood. Put in simple terms, male
- 14:49privilege positions the nature of womanhood, while white
- 14:52privilege through history positions.
- 14:54A white woman's reality is the universal norm of womanhood,
- 14:58leaving a woman of color defined by two layers of oppression.
- 15:01Our sidle norms inform us that crying indicates helplessness,
- 15:04which triggers an automatic sympathy for the white woman.
- 15:06The white woman's reality is visible, acknowledged, and
- 15:09legitimized because of her tears, while a woman of color's
- 15:12reality, like her struggle, is invisible, overlooked, and
- 15:15pathologized. Is based on the operating quote
- 15:18standard of humanity in streetcar Named desire.
- 15:20I have always depended on the kindness of strangers.
- 15:23This idea of a white woman in the terrible situation, but
- 15:28knows that she can go out and get the empathy of strangers and
- 15:31get people to help her just based on her whiteness and her
- 15:33powerlessness. I recently watched Little Shop
- 15:36of Horrors. I just noticed that Audrey
- 15:38spends the whole movie dressing pretty inappropriately for the
- 15:42workplace and also crying. She doesn't feel like she can do
- 15:47anything and every man is in there trying to make everything
- 15:50OK for her. Except for the evil dentist.
- 15:53She's a woman in the 60s. What kind of autonomy does she
- 15:56have? She needs to marry into safety.
- 16:00She's just trying to do that. She's just out there bust out
- 16:04trying to make it happen. Where the Guys Are drips the
- 16:07challenge and responsibility of any person who has one up, one
- 16:10down identity with one identity that is privileged and another
- 16:13that is oppressed, is to recognize when their privileged
- 16:16identity is the operating norm. White women have one up, one
- 16:20down identities, and as white women must recognize the power
- 16:23that comes with whiteness, recognizing privilege means
- 16:26acknowledging that our societal norms allow white women to
- 16:29toggle their identities, meaning that they can choose to be a
- 16:32woman and they can choose to be white.
- 16:34Let's talk a little more about the helpless white woman trope
- 16:37and the relevance and society. One of the most racist
- 16:41dichotomies in media is the missing white woman syndrome,
- 16:44where if a white girl is kidnapped or missing, it will be
- 16:49headline news. There will be a 24 hour coverage
- 16:53and a woman of the same age who's a woman of color.
- 16:57It's not news. It's not interesting.
- 16:59There's this scourge of Native American women being kidnapped
- 17:03and probably being trafficked but nobody cares nor notices.
- 17:08That's something I notice a lot on TikTok is people trying to
- 17:11boost information about black women who have been kidnapped or
- 17:15black girls even, because the media isn't covering it because
- 17:18it's not considered important news if it's not some sad white
- 17:22lady. In local news, if anyone is
- 17:24kidnapped, you're going to hear about it.
- 17:26But in national news, if it's not picked up, it's invisible
- 17:30and it's the No Kings March. Today, in real time, I was
- 17:34talking with my partner about the frustration we have because
- 17:37the last No Kings March was massive.
- 17:39It was said to be the biggest demonstration of any kind
- 17:42worldwide. They got very little press
- 17:44coverage because it's not the story that the dominant
- 17:47political party wants to be heard.
- 17:50And it's incredibly frustrating to feel that no matter what you
- 17:52do, no matter what action you take, because it's not being
- 17:56broadcast, it's kind of useless. And if you're a black woman
- 18:00who's been trafficked, every second counts.
- 18:03You can't find people if you don't know that they're lost.
- 18:06I also feel this way about Epstein.
- 18:08The reason why everyone cares so much about the Epstein
- 18:11situation. Those were well to do, white
- 18:13girls who were being trafficked. Well, not all of them, but the
- 18:16fact that there were white girls involved.
- 18:18There were lots of white girls from privileged families who
- 18:21were being taken into this scenario, and I think that
- 18:23that's why America still cares about it.
- 18:26The damsel in distressed trope of a helpless white.
- 18:29Woman, it's very attractive and women have been made to dress
- 18:33and comport themselves as helpless, wearing high heels and
- 18:37tight skirts and corsets and other things that are going to
- 18:40impede our ability to escape to safety.
- 18:43But it also feeds into this really negative message that
- 18:47women need rescue and need help and need to just wait around for
- 18:51the right guy. And that hurts everybody, not
- 18:54just white woman. If we look back at that idea of
- 18:56the social identity of being a white person, as a white woman,
- 19:00I do get more attention from people in helping positions.
- 19:05It's been 12 years and it's time to get another driver's license
- 19:09photo. I'm really sorry about that.
- 19:11It's going to be rough because the last time I was 12 years
- 19:14younger, plus I was fully pregnant, so my face was really
- 19:17thinned out and I had this kind of glow, tons of hair and now
- 19:21I'm just going to be a bald. When I walked into the DPS,
- 19:27apparently 12 years on, you have to have an appointment.
- 19:31You can't just walk in and wait. I walk in and I'm like, well,
- 19:34maybe I could force their hands, wink, nudge, nudge, say no more.
- 19:38They didn't fall for it, but I saw a lot of people standing
- 19:41around waiting for help and I immediately got helped.
- 19:43She walked over to the laptop and walked me through the whole
- 19:47process and she said I'm going to talk to this guy and see if
- 19:50he can squeeze you in. And they did.
- 19:52So I'm going to get a quick turn around on my driver's license
- 19:55because I'm an old white lady. I also had makeup on, so I was
- 19:58using my pretty privilege. Combining these two social
- 20:00identities, white women can be both helpless without the
- 20:03helplessness, being a reflection of all white people, and
- 20:06powerful by occupying a position of power as any white person in
- 20:10difficult conversations, Remember the goal of the
- 20:12conversation. White privilege allows you to
- 20:14shift the conversation about you and your feelings away from the
- 20:17original goal of the conversation.
- 20:19That's all about what it means. White privilege allows you to
- 20:21shift the conversation about you and your feelings away from the
- 20:24original goal of the conversation.
- 20:25For example, maybe I walked into the DPS and pushed aside three
- 20:30women of color physically, and then when they said, hey, that
- 20:34wasn't great, I start crying. And when I start crying, that
- 20:38means that the conversation goes away from my terrible behavior
- 20:41and moves to my victimhood. Instead of blanketing assumption
- 20:45observations, be specific about your observations rather than
- 20:48you are angry. Be specific about the
- 20:50observation. I noticed that when I pushed you
- 20:53aside, you were impacted in this manner.
- 20:55Be clear on not only naming emotions, but the root or cause
- 20:59of the emotions. Because I think that's the thing
- 21:01they're talking about. It's not just what I did, but
- 21:04the fact that I caused harm. When you think of protecting
- 21:09white privilege, it helps me understand what motivates
- 21:13terrible conservative women. They know they're on the
- 21:17backside because they're women, right?
- 21:19But they need to cozy up to the dominant party of white men to
- 21:25maintain the privilege that they do have.
- 21:27Right, I may have scraps of privilege, but at least I have
- 21:30some, so I need to hang on to those.
- 21:32We often do not hold ourselves accountable for our actions
- 21:35within our privileged spaces, which leads us to the underlying
- 21:38assumptions that things just mysteriously.
- 21:40Happen. It just happened that way.
- 21:42I was at the back of the line and somehow I just ended up at
- 21:45the very front and people were handing me $50.00 bills.
- 21:49That happens to me every day. There's something called the
- 21:52math effect that people who have initial advantages get more
- 21:56advantages over time. If you are in a room of 30
- 22:00people and one person is a little more famous or monied or
- 22:05successful, people will tend to divert their attentions,
- 22:10resources towards that person. And so that's why the rich get
- 22:13richer and the poor get the picture.
- 22:14So if you have always had white privilege, if you've always kind
- 22:18of defaulted to being an authority figure or a figure of
- 22:22sympathy, someone who things just happen to work out for, it
- 22:26may be because of this idea. Once you have occupied a higher
- 22:30status position, money, attention, reciprocation
- 22:34opportunities will flow towards you.
- 22:36Absolutely. I was at a bakery and I was
- 22:39waiting my turn and I was not the first person in line, but
- 22:43the white man who was behind the counter offered to give me his
- 22:47services 1st when there were two or three black and Hispanic
- 22:50women nearby and that wasn't great.
- 22:53No, that can't feel great. Privilege is not just about our
- 22:56social identity. Which behaviors do you
- 22:58privilege? Crying, Lower tone of voice?
- 23:00Direct eye contact. In which behaviors do you
- 23:02punish, anger or raise voices? Indirect eye contact.
- 23:06Recognize how certain preferred behaviors are associated with
- 23:08whiteness while problem or questionable behaviors are
- 23:11associated with different communities of color.
- 23:13Learn to recognize when you were in a position to be an ally.
- 23:16White people should also actively talk about white racism
- 23:19in safe, separate spaces to challenge themselves, their
- 23:21peers and or their Staffs. This process should be rooted in
- 23:24empowerment and not guilt. The empowerment of humanity.
- 23:28The empowerment of what, exactly?
- 23:30Because we are sacrificing our own empowerment and our own
- 23:34privilege to make a more egalitarian society.
- 23:37I feel more empowered when I'm making choices that are based on
- 23:40reality rather than this undeserved privilege that I'm
- 23:44ending up with. I will say, especially in
- 23:46Portland, and I welcome it and it's the correct thing, but my
- 23:49straight privilege is really going down the toilet.
- 23:53Tell me more about that. I had my time in the sun.
- 23:56Very nice. Comics will ask me, do you
- 23:58consider yourself queer? And I have to say no.
- 24:00Well, I've got a spot for a queer comic on the show.
- 24:03I see. OK.
- 24:04I thought you meant like getting a table in a restaurant.
- 24:07No, I've never gotten a table in a restaurant for being straight.
- 24:10But in comedy, in writing, in these kinds of opportunities,
- 24:14that privilege has passed on because we are accepting that
- 24:18other voices are just as valid, if not more valid, in this
- 24:21space. Right, exactly.
- 24:23So we're going to talk about when white women get caught
- 24:26victimhood as racialized violence.
- 24:29An important aside, I often notice white people retweeting
- 24:32me as a way to shift responsibility.
- 24:35This is just another strategy to avoid accountability.
- 24:37They are micro performing the same macro performances that
- 24:40white cultural and academic institutions do Performative
- 24:44allyship. White people have constant
- 24:46access and can weaponize it whenever they feel like.
- 24:49I want you to imagine racism as free floating levers that orbit
- 24:53our metaphysical space. White men constantly hold on to
- 24:56their levers with a firm and tight grass, violently yanking
- 24:59on it to display their power. White women pretend that they do
- 25:02not have access to levers, that they are always somehow just out
- 25:06of reach Black and women of color know white women well.
- 25:10We see how they sneakily dance their hands around it, flirting
- 25:14with it and threatening us with. The pull.
- 25:16How many levers are you pulling, Virginia?
- 25:18I do think it's important to really question your own
- 25:22motivations in the the split second decisions you're making.
- 25:26When I have opportunities in comedy, I really try to pull
- 25:30women of color first because unfortunately I will be
- 25:34occupying the white lady spot at work.
- 25:36I really try to promote equal consideration of women of color,
- 25:41especially for positions that are open at my company, because
- 25:44I truly believe that DI is a benefit for businesses and it's
- 25:49not a negative because America is many colors, Our customers
- 25:54are many colors. And if you just have white
- 25:56people trying to figure out what Hispanic people say in San
- 25:59Antonio want, there's not going to be any Hispanic Barbie dolls.
- 26:03They're all going to be white. Or they're going to be ethnic
- 26:06slurs. Or they're going to be racially
- 26:08charged. It's not the move.
- 26:11That to me, is what I find fascinating in general about
- 26:14commercials and marketing. Talk to somebody besides old
- 26:16white guys when y'all are making these ads.
- 26:18This doesn't make any sense. I've been watching old videos of
- 26:22120 minutes recently on YouTube frequently.
- 26:26The advertising has not been cut out and advertising in the 90s
- 26:30is so embarrassing. Every ad, every product is being
- 26:35promoted by a white person wrapping, That's unending.
- 26:39A white person using a Ave. wrapping or the sound of a
- 26:44record scratching? It's unending white entitlement,
- 26:48white Co opting and white privilege.
- 26:51It does make me feel good to see, like at least I can
- 26:53recognize it now and say we have made some amount of progress as
- 26:56a country. But that's what happens when you
- 26:58have all white voices in the room.
- 27:00And when I don't see my lever, I didn't know I had lovers back
- 27:03then. I just thought, oh, this is just
- 27:04marketing and advertising. This is the way.
- 27:06What it looks like. Now, even in the year of our
- 27:08Lord 2025, some people may have seen some of my AI tick tocks
- 27:13which everybody loves. I joined Sora and and right now
- 27:18it's a pretty small group of people because it's invite only,
- 27:21but I noticed most of the content is for thin white
- 27:24people. There's a lot of really
- 27:27offensive videos about fat people and usually they're
- 27:30people of color. This is what we're designing on
- 27:32the computer. We didn't cast anybody.
- 27:35I just decided with the tippy tappy of my fingers that I'm
- 27:38going to make this fat person some other ethnic minority and
- 27:41make fun of them. It's a bunch of white teenage
- 27:43boys that are making most of these Soras.
- 27:46I believe to make a sora, you have to type out word for word
- 27:50everything that's happening in the scene.
- 27:51You had to say this is a black fat person in a wheelchair for
- 27:56the scene to be that way, but even.
- 27:58Before that, one of the big disadvantages of AI has been AI
- 28:02is just scraping everything that's gone before AI is
- 28:05reflecting us back to ourselves. Review our Death by Chatbot
- 28:09episode. Right.
- 28:10When you ask AI to write a story and say who's the bad guy, well,
- 28:14the bad guy is going to be a person of color.
- 28:16When you ask AI guy who's the heroine, she's going to be a
- 28:19thin white woman. Because AI can see everything
- 28:21we've done before. We are going to get trapped in
- 28:23a. Cycle of copy pasting our own
- 28:26racism and white supremacy. And just amplifying it, right?
- 28:29Exactly. It is a quote, sisterhood UN
- 28:32quote that replicates the racial hierarchy between white and
- 28:35bodies of color. It is a quote sisterhood UN
- 28:38quote, that upholds white supremacy, which white women are
- 28:40invested in. It is a sisterhood that is for
- 28:42white membership only. Since I and many other black and
- 28:45women of color challenged her her visioning of the sisterhood
- 28:48by speaking, she had to put us back in our places.
- 28:50This would explain her racializing us as bullies and
- 28:53attackers and more personally tweeting me to shut up.
- 28:56White women don't like to be challenged.
- 29:00No, white women don't like to be challenged because white women
- 29:03have not been challenged. We are not used to it as a
- 29:06people, especially when we're talking to other women.
- 29:09We have an assumed position in the hierarchy and the only
- 29:12defense is abuse. Or crying in therapist spaces.
- 29:16It's obviously white women, but in the last few years I've been
- 29:19doing this NET training, there's a multiverse of different groups
- 29:24in the room. I found myself wanting to raise
- 29:26my hand every 10 seconds because that's my role in classrooms.
- 29:30But I discovered my opinion actually isn't more important or
- 29:33more interesting than anyone else's.
- 29:35Maybe I need to STFU and keep my ass in the seat and not worry
- 29:39about it. When I went to college, the
- 29:42first college I went to was a women's college, and I got a lot
- 29:46out of it, even though I was only there a year.
- 29:48Thanks a lot, Dad. It was really interesting and
- 29:50valuable because the lesson I learned there was when there are
- 29:54no men in the room, the women speak up.
- 29:56When you look around and who's the leader and all you see is
- 30:00other women, you're like, oh, maybe it's me.
- 30:02So when the white women shut up, that means everyone else can
- 30:04too. When you're making spaces for
- 30:06discussion, you have to leave space for women of color and
- 30:11other individuals to speak up. That's what sisterhood really
- 30:14is. Yeah, I agree with that.
- 30:15Have you read the book White Fragility by Robin D'Angelo?
- 30:20I haven't but I've seen a lot of it quoted on TikTok, does that
- 30:22count? Close enough.
- 30:24I read this book in Graduate School, and I found it very
- 30:27enlightening. I appreciated that it was
- 30:29written by a white woman who understands my experience.
- 30:33She's fallen under a lot of backlash in recent years because
- 30:37people are saying, yeah, you have no business talking about
- 30:39something that you benefit from. So we're going to quote from the
- 30:42article. What's so bad about Robin
- 30:44D'Angelo? White fragility does not demand
- 30:47that white people participate in a political movement that will
- 30:51readjust the balance of wealth and power in this country.
- 30:53This means that rather than fighting the racial status quo,
- 30:56it ends up supporting it by encouraging changing hearts and
- 31:00minds that will make the country feel less racist without
- 31:03actually addressing the worst existing racial disparities in
- 31:07who owns or controls what. So what do you make of that?
- 31:10I'm trying my. Best tell me more about what
- 31:12that means. Means in what way are you trying
- 31:15your best? I have to accept this as a valid
- 31:19criticism, but also if I feel motivated to write about my own
- 31:25fragility and my demonstration of helplessness and how it hurts
- 31:29the world and how we need to reconsider it.
- 31:31I'm challenged by the criticism that you shouldn't speak about
- 31:34this at all because you benefit from it.
- 31:36I think what they're saying is Robin D'Angelo is speaking as a
- 31:39white woman. She's getting up on this
- 31:41platform. She teaches all these trainings
- 31:43to. With IBM and Amazon, all these
- 31:45different companies, but all she talks about is working on
- 31:48myself. She doesn't talk about helping
- 31:51in a more global way to actually make this world equitable for
- 31:56everybody. I see there is actually a good
- 31:58reason to discuss quote white people, UN quote as a group,
- 32:01because the moment you say, well, of course there's some
- 32:03exceptions, everyone thinks they're the exception.
- 32:05Everyone thinks they're one of the good ones, right.
- 32:08The generalization is meant to force every white person to
- 32:11examine themselves, and it's again something that Martin
- 32:14Luther King himself did. Martin Luther King said whites,
- 32:17it must frankly be said, are not putting on a similar mass effort
- 32:21to reeducate themselves out of their racial ignorance.
- 32:23It is an aspect of their sense of superiority that the white
- 32:27people of America believe that they have so little to learn.
- 32:30Absolutely. And I don't think we were ready
- 32:32to hear that in the 60s. I personally am ready to hear it
- 32:34now. Mic drop MLK, let's do this.
- 32:37Only 75 years later. I'm ready to do it.
- 32:40It's a probably 3 pronged or maybe 12 pronged.
- 32:43I do think a big component of it is addressing this inherent
- 32:47belief that I am superior to other groups or that I deserve
- 32:51preferential treatment. I guess we would call it white
- 32:53narcissism. White women thinking that they
- 32:56should be at the head of the line or first in class and just
- 32:59working with that as their assumption.
- 33:01We need to address that and also we need to address redlining and
- 33:05gerrymandering and all the things that we have done to
- 33:08create situations where black people and people of color
- 33:11cannot get ahead and to. Minimize black voices because
- 33:14they make us. Uncomfortable and ICE raids.
- 33:17Oh, I don't know. I think ICE raids, I think
- 33:19there's great people on both sides.
- 33:21You know, there's good people all around.
- 33:23I think we're all just trying to find our way through these ICE
- 33:25raids. It's really challenging but
- 33:28really valuable to ask yourself, why do I feel like I get
- 33:31listened to when you've always been towards the front of the
- 33:34line? You think that you inherently
- 33:36deserve that. We've talked about this in a lot
- 33:38of different ways. If you've always experienced
- 33:40pretty privilege, then that feels very natural to you.
- 33:42And I think it's a really good exercise to try to examine.
- 33:46What do any of us deserve? Not much if we're looking for
- 33:50equality. None of us deserve to be put at
- 33:52the head of the line. Or all of us deserve to be put
- 33:55at the head of line. It's a really long complicated
- 33:57line. I think we have a lot to learn
- 33:59from trans men. I heard a trans man speaking
- 34:02recently and he was saying I think I understand the man cold
- 34:06situation. So they were saying I haven't
- 34:09had a period in three years. Now it feels like this is just
- 34:13my normal body and I don't have that monthly experience of
- 34:16everything being completely dysregulated and being in
- 34:19exhaustive pain and feeling like I'm going to die for for a week.
- 34:24Men haven't experienced this. For them, it's very jarring, but
- 34:28you know. Do not feel well, right?
- 34:30And so like, I think it's just stuff like that.
- 34:32I think that in my little silo over here as a privileged white
- 34:36lady, I didn't have access to many people of color really
- 34:39until I was probably 15 years old.
- 34:42I remember there was one Asian girl and one black girl at my K
- 34:47through 6 school. That's insane.
- 34:49I learned a lot of crap because I was living in this quote, UN
- 34:53quote, privileged position, and it was just sort of assumed
- 34:57that's how we learned that the world worked.
- 35:00One of my first jobs out of college, I worked in a
- 35:03laboratory, and there was the black girl who worked there with
- 35:06me. And when the conversation turned
- 35:09to concerns about people of color, like what kind of music,
- 35:13what kind of movies, she one time told me, like, it's
- 35:15exhausting having to represent for a whole race.
- 35:17I can't take all of this on. I can only speak to me.
- 35:21And it was weird because I just assumed that she was the expert
- 35:24on all things black culture because she was the black woman
- 35:26that I knew. Right, because we think of
- 35:28people as monoliths. I remember moving to Europe for
- 35:32the first. This is going to sound very
- 35:33white. I moved to Europe for the first
- 35:35time and it was when George Bush had been elected and everyone
- 35:38was up in arms about it because they thought that was a big
- 35:41deal. What?
- 35:42Sweet summer children we were. What innocent little babies.
- 35:45I know we never knew how bad it could really get, but I remember
- 35:48having to represent America every time I entered a
- 35:52conversation and it was exhausting.
- 35:54And I had that thought. I was like Oh my God, this is
- 35:57what it's like to be a person of color every day that ends in Y
- 36:00and this sucks. You know, the author of White
- 36:03Fragility, D'Angelo encourages white progressives to, quote,
- 36:07look inward, UN quote. But inward is precisely where
- 36:09they already look too much. Instead, they need to look
- 36:11outwards. Study the literature, history,
- 36:13and politics of groups different from themselves.
- 36:16Start caring about the ways the healthcare system, immigration
- 36:18system, and education system disadvantaged people who are not
- 36:21white. And instead of just committing
- 36:23yourself to learning and growing in your interpersonal life,
- 36:26commit yourself to lending your support to those who are trying
- 36:28to change the situation. I totally agree with this, but I
- 36:31also think that looking at where is the first step to recognize
- 36:34the privilege that we've benefited from and the privilege
- 36:37that we need to relinquish, I think that's the first.
- 36:40Step to being able to reach out and help lift other people up.
- 36:45I have a lot of sympathy for the men in my life who I asked
- 36:49constantly to unpack their privilege and really understand.
- 36:53You're in a position because of the society that you grew up in.
- 36:56There's nothing special about you.
- 36:58You don't have special powers, and I want you to explore and
- 37:00investigate the ways that you've benefit from these oppressive
- 37:04systems that hurt women. I can't really ask men to do
- 37:06that and then not be willing to do it myself.
- 37:08This week I had the extremely aggravating experience of
- 37:12receiving a fan e-mail, and I don't think he really was a fan,
- 37:15but it was someone who did. Aggravating.
- 37:16You don't like fan emails? I do.
- 37:18You can write me an hello at my sister's a therapist.
- 37:21I'm using fan very loosely. This is someone who had seen my
- 37:24act and I share my social media information after my set in case
- 37:30anybody wants to be my fan and follow my career.
- 37:32He wrote me in the middle of the night and said I enjoyed your
- 37:35ACT, but I just really am disheartened by how straight
- 37:38white men have become OK to punch down, how prevalent it is
- 37:42to bash on straight white men, and how accepted you can just
- 37:45criticize us and nobody cares. And I said man, please
- 37:48depersonalize this from being about you and see that it's
- 37:52about patriarchy. Why are you making this about
- 37:55yourself? Well, and also I'm allowed to
- 37:58punch at you if you're doing crappy stuff.
- 38:00And I'm allowed to punch at you even if you're not.
- 38:02I'm allowed to punch at you for any reason that I see fit.
- 38:05But not me. But I'm one of the good ones.
- 38:08I enjoyed your comedy, I said. I did and I said, you know man,
- 38:11please examine your own privilege that led you to write
- 38:14this e-mail in the 1st place. I'm trying to imagine a scenario
- 38:18in which you went to go see a male comic and had a bone to
- 38:21pick about something or another that they said and felt that you
- 38:23should drop them a note. I can't imagine it.
- 38:27You can't even move aside your own privilege to see your
- 38:30privilege, dude. Because I'm lost in the sauce of
- 38:32the patriarchy. Because I've been in it my whole
- 38:34life. This makes me feel bad.
- 38:36Whenever I start to feel like I'm chill, I'm good, I just
- 38:39watch S Africans talk about life and I think, oh, we're just
- 38:43doing that, but we're doing it quietly.
- 38:45I remember Trevor Noah saying we're doing the exact same
- 38:47things as in America as they did in South Africa.
- 38:49But he said, I actually prefer the South African method because
- 38:53it's overt and it's honest. And here you're just lying and
- 38:56winking and and whatnot the whole time.
- 38:59Thank you again, Anna, for this very interesting topic.
- 39:02I hope we did it justice. I hope we answered all of your
- 39:05questions. Virginia, what are your final
- 39:07thoughts on this topic? My final thoughts are this is a
- 39:10painful topic to talk about because everybody wants to feel
- 39:13like we're at the end of our learning.
- 39:16We're the product of all the work that we've done.
- 39:19And I still have challenges, I still have blind spots.
- 39:23I appreciate the opportunity to review them.
- 39:26I think it's hard for any person who has experienced any slight
- 39:31advantage in lifes pecking order to question that, say what did I
- 39:36do to deserve this? Another great lesson that I've
- 39:39had, and I've talked about this before when you talk about trans
- 39:42men's experience of the male cold.
- 39:44I've learned a ton from trans women in comedy because the
- 39:47women that I have known petition for themselves and they ask for
- 39:50things. They champion themselves.
- 39:53When I first interacted with this, I remember thinking, well,
- 39:55that's not ladylike and why should it be?
- 39:58Why am I just sitting on the sidelines going, I'll just sit
- 40:00here until somebody picks me. That's the ladylike thing to do.
- 40:04Screw that. I want to be less ladylike.
- 40:06I want to be. Less of a damsel in distress and
- 40:10I want to learn from people around me.
- 40:12Laura, what are your final? Thoughts.
- 40:13I really appreciate this topic being brought to the fore.
- 40:16It's something I think about a lot.
- 40:18It has been a really tough experience for me to unpack all
- 40:21of my bias and all my privilege and all these things over the
- 40:24last several years. And it's not for the faint
- 40:27hearted. It's really hard work to do.
- 40:29And it is also really hard work when you realize so much of the
- 40:32systems in place were not built for women, period, but
- 40:35especially not for women of color or people who are not able
- 40:40bodied white wealthy people. I saw TikTok the other day where
- 40:44they were looking at the economy and the economy is AK now
- 40:47because 20% of the population has all of them money going up
- 40:52and then 80% have the bottom part of the K with all the money
- 40:55going down. Isn't that wonderful?
- 40:57I love that this world is built for certain people and when
- 41:00you're not in that group life sucks a lot more.
- 41:03I was recently watching the new Superman movie.
- 41:06I was ashamed by how much white savior complex Superman has.
- 41:11Alien savior. Complex.
- 41:12Well, OK, but he's living as a privileged white man in America.
- 41:16He's watching TV and there's a little brown child covered in
- 41:20dirt and crying in a war-torn place and Superman just has to
- 41:25run over there and help him. And I just thought, God, this is
- 41:29disgusting and I can't believe I never noticed before.
- 41:32But that's my privilege. Part of being privileged is
- 41:34having blinders to all these things and just thinking, well,
- 41:36this is just the way things are. This is just normal, right?
- 41:40It's been a challenging task, but I'm always up for the
- 41:43challenge, trying to do better. I think the book The History of
- 41:47White People is really good because it shows you how much
- 41:49all of this stuff is just a construct.
- 41:51Virginia, if anyone wants to stop crying about their white
- 41:54privilege and stop feeling like a piece of garbage, you can be
- 41:58listening to some funny, probably sexist comedy.
- 42:01How would they go about doing that?
- 42:02Miss Interest Comedy please. You can find me at my website,
- 42:07which is Virginia BADINI a.com and on my TikTok, which is also
- 42:11Badinia. In my Instagram, it is also
- 42:13badinia. If you would like to check out
- 42:15our podcast, you can find us at my sisters thetherapist.com.
- 42:19You can find us on Instagram at my sisters the therapist, and
- 42:23you can find us on Laura's TikTok.
- 42:24I am Laura Ryan. You bring up an interesting
- 42:28point that I've been thinking about, about the K When this
- 42:32administration started and our president started destroying
- 42:36social protections and welfare programs, I was thinking, why
- 42:41does he want to do this? Why is it benefit him for the
- 42:44majority of the country to be just teetering on the precipice
- 42:48of destruction? Why does it benefit him for so
- 42:51many people in red states to be hungry and to be sick?
- 42:54And I realized it's because when you have any sort of
- 42:57independence, you get something called FU money, where you don't
- 43:00have to take crap from anybody, but if you have no money, you'll
- 43:03take anything from anyone. That's where he wants to put us.
- 43:06And that's brought me a lot of clarity.
- 43:08Oppression works. Yeah.
- 43:10He wants to have an oppressed populace that he can take
- 43:13additional advantage of. That at least makes sense to me.
- 43:16Why do you want to make people miserable when you are voted
- 43:19into office and these people will know that you've made them
- 43:22miserable, that you have actively worked their
- 43:25destruction because you want them to be so hungry and so
- 43:28tired and so desperate that they'll cling on to anything
- 43:31that they're given thumbs up. And on that thought, Laura, I
- 43:34know that people sometimes write us reviews or emails and we
- 43:38would love for you to write us a review.
- 43:40You can do it on Spotify. You can do it on Apple Podcast,
- 43:42you can do it on Audible. Laura, do you have a review to
- 43:45show this week? I certainly do.
- 43:46This is from Go Lilith and it was a review on Apple podcast.
- 43:51Shout out to the Lilith Fair. It's a five star review, which
- 43:56is my favorite kind on Apple podcast and it says love this
- 43:58pod. Fantastic podcast, entertaining,
- 44:01educational and the sister vibe is strong.
- 44:04Thanks Lola. That's awesome.
- 44:05Also, if you're interested in giving us money, you can e-mail
- 44:08us at hire us at mysisters@therapist.com.
- 44:11Shout out to G sauce. Shout out to imperfect Foods.
- 44:15Shout out to liquid death. Shout out to Costco.
- 44:20Shout out to Truvani vegan protein supplement.
- 44:23I'm really enjoying that. OK all.
- 44:25Right. I'll take it.
- 44:26Speaking of sisterhood, I want to close the show as we always
- 44:29do. The traveling pants.
- 44:30With the words of our spiritual founder Billy Ray Valentine
- 44:33Capricorn, as he said, we could make it, baby.
- 44:36Me and you.