Latest / Chatter that Matters / Cyber Crime - Hacked, Tracked and Attacked
Transcript
- 0:01The domain of attack is boundless. It can happen from anywhere. Because of the
- 0:05interconnectedness of the Internet. We go through life
- 0:09almost every moment with some element of risk and reward.
- 0:13We cross the street, there's a risk that we're going to get hit. We get
- 0:16on an airplane, there's a risk of a crash. I mean, it's just a
- 0:20constant trade off. But more often than not, we do our homework. We look both
- 0:23ways on the street and we navigate life.
- 0:28But when it comes to the subject tonight of cybercrime,
- 0:32I'm not exaggerating it, but I would say to us that if we're not prepared,
- 0:35if we haven't got countering strategies, it's not a matter of if,
- 0:39it's a matter of when. Providing access to the world through these
- 0:43smartphones, through social medias, without any boundaries or
- 0:47direction. Some of the most vulnerable are
- 0:50seniors, young adults. But I'd also just say the level of
- 0:54sophistication happening now when they can take a
- 0:57still picture of your granddaughter or grandson and clone their
- 1:01voice and have that person arrive to you on the screen and start talking to
- 1:05you. I mean, we're at an unprecedented level of crime.
- 1:09This is not someone that's going in in person with a balaclava on
- 1:12into a bank. They're committing it in other countries out of our jurisdiction
- 1:16where we can't reach. And that's what we're going to talk about tonight.
- 1:20Not so much to strike fear, but my hope that we take away
- 1:23from tonight, raise our awareness, more importantly, walk away
- 1:28with some smart countering strategies that we can use
- 1:31not only to protect our own assets, but the people that
- 1:35obviously we hold very close to us. So let's bring up the panel.
- 1:43Hi, it's Tony Chapman. Thank you for listening to Chatter that Matters presented
- 1:47by rbc. If you can please subscribe to the podcast
- 1:51and ratings reviews. Well, they're always welcome and they're always
- 1:54appreciated.
- 1:58On a special episode of Chatter that Matters, Margottt Denemy, a former Crown
- 2:02Counsel with over 20 years in criminal law. Milo
- 2:05Stoyodinovich, our cyber expert from rbc,
- 2:09and Detective Sergeant Colin Organ, a seasoned law
- 2:13enforcement officer specializing in cybercrime investigation.
- 2:17Colin, we were talking earlier. I know you're very senior in the
- 2:21police force, but just give us a sense of what's happening.
- 2:25Is this truly a wave that's growing almost at a tsunami level in
- 2:28terms of these kinds of crimes against humanity? Yeah, I would definitely agree with
- 2:32what you're saying from the police perspective of what we see. And again, I'M
- 2:36with York region. But although we can be confined kind of
- 2:39geographically, anything with cybercrime is far from
- 2:43that. So that's what they're doing to try to defeat it. But we see the
- 2:47cases going up and up and up and more people victimized,
- 2:51very vulnerable people that are affected by this. And to the
- 2:54point where, you know, seniors losing their homes, being kicked out of their
- 2:58homes, it's taken over because they've been scammed or put trust into
- 3:02someone that they shouldn't. So can you paint a picture of a story so we
- 3:06can personify it, personalize it of a senior that kind
- 3:10of went from thinking that their retirement was a beautifully paved
- 3:13speedway and then overnight their life turns upside down. It was
- 3:17a scam not known to them. They signed some paperwork,
- 3:21you know, on a door to door scam that they thought nothing of it,
- 3:25you know, over a quick check for their water heater. And they didn't
- 3:28realize they were signing loan documents and mortgages. They had
- 3:32their home, beautiful house in Richmond Hill, all paid off.
- 3:36Unbeknownst to them, there was about $2 million
- 3:39put lean onto their house and that ultimately
- 3:43led to they lost their house. We were working on trying to find
- 3:47them emergency housing through our
- 3:50resources, through the community and so forth. And that's someone that thought they were
- 3:54set for retirement. Their house was paid off and it's just horrible.
- 3:58See someone go through and you want to just say, wave the magic wand. This
- 4:02isn't fair. And the reality was, everything we tried, they still lost
- 4:05their home, an entire life that someone's affected. Maybe
- 4:09I'm just caught up in, you know, the CSIs and the Hollywood folklore, but
- 4:13I would say in the past there was a certain amount of different
- 4:16crimes. But is it fair to say that with this type of crime that is
- 4:20changing, it's getting more sophisticated, is getting more complex. Just when you think you've figured
- 4:24out their model, they're reinventing it. That's a tough one for me to
- 4:28admit. The reality is they're always
- 4:31a step or two ahead. Those involved in these crimes
- 4:35are some of the hardest working people you would ever meet. If they used it
- 4:38for good, they could do extraordinary things. But they don't.
- 4:42They can adapt, they overcome obstacles. The second
- 4:46we come up with a strategy to stop it, they
- 4:49learn how we stopped it and they change before we even know it. So
- 4:53it's always that catch up. You briefly touched on the AI and
- 4:57stuff like that. It just makes it even harder for us. And you
- 5:00said, this is not someone that's going in in person with a
- 5:04belaclav on into a bank where they're leaving fingerprints
- 5:07or so forth, a lot of these. And I could talk about one is
- 5:11it's happening. They're committing it in other countries out of our jurisdiction
- 5:15where we can't reach. So it's definitely difficult. We were
- 5:18chatting before and you talked about the math. You said how many
- 5:22thousand cases and how many officers that are available. It
- 5:26sounds to me almost like that fairytale story of the little Dutch boy trying to
- 5:30stick his finger in the. D. We spoke of it. I mean, I'm in charge
- 5:33of our financial crimes unit. Put in perspective for all of
- 5:36York region. I've got five teams with about
- 5:4025 to 30 officers and investigators. And
- 5:44last year we were over 7,000 cases. And that's not
- 5:48to talk about the dollar value. That's the amount of cases that you're trying to
- 5:51deal with on a level of volume that you just have to. You have
- 5:55to do the best of which ones you can. So it's. It's definitely
- 5:58overwhelming for sure, for the officers, but for the victims as well.
- 6:02You know, the reality is 7,000 cases, it's very
- 6:06important to that person. But it might take a couple weeks, it might take a
- 6:09long time for an investigator to get a hold even to find out, you know,
- 6:13we can't recover the money, which can be devastating for people. But it's a reality
- 6:17that we have to deal with. And how is AI and technology
- 6:20serving to your advantage versus just simply to the criminal's advantage?
- 6:24We're trying to catch up with that. It's. It's difficult from the policing
- 6:27aspect, the sensitivity of the information that we keep or the
- 6:31access we have. There's a lot of loopholes we have to go
- 6:35through in order to even introduce AI and so forth
- 6:38to work for us. Because right now it's who do we want to have access
- 6:42to some stuff if that was subject to a data breach or anything?
- 6:46So it's things where we're constantly trying to look at. Right now, I know we
- 6:50have a number of organizational projects that are trying to utilize
- 6:53AI. We're bringing in a program now where we have students,
- 6:57the new young minds to kind of work with us and try to
- 7:01figure out how we can kind of overcome this or come up with some different
- 7:04programs to try to combat it. A big part of the narrative through the whole
- 7:08election was this sense of catch and release. We even had unions,
- 7:12probably for the first time, police unions supporting the conservatives. These
- 7:15crimes against humanity, when you do, are Successful in capturing
- 7:19somebody. Do the courts view them truly as a crime against
- 7:23humanity? Or is it more all that was just a one off?
- 7:26We understand the constraints with the courts, but to
- 7:30be honest and upfront, it is frustrating. I come
- 7:34from a background with human trafficking and robbery squad
- 7:38and stuff like that. We even see violent offenders being released.
- 7:42And then coming to the financial crime world, you do see that the
- 7:45reality of it's a, you know, it's categorized as a nonviolent crime.
- 7:50When in reality, you know, my investigators are the ones
- 7:53constantly on the phone, email, dealing with someone. How do
- 7:57you deal with someone that now is thought they were financially set and now they're
- 8:00in peril, their housing is at risk, you know, everything
- 8:04there is a large impact and I'm not going to sugarcoat it
- 8:07either. We've unfortunately had victims that have, you know,
- 8:11because of the financial strain, it's led to self harm, it's led to
- 8:15suicide, disappointment with families and everything.
- 8:19So it's that side that we're trying constantly to
- 8:23have the courts be cognizant of of. This is not just a non violent
- 8:26offense. This has a long standing on victims. I've also
- 8:30read that when it comes to seniors, they're often so
- 8:33embarrassed that they don't want to share it with the police or even their family.
- 8:37Absolutely. Like that is 100% true. Generally
- 8:41anyone that's caught up in this, right, it's, they estimate only 5
- 8:45to 10% is actually reported and they had I think
- 8:48108,000 reports last year. So to put that in
- 8:52perspective, and it is a shameful thing, especially for someone that
- 8:56now may have really financially impacted their family
- 8:59because, you know, they got caught up in it, they're forced into quick
- 9:03decisions. These criminals know what they're doing. They know how to pressure you into
- 9:06situations. There is that level of shame that people think, I can't believe I
- 9:10fell for this. Now let's hear from the brilliant mind of
- 9:14Milos Stojadinovic, our cybersecurity
- 9:17expert from rbc. Just give us a
- 9:21sense. I know you're quite a modest guy, but you're very
- 9:24senior. I would argue RBC is one of the best in the
- 9:28world at trying to counter this. So just give us a sense of what you
- 9:31do for a living and then I can ask you a couple questions. My background
- 9:34is largely in what we call adversary emulation or perhaps a little
- 9:38bit more informally offensive security. So I have built the
- 9:42majority of my career breaking into governments, organizations,
- 9:46defense contractors, you name it, and using my skills of offense to inform
- 9:50how we should design adequate and appropriate defense. So by attacking
- 9:54organizations and institutes, we understand where are their gaps, where are their
- 9:57weaknesses in their environment, across people, process and technology and
- 10:01implementing that change. On the other side, I have a threat hunting team which
- 10:05sets the hypothesis that there are threats inside of our environment. There are threats that
- 10:08are targeting our clients. They actively try to hunt for those threats inside of our
- 10:12environment and in our digital channels. And lastly, I have a threat modeling team that
- 10:15integrates the thought process of security into the products and the solutions that we
- 10:19build. So we don't think about security as an afterthought. We think about it as
- 10:22something that's part of the journey. Do you ever think how much you could have
- 10:25made on the other side? So I'm not suggesting
- 10:29this, I'm just curious because, I mean, in my demonic mind, I'm going, I'm sure
- 10:32they're paying you a lot of money, but you're really good at what you do.
- 10:35Yeah, I mean, you sound like my little brother because you ask me that question
- 10:38all the time. But look, the reality is, is that ethics is a large part
- 10:41in what we play. Right? So in my role, I really have one thing.
- 10:46If you strip all my technical skill sets away, I have integrity. If I compromise
- 10:50my integrity, I obviously can't work in this industry. Not to mention there's top secret
- 10:53clearances and all the other stuff that happens. But I have a deep desire to
- 10:57want to help people and protect people. I don't believe in victimizing people. I've seen
- 11:00friends and family around me become victims of cyber crime or even traditional crime.
- 11:05Like most people in life, I've been a victim of crime as well. So it's
- 11:08just, it's not in me. Right. It's just one of those things I think you're
- 11:11born to do or not. And what got you into this? Because it is, I
- 11:15would say it's arguably it's a fairly young field, but it has grown
- 11:19in sophistication almost exponentially. It's just sort of how
- 11:22my brain works. I am the perpetual asker of why.
- 11:26When I was a kid, I used to like take apart watches and clocks and
- 11:29stuff and put them back together. I just have an innate curiosity for how things
- 11:32work. And I find that when I know how things work, I can then
- 11:36hypothesize and think about how could you potentially make this do something it's not
- 11:39supposed to do. So for me, it's almost like a second nature thought process.
- 11:43And that I think is the hardest Thing to teach when I look for people
- 11:46in this role. Like, I can teach technical skill set, but natural
- 11:50curiosity to understand how things work, or to take a look at a box
- 11:53and find a different way around a problem, that's the hardest skill set
- 11:57that we have to find. So, very young age, I got really interested
- 12:01into hacking stuff when I was a kid. Thankfully, didn't get into too much trouble.
- 12:04It really kind of intersected with this becoming a really popular industry
- 12:08because I almost went into physics, but cyber security was just turning into a thing.
- 12:11And I went, wait, I could take this, like, computer skill set I have about
- 12:14breaking stuff and actually do something with it, and the rest of it kind of
- 12:17breaks itself. So paint a picture for us what is really
- 12:21going on out there, because obviously RBC and all of
- 12:25your clients are all massive targets. So just open our
- 12:28minds to the seriousness of the threat. I kind of like to sort of summarize
- 12:32it as the industrialization of cybercrime, right? So 15 years ago or so, if
- 12:36you wanted to target a company or target, you know, someone of wealth, you had
- 12:40to, like, know all this stuff about how to target them, right? You had to
- 12:42know how to do reconnaissance and how you might get inside of the environment and
- 12:46how do you persist in that environment and how do you move around it and
- 12:49how you get access to the data. And that has become commoditized
- 12:53in many different ways. So these days, if you fancy the
- 12:56idea of being a ransomware threat actor and holding organizations for ransom,
- 13:00you don't have to know how to write ransomware that's sold as a service now
- 13:03on underground markets, you can get 24 by 7 support, where you can
- 13:07literally talk to someone 24 hours a day, seven days a week to get support
- 13:10for your malware. It's a big business model because what happens is the people who
- 13:14are authoring the malware, the ransomware are taking a cut off of
- 13:17anything that the ransomware their clients effectively are
- 13:21implanting. And then on the other hand, you have, for example, threat actors
- 13:25that focus on initial access brokering, so they may, you know,
- 13:29breach organizations or even, you know, people of wealth into their
- 13:32systems, and they just sell that access to the highest bidder.
- 13:36So if you don't know how to compromise and you don't also know how to
- 13:39write ransomware, but you've got maybe a sliver of that skill set if
- 13:43you have the funds to get started, this is how you can kind of approach
- 13:46that. And that's why we're seeing the scale grow up massively. That's why virtually
- 13:50all of us don't answer phone calls anymore that aren't from numbers that we know
- 13:53because we can almost be sure it's going to be a scam. We get text
- 13:56messages all the time asking us to go on links. It's because all of this
- 13:59has become commoditized and now you can just pay really pennies on
- 14:03the dollar to enable this stuff from someone else that offers as a service. So
- 14:07when you get that thought process of like hackers and cybercriminals are like people with
- 14:10hoodies in their basements. They're not the real crime
- 14:14has very much so stepped into cybercrime. And this is organized, it's
- 14:17sophisticated and they're making tons of money. I think we opened up the conversation
- 14:21with this being a $10.5 trillion problem globally. And
- 14:25there's also increasing nation state involvement and support in this. Right. It's
- 14:29not unknown, for example, that if you live in a country that's non allied with
- 14:33another country and you target their citizens or their corporations, you have virtually
- 14:36no chance of facing any consequence. And some countries actually even
- 14:40encourage that. Is it fair to. Because the other thing I was reading about is
- 14:44that some, those leaders actually also take a cut. I don't know that anyone's
- 14:47admitted to that on paper, but I mean, yeah, that's how most of crime in
- 14:51general works. Right. So. And there actually are nation states out there that
- 14:54are conducting crime for their own gain. Right. DPRK is well known for this.
- 14:58Right. If anyone remembers the bank of Bangladesh heist where they stole
- 15:02something like, I think it was $900 million through Swift.
- 15:06They ended up only losing about 90 million of it. They ended up laundering the
- 15:09money out through casinos in Maau. But that was all the, the North Korea, really,
- 15:13the Democratic Republic of North K. They are using that money
- 15:17to fund their government. What happens to this money when somebody grabs
- 15:21it? $10 trillion is a lot of money to launder. I think that's the hard
- 15:24part, right, is there's steps to this, right. And we won't make it an educational
- 15:28course on how to, how to get, how to move funds and launder them. But
- 15:31effectively one element is gaining access to funds. The other element is kind
- 15:34of separating those funds and kind of moving them around and then layering them
- 15:38into, into what looks like normal proceeds. But increasingly a
- 15:42lot of these funds are moving towards like cryptocurrencies, right. That don't are, they're not,
- 15:46not part of the same standard regulation. But these people can leverage that wealth
- 15:50to still do what they need to do, purchase the things that they want to
- 15:53purchase. And that kind of leaves them largely outside of the regulated space that
- 15:57the rest of the world operates in. How much do you think, and maybe this
- 16:00is an unfair question, but they talked a lot about the housing market, certainly in
- 16:04Vancouver was propped up with laundered money. The stock market.
- 16:07How much do you think of the assets that we take for granted that we're
- 16:11going to retire on are under threat because the fact is that
- 16:14they're overpriced. Because this 10 trillion has to move to something
- 16:18that looks normalized. It's very difficult to determine
- 16:22authenticity of documentation or origination of paperwork that comes out of
- 16:26country. Right. And it's increasingly more difficult in the world of
- 16:29AI where you can take a look at real samples, have AI models build
- 16:33a lot of this out for you. So I wouldn't be surprised at all to
- 16:37imagine that some of these funds could be coming from illicit sources and propping up
- 16:41artificial inflation in areas where it shouldn't exist.
- 16:47So, Margott, we're going to go to Margott Denim. Margott was on my podcast a
- 16:51while ago and she was the inspiration for doing this evening because a
- 16:55former Crown attorney sees a lot of things in court and that
- 16:58led her to creating this book and really focusing on
- 17:02children, especially with what we consider to be smartphones. So Margott,
- 17:06just first of all, just talk a little bit about your experience as a Crown
- 17:09attorney and what you saw and what caused so much concern,
- 17:13especially when it came to our story to Canadian youth. When you start as a
- 17:16Crown Attorney, you start dealing with youth. I guess
- 17:20it's where you can cause the least amount of damage when you're starting out.
- 17:24And I would see them time and time again get in trouble with the law.
- 17:28You look at their behavior and it's easy to get angry about the
- 17:32behavior. But when you saw the pre sentence report, when you saw
- 17:35the youth and what was happening in their life and
- 17:39really looked at that, I was never a Crown attorney that thought every child should
- 17:43have a criminal record. It was, how can we address this in a
- 17:46societal way and help this child to get on a better track?
- 17:50Because often that's not their choice. It's poor friendship,
- 17:54whatnot. There was one common factor and that was self
- 17:57esteem. I lecture about this now because it really is the
- 18:01foundation of all of us, but especially children. And
- 18:05now parents are putting technology in children's hands
- 18:08before self esteem and a sense of self has even been built.
- 18:13And then I had my own daughters and started to notice what
- 18:16they were looking at at social media, all of these images
- 18:20of people that quite frankly didn't exist. And this was
- 18:2412 years ago and this isn't going to end well because we
- 18:27can't have a whole generation of kids comparing themselves to people that
- 18:31are making them feel bad. So I wrote children's books
- 18:35and started to go to schools and educate kids about
- 18:39the dangers of comparing themselves to people in media that didn't exist.
- 18:43And, and in the lessons was all about the foundation of
- 18:46self esteem. All I could see were these headlines in the last
- 18:50five years about children's mental health crisis
- 18:54over and over and over, and it didn't seem like anything
- 18:57was happening. So I quickly pivoted from my role
- 19:01with the Ministry of the Attorney General and I started raising awareness
- 19:05about digital dangers. When we chatted in the podcast, we were dealing
- 19:09with Harrison Haynes, who was a young boy and, and insecure and kind
- 19:13of lived on his video games and next thing you know, he was approached by
- 19:16another male and one thing led to another and it almost destroyed
- 19:20him. What I loved about you when you joined the podcast, however, is you
- 19:24said you gotta think of that phone like you think of handing
- 19:28over keys to a car. Talk to us about that because that metaphor makes
- 19:31a lot of sense. Because I know parents are pestered at a very early age
- 19:35to get their kids a phone, very often with very persuasive arguments. You'll know where
- 19:39I am, mom and dad, but talk to me about what you feel is
- 19:42the dangers you mentioned initially, they haven't got a sense of self
- 19:46and self esteem. But what else do you say you notice? On the back of
- 19:49the book, I came across this brilliant quote from the former
- 19:53US Surgeon General, Dr. Vivek Murthy, that essentially
- 19:57said giving your child a smartphone without any boundaries or
- 20:00direction is the same as giving them the keys to the
- 20:04car without any rules of the road. And his last line is,
- 20:08it's insane when you think about it. And it really is insane when you think
- 20:11about it. Think about it. Cars are wonderful, but even with
- 20:15cars, they put in seat belts and airbags and
- 20:19guardrails. But right now we are
- 20:22saying, Happy 10th birthday. Providing access
- 20:26to the world through these smartphones, through social medias,
- 20:30without any boundaries or direction. So when you think about
- 20:33the driver's handbook, and it was intentional that it mimics
- 20:37the driver's handbook, one, because everybody's familiar with
- 20:41the look and feel of a driver's handbook, two, we expect
- 20:45kids to get their license around 16 years old. Which
- 20:48is what we're trying to get this movement towards,
- 20:52delaying smartphones. I'm noticing that some school systems are doing
- 20:55it. I think Australia or New Zealand just completely banned phones up
- 20:59until I think the last year of high school. But you gotta be getting a
- 21:03massive pushback because kids identity is wrapped up in that phone. So how
- 21:07do you counter that? When they think the world's within arms reach, your
- 21:10desire, if you're denying them that, they basically I have no social
- 21:14currency, I can't fit in, I can't laugh at that person's TikTok video. I
- 21:18mean how do you challenge that? This is where the collective action
- 21:22comes into play because it has to be all hands on deck.
- 21:25Jonathan Haidt, I don't know if you've read the Anxious Generation but He
- 21:29speaks of four foundational reforms. One, no
- 21:33smartphones before 14, no social media until
- 21:3616, phone free schools and back to a play based
- 21:40childhood. And how you counter that is if
- 21:44we worked collectively because we all have to be on the same
- 21:47page, we can turn the tide of the mental
- 21:51health, children's mental health crisis around, he says within two
- 21:55years. I think that's incredibly optimistic to turn this tide
- 21:59around because there are options. You can get a flip phone. You don't
- 22:03have to have access to the world, world. Let's continue this
- 22:07conversation. Colin, when you're. Have you noticed since you joined,
- 22:10I think it was 20 years that you mentioned you've been on the police force,
- 22:13you started as a constable, moved your way up to a very senior level. Have
- 22:17you noticed a change in the civility of the
- 22:20people you're dealing with? And do you point it to. What Margott might be
- 22:24saying is the issue is the fact that we're wrapped up in the phones as
- 22:27opposed to humans and humanity. We see it especially
- 22:31in the world of robberies, home invasions, everything.
- 22:35Offenders are getting younger and they're getting more and more violent
- 22:39and you're seeing access to, they have access to all this stuff at young
- 22:43ages. And again it goes back to, you know, the
- 22:46consequences of it at the time are they getting catch and release and just
- 22:50reoffending and reoffending and so forth. And there's pressures
- 22:54obviously with that too knowing, you know, criminal
- 22:57organizations use youth to kind of carry these out as well.
- 23:01They know that target them and they're susceptible, they're very
- 23:05impressionable and so forth. And Milos going to you on this.
- 23:08We've become a country where we really believe that other people will
- 23:12take care of us. The government's going to take care of us Corporations. My credit
- 23:15card is going to take care of me if I'm, if I get in trouble
- 23:18when I'm traveling. Do you see that from a bank's perspective, that when
- 23:22there is a crime against humanity, your clients are saying
- 23:26this is on your watch versus things that they should be doing to watch out.
- 23:29Sometimes there are scenarios where, you know, we've dealt with clients where we've
- 23:33tried to intervene and say, hey, this is a scam. And if people are so
- 23:36far down the mental trap, they're convinced that you're trying to stop them from
- 23:40gaining some significant amount of money. And then, of course, a week or two later,
- 23:43it dawns on them the reality. Right. And when we
- 23:47return, our focus shifts to how we can fight back and protect ourselves in
- 23:51this scary world of cybercrime. Some questions from the audience
- 23:55and my takeaways.
- 23:59Foreign.
- 24:04Chapman, host of Chatter that matters. You lock your doors, you
- 24:07protect your valuables, but how about your online activities?
- 24:11Cybercrime has become a household word, one of the biggest concerns
- 24:15facing businesses today. A big shout out to RBC for creating the
- 24:18Vault, an online cyber safety playbook packed with tips and steps
- 24:22you can take to counter cyber threats. Visit rbc.com
- 24:26and download your playbook today, helping you protect your online
- 24:30activities. Well, that matters to rbc.
- 24:35I lecture about this now because it really is the foundation of
- 24:38all of us, but especially children. And
- 24:42now parents are putting technology in children's hands
- 24:46before self esteem and a sense of self has even been built.
- 24:50On this special episode of Chatter that Matters, former crown
- 24:54attorney, bestselling author Margottt Denemy, Milos
- 24:57Stojadinovic, our cyber expert from rbc,
- 25:01and Detective Sergeant Colin Oregan, who leads a
- 25:05team of law enforcement officers specializing in
- 25:08cybercrime investigations.
- 25:15So how do we raise the awareness? Like, what can we walk away with,
- 25:19with to say that we're at least taking some steps to counter it?
- 25:23I mean, as you said, you know, we don't maybe answer that spam phone call
- 25:26anymore and believe that a Russian bride's right around the corner or
- 25:30the Nigerian prince is going to send you a million. Maybe we're getting a little
- 25:33better, but. And I'll go each one of you to talk about what do we
- 25:36need to do to kind of set up our own defense so that we're not
- 25:39just relying on RBC or relying on
- 25:43the police force. What can we do? Yeah, a couple of basic things that
- 25:47I would say that people can follow to try to improve that hygiene.
- 25:50Don't use simple passwords and don't use the same password for
- 25:54stuff. Everyone looks at me and goes, yes, Milos, I know,
- 25:58but I tell you, I have the stats. I see what happens in breaches. People
- 26:01reuse passwords all the time. They reuse passwords in their personal life and their business
- 26:05life, which leads personal breaches to turn into business breaches or
- 26:09vice versa. They reuse patterned passwords so they'll change, like, the
- 26:13last symbol from, like, an exclamation mark to an AT sign to whatever's down the
- 26:17row because it's easier for us to remember. Creating these unique
- 26:21items that are hard to break also ensures that you're not victimized down the
- 26:25line. Yes, rotate them, but pick complex ones. Don't memorize them. Put
- 26:28them in, like, a password manager or somewhere where you can reference them when you
- 26:31need to. And then the other element, too, is to stop
- 26:35and kind of exercise caution when something doesn't feel right.
- 26:39Social engineering is a thing that people hear about. And I sat through a talk.
- 26:43I remember this very vividly. I was in front of, like, 1500 insurance folks, and
- 26:46I was talking about social engineering. The whole talk was about social engineering. And someone
- 26:49interrupted me to talk and was like, that's not possible. I would never fall for
- 26:53that. Like, you can't engineer me to do something I'm not supposed to do. And
- 26:56my response was, do you have children? Because if you have children, I
- 27:00guarantee you you've been social engineer. The kids are great at that. That's what they
- 27:03do to get what they're trying to do. And we all do it in innocuous
- 27:06ways. Stop and think. Pressure is being asserted that maybe feels like an
- 27:10urgency is being created. Stop. Think about what you need to do. If you're not
- 27:14sure yourself, have somebody that you phone to get a second opinion on. Right? And
- 27:17think about, I do this a lot with my family members. Not super tech
- 27:21savvy, like, you got something, give me a call, shoot me a text message. I'll
- 27:24give you a sanity check before you make that decision. And is there an app
- 27:27that would automatically rotate your passwords? Like, has
- 27:31technology not come up with. There's some kind of biometrics or
- 27:35that protects us? There's always some trade off, generally. Right. Security and
- 27:39usability are kind of like this. This linked dimmer switch. Right. The more secure
- 27:42something is, the less usable it generally becomes. And vice versa is also
- 27:46true. So there are technologies that exist. Some. Some sites
- 27:50and platforms and applications do support it. Right. I would encourage, if any of
- 27:54you use, like, Gmail or any of the Popular kind of mail
- 27:57providers like use the multifactor authentication or the passkeys, because they are
- 28:01considerably more secure. There are other alternatives, but
- 28:05it's taking time to adopt in a secure way. Just because, you
- 28:08know, we say, hey, use a passkey or use a certificate, it becomes a question
- 28:12of storage. Right. Where are you going to put it? Right. If you put it
- 28:14somewhere where someone else can steal it, it's no safer than having a password password.
- 28:17So we're just now getting to the point where we have computers that have hardware
- 28:21that's designed to kind of keep this stuff on a chip that makes it extremely
- 28:24difficult, if not impossible, to extract. And you can effectively
- 28:28prove that you have some of this material by doing some mathematical
- 28:31challenges. But it'll take time for things to get up to speed. I'm going to
- 28:35add one more point, actually, that I think people often over overlook. If
- 28:38I asked everyone, like, actually, I'm going to do a little, a quick little poll
- 28:41if that's okay. Quick poll. If you had to think about
- 28:45like your most important, like, account that you have digitally, right. How many of you
- 28:48would say it's your banking account, like your banking client card password? Yeah, almost
- 28:52everyone. Right. What happens when you forget your banking password
- 28:56or your password for virtually anything online? You go through that
- 28:59password recovery form that asks you for your email
- 29:03and then you get a link to your email to reset your. So, yeah,
- 29:07their most prized type of credential that you have is your email email.
- 29:10Because your email is often used to reset every other account that
- 29:14you have linked to your identity. So yes, banking credentials are super important. I'm not
- 29:18saying they're not. But also think about the protection for your email because that's
- 29:22often a mechanism that's used to link back and if you're not savvy with that,
- 29:26breach of your email can now suddenly lead to someone just programmatically
- 29:29going through all your messages. Oh, they bank with this bank or they use this
- 29:32service. I'm going to see if they use the same password on that service or
- 29:35if they don't, I'm going to reset that password, delete the email before you read
- 29:38it and gain access to it. Margott, do you want to. Why don't you give
- 29:41us a little bit of advice that their birthday girls should be thinking
- 29:45about or advice for us to be thinking about with our children or grandchildren. You
- 29:48spoke about how we change this. How do we change the
- 29:52trajectory, especially amongst young parents, young children.
- 29:56I really equate it to what Mothers Against Drunk
- 29:59Driving did to Change the culture of drinking and driving.
- 30:04It took time, but it was a collective effort
- 30:07and they did it through education and awareness
- 30:11en masse, which has really caused a significant change
- 30:15in that culture, when you think about it. I'm thrilled to
- 30:19announce that I'm working on a curriculum right now with social emotional
- 30:22learning, grades three, right through 12. We have
- 30:26to educate young people. I'm not anti technology,
- 30:30but we have to start to talk about their digital footprint
- 30:34early. The predators online. When I was writing
- 30:38the guide, I realized just how insidious it is, from brain
- 30:42development to mental mental health to child predators to TikTok
- 30:46challenges, plus all of the criminal offenses that that
- 30:49impact our children. So when you really see it all in one
- 30:53book, you say, wow, maybe we should delay. This is the
- 30:57big challenge about getting the phones out of the schools. It's not so
- 31:00much the kids. The kids are actually happy once the rules are
- 31:04in place, because it's a lot of pressure to have a phone. It's the
- 31:08parents that are calling the office to say, I want to get a hold of
- 31:11Jimmy and find out what time I pick him up for soccer. How do you
- 31:14think history will the social media
- 31:17barons? Because there's a handful of them that are really corralling so
- 31:21much of the wealth in the world. How do you address that as part of
- 31:24it? Society has to put more pressure on social media
- 31:28to say, as much as you like monetizing that data that everybody
- 31:32excretes, that we've got to find a way to push back. It's a massive,
- 31:35massive concern. When you saw all of those people supporting Trump,
- 31:39you know, all of the SOS parents that have lost children to
- 31:43social media and, you know, died by suicide and all,
- 31:47all of these horrific things that have happened. And they're on Capitol
- 31:51Hill and they're lobbying for laws and we are
- 31:54even close. Legislation is never going to keep up with technology.
- 31:59So to your point, we have to hold big tech accountable, but
- 32:02big tech, it's so political. I'll add just a couple of points to this because
- 32:06I think just having some basic conversations with people to
- 32:09understand that, like, we all kind of know in the real world, there's no such
- 32:12thing as free lunch. Like, everyone's heard that one before, right? That is doubly
- 32:15true. On the Internet, there's no such thing as free products. Gmail's not free.
- 32:19Anything you use, it's not free. You pay for it with your data.
- 32:23That data is far more lucrative than you spending $4 or
- 32:27$5 a month, right? So when we talk about kind of tech billionaires and you
- 32:30know, some, some of them almost crusting trillionaire at this point status or at least
- 32:34at one point they're building algorithms and they're hiring some of the smartest
- 32:37scientists in the world to solve an optimization problem. The problem is
- 32:41get someone to use the platform for as long as possible. The longer they use
- 32:44the platform, the more ads they're served, the more they interact with, the more you
- 32:48can monetize their behavioral information as well as
- 32:52directly monetizing their time. Right. So when you start to think about
- 32:55it from that perspective of like it's not free, you're paying with your
- 32:59data and we start to feel the effects of that more,
- 33:03I think we'll start to think about what this means and how we instrument
- 33:07loss to protect against this and to regulate what is and isn't. Okay.
- 33:11I think a big sort of landmark incident that happened a couple months ago. I'm
- 33:14not sure if anybody read about this, but GM was found selling some of
- 33:18their car driving statistics to an insurance company in the States that was starting
- 33:22to raise rates for people that were perceived to be driving dangerously.
- 33:26And no one ever read the end user license agreement when they bought their GM
- 33:29car and got the connected drive and understood the GM actually were
- 33:33giving GM the right to sell their information to third
- 33:36parties for their own profit on top of selling them a car. Then that
- 33:40insurance company buys that data and goes, oh wow, Bob, you drive double the speed
- 33:43limit all the time and you're, you're, you're driving like a maniac through school zones.
- 33:47We're not going to insure you or we're going to charge you double the amount.
- 33:50Suddenly people start kind of feel it to be a little bit more real. So
- 33:53Colin, my last question, and I'll open it up and get a couple of questions
- 33:56to the audience and then. But you know, if anybody saw the Game of
- 34:00Thrones and they're trying to hold the north wall and they all start climbing over
- 34:03that wall and it just seems like there's no way we're going to ever
- 34:07counter this. How do you keep the morale of our police
- 34:11force, which is the bedrock of society? How do you keep the
- 34:14morale up knowing that exponentially this crime is increasing?
- 34:18And at the same time we do have this revolving, you know,
- 34:22the motivation. Is in the people that you can help. So even though there is,
- 34:26you know, overwhelming amount of cases, the ones that you can really
- 34:30make an impact on and help and get back, or like we say that
- 34:34horrible scenario of someone losing their home, you can intervene beforehand.
- 34:37It's those, those ones that mean a lot to the officers that are
- 34:41doing it. We're doing this job, you know, similar. We're not doing this to,
- 34:45to make money and get rich. It's because we generally want to,
- 34:49to help people. So that's the big thing with, with the officer,
- 34:53you know, as my job as a leader is constantly reminding them. It seems
- 34:57overwhelming, but you guys are making an impact every day that you come here,
- 35:00every day that you work, and you are making a positive impact on
- 35:04people, which is what they really, they really want to do.
- 35:10Let's open up three questions. So go ahead.
- 35:14What's next in cybercrime? With the introduction of AI,
- 35:20we're probably two to three years away from deep fakes being
- 35:23commoditized to the point where it's virtually impossible for the average person
- 35:27to tell that they're not talking to the person on the other end of the
- 35:31line or on the other end of the phone call or the video call because
- 35:34it looks like them. And it sounds like that might sound controversial, but I mean,
- 35:38like two years ago we had nothing and now we have very convincing stuff. And
- 35:41if you look at even what's open source, let alone what's available like commercially
- 35:45or on underground markets, like especially celebrities that have a lot of
- 35:49video or audio content on them, it's incredibly real.
- 35:52So we're on the precipice of what I call, or
- 35:56I consider to be an identity provenance crisis, right? So how do you
- 36:00prove in three years time that you are who you are when you're speaking to
- 36:03someone you're not face to face. And then the question becomes is how do we
- 36:06ensure the material that we create digitally can be authenticated? Right?
- 36:10So there is some conversation that's being had about this in hardware
- 36:13manufacturers of cameras and other companies that are looking at how
- 36:17do you confirm with cryptographic proof that something was
- 36:21generated? But we have to think about misinformation travels faster on
- 36:24social media than real information does. And in a world where
- 36:28we can't tell the difference between real and fake, imagine the impacts not
- 36:32only economically but socially, for being able to spread
- 36:35misinformation that reaches millions of people that no one can prove is real or
- 36:39unreal and any kind of immediate mechanism. So I think
- 36:43that's the big thing that's on the horizon with regards to cybersecurity
- 36:46challenge in the space of AI. One thing that you can do today is
- 36:50develop a family safe word for exactly the reasons that you've just
- 36:54Indicated it's so important that you have a family safe
- 36:58word. So if you do get that phone call and it seems a little off,
- 37:01you can have that word that can keep you safe. That's something you can do
- 37:05today with how fast AI is
- 37:08growing. Is humanity at peril? A little off topic, but
- 37:12it's a great question. As someone who's deeply passionate about like
- 37:15privacy and the digital world, we often
- 37:19think about this stuff when it's far too late, right? Like we talk about AI
- 37:22ethics when that ship is sailed, right? We talk about how we're going to regulate
- 37:26social media when it's been deregulated forever, right. I don't know that
- 37:29we're quite there. You know, wouldn't it be great if we lived in a world
- 37:32where all of our basic necessities were met and we got to pursue our passion
- 37:36projects and the things that we wanted to work on to enrich our lives and
- 37:39the lives of others around them? But there's also obviously potentially a
- 37:43negative of that. And it's, you know, you have to be pretty ignorant to not
- 37:46realize that there's a lot of wealth being concentrated in spaces that control this technology.
- 37:50The interesting thing that I'm most concerned about because I'm very involved in AI right
- 37:53now is our youth without purpose, which is what a job gives
- 37:57you without a place to go. Socialize,
- 38:01learn civil skills. If AI takes away those bottom rungs of the
- 38:05ladder and then the next lungs, the next rungs, we're as a society are going
- 38:08to have a massive problem on our hands. Because if you study history, civil unrest
- 38:12leads to anarchy. Another question here. Yeah.
- 38:16With so much deep fake audio and. Video out there, the Internet
- 38:19and in our social media, how do we deal with what's real
- 38:23and what's fake? You know, it's challenging
- 38:27because it is a sociological. It's a mental problem, right?
- 38:30It's people feel like, and they're conditioned this way and they're coached
- 38:34this way that, hey, people may try to stop you, they may intercept you. They
- 38:37don't want you, you know, they want to keep you in the system is often
- 38:40kind of like what we hear being said, right? So it is
- 38:44a challenge. This is where we're thinking about this digital provenance and content
- 38:47provenance, right? How do we create very, very quickly, give somebody a
- 38:51capability to see, I'm looking at this. Is this really published from rbc or is
- 38:55this really RBC CEO? Or is it really Mark Carney or who else? Because the,
- 38:59the level of chaos and manipulation that someone can enact through this
- 39:03deepfake is tremendous. It's unprecedented. I think.
- 39:08Just to wrap this up, what I'm so honored that we have people
- 39:11like this serving our country, because good and
- 39:15evil, it sounds like evil starting to run the table. And it's your only
- 39:19counter, people like you that find a way against all odds,
- 39:227,000 cases, only 10% reported. Margott, what you're doing
- 39:26with your career is successful as well. You said, this is going to be my
- 39:29calling. I'm going to make a dent in it. The fact that you could probably
- 39:33hack the Pentagon and the fact that you're doing it and saving us, it
- 39:36gives me hope. But I think the only way we're going to continue to get
- 39:40them inspiration and motivation. If we listen to what they say in terms
- 39:44of our passwords, encountering talking to our elderly,
- 39:48talking to our kids, and really having these conversations,
- 39:52because if we don't lead by example, I think that this thing will
- 39:55collapse because there's a lot fewer than them than a lot more over
- 39:59there. So a big round of applause for this fantastic home.
- 40:07Once again, a special thanks to RBC for supporting Chatter that matters.
- 40:11It's Tony Chapman. Thanks for listening and let's chat soon.
- 40:48When you get that thought process of like, hackers and cyber criminals are like people
- 40:52with hoodies in, in, in their basements. They're not.