Latest / The Bitcoin Way Podcast / Coldcard's NVK Was Obsessed With Attacking Us | Seedsigner Founder
Transcript
- 0:00People put too much trust in cold cards.
- 0:02You and NBK of CoinKite had gone back and forth
- 0:04on Twitter for a long time.
- 0:06A lot of people don't understand like the degree to which
- 0:09it was almost kind of like an obsession with him.
- 0:12Those URLs have been forwarded to like other weird stuff
- 0:15like the CIA.
- 0:16It's this kind of like juvenile trolling.
- 0:18People hear about running a node,
- 0:20taking self custody, dice rolls,
- 0:23and they're like, oh, it sounds complicated.
- 0:25Having more knowledge and more control over your setup
- 0:27is what gives you more peace of mind.
- 0:29I personally manage my life savings with a single seed signer.
- 0:47Hey there, Michael here with the Bitcoin Way podcast.
- 0:49Thank you for tuning in.
- 0:50Today on the show, I have Seed from the Seed Signer Project.
- 0:53We get into what happened with Coldcard.
- 0:56We get into his beef with NVK or NVK's beef with Seed rather.
- 0:59the history of all of that, OpenSats contributing or not contributing to certain projects. So a bit
- 1:05of the drama. Try to also get very practical with what the SeedSigner project is, why it's so
- 1:10important, what they're working on. And I think you're going to learn a lot from this episode
- 1:13and enjoy the ride. Hey everyone, like I said in the intro, I have Seed here. Seed, welcome to the
- 1:19BitcoinWay podcast. Appreciate you being here. Yeah, I appreciate you having me. I'm excited
- 1:24to talk a little bit. Yeah, this is going to be interesting. You have probably had a wild
- 1:29month or so since the cold card incident. I would love for everyone, our listeners to understand
- 1:35from your vantage point, what transpired? Maybe you can touch a little bit of, I think most people
- 1:40have heard the cold card story a little bit, what happened about a month ago. But if you want to
- 1:44maybe bring some color commentary to that, explain it briefly, just so people are up to speed, if
- 1:48maybe they don't understand it, and then what you've been up to and what this incident has meant
- 1:53for you and for Seedsider.
- 1:55Sure.
- 1:56I'm not the best person
- 1:57for a deep technical redux
- 2:01of the whole issue.
- 2:03But I believe it was 2021 or 22
- 2:06after Foundation
- 2:08legitimately used
- 2:11the cold card code
- 2:13to create what was the first version
- 2:16of the passport.
- 2:18Rodolfo Novak from Coink,
- 2:19I didn't like that,
- 2:21even though it was permissible within the bounds of their licensing at the time.
- 2:27And so CoinKite sought to rework some of their internal plumbing
- 2:33in terms of the libraries that they used in the cold card.
- 2:36And one of that was switching out, I think,
- 2:39some of the original treasure code for a library
- 2:41that was something like number go up or sign.
- 2:44I don't know all the technical details.
- 2:46But anyhow, I'll be super brief here
- 2:49because I'm not the best person to ask about all the details.
- 2:52But basically, there was a flawed implementation
- 2:55of the mechanism that was supposed to pull entropy or randomness
- 3:02from the secure element on board their hardware.
- 3:08My understanding, it was just like a flip bit or something.
- 3:11It was just a tiny detail in the code that caused that entropy
- 3:15not to be pulled properly from the secure element.
- 3:18and they ended up with private keys that unless you rolled dice
- 3:23or added a significant passphrase to it,
- 3:26they ended up with private keys that were a lot less than 128 bits long.
- 3:31I think they were somewhere in the 30s is what the default ended up being.
- 3:34So people who had used, was it a Mark II or Mark III?
- 3:42Mark III, yeah, with a very specific version of the firmware,
- 3:45did not get sufficient entropy again if they didn't add the dice rolls or a pass raise.
- 3:49I was on the tail end of a family trip to Europe with my wife and kids when all of this came out.
- 3:57We were probably like three or four days left on the trip.
- 4:00And all of a sudden, I'm really trying to be present with my family.
- 4:05So I was trying not to have my phone out very much.
- 4:07But I saw that this was happening.
- 4:09And in the beginning, it's kind of a fog of war thing.
- 4:11So you don't really know what's really going on.
- 4:14and people are still assessing what's affected and what's the cause and what the situation is.
- 4:19So I fortunately have a very understanding wife and children
- 4:23who have been kind of on the Seed Center journey with me for the last five or six years.
- 4:29So I was looking at my phone a lot and trying to understand what was going on
- 4:34and trying to process some of the increased interest in the Seed Center project.
- 4:39I think we were sort of a natural beneficiary of the unfortunate circumstance of people losing money.
- 4:46But Rodolfo and I had butted heads publicly in the past.
- 4:49And I think there's probably a strong cross-section between seed center users and cold card slash coin kite or cold card queue users.
- 5:01Just in terms of that type of Bitcoin, I think maybe that's why we had butted heads so much in the past,
- 5:07because he sensed that too and didn want us honing in on some of his customer base But yeah so for the last month as I was kind of explaining before we hit record
- 5:19for a few years now, I've personally sold seed signers.
- 5:23And in the beginning, the goal was really just to get the hardware into more people's hands.
- 5:28Because if you've used a seed signer, you understand that what you end up with in your
- 5:32hands feels much more like a commercial product that you would have bought instead of a DIY
- 5:36device that you put together yourself. And I really wanted to get the device into more people's hands
- 5:42so they could experience the amazing user interface and workflows. And it really is a useful device
- 5:49for Bitcoiners. So I started selling them as kits and assembled devices for people who maybe
- 5:55aren't confident with the idea of DIY or might not be sure they were buying the right things or
- 6:01who intimidated by putting a device together or anything like that and um yeah so the little
- 6:08tiny tiny shop that i have on square's uh online commerce platform blew up and so i my last month
- 6:15has been just trying to get signers out the door so that more people can experience what uh what
- 6:22really like an amazing cold storage tool that are contributors to the project it built fantastic man
- 6:30We'll jump a little bit more into the SeedCenter project and the device itself in a little bit.
- 6:36So talk to me a little bit about this, though.
- 6:38This was the bug that they identified or that was exposed was five years old.
- 6:44And we in Bitcoin talk a lot about don't trust Verify.
- 6:48And one of the things I've tried to explain to some people who were, because like the Bitcoin way supported Coldcard.
- 6:53We've never made money from supporting any device, but they're like, well, hey, how do we not know about this?
- 6:59And what becomes challenging that I think a lot of people don't realize when it comes to don't trust verify is unless you're going to the factory where hardware is being produced, you're assembling it all yourself, you're literally verifying every single component.
- 7:12There's some amount of trust that goes into that.
- 7:14When you hear don't trust verify, what does that mean to you? How do you try to go about as someone working on a project like SeedSigner, mitigate the risks related to the inherent trust that, you know, many people are probably going to have when they pick up a signing device?
- 7:30So our lead developer, after all this stuff kind of dropped, and he made this kind of epic comment in a private chat with me and some of our other developers that perhaps the most notable feature of SeedCenter is how unambitious it is.
- 7:51so we
- 7:53if you think about commercial
- 7:56your typical commercial hardware wallet
- 7:58like the cold car like a Trezor
- 8:01or a Ledger or whatever
- 8:02they do at least three things
- 8:04it's a private key generation machine
- 8:07it's a
- 8:08transaction signing device
- 8:11and it's a private key storage
- 8:13device that tries to put
- 8:15certain access controls or restrictions
- 8:16around that
- 8:18stored copy of your private key
- 8:20such that if the device got into someone else's hands who shouldn't have it, there would be some
- 8:26at least time delay or something before they'd be able to get access to your funds,
- 8:30if they would ultimately be able to. And so we really, with SeedSigner, we only try to do one
- 8:37of those things. We just try to securely generate the signatures necessary to spend Bitcoin. We don't
- 8:45try to store the private key persistently. SeedSigner is very intentionally what they call
- 8:49a stateless device. So when you turn it on, it doesn't know anything about private keys you've
- 8:54created or transactions you've made in the past. And we also very intentionally
- 8:59did not try to do any sort of random number generation where we were just going to
- 9:06provide people with a key. And this has been since the beginning, because there's been a lot
- 9:11of talk about entropy and such lately. We've always required users to bring some sort of
- 9:16randomness from the world around them to create a private key. You can also, with the seed signer,
- 9:20fire it up and load a key that you've created with a different device. That's fine too. But if
- 9:25you're going to use the seed signer to create a private key, we're going to ask, you know,
- 9:29you either do like a Bit39 lottery where you select the Bit39 seed words randomly from a hat
- 9:36or something, and the seed signer will help you calculate the last word that acts as a check sum
- 9:40against the other words, or sit down with some dice and roll dice 50 or 99 times to create a seed
- 9:46phrase. Or I guess a couple of years ago, we introduced, I think, an innovative feature that
- 9:54allows you to use entropy coming in from the onboard camera to create a private key. Now that
- 10:00approach puts the most trust in our code and the device itself in terms of creating the private key,
- 10:07But it is a very ingenious and quick way to just move the camera on, collect some video frames, and then take a photo.
- 10:14And all of that goes into what makes up the private key that's created.
- 10:18So SeedSighter has never tried to just create private keys without user input and we don try to store keys So that kind of dramatically limits what we need to focus on to make the device the best device it can be
- 10:33And we leverage, you know, another part of the SeedSigner value proposition is this whole concept of DIY.
- 10:42why I mentioned earlier that I sell
- 10:43seed centers, but
- 10:45everything you need to build one
- 10:48yourself that is identical to what
- 10:50myself and many other people throughout
- 10:51the world build is
- 10:53available in our website and in our
- 10:55GitHub repos. So all of the software
- 10:57that gets
- 10:59loaded onto the device,
- 11:01even the ability to build that software
- 11:03from source code into a binary
- 11:05that matches the exact bit
- 11:07for bit releases that we put out there.
- 11:10And then
- 11:10the hardware to buy and even the 3D printable enclosures that are out there in the world.
- 11:18Excuse me, all of that is available on the website.
- 11:20And so the idea is you can acquire a powerful tool to do Bitcoin self-custody and cold storage
- 11:28without necessarily doxing yourself.
- 11:32If you order all the components yourself, especially from multiple sources online,
- 11:36And that helps people avoid getting put onto another list of Bitcoiners that could become fodder for a wrench attack via some privacy leak or customer leak or something like that.
- 11:47So you can get all those components in your hands and build this device without identifying to the world that you're necessarily a Bitcoiner.
- 11:55So that's another advantage.
- 11:58So the main area where trust, you're relying on trust to some degree is if you're not a developer, you're trusting the source code.
- 12:05But it's an air-gapped signing device, not a key storage device, and you don't need to rely on an RNG to generate your seed phrase.
- 12:17So what you've basically done is you've taken a lot of these critical areas where people who are not technical, not developers, and therefore rely on trust, and you've minimized the amount of trust required to use a seed signer.
- 12:28Is that a fair way of framing it?
- 12:29Yeah, I think that that's fair.
- 12:32Two points I'd make is that I'm glad you brought up the air-gapping.
- 12:35I personally think that's a really important part of our approach.
- 12:39And some people like to fade air gapping, but I was a digital forensic examiner for law enforcement for 12 years.
- 12:48I was a 15-year career cop.
- 12:51And the mechanism we used to air gap the signer from the online coordinator, which are these animated QR codes,
- 12:59that really does shrink the attack surface by which you could gain access to the device
- 13:05or try to alter some of the code on it or something like that.
- 13:09Air gapping is just a necessarily slow and deliberate way of moving information between the devices.
- 13:16So for me, I think that's a critical part of our value proposition.
- 13:22And then, boy, brain fart, I forgot with you.
- 13:25other thing i was going to say was what circle yeah it'll it'll come back to you i think as we
- 13:31keep talking so you touched on something i think would be fun to maybe dig into just a little bit
- 13:36talk a little bit about law enforcement forensics what did you do exactly and then how it led to
- 13:40the seed signer project and i want to dive into a bit more like what is the seed signer project
- 13:45its origins that sort of thing so people have maybe better context i i've told this story
- 13:50a bunch of times before, but just at a high level. I was a cop for 15 years. For the first few years,
- 13:56I was just a guy driving a police car, responding to fights and burglaries and making traffic stops,
- 14:02all that kind of stuff. I have a little bit of a background in information systems and the higher
- 14:08ups at my office knew that. And there was, this is like in, I guess we'd say 2006, 2007.
- 14:15So computer forensics was still like a pretty darn new thing at that point. And there was a
- 14:20task force in the area where I worked that was trying to increase its capacity and was taking
- 14:27on potentially new examiners. And so they asked me if I'd have an interest in joining this digital
- 14:31forensic group that was basically a lab where police agencies could bring computers and eventually
- 14:37mobile phones, hard drives, whatever computer devices they might have that could be involved
- 14:45in an investigation and we would in a forensically sound way acquire data from those devices and then
- 14:52try to determine if they were involved in a crime or contain any evidence of a crime.
- 14:57Oddly enough, the forensic lab was where I first heard about Bitcoin back in late 2012 or 2013.
- 15:03There was a local kid who was mining Bitcoin with GPUs and then buying weed on the Silk Road
- 15:09with his mined Bitcoin. And then he was breaking the weed into dime bags and taking it to school.
- 15:14and eventually he got caught and that's how his computers ended up in our lab.
- 15:18It wasn't my case, but we had water cooler talk and discuss exams we're working on.
- 15:26And that was the first time I heard about Bitcoin.
- 15:29Again this is 2013 so I was in the forensic lab for another six years still and I was kind of a closeted Bitcoiner First looking at it kind of as an investment because I was a young guy with a family and a large mortgage and I was just
- 15:44looking for investments and ways to maximize our household income. And then I eventually
- 15:51kind of burned out on... Most of my work was Cribs Against Children involved. So CSAM has become
- 15:59apparently a word that a lot of Bitcoiners have heard over the last few months.
- 16:05And there just weren't a lot of emotional support kind of resources for that kind of stuff.
- 16:12So I eventually burned out, but I was super blessed that Bitcoin kind of paved the way for me to financially retire from law enforcement early and become a stay-at-home dad,
- 16:24which is a super, super big blessing in my life.
- 16:29My wife still works.
- 16:31She was always better at bringing money home.
- 16:32So I was the obvious choice to stay at home.
- 16:34And so I retired in 2019, right before COVID.
- 16:38And in 2020, that first year as Mr. Mom, I was not wanting to degrade until the guy wearing a bathrobe all day and kind of like the stereotypical failed stay-at-home dad.
- 16:55So I'm always a busy guy and I like to have projects.
- 16:57That first year I was taking up all sorts of projects like carpentry and started finishing our basement.
- 17:03And I was digging more into programming and always been interested in 3D printing for, I don't know, like 10 or 12 years now.
- 17:10And I was trying to rethink my cold storage because I had reflected and I wasn't really comfortable the way I'd been doing cold storage in the past.
- 17:22And I was looking for something new.
- 17:24At that time, multisig was something that was just becoming accessible to Bitcoin end users. Prior to that, it was really more of an institutional thing with companies like BitGo providing multisig wallet solutions to Coinbase and large institutions and companies operating in the Bitcoin space.
- 17:44But this software project called Spectre Desktop was, I think, the first to bring multiseg to a place where it was doable for the average Bitcoiner.
- 17:55And they also had kind of a companion project called the Spectre DIY, which is still a thing.
- 18:00But it's this DIY signing device that was one of the first signing devices slash wallets to implement that QR code exchange that I talked about before,
- 18:13where you basically draft a transaction on your online system
- 18:18that's talking to the internet, the Bitcoin protocol,
- 18:21and you have to move that proposed transaction
- 18:24in a secure way from the online computer
- 18:28to the offline computer where your private keys are
- 18:30and QR codes.
- 18:33The first time I did one of these QR code exchange transactions,
- 18:37it was like the first time I had made a Bitcoin transaction
- 18:40and the first time I made a Lightning transaction.
- 18:42It was just kind of a revelation for me.
- 18:44It was very satisfying because prior to that, mostly when you use a hardware wallet, you
- 18:51had to plug it into your laptop or your desktop computer.
- 18:55And with my background in forensics, that always just felt dirty.
- 19:01If you understand what's going on under the hood with the wrong software in place, bad
- 19:05things can happen.
- 19:06And so I was just never a fan of that idea of plugging in a hardware wallet.
- 19:11So between this suddenly multi-sig being accessible in a real way and this QR code exchange that for me offered a higher degree of certainty that your private keys stayed isolated on the device you were using to create the signatures, it was a revelation to me and I started taking steps to rework my own cold storage.
- 19:32and then i interacted a little bit with this uh bitcoin researcher his name is michael flaxman he
- 19:38created this um it's actually hosted in a github repository but it's called the bitcoin 10x
- 19:44security guide or the bitcoin security 10x guide if you google it you'll find it hosted on github
- 19:50and it's it's evergreen it still has a lot of important insights and the basic premise of it
- 19:55was like what are the ways in which um i can get the most bang for my buck in terms of improving my
- 20:01Bitcoin security posture. He also did an episode on the Stefan Levera podcast that I listened to.
- 20:07I started interacting with him a little bit and Flaxman had this idea to use a very specific
- 20:13version of the Raspberry Pi Zero that did not have Wi-Fi and it didn't have Bluetooth. So it
- 20:18was this naturally isolated environment where you could create a private key. And he had this idea
- 20:24to use that device as a way to generate the last word for Bitcoin seed phrases,
- 20:30where you picked the first 11 or the first 23 words at random,
- 20:34and then that last word to calculate it,
- 20:37you generally need a computer to do it.
- 20:39And so he shared that idea with me,
- 20:41and I mentioned I was at a point in my life
- 20:43where I was taking on projects and stuff.
- 20:47And so I hit a little bit of a bad.
- 20:50I took basically two classes in Java way back in like 2002 in college.
- 20:56And so I started watching Python videos on Udemy to learn like just the basics of what I needed to know.
- 21:04And I bought a Raspberry Pi and a little screen and controls for it.
- 21:09And like this is before AI, so it wasn't vibe coding.
- 21:14It was a much more painful process where you either bang your head against the wall, like with just iterating code until it works.
- 21:20Or you go to Stack Exchange and try to get some people smarter than you to give you some pointers.
- 21:25But anyhow, I created a very basic proof of concept that did what he had talked about, where it would let you input, you know, 23 C words that had been selected at random and it would give you the last word.
- 21:39and then as I was looking at my Spectre DIY
- 21:43that has a QR code scanner
- 21:45I thought what if we added just a simple inexpensive camera
- 21:49to this Raspberry Pi setup
- 21:50you would basically be able to do the same thing
- 21:53that the Spectre DIY did
- 21:55but at a much lower price point
- 21:57because I'm a cheapskate too
- 21:58and so it kind of became this challenge
- 22:01and I dug in and over the course of a month
- 22:04created a super janky proof of concept
- 22:07that actually scanned in these proposed transactions,
- 22:11generated the signatures needed to spend the Bitcoin,
- 22:13and that just displayed QR codes on the screen
- 22:16that you could then hold in front of your laptop's webcam.
- 22:19And that communicated the signatures back to your wallet
- 22:23that would be broadcast on the blockchain.
- 22:25I started kind of tweeting about it,
- 22:27and I made a presentation at the Miami Bitcoin Conference in 2021,
- 22:33I believe it was,
- 22:34and was just like almost out of the gate,
- 22:38super blessed that some other super smart,
- 22:43very diligent, conscientious Bitcoiners
- 22:46saw the value in my crappy, clumsy implementation
- 22:51and the potential in it
- 22:52and started helping me with the code
- 22:55and then eventually took over basically all of the coding.
- 22:59So I wrote the first couple versions of Seedsigner
- 23:03and then a guy named nick who uh it's kind of funny i was like tweeting about the seed signer
- 23:09proof of concept and stuff and he's not a big social media guy he was just searching on github
- 23:14for something like bitcoin wallet or something and he found uh what i posted with seed signer
- 23:20and um he forked the repo and started doing some work to make it work with
- 23:26blue wallet and him and i started interacting with and he is a super based like awesome guy
- 23:31and he is still our lead maintainer in the repo amazing contributor to the project and then i
- 23:38mentioned you know i presented on seed signer in the the sweaty nerd tent at the 2021 miami
- 23:45conference and two other people that were at that presentation i met and spoke with for the first
- 23:52time one of which who is keith nukai who became our lead developer still lead developer for the
- 23:58project when another is a nim who goes by the name easy uxd he is a ui ux designer by trade and
- 24:04that's what he does in his fiat job and he a year or two later basically reinvented our whole
- 24:11user interface to transform the almost dos like seed signer interface that i'd come up with into
- 24:18something that is beautiful and intuitive and makes it look like you know as i said before
- 24:25something you would buy as opposed to something you built yourself um so yeah that's that's kind
- 24:30of some a lot of people think that seat center is just me and that cannot be further from the truth
- 24:35i'm still very involved with the project but i don't uh submit code anymore i work more on hardware
- 24:41and 3d printing designs and of course uh talk about the project at conferences and podcasts
- 24:48like this. But it's been this tremendous community project that I think has really
- 24:57iterated and grown in the spirit of Bitcoin in terms of open source and self-reliance and
- 25:05compelling people to learn. That's what I was going to mention before when I got sidetracked
- 25:12and had my middle-aged guy moment.
- 25:15But this idea, and we can come back to it,
- 25:18that SeedSigner, it is a very approachable device,
- 25:21but you also have to invest in yourself
- 25:23and your understanding of Bitcoin
- 25:25before it's going to completely click with you.
- 25:29You have to do the work, as they say.
- 25:31But anyhow, that's been the SeedSigner project.
- 25:34It's still very much permissibly licensed
- 25:37under the MIT license.
- 25:40Anybody can fork the code.
- 25:42There's been Ethereum and Monero and other Litecoin and other forks that obviously we're not involved in.
- 25:52But yeah, it's been a wild ride.
- 25:56That an amazing origin story I didn know all of that So you keep describing it as a project I assume there a company behind the sale of your devices when you assembling or if you sell the component
- 26:10parts through your website. But is the actual SeedSigner project maybe like a less formal
- 26:18construct and it's just people participating, contributing where they can? Obviously with a
- 26:24degree of organization. It sounds like you probably are sort of the one quarterback in much of that.
- 26:31But is that maybe a way of thinking about it for people? Because it took me a little, like
- 26:34CoinKite was a company, right? And Foundation is a company. And SeedSigner is not precisely a
- 26:40company, even though you do sell your devices online. Yeah. As much as I've been reasonably
- 26:48able to, I've tried to keep what I do with, you know, my company is called Beats C Hardware
- 26:53solutions i sell not just seed signers but other uh mostly cold storage tools um but we very
- 26:59intentionally on the seed signer website seedcenter.com we very intentionally have never
- 27:04had like a buy now button or made sales officially through that website because we really do want to
- 27:09keep the focus on uh diy and making sure that people understand that one of the one of the
- 27:16important benefits of this device and this concept is that you can build it yourself and that you don't
- 27:22need to interact with a company to get you know the exact same thing that you could be buying
- 27:27um i myself have also never tried to corner the seed signer market um i've helped people start
- 27:37selling them i think on like four other continents now there's people selling them in
- 27:41south america in europe in asia and in australia that i'm in touch with so it makes a lot more sense
- 27:49maybe in the spirit of decentralization is one of Bitcoin's most important aspects.
- 27:56With SeedSigner, I think it's more important that it makes more sense for it to be done
- 28:02if people are going to be building and selling them as a cottage scale kind of enterprise
- 28:06that is done by people who already have a record of being trustworthy in their local Bitcoin community
- 28:14and who people can have some degree of trust with.
- 28:17Because Seatsighter is a powerful tool, but because it's built from off-the-shelf hardware, you can run any software on the device.
- 28:26I mean, you can play video games on the device if you want to load a different Linux installation with different software on it.
- 28:35So there's no, like a lot of the hardware wallets have what you call software authenticity assurance built into it to where if you attempt to load software that's not signed by the manufacturer under the device, it should throw a warning and say, hey, something looks wrong here, or maybe it won't start up.
- 28:52But seed signer is like a knife or a gun or a car.
- 28:57It's a powerful tool and you can cut yourself with it if you're not careful.
- 29:02So when people build seed signers and sell them, there's a possibility that a malicious actor could send people astray and point them to a download that maybe had issues with it.
- 29:18And so that's why I say it's important that these operations, I think they should stay small and the foundation of it should be on that Bitcoiners trust in the market.
- 29:27But to circle back to your original point, yeah, a lot of people don't understand that Seeds Hunter is not a company. It is just a volunteer open source software project. And me kind of as the guy, I joke that it's kind of like herding cats because people will come and tell me they want this new feature or this or that.
- 29:48And it's like our contributors generally scratch their own itch to some capacity.
- 29:53They obviously, security is paramount and they will consider new features that don't necessarily interest them.
- 30:02But they generally do scratch their own itch.
- 30:05And I can't assign a feature or some sort of programming test to anybody.
- 30:10So it's interesting how that has affected the evolution of the device because the current feature set and the workflows are kind of an expression of best practices that our core group agree on, basically.
- 30:31There are features that people have asked for, like encrypted QR codes, which are something that have been implemented on some of the other projects out there that are also kind of DIY-assigning devices.
- 30:45And I don't like just summarily rejecting feature requests because people are excited and they want to see something that they think would be useful to them on SeedCenter.
- 30:56But we think very carefully about the feature set that we offer and the decision tree that we present users with.
- 31:04And we think very carefully about what we think fits into that feature set and that decision tree And there are some things that we just think could present too many foot guns for users and the potential for people who don entirely understand what they doing to you know cause themselves a problem
- 31:22So, but the good news is like you can fork the code.
- 31:26And if you really want those encrypted QR codes, there are people out there who have built that into Forks of Seed Center.
- 31:35There's a super popular fork that they've implemented Java card support into.
- 31:40So like the CoinKite had a product for it, but people use Java cards to store Bitcoin private keys.
- 31:48And it's kind of an interesting trade-off in terms of something that's a little lower cost and more disposable,
- 31:54but that is really a security standard that all of our debit cards and all sorts of other security mechanisms rely on.
- 32:01So they're powerful tools, but it's just not something that we're at a point where we are ready to have that in the main branch of the project.
- 32:10And it may never get there, but we'll see.
- 32:12So I don't know.
- 32:13I'm meandering a bit.
- 32:15No, no.
- 32:16I think this stuff is fascinating.
- 32:19I like that it seems like the ethos of the project itself is it harkens back to these cypherpunk values.
- 32:27It's built slowly, methodically, thoughtfully.
- 32:29but at the discretion of the people who are participating and have a stake in this being
- 32:34the best product that it can be. So I want to jump into, I don't want this to turn into a soap opera,
- 32:39but I want to get a little bit into the drama because you and NVK of CoinKite had gone back
- 32:45and forth on Twitter for a long time. He was highly critical of SeedSigner. To be fair,
- 32:50he was highly critical of just about everything that wasn't a cold card, but he talked a lot
- 32:54about the raspberry pi he had issues with um lack of secure element can you maybe address
- 33:00to your recollection when did this start what were his critiques and how did you address those or
- 33:07articulate the trade-offs that were being made as you progressed this project right um interestingly
- 33:13enough we were on friendly terms in the very beginning i remember dming with him early on
- 33:18about just about general terms about seat center about cold card and features that he was looking
- 33:23to implement cold card that he was trying to build traction for and um i don't know for sure what
- 33:30when it switched from you know friendly occasional dming to something like a little more adversarial
- 33:36um but as you said like he's he was very proud of his thing and and thought that everything that
- 33:44wasn't his thing was inherently uh inferior to it but in terms of seed signer specifically uh one of
- 33:51his main, one of his main concerns revolved around a feature that we have that's called a seed QR.
- 34:00And what it, it's exactly what it sounds like. It is your seed, but not stored as 12 or 24 words.
- 34:07It's stored as a hand-drawn QR code. And the reason for that feature was that, you know,
- 34:14it's kind of a pain to type 12 or 24 words into, you know, this very small device that just has
- 34:21a thumbstick and a few buttons.
- 34:23So earlier in the project,
- 34:24because when the seed signer turns on,
- 34:26it doesn't know anything about keys you've used
- 34:28or created in the past.
- 34:29Every time you turn it on,
- 34:30you have to input your seed phrase
- 34:31to be able to set up a wallet or make transactions.
- 34:35And our lead developer, very clever guy,
- 34:37came up with this idea where you could create,
- 34:42as I said, a version of your seed phrase
- 34:45or your private key that is a QR code.
- 34:49And we intentionally do this.
- 34:50It sounds crazy to people who haven't heard of it or tried it, but it's intentionally a very offline manual process.
- 34:56So we have these templates of a blank QR code and we have a very smooth UX workflow on the device where you sit down with a template and a Sharpie or a pen or something.
- 35:08And you basically move through the QR code broken down into smaller grid sections and you just copy the dots as you see them on the seed signer screen.
- 35:17And then after you've copied all the dots,
- 35:19the very next thing you do is, of course,
- 35:21scan the thing that you've drawn to make sure that you've copied it correctly
- 35:24and that it works.
- 35:25I know it sounds crazy, but with the error correction and QR code,
- 35:28you can actually get up to like five or ten dots completely wrong,
- 35:32and it will still scan perfectly every time because of that error correction.
- 35:37But anyhow, you have this hand-drawn QR code version of your private key
- 35:40that now when you turn on your Seedsider,
- 35:42instead of typing in those 12 or 24 words,
- 35:45You just scan the QR code and instantly your key is active on the device.
- 35:50Rodolfo, I can hear him saying it from his podcast or see the words because he typed and said it so often, but he always talked about these QR codes being laying around or left laying around.
- 36:03And after you've gone through the workflow of using a seed center, like you have a very,
- 36:08a very acute understanding that that QR code represents the private key that is needed to
- 36:15spend your money, especially in a single SIG.
- 36:17Um but I guess in his mind like people just left these like on a coffee table in their home or their desk in their home office or whatever And it like you know first of all our users understand that like where you access these you know you not going to go to a cafe
- 36:33and start signing Bitcoin transactions.
- 36:35This is something that is, you know,
- 36:37you take this out in your home where you have a sense of like,
- 36:41are there cameras around?
- 36:42As a side note with text scanning and images these days,
- 36:48QR codes and written words are basically equivalent
- 36:51with all of the OCI that goes on.
- 36:56But anyhow, one, like our users understand what that represents
- 37:00and they're not just going to leave them laying around.
- 37:02These are something that they put in a safe at home
- 37:05or a safe deposit box or in a carefully hidden location
- 37:08or whatever they choose to do.
- 37:10And then the other facet being that SeedCenter,
- 37:14as I talked about with multi-sig, like from the beginning,
- 37:17SeedCenter has been a very multi-sig oriented
- 37:20project. The first few versions of our software actually didn't even offer the ability to set up
- 37:27single-sig wallets. That was a feature that users requested that we thought made sense and that we
- 37:33added to the feature set. But SeedCenter is very long-term savings focused. So this isn't a wallet
- 37:39that you're making multiple spends from every week or even every month. And two, we really
- 37:45focus on multi-sick where you have the keys geographically distributed around where you
- 37:50live so like i said one in a safe deposit box one in your best friend's gun safe one in you know
- 37:57a fire safe inside of your home buried under a tree in your favorite field or wherever you decide
- 38:03that you feel comfortable with those keys being um that's where you uh decide to store them but so
- 38:11that was one of his critiques was these QR codes are just naked keys that are laying around and
- 38:17that, you know, that people are going to be scanning, I don't know, whatever. People have
- 38:22security cameras in their home that are going to scan these QR codes or something and hackers are
- 38:26going to get them. So the QR code thing was one of his, his perpetual sort of concerns.
- 38:32And then he expressed some concerns around the Raspberry Pi and its firmware, the firmware,
- 38:37the whole firmware software thing in a Raspberry Pi,
- 38:40it's kind of a gray area where the line actually is
- 38:43between the firmware and the software.
- 38:44There is a small source of a small,
- 38:47how could I say this?
- 38:50A small portion of proprietary code
- 38:52that is loaded onto the board at the factory
- 38:54that supports the GPU in a limited way,
- 38:58other hardware functions on the board.
- 39:01It's my understanding,
- 39:02and I haven't read or seen anything
- 39:04after the research I've done to indicate otherwise.
- 39:06once that is burned in at the factory, it's basically a once in burn and it can't be changed
- 39:11after the fact. Seed signers are, I mean, there are, there are hundreds of millions of raspberry
- 39:17pies that are deployed around the world right now and that are still being produced and put
- 39:22in the market. Seed signer is a percent of a percent of a percent of, you know, the, the
- 39:27potential use case for all of those, um, raspberry pies. So hypothetically, could something be
- 39:35introduced at the factory that would downstream potentially affect the operation of a Raspberry
- 39:41Pi that could create a security issue for SeedCenter users. Hypothetically, it's possible.
- 39:48But again, even with the increased attention that SeedCenter's got, we are nowhere on the radar of
- 39:55the Raspberry Pi Foundation or really the rest of the open source single board computer
- 40:00computing community. And if you were the kind of person who was going to compromise a supply chain
- 40:08and you had the resources and the ability to do that, it would make a ton more sense to target
- 40:12a ledger or a trezor or a foundation or some company where there is not just a small, tiny
- 40:19percentage of those devices that are going to be used for Bitcoin cold storage, but basically all
- 40:24of the devices are going to be used for Bitcoin cold storage. So we have this kind of hiding in a
- 40:29crowd. A little bit of security through obscurity to some degree that doesn't exist with a dedicated
- 40:37corporation creating that sort of thing. There were trade-offs with that because as soon as
- 40:43like with a commercial wallet, as soon as it's known that even the sub-components are going to
- 40:48end up on a circuit board that goes into a harder wallet, that's when supply chain risk begins. And
- 40:54it continues from that point that those components are identified as going into a harder wallet,
- 40:59all the way through to it being delivered to your front door or handed to a conference or wherever
- 41:05or however you choose to buy it. And there's all sorts of exotic stuff. And then there's dumb stuff
- 41:12of just outright replacing devices with malicious hardware and then putting a skin on them that
- 41:17looks like a trezzer. We've seen instances of that where it's a malicious device that just is put
- 41:23inside of a trezzler enclosure.
- 41:25And so with SeedCenter,
- 41:27we kind of take the opposite side of the bet
- 41:30and say like,
- 41:31instead of exposing ourselves
- 41:33to all this supply chain risk,
- 41:34we are, as you say,
- 41:35going to kind of hide in the crowd
- 41:36and use off the shelf components
- 41:37that are,
- 41:39that uh we can build into our own thing um i'm trying to think about other
- 41:46i think criticisms i think you shared shortly after um i think it was you who shared like a
- 41:53just like a video scrolling through all of the comments he had made about raspberry pi and in
- 41:59the raspberry pi in particular and it was like yeah and it was just like it went on forever
- 42:05you know he'd been he'd been having on this for a long time i posted that video because a lot of
- 42:09people don't understand like the degree to which it was almost kind of like an obsession with him
- 42:16there's i can't say definitively but there are several like urls that are similar to seed signer
- 42:22like seed signer.edu seed signer.net seed signer.store seed signer.fail and a bunch of other
- 42:29similar ones that i suspect he has something to do with being redirected to like initially they
- 42:35were redirected to a website called airgapcomputer.com that advertised cold cards. And then when we made
- 42:44a complaint to the organization that regulates URLs about that seeming like commercial competition
- 42:53in the initial stages of that complaint after it was made to the party who owns those URLs,
- 43:02suddenly the cold card links were removed and it was uh claimed that that was just an informational
- 43:09website sharing information in the spirit of open source but then those urls have been forwarded to
- 43:14like other weird stuff like the cia now they get forwarded to a bitcoin knots website like it's
- 43:21it's this kind of like juvenile trolling um that i i don't know i i think ultimately
- 43:28even before this cold card thing blew up like i i talked to a lot of people who had stopped using
- 43:35and stopped buying gold cards just because of all the childish behavior not just towards us but to
- 43:39other people that he had exhibited over time and i think i i could go down quite a rabbit hole about
- 43:45this um but at this point it's kind of a moot issue given this wild turn of events wild unfortunate
- 43:53that has happened with Coldcard and the company and stuff.
- 43:57And so it's not even worth wasting the brain cycles on anymore at this point.
- 44:03Yeah. One more question, though, because I think this is something that needs...
- 44:08There's a lot of question, like I think valid questioning that needs to happen,
- 44:14consideration for how funding to open source projects need to be considered.
- 44:18and my understanding is that open sats was is one of the big uh providers to uh free open source
- 44:25software uh funding and nvk was i think on the was he on the board of open sats i don't know did
- 44:33you had you applied for funding uh for seed signer and it never never panned out and obviously
- 44:40there were some conflicts probably uh at the uh at the higher levels of that project uh right that
- 44:47might have restricted you i have no insight into the inner workings of open sats what i can say
- 44:52is that he was a voting member who um had a vote on uh projects that came through that
- 45:01involve requests for funding um i think by i think in their bylaws people are supposed to
- 45:08recuse themselves if they could have a potential conflict of interests
- 45:12with projects that come through in terms of grant requests.
- 45:16OpenSats doesn't publish its votes, and I think in some ways that's understandable.
- 45:21But did he recuse himself? Did he not recuse himself? I have no idea.
- 45:25Did he try to influence other board members and misrepresent or misframe the project
- 45:29to try to affect their votes? I have no insight on that either.
- 45:33I do know that there were at least four separate applications for seed center-related funding,
- 45:37one by myself and three by our lead developer. It's kind of this sad. So the first one that I
- 45:46submitted was very early and it was kind of a general application for funds that I was going to
- 45:53basically distribute to myself as well as the other people working on the project.
- 45:58And they rejected that one, I think, because that was my plan. And that's understandable.
- 46:03I don't know if that's a regulatory thing or maybe it's just their internal policy protocol.
- 46:08Keith made an application, got rejected.
- 46:12And then ironically, people inside of OpenSats encouraged him to reapply.
- 46:18I do have acquaintances and contacts with people who worked at OpenSats in different capacities.
- 46:26And he was encouraged to reapply.
- 46:28He submitted a new application.
- 46:30That was declined too.
- 46:33And then this is going to sound crazy, but someone else on the inside encouraged him to reapply and really helped him polish his application up and everything.
- 46:40So Keith applied for a third time and was rejected a third time.
- 46:45No real explanation as to why Or was it just a matter of Because Keith submitted those three applications I think on the third one they gave him very specific and pointed feedback that I think he didn necessarily agree with
- 46:57but kudos to them for providing it because it helps understand the framework and stuff.
- 47:03But another known fact is that Rodolfo Novak has stepped down from the board of OpenSATS.
- 47:12My hope is that because there were other, I guess you could say,
- 47:16concerns that had come up over time um one of the two co-creators of nostor uh i i can't think of
- 47:25his name right now uh jb55 i think is his his name had really expressed some serious concerns
- 47:32about funding and his access to funding through up and he did get several grants through open
- 47:38stats but he said uh in multiple nostor posts that he had raised some concerns about open
- 47:46sats and applications that were being rejected and who was getting access to funding and that
- 47:52kind of stuff and he said that rodolfo came to him privately and said like look you may need to
- 47:58stop criticizing the organization or you might stop getting grants basically um so as i alluded
- 48:05before rodolfo's no longer on the board i'm hoping and praying that that's changing things whereas
- 48:12as I I've been critical of his, his involvement on that board for some time,
- 48:17which is also, you know,
- 48:19for a time put me at odds with some of the other people at the organization.
- 48:24But I think now that he's gone, like I'm looking at this as like a clean slate
- 48:28and let's let them give, let's,
- 48:32let's give them some space and they're probably reorienting some of their
- 48:36priorities and their processes internally.
- 48:39like let's give them room to like see what happens next and i'm hoping because in terms of grant
- 48:46organizations like the human rights foundation and open sats are really the only two organizations
- 48:52that we qualify for funding from unless there's one or more that i don't know about there are
- 48:58there's like brink and some other funding ords but they generally only focus on funding people
- 49:04that work on Bitcoin Core.
- 49:06So OpenSats and HRF are kind of the only game in town for Seedsider.
- 49:10HRF, I feel like, has been very generous to us over time.
- 49:13Keith has received multiple grants.
- 49:15I received an early grant that was similar to what I described before,
- 49:20where I received the funds and then kind of distributed them to myself
- 49:25as well as other contributors because we hadn't really received anything
- 49:30in the way of financial support for what we were doing
- 49:33or anything like that.
- 49:36So I'm hoping that all of that drama is behind us
- 49:41with open stats and that, yeah, we'll see what happens.
- 49:45I don't think they owe us anything.
- 49:50So we'll just have to wait and see what happens.
- 49:53Absolutely.
- 49:53Just a couple more questions here
- 49:55and then we'll head for home.
- 49:56So one of them is very specific.
- 49:58So when you mentioned that SeedSigner
- 50:01was originally developed for InDesign to be used as part of a multi-sig setup. Do you see value in
- 50:09a multi-vendor multi-sig? What would you say to people who would consider a single seed signer
- 50:14device to be used for signing in a multi-sig? How do you think about the potential risks of
- 50:19one or the other? What are your thoughts? Yeah, I think you can make an argument for a single
- 50:26seed signer multi-sig setup i think that is definitely a step above just a single sig
- 50:33wallet and has some definitive advantages over that but the pinnacle of like multi-sig is always
- 50:40going to be multi-vendor multi-sig because um any vulnerability in any single device
- 50:47seed signer included um doesn't become a critical issue that takes down the multi-sig and causes you
- 50:54to lose funds or lose access to funds.
- 50:56So with a multi-sig, for people who may not be as deep on this,
- 51:02you can use a single seed center because it's stateless.
- 51:05It doesn't store your private key.
- 51:06You can use that to manage multiple private keys in a multi-sig quorum.
- 51:11In fact, you can manage an entire multi-sig quorum with a single seed center.
- 51:16That said, if you were to get tricked into downloading bad software
- 51:20and you didn't go through the steps of verifying,
- 51:22very important steps of verifying you had a good download that had been officially released in the
- 51:27project there are some attacks that could be executed that could cause you an issue if you
- 51:33were managing an entire multi-sig quorum with a single seed sire or if there was some unknown
- 51:40unknown and it's kind of funny with this cold card thing like we can't really it was an unknown
- 51:46unknown but at the same time it wasn't because multiple people it it appears had tried to alert
- 51:53the company to the very specific issue that that were causing the the entropy problem that they
- 51:59experienced but anyhow if there was an unknown unknown issue with a seed signer that wasn for whatever reason wasn even on our radar and you were managing an entire whorem with it that could be a big problem
- 52:11I personally manage my life savings with a single seed signer, but I'm obviously kind of an exception prior to the rule.
- 52:22And if someone really does want that diversity of hardware and diversity of software such that no single device can take you down,
- 52:30I love seed signer, but if you want the pinnacle of multi-sig, you should get multiple different devices, different hardware and software profiles, use that to set up.
- 52:38But I think the single seed center multi-sig does offer some advantages that kind of basically like if your concern is around key disclosure or key loss, if one of those keys gets stolen from your home or destroyed in a fire or is snooped on by a bank employee in a safe deposit box, that single seed center multi-sig, you're still just fine.
- 53:08And I think that's a significant advantage over the single SIG setup that a lot of people to this point typically lean on.
- 53:18Seems like a reasonable answer.
- 53:19All righty, man.
- 53:20Last question for you.
- 53:21I warned you.
- 53:21I was going to ask this at the beginning.
- 53:23What is an unpopular opinion that you have?
- 53:26And you get bonus points if you offend some Bitcoiners with it.
- 53:31This is probably a cheap answer.
- 53:34But I saw somebody who was, I managed the Seedsiner Twitter account, and there was somebody who's like one of these like 30 follower trolls who said that they'd been trying to build a Seedsiner for more than a year now and that they hadn't been able to do it.
- 53:52And I think I responded something like, you're not trying hard enough.
- 53:55If you're telling the truth here, you're not trying hard enough.
- 53:58So for people who know me, this probably is not controversial, but I think that DIY is accessible to many more people than what the Bitcoin ecosystem tends to signal or believe.
- 54:17I think early on with the project, I can remember Peter McCormick when SeedSigner came up on what Bitcoin did, just saying multiple times, it's just too technical. SeedSigner is just too technical or whatever in his British accent.
- 54:33and that is i think that because he's got a big audience that that caught fire as an opinion of
- 54:41the bitcoin community and seed center like it may be a good thing but it's just too technical and like
- 54:46i'm you know just a non-technical bitcoin or blah blah if you are willing to like take on a weekend
- 54:53project and learn some things and reach out to maybe some trusted bitcoiners in your meetup or
- 55:00people who are knowledgeable online, if you're willing to lean in and do it, I think DIY is
- 55:06accessible to a lot more people than we get credit for. And like I always tell people,
- 55:14build a seed center. Even if you decide that it's not going to be in your toolkit moving forward for
- 55:21cold storage, you will learn a significant amount about creating private keys, generating the public
- 55:29keys that are used, that are generated from the private keys that are used to set up a wallet.
- 55:34Then you're going to learn about how transactions are constructed and the process of actually
- 55:40generating the signatures and then moving them back to be broadcast on the, like that is consistent
- 55:45feedback I get from everybody who's a less technical Bitcoiner, but who puts in the effort
- 55:50to learn how to use a seed center is they learn a significant amount that gives them, even if they
- 55:54end up using something else that gives them tremendous insight into the importance of their
- 55:59seed phrase and their private key and how their Bitcoin does not live on the hardware wallet.
- 56:05And it gives them a roadmap for if something were to go wrong with their hardware wallet,
- 56:09how they would be able to retain access quickly to their funds. Because one, if you're doing a
- 56:17multi-vent or multi-sig, I think seed center is a no brainer to have in your quorum. But two,
- 56:22even if it's not, if you power on your ledger and the battery's swollen, or if you go to update
- 56:29the firmware on your Trezor and all of a sudden it looks like it's bricked, having a seed signer
- 56:35in your desk drawer is going to give you a tremendous amount of calmness and mental clarity
- 56:42as you're kind of freaking out because you think access to your Bitcoins may be in jeopardy.
- 56:47If you understand how to use it and you put in the time, you can very quickly
- 56:50put your seed phrase into that and use it to recreate your entire wallet on another device.
- 56:58If your laptop has crashed or something and suddenly your Sparrow installation,
- 57:02you don't have access to it anymore or your wallet backup isn't there,
- 57:07SeedSigner is an incredible recovery tool if you had an issue with a conventional hard wallet And there are a lot of people who either had a signer themselves or had a friend with a seed signer who were able to quickly move funds in this whole cold card
- 57:23to a solid newly created private key that was from Rolling Dice or even with our camera entropy feature.
- 57:33So I think it's something, it's an interesting security posture that seed signer takes in terms of trade-offs.
- 57:42Because there is no perfect insecurity. There are only trade-offs. But I think we take some really compelling trade-offs. And I think it's something that people should dig into. But that was a very self-serving response to your controversial Bitcoin takes.
- 57:58No, no. So I'm going to piggyback off of that just for a moment, because I think what you're hitting on is really an important concept, even more broadly than just DIY is accessible, because we experience this at the Bitcoin Way all the time. People hear about running a node, taking self-custody, dice rolls, and they're like, oh, it sounds complicated.
- 58:18it. And what I can say from experience is, first of all, I knew nothing about this three years ago
- 58:23when I hired the Bitcoin way to become a client. And now I know that we have, I think our oldest
- 58:28client is 86 years old. And that's not an anomaly. We have clients in their seventies and eighties
- 58:33who are running a node, know how to send an air gap transaction, have set up inheritance plans,
- 58:37fully self-custody. There's no key sharing, no KYC. We can't spy on when you send your Bitcoin,
- 58:43None of that. It is fully self-sovereign. And so if we can get people to accomplish that level of
- 58:51self-sovereignty with their Bitcoin stack, to assemble a seed signer is well within the
- 58:56capabilities of most people. It truly is, I think you would agree with this. It's really just a
- 59:01matter of disciplining yourself to sit down, take the time and prioritize some of these skills.
- 59:07But what you highlighted that I think is most important is that
- 59:10doing these things is how you learn about Bitcoin. It is how you improve your life and
- 59:16improve your skills as it relates to interacting with the Bitcoin ecosystem more broadly.
- 59:21Anything else to me is kind of training wheels and you can't go off-roading with training wheels.
- 59:26And I think it just brings like a new level of freedom to being a Bitcoiner. So that's my
- 59:33comment. I don't know if you want to chime in one more time on that. Yeah, no, I totally agree. And I
- 59:38I think one of the things I think that kind of,
- 59:41I refer to them as handholding services that you guys provide,
- 59:44which I think is super important and delivers a lot of value.
- 59:49I think an important part of that is the end result is people end up feeling a
- 59:54lot more confident about their cold storage setup because they understand that
- 1:00:00if their laptop crashed or if a particular device didn't work or whatever,
- 1:00:03They're probably the people who feel the most comfortable recovering access to their funds from source material for your wallet, which is your private keys.
- 1:00:16And so I think that being able to lay in bed awake at night and not have these nagging concerns about, you know, what if there wasn't sufficient entropy from the random number jader entering that went into my private key?
- 1:00:32Or what if there's like somebody planning a retirement attack at the vendor that I use?
- 1:00:38Or what if there's, you know, a three-letter government agency and a weak government agency that's trying to launch a supply chain attack on blah, blah, blah.
- 1:00:47Like all of these, like, what if, what if, you know, if you have a single say, what if my device won't work?
- 1:00:54What if all of these nagging little concerns, some of which are more tinfoil hat and some of which are more just legitimate, like what if kind of concerns.
- 1:01:02having more knowledge and more control over your setup is what gives you more peace of mind and
- 1:01:09doing the work is so important and maybe i'll circle back with like one more controversial take
- 1:01:15i i i am seeing a lot of it seems to me like bitki is experiencing an outsized version of growth as
- 1:01:26a result of this whole cold card episode which is kind of ironic to me because people put too
- 1:01:35much trust in cold card there was a there was an there was a findable bug in their code that caused
- 1:01:41people to lose money um but because like people put too much trust in their software stack there
- 1:01:49was an issue and it's like if the outcome of this whole episode is that like well we just need to
- 1:01:55trust harder and put our trust in something else with like more keys and a prettier user interface
- 1:02:02like i i don't think that's a productive lesson from this whole thing and i'm not
- 1:02:06trying to fud or say anything bad about uh big keys particular design choices um i think the whole
- 1:02:15community recovery thing is a compelling concept that they've implemented in an interesting way
- 1:02:23one like I'm an analog key guy
- 1:02:26like I think of digital
- 1:02:28copies of private keys as convenience
- 1:02:29And so all three of the keys being digital and that's up just like,
- 1:02:34it doesn't feel right to me.
- 1:02:36And then some of the keys being stored,
- 1:02:39like encrypted on a cloud server or whatever with a third party or whatever.
- 1:02:43I'm just like,
- 1:02:45I posted a meme a week or two ago and it's like,
- 1:02:49so you're saying the keys are encrypted and stored on different servers on
- 1:02:55different hardware devices,
- 1:02:56but they're connected to the internet.
- 1:02:58and it's like how is me keeping these keys me keeping the keys offline uh and under my own
- 1:03:07control like how is this better than that i i feel like i have a whole lot more control over the whole
- 1:03:12thing if i know that my keys have stayed offline and that i know where they're physically located
- 1:03:17and it would take someone basically going on a treasure hunt um and forcibly you know getting
- 1:03:23access to them or stealing them for my bitcoin to be at risk like that gives me more peace than
- 1:03:28the whole when you try to obscure away too much of the complexity and make it too easy
- 1:03:34one i think you you you run the risk of getting into this rube goldberg kind of like system that's
- 1:03:41so complicated that one of these tiny details like that happened with cold card one of these
- 1:03:46tiny details can take down the whole thing.
- 1:03:49And you deny people the peace of mind that comes with understanding what's going on when
- 1:03:56they doing cold storage When you try to obscure away too much when you make it too much of an easy button like those are some of the risks you run So I yeah I leave it at that
- 1:04:07I completely agree with you. Self-custody is not broken. It's just, it's, it's a, it's a single
- 1:04:13incident that compensating controls could have and did like for our clients account for. And I think
- 1:04:20it's just a matter of taking your self-custody set up to the next level and digging deeper and
- 1:04:24learning harder. I think for a lot of people, it's like what I like to say is that owning Bitcoin is
- 1:04:29an act of knowledge. Taking self-custody is an act of defiance. And we need more people doing that.
- 1:04:36And it's just like it's not voting harder, it's not trusting harder in a different direction. So
- 1:04:41Seed, I think this is a great place to wrap the conversation, man. Really appreciate your time.
- 1:04:46Why don't you give a handoff, tell people where they can buy directly from you, anywhere you want
- 1:04:50direct them for the SeedSigner project itself
- 1:04:53where they can follow you, anything else you want to share?
- 1:04:55So I'll just point out
- 1:04:56SeedSigner.com, not variants
- 1:04:59on that, but the top level
- 1:05:00dot com domain and then on
- 1:05:02Twitter
- 1:05:03we have the handle
- 1:05:06just at SeedSigner. I also
- 1:05:09have a personal account that sometimes is
- 1:05:10retweeted from the SeedSigner accounts. You
- 1:05:12won't have any trouble finding
- 1:05:14my personal account if you
- 1:05:16want to find it and then
- 1:05:18rather than
- 1:05:19referencing my own thing,
- 1:05:22I'm just gonna encourage people to get out there.
- 1:05:24And from SeedSigner.com,
- 1:05:27you can find information on how to build a SeedSigner We have a great explainers page with videos by Ben Sessions and all sorts of other people on how to build and use a seed signer We list out the components you need to buy
- 1:05:40We provide links to the GitHub repo that also explains how the software is put together and gives additional information on what you need to buy.
- 1:05:48It's just three simple components, a Raspberry Pi, a display and controls, and then a camera.
- 1:05:55And you basically have a seed signer, but they need to be very specific parts.
- 1:05:59and then the last plug will be for our telegram community um i telegram has somewhat of a deserved
- 1:06:07reputation for being kind of sketch and i think we are an oasis of signal inside of telegram so
- 1:06:18we have a great telegram community at ccenter.com on the main page towards the bottom you can find a
- 1:06:24linked to it uh but we have a great telegram community if you join it there's gonna be tons
- 1:06:29of people in there that are helpful and can help you do things like troubleshoot like if you're
- 1:06:35trying to boot your seed signer and it's not booting they can help you figure out like maybe
- 1:06:40the software didn't get rid into the micro st card properly or if you're trying to verify the
- 1:06:43software and you're having trouble with that all sorts of helpful people in there if you're just
- 1:06:47thinking through multi-sig and you know kind of the game theory around cold storage uh there's a
- 1:06:52a lot of that conversation that goes on in there.
- 1:06:55If you join the group and you post in there,
- 1:06:57you probably get some DMs from bots or scammy people trying to convince you to do dumb things like message them your seed phrase so they can help you or stuff like that Ignore all the DMs Every instance of help that happens in our Telegram
- 1:07:12community should happen out in the open so that everybody can verify it's on the up and up.
- 1:07:17But it really is a great community. I consistently hear that over and over again. So I encourage
- 1:07:21people to check that out. Fantastic, man. Thank you so much again for the time. I know it's been
- 1:07:26a busy month and hope to have you back on again in the future. Yeah. Thanks for inviting me. I
- 1:07:30appreciate this. Cheers, man. And that's a wrap. Again, hope you enjoyed my conversation with Seed.
- 1:07:35Go check out the Seed Signer project. We'll link to that in the show notes. He also mentioned all
- 1:07:39the places you can go follow them at the end of the episode here. And do me a huge favor,
- 1:07:43go follow the Bitcoin way on X. We're at the Bitcoin way underscore. I'm there as well at
- 1:07:48the other M Jordan. Be sure to smash that like button, subscribe to the channel if you haven't
- 1:07:52already engaged with our content. We'd really appreciate you helping to feed the algorithm.
- 1:07:56and of course go to thebitcoinway.com slash podcast you can schedule a free 30-minute
- 1:08:01consultation with a member of our team we'll walk you through what we do how we do it why it's so
- 1:08:06important to take proper 100 self-custody of your bitcoin the right way the first time
- 1:08:10and we also help with online security cyber security privacy phone setup we've got a plan
- 1:08:16b residency option in panama that you're going to want to hear about as well again that's the
- 1:08:21bitcoinway.com slash podcast. Until next time, stay safe, stay sovereign, and remember the yield
- 1:08:28on Bitcoin is freedom.