Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 145:4-146:5. Idolatry: Which Idols Are Permitted to Benefit From; Which Idols Can Be Anulled

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 145:4-146:5. Idolatry: Which Idols Are Permitted to Benefit From; Which Idols Can Be Anulled · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:03
  Morning, good morning. We are Simon Kaufman.
• 0:07
  Hey, got to SIF. Hey, that's what the direction
• 0:11
  told me last night. I think so so to oh to three Sif
• 0:20
  thousand. OK, fine.
• 0:21
  Sif 1000 Evan Schatzva la abdo. There's an Evan that you took
• 0:26
  out of the ground and you, you carved out whatever it is, you
• 0:31
  whatever someone. The Asura Bahana, which was, you
• 0:36
  know, you know, taking care of whatever.
• 0:39
  What's the word for it? It was shaped.
• 0:43
  It was shaped. It was whatever.
• 0:46
  Huge. Huge is the good word.
• 0:47
  Yeah. Chisel.
• 0:48
  Chisel. There you go.
• 0:49
  Yeah. Asura Bahana.
• 0:51
  It's also Bahana. Haisa Katsuva, if it was already
• 0:56
  we'd see River Qaeda and you went ahead and you made it all
• 0:59
  fancy and and and painted it and and drew on it.
• 1:03
  Whatever we should see Ave. someone should worship it.
• 1:06
  Afilo see every key at the Gufa. Evan even if you went ahead, it
• 1:10
  wasn't just like on a you covered it with something and
• 1:13
  then and then went ahead and painted.
• 1:15
  You painted or etched in the actual Evan late too much of
• 1:18
  fiddish. You could take off the outer
• 1:21
  layer that what you added on. There's someone, whoever it is
• 1:23
  who also Bahana. That outer layer is also Bahana
• 1:27
  of a Shahar Evan motor. But the rest of the Evan is
• 1:31
  motor, the honey beetle and the voter Zara that that beetle
• 1:39
  would work if you do alone, not only sham rock macheteer motor
• 1:43
  and a voter Zara, which is the honey beetle, meaning that of a
• 1:46
  of a non Jew. So then he all yells easy to
• 1:51
  take off, even if he you know, even he just took off the
• 1:56
  decorations or the OR the drawing.
• 1:59
  That's enough to move out to the motor, you know.
• 2:01
  So Derek Bittel, if he did it, Derek Bittel did it to take it
• 2:04
  off, not to like fix it up. Hey, Evan Chehemi and Alehha
• 2:10
  Eli, if you have a stone that they put put the Solomon Shelby
• 2:15
  Kahovim Raziel sewer that Evan is going to be Elsa brah.
• 2:18
  Now Cole's bunchy Alleha right. I mean you can't sit on it.
• 2:22
  Silka. They took it off Evan Muteris
• 2:26
  and the Evan the Evan is going to be motor to to sit on and to
• 2:31
  stand on and to whatever vah Elan Shenato Imitri lashi.
• 2:36
  Hey Nevada, the tree which was planted originally so it will be
• 2:40
  worshipped us about. No, that tree is always us
• 2:42
  about. No Hey Elon Natura, it was
• 2:45
  already planted the Godoy who paslo and they trimmed it up the
• 2:50
  shameli afilo Hevrika Hirku Elon even they put new branches in.
• 2:55
  They were grafted new branches on the Hootsie 3 game and they
• 2:59
  started growing. Chorus is a three-game.
• 3:01
  We cut off the new branches, the Haim asuri, those are usser, but
• 3:05
  hanak they, they had kavana. Those branches would be for a
• 3:09
  shayra for vodazara. Then you cut them off and the
• 3:11
  rest of the charilla motor and the rest of the tree will be
• 3:14
  motor. Well, no, because they're still
• 3:20
  the the branches are still usser.
• 3:22
  The thing is, the trees are already grown.
• 3:23
  They can't usser something which is over the carca unless it was
• 3:27
  planted for that, right? But then no, that's the first
• 3:33
  one. The second thing is if you have
• 3:34
  an Elon atour, yeah, that's already only Elon atour Elon
• 3:39
  Shimami Elon that they put the, the, the what's it called?
• 3:44
  The the shop says it's talking on a tree which was planted to
• 3:49
  put put a statue underneath it. Kohl's van Shaheed tact of also
• 3:55
  Bahana as long as it's underneath, it's also Bahana.
• 3:58
  It also is a shame of Shayra not be tact of if you take it away.
• 4:02
  If someone takes it away, all right, it's a motor nation even
• 4:05
  asks by who I never because it's not the tree.
• 4:08
  It's just they made the tree connected to the it's like no or
• 4:12
  whatever. So then once it's gone, then
• 4:14
  it's the tree is butter Bahana. In the previous case we got
• 4:21
  included the the shame and the name talking about the the tree
• 4:25
  that was the. Part that was cut off.
• 4:27
  Or they're they're they're carving the remaining.
• 4:33
  No, the the cases, they trimmed it.
• 4:36
  Well, yeah, they they trimmed it and to worship it, I mean they
• 4:39
  did something to it. They made a fancy shave comes.
• 4:43
  By and now shuns it or shapes it or does whatever for the purpose
• 4:47
  it's specific. It's a worship.
• 4:48
  It's a worship. Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
• 4:54
  Zion, Abubisha, Carca. Ola ain't on that.
• 4:56
  Sorry. A person can bow down to the
• 4:58
  Carca. It doesn't become ulcer, even
• 5:00
  ulcer. Bomisa.
• 5:01
  If they did some sort of mice do.
• 5:02
  We could go Schroffer Barbaros. They make caves or things for
• 5:08
  for Zara or let's say they they they carved, they took a, you
• 5:12
  know, and made a mound and made a lot of it.
• 5:14
  Whatever it is Lily Nessar, that ground becomes ulcer.
• 5:19
  It's just like in the Hoshi Mishpa.
• 5:20
  It says that there's though, you know that someone who show me on
• 5:24
  Karka says, OK, that you know, or there's also thing in the
• 5:27
  magic Karka. But the but the holds Rahman
• 5:31
  right here. But the Rahman says a person,
• 5:33
  you know, it digs, you know, big holes and and things and
• 5:37
  whatever. Then then it would be then then
• 5:42
  it would he would it is called being mazik.
• 5:44
  So there is such a thing as as as being Mazik can be such a
• 5:48
  thing as being Mazik Carka, as as doing something to the ground
• 5:51
  which will make it, which will change it from, you know, from
• 5:55
  cargo's regular Carka. Ever and ever in that place.
• 6:03
  You see, I don't, I mean ever. I mean, I don't know if you
• 6:05
  know, you did it. I mean at some point if you, if
• 6:07
  there's the equals to it, you know, but you know, if you know
• 6:11
  you did it, then Lahore, Yeah, Lahore, that would be, I'm not,
• 6:15
  I'm not mayor for sure. You have to, you have to look
• 6:19
  into it a little bit more about whether this is a Durbana.
• 6:21
  Der Isa, the Jews only by Der Isa, Lahore, This is, this might
• 6:24
  be Durbana. I'm not sure.
• 6:25
  This might only be Durbana. So then I don't know.
• 6:30
  Well, you have to look into it and open the slig I think has
• 6:34
  Balikhayim in on there. Sorry, Balikhayim can't become
• 6:37
  ulcer. Shafili stach with the behemoths
• 6:39
  are low. Even if someone bounced to his
• 6:41
  own animal low Nasra, it doesn't become it doesn't become ulcer.
• 6:46
  So, for example, in the in India, you know they have they
• 6:51
  they're mohabbid the cows. The truth is they don't really
• 6:53
  bow to they just they rehabid them because they're being
• 6:56
  carnated. They let them walk through the
• 6:58
  building room, whatever it is, they can write their they're.
• 7:04
  Not their. Gestures right, right, But
• 7:06
  they're not. But they don't not over the
• 7:07
  cows. They're just mohabbid them
• 7:10
  right, That's it, right. Also, will they consider holy
• 7:15
  because they're a reincarnation of whatever or or they're not?
• 7:23
  They're not. They're not physically.
• 7:26
  Worship, Worship animals. Are not bowed to they're.
• 7:29
  Not there's no right, it's not like a mitzvah they worship the
• 7:34
  it's not it's not to say it's not the same thing.
• 7:38
  However, even still doesn't mean that animals become awesome,
• 7:41
  even if it was never I'm just I'm saying you should know but
• 7:44
  but there's information. But let's say right if it's
• 7:48
  right, the mystery would bow down to his to his sheep.
• 7:52
  So it still doesn't come also also, but my Sir, but he did a
• 7:55
  my Sir. She shocked early Lily and he
• 7:57
  took his animal and he shafted it to Lily.
• 7:59
  I feel Simon echoed. Even if he just caught a little
• 8:02
  bit to kill it the Nasr it does become ulcer a few in a Shaloy,
• 8:07
  even if it's not his animal, but has an ability to ask us
• 8:14
  something which is not his terrace of Odessaro about Israel
• 8:19
  ain't no it's there. He can't ask us something of his
• 8:24
  friends Shavada Eno Mahavir El Itzaro.
• 8:28
  It's interesting. Technically, you know, so we say
• 8:30
  we have we have we have here. He does not really mean not
• 8:34
  really worshipping of Odessaro. It's what more it's more likely
• 8:38
  that he's he's trying to he's trying to get back, you know,
• 8:41
  trying to get his friend, you know, and he had to go ahead and
• 8:44
  to do the Verizar or not. He's showing me Shafilo in
• 8:47
  Geshlak. But even if he has a shot, if
• 8:50
  he's in an oyster, can't answer it because it's it's only a shot
• 8:54
  for us. If you sell Mumaru, whether he's
• 8:56
  sell Mumura as I'm assume it to a voter, Zara not talking about
• 9:00
  these. He's a murmur to a voter, Zara
• 9:03
  or he's, you know, not talking about these a murmur to to go to
• 9:08
  Burger King or something. Oh, he's Rubo or or they they
• 9:13
  they gave a Hasrah of Akib al Astra.
• 9:15
  I mean, he's high visa and he's Bakabala Hasrah.
• 9:18
  I raised Alyssa. Then he does ask her because we
• 9:20
  see clearly that he intends to he intends to to to to actually
• 9:27
  worship all the sorrow right to cover is Balikhayam Shamsham
• 9:33
  there. Sorry, the greatest Balikhayam
• 9:36
  and their Shamshim are become though they they do they do
• 9:41
  become. Also, you can ask someone else's
• 9:42
  thing by taking it and putting it on.
• 9:44
  What is our that you can that that they can do they?
• 9:50
  Give it a a promise to the Balkai, or the he brings a live
• 9:55
  sheep. To the to the water Zara right.
• 9:57
  If that's the Derrick Havoto, Nikki is there a Havoto is to
• 10:00
  bring the sheep out to chef de, but to bring the sheep in front
• 10:03
  of it. And I don't do whatever, do
• 10:04
  whatever that we call Tacritus that we even said before that if
• 10:09
  he checked it, then you know, definitely.
• 10:11
  But So what? That if you put it in the
• 10:16
  Takravit? No, I don't.
• 10:18
  I don't think there's a focus. I think it all I think is that
• 10:21
  the remote was just pointing this.
• 10:22
  Just adding. I don't think it is.
• 10:28
  Oh, you're saying Takrovit? Maybe maybe you're right.
• 10:29
  Takrovit. You're right.
• 10:31
  You're right. You're right.
• 10:32
  You're right. Right.
• 10:33
  Right. Yeah, you're right.
• 10:35
  I misunderstood for a second, right?
• 10:38
  So if you brought a Takrovis to Balkhai right then then even if
• 10:42
  the animal itself there becomes ulcer but the Takrovis or they
• 10:45
  decorated the animal, then they would become the ulcer.
• 10:49
  Tess Alphabisha Balikhayan Inanes.
• 10:51
  Sorry. Even though Balikhayan don't
• 10:53
  become ulcer, even Hichlif Balikhayan Belilim if they were
• 10:57
  Makhlif, they did the Philippian about the time for a leader.
• 11:02
  The guy had a cat, had a sheep and he's OK.
• 11:04
  Listen, I want to buy this Eliot.
• 11:05
  I want to buy you the statue. It was Machlifit for the statue
• 11:10
  Nasru of a Khalifa Khalifin. But if they if he if he went
• 11:16
  ahead and he traded the statue of he traded his car for
• 11:21
  Navodozara, right? Then he traded his car for a
• 11:24
  donkey, right? Or camel.
• 11:27
  Yeah, so, so then Khalipi Khalipi, but Khalifi over
• 11:33
  Allelui because it says because the possible says possible says
• 11:41
  who, who, who. But we part of the icing on
• 11:50
  bizarre. So we don't make the drosha and
• 11:54
  it's and and it's and and it's chalipin the the the and all the
• 12:01
  chalipin just like Shmita. And therefore it would stay.
• 12:06
  It would stay also, obviously it's a shadow there, Isa.
• 12:08
  There's what's and well, the grass says how good for this VH
• 12:14
  ice cream says into the Mahogius and it's the racer.
• 12:17
  It should be Mahmir, you know, but I guess you know, it's
• 12:20
  always clown in the Mahabir. Is is Stan VH you go after the
• 12:26
  you go after the you know, you have to.
• 12:30
  I think you go after Stan, but you can be Mahmir with the age.
• 12:37
  Oh, you know what? Maybe I'm confused.
• 12:38
  I'll leave that. All right.
• 12:39
  Kuf Ben vav Allelim Shalovic hovim Shabitla.
• 12:43
  If you have, if you have Allelim of a glory that he was Mavato
• 12:50
  Shabit Lovik hovim with terrorists and that that, that,
• 12:54
  that, that that peso becomes motor.
• 12:58
  You swell any Lovato Lilium Shabvik hovim.
• 13:01
  You swell cat Mavato, literally of of a guy kosher can't show
• 13:05
  you sell kosher can't he sells. She ain't no bit of Alamis.
• 13:09
  The other you sell can't come and say.
• 13:10
  Oh, you know it's bottle, but feeling issue of and even if the
• 13:16
  guy has a sutras in it aim bit of smell right.
• 13:22
  It doesn't help for the so therefore it doesn't become
• 13:25
  bottle. You know we'll see how later on
• 13:27
  how you move out to it. I'll just.
• 13:34
  I you know, I don't remember that was said before.
• 13:39
  I don't remember the top of my head.
• 13:43
  I think it's I think it I think it's only the Obama, but I'm not
• 13:45
  sure the the question will be and we'll see as we go along how
• 13:50
  you move out to it. But I'll leave the question up
• 13:53
  in the air for now. Is, you know, they do
• 13:55
  archaeological digs and they find sullen, right?
• 13:58
  So and you want to display them in a museum is can you get Hana
• 14:03
  from displaying them in a museum?
• 14:05
  Is that getting Hana from the Votozara or, or do you say these
• 14:08
  Votozara's rebuttal because everyone who worshipped them
• 14:11
  died. So, you know, or even Israel.
• 14:15
  I mean, if they let's say an archaeologist here finds a I'm
• 14:19
  sure they found Salim and they said, yeah, there was this is
• 14:23
  Matim, the pestle of of, of Yusra with that.
• 14:27
  Listen, it's old. It's only a Hashva.
• 14:31
  So you know, but Al Kapani, would that would that be also or
• 14:34
  not? Or you'd say it since since, you
• 14:36
  know, it says he sells also a long list.
• 14:38
  So if if the whole generation died in the generations of 2000
• 14:42
  years ago, was that called bottle?
• 14:45
  We'll we'll go through we'll see.
• 14:46
  But leaving the question up in the air for now, Bae's I feel a
• 14:51
  little even a Lilium of a goy which came to the hands of
• 14:56
  Yisrael with Zakhaba and he did a Kenyan on it or the Shah said
• 15:02
  a shot in the back and said the Shah was the Bach who says even
• 15:06
  if he it's a Mitzia and he or he was even he was gazel it, you
• 15:11
  know, like that's a like Rachel Lumenu shuve a la Bittel.
• 15:17
  These these things won't have bits of honey Mili Aleli Ansman.
• 15:20
  That's what they took the actual allelium of all the Shamshae
• 15:23
  allelium, but any of the Mashamshae, but Noya in Boli.
• 15:28
  I do sell the Africa bitla OV Kovim.
• 15:31
  You still kept the vato these Mashamsha and they also don't
• 15:35
  know. But if a if a guy was a vato
• 15:37
  that Eliel, then those become mutter mutarin and those noy
• 15:43
  become those decorations become mutter.
• 15:47
  OK, someone goes to you know, he he buys a container, right, They
• 15:56
  sell happens. You know what happens that
• 15:58
  there, you know there are containers, which some reason
• 16:01
  they leave by the leave by the port.
• 16:03
  No one, no one claims them. And so the people make a
• 16:06
  business out of it to resell, to resell.
• 16:09
  You know, whether they don't, they don't open the container.
• 16:11
  You buy a steel container and whatever's in it and they all
• 16:13
  they get. So you buy a steel Kutosa, pure
• 16:16
  Shuvikli mattress. This is talking about you buy
• 16:18
  junk, you know, let's say, let's say it's something like that,
• 16:21
  right? You know the Kahovim, the Mozza
• 16:23
  by Emililian, right? You got it from the Far East.
• 16:25
  Probably you found a bunch of Ilian inside of it.
• 16:29
  I am not some Moss. If he paid, if he paid for give
• 16:32
  money, but he didn't take it. He didn't moisture it.
• 16:36
  There was a din generally in the kosher Mishpa does is most
• 16:41
  corners or not so most corners pass in Dereisa money is kind of
• 16:45
  by Natal to them that if you give money that it's kind of
• 16:48
  However, the Khan said that that you need Mashika also because
• 16:53
  maybe the you know, maybe the thing or the money whatever in
• 16:57
  the meantime will get perked up and someone's going to lose.
• 16:59
  So whenever they they said that mouse Adam corners so over here
• 17:05
  in Nazar malls below Masha and he didn't go and he even though
• 17:09
  we say mouse corners by goy, but in this case, in this case,
• 17:14
  we're going to say he needs Mashika as well.
• 17:18
  Then he could just return them to to the goy in Masha.
• 17:23
  Let's say he was Masha. He told he said you don't know
• 17:29
  if he's I don't know if it's I don't know it's you know, it
• 17:36
  could be you don't know he's going to worship.
• 17:37
  It's not his or maybe he bought brutals, meaning it wasn't this
• 17:41
  guy. This guy was selling brutal.
• 17:43
  He didn't even know it was there.
• 17:45
  All right, So therefore he's not he's not worshipping it.
• 17:49
  The painting Masha Wellnessa mouse over his motion.
• 17:51
  I didn't you know, that's also the shock says it's also a
• 17:55
  Kenyan by by going it's and again, the Hershey Masha Masha
• 17:59
  and he didn't give the money. They set a price.
• 18:02
  We didn't pay him yet. Alphabetia Mashika, the
• 18:06
  Ovikhovin Kleene Kameka. Even though we say that Mashiko
• 18:11
  I go, I go is cleaner by a Mecca, let's call him.
• 18:18
  And we say that he never actually made a Kenyan on on
• 18:23
  these, on these Avodah Zaras that the way it works is the
• 18:29
  Kingdom was never hot. That wasn't that wasn't the
• 18:30
  intention. And therefore he never actually
• 18:33
  bought it. So, so therefore, it's therefore
• 18:38
  it's it's much to give it back to him.
• 18:41
  Nos and Mos 'cause there's another problem over here that
• 18:45
  if you give it back to him, it looks like you're and he gives,
• 18:47
  gives you back to him the money or things like that.
• 18:50
  Well, let's see Nos and Mos Well, Basha, if he paid him and
• 18:54
  he was my chef, then you so you have to throw the throw the
• 18:57
  allelium into the into into Yamamela or to any you mobbed
• 19:02
  them, so you destroy them. So because the point over here
• 19:07
  is really more Remaris iron that if you gave that, if you gave
• 19:11
  the money and then he he says, hey, it's about close and give
• 19:14
  me back, you know, give it, give me back my money.
• 19:16
  So it looks like he's selling of Ozara.
• 19:19
  So it's a so it's a it's a it's a Marisayan that that people
• 19:23
  think that he's he's he's selling, he's selling of Ozara.
• 19:28
  You know, the the gross, the gross seems to be mash.
• 19:30
  But he is understanding. He says it's the kind of the
• 19:32
  kind and and it's the, the, the, that the, that you can't just
• 19:38
  you know, it's, it's a you know, a lot of that it's it is a
• 19:44
  Kenyan. Most most is a Kenyan.
• 19:46
  So therefore, why do you mean Mashika?
• 19:48
  He says he doesn't exhaustion Aram bomb.
• 19:50
  He doesn't understand it. So he he says even if you just
• 19:53
  even if you just give money, the heart should be you should have
• 19:56
  the same problem, even the same necotos to give it back.
• 20:00
  But I hope on him. I mean, it's not so common, but
• 20:05
  if that would happen then then you could go ahead and try to
• 20:08
  get your money back for that Dalid Gare.
• 20:11
  So either Kukhovi and Shiarshu Saviya Megar, I know the Kukhovi
• 20:15
  who were Yorish. It's a din that Megar is
• 20:18
  Yorish's father. Sheva talks to the Surah, right?
• 20:21
  Maybe because maybe they'll go back to maybe they'll, they'll,
• 20:24
  they'll, they're going to go back to the way they were.
• 20:26
  If they don't get their minds, say they the father, their
• 20:28
  father's like a businessman, like a billionaire or president
• 20:31
  or something like that. And they want to be Yorish.
• 20:33
  So, you know, if they're not Yorish, their father, you know,
• 20:35
  maybe they'll just forget Yiddish guy.
• 20:37
  And that's the problem. So yeah, yeah, you can tell.
• 20:51
  They can tell the brother. OK, listen, you take the the
• 20:58
  most about the Shabbat, Ali. And there she was like, yeah,
• 21:00
  ulcer. He can mesalik.
• 21:02
  There's each grayer with the rebano.
• 21:03
  So therefore he can move over what he's getting.
• 21:06
  But once he gets it, then already it's in his for sure
• 21:09
  Zakahabad. He can't then then you know,
• 21:12
  because the Usha's only durabana.
• 21:13
  And so you can you can do brayer on it, but once he gets it, he
• 21:16
  can't get rid of it. Hey, Ovikahovim ovate Leela
• 21:22
  shaloh. Ovahovim can move out the Lily.
• 21:25
  And even if it's not his, I feel you know, or even though he
• 21:29
  doesn't not or even this, this, this a little I feel about
• 21:32
  Carco, even if the self forces him to do it.
• 21:36
  Vivaji other but TV Lily, he he has to know about Avozar.
• 21:41
  A guy doesn't you know, he has you know, he has some guy in the
• 21:44
  street. There's no anything about it.
• 21:45
  But if you you know, if you have some guy from Africa or I don't
• 21:49
  know where Indonesia, I don't know whatever it is, wherever
• 21:52
  he's born out of whatever it is. And they know about the leading,
• 21:54
  they can move out to it of a Cotton Cheney or they have a TV.
• 21:57
  But like Cotton doesn't really understand, doesn't know.
• 22:00
  How about the you know, Verazara?
• 22:03
  So he can't McCain, Shaita. Someone is a shape someone is
• 22:07
  not. He's an atheist.
• 22:09
  He doesn't work. Yeah.
• 22:10
  Oh, yeah, I wasn't worship at Lily because get toy shop.
• 22:13
  Or is it And you're calling Novato even though they're
• 22:16
  going. They can't Novato because they
• 22:18
  have to. They have to understand the idea
• 22:21
  of creating a deity and then to Novato that deity Ishmaelim
• 22:26
  Shanam of the of the any of of Novato.
• 22:29
  You want to take a you know, you want to ask an Arab to go ahead
• 22:33
  and you know off and around here you call one says of Shabbos
• 22:36
  goy. So you want to bring it of Azar
• 22:38
  goy. He can't be Mavato because he
• 22:40
  doesn't worship of Azar. He doesn't know anything about
• 22:44
  it. The pistol tuber says who had in
• 22:47
  who had in that he's throw that he saw a mummer.
• 22:56
  It could be he can't. We said before he can answer it
• 23:00
  that whether he can maybe it could be he can.
• 23:07
  It's just like he can answer it could be he can he can move out
• 23:09
  also, but it's a bit it's a bit unclear.
• 23:12
  Stop and have a question. Samaya and Jason will be back
• 23:17
  and give share on something.