Latest / Her Life: Women, identity, culture & modern life / Why I Stopped Watching Myself: The Cost of Media Mirrors | Her Life
Transcript
- You’re standing in line for coffee, staring at the back of someone’s head, and suddenly you realize you don’t actually know who they are. Or worse—you’re terrified that they see right through the version of yourself you’ve carefully constructed for this exact moment. I had a moment last Tuesday that I haven’t been able to shake since. I was waiting for the subway during rush hour, that specific kind of chaotic silence where everyone is packed shoulder-to-shoulder but no one makes eye contact. We’re all just… present. But performative. I looked around at the faces pressed against the glass doors, these strangers carrying their entire lives in their backpacks and tote bags, and I felt this sudden, sharp ache of recognition. We are all acting. Not in a malicious way, not like we’re trying to trick anyone, but because the city demands it. It asks us to be polished, efficient, unbothered versions of ourselves. If you stumble, if you cry, if you look lost, you break the social contract. So we smooth out our edges. We curate our expressions. And I found myself wondering: how much energy does it take to hold that mask up for twelve hours a day? Because here’s what I’m noticing lately—that exhaustion isn’t just physical. It’s spiritual. It’s the weight of constantly managing an impression rather than just living a life. Let’s sit with that for a second. There is this invisible curriculum that every woman learns when she moves to a western city. It’s not written down anywhere. You don’t get a syllabus on day one. But somehow, within six months, you know the rules. You know which neighborhoods signal success and which ones signal danger. You know how to walk fast enough to command respect but slow enough to appear approachable. You learn the subtle art of the ‘busy’ nod, the way to decline an invitation without offending, the precise amount of vulnerability required to make a new friend without scaring them off. It’s a complex dance, and we’re all learning it simultaneously, often by watching others and mimicking their steps. I remember my first year here, feeling like I was failing a test I didn’t study for. I wore the wrong shoes. I laughed too loud at the wrong jokes. I tried too hard to fit into a mold that seemed to shift every time I blinked. And I think that’s the hardest part—the realization that there is no fixed shape. The expectation is fluid, moving, always just out of reach. We tell ourselves stories about independence. We say things like, ‘I’m so free here,’ or ‘No one knows my past.’ And there is truth to that. The anonymity of the city can be a gift. It allows us to reinvent ourselves, to shed skins we grew tired of wearing. But I wonder if we also use that freedom as a shield. Because being alone in a crowd is a unique kind of loneliness. In a small town, your missteps are known, but so is your history. People remember who you were before the breakup, before the job loss, before the identity crisis. Here, you can disappear. And while that sounds liberating, it can also feel terrifyingly empty. You start to wonder if anyone would notice if you stopped performing. If you stopped smiling, stopped rushing, started crying in public—would anyone care? Or would they just step around you, maintaining the delicate balance of non-involvement? I’ve caught myself holding back tears in elevators because I didn’t want to inconvenience the person standing next to me. That’s the cost of this autonomy. We gain space, but we lose witness. And then there’s the digital layer. Because let’s be honest, the performance doesn’t stop when we leave the office or enter our apartments. It follows us home, glowing on our screens. We scroll through feeds of women who seem to have mastered the city game. They’re working from cafes that look like museums, eating meals that look like art, laughing with friends whose faces are always turned toward the light. It creates a standard of ease that feels impossible to meet. We compare our behind-the-scenes chaos with their highlight reels. And slowly, unconsciously, we start editing our own lives to match that aesthetic. We buy the plant even though we kill everything. We go to the gallery opening even though we hate modern art. We pretend to love the commute because it looks good in captions. It’s a feedback loop of aspiration and inadequacy. We’re trying to live up to an image that was never real to begin with. And the tragedy is, we’re so busy curating the appearance of having it together that we forget to actually enjoy the messy, unphotogenic reality of being alive. But here’s the thing about facades—they crack. And usually, they crack when we least expect it. For me, it happened when I dropped my groceries in the rain. Just a simple mistake. A plastic bag tore, apples rolled into a puddle, and I stood there, soaked and flustered, while people walked past. In that moment, I could have kept walking, kept the mask on. Or I could have laughed. So I laughed. A loud, ugly, hysterical laugh that made the woman next to me stop and stare. And instead of judging me, she smiled. She said, ‘I hope those apples are okay.’ And in that tiny interaction, the script broke. We weren’t two strangers performing politeness anymore. We were two humans sharing a moment of shared absurdity. It was small, but it felt huge. It reminded me that beneath the curated layers, beneath the expectations of efficiency and grace, we’re all just trying to keep our apples dry. We’re all vulnerable. We’re all figuring it out. And maybe, just maybe, letting the facade slip is the only way to find connection. So, what do we do with this? How do we navigate a world that demands perfection while honoring our need for authenticity? I think it starts with giving ourselves permission to be unpolished. To admit when we’re tired. To wear the comfortable shoes. To skip the event that drains us. To say no without offering an excuse. It’s a radical act in a culture that equates busyness with worth and visibility with value. I’ve started experimenting with small rebellions. I leave my phone at home sometimes, just to see how it feels to be unreachable. I talk to neighbors I’ve ignored for years. I admit when I don’t understand something. And with each small act of honesty, the weight lifts. Just a little. I’m not saying we should abandon all social norms or become antisocial hermits. But we can choose where to invest our performance. We can decide that our inner lives matter more than our outer impressions. We can choose to be real, even if it’s awkward. Even if it’s inconvenient. Especially if it’s inconvenient. Because that’s where the beauty lives. Not in the highlight reel, but in the raw, unedited footage of a life actually being lived. Thank you for listening, for showing up, for being exactly who you are. Until next time, take care of yourself. And remember, it’s okay to drop the apples. I’m Ciara Stewart, and this has been Her Life.