Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E034: Building Better On-Ramps in MENA with Talal Tabbaa
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:09Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:12management platform built on multi institution custody,
- 0:16leveraging our partnerships with industry veterans, Bit Go and
- 0:19Coin Cover on ramps. Multi Institution Custody is a
- 0:23segregated vault requiring two of three institutions at any
- 0:26point in time to sign once a client's unique permissions have
- 0:30been met. Our industry leading best in
- 0:32class approach to custody helps individuals and institutions
- 0:36secure new and existing Bitcoin positions.
- 0:39All keys are held in deep cold storage and kept 100% offline.
- 0:44Managed with institutional grade security best practices.
- 0:48The custody solution eliminates single points of failure and
- 0:52reduces counterparty risks. Ensuring maximum security and
- 0:55Peace of Mind on Ramp's suite of products includes our custody
- 0:59offering, a spot Bitcoin fund, private wealth services and
- 1:02inheritance planning, and managed wealth for advisors.
- 1:05Whether you're new to Bitcoin or a veteran in the space, we would
- 1:09love to connect with you. To understand your needs and how
- 1:11we can serve you, please visit our website at on
- 1:14rampbitcoin.com where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:17connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:22music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:25the biggest bag of odorous extra ever assembled in the history of
- 1:30darkness, 1974198792972000. And whatever we want to call
- 1:38this. It's all just the same thing
- 1:39over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:43I say when we sell, hey, I say when we sell.
- 1:52And we're live back to lash tray down a man this week our our Co
- 1:58host Jesse Myers is making a high time preference decision,
- 2:01closing on a house this morning. Wow, wow.
- 2:04Just throwing it all out there. You got to get it out there.
- 2:08I was going to. I was going to say something
- 2:10else about it being cold and him coming from California and this
- 2:14this cold weather might have kept him in the under the covers
- 2:17this early, but you just you just threw it all out there I
- 2:19guess. I guess it's live.
- 2:22Jesse will be back next week. We're happy for Jesse.
- 2:24Congrats Jesse, But we're here with Talal Tabaa, CEO of Coin
- 2:30Mana. Very excited for this
- 2:31conversation. I'm not gonna lie, gentlemen,
- 2:34I'm not gonna lie Talal. I've been in Bitcoin for 10
- 2:36years and my understanding of what's going on in the Middle
- 2:44East and Northern Africa with Bitcoin is lacking outside of
- 2:48some brief conversations with people and what you see in the
- 2:51news with countries getting into mining.
- 2:53Obviously Dubai, Abu Dhabi, big sort of parts of the world where
- 3:00bitcoiners are flocking to, but it's a part of the world, part
- 3:05of the Bitcoin community, if you will.
- 3:07I don't have a lot of exposure to it, so I'm really excited to
- 3:10sit down, speak with you, get your perspective, learn more
- 3:14about what's going on in your part of the world.
- 3:17But before we do that, how did you find Coin Mana?
- 3:21Why did you found it? And what is the experience been
- 3:25like for you as a as a Bitcoin or building a company in the
- 3:28Middle East? Beautiful.
- 3:30So first of all, I didn't found Coin Mana, my partner did and I
- 3:37joined as I'm a Co founder of the company, I'm CEO and yeah
- 3:42basically running the company but it wasn't my idea and I
- 3:44didn't really come up with with with the branding, the concept,
- 3:49et cetera. So we're three founders of the
- 3:51company, myself, Dina and Yazan. Dina used to run Bit Oasis, she
- 3:57was Head of Operations or Director of Operations at Bit
- 4:00Oasis, which is the oldest exchange in the Middle East.
- 4:03I think it kicked off in maybe 20/14/2015.
- 4:07I used to be a furious customer of theirs.
- 4:09I really used to be a very angry customer of theirs.
- 4:11And that's when I started realizing, all right, maybe the
- 4:14Middle East does need a more reliable exchange.
- 4:18And yeah, basically how I knew about Coin Mina is I got an
- 4:23e-mail saying welcome to, like, you know, log in to
- 4:28talat@coinmina.com. And that's basically my partner
- 4:32Yezen had sent out. I created basically the book the
- 4:37domain, set up the Gmail, and then sent me an invite to my
- 4:41e-mail. And that's how I knew about Coin
- 4:44me. Then that was around during
- 4:46COVID, probably first couple of weeks in COVID, like in 2020.
- 4:51And I told him all right, sure, I'm down to build an exchange.
- 4:53All of the ones in the Middle East are very underwhelming and
- 4:56I've personally suffered from this issue.
- 4:59I think it's a bit cliche, as you know, when they say like
- 5:01you're most suited to solving the problems that you've
- 5:04suffered yourself. I've suffered from the lack of
- 5:09quality service from other Middle Eastern exchanges and we
- 5:12set out to set up the best one. And my first request or demand
- 5:19was that I'd only do it if we are regulated by one of the top
- 5:23regulatory bodies. So we'll obviously today walk
- 5:26you through the different regulatory systems that you have
- 5:31in the Middle East and there's quite a few.
- 5:35But yeah, to answer your question directly, Cohemina
- 5:39wasn't necessarily my idea. But yeah, I've been working on
- 5:42it since 2021 and we've now become the largest local
- 5:48exchange in in in the region. Obviously your finances, your
- 5:52Okx's etcetera, they still have quite a bit of volume.
- 5:56But hopefully by the end of the year we believe we should be the
- 5:59number one player in in in the Middle East.
- 6:06So you mentioned Bit Oasis, the exchange landscape was not up to
- 6:11snuff for you particularly. What are you guys trying to
- 6:15improve on at Queen? Queen Mina specifically?
- 6:19Yeah. So if you ask me, I don't
- 6:23necessarily think that on ramp and off ramp is necessarily the
- 6:26sexiest use case of Bitcoin or crypto in general.
- 6:29However, it is the Trojan horse for launching all the different
- 6:34on chain services and on chain experiences that that I think is
- 6:39revolutionary. So it's impossible to do
- 6:42anything on chain if you don't have a reliable on ramp and off
- 6:45ramp. So I guess going Nina today
- 6:48offers customers the ability to deposit Fiat and buy crypto or
- 6:54deposit crypto and withdraw Fiat.
- 6:56And essentially we, the main differentiating factor between
- 7:00Coin MENA and other regional players is that we are reliable
- 7:05in terms of your ability to always be able to deposit money
- 7:08to Coin MENA and withdraw money from Coin MENA.
- 7:11And the reason why we're able to do that is from day zero we knew
- 7:15that the activity that we're doing requires massive reliance
- 7:19on the banks and we basically set up a fully regulated entity
- 7:24that complies with all the regulations.
- 7:27So basically not your keys, not your coins applies a lot.
- 7:32Now we're a centralized custodial service provider
- 7:36that's regulated by the central bank.
- 7:37So that's why we're able to have reliable on ramps and off ramps.
- 7:44And yeah, basically the user experience at Coinmina is
- 7:47significantly better than what it is at other regional players.
- 7:51And if I'm completely honest, the market is big enough for
- 7:56multiple big players and and and the reason for that is in the
- 8:00Middle East you have a very high GDP per capita.
- 8:03If you look at Upper Saudi, UAE, Kuwait, Roman, these countries
- 8:07all have very high GDP per capita.
- 8:09They also have a very young population with near full
- 8:13smartphone penetration. Yet you have some of the worst
- 8:16banking services in the world. Like if you compare how poor
- 8:20banks are in the Middle East versus Europe, China, the US,
- 8:25it's absolutely insane. So people are really
- 8:28incentivized, really incentivized to to to adopt
- 8:34crypto. Since we launched Coin Mina
- 8:38we've realized that the biggest use case today and as as a
- 8:44passionate bitcoiner it it sometimes pisses me off.
- 8:48But I guess I can understand why the retail and mass population
- 8:52want it, but it's USDT. Like for example in countries
- 8:56like Egypt, Lebanon, Pakistan where the local currency is
- 9:01literally collapsing, clients or customers want a reliable way to
- 9:07store USD. Like it's it's it's it's
- 9:09interesting how problems are relative.
- 9:11If you're sitting in the US, you're worried about your USD
- 9:15losing value and therefore you want to move to Bitcoin so that
- 9:18you can protect your purchasing power.
- 9:20Someone in Egypt, their local currency has dropped from maybe
- 9:2524 Egyptian pounds to $1.00 to maybe 40.
- 9:28So this is like in the past year or so.
- 9:31So purchasing power literally almost cut by half and customers
- 9:36want USDT because their cost structure is in USDT and they
- 9:40don't have the sophistication of hedging or so yeah, I guess the
- 9:45main take away from launching and operating coin Mina is that
- 9:49USDT is by far the most popular asset for emerging markets.
- 9:56And I think that's also related to the shortage of traditional
- 10:01U.S. dollars like normal U.S. dollars in in in in those
- 10:04markets. So I guess that that to me was a
- 10:07very interesting phenomena and it's actually solving a real
- 10:13world problem because if you are sitting in Egypt and you want to
- 10:17send $100,000 to China or the US or to Paris, it's not easy.
- 10:23It's really difficult to do so and you'd need to go through so
- 10:27many hoops and and you might or might not be able to do it.
- 10:30Whereas if you have USDT you can send it wherever you want and
- 10:36yeah I guess you wouldn't be part of the traditional
- 10:40financial system. So that's that's an area that I
- 10:43personally found to be very interesting like alternative
- 10:47rails. And to my surprise some
- 10:49customers don't even properly know what crypto is.
- 10:52They think of USDT as like a digital dollar.
- 10:56Yeah, it's good, it's good to get people using crypto, but
- 10:59hopefully people start realizing the importance of of Bitcoin as
- 11:03a way to preserve wealth. But in this case, people are
- 11:07using it for cross-border payments and not necessarily for
- 11:10savings. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense
- 11:13to law. I'd be curious and interested
- 11:16in. My understanding is in Bahrain
- 11:19initially you guys got the the license with the Central bank
- 11:23and and started but as you as the past few years you've
- 11:27expanded into other entities or other countries and curious how
- 11:31you thought about that expansion.
- 11:32But then also you you mentioned something early on about the
- 11:37regulatory bodies being very important if you were going to
- 11:40participate and a lot of people thinks it's the the Wild West
- 11:43and crypto and specifically in that region where it's my
- 11:45understanding it's completely opposite as far as getting the
- 11:47borrow licenses and actually getting the rails and things in
- 11:50place. I would love to hear kind of
- 11:52like how you thought about the, you know initial place where you
- 11:55domiciled in the in the regulatory bodies, but then
- 11:58going into Dubai and other industry or other regions, how
- 12:01you think about that? Yeah.
- 12:03So I guess I'll tell you a bit about what Koimina's thought
- 12:07process was and then I'll expand to the other regulators.
- 12:11So when we thought of Koimina in 2020 or 2021 as an on rampant
- 12:16off ramp, my single biggest reliance is on the banks.
- 12:20So if I'm going to be relying on the banks, I need to be
- 12:23regulated by the same body that regulates the banks so that they
- 12:25don't look down at my license. If we had obtained a license
- 12:30from like the equivalent of the SEC which is the security and
- 12:35commodity authority in Dubey for example, the banks would have
- 12:37easily said, hey listen this is not our regulator, we can't
- 12:41really touch this. So we initially set out to be
- 12:44licensed by the Central Bank of Bahrain and that proved to be a
- 12:46very smart decision because it allowed us to open all of these
- 12:49banking channels and the central Bank of Bahrain is a very
- 12:54reputable regulator. So by them having crypto it
- 12:58helped us massively in in in in being able to open bank accounts
- 13:03and and start kick get the ball rolling.
- 13:05So if you think of like the Middle East you have the Gulf
- 13:09cooperative countries with the GCC.
- 13:11The biggest market by far is Saudi Arabia.
- 13:14Saudi Arabia doesn't have crypto regulations yet.
- 13:17It's not legal and it's not legal.
- 13:19So they haven't regulated but they also haven't banned it.
- 13:23So people in Saudi Arabia mostly buy crypto from overseas
- 13:27exchanges like coin Mina or they use P2P markets.
- 13:30So Saudi is still a very untapped massive market and I
- 13:35guess I'll go from size of market and and and potential.
- 13:41And then in my opinion UAE is obviously the the financial
- 13:47center of the Middle East. So if you think of what are the
- 13:51global financial centers, obviously the first thing that
- 13:53comes to mind is New York, London comes to mind, Singapore,
- 13:57Hong Kong, Tokyo and now Dubey is also what the, the financial
- 14:03center of the Middle East. So for us we knew that we wanted
- 14:06to be regulated in Dubai. I personally live in Dubai, very
- 14:11big fan of the city. I think they move at a different
- 14:14pace from everyone else. Insanely visionary leadership
- 14:18and ability of execution is absolutely insane.
- 14:21Like I first moved to Dubai in 2012 and I can't explain how
- 14:26different the country is and they dream big.
- 14:30Like usually if you're the size of a city, you don't dream that
- 14:33big. But in Dubai, they always dream
- 14:36big. And I guess the regulator that
- 14:38they set up, which is literally called Vara, the Virtual Asset
- 14:41Regulatory Authority, only regulates crypto.
- 14:44They only regulate virtual assets.
- 14:46So let me take a step back. I talked about Saudi.
- 14:49There's no regulations in Saudi yet.
- 14:51But in the United Arab Emirates, you have the main two cities are
- 14:55Abu Dhabi, the capital, and then Dubai, the financial center.
- 14:58In Abu Dhabi you have ADGM, which is the Abu Dhabi Global
- 15:01Markets. You have a few exchanges set up
- 15:04there. Coinbase recently I believe set
- 15:07up their asset management arm there.
- 15:11You have finance have a custody license that they recently
- 15:15withdrew. So there's there's, there's some
- 15:17activity in ADGMI, personally liked Vara more and that's why
- 15:21we went for the Vara license. And Vara is again the Virtual
- 15:26Asset Regulatory Authority and they're based in Dubai and they
- 15:31specifically regulate virtual assets and they regulate it
- 15:34based on the service that you provide.
- 15:36So whether you're a custodian, broker, exchange, advisor, it
- 15:40doesn't matter what asset you're managing or servicing, they
- 15:44regulate you per your service. And in my opinion, that's a very
- 15:47good way to do it as opposed to what the Swiss tried to do back
- 15:51in the day and like payment token, utility token, security
- 15:54token and everyone tries to disguise their securities as a
- 15:57form of utility. No point doing that.
- 15:59I guess that's what Dubey realized.
- 16:01Then they set up Bora, so Co and Mina were regulated by Bora and
- 16:04the central Bank of Bahrain. You also have the Dubey
- 16:08International Financial Center, which is what where traditional
- 16:12banks historically have been set up.
- 16:14They are recently, they've recently announced their plans
- 16:17to also regulate crypto. So you do feel like there is
- 16:21some sort of healthy competition between the regulators and
- 16:24that's not something that is very common if I'm completely
- 16:27honest. It's great for us because it
- 16:31gives us optionality on where we want to launch specific products
- 16:35out of. But yeah, so to take a step back
- 16:39on the comment of of Dubai being the the wild, Wild West, similar
- 16:45to Crypto, when you have something that's super high
- 16:48growth, you attract the best and you attract the worst because
- 16:52there's lots of opportunities and legit and grifters would
- 16:55both want to take part or they all both want to capitalize on
- 17:00what's there. And as a regulated entity in the
- 17:03United Arab Emirates, it's actually very stringent.
- 17:06So you have to go through a lengthy licensing process.
- 17:10You can go to Vara's registry and you can see which
- 17:13applications and approved and which are pending.
- 17:16And the process takes time. It took us 13 months from start
- 17:19to finish and that involved a central bank approval for our
- 17:23client money account. And obviously there is an
- 17:27unregulated market in the UAE and that's the OTC market that
- 17:31deals with physical cash. But that's a completely
- 17:33different industry in my opinion.
- 17:35So at Coin MENA, we only accept wire transfers, card and crypto
- 17:40deposits. If you enter into the cash
- 17:42business, that's a completely different ball game.
- 17:45And that market is not regulated by Vara, so or regulated by any.
- 17:52But yeah, that's how I guess similar to how P2P markets are
- 17:56operating today in an unlicensed, unlicensed manner.
- 18:02Yeah, I guess also you have Roman, the Sultanate of Roman,
- 18:07which is just South of the United Arab Emirates.
- 18:11They've all launched their crypto regulations, which should
- 18:14be coming into effect this year. And then Qatar, which hosted the
- 18:18World Cup and is also a very ambitious country.
- 18:22They've launched their tokenized, I forgot what they
- 18:26call it, like tokenized digital assets.
- 18:28But in my opinion, it's no such thing as just tokenized
- 18:32financial assets. You need to have your core
- 18:35digital assets for you to be able to do these on chain
- 18:39tokenized assets, and if it's a private blockchain then it's
- 18:44again very different from what we're trying to do at at
- 18:48Coinmina. So I get many things in the
- 18:51digital asset space are brushed with the same brush, even though
- 18:54they're extremely different. Yeah, it's incredible.
- 18:58You must pinch yourself all the time thinking about the amount
- 19:00of opportunity. The one thing to to to share
- 19:05it's like the bet from a a leader is in my opinion will
- 19:09come from the market as we've seen like maybe it's finance and
- 19:12Coinbase historically the past 10 years.
- 19:14But over time as the market matures, you start to work hyper
- 19:16locally, you go to the places you trust, you go with the
- 19:18licenses that you recognize. And so it makes complete sense
- 19:22that other exchanges would have form like yourself and then
- 19:26establish relationships where people are going to be able to
- 19:28go to an office or be able to talk to somebody.
- 19:30We see that here in the US, in Texas, specifically during the
- 19:332021 bull bull market and the miners and folks would call us
- 19:36up. It's like I don't know about
- 19:37doing business with Coinbase. I don't know if I'm sending my
- 19:39dollars out to SF. And so I can imagine there's a
- 19:42similar feel across the world when it comes to finance and
- 19:44banking. Yeah, I mean that's that's SF
- 19:48and Texas where it is significantly less you when
- 19:52significantly easier than what a fragmented market in the Middle
- 19:56East is where you have to get different license in each
- 20:00country. But yeah, again, we believe that
- 20:03the opportunity is more than worth it.
- 20:06And that's why we've gone ahead and gotten those licenses,
- 20:08because we want to compliantly open and operate bank accounts
- 20:13that allow retail institutional corporate customers to deposit
- 20:17their dwindling Fiat in terms of purchasing power and move on to
- 20:22Bitcoin or whatever asset they want to move to.
- 20:29Sorry, I was on mute there because I was sneezing.
- 20:30But you mentioned earlier this is something I really want to
- 20:33dig into is just the overall understanding you.
- 20:37You mentioned that people really don't understand that they like
- 20:39tether because of the stability. Obviously we have countries like
- 20:43Lebanon, Turkey, Pakistan going through crazy hyperinflationary
- 20:48events over the last few years. And then obviously the Middle
- 20:53East is a very energy rich part of the world.
- 20:55You have countries that you mentioned, Oman, creating a
- 20:57regulatory structure. They also made a big investment
- 21:00in a private miner last year. I believe Exahash was the name
- 21:03of that miner. What do you think?
- 21:06How or not what do you think? How I know there may be a
- 21:11relatively lack of a relative lack of whole understanding what
- 21:18Bitcoin is, the potential it provides.
- 21:19But are people starting to wake up to this in your mind, to
- 21:23really understand the opportunity that Bitcoin
- 21:26presents and the opportunity the Middle East specifically has to
- 21:29lead in this new market, in this new industry?
- 21:34Yeah. So I think we need to separate
- 21:36between two types of countries, ones that produce oil and energy
- 21:40and ones that have a failing currency because these usually
- 21:43don't go hand in hand, like Lebanon, Turkey, Egypt.
- 21:48Their GDP doesn't come from selling oil, whereas Kuwait for
- 21:52example, or Roman or Saudi or the United Arab Emirates, a big
- 21:55part of the GDP is from oil exports and that means they are
- 22:00easily able to peg their currency and maintain that peg
- 22:04because they have so much USD reserves.
- 22:07So I would say that in the GCC countries where they produce
- 22:10oil, what are they doing? In reality, they are monetizing
- 22:14energy. What is the best way in the
- 22:16world to monetize energy? It's Bitcoin.
- 22:19So I think those countries have realized that.
- 22:21And I was actually earlier in Abu Dhabi today at one of the
- 22:25bigger Bitcoin mining facilities and it is run by one of the
- 22:30public or it's operated, sorry, by one of the public listed
- 22:33companies in the US and they're doing an awesome job.
- 22:37So far they're huddling only and I went to them to try and sell
- 22:40them our services so that they sell their Bitcoin through us
- 22:42and pay off their their operating expenses.
- 22:45But yeah, it seems they're hobbling so far.
- 22:48So countries that have oil production and have excess
- 22:52energy in their grid, they are going for Bitcoin mining because
- 22:56they've realized that. They've realized that basically
- 23:00this is the best way to monetize your energy.
- 23:03If you look at Abu Dhabi Stock Exchange, there was a mining
- 23:06company called Phoenix that IP owed and that I guess sets a
- 23:10precedent of the first digital asset company going public in
- 23:13the Middle East. Roman has also done the same and
- 23:17many other countries that produce oil are are looking at
- 23:20that because the reality is if your cost per kWh is less than
- 23:24$0.03 per kWh then you're making bank you're printing money
- 23:29between 3:00 and 5:00 kilowatt hours.
- 23:31Yeah, you can. You can make some money, but
- 23:34below 3 is considered like a very lucrative business.
- 23:36So in those countries you are able to get such a tariff and
- 23:42these countries know what bitcoins worth.
- 23:44It's all relative to the problems that you have.
- 23:46If you are UAE, Saudi, Roman, you're producing a lot of oil
- 23:51and therefore you have energy, but your monetization of that
- 23:55energy is not very efficient. Whereas if you mine Bitcoin,
- 23:58that is the most optimal way of monetizing your energy because
- 24:02you literally spend energy you get back your Bitcoin.
- 24:07And on the other hand countries like Turkey, Lebanon, Egypt
- 24:11where they don't have a pegged currency and the purchasing
- 24:15power has been literally falling exponentially like falling over
- 24:20time. They are looking for USBT.
- 24:24Those markets I've I've spoken to many of our customers that
- 24:28want what in their mind is like a dollar electronic, which is
- 24:33like digital dollar. They don't even know what crypto
- 24:36is. And I've actually spoken to many
- 24:39of our customers in Egypt that just want to buy this digital
- 24:43dollar and they don't even know what Bitcoin is.
- 24:46But I guess let me take a step back and give you some context
- 24:49on our customer base. We have shares that trade in $25
- 24:55million lots and we have customers that literally trade
- 24:59with 2-3 dollars. So we've covered a very wide
- 25:02spectrum of our customers. But to give you just an idea of
- 25:07how important education is, we had a customer that kept trying
- 25:11to withdraw Bitcoin to their physical address.
- 25:14You know, like on our application there's an address
- 25:17checker. So if your Bitcoin address
- 25:19starts with BC and whatever it's it goes through like it checks
- 25:23that your the address that you're sending to is correct.
- 25:27And we kept receiving this weird error that this customer's
- 25:29withdrawal wasn't going through. And we went and checked and it
- 25:33turned out this customer was trying to withdraw a big amount
- 25:35of Bitcoin to like apt 6F on a specific Rd. in Riyadh and Saudi
- 25:40Arabia. So we actually ended up
- 25:43delivering the bitcoins on a treasure to to to the customer.
- 25:49But that gives you an idea of how, Nathan, how nascent we are.
- 25:53So to answer your question on whether people realize the
- 25:56importance of Bitcoin, I think the wealthier countries, the
- 25:59ones that produce oil, have properly understood it.
- 26:03And in emerging markets, the biggest issue is lack of
- 26:07dollars. Today, if you're in Egypt and
- 26:09you want dollars, there isn't enough dollars in the country.
- 26:11So USDT trades at a very high premium and people still see
- 26:17Bitcoin as a higher risk asset that is too volatile.
- 26:21And I guess when you're hurt by your own currency failing by
- 26:253040% and you've seen Bitcoin to be volatile over time, USDT is
- 26:32the the preferred preferred choice in in those markets and
- 26:37actually in in Egypt and in Lebanon, yeah, Egypt we operate
- 26:44more, but we see over 90% of total trading volume on USDT,
- 26:48which is crazy. But again that that is because
- 26:52customers are afraid of their local currency and they've
- 26:54already been hurt by devaluation.
- 26:56So they have minimum risk tolerance or threshold or
- 27:01ability even like they can't afford to lose any money in the
- 27:05short term. And it's those countries usually
- 27:07they are not big on saving because you don't have a wealthy
- 27:11population. So whatever you have, you spend
- 27:13and I guess with with countries like Saudi, UE equate Qatar
- 27:19where you have a richer population a lot more people see
- 27:21the value of Bitcoin as a way to protect your wealth long term.
- 27:27It's very similar to American demographics in general.
- 27:29You know when you break it down, it's it's a similar stance on
- 27:32there's the thing it came out like 90% of stocks in the US are
- 27:36owned by top 10% of individuals or the top 90% of stocks are
- 27:39owned by 10% of the individuals. When you think about those
- 27:42individuals, are that like segment you're referring to that
- 27:44are looking at trying to understand Bitcoin and from a
- 27:47lens that are buying $25 million lots versus the person that's
- 27:50trying to just make it to the paycheck.
- 27:52The paycheck doesn't have the time or the luxury to think
- 27:54about how can they preserve their wealth because they don't
- 27:56have a lot of wealth to preserve.
- 28:00Yeah, agreed. Yeah, and it's it's so
- 28:05fascinating where we are right now.
- 28:06We're 15 years in to Bitcoin coming up on another halving.
- 28:09It's going to cut the subsidy from 6.25 to 3.125 and it has
- 28:14felt like over the last two years specifically.
- 28:16Obviously you've been with Coin MENA for the last few years and
- 28:20it feels like I don't want to use the cliche crossing the
- 28:24chasm. But it does feel like there is
- 28:28finally some urgency on behalf of business owners like yourself
- 28:34and countries particularly to recognize like, oh, this Bitcoin
- 28:38thing's not going away. We've got to take advantage of
- 28:42it, prepare, understand, and then capitalize on the
- 28:46opportunity that lays ahead. And So what do you think the
- 28:50next 2-3 five years look like for for Bitcoin in the Middle
- 28:56East? Like I my I think that the
- 29:00Middle East is going to become a powerhouse in the mining
- 29:02industry, which makes too much sense, little.
- 29:06Honesty, go ahead. I was just saying just add a
- 29:09little more meat because it's a it's a big I think that coupled
- 29:13with something that was really exciting when we started talking
- 29:17and and just excited to go out there And and what's happening
- 29:19is there's these like 3 like tailwinds I think that are
- 29:24working in favor of the region of what Marty just shared.
- 29:26And one of them my it didn't end up in the best way.
- 29:29But I think about I think it was the the Saudi sovereign fund
- 29:33that invested in Wework and there's this like been this
- 29:35narrative and it's happened. It's not just a narrative for
- 29:38the past 10 plus years of diversification away from oil
- 29:42into emerging technologies. And so I think that's like one.
- 29:45The other one is just global macro in general as we think
- 29:50about, you know this idea whether it's sovereign
- 29:52individual or this, you know, infringement of states rights on
- 29:55civil liberties And whether it's Dubai, Singapore and these other
- 29:59regions, even Texas where individuals are are fleeing or
- 30:03or leaving their existing places to go to places that treat them
- 30:06more like customers than you know, employees and really
- 30:12having to offer a good product. And then the last one is really
- 30:16the Bitcoin growth like this story of Bitcoin as emerging
- 30:18technology. So it fit into that tailwind
- 30:21that I just described. But then also it ties directly
- 30:24to the energy source which again sits at the core of you know the
- 30:27GDP of a Texas or the the MENA region.
- 30:30And curious like all those things combined to Marty's
- 30:33point, like it seems very positive and bullish for that
- 30:36region for the next 3-5 years. And curious on like how you see
- 30:39it, but then also how the market seen it in that region?
- 30:42Yeah. So I'll start off with the
- 30:44interesting point that you mentioned about like competition
- 30:46on residency. So I'm personally Jordanian, OK.
- 30:51So Jordan is a country that's a three hour flight north of
- 30:56Dubai. It's a great country.
- 30:59That's economic opportunities. There aren't that amazing so I
- 31:02moved to Dubai. The process was quite easy.
- 31:06I moved my money here easily via crypto.
- 31:08You have the ability to liquidate if you need to.
- 31:13But most importantly is that it's kind of created competition
- 31:16between other places that you could move.
- 31:18I used to live in Zoo Switzerland before that also
- 31:21moved for crypto reasons. But this crypto competitiveness
- 31:26or like the country competitiveness like they they
- 31:29are, it's like a customer acquisition plane.
- 31:32So for example, Dubai has this golden visa program that allows
- 31:36you to get permanent residency for 10 years and that will allow
- 31:39you to plan better and yeah and basically set up your life here.
- 31:45I don't know if anyone that's visited Dubai in months where
- 31:49it's not too hot. I think the overall feedback is
- 31:52it's one of the best places to live on earth.
- 31:55I'm certainly biased, I've been here for the past five years and
- 31:57realistically staying for the foreseeable future.
- 32:02But yeah, Dubai has been able to attract so many different people
- 32:07from the crypto world and I would say that it is a
- 32:10combination of multiple factors. So First off is insane Lehigh
- 32:15quality of life versus what you pay and the quality that you
- 32:18get. Dubai is unmatched in my
- 32:20opinion. Secondly is taxes.
- 32:24We have no taxes in Dubai. There's VAT tax and a few ones,
- 32:28but there's no personal income tax, no capital gains tax and
- 32:32that's something that I guess shocks some people in Europe or
- 32:36the US where tax literally the government's your, your your
- 32:42uninvited partner. And finally finally Safety Dubai
- 32:47is I've never seen anything as safe as Dubai.
- 32:49You could literally and obviously that is by design and
- 32:53it May is very harsh on anyone that that breaks the law, but
- 32:57that leads you to have a very, very safe country that is
- 33:00something that bitcoiners and and and people that have made it
- 33:03in crypto appreciate quite a bit.
- 33:05So that's that's a bit on the residency competitiveness side.
- 33:09But to go back to the original question on where do I see
- 33:11Bitcoin and specifically mining in the Middle East.
- 33:16OK. So historically the region had
- 33:20used to sell oil to the US when the US was a net importer.
- 33:25And now now I guess that's not no longer the case.
- 33:28And those countries, Saudi Arabia, UAE, etcetera, used to
- 33:33sell oil, receive money and keep it in treasury bills to make
- 33:36whatever yield that treasury is going to make.
- 33:39But the purchasing power of those treasury has constantly
- 33:42been going over time. So I think Saudi Arabia, UAE and
- 33:45other countries have started to essentially no longer put the
- 33:50funds in U.S. Treasury bills and that can be
- 33:53seen by the foreign ownership of U.S.
- 33:56Treasuries that that data corroborates the point that I'm
- 33:59mentioning. And they're starting to invest
- 34:01it in anything that's local that can allow them to move away from
- 34:05oil revenue diversification or sorry concentration, so to
- 34:08diversify their revenue streams, I guess one example is what
- 34:12they've done on the sports level in Saudi.
- 34:15They now own and run the PGA, which is the golf tournament.
- 34:22And they did that through live, which is I guess quite
- 34:25controversial and on how they did that.
- 34:27But the most followed sports, the most followed person on
- 34:30Instagram globally, Cristiano Ronaldo now lives in Riyadh.
- 34:34That would have that would have not been possible if the Saudis
- 34:38did not stop deploying the oil proceeds into treasuries and
- 34:43instead started to diversify them locally.
- 34:46So part of that exodus or part of that move of capital, I
- 34:51believe a big part will go towards mining.
- 34:54I think Phoenix Group being publicly listed in Abu Dhabi has
- 34:58opened up the eyes of so many different governments,
- 35:02government entities, and yeah, it's likely become like a
- 35:08subject of national security. Are you mining your Bitcoin
- 35:12locally? Are you storing it locally?
- 35:14Like, I I sometimes think of custody and and and how much
- 35:18it's going to change in the coming 10 years if like just
- 35:22imagine how much shit governments gave us about local
- 35:26data custody or local data storage.
- 35:29Like if you're using Amazon, I need to or at Coin Mina, when
- 35:33use Amazon, we need to use the Bahraini cluster of Amazon so
- 35:36that the data is stored locally in a compliant way.
- 35:40That's on data. Imagine what they're going to do
- 35:42for the ultimate form of money, where do you need to custody
- 35:44your Bitcoin? So I think that in the Middle
- 35:47East we'll see emergence of top quality custodians, but even
- 35:54beyond that, I think the types of players that will be involved
- 35:57will change. Now every bank during their
- 36:01board meeting they're going to discuss whether they're
- 36:03launching A crypto or a Bitcoin offering or not.
- 36:05Because if Blackrock's offering it, then there's no excuse for
- 36:11any local bank or any investment company not to also offer it to
- 36:14its customers. So as much as some people hate
- 36:19the ETF and think it goes against the principles of
- 36:22Bitcoin, in my opinion Bitcoin is anti fragile and should be
- 36:27able to sustain any type of pressure, including the ETF.
- 36:31But there is definitely an impact on how financial
- 36:36institutions think about it. Thanks for tuning in.
- 36:39If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 36:41further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 36:45a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 36:48our team at onrampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 36:52you on your Bitcoin journey. To to go back and answer your
- 36:55question in a more coherent manner, how do I think cryptos
- 36:58and Bitcoin is going to look like in the Middle East?
- 36:59In three to five years it will solidify the Middle East, will
- 37:02solidify its spot as one of the top regions in the world for
- 37:06crypto and Bitcoin across services, mining, regulation,
- 37:13custody. And part of that effort will
- 37:16also be quasi governmental because one of the things that I
- 37:21guess in the United Arab Emirates and in in other Arab
- 37:25countries is there, but not as common or maybe even frowned,
- 37:29frowned upon in the US or free markets is government
- 37:33involvement. So for example, Emirates
- 37:35Airline, I don't know if you've gone on Emirates Airline, it's
- 37:39insanely good and the impact of Emirates Airline on the country
- 37:43and the city was absolutely amazing.
- 37:45Dubai airport, Dubai International Airport is the
- 37:48busiest airport in the world and that is because the government
- 37:51spent smart money to build this carrier or this their airline
- 37:59that has a total net benefit for Dubai.
- 38:02So I guess even on the mining side, I do believe that we will
- 38:05see government backed government supported initiatives that yeah
- 38:11we'll we'll start a race for other countries to do so because
- 38:16yeah there's like a who's going to do it first.
- 38:18I think El Salvador was the first to be super aggressive and
- 38:22now we're seeing many countries follow suit, maybe not switching
- 38:26their local currency to Bitcoin, but working on quasi sovereign
- 38:30initiatives that will lead them to have a lot of Bitcoin
- 38:33custody. Look.
- 38:35It's all you got to. You got to slow down.
- 38:36Marty's packing his bag. He's he's ready to go.
- 38:41I'm, I'm glad you mentioned the El Salvador thing because I've
- 38:43talked to folks that are very close there.
- 38:45And while it's a it's very great thing to see, it's something I'm
- 38:48starting to learn in the Bitcoin space and the ecosystem is the
- 38:501st through the door may not necessarily be the ultimate
- 38:53winner. And when I think about like El
- 38:55Salvador, they established kind of a brand in a in a country in
- 39:00a way to do things. But the reality is you can take
- 39:02those learnings and then start to apply them in a more
- 39:05efficient way. And as you mentioned like the
- 39:07private public market, as you start to bring in other
- 39:11individuals from the private market into the the public
- 39:14market, in the reference to Dubai, you could start to just
- 39:18have a more kind of free market without the air quotes of like
- 39:21how you actually scale building a city or a country that's going
- 39:25to be friendly to this ecosystem versus like from a bureaucratic
- 39:28nature, which my understanding that's a lot of what's happened
- 39:30in El Salvo now while trying to be friendly to the ecosystem.
- 39:33It's actually been the opposite in the sense of when you're
- 39:36doing it brand new, you end up just with a lot of that natural
- 39:39kind of like, I don't know if tech that's the right word, but
- 39:41it's that same like legacy debt that's built into everything
- 39:44else you do versus starting with some of like the framework but
- 39:47then fresh eyes. Yeah.
- 39:50And I think that's that's like by the way that's the exact
- 39:53reason why we decided to go with VAR as our regulator because
- 39:58they're starting with as they say in French like carte
- 40:00blanche, it's a. There's nothing there.
- 40:02You know, they're just starting. There's no legacy knowledge of
- 40:06how FX brokers work or stock brokers work.
- 40:09It's purely designed for digital assets or virtual assets as they
- 40:12like to call it. And yeah, I guess we were one of
- 40:16the first to get licensed there. And so far it's definitely going
- 40:20in the right direction. No starting carte blanche like
- 40:24tabula rasa blank slate. I I, I guess a good natural
- 40:29segue into the partnership between on ramp and Coimena like
- 40:34you do have the opportunity where I think here in the USI
- 40:37think this last 12 months specifically, more specifically
- 40:41the last seven months with the lead up to the ETF approvals has
- 40:45proven that the regulators here in the United States are trying
- 40:49to like forfeit Bitcoin, this whole new alien technology into
- 40:55centuries old securities regulation and financial
- 40:59regulation. It's here in the US and by
- 41:03starting with a blank slate in the Middle East, there's a
- 41:06really good opportunity to really set the standard.
- 41:08That's something we've been talking about on this show for
- 41:11almost a year now and in other places is like I do believe that
- 41:15Bitcoin as a salient technology with these native properties
- 41:18that enable you to custody and secure your assets, your Bitcoin
- 41:24in a very unique way that is simply impossible in the
- 41:28incumbent system. You can, if you have a blank
- 41:31slate, go out and create new standards and really push the
- 41:35ball forward in terms of actually leveraging the
- 41:38innovative properties that exist with this with this technology.
- 41:42Something like multi sig, multi institution, multi sig, multi
- 41:45jurisdictional multi institution multi sig.
- 41:49I think this is where the market should go.
- 41:52And as an American, it is a bit disheartening to see that
- 41:59they're trying to form fit Bitcoin into again, regulation
- 42:03that was written over a century ago.
- 42:05Whereas it seems in the Middle East, you guys are sort of
- 42:08setting yourself up to really innovate on the regulatory front
- 42:12to ensure that individuals and companies are able to leverage
- 42:16these native properties that make Bitcoin a better asset in
- 42:19the digital age. Yeah.
- 42:21So I think 1933 is the securities law, right?
- 42:25It's yeah that's that's been a while none of us were were were
- 42:30even close to being here. Look, I think Dubai is a very
- 42:36ambitious city, which means that they always aim high.
- 42:39They sometimes don't necessarily hit the jackpot 100%.
- 42:44But on the ones that they do, yeah, I guess one of one of my
- 42:49favorites quotes is for his Zionist Muhammad ruler of Dubai,
- 42:53which I guess the don't quote me on the translation, but because
- 42:56it's in Arabic. But it basically says the
- 42:58biggest risk is not to take risk.
- 43:02So I guess that is the ethos of the city and it only was fitting
- 43:10for them to adopt digital assets in the way that they did.
- 43:15And honestly, having lived in Zook, which previously was like
- 43:19a a place where many crypto people moved to, I was there
- 43:23between 2015 and 2017. So now I've seen a lot more
- 43:28people that used to live in Zoo have moved to Dubai.
- 43:33Obviously, the US is still the largest market in the world and
- 43:37most of the innovation in web two and in web three has come
- 43:41out of the US If you think of like many of the applications
- 43:45that are built on Ethereum and whatnot, many of it have has
- 43:48come out of the US, whether New York, San Francisco, et cetera.
- 43:51So I wouldn't count the US out just yet.
- 43:56Maybe the regulators and the SEC in specific hasn't been has
- 44:01tried to box Bitcoin into the security wrapper.
- 44:05But I do believe that the perceived and potential upside
- 44:09of digital assets will end up winning and and entrepreneurs
- 44:13and companies in the US will find a way around it because the
- 44:16upside is so high that they're incentivized to do so.
- 44:21Yeah, I think that ties in something that market morally
- 44:23says often about, you know, States and states rights.
- 44:26And we see this in the US with Wyoming and Texas, Tennessees
- 44:29and other state that's really exercising kind of the
- 44:33friendliness, whether it's be a mining financial services, how
- 44:36Bitcoin as an asset is held. You said something that was
- 44:40about the risk or not to take it reminds me of a, you know, kind
- 44:44of I don't watch football anymore, but the Cowboys, you
- 44:47know, they just got completely crushed.
- 44:49And this idea that I was watching the game and I was
- 44:52thinking of this, this idea of you have to play to win, You
- 44:56can't play not to lose. And when people are tight, when
- 45:00they're kind of worried and and like they have a seat, they have
- 45:03a position that's like at the forefront in this analogy, like
- 45:06the Cowboys were you know one of the best teams and from a record
- 45:08perspective and that that would be like an incumbent financial
- 45:11institution or just an incumbent in the market, you kind of play
- 45:15it safe. And the reality is the market
- 45:16doesn't doesn't want that. It needs you to keep moving the
- 45:19the puck 4. That's how you become.
- 45:20I mean you think about Amazon and how like I think what's the
- 45:23whole thing. relentless.com still reverts back to Amazon.com
- 45:27that was he owned that domain. And so this idea of you have to
- 45:33play to win, not to lose. So you have to look at the
- 45:35opportunities with that fresh slate and then think about the
- 45:38innovation. So like in reference to Marty
- 45:40and the the partnership, I think the education is so important.
- 45:44I don't know if we'll pull it up, but it's on Coin Mana's
- 45:46website and I think we'll probably post it somewhere.
- 45:48But the first piece we we partnered was with Bitcoin
- 45:53Bitcoin's full potential valuation by Jesse and it's
- 45:56important because in the industry you rarely see kind of
- 45:59the Bitcoin native kind of like education that lives within that
- 46:04meets the market. On the asset management finance
- 46:06side, where they are, it's generally like 1 sided or the
- 46:09other where you kind of have the the bit wises and these cryptic
- 46:12firms that are putting you know 10 baskets of ETF or 10 baskets
- 46:16of cryptocurrencies in a in a bucket and selling it to the
- 46:19market. Or you have the other side
- 46:20that's telling the the market, hey you know you got to now your
- 46:23keys not your coin. But there's there's no like
- 46:25meeting them where they're at in the sense of like how do you
- 46:28evaluate this, how do you think about it as a in the global
- 46:30macro context and from a portfolio perspective.
- 46:34And so I think that it's going to and that that transcends all
- 46:37borders, right. It's the the the markets, the
- 46:39market from assets whether it's equities, commodities, bonds and
- 46:43the way you size it proportionally and the
- 46:45volatility exists in Dubai and Texas and Singapore all over the
- 46:48world. And so I I thought about that
- 46:51deeply as far as working with Coin Meno on the research and
- 46:54some of the other things that we're discussing in that
- 46:57bringing what we're kind of put together with you know Jesse
- 47:00Bryan on the team to be able to help transcend that.
- 47:02I that bitcoins volatile Bitcoin doesn't exist.
- 47:05There's a bunch of error between 0 and bitcoins current you know
- 47:08price $43,000. We all know and most people
- 47:11listening that there's a lot of fundamentals baked in, but the
- 47:14the fact of the matter is the market really doesn't know it
- 47:16yet and so be able to get that information out there is really
- 47:19important. Yeah.
- 47:21So it's it's my colleague Zaid, who leads content marketing
- 47:26education at Coimena. He used to send me on RAMPS
- 47:30reports and we realized that we're referring back to them
- 47:34pretty much in every conversation.
- 47:36So yeah, I guess it was we're very happy to have this
- 47:42partnership and I guess us being educated through Jesse's writing
- 47:46and and he has such an amazing, digestible style of writing that
- 47:53we need to figure out how we translate his style into Arabic.
- 47:56But I'm sure Zaid would be able to sort that out.
- 47:59And yeah, I mean, one of the biggest factors for, you know,
- 48:07adoption not going faster than than it is, is education.
- 48:12And I think it's only a matter of time until we see Bitcoin
- 48:16integrated into curriculums at school.
- 48:19Like there's there's no reason why kids don't learn about the
- 48:24importance of money and how hard money differs from soft money.
- 48:29Yeah. At an early stage and maybe at
- 48:32the Coimbena level school, kids aren't really our target
- 48:35addressable market. It's more so funds, investment
- 48:39managers, banks, etcetera. But yeah, I guess it's it's an
- 48:45area that we spent a lot of time and effort and resources on,
- 48:49even though it doesn't have, let's say, tangible, direct ROI.
- 48:52But it does have a very, yeah, very important impact.
- 48:59Because without it, it's impossible to acquire and retain
- 49:04proper clients. Like you can't convince people
- 49:06that don't understand Bitcoin properly, don't have the same
- 49:10conviction as people that properly understand it.
- 49:12And through those reports is how we aim to make our customers
- 49:17more conscious and aware of how groundbreaking this technology
- 49:21is. Yeah, it's exactly right.
- 49:23I think it's like the chicken or egg thing.
- 49:25I think our biggest cost center and investment is in is in
- 49:28education. When you think about the pods
- 49:31and the the content produced and the individuals that have have
- 49:33joined the firm because we've seen it.
- 49:35It's I always joke like for the next 10 years every company that
- 49:40navigates or leads in this industry will have to be an
- 49:42education company 1st and then they'll have their core service
- 49:46because it's just still so foreign these concepts, the
- 49:49asset, the volatility, the custody and there's a big
- 49:52component especially in the financial services of building
- 49:55trust and all of that. And so that that content, these
- 49:57podcasts, they they build trust over time.
- 50:03Like they they build it whether people know it or not in the
- 50:08sense of you build relationships with individuals.
- 50:10It's very hard to fake authenticity over every every
- 50:12week through the writing in these different forms.
- 50:15And when that happens, the trust accompanies it.
- 50:18And then that's how you're able to kind of like pull down that
- 50:21guard of, oh, well, you're just trying to like take my money Or
- 50:24you think about the past 15 years and the the craziness
- 50:27we've seen in the market where your counterparty, the
- 50:30difference between your counterparty being good and bad
- 50:32was effectively A0 and what you ended up in your allocation.
- 50:35And so that still exists and it'll probably exist for the
- 50:38next 5 to 10 years because people don't forget that easy
- 50:41that you that this stuff has happened.
- 50:43And so that trust and that education is very important in
- 50:46the front end. So then when they're ready and
- 50:48there are their ears and eyes are open, it's like OK that that
- 50:51guards down as far as like OK, this is a good actor.
- 50:54Now let's just have the discussion on like what you know
- 50:56what do I need? How do I custody at what's an
- 50:58allocation. How do I think about this from
- 51:00an inheritance perspective. All of those things you can't
- 51:02really get there unless you have trust built be built into the to
- 51:06the process. Yeah, fully agreed.
- 51:12One thing sorry I got let's clear this right.
- 51:17It's 60° in the the studio this morning, so shivering here as we
- 51:21talk. But one thing I wanted to touch
- 51:23on, Allen Farrington's written a lot about this.
- 51:26There's a lot of discussion. There's a bunch of bitcoiners I
- 51:30follow from the Middle East that are adamant that Bitcoin is the
- 51:34Sharia compliant money. And from the people that I
- 51:39follow, they seem to believe that that really at that meme or
- 51:43that idea hasn't really caught on in the Middle East.
- 51:46Is that conversation happening in the circles that you're in?
- 51:50To all Have you heard people really pushing Bitcoin over Fiat
- 51:55currencies because of this sort of the way it fits into Sharia
- 52:00law from the finance perspective?
- 52:03Before to start off, Sharia law doesn't permit usually or the
- 52:10interest basically does not allow like basically if I'm
- 52:15going to you know you need to do a first specific economic
- 52:19activity that adds value for you to get paid.
- 52:22You can make profit or loss but debt essentially or interest is
- 52:26not something that is allowed. And if you think of how the
- 52:29dollar is based, how many currencies that are pegged to
- 52:33the dollar are based. It is literally by the
- 52:35government issuing treasury bills that have interest in
- 52:38order to create this dollar. So inherently by design it
- 52:42cannot be Sharia compliant. So gold, which is a Sharia
- 52:47compliant asset or Sharia compliant money was the
- 52:52preferred method of transacting for thousands of years.
- 52:56And then as as the world became more global, as the world became
- 53:02more global and and you needed a better way to transfer value
- 53:05because gold is a pain in the ass to move and and store and
- 53:09whatnot, those governments ended up going for a non Sharia
- 53:14compliant form of money that is based and backed to the US
- 53:19dollar. Now with the emergence of
- 53:21Bitcoin you have something that is similar to dollars but
- 53:25digital. So I've actually looked into
- 53:28this quite heavily and Bitcoin is a Sharia compliant asset in
- 53:33my opinion. But again Sharia compliance is
- 53:37there's no one that plays the role of like the auditor for
- 53:41religion. You know it's it's as per your
- 53:43your perception. You know, for example, you can
- 53:47get an auditor to testify your financial statements and tell
- 53:50you if you have enough capital or not.
- 53:51But you can't really get someone that definitively says it's
- 53:56Shariah compliant or not, like an ISO approval or like AFDA
- 54:01approval for a drug or something, you know, But there
- 54:05are scientists or I guess they call them muftis, like clerks
- 54:10that look into this and give their opinion.
- 54:13Last year there was a very popular clerk in Saudi that came
- 54:17out and said Bitcoin is Shariah compliant and he had a very
- 54:21elegant analysis on why. At Coin Mina we don't offer
- 54:26margin, we don't offer leverage and we don't have any interest
- 54:30bearing instruments. So we are Sharia compliant as
- 54:33well. And I guess Bitcoin specifically
- 54:37is, by the way, Sharia compliance matters in some
- 54:41markets more than others. If you look at the United Arab
- 54:44Emirates where over 2/3 of the population or even more is not
- 54:49local, it's not Middle Eastern, it's not from the country.
- 54:54Sharia compliance is less important.
- 54:55I would say somewhere like Saudi Arabia, which I guess is is
- 55:01primarily Saudis that are Muslim.
- 55:05Sharia compliance becomes a significantly more important
- 55:10point. But in principle, Sharia
- 55:13compliance is revolves around risk mitigation and all of the
- 55:18principles of Bitcoin are fully aligned to Sharia law and
- 55:23finance, which I actually think is IS is a great way to look at
- 55:28things. It will open up markets in
- 55:31Indonesia and Malaysia and Saudi where Islamic finance or Sharia
- 55:37compliant finance, is the preferred way of doing business.
- 55:42Yeah, and I think the overarching tell me if I'm
- 55:44oversimplifying, but from like the finance side, there's like
- 55:47debt based money, right, Which Bitcoin isn't.
- 55:49It's you know, gold and Bitcoin bare assets.
- 55:53But then in finance from like a usury perspective in a future
- 55:56state, kind of like stumbled on this and talking with a client
- 55:59about, you know, offering products that would offer yield,
- 56:02right, Because you don't want to sell your Bitcoin in a future
- 56:04state if you're holding Bitcoin. But it's this idea kind of flips
- 56:07on its head of of an equity based system versus a debt based
- 56:11system where you'll you can generate quote, UN quote, yield
- 56:14or return on your Bitcoin. But it's because you are
- 56:16investing in a productive entity and they're providing you
- 56:21returns on the equity that you've invested in.
- 56:23And that is your return versus the the alternative of what we
- 56:27exist today where you you know you're basically taking out debt
- 56:32like in the. The way I think about this in
- 56:33the most simple form is like higher education where you you
- 56:37take on the debt and it's almost like shackles that exist post
- 56:40college and you're kind of strapped to that and sometimes
- 56:43you're strapped to the for the rest of your life where if there
- 56:45was an alternative that somebody invested in you as an individual
- 56:48or invested in the the productive upside of an of a
- 56:51business and you were and they were part of participating in
- 56:55the upside of the entity that you formed and also the
- 56:58downside. But that also makes for just a
- 57:00better society as far as like that person now wants to help
- 57:02you versus just get that dividend return.
- 57:05Does that make sense to all in the sense of, like how a
- 57:07productive society would form around that versus a debt base?
- 57:11Yeah, Yeah. So actually this is a very
- 57:13elegant way of explaining what Sharia law says about debt and
- 57:17equity. So equity is one of the few
- 57:19things that Keynesian Sharia, all different economists agree
- 57:23that it's the purest form of alignment of incentives.
- 57:27And that's why in Sharia, equity is always preferred and that's
- 57:32not allowed because in equity we win together and we lose
- 57:35together. So I'm not, I'm incentivized for
- 57:38you to win and if we lose, we lose together in debt.
- 57:41I could get screwed but you still get paid your money.
- 57:44So it doesn't align our incentives then that usually
- 57:47creates yeah incentives that lead to sub optimal outcomes.
- 57:52So yeah, I'm personally a way bigger fan of equity and I guess
- 58:00here we've looked at two things, the base asset which is not debt
- 58:03based money in Bitcoin or gold case but also financial services
- 58:07because you could lend out Bitcoin for interest and even
- 58:10though Bitcoin is a Sharia compliant, I said that financial
- 58:12service or that transaction wouldn't be.
- 58:15So yeah, I like how you combined it with the equity type and the
- 58:20main concept behind that in Sharia is for basically all
- 58:25parties to win and lose together.
- 58:26So that you think of yourself as as as one unit and not me
- 58:31wanting to win on on your behalf.
- 58:34Yep. Yeah, incentive alignment is
- 58:38very important and we've seen that the proliferation of a debt
- 58:43based society has done culturally to the social
- 58:46cohesion here in the United States and other parts of the
- 58:49world over the last 150 years. And I mean that's part of the
- 58:53reason why I'm in Bitcoin. I mean, even just from the
- 58:57Christian perspective, that's why Jesus went into the temples
- 58:59and chased the money chasers out.
- 59:01The money changers out is because they were doing
- 59:04something that was deeply immoral from a from a biblical
- 59:10perspective. And it is really fascinating
- 59:12that when you first get into Bitcoin, you really don't think
- 59:14about how it can apply to religious law across many
- 59:19different religions. But then you dig deeper and you
- 59:21dive in and it's like, oh wow, like this is actually a money
- 59:26that that has been written. Not Bitcoin specifically, but
- 59:29money has been written into all the religious texts throughout
- 59:34history. And it's funny that we're sort
- 59:35of rediscovering moral money through Bitcoin as time goes on.
- 59:41It's just really weird how this all plays together.
- 59:47It's also weird that we got kind of like psyopt into believing
- 59:49that it doesn't make sense. I we had Matt on and he was
- 59:52talking about open sets and the patronage that they've done and
- 59:54it and it's like so foreign that he's doing something great.
- 59:56But that's how historically you funded things previously.
- 59:59And it's like this idea of who will build the roads is like.
- 1:00:01Well, if we're all making money and, you know, we want to give
- 1:00:04back to society, we will produce productive things in the world
- 1:00:07because you want your kids and you want the people around you
- 1:00:10to not live, you know, in the gutter.
- 1:00:13And this idea of like we can't, we wouldn't do it ourselves.
- 1:00:15We need the government to make sure that they build the right
- 1:00:18roads in the right, you know, system so that we're all
- 1:00:21governed appropriately. It's just so foreign.
- 1:00:24But this is how things have been done for thousands of years,
- 1:00:25specifically to what Marty mentioned.
- 1:00:28Yeah I mean honestly Bitcoin is is I think it's absolutely
- 1:00:33fascinating how people from all different walks of life look and
- 1:00:39determine what's good in this asset.
- 1:00:42For example you mentioned the the, the money changers and how
- 1:00:45the relevance of that in in in in the Christian religion.
- 1:00:47But it all boils down to what you as a human think is good or
- 1:00:52bad. You know that based money if you
- 1:00:55think about it, if you want to say good or bad, I think you
- 1:00:59know anyone that spends time studying it will be able to come
- 1:01:02out to the conclusion that it is overall net bad.
- 1:01:05And if and when I say net bad or good, I know that's a very over
- 1:01:09generalization. But I'm talking about society in
- 1:01:11general and Marty I think you you nailed it on the head when
- 1:01:14you said the impact of the past 150 years is there.
- 1:01:18Society is not progressing in the way that I think it should
- 1:01:23and and debt based money plays a very big part in that for sure.
- 1:01:29Yeah. The other thing that's very
- 1:01:30fascinating is so the, I think Tal are you going to go to the
- 1:01:35Bitcoin Oasis conference? Yes, yes, in Dubai.
- 1:01:39OK. So I think it's is it the first
- 1:01:42Bitcoin only like conference happening in that region?
- 1:01:46Maybe of this scale, yes. Of this scale, yeah.
- 1:01:50Of this scale, yes. There's definitely some bit up
- 1:01:53to that. But yeah, this this would be,
- 1:01:55I'd say the, yeah, one of one of the more, the bigger ones that
- 1:01:59are only Bitcoin focused. Yeah.
- 1:02:01So we look forward to meeting in person.
- 1:02:03We'll see if we can convince Marga to go out.
- 1:02:06One of the things that's been fascinating talking with the
- 1:02:08group there, Lauren Lena with the the UA Bitcoin Association
- 1:02:12is they were describing a lot of the the conversations and the
- 1:02:14the way business is done in the region and they talked a lot
- 1:02:18about reputation and you know trust in in looking you know
- 1:02:25individuals in the eyes and you know shaking hands and all the
- 1:02:28things associated you come out and it's not about doing a deal
- 1:02:31or selling somebody. And I looked at him and it
- 1:02:33sounds like it sounds a lot like Texas.
- 1:02:34You know we we're just we wear different hats over here and I
- 1:02:38was like writing down we just wore different hats and I'm
- 1:02:40writing down like if you made a a case for somebody to move to a
- 1:02:44a friendly region they were coming from let's call it New
- 1:02:47York City and you're like and they were interested in getting
- 1:02:50into the into Bitcoin or or working in digital assets and
- 1:02:55you're like it's going to be hot but there's heavy oil and gas
- 1:02:58from AGDP perspective it's attracting a lot of talent in
- 1:03:02the ecosystem. From a Bitcoin perspective, the
- 1:03:04taxes are very friendly and it's all really trust and reputation
- 1:03:08based how things have been done for, for hundreds and thousands
- 1:03:11of years. Would you be describing Texas?
- 1:03:13Would you be describing Dubai and some of the other countries
- 1:03:15that guys are operating they're they're very similar.
- 1:03:18And so it's exciting to be participating and then finding
- 1:03:21out that there's a direct flight from Houston is going to is
- 1:03:24going to make things a little easier as well.
- 1:03:26Very nice. Yeah, it's you.
- 1:03:29You basically describe both. You could replace Dubai or Texas
- 1:03:35in in the description that you that you've had.
- 1:03:37And yeah, I've I've thought of this before for sure than the
- 1:03:41first time that I've heard this or thought about this.
- 1:03:44And yeah, excited to meet you guys in person.
- 1:03:46Hopefully, Marty also now that that we know that there's a
- 1:03:49direct flight from Houston that hopefully makes the pitch
- 1:03:52slightly easier. And it's not.
- 1:03:56It'll be well, I'll. Have my wife.
- 1:03:58I'll have my wife text, text his wife because she's she's not too
- 1:04:01happy so she'll watch. When is it?
- 1:04:05Next month? Yeah, February, February if
- 1:04:11anybody wants to jump on the Emirates train.
- 1:04:13February 6th through 9th or 7th through 10th?
- 1:04:18I need to. I need to visit the Middle East.
- 1:04:20I've never been. We'll see.
- 1:04:23We'll see if I can do a three-week turn around here.
- 1:04:26It's time. It's time.
- 1:04:28If there's a well, there's a way.
- 1:04:29And honestly, it's a good, it's a good event to come to and it's
- 1:04:34a very good time to visit. Debate in general.
- 1:04:36Like February is not as back as New Year's, but it's also
- 1:04:39beautiful weather. Yeah, would would love to have
- 1:04:43you here. I mean, all the bitcoiners I
- 1:04:45know that have moved to Dubai, absolutely love it.
- 1:04:47They rave about it and that's I need to, I need to add some
- 1:04:52stamps on my passport. So this could, this could
- 1:04:54happen. That's gonna happen.
- 1:04:56By the way, I don't think they stamp.
- 1:04:57They don't. They no longer stamp in Dubai.
- 1:04:59You just scan it. That's you.
- 1:05:00Just scan. Yeah, you just scan it.
- 1:05:02There's no more stamps. Where you scan the the the pass
- 1:05:06or the eyeballs? Because yeah.
- 1:05:10Yeah, so actually if you're a resident here, you don't need to
- 1:05:13scan your passport anymore. You just walk through the door,
- 1:05:17that's obviously your face is being scanned and they know
- 1:05:20either you're coming in and out. Let's see.
- 1:05:22The physical stamp I don't think exists anymore.
- 1:05:26We'll get you one for like as a souvenir we can.
- 1:05:29We can easily do that. It's for, yeah, it's you.
- 1:05:34You go through your passport every once in a while.
- 1:05:36You look at the stamps like, yeah, I remember this trip to
- 1:05:38Costa Rica. I remember this trip to to
- 1:05:40Latvia. I remember this trip to Dubai.
- 1:05:43It's a trip down memory lane in the in the passport stamp book.
- 1:05:47I've definitely. Done that before that's that's
- 1:05:50been one of the most the past few weeks.
- 1:05:51I think the West in general and this is maybe a generalization,
- 1:05:55but a little bit ignorant to what's happening in the Middle
- 1:05:57Eastern region and and the prosperity that that's going on.
- 1:06:01I think I I kind of understood that what I was more ignorant to
- 1:06:04was just the the friendliness from making it easy specifically
- 1:06:07in Dubai to move there. You talked about it.
- 1:06:10Laura was on Stefan Lavera's podcast and the the the idea of
- 1:06:16getting a visa established in a country in the region is in in I
- 1:06:20think getting having only being in the country twice a year, is
- 1:06:25that correct? It's very easy to actually, you
- 1:06:28know, set up shop in that market.
- 1:06:31Honestly, it's not easy only to set up shop, it's easy to get
- 1:06:35integrated into anything that you put efforts into like.
- 1:06:38And that's something that I guess I'm a clearly a Dubey fan
- 1:06:44because I moved here five years ago and have been super hands on
- 1:06:49when it comes to anything crypto, anything, Bitcoin,
- 1:06:52whether it's giving feedback on regulations, whether it's
- 1:06:55setting up my entity here, whether it's bringing, trying to
- 1:06:58convince people to move to Dubai.
- 1:07:01I was honored and surprised last in 2022, Sheikh Mohammed, the
- 1:07:07ruler of Dubai elected an Advisory Board for the debate
- 1:07:11Chamber of Commerce. I'm not from Dubai and I was
- 1:07:15elected on that board by His Highness and as a foreigner that
- 1:07:20came to the country to to like make a living and live a good
- 1:07:24life, it was shocking because where I'm from if like you have
- 1:07:28to be not only local but you need to have gone through a
- 1:07:32specific, let's say, path in order to reach such a government
- 1:07:38advisory position. I guess Dubai is.
- 1:07:42It pushes the boundary across so many walks of life that it's
- 1:07:46it's amazing and I can't recommend it enough.
- 1:07:49And hopefully Marky were able to show you in person what this
- 1:07:52city is all about. I love the hard sell.
- 1:07:56You don't have to sell me that hard.
- 1:07:58I want to. I want to make the trip.
- 1:08:00If it's not been Oasis, I'll be there in 2024.
- 1:08:03We we do have plans on the 10:30 one side of things to get over
- 1:08:08there at some point this year. Maybe it's in a few weeks, but
- 1:08:13to all this has been incredible. Is there anything we should wrap
- 1:08:17up with Michael before we end it here in terms of what you guys
- 1:08:23are doing together? No, I think we covered.
- 1:08:26I'm extremely excited like you said, even more so after this
- 1:08:29podcast to get out there. It's going to be a good, good
- 1:08:32time from all the things and the programming going on and being
- 1:08:35able to hopefully go to dinner with you and Zaid and it's going
- 1:08:39to be, it's going to be very good.
- 1:08:41What What can we expect from Coin Man?
- 1:08:43What are you excited for this year, the next few years from
- 1:08:48the Coin Mina perspective? Yeah, So on the Coin Mina side,
- 1:08:53the goal is to onboard the million users and get Bitcoin in
- 1:08:56the hands of 1,000,000 users. So that's one of one of our main
- 1:09:00goals we set up about two years ago.
- 1:09:03Now we're the largest of the local players.
- 1:09:05The goal is to be the biggest crypto business in all of the
- 1:09:08Middle East. So that includes the finances,
- 1:09:10the crypto dot coms, the coin bases and whatnot.
- 1:09:13And yeah, I guess helping improve people's lives by giving
- 1:09:19them access to a superior form of money.
- 1:09:24And I believe that if we do that properly, then we'll be able to
- 1:09:27have a very profitable high growth business.
- 1:09:31So like, yeah, you're able to do good by doing good.
- 1:09:35Can you do it for yourself as well?
- 1:09:36Like, we're not running a charity, We're still making
- 1:09:38money. But you're doing it in a way
- 1:09:40that benefits the public, which obviously makes you and the team
- 1:09:45feel way better about what they're what they're doing.
- 1:09:48So yeah, very excited to continue growing in the Middle
- 1:09:51East and expanding our reach as much as we can.
- 1:09:56Yeah, it's the best part about working in this industry.
- 1:09:58You don't feel, I don't feel dirty going home to work to your
- 1:10:02wife. It's like I feel like I did
- 1:10:04something good today. It's not a 0 sum, it's not a 0
- 1:10:07sum game in general, it's a forever game.
- 1:10:11Yeah. Well, Talal, thank you for doing
- 1:10:13what you do. You guys are crushing it at
- 1:10:16Queen Mina and I'm really excited to see what you guys do
- 1:10:20over the next few years and really excited to meet in person
- 1:10:22at some point this year, maybe in a few weeks.
- 1:10:25So you'll go home, talk, talk to my wife and.
- 1:10:28Maybe, maybe I'll be in Texas as well and you never know, I visit
- 1:10:31the US often as well. So we'll hopefully have both you
- 1:10:35guys visit Dubai and and I'll love to come see you in the US
- 1:10:38as well. Yeah, the Texas Dubai connection
- 1:10:40is something that needs to be strengthened over the next few
- 1:10:44years. We have a lot in common.
- 1:10:46Fully agreed, yeah. Well, awesome.
- 1:10:49Gentlemen, it's been a pleasure. I learned a lot this episode to
- 1:10:52LOL, thank you again. As I said in the beginning, the
- 1:10:57Middle East is a part of the world that I'm frankly not as
- 1:11:02well educated on as I am in other parts of the world.
- 1:11:05And I'm extremely fascinated watching from afar what's
- 1:11:08happening across the region in terms of Bitcoin adoption and
- 1:11:13integration into industries. And it's probably one of the
- 1:11:17most exciting parts of the world right now, specifically Dubai,
- 1:11:20how the city's really leaning into innovating and leading
- 1:11:24individual age and it's a good example to set.
- 1:11:28Hopefully it induces FOMO for United States entrepreneurs and
- 1:11:34regulators to to wake up and say, hey, we're going to get
- 1:11:37blown out if we don't adopt this type of strategy as well.
- 1:11:41So you're you're sitting in a good spot and appreciate you
- 1:11:44coming on talking with us today. No, thank you.
- 1:11:47Thank you. Great.
- 1:11:50Thanks so much for your time guys.
- 1:11:51Really appreciate it. Really enjoyed it.
- 1:11:53All right. That's all we got.
- 1:11:55We'll be back next week, Jesse. We'll be back as well.
- 1:11:59Congrats on the House, Jesse. Congrats, Jesse.
- 1:12:03See you guys. Thank.
- 1:12:04You.