Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Get Useful Feedback When Your Manager Gives None
Transcript
- Lucas: So here's a question that landed in the inbox this week — and I think it's going to resonate with a lot of you. The listener writes: 'My manager never gives me useful feedback. During our one-on-ones, she says everything is fine, or she gives me a generic good job, but I have no idea what I should actually keep doing or improve. How do I get real feedback without coming across as needy or difficult?' Luna: Oof. That is such a common frustration. I've been there myself — you walk out of a one-on-one with zero actionable intel and you're left guessing. Lucas: Right. And the instinct is to assume your manager just doesn't care or is bad at their job. But I think the reality is more nuanced. A lot of managers avoid giving specific feedback because it makes them uncomfortable — they're afraid of demotivating you, or they don't want to spend the emotional energy, or frankly they've never been trained to do it. Luna: Yeah, and if the company culture doesn't reward honest feedback, it's easier to just say 'you're doing great' and move on. So how do you break that cycle? Lucas: Look, before we get into tactics, I want to mention something briefly. If you're listening and you've ever found yourself stuck in a situation like this — wondering how to navigate a tricky work conversation — that's exactly why we make this show. We keep Office Hours completely ad-free, and that's only possible because listeners who find value in it choose to support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep this resource available to everyone. No pressure, just if it's helped you. Luna: Absolutely. And it's listeners like that who help us cover topics like this one — the practical, everyday stuff that can make a real difference in your career. Lucas: Alright, so back to the feedback problem. I want to give you three specific tactics. The first is about reframing how you ask. Instead of saying 'Can you give me some feedback?' — which is broad and puts the manager on the spot — try a more structured approach. Say something like: 'In the next quarter, what's the one skill you'd most like to see me develop to add more value to the team?' Luna: That's smart because it gives the manager a safe frame. It's not about what you're doing wrong — it's about future growth. And it's specific enough that they can't just say 'everything's fine.' Lucas: Exactly. You're essentially lowering the bar for them. They just have to name one thing. And if they still say 'I can't think of anything' — which happens — you can follow up with: 'Is there a project or skill you've seen someone else on the team excel at that you think would be useful for me to learn?' Luna: That's a nice pivot. You're not asking about your own performance directly, you're asking about capability gaps on the team. It feels less personal. Lucas: Right. And if that still doesn't work, you move to tactic two: the feedback sandwich. But I don't mean the old 'compliment criticism compliment' sandwich — that's been debunked. I mean you sandwich your request between two specific observations you've made about your own work. For example: 'I noticed that in the last sprint, I took longer than expected on the data analysis phase. I think I might be overcomplicating the approach. Could you watch how I handle that next time and give me pointers?' Luna: Oh, I like that. You're giving them something concrete to react to. It's almost like you're providing the raw material for their feedback. Lucas: Exactly. The manager doesn't have to generate feedback from scratch — they just have to confirm or adjust your self-assessment. That's way easier for them psychologically. And if they still say 'no, you're fine,' you can gently push: 'I appreciate that, but I think even small tweaks could save me a few hours. I'd love your perspective.' Luna: And if that still doesn't work? What's tactic three? Lucas: Tactic three is the most direct, and I recommend it only after the first two haven't worked for at least two one-on-ones. You schedule a separate meeting — call it a 'development check-in' or 'quarterly review' — and you frame it as: 'I want to make sure I'm on track for my goals this year. Could we spend 30 minutes reviewing my progress and identifying any blind spots?' Luna: So you're escalating the formality a little. It's no longer a casual ask during a regular one-on-one — it's a dedicated conversation. That signals to the manager that this matters to you. Lucas: Right. And in that meeting, you come with specific examples of your work and ask for a 'red flag review.' Say: 'If there's one thing I'm doing that, if left unaddressed, could hold back my promotion or my effectiveness in the next six months, I need to know it now.' That language — 'need to know' — shifts the frame from 'please give me feedback' to 'I need your help to avoid a future problem.' Luna: That's powerful because it makes the manager feel like they're being proactive in preventing a crisis, rather than critiquing you. Lucas: Exactly. And if they still dodge? Then you have a different problem — and you might need to find mentors elsewhere in the organization, or consider whether this manager is capable of supporting your growth long-term. But in my experience, most managers will respond to at least one of these three approaches. Luna: I want to add one more thing. This all assumes you're dealing with a manager who's well-meaning but untrained. But what if the feedback avoidance is more deliberate — like they're threatened by you or they want to keep you in the dark? Lucas: That's a real scenario, and it's harder. In that case, the tactics still help because they create a paper trail. You're documenting that you asked. If you ever need to escalate or leave, you have a record that you sought feedback and got nothing. But also, I'd suggest looking for feedback from peers, cross-functional partners, even clients — build a 360-degree view of your performance that doesn't depend solely on your manager. Luna: Yeah, that's a smart hedge. And honestly, a manager who withholds feedback deliberately is a red flag. At that point, your best career move might be to start looking internally or externally for a role where growth is actually supported. Lucas: Let me give you a real example. A listener — let's call her Priya — was in this exact situation. She was a marketing manager at a mid-sized tech company. Her boss, the VP of Marketing, would say things like 'you're crushing it' in their one-on-ones, but she never got detailed feedback. She tried tactic one — asking about skills to develop — and got 'you're good, keep doing what you're doing.' So she tried tactic two: she brought a specific campaign she ran and said, 'I think the email open rate was lower than expected. How would you have approached the subject line?' Luna: And did the VP bite? Lucas: She did. The VP actually said, 'Oh, I would have tested a more urgent tone. Let me show you our old A/B test results.' And that opened a 15-minute coaching conversation. Priya told me that after that, she started bringing one specific deliverable to every one-on-one and framing it as a 'could this be better?' — and over time, the VP got used to giving her real input. It became their normal. Luna: That's such a great example of how a small change in your approach can rewire the dynamic. You're essentially training your manager to give feedback. Lucas: Exactly. And the key is consistency. The first time might feel awkward, but after three or four meetings where you model the kind of specific, constructive conversation you want, most managers will meet you there. Luna: Alright, so let's recap. Tactic one: reframe your ask around future growth. Tactic two: use a self-assessment sandwich to give them something to react to. Tactic three: schedule a dedicated development check-in and use the 'red flag review' language. Lucas: And bonus: if you've tried all three and still get nothing, it's time to build feedback channels elsewhere and potentially re-evaluate whether this manager is the right person to support your career. But in most cases, one of these will work. Luna: Great episode. If you have a career question you'd like us to tackle, send it in. And for those who support the show — we see you, and we appreciate you. Lucas: Yeah, thanks for listening, and we'll catch you next time.