Latest / 5 Minute UX / Economy of Elements (Chartjunk): How to Evaluate Effectively
Transcript
- 0:08This lesson is Economy of Elements (Chartjunk): How to
- 0:12Evaluate Effectively. Let's get started.
- 0:21Stop calling designs cluttered. It’s vague, unhelpful, and stops
- 0:24progress. Instead, shift from aesthetic judgment to functional
- 0:28assessment. You need to ask if every element serves a user goal
- 0:31or just decorates the screen. Economy of elements means
- 0:33minimizing chartjunk. It’s about distinguishing necessary
- 0:36complexity from visual noise that hinders usability. You
- 0:39just spent hours debating button colors while users couldn’t find
- 0:42the checkout option. That’s the pain of aesthetic focus. When
- 0:45you evaluate based on function, clarity emerges. You can
- 0:48identify the four primary evaluation dimensions:
- 0:50accessibility, findability, readability, and usability.
- 0:53Measure content against these attributes. Does it help users
- 0:56achieve their top tasks? Can they identify their next best
- 0:59action without distraction? If not, it’s weak work. Strong
- 1:02work adheres to writing standards and uses a value
- 1:05filter. Every element must provide tangible value. Weak
- 1:07work obscures goals. Apply severity ratings to distinguish
- 1:10between high-impact usability blockers and low-impact brand
- 1:13deviations. Blockers get fixed first. That's your Fix on
- 1:16evaluating chartjunk!
- 1:24By the end of this section, you'll be able to identify the
- 1:26four primary evaluation dimensions: accessibility,
- 1:29findability, readability, and usability. These attributes
- 1:31shift your focus from aesthetic preference to functional impact.
- 1:34You'll learn to describe signals of strong work, such as
- 1:37adherence to writing standards and value-filtered content. This
- 1:40ensures every element earns its place on the screen. Start by
- 1:43defining clear writing standards for your projects. Strong work
- 1:46adheres to these standards for voice and clarity. It optimizes
- 1:49engagement through a value filter, ensuring tangible user
- 1:51value. When teams do this well, users find information easily
- 1:54without distraction. The design supports their ability to take
- 1:57appropriate actions. Weak work often fails to help users
- 2:00achieve their top tasks. Look for content that is not
- 2:02actionable. If a user cannot identify their next best action,
- 2:05the design suffers from poor economy. Clutter obscures the
- 2:08path forward, blocking goal completion. This is a high-
- 2:10severity issue in any usability review. Apply severity ratings
- 2:13to distinguish between usability blockers and brand deviations.
- 2:16Issues preventing task completion rate as high
- 2:18severity. Minor voice deviations may be lower severity if they
- 2:21don't impede usability. This structured approach prevents
- 2:24vague aesthetic opinions from dominating feedback. Implement
- 2:27continuous critique sessions to involve the broader team.
- 2:29Actionable feedback references specific attributes, like how an
- 2:32element affects readability. Instead of calling a design
- 2:35"cluttered," explain how it obscures the next best action.
- 2:38This drives meaningful improvements in design quality.
- 2:47The sequence begins by shifting your focus from aesthetic
- 2:49preference to functional assessment. You need to evaluate
- 2:52whether every visual element serves a clear purpose. This
- 2:54means measuring content against four primary evaluation
- 2:57dimensions: accessibility, findability, readability, and
- 2:59usability. When you ground your review in these attributes, you
- 3:02distinguish necessary complexity from noise. Strong work is
- 3:05indicated by clear writing standards for voice and clarity.
- 3:07You should look for content optimized through a value
- 3:10filter, ensuring every element provides tangible value. This
- 3:12rigor maintains brand equity while helping users understand
- 3:15the interface. The design supports the user’s ability to
- 3:17find information easily. It allows them to take appropriate
- 3:20actions without distraction. Conversely, weak work manifests
- 3:23as a lack of alignment with user goals. Reviewers should identify
- 3:25content that fails to help users achieve their top tasks. If the
- 3:28design is cluttered with non- functional elements, usability
- 3:31suffers. You will notice that users cannot clearly identify
- 3:34their next best action. This signals that the economy of
- 3:36elements has broken down. Brand equity is at risk when you see
- 3:39deviations from established writing standards. These
- 3:41deviations signal a lack of rigor, even if they do not
- 3:43immediately block usability. High-severity issues prevent
- 3:46goal completion, so they demand immediate attention. Lower-
- 3:49severity issues, like minor voice inconsistencies, still
- 3:51erode trust over time. You must apply severity ratings to
- 3:54distinguish between these impacts. A common reviewer
- 3:56error is focusing solely on aesthetic preferences. This
- 3:58leads to isolated feedback that misses functional goals like
- 4:01usability. Instead, leverage continuous critique practices to
- 4:04involve the broader team. Actionable feedback references
- 4:06specific attributes, such as how an element affects readability.
- 4:09It identifies whether a detail obscures the next best action.
- 4:12This approach drives meaningful improvements in design quality.
- 4:21Here is how this works in practice when you sit down to
- 4:24review a design. Start by defining clear writing standards
- 4:26and quality attributes for your projects, including
- 4:28accessibility and usability metrics. This sets the baseline.
- 4:31You are no longer guessing if something looks right. You are
- 4:33measuring it against a known standard. Let’s say you are
- 4:36reviewing a dashboard with too many charts. Do not just say it
- 4:38looks cluttered. That is vague. Instead, ask whether each
- 4:41element helps the user achieve their top tasks or identify
- 4:43their next best action. If a chart hides the primary button,
- 4:46it fails the test. The evaluation should determine if
- 4:48the design elements help users achieve their top tasks or goals
- 4:51when interacting with the product. If they do not, they
- 4:53are chartjunk. Now, apply the severity framework. Issues that
- 4:56prevent users from achieving their top tasks or identifying
- 4:58their next best action should be rated as high severity. These
- 5:01are blockers. They stop the work. But what about a font
- 5:03choice that slightly misses the brand guide? Minor deviations
- 5:06from writing standards or brand voice, while important for brand
- 5:08equity, may be rated as lower severity if they do not impede
- 5:11usability. Distinguish between what breaks the flow and what
- 5:14just needs a polish. This distinction saves your team from
- 5:16arguing over pixels when the navigation is broken. Make your
- 5:19feedback actionable by referencing specific attributes.
- 5:21Tell the designer how a particular element affects
- 5:23readability or whether it obscures the next best action
- 5:25for the user. This gives them a clear path to fix it. You are
- 5:28identifying specific growth opportunities rather than
- 5:30offering vague aesthetic opinions. This builds trust in
- 5:33the critique process. Finally, implement continuous critique
- 5:35sessions to involve the broader team. This ensures that feedback
- 5:38is constructive, identifies growth opportunities, and drives
- 5:41meaningful improvements in design quality. When teams do
- 5:43this well, training needs surface naturally. You uncover
- 5:45who needs support on accessibility or findability.
- 5:47The reverse pattern shows up in the field as isolated reviews
- 5:50that miss systemic issues. By involving everyone, you turn a
- 5:53single design review into a team-wide learning moment. This
- 5:55is how you evaluate effectively.
- 6:04Pause and think about your last project review. Did you catch
- 6:07the chartjunk, or just judge the aesthetics? You need to evaluate
- 6:11design artifacts for economy of elements using functional
- 6:13quality attributes. Start by identifying the four primary
- 6:16evaluation dimensions: accessibility, findability,
- 6:19readability, and usability. Look at a sample interface. Find one
- 6:22element that fails the actionability test. Does it help
- 6:24the user achieve their top tasks? If not, it’s noise. Now,
- 6:27apply severity ratings. If that element blocks a top task, rate
- 6:30it high severity. If it’s just a minor brand deviation, keep it
- 6:33low. The difference is clear. Strong work helps users identify
- 6:36their next best action without distraction. Weak work leaves
- 6:39them lost. Make your feedback specific. Don’t say it’s
- 6:42cluttered. Say it hurts readability. Then, define clear
- 6:45writing standards for your next project. Ask specific questions
- 6:48during critique sessions. Does every element support the user
- 6:51goal? This shifts your team from vague opinions to actionable
- 6:54improvements. You’ll catch the trade-offs sooner. The result is
- 6:57cleaner, more effective design.
- 7:01Welcome to The Take. I'm joined by a fellow practitioner and
- 7:04together we're going to dig into Economy of Elements (Chartjunk):
- 7:08How to Evaluate Effectively — what it means in practice and
- 7:11what's worth remembering.