Latest / Deep Thoughts About Stupid Sh*t: A Pop-Culture Comedy Podcast / Deep Thoughts about Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory
Transcript
- 0:00Emily Guy Birken: I'm Emily Guy-Burken and you're listening to Deep Thoughts about Stupid Shit, because pop culture is still culture, and shouldn't you know what's in your head?
- 0:08Emily Guy Birken: On today's episode, I will be discussing the 1971 classic Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory with my sister, tracy Guy Decker, and with you.
- 0:18Emily Guy Birken: Let's dive in.
- 0:21Tracie Guy-Decker: Have you ever had something you love dismissed because it's just pop culture, what others might deem stupid shit?
- 0:28Tracie Guy-Decker: You know matters.
- 0:30Tracie Guy-Decker: You know it's worth talking and thinking about, and so do we.
- 0:33Tracie Guy-Decker: So come over, think with us as we delve into our deep thoughts about Stupid Shit.
- 0:38Tracie Guy-Decker: This show is a labor of love, but that doesn't make it free to produce.
- 0:42Tracie Guy-Decker: If you enjoy it even half as much as we do, please consider helping to keep us overthinking.
- 0:48Tracie Guy-Decker: You can support us at our Patreon there's a link in the show notes or leave a positive review so others can find us and, of course, share the show with your people.
- 0:58Emily Guy Birken: So Trace, this is a shared movie from our childhood.
- 1:03Emily Guy Birken: It actually came out before either of us were born and was already a classic in the 80s by the time we were watching it.
- 1:12Emily Guy Birken: But can you tell me what you remember about this version of the story, because there's been multiple ones, and this is the classic with Gene Wilder, there was the remake with Johnny Depp that really kind of missed the mark, and now there is a new prequel out with Timothy Chalamet.
- 1:34Emily Guy Birken: So we want to go back to the basics, back to the original.
- 1:38Emily Guy Birken: So tell me about your experience with this movie.
- 1:42Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, it, definitely.
- 1:44Tracie Guy-Decker: This is one of those like building blocks of my childhood, our childhood for sure.
- 1:48Tracie Guy-Decker: I have very distinct memories of watching it at Grandma's house, grandma Betta's house, mm-hmm, I think the things that come up first for me is the music, actually, with Gene Wilder singing about pure imagination, with the sort of scary one when they're on the boat, the scary song.
- 2:05Tracie Guy-Decker: Those are some of the things that come up first, and then immediately actually from Ted Lasso, which I don't think you watched yet.
- 2:13Tracie Guy-Decker: You should watch it, you'll enjoy it.
- 2:15Tracie Guy-Decker: But from Ted Lasso there's like a brief interaction about this story where one of the characters, leslie, says to Rebecca something like, oh, and all those children died in that factory.
- 2:27Tracie Guy-Decker: And Rebecca is like, no, that's not what happened.
- 2:29Tracie Guy-Decker: And Leslie like Rebecca I'm sorry, those children are dead and like something about like Leslie is a man and he's just like very earnest and like sweet and something about his delivery.
- 2:42Tracie Guy-Decker: I was like, oh, my God, he's right, those children are dead, and like it's just totally like colored my thinking about it.
- 2:50Tracie Guy-Decker: So there's I'm sure there's lots more.
- 2:55Tracie Guy-Decker: There's lots of like moments that I remember, as like the snapshots of them that kind of bubble up as memories.
- 3:02Tracie Guy-Decker: But I don't need to get into those.
- 3:03Tracie Guy-Decker: I'm sure that some of them will come up and I know there's a lot there.
- 3:08Tracie Guy-Decker: Like, roald Dahl has become sort of a controversial figure.
- 3:12Tracie Guy-Decker: He's the guy who wrote the book in the first place for various good reasons that I expect you'll get into.
- 3:18Tracie Guy-Decker: And yeah, there's some less savory things.
- 3:20Tracie Guy-Decker: I have a feeling hiding underneath the fun songs about imagination and the Oopaloopas judging us.
- 3:29Tracie Guy-Decker: But yeah, tell me what's at stake.
- 3:34Tracie Guy-Decker: Why are we talking about Charlie and the Chocolate Factory today?
- 3:38Emily Guy Birken: So I loved the film as a kid, really really loved it.
- 3:43Emily Guy Birken: I'm sure I know I saw the film before I read the book, but Charlie and the Chocolate Factory became one of the books that I read over and over, and over and over again.
- 3:51Emily Guy Birken: It's one of the early ones I can remember just always wanting to pick up and reread, which has become a habit of mine over a lifetime.
- 4:02Emily Guy Birken: I did that also with James and the Giant Peach, but I think I like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory even a little bit more, so for me there's like a personal connection to this story.
- 4:11Emily Guy Birken: It also I got to be the eight year old going, oh, the book's better, which I appreciate it, which is actually one of the reasons why, when the 2005 Tim Burton film with Johnny Depp came out, I was not immediately horrified because I was just like, oh, ok, well, it'll be closer to the actual book Because there are quite a few changes.
- 4:36Emily Guy Birken: Some of them had to do with the fact that it's not an easy story to film with 1971 technology, and then some of it just had to do with the changes that were made in the process.
- 4:47Emily Guy Birken: But so, like originally, I was just like, yeah, I'm excited to see the Tim Burton version because you know I might be closer to the book and it was but I'm not a fan of that version.
- 4:58Emily Guy Birken: In any case, it was an important part of my literary DNA, my childhood.
- 5:07Emily Guy Birken: I recently rewatched it with my kids.
- 5:11Emily Guy Birken: They both loved it, and what is amazing to me is how well this movie is made.
- 5:20Emily Guy Birken: So the scene when Charlie finds the golden ticket, it is a huge thing.
- 5:27Emily Guy Birken: It is a child unwrapping a candy bar, and the directorial choices, the camera choices, the acting choices they asked Peter Ostrom to do.
- 5:41Emily Guy Birken: The boy played Charlie, the music, all of that.
- 5:45Emily Guy Birken: They do such a good job that you are on the edge of your seat watching a little boy unwrap a candy bar.
- 5:51Emily Guy Birken: And so that is part of the reason why this film has remained beloved for over 50 years now and why, even very close to the end of his life, jean Wilder was still getting like it's Willy Wonka from people as he went out and about.
- 6:11Emily Guy Birken: So like.
- 6:13Emily Guy Birken: The film is a masterpiece and it is one that I am very glad to introduce my kids to.
- 6:22Emily Guy Birken: In terms of how to tell a story, what choices can be made to raise stakes for something, particularly when there are things that don't make much sense if you think about them logically, and my love for Jean Wilder comes originally from this film.
- 6:41Emily Guy Birken: There are many others that I love him in, but this was how I was first introduced to him, and he is amazing, magnetic, magical, mysterious, terrifying all of those things.
- 6:54Emily Guy Birken: And there is a core of sweetness under it all, even under the terrifying aspects.
- 6:59Emily Guy Birken: So this is an important movie.
- 7:01Emily Guy Birken: You know, it's an important movie for me, it's an important movie for our culture, but there are some really ugly undersides to this and I think that we can trace them directly to Roald Dahl and some of them, like there's some, some dark undercurrents that are just, I think, good storytelling.
- 7:23Emily Guy Birken: You know, the fact that Willy Wonka is not entirely trustworthy as a character is not necessarily a bad thing about a children's movie.
- 7:31Emily Guy Birken: The fact that terrible things happen to children is not necessarily a bad thing in a children's movie.
- 7:38Emily Guy Birken: But there are other aspects of the story that I think deserve our scrutiny and that we should really really be cautious about what that lesson is, that we're taking in, that we're imbibing and we're teaching our children without looking at it closer.
- 7:57Tracie Guy-Decker: All right, let's catch everybody up.
- 7:59Tracie Guy-Decker: I mean, it's an over 15 year old movie.
- 8:01Tracie Guy-Decker: As you say, it's important to the culture, so I think a lot of our listeners have probably seen it.
- 8:05Tracie Guy-Decker: But let's just do the quick, like what happened in this movie.
- 8:09Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, quick, quick thumbnail.
- 8:11Emily Guy Birken: So this movie is about Charlie Bucket.
- 8:15Emily Guy Birken: They changed it to Willy Wonka and the chocolate factory, even though the book was called Charlie and the chocolate factory.
- 8:20Emily Guy Birken: So Charlie lives in the same town as the Wonka chocolate factory, which has been closed to factory workers for some period of time, like 15, 20 years since, longer than Charlie's been alive and he's about 10.
- 8:36Emily Guy Birken: But it still is producing chocolate and nobody knows how.
- 8:40Emily Guy Birken: Charlie is extremely poor.
- 8:43Emily Guy Birken: He lives with his mother and his four grandparents, Grandpa Joe, oh yeah, all in the same bed.
- 8:48Tracie Guy-Decker: All in the same bed, grandpa, joe, grandma.
- 8:50Emily Guy Birken: Josephine, grandpa George and Grandma Georgina.
- 8:53Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, yeah, much a narcissistic grandparents Married people with their same name.
- 9:00Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, okay, yes.
- 9:02Emily Guy Birken: So he lives with them.
- 9:04Emily Guy Birken: We don't know where in the book his father is there as well, but in the film presumably he's dead because his parents are still living with them.
- 9:13Emily Guy Birken: His mother works as a in a laundry or something like that, and Charlie has a paper route to bring some money in, because otherwise all they eat is cabbage soup.
- 9:24Emily Guy Birken: There is a major announcement that Wonka will be opening up the factory for five lucky individuals who find a golden ticket in one of the candy bars, and so first half of the movie is basically about the first four people who find tickets.
- 9:42Emily Guy Birken: There is Augustus Gloop, who is a child in Germany who it is made clear that he is kind of a glutton, as are his parents.
- 9:51Emily Guy Birken: Then there is Veruca Salt, who is the British daughter of a man who has a nut factory.
- 9:58Emily Guy Birken: He has, like this huge production line of people who shell peanuts for him, and he puts the production line at work to open candy bars to find the golden ticket for Veruca.
- 10:08Emily Guy Birken: There is Violet Beauregard, who is actually an American gum chewer, but she puts the gum aside for a little while until she can find a golden ticket.
- 10:18Emily Guy Birken: She is from Montana.
- 10:19Emily Guy Birken: Then there's Mike TV who, if I remember correctly, is from Arizona, who is a kid who loves television.
- 10:26Emily Guy Birken: His mom actually says he's never eaten a meal at the dining room table because he always eats it in front of the TV.
- 10:32Emily Guy Birken: People are led to believe that the fifth ticket has been found.
- 10:34Emily Guy Birken: Charlie happens to find money in the street.
- 10:37Emily Guy Birken: He buys a chocolate bar for himself with the money and he's starving because of how little he gets to eat.
- 10:43Emily Guy Birken: He just swallows it down.
- 10:45Emily Guy Birken: He's about to take the rest of the money because he found a dollar the other 90 cents to go home to give to his family.
- 10:53Emily Guy Birken: He decides you know what?
- 10:54Emily Guy Birken: No, I'm going to get a chocolate bar for Grandpa Joe.
- 10:56Emily Guy Birken: He gets a chocolate bar and learns as he's walking home that there is one ticket left.
- 11:04Emily Guy Birken: He opens his candy and finds it there.
- 11:06Emily Guy Birken: On his way home he is stopped by Slugworth, who was the main rival to Willy Wonka, who offers him money beyond his wildest dreams and security for his family if he can give him an everlasting gobstopper from out of the Wonka factory, despite the fact that he has been in bed for 20 years.
- 11:26Emily Guy Birken: Grandpa Joe, as soon as he has a reason to get up, gets up and dances around because we've got a golden ticket.
- 11:33Emily Guy Birken: He does stumble a little.
- 11:35Emily Guy Birken: He does stumble a little.
- 11:36Emily Guy Birken: They end up on the factory tour which is the very next day we meet.
- 11:43Emily Guy Birken: When we meet Willy Wonka, he comes out of the factory on a cane and is like kind of stumbling his way to the front gate.
- 11:52Emily Guy Birken: His cane at one point stops, gets stuck in the cobblestones.
- 11:57Emily Guy Birken: He kind of stumbles a little bit and then does a forward flip and jumps up.
- 12:03Emily Guy Birken: Apparently Gene Wilder insisted on that.
- 12:06Emily Guy Birken: He wanted it to be clear from the very beginning that you can never know if you can trust anything from this character.
- 12:12Emily Guy Birken: The reactions of the children were genuine because they did not know how he was going to enter.
- 12:18Emily Guy Birken: They come in and they start seeing the crazy, weird, wild stuff in the factory, starting with the main chocolate floor, which is actually a river of chocolate through a candy meadow.
- 12:32Emily Guy Birken: We start to lose the children one by one.
- 12:34Emily Guy Birken: First is Augustus Glup, who is drinking the chocolate out of the river, and he gets sucked into the river and then up through a tube into the marshmallow room, I think.
- 12:43Emily Guy Birken: Next is Violet Beauregard who tries a gum that Willy Wonka has made that creates a full meal.
- 12:53Emily Guy Birken: It works until she gets the blueberry pie when she turns into a blueberry.
- 12:57Emily Guy Birken: Then is Ruka Salt, who wants one of the geese that lays golden eggs.
- 13:04Emily Guy Birken: She jumps on top of the scale that determines if it's a good egg or a bad egg, and is determined to be a bad egg, she gets shoved into the garbage chute.
- 13:13Emily Guy Birken: Miketv decides to go through the TV.
- 13:17Emily Guy Birken: They use a huge chocolate bar that they then send through the TV that you can reach into the TV and take out.
- 13:23Emily Guy Birken: Mike wants to do that too, so he goes from being a normal kid to being six inches high.
- 13:27Emily Guy Birken: Meanwhile Wonka's workers, who are oompa-loompas, which is a fake people, who are only about knee high, according to the book sing about what the children have done wrong and otherwise don't really interact with the kids.
- 13:44Emily Guy Birken: By the end of the tour it's just Charlie.
- 13:46Emily Guy Birken: In that time there was one point where his grandfather convinced him to try a fizzy lifting drink, even though they were told not to.
- 13:53Emily Guy Birken: Charlie says well, can I have the lifetime supply of chocolate now?
- 13:59Emily Guy Birken: Wonka says you get nothing because you broke the rules.
- 14:03Emily Guy Birken: Grandpa Joe says we're leaving and if Slugworth wants his everlasting gobstopper, he's going to get it.
- 14:09Emily Guy Birken: Charlie returns it to Mr Wonka, who puts his hand over it and says so shines a bright deed in a weary world, and he then says you've won.
- 14:19Emily Guy Birken: You've won everything, charlie.
- 14:20Emily Guy Birken: And he reveals that this entire stunt was to find an heir.
- 14:25Emily Guy Birken: He wanted a child to take over for him because he wants to keep making chocolate in the same way, with the same magical way, and an adult would have their own opinions on things.
- 14:38Emily Guy Birken: So he wants a child who he can teach, and the film ends with him going in the great class elevator which goes up through the ceiling of the factory and floats over the over the city, and that is the end of the film.
- 14:51Emily Guy Birken: Yeah that's a lot, so let me start with Roald Dahl, who was a hell of a writer.
- 14:57Emily Guy Birken: It's interesting that he's known for his children's stories, so Matilda, charlie the Chocolate Factory, the BFG, james and the Giant Peach, charlie and the Great Class, which was the sequel to Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.
- 15:09Emily Guy Birken: I'm sure I'm forgetting some, because he did not like children.
- 15:15Tracie Guy-Decker: He didn't.
- 15:16Emily Guy Birken: And he made it from Charlie.
- 15:17Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, I have read some of his short stories that were intended for adults that have very similar kind of bloodthirstiness with endicoding.
- 15:30Emily Guy Birken: So for instance, there's a.
- 15:33Emily Guy Birken: One of his most famous short stories is about a woman who murders her husband with a frozen leg of lamb.
- 15:39Emily Guy Birken: She's just just done done with him, and so she clubs him over the head with a frozen leg of lamb, then she puts it in the oven and serves it to the police officers who come to investigate the murder.
- 15:52Emily Guy Birken: So similar kind of like playfulness and menace in there.
- 15:59Emily Guy Birken: There's quite a bit of that kind of like irony and playful menace.
- 16:06Emily Guy Birken: So I have immense respect for his abilities.
- 16:08Emily Guy Birken: I also have immense respect.
- 16:11Emily Guy Birken: He lost one of his children to I can't remember if it was the measles, something that there is now a vaccine for and there was not when she died and he was very vocal about the fact that her life would have been saved by these vaccines, because vaccine denial is something that has happened every time we've come up with vaccines throughout history.
- 16:34Emily Guy Birken: So I have a great deal of respect for that.
- 16:36Emily Guy Birken: Dahl, however, would not like me because he was an anti-semite.
- 16:43Emily Guy Birken: He actually said, yeah, hitler may have been a stinker, but he kind of had a point about the Jews.
- 16:52Tracie Guy-Decker: Whoa.
- 16:54Emily Guy Birken: And that's the word stinker Like.
- 16:58Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, that's the word that I want to use for the man responsible for 11 million deaths.
- 17:03Tracie Guy-Decker: So ew Was he American.
- 17:36Emily Guy Birken: No, he was British, very British.
- 17:38Emily Guy Birken: Yes, he knew Ian Fleming Like I think they served together in the war.
- 17:41Emily Guy Birken: The guy who wrote James Bond yeah.
- 17:45Tracie Guy-Decker: So, like Willy Wonka and James Bond, Like we share a cinematic universe.
- 17:50Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah.
- 17:53Emily Guy Birken: And I think a lot of the negativity that I see, the things that I find very distasteful about Willy Wonka and the books that I imbibed and loved as a child, stem from Roald Dahl's early 20th century Britishness.
- 18:14Tracie Guy-Decker: In a lot of ways.
- 18:15Emily Guy Birken: He was very much an imperialist, whether or not he described himself that way.
- 18:21Emily Guy Birken: So let's talk about the Oompa-Lompas.
- 18:24Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah.
- 18:25Emily Guy Birken: So the Oompa-Lompas are Willy Wonka's workers who he rescued from Loompa land where they were menaced by horrible creatures like verminous knids and wang doodles.
- 18:38Emily Guy Birken: And in the addition that I read, there were illustrations of the Oompa-Lompas and they were clearly shown to have brown skin and were intended to look like Africans or maybe South Asians South Asians, yes.
- 19:00Emily Guy Birken: So when they made the 1971 film, it was already like oh, we can't do that.
- 19:08Emily Guy Birken: And I believe there were other editions where even Roald Dahl was like maybe we should change the illustrations.
- 19:15Emily Guy Birken: But they gave them the orange skin and green hair to make it clear that they are not humans.
- 19:21Tracie Guy-Decker: Right.
- 19:22Emily Guy Birken: But the way that Wonka talks about them is he doesn't have to pay them because all they want is chocolate or cocoa beans Cocoa beans, yeah yeah, which kind of sounds like oh yeah, we paid for the Isle of Manhattan with beads.
- 19:38Emily Guy Birken: You know, this is like that's really uncomfortable.
- 19:43Emily Guy Birken: And there is this like white saviorism of like Willy Wonka saved them from this horrible place and brought them to a factory where they don't see the light of day.
- 19:55Tracie Guy-Decker: Right when they work for no pay.
- 19:58Tracie Guy-Decker: Work for no pay or pay in food?
- 20:01Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, and where?
- 20:05Emily Guy Birken: Considering the fact that Wonka knows he's not going to live forever or he chooses some random kid to be his successor, rather, than who is white, rather than one of the Oompa Loompas who have been working for him for years and know the entire process already, and our adults, and can teach others, and I mean, and should be rewarded for their work as well.
- 20:30Emily Guy Birken: So, yikes, that's worrisome.
- 20:36Tracie Guy-Decker: Even the way that, even within the Gene Wilder movie, to the way that the Oompa Loompas interact with Wonka right, like he has that weird little flute that he plays, that they then show up, and then there's it's very, it's very differential.
- 20:53Tracie Guy-Decker: The hierarchy is very, very clear.
- 20:56Emily Guy Birken: Yes, and so the fact that you know all five of the children who find the golden tickets.
- 21:03Emily Guy Birken: Now, when I was a kid, I remember being like why is it all kids who found golden tickets?
- 21:07Emily Guy Birken: You know that just doesn't make sense to me Like grownups, like Candy 2.
- 21:11Emily Guy Birken: As I got older, I was like, why are all five of them white and speak English, with the exception of Augustus Gloop?
- 21:18Emily Guy Birken: I mean, he does speak English, but he's got a German accent.
- 21:22Emily Guy Birken: You know, like what's going on here.
- 21:24Emily Guy Birken: And then the fact that the one that Willy Wonka chooses is the blonde, blue eyed kid.
- 21:32Emily Guy Birken: No, I don't remember how Charlie was described in the book.
- 21:36Emily Guy Birken: So that's casting decision.
- 21:40Emily Guy Birken: Peter Ostrom did an amazing job and one of the things that I most appreciate about Peter Ostrom is that he refused to sign a deal to make multiple movies.
- 21:52Emily Guy Birken: He made the one and then he was done and he is a large animal vet now.
- 21:57Emily Guy Birken: Wow, yeah, I don't know how he came to that decision.
- 21:59Emily Guy Birken: Don't know if that was his parents or if he just was a very, very preternaturally wise young kid who was like, yeah, this was fun, but I don't need to do this anymore.
- 22:10Emily Guy Birken: But yeah, and I'm reminded of I don't know if you remember this, but I know Dad was horrified by, like the way child actors are exploited.
- 22:21Emily Guy Birken: But you need children in movies, like you can't make movies without child actors, at least sometimes.
- 22:28Emily Guy Birken: And he's like they should only be allowed to make one film and then that's it.
- 22:32Emily Guy Birken: What's an option of coming back when they're 18.
- 22:34Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, I remember him saying that.
- 22:37Tracie Guy-Decker: I think actually Drew Barrymore is the one that when I that I remember him saying that about, I think he saw us, and Drew Barrymore because she's about my age, yeah, yeah, and so, like I think that's the one that I remember the most and so like I feel like Peter Ostrom is like the template for that.
- 22:56Emily Guy Birken: So, in any case, the racism, colonialism, imperialism, like white saviorism, just inherent in the idea of Willy Wonka finding these people telling them oh, your homeland is awful, Come with me and be my slaves, basically yeah.
- 23:18Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, kind of horrific.
- 23:19Emily Guy Birken: And you cannot remove the Oompa Loompas from the story of Willy Wonka, like that is an integral part of it and that's something to kind of fix it in the Timothy Chalamet version.
- 23:29Emily Guy Birken: I haven't seen it yet, but I've read some articles about it.
- 23:33Emily Guy Birken: I'm not super interested in it as a story but in terms of imagery it looks gorgeous Like that that I want to see.
- 23:41Emily Guy Birken: But the explanation they give is that like the Hugh Grant as Anupalumpa would steal people's chocolate and so like part of what the Timothy Chalamet's Wonka is doing is like oh, ok, I'll give it to you so you don't have to steal it and you know if you work for me.
- 23:59Emily Guy Birken: I don't know if that makes it better.
- 24:01Emily Guy Birken: Is he the only?
- 24:03Emily Guy Birken: I think he's the only one in this, but I'm not sure I mean.
- 24:07Tracie Guy-Decker: I think a singular actually does make it better.
- 24:09Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, I'm not saying it makes it OK, I haven't seen it yet but there's a does feel like a big difference between, like, taking an entire people from their homeland, rescuing them with air quotes in order to serve you in your factory, versus one individual.
- 24:25Tracie Guy-Decker: That does feel different.
- 24:27Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, yeah.
- 24:28Emily Guy Birken: So there's, that's big, big, it's a big ugly.
- 24:36Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, that's a mark in the hole.
- 24:37Tracie Guy-Decker: That's a structurally ugly Like.
- 24:39Tracie Guy-Decker: That's a piece of ugly structure in the storytelling.
- 24:42Tracie Guy-Decker: It's not like a yeah, it's not just a layer.
- 24:46Emily Guy Birken: that you could sort of wipe away.
- 24:49Emily Guy Birken: So that gets to another aspect of this that I definitely did not catch as a kid, and that is how weirdly pro capitalist the story is and pro ruling class.
- 25:06Emily Guy Birken: So we find out when Charlie refuses to sell the everlasting gobstopper that slug worth isn't actually slug worth.
- 25:16Emily Guy Birken: He's someone who his name is Mr Wilkins and he works for for Wonka and this part I don't believe was in the book, I believe this was added for the film when Charlie returns the everlasting gobstopper and is like I'm not going to sell your secrets, that shows how pure of heart Charlie is.
- 25:36Emily Guy Birken: The thing is based on Charlie's understanding of what's happening.
- 25:45Emily Guy Birken: That is objectively the wrong thing to do.
- 25:47Emily Guy Birken: His family lives in poverty, he is constantly starving, his grandparents share a single bed, his mother is works backbreaking labor and this one piece of candy from a man who has been cruel to him could ensure that the security of his family for life.
- 26:12Emily Guy Birken: And once I saw it that way, I couldn't like.
- 26:19Emily Guy Birken: That blew my mind because you know I was, you know, gold star achieving rule follower as a kid.
- 26:25Emily Guy Birken: And so of course Charlie does the right thing.
- 26:28Emily Guy Birken: Of course he does the right thing of giving that back.
- 26:32Tracie Guy-Decker: Well, that's the message of the movie as well.
- 26:34Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes, I mean that is absolutely.
- 26:35Tracie Guy-Decker: He gets rewarded for it.
- 26:37Tracie Guy-Decker: Absolutely.
- 26:38Tracie Guy-Decker: That is the message we are given.
- 26:40Tracie Guy-Decker: Is that this?
- 26:40Emily Guy Birken: is the right thing to do.
- 26:42Tracie Guy-Decker: But you're right he's.
- 26:43Tracie Guy-Decker: He is respecting the intellectual property of a cruel man over the needs of his own family.
- 26:50Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes, and it's the intellectual property as well.
- 26:53Tracie Guy-Decker: He's not actually like he's not stealing from Wonka, right?
- 26:58Emily Guy Birken: Exactly.
- 27:00Tracie Guy-Decker: He's stealing intellectual property, but it's not as though he is keeping Wonka.
- 27:05Tracie Guy-Decker: He's not even keeping Wonka from making money in the future, right?
- 27:09Tracie Guy-Decker: So he's not even stealing from Wonka's future, yeah, yeah.
- 27:16Emily Guy Birken: And boy, that's a mess.
- 27:17Emily Guy Birken: Now it's a good thing that Charlie did return it, because Slughworth wasn't real and they wouldn't have had the security.
- 27:25Emily Guy Birken: But he didn't know that, just as he didn't know that, like at the end of the tour, he wasn't going to get what he was promised.
- 27:32Emily Guy Birken: The other aspect of it is, by choosing a successor the way that he does, wonka is hoarding generational wealth instead of sharing it with his workers, and he is ensuring that there is no change or innovation or anything like.
- 27:51Emily Guy Birken: He is going to mold Charlie in his own image, which is deeply disturbing.
- 27:58Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, there's also in terms of the pro capitalism message, like by shuttering the factory to workers, Wonka has decimated this town Right and as viewers we're meant to sympathize with him for that.
- 28:14Tracie Guy-Decker: We're meant to think he has made the right choice by enslaving these obliquas so that he doesn't have to pay the folks who live around the factory.
- 28:27Emily Guy Birken: Well, the reason why he shuttered the factory was because Slughworth and other candy makers were sending in spies as workers.
- 28:35Emily Guy Birken: So it wasn't that he didn't want to pay the workers, necessarily.
- 28:41Emily Guy Birken: No, I understand.
- 28:42Tracie Guy-Decker: I understand, but nevertheless, that is the impact, regardless of the intention.
- 28:47Tracie Guy-Decker: And, as I said, like so your competitor has a similar product.
- 28:54Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, that's the way markets work.
- 29:00Emily Guy Birken: That's also like, that's kind of the like, the pro deregulated capitalism, it's pro monopoly really is what it is.
- 29:07Tracie Guy-Decker: That's what it is.
- 29:08Tracie Guy-Decker: It's pro monopoly because ultimately that is how markets work If you have a product that has a market share and competitors can recreate it, even approximate it.
- 29:20Tracie Guy-Decker: That's how capitalism works.
- 29:23Tracie Guy-Decker: The demand somebody is going to supply, mm, hmm, mm hmm.
- 29:29Emily Guy Birken: Well, and it's.
- 29:30Emily Guy Birken: It always struck me as really weird that the everlasting gobstopper was the thing that Slughworth wanted, because that is not going to be a moneymaker.
- 29:38Emily Guy Birken: It's the one that it's for children.
- 29:40Emily Guy Birken: Very little pocket money because it lasts forever.
- 29:42Emily Guy Birken: None of that makes sense.
- 29:45Emily Guy Birken: That's the wrong one.
- 29:46Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, yeah, I'm like.
- 29:50Emily Guy Birken: You're not going to buy more than one of those, right?
- 29:52Emily Guy Birken: I?
- 29:52Tracie Guy-Decker: mean the opposite of plan obsolescence yeah.
- 29:56Emily Guy Birken: And that that I really feel like is so much of that Like there are aspects that were not necessarily in the book, but so much of it is, I think, representative of Roald Dahl.
- 30:08Emily Guy Birken: He was a product of his time.
- 30:12Emily Guy Birken: I think he really did believe in hierarchies of people and believed that it's a meritocracy, while at the same time setting up rules to make sure that he got all the merit.
- 30:25Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, let's talk about that, because there's a lot of judgment on these four, the four other kids that we see.
- 30:33Tracie Guy-Decker: So let's let's talk about that hierarchy of people and judgment and meritocracy and like what is meritous and what is not yeah.
- 30:41Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, so I want to start with Ruka salt, because I love her.
- 30:46Emily Guy Birken: She is an icon I want the whole world yeah.
- 30:51Emily Guy Birken: That's, and it's funny because I don't remember how it came up, but I was talking to my spouse about the fact that I am reevaluating Ruka salt now as an adult, and he's like, oh really, and I'm like that, that, right there, that's exactly why I'm doing it, because it was a spoiled little girl, not a spoiled little boy.
- 31:11Emily Guy Birken: And there is the inherent misogyny within that, like, how dare a girl or a female coded person want things?
- 31:23Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, absolutely.
- 31:25Emily Guy Birken: And yes, she is a brat is the best way to describe it.
- 31:33Emily Guy Birken: It is very clear that her parents have never said no to her, so she has learned that this is what one does.
- 31:39Emily Guy Birken: This is how, like, she has adapted to the world she lives in.
- 31:42Emily Guy Birken: But you also see, when she sings that song about I want it.
- 31:47Emily Guy Birken: Now there's a point where she kind of like goes into this frenzy and then she kind of like smooths her dress and calms down, smooths her hair, and so there is also this like idea of performance.
- 31:58Emily Guy Birken: Same thing when she first she wants to be the first one in the gates and she like performs being a sweet child because she's been taught that's what she's supposed to be.
- 32:09Emily Guy Birken: So I'm not saying that I have any particular affection or affinity for kids who don't, who can't handle being told no, but the fact that she is so well adapted to this world that she has been given there's something just like iconic about it, and the fact that she unapologetically wants what she wants when she wants it, when women are taught not to do that makes me kind of love her.
- 32:46Tracie Guy-Decker: I'm thinking about the fact that in men it's men and boys it's sort of received as ambition and in women it's received as entitlement.
- 32:57Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes, yeah, and I mean I feel like that's the case regardless, like that, that sort of like I don't know why I don't quite like her.
- 33:05Tracie Guy-Decker: You know about ambitious women.
- 33:06Tracie Guy-Decker: In fact, I think I was recently reading Glennon Doyle in Untamed.
- 33:11Tracie Guy-Decker: She talks about that, about the fact that and that she talks about investigating in herself when she reacts badly to to other women.
- 33:20Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, I think that's exactly it.
- 33:23Tracie Guy-Decker: And men it's.
- 33:24Tracie Guy-Decker: It's received as ambition and we like it.
- 33:25Tracie Guy-Decker: And we celebrate it.
- 33:28Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes.
- 33:28Tracie Guy-Decker: Or like he's driven, he's goal oriented, whereas women are seen as entitled and overreaching.
- 33:38Emily Guy Birken: And the way that her father is portrayed.
- 33:41Emily Guy Birken: He is portrayed as like this harried hen, pecked like Massaculated.
- 33:48Emily Guy Birken: Partial man yeah, he's emasculated by her wants.
- 33:50Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, when all he had to do was say no, so I think that's the case.
- 33:55Emily Guy Birken: So I find I find her portrayal very, very interesting.
- 33:58Emily Guy Birken: I think it's is very much reflection on Roald Dahl, who I believe was was a misogynist.
- 34:06Emily Guy Birken: I mean, I don't think he went out, I was like I hate women but I really do.
- 34:10Emily Guy Birken: The way that he treated women in his stories, even when he subverted, so like the story I was telling you about with the leg of lamb there, that was a subversion because no one believed this sweet woman who was feeding all the police officers could do anything like or so awful yeah.
- 34:28Emily Guy Birken: He was subverting it.
- 34:29Emily Guy Birken: But there's still, like, this sense of like.
- 34:31Emily Guy Birken: You know well, you know there's something wrong with this woman because she couldn't do that, yeah, so there's that.
- 34:38Emily Guy Birken: And then there's the the, the way that women and girls have always been treated in 50 years ago, what was just a given in in making a film.
- 34:46Emily Guy Birken: And in fact she gets one of the least gruesome ends of the four children.
- 34:50Emily Guy Birken: She just falls into a trash, shoot Now they.
- 34:53Emily Guy Birken: The furnace is fired every other day, so there's the possibility she's going to be burnt to a crisp Right and her father jumps in right after her.
- 35:03Emily Guy Birken: That is something I also never really appreciated as a kid.
- 35:06Emily Guy Birken: Like he doesn't say good riddance to bad rubbish.
- 35:10Emily Guy Birken: He's like Varouka, honey, I'm coming.
- 35:12Emily Guy Birken: He loves his daughter.
- 35:15Emily Guy Birken: He's really bad at loving her.
- 35:17Emily Guy Birken: He thinks that loving her is giving her whatever she wants, and many people have that make that mistake.
- 35:23Emily Guy Birken: And he happens to be rich enough that he can.
- 35:27Emily Guy Birken: And the you see one scene with her mother where her mother is saying like a happy child brings, brings joy to a home, or something like that.
- 35:37Emily Guy Birken: It's clear they're, they're, they're not a bad family.
- 35:40Tracie Guy-Decker: They're doing their best.
- 35:41Emily Guy Birken: They're doing their best.
- 35:42Emily Guy Birken: They just don't have a good sense of how to do it, which then brings up would Charlie be a good person if you weren't poor?
- 35:52Emily Guy Birken: Right Like is is the only thing that makes him good the fact that he has nothing which is, which is another weird sort of like pro capitalist.
- 36:02Emily Guy Birken: Well, and fetishization of, like the worthy poor, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 36:06Emily Guy Birken: So the other three kids.
- 36:11Tracie Guy-Decker: So Augustus Gloop that yeah, let's, let's talk about poor Augustus.
- 36:16Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, the fat, and child doll was a fat child.
- 36:20Emily Guy Birken: She was a small and cute housewife.
- 36:22Emily Guy Birken: It was called the Jack and the Jack Jamer.
- 36:25Emily Guy Birken: In James and the Giant Peach there were two awful aunts James is too awful, aunt Spiker and Aunt Sponge.
- 36:33Emily Guy Birken: On Spiker was like a skinny and on Sponge was fat, and they both were bad women and the their shapes represented the ways in which they were bad.
- 36:46Emily Guy Birken: Aunt Spiker was too sharp, yeah, and wanted everything for herself.
- 36:52Emily Guy Birken: So it is not at all surprising that Roald Dahl wrote Augustus Gloop as a glutton, as someone who, despite the fact that there is candy everywhere, the eye can see that he can eat anything he wants, but goes for the chocolate in the river which he's not allowed to have.
- 37:13Emily Guy Birken: You also see when the news media is interviewing the Gloop family, mr Gloop, they're eating and they put a microphone into Mr Gloop's face to say, like, what do you think about this?
- 37:27Emily Guy Birken: And he eats the cover of the microphone because ha ha ha, isn't it funny when fat people eat?
- 37:33Emily Guy Birken: And it kind of reinforces the idea that excess adipose tissue comes from overeating and not having control of yourself.
- 37:45Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, I mean that's what the Oompa Loopa sing about, yeah.
- 37:49Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, so you know again, completely understandable why, where that comes from, particularly from a writer who was writing in the early mid 20th century and a movie that comes out in 1971.
- 38:04Emily Guy Birken: But poor Augustus did not deserve that.
- 38:06Emily Guy Birken: Nor did Mrs Gloop, right, she's made fun of.
- 38:12Emily Guy Birken: When she's like, oh my god, he's gonna be made into fudge, and Wonka goes like, oh no, of course that would never happen.
- 38:19Emily Guy Birken: That goes to the Marshmallow Room, right?
- 38:21Emily Guy Birken: So, like well, how dare you be concerned about your child who just got sucked up into a tube?
- 38:27Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, so we still haven't spoken about Violet and Mike TV.
- 38:33Emily Guy Birken: Yes, and in both cases those to me seem to be Roald Dahl's specific bugaboos and the way that they made it in the film was that they're both know-it-alls Because Roald Dahl thought gum chewing was disgusting.
- 38:50Emily Guy Birken: That's that that was his moral judgment.
- 38:53Emily Guy Birken: Like chewing gum is gross.
- 38:55Emily Guy Birken: And in fact they, in the 2005 update they made it that Violet Beauregard was competitive.
- 39:02Emily Guy Birken: She was a competitive gum chewer and it was about the like wanting the gold star.
- 39:07Emily Guy Birken: Being competitive is what was being lampooned rather than the gum chewing, and there is a bit of like the know-it-all aspect of it.
- 39:16Emily Guy Birken: There was the American-ness of Mr Beauregard, who was a used car dealer.
- 39:23Emily Guy Birken: Right is another aspect of it, which I, frankly, I don't blame Roald Dahl at all.
- 39:28Emily Guy Birken: There are some American stereotypes that are I'm perfectly happy to have lampooned, but just that the gum chewing is as a moral failing is just weird.
- 39:40Tracie Guy-Decker: It's in particular since Wonko was working on gum Like, her mistake was not chewing gum, it was chewing gum that wasn't out of R&D yet.
- 39:52Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes, yeah.
- 39:55Emily Guy Birken: And then it's basically the same thing happens to Mike TV, who he is really excited to get I don't know sent through the television.
- 40:04Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah.
- 40:05Emily Guy Birken: Beamed through the TV without any thought for the consequences.
- 40:10Tracie Guy-Decker: Right, he also does it before, right before it's out of R&D.
- 40:15Emily Guy Birken: Mm-hmm, yeah, yeah.
- 40:16Emily Guy Birken: His is actually makes even less sense because, like with Violet, it's like oh, I know gum, I'm trying this gum.
- 40:22Emily Guy Birken: With this it's like okay, I just saw something I've never seen happen before and a giant candy bar became a normal size candy bar.
- 40:30Emily Guy Birken: So I want to do that why.
- 40:33Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, yeah.
- 40:34Tracie Guy-Decker: My recollection too is that he says he wants to do it again and then and his mom is like you won't be exist if you're already like whatever sanctioned, yeah, and Wonko says he's going to send him to the taffy room to have him stretched out.
- 40:47Tracie Guy-Decker: Mm-hmm.
- 40:48Emily Guy Birken: And that's actually so in the book and again in the 2005 version.
- 40:54Emily Guy Birken: They do show the four children leaving.
- 40:56Emily Guy Birken: They do survive.
- 40:57Emily Guy Birken: They do stretch mic out because little boys are remarkably rubbery, which kind of that fits with.
- 41:05Emily Guy Birken: Like my spouse and I joked when the kids were much younger that, like you know, they don't have bones when they're little.
- 41:11Emily Guy Birken: Yeah like they, they.
- 41:13Emily Guy Birken: They insert the bones at some point during a well child visit, while the parents doing power paperwork.
- 41:18Emily Guy Birken: Yeah.
- 41:19Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, they are definitely more bouncy when they're little.
- 41:22Emily Guy Birken: So, yeah, all, all, all four kids survive according to the book, and you know, of the four, like Ruka Salt has the least terrible thing happen to her, because she's just covered in rash.
- 41:32Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, but the the, the judgments of children as being left wanting and, you know, worthy of an entire song about their moral failings.
- 41:46Tracie Guy-Decker: Well, and the families?
- 41:48Tracie Guy-Decker: Right, Because I remember, like we know, who's to blame the mother.
- 41:53Emily Guy Birken: The mother and the father.
- 41:55Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, yeah, to be fair.
- 41:58Emily Guy Birken: And gosh, I wish I'd had time to reread the book.
- 42:01Emily Guy Birken: I'm curious if the adding the mom and dad as being to blame is new in 1971 compared to the the book, because I wouldn't put it past all to just be like, yep, these children are rotten through and through.
- 42:18Emily Guy Birken: So it's, it's a mixed bag.
- 42:22Emily Guy Birken: I do want to say.
- 42:24Emily Guy Birken: I want to talk a little bit about Gene Wilder's performance and the addition of poetry to the script.
- 42:31Emily Guy Birken: I love that.
- 42:33Emily Guy Birken: Gene Wilder is Wonka that is what he is best known for like and even as a very old man.
- 42:40Emily Guy Birken: And actually one of the reasons why he kept his Alzheimer's a secret and did not go out much as he got closer to the end of his life is he didn't want to ruin the magic for children, which just makes my heart clutch.
- 42:55Emily Guy Birken: It's just, it's just lovely.
- 42:57Emily Guy Birken: He apparently I found something this morning as I was doing a little research.
- 43:01Emily Guy Birken: Someone asked him how he, how he felt about working with the kids and he said four of them are fantastic.
- 43:07Emily Guy Birken: I want to want to throttle so what he brought to the character, which is different from how he is written in the book.
- 43:12Emily Guy Birken: In the book.
- 43:12Emily Guy Birken: He's just a little bit different In the book.
- 43:21Emily Guy Birken: In the book he's kind of like a manic pixie dream capitalist.
- 43:26Emily Guy Birken: He brings a gentleness and like the core of sweetness, as well as a more overt menace.
- 43:37Emily Guy Birken: Not that that's dolls, wonka wasn't menacing, but he was a little more like all over the place.
- 43:46Emily Guy Birken: He was kind of ADHD, whereas this Wonka he's not distracted, he knows what he's doing at all times and he does not suffer fools and is.
- 43:59Emily Guy Birken: You know?
- 44:00Emily Guy Birken: There is something, there's an undercurrent of menace there.
- 44:04Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, there's this.
- 44:05Tracie Guy-Decker: I my sense, like in my memory, is exactly what you're saying about the calculating, because there's even there are the moments where we see, like when Augustus has his hands in the river and he's like, no, don't stop.
- 44:19Tracie Guy-Decker: Like he says the words, but it's, it's clearly the message is is clearly the opposite of what he's saying there's also, I feel I feel like there's a pathos to Wilders Wonka, in that final moment that you have described, where Charlie puts the gop stopper on the desk and Wilder puts his hand over it, and there's this pause and there's this shift from having, when he was short and barking and like you did this and you broke the contract and the whatever, and then into the sweetness where, taken as a whole, we see he was hurt.
- 44:57Tracie Guy-Decker: There was, there was pain in the earlier cruelty.
- 45:02Tracie Guy-Decker: That then has been addressed in Charlie's kindness, which is what we're meant to think.
- 45:11Tracie Guy-Decker: I mean, is it in fact kindness?
- 45:13Tracie Guy-Decker: I don't know, but that is, that's the way Wilder was playing it.
- 45:17Tracie Guy-Decker: That is part of what made him so sympathetic.
- 45:21Emily Guy Birken: Yes, yes, yeah, that that the pathos, that's.
- 45:25Emily Guy Birken: That's exactly it.
- 45:26Emily Guy Birken: There's that you also believe the like.
- 45:29Emily Guy Birken: You know, I know I'm not going to be around forever.
- 45:31Emily Guy Birken: There is that that, like I've built this wonderful world and I realize I have no one to share it with, is kind of what's in there as well.
- 45:41Tracie Guy-Decker: Which then comes back around to like the, the normalizing of the Obaloomba's aren't people?
- 45:46Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes, they're there, they're no one, mm.
- 45:49Tracie Guy-Decker: Hmm, because he's already sharing it with him.
- 45:52Emily Guy Birken: Yes, I will never not love Let me say I will always love Wilder's performance as Willy Wonka, and in fact there have been times where I have because it's on Netflix or something you know it's streaming somewhere where I'll just fast forward to the parts with him in it, because he is magical and part of that is that magic is not all good, magic is not all beneficial.
- 46:20Emily Guy Birken: There there is like a price for magic and he is real clear about that, and so you know, that's something that I just find really captivating about his performance.
- 46:36Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, and I don't think I mean Johnny Depp seemed to be channeling Michael Jackson.
- 46:44Emily Guy Birken: I think he actually said that I'm like I, so it was just deeply unsettling his portrayal.
- 46:52Emily Guy Birken: And I have I don't know much about Timothy Chalamet, but like you're not going to be Jane Wilder, you're not going to be able to have, because even when, when he played like young Frankenstein and stuff like that, he managed to have that like over the top Performance and pathos when he was bloom in what's that called the producers.
- 47:12Emily Guy Birken: There's pathos in that ridiculous performance, which is one of the reasons why I tried to watch the the version with Matthew Broderick in Gene Wilder's role and I was like.
- 47:23Emily Guy Birken: It just doesn't work for me because you're not bringing that like that core of sadness in there that needs to be there for me to believe that my blue blankie, I really appreciate that, considering role doll was an anti-Semite, that Gene Wilder, who was raised in the Jewish neighborhood a couple blocks away from where I live right now in Milwaukee, is synonymous with dolls character forever.
- 47:55Emily Guy Birken: Like that makes me very happy.
- 47:57Emily Guy Birken: The other thing that I think that the movie does so well that is completely absent from the book is the poetry.
- 48:07Emily Guy Birken: There are a number of different lines of poetry throughout the film and it came about because originally doll was contracted to write the film, the script.
- 48:18Emily Guy Birken: He apparently just kept referring people back to the book.
- 48:21Emily Guy Birken: Oh, for this section, look at the book.
- 48:23Emily Guy Birken: And so he has the sole writing credit, even though someone else really wrote it.
- 48:27Emily Guy Birken: They had written the script and it felt like it was missing something, and the person who wrote it who's I'll have to link in the show notes because I can't remember his name decided like this needs more, and so he added like lines of poetry.
- 48:44Emily Guy Birken: So the one that I can remember always off top of my head is when someone asks about like butter, rum butterscotch and he says.
- 48:52Emily Guy Birken: He says Candy is dandy, but liquor is quicker, which is that very short poem by Ogden Nash which is on breaking the ice, is the title of the poem Candy is dandy.
- 49:02Tracie Guy-Decker: I thought that was Dorothy Parker.
- 49:05Emily Guy Birken: No, that's not a Nash.
- 49:06Emily Guy Birken: I once wrote down all of the not going to be able to find it wrote down all of the poetry in the film there's.
- 49:17Emily Guy Birken: There's another poem that he says during the tunnel scene, when they're in the boat.
- 49:22Emily Guy Birken: Wonka says it.
- 49:23Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, wonka says it, with one exception.
- 49:26Emily Guy Birken: All the poetry comes from.
- 49:27Tracie Guy-Decker: Wonka.
- 49:28Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, the one exception is when Charlie is outside the gates of the factory there's like a tin man, like a guy with tin shears and stuff like that comes by and recites a poem in a way that feels like menacing to Charlie and he runs away.
- 49:43Emily Guy Birken: But other than that it's all Wonka, which again adds a different flavor to who Wonka is and that just Wilder nailed it.
- 49:53Emily Guy Birken: He nailed that, that the delivery and the just charming menace and sweet pathos.
- 50:03Tracie Guy-Decker: Well, we've been talking actually for a while, so maybe I can see if I can reflect back to you some of the some of the analysis that you brought.
- 50:10Tracie Guy-Decker: So, though, you will always love Jane Wilder's performance in this really magical movie, there's some kind of ugly underbelly stuff here.
- 50:22Tracie Guy-Decker: So I heard about sort of an imperialist kind of colonialist kind of white supremacy, white saviorism vis-a-vis the Oompa-Loompas.
- 50:33Tracie Guy-Decker: I heard a very pro capitalist and like pro unregulated capitalist sentiment that puts capital and property, and even intellectual property, above the needs of human beings.
- 50:50Tracie Guy-Decker: I heard about some unpleasant judgment about kids in particular, around bodies, body shaming and fat shaming around, especially a girl in Veruca, salt, wanting things and being unashamed about wanting those things and saying it out loud.
- 51:13Tracie Guy-Decker: And I think it's significant that this is a girl.
- 51:16Tracie Guy-Decker: You pointed out and we talked about the fact that if, if Veruca had been a boy, if it had been Victor or something, we would have received him differently.
- 51:25Tracie Guy-Decker: Still a brat, but not, as he's going places yeah, going to take over his father's factory.
- 51:35Tracie Guy-Decker: That ambition is going to serve him well, we might have said as opposed to having him be deemed a bad egg and sent to the trash.
- 51:43Tracie Guy-Decker: And then Dahl's weird bugaboo about gum chewing and TV viewing as judgmental.
- 51:51Tracie Guy-Decker: Oh, we also spent some time talking about Dahl and his kind of early 20th century Britishism, which then brings with it, unfortunately, anti-semitism and, in his case, in his case in his case, and very much hierarchical thinking and the idea of a meritocracy which is set up structurally to ensure that people like Mr Dahl have merit.
- 52:19Emily Guy Birken: And that's why Charlie is the successor is because he is a diamond in the rough.
- 52:24Emily Guy Birken: He is like Wonka and Dahl.
- 52:29Emily Guy Birken: He just happened to be born to poor parents and we'll fix that.
- 52:35Tracie Guy-Decker: He doesn't deserve poverty, unlike those other people those other poor people who do deserve it.
- 52:41Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, you also pointed out, in terms of the on the positives column, you pointed out some of the really lovely cinematographic choices, such that the audience can be on the edge of our seat watching a child unwrap a chocolate bar, which is remarkable.
- 52:59Tracie Guy-Decker: There's a lot of magic in this film and in particular, gene Wilder's performance, which has a combination of magic and menace and pathos.
- 53:09Tracie Guy-Decker: What did I?
- 53:10Emily Guy Birken: forget.
- 53:10Emily Guy Birken: I don't think there's anything else in there.
- 53:13Emily Guy Birken: The one thing that I do kind of want to underline is why it disturbs me so much that Charlie's respect for Wonka's property is a problem.
- 53:28Emily Guy Birken: And it's because of the reactions that I saw from friends of mine who have never had to go without in their lives in the wake of the uprisings after George Floyd's murder, when there were gas stations and CVSs and stuff like that that were destroyed during those uprisings.
- 53:50Emily Guy Birken: And the response I would hear from these friends is like I totally understand why people are upset, but don't destroy other people's things.
- 53:59Emily Guy Birken: And on the one hand I was like well, it's not necessarily the protesters who are doing that.
- 54:07Emily Guy Birken: A, b, that's why God invented insurance.
- 54:14Emily Guy Birken: When you are comparing the death the extrajudicial and extraordinarily painful and upsetting, horrifying death of a person and the destruction of property, how can you compare them?
- 54:29Emily Guy Birken: How can you say like oh, I understand why you're upset, but don't go breaking windows Like I don't know.
- 54:34Emily Guy Birken: Broken windows seems appropriate and an appropriate level of upset to me, and that's why I kind of want to underline and that's part of the reason why it was such a revelation to me to be like oh, my God, charlie's not doing the right thing right here because he is putting property above the lives of his family.
- 54:53Emily Guy Birken: And we so often imbibe that message in so much of our media, including this beloved gem of our childhood, that we don't even think about it.
- 55:04Emily Guy Birken: We don't even think about, like, what is this compared to people's lives, so that we're able to pare it back, the idea like, well, yeah, it's understandable, they're upset, but you know why are you throwing chairs through windows, like because it's that level of upset?
- 55:20Emily Guy Birken: This is not.
- 55:21Emily Guy Birken: I am peeved.
- 55:23Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, I mean also like if people don't respond to your inside voice, you got to use your outside voice.
- 55:29Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes, yeah, yes.
- 55:31Emily Guy Birken: So and I remember talking to these friends and kind of like helping them get around that corner and like, oh okay, yeah, oh okay, I get it because they just never had.
- 55:41Emily Guy Birken: And they never had because of messages like this, which make it clear that the property of wealthy people is paramount.
- 55:53Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah.
- 55:54Emily Guy Birken: And we must respect it.
- 55:56Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah.
- 55:59Emily Guy Birken: Childhood ruining.
- 56:03Tracie Guy-Decker: I feel like that could actually be the subtitle of this show.
- 56:05Emily Guy Birken: Yes, deep thoughts about stupid shit will ruin your childhood.
- 56:10Tracie Guy-Decker: Tracy and Emily ruin your childhood, yeah.
- 56:13Emily Guy Birken: Ruinning childhood since 2023.
- 56:15Emily Guy Birken: But again, there is.
- 56:18Emily Guy Birken: There is much to love in this film, and that's I don't ever want to be like, so don't watch it, right?
- 56:25Emily Guy Birken: That's not.
- 56:26Emily Guy Birken: That's not what we're saying.
- 56:27Emily Guy Birken: We're saying when you watch it, recognize what you're, what you're being told.
- 56:31Tracie Guy-Decker: Well, I think that the thing is to like.
- 56:33Tracie Guy-Decker: Those lessons are in your head whether you're examining them or not, so let's examine them so that we can respond to them instead of reacting with them.
- 56:41Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 56:43Tracie Guy-Decker: So next time, next time.
- 56:46Emily Guy Birken: I think you're going next time.
- 56:47Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes, next time I am going to share my deep thoughts about Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark.
- 56:54Tracie Guy-Decker: I have a feeling you're going to ruin my childhood.
- 56:57Tracie Guy-Decker: It's entirely possible.
- 56:59Tracie Guy-Decker: I'm really looking like, I'm really looking forward to this one.
- 57:03Tracie Guy-Decker: I don't think that I've watched it again since I, you know, did my undergraduate and graduate work in religion, so that piece of it I'm kind of excited about.
- 57:15Tracie Guy-Decker: It's like a minor piece of it.
- 57:18Emily Guy Birken: But there I do know that there was a brief time where you and I were doing Torah study together and we got to the section describing the Ark of the Covenant.
- 57:27Emily Guy Birken: I'm like, oh my God, they did a really good job.
- 57:30Tracie Guy-Decker: Hey you, yeah you.
- 57:32Tracie Guy-Decker: You're a deep thinker, I can tell.
- 57:35Tracie Guy-Decker: Let's make it official.
- 57:36Tracie Guy-Decker: Head on over to our website, guygirlsmediacom, and make sure you don't miss a single deep thought.
- 57:43Tracie Guy-Decker: You can get me and Emily in your inbox every week.
- 57:46Tracie Guy-Decker: What are you waiting for?
- 57:48Tracie Guy-Decker: Thanks for listening.
- 57:50Tracie Guy-Decker: Our theme music is Professor Umlaut by Kevin McLeod from incompetechcom.
- 57:55Tracie Guy-Decker: Find full music credits in the show notes.
- 57:58Tracie Guy-Decker: Until next time, remember, pop culture is still culture, and shouldn't you know what's in your head?