Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Health Care Law 101: A Survey of Current Healthcare Legal Issues
Transcript
- 0:02Hi everyone, my name is Ruby Singh and I'm the
- 0:05chair of the healthcare law section for the Beverly
- 0:08Hills Bar Association. I'm excited to introduce
- 0:11our speaker this morning, John Mills. John is
- 0:14a partner in the healthcare practice group at
- 0:16Leach Tishman in Los Angeles. He focuses on healthcare
- 0:19litigation and reimbursement disputes, representing
- 0:22hospitals, addiction treatment centers, physicians,
- 0:26medical groups, and pharmacies. John advises
- 0:29clients on managed care and reimbursement compliance,
- 0:32anti -kickback on strike law issues, peer review
- 0:35and credentialing matters, and the federal 340B
- 0:38drug discount program. He's been recognized by
- 0:41best lawyers in healthcare law and as a Southern
- 0:44California super lawyer. John is a member of
- 0:47the American Health Lawyers Association and the
- 0:49California Society for Healthcare Attorneys.
- 0:52And now I'd like to turn it over to John to go
- 0:54ahead and get started. Thank you. Thank you,
- 0:59Ruhi, and thank you everyone for attending. I'm
- 1:02excited to speak to you today about healthcare
- 1:05law, which has been my area of practice for pretty
- 1:08much my entire career. With this presentation,
- 1:12I get to talk about some of the kinds of cases
- 1:16and issues that I commonly handle in my practice
- 1:20and that I often litigate. I wanna be clear at
- 1:25the outset, I've designed this presentation for
- 1:28the non healthcare lawyer or the lawyer who is
- 1:32early in their healthcare practice. This is a
- 1:35very high level presentation where I'm going
- 1:37to be scratching the surface of several major
- 1:41areas of healthcare law. The operative word in
- 1:44the presentation's title is reef. I hope you're
- 1:48not here because you're expecting a deep dive
- 1:50into the anti -kickback laws or HIPAA. Unfortunately,
- 1:54in a single hour, I simply don't have the time
- 1:57to deep dive into any particular topic. Rather,
- 2:02I will hopefully provide all of you with a sense
- 2:06of what healthcare law entails and help you with
- 2:10issue spotting. I should also point out that
- 2:13my entire practice is dedicated to representing
- 2:15healthcare providers. That means the doctors,
- 2:19the hospitals, the pharmacies, laboratories,
- 2:22everyone on the on the provider side of the equation.
- 2:25I don't represent patients, nor do I represent
- 2:28health care payers like health insurance companies.
- 2:32So please keep that in mind. This presentation
- 2:35comes from the perspective of provider side counsel.
- 2:40Next slide, please. So with that, I must, of
- 2:45course, give the obligatory disclaimer. I am
- 2:49not here providing legal advice. This presentation
- 2:51is for informational purposes only. Next slide,
- 2:56please. I have broken this presentation into
- 3:02three broad areas. These are areas that, in my
- 3:06opinion, every healthcare lawyer needs to have
- 3:09some familiarity with. Even if they don't specialize
- 3:12in one of these areas, they should be able to
- 3:14have a working knowledge of these areas and be
- 3:17able to spot these issues when dealing with their
- 3:19clients. So my three broad areas are going to
- 3:23be first licensing and peer review. Then I'll
- 3:27talk about reimbursement. And then I'll finish
- 3:30with some common topics in regulatory compliance.
- 3:37And by the way, I'm not a transactional lawyer.
- 3:39I primarily litigate and I provide regulatory
- 3:42compliance advice. I'm mentioning this because
- 3:45my chosen topics tend to be more illustrative
- 3:50of my practice to the exclusion of a lot of interesting
- 3:54topics that a healthcare transaction lawyer would
- 3:57probably talk about if they were giving this
- 3:59presentation. Next slide, please. We'll start
- 4:06with licensing and peer review disputes. When
- 4:10I tell people I'm a healthcare lawyer, they often
- 4:13assume that I'm a medical malpractice lawyer.
- 4:17And while I certainly consider medical malpractice
- 4:20to be an area of healthcare law, it's not an
- 4:23area that I frequently practice in. But I also,
- 4:29I do get to regularly litigate cases where the
- 4:32central issue is whether a healthcare professional
- 4:35or healthcare entity acted within the standard
- 4:38of care and in compliance with the various rules
- 4:42and regulations applicable to their licensure.
- 4:47This comes up in the area of disciplinary actions
- 4:51brought by licensing agencies as well as hospital
- 4:55peer review bodies. Next slide, please. As you
- 5:03probably know, healthcare practitioners and healthcare
- 5:07entities need lots of licenses lots of certifications
- 5:11and accreditations. This includes everything
- 5:15from a medical license from the medical board,
- 5:18to a pharmacy license from the pharmacy board,
- 5:20to nursing board licenses, group home licenses
- 5:24from the Department of Social Services, et cetera,
- 5:27et cetera. A provider can come under investigation
- 5:30by the licensing agency for a number of different
- 5:33reasons. Some of them I've listed on this slide.
- 5:36For example, a physician might come under scrutiny
- 5:40by the medical board if the board receives complaints
- 5:43from patients. Licensing boards will often get
- 5:47wind of complaints because there is a pending
- 5:50civil malpractice case, or there has been a settlement
- 5:54of a malpractice case. Under the law, malpractice
- 5:58settlements over a certain dollar amount have
- 6:00to be reported to the medical board. Often there
- 6:04will be referrals to the licensing agencies by
- 6:07other healthcare practitioners or other government
- 6:10agencies who are concerned for one reason or
- 6:13the other about the quality of that physician
- 6:18or practitioner's care. 805 reports are mandatory
- 6:24reports that must be submitted to the medical
- 6:26board by hospitals. and other entities defined
- 6:30under the law as peer reviewed bodies. A common
- 6:34scenario is if a doctor comes under investigation
- 6:37by a hospital for something concerning the doctor's
- 6:41medical practice, then that must be reported
- 6:44to the board if the hospital takes certain disciplinary
- 6:48actions against the doctor. For example, revoking
- 6:51their privileges or putting some sort of restrictions
- 6:55on their privileges. Healthcare lawyers will
- 6:59represent the provider in the licensing agency's
- 7:02investigation, which will usually include an
- 7:05interview and sometimes a subpoena for documents.
- 7:08If the agency files what's known as an accusation,
- 7:12the provider has the right to a defense in an
- 7:15administrative process that will result in an
- 7:18evidentiary hearing before an administrative
- 7:21law judge. If the provider loses before the ALJ,
- 7:25then the provider can challenge the decision
- 7:27in California Superior Court by filing a writ
- 7:31of administrative mandate under Code of Civil
- 7:34Procedure, Section 1094 .5. The court can review
- 7:39for errors of law. It can review whether the
- 7:42ALJ's decision is incompatible with the substantial
- 7:46weight of the evidence. There's a number of issues
- 7:49that the court can review. Although in large
- 7:53part, it's really acting like an appellate court
- 7:58would review a trial. So it's really focused
- 8:02on whether the weight of the evidence was simply
- 8:04ignored. Next slide, please. So most doctors
- 8:14are not employees of the hospitals they work
- 8:17at, but rather they are members of the hospital's
- 8:20medical staff. A medical staff is an independent
- 8:24legal entity under California law. The medical
- 8:27staff is a self -governing association with its
- 8:30own bylaws, rules, and policies. If a doctor
- 8:34wants to see patients at a particular hospital,
- 8:38then he or she must obtain clinical privileges
- 8:41from the hospital's medical staff. If an issue
- 8:45arises with a doctor on the medical staff, The
- 8:48medical staff is responsible for investigating
- 8:52that issue and potentially taking disciplinary
- 8:55action against the doctor. As I mentioned before,
- 8:59that might result in an 805 report to the medical
- 9:02board. 805, by the way, is business and professions
- 9:04code section 805. By law, the doctor is entitled
- 9:10to a peer review hearing before final disciplinary
- 9:13action can be taken against the doctor's privileges.
- 9:17Discipline could range from revoking privileges
- 9:20and removing the doctor from the staff to requiring
- 9:23the doctor to have a proctor while performing
- 9:25certain procedures, a whole host of different
- 9:29restrictions that might be imposed on the doctor's
- 9:32practice at the hospital. The origin of these
- 9:36procedural rights derives from the common law
- 9:39doctrine of fair procedure. which essentially
- 9:43states that a physician's privileges to practice
- 9:46at a hospital are akin to a property right that
- 9:49cannot be taken away without procedurally and
- 9:53substantively fair reasons. This is sort of a
- 9:57due process, but in the private context. And
- 10:01this principle, this principle of fair procedure
- 10:03has now been codified in California in Business
- 10:07and Professions Code Section 809. When hospitals
- 10:12do take action against a physician's privileges,
- 10:16often what we see is that a physician will want
- 10:19to sue the hospital or sue the hospital medical
- 10:22staff and argue that the peer review process
- 10:25was a sham or was retaliatory or was driven by
- 10:31anti -competitive reasons or something along
- 10:34those lines. And when a physician... files that
- 10:39kind of lawsuit, this will invariably be met
- 10:42with what's known as an anti -slap motion filed
- 10:46by the hospital or the hospital's medical staff.
- 10:49And the anti -slap theory is that the peer review
- 10:52is protected activity. Now, I'm not going to
- 10:55get into all the anti -slap is a whole separate
- 10:58presentation in and of itself, but just keep
- 11:00in mind that peer review is considered a protective
- 11:03activity under the anti -slap. Over the years,
- 11:07there have been perhaps probably a dozen appellate
- 11:10court decisions in this area, just in the issue
- 11:13of applying the anti -SLAP to peer review. It's
- 11:18a constantly evolving area and the courts, they
- 11:22really seem to struggle with it because there's
- 11:23so many published opinions out there. They seem
- 11:25to be this sort of, it's evolving over time.
- 11:30And frankly, this would be a great topic for
- 11:32an entire separate presentation. But I don't
- 11:35have time for that now. I'll just point out that
- 11:37the most recent decision on this issue is the
- 11:412024 case, Dignity Health versus Mounts. And
- 11:45in that case, the court held that, the appellate
- 11:49court held that the medical staff communications,
- 11:52including a medical staff's failure to respond
- 11:55to a peer review inquiry from another hospital's
- 11:58medical staff where the doctor was seeking privileges,
- 12:01this was considered protected by the litigation
- 12:05privilege under civil code section 47. So that
- 12:09was the defense that was being raised by the
- 12:12defendants through their anti -slap motion. And
- 12:15this holding, it strengthens the ability of hospitals
- 12:19to defend against lawsuits alleging sham peer
- 12:23review. But I really don't think this is gonna
- 12:25be the last word on the issue. I think we're
- 12:27gonna see more activity in this area. Next slide,
- 12:30please. All right, let's switch gears and talk
- 12:37about reimbursement. Reimbursement is just another
- 12:41word for collections, and collecting payment
- 12:44in the world of healthcare is not simple. Most
- 12:47healthcare providers do not receive the majority
- 12:50of payment for their services from their patients.
- 12:54Most of the payment comes from health insurance,
- 12:56whether it's federal programs like Medicare or
- 12:59private commercial plans like Anthem Blue Cross
- 13:01or United Health, Aetna, et cetera. This is always,
- 13:06always an active area because nearly every healthcare
- 13:08provider will at some point have a dispute with
- 13:11a health plan or health payer over receiving
- 13:15reimbursement for their services. Next slide.
- 13:24Allow me to give a very high level overview of
- 13:27the main reimbursement programs that I commonly
- 13:29encounter as a healthcare lawyer. There are a
- 13:32number of federally funded healthcare programs.
- 13:34The main one, of course, is Medicare. As you
- 13:37may know, Medicare covers people 65 or older,
- 13:41disabled people, and people with end -stage renal
- 13:45disease. Medicaid is also considered a federal
- 13:48program, although it's a hybrid federal and state
- 13:54program. And Medicaid covers low -income adults,
- 13:59pregnant women, and children. Then there is the
- 14:02Federal Employee Health Benefit Act for federal
- 14:04employees. And a couple of other big ones are
- 14:08the TRICARE program for the military and the
- 14:10VA program for veterans. At the state level,
- 14:15the main government funded program is of course
- 14:18Medicaid, which in California is referred to
- 14:21as Medi -Cal. Medicaid is administered at the
- 14:24state level, but must follow certain federal
- 14:27guidelines. and it's mostly provided through
- 14:31managed care organizations. On the private side,
- 14:35there is commercial health insurance and health
- 14:38plans. Health insurance is basically an indemnity
- 14:42policy that is funded by the insurance company
- 14:46and is sold on the insurance marketplace directly
- 14:49to consumers and small employer groups. In California,
- 14:53it is regulated by the Department of Insurance.
- 14:56More common are managed care plans, which are
- 14:59different than traditional health insurance.
- 15:02Managed care is based around the concept of provider
- 15:05networks, like PPOs and HMOs, where the provider
- 15:10contracts with the health plan to offer their
- 15:14services at a reduced cost. As the name suggests,
- 15:18it's all about managing care. through a network
- 15:21of providers who are contractually aligned with
- 15:24the health plan with the shared goal of keeping
- 15:27costs down. In California, managed care is regulated
- 15:32by the Department of Managed Health Care. A PPO
- 15:37is a managed care plan where you have the option
- 15:41to see doctors outside the network, but you pay
- 15:44a higher premium for that flexibility and likely
- 15:49you're going to pay higher out of pocket costs
- 15:51when you go out of network. A HMO limits you
- 15:56to seeing doctors within the plan's network and
- 15:59you must get referrals to specialists. from primary
- 16:02care doctors who act as, essentially act as gatekeepers
- 16:06to manage your care and keep costs down for the
- 16:09plan. Most Americans actually get their insurance
- 16:14from their employers, and employer sponsored
- 16:16insurance falls within the scope of the federal
- 16:20ERISA law. We'll talk a little bit more about
- 16:23ERISA in a few minutes, but for now, let me just
- 16:25point out that under ERISA, we have basically
- 16:29two types of plans. There's fully insured plans,
- 16:33which is like traditional insurance in that an
- 16:36insurance company insures the policy and it's
- 16:38on the hook for paying benefits. And then we've
- 16:41got self -insured plans, which means the employer
- 16:44is funding the plan and it's on the hook to pay
- 16:48the benefits. Self -funded plans, which are generally
- 16:51large employers. They hire the insurance companies
- 16:54to administer claims and to provide the employer
- 16:59access to a network of providers. Next slide,
- 17:04please. Let's spend a couple of minutes on Medicare,
- 17:11which happens to be the largest purchaser and
- 17:14payer of healthcare services in the United States.
- 17:18Medicare has different reimbursement. programs
- 17:21for different types of services. Part A is for
- 17:25hospitals and skilled nursing facilities. It
- 17:27follows a prospective payment system, which means
- 17:30that Medicare payment is based on a predetermined
- 17:33fixed amount. The payment for a particular service
- 17:37is derived from a classification system of that
- 17:40service. An example would be a diagnosis -related
- 17:44group for inpatient hospital services. Part B
- 17:48is for physicians and ancillary services such
- 17:51as medical equipment. It follows a fee schedule
- 17:55payment system, which means that services are
- 17:57reimbursed at a fixed fee as determined by federal
- 18:01regulation after the service has been rendered.
- 18:04If you've ever heard of the annual physician
- 18:07fee schedule, that's what this is referring to.
- 18:10Part C, which is known as Medicare Advantage,
- 18:13is a risk -bearing model where private insurance
- 18:16companies contract with the Medicare program
- 18:18to accept a certain amount of money. And then
- 18:21it's up to those companies to manage the care
- 18:23of the Medicare beneficiaries enrolled in that
- 18:26particular plan. And then finally, we've got
- 18:29Part D, which covers outpatient prescription
- 18:31drugs. It operates actually quite similar to
- 18:35Part C. An issue that comes up quite frequently
- 18:41in Medicare and other reimbursement programs
- 18:43is what happens when the provider is overpaid
- 18:47for their services. And this can happen for a
- 18:50number of reasons, including that the provider
- 18:52may have submitted incorrect information, or
- 18:55there was an administrative error at the payer's
- 18:57end that resulted in an overpayment. Of course,
- 19:01there could also be intentional fraud. I'm not
- 19:02really going to focus on that purpose of this
- 19:05discussion, but that, of course, is a reason
- 19:08for an overpayment as well. The law has long
- 19:12required that a provider who receives an overpayment
- 19:15must return the money within 60 days after identifying
- 19:20the overpayment. However, the underlying statute
- 19:24in the Medicare Act does not define what constitutes
- 19:28identification. And this has caused uncertainty
- 19:32and confusion and much litigation over the years.
- 19:36In 2025, the agency that administers the Medicare
- 19:40program, known as CMS, issued a rule stating
- 19:44that an overpayment has been identified when
- 19:47someone has actual knowledge of information that
- 19:50would establish an overpayment. Significantly,
- 19:54deliberate ignorance of the truth or falsity
- 19:57of that information or acting in reckless disregard
- 20:00of that information also constitutes identification.
- 20:04In other words, if you have information suggesting
- 20:07that you've received an overpayment, you can't
- 20:10just put your head in the sand. If you would
- 20:13have obtained actual knowledge by looking into
- 20:15the issue, then you're deemed to have identified
- 20:18the overpayment. Under the new rule, once a provider
- 20:22has identified an overpayment, then they have
- 20:26180 days to conduct a good faith investigation
- 20:30to determine the full scope of the overpayment.
- 20:33and quantify the full amount of the overpayment.
- 20:36So typically, if it's some billing error and
- 20:41a provider is submitting hundreds of claims,
- 20:43thousands of claims, and they discover that error
- 20:46with respect to one claim, then it's probably
- 20:49going to have infected all of those claims. So
- 20:51that's what this 180 days is for. It's for the
- 20:53provider to really do their due diligence, figure
- 20:55out how many claims were overpaid and what's
- 20:58the dollar amount at issue. then the provider
- 21:01then has 60 days, once they figure that out,
- 21:04they've got 60 days to refund the full amount
- 21:07to the government. And if a provider fails to
- 21:11comply with this rule, then that can give rise
- 21:15to False Claims Act liability. I don't, again,
- 21:19have time to delve deep into the False Claims
- 21:21Act, but let me just... briefly say for those
- 21:24of you who don't know what that is, it's a federal
- 21:26statute that's been around since like the Civil
- 21:28War. It applies to anybody who's contracting
- 21:32with the government and submitting claims to
- 21:33the government for payment. If you submit claims
- 21:36that are false, then you can be liable under
- 21:39this federal statute and you can be liable to
- 21:41pay back triple the amount that you received
- 21:45in payment. And there's all sorts of other penalties.
- 21:51You don't want a false claims act case being
- 21:53brought against you. So keep that in mind. The
- 21:56failure to comply with this rule, the 60 -day
- 21:57rule, could be the basis for a false claims act
- 22:02case against you, brought by the government or
- 22:04brought by whistleblower. If somebody in your
- 22:07organization or your client's organization understands
- 22:10these issues, they know that you've been overpaid
- 22:14and you're not voluntarily repaying that back.
- 22:17they might turn into a whistleblower under the
- 22:19False Claims Act. Okay, next slide please. All
- 22:26right, let's talk about per commercial payer
- 22:28disputes. This is probably the area of healthcare
- 22:31law that keeps me the busiest. I get a lot of
- 22:36calls and a lot of emails from providers who
- 22:38are having trouble getting paid from commercial
- 22:41payers. And one of the first questions I ask,
- 22:44or one of the first things I need to know, is
- 22:46whether the dispute involves in -network claims
- 22:49or out -of -network claims. In -network disputes
- 22:52are generally more run -of -the -mill. The provider
- 22:55has a contract with the payer where there's an
- 22:58agreement as to the price for services, which
- 23:02are usually pretty low rates. But what the provider
- 23:06gets in exchange for accepting these low rates
- 23:08is they get patient steerage. They are marketed
- 23:11by the payer as being within the network, and
- 23:15of course patients are encouraged to stay in
- 23:18network. Usually the contracts are pretty one
- 23:21-sided in favor of the payer, although there
- 23:24is a host of regulations that require certain
- 23:28terms to be present in the contracts to protect
- 23:31the provider. In -network disputes are resolved
- 23:34through mediation or arbitration. They rarely
- 23:37get into court. Where it can get really interesting
- 23:43is when a payer terminates the provider's contract.
- 23:48So I mentioned earlier that doctrine of fair
- 23:50procedure in the context of medical staff privileges.
- 23:55Well, that same doctrine of fair procedure has
- 23:57made its way into the world of healthcare contracting,
- 24:02at least on the private side, where if a plan
- 24:07terminates a provider, the provider can argue
- 24:10that they're entitled to a hearing before that
- 24:13contract termination goes into effect, because
- 24:16those contracts are so valuable. And some providers
- 24:20in a certain geographic area, I mean, if they're
- 24:22not contracted with that plan, they're out of
- 24:24business, essentially. So there's a well -known
- 24:27California Supreme Court case called Potman,
- 24:30where the court said, even if the contract says
- 24:33it can be terminated without cause, that would
- 24:36be unenforceable in certain circumstances and
- 24:39the payer, the plan would have to give that provider
- 24:43a procedurally fair hearing based on a termination
- 24:49that's based on substantively rational reasons.
- 24:54Turning to out of network disputes where the
- 24:56payer doesn't, sorry, the provider does not have
- 24:58a contract with the payer. These tend to be more
- 25:02contentious and are usually litigated in court.
- 25:05sometimes in state court, sometimes in federal
- 25:07court. And the reason these are more contentious
- 25:10disputes is because the provider can essentially
- 25:14bill the insurance company whatever price they
- 25:17want. And if they don't like the amount they
- 25:19receive for their services, they can file a lawsuit
- 25:21over it and seek a jury trial. Naturally, payers
- 25:25don't want to pay out of network rates and payers
- 25:30actively encourage members to stay in network.
- 25:32payers frequently come up with various initiatives
- 25:35to minimize the amount they paid out of network
- 25:38providers. Payers will audit and investigate
- 25:42in network providers, sorry, payers will audit
- 25:45and investigate out of network providers very
- 25:47aggressively and will go after out of network
- 25:52providers and put a stop payment on their tax
- 25:58ID number for really no reason at all often,
- 26:01in my view at least. And they do this, I think,
- 26:04often to slow down just making payment and to
- 26:07get around certain regulatory timelines that
- 26:10exist for making timely payments. So it gives
- 26:14the payer a chance to kind of put the brakes
- 26:17on things and kind of look into that out of network
- 26:19provider and maybe ultimately force that provider
- 26:22into some kind of negotiation where the provider
- 26:25is going to be accepting lower rates than what
- 26:27they're currently billing. Let's see, talk about
- 26:31ERISA for a minute. Most out of network disputes
- 26:35involve ERISA plans. Since the provider has no
- 26:38contract with the payer, the provider takes an
- 26:41assignment of benefits from the patient and submits
- 26:45claims as the assignee under the patient's health
- 26:49insurance policy. But when a dispute arises,
- 26:52the policy generally favors the payer and under
- 26:56federal ERISA law, the planned fiduciaries, which
- 26:59could include the insurance companies or the
- 27:01self -funded employer, they're giving an enormous
- 27:04amount of deference in how they interpret and
- 27:07apply the policy. So often, as a provider -side
- 27:12litigator, we'll often want to come up with a
- 27:15state law theory like implied contract or quantum
- 27:18merit or promissory estoppel in order to proceed
- 27:22in state court. On the other hand though, if
- 27:25the plan terms, if you're able to get ahold of
- 27:27the plan, you're representing an out -of -network
- 27:29provider and you're able to get the plan terms,
- 27:31you might find that they're actually quite favorable.
- 27:34And you might find that there's actually a straightforward
- 27:36case of the payer breaching the plan terms. And
- 27:41in that case, then we wanna be in federal court.
- 27:44We'll actively sue under ERISA as an assignee
- 27:48of the patient. Because under ERISA, if you're
- 27:52a prevailing plaintiff, then you do obtain attorney's
- 27:55fees. Whereas, of course, you're not going to
- 27:57get attorney's fees under a state law theory
- 28:00like a black contract. Listen, let's talk about
- 28:05mental health parity for a minute. So this is
- 28:11an area that's kept me pretty busy for the past
- 28:1310 years or so, because there's so many reimbursement
- 28:16disputes involving mental health providers. One
- 28:20reason this has been a hot area is because of
- 28:24the development and gradual strengthening of
- 28:27mental health parity laws. So what is mental
- 28:30health parity? It's a recognition that mental
- 28:33health and substance use disorders are a disease
- 28:36of the brain. They are health condition, not
- 28:39a moral condition. So these laws are designed
- 28:43to protect those suffering from mental health
- 28:46and substance use disorders from discriminatory
- 28:50insurance practices. It will probably come as
- 28:54no surprise that the insurance companies are
- 28:55not thrilled about paying for mental health care.
- 28:58And it's really largely a result of Obamacare
- 29:02and other initiatives that have really required
- 29:06mental health to be a covered service. It's a
- 29:09mandatory covered services. then the insurance
- 29:14companies will often try to find ways to avoid
- 29:16paying it. And so these parity laws now have
- 29:19been passed to make sure that mental health is
- 29:23not being discriminated against by the insurance
- 29:25companies. Probably the most important and pervasive
- 29:28parity law is the Federal Mental Health Parity
- 29:31and Addiction Equity Act of 2008. The gist of
- 29:36the federal parity law is that it prohibits more
- 29:39restrictive limitations for mental health and
- 29:44substance use sort of benefits compared to medical
- 29:48and surgical benefits within certain categories.
- 29:51So for example, outpatient services could be
- 29:54considered a similar classification. If an insurance
- 29:57company requires a pre -authorization to obtain
- 30:00outpatient mental health therapy, but does not
- 30:03require through pre -authorization for physical
- 30:06therapy, then that would be scrutinized under
- 30:09the federal parity law. This then forces payers
- 30:13to comply with this law. They must defend and
- 30:17justify treatment and limitations that apply
- 30:20solely to mental health coverage. A recent case
- 30:26illustrating the federal parity law in action
- 30:28is Allison B versus Blue Cross. There, the policyholders
- 30:34sought coverage for their minor child to attend
- 30:37a residential care facility for behavioral health
- 30:40and substance abuse issues. Even though there
- 30:43was clinical necessity, Blue Cross denied coverage,
- 30:46including on the basis that the facility did
- 30:49not have 24 -hour on -site nursing. The plaintiff
- 30:53alleged a violation of the parity law because
- 30:55Blue Cross applied stricter rules to mental health
- 30:59residential care than to comparable medical care.
- 31:03For example, Blue Cross did not require 24 -hour
- 31:07on -site nursing at skilled nursing facilities.
- 31:10Based on this and other rules that Blue Cross
- 31:13appeared to be enforcing more strictly in the
- 31:15mental health context, the court allowed that
- 31:18lawsuit to proceed. Another important development
- 31:22under the federal parity law is that certain
- 31:25regulatory requirements promulgated by the Department
- 31:28of Labor and Health and Human Services in 2024.
- 31:36These new rules would have significantly given
- 31:39more teeth to the law, more enforcement teeth.
- 31:43But that 2024 rule has since been put on ice
- 31:48by the Trump administration. So we're keeping
- 31:50an eye on that to see whether those rules will
- 31:54ever be given effect. They would be a huge benefit
- 31:59to both the patient and provider community, but
- 32:03the insurance company lobby was very, very strong
- 32:06in the situation, and the Trump administration,
- 32:08for the time being, is not enforcing those rules.
- 32:12Lastly, I should mention that California has
- 32:14its own version of a mental health parity law.
- 32:17It's been around a long time, and about five
- 32:21years ago, it was amended under Senate Bill 855
- 32:24to give additional protections. particularly
- 32:27for treatment of substance use disorders. However,
- 32:32the California law is limited in its application
- 32:34to health plans and insurance policies that are
- 32:37regulated by California law. So unlike the federal
- 32:40parity law, they generally do not reach employer
- 32:43-sponsored plans, which of course is where most
- 32:45people, most Americans get their health insurance.
- 32:48All right, next slide, please. Okay, we'll talk
- 33:00about regulatory compliance. This is really the
- 33:03bread and butter of healthcare law. As you probably
- 33:07already know, healthcare is an extremely regulated
- 33:10industry and you cannot do a transaction in healthcare
- 33:14without considering the regulatory risks involved.
- 33:18So whether you're a litigator or a transactional
- 33:20lawyer in healthcare, you can't help but also
- 33:23be a compliance lawyer. Next slide, please. I
- 33:30think a good place to start is what's known as
- 33:34the prohibition on the corporate practice of
- 33:36medicine. In broad terms, the corporate practice
- 33:41doctrine, it's a prohibition that makes it unlawful
- 33:45for a lay person or a lay corporation to employ
- 33:49physicians to practice medicine or to otherwise
- 33:52interfere in medical decision making. Of course,
- 33:55there are many workarounds. We have what is known
- 33:59as the MSO friendly PC model. So MSO stands for
- 34:04management services organization. What this is
- 34:08and it's pretty complex, but essentially you'll
- 34:11have a separate entity set up to manage the physician
- 34:16practice, the professional corporation that's
- 34:19owned by a doctor. And through various complicated
- 34:23contracts, it can be set up that if that physician
- 34:26ever leaves the practice, The MSO has the ability
- 34:29to essentially replace that physician with a
- 34:34new friendly physician. And there'll be restrictions
- 34:38on that departing physician's ability to compete
- 34:40and all that. So it's sort of a, yeah, it's a
- 34:45common workaround where you've got situations
- 34:47with lay people, lay corporations that want to
- 34:51essentially run a medical practice, but they
- 34:54can't own it because the law does not allow a...
- 34:57a lay person to own a medical practice or to
- 35:00directly employ a doctor. But instruction in
- 35:03these arrangements, healthcare lawyers have to
- 35:05be very careful that the MSO is not given control
- 35:09over decisions that should be left to the physician.
- 35:13And we must make sure that not to pay the MSO
- 35:16too much money, especially if the MSO is involved
- 35:19in marketing the physician's services, because
- 35:22then this can look like unlawful fee splitting
- 35:24for generating referrals. Another work around,
- 35:29a common work around the corporate practice doctrine
- 35:31is the medical foundation model. This is one
- 35:35of the main ways that large nonprofit hospital
- 35:38systems can integrate physician practices into
- 35:41their system. There are certain statutory elements
- 35:44to creating a foundation. Broad terms, there
- 35:49must be a clinic operated by a nonprofit corporation.
- 35:53The clinic must conduct medical research and
- 35:55provide clinical care. and the foundation must
- 35:58have a staff of at least 40 physicians who are
- 36:01not employed by the nonprofit corp. So pretty
- 36:04much these days, most of the large health care
- 36:06systems at this point have a medical foundation
- 36:09that contracts with all of the doctors. So a
- 36:14lot of ways those doctors are sort of beholden
- 36:16to that medical system. There's an interesting
- 36:19debate about whether the corporate practice doctrine
- 36:23is waning in California. On the one hand, there
- 36:26are a lot of practical and financial considerations
- 36:28that suggest the doctrine is antiquated. I've
- 36:33listed some factors here on this slide. There's
- 36:36health systems and large payers. They want to
- 36:38integrate the direct provision of professional
- 36:42services into their operations. There is a demand
- 36:45for physicians to practice more efficiently,
- 36:47to spend more time on patient care, which would
- 36:50then leave them less time for administrative
- 36:52and business concerns. So leave those concerns
- 36:55up to the business folks. And then, of course,
- 36:58there's private equity in venture capital that's
- 37:01needed to scale and compete in modern health
- 37:04care environments. And so a lot of doctors, they
- 37:07just need to bring in that capital to really
- 37:11be able to have a sustainable practice. So based
- 37:17on recent legislation though, it looks like the
- 37:20corporate practice doctrine isn't going away
- 37:22anytime soon. On January 1st of this year, two
- 37:26new California laws went into effect that established
- 37:29California as having the most strict corporate
- 37:32practice laws in the country. First, I'll talk
- 37:35about Senate Bill 351. It expressly applies the
- 37:40corporate practice of medicine doctrine to...
- 37:43corporate practice of medicine prohibition to
- 37:46private equity groups and hedge funds, prohibits
- 37:49them from interfering with the professional judgment
- 37:51of licensed healthcare professionals or exercising
- 37:54certain forms of control over healthcare operations,
- 37:58including through the use of management service
- 38:00organizations. SB 351 is a reaction to a perceived
- 38:05unhealthy influence by private equity in buying
- 38:09up healthcare practices and prioritizing profits
- 38:12over careful professional judgment. SP -51 also
- 38:18renders void any non -compete or non -disparagement
- 38:22provision in a contract involving the management
- 38:25of a physician practice. Notably though, this
- 38:29does not prevent a non -compete where a physician
- 38:33sells all of their equity in their practice or
- 38:36the business goodwill as part of an asset sale.
- 38:40Healthcare transaction lawyers aren't completely
- 38:43freaking out over Senate Bill 3521. They're still
- 38:45able to set up the MSO friendly PC model that
- 38:49I was talking about earlier. Assembly Bill 415
- 38:54extends existing reporting obligations to private
- 38:59equity and hedge funds when they engage in certain
- 39:02transactions involving healthcare entities. So
- 39:06there are certain transactions, which I'm not
- 39:08going to get into the weeds on that, but certain
- 39:10transactions have to be reported to a new state
- 39:12agency known as the Office of Healthcare Affordability.
- 39:18This agency, it can't block the transactions,
- 39:20but it can conduct a market analysis review that
- 39:26ultimately can slow the transaction down. So
- 39:29this is something that... If you're doing deals,
- 39:32healthcare deals in California, you need to be
- 39:34aware of this and kind of build this review into
- 39:37your timeline because you're not going to necessarily
- 39:41be able to close as quickly as the client may
- 39:44want to. So they need to understand the existence
- 39:47of these new laws. All right, next slide, please.
- 39:56All right, let's talk about the anti -kickback
- 39:57laws. These are laws that make it a crime to
- 40:03knowingly and willfully solicit, receive, pay,
- 40:07or offer any remuneration directly or indirectly,
- 40:12overtly or covertly, in cash or in kind, for
- 40:18the purpose of inducing a patient referral. I've
- 40:21listed some example anti -kickback laws that
- 40:25regularly come up in my practice. So we've got
- 40:28business and professions code section 650. This
- 40:31is a California law. It specifically applies
- 40:36to physicians. It basically prohibits what I
- 40:41just read. But what's interesting about this
- 40:44law is it does not require insurance payment.
- 40:47So if the payment's coming directly from the
- 40:50patient, then this law could still apply. Now,
- 40:53it's very rare that you see that situation where
- 40:56the the payments come from the patient, usually
- 40:58it's insurance, but just keep that in mind that
- 41:01650 does not require there to be insurance benefits
- 41:06at issue. On the other hand, insurance code section
- 41:09750 does require payment of insurance benefits,
- 41:16but 750 applies to anyone. So it's not limited
- 41:20to referrals for services paid by... by insurance
- 41:23regulated by the Department of Insurance, it
- 41:25can apply to any kind of referrals. Welfare and
- 41:31Institutions Code, Section 14107 .2. This is
- 41:36the Medi -Cal, basically the Medi -Cal anti -kickback
- 41:39statute. Again, it can apply to anyone or any
- 41:43kind of provider, but it's limited to referrals
- 41:47for services paid by Medi -Cal. Then we've got
- 41:51a couple of federal anti -kickback statutes.
- 41:54The first one, which is probably the most important
- 41:57anti -kickback statute is what we call the anti
- 42:02-kickback statute, the AKS, 42 USC section 1320A
- 42:07-7B. This is the, primarily it's the Medicare
- 42:11and Medicaid anti -kickback statute. This is
- 42:16a very complicated law. it's got a lot of what
- 42:21are known as safe harbors. Safe harbors are essentially
- 42:24exceptions. What that means is even if your conduct
- 42:31violates the prohibition of the anti -kickback
- 42:35law, if you meet one of these statutory or regulatory
- 42:40safe harbors, you're essentially given a free
- 42:43pass. So if the government over time has had
- 42:45to recognize it, This law is so broad in its
- 42:49application that there's so many transactions
- 42:51that would fall under its tent, it would make
- 42:56the business of healthcare impossible. So there's
- 42:58probably 30 safe harbors now. But there's still
- 43:03a lot of enforcement of the AKS. It's one of
- 43:07the most heavily enforced laws in healthcare.
- 43:16I mentioned a case here at the bottom, the 2025
- 43:19case, bottom of the slide, Pharmaceutical Coalition
- 43:22for Patient Access versus United States. And
- 43:27this is essentially a case that recognized how
- 43:31broadly interpreted the anti -kickback laws are.
- 43:35So in this case, the Fourth Circuit interpreted
- 43:38the term remuneration as any payment or consideration,
- 43:43even if it does not corrupt medical decision
- 43:46-making from the provider who's receiving the
- 43:49payment. And the court interpreted inducement
- 43:53as any remuneration that would influence the
- 43:56decision to purchase healthcare services or goods.
- 44:00In this case, The court held that a charitable
- 44:03patient assistance program funded by drug manufacturers
- 44:07would implicate the federal AKS so long as the
- 44:12program subsidizes the cost of drugs from the
- 44:15funding manufacturers, even if the program does
- 44:18not require the patient or the patient's referring
- 44:21physician to select any specific medication.
- 44:27I also mentioned in the slide, the ECRA law,
- 44:32that's 18 USC section 220. This is a kickback
- 44:39law that applies specifically to addiction recovery
- 44:43providers and clinical labs. It has also very
- 44:49broad exposure. It applies to commercial insurance
- 44:53and it has much fewer safe harbors than the Medicare
- 44:58AKS. And it's a particularly nasty law for laboratories,
- 45:03because historically labs would always look to
- 45:07AKS safe harbors to protect certain conduct.
- 45:11Well, now this ECRA applies to all labs, not
- 45:14just labs involved in addiction treatment. And
- 45:20while that was previously protected under the
- 45:23AKS, at least under the black letter of ECRA
- 45:26law, is not protected. So this is causing a lot
- 45:29of consternation and confusion in the lab industry
- 45:32and we expect that over time regulations will
- 45:37be passed that will clarify that perhaps this
- 45:40law is only applicable to clinical labs when
- 45:43it comes to their involvement in treatment, testing
- 45:47and treatment of addiction issues. And yeah,
- 45:54I'm running out of time here. So the main takeaway
- 45:57is that every business arrangement in transaction
- 45:59and healthcare should be carefully reviewed by
- 46:03healthcare counsel. to make sure there's not
- 46:05a violation of the many different anti -kickback
- 46:10laws. And keep in mind that violations of these
- 46:14laws carry both civil and criminal penalties.
- 46:18And on top of that, a violation of the federal
- 46:21anti -kickback statute can also be a predicate
- 46:25for a False Claims Act case. And I talked earlier
- 46:28about what the False Claims Act case is. All
- 46:32right, next slide, please. Let me spend a few
- 46:40minutes on the Stark Law. So the Stark Law generally
- 46:46prohibits physicians from referring patients
- 46:49for designated health services payable by Medicare
- 46:53to entities with which the physician or an immediate
- 46:57family member of the physician where they have
- 47:01a financial relationship unless there's a statutory
- 47:03or regulatory exception that applies. Designated
- 47:09health services include, among other things,
- 47:13laboratory services, imaging services, durable
- 47:16medical equipment, hospital services. So, for
- 47:20example, just to kind of put this in context,
- 47:21if a physician has privileges at a hospital,
- 47:26is referring to that hospital, and enters into
- 47:29some sort of transaction with the hospital, maybe
- 47:31the physician's going to lease office space from
- 47:35that hospital. That lease agreement then needs
- 47:39to be scrutinized very carefully to make sure
- 47:41it doesn't violate the Stark law. And as it turns
- 47:44out, there's a specific exception within Stark
- 47:47for leases between physicians and hospitals.
- 47:51So you need to look to see, well, is there an
- 47:53exception that applies? And if there is, you
- 47:55need to make sure you fit that transaction very
- 47:57specifically within the elements of that exception.
- 48:03It's very important to understand that the Stark
- 48:05law operates as a strict liability statute, so
- 48:09intent to violate the law is not required. If
- 48:12a financial relationship fails to meet the requirements
- 48:15of an applicable Stark exception, then referrals
- 48:19may be prohibited and claims that were submitted
- 48:22to Medicare based on those referrals may be deemed
- 48:25non -payable. As a result, Stark violations can
- 48:29trigger significant financial consequences, including
- 48:33repayment obligations, civil monetary penalties,
- 48:36and potential liability under the False Claims
- 48:38Act. Given that all health systems rely heavily
- 48:43on financial relationships with physicians who
- 48:46are in a position to refer patients to the hospital,
- 48:49Stark law compliance is a central component of
- 48:52any enterprise risk management. And this is well
- 48:56illustrated in a recent $345 million settlement
- 49:00between Community Health Network in Indiana and
- 49:04the federal government. And there the government
- 49:08alleged that the hospital's physician employment
- 49:11arrangements included compensation structures
- 49:14that were not commercially reasonable and that
- 49:18allegedly took into account the volume or value
- 49:22of referrals. being generated by those physicians.
- 49:26There was evidence that community engaged in
- 49:29aggressive physician recruitment and retention
- 49:32strategies, particularly with respect to high
- 49:35referring specialists. The government alleged
- 49:38that the compensation packages exceeded typical
- 49:42market benchmarks. In other words, it was not
- 49:47fair market value for those compensation. The
- 49:50government concluded that community's compensation
- 49:52assumptions, its productivity metrics, and all
- 49:56of this, the referral patterns, and I looked
- 49:58at the whole package, it simply did not align
- 50:02with a good faith fair market valuation analysis.
- 50:07So an important takeaway is that fair market
- 50:10value analyses should be grounded in accurate
- 50:14operational data. and reasonable assumptions.
- 50:17Hospitals and health systems regularly, they
- 50:20regularly use or employ valuation firms to conduct
- 50:24and prepare a fair market valuation report. But
- 50:28it's up to the provider, up to that entity, to
- 50:31provide the valuation firm with complete and
- 50:34accurate information regarding physician duties,
- 50:38expected productivity, call coverage obligations.
- 50:42service line, economics, all of those factors
- 50:44are very important, and they must be accurate.
- 50:47Otherwise, you're going to get a, because in
- 50:49community health, you know, the hospital said,
- 50:51well, wait a minute, we've got a valuation report.
- 50:53What we're paying these doctors was what our
- 50:56valuation firm said we could pay. But as it turned
- 50:58out, all the underlying information that the
- 51:01valuation firm was provided to prepare those
- 51:03reports was just not accurate. It wasn't, the
- 51:06assumptions were not realistic. Okay, next slide,
- 51:11please. Okay, we'll conclude here with the Health
- 51:21Insurance Portability and Accountability Act
- 51:23of 1996, better known as HIPAA. So, what does
- 51:31HIPAA, what does it protect? What type of information
- 51:34is protected by HIPAA? It's what we call patient
- 51:40identifying information. We know it as PHI. patient
- 51:46health information or protected health information.
- 51:49But that's what we know in the industry called
- 51:50PHI. And it covers, HIPAA covers what are known
- 51:57as covered entities. So covered entities are
- 52:00pretty much healthcare providers. It's a little
- 52:04more complicated than that, more nuanced than
- 52:06that, but essentially it's healthcare providers.
- 52:08But it also covers those providers. business
- 52:12associates. So anybody who's contracting with
- 52:14those providers and receiving that PHI is also
- 52:17within the scope of HIPAA. So for example, as
- 52:19healthcare lawyers, every time we have a new
- 52:22client sign an engagement agreement, we also
- 52:25have them sign what's called a business associate
- 52:27agreement. And that's an agreement that's designed
- 52:30to comply with HIPAA that enables us to receive
- 52:34that PHI information from our clients so that
- 52:37we can do our jobs. But without that business
- 52:40associate agreement, if there was some kind of
- 52:41audit, not only would our clients get in trouble,
- 52:45we could get in trouble as well. And how does
- 52:50patient information, how does it get used and
- 52:53disclosed under HIPAA? There's all these privacy
- 52:56rules, these security rules. It's all quite complicated
- 53:00and I don't have time to get into it. But what
- 53:02I'll say is what is the golden rule is you always
- 53:06have to disclose what's minimum necessary. So
- 53:11even if it's a protected disclosure from one
- 53:16provider to another provider, that provider can
- 53:19only give what's the minimum amount of PHI that's
- 53:23necessary for the other provider to do what they
- 53:25need to do. There are two providers working with
- 53:28the same patient. you know, the one provider
- 53:33can't say, oh, you know what? And here's also
- 53:34this person's therapy notes. Like that would
- 53:37be a violation of HIPAA. But if they were, you
- 53:41know, two providers working on some cardiology
- 53:43issue, then obviously any records relating to
- 53:46those issues would be fair, it would be protected.
- 53:52HIPAA is a law that, well, before I get into
- 53:56that, let me point out that Enforcement under
- 54:00HIPAA is driven by the Health and Human Services
- 54:04Office for Civil Rights. If you discover a HIPAA
- 54:08violation, if you're a provider or a covered
- 54:09entity that discovers a HIPAA violation, you've
- 54:11got certain required reporting obligations, certain
- 54:16corrective actions that you need to take. And
- 54:19if you don't do all those things timely and efficiently,
- 54:22then you are... subject to fines and possible
- 54:27referrals to the Department of Justice. The common
- 54:32enforcement issues that we see are lack of safety
- 54:35that covered entities don't have enough safeguards
- 54:37in place to protect PHI. They're doing silly
- 54:40things like transmitting PHI through non -secure
- 54:44channels. They're not... you know, storing it,
- 54:48and they're leaving the laptop in the car kind
- 54:50of thing, or somebody steals the car, gets the
- 54:53laptop, opens it up, and there's tons of patient
- 54:55information on the laptop. They're not giving
- 55:01patients adequate access to their own information,
- 55:04and they're disclosing more information than
- 55:08is necessary. Those are the kinds of things that
- 55:10we see get commonly enforced by the Office for
- 55:15Civil Rights. It's important to know that there
- 55:19is no private right of action under HIPAA. So
- 55:22a patient whose HIPAA rights have been violated
- 55:25actually can't sue directly under a HIPAA. But
- 55:30California has a very similar law, in fact, in
- 55:32a lot of ways more strict than HIPAA, known as
- 55:35the California Medical Information Act. It's
- 55:37a civil code section 56 .10. And it does give
- 55:43a private right of action. So typically if there's
- 55:45a HIPAA violation, and a patient wants to bring
- 55:48a lawsuit, they're going to bring it under the
- 55:50CMIA. Last thing I'll say is that HIPAA is actually
- 55:55a really good way to segue into talking about
- 55:58telehealth and AI in healthcare, which I would
- 56:03love to be able to talk about. I don't have the
- 56:04time, and we would need an entire separate presentation
- 56:07on that. but it's really kind of quite fascinating.
- 56:11It's probably the main area. Telehealth and AI
- 56:13is absolutely the main area of innovation and
- 56:16transformation in healthcare. Legislators and
- 56:20regulators are rushing to catch up. And I think
- 56:23the primary challenge is ensuring that AI tools,
- 56:29that those tools are being used to make decisions
- 56:32about healthcare in a way that's... actively
- 56:36supervised by physicians and other qualified
- 56:39personnel. It's not much different than using
- 56:41it in AI and law or any other industry. You want
- 56:43to make sure that people are still involved and
- 56:45are overseeing what's being done. So with that,
- 56:49I've run out of time. I am happy to take a few
- 56:52questions. And thank you very much for listening.
- 57:11Yeah, I'm not seeing any questions so Well, so
- 57:17it looks like we don't have any questions um
- 57:20Thank you John for an excellent presentation
- 57:23and thank you so much to our audience. Have a
- 57:25great day everybody All right. Thank you