Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / CAMEL CODE 4 - What You NEED to Know
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Hey, everyone.
- 0:35This is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:38I'm excited today to be here with Steve Farr and Todd Miller.
- 0:42You've heard them here often and guys, how are you doing today?
- 0:46Doing good.
- 0:47Doing good.
- 0:47Still doing good.
- 0:48Glad to hear it.
- 0:49Doing well as well.
- 0:51Doing well.
- 0:51All right.
- 0:52And so some listeners may have not heard They may be new but as a refresher for
- 0:57the old time listeners or the the new listeners, Steve, why don't you give
- 1:02a little bit of your background and what you did at NCUA before retiring
- 1:06from NCUA and then changing teams with Todd and I and helping credit unions.
- 1:11Okay.
- 1:12Yeah, I can break my 30 year career at NCA into to two separate pieces.
- 1:18The first 15 years I was in the field predominantly as a problem case officer
- 1:24working with credit unions primarily on the west coast, but got involved
- 1:27in projects throughout the nation.
- 1:30Then I spent the next basically 15 years in the central office in
- 1:34the division of risk management.
- 1:36Involved in multiple projects there that get me very interested and engaged doing
- 1:43the enforcement manual, the corporate resolution risk based capital which
- 1:49I finished up right before I retired.
- 1:51And it took forever for that to come into place.
- 1:54Then in retirement I did get called in and worked at a conservatorship
- 2:00for NCOA as a chief financial officer.
- 2:03That was kinda my changing over from being an NCOA to being on the side of
- 2:08the, working with the credit unions closely and then have been working
- 2:11with Mark since we started his agency.
- 2:13Very good.
- 2:14And Todd?
- 2:15So I spent right at 34 years with N.
- 2:18C.
- 2:18U.
- 2:18A.
- 2:18I can break my career into maybe three pieces as opposed to Steve's to
- 2:23I spent the 1st decade roughly as a.
- 2:27Examiner and problem case officer in the western region.
- 2:31That middle third of my career, I spent it as a regional capital market
- 2:35specialist in the western region that also involved a lot of training of
- 2:39the examiners on interest rate, risk, liquidity and investments involved writing
- 2:44policies for NCUA's interest rate, risk, and liquidity reviews at that time.
- 2:49And then the last 11 years of my career, I spent it as a director of
- 2:52special actions in the Western region, supervising problem case officers and
- 2:57supervising regional capital market specialists, sat on more than a few
- 3:01committees during that time frame that were internal to NCUA, including
- 3:05their supervisory review committee.
- 3:08All in all, it was an enjoyable 34 years.
- 3:11I retired and Martin gave me about three months off and called
- 3:13me and said, Hey, can you come back to work for the other side?
- 3:16I said, that sounds fun.
- 3:18And it has been.
- 3:19And we've been having fun ever since.
- 3:21Some of our best war stories, some of our greatest accomplishments, some
- 3:25of our proudest moments in credit unions was when a credit union Would
- 3:31have to became troubled, right?
- 3:33And went into special actions or as a principal examiner,
- 3:36you work with the credit union.
- 3:38They have some issues.
- 3:40You get a good working relationship going.
- 3:42Credit union takes it serious.
- 3:44And lo and behold, they might come out stronger.
- 3:46But to get to that point, you have to have a setback first.
- 3:49Your code, your camel code one to forever Some bad luck comes along or
- 3:54some bad decisions come along and gets a little bit more aggressive code.
- 3:58You a three.
- 3:59We did a podcast on that.
- 4:01We published last week on that.
- 4:03Now we're in a credit union that has transitioned from a 3 to a 4
- 4:08or from a 2 to a 4, which happens on occasions when stuff goes awry.
- 4:13And that's what this podcast is about.
- 4:16It's about becoming a camel code for, and I'll never say camels it's camel to me.
- 4:20You, they added the yes, but in my mind, it's camel camel, you'll be
- 4:24your camel code for, and so your camel code for, so now what does
- 4:29that mean for the credit union?
- 4:30What does it mean for NCUA?
- 4:32What should a credit union be expecting?
- 4:35What are your thoughts relative to a downgrade just happened today?
- 4:38What does that mean?
- 4:40From NCOA's perspective, once you become a CAMEL 4 they generally see you
- 4:46as a cretine that's exhibiting unsafe and unsound practices or conditions.
- 4:53They think risk management practices are unacceptable relative to
- 4:58the cretine size and complexity.
- 5:00They may even have some concerns whether management is willing and
- 5:04able to correct the nature of these problems, which they consider severe.
- 5:10And as such, it informs their entire supervision process and
- 5:16their administrative record process.
- 5:18At this point, they are building an administrative record.
- 5:21So if things continue to go south, it enables them to take other actions.
- 5:26So they're starting that whole building block of a formal administrative record.
- 5:32So the first thing as a code for what it means is you're going to be under
- 5:36some form of administrative action.
- 5:38In most cases, that's an unpublished letter of understanding and agreement.
- 5:42If a board doesn't agree to that, they can end up with a preliminary warning letter.
- 5:47Generally, these are unpublished, although they may be published.
- 5:51There's reputation risk if they're published.
- 5:54For some of the state chartered credit unions, publication of these are
- 5:58required, depending on state statutes.
- 6:00There's not a lot of states, but there is a few states out there
- 6:03that do require these administrative actions to be published.
- 6:07The next biggest thing that's going to happen is you're going to see
- 6:10your examiners every 120 days.
- 6:13So they're going to be doing an exam.
- 6:15They're going to do follow ups a couple times a year.
- 6:18So you're going to get to know your examiner very well because you're going
- 6:21to be seeing them very frequently.
- 6:24They're probably going to spend six to eight to 12 weeks a year with you.
- 6:28So that's a good chunk of the year that you're going to have examiners
- 6:32involved with your operation then.
- 6:35It's a huge burden just to deal with that aspect of it, but from NCOA's
- 6:41perspective, that needs to occur.
- 6:43They need to know that you're resolving problems and they're going to make
- 6:48themselves a bee in your bonnet until problems are resolved or they know
- 6:51they have to take some other action.
- 6:53Other things that go with the Code 4 when NCOA codes a credit unit for the
- 6:58Federal Reserve is known, let known, and so usually you're going to lose
- 7:03access to your daylight overdrafts.
- 7:05They may actually ask you to, if you're borrowing from the Fed or have
- 7:09borrowing agreements with the Federal Reserve, they may start asking you
- 7:13for more collateral, or they may ask you to put your collateral on site.
- 7:17I've seen that in a number of different places with the Federal Reserve Bank.
- 7:21Most Code 4 credit unions are not borrowing from the Federal Reserve,
- 7:24but it does occur on occasion.
- 7:27If you're a larger credit union, you're likely to get assigned to
- 7:30the Division of Special Actions.
- 7:33If you're one of the worst problems in the region, that can be a good or bad thing.
- 7:37Actually, a lot of troubled credit unions find it's a good thing because those
- 7:41Problem case officers have more experience than regular examiners and there tend
- 7:46to be a little bit more open minded and have a broader set of experiences
- 7:51as to what works and doesn't work.
- 7:53So in many cases, that turns out to be a good thing for the credit union.
- 7:58But the big thing for writing under a code for You're going to be spending
- 8:03that 12, 18, 20 weeks a year with your PCO examiner because they're going to be
- 8:09doing exams or follow ups every 120 days.
- 8:13And did you say did I don't know if I caught you talk about the Federal
- 8:16Reserve, but the Federal Home Loan Bank also becomes aware of the camel
- 8:21cone for eventually the Federal Home Loan Bank, with the Federal Reserve
- 8:25NCA tells the Federal Reserve when we go to place the floor so they know
- 8:29within a couple days of when the exam is completed, the Federal Reserve.
- 8:34Federal Home Loan Bank, we don't actually tell them, but the Federal Home Loan
- 8:38Bank has their own credit reviews.
- 8:41Once a year, they typically ask NCUA for an exam report, and they pay us whatever
- 8:47they, NCUA charges them nowadays for that.
- 8:49They do charge the FHLB for those exam reports.
- 8:53So eventually, the FHLB is going to find out because as part of their credit review
- 8:58processes, they tend to ask for those exam reports once a year or every 18 months.
- 9:04And so eventually, they will find out and it may affect how you deal with them.
- 9:11A lot of the FHLB credit processes are net worth driven, though, as opposed to CAMEL.
- 9:17I'm sure you get a higher risk rating when FHLB finds out you're a code 4,
- 9:21but if you still have decent net worth, it doesn't seem in my history with
- 9:26as a PCO and a DSA, it doesn't seem to impact your borrowing authority to
- 9:33getting a camel 4 if your net worth is still up at those regulatory levels.
- 9:38As soon as your net worth starts dropping down into PCA and stuff then it can impact
- 9:44your borrowing ability with the FHLBs.
- 9:46They will start shortening the length of terms that you can borrow.
- 9:50So instead of long term advances that are going to cut you down to shorter
- 9:53term time periods, they may start asking you to they'll put haircuts on your
- 9:59collateral when net worth starts getting down under that five percent range.
- 10:05It's not Unusual for the FHLB to say haul those loan files over to our
- 10:10office or some other designated third party where we want them stored.
- 10:15And there's a huge operational expense involved in that too because now you
- 10:18don't have your original files and people refinance and things of that nature.
- 10:23You're checking them back out of the facility.
- 10:25It becomes A burdensome and basically if you get a code four as a credit union
- 10:31for the board and management your life is going to become more burdensome.
- 10:36It's a little bit more problematic, which reminds me of a post I did
- 10:39when I first started taking a country western song that was called, How
- 10:43Can I Miss You If You Won't Go Away.
- 10:46And they don't go away.
- 10:47It seems like they're always there.
- 10:49You said 20 weeks.
- 10:51Your examiners come visit for a long time.
- 10:53And I got a question for Steve as it relates to what Todd just said,
- 10:57and the central liquidity facility.
- 11:00So let's say you're downgraded to a, from a 3 to a 4.
- 11:04There are, Some liquidity challenges.
- 11:07The federal home loan bank says, yeah, you know what?
- 11:09We're going to give you more haircuts on this, or we're going to
- 11:12cut your line because of capital.
- 11:15And then lo and behold you've got a line, the last line that you can utilize is
- 11:20at the corporate, the local corporate there's a thing called a lot of credit
- 11:24unions don't know about it, but a guaranteed line of credit at the corporate
- 11:27and the CLF gets involved in that.
- 11:30Can you share?
- 11:31Now, this isn't directly linked to a 4, but I would say there's a strong
- 11:35correlation that code 4s might end up at the doorstep of their corporate.
- 11:40And then the corporate may make a phone call to N.
- 11:42C.
- 11:43U.
- 11:43A.
- 11:43Could you expand upon what I just tiptoed into there, Steve?
- 11:47Yeah, and there's always.
- 11:49Mistakes made on that.
- 11:50And yes, you do have the option of joining the central liquidity facility,
- 11:55but that the central liquidity isn't really a lender of last resort in that.
- 12:00You still have to be credit worthy to get a loan from the
- 12:02central liquidity facility.
- 12:04And then there's this whole, you have to do the deposit and all that kind of stuff.
- 12:08So it is a source.
- 12:09Of liquidity that's out there in addition to the other ones
- 12:13that are receiving the reports.
- 12:15Mark talked about a guaranteed line of credit, which is a type of to
- 12:20assistance under Section 208 of the Federal Credit Union Act, and that
- 12:24the insurance fund would basically be guaranteeing payment to the we usually
- 12:31work with the corporate credit union on doing guaranteed lines of credit.
- 12:35Now, they used to be used more often when we had credit unions that were
- 12:40operating with lower levels of capital.
- 12:42But since PCA, they're really rare that we would do those.
- 12:46And you might see it in terms of if you were in conservatorship.
- 12:51Now, the other thing that I wanted to bring up on that is, is, as credit
- 12:56unions get to be a camel four, and they're larger, it can start to have.
- 13:02Some impact on the N.
- 13:04C.
- 13:04U.
- 13:04S.
- 13:05I.
- 13:05F.
- 13:05equity ratio because the math is there is the same as your credit unions is your
- 13:11delinquency on your portfolio increases.
- 13:14You have to have more money set aside for.
- 13:16The expected losses on that.
- 13:19So the same thing happens is that credit unions camo codes
- 13:23become worse and they're larger.
- 13:26You can start seeing that the insurance fund is starting to have to put more money
- 13:31in the reserve for losses, which reduces the equity of the insurance fund, which.
- 13:35Can lead to reduction in the equity level and potential premiums that
- 13:40have to be paid to recover from that.
- 13:43So that all plays into that equation on that.
- 13:45So I thought it would bring that up.
- 13:47That's a great point.
- 13:48And when we talked about code 3s in our code 3 podcast, we talked about
- 13:53trends of large code 3s increasing and that the smaller code 3s in number.
- 14:00the same, adjusting for mergers, but that the growth seemed to be That the average
- 14:05size of a code three was going up because when a few big credit unions fall into
- 14:09that category, it can impact the numbers.
- 14:12And of course, if they slip into code fours, as you're saying that can increase
- 14:17the map on math on the calculation.
- 14:20On what needs to be in the insurance fund so far, the code 3 code for
- 14:24data doesn't seem to reveal too much.
- 14:28I don't know if you have that there in front of you, but
- 14:30are there any trends in code?
- 14:324 is that you've seen?
- 14:33Or is that maybe what's coming around the band?
- 14:35On the short run there, they haven't increased the number.
- 14:37It's been 125.
- 14:39Gamma fours in December and again in March.
- 14:43It was the same number, but the assets and their increase from 5.
- 14:465 billion to 7 billion.
- 14:49But if you look at like FBI, see, sometimes runs a little bit ahead
- 14:53of recognizing potential problems a little bit faster than in two.
- 14:58It is in the same time period.
- 15:02They went from 52 institutions that are the problem bank, which is four
- 15:07and five from 52 to 63, but their assets went from 66 billion in
- 15:13those institutions to 82 billion.
- 15:15And that's what we're always concerned about is, now that this, the delinquency
- 15:19is coming up and we're seeing more losses that are occurring on the credit side.
- 15:23And the credit side is where the insurance fund gets its losses.
- 15:27We can ride through liquidity and interest rate risk might
- 15:31cause an institution to fail.
- 15:33It doesn't generally cost the insurance fund money.
- 15:36Credit losses cause the insur insurance fund money.
- 15:39So that's that's why, people get really concerned once you're a Camel
- 15:444, and that it needs to be fixed quickly, so it doesn't turn out to
- 15:47be a loss to the insurance fund.
- 15:49Because I was always that, the NFL for the football league has protect
- 15:53the shield and I was always out there.
- 15:55My job is to protect the fun And that was a real cheerleader on that when I was in
- 16:00ncua And then at the end of the day when all the people at ncua gather at the bar
- 16:05They would toast to the fund because the fund was paying their salary you hung
- 16:10out with different examiners than I did
- 16:13That was an east coast thing.
- 16:14That was a There's a, there's someone who may or may not be in the office
- 16:19of the national exam and supervision who was who started not saying at what
- 16:23level and not at the top, not at the tippy top, but there was someone that,
- 16:28that came up with toasting to the fund.
- 16:30And if they're, I don't know if they're a listener, but there are,
- 16:32they're probably smiling right now.
- 16:33All right.
- 16:34And.
- 16:35So go ahead, Todd.
- 16:36There's one more thing we didn't talk about that applies to camel
- 16:40fours is they're officially a troubled credit union under section
- 16:45seven Oh one 14 of the regulations.
- 16:47And NC way now gets a say in change of senior management
- 16:51officials and elected officials.
- 16:53So there's an approval process and they have a right to veto various
- 16:59management changes or board changes.
- 17:03And that That's just another administrative burden of putting the
- 17:06people in putting their resume and whether it's a board member or an official.
- 17:10Now, refresh my memory.
- 17:11Some of them can serve temporarily.
- 17:13Is it so if you have a board election, they can serve for
- 17:1730 days without that approval.
- 17:21I'd have to go back and read the reg.
- 17:22I think you have to send notice into NCA like by the third business day
- 17:27or something that air here's a change in our election and I don't know,
- 17:31you got until day seven or something where somewhere in there to actually
- 17:34send in the change in approval, you'd have to go look up the reg.
- 17:37I don't remember it exactly, but elected officials can serve.
- 17:42For that 30 day period while NCOA processes that approval form, or
- 17:48senior executives, they need approval from NCOA before they can serve.
- 17:54And and the obviously the reason there is there's risk to the fund.
- 17:58They want to make sure who's ever put in place at an institution coded a four
- 18:02as the skill sets to help reposition and reduce the risk to the credit union.
- 18:07And then, of course, thereby reducing the risk to the insurance
- 18:11does say no to some of those.
- 18:13They do.
- 18:14They do.
- 18:15Indeed.
- 18:15I think we've all been involved in a few of those.
- 18:17More often than not, if you've done a good search and there's no skeletons per
- 18:22se in the closet of who you've selected, you'll see approval so you can get them on
- 18:27board and start dealing with the issues.
- 18:29Now code ones and twos can get document resolutions.
- 18:33Code threes.
- 18:33You're definitely going to have a document resolution.
- 18:36So now you're a code for You got You're going to have document resolutions,
- 18:42but those document resolutions might also then turn into what?
- 18:46In most places if NCUA's preferred path is they turn into an unpublished
- 18:51letter of understanding and agreement.
- 18:53That's the preferred and the path that happens most of the time.
- 18:58Some cardines prefer not to enter into letters of understanding and agreement.
- 19:03So NCUA will issue you a preliminary warning letter if you refuse to sign
- 19:08that letter of understanding agreement.
- 19:10It will say essentially all of the same items.
- 19:13Increasingly NCOA is reserving the right to publish letters
- 19:17of understanding and agreement.
- 19:19Historically, they do that in only rare cases.
- 19:23And like we mentioned earlier in the podcast, there are some states
- 19:26that have statutes that require them to publish those letters
- 19:29of understanding and agreement.
- 19:31Now, usually they bury it on their webpage, they don't issue a press release
- 19:35to the newspapers or anything because they would rather the public not know
- 19:39and create reputation risk for the credit union, but there are some states that will
- 19:44publish those letters of understanding agreement because they have no choice.
- 19:48Their statutes require it.
- 19:50If you're a state charter, just know what your state regulations
- 19:53require if you fall into this task.
- 19:56There's a special thing too, so we've talked about code fours in general, but
- 20:01there's code fours that start having challenges to capital, and once your
- 20:06net worth starts falling below those regulatory limits and you have that code
- 20:11four, There's other implications too.
- 20:14You start finding out all your letters want, lenders want collateral.
- 20:19If you're doing mortgage, selling mortgages on the secondary market,
- 20:24this gets very problematic.
- 20:26And especially with Bannie Mae and choosing to not want to buy your
- 20:31mortgages, Bannie Mae will often take your servicing rights away from you.
- 20:35Bannie Mae will often make you post collateral.
- 20:38to retain those servicing rights.
- 20:41So there's other implications that come into play if your capital starts falling
- 20:47at the same time you get that code four.
- 20:50Got it.
- 20:51Yeah.
- 20:51So it's not a good place to be.
- 20:53You might get assigned to special actions, generally speaking,
- 20:56after the shock and awe of getting assigned to special actions is over.
- 21:01Generally speaking, I think our history has been that the credit union Likes the
- 21:05better staff, the more educated, longer term staff the not so risk averse staff
- 21:09that are in special actions because sometimes they've seen so much more
- 21:13that they have a better context because of the journey that they've been on.
- 21:17At least a better resolution for the credit union.
- 21:20So anything else on code for us before we do a short chat about code fives.
- 21:27We talked about this in our Code 3 podcast too.
- 21:29There's a higher expectation on the board that they're going to hold management
- 21:33accountable and monitor progress on these DOORS and administrative actions.
- 21:38There's an expectation that management's going to keep their board informed as
- 21:42to progress on resolving these issues.
- 21:45In general, though, for board members, NCUA is going to put more pressure on
- 21:50them to hold their management accountable and understand the nature of the
- 21:55problems and what is needed for progress.
- 21:59There's going to be some expectation that the board will authorize the resources
- 22:03necessary to address these problems, because generally when you get down
- 22:07to the Code 4, it involves additional people, additional third parties, lots
- 22:11of overtime expense levels will go up.
- 22:14Even though NCOA might give you a door that says reduce expenses, the corrective
- 22:19actions are going to usually require you to spend a fair amount of money.
- 22:23And there's going to be some expectations that board are
- 22:26going to authorize the resources necessary to resolve these problems.
- 22:32Makes sense.
- 22:33Steve, any last thoughts on force?
- 22:35Yeah, and those documents or resolutions for fours often become
- 22:39really voluminous and it becomes a big project management issue.
- 22:43And what part of that project management is that reporting that Todd talked about.
- 22:47Very good.
- 22:48The worst code it's the functional equivalent of an F in school, right?
- 22:52If a 4 is a D and a 3 is a C, and NCOA doesn't really look at it in
- 22:56that mind, but I always did when I was there because it's an easy translation.
- 23:01If you get an F in school You might have to withdraw from the class.
- 23:05We might have to redo the class.
- 23:07Code fives are rare, but any thoughts on, and I can always
- 23:11remember it's okay it's good.
- 23:12It's a four, it's going to be a five.
- 23:15You start.
- 23:16Coding it a five, we're thinking of further administrative actions and
- 23:19sometimes you think you're writing a code five and before you deliver
- 23:23the report, you actually end up conserving the credit union because
- 23:25the risks are identified are so bad.
- 23:27But general thoughts on the death wish code also known as a camel code five.
- 23:33Yeah, failure is usually imminent and you're either going to be, they're
- 23:36going to be quickly trying to find a merger partner for you, but it'll be a
- 23:42merger partner with NCOA or in the state regulator, highly involved in that process
- 23:48and your choices will be very limited.
- 23:50They'll take the least cost option to resolve the credit union quickly.
- 23:56Excellent point.
- 23:57In other words, what Steve is saying is the regulator is going to
- 24:00pick your merger partner, not you.
- 24:02Self determination is out the window at that juncture.
- 24:06At that point, as an NCUA employee, you're just trying to reduce the cost
- 24:11of the insurance fund to the lowest dollar possible by any means possible.
- 24:15Well said.
- 24:16Said.
- 24:16All right, guys, we'll go ahead.
- 24:18Todd, looks like you were going to say something.
- 24:20No, we do NCUA.
- 24:22Really for code fives, and you mentioned it already, you're getting ready to write
- 24:26a report to issue a code five and quite often it turns into a conservatorship.
- 24:31Especially in recessionary area periods, that's very much a true statement.
- 24:35We talked about fun stuff that we've had as examiners and probably the
- 24:41most gratifying thing is, taking a conservatorship and actually fixing
- 24:45it and returning it to the members.
- 24:48Prior to the credit union membership act, there was lots of easy ways
- 24:51for NCUA to provide cash assistance for credit unions to keep them open.
- 24:56And I know Steve did a lot of that early in his career.
- 25:00I did a little bit of it.
- 25:02The credit union membership act took away NCUA's ability to provide assistance
- 25:06to keep a failing credit union open.
- 25:08It, came back to NCUA in 2010 2011, but it's very much limited to capital
- 25:14notes, no other form of assistance.
- 25:17And so they're done pretty rarely, although we did do a couple
- 25:20of them at the last recession.
- 25:22NCUA did save a couple conservatorships by recapitalizing them.
- 25:26Those were always the most rewarding parts of the job, though, is when
- 25:29you take a trouble crediting and actually resolve those issues and
- 25:33see it returned to the members.
- 25:35Yeah, that's a great point.
- 25:37It reminds me of an act, an old acronym, right?
- 25:39The P.
- 25:39U.
- 25:40E.
- 25:40D.
- 25:41the prior undivided earnings deficit for what Todd's alluding to is you N.
- 25:46C.
- 25:47U.
- 25:47A.
- 25:47could guarantee a deficit.
- 25:48So where we have prompt corrective action now.
- 25:51That says you have to do this at 7%, you have to do this at 6, you have to
- 25:55do this at 4, you fall under 4, NCOA is pushing you to merge and or having other
- 26:00corrective action and a plan for you to merge at some point in time in there,
- 26:04is it at 2 or 4, they have to conserve.
- 26:07We used to let credit unions run if they put a plan together to get
- 26:11back to zero within four, within 24 months, if I remember right.
- 26:18That was the general timeframe.
- 26:19I did two or three PUE Ds.
- 26:22Steve probably did a dozen or more.
- 26:25It's.
- 26:26I understand the public policy point of view of why they can no longer do that.
- 26:31But I can also just actually look around today and see at least five credit unions
- 26:36that we saved that way that it would have otherwise been closed in the early
- 26:401990s that are still here today in 2024.
- 26:44They were successful ways to preserve a credit union.
- 26:49It's unfortunate that statutes by Congress no longer give NCUA that option anymore.
- 26:55Agree.
- 26:56I agree.
- 26:56Those were good tools to be able to use in the right situations and they took
- 27:00flexibility out of staff's hands because public policy required that to happen.
- 27:07All right, guys, any last thoughts here before we wrap
- 27:09up today on fours and fives?
- 27:12Very good.
- 27:13As always, this was fun.
- 27:14Brings back triggers, some synapses.
- 27:16I hadn't thought of the acronym P U E D in, in a few years.
- 27:21That's always fun to, to make my brain think of a long lost acronyms.
- 27:26Thanks so much guys.
- 27:28Take care.
- 27:29Have a good day.
- 27:30You too.
- 27:31And listeners, as always, I appreciate you listening.
- 27:34I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 27:36Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 27:44Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 27:48your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 27:52of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 27:56If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 27:59out our services at marktreichel.
- 28:02com.