Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage a Team Member Who Always Says I Tried That
Transcript
- Lucas: You propose a new approach in a team meeting, and before you've even finished the sentence, one of your senior people says, 'I tried that. It didn't work.' And just like that, the idea is dead. Luna: I've been on both sides of that. As a manager, it's exhausting. As the person saying it, I thought I was being helpful — saving everyone time. Lucas: Right. That's the tricky part. The employee often genuinely believes they're protecting the team from wasted effort. But when it becomes a reflex, it shuts down innovation and creates a culture where no new idea survives. Luna: So how do you tell the difference between helpful caution and a pattern that's holding the team back? Lucas: Frequency is the first clue. If it happens more than once a month with the same person, you've got a pattern. I worked with a marketing manager at a mid-sized SaaS company — let's call her Priya — who, in a single one-hour meeting, shot down seven out of eight proposed campaign strategies with 'I tried that.' Luna: Seven out of eight. At that point it's not about the ideas, it's about the person. Lucas: Exactly. So I want to unpack what's really going on underneath that phrase. I think there are three root causes. First: learned helplessness — they tried something once, it failed, and they concluded that version of the idea is permanently broken. Luna: Which ignores that context changes. The market, the team, the tools — all of that can be different. Lucas: Second root cause: fear of repeating a visible failure. If their last attempt was public and painful, they're protecting themselves from that embarrassment again. And third: a need for psychological safety — they don't trust that the team will handle another failure well. Luna: So the phrase 'I tried that' is really a symptom of something deeper. How do you address it without making the person defensive? Lucas: You reframe the conversation. Instead of arguing about whether the idea worked before, you ask: 'What would need to be different for this to work now?' That shifts them from gatekeeper to problem-solver. Priya's manager used that exact question, and it turned the conversation around. Luna: That's a good script. But what if they still resist? Lucas: Then you go to the 'small bet' tactic. You propose a scaled-down version — a two-week test instead of a full campaign, a pilot with a single customer segment. The goal is to make the failure cheap and the learning fast. Priya agreed to test one of the ideas with just ten customers. It worked, and she later admitted her old attempt had used a completely different channel. Luna: So the small bet bypasses their binary thinking — it either works or it doesn't — and turns it into a learning experiment. Lucas: Right. And if the small bet fails, you've only invested two weeks. But you've also built trust, because you showed you were willing to test their concern rather than override it. Luna: That feels much more respectful than just saying 'try harder' or 'be more open-minded.' Lucas: Exactly. Now, I want to get into the one-on-one conversation itself. You don't want to call them out in a meeting. You schedule a private chat, and you lead with curiosity, not accusation. Luna: What does that sound like? Lucas: Something like: 'I noticed in yesterday's meeting you had experience with several of the ideas. I'd love to hear more about what happened with those attempts — what worked, what didn't, and what you think we should learn from that.' Luna: That invites them to share their expertise, not defend their position. Lucas: And then you follow up with: 'Going forward, when you hear an idea that sounds similar to something that failed before, could you help the team brainstorm what would need to be different this time? I think your experience would be incredibly valuable there.' Luna: You're redefining their role from naysayer to consultant. That's smart. Lucas: If today was actually useful to you, the way these stay ad-free is listener support — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small gesture that keeps the conversations going. Luna: Yeah, and we really appreciate it. It makes a difference. Lucas: So back to the one-on-one. After that conversation, you need to follow up. Check in after a few weeks. Notice and acknowledge when they contribute constructively instead of shutting down. Luna: Positive reinforcement. Classic, but it works. Lucas: One more thing: sometimes the employee is right. The idea genuinely won't work. Your job as a manager is to distinguish between a pattern of resistance and a legitimate warning. If they have a track record of being right, you want to harness that judgment, not silence it. Luna: So how do you tell the difference? Lucas: Look at the data. If their 'I tried that' objections are consistently accurate — the idea really does fail — then they're a valuable risk detector. But if the team misses opportunities because of their reflex, it's a problem. Luna: So it's not about eliminating the phrase entirely, it's about changing the context in which it's used. Lucas: Exactly. You want them to say, 'I tried something similar, and here's what I learned, and here's what I'd suggest we do differently.' That turns experience into a gift rather than a roadblock. Luna: I also think it helps to model that behavior yourself as a manager. If you're willing to say 'I was wrong' or 'let's try it anyway,' it gives them permission to take risks. Lucas: That's a great point. Psychological safety starts at the top. If you punish failure, you'll get a team full of people who say 'I tried that' before they even try. Luna: So the big takeaway: don't fight the phrase. Understand the fear underneath it, reframe the conversation, and use small bets to build a new pattern. Lucas: And if you're a first-time manager, don't expect this to change overnight. It might take three or four one-on-ones before the reflex starts to shift. Be patient, be consistent, and keep the focus on learning. Luna: Solid advice. Next time someone says 'I tried that,' you'll have a plan. Lucas: Thanks for listening. See you next Monday.