Latest / Mulliken No Filter / Special Village Meeting November 2025
Transcript
- 0:02Cherry, Pat here. Will Simon here, Brandon.
- 0:06Lambert here. Bob Cosby.
- 0:08Here, Cory's here Greg Guilford here, here with the.
- 0:11Pledge. Allegiance.
- 0:25I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America
- 0:30and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God,
- 0:34indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
- 0:44All right, we're going to cut to the chase and we're going to do
- 0:58public comment, and I'd like you to state your name and address
- 1:03as you do it. We'll start right here.
- 1:08You don't have to if you anybody who wants to.
- 1:10OK. I just need it for anybody to
- 1:13speak because I think I'd like to hear a lot of, I don't need
- 1:20it arterial Dell. I'd like to hear what's actually
- 1:22happening with the property and what the options are and what
- 1:26we've got. Going so far and what we can do.
- 1:30OK, Yes, it does. Yeah.
- 1:38I'm just kind of wonder if it was going to go on with the
- 1:40property and everything too. I mean, I it's a shame that we
- 1:43had to do it this way to get the property.
- 1:46And then again, how much we have to spend to do that?
- 1:49You have to. Start with your name and your
- 1:52name. Woods.
- 1:58Last name is Wood. Chris.
- 2:04Roger. Yeah.
- 2:07Portland, MI. Were you sworn in to tell the
- 2:12truth when you took this job? Yes.
- 2:15You got to tell the truth, right?
- 2:16I am telling the truth. Did you tell these guys what you
- 2:20told me on the phone? We weren't interested in it
- 2:23until I found out we were on the hook for investments.
- 2:29And you told terrier down there the same thing, right?
- 2:33Well, you know, when I was advised of all this, he was
- 2:40going to work for me, he said he looked at my contract and he
- 2:47said you got screwed. I got about 80 grand in that
- 2:51place over there. And he said, you know what, I'm
- 2:54going to do something for you. He said, we're going to get this
- 2:58piece of property cut out of it, you know, until you come in.
- 3:02And that ended it right there. I asked him when I first got
- 3:06there. He said like there.
- 3:07And I said, there's a village in Walton have anything to do with
- 3:11this? Because if they do, I don't want
- 3:14to do anything against them. I understand what's going on
- 3:17and, and all I got to know is that that do not involve and
- 3:22then we'll go ahead with this. He had, he told me, he said you
- 3:27got to get a lawyer and we've got to get this option stopped.
- 3:31He said when we get it stopped, I'll get it appointed so we can
- 3:35go into court and cut this piece of property out that you paid
- 3:39for. And he said we will even pay
- 3:43half of the survey because that lot over there, the next lot
- 3:47going to John's, half of that is under my building.
- 3:53So I'm going to have the survey of that to get that piece in it.
- 3:58And so naturally, I went for the five grand to get to start it.
- 4:04And to be honest with you, my lawyer, she's kind of a
- 4:08religious woman and she did not like the answer she got over
- 4:13here. She said you were really rude to
- 4:15her. I was rude to her.
- 4:17That's what she said. Did she talk to me?
- 4:20Let's not get. Into it back and forth it's
- 4:22public comments. Now I have a question and.
- 4:24Answer and the next thing was, is she just said that you
- 4:28wouldn't give her any information to who the lawyer
- 4:31was or phone number or anything like that.
- 4:36But anyway, that's the same point.
- 4:41You know, we got a lot of money tied up in that thing.
- 4:43That was my retirement over there.
- 4:46And for you guys the wall sit and buy it after you told me you
- 4:50didn't want nothing to do with it.
- 4:51I just thought that was a little little decided that OK done you
- 5:06guys been going after you since I bought it.
- 5:08I can't say I tried to approve it, but you know when you get
- 5:14take somebody to 4:45 minutes or nothing.
- 5:16How many people in this the ability to kept the court 25
- 5:22years. What?
- 5:24What? Heather.
- 5:25Since I've been. I mean, this started before I
- 5:28was in charge. Yeah.
- 5:30There's no record of anybody else.
- 5:33OK. We've been running the court.
- 5:35It's just a longer taken. That's all it is.
- 5:40Thank you. Not for me.
- 5:49Any other man in the corner. No.
- 5:53This gentleman over here. Well, I guess the only thing I
- 5:56got to say is, you know, I know. They've been village been after
- 6:01John since John got that property.
- 6:05It's sad that it had to end up the way it did, but if the
- 6:11village is going to be on the hook for money for that property
- 6:14because it's gone to auction, the village might as well buy
- 6:16that property. Get in with the fire department,
- 6:20go 5050, remediate it, put a new fire station over there, Turn
- 6:25that light into a parking lot for the village so you can get
- 6:28overnight parking off the street so you can plow and be done with
- 6:33it. What's your name?
- 6:34Larry Ashbury been going on for way too many years.
- 6:41The village has put in way too much money.
- 6:44Get it back from the county, whatever.
- 6:47It's been going on way too long. It needs to stop.
- 6:53OK, any more limited public comment?
- 6:56I just told Lewis, all right, I'm going to continue with the
- 7:04meeting and I would like to have a roll call vote.
- 7:07We'd like to close this session and if we do, the members will
- 7:11go in there for a minute and we'll come back out here and
- 7:14open it back up. Purpose of which is to go into
- 7:19closed session to discuss with me the top, the village's
- 7:21attorney, a confidential attorney-client privilege, legal
- 7:25opinion. So we just need a motion and a
- 7:27second and a roll call back. Anybody 2nd?
- 7:32I'll second. OK.
- 7:37Cheryl. Cheryl.
- 7:42Yes. Yes.
- 7:44Brandon. Yes.
- 7:46Yeah. Bob.
- 7:48Yeah, I'm sorry. Grand.
- 7:50Yep. Corey.
- 7:52Yes. Will.
- 7:53Nay. I'd like to keep it open, but so
- 7:58the motion carries, we'll get back and at this time the
- 8:12village attorney is going to give a little speech about
- 8:15everything. So for those of you who don't
- 8:20know me, which is probably Bellevue, he's in the council.
- 8:22My name is Leslie Abdu. I'm an attorney at a office
- 8:25called Posture Stick in Grand Rapids.
- 8:27I have been representing the village for at least a decade
- 8:30now and primarily my involvement with the village has been
- 8:35dealing with this property just down the street.
- 8:38From us. The issue, as many of you know,
- 8:42has been an ordinance enforcement matter and to the
- 8:45court related to violations from the town building on the
- 8:51property. There are many of them related
- 8:55to blight and abandoned motor vehicles.
- 8:59Lawful use of the property in a zoned commercial technically
- 9:03can't be used as a as a residence.
- 9:06There are, there are many. If you walk, you walk by, you
- 9:09probably understand for yourself what's known by that case.
- 9:15Started back in 2005, so it's been going on for about 20 years
- 9:19now, even before I began representing the village.
- 9:22It's gone through at least three judges now and through the
- 9:26course of that litigation, the court has authorized the village
- 9:30to go onto the property to clean it up.
- 9:33There's been a court appointed receiver who's an attorney who's
- 9:36essentially helped facilitate auctioning off items that are on
- 9:41the property to try to collect mitigate some of the fees that
- 9:46the villages had to incur in enforcing its ordinances.
- 9:51There has been at least two options as well as of course all
- 9:56the fees, my fees, the receiver's fees, and in that
- 10:01process the court. There's a statutory provision,
- 10:06legal provision that allows the court to authorize the village
- 10:10to put liens on the property so that the village can recruit
- 10:13those costs. There have been two liens based
- 10:16on the property at least two years ago and they total roughly
- 10:22and $70,000 an ish. And and what those means consist
- 10:27of our court costs, attorneys fees, the fees that the village
- 10:31has had to pay contractors to want property to clean it up.
- 10:36So as you can imagine that amount has accumulated over the
- 10:40last 20 years of how many times that the property has been
- 10:44needed to clean up. It has continued to remain in
- 10:48its current condition even after clean up.
- 10:51And so as part of the lien process, those are typically
- 10:56collected as regular property taxes.
- 11:00So the county goes through the process of collecting the
- 11:03property taxes and when they become delinquent like property
- 11:07taxes, the property goes into foreclosure.
- 11:10The county handles that process, but what happens is when the
- 11:17property goes into tax foreclosure, the county pays
- 11:21back the village a certain amount of money based on what
- 11:25the lien was to make the village whole for the amount of its debt
- 11:30that it's incurred on the property.
- 11:33The tax foreclosure process is very lengthy.
- 11:35I'm not going to go through the insurance and outs of it, but it
- 11:37takes a long time. Obviously, property owners have
- 11:40significant rights when it comes to being able to redeem their
- 11:44property. We better known somebody.
- 11:46You're vending the tax foreclosure process yourself.
- 11:49You know you've given many opportunities to redeem and pay
- 11:53those taxes so that you can keep your property.
- 11:56What has happened is that those taxes and those liens have not
- 11:59been paid. It's been at least three years
- 12:03now and the county has been authorized to go through what is
- 12:07that final foreclosure process which is attempting to sell the
- 12:10property to collect as much as it can recoup those costs that
- 12:15have been lost in the not unpaid property taxes.
- 12:18And the leads the the village as a municipality in which the
- 12:25property is situated has it's called a right of first refusal.
- 12:29The village has the first right to exercise purchase of the
- 12:34property for the amount of the minimum bid.
- 12:37There's a minimum bid that's set.
- 12:39So county schedules a sale of the public sale.
- 12:44Any anybody could come. That was published in the paper.
- 12:46They posted that on the property.
- 12:49Everybody should come bid at it except Mr. Hoover who is the
- 12:52former owner. They they are not allowed to
- 12:54redeem at that stage and did on the property.
- 12:59What has happened is there was a sale earlier this week and what
- 13:04is required was to pay the minimum bid.
- 13:06The minimum bid is the amount that has been unpaid on property
- 13:11taxes in addition to the villages liens, as well as
- 13:16certain costs and interest that has accrued over the last three
- 13:19years. The total amount, is that going
- 13:21to be 118, that's 100,018, correct?
- 13:29Yep, Yep. So that's, that's what anybody,
- 13:32if they were to have shown enough have the sale would have
- 13:36had to pay that in order to get the property.
- 13:40Otherwise, if there were two people that bid on it, then it
- 13:43would go, you know, just like a range regular auction.
- 13:46Obviously, the county is trying to collect as much as possible
- 13:49to the village's debt, as well as the debt the county had for
- 13:56its lost property taxes. So the village really has two
- 14:01options. It can exercise its right of
- 14:03first refusal, which is to pay the amount that's owed in order
- 14:10to take control over the property.
- 14:13That allows the village to, like I said, control it.
- 14:17It would own the property. It could use it for any any
- 14:22purpose. It could, as suggested, turn it
- 14:25into a new fire station. It could sell it to another
- 14:28buyer to try to offset its cost that it had to incur to pay for
- 14:34the property. That $100,000 the property is
- 14:38worth. According to the county, the
- 14:41true cash value is a roughly 116,000.
- 14:45That's just based off of general.
- 14:47There hasn't been a market study done or anything like that.
- 14:50And I'm certainly not a realtor expert in property valuation,
- 14:54but that's generally speaking roughly what those three.
- 14:58There's three properties, 3 parcels that encompass that
- 15:01larger spot is what it could potentially sell for.
- 15:07So the village can do that. It could, it could redeem, it
- 15:11could clean up the property, it could try to sell it.
- 15:13It could use it for a village purpose and could sell it to
- 15:17commercial endeavor, obviously with the goal of trying to limit
- 15:21any costs associated with associated with that.
- 15:26And hopefully try to bring it to some sort of productive news to
- 15:29start collecting property taxes again.
- 15:31Because in the, in the current status that it's sitting right
- 15:34now, it's it's kind of just valueless to the village.
- 15:41Obviously there are some costs associated with that in in
- 15:45particular the fact that the village has to pay that minimum
- 15:49bid amount in order to own the property.
- 15:52The alternative would be for the village to decide to decline to
- 15:57bid on the property, not exercise its right of first
- 16:01refusal, in which case the county would try to sell.
- 16:05It would go to what we call a scavenger sale and the property,
- 16:09the county would try to sell it for whatever they could.
- 16:12That could be $5. It just depends on you know what
- 16:17what interest there is. My understanding at the first
- 16:21sale was that the only interested individuals were in
- 16:24the same and the village was represented there.
- 16:27So Mr. Hussein could hypothetically purchase the
- 16:31property at that scavenger auction, but would not have to
- 16:36pay them for one bit anything. If the if the property sells for
- 16:42a lower amount for $5 a $1000, the village has to pay the
- 16:48difference between what that bid was and what the minimum bids at
- 16:53118,000 back to the county. So they have to make the county
- 16:59whole again. They have to pay the county the
- 17:01tax revolving funds that difference.
- 17:03So the money that they got back in that first year would have to
- 17:07be reimbursed back to the county and the village doesn't retain
- 17:11the property and it goes to the new owner.
- 17:16So obviously there are some certain risks associated with
- 17:19that. You don't know who would buy the
- 17:22property. You don't know how much it would
- 17:24sell for at auction. If it goes to somebody who's
- 17:28going to continue maintaining the property in the same manner
- 17:32that it's in right now, the village could be back at square
- 17:36one having to proceed, pursue ordinance enforcement on to try
- 17:41to get the property cleaned back up and it would just be this
- 17:44revolving door. So obviously there are certain
- 17:47risks associated with having to go that route when it comes to
- 17:51the condition of the property as it currently stands.
- 17:54I just kind of want to give a little bit of a background.
- 17:57I'm not sure how many of you have seen it or familiar.
- 18:02Like I said, this has been going on for about 20 years.
- 18:06There are have been individuals living on the property.
- 18:10I know there's some drug use going on at the property that
- 18:13have been fires on the property that have resulted in injuries.
- 18:18There are the health department, the health department has been
- 18:22on the property multiple times because there are some sanitary
- 18:28that you might be able to explore, explore that better
- 18:30issues with respect with respect to yeah, with respect to Kitty
- 18:38avidation, I mean there are there are inoperable vehicles
- 18:41that are likely leaking oil. So I'm not sure what kind of
- 18:46environmental contamination is on the property, but I would
- 18:48suspect that there is some. So there are certainly health
- 18:53hazards that are of the villages concern as well as the County
- 18:57Health Department and and their involvement of this as well.
- 19:00So that, that's certainly something that the county or
- 19:03that the village, I advise the village to take into
- 19:05consideration because of course the alternative is we just sit
- 19:09back and do nothing and just let it stay as it is.
- 19:13And I'm sure that would be advantageous to some people.
- 19:17But as the village council, as elected officials, of course one
- 19:22of their roles as elected officials is to, you know,
- 19:26promote the public health, safety and welfare.
- 19:28And I, I do, I, my practice is almost entirely municipal.
- 19:34I represent mostly municipalities.
- 19:37I do a lot of code enforcement work, so dealing with properties
- 19:42like that down the street and this is one of the worst that
- 19:45I've seen in terms of the condition, just in terms of life
- 19:49and what's out there. And I have real concerns about
- 19:52it too. And I don't even live here or
- 19:53here. So.
- 19:55So that's kind of a summary of the of the issues in the
- 19:59villages actions. I've advised the village what
- 20:02their options are, which would be to exercise that right of
- 20:05first refusal, pay the minimum bid and retain control of the
- 20:09property. Or alternatively, decline that
- 20:12right, see if it sells in a scavenger sale, but then be on
- 20:17the hook for that remaining balance and retain and lose
- 20:21control of the property. There are risks associated with
- 20:24doing that. As I outlined, you don't know
- 20:27who will buy it, you don't know how much it will sell for.
- 20:32In addition, I also want to point out to in addition to
- 20:35having to pay that, the difference between that minimum
- 20:38bid and whatever it sells for, the village also has to pay the
- 20:42interest on the taxes that have occurred over the last three
- 20:44years. So just in terms of dollars and
- 20:48cents, the first year the interest is 1% per month.
- 20:53So that's 12% a year. The second year it's 1 1/2% per
- 20:57month. So that's 18%.
- 21:00So if you're talking about $100,000 in owed amount and owed
- 21:03tax, 18% is a lot 10s of thousands of dollars in addition
- 21:11to what the village has to pay just to make the county whole
- 21:15again. So it's a substantial amount of
- 21:18money we. Understand a lot of that but one
- 21:20thing I want to understand is does the village have the money
- 21:24paying 118,000 at this point? And if not then what are your
- 21:32options? Are you, since you've won the
- 21:34bid, are you going to say maybe Roger would like to buy a
- 21:38certain portion and have a survey so he could purchase?
- 21:42I was going to bring that up and I get a chance to talk.
- 21:45That's. Entirely up to to the village,
- 21:48really. We're not at that point yet.
- 21:50We're just at the deciding the point of deciding whether to
- 21:53even exercise that right or not. And the.
- 21:56Other thing is, so if the village has the money to go
- 22:00ahead and just hit and then do whatever they want, right?
- 22:04The people that are already got something invested, how long do
- 22:07they have to remove? Because just because you spend
- 22:11118,000 doesn't mean that Roger can't take out some of this
- 22:15stuff. Correct.
- 22:17And John's got some valuable stuff, yeah.
- 22:20Personal property can be removed and then the village can go.
- 22:23It just goes like any you think about like a mortgage
- 22:27foreclosure that that a bank takes control of the property,
- 22:31they can go pursue addiction proceedings to remove
- 22:36individuals. 60 days. Yeah, 60 to 90 days, it's A and
- 22:41it. And it won't happen immediately,
- 22:43of course, because there's paperwork and you.
- 22:46Know there's Well, they have to officially.
- 22:48Here's the money. Yeah, yeah.
- 22:53And and make sure guys are guided in these are crossed and
- 22:56obviously the village doesn't have a need at this point.
- 22:59So we would have to get that first before pursuing that
- 23:02option. But yeah, it's not an overnight
- 23:04thing like tomorrow. You kick every, you're even,
- 23:09Yeah, even, I mean even renters there.
- 23:12If you've ever had a situation where there's been an eviction,
- 23:15you know, you know that even even squatters, even people.
- 23:18Who don't have? A property right have rights to,
- 23:23you know, get, you know, there's a process there.
- 23:26So there's a process that will go through to ensure that you
- 23:31know that that situation like that does not happen, but the
- 23:34village would have the control over the building.
- 23:37So does the village have the village?
- 23:43On balance, is in excellent shape currently.
- 23:47I'm saying that and I'm saying that we haven't raised text.
- 23:55Almost 15 years. We haven't even raised it.
- 23:59Yeah. At this point, there's no
- 24:02reason. One thing I want to I want to
- 24:06keep. I want to point that out though
- 24:07for two reasons. One, by not exercising that rate
- 24:13of first refusal, they have to pay the difference anyway.
- 24:16So you're still out this roughly the same amount of money in the
- 24:21end versus. But in one scenario, the village
- 24:25doesn't own the property in the end, and in the other scenario
- 24:29they do. And then the other point I want
- 24:32to make to that is if they do exercise that right and own it,
- 24:37the village could sell it and try to remove some of those
- 24:40costs to an interested buyer. Yep.
- 24:42And that's why I talked about the fair market value of the
- 24:45property. So and then it could clean it up
- 24:48first and then try to sell it. It could sell as is.
- 24:51That's something that the village, from a policy
- 24:53standpoint, would have to decide if they go through that process.
- 24:56Well, if you had like if you had 60 or 90 days, then then they
- 25:00could personally clean up and group the money themselves by
- 25:05cleaning up some of that stuff, right?
- 25:07Sure, yeah. And they they can take personal
- 25:09property from that. Because technically, John owns
- 25:13the stuff that's. Made, yeah, certain things,
- 25:16fixtures depends on how it's affixed to the ground, but
- 25:21personal property is generally something that can be taken and
- 25:25picture like something in a building is obviously the
- 25:29building. Yes.
- 25:32What about the sidewalks? Are they going to have to?
- 25:36Remain that one. And when company advisors, are
- 25:39they going to remove the sidewalks?
- 25:41That's a there I have it. That's up to the village.
- 25:44That could be something that if the village decides to sell the
- 25:47property, they could condition it the sale on.
- 25:51It. All the other buildings.
- 25:53Down down level, just do we have it in the village to pay.
- 25:58They have those silos put down. No, we don't have that's going
- 26:03to cost a lot. A lot.
- 26:04Well, we could make that a condition to the if you're
- 26:08taking it away from town and you're.
- 26:10Leaving it the way it. Is what was the sense of doing.
- 26:13Right. And that's, and that's the
- 26:15conversation that council has had.
- 26:18And you know what, what is the ultimate goal and is our goal to
- 26:21try to retain the property? Is it is it to try to turn it
- 26:26into some productive use and hopefully start to generate some
- 26:30property taxes from it? And I would suspect in addition
- 26:33to that, rectify the serious health hazards that are on the
- 26:37property, which is I think another goal of the village as
- 26:40well. So I mean, it's a fantastic
- 26:43property. I think we got, we can all agree
- 26:45it's a great location. I can see a lot of wonderful
- 26:50uses for it. So yeah, I mean that's a
- 26:56something that needs to be discussed as a community for
- 26:59what happened to the money when they.
- 27:01Took all the scrap off of the problem.
- 27:04What happened? It was sold and offset and the
- 27:06auctioneer cost, but it was minimal.
- 27:11Yeah, I think that. I think we any, any value was
- 27:14taken off our our. He had a control, yeah.
- 27:18Yep, there. It never came to us.
- 27:21Yeah, then it went, it went to pay the auctioneer or that the
- 27:24contractors Ken O Dean's cost. Who is the receiver?
- 27:28Because they took a lot of scrap.
- 27:30Yeah. And it it's only worth so much.
- 27:33So it obviously did not cover all of the costs associated.
- 27:37What about some of the? Fines that John had.
- 27:39Paid. Did that go towards that block?
- 27:41Philippines. The the amount of the liens was
- 27:46solely out of pocket costs of the village.
- 27:48It wasn't fines, it was attorney's fees, the fees of the
- 27:52receiver, and the actual contractor's cost.
- 27:55So it was direct out of pocket expenses that the village had
- 27:59and that's all public record. And then you can access that
- 28:01information, the bill of costs at the Circuit Court to see what
- 28:05was part of those charges. But it was that only out of
- 28:10pocket costs, not fines. Fines were not included in that.
- 28:14You don't generally put that as money on somebody's property
- 28:16unless. You don't pay any of the taxes.
- 28:18At all for three. Years.
- 28:20No. I have a question, can I hang
- 28:27on? Yeah, there's some.
- 28:28There's some water and sewer. No water.
- 28:31Sewer holders, do you have more or should we move the public?
- 28:35House yeah why don't we instead of turning this into AQ and a
- 28:38why don't we unless anybody from council has anything they.
- 28:42Want to. I'm going to say a few things.
- 28:44If we buy this, we can divide it up.
- 28:48If Rogers wants that part down there, we could cut a deal,
- 28:53divide it up so he's got his shop yet and we'll have to take
- 28:57the money off what we owe. That's one thing we can do.
- 29:02And both the silos, I think they have to come down.
- 29:06But the one on the far corner, I put a picture of a tractor on
- 29:10that or a thing for this is a, this is a town where it's a farm
- 29:15town. Put a big picture on there.
- 29:18That's what I would do, you know.
- 29:21But that's about all I have to say.
- 29:23But we can divide it up and shall it, you know.
- 29:31So at this stage, unless any members of Council have any
- 29:34questions or comments for me, and we'll obviously opportunity
- 29:38afterwards before a decision is made, why don't we open it back
- 29:41up for another round of public comment?
- 29:45Again, this isn't really AQ and a sort of thing, it's really
- 29:47more your thoughts and opinions. Responding, responding,
- 29:51understanding the situation before Council makes the
- 29:55decision. I want to do just please.
- 29:58Wait, yeah, we don't have to go through and just.
- 30:01I think you're just thinking a question, but I think it's
- 30:03pretty important to know the fact whether Mr. Shane wants a
- 30:07property or not. Has any taxes been paid on the
- 30:10property from Myrtle Streets all the way to the corner?
- 30:14Any property taxes? There are three parcels and
- 30:18there are There are no property analysis or.
- 30:21Anything on that? Does anybody have a deed and the
- 30:23property that's located in those?
- 30:25Locations. Does anybody have a?
- 30:26What a deed 2O2D. Mr. Hoover.
- 30:30For all three parcels. So basically Mr. Stain's
- 30:34property of these is built Mr. Stain does not own any of those
- 30:38three properties. But he still has an interest in
- 30:43the properties. Not a legal.
- 30:45Interest that, that's my question because it's very
- 30:48important. That has been litigated already.
- 30:50OK, that is an opinion, Sir. Let's see.
- 30:57I don't think we have his name. Cheryl.
- 30:59Your name. My name is unimportant to the
- 31:03matter for the committee it. Has to go on the note.
- 31:06Sir, excuse me, attorney, you might want to read some laws on
- 31:09that Attorney. Attorney General's opinion 7240
- 31:15from 2000 times. You might want to read that.
- 31:17OK, You're speaking. You asked me.
- 31:21I think I am. I open to talk.
- 31:24Yeah. And you?
- 31:25OK. You're speaking in the context
- 31:27of them purchasing. It wasn't in the sale on Tuesday
- 31:35and then they bid it off. And aren't sales all final?
- 31:38They have 21 days to finalize the sale after the after the
- 31:43auction. To finalize.
- 31:44But ain't they final? No, they could.
- 31:47They could withdraw that bid between now and 21 days, so
- 31:53tonight is deciding whether to ratify the decision on the bid
- 31:56or to withdraw the bid. So there was an approval prior
- 31:59to the bid you're saying, is that what you're saying?
- 32:03That's my understanding they're making a decision tonight
- 32:06whether to to continue with the bid or to withdraw the bid.
- 32:10So there was no approval to purchase the property?
- 32:13Yeah, that's been purchased. It has not been purchased yet.
- 32:19Well, there's a court date third, but it auctioned off in
- 32:24the auction. OK, hold.
- 32:26On hold, on, hold on. One person talking at a time.
- 32:28This is not Q and this is not a Q and AI think I answered your
- 32:33questions tonight as deciding whether to ratify the bid or to
- 32:37withdraw the bid. Any other public comments?
- 32:48Actually I am. You have opened an interesting
- 32:51question. So anybody that would have bid
- 32:55on that property had 21 days to exercise their bid, is that what
- 33:01you're saying? You have 21 days to pay after
- 33:05the sale. That's not what you told me, but
- 33:07if I if I can have a, that's. What I said, yeah, 21 days to.
- 33:11Pay if I had a follow up. So if the council decides not to
- 33:19pay and goes back to auction again.
- 33:22Correct. Thank you and.
- 33:27The 2nd, and I'll just add that second auction is what we call
- 33:30that scavenger sale and that's the one where it could go for
- 33:36heavies, OK? Thank you very much.
- 33:38And the village would have to pay for the difference.
- 33:41Thank you. Have the tax laws changed
- 33:44because the the the loss for tax sales changed because any tax
- 33:51sale I've been to you bid on something you pay.
- 33:54You. You don't leave, you pay.
- 33:57You can pay 21 there. I can pull up the statute if you
- 34:01want 21 days to make it pay. For all the tax sales in the
- 34:05state that way, now you got 20. One days I'm just telling you
- 34:08what the statute says. What statute is it?
- 34:16So I get the general property tax at.
- 34:21Sunny sale I was at. You paid.
- 34:31You didn't have 21 days to do anything.
- 34:47Is this a specific exception for the municipalities?
- 34:51Or MCL 211.78 M It's a very long statute so just bear with me
- 35:15before closing. Governmental unit, which means
- 35:17the county shall cancel the sale of unpaid property.
- 35:20Taxes go down a property or properties at the time of sale,
- 35:24which means that minimum bid are not paid within 21 days of the
- 35:27sale. That means the sale is
- 35:30cancelled. If the sale is cancelled under
- 35:33the subsection, the county may offer the property to the next
- 35:36highest bidder and convey the property to that bidder under
- 35:40the subsection. Thank you.
- 35:45I appreciate that information. Yeah, the tax sales are fine.
- 35:53You have 21 days to sum it up. It looks to me like you're
- 35:58making a decision after you already agreed to purchase it.
- 36:02Now you're potentially looking to remit or to approve what
- 36:06you've already done, which is should have been done being at
- 36:10the last meeting. So it seems pretty shady what's
- 36:13going on here? Just for the record, anybody
- 36:22else at this time we're going to do a roll call vote well.
- 36:29Yeah, let's if there's any. Visibility you guys, any
- 36:33questions? Question.
- 36:34Otherwise, we can entertain a motion and then the two motions
- 36:39that I would suggest offering with the other to ratify the bid
- 36:42to exercise the right of first refusal for the to purchase the
- 36:46property at 345 Main Street. Or a motion to decline the right
- 36:51of first refusal and direct the village treasurer to withdraw
- 36:53the bid for the property located at 345 Main St.
- 37:00And I can reread that if somebody makes a motion and
- 37:03forgets it. Do we have a motion?
- 37:10I'm still not. Still have there.
- 37:13Still have 5045 minutes, still tearing.
- 37:21Do we have a 2nd? I'll second.
- 37:26I am doing a roll call vote. Sherry.
- 37:28Yes. Brandon.
- 37:31Yes. Bob.
- 37:33Yeah, I guess you will. Greg.
- 37:35Yep, Corey. Yes, Well, nay, OK.
- 37:41We have 1/5 to one. Our motion carries another
- 37:47business otherwise. Can I?
- 37:52Have a motion to can I change my name?
- 37:56Can't do it after you vote. Can we have a motion?
- 38:00I think it's still passes forward.
- 38:03To two anyone. I, I, nay, I don't go for it.
- 38:08OK, still passes. So you've changed.
- 38:12Yours did. You hear that?
- 38:15Guys, Yep, Bob's in there. Yep.
- 38:17Do we have a motion for adjourn? I'll make a motion to adjourn.
- 38:22Second. All in favor.
- 38:25Aye aye, aye, aye aye.