Latest / Microsoft Cloud IT Pro Podcast / Episode 423 – Non-Human Identities in Microsoft Entra with Eric Woodruff and Chris Brumm
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to episode 423
- 0:06of the Microsoft Cloud IT Pro podcast recorded
- 0:09live from Workplace Ninjas US in December
- 0:122025.
- 0:13This is a show about Microsoft three sixty
- 0:16five and Azure from the perspective of IT
- 0:18pros and end users, where we discuss a
- 0:20topic or recent news and how it relates
- 0:22to you. In this episode, Ben sits down
- 0:25with fellow security MVPs, Eric Woodruff and Chris
- 0:28Brum, to discuss the often overlooked world of
- 0:31nonhuman
- 0:32identities in Microsoft EntraID.
- 0:35We cover service principles,
- 0:37why they tend to fly under the radar,
- 0:39and how attackers actively
- 0:41exploit that gap. They also spend time talking
- 0:43about credential management best practices, challenges around nonhuman
- 0:47identities, and how you should be thinking about
- 0:50them, especially with the growing challenges of how
- 0:53they relate to AI. Let's dive in.
- 0:58I'm sitting here with another episode of Microsoft
- 1:01Cloud IT Pro podcast
- 1:02at Workplace Ninjas, the first one in 2025.
- 1:05We all get to be honorary attendees, so
- 1:08Scott, who I normally do the podcast with,
- 1:10if you guys if people listen, is not
- 1:13here once more. But instead, I have Eric
- 1:16Woodruff
- 1:17and
- 1:18Chris Brum. And, we are going to talk
- 1:20about
- 1:21non human identities in Entra. So, this is
- 1:24an interesting topic because, yeah, I'm excited to
- 1:27dive into it. But first, do you guys
- 1:28wanna tell us a little bit about who
- 1:31you are, where you are, company that you
- 1:33work for? Yeah. Sure. Yeah. So I'm Eric
- 1:36Woodruff. Currently, I'm the chief identity architect at
- 1:39Semperis.
- 1:39I I do a whole mixed bag of
- 1:41things, which I I won't sorta go down
- 1:43the rabbit hole on there.
- 1:45But, yeah, MVP
- 1:47in security focused on identity, so all things,
- 1:50Entra, some active directory
- 1:52thrown in the mix. Yeah. And it's just
- 1:54it's, you know, great to be here. You
- 1:56know, I will say you can find me
- 1:58on the socials as Eric on Identity. It's
- 2:01maybe not super hackery sounding, but it's hopefully
- 2:03easy to remember. Okay.
- 2:06Yeah. There you go. Easy to remember is
- 2:08good.
- 2:09Hi. I'm Chris Broom. I'm from Germany,
- 2:12and I'm a cybersecurity architect with Glucanje.
- 2:17And, yeah, I'm doing
- 2:18cybersecurity
- 2:19for, I don't know, sixteen years or so.
- 2:22I think I did everything that you could
- 2:24do there, but my main topic is identity
- 2:27security.
- 2:28And like Eric, I'm also an MVP in
- 2:30that area. So my company is doing,
- 2:33yeah, managed SOC services mainly.
- 2:36Okay. And,
- 2:37yeah, we are protecting our customers, and I
- 2:39think identity is one of the main main
- 2:40topics there. Alright. So no red teaming? Are
- 2:43my devices safe around you? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:45I'm I'm in the blue team. Absolutely.
- 2:48So
- 2:50Yeah. That's kind of funny. Like security conferences
- 2:52are like, don't ever connect to the WiFi
- 2:53because you never know who you can connect.
- 2:54Yeah.
- 2:55You just have to scan this QR code.
- 2:58Yeah. So that's been funny. This conference, the
- 3:00amount of QR codes and everybody's like, this
- 3:02is a security conference.
- 3:04Yeah. Yeah. And we just found here USB
- 3:07sticks. Have you plugged it in yet? No.
- 3:10I don't do this in general.
- 3:13Oh,
- 3:14good times. So moving on to non human
- 3:16identity. It's like when I kinda reached out
- 3:18and said, who wants to talk on the
- 3:20podcast? Who wants to do some interviews?
- 3:22You guys were like, well, we did a
- 3:23session on non human identities
- 3:25in Entra. And this is an interesting one
- 3:27because a lot of times when people think
- 3:30Entra, they think, oh that's how I log
- 3:32in. I have my username, my password,
- 3:36I'm doing MFA whatever Entra. But there's a
- 3:39whole another component to it around
- 3:42non human identities and Entra that maybe sometimes
- 3:45gets forgotten and I think that was some
- 3:47of the premise of
- 3:49your presentation. Kind of what we wanna talk
- 3:50about today. Yeah. Our basic idea was to
- 3:53to just collect all the stuff that should
- 3:56become a knowledge by an intro admin
- 3:59and just to make sure that everyone knows
- 4:01it. So about
- 4:02permissions and credential handling
- 4:04and all the stuff that yeah. What could
- 4:06go possibly go wrong? Yeah. What are our
- 4:08topic? Yeah.
- 4:10Yeah. And I'll just say, like, I think,
- 4:12really mean the the term is new, but
- 4:14nonhuman identities have been in Entra for as
- 4:16long as it's
- 4:18been Azure AD. Right? I mean, like, we've
- 4:19been talking about service principles and stuff. They've
- 4:21always been there. But, yes, it's like a
- 4:23a hot topic in the industry now with
- 4:25nonhuman or workload identities, whatever you wanna call
- 4:28them. But yeah. And for as long as
- 4:30these have they have existed,
- 4:32there's
- 4:33abuses on them that attackers love. So trying
- 4:36to talk about those things.
- 4:38Yeah. So if somebody's
- 4:40newer to this because sometimes I think we
- 4:42even make the assumption, oh, everybody to your
- 4:44point, everybody should know about non human identities.
- 4:47When you start talking about non human identities,
- 4:49we're talking about SPNs. What are those? For
- 4:51somebody that may be newer to enter is
- 4:53like, wait a minute, I need to think
- 4:54about non human identities in Entra. Where do
- 4:56you kinda start with those when you talk
- 4:58to people about non human identities in Entra?
- 5:00I mean, I would say
- 5:03Chris is like, oh, no, not this topic.
- 5:09I mean, I guess it depends if they
- 5:10know AD. Right? If they know AD, I
- 5:12would try to relate it to, you know,
- 5:14GMSA's
- 5:16service accounts. Right? And if they don't know
- 5:18anything in general, I guess not that they
- 5:20don't know stuff. Right? I guess I'd be
- 5:22saying that this is like for you know,
- 5:24you think of applications that might go do
- 5:26stuff. You have SaaS apps that are doing
- 5:28things behind the scenes with, you know, data
- 5:30and like SharePoint or OneDrive or, you know,
- 5:33Exchange. Right? There's still identities to all those
- 5:36things. Right? Those services under the covers and
- 5:38that's essentially what, like, service principles are that
- 5:41are operating, like, without people. That's the the
- 5:44non human part. Yeah. And a lot of
- 5:46those have access to data. And I think
- 5:48that was a big part of your talk
- 5:49is or part of your talk, and I'll
- 5:51let you guys kind of direct it is
- 5:53managing those SPNs and to your point, they
- 5:55have
- 5:56access to data
- 5:57much like a user would, but yet I
- 6:00don't think they maybe get us necessarily as
- 6:02much attention
- 6:03as users and what they have access to.
- 6:06Yeah. I think there are two big topics
- 6:08that
- 6:08we have to talk about. And the first
- 6:10thing is what permissions can f apps have.
- 6:14So and apps can have huge permissions.
- 6:18So and
- 6:19we should if an app has the same
- 6:21permissions like a global administrator, we should handle
- 6:24it like a global administrator. And the other
- 6:26part is, okay, who has permissions on apps?
- 6:29And there are some really bad practices out
- 6:31there. So as an example,
- 6:33yeah, a lot of companies are assigning owners
- 6:36at at the app registration and the service
- 6:38principles, and they are assigning that owner permission
- 6:41to normal user accounts. So and an owner
- 6:44is such, yeah, is a person who can
- 6:46do everything with that app. So including
- 6:48adding new secrets and log in as that
- 6:50app and use the permission of the app.
- 6:52So there's a big potential for stuff that
- 6:55could go wrong. Yeah. So as you're working
- 6:57at identity then, you're working with this SPNs
- 7:00and the owner rights and doing all of
- 7:01that. How do you start
- 7:03guiding people through some of that
- 7:06management of those
- 7:09SPNs? Yeah. I mean, I'll I'll say it's
- 7:11tricky at times because
- 7:13but there's always places where
- 7:16customers love Microsoft docs and customers want to
- 7:18do nothing against Microsoft. Right? They wanna do
- 7:20things as, like, this is what Microsoft wrote.
- 7:22That's what we wanna do. And occasionally, right,
- 7:25the rest of the industry
- 7:27disagrees.
- 7:28And and, like, owners is a thing. In
- 7:30particular, like, when I worked at Microsoft,
- 7:33I would tell people,
- 7:34go add, you know, Joe, you know, owns
- 7:37Salesforce in the business. Right? Go make Joe
- 7:39an owner. So that way you sort of
- 7:41know, right, we gotta go bother Joe about
- 7:43Salesforce. Not realizing
- 7:44that again, if an attacker
- 7:46targets Joe who's not treated as a privileged
- 7:49user. Right? That now
- 7:51attacker, right, compromises Joe, phishes him, whatever. And
- 7:54now attacker can move into Salesforce. And and
- 7:56to your point about data. Right? You see
- 7:59in the news
- 8:00that data is the thing attackers want. Yeah.
- 8:03But identity So it's a little bit.
- 8:05Yeah. Yeah. And but the I mean,
- 8:07I think to what we were saying about
- 8:09the permissions that they have on data. Right?
- 8:11Like,
- 8:13obviously, like,
- 8:14it's very broad. Right? Like, if an application
- 8:17has permissions to exchange, right, many times, it's
- 8:19like it has permissions to everyone's mailbox and
- 8:23can do
- 8:24whatever it wants with all that. So,
- 8:26yeah. Yeah. I think about that. Like, I've
- 8:28I've done migrations before. Right? Whenever you start
- 8:31migrating email, they're like, oh, go create the
- 8:33migration tool, the
- 8:36exchange
- 8:37web I think it's exchange web services Yep.
- 8:39In the SPN. Go create an SPN for
- 8:40it. Go create access so it can migrate
- 8:42all the email
- 8:43and
- 8:44it is it's that concept of
- 8:46wait a minute if this is migrating all
- 8:48the email it's touching all the email which
- 8:49means it's going to have access to all
- 8:52of the email and am I treating this
- 8:55in that way? Yep. And in this case,
- 8:57it's not only about write permission. So people
- 8:59don't usually, when when I talk to people,
- 9:02say relax when they heard say, it's only
- 9:04read permission. So, yeah, but read permission to
- 9:06your whole file system or your whole mailbox
- 9:08is, yeah, also. But Yeah. Pricing. Data data
- 9:11exfiltration is a is a huge problem right
- 9:13now. So yeah. And I think
- 9:17we you maybe have or we see better
- 9:20practices
- 9:21regarding authentication method policies and conditional access rule
- 9:25set, but it doesn't affect work nonhuman identities
- 9:28usually. So there are other policies.
- 9:31There are application management policies, and there is
- 9:33conditional access for workloads by yeah. But I
- 9:36rarely see this. Yeah. Yeah. And I mean
- 9:38I think it's almost like right like workloads,
- 9:41service principles,
- 9:42they're treated like a sort of second class
- 9:44citizen. And and I get like as a
- 9:46sys admin right you might feel like you
- 9:47already have too much to do. So
- 9:50it's easy to say you have to do
- 9:52more. But on the other hand,
- 9:55attackers
- 9:56love going after service principles because they they
- 9:59tend to know that assist admins don't have
- 10:01a strong understanding
- 10:02of what they do or what they have
- 10:04access to. And and again, if you see
- 10:06a tax on, you know, Microsoft three sixty
- 10:08five going after, you know, OneDrive, SharePoint, Exchange,
- 10:12many times it is using those, you know,
- 10:14enterprise apps as your service principles that they'll
- 10:17they'll leverage. So
- 10:24This episode is brought to you by Trusted
- 10:26Tech. If you're managing Microsoft three sixty five,
- 10:29you already know licensing isn't simple.
- 10:32E three versus e five, the brand new
- 10:34e seven licenses,
- 10:35Copilot security bundles, and with price changes coming
- 10:38in July
- 10:392026,
- 10:40the stakes are getting higher. Trusted tech helps
- 10:43IT leaders make sense of their Microsoft three
- 10:46sixty five environment with a free licensing consultation.
- 10:49Their engineers
- 10:50analyze what you're licensed for and what you're
- 10:52actually using and where you can optimize, whether
- 10:55that means consolidating security tools, preparing for copilot,
- 10:59or eliminating wasted spend. Plus, they offer proactive
- 11:03and reactive support, which has been awarded yet
- 11:06another solution partner designation from Microsoft
- 11:09for support services.
- 11:11If you want a clear, data backed plan
- 11:14that has helped over seven five hundred subscribing
- 11:17customers save up to 20% on Microsoft three
- 11:20sixty five before your next renewal, visit trustedtech.team/mscloudprom365
- 11:29and schedule your free consultation
- 11:32today.
- 11:37We talk about security risk for unused user
- 11:39accounts. Right? Like, you have an unused user
- 11:41account that's active. Part of the reason that's
- 11:42a security risk is it's not monitored or
- 11:45watched as closely because the user's not using
- 11:47it. I feel like service principles can kind
- 11:49of fall in that boat as, yeah, they're
- 11:51being used, but they're probably not being watched
- 11:54Yeah. Quite as closely
- 11:56as
- 11:58a normal user account Yeah. So to speak.
- 12:00And
- 12:02attackers
- 12:03probably tend they don't wanna be seen. Yeah.
- 12:05Yeah. They're gonna go after things that aren't
- 12:07as visible. Yep. Yep. Yeah. I mean, I
- 12:09would say, you know, using service principles for
- 12:12persistent. Right? Persistence, like, assigning credentials to them,
- 12:15but in the way that they can dwell.
- 12:17Right? Like, they might get access to something
- 12:19and then wait and see if they're detected.
- 12:21Right? And then after some time, then they
- 12:23go on to do their their nasty Yes.
- 12:25So yeah. And as I said, my team
- 12:27is running SOC services. So and monitoring
- 12:30credential addition to a service principle in a
- 12:33bigger environment,
- 12:35that's so loud. We see a lot of
- 12:38modifications. We'll see a lot of
- 12:40credential adding and so on. You really have
- 12:43to correlate this with
- 12:46the permissions of the app to get a
- 12:49reasonable signal to noise ratio. So Right. So
- 12:52do you have guidelines, Chris, in, like, how
- 12:54you guys
- 12:55do that from a SOC perspective that if
- 12:57end users are doing this or not end
- 12:59users, but other sysadmins,
- 13:01companies are doing it internally is how do
- 13:03you go about even starting to monitor
- 13:07things you maybe watch for?
- 13:09You have to do both. You have to
- 13:10do prevention and detection.
- 13:12And I always start with, okay, do you
- 13:15have any life cycle processes? So companies usually
- 13:18have managed to have life cycle processes for
- 13:21their users.
- 13:23Admins is getting more rare and for non
- 13:26human identities. So, yeah, it's
- 13:30lost in vain.
- 13:31There are some good practices. So there are
- 13:33a lot of good practices around how to
- 13:36implement OpenID Connect. So this is for the
- 13:38developers. You have to be the go to
- 13:40person for your developers
- 13:42regarding identity. And there are some good practices
- 13:45how to configure the applications.
- 13:48And you should leverage that. Yeah, that workload
- 13:51ID features.
- 13:53Is that it's a separate license, but, yeah,
- 13:57we for powerful apps, I think it's reasonable
- 14:01to protect them. And if you want to
- 14:03monitor
- 14:04your apps, you have to rely on on
- 14:07the intro audit logs and you can adjust
- 14:10them in Sentinel.
- 14:11A good starting point is Microsoft has has
- 14:14a repository
- 14:15full of detections.
- 14:16But yet, to be honest,
- 14:18this is very noisy because it's just detecting,
- 14:22yeah, someone added a reply URL. Someone added
- 14:25a credential.
- 14:26So without context, it's very, very hard. So
- 14:29and this is what yeah. This is what
- 14:31what SOC providers are doing. So someone added
- 14:33a credential. Okay. We have a sign in
- 14:36risk. Okay. But if we have a sign
- 14:38in risk and then
- 14:40this person is adding,
- 14:42credential to an app. This is interesting.
- 14:44So it's regarding context.
- 14:46And another context is, okay, are we talking
- 14:49about an app
- 14:51without big permissions or are we talking about
- 14:53an app with very high permissions?
- 14:56And bringing all that stuff together.
- 14:58But, say, yes, there's it's hard to do
- 15:00a one on one on this.
- 15:02Yeah. There's a lot of data there. And
- 15:05it was interesting you mentioned developers and because
- 15:07I do IT pro stuff, I like to
- 15:09pick on developers and probably pushing that because
- 15:12developers probably have a tendency too to say,
- 15:14oh, I'm writing an app. It needs a
- 15:15service principle. Just give it these permissions versus
- 15:18really trying to narrow down and really hone
- 15:22what does it really need versus what makes
- 15:24a developer's job easier. Yep. Yeah. I mean,
- 15:27it's it's easy to sort of dump on
- 15:29developers and, you know, no offense to them.
- 15:30And I get that they have a job.
- 15:31Right? Like, if Yep. If you're a software
- 15:33company and you're not making software, then you'd
- 15:35have no reason to be there. But, yeah,
- 15:36there it it's I think the problem is
- 15:39finding in the business, like, the balance. Right?
- 15:41And it's not the same across the board.
- 15:43Again, companies just wanna be sort of told
- 15:45what to do, but it's it's more of
- 15:47an art, I'd say, than a than a
- 15:48science because, you know, like, developers, right, you
- 15:51need to make sure that if if you
- 15:52create too much friction they'll go spin up
- 15:54their own tenants their own subscriptions right and
- 15:56they'll go do all their developer stuff possibly
- 15:59with like real data and now you have
- 16:02shadow IT things going on. Right. So yeah,
- 16:05you definitely have to like configure things in
- 16:06a way where you can let developers
- 16:08do their stuff, but I think I'll just
- 16:10say also security people tend not to like
- 16:13to talk to anyone. Right? Yeah. Yeah. We
- 16:15really don't. But but I mean it is
- 16:17one of the the points we try to
- 16:18drive home in our talk is like you
- 16:20need to work with your developers, right? Like
- 16:22you you can't expect
- 16:24everyone to be an expert in like OpenID
- 16:27Connect. I mean barely security people in the
- 16:29industry. But you need to work with them,
- 16:31right, to make sure that when they're implementing
- 16:33things that they're doing it right and not,
- 16:35I'd say, almost like shaming them for not,
- 16:37like, understanding
- 16:38every OAuth flow out there.
- 16:41Yeah. Yeah. And and I think another
- 16:43important thing is, so, yeah, people make mistakes.
- 16:45We don't know stuff. Yeah. We know today
- 16:48maybe stuff that we didn't know two years
- 16:50ago. So and it's a good idea to
- 16:52make regular reviews. And there's a lot of
- 16:54open source community tools out there. So stuff
- 16:58like, entra ops. So greetings to Thomas Nalheim.
- 17:01And, yeah, just use it and review your
- 17:04environment and find that stuff. Yeah. Yeah. And
- 17:07another thing that kinda goes with developers, and
- 17:10I know another thing you touched on in
- 17:12your talk was
- 17:14not just these SPNs and the permissions they
- 17:16have, but
- 17:17there's
- 17:18secrets and certificates
- 17:20and how these
- 17:22how you actually authenticate
- 17:23to these applications Yeah. And
- 17:25managing some of that. Do you want to
- 17:26talk a little bit about what you guys
- 17:29touched on best practices, things that people should
- 17:31be aware of when it comes to credential
- 17:33management
- 17:34for non human identities. Yeah. I mean, that
- 17:36that is a ball in itself. Right? Like,
- 17:38I mean, if you're talking about credentials, I
- 17:40mean, you have secrets which are the easy
- 17:42thing, but it essentially is just a password.
- 17:44Right? It is a password for an application.
- 17:46It's a better name.
- 17:48Yeah.
- 17:49Right. Yeah. We should just call it app
- 17:51passwords or something. Although we used to have
- 17:53those in Entra. Well, I think
- 17:55in graphs,
- 17:56either on app registrations or service principles somewhere,
- 17:59like, it It's a lot of secrets in
- 18:02the UI, but you then you have certificates,
- 18:05right, which are better, but certificates also, right,
- 18:08people can still do silly things, leaving them
- 18:11laying around. Yep. Like that. Save them to
- 18:13their documents so they sync it up to
- 18:15OneDrive. Yeah. So I mean, Lori, the the
- 18:17North Star is is like federated credentials, which,
- 18:20again, is something that's difficult
- 18:23to understand for some people. But in if
- 18:25you're, like, solely like a Microsoft shop, right,
- 18:27like, it's manage identities, which are easier to
- 18:30deploy. Right? Because then you don't have credential
- 18:32management. Nobody's having to hold secrets or Right.
- 18:35Use them. And another advantage of the managed
- 18:37identities is that you have an integrated life
- 18:40cycle. If you delete that function, the,
- 18:43the managed identity is also gone, including its
- 18:46permissions. So Yep. Yep. And I mean, I
- 18:48I will say, right, there's security research out
- 18:50there that will show
- 18:52there's sometimes cracks in sort of hybrid things
- 18:54like with ARC relative to manage identities. But
- 18:57I think if you sort of zoom out,
- 18:59right, and look at all the issues people
- 19:01have with secrets, right, it's still better to
- 19:03use
- 19:04manage identities whenever, you know, possible than, you
- 19:07know, certificates or or secrets. So yeah. And
- 19:09and I think we have to talk about
- 19:11this secret password. So if we if the
- 19:14time comes, we have to get rid of
- 19:16it because
- 19:17I know it's hard
- 19:19to do it,
- 19:20and it's even harder than with end users.
- 19:24But we see attacks
- 19:26where attackers
- 19:28are phishing developers
- 19:30and or attacking developers
- 19:32to get their secrets. So there is an
- 19:35attack out there that's called, ShyHulu,
- 19:38and it's
- 19:39leveraging that NPM packages. So they're they're
- 19:43targeting developers
- 19:45for
- 19:46NPM packages,
- 19:48then they are distributing
- 19:50malicious NPM packages
- 19:52to the max of the developers.
- 19:54And then there are tools like TruffleHawk
- 19:58that are scanning for secrets in GitHub repositories.
- 20:02And
- 20:03then you see an a login of an
- 20:05of an application
- 20:07with a correct password
- 20:08out of nothing,
- 20:10with a correct secret and so on. And
- 20:12it's, yeah, almost impossible to monitor.
- 20:15So and and even on the endpoint perspective,
- 20:18so
- 20:19yeah. Developers are
- 20:21not the best protected part of most environments
- 20:25and lock in lock ingestion into your theme
- 20:28from the GitHub and so on. This is
- 20:31also not very common.
- 20:33So yeah. And at the end, we have
- 20:35also as I said, we have to do
- 20:36some preventive stuff and we have to do
- 20:38some detection
- 20:39and prepare for response. But as the best
- 20:41prevention is to get rid of these secrets
- 20:44or passwords. When I think of nonhuman identities,
- 20:46I probably tend to hear the most is,
- 20:48to your point, someone leaving a secret
- 20:50in their code or
- 20:52they go in and check some code that
- 20:54has that secret
- 20:56into a public repo and it's like, oh,
- 20:59but I pulled it down five minutes later
- 21:01after I realized it. You don't know who
- 21:03saw that in those five minutes. Yeah. I
- 21:05feel like that's where I hear the most
- 21:06compromises when it comes to SPNs is due
- 21:09to those secrets and just I don't know
- 21:11that I wanna say carelessness, but just accidents
- 21:14happen. Right? Probably everyone whether they want to
- 21:17admit it or not. Right? Is guilty of
- 21:19like sending a password or something over Teams
- 21:21and be like, I'll delete it right after.
- 21:23Right? But I mean, there there's absolutely, you
- 21:25know, risk in there. I mean, and I
- 21:26I've been guilty of the these things, you
- 21:28know, myself. Right? Yeah. I mean, the secret
- 21:30part I think is also tough. Just just
- 21:32made me think of earlier when you were
- 21:34asking Chris about detection.
- 21:36It's one of the other things with secret
- 21:37management as we we now are also starting
- 21:39to talk about, like, well, let's lower the
- 21:41lifetime. Right? Because it it'd be like, well,
- 21:43I'll go ahead the certificate as a secret,
- 21:45and I'll just have it not expire until
- 21:46I'm retiring. Right? I'll
- 21:48make it somebody else's problem because we all
- 21:51hate rotating search. But now we're we're going
- 21:53down this path of saying like short lifetimes
- 21:56whether it's certificates or secrets which is awesome
- 21:58but now it creates I mean, in my
- 22:00eyes, right, even more noise if we're saying
- 22:02every every week, right, that that credential should
- 22:05be rotated. Yeah. And if we have different
- 22:07policies for lifetime, for secrets, and for certificates,
- 22:10maybe we are nudging
- 22:12the developers
- 22:13to rethink if a certificate would be an
- 22:16alternative. Yeah. Yeah. So when you work with
- 22:18customers, do you it I'm sure it varies
- 22:21customer to customer, but do you guys kinda
- 22:24have like a recommended,
- 22:26you should maybe we're not gonna go till
- 22:28you retire,
- 22:29but it's okay to go a year, two
- 22:31years, or I know passwords like the NIST
- 22:34is now saying, oh, just rotate it when
- 22:36there's a risk detected. Yep. Yep. I mean,
- 22:39I don't know, like, I think certificates like
- 22:42the Microsoft recommendation now what I think is
- 22:44six months for the lifetime on them. I
- 22:46mean, I I would say
- 22:48in ways, right, you could be more aggressive
- 22:51than that. I mean, honestly, like, I'm not
- 22:53a developer so I don't wanna pretend that
- 22:55coding is easy.
- 22:57But in other ways, right, like, I think
- 22:58sometimes people don't put the effort into the
- 23:00fact that, like, if you own if you
- 23:02have control over the currency graph, it's just
- 23:04like a few graph API calls to ask
- 23:07for a new one. Right? And and I
- 23:08mean, if you see a big identity systems
- 23:12where they have certain workload stuff like, I
- 23:14think Spiffy Inspire do things where it's like,
- 23:16you know, they're they're like rotating the secret
- 23:18like daily. Like that is used behind the
- 23:20covers for some of this stuff. I'd like
- 23:22to pick up the point, change password only
- 23:24if you have a reason. So this is
- 23:26something for
- 23:28user accounts, not for admin accounts.
- 23:30And we should delete workload
- 23:32nonhuman identities more than admin accounts than as
- 23:35user accounts.
- 23:36And I think that don't share don't rotate
- 23:40passwords
- 23:41is there is a yeah. I think we
- 23:43all think or come to the conclusion, a
- 23:46password is not enough. And we have additional
- 23:49stuff like MFA, device compliance, and all of
- 23:52those things.
- 23:54And, yeah,
- 23:55we don't have it in place in most
- 23:57environments for nonhuman identities.
- 24:00So the only things that is between an
- 24:03attacker and the and the resources is just
- 24:05a password at that point. Yeah. And I
- 24:08think, yeah, we should try to get rid
- 24:10of passwords. We should
- 24:12decrease the lifetime.
- 24:14And and, yes, we should
- 24:17introduce stuff like conditional access for workloads. So
- 24:20Yep. Yeah. I mean, I was just saying
- 24:21not not to increase my my Microsoft stock
- 24:24value but
- 24:25like for like a lot of people don't
- 24:27do workload identity protection. Right? Because it's like
- 24:30a pay for thing. But I would just
- 24:32say and I try to tell people like
- 24:34if you can identify what is considered like
- 24:37the high privileged risky workloads.
- 24:39Right? I mean, it's, like, $3 a month
- 24:41or something. So say you have 10 or
- 24:4215 service principles,
- 24:44like, start there. Right? It's only, you know,
- 24:46maybe a $100 a month to protect those.
- 24:49Right? But you could be potentially protecting
- 24:51the keys to your kingdom with, you know,
- 24:53conditional access for workloads and the identity protection
- 24:56features. So That's an interesting one too. Is
- 24:59Microsoft starting to do There's a couple aspects
- 25:02there. They're starting to do a lot more
- 25:03with conditional access for non human identities.
- 25:05Around
- 25:07SPNs,
- 25:08Ignite, couple weeks ago they said you can
- 25:10start doing conditional access now for
- 25:13agents which are just Yeah. Yeah. Look, agents
- 25:16are exploding in creating just a massive new
- 25:19influx of
- 25:20additional nonhuman identities. Do you work with clients
- 25:23around the conditional access and around some of
- 25:25the how do we start thinking about agents?
- 25:27Kinda two questions in there. It it it
- 25:29starts. So I think we are in the
- 25:31beginning of that. So there's just a big
- 25:33interest out there. So and our first message
- 25:35is the building blocks for agent IDs are
- 25:39human and non human identities.
- 25:41So they are not reinventing the wheel. They're
- 25:43reusing the building blocks that we already have.
- 25:46And if you have a good practice for
- 25:47protecting your human and not non human
- 25:51identities,
- 25:52you have a very good
- 25:54starting point
- 25:55for all that agents. But, I mean, I
- 25:57would just say with agent IDs and and
- 25:59workloads
- 26:00specific to conditional access, I think it's so
- 26:02when it's like being open minded. Right? Like,
- 26:05in for a long
- 26:06time, we say zero trust does not, you
- 26:08know, network. And people are like, well, I'm
- 26:10just gonna make my conditional access policy for
- 26:12users say, well, if you're coming from corporate
- 26:14network, like, don't MFA. And we're like, that's
- 26:16an awful idea. Right. But if you look
- 26:18at workload, right, like, workload
- 26:20because it's different and agent ID included here.
- 26:23Right? If you have the ability to say,
- 26:26if it's coming from, you know, this, you
- 26:29know, data center, the this egress. Right? Network
- 26:32location is one of the few things that
- 26:33you can use. Right? So it's like, in
- 26:35these cases, it's better than nothing. Right. You
- 26:37can't really MFA a SPN. That would be
- 26:40Right. Right. And I mean Certificates
- 26:42are MFA.
- 26:43Yeah. I mean, but I see I've seen
- 26:45people ask, like, weird things like, can you
- 26:47assign FIDO two keys to you know
- 26:51Yeah. And and yeah. But it like sometimes
- 26:53I think I'll see people say well we're
- 26:55not supposed to do
- 26:56network for users so why would we do
- 26:59it for workloads and and almost like right
- 27:02maybe we've caused the own problem as security
- 27:04people by saying don't do that so much.
- 27:05But I think it's like looking at it
- 27:06right well, it's it's better than nothing.
- 27:09Right. It's one of the few things we
- 27:10have. So Yeah. And I'd like to add
- 27:12something. I think so we will see what
- 27:15happens with that agent IDs, but I think
- 27:18we will have a lot more
- 27:21non human identities. So there will be much
- 27:24more agents and applications,
- 27:26and we already have in many environments more
- 27:29applications and user.
- 27:31So just from the quantity,
- 27:33we have a bigger problem there. And I
- 27:36think the permissions of agents will be a
- 27:38little broader because you don't exactly
- 27:42know what is really needed.
- 27:45So and I think over time,
- 27:47the permissions of the agents will extend. So
- 27:50we have more of them. They have more
- 27:52permissions. So, yeah. We have to take care
- 27:54of it. Yeah. Because I think especially with
- 27:56agents, to your point people are like an
- 27:58agent's not any good if it doesn't have
- 28:00access to data. Right. People are like I
- 28:02want it to have the access to the
- 28:03most amount of data so my agent's good
- 28:05or
- 28:05this data or that data.
- 28:08And we've already seen, right? Copilot came out
- 28:10and everybody's like, Oh, all these security issues.
- 28:12And it's, no, it doesn't create new security
- 28:14issues. It just It identifies. It highlights
- 28:16quicker Yes. The security issues you already had.
- 28:19Yep. Yep. And we're gonna continue
- 28:21to see that and I think to your
- 28:22point it's just going to create a whole
- 28:24new
- 28:25security issues are gonna become more easily quickly
- 28:29visible. Yeah. But yeah, I mean that's like
- 28:31I feel like I'd see so many people
- 28:33you you had the similar problem with with
- 28:35Delve. Right? But like Yep. You know, point
- 28:37at SharePoint and then all of a sudden
- 28:39people like, how come I can see all
- 28:41this corporate data I'm not supposed to because
- 28:43it's indexed and you can just go write
- 28:45query.
- 28:46But that's not, like, AI's fault. It's that
- 28:49you have, like, everyone has access to everything
- 28:52permissions going on. Right. If you would've used
- 28:54SharePoint search or Microsoft three sixty five search,
- 28:57you probably could've found them. It would've just
- 28:59taken a little longer.
- 29:00But no. I mean, it it's definitely, like,
- 29:03not even just a Microsoft, but industry thing
- 29:06that I feel like people are noodling on.
- 29:08Right? Because we have this issue where, yes,
- 29:10you wanted to have permissions, but then you
- 29:11say, well, you only wanted to have permissions
- 29:13when it needs them. But also if if
- 29:16you're hammering a user constantly saying, like, do
- 29:18you want the AI to still have permissions?
- 29:20Like, you have fatigue and people just start
- 29:22hitting yes all the time to things. Right?
- 29:24I mean, that's like a lot of consent
- 29:26grant issues where because nobody reads the thing.
- 29:28Right? You're just like, I just want it
- 29:30to work. Yes. Yeah.
- 29:33Yeah. So it's like trying to figure out
- 29:35how how can you let AI do its
- 29:37thing,
- 29:38but also not let it just, like, run
- 29:40away with access that is, you know, out
- 29:43of control. So
- 29:44and I don't know if there is, like,
- 29:46an answer out there yet for a lot
- 29:48of this. So Yeah. I think we can
- 29:50be happy that Microsoft has just launched that
- 29:54that AirBad stuff,
- 29:56and we will have conditional access and all
- 29:58of that stuff so that we
- 30:00we can, yeah, build good practices and guardrails
- 30:04and all of that stuff. Yeah.
- 30:09Do you feel overwhelmed by trying to manage
- 30:11your Office three sixty five environment? Are you
- 30:13facing unexpected issues that disrupt your company's productivity?
- 30:17Intelligink is here to help. Much like you
- 30:18take your car to the mechanic that has
- 30:20specialized knowledge on how to best keep your
- 30:22car running, Intelligent helps you with your Microsoft
- 30:26cloud environment because that's their expertise.
- 30:28Intelligent keeps up with the latest updates in
- 30:30the Microsoft cloud to help keep your business
- 30:33running smoothly and ahead of the curve. Whether
- 30:35you are a small organization with just a
- 30:37few users up to an organization of several
- 30:39thousand employees.
- 30:41They want to partner with you to implement
- 30:43and administer
- 30:44your Microsoft cloud technology.
- 30:46Visit them at inteligync.com/podcast.
- 30:50That's intelligink.com/podcast
- 30:57for more information or to schedule a thirty
- 30:59minute call to get started with them today.
- 31:02Remember, Intelligink focuses on the Microsoft cloud so
- 31:05you can focus on your business.
- 31:09Anything else that
- 31:11you wanna talk about, you wanna make users
- 31:14aware of when it comes to managing those
- 31:16nonhuman identities and and try. I think we
- 31:18covered
- 31:19some of that credential management, the permissions. I
- 31:21think we touched on ownership a little bit,
- 31:23some of the agents. Anything else?
- 31:24I think when I look at our presentation
- 31:28from yesterday, there are two things that are,
- 31:31yeah,
- 31:32problematic.
- 31:32And we already discussed the first thing that
- 31:34was the owner assignment, get rid of it.
- 31:36Yep. So use administrative
- 31:39roles for this. So like a cloud application
- 31:42admin, scope it to the dev. And the
- 31:43other part was, yeah, multi tenant apps are
- 31:46really
- 31:48challenge.
- 31:49So and we see we we saw a
- 31:51funny incident with, yeah, multi tenant apps by
- 31:54accident. So I think the Bing Bang story
- 31:57was one of the more known or someone
- 31:59it's just a radio button. Who is able
- 32:01to sign in? And Yeah. I mean, I
- 32:04I I tell you like with that. Right?
- 32:05So Bing Bang was when Wiz did research
- 32:07and found they could basically they they got
- 32:09into, like, some Bing back end and they
- 32:11could edit, like, search results.
- 32:12Got it. But yeah. Right. It it's like
- 32:15a radio button, but a lot of times
- 32:16you'll see devs again maybe sort of jumping
- 32:19on dev. See, right? They'll they'll pull up
- 32:20basically all the authorization
- 32:22sort of checks on enter. Right? And, like,
- 32:24people conflate authentication and authorization.
- 32:27So they won't have any logic in their
- 32:29app and they're just like, well, if they've
- 32:31authenticated, then I guess they should be here.
- 32:34Right? And now it's a multi tenant app
- 32:36that shouldn't be. And so you end up
- 32:38with anyone. Right? If they stumble across a
- 32:41thing, can go sign into it. And interestingly
- 32:44enough, you'll see a lot of times devs
- 32:46won't invest
- 32:47effort on, like, an admin sort of interface.
- 32:49Right? So maybe they have all this authorization
- 32:52stuff on a front end where all their
- 32:54customers are logging in and then there's some
- 32:55other admin portal thing that if you can
- 32:58get into it, right, you just have free
- 33:00reign to do whatever you want. And again,
- 33:02that's like basically what Wizz found in a
- 33:04lot of their the research. I mean, they
- 33:05were going after Microsoft stuff specifically. So Got
- 33:08it. I think the common
- 33:10the main problem with multi tenant apps is
- 33:13that we have a lot of controls
- 33:16in the
- 33:17app that where is the service principle, not
- 33:19in the app where the app registration is.
- 33:22And the attacker can have its own service
- 33:24principle and has control over assignment
- 33:27and role mappings and all of that stuff.
- 33:30And, yeah, Eric just yesterday showed those in
- 33:33no hours attacks, so you can find it
- 33:35also on, it's on your on your blocks.
- 33:37Right? Yeah. And and we know of, is
- 33:39on the December's blog. I I would spend
- 33:42an hour trying to explain it because I
- 33:43ramble about
- 33:45I mean, I I think I think a
- 33:46simple thing with with multi tenant apps is
- 33:48like, if you are not a software developer,
- 33:51like, as a business, you probably
- 33:53shouldn't have the app there. And and that
- 33:55is something again that you could use, you
- 33:57know, free tooling, paid tooling, right, to go
- 34:00find those sorts of things. So Yeah. So
- 34:02and if you are troubleshooting
- 34:04and switching
- 34:05configurations of your app I've seen that a
- 34:07lot. Don't touch this. It won't solve your
- 34:09problem, but bring you new problems. Yeah.
- 34:12Yeah. And
- 34:13and as I was saying, again, it's good
- 34:15to do reviews. When I I'm doing re
- 34:18entra reviews, so we are selling this as
- 34:21a as a package to customers. So and
- 34:23one of the main things I'm looking for,
- 34:25okay, do you have I'm always upfront asking,
- 34:28do you have any multitenant apps? No. We
- 34:30don't have. So and then I just turn
- 34:33turn on the tools. Okay. We found 20
- 34:35of
- 34:37them.
- 34:38And usually, you just can turn them off.
- 34:40And when there are some that are not
- 34:43by accident,
- 34:44you have to endure that people running the
- 34:46application
- 34:47are doing
- 34:48additional stuff. Yeah. So Yeah. And I think
- 34:51that highlights again, like we talked about earlier,
- 34:54the need
- 34:55for security and developers to talk to each
- 34:57other. Yeah. Whether developers don't even, some developers
- 35:00may not even know, I don't even know
- 35:01what the difference is between single tenant and
- 35:03multi tenants.
- 35:04And really having that conversation and I've seen
- 35:07this across all of Microsoft March
- 35:09is
- 35:10one thing I feel like the cloud has
- 35:12done is it's caused IT people that don't
- 35:15typically like to talk to each other Yep.
- 35:17To have to talk Yep. Because all this
- 35:19stuff is so tightly integrated and has some
- 35:22of those broader reaching effects. Yep. No. I
- 35:25mean, absolutely right. Like, you start to see
- 35:27conversations about soft skills and communication, all that.
- 35:30Right? Like, coming into the industry because,
- 35:32like, sometimes the best security person isn't because
- 35:36you have the biggest brain. It's because you
- 35:38can work across the organization,
- 35:40right, to help implement
- 35:42strong security practices amongst your developers, amongst your
- 35:45end users. Right? This isn't like the old
- 35:48days where you could be that bastard operator
- 35:50from hell,
- 35:51you know, and just tell people to do
- 35:53this thing. Right? Because then you get shadow
- 35:55IT and and all sorts of stuff.
- 35:57So, yep. Awesome. Well, thanks guys. Yeah. I
- 36:00I appreciate the conversation, talking a little bit
- 36:02more about non human identities.
- 36:04We'll include a bunch of links in the
- 36:06show notes. I'll get links from you guys
- 36:08to social media where you want, if people
- 36:10wanna connect with you there, websites. If you
- 36:13have links to tools, I'll get some of
- 36:14those that we can put in the show
- 36:15notes as well. Any last
- 36:17things you wanna share, highlights, telling people to
- 36:20come to this conference next year or 2027,
- 36:23I guess. It was really a nice event,
- 36:26so Yeah. No. I mean, this has been
- 36:28great being at the inaugural Workplace Ninjas and
- 36:31hopefully I mean, we're a little ahead. I'm
- 36:33I'm hoping I can claim now that I
- 36:35will become the intra idol
- 36:37from the inaugural
- 36:39workplace Oh, do I need to go I
- 36:40have not voted yet. Do I need to
- 36:42go vote for You need to go vote
- 36:43for me, Ben. You have to you have
- 36:45to vote for Eric. Yeah.
- 36:47But, no, I mean, as far as myself,
- 36:48I'll be actually over in Europe at MC2MC
- 36:52and then
- 36:53Hip Europe
- 36:54a couple days after that and
- 36:56then Experts Live Denmark.
- 36:58We're co presenting Chris and I at MC
- 37:00two MC so Okay. Are you gonna go
- 37:03most important question if you're going to Denmark.
- 37:05Are you gonna go to the Lego
- 37:07headquarters while you're in Denmark? Oh, I do.
- 37:09Are you a Lego guy? Yeah. Yeah. It's
- 37:10not really close to Kommang.
- 37:13Is it? Oh, I I have no idea.
- 37:15But, yeah, I I am a Lego guy,
- 37:17so
- 37:19You can go get those secret Lego sets.
- 37:21There's what? The two LEGO sets that you
- 37:22can only get at LEGO headquarters in Denmark.
- 37:26Oh, I did. Oh. I'll have to how
- 37:28far is it?
- 37:31I think for for Americans it's not that
- 37:33far.
- 37:38I will go rent the biggest SUV in
- 37:40all of Denmark.
- 37:42Go buy Allego. Right? We're in Texas. We're
- 37:44like
- 37:45Texas is huge over there. Everything's closer than
- 37:48driving across Texas.
- 37:51So, yeah, I'm really looking forward. So this
- 37:53year was also was already a cool event
- 37:55in in Copenhagen, but and and next year
- 37:58will be a really huge, I think. So
- 38:00Yeah. And but I also in enjoyed this
- 38:02web with New Year's US. It was also
- 38:03a very nice event.
- 38:05And, yeah, we have a full second day.
- 38:07So Yeah. Yeah. Alright. Well, I will let
- 38:10you guys go enjoy your second day. Thanks
- 38:12again. Enjoy the rest of the conference. Awesome.
- 38:14Talk to you guys later. Thank you. Bye.
- 38:18If you enjoyed the podcast, go leave us
- 38:20a five star rating in iTunes. It helps
- 38:22to get the word out so more IT
- 38:24pros can learn about Office three sixty five
- 38:26and Azure.
- 38:27If you have any questions you want us
- 38:29to address on the show or feedback about
- 38:31the show, feel free to reach out via
- 38:34our website, Twitter, or Facebook.
- 38:36Thanks again for listening, and have a great
- 38:38day.