Latest / NeedleStack / Where Woodward meets Holmes: OSINT and investigative journalism
Transcript
- 0:00I got a phone call from my now boss,
- 0:04the editor-in-chief of Knack, to ask if I wanted to become a fact checker.
- 0:09I had to Google what a fact checker exactly did.
- 0:12At the time, I was not really familiar
- 0:13with it but I quickly find out that's really my cup of tea,
- 0:18debunking viral videos, looking for the truth,
- 0:22seeing what's what I can find online to prove something right or wrong.
- 0:27Yeah, that's really what I love to do.
- 0:29OSINT is my main tool for it.
- 0:31Like it's being Sherlock Holmes
- 0:34online and I just love it.
- 0:46Welcome to NeedleStack, the podcast for professional Online research.
- 0:50I'm your host, Matt Ashburn.
- 0:53I'm Jeff Phillips, tech industry veteran and curious to a fault.
- 0:56Today, we're continuing our series
- 0:58on fact-checking and debunking. We're going to turn our attention to the growing
- 1:03importance of independent researchers and journalists that are putting their
- 1:07findings out on Twitter and other social media platforms.
- 1:12We've talked about this in past episodes that the war in Ukraine has really put a
- 1:17spotlight on the open source information available on social media and other public
- 1:21sources as well as the individuals that analyze that info.
- 1:27We're joined by one of those individuals in this episode.
- 1:31Brecht Castel is an independent journalist and fact checker.
- 1:35You can find his work in the Belgian magazine, Knack among other publications.
- 1:41He's very active on Twitter at @brechtcastel with tons of tips
- 1:46on OSINT and visual forensic, how he debunks viral videos in fact-checking.
- 1:53Definitely go check that out.
- 1:55Welcome to the show Brecht. Thank you very much.
- 1:58Nice introduction. Good.
- 2:01Hopefully, we covered it all.
- 2:02It's quite the background you have there, sir. Let's jump into that.
- 2:07Where did your experience in fact-checking begin?
- 2:11Did you already have an interest in OSINT
- 2:13or is this something that's been fostered as you've gotten into fact-checking?
- 2:20Well, yeah I started as a normal freelance journalist and the first of April 2020.
- 2:26In the midst of the COVID crisis, I got a phone call from my now boss,
- 2:32the editor-in-chief of Knack to ask if I wanted to become a fact checker.
- 2:37I had to Google what a fact checker exactly did.
- 2:40At the time, I was not really familiar with it, but I quickly find out it's
- 2:45really my cup of tea, debunking viral videos looking
- 2:48for the truth, seeing what I can find online to prove something right or wrong.
- 2:55Yeah, that's really what I love to do.
- 2:57OSINT is my main tool for it.
- 2:59Like it's being Sherlock Holmes online and I just love it.
- 3:03Yeah. That's great.
- 3:07Something we talked about earlier was
- 3:09that researchers need to be both persistent and creative in your work.
- 3:13How do you latch onto something that you
- 3:15really want to investigate what drives you for that?
- 3:20No.
- 3:22Actually, I always start from one picture or video.
- 3:25If it's intriguing to me,
- 3:27it's mostly intriguing to other people, that's why it's mostly going viral because
- 3:31a lot of people think like this is strange, it's interesting.
- 3:34Where does it come from?
- 3:35What do we see actually?
- 3:36This is also the question I'm asking.
- 3:39If it's going viral, it doesn't mean that maybe some people
- 3:42have looked into it, but didn't find what it actually is.
- 3:45I try to get a bit further and see what we actually see.
- 3:49For example, recently there was a video
- 3:51going viral of a mosquito with a number on it.
- 3:54People linked it to Bill Gates
- 3:56and microchips into ants and very weird conspiracy theories.
- 4:00But still, I was wondering, what actually do we see?
- 4:02Is it a real number?
- 4:04Is it a real mosquito?
- 4:05Where does it come from?
- 4:06What is it?
- 4:07These basic journalistic questions like what's true, what's not?
- 4:11Where is something? What do we see?
- 4:13Very basic questions.
- 4:15They just drive me.
- 4:16I just want to continue digging harder and deeper to find what we actually see.
- 4:22Now, you have me curious about this mosquito and what that was, I guess.
- 4:27Well, that's a good point.
- 4:30Actually, it wasn't even a mosquito.
- 4:32It was [inaudible 00:04:33] another type of ant.
- 4:35The number we see is just like natural spots on the ends.
- 4:42We think it's a number.
- 4:44It's our human brain would just see
- 4:48numbers, see patterns, it's wired like this.
- 4:51It's not really a number.
- 4:53Yeah, that was the explanation I got
- 4:55from talking to experts and from doing OSINT investigation.
- 4:59That's awesome.
- 5:00It's how our brains are wired to see faces and people see faces in rock formations
- 5:04and leaves and trees and everything else, even though they're not really there.
- 5:08Exactly.
- 5:10The conflict in Ukraine is obviously a big topic now.
- 5:14How has the role of OSINT changed in fact-checking?
- 5:17How has all of this changed during the conflict in Ukraine?
- 5:21Or do you think that OSINT and fact-
- 5:23checking is just getting more attention now?
- 5:26It's definitely getting more attention.
- 5:28If I read the newspaper now, for me,
- 5:31mostly it's old news because I've seen it on Twitter the day before and I've seen
- 5:35videos being debunked or verified and then the day after it's in the newspaper.
- 5:42I think that's a major change because
- 5:45in the war in Syria, there was already some fact-checking going on.
- 5:48I think [inaudible 00:05:49] gets started.
- 5:50It was the spark of OSINT and war journalism.
- 5:54But still journalists were skeptic about it.
- 5:57It was like a marginal thing.
- 6:00Now, I think most of our journalists is really driven by OSINT.
- 6:04Also, we see a lot of journalists working at home, not on the front line
- 6:08and collaborating with journalists in Ukraine to really verify things.
- 6:14I had a very interesting case about
- 6:16a burned body was a shared widely on Russian platforms.
- 6:20It was compared with pictures of ISIS.
- 6:23They were saying, "Look,
- 6:24those Ukrainian soldiers, they burned his body and they put it
- 6:27in a cage just like ISIS did in Syria." I started investigating this picture.
- 6:34We found the location.
- 6:35We tried to prove if it was tortured alive or it was set on fire afterwards.
- 6:40We couldn't prove that,
- 6:42but we still find out a lot of things about this one picture.
- 6:45After publication of this fact check,
- 6:47I got in contact with a photographer was on the ground, was in Ukraine and he took
- 6:52a photograph of this body a few weeks later.
- 6:55When I called him, he knew less about it than I did after an OSINT investigation.
- 7:00For me, it was so weird, he knew there was this body.
- 7:05He wanted to photograph it for a couple of days or weeks.
- 7:08The Ukrainian army was saying, "No,
- 7:11you cannot go there, we don't want you to take a picture of it."
- 7:17Behind my laptop in Belgium,
- 7:19I drew a lot of social media posts and a lot of talking to experts,
- 7:23I knew more about this burned body than this photographer in Ukraine.
- 7:28That's crazy.
- 7:31It doesn't mean that we don't need journalists on the ground, they are hugely
- 7:36important and they do a much more dangerous work that I do.
- 7:41Of course, we need them definitely.
- 7:45But I think in combination with OSINT investigation, it can be very strong.
- 7:50Yeah. It's almost an abdication
- 7:52of responsibility if you don't provide that context that you're talking about
- 7:56there and if you provide only a photograph and then a quick blurb about it.
- 8:01Rumors and false stories can run amuck and be very damaging.
- 8:06Yeah.
- 8:07You should also be very transparent about what you can find and cannot find.
- 8:11OSINT is very powerful, but it also has limitations.
- 8:15These experts said to me,
- 8:16"I cannot say if this body was burned alive or not if I not can do an autopsy
- 8:22on the body." Only from the pictures, it's not possible to say it 100% for sure.
- 8:26Then you also have to say this to your
- 8:28audience to say, "Okay, we did our best to be analyzed a lot.
- 8:32We worked hard. We talked to experts.
- 8:34But the conclusion is, inconclusive." I think we gain... How to say.
- 8:42If people don't trust the media, it's also because we don't do this.
- 8:46We have do this more often, we have to be more transparent about what
- 8:48we know for sure, which we're doubting about.
- 8:53That's amazing input.
- 8:56If we stick on the Ukraine a little bit,
- 8:59we're all following that news, are there certain sources or tools
- 9:05at the moment that are helping you either from the journalism side or from the fact-
- 9:12checking side against maybe specific to the war on Ukraine?
- 9:15How are you getting your information in?
- 9:21Open source intelligence starts with open sources.
- 9:23Finding these sources is a first important step.
- 9:26For this in the war in Ukraine,
- 9:28there is a great website, very easy to remember, osintukraine.com.
- 9:32It just created some bots, we're just scraping a lot of contents.
- 9:38For example, they're following 90 telegram channels, Russian telegram channels,
- 9:4290 Ukrainian telegram channels, and they put it in one feed.
- 9:46They also do automatic translation from these videos.
- 9:50You can just follow the war in real time and see a lot of sources.
- 9:56Of course, this is only the starting point.
- 9:58There can be a lot of fakes in there.
- 10:00You have to be very careful.
- 10:01The Ukrainian sites want to tell their story.
- 10:04The Russian sites want to tell their story.
- 10:05There is a lot of propaganda there.
- 10:08But if you're just new to the conflict and you just want to start somewhere,
- 10:12it's a good way to get away from what news media are saying and just try to see what
- 10:17is being shared on social media in Ukraine and in Russia.
- 10:22With automatic translation, nowadays,
- 10:24it's even possible to follow Russian videos, Ukrainian videos and so on.
- 10:29Both sides. That's super interesting.
- 10:33What are some of the strategies that you
- 10:34use in trying to combat false information or to debunk things?
- 10:38What are some of the principles, I guess, that are consistent across your work?
- 10:43One principle is always find the oldest version.
- 10:48If you find the oldest version online,
- 10:51then you get closer to the real context and if you find the real context,
- 10:54the meaning of the picture can change or you can get closer to the true.
- 10:58That's very important.
- 10:59Contextualizing what we actually see, that's a very important one.
- 11:03Of course, also see if there has been some manipulation.
- 11:07Also, if you find the oldest version,
- 11:09you will see it immediately if this is like this.
- 11:14Combining sources,
- 11:17never take one sources for granted, try to combine Russian and Ukrainian
- 11:22sources, combining a lot of points of view that really helps.
- 11:27For example, the burnt body we found different videos from different angles.
- 11:31We could say, "Okay, the body was there for a long period of time.
- 11:34We see different shades." It really helps to see what we really see.
- 11:40Speaking of that, so I'm curious,
- 11:43since you started off on the journalism side and then moved into fact checking,
- 11:50have you surprised yourself with what you've been able to apply OSINT
- 11:55to and what you've been able to figure out through open source sources?
- 12:00Yeah, definitely.
- 12:04Surprise on a daily basis, I would say.
- 12:06The force of OSINT is amazing.
- 12:09One aha moment that it's a bit strange
- 12:11story is I was just fact-checking a picture of an old tree
- 12:15and it was said that it was 6,000 years old in South Africa.
- 12:19I was like, "I want to find where this
- 12:21tree is and how old it can actually be." B y combining Instagram, YouTube, Flickr,
- 12:28a lot of social media platforms, and Google Earth, of course,
- 12:32I could really find the exact location of this tree.
- 12:34This was like stunning for me.
- 12:36If you're a bit persistent.
- 12:37If you work hard enough, you can really find one tree in the whole world.
- 12:42That's crazy if you think about it.
- 12:45That's a force of open source intelligence.
- 12:48If you combine a lot of platforms, a lot of sources, you can really get close
- 12:52to the truth and using it to find a tree is a bit silly.
- 12:55I agree on that.
- 12:57But you can also use it to find this burnt
- 12:59body in Ukraine or to investigate war crimes.
- 13:04I'm doing this for a couple of years.
- 13:06But OSINT investigators
- 13:08from Amnesty International are doing this for over a decade.
- 13:11This is not new.
- 13:12But for me, this is eye-opening.
- 13:14When I was a normal journalist just
- 13:16talking to people, basically, that's what you do.
- 13:19You talk to experts, you talk to people.
- 13:22I didn't know that there's such a wide
- 13:24world of open source intelligence and combining the two is also great.
- 13:29Talking to experts and doing your OSINT
- 13:31investigation, go with your OSINT investigation
- 13:33to experts and see like this is what I found out.
- 13:35Does it make sense or why can it not be like this?
- 13:39That's really wonderful.
- 13:41A quick follow-up because this has come up in some other episodes and talking
- 13:46with different individuals, what are your thoughts from a journalism
- 13:51perspective about working with some of the amateurs that are out there?
- 13:54There are a lot of amateurs loose these days.
- 13:57What are your thoughts in using those sources?
- 14:01First and foremost, if a tweet has a hashtag OSINT, it doesn't mean it's true.
- 14:06Let's all agree on that.
- 14:09Some people just see OSNIT and they think, "Yeah.
- 14:11That's true." No, it's not like a magic word to say the truth.
- 14:16Most of the times it's just people
- 14:17who found the video on Telegram and put it on Twitter.
- 14:20That's not OSINT.
- 14:22But I love working with amateurs.
- 14:25I've worked with them a lot of times and they helped me immensely.
- 14:30I keep coming back to this fact check of this burnt body.
- 14:34But for example, I keep coming back to this factor for this burn body.
- 14:42I was looking for the location to start digging, but I didn't find a location.
- 14:46I went to some amateur OSINT people I know.
- 14:49I put it out there.
- 14:50After a few days, they found a location
- 14:52and that was actually the starting point of my investigation.
- 14:56If you cannot find it yourself, use the community and you're stronger together.
- 15:00Definitely.
- 15:01The good thing about OSINT is you don't have to know the person behind the screen.
- 15:06You don't have to...
- 15:07I work with anonymous people, which I don't trust per se.
- 15:11But if they tell you something, you can verify.
- 15:14You can check these open source they used to get there, I could get on Google Maps,
- 15:18Google Street I see, yeah, it's definitely this location.
- 15:21How this person found it,
- 15:23I'm not sure and he definitely worked a lot of long hours to get it.
- 15:27But we can see it's true. I can trust it.
- 15:31That's great. They help me a lot.
- 15:34I love amateur OSINT investigators.
- 15:38A lot of people out there who are going to like hearing that.
- 15:41Absolutely.
- 15:44Sometimes, they don't see the journalistic value of what they do.
- 15:47That's where I come in and like, "Okay.
- 15:50Now, you find this location.
- 15:51It's not finished.
- 15:53We have to dig further and talk to experts and so on." Usually,
- 15:57they are very happy that they can contribute to something bigger.
- 16:01If they want, I take them on Twitter or I give them some reconnaissance in this way
- 16:08or sometimes they just want to stay anonymous and I don't mention them at all.
- 16:12But I'm just open that I didn't find it myself, of course.
- 16:17Yeah.
- 16:17That's great. Brecht, as we start to close out, what are some of the tips or
- 16:22techniques that you want to leave with the audience today?
- 16:26Well, mostly people are asking for specific new tools.
- 16:31Well, I'm going to disappoint you.
- 16:34I will not give you one of the latest tools.
- 16:36If you want to stay up to date,
- 16:37I would recommend to the Newsletter Week in OSINT.
- 16:40I think it's a great weekly update of the newest kit on the blog.
- 16:45For me, OSINT is all about creativity and persistence.
- 16:49Creativity, I mean, combining a lot
- 16:51of sources, combining a lot of techniques, looking for new ways to find something.
- 16:57For example, now I'm fact-checking a video of Chinese troops entering Ukraine.
- 17:01That's the claim they make and we see Chinese vehicles.
- 17:04If I can prove that this video was
- 17:06recorded somewhere else in Russia close to Vladivostok, that's good proof.
- 17:11If it's not possible, I can also look for another way to prove it.
- 17:14For example, if I find a number of plates
- 17:15of these vehicles and I find other videos and I can geolocate these videos.
- 17:20That's, for example, a creative way of thinking, how can I fact-check this?
- 17:25Another thing is persistence.
- 17:26Sometimes people are like, how can you find this?
- 17:29It's impossible. Well, yeah, it took me a few days.
- 17:32It's hard work sometimes.
- 17:35If I cannot sleep, I get up.
- 17:38I search a few hours and sometimes then I find the location of a video or picture.
- 17:43Persistence and creativity are key.
- 17:45You just learn it by doing it.
- 17:48I just start and you get better it day by day.
- 17:50I think I'll be a better OSINT
- 17:52investigator year in one year from now than I'm today, that's for sure.
- 17:57That's great.
- 17:58Brecht, thank you so much for joining us today.
- 18:00I really do appreciate the conversation with you.
- 18:03If you're listening at home, you can always find Brecht Castel
- 18:06on Twitter @brechtcastel, first name, last name.
- 18:10If you liked what you heard,
- 18:11you can subscribe to our show wherever you get your podcast.
- 18:13You can also watch our episodes on YouTube and get more information at our website
- 18:18that's authentic8.com/needlestack, authentic with #8.com/needlestack.
- 18:24Also, be sure to follow us on Twitter as well.
- 18:27Needlestack Pod is our handle on Twitter.
- 18:30We'll be back next week with more
- 18:31information on debunking and fact checking and all things OSINT.
- 18:35We'll see you then.