Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Brad Edwards And His Affidavit In Support Of Epstein Related Transparency By The DOJ (Part 1)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to continue taking
- 0:06a look at some more court documents in regard to
- 0:10the CVRA and the non prosecution Agreement, and this time
- 0:14we're taking a look at the Affid David of Bradley
- 0:18Edwards regarding need for the production of documents Case number
- 0:23nine zero eight DASH CV DASH eight zero seven three
- 0:28six DASH KAM Jane Do one Jane Do two versus
- 0:33the United States of America The Affid David of Bradley J. Edwards.
- 0:39I Bradley J. Edwards Do hereby declare that I'm a
- 0:42member in good standing of the Bar of the State
- 0:44of Florida. Along with co Council, I represent Jane Do
- 0:49number one and Jane Do number two as referred to
- 0:52as victims in the above listed action to enforce their
- 0:55rights under the Crime Victims Rights Act. I also represented
- 0:58them in several other victims in civil suits against Jeffrey
- 1:01Epstein for sexually abusing them. I am also familiar with
- 1:06the criminal justice system, having served as a state prosecutor
- 1:09in the Broward County State Attorney's Office. The Affid David
- 1:13covers factual issues regarding the government's assertions of privilege to
- 1:17more than thirteen thousand pages of documents it has produced
- 1:20for in camera inspection. In the case, this affid David
- 1:24provides factual information demonstrating that the government's assertions of privilege
- 1:29are not well founded. It further demonstrates that the victims
- 1:32have a compelling and substantial need for the information requested
- 1:36and have no other way of obtaining that information. Background
- 1:40regarding unsuccessful efforts to reach stipulated facts with the government.
- 1:44On July seven, two thousand and eight, I filed a
- 1:47petition to enforce the CVR rights at Jane DO one
- 1:50and Jane DO two with regard to sex offenses committed
- 1:53against them by Jeffrey Epstein while they were miners. Though
- 1:57a course of the proceedings since then is one known
- 2:00to the Court. For purposes of this Affidavid regarding privileges,
- 2:04it's enough to briefly recount the efforts of the victims
- 2:07to reach a stipulated set of facts with the government,
- 2:10efforts that the government has blocked. The Court first held
- 2:14a hearing on victims petition on July eleventh, two thousand
- 2:17and eight. The Court discussed a need to have complete record,
- 2:20and this is going to be an issue that's going
- 2:22to go to the Eleventh Circuit, so it may be
- 2:25better to have a complete record as to what your
- 2:27position is and the governments is to what actions were taken.
- 2:32The court concluded that the hearing with the following instructions,
- 2:35So I'll let both of you confer about whether there
- 2:38is a need for any additional evidence to be presented.
- 2:42And that was the transcript we did previously, so this
- 2:45is building on that. The victims and the US Attorney's
- 2:49Office then attempted to reach a stipulated set of facts
- 2:52underlying the case. The US Attorney's Office offered a very
- 2:55abbreviated set of proposed facts, and the victims responded with
- 2:59the detailed set of proposed facts rather than respond to
- 3:02the victim's specific facts. However, the U. S. Attorney's Office
- 3:06suddenly reversed course. On July twenty ninth, two thousand and eight,
- 3:10it filed a notice to court regarding absence of need
- 3:13for evidentiary hearing. The U. S. Attorney's Office took the
- 3:17following position after consideration, the government believes that an evidentiary
- 3:21hearing is not necessary. The office asserted that the court
- 3:25need only take judicial notice of the fact that no
- 3:28indictment had been filed against Epstein to resolve the case.
- 3:32On August first, two thousand and eight, the victims filed
- 3:35a response to the government's notice, given a proposed statement
- 3:38of facts surrounding the case. The victim's response also requested
- 3:42that the court direct the government to confer with the
- 3:45victims regarding the undisputed facts of the case and produced
- 3:49the non prosecution agreement and other information about the case.
- 3:53On August fourteenth, two thousand and eight, the Court held
- 3:56a hearing on the case regarding the confidentiality of the
- 3:59non na prosecution agreement. The court ultimately ordered production of
- 4:03the agreement to the victims. After the U. S. Attorney's
- 4:07Office made the non prosecution agreement available to the victims,
- 4:10the victims reviewed it and pursued further discussion with the U. S.
- 4:14Attorney's Office. Ultimately, however, the U. S. Attorney's Office declined
- 4:18to reach a stipulated set of facts with the victims
- 4:22and declined to provide further information about the case. With
- 4:26negotiations at an impasse, the victims attempted to learn the
- 4:29facts of the case in other ways. In approximately May
- 4:34of two thousand and nine, Council for the Victims propounded
- 4:37discovery requests in both states and federal civil cases against Epstein,
- 4:42seeking to obtain correspondence between Epstein and prosecutors regarding his
- 4:47plea agreement, information that the U. S. Attorney's Office was
- 4:51unwilling to provide to the victims, and information that was
- 4:54highly relevant both to the victim's civil suit and their
- 4:57CVRA enforcement action. Epstein refused to produce the information, and,
- 5:02as the Court is aware, extended litigation to obtain the
- 5:06materials followed. The Court rejected all of Epstein's objections to
- 5:10producing the materials. On June thirtieth, twenty ten, Council for
- 5:15Epstein sent to Council for Victims approximately three hundred and
- 5:19fifty eight pages of email correspondence between Criminal Defense Council
- 5:23and the U. S. Attorney's Office regarding the plea agreement
- 5:26that had been negotiated between them. These emails began to
- 5:30disclose for the first time the extreme steps that had
- 5:33been taken by the US Attorney's Office to avoid prosecuting
- 5:37Epstein and to avoid having the victims in the case
- 5:40learn about the non prosecution agreement that had been reached
- 5:43between Epstein and the government. While the court ordered that
- 5:47all of the correspondents be turned over to the victims,
- 5:50Epstein chose to disobey that order and instead only produced
- 5:53the correspondents authored by the government and redacted all correspondents
- 5:57authored by him or his attorneys. In mid July twenty ten,
- 6:02Jane do one and Jane do two settled their civil
- 6:05lawsuits against Epstein. Then, armed with new information, they turned
- 6:09to moving forward in the CVR case. On September thirteenth,
- 6:13twenty ten, the victims informed the court that they were
- 6:17preparing new filings in the case. On October twelfth, twenty ten,
- 6:22the court entered in order directing the victims to provide
- 6:25a status report on the case by October twenty seventh,
- 6:28twenty ten. That same day, Council for the victims again
- 6:32contacted the US Attorney's Office about the possibility of reaching
- 6:36a stipulated set of facts in the case. That same day,
- 6:40the US Attorney's Office responded, we don't have any problem
- 6:43with agreeing that a factual assertion is correct if we
- 6:46agree that is what occurred. On October twenty third, twenty ten,
- 6:51the victims email to the US Attorney's Office a detailed
- 6:54proposal statement of facts that many of the facts now
- 6:57documented by the correspondents between the US Attorney's Office and
- 7:01Epstein's council. The victims requested that the US Attorney's Office
- 7:06identify which facts it would agree to. In a letter
- 7:09to the US Attorney's Office, the victim stated, if you
- 7:12believe that any of the facts they proposed during correct,
- 7:16Jane do one and Jane Doe two would reiterate their
- 7:19long standing request that you work with us to arrive
- 7:22at a mutually agreed statement of facts. As you know,
- 7:25in the summer of two thousand and eight, Jane do
- 7:27one and Jane do two were working with you on
- 7:30a stipulation of facts when you reverse course and took
- 7:32the position that no recitation of the facts was necessary.
- 7:37I hope that your email means that you will at
- 7:39least look at our facts and propose any modifications that
- 7:43you deem appropriate. Having that evidence quickly available to the
- 7:47court would help move the case to a conclusion. That
- 7:49same day, the US Attorney's Office agreed to forward the
- 7:52proposed statement of facts to the appropriate Assistant US Attorney
- 7:56for review on October twenty six, twenty ten. Rather than
- 8:00stipulate to undisputed facts, the US Attorney's Office contacted the
- 8:04victims attorneys and asked them to delay the filing of
- 8:08their motion for a two week period of time so
- 8:10that negotiations could be held between the office and the
- 8:13victims in an attempt to narrow the range of disputes
- 8:16in the case and hopefully reach a settlement resolution without
- 8:20the need for further litigation. Negotiation between the victims in
- 8:24the US Attorney's Office then followed over the next two days. However,
- 8:29at six eleven pm on October twenty seventh, twenty ten,
- 8:33the date on which the victims pleading was due, the
- 8:36US Attorney's Office informed the victims that it did not
- 8:39believe that it had time to review the victim's proposed
- 8:42statement of the facts and advise which were accurate and
- 8:45which were inaccurate. The office further advised the victims that
- 8:50it believed that the victims did not have a right
- 8:53to confer with their office under the CVRA in this case, because,
- 8:57in its view, the case is civil litigation rather than
- 9:01criminal litigation. As a result, purely as an accommodation to
- 9:05the US Attorney's Office. On October twenty seventh, twenty ten,
- 9:09the victims filed a report with the court in which
- 9:12they agreed to delay filing their motion and accompanying facts
- 9:15for up to two weeks to see if negotiations can
- 9:18resolve or narrow the disputes with the U. S. Attorney's Office.
- 9:23Discussions with the U. S. Attorney's Office dragged on, including
- 9:26a personal meeting between Jane do One and the U.
- 9:28S Attorney in December of twenty ten. After further discussion
- 9:34failed to produce any agreement or other visible progress, the
- 9:38victims informed the US Attorney's Office that they would file
- 9:41their summary judgment motion with the court on March eighteenth,
- 9:44twenty eleven, and requested further cooperation from the office on
- 9:49the facts. Ultimately, after months of discussion, the US Attorney's
- 9:53Office in formed Council for the Victims that, contrary to
- 9:56promises made earlier to stipulate to undisputed facts, no such
- 10:00stipulation would be forthcoming. Instead, on March fifteenth, twenty eleven,
- 10:05the US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida,
- 10:08wil Fredo A. Farah sent a letter to the victims
- 10:11declining to reach any agreement on the facts, because, as
- 10:15a matter of law, the CVRA is inapplicable to this matter,
- 10:19in which no federal criminal charges were ever filed. Your
- 10:22request for the government's agreement on a set of proposed
- 10:24stipulated facts is unnecessary and premature. That is because whether
- 10:29the rights in eighteen US Code Section thirty seven to
- 10:33seventy one a attached prior to the filing of a
- 10:36charge in federal court is a matter of statutory interpretation.
- 10:40Resolution of that question is not dependent upon the existence
- 10:44of any certain set of facts other than whether a
- 10:46charging document was ever filed against Jeffrey Epstein in the U. S.
- 10:50District Court for the Southern District of Florida. And while
- 10:53this office remains willing to cooperate, cooperation does not mean
- 10:57agreeing to facts that are not relevant to the resolution
- 11:00of the legal dispute at issue. Letter from Wilfredo A.
- 11:05Ferrer to Paul G. Cassel, accordingly, unable to work with
- 11:10the government to reach a resolution of the facts. On
- 11:12March twenty first, twenty eleven, the victims filed emotion for
- 11:16some rejudgment alleging fifty three undisputed facts, along with some
- 11:21evidentiary support for each of the facts. The victims also
- 11:25filed a motion to have their facts accepted because of
- 11:28the government's failure to contest their facts. The victims also
- 11:32filed emotion to have the court direct the government not
- 11:35to withhold relevant evidence. Following a hearing on the motions
- 11:39on September twenty six, twenty eleven, the court rejected the
- 11:43government's argument that the CBRA was inapplicable in the case
- 11:47because the government had never filed charges against Epstein. The court, however,
- 11:52rejected the victim's argument that it should accept their facts
- 11:55because of the government's failure to contest the facts. Instead,
- 11:59the court directed that discovery could proceed in the form
- 12:02of requests for admissions and document production requests. The court
- 12:06reserved ruling on the victim's motion that the government should
- 12:09be directed not to withhold evidence. All right, folks, we're
- 12:13gonna wrap up right here, and in the next episode,
- 12:15we're gonna pick up where we left off. All of
- 12:18the information that goes with this episode can be found
- 12:21in the description box.