Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Handle a Workplace Power Struggle Without Losing Your Cool
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this scenario I keep hearing about from listeners — you're in a meeting, and two senior people start going at it. Not a polite disagreement — a real power struggle. Everyone else is just staring at their notebooks. Luna: And the worst part is when one of them looks at you and says, 'What do you think?' You're suddenly the rope in a tug of war. Lucas: Exactly. I want to talk about a specific case — a mid-size tech company, about four hundred employees. A veteran director named Maria — she's been there twelve years, knows every process, every client — and a new VP named Tom, brought in six months ago to 'modernize' the division. Luna: The classic insider versus outsider dynamic. I've seen that play out a dozen times. Usually ends with one of them leaving. Lucas: Right, but here's the twist — the person caught in the middle was a senior analyst named James. He reported to both of them on different projects. And he had to figure out how to survive without picking a side or becoming a messenger. Luna: So what did James do? Because most people either pick a side — which is risky — or they try to hide, which makes them look weak. Lucas: He did something smarter. He started by mapping interests — not positions. Tom's public position was 'we need faster delivery.' Maria's was 'we need to maintain quality.' But underneath, Tom's real interest was proving his value to the CEO within his first year. Maria's was protecting her team's legacy and her own job security. Luna: So the surface conflict was about process, but the real conflict was about survival. That's almost always the case. Lucas: And James used that to reframe the conversation. Instead of defending either approach, he started asking questions in one-on-ones. 'If we could get faster delivery without dropping quality, would that work for both of you?' That forced them to articulate what they actually needed. Luna: That's a great move — it shifts from debating positions to solving a shared problem. And it positions James as the person who can bridge the gap. Lucas: Exactly. He also used what I call the 'public win' tactic. In a monthly review meeting, he presented a small pilot project where he'd improved delivery time by fifteen percent — with zero quality issues. He credited both Tom's methodology and Maria's process documentation. Luna: So he gave each of them a piece of the credit. That's smart — it makes both feel like they contributed, and it shows he's loyal to the outcome, not to a person. Lucas: And the result? Over about three months, the tension eased. Tom started including Maria in strategy discussions, and Maria stopped blocking his initiatives. James became the go-to person for cross-functional work. He got a promotion six months later. Luna: But what if you're in a situation where the power struggle is more aggressive — like one person is actively undermining the other? Does this still work? Lucas: That's harder, and honestly, sometimes you can't fix it. But even then, the interest-mapping approach helps you decide when to exit. If you can see that one party's real interest is 'I want total control' and the other's is 'I want autonomy,' there's no middle ground. Then your interest becomes protecting your own career — maybe by documenting everything or looking for a lateral move. Luna: So the first step is always diagnosis: figure out what each person actually needs. Not what they're saying, but what they're afraid of losing. Lucas: Right. And the second step is what I call 'strategic neutrality.' You don't say 'I'm not taking sides.' You say 'I want to make sure we find the best path forward for the company.' That's a different frame. Luna: That language is crucial. If you say 'I'm neutral,' people think you're weak or indecisive. If you say 'I'm focused on the best outcome,' you look like a leader. Lucas: Yes. And then you back it up with data. James brought numbers to every conversation. He didn't argue opinions; he presented what the pilot showed. That's hard to attack. Luna: Okay, I want to circle back to something you mentioned earlier — the 'public win.' What if you don't have a project that succeeded yet? Can you still build that bridge? Lucas: You can create a small win. Find a low-risk task where both sides can contribute something — maybe a process improvement or a client feedback summary. Frame it as a test. 'Let's try this approach on a small scale and see what happens.' That gives you data without committing to a big bet. Luna: And if the test fails? Doesn't that make you look bad? Lucas: Only if you frame it as a failure. If you frame it as a learning experiment — 'we discovered that this approach doesn't work because of X, which tells us we need to adjust Y' — you still look thoughtful. The key is to own the learning, not the result. Luna: That's a great reframe. I think a lot of people are terrified of failure in these situations because they think it'll be used against them. But if you're the one controlling the narrative, you can make it a data point. Lucas: Exactly. And that brings me to another tactic: always be the one who writes the summary after the meeting. If you can capture what was agreed, who's doing what, and why — you're subtly influencing the outcome. People rarely rewrite a well-written summary. Luna: That's so true. I've seen people win arguments just by sending a follow-up email that frames the decision their way. It's almost unfair. Lucas: It is a little unfair. But it's also a skill. And if you're in the middle of a power struggle, that skill can be your lifeline. You're not taking sides — you're just making sure the conversation doesn't stall or get twisted. Luna: Alright, so let's say you're doing all this — mapping interests, staying strategically neutral, creating small wins, writing the summaries. But the struggle is still churning. At what point do you decide it's time to leave? Lucas: You know, that's a really good question. And I think it comes down to whether the conflict is about the work or about ego. If it's about the work, you can usually find a path. If it's about ego — and both parties are unwilling to compromise — then your best move is to protect your reputation and start looking. Luna: And you want to leave on your terms, not when you're burned out or forced out. So part of navigating a power struggle is knowing when to disengage. Lucas: Exactly. And if today's episode helped you think through that — whether it's how to map interests, how to stay neutral without looking passive, or when to walk away — the way these episodes stay ad-free is listener support. If you found value, you can help keep this going at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a small thing that makes a big difference for us. We really appreciate those who chip in. Lucas: So back to the power struggle playbook — one more tactic I want to mention: the 'third option.' When two people are locked in a binary debate — 'do it my way or her way' — you can introduce a third option that neither has considered. That immediately changes the dynamic because now you're all exploring something new together. Luna: That's a classic negotiation move. It breaks the deadlock and positions you as creative and collaborative. Do you have an example? Lucas: Sure. In James's case, the binary was 'speed vs. quality.' He proposed a third option: run two parallel teams — one using Tom's fast-track method on a low-risk product, one using Maria's thorough process on a high-stakes client. Compare results after one quarter. Both got to prove their approach, and the company got actual data. Luna: That's brilliant. It gives everyone a win — Tom gets to test his method, Maria protects her high-stakes work, and James looks like the person who made it happen. Lucas: And importantly, it wasn't his fight. He wasn't defending his own idea about how things should run. He was just facilitating a better way to decide. That's the role you want to play. Luna: So the takeaway for anyone stuck in a power struggle: diagnose the real interests, stay neutral by focusing on outcomes, create small wins that give both sides credit, write the narrative, and when possible, offer a third path. Lucas: That's the playbook. And it works because it's not about winning the struggle — it's about making the struggle irrelevant. You become the person who moves the work forward. Luna: I love that framing. Not 'how do I survive this power struggle' but 'how do I make the power struggle irrelevant.' That's a career superpower. Lucas: I think we could do a whole episode just on that reframe. Maybe we will. But for now — thanks for listening, and if you found this useful, you know where to find us.