Latest / Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick, powered by CBT News / Ryan Kerrigan on Record Toyota and Lexus Dealership Values
Transcript
- 0:07SPEAKER_01: Welcome to Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:11Jim Fitzpatrick: What's driving buyer demand across the industry?
- 0:13Jim Fitzpatrick: Ryan Kerrigan, managing director at Kerrigan Advisors, joins us now to talk inventory, profitability, and where the buy-sell market heads next.
- 0:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Thank you, Ryan, for taking the time out of what appears to be a very busy schedule, closing deals all over America.
- 0:29Jim Fitzpatrick: In fact, right here in our home state of uh Atlanta, or I should say Georgia, but uh in our home city of Atlanta.
- 0:35Jim Fitzpatrick: So uh so let's let's start with Toyota.
- 0:38Jim Fitzpatrick: I keep hearing about uh Toyota and and it seems to be trending in every sense.
- 0:44Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 0:44Ryan Kerrigan: Well, Jim, always good to be with you.
- 0:46Ryan Kerrigan: And yes, it was uh good to be in Atlanta.
- 0:48Ryan Kerrigan: We'll uh we can touch on that in a moment, but it was down there about a week ago for the formal closing of Hennessy.
- 0:53Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, congrats again.
- 0:54Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, we uh we should talk about Toyota.
- 0:56Ryan Kerrigan: Um, Toyota continues to hit on absolutely every element.
- 1:01Ryan Kerrigan: Um, we have long talked about the quality of the business model, and that just is on full display um across the board.
- 1:08Ryan Kerrigan: And so um they grew market share again in Q3, um, and they're edging up on General Motors.
- 1:14Ryan Kerrigan: Um this trend continues, they are going to be the largest um brand in the United States.
- 1:19Ryan Kerrigan: Um, General Motors, again, highly profitable.
- 1:22Ryan Kerrigan: GM's doing a lot of things well, but from a market share perspective, down five and a half percent in Q3.
- 1:28Ryan Kerrigan: Toyota picked up uh just over a half a percent.
- 1:30Ryan Kerrigan: And so they are edging into being sort of the volume crown leader here in the United States.
- 1:36Ryan Kerrigan: Um and this is just, and I should pause actually, and and and think about the absence of the new dealers being put into their system in the last 20 or 30 years.
- 1:47Ryan Kerrigan: They've largely done this with the existing dealer body on top of that.
- 1:51Ryan Kerrigan: So think about that kind of incredible market share growth year over year, decade over decade, and really sticking and being very loyal to their dealer base.
- 1:59Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, and this is just leading to some extraordinary outcomes, real time in the buy-sell world.
- 2:04Ryan Kerrigan: I mean, the valuations right now on Toyota and by extension Lexus are just there's no precedent to this.
- 2:11Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 2:11Ryan Kerrigan: Um, it started out, for example, with the public announcement of$500 million for the two Lexus stores in Orlando, purchased by Penske.
- 2:19Ryan Kerrigan: That was preceded by a very good, uh, a very large outcome uh for the two Lexus stores in Utah.
- 2:25Ryan Kerrigan: There are now multiple uh Toyota and Lexus stores that have traded for multiple hundred million dollars of blue sky.
- 2:31Ryan Kerrigan: So this is just um a complete resetting of the table of valuation around those two franchises.
- 2:38Ryan Kerrigan: There's a perception among the buyer community that these rare, rare assets are coming to market infrequently, and when they do, and it's extraordinary.
- 2:46Ryan Kerrigan: The conversations that we have with prospective buyers of Toyota and Lexus and what they're willing to do today, even relative just to 12 months ago, uh, as I mentioned, is just has no precedent.
- 2:55Ryan Kerrigan: It's amazing.
- 2:56Ryan Kerrigan: Wow.
- 2:56Jim Fitzpatrick: And that isn't that something, yeah.
- 2:58Jim Fitzpatrick: It it really is.
- 2:59Jim Fitzpatrick: They're uh I've spoken to both the general manager of Lexus and the general manager um uh David Christ of uh Toyota.
- 3:07Jim Fitzpatrick: And it's it's so interesting because they're they're very calm, cool, collected.
- 3:11Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, there's no flexing, there's no, wow, we're just a humble automotive company trying to, you know, do what we can.
- 3:19Jim Fitzpatrick: And then when I ask him a question, what's a daily supply look like?
- 3:22Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, and he's like, oh, we're right now at about a uh one-week supply of cars.
- 3:26Jim Fitzpatrick: It's just incredible.
- 3:28Jim Fitzpatrick: So if you're a Toyota dealer, you literally have no floor plan.
- 3:31Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, you're selling everything that hits.
- 3:33Jim Fitzpatrick: The you know, the gross profits are still very, very good.
- 3:36Jim Fitzpatrick: What's amazing to me too, Ryan, is that when you look at you know, Toyota's lineup, they've got so many hybrids involved there.
- 3:42Jim Fitzpatrick: And of course, they leaned in when the other when the industry said, nope, we're going all EVs.
- 3:46Jim Fitzpatrick: And then you look at GM and you say, how many hybrids do you have available for consumers?
- 3:51Jim Fitzpatrick: And they've got one right now, which is a which is a Corvette.
- 3:54Jim Fitzpatrick: And you're like, guys, how did you how did you miss this so terribly?
- 3:59Jim Fitzpatrick: You know?
- 3:59Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 4:00Ryan Kerrigan: And uh well, and this is, I mean, Toyota's done a lot of things right for a long time, but as it stands right now, um, where they went on hybrids is playing out absolutely beautifully.
- 4:11Ryan Kerrigan: So hybrids are booming in America.
- 4:12Ryan Kerrigan: So we're looking about 16% market share in the most recent numbers.
- 4:16Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, um, that's up like 25, 26 percent, um, versus EVs.
- 4:21Ryan Kerrigan: EVs now 6% market share.
- 4:22Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, that is down about almost as much as hybrids is up, that's down.
- 4:26Ryan Kerrigan: Right.
- 4:26Ryan Kerrigan: So you've got this complete reversal in market share.
- 4:29Ryan Kerrigan: Uh Toyota dominates.
- 4:30Ryan Kerrigan: Toyota is selling uh the majority of hybrids, right on 45, 50%, I believe.
- 4:36Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 4:36Ryan Kerrigan: And they have, you know, four of the five top brands in the hybrid category.
- 4:40Ryan Kerrigan: And so where the market is hot, where the market's growing 24% this year is exactly where they are positioned.
- 4:46Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 4:46Ryan Kerrigan: And the other, many other companies, virtually all of them, made this extraordinary leap into EVs.
- 4:53Ryan Kerrigan: Um, you and I talked about it.
- 4:54Ryan Kerrigan: We were sort of commentating it as it happened, it seemed awfully rash.
- 4:57Ryan Kerrigan: It didn't seem backed up by consumer demand, by by sort of the appropriate pricing, nor having the infrastructure.
- 5:04Ryan Kerrigan: And so the companies that triple down on those multiple crazy multi, multi-billion dollar um crash investments in EVs are really writing off a lot of that, literally writing off a lot of that.
- 5:18Ryan Kerrigan: And then you have Toyota, who took some heat there for a short while for not embracing EVs as aggressively as the others.
- 5:26Ryan Kerrigan: And here they are gobbling up market share.
- 5:28Ryan Kerrigan: Their business could not be stronger today.
- 5:30Jim Fitzpatrick: And then you worry about, you know, if you're a Chevy dealer and you lose and somebody wants to get a hybrid, and they've got okay, they go to Toyota.
- 5:38Jim Fitzpatrick: Well, then what are the chances of that consumer after tasting that Toyota, okay, realizing what ownership looks like because it's just a great car all around, um, are they ever going to come back to G.
- 5:49Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 5:50Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, this isn't this isn't a temporary move.
- 5:52Jim Fitzpatrick: This could be a move for life with that consumer.
- 5:54Jim Fitzpatrick: And in many cases, so goes the family, right?
- 5:57Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 5:57Ryan Kerrigan: And well, last time I checked, um, you know, uh consumer loyalty to Toyota is pretty darn strong.
- 6:03Ryan Kerrigan: And others as well, but we're talking about Toyota at the moment.
- 6:06Ryan Kerrigan: So yeah, I mean, though that the loss of that customer because you don't have something in the segment, um, you're out, you're outpriced, you don't have the right powertrain.
- 6:15Ryan Kerrigan: And you're exactly right, you lose the car sale, but in the same way that most of us grew up in families where there was you know significant brand loyalty, yeah.
- 6:22Ryan Kerrigan: We would kind of refer to our family or our dads or our mom as being this kind of buyer.
- 6:26Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, I mean, that's still true.
- 6:27Ryan Kerrigan: I mean, people get comfortable uh with the particularly OEM, the the product works well, that's right, and they get very sticky.
- 6:33Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, especially if the parents have an influence in the in the child's first car, you know, and they love Toyota, they're gonna obviously steer them towards a you know an inexpensive Toyota to start out with and and go from there.
- 6:44Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh Yeah, it's it's it's um it's unfortunate that that GM held off on on hybrids, but it looks like now they're trying to get back into to the to the hybrid market, you know, with some of the um with some of the models that they've announced.
- 6:57Jim Fitzpatrick: But uh so more broadly, uh tell tell us about what's going on in the industry.
- 7:02Jim Fitzpatrick: Inventories have have have uh kind of ticked up and some sources citing three million units.
- 7:08Jim Fitzpatrick: What does that tell us?
- 7:09Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, you know, um, so we have been talking about or we've been experiencing high interest rates for quite some time.
- 7:14Ryan Kerrigan: They've ticked up yet again.
- 7:16Ryan Kerrigan: It didn't seem to have much of a drag on the auto business, but now we're starting to see inventories finally starting to really consistently start to grow.
- 7:22Ryan Kerrigan: October, the reports are about three million.
- 7:25Ryan Kerrigan: There's a real weighting of that inventory towards more expensive product, heavier product, less fuel efficient product.
- 7:31Ryan Kerrigan: Um, so that weighs on dealers' balance sheets and floor lines uh more so.
- 7:35Ryan Kerrigan: So yeah, it's um there we're starting to see the impact of this.
- 7:40Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, for sure.
- 7:41Jim Fitzpatrick: How does that how does it vary across brands?
- 7:44Ryan Kerrigan: No surprise.
- 7:45Ryan Kerrigan: Um, you know, it there's a and actually the variance is broader than historically, but there's there's always a spread.
- 7:51Ryan Kerrigan: But today that spread is as wide as ever.
- 7:53Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 7:54Ryan Kerrigan: Um this will be the Toyota salothon today as we as we keep kind of brushing up against this.
- 7:58Ryan Kerrigan: But of course, Toyota and Lexus have an incredibly low um day supply, about 40 for Toyota.
- 8:05Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 8:05Ryan Kerrigan: Um, Honda and Subaru are 50, 60, the domestics higher.
- 8:09Ryan Kerrigan: Stillantis still really struggling, and particularly what we're told is um on the more expensive product.
- 8:15Ryan Kerrigan: And that's not shocking.
- 8:17Ryan Kerrigan: If you look at interest rates and you look at what's going on at the pump, um, it's not shocking that really expensive heavy uh pickups, for example, in the Dodge and Ram family are they are slowing down.
- 8:27Ryan Kerrigan: So you're looking at uh day supply of 130, 140, 150 is some of those products with Dodge, uh uh Dodge, Ram, and Jeep.
- 8:35Ryan Kerrigan: Um, so it's a real spread.
- 8:37Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, there's no question.
- 8:38Jim Fitzpatrick: Uh less expensive cars are turning faster with uh for obvious reason.
- 8:43Jim Fitzpatrick: Affordability still is uh applying major pressure to to retail automotive.
- 8:48Jim Fitzpatrick: People just can't afford a$60,000,$70,000 SUV.
- 8:51Jim Fitzpatrick: That's exactly right.
- 8:53Ryan Kerrigan: There's less and less down in that$30,000 um price point on new cars, but you've got the Civic, you've got the Corolla, um, you've got the Camry down to those lower levels.
- 9:02Ryan Kerrigan: The turn on those cars are at industry highs.
- 9:05Ryan Kerrigan: And so, yeah, no supply there.
- 9:07Ryan Kerrigan: Um, and and that kind of gets into another long-standing industry issue, and that is affordability.
- 9:12Ryan Kerrigan: The the price of new cars has continued to mount.
- 9:15Ryan Kerrigan: Um, you layer on interest rates, so payment, payment um sort of issues.
- 9:19Ryan Kerrigan: Um, and and yeah, there's just there's there's a challenge there for those that have committed to staying in that small car market, that affordable car market, those cars are moving fast.
- 9:28Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, boy, that that's for sure.
- 9:30Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, Lexus is sending an additional 35,000 units vehicles to the U.S.
- 9:35Jim Fitzpatrick: what what's behind that decision?
- 9:37Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, some some great news.
- 9:38Ryan Kerrigan: And so Lexis, obviously wildly disciplined, uh, always in terms of allocations.
- 9:43Ryan Kerrigan: The U.S.
- 9:43Ryan Kerrigan: dealers have been um asking for, begging for more product for a long, long time.
- 9:48Ryan Kerrigan: Um, the combination, I think, softness in China, there's no question mark, and this is not just sort of a quarter-to-quarter, year-to-year thing.
- 9:55Ryan Kerrigan: I mean, there's secular uh softness in China for virtually all the Western brands, and the Chinese market's down by 25%.
- 10:01Ryan Kerrigan: So I think that's made um the Lexus folks comfortable with making, and again, I'm I I don't know this for certain, but but usually when they make a decision like this to allocate more cars, it's not a one-time thing.
- 10:12Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 10:13Ryan Kerrigan: So what I read into it is they're reading incredible strength in the US market, which certainly all the data backs up, long-term weakness in the Chinese market.
- 10:21Ryan Kerrigan: And so it started with a reallocation globally of 35,000 units to the US that will allow Lexus to grow nicely this year.
- 10:29Ryan Kerrigan: And I would imagine that that would be uh something that they would would maintain and maybe even grow over time.
- 10:33Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, that's that that's good news for the Lexus dealers, that's for sure.
- 10:36Jim Fitzpatrick: Yep, indeed.
- 10:37Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, and they've come out with some just incredible new product that uh is just yeah, there's a obviously a nice the the the the full size that uh dealers have been clamoring for for a long time, that full um three-seat version, which um I don't know if I've seen one on the road, but I've certainly seen a fair bit of advertising for them um in watching football as of late.
- 10:55Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 10:55Ryan Kerrigan: So they're they're putting some real energy behind that product.
- 10:58Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, then no, no question.
- 11:00Jim Fitzpatrick: So now the big the big deal, the the Hennessy transaction here in Atlanta formerly uh closed in recent days, is is there any more activity in the Southeast?
- 11:09Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, I I I I'm sure that you've either gotten some phone calls or what have you to say, wow, Ryan, show show me the way here.
- 11:18Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, so it's going to be in Atlanta and and to get that deal finalized just in recent days.
- 11:22Ryan Kerrigan: Um I know that group one is very, very pleased with the acquisition across the board.
- 11:27Ryan Kerrigan: Um they uh nothing but positive news from them in terms of the quality of the assets, the culture, the people, et cetera.
- 11:33Ryan Kerrigan: So that's just really been um a nice thing to watch.
- 11:36Ryan Kerrigan: Um yeah, we have been, I mean, the Southeast um and the smile states broadly continue to be where the energy is.
- 11:42Ryan Kerrigan: Our most recent announcements were Atlanta, as you just mentioned, uh North Carolina, um, and um and one other that's gonna be oh Memphis, Tennessee.
- 11:52Ryan Kerrigan: We represent the Gossets.
- 11:53Jim Fitzpatrick: It's hard when you've got so many closings that you can't you can't even really, you know, yeah.
- 11:57Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, it's been so so our most recent activity has has been there for sure.
- 12:02Ryan Kerrigan: Um, and more to come.
- 12:03Ryan Kerrigan: And we've got uh a handful of things in Florida, for example.
- 12:06Ryan Kerrigan: So yeah, the Southwee Southeast continues to be very strong.
- 12:09Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 12:09Ryan Kerrigan: And you know, the multiples represented, um, and and I I'll say this carefully here because um the the smaller the deal and the more underperforming the deal, the more upside is, for example.
- 12:20Ryan Kerrigan: So um at some size, there is just a limit to the multiples that can be paid for certain deals.
- 12:27Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 12:28Ryan Kerrigan: Um that said, in the Southeast, if you, for example, have let's say, just let's say a modest sized Toyota Honda store, um, not overperforming in a significant way, the the multiples that can be achieved on that are just so far above what is sort of the national average, as an example.
- 12:47Ryan Kerrigan: So just lots and lots of energy in the smile states, but but in particular in the southeast.
- 12:52Ryan Kerrigan: That's where the growth is, that's where the profits are, and that's where we've been active.
- 12:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Are you gonna be moving to the southeast?
- 12:58Ryan Kerrigan: No, I don't think we're gonna move to the southeast.
- 13:01Ryan Kerrigan: Uh we're still very active.
- 13:02Ryan Kerrigan: We've got lots going on in the Pacific Northwest, the uh California, Midwest.
- 13:07Ryan Kerrigan: Um, so no immediate plans.
- 13:09Ryan Kerrigan: We we remain a national firm, um, but we do have some colleagues in the Mid-Atlantic and in South Florida.
- 13:14Ryan Kerrigan: So we are well represented there, but uh, I I'm not uh not looking, I'm not on Zillow at this point.
- 13:22Jim Fitzpatrick: So the publics released earnings last week.
- 13:24Jim Fitzpatrick: What what are the highlights in that?
- 13:26Jim Fitzpatrick: What what do you take from that?
- 13:28Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, so um the the publics were uh across the board pretty flat on revenue.
- 13:32Ryan Kerrigan: Penske was up nine percent on revenue, but across the board they were pretty flat.
- 13:36Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 13:37Ryan Kerrigan: Um and and earnings were down on average about eight percent.
- 13:40Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 13:41Ryan Kerrigan: So, you know, not not a not a great quarter, but also not a surprise.
- 13:44Ryan Kerrigan: And light that we've talked about interest rates, we've talked about gas prices, we've talked about a vehicle affordability.
- 13:49Ryan Kerrigan: I mean, there's some very obvious challenges that we're facing.
- 13:52Ryan Kerrigan: Um, and so it's not surprising that they're down, down eight percent.
- 13:55Ryan Kerrigan: So it varies across the board, but a solid quarter.
- 13:59Ryan Kerrigan: We remain in a world of very elevated profitability relative to the automotive business that we knew from years ago.
- 14:04Ryan Kerrigan: So um things remain very good, but on a year-over-year basis, um we are down about eight percent across the board.
- 14:10Jim Fitzpatrick: Okay.
- 14:10Jim Fitzpatrick: Uh and and are you referring to the publics or pretty much the okay, what what are you hearing from the private cap dealers that you work with?
- 14:18Jim Fitzpatrick: How how did they how'd they finish?
- 14:21Ryan Kerrigan: They are um so there again, uh flight to quality, um, the the folks that have got the right franchise and the right markets, profitability in some cases um at all-time highs, but certainly in that range.
- 14:34Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 14:34Ryan Kerrigan: We've been in this post-COVID range now for five years.
- 14:37Ryan Kerrigan: You know, some peaked in 22-23.
- 14:39Ryan Kerrigan: Um, some, however, continued.
- 14:41Ryan Kerrigan: Uh Toyota and Lexis, to go back to that uh topic, uh, are trending in the positive direction here in 2020, 26.
- 14:48Ryan Kerrigan: So it depends.
- 14:49Ryan Kerrigan: Um the there's no question that there are franchises, there are locations where there's been a lot of retreat in margins.
- 14:56Ryan Kerrigan: But uh in the in the in the best franchises, the best markets, there are folks who continue to put uh top profitability uh numbers up.
- 15:04Jim Fitzpatrick: Okay, okay.
- 15:05Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh speaking of the publics, uh once again, where do where does Penske's uh take private uh stand today?
- 15:13Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, um it is going forward.
- 15:15Ryan Kerrigan: So they announced it in the summer months.
- 15:17Ryan Kerrigan: Um the stock ran up.
- 15:18Ryan Kerrigan: I think there's a little bit of question, at least those in the public uh kind of community, um, talking about it, but that um formally as of mid-October, that that is a go forward.
- 15:28Ryan Kerrigan: I think 212 was the strike price for the deal.
- 15:32Ryan Kerrigan: Okay.
- 15:32Ryan Kerrigan: And uh they will go private.
- 15:34Ryan Kerrigan: Uh Penske will own um, you know, about 70% of the deal.
- 15:37Ryan Kerrigan: Matsui will own the balance.
- 15:39Ryan Kerrigan: And that very substantial organization, very important player throughout transportation infrastructure, will be private here in the coming months.
- 15:46Jim Fitzpatrick: Why?
- 15:47Jim Fitzpatrick: And from your perspective, why did why did why does a company like that want to go private?
- 15:51Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, kind of unheard of.
- 15:52Ryan Kerrigan: If you think about the size of the company and then and then the balance sheet intensity of what they do, a little atypical, but it just speaks broadly to what's going on in the financial markets.
- 16:02Ryan Kerrigan: And that is to say the ability to raise capital.
- 16:05Ryan Kerrigan: There was always an assumption that at some point you just had to be in the public markets to raise a certain quantum of capital.
- 16:12Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 16:12Ryan Kerrigan: And now, for example, we look at the tech world, a very different industry than ours, and you see venture capital uh rounds being raised in the billions of dollars.
- 16:20Ryan Kerrigan: So they're able to literally just kind of use their private networks to generate these massive outcomes.
- 16:25Ryan Kerrigan: And so that is now spilling over broadly into industrial companies and retail companies and the places in which we play.
- 16:33Ryan Kerrigan: And so the the need to be public and to bear the the all the costs of being public and the quarter-to-quarter uh scrutiny that comes with that are just no longer required, um, even running a company of the size of Penske, and even if they did seek to continue to attract new capital to the balance sheet.
- 16:49Jim Fitzpatrick: Sure, sure.
- 16:50Jim Fitzpatrick: So looking ahead, what are you most optimistic about?
- 16:54Ryan Kerrigan: You know, the one thing we didn't talk about here, so AI is is uh being talked about sort of in all aspects of business.
- 17:01Ryan Kerrigan: That's fair.
- 17:02Ryan Kerrigan: But it has very real implications for auto-retailers, for example.
- 17:05Ryan Kerrigan: I mean, you know, we are service-intensive businesses, um, always looking for ways to um bring in better quality, better quality controls, and to reduce human expense when it's not necessary.
- 17:16Ryan Kerrigan: Um, and so there's no question that dealers are being very creative, and we think that that's gonna be a very, very helpful on margins at a very good time in light of some of the macroeconomic issues that we've discussed in our time together.
- 17:29Ryan Kerrigan: Um, this is this is coming at a perfect time, and there's no question that dealers are gonna be able to take expense out.
- 17:35Ryan Kerrigan: And there's probably a bit of a consolidation player there in the sense that the that the the the larger players, I don't think you need to be the largest in the country, but those that have 10, 20, 30 stores are probably more adept at playing with these technologies and adopting them than I would say your typical deal that has one, two, three, four stores.
- 17:52Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah, good.
- 17:53Ryan Kerrigan: So I think it's good for profits, and it's also on the margin, probably better for the bigger guys who will probably allocate more time and more expense to figuring it out.
- 18:01Ryan Kerrigan: That's right.
- 18:02Jim Fitzpatrick: It's amazing.
- 18:03Jim Fitzpatrick: I, from my position here at CBT News, talking to all of these vendors and companies out there and uh and talking to dealers as well, AI now has affected every single aspect and phase of retail automotive, whether from starting with the search of the car itself or the search of the fixed operations, you know, the service department at a dealership right through to the phone call, to the to the person that takes it, to the follow-up, to the I mean, every single touch point in a dealership, there is an AI element that has been created for that.
- 18:36Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh it's exciting to see.
- 18:38Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, I I I think that there's some dealers out there that are still trying to get their hands around this whole thing because it's moving so rapidly fast.
- 18:45Jim Fitzpatrick: It's just incredible.
- 18:47Jim Fitzpatrick: But there you say I I don't care what, I don't care the department, I don't care about the person or the the the position the person holds.
- 18:54Jim Fitzpatrick: There is an AI either solution or in some cases a replacement for that individual at that dealership.
- 19:01Jim Fitzpatrick: But what it can do uh in the in the way of reaching out to consumers or to to to uh customers of dealerships for you know things like uh recalls, you know, that can do it on a mass scale within you know seconds and and uh taking inbound service calls and scheduling appointments and whether it be for the body shop or parts department or fixed, whatever it might be.
- 19:24Jim Fitzpatrick: It's just really incredible.
- 19:25Jim Fitzpatrick: And now uh even technicians are using it for uh problem solving and solutions, and it it really is going to revolutionize the this whole you know retail automotive over the course of the next few years.
- 19:37Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, it's exciting to be to be a witness and have a front row seat at all of this, you know.
- 19:42Ryan Kerrigan: Yep.
- 19:43Ryan Kerrigan: I completely agree.
- 19:44Ryan Kerrigan: And if you think about it, so as an industry, we've always had a big issue with turnover.
- 19:48Ryan Kerrigan: I mean, that's been sort of widely documented, particularly on the variable side of the house.
- 19:52Ryan Kerrigan: Typically the fixed operations tend to be stickier.
- 19:54Ryan Kerrigan: You take those out, the the problem gets even worse.
- 19:57Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 19:57Ryan Kerrigan: So clearly, there's something about the nature of the people coming into the jobs, how the jobs are being done, how they're being compensated, that don't create loyalty.
- 20:05Ryan Kerrigan: So if you can start bringing AI in to not so much just eliminate people across the board, yeah, but to maybe get rid of the tasks that are causing people to churn and then create better jobs for those that really want to be in the industry for the long run.
- 20:19Ryan Kerrigan: Yeah.
- 20:19Ryan Kerrigan: So I think it can be a win-win here.
- 20:20Jim Fitzpatrick: I I agree.
- 20:21Jim Fitzpatrick: I agree.
- 20:22Jim Fitzpatrick: I just interviewed uh Brian Benstock and uh he he we were talking about the turnover, and he said it was a real eye-opener for me.
- 20:29Jim Fitzpatrick: He said, I he said the the exercise that I went through was to say how many employees do I currently have in my employment, you know, for for the dealerships that I'm over.
- 20:38Jim Fitzpatrick: He said, and then I counted up all of the W-2s that we send out uh at the end of the year, you know, to for everybody that egoes and I went, oh my gosh.
- 20:47Jim Fitzpatrick: So that gap is the is the turnover, you know?
- 20:50Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 20:51Ryan Kerrigan: And uh huge, huge eye opener because you know the industry's been trying, you know, been working on that forever, trying to create um hours that allow for better family life and work-life balance.
- 21:02Ryan Kerrigan: I mean, there's been lots of attempts to do it, but something about um the jobs and how they're defined today, particularly in the front end of the house, yeah, are still conducive to high turnover.
- 21:12Ryan Kerrigan: And again, I think technology could be something that makes the jobs that are there um something that are more attractive.
- 21:19Jim Fitzpatrick: I agree.
- 21:20Jim Fitzpatrick: I agree.
- 21:20Jim Fitzpatrick: So will we see uh still a pretty brisk buy-sell market going into 2027?
- 21:25Ryan Kerrigan: I think so.
- 21:26Ryan Kerrigan: There's no question that the the general trend is towards um lots of buy-sell activity and acceleration of consolidation.
- 21:34Ryan Kerrigan: That's the general trend.
- 21:35Ryan Kerrigan: Right.
- 21:36Ryan Kerrigan: Um we are gonna now be running into higher interest rates um and some of those things.
- 21:40Ryan Kerrigan: And so at some point, maybe there'll be a modest slowing.
- 21:43Ryan Kerrigan: I don't think it's gonna be anything dramatic.
- 21:45Ryan Kerrigan: Um, but certainly the it's plausible that we get into a market that's a little choosier going forward.
- 21:52Ryan Kerrigan: But the the the direction of the industry, I think, is pretty well baked for the foreseeable future.
- 21:57Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, for sure.
- 21:58Ryan Kerrigan: For sure.
- 21:58Jim Fitzpatrick: Brian Kerrigan, managing director of Kerrigan Advisors.
- 22:02Jim Fitzpatrick: Thank you so much for joining me once again on the show.
- 22:04Jim Fitzpatrick: Very much appreciate it.
- 22:05Jim Fitzpatrick: Say hello to your wife, Erin Forrest, and uh till next time, stay well.
- 22:10SPEAKER_01: Great.
- 22:11SPEAKER_01: Thanks so much.
- 22:13SPEAKER_01: Thanks for watching Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.