Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Are Meta, Microsoft, and Nvidia Really Terrible Investments From Now ON
Transcript
- 0:00What if some of the biggest, most dominant companies out
- 0:06there, you know, the S&P 500 leaders like Apple, Microsoft,
- 0:09NVIDIA, what if they're actually considered like terrible
- 0:14investments when you look at them through a really
- 0:15conservative old school value lens?
- 0:18Today we're doing a deep dive into an analysis that takes some
- 0:21seriously rigorous metrics, these old school value metrics,
- 0:25and applies them to these giants.
- 0:27And what it shows is this fascinating, almost shocking
- 0:31disconnect between their current market values and what a
- 0:34traditional value investor would even think about touching.
- 0:37Welcome, everyone. Yeah, this deep dive is really
- 0:39all about clashing perspectives, different paradigms.
- 0:42We're going to explore some core value investing ideas,
- 0:44specifically the 10 cap rate, margin of safety and payback
- 0:47time. And then we'll see how the
- 0:49world's biggest companies stack up against these, well,
- 0:51exceptionally tough criteria. And what's really interesting
- 0:54isn't just the final numbers, though they are stark, but what
- 0:57it tells us about how different investors actually see value
- 1:00today. Exactly.
- 1:02Our mission here is to give you a really clear understanding of
- 1:05these valuation tools, these powerful tools, and then show
- 1:07you this stark, data-driven picture of how these companies
- 1:11look through that very old school lens.
- 1:12Yeah, prepare for maybe a few aha.
- 1:14Moments, definitely. The results might just surprise
- 1:17you. Maybe challenge how you think
- 1:18about some big names in your own portfolio.
- 1:21OK, so let's unpack this value investors toolkit.
- 1:23We should start with this thing called the 10 cap rule.
- 1:26Simple idea. Sounds simple, but it's actually
- 1:30incredibly powerful. Right.
- 1:32And its roots are actually in real estate, aren't they?
- 1:34They are, yeah. Imagine you're buying, I don't
- 1:37know, a farm, let's say it cost $500,000, OK.
- 1:40And it generates $50,000 a year in net operating income, NOI.
- 1:45That's your income after operating expenses but before
- 1:49debt payments and taxes. Got it.
- 1:50Your cap rate is simply that $50,000 divided by the $500,000
- 1:54purchase price. So 10%.
- 1:56It's your unlevered pre tax return.
- 1:59If you paid all cash, it tells you your immediate cash yield on
- 2:02that investment. And that's the key insight,
- 2:05isn't it? It forces you to view a stock, a
- 2:08business, like you'd view that farm.
- 2:09What's the immediate cash on cash return?
- 2:11Forget market hype for a second, right?
- 2:13It's stripping away sentiment and asking what is this thing
- 2:18actually earning for me right now, today?
- 2:21Precisely. So value investors, you know,
- 2:24figures like Warren Buffett, they adapted this very tangible
- 2:27idea for stocks. Instead of net operating income,
- 2:30they use something called owner earnings, and they divide that
- 2:33by the company's total market value.
- 2:36It's market capitalization. That's just the share price
- 2:38times all the shares out there. And the rule of thumb generally
- 2:42is that a company looks interesting, maybe undervalued,
- 2:45if this calculation gives you a cap rate of 10% or more. 10%,
- 2:49OK. But let's dig into owner
- 2:50earnings. Can you break down why that
- 2:53specific term, that specific calculation, is so important for
- 2:56getting this sort of conservative view?
- 2:58Yeah, absolutely. So owner earnings in its, let's
- 3:01say, purest conceptual form is operating cash flow.
- 3:04That's the cash the business generates just from its normal
- 3:07day-to-day operations. Yeah, minus maintenance capital
- 3:09expenditures. And that distinction is really
- 3:12critical. Unions, CapEx.
- 3:13Maintenance CapEx is the money a company absolutely has to spend
- 3:16just to keep the lights on. You know, to replace worn out
- 3:19equipment, repair things, maintain the current level of
- 3:22operations. Right.
- 3:23Just stay in business at the same level.
- 3:25Exactly. It doesn't include money spent
- 3:27on growth like building a whole new factory or launching into a
- 3:31new country. Got it.
- 3:32So by focusing only on that maintenance CapEx, you're trying
- 3:36to isolate the true earning power of the assets the company
- 3:40already has. It gives you a cleaner picture
- 3:43of operational profitability before you factor in any big
- 3:46expansion plans or how the company finances itself.
- 3:49That makes a lot of sense. It's like asking what cash does
- 3:52this thing throw off just by existing as it is right now.
- 3:55Precisely. But I noticed something
- 3:57interesting in the report we're looking at today, they actually
- 3:59went even further with the conservatism.
- 4:02They didn't use maintenance CapEx.
- 4:04They calculated owner earnings as operating cash flow minus
- 4:09total capital expenditures. Yes, that's a key point for this
- 4:14specific analysis. Yeah, it seems like a big
- 4:16difference. What is using total CapEx do?
- 4:19What does that imply? Well, it's a fantastic point and
- 4:22it's really central to how this whole analysis plays out.
- 4:25Using total CapEx means you're essentially penalizing the
- 4:28company for all its capital spending, including the money
- 4:31it's investing for future growth.
- 4:33It's almost like the analyst is saying, look, I only care about
- 4:36the cash leftover after absolutely everything is spent,
- 4:40even if that spending is building the next big thing that
- 4:43could double profits down the road.
- 4:44Wow. It deliberately makes the hurdle
- 4:47much, much higher. It's designed to find only those
- 4:49businesses that are gushing cash even while they're potentially
- 4:52investing heavily. It's an extra layer of
- 4:55skepticism baked right in. OK.
- 4:56So that's setting an incredibly high bar from the get go, which
- 5:01brings us neatly to the next piece, the margin of safety.
- 5:04The Cornerstone. Yeah, the absolute bedrock of
- 5:06preserving capital. Famously championed by Benjamin
- 5:10Graham and David Dodd. The idea is simple but profound.
- 5:15Only buy something when its market price is significantly
- 5:17below what you calculate it's real intrinsic value to be.
- 5:21Right, intrinsic value being what it's really worth, not just
- 5:24the ticker. Price.
- 5:25Exactly. And Buffett had that great
- 5:26analogy right about building a bridge.
- 5:29You insist it can hold 30,000 lbs but you only plan to drive
- 5:33£10,000 trucks across it. Love that analogy, it's perfect.
- 5:36But extra capacity, that's your margin of safety and it does
- 5:40three key things. Protects you if your valuation
- 5:43is a bit off or if something bad and unexpected happens.
- 5:46Mitigates. Risk preserves your capital,
- 5:48obviously, and it actually enhances your potential return
- 5:52if things go right. Now most value folks might look
- 5:55for say the 20% or 30% margin. Pretty standard range.
- 5:59But this report, it went to the extreme end.
- 6:02It demanded a 50% margin of safety. 50%, yeah.
- 6:05For companies like Apple or Microsoft, what does demanding
- 6:09that kind of discount on these giants even signify?
- 6:12Yeah. Is it just extreme caution or
- 6:14does it imply something deeper about market perception?
- 6:17It suggests, I think, a really profound skepticism, applying a
- 6:2050% OS to the world's biggest, seemingly most stable companies.
- 6:25It signals an investor who wants absolute protection above
- 6:28literally everything else. It implies A belief that either
- 6:31the market prices are frankly, wildly optimistic, detached from
- 6:36reality, right, or that these giants, despite appearances,
- 6:40carry some kind of hidden systemic risk that justifies
- 6:44needing that massive cushion. It's not just guarding against a
- 6:47calculation error. It's insulating yourself from
- 6:50potential catastrophe. It's like saying I'll only buy
- 6:54if it's half price, even after I've already been conservative
- 6:57and figuring out the price. Pretty much, it's definitely
- 6:59leaning towards the punitive side of value investing it.
- 7:02Really is OK Our final metric for today is payback time.
- 7:06Simple, Sounds intuitive. How long till I get my money
- 7:09back? Straightforward question.
- 7:10Yeah, it just measures how long it takes for the cumulative cash
- 7:13flows from an investment to equal what you initially paid.
- 7:16You divide the initial cost by the annual cash flow.
- 7:19Shorter payback, less perceived risk, quicker return of your
- 7:22capital. Makes sense on the surface.
- 7:23And it's important to see the direct link to cap rate here.
- 7:26They're basically reciprocals. So the eight-year payback time
- 7:30that this report demands that implicitly requires a 12.5% cap
- 7:35rate. Remember the standard was 10%.
- 7:38This is even higher. So even more demanding than the
- 7:4010 cap rule. Exactly.
- 7:43But payback time has some serious flaws, doesn't it?
- 7:45Particularly for the kinds of companies we're looking at.
- 7:48Oh absolutely 2 huge ones. First, it completely ignores the
- 7:52time value of money. A dollar earned in Year 8 is
- 7:55treated the same as a dollar earned today.
- 7:57Which we know isn't right. Definitely not.
- 7:59And 2nd, and this is critical for growth companies, it totally
- 8:02ignores any cash flows after the payback period once you get your
- 8:06initial investment back. This metric says job done,
- 8:09effectively valuing all future profits at 0.
- 8:12Wow, 0 value after year eight in this case, yeah.
- 8:15And think about companies like the S&P 500 liters.
- 8:18Their value isn't just in the next few years, it's in the
- 8:21potential for decades of compounding growth.
- 8:23Right, the long tail. Exactly.
- 8:25Payback time prioritizes getting your money back return of
- 8:28capital over maximizing your long term return on capital.
- 8:31For a deep value investor, maybe that quick return feels safe.
- 8:35But for anyone focused on long term compounding, this metric
- 8:39just completely misses the point.
- 8:41It's a blunt instrument. OK.
- 8:43So that's our toolkit. Owner Ernie's calculated very
- 8:45conservatively, a massive 50% margin of safety and a demanding
- 8:498 year payback or 12.5% cap rate.
- 8:52Very tough set of hurdles. Definitely.
- 8:55Now let's see what happened when this analysis applied that
- 8:57toolkit to the 10 largest S&P 500 companies over the last
- 9:00decade, roughly fiscal 2015 to 2024.
- 9:04They use public annual reports and remember calculated owner
- 9:07earnings as operating cash flow minus total CapEx.
- 9:10Right. That uniform, very conservative
- 9:12calculation. It gives us a consistent, if
- 9:14tough, basis for comparing them all.
- 9:16Let's highlight a few that really tell the story.
- 9:18Take NVIDIA. Huge story stock, obviously.
- 9:20Passive, especially recently. From 2015 to 2020, solid growth.
- 9:24Then 2021 to 2024 with the AI boom, owner earnings just
- 9:28exploded upwards. Phenomenal operational growth.
- 9:31But, and here's the kicker, it's market cap grew even faster.
- 9:35The stock price went vertical. Right.
- 9:37The market got way ahead of even those exploding earnings.
- 9:39So it's cap rate, which was OK, maybe 2.5% to 6.7% earlier, got
- 9:45crushed down to just 1% to 2.1%. Tidy yield.
- 9:48Which means the payback time stretched from maybe 15 years,
- 9:51which is already longish, to a staggering 46 to 100 years.
- 9:56A century. Wow.
- 9:58Yeah. It just highlights how much
- 10:00future growth is being priced in now.
- 10:02Investors are paying a massive premium today based on the hope
- 10:05of enormous earnings way, way down the line.
- 10:08It's pure growth narrative pricing.
- 10:10NVIDIA is the perfect example of that clash.
- 10:12The market sees decades of AI dominance.
- 10:15This framework sees a 1% immediate cash yield and says no
- 10:18thanks. Exactly.
- 10:19And then look at Apple, you know, just a monster cash
- 10:22machine. Absolutely prodigious amounts of
- 10:24cash. And interestingly back in 2015
- 10:26for a short period actually did look like a classic value play.
- 10:29By some metrics. It's cap rate was almost 12% pay
- 10:32back around 8:00 years. It actually qualified briefly.
- 10:35It did, but then as its ecosystem, its services business
- 10:39really took hold and showed incredible resilience.
- 10:42The market dramatically re rated the stock.
- 10:45The valuation multiple expanded hugely.
- 10:47Right, it shifted. It shifted from being maybe
- 10:51value to being quality to premium price.
- 10:54Now it's cap rates are down in the three 5% range pay back over
- 10:5730 years. So Apple shows how a company's
- 10:59success can actually price it out of the deep value category.
- 11:03The market recognizes the quality and stability and says
- 11:05we'll pay up for that certainty even if the immediate yield is
- 11:08lower. Great point.
- 11:10And one more maybe, is a contrast Berkshire Hathaway,
- 11:13Warren Buffett's company. The quintessential value
- 11:15oriented conglomerate, Yeah. And it really stands out for its
- 11:18stability, consistent cash generation owner earnings nearly
- 11:21doubled over the decade. But what's fascinating is this
- 11:23valuation stayed relatively rational, consistent compared to
- 11:28the other. Grounded.
- 11:29Yeah, cap rate stayed in a pretty narrow band, like 3.5% to
- 11:335.2% payback length, and sure, for maybe 20 to 28 years, but
- 11:37gradually it reflects that steady appreciation, its status
- 11:40as a safe haven. But even Berkshire.
- 11:42Right. Even Berkshire, the model of
- 11:44value creation, still end up looking expensive through this
- 11:48ultra conservative lens we're using today.
- 11:50It really underscores just how demanding these specific
- 11:54criteria are. If even Berkshire doesn't clear
- 11:57the bar by a huge margin, it tells you something about the
- 11:59filter itself. Definitely.
- 12:01And the stories for the others, Microsoft, Amazon, Meta,
- 12:04Broadcom, Tesla, they mostly echo these themes.
- 12:09You see compressed cap rates because market excitement
- 12:12outpaced even strong earnings growth, right?
- 12:14You see high volatility in owner earnings, especially for
- 12:17companies investing heavily like Amazon or Tesla, making the
- 12:20metric bounce around. Or even turn negative.
- 12:22Exactly. Or you run into issues where
- 12:24this cash flow framework just isn't the best fit, like with a
- 12:27big bank like JP Morgan Chase. Yeah, their operating cash flow
- 12:30is notoriously volatile and doesn't mean the same thing.
- 12:33Yeah. Different business model
- 12:34entirely I'll suited for this specific tool.
- 12:38So for most of them, the market was clearly looking past the
- 12:40immediate conservatively calculated cash flow.
- 12:43It was valuing revenue growth, future potential like AWS for
- 12:47Amazon, AI for Microsoft and Broadcom, EV dominance for
- 12:51Tesla, network effects for Meta, things this framework doesn't
- 12:56really capture. Intangibles and long term
- 12:57narratives. Precisely.
- 12:59OK, So we've got the tools. We've seen how the companies
- 13:01performed historically against them.
- 13:03Now for the really interesting part, calculating an actual buy
- 13:07price using this ultra conservative framework, the.
- 13:10Moment of truth based on these rules.
- 13:12Right. First step, establishing A
- 13:14conservative growth rate. Yeah, the report did something
- 13:17pretty brutal here. It took the single lowest annual
- 13:19growth weight in owner earnings each company experienced over
- 13:22the entire past decade. The worst year's growth?
- 13:25Ouch. Yeah.
- 13:26So if a company had one bad year where owner earnings dipped,
- 13:29that negative growth rate or very low growth rate was assumed
- 13:33to be the permanent future growth rate for valuation
- 13:35purposes. Wow, OK, that's not just
- 13:38conservative, that's almost assuming the worst historical
- 13:40blip becomes the new normal forever stress testing it
- 13:42against a worst case scenario becoming permanent.
- 13:44Exactly. Then they plug this ultra
- 13:47conservative growth rate into a standard perpetual growth model
- 13:51to get an intrinsic value. The formula is basically
- 13:54intrinsic value if use owner earnings next year, discount
- 13:58rate, growth rate. Standard model, but with
- 14:01punishing inputs. Right.
- 14:02They use a 10% discount rate. That's the minimum return the
- 14:06investor demands. And remember, G, is that
- 14:09potentially negative or tiny growth rate, OK.
- 14:11So you get a very low intrinsic value estimate to start with.
- 14:14You do, but then they applied the final two constraints,
- 14:18layering them on top. First, that massive 50% margin
- 14:22of safety. So they took that already
- 14:23conservatively calculated intrinsic value and just cut it
- 14:26in half. Cut it in half.
- 14:27OK. And second, they calculated the
- 14:29price needed to achieve that eight-year payback, which we
- 14:31know equals a 12.5% cap rate demand.
- 14:34Got it. So 2 potential buy prices
- 14:36calculated. Exactly.
- 14:37And the lower of those two became the final target buy
- 14:40price. And of course, if owner earnings
- 14:42were negative or if that worst case growth rate G was actually
- 14:45higher than the 10% discount rate, which happens sometimes
- 14:48with volatile earnings, the model just broke.
- 14:51It was mathematically invalid. Deeming them instantly
- 14:54uninvestable under these rules. Right.
- 14:56So when you apply this incredibly tough backward
- 15:00looking growth assumption plus the 50% MOS plus the 12.5%
- 15:05required yield, what kind of results do you think you get for
- 15:09these market darlings? I'm guessing not pretty.
- 15:12That sounds like a framework designed to say no to almost
- 15:15everything in the current market.
- 15:16A real gauntlet. You guess right.
- 15:18The findings were stark is putting it mildly.
- 15:21The report's conclusion was that none of these top ten S&P 500
- 15:24liters currently represent an investable opportunity based on
- 15:28these specific conservative criteria.
- 15:30None of them. Wow.
- 15:31The calculated buy prices were just tiny fractions of where the
- 15:34stocks were actually trading. The required downsides were
- 15:37massive, ranging from 80% to over 96%. 96% downside.
- 15:41Good grief. Yeah.
- 15:43And for several of them, Amazon, Meta, Broadcom, Tesla, GP,
- 15:47Morgan, the model was, as we anticipated, mathematically
- 15:50invalid because of negative owner earnings in some years or
- 15:54weird growth rates derived from that worst year rule.
- 15:57So they didn't even get a price target just to fail.
- 15:59Pretty much. Let me throw out a few numbers
- 16:01just to illustrate how dramatic this is.
- 16:03NVIDIA trading around $125. At the time of the analysis, the
- 16:07target buy price was $25. That's an 80% drop needed Apple
- 16:12trading around $250 Target buy price $8.18 and 96.2% downside.
- 16:19Required $8 Microsoft around $450 Target price $27.34.
- 16:25That's a 93.9% downside. Almost 94%.
- 16:28And even Berkshire Hathaway may be the closest thing to a
- 16:30traditional value stock in the list, trading around $620,000
- 16:34for the A shares, the target price of $61,914.00, still
- 16:38needing roughly a 90% drop. So even the Oracle of Omaha's
- 16:41own company doesn't pass his own.
- 16:43Well, maybe not his rules, but these extremely stringent rules.
- 16:46Exactly. So what does this all mean?
- 16:48What's the big picture take away from this exercise?
- 16:50Well, it fundamentally highlights this profound
- 16:53disconnect, doesn't it, between how the current market is
- 16:56valuing these absolute Titans and how a deep value investor
- 17:00rigidly sticking to these specific metrics would see them.
- 17:04It's a fundamental clash of investment philosophies of
- 17:08paradigms. Yeah, absolutely.
- 17:09On one side you've got the market narrative.
- 17:11It's all about sustained high growth, tech dominance, network
- 17:14effects, AI revolutions, long term compounding.
- 17:18The future potential. Right.
- 17:20It's a quality to premium or maybe even growth at any price
- 17:23mindset sometimes. Investors are clearly willing to
- 17:26pay a very significant premium today for the promise of much,
- 17:30much larger cash flows way out in the future.
- 17:32They're discounting the distant future at a lower rate,
- 17:35essentially believing in that long term story.
- 17:36Exactly. And on the other side, you have
- 17:38the framework used in this report.
- 17:40It represents the polar opposite end of the spectrum.
- 17:43Totally different philosophy. It's deep value statistical,
- 17:45almost mechanical. It prioritizes just three things
- 17:48above all else. 1st, a high immediate cash on cash return.
- 17:52That 12.5% cap rate? Cash now second protection
- 17:57against the absolute worst case historical performance becoming
- 18:00permanent using that lowest growth rate.
- 18:02Protect the downside, Assume the worst.
- 18:04And 3rd, an enormous margin for error, that 50% margin of
- 18:08safety. It's about wanting absolute
- 18:10safety and clearly demonstrable value today.
- 18:14Less about forecasting the future, more about assessing the
- 18:17present reality very, very harshly.
- 18:20Precisely this framework is basically built.
- 18:22It's structurally designed to ignore or heavily discount long
- 18:26term growth stories and intangible assets.
- 18:29Brand Moat innovation pipelines. All the things the market seems
- 18:33to love right now. Right.
- 18:34It disregards those in favor of hard, tangible, immediate cash
- 18:38yield and statistical safety Nets, and the analysis just lays
- 18:41it bare. If you are an investor who
- 18:44rigidly follows these specific, very severe constraints, then
- 18:48the most popular, most successful, most widely owned
- 18:50companies in the world today? They are likely going to look
- 18:52perpetually uninvestable. The Gauntlet was thrown down,
- 18:55and by its incredibly strict rules, none of these Titans came
- 18:58close to passing. A sobering perspective depending
- 19:01on how you look at it. It really is.
- 19:03And just to be clear, this deep talk wasn't about saying NVIDIA
- 19:07or Apple will crash 90%. It wasn't predicting their
- 19:10future. No, not at.
- 19:12All it was about understanding different ways to define and
- 19:14measure value, and seeing how today's market leaders stack up
- 19:18against one very specific, very conservative methodology.
- 19:23And it really forces you to think, doesn't it?
- 19:25Is the current market sentiment justified?
- 19:27Is this time different? Is there a new paradigm of
- 19:30growth and innovation that makes these old rules less relevant
- 19:34for these specific companies? Or is the market maybe
- 19:37overlooking fundamental safety principles and its enthusiasm?
- 19:41What happens if those growth narratives falter?
- 19:44What's the underlying value then?
- 19:45Those are the big questions. So what stands out to you
- 19:48listening to this? Does this analysis resonate?
- 19:50Does it clash with how you see things?
- 19:52What does it tell you about your own investment philosophy,
- 19:55maybe? Lots to chew on there.
- 19:56Definitely. We hope this deep dive has given
- 19:59you some fresh perspective. And hey, if you are interested
- 20:02in tracking overall market valuation, sort of the bigger
- 20:05picture, you might want to check out an app called the Buffett
- 20:08Indicator. You can search for it and
- 20:09download it from the iOS App Store.
- 20:11It gives you daily updates on that specific metric.
- 20:14And of course, if you find these kinds of deep dives into value
- 20:17investing topics interesting, please do subscribe to our
- 20:20channel, Deep Value Investing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 20:23Yeah, and check the description for this deep dive.
- 20:25We've put a list of some foundational value investing
- 20:27books there too. Great resources.
- 20:29And finally, the standard disclaimer.
- 20:31All the analysis we discuss is based on publicly available
- 20:34information. It's for educational purposes
- 20:37only. Definitely not investment
- 20:39advice, no. Please always do your own
- 20:41research and due diligence before making any investment
- 20:43decisions.