Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 298: Why Your Team Is Underperforming - And How to Fix It. Colin M. Fisher
Transcript
- 0:00Most teams underperform, not because of bad people, but broken systems.
- 0:05This episode shows you how to fix that with real research-backed strategies.
- 0:09I'm joined by the expert on the subject, Colin Fisher.
- 0:13He's a Harvard-trained, management professor, he's the author of a brand new book called
- 0:17The Collective Edge and a former jazz musician.
- 0:20We bust the biggest myths about trust, teamwork and leadership.
- 0:24Why more people equal slower teams?
- 0:27How do we set a broken team without firing people?
- 0:29And what it really takes to build a high-performing team in 2025 or beyond?
- 0:37What's your take on team building exercises?
- 0:40Team building exercises are one of the most misunderstood things that I encounter in my research
- 0:46and in my teaching, where people, when I say I study teams, I study group dynamics, people
- 0:52automatically their mind goes to these team building exercises.
- 0:57The funny thing is a lot of these team building exercises are based on a kind of misguided
- 1:04understanding of how teams develop.
- 1:06Are you saying if I let myself fall into the arms of my teammate, that's not going to help us build a great team?
- 1:13No, unfortunately, if only trust falls were a recipe for better team dynamics,
- 1:20that would certainly make my job easier, although it might put me out of work a little bit too, so...
- 1:26It's been more complex in math, right?
- 1:27It is a bit more complex.
- 1:29So there's kind of this idea out there in the popular imagination
- 1:34that in order for us to work together, we need to trust each other first.
- 1:39And there's of course some truth to that that we're a lot more likely to collaborate well
- 1:44with somebody that we really trust.
- 1:47But there's actually two different flavors of trust.
- 1:50There's trust, like I trust you with my deepest darkest secrets,
- 1:55and to reveal, you know, everything about my inner world and show myself.
- 2:00And that we usually would call relational trust.
- 2:03But most teams actually need more of cask-based trust,
- 2:08that when you say you're going to do something, you're going to do that thing,
- 2:12and you're going to do it up to a pretty good standard of work.
- 2:15So when I'm depending on you and we're interdependent in the team,
- 2:19you're going to give me your work, I'm going to be able to use it.
- 2:23And that that kind of trust is actually built through the process of working together.
- 2:28So trust is built while we are working together,
- 2:31we don't have to build trust in order to work together.
- 2:34But it's tricky because of course it is a never-ending circle
- 2:38that you need at least a little bit of trust to say,
- 2:41hey, I'm going to work on the team with you,
- 2:43and that means I'm going to depend on you for some things.
- 2:46And somebody does have to take that leap first,
- 2:49but that doing these kinds of fake fun, trust falls
- 2:54that are meant to fundamentally build more of that relational,
- 2:58socio-emotional trust.
- 2:59Those things actually don't translate very well into teams working together better.
- 3:05And so the research on real team building
- 3:09shows that the more task-like the exercises that you're doing ahead of time are,
- 3:16the more it's like simulating the real work you're going to do together,
- 3:19the more that that builds cooperative capacity.
- 3:23And so the further away we get from that,
- 3:26when we're doing trust falls, when we're putting on silly hats,
- 3:29when we're doing relay races outside,
- 3:31those things aren't doing as good a job as often just getting to work might do.
- 3:37That's so fascinating.
- 3:39I mean, how did you get into this game?
- 3:41I know you were a jazz musician before,
- 3:43you became one of the leading researchers and thought leaders on teams.
- 3:47You know, how are these two related?
- 3:49Yeah, well, it's the usual story, right?
- 3:51It's, you go to music school, you become a jazz musician,
- 3:55and then they make your business school professor at the other end of it.
- 3:57Of course.
- 3:57Yeah, I do.
- 3:59But I've always been fascinated with the collaborative aspects of life,
- 4:06in part because I don't tell anyone,
- 4:10but I'm a little bit of a loner in my real life.
- 4:14And so for some, on some level,
- 4:16looking at people in groups and teams
- 4:19is something I could look at from the outside and go,
- 4:21wait a minute, how does that work?
- 4:22Everybody seems so happy in these groups.
- 4:25How did those really work?
- 4:27But then being in the world of jazz and really having to collaborate deeply
- 4:32and collaborate with a really wide variety of different kinds of people
- 4:35all over the world really opened my eyes
- 4:38to how groups can bring out the best in us
- 4:42and things that we don't even know we have within us.
- 4:46So I was playing music and as many of us do
- 4:50as jazz musicians move down to New York
- 4:53and try to quote unquote make it as a musician in New York.
- 4:58And as I was doing that,
- 5:00I worked on the master's degree where I studied improvisation and the arts
- 5:04across all different kinds of art forms.
- 5:06So I was looking at theater and comedy and dance
- 5:10and of course, different musical traditions.
- 5:13And as I was writing my master's thesis,
- 5:15I was doing, I stumbled across the research of this woman
- 5:18who was doing work on the social psychology of creativity.
- 5:22And her name was Theresa Mobile and it turned out
- 5:24she taught in the business school, the Harvard Business School, in fact.
- 5:28And so I thought, hmm, maybe she'd be interested in this idea of
- 5:31how do teams collaborate more creatively
- 5:34and that was really what I wanted to know.
- 5:36Under what conditions can teams spontaneously come up with ideas
- 5:42that no one of the people involved could have come up with?
- 5:45And that's something we experience all the time in jazz and in music.
- 5:50And to my everlasting surprise, they Theresa thought that was a good idea
- 5:54and then you become a business school professor.
- 5:57So you did your PhD at Harvard and did a lot of research.
- 6:01I did my thesis at Harvard and while I was there,
- 6:05I also started working with a really well-known scholar of groups and teams
- 6:09and so much of the book owes its intellectual legacy to him
- 6:13and that's Richard Hackman.
- 6:15So if you're into teams and you want to know more about them,
- 6:19you know, Richard's research is really at the base for all of us.
- 6:23And we started working together on questions,
- 6:26especially about coaching teams.
- 6:28So one of the things that really sparked my research on teams
- 6:33was he was working with Anita Willie,
- 6:36who's now a professor at Carnegie Mellon,
- 6:38but she was a post-doc at Harvard at the time.
- 6:41And they were actually working with the US government
- 6:45on these interagency analysis teams
- 6:49where they were sharing information
- 6:50across different government agencies,
- 6:52which is a big problem, actually.
- 6:53You'd think the government all easily shares information.
- 6:56Not so silo as I'm sure.
- 6:58But no, they don't.
- 7:00So they were training this team leader
- 7:03who read Richard's book called Leading Teams.
- 7:06And he really understood everything.
- 7:07He was a great student.
- 7:09He knew the material.
- 7:11And then he went in to try and put it into practice.
- 7:14And Richard and Anita came back to our research group and they said,
- 7:18this guy just had terrible timing.
- 7:21He could not read the group.
- 7:22He didn't really understand how to insert himself
- 7:25into the ongoing flow of group process.
- 7:28And that really was the beginning of me trying to say,
- 7:31I think that is improvisation.
- 7:33I think that's how we are understanding and reacting
- 7:37to other people, how we listen, how we help.
- 7:40Those things I think are fundamentally
- 7:42about the same things that we deal with as jazz musicians.
- 7:45It's an interesting analogy, right?
- 7:46That a team, which is probably the same size
- 7:49roughly as a jazz combo,
- 7:51also has to riff off each other.
- 7:52There's chaos, but there's also order.
- 7:55And it's a back and forth.
- 7:56And everyone's playing their role.
- 7:58Only if everyone's playing together well,
- 8:00is their beautiful outcome in the form of a new product,
- 8:04a creative campaign, or whatever it may be for a team,
- 8:06as well as beautiful music that we love to go to Jazz Club.
- 8:09And listen to it.
- 8:10I mean, a jazz combo is a team.
- 8:13Many of the things are exactly the same.
- 8:15The importance of listening to one another,
- 8:19of responding, the interdependence,
- 8:22the way in which different roles come together.
- 8:24Those things are really highlighted in a jazz situation.
- 8:29But I do think that jazz, sometimes,
- 8:32we do have an advantage over other kinds
- 8:35of teams and organizations, which is we have very clear roles
- 8:39based on the instruments we play,
- 8:41that we have a lot of shared knowledge and shared norms
- 8:46about how we're going to behave in these situations.
- 8:48Whereas if you're in a management consulting team,
- 8:51or you're in a project team in your organization,
- 8:53those roles aren't always so clear.
- 8:56The norms aren't always so clear.
- 8:59And most importantly, making music is fun.
- 9:03It's gotten a lot of the characteristics
- 9:05that psychology research has shown that we like and test.
- 9:09They're intrinsically motivating, as we'd say,
- 9:12as social psychologists.
- 9:14But not all work has that character.
- 9:17And so in jazz, we definitely have some things
- 9:20that are just like every other team.
- 9:23But we also have some advantages
- 9:24that other kinds of teams don't have.
- 9:27You show up with a trumpet, right?
- 9:28And it's clear that you're the trumpeter,
- 9:30whereas in a team, everyone has the same laptop.
- 9:32And it's not obvious who does what,
- 9:35unless there's good leadership.
- 9:36Yeah, exactly.
- 9:37And so we have to create that.
- 9:39And I think that what gets overlooked is that
- 9:41in these areas where we don't have clear norms,
- 9:44we don't have clear roles,
- 9:45we don't have super motivating tasks.
- 9:48It's our job to create those things.
- 9:51And when we take all of our lessons about teamwork
- 9:53from the situations that are like musical ensembles
- 9:57or sports teams, but we can't forget
- 10:00that those situations also have some advantages
- 10:02that we often don't have in the rest of our lives.
- 10:05That's a really good point.
- 10:06Do you think that we've pushed the cultural idea
- 10:11of the individual too far in recent decades?
- 10:14We talk about the political leader.
- 10:16We talk about great entrepreneurs building these companies.
- 10:19There are a few people talk about the teams
- 10:21that actually do in the work.
- 10:22What would you say has come to far?
- 10:24I absolutely think it's gone too far.
- 10:27And that there's been a lot of research showing
- 10:31that individualism is on the rise all over the world.
- 10:35So even in countries that we usually think
- 10:37of having more collectivistic values,
- 10:40you know, China and other East Asian countries
- 10:43are the kind of prototypical more collectivistic cultures
- 10:46where people think of their friends, their families,
- 10:49their organizations as more a part of themselves,
- 10:52where especially in America is one
- 10:54of the prototypical individualistic countries,
- 10:57people tend to not think of, you know,
- 11:00even their close family members as much of as part of themselves.
- 11:04And so that's a big cultural difference,
- 11:07but that even in collectivist countries,
- 11:09individualism's on the rise
- 11:11and that no matter what measures we look at,
- 11:14we see people using more individualistic language,
- 11:16we see more people living alone,
- 11:19we see people with increasingly smaller families,
- 11:22there's a lot of indications that individualism is on the rise.
- 11:26And it's compounded by the same factors
- 11:29that you mentioned are sort of obsession
- 11:32with lone geniuses and these great CEOs
- 11:35and political leaders and inventors
- 11:39as the movers and chakers of history.
- 11:43When we really look underneath the stories
- 11:45of any great business, any invention,
- 11:49and any great artistic product except for
- 11:54in a few very individualistic domains,
- 11:57we usually find a group and that we find there's more people
- 12:02than just the one who's getting all the credit.
- 12:05Thomas Edison's a classic example
- 12:07where we all know Thomas Edison's name
- 12:10and a lot of people think he invented the light bulb
- 12:12which he absolutely did not do
- 12:15that the light bulb had been invented quite a while
- 12:18before Edison ever came along,
- 12:20but that he patented the mass market version of the light bulb
- 12:25that is closer to what we all use today.
- 12:28He was not working alone.
- 12:30He had a whole team that he called his muckers.
- 12:34For the most part, those people are lost to history.
- 12:37Historians have unpeeled the layers of this story
- 12:41and found a lot of these people were just as responsible
- 12:45as Edison for these outcomes.
- 12:47It's the same when we look at who wins the Nobel Prize,
- 12:51we look at who wins Oscars or who's elected
- 12:56to high offices in every country around the world.
- 13:00They're not doing it on their own
- 13:02in that groups and teams are still humanities
- 13:05best tool for solving problems.
- 13:07And when we think of ourselves,
- 13:09it just as individuals as oh,
- 13:12that's gonna be the way the world changes
- 13:14is by me changing myself, by me going it alone
- 13:19or I'm gonna put my faith in this one leader
- 13:22and they're gonna do all the change.
- 13:24That's really just not how the world works.
- 13:26I agree.
- 13:27I think we pushed the load range a don't too far
- 13:30and it is often the case that many people do the work
- 13:32at the one person gets the credit, slash the blame.
- 13:35It way it's an easier story to tell, right?
- 13:37It kind of fits in with sort of the modern media narrative
- 13:40but also in general how we can talk about things
- 13:44happening in the world that there's a protagonist
- 13:46and antagonist, they have obstacles, et cetera.
- 13:49So it kind of makes sense that we went
- 13:51to find this direction, but if we take it back a little,
- 13:54how do we build a great team?
- 13:57How big it doesn't have to be, how diverse
- 13:59what it should it look like?
- 14:01If I'm running a business or need to build a new team,
- 14:04how would it go about it?
- 14:06How do I build a great team?
- 14:07If you're asking yourself that question,
- 14:09you're already kind of ahead of the game.
- 14:12So just saying how big should it be?
- 14:16It's amazing how many leaders
- 14:18don't ever ask themselves that question.
- 14:21There's a great study by my collaborator Ruth Wagman
- 14:25and some of her colleagues from the Hey Group
- 14:28where they looked at different top management teams
- 14:31around the world, I think there were 111
- 14:33top management teams in their study.
- 14:36And the way you get on some of these top management teams
- 14:40is just sometimes by asking, right?
- 14:43It's like, oh, you know, can I start coming to the meeting
- 14:46and they always say yes and they keep growing
- 14:49and they keep growing and they keep growing?
- 14:51And no one says, well, what would a good size
- 14:53for this team to actually be?
- 14:55And in fact, in that study, nobody knew
- 14:58how big the teams actually were.
- 15:00So when you asked all the different members,
- 15:03how big is this team?
- 15:04How many people are on our top management team?
- 15:07Only 7% of top management teams agreed
- 15:11on how many people were on the team.
- 15:1490% of them disagreed and gave different numbers
- 15:18than the CEO did.
- 15:20So it's something that a lot of people
- 15:23do approach really thoughtlessly.
- 15:25And then so I've kind of given you the long preamble
- 15:29to your head of the game by thinking about it,
- 15:31but that the answer is you wanna have four or five people
- 15:36on your team, ideally.
- 15:38Or if you wanna expand that a little bit,
- 15:40three to seven members is about
- 15:43where we have enough skill to solve problems
- 15:47we couldn't solve as individuals, enough information,
- 15:51perspectives, whatever it is we need.
- 15:54But we don't have too many coordination costs
- 15:57that accrue when we add more members to a team.
- 16:01It's interesting, coordination costs are real, right?
- 16:03Because often it feels like a team work
- 16:05and you can see that it would be way faster
- 16:08if I did it on my own.
- 16:10Is that true?
- 16:11Well, for some things, right?
- 16:13There are definitely times when coordination costs
- 16:16outweigh the value of teamwork.
- 16:19And researchers have looked at when that's most likely
- 16:22to happen and that it's most likely to happen
- 16:25in really simple repetitive tasks.
- 16:29So if all we're doing is putting letters into envelopes
- 16:35or something or we're shoveling snow,
- 16:37we don't wanna collaborate in the sense of,
- 16:39we're both trying to put the same letter
- 16:41into the same envelope or to use the same shovel, right?
- 16:44That we just wanna add up individual contributions,
- 16:47but we want people to fundamentally work on those tasks
- 16:50independently, not collaboratively, yeah.
- 16:53But the more collaborative the task gets
- 16:56and the more complex the work is,
- 16:59the more value there is in collaboration.
- 17:03So when we're doing things like we need new inventions,
- 17:06we need to solve big problems in the organization.
- 17:09We need to solve big problems in the world.
- 17:11Those are jobs for teams, but not so much individuals.
- 17:16So there's always a cost to working together,
- 17:19but there isn't always a gain.
- 17:21So when we're thinking about teamwork,
- 17:23we have to ensure that the gains are bigger
- 17:26than the cost of just making sure we're working together.
- 17:30And I see this a lot in communications, right?
- 17:32That teams that are not particularly functioning well,
- 17:36there's so much communication
- 17:38because they're not completely aligned in terms of the mission
- 17:42in terms of the goals they're pursuing,
- 17:44which means they have to constantly check in
- 17:47due to this lack of clarity.
- 17:49In a way, it's a good sign if there's a lot of this communication
- 17:53when there's a lack of clarity
- 17:55because at least it's showing that people are motivated
- 17:58to make it clearer than it is right now.
- 18:01And so if you notice, people are confused.
- 18:04The being confused about the goals
- 18:06is the first natural first place to look.
- 18:09So I think that's absolutely true
- 18:11and that if we're seeing a lot of communication
- 18:13that doesn't seem like people are on the same page,
- 18:17that's definitely the time to reaffirm our goals
- 18:21for somebody to say, hey, this is my understanding
- 18:24of what it is we're supposed to be doing,
- 18:26is that you're understanding
- 18:28and to have that conversation.
- 18:30There's actually interesting research
- 18:32that this didn't make it into the book
- 18:33and I wish it did.
- 18:35I think this was a study of innovation,
- 18:38like tech companies in the kind of 1990s boom.
- 18:41And they looked at the amount of communication
- 18:44in these top management teams
- 18:45and they compared the teams that were really
- 18:48seemed agile and doing well and moving fast
- 18:51and making fast decisions to the teams
- 18:54that were not adapting to the environment very well.
- 18:57And they actually found that the teams
- 18:59that were moving the fastest
- 19:00and making the fastest decisions were communicating more.
- 19:05And that the actually what happens
- 19:09when teams are really dysfunctional,
- 19:11I think more dysfunctional than the situation
- 19:13you were describing is they start avoiding.
- 19:16They start avoiding each other,
- 19:17they start avoiding the really important issues
- 19:21and even the top management teams of companies
- 19:24will stop talking to each other about the strategy
- 19:27if it becomes too emotionally taxing for them to do it.
- 19:31So like I said, as long as we're all communicating a lot,
- 19:36everyone still seems engaged to me.
- 19:38And I'm saying that's a team
- 19:39that we can still really help.
- 19:41They just need to get clearer on the goals.
- 19:44But when we're not communicating a lot,
- 19:46that's not always a good sign.
- 19:47That's often the sign that's like,
- 19:49we're actually a bit disengaged.
- 19:51We don't care about finding this clarity for ourselves
- 19:55because we're all in a changing environment.
- 19:57We're all doing our work.
- 19:59The situation today is different
- 20:00than the situation yesterday.
- 20:02And we need some of that communication
- 20:05to stay on the same page.
- 20:07It's such a good point.
- 20:08And what I recommend to leaders
- 20:10is they see too many select messages going back
- 20:12and forth about alignment questions.
- 20:15Paul's reflect and try to inject clarity
- 20:18because that is a sign there's probably something
- 20:20it means that can probably be corrected relatively easily.
- 20:24I do think we underestimate the complexity of teams,
- 20:27as they grow or groups that say businesses.
- 20:30When you have, these are numbers from your book, obviously.
- 20:34A group of two only needs to manage one relationship,
- 20:36the group of 20, it's not a big company, a group of 20,
- 20:40you have 190 individual bilateral relationships.
- 20:45Wow, just this relatively small company of 20 people,
- 20:49you almost have 200 relationships between people.
- 20:53And that is a lot to manage.
- 20:54Yeah, absolutely.
- 20:56And I mean, we really underestimate this.
- 20:59And if we go back to this idea that we're trying
- 21:02to solve problems by adding people to a team,
- 21:06we're adding all the complexity.
- 21:07That is so true.
- 21:08That is so true.
- 21:09The usual response in an organization,
- 21:11there's a problem something needs to get done.
- 21:13Let's get more people in.
- 21:15And it seems like the obvious thing to do,
- 21:17but usually to reduce the complexity
- 21:19rather than adding people which increase the complexity.
- 21:23Yeah, absolutely.
- 21:24There's a famous engineer at IBM
- 21:27who coined what was called Brooks's Law,
- 21:30which said if you want to make a late project later,
- 21:35add more manpower to the team.
- 21:37And so yeah, so it's definitely kind of a trueism
- 21:42that people try to solve a lot of problems in teams,
- 21:46the teams rang behind,
- 21:48it seems like things aren't going well.
- 21:50Maybe we don't have the expertise we need.
- 21:51And we're just going to add somebody,
- 21:53but then we're not going to subtract anybody
- 21:56to kind of make the coordination easier.
- 21:59So it's absolutely the case that we underestimate
- 22:02how complex it is to manage a team of 10 relative
- 22:07to a team of six.
- 22:09It's not just 40% more complicated.
- 22:12This is an exponential function
- 22:14where it doesn't just go one more,
- 22:18click up the complexity scale.
- 22:20It goes quite a few clicks up with each person we add.
- 22:23So the advice of having these really small teams,
- 22:27where if we were sitting around the table
- 22:30and we had a half hour hour long meeting,
- 22:33everyone could contribute to a meeting,
- 22:37could be heard, feel like they were able
- 22:39to contribute their opinions,
- 22:41and that if we, almost everyone who's worked,
- 22:44you can think of what that size really is.
- 22:47It's like in a meeting that's got four or five people,
- 22:51I feel really good about our chances, right?
- 22:53Like if we meet for an hour,
- 22:55we're all going to know with each other
- 22:57think about this issue.
- 22:59But if there's 10 people there,
- 23:01and now it's like, yeah, yeah.
- 23:03Maybe, maybe, maybe not,
- 23:05that our chances aren't that great.
- 23:06And if they're 20, there's no chance, right?
- 23:09Like we're not going to have an hour long meeting
- 23:11where everyone can contribute.
- 23:14And yet, this is how people work.
- 23:17That people are like, oh yeah,
- 23:18I have my team meeting with all 25 of my people every day.
- 23:22And it's like, well, who is that for?
- 23:25What's that accomplishing?
- 23:27And the EU, 27 or 28 member states,
- 23:30that you have the ministers or heads of government,
- 23:33and you go around the table,
- 23:35and everyone states their position,
- 23:37the meetings over, essentially,
- 23:38which makes it so hard to get to results quickly,
- 23:41and that's why everything takes so long in Brussels.
- 23:44What about diversity?
- 23:45Is there a sweet spot, a certain degree,
- 23:48is a certain degree of diversity,
- 23:50good for innovation,
- 23:51to your experience, performance, et cetera?
- 23:54Yeah, absolutely.
- 23:55So, more diversity is generally better for learning,
- 24:01for innovation,
- 24:02and for doing these kinds of complex problem-solving kinds
- 24:06of tasks that we usually want people
- 24:08who have different information,
- 24:10different perspectives, different expertise,
- 24:13and that's the value a team can really provide.
- 24:17Now, you would think that, as you say,
- 24:19there's kind of this Goldilocks effects of diversity,
- 24:22if you have two little,
- 24:23if everyone thinks the same thing,
- 24:25everyone knows exactly the same information,
- 24:28there's not much opportunity for members
- 24:30to learn from one another,
- 24:32and kind of come to a synthesis,
- 24:34or in achieve what I call in the book, Synergy,
- 24:36where the group is more than the sum of its parts, right?
- 24:39Yeah, and that's group thing, right?
- 24:41You have certain people that all think alike,
- 24:43because they went to the same university,
- 24:44they're all full-stack engineers,
- 24:45or business majors, or whatever,
- 24:49and they essentially have the same school of thought.
- 24:53Yeah, and so that much research tells us
- 24:57absolutely can happen,
- 24:58that we can have two little diversity in the team,
- 25:01and that that team's going to underperform,
- 25:04it's kind of collective potential.
- 25:07Now, theoretically, it should be possible
- 25:10to have too much diversity as well,
- 25:12and if we push that to an extreme,
- 25:14think of a group where no two people speak the same language,
- 25:19yeah, we all have really different backgrounds,
- 25:22really different knowledge, really different skills,
- 25:24so much so that we can't understand each other.
- 25:27So that, in theory, that's certainly possible,
- 25:31but that in actual organizations,
- 25:34research really doesn't find much evidence
- 25:36that we ever get to that really high degree of diversity,
- 25:40and that so much so that the team can't collaborate,
- 25:43and that for many years, researchers kept finding,
- 25:46yeah, there was some situations
- 25:50where too much diversity was harming team performance,
- 25:53but a recent study by Dutch researchers found that
- 25:58all the studies that were finding these negative effects,
- 26:01or I should say the predominant effect of averaging all of them,
- 26:05so not each individual study, but that generally speaking,
- 26:09the studies that found a negative effect
- 26:11of high levels of diversity were times
- 26:13where there was no objective performance measure,
- 26:16and the performance was being measured by somebody
- 26:19outside the team, so a manager was looking at that team
- 26:23and giving that more diverse team lower performance ratings,
- 26:27not that the team was objectively performing worse,
- 26:31and that suggests that again, when you take that effect out
- 26:34and you take all the teams that didn't have
- 26:36objective performance measures out,
- 26:38we still see a positive, effective diversity
- 26:41on team performance.
- 26:43So at least where my read of this literature right now
- 26:47is if there's an upper limit to how much diversity,
- 26:51real teams in your organization should have,
- 26:53that the same organization already hired all these people
- 26:55and they work there and work together,
- 26:58it doesn't seem like making the team more diverse
- 27:01could is gonna hurt performance.
- 27:03It seems like if anything, it's gonna help performance,
- 27:05and that it's definitely the case that if we're left
- 27:08to our own devices, there's this effect called homophily,
- 27:11where birds of a feather flock together as a joy,
- 27:13that we're likely to go to people who think like us
- 27:17and look like us and are more like us
- 27:20than the variety of dimensions.
- 27:22So most of the time, what you need to do
- 27:24is add diversity to your team.
- 27:26It makes sense, I think that's the reality in business,
- 27:29not that people can't speak the same language,
- 27:31we silly.
- 27:33What about hierarchy?
- 27:34Is it good to have levels of hierarchy in the team?
- 27:38So hierarchy, this is another area where I think,
- 27:42if there's a perfect level of hierarchy,
- 27:45we haven't done a great job of perfectly quantifying it,
- 27:49but that generally, more hierarchy harms team performance.
- 27:55So the more hierarchy, we have the harder it is
- 27:58for that team to be flexible, to learn, to grow.
- 28:02Now, but there also is some kind of new-ish research
- 28:10showing, having extreme levels of flatness,
- 28:15where everybody is completely equal, can be difficult
- 28:20and that the whole organizations that have
- 28:23almost no hierarchy often do struggle
- 28:27with some of the challenges that emerge from that.
- 28:30And so I think the question is really,
- 28:33when do we need different forms of leadership
- 28:36and who can provide that and that when do we need people
- 28:40to set direction, somebody to step in and say,
- 28:43hey, it seems like we're all confused.
- 28:46Let's try and get back on the same page
- 28:49and that do we need formal ranks to do all those things?
- 28:52Do we need formal roles?
- 28:54In some cases, yes, but that teams really benefit
- 28:57when they do share leadership more broadly.
- 29:00We don't say, you're all over, you're in the leader
- 29:04of this team and that means you're responsible
- 29:07for every leadership function we can imagine.
- 29:09You've got to set direction, you've got to get all our resources,
- 29:13you've got to manage our processes
- 29:15and do all the helping and coaching.
- 29:17And that's generally teams that spread that load out
- 29:20or do what we call share leadership tend to do better
- 29:25than teams that consolidate all of those leadership functions
- 29:28in a single person.
- 29:30It would require this one person to be better at everything
- 29:33than anyone else.
- 29:34And often it's that sort of situational leadership
- 29:37when naturally the group looks at one person says,
- 29:40you're probably the best to lead this project
- 29:43because you have the most experience in this area
- 29:45and that makes a lot of sense to me.
- 29:47I mean, groups are wonderful.
- 29:49We all love to work in teams, I love to have a team
- 29:52and we all have that group instinct in us, right?
- 29:56But humans are also motivated by autonomy.
- 30:00So how do we square that circle?
- 30:02I think you've hit on, I think the fundamental tension
- 30:06of our impulse for group to be part of a group
- 30:10and to experience a sense of belonging
- 30:12and being accepted by others with our need
- 30:17and it's a very fundamental deep psychological need
- 30:20to be the masters of our own destiny
- 30:22that we want to experience autonomy.
- 30:24We don't like to feel controlled,
- 30:26we're less motivated, we're less creative,
- 30:28we don't learn as well when we feel like
- 30:30we're being controlled from the outside.
- 30:33So these two things are always a little bit intention
- 30:37because being a member of a group
- 30:41means you are going to have to conform
- 30:43to some norms of behavior within that group.
- 30:48You're going to have to strive towards shared goals
- 30:52that hopefully are largely consonant
- 30:55with your individual goals,
- 30:56but they may not be 100% consonant,
- 30:58that even in a job we love,
- 31:01like it would be better for the organization
- 31:03if we worked a little more and worked a little harder
- 31:06for less pay, that's better for the organization as a whole,
- 31:10but it's not better for us.
- 31:11So there's always at least a little bit of tension
- 31:14between these two things.
- 31:15And so I like to think that we get the best of both worlds.
- 31:19When we give these small groups and what I would call
- 31:24a real team of three to seven people
- 31:27who are interdependent for a complex task
- 31:33where it's a whole piece of work
- 31:34where they can sort of do the whole thing
- 31:36and see the results of their labor.
- 31:39And we give them autonomy over how to do their work.
- 31:44So giving people autonomy over both their goals
- 31:50and their processes can be a little dangerous
- 31:53that if we don't have these shared goals
- 31:55as you were saying in your examples before,
- 31:58it's easy for us to get confused and come apart.
- 32:01But if we're all very clear on this is what we're trying
- 32:04to achieve and we can picture in our minds,
- 32:07this is the world that's going to exist
- 32:09after we're done with this group task,
- 32:14then you can give a team a ton of autonomy
- 32:17and say, well, how you get there,
- 32:19how you realize that, that's up to you.
- 32:23And that's where we can really get the best of both worlds
- 32:25where we feel like, hey, this is a small enough group
- 32:29where I can see myself.
- 32:31I feel like we're getting credit.
- 32:32I'm recognized by my fellows.
- 32:34I feel the sense of belonging,
- 32:36but there's still a lot of autonomy
- 32:38in how we act, how we do things
- 32:40and that I can have that input
- 32:42in these group meetings or in the group
- 32:46into how I live my life.
- 32:49Makes sense, there's also good leadership, right?
- 32:50We agree what we work on,
- 32:53but you can decide how you get there, right?
- 32:55And that's where the autonomy comes in
- 32:57and I think this is also plausible.
- 33:00This sort of tension,
- 33:01this is not just a business, right?
- 33:02Or an organization, this is across the board,
- 33:04this is just human life that we have these both
- 33:07hearts beating in our chest,
- 33:09the individual heart and the group heart
- 33:12and somehow they need to coexist,
- 33:13but that also makes life beautiful.
- 33:16Yeah, absolutely.
- 33:17We're just so hardwired for this stuff, right?
- 33:19That there's no sort of deeper explanation
- 33:22than we've evolved to want to be in groups.
- 33:28That it used to be in some ways a huge threat
- 33:33to our survival if a group were to ostracize us.
- 33:36That were these hairless, claless creatures
- 33:39that weren't equipped to survive
- 33:42in a prehistoric world on our own.
- 33:45And so we needed groups
- 33:47and that we really wanted to be a part of them,
- 33:49but that we also don't want to feel controlled
- 33:55and we're not ants, right?
- 33:57And that there was this sort of debate
- 34:00in evolutionary biology that I don't know if you know
- 34:04the work of Edward O. Wilson who's really famous
- 34:08evolutionary biologist and he was constantly making the case
- 34:11that both ants and human beings
- 34:14are what he calls a superorganism.
- 34:16That that's why we take over the world.
- 34:19Ants are hugely successful.
- 34:21They weigh more than all of our domesticated animals combined.
- 34:25There's a lot of them and that humans obviously
- 34:27are a really successful organism as well.
- 34:30But most evolutionary biologists
- 34:32because we have this drive for autonomy,
- 34:34don't didn't accept Wilson's argument
- 34:37that humans actually qualify as a superorganism
- 34:40the same way that ants or termites
- 34:43or other kinds of small creatures are.
- 34:46So I think we have a lot of the benefits
- 34:50of these, our tendencies for cooperations and groupiness,
- 34:54but we don't have that cost of feeling like we're just slaves
- 34:59to the leader or the queen ants.
- 35:03We can opt out of it's too much.
- 35:05If the hive mind is technically we can opt out.
- 35:09This is for Brailleans, so I would like to make
- 35:11this really practical now for people.
- 35:13And you said that an ideal team, three to seven people,
- 35:17so if I have a team of 40, okay,
- 35:18should probably split this into two.
- 35:20And we know this from like workshops where I was like,
- 35:22oh, you know, six, seven people is really max in one group.
- 35:25If we have 12, we really need two people there
- 35:28to work with a group.
- 35:29Interesting.
- 35:31So three to seven people diversity is good,
- 35:34especially diversity of thought.
- 35:36And hierarchy, yeah, to some extent to give guidance,
- 35:40but ideally meritocratic and situational,
- 35:42lot, lots of layers of hierarchy.
- 35:44That's right.
- 35:45If I'm a leader now and I say, okay, that's cool.
- 35:48How, what else can I do to get the most out of my team
- 35:52tomorrow morning when I go show up at the office?
- 35:55So the time when you have the most influence
- 36:00over your team is actually right at the very beginning.
- 36:04So let's say you've done everything right ahead of time.
- 36:06You've come up with a really great team task
- 36:10and a goal for that team to pursue.
- 36:12You've gathered a diverse mix of people,
- 36:15of three to seven people in the room to achieve that goal.
- 36:18Okay, so you've done a lot of the pre-work ahead of time.
- 36:21Now we've got to bring that to life
- 36:23and that we bring that to life by one,
- 36:26making sure we really articulate those goals
- 36:28and paint the picture of the future that we can all share.
- 36:32So the classic example is John F. Kennedy's
- 36:37charged to NASA to put a man on the moon within 10 years
- 36:41or Bill Gates charged to Microsoft
- 36:43to put a computer on every desk and every home
- 36:47within five years, right?
- 36:48It's a shared vision of the future
- 36:50that we can imagine and we can share.
- 36:54So we're bringing that goal to life.
- 36:56But then the thing that a lot of leaders don't do
- 37:01is to use the power of social norms to their advantage.
- 37:06So we usually think of social norms as being things like
- 37:09how we greet each other in different countries
- 37:12or how appropriate it is to have these emotional displays
- 37:16and in different countries like in America
- 37:19is much more pro big emotional display
- 37:22and Germany is historically less so.
- 37:25So we usually think of norms
- 37:28as these kind of take him for granted invisible things.
- 37:30But groups, small groups develop their own norms
- 37:33and they develop them really, really fast.
- 37:35So where you sit, who talks the most,
- 37:38all those things tend to emerge in the very first meeting
- 37:41sometimes in the first few minutes.
- 37:43And so a really savvy leader can go in and say,
- 37:46all right, what norms do we need?
- 37:48And the number one thing we need is something
- 37:51I hope your listeners have heard of before
- 37:54which is what Amy Edmondson calls psychological safety.
- 37:57So we need to feel like it's okay to speak up,
- 38:00to share our perspective, to share our information,
- 38:03to ask questions, to do experiments and make mistakes.
- 38:08And the best way to do that is for a leader
- 38:10to say those things, to say that you value those things,
- 38:13that hey, we're gonna have to experiment here.
- 38:15Here's the things that we have to learn
- 38:17that we don't know how to do.
- 38:19I expect us to make mistakes, sometimes to own up
- 38:22to those mistakes yourself in front of the group
- 38:26and say, hey, I've made these mistakes.
- 38:27Here's what I've learned.
- 38:29And that to keep asking these questions,
- 38:31they're encouraging people to share what they know
- 38:35and to feel safe and valued when they're doing that.
- 38:38And so if you do that in the very first meeting,
- 38:41you have a huge advantage over other groups.
- 38:45And then, yeah, interesting.
- 38:47And if it's not a first meeting, I say,
- 38:49I'm already working with the team.
- 38:51Things that get a little stale, people maybe,
- 38:53we can reset, right?
- 38:55We can just take any, maybe do it a random Tuesday
- 38:58but say, hey, at the end of the summer,
- 39:00let's do a reset, or beginning of the quarter,
- 39:02or beginning of the month, or whatever it may be,
- 39:05some logical connection to the date is useful,
- 39:09but to shake things up, do exactly what you said,
- 39:13but essentially frame it as a reset,
- 39:16or as a next phase, let's say, next chapter.
- 39:19Yeah, absolutely, yeah, I call those relaunches.
- 39:22So that launches are super powerful,
- 39:25and the way we can harness that power in an ongoing team
- 39:28is, as you say, to do a relaunch
- 39:31and that it's easiest to justify those things
- 39:35when there's a clear sign in the calendar
- 39:38or a part of the work that we've completed,
- 39:41but that I think great leaders often make up an excuse
- 39:45to have these things when they think they need one.
- 39:48So whatever excuse you can come up with,
- 39:52I think that's a good excuse.
- 39:53And rather than the frame it is incidental,
- 39:56I would actually be much more purposeful
- 40:00in trying to make a difference
- 40:02with what we've done before.
- 40:04So in other words, if we were meeting on Tuesdays,
- 40:09as our weekly meeting, I would meet on a different day.
- 40:13I would do it in a different room.
- 40:15I would invite other people to play different roles
- 40:20maybe than they've played before.
- 40:21So if you've been facilitating all the meetings,
- 40:25maybe suggest that somebody else facilitates part
- 40:28or plays a different role than they were playing.
- 40:30Anything you can do to shake things up
- 40:32and really create that sense of newness is really important
- 40:37because social norms are really sticky
- 40:40and that we don't give them up easily.
- 40:42So if we've got a team that has developed these kind of norms
- 40:46where we're not really speaking up
- 40:48or we're not trying our hardest,
- 40:51we're gonna have to work hard to break those things
- 40:54and that just kind of doing it halfway often won't quite be enough.
- 41:00Makes a lot of sense.
- 41:02What's the biggest mistake you see leaders make
- 41:04when it comes to the stakes that potentially undermine teams?
- 41:09So I think the biggest mistake is they're just not
- 41:12really paying attention to teams as the unit of thing
- 41:16that they're supposed to be managing.
- 41:18So so many organizations are geared towards managing individuals.
- 41:22All the performance metrics are individual promotions,
- 41:27punishments, firings, everything is oriented towards individuals.
- 41:31So we create these systems for managing individual performance.
- 41:36And then as we said, there's always attention, right there.
- 41:40And even an organization where we all seemingly have the same goals,
- 41:45there's times where our individual goals,
- 41:46what's gonna get me promoted, what's gonna get me credit,
- 41:49what's gonna get my boss upset with me are at odds
- 41:53with the collective goals.
- 41:55And so if we don't have whole systems
- 41:59that are stacking the deck in favor of group performance,
- 42:02not just individual performance,
- 42:05we're not going to have very effective teams.
- 42:07And so if everything in your organization and your handbook
- 42:10and your performance management system is about individuals,
- 42:14and you come to me and say, oh,
- 42:16our teams aren't doing very well.
- 42:18It's like, well, you've created a whole system
- 42:22that's not supportive of teams.
- 42:25So the first thing is just paying attention.
- 42:28You're already ahead of a lot of the world.
- 42:30If you're asking this question,
- 42:32how do I make my groups better?
- 42:34And then the other things is then stack the deck
- 42:37that, you know, just like, you know,
- 42:40we shouldn't all go spend all of our time
- 42:42in a casino playing a game that's stacked against us.
- 42:45Yet when we put teams in organizations out there in the world,
- 42:50we're often putting them into situation
- 42:52into games that they're stacked against them,
- 42:55that they're in a system that's designed for individuals,
- 42:58that's designed to kind of keep them pulling apart
- 43:00and going in their individual directions
- 43:03rather than coming together.
- 43:05And so the, you know, the main thing I would say
- 43:08is an unwillingness to change these systemic factors
- 43:13about the structure that the group is in
- 43:15and the structure of the group operates,
- 43:17then and instead going straight to group process
- 43:20and saying, oh, we've got these problems.
- 43:23I'm gonna try to, you know, do some trust falls
- 43:25and get you to trust each other more
- 43:27and that's gonna fix everything.
- 43:29And, you know, it's just not gonna fix it for long.
- 43:32Even if you have a really effective intervention
- 43:37that's focused on process,
- 43:38but you're still operating in a bad structure,
- 43:41structures eventually gonna win again.
- 43:43That structure is always going to overcome
- 43:45these procedural forces in the long run.
- 43:48So, being consistent and structured,
- 43:51we need the right mindset to actually see the team
- 43:54as the unit that will deliver the performance.
- 43:56Is that fair?
- 43:57Yes, absolutely.
- 43:58That's a great summary of it.
- 43:59Wow, yeah, that's a lot to take in
- 44:01because we as organizations
- 44:03can't not be able to do that,
- 44:05but I love that you put this on the agenda.
- 44:08Where can people find out more about you in the book?
- 44:11So you can find out about me
- 44:13and order the book at colonmfisher.com
- 44:18and yeah, I hope you'll follow me on LinkedIn,
- 44:21subscribe to my newsletter and please pick up the book
- 44:24and let me know if you like it.
- 44:26What's it called?
- 44:27It is called the Collective Edge,
- 44:29Unlocking the Secret Power of Groups.
- 44:31Yes, and I love it, it's highly recommended.
- 44:34The book is so good.
- 44:35And there's a lot of the research,
- 44:37a lot of the examples you've heard,
- 44:38but many more as well.
- 44:40And you really, it's one of these red books
- 44:42that shifts your thinking about how we interact at work
- 44:45and how we should communicate at work, sir.
- 44:47Really appreciate you, really appreciate the work
- 44:50you've done colon over many years now
- 44:52that culminated in this book now.
- 44:54And this is always my final question.
- 44:56What's the best piece of communications advice?
- 44:59So, you know, from as a group scholar,
- 45:02I think my, the thing I've learned so much
- 45:05from studying groups is don't make assumptions
- 45:10that other people think the way you think.
- 45:13And so if you come in with the assumption that,
- 45:16hey, this other person may see the world
- 45:19completely differently.
- 45:21And everything I'm doing is oriented towards
- 45:24learning about what your perspective is.
- 45:28I think we'll have much more effective communication.
- 45:31So a learning orientation to conversations,
- 45:35to make explicit things that I often don't think
- 45:39need to be made explicit,
- 45:40like the goals or the norms of our group
- 45:43and to really discuss those things
- 45:45and make sure we're on the same page.
- 45:47I think is my main communication advice.
- 45:51Absolutely.
- 45:52I love it when people come from a position
- 45:55of curiosity rather than certainty.
- 45:57I think that's one of the biggest mistakes
- 45:59we're making conversations that we believe
- 46:01we already know what the other person's thinking
- 46:03and will say.
- 46:04And therefore, we're not really listening
- 46:07and that can be a big problem.
- 46:09So curiosity, openness in those conversations, beautiful.
- 46:13Colin, thank you.
- 46:15Thank you so much, Oliver.
- 46:16All the best for the boat.
- 46:17And yeah, hope to continue our conversation,
- 46:19your wife's German,
- 46:20so that we can meet it up in person at some point.
- 46:23Yes, absolutely, really looking forward to it.