Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 270:1-2. Sefer Torah: The Mitzva of Writing, Modern Fulfillment In Printed Sefarim
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. We are starting Hilka Safetaria
- 0:03as a sham. I am Raish, Raish.
- 0:07I am, you know, to then he gets to switch the the things Saif
- 0:10Alef Mrs. SA. I'll call Ishmi Sahalik Devloy
- 0:16Safetar. It's a Mrs. SA for every person
- 0:21to write a safe retire. Apostle says not taqisu lachena
- 0:29Sashira Hazois Lamin is lamin is bene.
- 0:35So they say from here that it's what what does it mean?
- 0:38It's Sashira Hazois. You can't just write.
- 0:41It means from Hazinu until the end of the tyre.
- 0:44That's what the you can't just write.
- 0:47You know, you can't just write part of a state for Tyre.
- 0:50LMI means we since since it's not culture, it's just part of
- 0:53it. It means it means the mitzvahs
- 0:55on every to write everything. And the Gemara says that someone
- 1:03who buys will see in the Rama brings in someone who buys and
- 1:05say fitera from the shook. It's creative mitzvah in a shock
- 1:09he's like so the new creative task was in creative explains
- 1:15that the point of of Takis of of Steve safer Tara is that should
- 1:20be the kid in Sinasa, which was through Tyra right the person
- 1:25who who either writes himself or he hires A safer and he has to
- 1:30go back and forth as a safer all this.
- 1:32Oh yeah, but where's the progress?
- 1:34And what then we have to get a different clap.
- 1:36Whatever the Kool-aid and leaseball safer after that of
- 1:41Kibla. And it's so the the law should
- 1:46is you should meet us are actually Noimarcus should Tarak
- 1:49Lazag, Kenya, Tereka Lekhas, the mid bar, the Kabul Meharsini,
- 1:54just like you would have you put all the effort in over here to
- 1:57get the safer tour of it and you would have put the effort in to
- 1:59go to the to go to the mid bar to the Kabul from Harsini.
- 2:04But if you just go ahead and you buy it, just buy a ready made
- 2:08one from the shop. So then it could be a Kitzberg
- 2:12and saying, ah, you were looking for the easy way out.
- 2:14Who says he would have gone to the mid bar and and and the
- 2:18bacab of the turret. This is the creative Al Kapa
- 2:22name. I mean Rashi Taka holes that you
- 2:25are that you did there. There are cheetahs of Mashma
- 2:28that you that you don't do a mitzvah Mikhal and someone says
- 2:32no, you I've added it's a mitzvah, but it's not the rashes
- 2:35rashes on mitzvah in a move point.
- 2:37Now this is nothing. This is a separate din from
- 2:41that. There's a mitzvah on the
- 2:43seaboard to be sure they have a safer Tyra to read the for Prius
- 2:47attire. It's not there's nothing to do
- 2:49with this. That's even if no one's writing
- 2:52a safer terror. No whatever is a bit from the
- 2:54seaboard to get money together. Hire a safer to write a safer
- 2:56terror because they need one. But that's that's separate from
- 3:00this from from this Din the play scheme say that the Bershuttus
- 3:06as a dealer in the play scheme, whether whether Bershuttus has a
- 3:11Takis to Lakham. Can it be Bershuttus?
- 3:14I think the mini gives says the mini gives Bershuttus is OK.
- 3:18Yeah, it could be there's a hitter not to do Bershuttus but
- 3:22but but but a Copani, you know, but but but in Saffirs all
- 3:26everything in it's always there's always a hitter and more
- 3:30hitter and more hitter and more hitter.
- 3:34But the meaning is that Shuttus is is OK, Just there is a there
- 3:38is there is a Milah not to do it, but Shuttvis.
- 3:41What about a woman Ishmi Israel Shaka Sari.
- 3:46So there are those who say that no, there is no mitzvah on the
- 3:49on the on the woman to to write a safer to her because the lama
- 3:54says the lama is Vinay Israel and there's no mitzvah for her
- 3:57to learn. Shaka Sari says, what do you
- 3:59mean he has to learn her did him and there is a mitzvah.
- 4:02She says Birkha Satayra and those who say, well, what do you
- 4:05mean it's not it's not mitzvah. It's a mitzvah to naudinium.
- 4:09So a bit of a Mohic is over there with it.
- 4:11But I think the mitigates definitely some sort of she is
- 4:15the kind some sort of mitzvah definitely, but obviously
- 4:17donated say to Tara. Is it the you know, it's Shyla
- 4:21about this. She is Kitsu Lochheim.
- 4:24Is it calling her or not? But a component She definitely
- 4:27there definitely is obviously a big scores and obviously a big
- 4:30Milo for her. There's a mitzvah.
- 4:33Yeah. I'm not sure I could be shocked
- 4:39if I hold the whole it's a little bit unclear.
- 4:40You really didn't write it like, you know, the the tuba was a
- 4:43little bit like he said, like I will see, but that's later on.
- 4:48We'll see about the woman writing secretary.
- 4:50I don't I I don't think it's kosher.
- 4:52But you know, I don't it's a little bit later on.
- 4:54Who's kosher to write? I'm not sure there's a real It's
- 5:00not clear. Pasha is the Shiloh is a
- 5:02mitzvah, not a hova. Pasha is a no, no for a woman.
- 5:06Pasha is a Hova is a mitzvah. Shiloh is a mitzvah.
- 5:11So I have to look at the chakrasari again, but also as a
- 5:14Shiloh in between syphonic and syphase.
- 5:17We're going to see is there the kiss?
- 5:19You look him as a totally only mood or not?
- 5:21We'll see that in a minute. It sort of depends on that sort
- 5:24of depends on on that issue. And if it doesn't depend on on
- 5:29Lambert this it doesn't depend on Lemood.
- 5:31So it could be that it's definitely more of a kova, but
- 5:35the play scheme definitely the Gilmer Shah brings his below
- 5:42Isha. He makes he's the dike.
- 5:44The Shahnark says Koh Ish below Isha again, the shark is not so
- 5:52sure about it, you know. So I'll component the what's it
- 5:58called and lift the low is safer Tyra.
- 6:03The shyly is a little Torres shine.
- 6:06Let me step here. There's an issue.
- 6:09So as a question is lift the low safer Tyra.
- 6:13So if you give it, if you have a cottage, safer tour to the shul,
- 6:17are you you'd say you're mitzvah seem a safer tour because the
- 6:22the the Pasha says is the point. The point of the Steve, a safer
- 6:25tour is for you to have your own safer tour in the house and or
- 6:28to own your safer tour. So if you Mack this shit to the
- 6:31shul, that's the shuls. It's not yours.
- 6:34It is. So there's a stop question about
- 6:36if someone didn't fulfill the mitzvah and is it the one that's
- 6:40kind of other basically, if, if, if, if a person, if a person
- 6:43hadn't, say Vitor rode safer tour and it got lost or it's
- 6:46destroyed, whatever it was was strong.
- 6:48So then it's if I have to write another one or is it enough that
- 6:51he wrote one once in his life? Is that is that enough?
- 6:56Tasha says a lot of the boys can say that once he wrote it once
- 6:59in his life. That's enough.
- 7:03But the, the Torres Stein says if you if you give it to a shul,
- 7:06then you're not that you're not, you're not it's you, you, you
- 7:10lost your mitzvah because it's, it's in that it's not just the
- 7:16Siva, it's the IT should be yours.
- 7:21So what the, the the aids to get out of this is the the person
- 7:24can say is to that. When the person gives a safe
- 7:27return to the shore, they don't donate it to the shore.
- 7:29They lend it to the shore, you know, because you don't want to
- 7:34keep a safe return in your house.
- 7:36People do. But it could be a, you know,
- 7:38room. It's a headache if locked up.
- 7:39I don't know whatever. Yeah, you have to know how to
- 7:43keep it. Whatever.
- 7:43So so you want to keep it. You want to lend it to the
- 7:46shore. That's the generally the meaning
- 7:48is to lend it to a shore, you know, but you know Uncle Ponting
- 7:51that you know, obviously you have a right to go ahead and
- 7:53take it back whenever you want to.
- 7:55All right. Gets into shy as you I think to
- 7:57see where they know they're safe with her.
- 7:58I don't know different things but but but but you have a right
- 8:02but but that's that's how they get around the the tourist time.
- 8:08Who is the tourist? Dachran Thorstein Common.
- 8:14Huh. It's first time on Chaz.
- 8:18I don't remember his name. It's for sure Whatever.
- 8:22For sure. It's for sure.
- 8:26I think it's the first time also.
- 8:29Yeah. Hold on Chaz.
- 8:31So the the filer Nicola of safer Tyra mitzvah lift of Michela,
- 8:40even if it's even if he got a safer tour near Russia, he has a
- 8:44mitzvah to write his own safer Tyra, the Eno Rushai Lomachroy
- 8:51and there's and it's also it's forbidden for him to sell it
- 8:55affiliation of Harvey Safer Tyra.
- 8:57Even if he has a whole our employee of safer Tyra, he's not
- 9:01allowed to sell it because it's a it's a be Zion.
- 9:05It's a design to the safer Torah to sell it.
- 9:07Now this is not again, this is not the same thing as in
- 9:12archaimer talks about whether it's Seabor can sell a safer
- 9:16Tara or not, and that's Shiloh. But Seabor is all different.
- 9:20Shiloh's Shiloh is a yocha allowed to sell a safer Tara.
- 9:23Here we're talking about seller because he needs money, as Verma
- 9:26says. Even if he doesn't have even if
- 9:36he only has, you know, barely any food to eat that he's not at
- 9:40the solicitor to go ahead and to and to and to buy food.
- 9:46The Shah says he then, you know, then he should go collect, you
- 9:49know, go to the Cooper Schultz Taka before you know, and and
- 9:53obviously because after that finish, we'll see in the second
- 9:55patient. We're going to see in a minute.
- 9:56But we're not talking about that case.
- 9:57I didn't have It's 56 Victoria and he wants to move to a new
- 10:01house doesn't it's not to sell can't get in the way.
- 10:09So that's how well I was a little bit unclear.
- 10:11No one talks about can you can you get even giving it away.
- 10:13It seems like it's unclear. You can yeah, you can lend it.
- 10:16You can you can you can lend it to people, but it's the point is
- 10:19to giving up ownership is is more of an issue.
- 10:22But fielding Koyosham today leak nice Kodosh also.
- 10:25And even if you want to sell an old one to to buy a new one,
- 10:30it's it that that's also awesome to do that of a limo Taira Alisa
- 10:36Isha multi limp core. But to go ahead and if he needs
- 10:41to if he needs to go learn, he needs to, you know, go, you
- 10:44know, go to yeshiva or you know, or to support himself, whatever
- 10:47it is to learn Alisa Isha or or he needs, you know, to get
- 10:52married. I don't know if it means I don't
- 10:54know if you're allowed to sell the Safetar for your daughters
- 10:56to get married that I'm not sure you know to support the the son
- 10:59in law's and coil. I don't know.
- 11:01I think it's your personal mitzvah motor limb corps and
- 11:05it's motor limb corps in main load of our Akhair limb corps.
- 11:09But it's only again, this is only if there's nothing else to
- 11:12sell, because that's the otherwise otherwise it's still
- 11:17it's a bit it's a bizzon, the safetara.
- 11:20And therefore you can't and then you can't you can't sell it for
- 11:28who? I mean, who are they?
- 11:29That's our pigeon shwim motor Lamacro even.
- 11:32And and so who who are they have opinion shwing or obviously any
- 11:36other. Let's say the guy needs a, you
- 11:38know, life saving medical treatment and things like that.
- 11:40Obviously, you know, and yeah, we'll be motored to go ahead and
- 11:43to sell to sell, say for Tyra things like that for you know, I
- 11:50don't know for for I'll admit, since I'm not sure.
- 11:58Second, I'm Beilaudina by Arkansas and Kufnam Gimel.
- 12:01There's a look over there for the other DNA of of for, you
- 12:04know, if they have the tieber cells and things like that.
- 12:06Sakharlo Saifer lifted those Sepitura Oshakanoy.
- 12:11Oh yeah, Muta, if he hired, if he couldn't do it himself and he
- 12:16hired A Seifer or he bought a, he bought a safer the parcel
- 12:21safer tire and he fixed it up. I always think he looked costly.
- 12:25So even if there was 1 ice, even if there was 1 ice, which was
- 12:29bad and he bought the safer tire and he fixed the one ice, it's
- 12:33considered as if he wrote the whole safer tire and he's in the
- 12:35mitzvah of. So obviously we've also for a
- 12:40person to get it, try to buy a crusher Vitor hassle impossible.
- 12:44I don't know if that's filter, but off the phone then he finds
- 12:46a puzzle safe Vitor and and fixes it.
- 12:51But if he bought it, if you bought it a puzzle safe Vitor
- 12:55and he wasn't McGee any of it, how he could create a Vincent
- 13:00Vitor. He wasn't Maggia.
- 13:02He's like a collective Vincent and he's not Yeatsi.
- 13:08We'll see later on there to buy a person that's also to be Masha
- 13:10puzzle safe with her in his house.
- 13:12In case people use it. It's a later simian and not all
- 13:15the protein and I don't know yet to see that by Alpha Panem.
- 13:20It's but but but quite if it's a little, as I said, whether there
- 13:26is a bit of a mitzvah or not the the I mean Knights of the
- 13:31Grosses of the Rashi Rashi is Icker that it's not that it's
- 13:36it's no mitzvah. He gets a mitzvah, just not the
- 13:38the Myla of of Siva Saifatera. But definitely it's you know,
- 13:43it's it's a it's just not the it's not the the best OK, Baze
- 13:50Sif Baze Haidah nowadays mitzvah nowadays that it's motive for us
- 13:56to write down to Rushabal PE mitzvah litoye kumashe Taira
- 14:01Omishnah gumara piroshaya. It's mitzvah to write kumashe
- 14:05mishnayez kumara and Mifarshim loyim Kareem.
- 14:09And it's also to sell them in LO limo Taira Alisaisha.
- 14:13It's also to sell swarim unless you were going needed to learn
- 14:17Taira or to nor to or to get married.
- 14:21Now this this sif here is all is all big tomo the whole big
- 14:24mahogis. This is the sheeta sarosh.
- 14:29The rush says that nowadays that you know that, that, that, that
- 14:33we, that we, he, he understands, he's a sheet that holds the
- 14:38darshian's Allah, that the point of the, of the having a safer
- 14:42Torah in the house is to learn from it.
- 14:45And, and nowadays that we don't learn from safer Torah.
- 14:49So the mitzvah now has has transferred over to to Mishnais
- 14:54and and and Shasim and things like that.
- 14:57Now there's the mahogany, the base Asif, the Mahabir and the
- 15:01precia on the and the pre in the shock was the precia that the
- 15:06the Mahabir understands that it's not that the rush holds
- 15:10that that there's no mitzvah. It's even safe at our nowadays
- 15:14if we don't learn from it. It's not that.
- 15:17It's just that there's also a mitzvah that's master from the
- 15:19way the triple arc writes in the mitzvah lift, the meeting is
- 15:23also a mitzvah to write commotion because of the
- 15:26lobbyist. And there's a mitzvah to buy
- 15:28them and to learn from them. Not to, by the way, not to,
- 15:31like, keep them on the shelf. Nice.
- 15:33Nicely behind, you know, Katrina and, you know, and the, you
- 15:36know, whatever. Yeah, a person has to actually
- 15:39open it up and learn from it. Otherwise he's not yet to the
- 15:41mitzvah. So you know, there's there's
- 15:46also a mitzvah to you know, I don't again, I don't know how
- 15:49how many sparring. This refers to the person Pasha
- 15:53says from the Shokanara person should have a, you know, homage.
- 15:57If a person has a shot or is he, I'd say Mish Nagubaro appear
- 16:00with Cheyenne because it has it has all of them in there, you
- 16:04know, and if you're brisker, you need a round bomb.
- 16:07Otherwise, it's not I've heard stories of whatever real
- 16:13stories, but but but you would need you know, you need the I
- 16:17don't know if you need the whole shots If you if you use it with
- 16:21one volume, could be use it with one volume.
- 16:23I'm not sure. The shock and the Pisa and the
- 16:26shock hold that the rush, the rush holds of the the mitzvahs
- 16:30Dafka Alameda scam and therefore he comes al fuque that that the
- 16:35mitzvah did transfer over to to sperm and according to them,
- 16:38there's no mitzvah safer Torah. Nowadays there's a mitzvah on
- 16:41the seaboard to buy a safer Torah.
- 16:44But the coin of the shock on the pre show, there's no personal
- 16:47mitzvah anymore. Nora Harvard is not like the
- 16:53shock on the pre show, but a person will want to be want to
- 16:56be Yates at the shock on the pre show.
- 16:59Then they if they have a safer Tyra then they should they could
- 17:02be they should learn from it every once in a while open it
- 17:05up, Mavra said for a little bit learn learn a little bit so that
- 17:09because because the rush holds alumnus for the point of having
- 17:14a kids decision secretary is to learn from it.
- 17:17His problem is if you don't or are you are you allowed to do
- 17:20that? Well you walk into the show sure
- 17:21I don't leave it alone. You take it out whatever I don't
- 17:25know if it's you're safe entire you are yeah, I don't walk in
- 17:28the middle of the morning. I don't know, but I don't know
- 17:30how often, but yeah, it's a you know, it could be, but that's
- 17:36not the meaning. But it could be.
- 17:37There's according to the shock and the preacher, there's a
- 17:39hitter that there will be a hitter to do the minute.
- 17:41But the minute the meaning is that is that there's also a
- 17:44mitzvah in these things. Somebody hears Creusetur from
- 17:51his own city. So Creusetur is not the not
- 17:53considered Lima. No, the post can say it's very
- 17:55clear. I think the Russians the Le
- 17:56Creusetur no, it's not considered LL means actual
- 18:00learning, not not creasatur creasatur receiver.
- 18:03It's not it's not next of the straight.
- 18:06It's not next of not next of learning.
- 18:09The person actually has to learn has to try to learn something
- 18:12from it. So and the question is, is
- 18:16William Kareem in the Lumo of Terra Verdi.
- 18:18So Isha, are you allowed to sell Sfarim Amatia?
- 18:21The couple of truths of Amatia. Amatia has a so about the first
- 18:27of all about the first thing so you tell Risha has a long tuber
- 18:31and he says the last piece of the puzzle here which is
- 18:35important is the Shakasari tries to understand the Russian he
- 18:40says could be the shot in the rush is that you know he says
- 18:45the fiddish. He says that since we're not
- 18:48bakeem in the Caseros Yaseros Kumar says time of the Kumar
- 18:53they weren't became so therefore there's only a mitzvah.
- 18:56Therefore time of the denying they were became there's a
- 18:59mitzvah right so Tyra now once we came low became there's no
- 19:03mitzvah. There is anymore to write a
- 19:05safer Toyota. It's a shaka sari rights and he
- 19:08says and it could be even nowadays it could be even not
- 19:10even a mitzvah so they miss it to her bottom.
- 19:12It could be it's even less was whatever everyone says what they
- 19:18say. Well, it's farming absolutely
- 19:20like you're starting to be thrown absolutely.
- 19:24I don't understand, you know, we we rely on them to serve the
- 19:27things which are seriously or we just we we have a certain
- 19:31Messiah, or maybe a Messiah is not the best.
- 19:33The puzzle safe for Tyra is only something which is Manish
- 19:36missing, you know, So we hold it's caution.
- 19:40You know, the still does not like the the Shaka.
- 19:42Sorry, a Little Pony. The the Ramesha writes.
- 19:46He says it could be the you know, he says that not
- 19:49everyone's safe here. Why that we're not all safe to
- 19:52write to write the safe with Tyra.
- 19:54So how do we get out of it? So some say it's 1 patriot.
- 19:59Yeah, he can't be yourself if you don't have enough money.
- 20:02Whatever Ramesh says, according according to the way the
- 20:06according to the rush, according to the the shock, according to
- 20:09the and and and the Shagasari. Nowadays the person you know
- 20:14that we I'd say by buying, if he buys farming, you learn from
- 20:17them. According to the Yoda according
- 20:19to the Yoda of the rush and and the Shagasari holds that.
- 20:23You know, even by even buying anyway, nowadays we're in SIM.
- 20:26No one can no one can really be used to the midst of keisu
- 20:28Lochem properly. So that's what Raisha says.
- 20:31Therefore, that's what they'll they'll still get a mitzvah of
- 20:36keisu Lochem even if they didn't write a safer term about it.
- 20:39It's a big hitter to write 1. You know, whatever that's that's
- 20:42the question. And then you know, that's just a
- 20:45question is everyone else. You know what you know what to
- 20:48do and selling firm emotion said asked if you have a whole bunch
- 20:53of copies of one of of sparring, what do you do?
- 20:55So he says in that case, you are allowed to you are allowed to
- 20:58sell sparring to put sparring. I didn't I didn't say put
- 21:03sparring and the needs to stop because he wants space.
- 21:06Don't know. I thought the he thought brings
- 21:08a if he does bring the city something like that where it was
- 21:12said that someone like sold some fire and gave him away and and
- 21:17he had a dream whether they called him a Bahama.
- 21:20BRT how Kodesh, we have bias. There's there's there's nearly
- 21:23not to give, not not not not to not to give it as far and I
- 21:27don't know. Again, obviously the meteorite
- 21:29is the safer is torn. You know, you can you can get
- 21:32rid of it. You know, even even if it's like
- 21:33missing the whole pure Sharash, you're not going to learn from
- 21:36Gamar. It's torn without saying
- 21:38something, which is not, you know, whatever to to buy us a
- 21:42new print and give rid of the old print.
- 21:43It could be it could be giving it to a short putting it out for
- 21:47the for Ganisa. I don't know to make room person
- 21:51has to do it in a way. I don't know.
- 21:54That's that's the thing. Finally, I don't know.
- 21:56It's a little bit unclear. Shiloh should be asked right.
- 22:00So that's a that's problem. It's a Shiloh.
- 22:02It's a Shiloh. It's a Shiloh to be Now my
- 22:05question is once, what if it's sparring that you'll never open
- 22:07up? Someone gave you sparring like
- 22:08bar mitzvah boy and he's like these weird sparring.
- 22:11No one's ever going to touch. I don't know.
- 22:14You know, I don't know. I don't know in that case, you
- 22:18know, it's a little bit that's a little bit unclear.
- 22:20Shaila isn't her. Another Shaila is a person.
- 22:22You'd say this in the midst of the rush with a Hassan Shas.
- 22:26If he gets it from his schwer is that is it after if he buys it
- 22:31himself or if he gets it as a gift, it's a little bit unclear.
- 22:34Some say all the Duke him before about Tarah and all that and
- 22:38everything is only a safer Tyra, not the rush doesn't hold it by
- 22:42sparring. All that applies.
- 22:44I think it's London bizarre. If he star he's door issues
- 22:47across the shots. Maybe that will work.
- 22:49I don't know, but I'm not getting into that, you know, but
- 22:53whatever. And and with digital digital
- 22:58libraries, I don't know if you're with the printed
- 23:02sparring, you go to say with digital libraries, I don't know
- 23:05if that would cause a compliance.
- 23:06Keisuke Ham Richard writes the person writers on sparring.
- 23:09He wouldn't he wouldn't he wouldn't be learning.
- 23:12So there's no point. But you know to write it's only
- 23:15it's a kiss looking to write your own, to write your to write
- 23:19copy over homish to write you on is a whole different thing.
- 23:23I don't know if it's in here. That's all I don't It's a whole
- 23:25different say. I don't know if I didn't say I'm
- 23:27talk about applies in this or not, but but 11 last hara.
- 23:34One last thing is that the Mesa selling Sfarin the Mishtabura
- 23:38writes machine the margin ofron that it could be.
- 23:40It's only the Issa is only on Sfarin that was of the seaboard,
- 23:44not a private Sfarin. And and and that's that's the
- 23:48horror. What the that that's what the
- 23:51item is selling on when they sell get rid of?