Latest / This is Oregon / S2E6: The Future of Mass Timber
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to This Is Oregon, the podcast where we take you inside research
- 0:05happening at the University of Oregon,
- 0:06and show you how it applies to your daily life.
- 0:09I'm Ed Dorsch, and this is part two of my conversation with Judith Sheine,
- 0:12professor of Architecture and director of Design
- 0:14for the TallWood Design Institute, a collaboration of the University
- 0:17of Oregon and Oregon State University working to advance mass timber.
- 0:21And now, part two of our conversation.
- 0:24And mass timber is relatively new, but mass timber construction
- 0:27began in Europe during the mid-1990s and it's catching on now in the US.
- 0:31But it's primarily been for taller buildings, commercial buildings,
- 0:34maybe apartments, multi-family dwellings.
- 0:37But Judith, you imagine smaller homes that are built for mass timber.
- 0:42And these homes are not the kind of home construction that we're used to.
- 0:45You mentioned there is no two-by-fours.
- 0:47These panels kind of fit together, like a gingerbread house.
- 0:52And you've actually built a test model,
- 0:55and we have another one in the works—tell us more about that.
- 0:58What really started this kind of revolution in mass
- 1:00timber was the development of something called cross-laminated timber
- 1:04in Europe in the mid-1990s, which is really a bunch of two-by-fours
- 1:08that are glued together in perpendicular layers.
- 1:11It's often been described as “plywood on steroids.” So instead of, you know, veneer
- 1:16and you cross-laminate different grains, you cross-laminate lumber.
- 1:19And this is what began to, you know, replace
- 1:22steel and concrete in buildings, especially in Europe.
- 1:26The U.S.
- 1:27first started to produce cross-laminated timber in 2015 here in Oregon, again,
- 1:31the kind of brainchild of Dean Thomas Maness, who thought we should really start
- 1:36the mass timber industry here in Oregon, which is what happened.
- 1:39And then, Freres Lumber, which has been around
- 1:42now, Freres Engineered Wood, which has been around for over 100 years
- 1:45in the Santiam Canyon—they've been making plywood for a very long time.
- 1:49And they thought “We could make massive plywood panels,” and both D.R.
- 1:53Johnson, which made the first cross-laminated
- 1:55timber panels and the mass plywood panels, those products and processes
- 2:01were developed with faculty at Oregon State University
- 2:03who are part of our TallWood Design Institute.
- 2:07So those new products allowed us to look at, you know, building big buildings.
- 2:12What was pretty clear, fairly early on is that these products
- 2:17can compete with steel and concrete, as you said, at a higher level.
- 2:21You know, anything above five stories, but anything that you can build by code,
- 2:25you know, five stories and less out of light wood frame,
- 2:28that's where it's harder to compete.
- 2:31And you might ask why we would want to compete with light wood frame.
- 2:34Well, because mass timber is more fire resistant.
- 2:37It can be more resilient in general.
- 2:40It can make very tight thermal envelopes for more energy efficiency,
- 2:44and it can create jobs in rural communities that really need them.
- 2:49So those are all advantages.
- 2:50So we started looking at whether you could actually make affordable
- 2:54housing at a small scale out of mass timber.
- 2:58And what we found is that with mass plywood, you could use panels
- 3:02that are thin as 3 inches or 2 inches, but a three inch cross-laminated
- 3:07timber panel is not as strong and stiff as a three inch mass plywood panel.
- 3:12So we started looking at the possibility of making
- 3:14small houses out of that material.
- 3:17And at the same time, Oregon passed
- 3:21legislation, HB 2001, essentially getting rid of single family
- 3:25zoning in any community above 10,000 population.
- 3:29So we began to look at developing a house type
- 3:31that could work for what are called “cottage clusters.”
- 3:35So that would be a group of small houses around a courtyard
- 3:38in what had originally been zoned for a single family house.
- 3:42So we developed a small footprint, two bedroom, two story model
- 3:47that, as you said, we were able to do our first prototype in the Emmerson lab,
- 3:52which is at the College of Forestry at OSU,
- 3:54which is the home of the TallWood Institute.
- 3:56We have a big, strong foreign wall, and some cranes,
- 4:00and a CNC machine, and a press
- 4:03for making experimental mass timber and a robot,
- 4:07so we have a whole lot of things there for both manufacturing and milling
- 4:11and building and testing.
- 4:12And so we managed to make our first mass plywood little house.
- 4:17And we were looking forward to building a second prototype
- 4:20after some structural optimization.
- 4:23Outside of the lab, which we want to keep up
- 4:26for about a year or so that we can test daylight, thermal
- 4:30performance, indoor air quality, acoustics, and all sorts of other things.
- 4:34And we actually built the first one ourselves—not me.
- 4:38I really didn't do any building, but our research faculty
- 4:40and our faculty did and our graduate students.
- 4:42But the second one, we're going to have a contractor
- 4:46build and fabricate to really dial in on labor costs.
- 4:49We know what the material costs are.
- 4:51And in our second one, in structurally optimizing it,
- 4:54we've managed to cut out about $15,000 worth of materials.
- 4:58So we are optimistic that will actually be able
- 5:01to compete with light wood frame at that scale.
- 5:04And create more demand for mass timber, more jobs in rural communities,
- 5:08make some prefabricated housing, which we desperately need in the state,
- 5:13that could be produced and put up very rapidly,
- 5:16and we think it can compete in cost—we hope it can compete on cost
- 5:19with light wood frame.
- 5:21The director for the TallWood Design Institute is Iain MacDonald,
- 5:24who's based at Oregon State University.
- 5:26And our home is the Emmerson Lab.
- 5:29It's officially known as the AA “Red” Emmerson Advanced Wood Products
- 5:33Laboratory,
- 5:35which is where we do a huge amount of work and, you I was very privileged.
- 5:38Our College of Design can work there alongside OSU researchers,
- 5:42which is very exciting for us
- 5:44and for our graduate students and some undergraduates who work there.
- 5:47So the first home was built
- 5:48for indoor testing, and this new one's for outdoor testing.
- 5:51It's a home prototype built by two Oregon universities
- 5:56with a product manufactured in Oregon,
- 5:59and hopefully might offer a solution for affordable housing in Oregon.
- 6:03And you're really looking at every aspect of it, from the source
- 6:08material to the engineering to the manufacturing, all the way to the
- 6:11to the zoning on the ground and making these feasible, in cities,
- 6:16because it's a whole new way of looking at at home construction.
- 6:20Right.
- 6:21We've been at the TallWood Design Institute—UO and OSU—We've
- 6:25been working with a number of state agencies since ‘21.
- 6:29Really inspired by the devastating Labor Day 2020 fires,
- 6:33which took out a million acres of forest and over 500 homes.
- 6:39We started talking to the Port of Portland, Business Oregon,
- 6:43the Oregon Department of Forestry
- 6:44and the Department of Land Conservation and Development
- 6:47about looking at a kind of comprehensive plan from forest to factory.
- 6:51You know, sustainable forest management, thinning that would allow more fiber
- 6:56supply of small diameter logs, a revenue stream for that thinning
- 7:01because they could be used in mass timber and then dealing with the housing crisis
- 7:05by looking at the possibility of doing pre manufactured
- 7:10housing and factories, looking at both flat-pack, which is what
- 7:14we're doing, we're like the IKEA model with our little house,
- 7:17or volumetric, which is one of the things they'll be doing up at the port.
- 7:21The Port of Portland is has converted an unused marine terminal
- 7:25two to what they call the Mass Timber and Housing Innovation Campus.
- 7:29And that has just gotten a commitment from a Swiss firm, Zaugg Timber
- 7:33Solutions, to open a modular mass timber
- 7:36manufacture there, both for housing and for other building types.
- 7:40So we looked at everything from forestry through to factory production of housing.
- 7:46And we're lucky enough to get an Economic Development Administration
- 7:50Build Back Better Regional Challenge grant for this project.
- 7:54That's a mouthful. Yeah, it's certainly is.
- 7:57We generally say, “BBBRC,” and that also
- 8:02funded the prototyping for these mass plywood houses that we've been working on.
- 8:06So you're really building a broad coalition across industry,
- 8:11in R&D, education, working with municipalities
- 8:15to create this mass timber ecosystem in the Pacific Northwest.
- 8:20And, for those of you who have been through
- 8:23the Portland International Airport anytime recently, about a year ago,
- 8:27they opened their new main terminal, which if you looked up,
- 8:31you probably
- 8:32noticed the nine acre mass timber roof
- 8:35made with trees harvested within 300 miles of that location.
- 8:38Now, at the time, and perhaps still,
- 8:40it was the largest mass timber project of its kind in the world.
- 8:44What does this symbolize for the Pacific Northwest?
- 8:47It really showcases how the Pacific Northwest
- 8:51can make really huge, beautiful
- 8:54buildings out of locally sourced timber
- 8:58that provides all kinds of economic and environmental benefits for the region.
- 9:03It was really an exciting project.
- 9:05And, ZGF, you know, the architecture firm actually designed it.
- 9:09The lead designer, Gene
- 9:10Sandoval, is a graduate of our Bachelor of Architecture program.
- 9:14The roof is made out of mass
- 9:17plywood from Freres, which our faculty helped develop.
- 9:21The giant glue lamp beams were actually fabricated
- 9:24right here in Eugene at Zip-O Logs right down the road.
- 9:28So, and Timberlab, which is a company that, was kind of spun off
- 9:33of Swinerton Builders in 2021, did all the fabricating
- 9:38and installation of all the timber and really the timber design.
- 9:42And Timberlab, it's kind of a success story—Swinerton really saw an opportunity
- 9:47to dive into mass timber building and become quite expert
- 9:50spin off Timberlab, which is what we call a vertically integrated firm.
- 9:54What that means is they do timber engineering, fabrication,
- 9:58detailing and design and installation of mass timber.
- 10:02They opened a second facility,
- 10:04actually in South Carolina, and they're building all over now.
- 10:07But maybe more relevant for us is that they're building a new facility
- 10:11just up the road in Millersburg, which will be both,
- 10:14cross-laminated timber production, very automated and fabrication.
- 10:18And they are very excited about being close to the two universities
- 10:22because we collaborate very closely together.
- 10:24We are very regional.
- 10:26You know, we're not something that can be done
- 10:28in the same way in other parts of the country.
- 10:31Our TallWood Design Institute has really been recognized as the leading,
- 10:36mass timber research institute in the U.S., we have a number of
- 10:40firms are both family owned and new firms that are producing mass timber.
- 10:45We have research in virtually every area of it.
- 10:48As with any new endeavor, I'm sure you face some obstacles and setbacks.
- 10:53What are you working to overcome as you promote
- 10:56innovation and the adoption of mass timber?
- 10:59Well, dealing with building codes and zoning codes are a big one;
- 11:04part of our Build Back Better Regional Challenge
- 11:06grant went to the Department of Land Conservation and Development.
- 11:10They developed a model code and worked with ten communities
- 11:14to change the zoning codes to allow more prefabricated housing.
- 11:18That's a big issue.
- 11:19We're also working to change building codes,
- 11:22so that more and more—I mean, there is acceptance of mass timber.
- 11:25In fact, Oregon was the first jurisdiction
- 11:27in the US to adopt the new Tall Mass Timber building codes.
- 11:31But there's a lot of work to be done.
- 11:32So one of the things we proposed in our engine is doing more data collection,
- 11:37both to help update building codes, but also to reduce actual
- 11:42and perceived risk, because right now lenders have some reluctance.
- 11:47It's a new material. We don't know how it works.
- 11:49Insurance premiums are kind of high.
- 11:51The more data we can produce about fire resistance, durability, moisture,
- 11:57you know, seismic, of course, all of that will help to make lenders
- 12:01and insurance agencies understand real risk better
- 12:05and will enable many more buildings to be built.
- 12:09So there are a number of things that that do have and and workforce there.
- 12:13We need to train new workforce
- 12:15to work with essentially digital machines instead of just hammers.
- 12:19Right.
- 12:19That's a new thing.
- 12:20So there are a number of things that have to be done, all of which we,
- 12:25you know, when our NSF engine proposal, we had very comprehensive plans for.
- 12:29And then imagining a decade or two
- 12:32into the future, what's your ideal future scenario?
- 12:35What do you see?
- 12:36What do you hope to see as far as innovation and adoption of mass timber?
- 12:40And what do you hope to see for the Pacific Northwest?
- 12:43Well, ideally, we would like to see many new mass timber
- 12:48factories producing you know, new types
- 12:51of mass timber of all kinds using underutilized species
- 12:56and also embedding, you know, sensors in them for smart panels
- 13:01that will sense moisture, ones that will have acoustic materials.
- 13:04And then we think there's enormous potential for new factories doing that.
- 13:08We think there's also enormous potential for factories
- 13:11making prefabricated housing,
- 13:13both flat-pack like the panel size that we're looking at specifically,
- 13:17and the volumetric that is being looked at partly up at the,
- 13:22at the Port of Portland's Mass Timber Housing and Innovation Campus.
- 13:25So we see potential for two kinds of factories and lots
- 13:29and lots of jobs associated with them, and the potential to create an enormous
- 13:33amount of rapidly produced and much needed affordable housing, which is needed
- 13:38not just in Oregon, but, you know, across the West Coast and really across America.
- 13:42But we have a very comprehensive network
- 13:45looking at every possible aspect of this.
- 13:48And, we've been organizing it here from University of Oregon.
- 13:53We also have specifically here
- 13:55we have researchers in a lot of areas of mass chamber performance.
- 13:59In a lot of areas, we in the architecture department
- 14:02have had a history of building science labs, which is not that common
- 14:06in architecture departments, really, since the late 1970s under Charlie Brown.
- 14:10And the Energy Studies and Building Lab is now part of a bigger effort.
- 14:14The Institute for Health in the Built Environment,
- 14:16which includes the Energy Studies and Building Lab, the Biology
- 14:21and the Built Environment Lab, and the Baker Lighting Lab,
- 14:24and, the Biology in the Built Environment in the lab,
- 14:27joined with the biology department a number of years ago to type indoor
- 14:32biomes, you know, for bacteria, of course, during COVID, they expanded to viruses.
- 14:37And they're doing a lot of work now looking at mass timber and health care.
- 14:42Health care, of course, is a growing area in the US
- 14:46and they're doing other kinds of work and they're looking at, you know,
- 14:49both bacterial and viral absorption in, in timber.
- 14:53They're working on our prototyping projects and design,
- 14:56of course, we do design. So we do a bunch of that.
- 14:58We have a faculty member who works in robotics
- 15:01and in kind of new forms of fabrication and a lot of parametric design.
- 15:05He's working with a researcher in robotics over at Oregon State University.
- 15:10So we do a lot of R&D here, both with internal collaboration
- 15:14but a lot of collaboration with OSU people in both
- 15:17the College of Forestry and in the College of Engineering.
- 15:22So we have architects working in laboratories,
- 15:25which I think might surprise a lot of folks.
- 15:27And then we have, in addition to architects working in laboratories,
- 15:30we have architects collaborating with biologists in laboratories
- 15:33as well as municipal planners and other universities.
- 15:36So it really is this ecosystem of collaboration with with one goal in mind.
- 15:41That's a great way to put it.
- 15:42You need a lot of stakeholders with different kinds
- 15:46of areas of expertise coming together in a collaborative way.
- 15:49And I can say what's been really interesting about the mass timber world
- 15:53is that it's been very collaborative, particularly here in Oregon,
- 15:57is that we have great relationships with industry,
- 16:00with government organizations, nonprofit organizations and communities
- 16:04all over Oregon, and that's kind of exciting in itself.
- 16:08Now, I'm a homeowner.
- 16:09What advice would you have for me?
- 16:11Or perhaps an architect, or an engineer or even a student
- 16:15who's interested in being part of the mass timber movement?
- 16:20How can we begin to adopt
- 16:22some of these building materials or promote their use?
- 16:26I think that if you are lucky enough to be a developer, of course,
- 16:30or an architect, we encourage you to, you know,
- 16:33specify the use of these materials and promote them.
- 16:36As a homeowner, we hope that in a couple of years
- 16:40we'll have factories producing both flat-pack and volumetric
- 16:44mass timber housing, and we encourage homeowners to visit
- 16:48model homes and to think about purchasing these products.
- 16:52We actually, for the first house prototype,
- 16:54which we did inside our lab, we had many, many tours,
- 16:57but we actually hosted an open house and we furnished the entire house.
- 17:02We looked in the IKEA catalog and furnished living room,
- 17:06dining room, bedrooms, linens, lighting, fixtures.
- 17:09We did everything and we had an open house and we didn't even start
- 17:12counting how many people came until about half an hour into it.
- 17:16There were over 120 people, and usually when you have RSVPs, is
- 17:19you get about half those people showing up.
- 17:21This time we had twice as many people showing up because they RSVP’d.
- 17:25And I mean, it was great.
- 17:27And, I had some concerns about how people would feel about living
- 17:32in an all mass plywood house with the mass plywood exposed on the inside.
- 17:35But, you know, these people are Oregonians.
- 17:38They love wood.
- 17:39So in general, people are very enthusiastic
- 17:42and we hope to have more demonstration houses up that homeowners can come see.
- 17:47We've actually had,
- 17:48I mean including yesterday, I mean I can inquiries all the time
- 17:52about “How can I purchase one of these?” And we're like, “We're not ready yet.
- 17:55We're going to do a second prototype.”
- 17:57We have a pilot project coming up for four of them in Burns, Oregon.
- 18:01And we have interest from two different manufacturers
- 18:04in starting up businesses that will be making these flat-pack kits.
- 18:08So in a couple of years, we think we'll be able to say
- 18:11instead of “You got to wait a couple of years,”
- 18:12we hope we're going to be able to say “We have this model home.
- 18:15This is how you can purchase one.” Well, I've seen it
- 18:18and I want one in my backyard as soon as possible.
- 18:22Thank you, Judith, for joining us today and telling us everything
- 18:24going on with mass timber.
- 18:26Thank you for hosting me
- 18:27and for giving us this platform for talking about mass timber!
- 18:32If you're
- 18:32interested in learning more, check out the links in the episode description,
- 18:36and don't forget to follow
- 18:38This Is Oregon for more stories from the University of Oregon.
- 18:41See you next time!
- 18:43This Is Oregon is produced by the Division of University Communications.
- 18:46For more on the latest University of Oregon
- 18:48research and news, visit news.uoregon.edu
- 18:52or find us on your favorite social media platform using the handle @uoregon.
- 18:57Thanks for listening and Go Ducks!