Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 11 : The $31,000 Salary-Dividend Mistake Most Incorporated Canadian Doctors Make
Transcript
- Vishal Gill, CFP: Hey everyone, welcome to episode 11 of Portfolio Talks. Today we're gonna talk to you guys how you can save around $24,000, like a lot of our doctors do when they first start working with us and rebuild out the way that they pay themselves. So I know we've talked about dividends and salary a bunch of times in a bunch of different contexts, but in today's episode, we're gonna show you some real world numbers attached to it so you can identify for yourself are you running in this problem? Is this problem right over the horizon for you? Come tax time. And hopefully you can better navigate it by the end of this episode. So if this gives you some value, please make sure you support the show. Like, share, subscribe, and let's jump right into it. Salary dividends for doctors in Canada. How are you gonna save yourself $24,000? Let's jump into it. All right, we're back. Portfolio Talks. And before we jump into it, it is crazy outside. meantiques we're just talking about it. It is smoky. here in Abbey, it is very, very smoky. worse off, actually, it was worse in the morning. It's clearing up a bit now, but it was I was quite surprised because here it's been raining for the last week. It's been a really weird summer. You get real hot weather, like 36 degrees for a couple days, and then it pours rain, and then it's back to 20, and then it's 30, and then it's raining. but clearly that's not the case everywhere, so it's fires all over the place. But how's the how's the weather conditions over there? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I noticed it this morning. It was overcast, like a lot of s smoky overcast. It didn't smell really where I was, and then I had to do some running around this morning. And the longer I drove in the car, the more I smelt the smoke like filtering in. And I guess it's just the nature of summer. I think we got away with it last year where we didn't really have this. And this fires in the Okanagan, in central BC interior, in Washington State, so we're just kinda surrounded by it. And it's gonna happen. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, and there's been some real weird rhetoric I've seen online. Like I know like the states. I just saw this bunch of people like I don't know if it was Trump exactly who said it, but but something about like, Canada's gotta pay more terrorists because forest fires and stuff, and you're just like, What is going on? Like the the lack of sensibility in the world nowadays is crazy. And then even when I saw online the fires in Vernon, it's tough how much people politicize it where it's like, and This is because the US, or to do this, or what you know, and it's just one of those things that it's sad to see people's houses are burning, they're evacuating their towns, and then it's become political, which it never should be really. but that being said, I hope everyone who's impacted by the fires, directly or indirectly, is is getting the support that they need. But it happens every single year. It's it's unfortunate. But if you live somewhere that is very heavy on the green belt, like we are here, lots of forests, lots of nature. there's always been forest fires. I believe over the last couple of years it's mild it out actually. But I remember like seven years ago, there was a couple of years where it was so bad, like you you could smell it when you woke up in the morning in your house. You could smell smoked, you taste it almost. couldn't really walk outside without being able to see more than 50 feet in front of you. and I've really had that. Hopefully that's not the case again, but I haven't had that in several, several years. So forest fires are a thing. People are affected. Always remember that. It's not political. There's people that are actually affected. So sending our thoughts and prayers to everyone that's affected by the fire. So hopefully you get some rain here. fingers crossed. One of the only times you ever hope for rain, that's a good thing about living in BC. Well, it's inevitable, it's coming. Tyson Nagasaka: Coming. Yep. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. all right. So speaking of raining in a different way would be raining on your parade in taxes. So it is not tax time right now, it's August, so summertime is is here, but it's a good time to get your house in order in regards to. How you manage your cash flow, admit your check-in either with your financial planning team or yourselves, or however you're running it, and just make sure that there's any corrections you can get ahead of it, which is what we want to talk about today. Excuse me. So, you know, a lot of the times most incorporated healthcare professionals, like doctors, dentists, physicians, optometrists, they all kind of run to the same issues. You you earn a lot of money, it's earned inside your private corporation, your professional corporation for the most part, and then you're paying it to yourself to live. your life. However, what we see on average is about twenty to sixty thousand dollars in bleeding on their taxes because of the way that they are organizing their finances or doing their finances or doing their cash flow. it's not just because of one decision. It's it's a series of decisions or lack of decisions that end up resulting in you paying another twenty to sixty thousand dollars in taxes, which I don't think anyone really wants to do. So kind of what we want to talk about first is the problem and Before we get into the problems, let's talk about the common mistakes that we actually see. corporation, for those of you who don't know, is essentially another entity that you will create at some point in your career that's gonna earn income in a different tax rate. So as you earn your income, it'll be taxed at your corporate tax rate. And then you can pull it to the personal side as you spend your money personally. so your corporation, if if we lose you when we're talking about corpse and PCs and professional corporations. That's what we mean. It's that new entity that you eventually build, usually three years, two, three years into your career. Once you start earning more than you need, you'll open up this new corporation. Money will be earned inside of that. And then you can kick it over to yourself personally. But let's start there, Dyson. What are some of the common mistakes that you see when it comes to people that come to you as new clients and they either have a new corporation, they just opened our corporation, or they're thinking about opening up a corporation for the first time? What are some of the common mistakes that you see? Tyson Nagasaka: well I think in general a lot of people misunderstand like you were just explaining, they misunderstand what it is, why you're doing it, and and how to properly utilize it. I find especially because we speak to a lot of students in the medical fields, whether that's dentists, optometries, or even the physicians, they are told that they should incorporate, but they don't know why, they don't know what that means, they don't even know how to like properly Earn money in and allocate those dollars yet because they've been a student forever. And you want to graduate and get into the game. Then we have some of the people that are sort of on a different part of the spectrum where they've been practicing, they might have been an associate for 10 years, and now they're finally incorporating. And I've I've come across a few of those this year too, where they finally incorporated, they're pretty seasoned, but they've never understood. the money game and that, you know, the money that you keep in your corp can be lightly taxed and then what you need to live can be drawn out and have a strategy for that. And I think it's just layering strategies. So I think the number one thing that I come across that I see is they don't understand how to properly utilize it as a tool and as a piece of their system. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, yeah, very common. on my side, there's a couple of things that are very specific that I see more times than not. And this is usually when the corporation has just started. So this is right when they start to open up their their new corporation. and a lot of it's just because the bandwidth that our kind of clientele have is is you have a very intensive career. So by the time you get home, life, you know, there's there's errands, there's kids, there's all the stuff they gotta do. So it's just on their to-do list forever. but one thing to note is your corporation sounds great. Okay, yeah. Like if I'm a BCE, instead of paying at my top marginal tax rate 53 and a half percent, I can earn at 11%. That that's simple math. That makes a lot of sense. That doesn't work unless you start to get paid inside your corporation. And that's the first mistake that I see very, very often is you know a physician will get so close to the finish line of opening the new corporation and it's all basically there but they haven't updated you know msp or or whoever they're getting paid for whoever they're billing they haven't updated it to send the funds and bill it directly to the corporation it's still on the personal side and you know we can try and remind as much as possible but you're the one that has to do it so making sure that as soon as your corp is set up you've gone to the bank you get this new void check or banking info for this new account You gotta update that ASAP because for as long as you don't update that, that money is still being taxed onto your personal side. And that can end up causing you a lot of problem with a lot of a lot of extra money. Like for example, if you know it's it's summer, so let's say it's halfway through the year, and you started the incorporation process in January, February, and you just forgot to update your new banking account and you've earned $250,000 so far for the year. The difference of you updating it inside your corporation. So if you earned that $250 into your corporation, you'd be taxed at about $27.5. So $27,500 would be your tax bill on your $250,000 so far in the year. However, if you didn't do that and you left it out onto the personal side, you're looking at about $81,000 in taxes just because you didn't update your bank account. Sounds crazy, but it happens more times than you think because there's a hundred things that you guys are trying to do the same time. So Understand that when you open up your corporation, in theory, to Tyson's point, it sounds great that you can earn that money inside your corp, but it doesn't work functionally until you update your billings. So whoever you're billing, that money is being directed into the corporation. So it's taxed on the corporation, and then you can decide how much you pay yourself personally. If you don't do that, it's going to keep on being billed to yourself personally, and that's going to run you into a bunch of problems. The second thing that we see is let's say you did do that. So You know, all is well, you've updated your bank accounts and and now the income is being taxed at the corporate level. So instead of your eighty-one thousand dollars in taxes, you're paying twenty seven and a half thousand dollars in taxes. Great. What about the expenses? And this is another thing that I see often is it takes about a year or two for all those expenses to flip over to the corporate side. So instead of paying your association fees, instead of paying your you know, professional fees, whatever whatever that may be from your corporate account. Some of it is still lingering on the personal side. And it's not a huge amount of number, but it's just money you're leaving on the table for no reason. and let's say you miss $10,000 in deductions. So instead of moving into your corporation, it's just still sitting on the personal side, or you just forget about it and you forget to pay it from the right account and gets lost in your bookkeeping because you forgot the receipt or you have it somewhere, don't know where it is, you don't have the time to look for it, whatever. I'll just eat the cost. On $10,000, you're missing only about $1,100 in free money that's just sitting on the table that you're losing. For just not being organized. So if you do this stuff right in the beginning, if you add it to your like checklist of when you start the incorporation process, okay, once I incorporate, I'm gonna update my banking accounts. I'm also gonna take a quick review with my financial planning team of what expenses are are should be attributed and now moved into my corporation. That can save you significant, significant money. That can just be left inside your corporation, invested, doing anything else for you besides just being paid to the CRA, because we gotta pay taxes. But you don't want to leave a tip because you made a mistake and a mental error. So those are two mistakes I see more often than not, which is quite surprising. until you're in that situation where you're so busy, you're doing you know long shifts, multi-day on call, and and you just don't have the time or the mental capacity to just get this thing done on your to-do list. Hopefully the numbers will inspire you to get that done a little bit faster. So Make sure you update your bank accounts and then make sure you also take a look at your expenses and make sure that the ones that are deductible are actually being deducted inside your corporation. And a good rule of thumb is if it takes money to make money, chances are that's gonna be a deductible expense that you can use to offset your taxes. okay, cool. And you know, what about getting things wrong? so we talked about a couple things that you can do right off the bat to save your money in inside the corporation. Let's just assume that's done. So now corporation has been set up, that's there, your money's being earned there, all that, all that is done correctly. The mistakes don't stop happening. now we want to talk about some bigger mistakes, which is the cash flow ones, which are gonna lead to our topic about salary versus dividends. So it's instead of just a concept, I kind of want to share some real world examples of some clients that we have and kind of what that looks like. So I'm gonna share my screen in a second here, but while I do that, Tyson, salary, dividends, what what are some kind of mistakes that that that we see our clients have or or people that that come to us for the first time that we're seeing from their cash flow from their professional corporation to their personal side. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I think people on a very simple level, a lot of newly incorporated professionals treat their professional corporation like their personal bank account. And we we have to have the understanding that it's a separate entity, like you were saying. Your company and your corporation is a separate person, a separate earning being, and there's you personally. And the monies are supposed to be separate. So it's very easy, line of sight. If you were to get audited, it's very obvious what is corporate and what is personal. and so we see personal spending coming out of corporate accounts sometimes, and vice versa. We see personal credit cards being used for business expenses, and that's fine, but your accountant might pull some hair out when they finally go back and do the bookkeeping and try and sort out what expense belongs where. And it it the small errors just end up costing the clients money in cleanup. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And that is the perfect segue where I want to actually share right here. So as a reminder for those of you that are not watching and you're listening, we'll we'll try and talk through it as well so you can understand what we're looking at. But for those of you being able to watch us on YouTube or Spotify video or whatever, here's some kind of quick examples here. So here Tyson nailed that that is the problem that we see more times than not is a disorganization of well, it's my money, it's it's all my money. It's one big pool of money. So it doesn't matter if I want to spend money, I'll just take from this account, move it over here, it's all good. It is all your money, but it's all taxed very differently. So the more money you pay in taxes by being disorganized or deviating from a plan, the less capital you have to work towards your goals, like early retirement, like buying a home. Like expanding your practice and anything else really in between. So it's very important to keep your cash in your pocket so you can, you know, use that and deploy that to accomplish your other goals via investing and other things. So here's an example strictly actually from one of our live clients that just wanted a screenshot. And this is a a snipshot of kind of how we organize our clients' finances because no one no one really does the Excel budgets anymore. I I think. That used to be the thing. You start off setting up a budget at the start of the year, you go to a coffee shop, have all these great intentions, and then you never look at it again. Instead of what we do is use some APIs and actually track this on a daily basis so we can see if our clients are spending more money than they should be, capture some issues before tax time, before the corporate year end, all that kind of fun stuff. So here's an example of one of our clients that is recovering from that problem that Tyson was just saying. Prior to working with us, they were just okay, well, it's all my money, I'm just gonna move it around. And what happened is they drew a really large shareholder loan that they had no idea how to get out of. And as a reminder, all of you, all of you are drawing a shareholder loan throughout the year. So anytime you move your money from your corporate account into your personal account, that is incurring a shareholder loan. So if you're doing $10,000 a month from corp to personal, You're building $120,000 in shareholder loans by the end of the calendar year. What happens in tax time is you're gonna declare and clear that shareholder loan by saying how much of the $120,000 was salary or dividends. And those are just different ways to pay yourselves. They're treated differently, they're taxed differently, all that kind of stuff. Oversimplification: salary has some other benefits, but you're gonna have to pay more on the personal side for that tax. And dividends is cheaper on the personal side, but you pay more tax on the corporate side. And you don't have other benefits like RSP room and CPP contributions and things like that. so that is a real big difference. And in Canada, we have a a tax system that is integrated. So whether you pay yourself salary or dividends, more or less, all the dollars are gonna end up being very similar because the way deductions work. but that's What's happening is all of you are drawing a shareholder loan. You're just gonna be declaring it and clearing it differently on an annual basis, unless you're like this client and many clients, to be honest, that come to us because they did a large draw, usually around a big time in their life, like buying a house or whatever it is, and they just haven't really recovered from it. So as per the income tax act, you're supposed to clear this in in basically two years. but sometimes it carries over and you need to Clear it. And the only way to clear it is to pay yourself more. The problem is you already pay yourself a lot. So you want to be in a high tax rate. And this is the problem that people endlessly fall into a high tax bill over and over and over again. So looking at the top here, this client so far in the year is at $287,000 of income. $287,000 of income. And of that, if you look at the second category right here, $216,000 of it is business income. So that is inside the corporation being taxed at the $11%. Tax rate. This client is in PC, but whatever province you're in, you're gonna be in that corporate tax rate. So of the 287, $216,000 of it is in the corporate side. You can see right here, $59,000 is a shareholder draw. So that is money that's moved from the corp account to the personal account for whatever reason, but that is drawing a shareholder loan, which is gonna have to be declared on tax time in April so far for $59,000. This client is usually doing about $100,000. $20,000 $130,000 a year is what their normal is, which kind of checks out that makes sense. So they're at $60,000 basically halfway through the year. So that all checks out. The problem though is because of last year, they had shareholder loans that they had to clear. So let's say you have an extra hundred thousand dollars in shareholder loans. How you're gonna clear that is basically adding another fifty thousand dollars of income onto your personal tax return for two years, and you'll be cleared. The problem with that is as you do that, you're drawing a bigger tax bill because in order to add the $50,000, you have to pay more tax. and to get that tax, usually it's not allocated in your cash flow. So sitting in your corporate account because it's all my money. Who cares? This is the problem you can see right here, is for an added expense, they've paid fifty-seven thousand dollars in personal taxes in this calendar year. It was for last year's tax bill, but it was paid in this year. So this client, and and some of you on the call, this was you, you may think, okay, I'm doing pretty good. I've only spent $59,000 so far this year. So I'm on track with my taxes. What you feel to see is you also have an additional $57,000 that's going to be added to your personal taxes. So you're already, you know, basically doubled up what you thought you've paid yourself, and you're already at about $120,000 on personal income, let alone what you end up spending the rest of the year. So, this is the problem that people run into is adding to the tax bill constantly. And if you do that over and over and over again, you run into big problems of an endless cycle of shareholder draw draws or endless cycle of dividends, not to add any other complexity that happened with big weddings or or house payments or whatever that may be. Another way to look at that is, and this is just a real world example, but another one to show you exactly what that looks like on a tax bill is Let's say that you have $190,000 is what you pay yourself. So you pay yourself $190,000 and you're just doing that by transferring money from the court to the personal side. And then come April, your accountant is like, hey, Tyson, you paid yourself $190K. at this point, you know, RSPCs have already passed. was right the the tail end of tax time. So we're gonna declare this, we're gonna clear your shareholder loan by paying $190,000 in dividends. You're okay, that sounds fine. It's it's less tax on the personal side than if I had to do a salary. But you know, it's it's still gonna cost forty-four thousand dollars and change in tax. So for you to get 190K clear for insurance loan, you're gonna pay a dividend of 44 and change. So that's really gonna bring your overall tax situation to sixty-eight thousand dollars. Some of it will be pushed on to the next year, but this is your real cost. And if you keep doing that over and over and over and over and over and over again, you're gonna be a caughtless sorry, constant cycle of trying to clear shoulder loan by adding to your tax bill. And if you have lifestyle inflation, it's gonna make the problem even worse. So this is the problem that a lot of people are running into that we want to help you get ahead of and start to solve. But a lot of you on this call watching or listening are probably nodding your head like, yeah, that that sounds right. That sounds my exact problem. because this is what we see constantly on a on a day-to-day basis when new clients are coming to us is it's a shareholder loan and his cash flow is a constant problem because you made a mistake once and then it's so hard to get on board with clearing a shareholder loan by paying everything out in one year and pay 53% tax. that's that's a hard pill to swallow. So what happens is you try and break it up over several years and then you keep writing the same issue over and over and over again. So if it sounds like you, I know it sucks, I know it stings, but it's not just you. A lot of your colleagues deal with the same problems over and over again. And we're going to talk about some ways to fix that. But before we keep going, Tyson, anything to add here? Tyson Nagasaka: when we talk to some of our accounting partners, we do have some clients that run a perpetual shareholder loan balance. It is a debit balance that exists and some clients feel like they're getting away with something, and the accountant always is addressing the risk in that the the risk is you could be audited at any moment and be forced to pay that all back now. Which means depleting corporate dollars or registered accounts or something to pay this tax bill. So you gotta raise capital somehow. so ignoring the problem doesn't make it go away. And sometimes I know we're gonna talk about how to how to clear this and what that might look like, but sometimes what we look at is maybe you spend less for a year or two and clear these debit balances, clear the budget up, or maybe you you know, tackle with one of the other solutions. But definitely something that we see. You don't want to be in a position where you're running an endless perpetual debit balance for risk of being audited and then getting a bill to say, pay now. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And you know, that's that's kind of a a a quick thing that we can talk about some overarching strategies. And I think on an another episode we'll do a full episode on the actual hard numbers of ways to solve your shareholder loan. but a couple of things that we look at for our clients is again, this all depends on what assets you have and what your situation is. But let's say you do have a shareholder loan that you're trying to get out ahead of and it's just it's a tough thing. Let's say it's I don't know, let's say it's three hundred thousand dollars, four hundred thousand dollars, whatever that may be. Tyson's right. If you get audited, then you have to be ready to get a massive tax bill in that in that year. Or you try and get it solve it, or you look at some creative ways to solve it. And some creative ways to solve it is if you have a primary residence, or let's say have a home that has a lot of extra value in it. So you owe, I don't know, $700,000 on the property, but it's worth like $1.4. You have some equity in the home. One thing you could do is. Borrow more from your home and then send it back to your corporation to clear that shareholder loan. The thing to keep in mind is you're gonna be paying a higher mortgage payment, obviously. So if you're taking on more debt, you have to pay more of a mortgage payment. And that's gonna increase your cash flow that you take from the corp on the personal side. But what will happen is you'll have a larger lump sum of money that's gonna sit into the corporate account that you can start to invest. And those returns can help you mitigate that extra cash flow. If you're doing a comprehensive solution to your investments with let's just say it's four hundred thousand dollars, you take 400k from your primary residence, you send it back to your corporation, clear the shareholder loan, now you have 400k cash in your corp, start to invest it, and over time you start to create CDA room by you know capital gains harvesting and things of that type. you'll you'll end up having a bunch of different avenues to solve that problem without trying to get too complicated. you can always tell what I'm talking about. I'm trying to stop myself from going too far into the weeds. I have a bit of hesitation when I'm talking, but that's one option you could do to solve that shareholder loan is borrow money from real estate. It's not taxable on the personal side, send it back to your corporation. You'll have to keep in mind the potential risk of a floating interest rate. so what if interest rates go up? What if interests go down? down is great, but what if it goes up really is is what's gonna potentially hurt you. but as long as you're investing that money inside the corporation, it can allow you to do some some cool and creative things. capital gains harvesting is a great example that you could open up CDA room. you can utilize that later on in retirement to send money from the court to the personal side, pay off your your mortgage. there's a bunch of different ways you could do so. That's one solution you could do with that. besides the other ones of just paying yourself better and things of that type. But that's just one example. cool. Another example is really just to pay yourself properly and get ahead of it. So by doing proper cash flow, this is one thing that'll not only help you recover from a shareholder loan, but more importantly, prevent a shareholder loan from ever happening. And that is where you want to be. for those of you that are early on in your career and you haven't ran into a shareholder loan problem yet, that is fantastic. We want to make sure that you never run into a shareholder problem. so cash flow is key. So, how are you paying yourself on the personal side? How much are you paying yourself? and that that is always a question that gets kicked around a lot. Like what is kind of the magic number? we have our thoughts on it, but Tiza, maybe start us off with like what's our kind of ideal number that you really want to start to look to pay yourself for our clients like in that in that professional doctor space? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, well, a lot of this is dependent on lifestyle demand and what are they what are they spending. So we do have some clients that are extremely high earning and they're very low expense. very low expense. And so that that is great, but you you know, you're allowed to spend you are allowed to spend some money. It's good for the economy. but one of the ones that we're talking about, especially once we get into blending of salary and dividends, which is usually where the magic happens. exactly what you're pointing at here. We're looking at about $186,000, $187,000 of salary. And then the rest is dividend out. It could be you can consider it a bonus, you can consider it extra money. and the reason that we like the the what's called the YMPE, the yearly maximum pension pensionable earning. It's it's gonna hit all the the markers and the levels. It's gonna give you RRSP contribution room, it's gonna maximize CPP contributions. and if you are 45 and older, individual pension plan IPP might become a strategy that you want to take advantage of. Your actuary and your accountant will thank you for paying yourself salary. it does go to contributing to your ability to fund. your IPP fund, which I do talk about a lot and we won't talk about it on this episode, but that's where that blend of salary and dividend really, really starts to shine is the registered account room. It opens up for you. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. and I really like this number. Like obviously it's not a guarantee for every single one of our clients, but if we were going to give you a ballpark of what the vast majority of our clients that are very successful with their cash flow, working towards their goals, you know, really not exposing themselves to these these these risks and and these issues, it it's it's about $187,000 is is really the number, the magic number that we see for a couple of reasons that Tyson just mentioned. But I'm a I'm a big fan of CPP. level one. So there's two levels of CPP. There's the the upper ceiling or CPP two. but I think the first level of CPP is beneficial. It's a you know source of income that is indexed to inflation, which is great. So as you get older and and the reality is people of a higher income level tend to live a longer life because you have better nutrition, better, you know Hobbies, you have more cash to be able to do more things that will increase your life expectancy. As long as you're good vices, not bad vices. But Tyson Nagasaka: Correct. Vishal Gill, CFP: I guess there are people that have a lot of money that have bad vices, but that's not you guys on this call. So usually we have to keep in mind that a longer than regular life expectancy is a potential. So having a source of income that's indexed to inflation is really beneficial for you. and CPP gives you that. CPP two will run to a problem where you might have too much earned income and retirement. And then between that and your RSP that turns into a RIF and any other dividends that you have from your corporation, you might be in the same marginal tax rate, if not higher, than you were when you're working. And then that's all pointless. It doesn't make any sense. But CPP level one is great. also a big believer of opening up our RSP room, because understanding as a professional corporation, for the most part, you have to have all of your Corporate money onto the personal side at some point, whether you're alive or when you're dead, that money has to come to the personal side. If you just defer it forever inside your corporation, you're exposing yourself to double taxation. Or if it spent a lot of money on like pipeline strategies or carry loss backs and things of that type to be able to solve that problem, versus an RRSP is a free area to solve that problem. Because again, Canada has an integrated tax. So salary or dividends, your overall tax is more or less the same. But if you can pay yourself differently and open up RSP room, which is free to open up, you can invest your money in there. It's going to be growing. Apologies, I'm trying not to lose my voice, but it'll be growing tax deferred. it doesn't cost you anything to keep open up your account or open up the room. It's just the way that you're declaring your your taxes and it compounds tax deferred. All that is great. So if you can get that. And CPP for just paying yourself $187,000 of let's say your $250K that you use for your lifestyle expenses. Of the $250,000 you're putting on paper that $187 of that is going to be T4 or salary. You're going to open up the max RSP room that you can use, and you're going to open up CPP room that you'll use later on in life as well. And also keeping in mind that your RSP room, you will have a once you build a financial plan, you will have a hard stop on your RSP because we want to. kind of look at all your expected income in retirement. And all of you will have a hard stop number at your RSP because you don't want to get bigger than that because by the time you switch it to a RIF, you're gonna be all your sources of income in the same marginal tax rate as you were while you're working. That doesn't make sense. You want to make sure you have a hard stop. So opening up your RSP room is beneficial. At some point you may run into the issue that your advisor tells you, okay, RSPs are done. that doesn't make sense for you anymore. So now we're just gonna do dividends and and whatever and that that's fine. But for the early years, you should open up your RSP because the compounding effects are so beneficial for you when you're young, as opposed to what we see a lot of times when clients first come to us, they're just doing dividends because they don't no one's ever told them anything. And they only start doing RSPs to try and open up RSP room later on in life, but you're losing so much compound growth. so doing it early on or in your you know main income earning years is so, so, so beneficial. So really like the 187 number. and again, the reason why we don't want to get higher is you don't really benefit from doing CPP2. even if you first level of CPP ends up pushing you a bit over some clawbacks and thresholds, you can always donate some of your CPP benefits in the future. So that's fine. so that's all great. The one thing to keep in mind with salary is as you declare this in salary, you need to make sure that you have the cash on the personal side to pay this tax bill. So we like doing installments. we like building it into the cash flow. So for those of you that are gonna be looking to do something like this, make sure you bake it into your your cash flow of if you need you know, whatever $250,000, make sure you have the consideration of how much personal tax will have to be paid because if you're doing $187, it's gonna incur more tax that has to be paid on the personal side. So you want make sure that's already part of your plan to have that personally and just send it in the solvents to the CRA so you're not shocked at the end of each tax year. so you're not running into shareholder local problems where you spent that money. Okay, I gotta pay that tax, I'm gonna dividend it out to myself. And now you're adding that into 2027 taxes, the 2028 taxes, and running into a problem. Just make sure that you have a good plan in place to earn this money, pay your installments on the personal side, and then you're not gonna be shocked. Come tax time, but you are gonna open up the RSP room and you are gonna open up CPP for you know just paying yourself on paper a little bit different, which is great. On that point, passive income. So when we talk about corporate rates, corporates are all great, and we have here at the bottom: if you're BC, 11%, Ontario 12.2%, and Alberta, 9%. so that's all great because all the money, let's say you're earning $300,000, you pay yourself $250, $187 is going to be on salary, the rest is gonna be dividends. You still have a big surplus of money sitting inside your corporation. so anytime we talk about corporations, we should always talk about. the small business rate and the passive tax grind. So I know we talked about that before, but Tyson, maybe you know, you want to chat about it again. What is a small passive problem that professional corporations in particular can run into an issue with? Tyson Nagasaka: I'm sorry, so you you want me to talk about what is small business deduction grind and how does that impact? Okay. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: so small business deduction grind happens when you have what's called non-active income or or passive income in your corporation, sometimes called II A I I, it's aggregate investment income. When you're doing when you're doing the business of the business, it's taxed at the general rates, whether you get the small business deduction rate, and then past that you get the general tax rate inside your corporation. But when you're doing other things, so if you have a portfolio that pays interest and dividends, if you have rental real estate, if you have other holdings inside your corporation that erode the small business deduction limit, because They are now exceeding $50,000 of passive income, it does become something that you want to be aware of. Now, your small business deduction limit will be ground down $5 for every $1 of passive income that you earn. We want to be aware of that because when you're earning a hundred thousand dollars passively in your in your corporation. It's affecting the tax, the small tax rate on your first five hundred thousand dollars of earnings. So for a lot of our doctor or professional clients, if you're earning six hundred thousand dollars in your corporation, the first five hundred thousand dollars tax at eleven percent, that small tax rate, that small corporate tax rate, that's huge. That's really beneficial. Otherwise, you're paying tax at twenty seven percent, which is the general rate. And so we're losing that, That really nice, comfortable, small tax limit. And those passive ingredients that we have invested under our corporate umbrella are starting to erode that. And there's ways to deal with that. But really, it's a thing to monitor. And it's definitely a question that we want to ask of why are we holding real estate in our corporation? Why are we holding this in our corporation or that in a corporation? There's ways that you can invest that. defer that or we can c have mechanisms of control, but it's definitely something to be aware of because again, kind of like the theme of this episode is not paying attention to the details. takes away some of our really nice perks and benefits. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep, love that. And the reason why I wanted to share this is sometimes people will have this thought. Okay, so I'm earning extra money in my corporation. okay, Michelle, I agree. $187,000. I'm gonna do that as a salary to give myself 33 and change in RSP room that we'll use over time. That sounds fantastic. But you know, I still have the rest of the the money I I need personally. Instead of adding it to my own taxable income, I'll pass it over to my spouse or my kids and you know, we'll just split the income and then that way our overall tax inside our household is cheaper. yes, no is at our side. let's talk about Tozi. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. I remember being in the industry about 10 years ago, and the tax rules changed, and this was a big, big deal. There was something that was called income sprinkling. So you used to be able to run your practice and have your wife do the bookkeeping or take out the garbage, and you can have your kids do the shredding, and you can pay them 20 grand a year, you know, and like they're 12 and 15 years old, you're paying them a small salary because technically they would be at a very, very low tax threshold, and it would be a way for you to get money out of your corporation at a much lower tax threshold than if you were paying yourself $187,000 a year. CRA clamped down on that. They created something that, or they really started enforcing something. It was called tax on split income or TOSI. And they really want to. Create environment where you could be accountable and auditable for your actions in and around the business. So if you are a doctor and you are incorporated and you want your wife to get paid a salary, she has to be able to prove that she's working in the business or vice versa. We actually have a lot of female doctors that are clients. And so if your husband wants to take a salary from the business or get paid dividends somehow, they have to prove that. He is working somehow in the business legitimately logged hours every week, just like going to a job. You can't get mailed a paycheck just because you know, you have the same last name. and so that was really CRA's effort to clamp down on this loophole that was there to allow you to pay money out at a lower tax bracket to another member of your family. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, and you know, section one twenty in the income tax act one twenty point four is really hard on professionals. reason being is Tulsi is the overarching rule, and there's a couple things you can do to be on side. one of the best ways to be on side is shares. So if someone owns more than 10% of the shares of a corporation. You can give them dividends and and it makes sense. The problem with professionals, like you know, those of you on this call is college rules. You can't have someone who's not a doctor own shares of any type of, you know, doctor course. So whether it's an OD, dentist, physician, whatever. so that that kind of shuts that off for you. So, what are some ways that you can legitimately split income? Because the idea is sound, it makes sense. Instead of putting 250 in only my hands, why don't I split that 250 between myself and my wife? And then both at a lower marginal tax rate, and then our overall tax situation will be more favorable. There's a couple ways that you can do it as a professional corporation. And one of them is to nice point, if you have an active spouse. So again, those of you that are watching on YouTube or Spotify video, you can see this guide. For the other ones we'll we'll try and walk you through here. So one of the areas that you can do it is if you have an active spouse for a child that is working 20 plus hours a week proven inside the clinic. Doing legitimate work for either it has to be an average. So it's not to be exactly 20 hours if they are, you know, heavy on the first half of the year and then a little bit later on the back half of the year. As long as it's averaging 20 plus hours a week, that's great. and it can be in this year or the past five years, then that is onside with Tossi and you can split income and just make sure you consult your your accountant to make sure this all works, but then you can legitimately split income and that's all great. For the most part. You have to have a reasonable return. And this is the second area right here, which is an inactive spouse. so this means inactive that they're not on average 20 plus hours a week. So they're infrequently employed. examples that we've seen with our clients would be spouses that help with you know, business strategy or could be cleaning or admin or MOAs or whatever. so they're inactive spouse, meaning that they're working. in the clinic, but l not more than an average of twenty plus hours a week. And you can only give them a reasonable return. So let's say they're doing some social media for your your practice and your clinic and you're paying them a hundred K in in dividends. That's not a reasonable return. So the problem is if you do get audited and that's always a problem with everything, you can roll the dice, but if you get audited, you know, there's there's penalties that come with that. and what happens is you're gonna be taxed at the highest marginal tax rate. So The problem is you roll the dice for let's say you you pay your kid $100,000 for doing some social media posts, like two posts a week or something like that. and then you're like, okay, perfect, 100K will be taxed in their hands, and then I'll just use it to fund my household expenses. The 100K will be taxed at the highest marginal tax rate back to you or attributed back to you. and the problem with that is that the highest tax rate, you're paying $53,000 in taxes for trying to navigate this and pay this kid way more than they deserved, way more that was reasonable. So for the 100K, your your penalty will be paying the highest marginal tax rate, which is $53,000 in taxes, let alone whatever your other tax bill is going to be. So you don't want to do that. What is legitimate though is if you pay them a reasonable return. So if they are doing MOA work, you can pay them industry average for an MOA. If they're doing janitorial work, you can do that. Social media work, you can do that. Like all they're allowed to work inside your clinic and you're allowed to pay them for working inside the clinic. It just has to be reasonable. so that is all fine to do. One of the best things is we often talk to our clients about treating your corp like an unlimited RRSP. So you pay the small business limit. You can invest that money. We can navigate on the passive income tax, and that's all that's all good. but eventually you will retire. or you might semi-retire. So a lot of our clients don't actually retire. They just Tyson calls it preferment. So they work when they want to, not when they have to. So as long as you're over age 65, you can always split your income. with even with the inactive spouse. So if You're over 65, you're both 66 now. you can actually continue to earn your income. So you can still practice, still earn a high income, and then you can split that right away down the middle. So if you needed $300,000 of personal income, you could do $150, $150, that's on side, no to see, no concerns, you're good to go there. Which is great. So it's a great planning tool when it comes to retirement. Of let's say we map out your retirement, you're opening up RSP room throughout your working years. You're investing inside your corporation. We're opening up CDA room. You have all these different levers you're using to deplete the excess funds inside your corporation. So you're not trapped with so much money inside your corporation. You can really enter retirement in a lucrative way. And then whatever excess money you want to earn, you can split that down the middle, 50 50 with you and your spouse, even if they're inactive, so long as you guys are over age 65 and you can still be working. So that's great. And then children under 18 is almost never on side. So that was Tyson's point. That's how it used to be back in the days. Everyone had their kids part of the corporation, everyone's getting 50K, 50K, 50K, and the parent was taking all that money. that is not gonna happen anymore. So just know that you run that risk of TOSI, which is gonna hit you with the highest marginal tax rate attributed back to you. So if you try and give 50k to your kid, you'll get 50k taxed at that 53% rate, which obviously hurts you a significant amount of money. So it's it's not great to do. so just make sure that if you are trying to split income, if it's part of your strategy, or if you're just doing it because you saw a post about it one time or s a colleague told you about it one time that they did it or they used to do it, especially if they used to do it, that's a big one that we see because things have changed from the older you know, colleagues to the the younger generation. Things are very, very different. Here are some ways that are legitimate and here's some ways that are not legitimate. So feel free to take a screenshot of this one. But yeah, if you have an active spouse that's working more than twenty hours a week on average, they're active, you can split income. if you have an inactive spouse so they do infrequent work, it has to make sure it's reasonable. If you have an inactive spouse and you guys are over the age of sixty five, all good, you can split your income and that's no problem. And just make sure that's part of your plan and staying on side. anything to add there before we wrap up on that point. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, it used to be an incentive to have lots of kids. And you know, now we don't have that incentive anymore. Vishal Gill, CFP: Exactly. That's what changed is like they got rid of Toasty and all of a sudden you see people like, Yeah, it's all good. I'm not gonna have kids anymore. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, what are these kids for? Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, exactly. Exactly. So yeah, I mean that that's basically yeah. I think we wanna kinda wanna stop there and just kinda summarize some the the main points. at the end of the day, a lot of you are going to pay tax, inevitably. What you don't want to do is be, you know, not open to the available strategies that are there for you to keep more of your money. If you keep more of your money, you can invest it. If you can invest it, you can open more CDA room. If you do that, you can deplete your corporation when it comes time to retirement. So you're not Stuck with double taxation of all those retained money inside your corporation. we talked briefly about one strategy of how to clear your shareholder loan. If you have real estate on the personal side that has equity, you can move that over to the the corporation to clear the shareholder loan, understanding that your mortgage payments will be higher, but you have a bigger lump sum to invest. And depending on what your strategy is on that side, that can make sense. but one of the biggest things to do is prevent the shareholder loan from happening by making sure that you're practicing sound cash flow management. So Keeping track of your expenses, allocating some money on the personal side, earmarked for that tax bill if you're not surprised by it, and then running into a shareholder loan over and over and over again. And then if you are starting to incorporate, make sure that you avoid the common mistakes that we see when clients first come to us, which is, hey, I'm incorporated, but I didn't actually switch over my billing. So all my money is still being taxed on the personal side. and then not moving your expenses or keeping track of your expenses on the corporate side as well, because that can be eleven hundred dollars easy on ten thousand dollars of expenses that you're missing. and I think I hit all the points. I don't know if I missed anything there, Tyson. Tyson Nagasaka: No, I think you hit them all. I think one of the the tales of caution that that we've said here before and we say it in a lot of our our meetings and webinars is knowing all of this is great and implementing strategy is great, but don't let the tax tale wag the dog. As some advisors, whether they're financial advisors or tax advisors, they set up the entire financial plan based on tax. Well, we also take into account what your lifestyle goals are. What are we trying to accomplish? Do you want to enjoy your money? do you want to wait till age 65 to start living or do you want to live now? And so it's it's a blend and a balance of all of these factors, and it's okay to pay some tax. we don't want you to overpay, but it's okay to pay some tax along the way, and we'll we'll help devise strategies to do that, minimize on some fronts, but really the main goal is to have a good life. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, perfectly said. And understanding that again, it's an integrated tax in in Canada. So everyone that's listening to this is is gonna be incorporated or is incorporated. so really the it's not like you're paying more tax. It just depends where you're paying that tax from. if you are someone who doesn't keep a lot of reserves on the personal side, you're probably doing dividends because you want to pay little tax as possible, but then you're taking more dividends to pay that personal tax. but if you're someone that's ahead of it, it's you have those reserves on the process side as part of your budget, part your cash flow. and and then it's all good. But you know, we kind of talked about our kind of magic number, which we really like, is like the 180 and change on paying yourself personally via salary, because you're opening up up RSP room, you're opening up CPP contributions, and that's all great. So you're opening up revenues in the future and by just papering things differently and just having a strategy as opposed to just being reactive to taxes. So I like that saying what was that? Don't let the tax tail wig the dog. What did you say? Tyson Nagasaka: Don't let the tack's tail wag the dog, yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: Well, I I I thought I butchered it, but yeah, I guess I got it right. So that that's fantastic. I like that. I've never heard that before. but yeah, so hopefully by the end of the episode, this is gonna give you some good clarity on how to save money or stop bleeding money. hopefully you can use these cautionary tales of you know, truthfully colleagues of yours that that that we've seen that we've worked with, that we've helped solve these problems, but it takes you know, a few years to get ahead of it and and and stop the bleeding. Hopefully you can use these cautionary tales to prevent that from happening into your own situation. And if you're on this, listen to this and you're thinking, damn, this all sounds complicated. Like it's one of those classic things that we can give you all the answers, but it doesn't mean you can implement it. If need help understanding, you know, what is your perfect blend, what is your RSP limit, what is like all these things that we talked about, feel free to book a free consultation with us. Our our link is always in the show notes. and or just reach out. We know we're available on social media and a lot of you will probably see us at your association events or universities and things of that type as well. But ask away. I I think ask the questions that are relevant for you. because if you sit around and waiting on theory too long while you're still running into the same issues of shareholder loans over and over and over again, you're just making your problem bigger. And the longer that sits there, the longer potential it is for the C A to eventually come knocking and audit you. And now you gotta do a knee jerk payment on on everything and and that can really, really hurt. So Hopefully that never happens to you. and if you want to get ahead of it, feel free to reach out to us. But besides that, if this gave you a lot of value, which we hope it did, we're we're hoping that this episode is gonna be, you know, well received, a little bit more technical than we usually do. We like to talk more conceptual. And I think on further episodes, we'll do a bit of both. We'll do some episodes that are more conceptual, less numbers heavy. We'll do some episodes that are a little bit more numbers heavy and into the weeds. If this was too much for you, all good. Or feel some episodes in the future are gonna be a little bit easier. And if this was exactly what you'd like to see, awesome, subscribe and we're gonna have some more than coming out like that as well. and as always, if you have more questions, we have our Facebook group that's available to doctors across Canada. You can join that, ask questions, and we can carry the conversation on there. But besides that, make sure you subscribe so you don't miss another episode. I will be back in a couple weeks, and hopefully by then you'll be on the path to saving more money in your taxes. By having a better shareholder loan strategy going forward. So hopefully you guys have a great day, and we'll see you on the next episode.