Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / The Most Remarkable American Most People Have Never Heard Of
Transcript
- 0:01Say free the Thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule,
- 0:13rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Said Andrews.
- 0:56I'm going to start with a quote, all right, and I'm not
- 0:59going to tell you who said this, but I read it for the first
- 1:03time a few days ago, snapshot at it, posted it on my social
- 1:07media pages. It says this quote, when I became convinced that the universe
- 1:12is natural, that all the ghosts and gods are myths, there entered into
- 1:19my brain, into my soul, into every drop of my blood, the
- 1:23sense, the feeling, the joy of freedom. The walls of my prison
- 1:27crumbled and fell. The dungeon was flooded with light, and all the bolts
- 1:33and bars and manacles became dust. I was no longer a servant to serve
- 1:38for a slave. There was for me no master in all the wide world,
- 1:42not even in infinite space. I was free, free to think,
- 1:48to express my thoughts, free to live in my own ideal, Free to
- 1:52live for myself and those I loved, Free to use all my faculties,
- 1:57all my senses, free to spread imagination's wings, free to investigate, to
- 2:05guests and dream and hope, Free to judge and determine for myself, Free
- 2:09to reject all ignorant and cruel creeds, all the quote unquote inspired books that
- 2:16savages have produced, and all the barbarous legends of the past. Free from
- 2:22all the called and set apart, free from sanctified mistakes and holy lies,
- 2:29free from the fear of eternal pain, free from the winged monsters of the
- 2:35night, free from devils, ghosts, and gods. For the first time,
- 2:39I was free. There were no prohibited places in all the realms of
- 2:46thought. No air, no space where fancy could not spread her painted wings.
- 2:52No chains for my limbs, no lashes for my back, no fires
- 2:57for my flesh. No masters round or threat, no following another steps,
- 3:04no need to bow or cringe or crawl or utter lying words. I was
- 3:08free. I stood erect and fearlessly, joyously faced all worlds. And then
- 3:17my heart was filled with gratitude, with thankfulness, and went out in love
- 3:23to all the heroes, the thinkers who gave their lives for the liberty of
- 3:28hand and brain, to all the wise, the good, the brave of
- 3:31every land, whose thoughts and deeds have given freedom to the sons of men.
- 3:38And then I vowed to grasp the torch that they had held and hold
- 3:43it high that light might conquer darkness. Still, I posted this quote on
- 3:51my social media wall, and I said, he gets me, because I
- 3:54feel the same way. You know, coming out of a high control religion.
- 3:59I was scared at first, but then I felt freedom. I felt
- 4:01the oxygen. You know. I wasn't controlled, no gods, no masters.
- 4:05Right. I get to discover every day and I get to take ownership
- 4:09and agency of my own life. And I felt like this quote encapsulated so
- 4:14poetically much of that. And it wasn't written last week, and it wasn't
- 4:17written fifteen years ago by one of the quote unquote new atheist. And I'm
- 4:21going to get back to that. It was written by a man who was
- 4:25born in eighteen thirty three. He was nicknamed the Great Agnostic. He was
- 4:30an attorney, son of a preacher, and perhaps one of the greatest writers
- 4:34and speakers of the last how many hundred years. Robert Green Ingersaul who has
- 4:43been called the most remarkable American most people never heard of. You know,
- 4:49I hear people talk about the new atheist, and for those who don't know
- 4:53what that is, fifteen or so years ago we saw a resurgence in conversations
- 4:57about atheism, and we saw it was a Dawkin Hitchens, Sam Harris,
- 5:00and Daniel Dennett right dubbed the Four Horsemen by somebody, and their books and
- 5:06debates and speeches and all of those high profile efforts that were going on became
- 5:14headline news, and the national and international conversation about non belief, atheism,
- 5:18religious criticism, et cetera kind of surge during that time. And so I
- 5:24think when people talk about the new atheists, they may be trying to chapterize
- 5:29that particular cultural moment. But I've said this before, and I've used angersall
- 5:34as an example, and George Bernard Shaw and Bertrand Russell and Mark Twain and
- 5:41even some of the founding fathers. What these quote unquote new atheists were saying
- 5:46was compelling, and much of their writings changed my life. Some of those
- 5:50debates and speeches propelled me forward on my journey. I'm not negating the power
- 5:56of it, but what they were saying was not new, not really.
- 6:04These were not the first people in challenging highly religious cultures to go hard at
- 6:10religion, superstition, high control, fundamental cultures. These people were out there
- 6:15on the front lines. I was given the honor of being the keynote speaker
- 6:19at the Robert green Ingersoll Birthplace Museum's thirtieth anniversary. Why they invited me,
- 6:26I have no idea, because I'm not a great mind, but I was
- 6:32affected by his work, and so they brought me out to sort of cap
- 6:39the day. And it was a charming, amazing, wonderful day. We're
- 6:43all outside, crammed under this ten seventy five degrees, and all of a
- 6:46sudden, the thunder and the rainstorms move in and we're all huddled underneath.
- 6:50And yet we pressed on and the rains cleared, and everybody left encouraged.
- 6:55I think we all just had a tremendous time. But It was also an
- 6:59education for me about Ingersol beyond what I already knew, and I'd kind of
- 7:03want to introduce you to the writings. And I brought some great quotes,
- 7:08some excerpts from some of the stuff this guy had said in his life that
- 7:12I think could have been written last night. And I'm like, how much
- 7:16has not changed about the world we live in? The fanatics have always been
- 7:21around. The high control, god invoking, Bible thumping moralist have always been
- 7:28around Robert Green Ingersoll. He was born the eleventh of August eighteen thirty three.
- 7:34His dad was a minister. He was a preacher for the Congregationalist Church.
- 7:41This is a pretty fundy church. They had a lot of Calvinistic influences,
- 7:46you know, a lot of self flagellation going on and Bible literalism going
- 7:49on. But not John. John Ingersoll is up there from the podium,
- 7:54and he was in many ways kind of preaching humanism. Right. It's funny
- 7:58we see this a lot as pastors and reverends and whatnot to become more and
- 8:03more egalitarian and humanitarian, they preach a little less Bible and a little more
- 8:07humanity. And I think that's what John Ingersoll was doing and the clerics freaked,
- 8:13this man is not preaching our doctrine. And some of these churches actually
- 8:18held trials. In fact, there was a famous trial in Madison, Ohio.
- 8:22Or the church put him on trial and it ended his career as a
- 8:28pastor. They said, well, you're a good guy, you might even
- 8:30be a good Christian, but you are not a proper minister. You're not
- 8:33preaching the correct things, and so you're out. And I wonder if John's
- 8:39son, Robert green Ingersoll, kind of watched the treatment of his dad,
- 8:41how he was vilified and kind of tardan feathered in that way, and that
- 8:46maybe propelled him on his journey to become a rationalist and a critic of the
- 8:52church. I'm going to spare you most of the biography, which you can
- 8:54look up for yourself, but just the basics. Robert Green Ingersoll became a
- 9:00lawyer. He once defended a guy who had been accused of the crime of
- 9:05blasphemy. And if you didn't think America had blasphemy laws, yes we did.
- 9:11The year was eighteen eighty seven. The accused guy was a man named
- 9:15Charles B. Reynolds, and he was an ex vangelical, he left the
- 9:20faith and became a vocal critic of his former religion. And doesn't that sound
- 9:26familiar right to me? And you and a lot of us aren't there.
- 9:30Okay. So he's going from town to town, city to city, and
- 9:33he's talking about state church separation. Enough of this Christian nationalism cramp. This
- 9:41is improper, it's not equal, it's unconstitutional. By the way, the
- 9:45Bible is a contradictory, immoral, intolerant, error filled mess. So he's
- 9:54going around saying, we got to separate the state and the church, and
- 9:58the Bible is crap. And the churches in the cities in which he put
- 10:01up his tent to speak lost it. There were organized efforts by Baptist churches,
- 10:07Methodist churches, Catholic churches. They would launch whole campaigns. They would
- 10:11go to the tents and they would shout him down. They threw food at
- 10:13the guy, they chopped down his tent ropes, and so the whole tent
- 10:18would collapse upon everybody, and they'd steal what was underneath. And sometimes Charles
- 10:22Reynolds had to grab his wife and kids and they had to run for their
- 10:26lives. It was the satanic panic, not of the nineteen eighties, but
- 10:31of the eighteen eighties. And the reason that Charles Reynolds was brought up on
- 10:37trial is because New Jersey actually had a blasphemy law, had a blasphemy statute.
- 10:43You could be fined for blasphemy about two hundred bucks, which is today's
- 10:48equivalent of sixty four hundred dollars, So they could find you over sixth grand,
- 10:54and they might put you in jail for a year. God will not
- 11:00be mocked. And yet there was that pain in the ass Charles Reynolds going
- 11:05from city to city, town to town, putting up his tents and speaking
- 11:09heresy, and handing out these pamphlets that dared to say that the Bible is
- 11:16not inerrant, it has errors in it, blasphemy. This must be brought
- 11:24before a judge and jury. And there in the courtroom, representing Charles Reynolds
- 11:30would be the great agnostic Robert Green Ingersoll. And Ingersoll didn't call any defense
- 11:37witnesses, no character witnesses, nothing like that. Ingersoll's whole defense was he
- 11:43stood up and he gave a three hour speech. And this guy could give
- 11:48one hell of a speech, and he talked about the merits and importance of
- 11:52protected blasphemy, and I've got a blasphemy quote from him coming up in just
- 12:01a few that's just awesome. So he goes up and he gave this amazing
- 12:05speech, but it was not enough. The jury came back with a guilty
- 12:11verdict. Still, I think because Ingersoll's words had been so powerful, and
- 12:16because this whole trial was just getting blasted by the newspapers who called it a
- 12:20circus. This is just crazy, right. They gave Charles Reynolds a slap
- 12:24on the wrist, a very very very small fine, which Ingersol himself paid,
- 12:30and except for one case in Maine that happened in the early nineteen hundreds,
- 12:33that was the last trial against criminal blasphemy in the United States of America.
- 12:41Just changed the game, it changed the culture, and this trial is
- 12:46a landmark court case. It's often cited by historians when they talk about blasphemy
- 12:52laws here in the United States. Robert Ingersoll joined the Union Army afterward became
- 12:58Illinois Attorney General. Politics was going to be a problem for him, because
- 13:03you know, he was an agnostic and he hated slavery, and he thought
- 13:07that women ought to be treated and held in regard and paid equally. And
- 13:13he also said that gods were the phantoms of the fearful, the weapons of
- 13:18the bigots and the privileged powerful. Oh hell no, he was not ever
- 13:24going to be elected to high office with that attitude. His birthplace in Dresden,
- 13:30New York, the house which I was honored to a visit and tour,
- 13:33has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places. I believe it's
- 13:39open every weekend if you are in the area. Now, let's imagine this
- 13:46guy who died of a heart attack in eighteen ninety nine. Let's say he
- 13:50was here right now in twenty twenty three. I would bet that if he
- 13:56looked around, he would go and dig out some of his old material,
- 13:58help all of his old material from the eighteen hundreds, and it would stick
- 14:03like glue to the stuff that you and I are seeing right now. He
- 14:09looks around today at the Bible banging, Satanic panickers, the Christian nationalists,
- 14:15the bigots, the zealots, and then he reads aloud what he wrote in
- 14:20eighteen eighty one. He says, whoever imagines himself a favorite of God holds
- 14:26other people in contempt. Whenever a man believes that he has the exact truth
- 14:33from God. There is in that man no spirit of compromise. He has
- 14:37not the modesty born of the imperfections of human nature. He has the arrogance
- 14:45of theological certainty, and the tyranny born of ignorant assurance. Believing himself to
- 14:50be the slave of God, he imitates his master. And of all tyrants,
- 14:56the worst is a slave power state church separation. This is Ingersol eighteen
- 15:05seventy three quote. The Declaration of Independence announces the sublime truth that all power
- 15:11comes from the people. This was a denial, and the first denial of
- 15:16a nation, of the infamous dogma that God confers the right upon one man
- 15:22to govern others. Six years after that, Ingersol said this, it probably
- 15:30will not be long until the churches will divide as sharply upon political as upon
- 15:35theological questions. And when that day comes, if there are not liberals enough
- 15:41to hold the balance of power, this government will be destroyed. The liberty
- 15:46of man is not safe in the hands of any church. This statement published
- 15:56in eighteen ninety two. I will not attack your doctrines nor your creeds if
- 16:00they accord liberty to me, if they hold thought to be dangerous. If
- 16:06they aver that doubt is a crime, then I attack them one and all
- 16:11because they enslave the minds of men. I would love to have seen Robert
- 16:18Ingersoll go toe to toe with the apologists. These people who are speaking in
- 16:25defense of the faith, whether it's in a church or in a debate setting,
- 16:30are on Twitter or ax or whatever we're supposed to call it. Right,
- 16:34the people that were saying the Bible is still a good book, even
- 16:37though it endorsed horrible things that were not good, but they are still good
- 16:44because context or mysterious ways, or you need the Holy Spirit, or what.
- 16:48I would love to see Ingersoll engage these good book defenders again his words
- 16:53from one hundred fifty years ago. He said, the believer in the inspiration
- 16:59of the Bible is compelled to say that there was a time when slavery was
- 17:03right, when women could sell their babes, when polygamy was the highest form
- 17:10of virtue, when wars of extermination were waged with the sword of mercy,
- 17:15when religious toleration was a crime, and when death was the just penalty for
- 17:22having expressed an honest thought. He is compelled to insist that Jehovah is as
- 17:27bad now as he was then, that he is as good now as he
- 17:33was then. Once all the crimes that I've mentioned were commanded by God.
- 17:37Now they are prohibited. Once God was in favor of them all. Now
- 17:44the devil is their defender. In other words, the devil entertained the same
- 17:48opinion today that God held four thousand years ago. The devil is as good
- 17:55now as Jehovah was then, and God was as bad then as the devil
- 18:02is now. Oh, the blasphemy. When I came out of my Christian
- 18:10faith, I was still weird about heresy or blasphemy. I mean, logically,
- 18:15I knew these are all myths and monsters like in my brain I realized
- 18:19that, But emotionally I still carried that baggage. And somebody would say something
- 18:25that had been deemed heretical, and I would I'd WinCE just a little bit.
- 18:30An Ingersoll opened my mind on this and gave me a perspective on heresy
- 18:36and the necessity of heresy that I had not before considered. He summed it
- 18:41up so well eighteen seventy four in Heretics and Heresies quote whoever has an opinion
- 18:48of his own and honestly expresses it will be guilty of heresy. Heresy is
- 18:53what the minority believe. It is the name given by the powerful to the
- 18:59doctrine of the week. Heresy cannot be burned, or imprisoned, nor starved.
- 19:06It laughs at presbyters and synods, at ecumenical counsels on the impotent thunders
- 19:11of Sinai. Heresy is the eternal day, the morning star, the glittering
- 19:18herald of the day. Heresy is the last and best thought. It is
- 19:25the perpetual of the new world, the unknown sea toward which the braves sale.
- 19:30It is the eternal horizon of progress. Heresy. His take on it
- 19:40evolved my own thinking. In fact, I wrote a book eight years ago
- 19:44called Sacred Cows, and it's kind of a romp around the world. But
- 19:48between the lines is this message that no idea is sacred. If somebody looks
- 19:53down their nose and says no, no, no, you're not allowed to
- 19:56question this or criticize this, I always look back at them and I say,
- 20:00congratulations, this thing is now number one on my list, right.
- 20:07I mean, they're trying to protect thought, but ideas should not be protected.
- 20:11They have to earn respect when you challenge the sacred. So often you're
- 20:17speaking to power. You are participating in critical thought, the thought that sails
- 20:22us forward toward the eternal horizon of progress. There can be no progress unless
- 20:30you and I are willing to look power in the face and commit what they
- 20:33call heresy. Is it any wonder that high control fundamentalist cultures discourage down right
- 20:41doubts a sin. Doubts, weakness, doubts an attack. If you are
- 20:47strong, you would be sure of yourself. You'd never doubts. Doubt is
- 20:52called a sin in the Bible. The one who doubts is like a wave
- 20:56of the sea. That person will be blown and tossed about like a wind,
- 21:00and should not expect to receive anything from the Lord. Doubting Thomas was
- 21:06chastised by Jesus for daring to say, oh, great, you're resurrected.
- 21:11Please show me the nail holes he doubted, and he was called out and
- 21:18chastised. And yet people use doubt and all the other aspects of their lives,
- 21:22and it helps to keep them from being scammed or harmed. A stranger
- 21:27pulls up next to your kid on the street, opens the car door,
- 21:32Hey, your mom sent me hop inside. The doubt that you have trained
- 21:36into your child will keep them from believing it and perhaps keep them safe.
- 21:42A salesperson rings your doorbell. I'm selling all kinds of stuff here, great
- 21:48products that will probably change your life just ninety nine ninety five. If I
- 21:52can step inside and do a demonstration, your doubt may keep you from getting
- 21:56scammed and maybe even allowing a predator access to the inside of your house.
- 22:03You open the fridge, you see a gallon of milk. The expiration date.
- 22:08Don't no, it's three days ago. I doubt this is still good.
- 22:14If I drink it, I might get sick. Your doubt will keep
- 22:18you from throwing up Believers totally engage the engine of doubt when it comes to
- 22:26other faith claims. The Christian hears the Islamist apologist and they're like, no,
- 22:32I totally doubt that. You know, Muhammad rode into the heavens on
- 22:36a winged horse or whatever. That sounds kind of sketch. You know.
- 22:41The Muslim hears the scientology claims about Xenu. That sounds totally bogus. I
- 22:48doubt that's true. I don't buy it. The Mormons doubt the doctrines of
- 22:52the Jehovah's witnesses hell. Even within one faith tradition Christianity, the Methodist doubt,
- 22:59the Baptist doubt, the Pentecostals doubt, the Calvinists doubt, the Lutherans
- 23:03doubt, the Catholics. I mean, it's crazy, doubt engaged all the
- 23:07time. But apparently this is supposed to be a problem, and the people
- 23:11selling us the idea that it's a problem are those who are selling something they
- 23:15want us to buy without thinking. Ingersol doubted the existence of God's disbelieved in
- 23:25God's He said this from the stage in eighteen eighty. Each nation has created
- 23:30a God, and the God has always resembled his creators. He hated and
- 23:37loved what they hated and loved, and he was invariably found on the side
- 23:41of those in power. Each God was intensely patriotic and detested all nations but
- 23:48his own. All these gods demanded praise, flattery, and worship. Most
- 23:55of them were pleased with sacrifice, and the smell of innocent blood has ever
- 24:00been considered a divine perfume. Speaking truth to power in the face of the
- 24:07power players today, I gotta wonder if Ingersol would have been targeted today,
- 24:12let's say his writings were made available in school libraries, would the book banners
- 24:18have targeted this man? Our children cannot be exposed to this anti god heresy.
- 24:26He is an enemy of religious liberty, spreading falsehoods. We must protect
- 24:33the generations. You think they'd grab his writings and throw them in boxes and
- 24:37take them out to be discarded or burned, or at least filed away,
- 24:42buried somewhere, never to be seen again. How would they have treated the
- 24:47man who said these words? Orthodox religion is a kind of boa constrictor anything
- 24:53it cannot dodge, it will swallow. As ready as I am to continue
- 25:03introducing you to the great heretic, I got to take a short break.
- 25:07I'll be right back and we shall continue. Today is a show that is
- 25:18taking you back in time and also relating a man of our history to the
- 25:23times of the day. We're talking about Robert Green Ingersoll, and we've been
- 25:30speaking recently about the necessity of heresy. You know, I mentioned that blasphemy
- 25:37trial right, Charles Reynolds on trial for heresy and Ingersoll's three hour defense,
- 25:44and in that oration, as he was speaking to the judge and jury.
- 25:47He said this quote, If you could only imprison a thought, then intellectual
- 25:52tyranny might succeed. If you could only take an argument and put a strip
- 25:57suit of clothes on it. If you could only take a good, splendid,
- 26:02shining fact and lock it up in some dungeon of ignorance so that its
- 26:07light would never again enter the mind of man, then you might succeed in
- 26:11stopping human progress. Otherwise, No, In a lot of ways, Ingersoll
- 26:21reminds me a little bit of Christopher Hitchens. And I'll tell you why.
- 26:26Christopher Hitchens was a pit bull, right. I mean he was fearless,
- 26:30and he was strong, and he took no crap, and he gave no
- 26:36quarter when he went in the room. Look out, because you're not going
- 26:40to get patted on the head and treated with deference, at least when it
- 26:42comes to ideas. But even in debates with the most idiotic of opponents.
- 26:49And I won't mention names here, denish to Susan and several others, Hitchens
- 26:56was the adult in the room. Now, sometimes he did raise his voice,
- 27:02but he wasn't just screaming. He didn't lose control, He wasn't trying
- 27:04to win by verve or volume. He didn't become unhinged, he didn't lose
- 27:10control, and in so many cases, I was just struck by the fact
- 27:14that if you watch a debate with Christopher Hitchens, he treated his interlocutors respectfully,
- 27:21not necessarily their ideas. You know, he'd go hard on the ideas,
- 27:25but he almost always respected their humanity. He would take questions from the
- 27:30audience. Yeah, some people got hitch slapped, it's true, But how
- 27:37many times did he field questions and challenges from devout believers or just people who
- 27:44had horrible ideas, and he would respond to them without calling him names,
- 27:48without carpet bombing them as human beings. And I really think Ingersoll was a
- 27:55lot like this. I think he was charitable with many Christians. One hundred
- 28:00and fifty years ago, he wrote that arguments cannot be branded with insults.
- 28:06Kindness is strength. Anger blows out the lamp of the mind. In the
- 28:12examination of a great and important question, everyone should be serene, slow pulsed,
- 28:18and calm. Now again, I'm not saying he never lost his temper,
- 28:25and I'm not saying that there aren't times for us to get good and
- 28:27angry, you know, to get into it. I'm not saying that,
- 28:32but in the overall he realized that you're not going to insult people into being
- 28:37better people. Hey, dumbass, and someone says, you know what,
- 28:41You're absolutely right. I am a total dumbass and I was wrong. Thank
- 28:45you for correcting me and setting me on the straight and narrow path. This
- 28:48does not happen. I'm reminded of that quote from Melanie treset Green. She
- 28:53brought it to my attention. I don't know if she actually said it,
- 28:56but she runs the Thinking is Power website, and she brought to my attention
- 29:02this line. People won't care what you believe unless they believe that you care.
- 29:10Man, that is good. I'm using that. I'm stealing it or
- 29:15borrowing it. I'm applying it right. People won't care what we believe unless
- 29:19they believe that we care. And I do not buy the lie that kindness
- 29:26is weakness. I think a lot of times it takes the stronger person to
- 29:33lower their voice to be kind. Anybody can surrender to their rage. Anybody
- 29:40can just knee jerk at anybody and everything that grates against them. Anybody can
- 29:45blow their stack at the drop of a hat. A reaction's easy. It
- 29:48doesn't have to be thoughtful, it doesn't have to use consideration. But if
- 29:52you're going to be the adult in the room, if you're going to be
- 29:56strong and firm and resolute and brave and committed to your values without throwing knives
- 30:02or throwing insults or throwing a tantrum, that is the Ingersol way. Over
- 30:08the course of his life, at various times he wrote things like this,
- 30:14kindness is the sunshine in which virtue grows. I would rather live and love
- 30:21where death is king, than have eternal life where love is not. Hope
- 30:27is the only bee that makes honey without flowers. A great man is a
- 30:34torch in the darkness, a beacon in superstition's night, an inspiration, and
- 30:41a prophecy. The superior man is the providence of the inferior. He is
- 30:47eyes for the blind, strength for the weak, and a shield for the
- 30:51defenseless. He stands erect by bending above the fallen. He rises by lifting
- 30:59others. Anyway. You know, given my recent experience, the privilege of
- 31:04speaking at the Ingersoll Birthplace Museum, and because his writings have been so influential
- 31:11to me, sometimes I even quote him in when I sign a book,
- 31:15someone will bring me a book and they'll say, hey, you know what,
- 31:18you sign one of your books, And at the top, I'll write
- 31:21Ingersoll's quote. And it's one of my favorite quotes, perhaps ever, ever,
- 31:26ever, it's really my coda. Ingersol said this, the more false
- 31:32weet destroy, the more room there will be for the true. And that's
- 31:38what I say to people who ask me, well, why do you have
- 31:41to speak out so much against relention? Why do you have to speak out
- 31:45so much against this, this or this, especially given that it makes people
- 31:49happy. They use the happiness argument, and I respond, it's not enough
- 31:56that it makes someone happy. We must seek out and embrace what is true.
- 32:01The more false sweet destroy, the more room we make for the true.
- 32:08The more oxygen, the more elbow room, the more latitude, the
- 32:13more opportunities, the more power the true has in this world. Man,
- 32:19that's good. It just drives me, you know, it drives many of
- 32:22us as we speak out against the cancer, the ignorance, and the dogma
- 32:28and the bad agents. The more false sweet destroy, the more room there
- 32:34will be for the true. Robert Ingersoll, you can hear me. The
- 32:38world is still crazy. The Satanic panic is still going on. The zealots
- 32:45are still killing us out there, and sometimes I feel overwhelmed by it all.
- 32:52But I take a lot of encouragement, and I have echoed many of
- 32:54the words that you wrote during your lifetime. You had no idea when you
- 33:00wrote this stuff in the eighteen hundreds that you would help this exvangelical when he
- 33:05escaped religion in two thousand eight. You would have no idea who I am,
- 33:10or the fact that I have borrowed so much of what you said as
- 33:15I have conversations in my own circles. But you are evidence that in many
- 33:20important ways, even though we don't believe in an afterlife, we can have
- 33:25an afterlife. The ripple of our lives can go on to influence and encourage
- 33:30and inspire others for generations, so that we two can be true to the
- 33:37loftiest and most generous promptings of the human heart. Let me finish with a
- 33:45series of various statements Ingersol said that resonate today. He said, as more
- 33:51people become more intelligent, they care less for preachers and more for teachers.
- 34:00Give me the storm and tempest of thought and action, rather than the dead
- 34:05calm of ignorance and faith. Banish me from eating when you will, but
- 34:09first let me eat of the fruits of the tree of knowledge. I do
- 34:15not believe in forgiveness as it is preached by the Church. We do not
- 34:20need the forgiveness of God, but of each other and of ourselves. In
- 34:27the republic of mediocrity, genius is dangerous. Take from the Church the miraculous,
- 34:36the supernatural, the incomprehensible, the unreasonable, the impossible, the unknowable,
- 34:42the absurd, and nothing but a vacuum remains. The more a man
- 34:49knows, the more willing he is to learn. The less a man knows,
- 34:53the more positive he is that he knows everything. The truth shall make
- 35:01you free, but first it shall make you angry. Justice is the only
- 35:08worship. Love is the only priest. It may be that ministers really think
- 35:17that their prayers do good, and it may be that frogs imagine that their
- 35:22croaking brings spring. There is something wrong in a government where they who do
- 35:30the most have the least. There's something wrong when honesty wears a rag and
- 35:37rascality a robe. When the loving the tender eat a crust while the infamous
- 35:43sits at banquets. Nothing discloses real character like the use of power. It
- 35:51is easy for the weak to be gentle. Most people can bear adversity.
- 35:55But if you wish to know what a man really is, give him empower.
- 36:00This is the supreme test. It is the glory of Lincoln that,
- 36:06having almost absolute power, he never abused it except upon the side of mercy.
- 36:14And perhaps his most famous quote to finish us off, he once said,
- 36:17reason, observation, and experience, the holy trinity of science, have
- 36:22taught us that happiness is the only good. That the time to be happy
- 36:29is now, and the way to be happy is to make others. So
- 36:36thanks for allowing me to introduce you to one of my inspirations, Robert green
- 36:40Ingersoll, the most remarkable American most people have never heard of. Have a
- 36:50great week. I'll see you next time. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook
- 36:53and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos. Products like mugs and
- 36:59t shirts feature ring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources,
- 37:04and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website,
- 37:08The Thinking Atheist dot com.