Latest / Faster, Please! β The Podcast / π½ America's immigration edge: My chat (+transcript) with policy expert Alex Nowrasteh
Transcript
- 0:06SPEAKER_00: Welcome to Faster Please, the podcast.
- 0:09SPEAKER_00: I'm your host, Jim Pethikoukis.
- 0:12SPEAKER_00: Several times a month,
- 0:13I'll feature a lively conversation with a fascinating and
- 0:16provocative guest about
- 0:18SPEAKER_00: how to make the world a better place through scientific discovery,
- 0:21SPEAKER_00: technological innovation,
- 0:23SPEAKER_00: and economic growth.
- 0:24SPEAKER_00: You're also going to want to check out my Faster Please newsletter.
- 0:27SPEAKER_00: You're on Substack throughout the week for fresh essays,
- 0:30SPEAKER_00: Q&As,
- 0:31SPEAKER_00: and stories from around the internet and around the world.
- 0:35With the rise of American populist nationalism has come the
- 0:39rise of nativism,
- 0:41a belief in the concept of heritage Americans and a deep
- 0:44distrust of immigration.
- 0:47SPEAKER_00: Today on Faster Please,
- 0:48SPEAKER_00: the podcast,
- 0:49I talk with Alex Narasta about the ideology beneath the severe skepticism,
- 0:54as well as what Americans would lose economically if we shut
- 0:58our doors to both low-
- 0:59SPEAKER_00: and high-skilled immigrants.
- 1:01Narasta is the Vice President for Economic and Social Policy
- 1:04Studies at the Cato Institute.
- 1:06SPEAKER_00: He is the author of his own Substack with David Beer,
- 1:09SPEAKER_00: as well as the co-author of Wretched Refuse,
- 1:12SPEAKER_00: The Political Economy of Immigration and Institutions.
- 1:16SPEAKER_00: Will you,
- 1:17SPEAKER_00: in a very short period of time,
- 1:21give me a sense of the situation at the southern border of the
- 1:25United States of
- 1:26SPEAKER_00: America in terms of immigration,
- 1:29SPEAKER_00: how that has evolved from Trump one to Biden to now?
- 1:34SPEAKER_00: Is it possible to give me a concise summary of that?
- 1:40From Obama through Trump one,
- 1:42the border apprehension numbers were pretty reasonable.
- 1:45SPEAKER_01: You were talking about somewhere between four and 800,000 per year.
- 1:50Then came COVID,
- 1:51crashed those numbers down to basically nothing by April of 2020.
- 1:57SPEAKER_01: After that, the numbers progressively rose.
- 2:00They were at the highest point in December of 2020 than they
- 2:04had been for any other
- 2:06SPEAKER_01: December going back over 25 years.
- 2:09SPEAKER_01: And then Biden takes office.
- 2:11SPEAKER_01: The numbers shoot through the roof.
- 2:13SPEAKER_01: We're talking about 170,000 to 250,000, sometimes 300,000 a month.
- 2:19SPEAKER_01: until January or so of 2024.
- 2:21SPEAKER_01: Those numbers start coming down precipitously.
- 2:24SPEAKER_01: December of 2024, they're at 40,000 or so, 45,000.
- 2:30SPEAKER_01: January 2025, Trump comes in, they go down again.
- 2:36First full month of Trump's administration in February,
- 2:38they're about 8,000.
- 2:39SPEAKER_01: The lowest numbers without a pandemic in a very long time.
- 2:45SPEAKER_01: What's the right number?
- 2:47SPEAKER_01: So the right number, that's a hard question to answer, right?
- 2:53So in an ideal world where costs and benefits didn't matter,
- 2:57I think the ideal number is zero.
- 3:00SPEAKER_01: But the question is, how do you get to that ideal number, right?
- 3:03Is it by having an insane amount of enforcement of existing
- 3:08laws where you
- 3:09SPEAKER_01: basically end up brutalizing people to an incredible extent?
- 3:13SPEAKER_01: Or is it practically zero because we let people come in lawfully?
- 3:18SPEAKER_01: to work in this country.
- 3:20And I think the system that I would favor is one that allows a
- 3:25substantially larger
- 3:26SPEAKER_01: number of people at every skill level to come into this country legally,
- 3:29SPEAKER_01: to work,
- 3:29SPEAKER_01: to live,
- 3:30SPEAKER_01: and to become Americans.
- 3:31SPEAKER_01: And that would bring that number down to about what it is now,
- 3:36SPEAKER_01: or even lower than what it is now every month.
- 3:39Because the reason people come illegally is because this
- 3:42country demands their
- 3:43SPEAKER_01: labor and there's no way for them to come legally.
- 3:47SPEAKER_00: As I've sort of understood it and maybe understand it wrong,
- 3:51is this issue has developed that it at first it seemed like the
- 3:55concern and it
- 3:57SPEAKER_00: still is the concern are with illegal,
- 4:00SPEAKER_00: undocumented immigrants.
- 4:04SPEAKER_00: And then it seems to me the argument became, well, we don't want those.
- 4:09SPEAKER_00: And then we also really don't want low-skill immigrants either.
- 4:13SPEAKER_00: And now it seems,
- 4:14SPEAKER_00: and maybe you have a different perspective,
- 4:16SPEAKER_00: that it's,
- 4:17SPEAKER_00: well,
- 4:18SPEAKER_00: we don't really maybe want those high-skill immigrants either.
- 4:23You gave me the current state of illegal immigration at the
- 4:25southern border.
- 4:26SPEAKER_00: What is the current state of the argument among people who want less,
- 4:31SPEAKER_00: perhaps even no immigration in this country?
- 4:34SPEAKER_01: State of the argument is actually what you describe.
- 4:38SPEAKER_01: When I started working on this topic about 15 years ago,
- 4:41I never thought I would have heard people come out against the
- 4:45H-1B visa or against
- 4:46SPEAKER_01: high-skilled immigrants or against foreign entrepreneurs.
- 4:49SPEAKER_01: But you saw this over Christmas, actually, December of 2024.
- 4:55SPEAKER_01: You saw this basically online H-1B gate.
- 4:58SPEAKER_01: Where Vivek Ramaswamy and Elon Musk were saying H1Bs are great.
- 5:03You know,
- 5:04I think Musk even tweeted,
- 5:05like,
- 5:05over my dead body,
- 5:06we're going to cut the H1B,
- 5:07right?
- 5:08And you see just this groundswell of,
- 5:12I mean,
- 5:13conservatives and Republicans,
- 5:15right?
- 5:16Not all of them,
- 5:17by any means,
- 5:18come out and say,
- 5:19we don't even want these guys,
- 5:20right?
- 5:20SPEAKER_01: We don't want these skilled immigrants using a whole range of arguments,
- 5:24SPEAKER_01: none of them economic,
- 5:24SPEAKER_01: by the way,
- 5:25SPEAKER_01: almost none of them economics,
- 5:27SPEAKER_01: all culture,
- 5:28SPEAKER_01: all voting habits,
- 5:30SPEAKER_01: all stereotypes,
- 5:31SPEAKER_01: a lot of them pretty nasty,
- 5:33SPEAKER_01: in my opinion.
- 5:34SPEAKER_01: And so there is this sense where some people just don't want immigrants.
- 5:39SPEAKER_01: And,
- 5:39SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 5:39the first time I think I encountered this in writing from a
- 5:42from a person who was prominent,
- 5:46SPEAKER_01: was Ann Coulter,
- 5:50SPEAKER_01: Jeff Sessions when he was Senator,
- 5:52SPEAKER_01: and these types of people around 2015,
- 5:54SPEAKER_01: like in a big way.
- 5:55And it seems to have become much more prominent than I ever
- 5:59thought it would be.
- 6:01SPEAKER_00: Is it that they don't understand the economic argument?
- 6:05SPEAKER_00: Or they just don't care about that argument?
- 6:06SPEAKER_01: They don't care about it.
- 6:08SPEAKER_01: They don't care about it.
- 6:09I have come to the realization β this makes me sad because I'm
- 6:13an economist by training.
- 6:14But I just don't think the economic argument is what moves
- 6:17people on this topic.
- 6:18SPEAKER_01: I don't think it's what they care about.
- 6:19SPEAKER_01: I don't think it animates β it animates me.
- 6:23SPEAKER_01: As a pro-immigration person, I think it animates you, right?
- 6:26SPEAKER_01: It does, yeah, it sure does.
- 6:28SPEAKER_01: But it does not animate the people who are opposed to it.
- 6:31I think it is a cultural argument,
- 6:33it is a crime element,
- 6:34it is a threat element.
- 6:35It is a,
- 6:36this makes us less American somehow,
- 6:39weird fuzzy feeling argument.
- 6:42Would it matter if the immigrants were all coming from Germany,
- 6:47France,
- 6:48and Norway?
- 6:49maybe for a handful of them but generally no i don't think so
- 6:54and i think the idea
- 6:56that america is special is different is some kind of unique
- 7:01nation that ethnically
- 7:03just or or in other ways cannot be pierced or contaminated by
- 7:08foreigners i think
- 7:08it's just like you foreigners type of sentiment that people
- 7:11have like a xenophobia
- 7:12SPEAKER_01: like a base xenophobia
- 7:14that a lot of people have combined with a very reasonable fear
- 7:20and dislike of chaos.
- 7:22SPEAKER_01: And when people see chaos on the border, they hate it.
- 7:25SPEAKER_01: I hate chaos on the border.
- 7:28SPEAKER_01: My answer,
- 7:28SPEAKER_01: and I assume you do too,
- 7:30like my answer is to get rid of the chaos by letting people
- 7:33come in legally.
- 7:35SPEAKER_01: Because you legalize a market, you can actually regulate it.
- 7:37SPEAKER_01: You can't regulate an illegal market, right?
- 7:40SPEAKER_01: But I think other people see chaos.
- 7:42They have this sort of purity conception of America that's just fanciful,
- 7:46in my opinion.
- 7:47SPEAKER_01: And they just don't want foreigners.
- 7:48SPEAKER_01: And the chaos prompts them, makes it even more powerful.
- 7:53To what extent is it fear that all these immigrants will
- 7:56eventually vote for things
- 7:57SPEAKER_00: you don't want?
- 7:58SPEAKER_00: Or in this case, they're all going to become Democrats.
- 8:01SPEAKER_00: So Republicans don't want them.
- 8:02SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's definitely part of it.
- 8:04I think that's more of an elite Republican fear or an elite
- 8:08sort of nativist or
- 8:10conservative fear than it is amongst the people online who are
- 8:15yelling at me all
- 8:15SPEAKER_01: the time or yelling at Elon Musk.
- 8:18So I think that resonates a lot more like in this city and in
- 8:21online conservative publications.
- 8:23SPEAKER_01: I think that that resonates much more.
- 8:25SPEAKER_01: I don't think it's borne out by the facts.
- 8:29SPEAKER_01: But that and it's and people also,
- 8:31SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 8:31who say this will also loudly trumpet how Hispanics now
- 8:36basically split their vote
- 8:38SPEAKER_01: in the 2024 election.
- 8:40SPEAKER_01: And David Shore,
- 8:42SPEAKER_01: who is the progressive analyst of electoral politics,
- 8:46SPEAKER_01: said he thinks that Trump actually won the naturalized immigrant vote.
- 8:53Which is probably the first time a Republican has won the
- 8:56naturalized immigrant
- 8:57SPEAKER_01: growth since like the 19th century.
- 8:59SPEAKER_00: The immediate question is,
- 9:00SPEAKER_00: does that kind of thing,
- 9:02SPEAKER_00: will that resonate into changing,
- 9:04SPEAKER_00: a changing opinion among folks on the right?
- 9:07SPEAKER_00: If they feel like they can, they feel like they can win these voters.
- 9:12SPEAKER_01: I don't think so.
- 9:13SPEAKER_01: Because I think it's about deeper issues than that.
- 9:16SPEAKER_01: And I think it's a real like feelings, values based issue.
- 9:20SPEAKER_00: Has this been there for a long time?
- 9:22SPEAKER_00: Was it exacerbated?
- 9:25for some reason was exacerbated by like the financial crisis
- 9:28and the slow economy afterward.
- 9:31SPEAKER_00: The only time I remember hearing about people using,
- 9:34SPEAKER_00: not the phrase,
- 9:35SPEAKER_00: but the idea of heritage Americans were like elite people who came over,
- 9:41SPEAKER_00: who's great,
- 9:42SPEAKER_00: great,
- 9:42SPEAKER_00: great,
- 9:42came over on the Mayflower and they thought they were better
- 9:44than everybody else.
- 9:44SPEAKER_00: They were elite.
- 9:45SPEAKER_00: They were these kind of Boston Brahmins.
- 9:47So I was aware of the concept from that,
- 9:49but I've never heard people,
- 9:51and I hear it now about
- 9:54SPEAKER_00: People who were not part of the original Mayflower wave or something,
- 9:58SPEAKER_00: pilgrims,
- 10:00think of themselves as heritage Americans because their parents
- 10:05came over in the
- 10:08SPEAKER_00: 1850s or the 1880s,
- 10:09SPEAKER_00: but now they're heritage.
- 10:11SPEAKER_00: That idea to me seems new.
- 10:14I hadn't heard of it until several years,
- 10:16just a few years ago,
- 10:17frankly,
- 10:18at all.
- 10:19SPEAKER_01: And I racked my brain about this because I used to be,
- 10:24SPEAKER_01: I used to have a lot of affinity for the Republican Party,
- 10:27SPEAKER_01: just to be frank.
- 10:28SPEAKER_01: And I'm from California.
- 10:30SPEAKER_01: So β and I'm in my 40s.
- 10:32And so I remember Prop 187 in 1994 when the state had a big
- 10:38campaign about this,
- 10:40SPEAKER_01: illegal immigrants' enforcement and welfare.
- 10:44And it really changed the state's voting patterns to be much
- 10:47more democratic eventually,
- 10:49right?
- 10:49SPEAKER_01: But β
- 10:51SPEAKER_01: And so I and then I saw the Republican Party under George W.
- 10:54SPEAKER_01: Bush and John McCain and all these other guys who are pro Republican,
- 10:58SPEAKER_01: but always in California,
- 11:00SPEAKER_01: the Republicans were very skeptical of immigration across the board.
- 11:04SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 11:04SPEAKER_01: But I never I didn't really see that spread.
- 11:07SPEAKER_01: And then I saw it go to Arizona in 2010, 2009, 2008, around there.
- 11:14SPEAKER_01: I saw it go to South Carolina, Mississippi, some of these places.
- 11:18SPEAKER_01: And then all of a sudden went Trump and went everywhere.
- 11:20SPEAKER_01: So I racked my brain thinking like, did I miss something?
- 11:23SPEAKER_01: Was there always something there?
- 11:25And I was just too myopic to view it or I wasn't in those
- 11:30circles or I wanted to
- 11:31SPEAKER_01: convince myself that it wasn't there.
- 11:33SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 11:34SPEAKER_01: And I really think that it was always there to some small extent.
- 11:38SPEAKER_01: But Trump is the most brilliant political entrepreneur.
- 11:44SPEAKER_01: of our lifetime and probably of our country's history.
- 11:47And that he took over this party from the outside and he
- 11:50convinced people to be nativists.
- 11:54SPEAKER_01: Because what he was saying,
- 11:55SPEAKER_01: the words,
- 11:56SPEAKER_01: not that different from Scott Walker saying about immigration.
- 11:59It was not that different from what Mike Huckabee was saying
- 12:01about immigration.
- 12:02SPEAKER_01: Wasn't that different from Santorum.
- 12:03SPEAKER_01: But he said it or sold it in a way that just worked.
- 12:09SPEAKER_01: I guess.
- 12:10And that maybe absolves me of some responsibility or maybe
- 12:14allows me to say that I
- 12:16SPEAKER_01: didn't miss anything.
- 12:19SPEAKER_01: But I do think that that largely explains it.
- 12:22SPEAKER_00: And how does it explain it?
- 12:23SPEAKER_00: You may not have an answer because it seems like, again, it's
- 12:28I can sort of understand sort of the visceral concern about
- 12:32chaos at the border or
- 12:34SPEAKER_00: people coming here illegally.
- 12:37SPEAKER_00: But then to take it to the point that we don't even want,
- 12:41SPEAKER_00: like,
- 12:41SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 12:41SPEAKER_00: we don't want AI engineers to come to this country from India.
- 12:45SPEAKER_00: Or,
- 12:45SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 12:47I'm really angry that someone from a foreign country is taking
- 12:53my kid's spot at Harvard.
- 12:55SPEAKER_00: That, to me, seems almost inexplicable.
- 12:58SPEAKER_01: It's not the fact of the chaos, but it's the perception of the chaos.
- 13:05Because when Trump came in in 2015,
- 13:07the border crossing numbers were really low.
- 13:10SPEAKER_01: They're in the 300,000s, low 400,000s, right?
- 13:14SPEAKER_01: But he talked about it like it was millions.
- 13:16SPEAKER_01: And he created this perception of just insane, outrageous chaos.
- 13:22SPEAKER_01: And that...
- 13:24There's research in political psychology fields about the locus
- 13:29of control.
- 13:30And when people feel like they don't have control of something
- 13:34in their country or
- 13:35SPEAKER_01: their government doesn't have control of something,
- 13:37SPEAKER_01: they become anti whatever is the source of that chaos,
- 13:42SPEAKER_01: even the legal versions of it.
- 13:44SPEAKER_01: And in some way, it's like an understandable human reaction.
- 13:49SPEAKER_01: But in some ways, it is so destructive.
- 13:51But like you said,
- 13:52it spreads to AI engineers from China because it's like all immigration.
- 13:58SPEAKER_01: And it's so bad and it's so destructive.
- 14:00SPEAKER_01: And that is the best explanation that I've seen out there about that.
- 14:04SPEAKER_00: I write a lot about,
- 14:05SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 14:06hopefully like this technological wave that we're going to be experiencing.
- 14:11SPEAKER_00: And then I also, you know, write a little about immigration.
- 14:15SPEAKER_00: And the question I get is...
- 14:18If we're going to be worried about the jobs of the future being
- 14:21taken over by
- 14:23SPEAKER_00: software or by robots,
- 14:25SPEAKER_00: if we really think that's going to happen,
- 14:28shouldn't we really be thinking very hard about the kinds of
- 14:31people we let enter
- 14:33SPEAKER_00: into this country,
- 14:34SPEAKER_00: even legally,
- 14:35SPEAKER_00: and their ability to function in that kind of economy?
- 14:40So I think we need to think about what is the best mechanism to
- 14:46select people to come here?
- 14:48SPEAKER_01: That the economy needs.
- 14:49SPEAKER_01: And I think that what you described is like,
- 14:53SPEAKER_01: I guess what your critics would say or a thoughtful person would say,
- 14:56SPEAKER_01: right?
- 14:56What you described assumes an amount of knowledge and foresight
- 15:02and frankly,
- 15:03SPEAKER_01: the incentive to make a wise decision.
- 15:07in the hands of bureaucrats and politicians and that they just
- 15:10do not have and that
- 15:11SPEAKER_01: they will never have.
- 15:12SPEAKER_00: You can say like STEM degrees only.
- 15:14Like I only want people who have STEM degrees from colleges
- 15:20that on some global
- 15:21SPEAKER_00: ranking are in the top 500 universities.
- 15:25SPEAKER_00: You could say that.
- 15:25SPEAKER_00: I mean, that would be one way of selecting.
- 15:28SPEAKER_00: they could centrally try to centrally plan it like that, right?
- 15:30Now you're saying centrally plan because you know that's going
- 15:34to get a reaction
- 15:35SPEAKER_00: out of me,
- 15:36SPEAKER_01: but go ahead.
- 15:37SPEAKER_01: I do, I do.
- 15:38So the thing is like,
- 15:39there's all different types of ways to have an immigration system,
- 15:42right?
- 15:43And there's going to be a little bit of planning in an
- 15:47immigration system,
- 15:47right?
- 15:48But I think the one that will work best is the one that allows
- 15:51the market to have
- 15:52SPEAKER_01: the widest possible choice,
- 15:53SPEAKER_01: right?
- 15:54SPEAKER_01: And we don't know how automation works
- 15:57SPEAKER_01: or the future automation is going to turn out.
- 15:59SPEAKER_01: I think it's,
- 15:59SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 16:00SPEAKER_01: there's this thing called Moravex Paradox and a lot of AI writing,
- 16:04which is the idea that you will probably be able to automate a
- 16:07lot of high-skilled
- 16:07SPEAKER_01: jobs more easily than you will be able to automate,
- 16:10SPEAKER_01: say,
- 16:11SPEAKER_01: somebody who's a maid or a nanny or a nurse or a plumber.
- 16:14Just because the real world is harder than,
- 16:16you know,
- 16:17you and I type and talk and do math.
- 16:19SPEAKER_01: Like, that's probably easier to do.
- 16:21So maybe the optimal thing to do would be to increase
- 16:25immigration for low-skilled
- 16:27people because all the jobs in the future are going to be
- 16:29low-skilled anyway
- 16:31SPEAKER_01: because we're going to be able to automate the high-skilled jobs.
- 16:34Though you could say then that would take away the jobs for the natives,
- 16:38right?
- 16:38SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 16:39SPEAKER_01: You could you could say that,
- 16:40SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 16:41SPEAKER_01: what what we notice in the economics of immigration,
- 16:45SPEAKER_01: when we when we do these types of studies,
- 16:47SPEAKER_01: we take a look at the wage impacts.
- 16:48SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 16:50SPEAKER_01: We've got basically no wage effect on on those native born Americans.
- 16:55SPEAKER_01: And if we were to have a situation where, let's say,
- 16:58SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 16:59massive amounts of jobs disappear and entire sectors of the
- 17:02economy vanish because
- 17:03SPEAKER_01: they're automated.
- 17:04SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 17:04that just means that we're going to have more opportunities and
- 17:08specialization
- 17:09SPEAKER_01: division of labor where there's going to be a lot more lower skilled and
- 17:11mid-skilled jobs just because there's such a much larger and
- 17:15more productive side
- 17:16SPEAKER_01: of the economy.
- 17:16There's going to be so much more profits in these other ones
- 17:19that we're going to
- 17:20have a bigger economy in the same way that like when
- 17:22agriculture basically shrank
- 17:24SPEAKER_01: as a massive section of the workforce.
- 17:25SPEAKER_01: I mean, those people...
- 17:28SPEAKER_01: got other jobs that were more productive.
- 17:30SPEAKER_01: And it was great.
- 17:30SPEAKER_01: And I think we could maybe see that again.
- 17:32SPEAKER_01: And I hope we do.
- 17:34SPEAKER_01: I don't want to have to work anymore.
- 17:35SPEAKER_00: Sort of the scenario,
- 17:36and this was sort of highlighted to me by one of our scholars
- 17:41who looks a lot about
- 17:42SPEAKER_00: demographics and population growth,
- 17:44SPEAKER_00: that
- 17:45SPEAKER_00: His theory is that all the population decline estimates,
- 17:50SPEAKER_00: shrinkage,
- 17:51SPEAKER_00: and slowing down estimates from the United Nation are way too optimistic.
- 17:55SPEAKER_00: That population would begin to level off much faster,
- 17:58SPEAKER_00: whatever the UN's like low or worst case scenario is,
- 18:01SPEAKER_00: if you wanna say,
- 18:02SPEAKER_00: put a qualifier on it like that.
- 18:04SPEAKER_00: It's probably like that.
- 18:06And a lot of policymakers are underestimating the decline in
- 18:11fertility rates.
- 18:12SPEAKER_00: And eventually everyone's gonna kind of figure that out.
- 18:15SPEAKER_00: And there'll be a mad global scandal for population,
- 18:19SPEAKER_00: for people,
- 18:20SPEAKER_00: because,
- 18:20SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 18:22SPEAKER_00: because there's a huge advantage.
- 18:24SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 18:25there's going to be tons of labor shortages and you're going to
- 18:27want people and
- 18:28SPEAKER_00: there's going to be this scramble.
- 18:30SPEAKER_00: And not every country is going to be as good at it.
- 18:33SPEAKER_00: And one country like.
- 18:36SPEAKER_00: If people who want to immigrate,
- 18:37SPEAKER_00: they're probably more likely,
- 18:39SPEAKER_00: everything else equal,
- 18:40they're going to want to go to the United States as opposed to
- 18:44not to smear another country,
- 18:46SPEAKER_00: I don't know,
- 18:46SPEAKER_00: Argentina or something.
- 18:48SPEAKER_00: So we have this great sort of ability to...
- 18:53to accept people to come here and for them to succeed and build
- 18:58companies maybe
- 18:58that company's bodega maybe that company's uh technology
- 19:02company so we're at this
- 19:04sort of moment where we have this great natural advantage but
- 19:08it seems like we're
- 19:08utterly rejecting it all right we are not just rejecting it i
- 19:13mean we are turning
- 19:14it from a positive into a big negative right i mean you have
- 19:18these students
- 19:19who are being apprehended and having their visas canceled
- 19:24because of a phishing
- 19:26SPEAKER_01: license violation six years ago.
- 19:28People who are skilled science students studying in the United
- 19:33States who could go
- 19:35SPEAKER_01: on to be founders of big companies or just high-skilled workers.
- 19:38SPEAKER_01: And we're saying, nope, can't do it, sorry.
- 19:41SPEAKER_01: We're kicking people out for...
- 19:45SPEAKER_01: For reasons of speech,
- 19:46SPEAKER_01: speech I often don't like,
- 19:48SPEAKER_01: by the way,
- 19:49SPEAKER_01: but it doesn't matter because I believe it on principle.
- 19:51SPEAKER_01: It's important.
- 19:52And that is going to be and we already see it showing up in
- 19:55tourism numbers
- 19:57SPEAKER_01: plummeting to the United States.
- 19:59SPEAKER_01: And I think we're going to see it in student visa numbers.
- 20:02And student visas is like the first step on that long chain of
- 20:06being able to be a
- 20:07SPEAKER_01: high skilled immigrant one day.
- 20:09SPEAKER_01: And so we are really doing long term damage.
- 20:11SPEAKER_01: And on the population stuff, I completely agree.
- 20:13SPEAKER_01: And,
- 20:14SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 20:16SPEAKER_01: if the whole world is going to have population decline in 20,
- 20:18SPEAKER_01: 30,
- 20:2250 years,
- 20:18SPEAKER_01: we're going to have to deal with that at some point.
- 20:22But I'd rather deal with that problem with a population of 600
- 20:25million Americans
- 20:27SPEAKER_01: than a population of 350 million Americans.
- 20:30SPEAKER_00: What is sort of your general take on the notion of assimilation?
- 20:35SPEAKER_00: Is that a problem?
- 20:37SPEAKER_00: Should we be doing more to make sure people are successful here?
- 20:40SPEAKER_00: How do you think about that?
- 20:42SPEAKER_01: I do think assimilation is important.
- 20:44SPEAKER_01: I don't think it's a problem.
- 20:46And when I talk about assimilation,
- 20:49I use it in the way like Jacob Vigdor.
- 20:50SPEAKER_01: Jake is a professor, University of Washington economist.
- 20:54And he says assimilation is when an immigrant or their kids are
- 21:01indistinguishable
- 21:02SPEAKER_01: from long-settled Americans on the measurements of family size,
- 21:08SPEAKER_01: civic participation,
- 21:09SPEAKER_01: income β
- 21:11SPEAKER_01: education, language.
- 21:13SPEAKER_01: And basically it takes three generations.
- 21:14SPEAKER_01: That is the first generation of the immigrants,
- 21:16SPEAKER_01: second are their kids,
- 21:17SPEAKER_01: third are their grandkids on average.
- 21:19SPEAKER_01: Some much faster.
- 21:20SPEAKER_01: Like my Indian neighbors are,
- 21:24SPEAKER_01: I mean they're more than assimilated in the first generation.
- 21:26They do better than native-born Americans on most of those measures,
- 21:30right?
- 21:31Some β like some lower-skilled Hispanic or some East African
- 21:36immigrants takes three,
- 21:38SPEAKER_01: three and a half,
- 21:39SPEAKER_01: four sometimes to do that well.
- 21:42SPEAKER_01: But it's going very well.
- 21:43SPEAKER_01: We do not have the cultural β
- 21:46issues that some countries in europe uh have to some extent
- 21:51it's overblown in
- 21:52europe those problems but they do exist and they exist to a
- 21:54greater extent than
- 21:55they do here so the idea like and part of that is because we
- 21:58have birthright
- 21:58citizenship people who are born in this country as citizens
- 22:01they don't feel like
- 22:02they're an illegal underclass because they're not they feel
- 22:05totally accepted
- 22:06because they are legally and we have an ethos in this country
- 22:10because we don't have
- 22:11SPEAKER_01: an ethnic identification of being american
- 22:14Like they do in places like Germany or in Norway or my family
- 22:18members in Norway who
- 22:20SPEAKER_01: are half Iranian.
- 22:22SPEAKER_01: And they're not really considered to be Norwegian culturally.
- 22:25SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 22:26SPEAKER_01: And here it's the opposite.
- 22:27SPEAKER_01: If I were to go say I'm not an American, people would be offended.
- 22:32SPEAKER_01: There,
- 22:32SPEAKER_01: if you say,
- 22:33SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 22:34SPEAKER_01: I'm Norwegian,
- 22:35SPEAKER_01: they'll correct you and be like,
- 22:37SPEAKER_01: no,
- 22:37SPEAKER_01: you're not Norwegian.
- 22:38SPEAKER_01: You're something else.
- 22:39We got this great secret sauce born of our culture,
- 22:42born of our lack of an ethnic Americanness.
- 22:46SPEAKER_01: It doesn't matter what ethnicity or race you are or religion.
- 22:49SPEAKER_01: Anybody can be American.
- 22:51SPEAKER_01: And we have done it so well.
- 22:52SPEAKER_01: So we just don't have these issues.
- 22:54And I don't think as a result we should do more because I'm
- 22:57worried about the
- 22:57SPEAKER_01: government breaking it.
- 22:59SPEAKER_00: based on what you just said,
- 23:00SPEAKER_00: sort of at a gut level,
- 23:02SPEAKER_00: like how do you feel when someone uses the phrase like,
- 23:09heritage Americans and you know they hate the idea of what
- 23:13you're saying of America
- 23:15is kind of an idea and to be an American you need to have been
- 23:18here for a long time
- 23:20like that whole that whole way of looking at it do you get it
- 23:24or do you like I just
- 23:26SPEAKER_00: at some level like I do not I'm not a psychologist I do not understand it
- 23:30It makes sense of it by swapping out the word American in their
- 23:35sentence and
- 23:36replace it with the word like Frenchman or German or Russian or
- 23:42Japanese or some
- 23:43other country that's a nation state where the identity is bound
- 23:47up with ethnicity.
- 23:48SPEAKER_01: That's the way that I make sense of it.
- 23:50And I think this is a concept that just does not work in the
- 23:55United States.
- 23:56SPEAKER_01: It cannot work.
- 23:58SPEAKER_01: Maybe it's like the most nationalistic I am.
- 24:00But I think that that's just a fundamentally foreign idea that
- 24:03could never work in
- 24:04SPEAKER_01: the United States.
- 24:05SPEAKER_01: And it sounds more at home in Europe and other places.
- 24:08SPEAKER_01: That's what strikes me.
- 24:10SPEAKER_00: As I finish up,
- 24:11I know you have all kinds of ideas to improve the American
- 24:14immigration system,
- 24:15SPEAKER_00: which we'll try to link to.
- 24:17But instead of me asking you to give me your five point plan
- 24:20for perfection,
- 24:21SPEAKER_00: I'm going to ask you,
- 24:23SPEAKER_00: how does this turn around?
- 24:24SPEAKER_00: What is the scenario in which we
- 24:27become more accepting again of immigrants,
- 24:31perhaps the way we were,
- 24:32you know,
- 24:3230 years ago.
- 24:34SPEAKER_01: That really is a $64,000 question.
- 24:38SPEAKER_01: The idea that I have floated,
- 24:41SPEAKER_01: which probably won't work,
- 24:44SPEAKER_01: but at least gets people to pause,
- 24:47SPEAKER_01: is the entitlement programs are going insolvent and
- 24:51SPEAKER_01: And I have pitched to my grandmother-in-law,
- 24:55SPEAKER_01: who is a very nice woman,
- 24:57SPEAKER_01: who is a Republican,
- 24:58SPEAKER_01: who is skeptical of immigration,
- 25:00SPEAKER_01: but who is worried about Social Security going bankrupt.
- 25:02SPEAKER_01: I say,
- 25:03SPEAKER_01: well,
- 25:03SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 25:04there is one way to increase the solvency of this program for
- 25:0930 or 40 years.
- 25:10SPEAKER_01: And she said, what's that?
- 25:11SPEAKER_01: And I say, let in 100 million immigrants between the age of 20 and 30.
- 25:13SPEAKER_01: And it gives her pause.
- 25:17SPEAKER_01: And I think if that idea can give her pause,
- 25:23then maybe it has a shot when this country seriously starts to
- 25:29grapple with the
- 25:30SPEAKER_01: insolvency of entitlement programs.
- 25:32SPEAKER_01: That's looming.